2/6/25, 11:00 AM - Full Formal Session: House Session, House Chamber

Status: Normal
Date/Time: 2/6/25 11:00 AM
Location: House Chamber
Committee: House Session (HS)
Add to your calendar
     

02/06/2025 - Formal House Session 13
Show All
Printable
Transcript
This edited transcript may contain spelling errors due to the technical nature of the content.
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


REP146.37 GARBALLEY146.37 -146.37 The146.37 chair146.61 will146.85 announce147.17 that147.73 the147.97 special148.21 committee148.61 of149.17 the149.33 house149.57 appointed150.13 at150.69 the150.85 sit-in151.33 on151.57 01/06/2025,151.89 relative155.06 to155.47 the155.63 qualification155.86 of156.66 Representative-elect157.63 Carol158.5 a158.91 Doherty,159.14 member160.03 elect160.42 from160.82 the161.14 Third161.31 Bristol161.54 District,162.1 had162.66 completed163.38 its163.94 assignment,164.19 and164.91 that165.14 representative165.78 Doherty166.58 had,167.06 on167.31 Wednesday,167.47 02/05/2025,168.1 taken170.88 and171.2 subscribed171.6 the172.4 necessary172.64 oath173.28 of173.6 office173.76 and174.56 was174.8 now174.96 duly175.36 qualified175.76 as176.64 a176.8 member176.96 of177.6 the177.76 House177.92 of178.24 Representatives.178.48
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


954.27 REP954.27 MICHLEWITZ954.27 -954.27 HB954.27 57954.27 -954.27 Thank954.27 you,954.59 Madam954.99 Speaker.955.23 And955.23 through955.31 you955.55 to955.63 the955.71 members,955.87 I956.83 rise956.99 in957.23 support957.39 of957.79 House957.95 Bill958.19 57,958.51 an959.31 act959.47 making960.27 supplemental960.59 appropriations961.23 for961.87 the962.03 fiscal962.19 year962.59 of962.83 2025.962.99 Since964.73 the964.96 fall965.2 of965.61 22,965.92 02/2022,966.73 the968.49 Commonwealth968.64 has969.2 attempted969.37 to969.76 mitigate969.85 the970.25 unprecedented970.49 strain971.28 the972 emergency972.25 shelter972.73 system973.13 has973.37 faced973.61 due973.85 to974 the974.16 increase974.33 in974.88 legal975.13 asylum-seeking976.25 migrants.976.64 We978.09 have978.25 done978.49 so978.57 with978.81 compassion979.13 and979.61 care979.77 while980.65 watching980.97 our981.29 federal981.45 partners981.85 do982.25 the982.41 opposite,982.57 pointing983.29 fingers983.69 and984.33 using984.57 this984.89 issue984.97 as985.29 a985.45 political985.53 football.985.93 The987.37 current987.61 right-to-shelter988.25 law988.65 has988.81 shown989.05 some989.29 benefits989.45 for989.85 the990.01 Commonwealth.990.09 We991.22 have991.38 watched991.54 our991.7 population991.86 increase992.58 for992.89 the993.06 first993.13 time993.38 this993.62 decade,993.77 and994.82 we994.98 have995.13 watched995.3 a995.54 number995.7 of995.93 industries996.1 alleviate997.13 their997.86 post-COVID998.42 workforce998.74 shortages,999.22 particularly999.86 in1000.34 the1000.5 healthcare1000.82 sector.1000.98 But1002.34 with1002.5 these1002.65 positive1002.89 impacts1003.38 have1004.35 also1004.59 come1004.83 some1005.07 serious1005.31 challenges,1005.71 ones1006.83 that1006.99 have1007.23 touched1007.39 upon1007.63 nearly1007.95 everyone's1008.27 district.1008.67 Because1010.03 of1010.35 the1010.43 advocacy1010.59 of1011.07 the1011.23 members1011.31 in1011.63 this1011.79 chamber,1012.03 it1012.83 has1012.99 been1013.15 this1013.31 house1013.55 who1013.95 has1014.19 attempted1014.35 to1014.75 take1014.83 initiative1015.07 on1015.95 com1016.11 on1016.35 combating1016.51 these1016.99 issues.1017.15

1017.15 Whether1018.25 it1018.49 was1018.57 originally1019.29 ensuring1019.76 that1020.16 overflow1020.4 shelters1020.88 were1021.29 put1021.45 in1021.61 place1021.76 or1022.64 originally1023.04 proposing1023.52 to1024.01 limit1024.09 the1024.4 length1024.48 of1024.81 stay1024.88 for1025.2 families1025.37 in1025.68 the1025.85 system.1025.92 And1027.29 every1027.44 time1027.68 we1027.92 have1028.01 done1028.16 so,1028.4 we1028.96 have1029.13 warned1029.29 that1029.61 the1029.85 system1029.92 is1030.24 in1030.4 danger1030.48 of1030.81 collapsing1030.96 under1031.44 its1031.68 own1031.92 weight1032.09 due1033.01 to1033.17 that1033.33 federal1033.65 inaction1033.97 and1034.77 complacency1035.01 on1035.65 the1035.81 immigration1035.97 issue.1036.45 Now1038.21 with1038.45 the1038.69 chaos1038.77 that1039.17 continues1039.33 to1039.73 surround1039.81 Washington1040.21 and1041.41 with1041.57 the1041.81 Commonwealth's1041.89 fiscal1042.45 constraints1042.77 growing,1043.33 we1044.05 are1044.21 quickly1044.45 approaching1044.93 the1045.41 breaking1045.57 point.1045.97 There1047.34 has1047.49 been1047.65 mismanagement,1047.89 fiscal1049.1 financial1049.82 challenges,1050.46 and1051.82 dire1052.13 public1052.54 safety1052.93 concerns.1053.26 Last1055.1 month,1055.41 acting1056.06 upon1056.3 questions1056.62 that1057.02 many1057.26 members1057.49 of1057.82 the1057.89 house1058.06 have1058.3 asked,1058.46 my1059.37 office1059.61 sent1059.85 the1060.01 administration1060.25 a1060.73 number1060.89 of1061.13 detailed1061.21 questions1061.61 regarding1062.09 the1062.41 emergency1062.65 shelter1063.21 system.1063.53 The1064.97 administration1065.29 was1065.69 able1065.85 to1066.09 provide1066.17 clarity1066.49 on1066.89 some1067.13 issues,1067.45 and1067.85 we1068.01 will1068.17 continue1068.41 to1068.73 work1068.89 with1069.13 them1069.29 to1069.61 get1069.77 further1069.93 answers1070.25 to1070.57 all1070.73 your1070.97 questions.1071.13 But1072.58 in1072.69 the1072.82 meantime,1073.05 with1073.93 concerns1074.26 continuing1074.65 to1075.13 mount1075.29 and1076.1 the1076.26 funding1076.41 for1076.82 this1076.97 program1077.13 running1077.53 out,1077.86 we1078.34 must1078.58 act.1078.82 Contained1080.34 in1080.73 this1080.89 bill1081.05 are1081.77 a1081.93 number1082.1 of1082.34 reforms,1082.49 many1083.21 of1083.45 which1083.53 Her1083.93 Excellency1084.41 the1084.41 Governor1084.58 has1084.89 asked1085.05 for1085.29 herself.1085.45

1085.45 Some1087.18 of1087.42 you1087.5 will1087.66 think1087.82 these1087.98 reforms1088.22 go1088.62 too1088.86 far.1088.94 Others1090.14 will1090.46 say1090.62 we1090.78 do1090.94 not1091.1 go1091.26 far1091.42 enough.1091.66 And1092.7 that1092.86 is1093.02 fair1093.18 because1093.5 this1093.74 is1093.9 not1094.06 a1094.22 particularly1094.3 easy1094.78 issue.1095.02 However,1096.22 as1097.18 someone1097.42 who1097.66 has1097.82 been1097.98 looking1098.14 at1098.38 this1098.54 program1098.7 for1099.1 years1099.34 now,1099.66 I1100.2 can1100.37 say1100.61 we1100.68 must1100.92 make1101.16 these1101.33 changes.1101.57 Otherwise,1103.24 the1103.88 very1104.04 existence1104.28 of1104.85 the1104.92 Commonwealth's1105.09 cherished1105.8 right1106.2 to1106.37 shelter1106.52 legacy1107.01 will1107.48 be1107.64 put1107.8 in1107.96 serious1108.2 jeopardy.1108.61 This1110.68 bill1111.01 proposes1111.24 spending1111.72 425,000,0001112.04 on1113.24 the1113.4 shelter1113.48 program1113.88 to1114.2 fund1114.37 it1114.52 for1114.61 the1114.77 remainder1114.92 of1115.24 the1115.33 fiscal1115.48 year.1115.8 Accompanying1117.62 the1118.1 funding1118.34 contained1118.9 in1119.38 this1119.54 bill1119.7 is1120.02 at1120.26 the1120.34 governor's1120.5 request1120.9 a1121.3 verification1121.46 process1122.1 for1122.5 those1122.66 coming1122.9 into1123.14 the1123.38 system.1123.54 Families1125.14 entering1125.62 the1125.94 program1126.02 must1126.42 verify1126.66 eligibility1127.06 before1127.7 enrolling1128.1 in1128.66 the1128.82 EA1129.06 system1129.46 to1129.86 confirm1130.26 qualifications,1130.74 which1131.93 will1132.1 prioritize1132.26 the1132.82 safety1133.05 and1133.45 security1133.78 of1134.26 the1134.34 shelters.1134.41 The1136.17 right1136.41 to1136.65 shelter1136.73 law1137.05 has1137.21 been1137.38 in1137.54 existence1137.69 since1138.17 1983,1138.41 and1139.29 we1139.54 wanna1139.62 be1139.86 able1140.02 to1140.17 preserve1140.26 the1140.65 benefits1140.73 and1141.13 integrity1141.29 of1141.78 the1141.86 program1142.02 while1142.58 being1142.82 fiscally1143.05 responsible.1143.54 To1145.48 be1145.64 able1145.72 to1145.96 effectively1146.12 do1146.6 this,1146.84 the1147.48 Executive1147.64 Office1148.12 of1148.44 Housing1148.6 and1148.92 Livable1149 Communities1149.4 needs1150.12 to1150.28 be1150.44 able1150.6 to1150.84 verify1151 residency1151.48 immediately1152.04 at1153.16 intake1153.32 for1153.8 each1153.96 applicant,1154.2 rather1154.84 than1155.16 waiting1155.32 301155.64 days1155.88 after1156.2 benefits1156.52 have1156.84 started.1157.08

1157.08 Benefits1158.73 will1159.13 be1159.37 provided1159.53 only1159.92 to1160.16 families1160.33 who1160.64 are1160.81 of1160.97 any1161.05 of1161.21 the1161.37 following,1161.53 residents1162.16 of1162.48 Massachusetts1162.81 and1163.37 are1163.61 United1163.77 States1164.01 citizens,1164.33 persons1165.37 lawfully1165.92 admitted1166.4 for1166.81 permanent1166.97 residence,1167.45 or1168.64 otherwise1168.88 permanently1169.45 right1170.09 residing1170.33 under1170.73 the1170.97 color1171.05 of1171.37 law1171.45 in1171.61 The1171.77 United1171.85 States.1172.16 The1173.61 bill1173.85 authorizes1174.17 HLC1174.97 to1175.53 allow1175.69 an1176.01 exemption1176.17 in1176.57 cases1177.21 where1177.77 a1178.09 child1178.25 in1178.81 the1178.89 family1179.05 is1179.37 a1179.45 citizen1179.61 of1179.81 The1180.01 United1180.09 States,1180.41 a1181.13 person1181.37 lawfully1181.69 admitted,1182.25 or1182.81 a1182.97 person1183.05 permanently1183.45 residing1184.01 under1184.57 the1184.81 color1184.89 of1185.21 law.1185.29 In1186.73 order1186.89 to1187.21 ensure1187.38 families1187.86 have1188.26 a1188.49 place1188.58 to1188.82 go1188.97 while1189.62 they1189.93 are1190.1 in1190.17 the1190.34 verification1190.49 process,1191.21 the1192.41 temporary1192.58 respite1193.05 sites,1193.45 what1194.41 were1194.58 once1194.82 known1195.13 as1195.53 overflow1195.77 shelters,1196.34 will1196.82 now1197.05 be1197.29 open1197.45 to1197.69 all1197.86 families1198.1 for1198.65 301198.89 days1199.21 while1199.78 they1199.94 are1200.1 attempting1200.18 to1200.58 get1200.74 approval1200.9 into1201.38 the1201.62 system1201.78 or1202.26 if1202.42 they1202.58 decide1202.74 to1203.06 make1203.22 other1203.46 plans.1203.62 HLC1205.46 may1205.94 offer1206.18 a1206.42 case-specific1206.9 waiver1207.46 for1208.02 acute1208.26 circumstances,1210.5 which1211.62 would1211.78 extend1212.02 to1212.34 qualified1212.58 veterans1213.79 or1214.27 someone1214.51 experiencing1215.07 imminent1215.55 threat1216.03 of1216.83 domestic1217.07 violence.1217.47 Once1219.95 families1220.35 are1220.66 in1220.83 the1220.9 shelter1221.07 system,1221.38 the1222.03 bill1222.18 would1222.35 also1222.59 reduce1222.83 the1223.14 maximum1223.23 length1223.63 of1223.87 stay1224.03 in1224.35 the1224.51 EA1224.66 shelter1224.98 from1225.63 nine1225.87 months1226.11 to1226.42 six1226.59 consecutive1226.9 months.1227.38

1227.38 The1228.92 ability1229.08 for1229.4 HLC1229.56 to1230.04 provide1230.12 hardship1230.44 waivers1230.84 after1231.16 six1231.4 months1231.64 would1231.88 also1232.04 be1232.2 maintained.1232.44 On1233.96 safety1234.2 concerns,1234.52 the1235.72 bill1235.96 will1236.12 permanently1236.36 require1236.84 each1237.32 individual1237.48 applicant1238.04 or1238.52 beneficiary1238.68 of1239.72 the1239.8 of1240.12 the1240.28 emergency1240.44 housing1240.84 program1241.08 assistance1241.48 program1241.96 to1242.63 disclose1242.88 all1243.43 prior1243.76 criminal1244.08 convictions1244.48 in1244.96 Massachusetts1245.12 in1245.91 any1246.08 other1246.32 jurisdiction,1246.56 while1247.84 exempting1248.24 from1248.72 disclosure1249.04 prior1249.67 convictions1249.91 that1250.39 have1250.56 been1250.63 sealed1250.8 or1251.12 expunged.1251.28 It1252.88 also1253.12 requires1253.43 CORI1253.84 checks1254.15 for1254.39 each1254.56 individual1254.8 adult1255.28 applicant1255.67 or1256.08 beneficiary1256.24 prior1256.88 to1257.12 placement1257.28 in1257.76 the1257.84 program.1257.99 The1259.73 bill1259.97 maintain1260.29 mandates,1260.77 excuse1261.41 me,1261.73 HLC1262.29 to1262.77 permanently1263.01 require1263.41 each1263.81 adult1264.05 applicant1264.45 or1265.01 beneficiary1265.25 that1265.81 joins1266.05 the1266.37 family1266.45 to1267.17 provide1267.33 notice,1267.73 allowing1268.37 HLC1268.85 the1269.33 ability1269.49 to1269.81 verify1269.97 the1270.37 individual's1270.53 eligibility1271.09 for1271.73 the1271.97 program.1272.05 If1273.8 there1273.96 is1274.13 a1274.2 failure1274.37 to1274.68 report1274.85 the1275.16 necessary1275.33 information1275.72 for1276.13 complete1276.37 verification,1276.68 the1277.72 applicant1277.96 or1278.37 beneficiary1278.61 will1279.16 no1279.33 longer1279.48 be1279.8 eligible1279.96 for1280.37 benefits,1280.53 and1280.85 existing1281.09 benefits1281.57 will1281.88 be1282.04 terminated.1282.2 In1283.8 order1284.04 to1284.29 make1284.44 this1284.61 program1284.77 more1285.16 manageable,1285.4 we1285.88 are1286.04 proposing1286.2 a1286.61 temporary1286.68 cap1287.16 of1288.6 the1288.76 total1288.84 capacity1289.24 in1289.72 the1289.88 system1290.04 to1290.44 4,0001290.68 families1291.24 by1291.56 the1291.72 end1291.88 of1292.04 the1292.12 calendar1292.2 year1292.6 2025.1292.84

1294.76 As1294.76 of1295 the1295.16 end1295.32 of1295.48 this1295.64 January,1295.96 there1296.68 were1296.84 approximately1297.08 6,1001297.64 families1298.36 in1298.68 the1298.84 system,1298.92 down1299.32 from1299.56 a1299.72 high1299.88 of1300.04 7,7001300.28 families1301.08 towards1301.4 the1301.72 end1301.8 of1301.96 last1302.12 year.1302.36 In1303.88 conclusion,1304.13 through1304.77 careful1305.09 consideration,1305.4 I1306.29 feel1306.45 this1306.61 is1306.85 the1306.92 most1307.09 viable1307.24 path1307.64 moving1307.88 forward.1308.2 The1309.4 program1309.64 ballooned1310.05 beyond1310.45 anyone's1310.77 imagination1311.09 and1311.72 the1311.96 influx1312.13 has1312.45 overwhelmed1312.68 our1313.16 capacities.1313.33 With1314.77 no1315.01 relief1315.16 from1315.48 Washington1315.72 in1316.2 sight1316.37 and1316.73 with1316.97 every1317.13 federal1317.37 assistance1317.77 dollar1318.25 now1318.57 in1318.73 question,1318.89 we1319.53 are1319.69 left1319.85 with1320.09 no1320.25 choice1320.41 but1320.73 to1320.89 put1320.97 temporary1321.29 restraints1321.69 on1322.09 the1322.17 emergency1322.33 shelter1322.89 assistance1323.45 program.1323.93 Otherwise,1325.29 we1325.69 will1325.85 be1326.01 forced1326.09 to1326.33 consider1326.49 the1326.81 unthinkable,1326.89 potentially1327.69 ending1328.17 the1328.57 right1328.65 to1328.89 shelter1328.97 completely.1329.37 By1330.96 making1331.28 these1331.52 temporary1331.76 adjustments,1332.23 we1332.8 ensure1333.04 the1333.36 sustainability1333.52 of1334.08 the1334.23 right-to-shelter1334.63 law1334.96 for1335.12 years1335.28 to1335.6 come.1335.67 We1336.63 do1336.88 not1336.96 make1337.2 this1337.28 proposal1337.52 lightly,1337.99 but1338.96 as1339.2 one1339.28 we1339.52 feel1339.67 is1339.91 very1340.23 necessary1340.47 to1340.88 uphold1341.04 the1341.36 fiscal1341.43 health1341.84 of1341.99 the1342.08 Commonwealth.1342.23 Thank1343.33 you,1343.49 Mr.1344.05 Speaker.1344.37 And1344.37 when1344.61 this1344.77 matter1344.85 is1345.09 taken,1345.33 I1345.73 ask1345.89 for1346.05 a1346.13 call1346.21 of1346.33 the1346.45 ayes1346.61 and1346.77 nays.1346.93
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


1375.83 REP1375.83 MARIANO1375.83 -1375.83 The1375.83 chair1376.15 would1376.47 like1376.63 to1376.87 take1377.03 this1377.35 moment1377.51 to1378.79 introduce1379.11 a1379.67 very1379.75 special1380.07 guest1380.55 to1381.75 the1381.99 left1382.15 of1382.47 the1382.63 rostrum1385.71 a1385.71 guest1385.87 of1386.18 Mr.1386.35 Moran1386.74 of1387.31 Lawrence.1387.55 He1390.27 would1390.51 like1390.66 to1390.9 introduce1391.07 the1391.63 former1391.79 mayor1392.18 and1392.59 that1394.27 we1396.51 screwed1396.74 this1397.07 up.1397.38 You1402.26 are1402.42 not1402.66 the1402.82 former1403.06 mayor1403.38 of1403.7 Lawrence.1403.86 This1408.9 is1409.22 what1409.3 happens1409.54 when1409.86 you1410.1 don't1410.18 rehearse1410.42 for1410.82 a1411.06 year.1411.14 We'd1412.74 like1412.98 to1413.14 introduce1413.3 the1414.34 former1414.5 mayor1415.64 and1415.96 the1416.2 city1416.37 councilor1416.68 of1417.09 Lawrence,1417.24 Mr.1417.88 Kendris1418.28 Vasquez,1418.85 and1419.88 his1420.13 family.1420.37 Mister1421.4 Vasquez1421.8 and1422.28 his1422.44 son,1422.61 EMEA,1423.01 spend1424.2 their1424.52 time1424.76 raising1425.48 awareness1425.96 of1427.16 TSWS,1427.48 or1430.49 tropical1430.65 steroid1431.37 withdrawal1432.25 syndrome,1433.85 a1435.21 severe1435.53 skin1436.09 condition1436.57 that1437.69 results1438.01 from1439.21 exposure1439.61 to1440.89 topical1441.21 steroids.1442.01 Despite1444.04 living1444.52 with1444.84 the1445.08 syndrome1445.24 himself,1445.8 the1447.48 6-year-old1448.2 Amir1448.43 is1449.48 an1449.63 outspoken1449.96 advocate1451.24 beyond1452.76 his1453.39 years.1453.72 Due1455.56 to1455.88 the1456.04 hard1456.2 work1456.43 of1456.67 the1456.84 Vasquez1456.99 family1457.56 from1458.41 this1458.65 day1458.81 forward,1459.29 February1460.57 31461.22 is1462.01 now1462.25 recognized1462.57 as1464.41 TSWS1465.21 Awareness1466.97 Day1467.61 in1468.25 the1468.41 Commonwealth1468.65 of1469.21 Massachusetts.1469.53 Congratulations,1471.1 Eimer,1472.21 for1472.62 your1472.78 success.1472.93 Now1502.21 get1502.45 to1502.78 City1502.86 Hall1503.1 and1503.34 take1503.49 out1503.65 papers1503.89 against1504.3 Moran.1504.69
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


1747.95 REP1747.95 JONES1747.95 JR.1747.95 -1747.95 Thank1747.95 you,1748.18 Madam1748.66 Speaker.1748.98 Through1748.98 the1749.07 members,1749.22 I1749.55 would1749.63 ask1749.79 that1750.03 when1750.11 a1750.18 vote1750.27 is1750.51 taken1750.59 of1750.83 this1750.98 matter,1751.07 it'd1751.22 be1751.31 taken1751.46 by1751.71 a1751.87 call1751.95 of1752.11 the1752.18 yays1752.27 and1752.51 nays.1752.66
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


1770.74 JONES1770.74 JR1770.74 -1770.74 AMENDMENT1770.74 61770.74 -1770.74 Thank1770.74 you,1770.98 Madam1771.46 Speaker,1771.78 and1771.78 to1771.94 the1772.1 members.1772.26 And1772.66 I1772.82 appreciate,1772.98 the1773.7 remarks1773.86 of1774.42 the1775.35 chair1775.51 of1775.66 Ways1775.74 and1775.98 Means,1776.14 relatives1776.95 to1777.35 some1777.51 of1777.59 the1777.66 things1778.38 that1778.71 they've1778.79 included,1779.11 in1780.31 this1780.55 version1780.87 of1781.98 emergency1782.38 assistance1783.03 funding.1783.98 And1785.35 I1785.51 would1785.66 agree1785.83 with1786.07 him.1786.14 I1786.38 know1786.46 there's1786.63 a1786.74 there's1786.87 a1787.18 discussion1787.35 between1787.74 his1788.07 caucus1788.31 this1788.63 morning.1788.87 You1789.44 know,1789.52 does1789.6 this1789.84 go1789.92 too1790.16 far?1790.32 Does1790.64 it1790.8 not1790.88 go1791.12 far1791.2 enough?1791.36 And1791.6 been1791.68 a1791.84 debate1791.92 we've1792.16 been1792.4 going,1792.48 obviously,1792.64 from1793.28 the1793.6 side1793.68 of1793.92 the1794 aisle1794.16 that1794.4 thinks1794.56 we1794.8 need1794.88 to1795.04 go1795.12 a1795.28 little1795.36 further,1795.52 and1796.4 that1796.56 we're1796.72 starting1796.96 today1797.28 where1797.52 we1797.68 probably1797.84 should1798.08 have1798.24 started1798.4 a1798.72 couple1798.8 years1799.04 ago.1799.28 And1800.24 this1800.4 amendment1800.64 focuses1801.12 on1801.52 one1801.68 area,1801.84 which1802.55 is1802.63 the1802.76 issue1802.88 of1803.12 background1803.19 checks.1803.6 It's1803.84 gotten1804.08 a1804.32 lot1804.39 of1804.63 attention1804.79 lately1805.12 because,1805.52 in1806.71 early1806.88 January,1807.19 the1807.67 governor1807.84 came1808.32 out1808.55 and1808.71 was1808.88 forced1809.43 to1809.76 admit1809.91 something1810.23 that1810.47 she1810.63 had1810.79 let1811.04 us1811.19 all1811.36 to1811.6 believe1811.67 was1811.91 happening.1812.15 Something1812.79 that1813.12 she1813.28 directed1813.43 to1813.84 happen,1813.99 which1814.23 is1814.47 background1814.63 checks,1815.12 at1815.98 least1816.14 at1816.3 the1816.46 most1816.54 basic1816.78 level,1817.18 were1817.74 happening1817.98 routinely.1818.38 And1819.58 it1819.74 turns1819.9 out,1820.14 she1821.34 was1821.5 mistaken.1821.66 They1822.22 weren't1822.38 happening.1822.54

1823.82 And1823.82 I1823.98 appreciate1824.14 that1824.54 the1824.78 chair1824.86 has1825.1 now1825.26 added1825.58 some1825.82 language1827.18 in1827.58 here,1827.82 essentially,1828.06 in1828.66 one1828.9 instance,1829.07 allowing1829.38 for1829.71 self1829.95 attestation1830.35 whether1830.9 you1831.23 have1831.31 any1831.55 kind1831.71 of1831.87 a1831.95 criminal1832.03 background,1832.42 criminal1833.31 convictions,1833.63 and1834.42 then1834.66 a1834.98 basic1835.23 level1835.63 sort1836.42 of1836.59 quarry1836.66 check,1837.14 the1838.59 kind,1838.74 you1838.98 know,1839.14 you1839.31 might1839.38 get1839.55 if1839.71 you're1839.87 a1840.03 mom1840.11 and1840.27 dad1840.42 going1840.59 on1840.83 a1840.9 field1841.07 trip1841.23 or1841.47 coaching1841.79 your1842.42 son1842.66 or1842.9 daughter's1843.07 team.1843.55 We1844.49 think1844.65 that1844.97 that1845.29 needs1845.45 to1845.77 go1845.85 further.1846.01 Because1847.37 oftentimes,1847.93 you1848.57 may1848.73 be1848.97 someone1849.05 who's1849.37 been1850.25 found1850.65 guilty1850.89 of1851.29 crimes1851.53 beyond1851.93 the1852.25 jurisdiction1852.41 of1852.81 the1852.89 Commonwealth1852.97 of1853.37 Massachusetts,1853.53 either1854.65 in1855.05 the1855.53 country,1855.69 or1856.84 internationally.1857.08 You've1858.19 seen1858.36 some1858.6 of1858.76 the1858.84 cases1858.91 where1859.23 some1859.47 people1859.63 have1859.88 been1860.03 apprehended1860.84 that1861.32 have1861.47 Interpol1861.71 read1862.12 notices.1862.36 Something1863.88 I1864.28 don't1864.36 think1864.52 you1864.76 achieve1864.91 easily,1865.32 and1866.36 something1866.6 that1866.91 I1867.15 think1867.23 if1867.39 we1867.55 can1867.63 determine1868.12 upfront1868.84 would1869.32 be1869.55 helpful.1869.71 And1870.74 I'm1870.82 sorry,1870.98 I1871.3 don't1871.38 think1871.54 a1871.86 lot1872.02 relying1872.34 on1872.74 self-attestation,1873.46 even1875.46 for1875.78 I1875.94 understand1876.18 many1876.58 well-intended1877.06 people,1877.46 we're1877.7 also1877.94 dealing1878.18 with1878.5 some1878.66 people1878.9 that1879.14 have1879.46 ill1879.7 intention.1879.94 I1880.58 don't1880.74 feel1880.9 comfortable1881.14 relying1881.7 on1882.02 that,1882.18 nor1882.9 the1883.14 simple1883.22 basic1883.54 core1883.86 check-in1884.18 Massachusetts.1884.5 So1885.55 while1885.79 I1885.95 appreciate1886.03 that1886.51 the1886.74 chair1887.31 Ways1887.79 and1887.79 Means1887.95 has1888.11 included1888.27 some1888.74 items1888.9 in1889.07 this,1889.23 I1889.63 think1889.79 we1889.95 need1890.03 to1890.18 go1890.27 a1890.42 little1890.51 further.1890.66 That's1891.14 what1891.31 this1891.47 amendment1891.63 seeks1892.03 to1892.27 do1892.35 by1892.51 expanding1892.74 the1893.31 kind1893.47 of1893.63 background1893.71 check1894.11 that1894.27 we1894.35 would1894.51 do.1894.66 Thank1894.9 you,1895.07 Madam1895.63 Speaker.1895.63
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


1917.43 REP1917.43 DAY-1917.43 AMENDMENT1917.43 61917.43 -1917.43 Thank1917.43 you,1917.76 Madam1918.32 Speaker.1918.63 And1918.63 through1918.8 you1918.95 to1919.12 the1919.19 members,1919.36 madam1919.91 speaker,1920.23 I1920.63 rise1920.88 in1921.36 opposition1921.6 to1923.28 this,1923.43 amendment.1924.08 As1925.19 we1925.43 all1925.6 know,1925.76 the1925.91 emergency1926.08 shelter1926.63 system1927.04 is1927.6 set1927.84 up1928.08 for1928.23 families1928.47 with1929.82 young1930.14 children1930.38 and1931.18 pregnant1931.5 women1931.98 who,1932.86 perhaps1933.34 not1933.74 surprisingly,1933.98 face1934.7 immediate1935.02 and1935.5 emergency1935.66 shelter1936.38 needs.1936.78 Under1939.02 this1939.26 amendment1939.5 I1940.22 pardon1941.02 me.1941.34 Under1941.58 our1941.9 bill1942.06 as1942.3 proposed,1942.46 we1943.38 now1943.62 move1943.78 to1944.02 require1944.26 rudimentary1944.89 criminal1945.46 background1945.86 checks1946.26 on1946.58 applicants1946.73 given1947.78 the1948.02 abuses1948.1 perpetrated1948.82 by1949.3 individuals1949.46 recently1950.1 who1950.49 frankly1950.65 should1951.38 not1951.54 have1951.78 been1951.93 in1952.1 those1952.26 shelters1952.49 to1953.06 begin1953.22 with.1953.46 So1955.22 we're1955.38 moving1955.62 to1955.86 ensure1956.1 the1956.41 safety1956.58 of1956.98 our1957.13 shelter1957.3 residents1957.7 through1958.28 the1958.52 underlying1958.68 bill1959.08 today.1959.32 This1960.36 amendment,1960.6 reportedly1962.6 to1963.16 further1963.4 ensure1963.96 the1964.36 safety1964.52 of1964.84 these1965 residents,1965.16 wants1966.04 to1966.28 know1966.44 now1966.76 about1967 the1967.24 educational1967.4 history1967.96 of1969.32 a1969.4 pregnant1969.48 woman1969.88 trying1970.52 to1970.76 get1970.84 into1971 a1971.24 shelter1971.32 before1972.64 admitting1972.96 them1973.29 into1973.44 emergency1973.68 shelter.1974.24

1975.2 Now1975.2 we1975.44 wanna1975.61 find1975.92 out1976.09 the1976.33 creditworthiness1976.57 of1978.48 a1978.64 young1978.8 family1979.05 applying1979.77 for1980.01 emergency1980.33 shelter.1980.8 That's1981.37 gonna1981.68 make1981.92 the1982.09 shelters1982.24 and1982.96 the1983.13 residents1983.2 safer.1983.85 Finding1984.48 out1984.8 what1984.96 Coles1985.13 thinks1985.44 about1986.16 the1986.4 ability1986.48 to1986.88 get1986.96 a1987.13 credit1987.2 card.1987.53 I1988.62 can1988.78 probably1988.94 alleviate1989.58 some1989.98 of1990.14 the1990.22 uncertainty1990.38 the1991.26 support1991.5 of1991.74 this1991.9 amendment1992.06 may1992.38 have.1992.62 Since1993.42 we've1993.66 got1993.9 a1994.06 young1994.14 family1994.38 applying1994.7 for1994.94 emergency1995.18 shelter1995.58 and1995.98 assistance,1996.06 I1997.02 can1997.26 provide1997.42 you1997.74 with1997.82 some1997.98 assurances1998.22 that1998.7 that1998.94 party1999.1 is1999.5 probably1999.66 not2000.22 what2000.54 you'd2000.7 call2001.02 credit-worthy.2001.66 That's2002.22 why2002.46 they're2002.62 seeking2002.86 emergency2003.18 shelter.2003.74 I'd2004.42 say,2004.66 let's2004.83 call2005.07 this2005.3 for2005.54 what2005.63 it2005.87 is.2005.94 We're2006.59 going2006.9 beyond2007.14 background2007.94 checks2008.35 here,2008.66 and2009.46 it's2009.63 an2009.87 attempt2010.51 to2010.9 background2011.14 and2011.87 backdoor2012.11 strangle2012.74 our2013.46 emergency2013.7 shelter2014.18 law2014.59 altogether,2014.74 attempt2015.46 to2015.94 kill2016.11 it2016.35 from2016.51 within,2016.74 a2017.54 way2017.78 to2017.86 put2017.94 up2018.1 hurdles2018.26 that2018.58 have2018.82 nothing2018.98 to2019.22 do2019.38 with2019.94 helping2020.18 out2020.58 a2020.9 pregnant2020.98 woman2021.38 or2021.94 a2022.18 young2022.26 family2022.5 facing2023.22 the2023.54 most2023.62 significant2023.86 challenges2024.5 they2025.06 are2025.22 gonna2025.3 face2025.54 in2025.78 their2025.94 life2026.1 to2026.74 kill2026.9 the2027.3 EA2027.54 program.2027.86 I2028.66 urge2028.74 you2028.98 to2029.14 vote2029.22 against2029.54 this2029.94 amendment.2030.18 Thank2030.98 you.2031.22 Madam2032.82 Speaker.2035.45
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


REP2039.21 FROST2039.21 -2039.21 AMENDMENT2039.21 62039.21 -2039.21 Thank2039.21 you,2039.45 Madam2040.1 Speaker,2040.34 and2040.34 through2040.49 you2040.65 to2040.73 the2040.89 members.2040.97 Look.2042.41 This2042.73 amendment,2042.97 all2043.62 it's2043.77 intending2044.01 to2044.65 do2044.73 is2045.93 say,2046.17 look.2046.49 We're2047.73 gonna2047.81 have2048.13 a2048.21 background2048.45 check2048.93 that2049.41 goes2049.57 beyond2049.89 just2050.85 the2051.17 state2051.25 of2051.41 Massachusetts.2051.57 If2052.61 we're2052.85 going2053.09 to2053.49 have2053.65 a2054.05 program,2054.29 okay,2056.05 that's2056.45 taking2056.77 in2057.09 thousands2058.37 and2058.85 thousands2059.01 and2059.41 thousands2059.57 of2060.05 folks2060.13 from2061.28 outside2061.53 the2062.09 state2062.32 of2062.57 Massachusetts,2062.72 a2064.32 simple2064.57 CORI2064.89 check2065.28 isn't2065.61 gonna2065.92 be2066.16 enough.2066.32 We2067.28 need2067.44 a2067.61 more2067.76 universal2068.09 background2068.64 check2069.05 to2070.16 see2070.41 what2071.61 these2072.01 individuals2072.24 and2072.89 their2073.05 families2073.28 that2074.48 are2074.64 coming2074.8 with2075.13 them,2075.28 if2076.33 they2076.49 have2076.57 any2078.49 violent2078.73 history2079.53 or2080.01 what2080.25 have2080.41 you,2080.65 in2082.09 another2082.33 state2082.81 or2083.45 from2083.69 another2083.93 country.2084.25 It2085.37 makes2085.61 perfect2086.33 sense2086.89 for2087.85 us2088.09 to2088.73 have2088.97 this2089.45 kind2089.69 of2090.01 check2090.09 because2090.91 we've2090.99 all2091.23 read2091.32 the2091.64 headlines,2091.8 we2092.2 know2092.36 what's2092.51 happening,2092.84 we2093.39 need2093.64 to2093.8 do2093.88 better.2094.03 Thank2094.43 you,2094.68 Madam2095.32
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


2120.09 REP2120.09 LIVINGSTONE2120.09 -2120.09 AMENDMENT2120.09 62120.09 -2120.09 To2120.09 deal2120.24 with2120.41 the2122.01 situation2122.72 that2123.2 we've2123.45 all2123.76 heard2124.01 of.2124.24 And2124.49 I2124.64 appreciate2124.89 the2125.93 gentleman2126.09 from2126.49 the2126.64 North2126.72 End2126.97 remarks,2128.16 the2128.8 gentleman2128.97 from2129.28 Stoner's2129.53 remarks,2130.01 to2131.61 that2131.84 effect.2132.09 I2132.93 think2133.09 the2134.69 the2134.93 check2135.01 that2135.33 we're2135.49 requiring2136.45 the2136.93 administration2137.09 to2137.73 do2137.81 is2138.61 a2138.85 standard2139.01 check2139.41 that2139.73 we2139.97 use2140.21 across2141.09 our2141.49 government2141.65 system2142.21 in2143.25 our2143.49 courts,2143.73 for2145.17 various2145.41 programs,2145.81 and2146.45 I2146.69 think2146.77 it's2146.93 the2147.17 appropriate2147.33 check.2147.81 I2148.26 think2148.41 the2148.65 the2149.45 amendment,2149.53 from2150.57 the2150.82 gentleman2150.97 from2151.38 the,2152.09 from2153.45 Redding2153.69 is,2154.57 goes2156.09 too2156.34 far2156.57 as2157.21 was2157.61 pointed2157.86 out,2158.26 requiring2159.13 much2159.69 more2160.01 information2160.26 regarding2160.89 creditworthiness2161.38 and2162.26 others2162.41 that2163.25 are2163.49 not2163.65 gonna2163.81 be2164.05 helpful2164.13 on2164.85 whether2165.01 or2165.25 not2165.33 somebody2165.49 should2165.81 enter2166.05 a2166.45 shelter.2166.61 Thank2167.65 you.2167.89
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


2594.59 REP2594.59 HOGAN2594.59 -2594.59 Time2594.59 for2594.84 voting2595.07 has2595.39 expired.2595.64 The2596.03 clerk2596.28 will2596.52 display2596.68 the2597.07 tally2597.32 on2598.76 this2598.99 matter.2599.24 262600.78 in2601.42 the2601.66 affirmative.2601.9 1252602.78 in2604.3 the2604.62 negative.2604.78 The2605.9 amendment2606.14 is2606.94 not2607.18 adopted.2607.5
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


2692.74 REP2692.74 MURADIAN2692.74 JR.2692.74 -2692.74 AMENDMENT2692.74 82692.74 -2692.74 Thank2692.74 you,2692.91 Madam2693.39 Speaker,2693.7 and2693.7 through2693.95 you2694.18 to2694.27 the2694.43 members.2694.59 I2695.47 am2695.63 grateful2695.79 to2696.27 see2696.43 some2696.74 of2696.91 the2697.14 Republican-led2698.03 reforms2698.34 being2698.91 championed2699.14 by2699.63 the2699.79 governor2699.95 and2700.66 included2700.91 in2701.3 this2701.47 bill.2701.63 For2702.51 a2702.82 year2702.91 plus,2703.14 we2703.47 in2703.63 the2703.79 minority2703.86 party2704.43 have2704.99 been2705.22 speaking2705.39 about2705.79 the2706.03 unsustainable2706.27 nature2707.22 of2707.91 the2708.07 shelter2708.23 system2708.71 and2709.19 how2709.43 it2709.67 needs2709.83 meaningful2710.15 change.2710.71 Amendment2711.59 82712.07 would2712.23 continue2712.47 this2712.95 meaningful2713.27 change,2713.75 moving2714.79 the2715.11 allocation2715.35 of2715.83 funding2715.91 from2716.31 425,000,0002716.55 to2718.23 200,000,000.2718.47 It2719.75 has2719.91 been2720.07 widely2720.31 reported,2721.03 including2721.83 by2722.39 the2722.55 Center2722.71 for2723.57 Immigration2723.82 Studies,2724.38 that2725.34 Massachusetts2725.57 is2726.38 anticipating2726.61 spending2727.66 over2727.97 $1,800,000,0002728.3 on2730.14 the2730.3 shelter2730.45 system2730.86 in2731.41 the2731.49 next2731.66 two2732.05 years.2732.22 These2733.02 numbers2733.26 come2733.66 at2733.82 a2733.97 time2734.05 when2734.3 I2734.54 know2734.7 that2734.86 my2735.18 local2735.34 school2735.74 districts,2735.97 and2736.63 I2736.79 would2736.95 say2737.11 all2737.35 of2737.59 our2737.75 local2737.91 school2738.23 districts,2738.47 are2739.27 in2739.43 desperate2739.59 need2740.07 of2740.23 additional2740.47 funds.2740.95 Education,2741.99 public2742.79 safety,2743.35 infrastructure,2743.91 these2745.11 are2745.35 few2745.43 of2745.67 the2745.75 needs2745.91 that2746.15 run2746.31 the2746.55 risk2746.71 of2747.43 being2747.67 funded2747.99 non2748.79 adequately2749.11 if2749.91 we2750.07 continue2750.22 spending2750.55 the2750.95 shelter2751.11 system2751.59 as2752.07 we2752.3 have.2752.47

2753.27 However,2753.27 adjusting2754.14 the2754.63 number2754.7 to2755.03 200,000,0002755.27 for2756.3 the2756.55 shelter2756.7 program2757.18 would2757.91 provide2758.14 a2758.55 much2758.7 sounder2759.11 approach.2759.51 Please2760.63 allow2760.95 me2761.27 for2761.43 a2761.59 minute2761.66 to2761.99 outline2762.14 the2762.55 reasons2762.7 as2763.38 I2763.54 believe2763.7 we2764.02 can2764.18 all2764.34 agree2764.58 that2764.82 they're2765.06 quite2765.3 practical.2765.62 The2766.9 auditor2767.22 herself2767.7 has2768.18 mentioned2768.42 of2769.14 an2769.22 audit2769.46 of2769.86 the2770.02 executive2770.18 office2770.74 of2771.06 housing2771.22 and2771.62 livable2771.7 communities2772.18 that2773.06 is2773.3 examining2773.54 among2774.1 other2774.5 topics,2774.9 issues2775.97 pertaining2776.38 to2776.78 the2776.93 Commonwealth's2777.1 emergency2777.82 shelter2778.38 system.2779.18 The2780.06 federal2780.3 government2780.7 has2781.18 taken2781.34 drastic2781.66 steps2782.14 to2782.78 reform2782.93 the2783.34 migrant2783.49 situation.2783.97 It2784.93 would2785.1 stand2785.26 to2785.58 reason2785.74 that2786.06 any2786.38 movement2786.7 to2787.34 reduce2787.58 the2787.82 number2787.97 of2788.22 individuals2788.38 entering2788.93 our2789.34 country2789.49 and2789.82 our2789.97 Commonwealth2790.14 would2791.04 reduce2791.36 the2791.68 financial2791.92 burden2792.4 and2793.04 need.2793.28 And2794.16 lastly,2794.4 in2795.04 the2795.12 past,2795.28 this2796.08 very2796.32 body2796.56 has2796.96 passed2797.2 1122797.76 budgets2798.16 to2798.96 maintain2799.2 core2799.76 services2800.16 while2801.12 we2801.28 await2801.52 agreements2801.84 pending2802.32 budgetary2802.64 legislation.2803.28

2804.48 This2804.48 amendment2804.72 will2805.13 serve2805.28 as2805.53 just2805.68 that,2806.09 basically2806.72 a2807.13 1122807.53 budget2807.84 of2808.24 sorts2808.41 to2809.13 continue2809.28 providing2809.84 the2810.32 core2810.48 services,2810.8 at2811.68 the2811.84 same2812.01 time2812.32 giving2812.96 an2813.2 opportunity2813.53 for2814.48 the2814.72 reforms2814.89 contained2815.45 in2816.09 this2816.24 bill2816.48 and2816.89 hopefully2817.05 future2817.53 reforms2817.93 to2818.72 be2818.8 implemented.2818.96 Depending2820.14 on2820.46 it,2820.7 the2820.94 federal2821.1 actions,2821.5 and2822.06 our2822.3 willingness2822.46 to2823.02 take2823.1 a2823.34 practical2823.5 wait-and-see2824.78 approach,2824.94 these2825.74 are2826.06 but2826.22 some2826.38 of2826.54 the2826.7 reasons2826.86 as2827.42 to2827.66 why2827.74 the2827.98 numbers2828.06 should2828.46 be2828.62 more2828.7 manageable.2828.94 We2829.98 all2830.14 know2830.38 that2830.54 our2830.7 legislative2830.94 session's2831.58 going2832.06 to2832.3 ramp2832.46 up,2832.78 and2833.16 we2833.32 will2833.39 be2833.55 in2833.64 this2833.88 very2834.11 chamber2834.36 on2834.76 several2834.91 occasions.2835.32 If2836.36 we2836.59 must2836.76 take2837.07 up2837.32 another2837.47 vote2837.88 to2838.2 provide2838.36 additional2838.76 dollars2839.39 to2840.03 the2840.2 shelter2840.36 system2840.76 when2841.16 it2841.32 inevitably2841.47 runs2842.11 out2842.36 again,2842.52 then2843.16 so2843.55 be2843.72 it.2843.95 But2844.43 we2844.59 have2844.84 that2845.07 luxury2845.32 of2846.09 being2846.25 able2846.49 to2846.73 see2846.89 how2847.05 meaningful2847.85 reform2848.49 does2849.05 play2849.29 out,2849.53 and2849.85 we2850.09 owe2850.25 it2850.49 to2850.65 the2850.73 taxpayers2850.89 of2851.45 the2851.53 Commonwealth2851.77 to2852.33 do2852.49 so.2852.65 I2853.21 urge2853.37 you2853.53 to2853.69 support2853.85 amendment2854.25 82854.73 and2854.97 ask2855.21 that2855.37 when2855.45 a2855.69 vote2855.77 is2856.01 taken,2856.09 it's2856.33 taken2856.49 by2856.73 the2856.89 ayes2857.05 and2857.21 nays.2857.37 Thank2857.77 you.2858.01
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


2877.67 MICHLEWITZ2877.67 -2877.67 AMENDMENT2877.67 82877.67 -2877.67 Thank2877.67 you,2877.83 Madam2878.23 Speaker,2878.47 and2878.47 through2878.63 to2878.79 the2878.95 members.2879.03 I2879.59 rise2879.75 in2879.99 opposition2880.15 of2880.55 this2880.71 amendment,2880.79 and2881.11 I2881.27 thank2881.43 the2881.59 gentleman2881.67 from2881.99 Grafton2882.15 for2882.55 his2882.71 remarks.2882.87 I'm2883.35 under2883.59 no2883.83 illusion2884.07 that2884.47 if2884.63 we2884.79 do2884.87 take2885.11 up2885.27 this2885.35 amendment2885.59 that,2885.91 him2886.47 and2886.63 his,2886.79 friends,2887.19 in2887.91 the2888.07 second2888.15 division2888.39 will2888.71 be2888.88 voting2889.03 for2889.28 this2889.36 final2889.51 bill2889.76 at2889.99 the2890.15 end2890.23 of2890.32 the2890.39 day2890.47 no2890.71 matter2890.8 what2891.03 the2891.19 number2891.28 cost,2891.51 dollar2892.07 amount2892.32 is.2892.63 And2893.36 so2893.59 I2893.67 do2893.84 wanna2893.91 point2894.32 that2894.55 out.2894.63 But2894.8 I2894.95 do2895.11 thank2895.51 him2895.67 for2895.84 the2895.99 for2896.07 the,2896.23 for2896.63 the2896.8 for2896.95 the2897.11 discussion2897.28 because2897.67 it2897.99 was2898.15 something2898.32 that2898.55 we2898.71 certainly2898.88 considered2899.43 in2899.91 relation2900.07 to2900.47 how2900.63 to2900.8 move2900.88 forward2901.11 with2901.36 this2901.51 discussion.2901.76 And,2902.63 you2902.87 know,2902.95 I2903.11 will2903.51 point2903.83 out2903.99 I2904.23 will2904.39 use2904.55 the2904.71 opposite2904.79 argument2905.19 that2905.59 the2906.07 reforms2906.47 that2906.95 we2907.11 are2907.27 implementing2907.99 here2908.55 today2908.79 are2909.35 major.2909.59 They2909.91 are2910.15 gonna2910.31 take2910.55 some2910.71 time2910.87 to2911.11 implement.2911.19 They2911.59 are2911.75 gonna2911.83 take2912.07 some2912.23 time2912.47 to2912.63 really2912.71 see,2912.95 itself2913.35 through.2913.67 We2913.91 have2913.99 to2914.15 give2914.23 the2914.39 administration2914.47 some2915.19 time.2915.35 And2915.84 what2916.07 this2916.23 bill2916.32 does2916.55 from2916.88 a2917.03 financial2917.2 standpoint2917.51 and2917.84 lets2918.07 us2918.23 get2918.32 through2918.47 the2918.64 remainder2918.8 of2919.11 the2919.2 fiscal2919.28 year,2919.59 in2920.32 this2920.47 conversation.2920.64 We2921.2 are2921.43 going2921.51 to2921.84 be2921.91 back2922.07 here,2922.23 in2923.11 April,2923.28 during2924.07 our2924.39 annual2925.03 FY2925.68 262925.84 budget2926.64 discussion,2926.95 having2927.43 this2927.76 same2927.91 kind2928.16 of2928.32 conversation2928.47 about2928.95 what2929.2 to2929.36 do2929.43 going2929.59 forward.2929.84 And2930.27 we2930.35 will,2930.51 at2930.59 that2930.67 point2930.91 in2931.07 time,2931.23 have2931.39 an2931.55 opportunity2931.71 to2932.11 see2932.19 if2932.59 the2932.83 reforms2932.91 are2933.39 making2933.47 a2933.71 difference2933.79 and2934.03 if2934.19 we2934.35 do2934.51 have2934.67 to2934.83 make2934.91 changes2935.07 potentially.2935.47 I2936.27 look2936.35 forward2936.59 to2936.83 keeping2936.99 those2937.23 conversations2937.55 with2938.03 all2938.19 of2938.35 you,2938.43 and2938.91 I2939.07 ask2939.23 that2939.47 today2939.55 we2939.87 reject2940.03 this2940.27 amendment.2940.51 Thank2940.75 you,2940.91 Madam2941.39 Speaker.2941.39
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


3289.53 HOGAN3289.53 -3289.53 Time3289.53 for3289.85 voting3290.01 has3290.33 expired.3290.57 The3290.97 clerk3291.13 will3291.37 display3291.61 display3291.85 the3292.41 tally.3292.57 263294.33 to3294.97 124.3295.37 In3296.09 this3296.25 matter,3296.49 263297.05 in3297.61 the3297.77 affirmative,3297.93 1263298.65 in3299.53 the3299.61 negative.3299.77 The3300.09 amendment3300.25 is3300.65 not3300.73 adopted.3300.97
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


3496.05 FROST3496.05 -3496.05 Thank3496.05 you,3496.3 Madam3496.86 Speaker,3497.41 and3497.41 through3497.66 you3497.82 to3497.97 the3498.05 members3498.14 of3498.45 the3498.61 house.3498.7 Once3500.3 again,3500.61 I'm3501.57 here3501.89 to3502.22 talk3502.45 about3502.7 an3502.93 issue3503.09 that3503.41 we3503.66 discussed,3505.18 debated3505.66 at3506.22 length3506.38 in3507.51 the3507.75 previous3507.91 session.3508.47 But3511.27 with3512.15 a3512.39 lot3512.47 of3512.63 new3512.71 members3512.95 now3513.27 joining3513.51 us3513.83 who3513.99 are3514.15 not3514.31 here3514.47 for3514.71 that3514.87 debate,3515.03 I3515.83 think3515.91 it's3516.07 important3516.31 that3516.71 we3516.87 have3517.03 it3517.19 yet3517.43 again3517.67 as3518.55 we're3518.71 back3518.95 yet3519.35 again3519.59 looking3520.82 for3521.57 more3522.34 money3522.66 for3524.01 this3524.26 program.3524.57 Now3526.09 it3528.66 doesn't3528.89 take3529.21 an3531.93 individual3532.18 to3532.73 have3533.21 their3533.38 bachelor's3533.53 degree3534.01 from3534.26 the3534.49 University3534.57 of3535.21 Massachusetts3535.38 Amherst,3537.03 like3538.55 myself,3538.87 to3540.39 see3540.63 that3540.95 the3543.11 program3543.35 isn't3543.75 working.3544.07 And3544.47 we've3544.63 been3544.87 saying3544.95 this3545.19 for3545.43 a3545.55 number3545.67 of3545.91 years3546.07 now,3546.39 that3547.91 there's3548.15 been3548.39 problems,3548.55 that3549.35 we3549.51 need3549.67 to3549.83 address3549.99 it,3550.39 that3551.32 we3551.47 need3551.72 to3552.11 do3552.2 more3553.88 to3554.2 limit3554.43 folks3554.91 who3555.16 are3555.39 coming3555.47 from3555.8 out3556.04 of3556.28 state,3556.43 competing3557.88 with3558.28 folks3558.6 in3558.91 state3559.16 for3560.6 these3560.84 necessary3561.08 emergency3561.64 services.3562.28 So3564.94 what3565.18 this3565.5 amendment3565.74 does3566.22 is3567.66 it3567.9 asks3568.46 ask3569.02 or3569.42 request3569.74 that3570.14 we3570.22 put3570.38 in3570.54 a3571.98 one-year3572.38 residency3572.7 requirement3573.34 for3575.58 anyone3575.82 applying3577.18 for3578.57 our3578.82 emergency3578.89 shelter3579.38 services.3579.78

3582.09 This3582.09 will3582.34 send3582.49 a3582.74 very3582.82 clear3583.14 message3583.54 at3583.93 the3584.09 border3584.26 or3584.82 anywhere3585.14 else3585.54 to3586.57 any3586.74 nonprofit3586.97 organizations3587.7 that3589.7 Massachusetts3589.86 doesn't3592.81 have3593.13 the3593.37 not3593.69 only3593.85 not3594.09 doesn't3594.17 have3594.41 the3594.57 capacity,3594.73 but3596.49 our3596.73 laws3596.97 do3597.37 not3597.61 allow3597.77 individuals,3599.69 unless3600.25 they've3600.57 been3600.81 here3600.97 for3601.21 a3601.37 year3601.45 or3601.69 more,3601.77 to3602.89 gain3603.13 these3603.37 benefits.3603.53 Because3605.61 these3605.93 nonprofit3606.16 organizations3606.81 are3608.16 encouraging3608.49 or3609.2 sending3609.61 families3611.84 here3612.32 because3612.97 of3613.29 our3613.45 right-to-shelter3613.93 law.3614.41 Now3615.36 we're3615.61 not3615.84 looking3616.01 to3616.32 get3616.49 rid3616.64 of3616.81 it3617.06 because3617.65 we3617.89 know3617.97 that3618.21 that3618.45 right3618.61 to3618.77 shelter3618.93 law,3619.33 which3620.13 has3620.37 been3620.45 in3620.69 place3620.77 since3621.01 the3621.25 eighties3621.49 and3622.37 has3622.53 always3622.77 been3623.09 intended,3623.33 and3623.65 I3623.89 think3623.97 even3624.29 the3624.53 governor3624.61 has3625.01 even3625.17 mentioned3625.41 this,3625.65 has3626.45 has3626.77 was3627.49 intended3627.65 for3628.37 our3628.53 own3628.69 residents3628.93 here3629.41 in3629.57 Massachusetts3629.73 to3631.45 receive3631.61 these3631.76 emergency3632.16 services3632.72 if3633.13 they3633.28 find3633.45 themselves3633.68 homeless.3634.09 One3637.84 of3638.09 the3638.24 things3639.05 we're3639.36 dealing3639.61 with3639.93 today3640.16 and3640.57 have3640.72 been3640.89 dealt3641.05 with,3641.28 say,3641.68 for3641.93 the3642.09 last3642.24 year3642.72 and3642.89 a3643.13 half3643.2 or3643.36 so.3643.61

3645.53 And3645.53 some3645.93 of3646.17 the3646.25 tweaks3646.41 the3646.73 governor3646.97 has3647.37 made,3647.53 within3649.37 the3649.69 administration3649.85 through3651.37 executive3651.61 order3652.09 in3652.33 dealing3652.49 with3652.73 some3652.89 of3653.05 these3653.13 issues3653.37 are3654.73 just3654.89 not3655.13 enough.3655.29 We're3655.53 just3655.69 kinda3655.85 nibbling,3656.17 nibbling,3656.49 nibbling.3656.89 And3657.53 until3657.77 we3658.09 put3658.25 in3658.49 the3658.65 statute3658.81 what3660.55 qualifies3660.86 and3661.43 what3661.59 doesn't3661.74 qualify,3661.99 who's3662.39 eligible,3662.7 who's3663.18 not3663.43 eligible,3663.66 this3664.95 will3665.18 continue3665.51 on3665.99 and3666.31 on3666.39 and3666.63 on.3666.79 And3667.59 we3667.74 leave3667.99 it3668.07 up3668.22 to3668.39 the3668.47 whims3668.63 of3668.86 a3669.03 certain3669.11 administration,3669.51 whether3670.07 that's3670.39 the3671.03 corner3671.18 office3671.59 here3672.14 in3672.31 Massachusetts3672.47 or3674.07 whether3674.31 it's3674.55 the3674.95 White3675.11 House3675.35 in3676.85 Washington3677.01 DC.3677.57 We3679.81 can't3679.97 go3680.21 by3680.37 the3680.61 whims3680.77 of3680.93 whatever3681.09 administration3681.49 is3682.21 in3682.37 charge3682.53 or3682.77 whatever3683.01 party3683.65 is3684.53 in3684.69 charge3684.85 in3685.25 Washington3685.41 on3686.85 what's3687.09 gonna3687.41 happen3687.65 and3687.89 not's3688.05 gonna3688.37 happen.3688.61 We3690.26 have3690.49 to3690.65 take3690.73 action3691.14 on3691.45 our3691.69 own3691.86 because3692.01 it's3692.34 our3692.57 money3692.89 that3694.17 we're3694.41 spending.3694.57 And3695.05 we3695.3 may3695.53 not3695.78 have3696.01 going3697.05 forward.3697.38 We're3697.61 using3697.78 a3698.01 lot3698.17 of3698.26 one-time3698.73 resources3699.14 as3699.69 it3699.86 is3700.01 just3702.27 to3702.51 get3702.67 by3702.91 on3703.15 this.3703.39 So3704.11 it3704.35 needs3704.51 to3704.75 stop,3704.99 and3705.39 we3705.55 need3705.71 to3705.87 be3706.03 stronger3707.47 and3708.11 put3708.35 more3708.59 into3708.83 statute3709.23 on3709.79 what3709.95 qualifies3710.19 and3710.67 what3710.83 does3710.91 not3711.15 qualify.3711.39

3712.83 Because3712.83 it's3713.15 not3713.31 fair3713.55 to3713.79 the3713.87 taxpayers3714.03 of3714.51 the3714.67 Commonwealth,3714.83 and3715.63 it's3715.7 not3716.03 fair3716.26 to3716.82 the3717.07 residents3717.22 of3717.7 Massachusetts3718.03 who3719.3 desperately3719.63 need3720.26 these3720.51 services3720.66 and3721.55 are3721.78 competing3721.94 on3722.42 waiting3722.59 lists3722.98 for3723.55 them.3723.78 It's3726.59 wrong.3726.91 We3727.39 need3727.55 to3727.7 put3727.86 a3728.03 stop3728.11 to3728.34 it3728.51 and3728.66 we3728.82 can3728.98 by3729.55 adopting3729.78 this3730.26 amendment,3730.51 by3731.72 putting3731.88 a3732.28 residency3732.52 requirement.3733.08 Now3733.48 I3733.64 understand3733.88 we3735.4 will3735.56 hear3735.8 that3736.84 this3737.08 is3737.32 maybe3737.4 this3737.72 might3737.96 be,3738.2 could3738.6 be3738.84 unconstitutional.3739.64 Well,3742.04 as3742.76 I've3743 said3743.24 before3743.48 here,3743.96 the3745.3 governor3745.46 has3745.86 done3746.03 quite3746.26 a3746.59 few3746.66 things3746.82 on3748.11 trying3748.34 to3748.82 put3748.98 a3749.14 cap3749.3 on3749.55 the3749.63 shelter3749.7 to3750.11 a3750.22 bunch3750.34 of3750.51 other3750.59 things3750.82 that3750.98 were3751.22 challenged3751.55 in3752.03 court,3752.26 and3753.14 the3753.39 court3753.55 upheld3753.78 them.3754.11 So3756.11 lest3757.24 the3757.48 court's3757.56 gonna3757.88 come3758.12 here3758.36 and3758.6 help3758.76 find3758.92 ways3759.24 to3759.48 fund3759.64 it3759.88 and3760.12 leak3760.36 it,3761.32 you3761.48 know,3761.56 hey,3761.88 anybody3762.12 from3762.52 anywhere3762.76 outside3763.56 of3763.88 Massachusetts,3764.04 anywhere3765.32 in3766.12 the3766.28 country,3766.44 anywhere3766.76 across3767.08 the3767.4 world3767.48 can3767.8 come3767.96 here3768.12 and3768.28 get3768.52 these3768.68 benefits3768.92 from3769.32 day3769.56 one,3769.8 unless3771.98 they're3772.3 gonna3772.47 find3772.7 a3772.86 way3772.95 to3773.11 pay3773.18 for3773.43 it,3773.59 then3775.11 let's3775.26 send3775.51 it3775.66 to3775.82 the3775.91 court3775.98 if3776.3 that's3776.47 what3776.63 it3776.78 takes.3776.95 But3778.14 we3778.39 gotta3778.55 get3778.86 serious,3779.43 and3780.3 this3780.55 is3780.7 a3780.78 way3780.95 of3781.11 doing3781.26 that.3781.51 So,3783.43 Madam3783.74 Speaker,3783.74 I3783.74 ask3783.82 when3784.07 a3784.14 vote3784.22 be3784.47 taken,3784.63 it3784.95 be3785.11 taken3785.18 by3785.51 a3785.66 call3785.74 of3785.98 the3786.14 ayes3786.3 and3786.55 nays.3786.7
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


3811.32 REP3811.32 PEISCH3811.32 -3811.32 Thank3811.32 you,3811.64 Madam3812.2 Speaker,3812.68 and3812.68 through3812.93 you3813.16 to3813.32 the3813.49 members.3813.64 I3814.58 rise3814.82 in3814.98 opposition3815.3 to3815.7 the3815.86 amendment,3816.02 and3816.74 I3817.06 would3817.14 like3817.3 to3817.54 remind3817.7 those3818.18 of3818.34 you3818.5 who3818.74 have3818.9 been3818.98 here,3819.22 who3819.62 are3819.78 not,3819.94 for3820.5 whom3820.74 this3820.98 is3821.22 not3821.3 your3821.46 first3821.62 session,3821.94 that3822.98 we've3823.14 been3823.3 down3823.54 this3823.78 road3823.94 before,3824.26 not3825.22 once3825.46 but3825.78 twice.3826.02 And3827.11 while3827.36 I3827.68 appreciate3827.91 the3828.39 gentleman3828.55 from3828.88 Auburn's3829.11 comments,3829.59 regarding,3830.39 the,3831.36 ability3832.16 of3832.55 some3832.8 changes,3833.03 to3834.07 this3834.32 program3834.47 to,3834.95 survive,3835.59 legal3836.64 challenges,3837.03 this3837.99 is3838.24 different.3838.39 This3839.29 is3839.37 something3839.53 that3840.01 would3840.33 be,3840.65 connected3841.37 to,3842.25 alienage3843.13 and3844.01 that3844.25 for3844.81 which3845.05 we3845.37 have3845.53 precedent3845.85 at3846.41 both3846.49 our3847.29 own3847.45 SJC3847.69 and3848.49 the,3848.81 United3849.29 States3849.69 Supreme3850.01 Court.3850.41 So3851.13 I3851.37 think3851.53 that3851.85 this3852.17 is3852.49 actually3852.73 a3853.29 very,3853.45 raises3854.42 a3854.74 very3854.9 serious3855.14 question3855.46 of3855.86 constitutionality.3856.18 And,3857.78 I3858.9 also,3859.14 remind3860.03 the3860.34 members3860.51 that,3860.98 that3862.26 will3862.51 take3862.74 a3863.3 significant3863.63 period3864.26 of3864.66 time,3864.9 to3865.86 work3865.94 its3866.18 way3866.42 through3866.66 the3866.9 courts.3866.98 And3867.88 this3868.2 is3868.44 a,3868.92 we3869.88 are3870.12 taking3870.76 up3871 here3871.16 a3871.4 supplemental3871.56 budget,3872.12 that3873 applies3873.24 only3873.8 to3874.2 the3874.44 remainder3874.6 of,3875.56 this3876.36 fiscal3876.6 year.3877 So3877.64 the3878.12 likelihood3878.84 that3879.48 we3879.8 would3879.96 have3880.12 any3880.28 resolution3880.52 in3881.24 that3881.32 short3881.64 period3881.88 of3882.2 time,3882.36 I3882.68 think,3882.76 is,3883.08 quite3884.14 small.3884.63

3885.74 I3885.74 would3885.82 would3885.82 also3886.07 remind3886.39 the3886.7 members3886.86 that3887.51 we3887.66 are3887.99 talking3888.3 about,3888.79 families3890.07 with3890.55 children.3890.79 And3891.82 at3892.3 this3892.55 time3892.86 of3893.11 the3893.27 year,3893.43 to3893.74 be3894.07 placed3894.55 further3895.03 restrictions,3895.59 on3897.12 this3897.36 program,3897.68 I3898.4 think3898.56 is3898.8 something3898.96 that3899.36 most3899.6 of3899.84 us3899.92 would3900.16 find3900.4 to3900.8 be,3900.88 not3902.16 desirable.3902.64 Looking3903.92 outside3904.32 the3904.88 window3905.04 today,3905.36 we3905.76 have,3905.92 snow3906.64 on3906.8 the3906.96 ground3907.12 and,3907.44 we3908.48 do3908.72 not3908.88 wanna3909.12 be3909.36 in3909.52 the3909.68 position3909.84 of3910.4 saying3910.64 no3910.96 to3911.12 families,3911.36 with3912.34 young3912.59 children3912.91 who3913.3 would3913.95 otherwise3914.26 be3914.98 qualified.3915.3 I3916.82 do3916.98 note3917.22 that3917.55 in3917.78 this3917.95 bill,3918.18 we3918.51 are,3918.74 placing3920.59 more,3921.47 significant,3922.18 verification,3923.39 requirements3925.07 with3925.63 respect3925.87 to3926.51 residency.3926.75 We3927.71 do3927.95 require3928.19 that3928.51 you3928.67 be3928.83 a3928.99 Massachusetts3929.07 resident.3929.71 We3930.11 just3930.35 don't3930.51 have3930.67 this3930.91 duration3931.23 requirement3931.95 that3932.51 the3932.67 gentleman3932.75 referred3933.31 to.3933.63 And,3934.43 with3936.43 the3936.67 new3936.99 program,3937.31 the3937.97 new3938.2 requirement3938.45 that3939.09 verification3939.41 will3940.2 be3940.53 required3940.61 prior3941.09 to3941.41 placement,3941.57 I3942.2 think3942.29 that3942.45 really3942.68 addresses3942.93 concerns3943.49 that3943.89 many3944.13 have3944.36 had,3944.61 about,3945.49 who3946.36 this,3946.61 program3947.24 is3947.81 actually3948.05 serving.3948.45 So3949.97 I3950.36 ask3950.53 for3950.77 these3951.01 reasons,3951.24 I3951.64 ask3951.81 that3952.13 you3952.29 reject3952.45 the3953.01 amendment.3953.09 Thank3953.78 you.3957.46
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


4420.47 HOGAN4420.47 -4420.47 Time4420.47 for4420.71 voting4420.87 has4421.19 expired.4421.35 The4421.75 clerk4421.83 will4422.07 display4422.31 the4422.63 tally4422.79 on4423.19 this4423.43 matter.4423.59 264426.03 members4426.68 have4426.99 a4427.16 voting4427.24 in4427.48 the4427.64 affirmative,4427.72 1244428.52 in4429.48 the4429.64 negative.4429.72 The4430.28 amendment4430.44 is4430.84 not4431.07 adopted.4431.31
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


4567.59 FROST4567.59 -4567.59 AMENDMENT4567.59 184567.59 -4567.59 Thank4567.59 you,4567.82 Mr.4568.31 Speaker.4568.63 And4568.63 through4568.78 you4568.94 to4569.1 the4569.19 members4569.27 of4569.59 the4569.74 house,4569.82 I4570.23 rise4570.47 in4570.7 support4570.86 of4571.19 amendment4571.34 18,4571.74 which4573.74 seeks4574.15 to4574.55 put4575.19 in4575.43 an4575.66 eligibility4575.98 requirement4576.86 for4578.7 the4578.86 emergency4579.1 shelter4579.74 program4580.46 provided4580.54 that4584.7 the4585.1 cause4585.42 or4587.18 the4587.42 need4587.58 for4587.82 the4587.98 emergency4588.22 shelter4589.58 was4591.16 a4591.41 result4591.56 of4591.97 something4592.05 that4592.45 happened4592.6 within4593.01 the4593.56 Commonwealth4593.73 of4594.2 Massachusetts.4594.45 I4597.16 believe4597.32 that4597.73 this4597.89 is4598.13 also4599.24 a4599.65 way4599.81 that4601.32 we4601.56 can4601.73 make4601.97 sure4602.2 that4603.61 we're4603.77 helping4603.93 and4604.49 benefiting4604.73 the4605.21 initial4605.45 intent4605.93 of4606.33 the4606.49 program4606.65 to4608.41 benefit4608.65 those4609.13 who4609.61 are4609.85 Massachusetts4610.01 residents.4610.81 And4612.89 again,4613.21 putting4614.17 priority,4614.57 if4615.13 you4615.37 will,4615.45 over4616.84 those4616.99 who4617.56 may4617.88 have4618.11 come4618.84 here4619.07 because4620.19 of4620.52 result4620.6 of4620.91 homelessness4621.07 or4623.15 some4623.4 other4623.64 problem4623.95 that4624.84 resulted4625.07 somewhere4625.56 else.4625.95 Again,4627.8 we4628.84 cannot4629.07 afford,4629.48 we4630.27 know4630.52 that,4630.76 we4630.99 see4631.23 that,4631.48 afford4633.94 to4634.58 house4634.82 or4635.78 provide4635.94 emergency4636.34 shelter4636.9 for4639.22 everyone4639.46 who4641.14 comes4641.46 here4641.78 from4642.58 outside4642.82 of4643.22 Massachusetts.4643.46 We4644.42 just4644.58 can't4644.82 do4645.06 it.4645.22 So4648.22 I4648.7 think4648.85 this4649.1 really4649.41 gets4649.74 to4650.06 the4650.3 crux4650.38 of4650.7 it,4650.78 where4651.66 we4651.9 just4652.06 say,4652.3 hey4652.53 look,4652.78 you4653.49 can4653.74 be4653.9 eligible4653.98 for4654.45 these4654.53 programs,4654.78 but4655.49 the4655.66 result4655.81 of4656.3 why4656.53 you4656.85 need4657.1 them4657.26 had4659.12 to4659.36 be4659.44 the4659.6 cause,4659.84 had4660.16 to4660.4 be4660.56 something4660.96 that4661.28 happened4661.6 within4662 Massachusetts4662.8 itself.4663.68

4666.16 I4666.16 also4666.4 have4666.64 amendment4666.88 20,4667.36 which4668.72 I'll4668.88 just4669.04 gonna4669.28 briefly4669.52 mention4670.08 that's4670.4 similar4670.64 to4671.04 this,4671.2 does4672 the4672.24 same4672.4 criteria,4672.64 but4674.61 does4674.85 so4675.26 for4675.57 programs4675.9 that4677.57 go4677.81 to4678.06 folks4678.3 that4678.61 are4678.94 looking4681.26 for4681.57 more4681.81 long-term4682.77 housing,4683.1 more4685.26 stable4685.41 housing.4685.81 Because4686.53 now4686.94 what4687.18 we4687.34 do4687.57 have,4687.81 and4688.14 being4688.38 on4688.53 that4688.69 commission,4688.94 how4690.35 the4690.67 commission4691.55 on4691.95 the4692.19 emergency4692.27 shelters,4692.75 one4694.11 of4694.27 the4694.43 things4694.51 that4694.75 was4694.91 brought4695.07 up4695.31 was4695.55 the4695.79 money4695.87 that4696.11 we're4696.27 now4696.43 spending4696.75 on4697.71 moving4697.95 folks4698.27 outside4698.67 of4699.15 the4699.23 hotels4701.55 and4703.47 putting4703.71 them4704.03 into4704.27 other4705.34 subsidized,4705.74 state-subsidized4706.78 programs4707.34 for4708.45 more4708.7 permanent4708.94 housing.4709.34 Subsidized4709.98 housing.4710.61 Now,4712.06 I4712.94 mean4713.02 most4713.26 people,4713.66 even4715.26 after4715.49 they4715.82 get4715.98 jobs,4716.22 cannot4716.7 afford4717.1 market-rate4717.9 housing4718.3 in4718.7 Massachusetts.4718.85 So4720.05 now4720.21 they're4720.45 competing4720.85 with4721.81 again,4722.21 the4722.93 very4723.09 residents4723.41 of4724.45 Massachusetts4724.61 who4725.73 are4725.89 looking4726.05 to4726.29 get4726.45 into4726.61 those4726.77 programs,4727.01 may4727.57 have4727.73 been4727.81 looking4727.97 to4728.13 get4728.21 into4728.37 these4728.53 programs4728.69 for4729.01 a4729.17 long4729.25 period4729.49 of4729.81 time,4729.97 and4730.37 are4730.61 now4730.77 competing4731.33 with4732.89 folks4733.13 who4733.28 originally4733.6 came4734.01 out4734.24 from4734.41 outside4734.56 of4734.97 Massachusetts,4735.13 the4735.69 new4735.85 arrivals4736.09 if4736.56 you4736.73 will.4736.81 So,4738.24 I4738.73 think4738.89 this4739.36 criteria4739.6 should4740.32 also4740.56 be4741.2 included4741.36 in4741.85 Amendment4742.01 204742.48 when4742.81 that4743.05 comes4743.2 up.4743.45 Thank4745.06 you,4745.22 Mr.4746.18 Speaker.4746.5 And4746.5 I4746.66 hope4746.74 when4746.9 a4747.06 vote4747.14 is4747.38 taken,4747.46 it'll4747.7 be4747.94 taken4748.1 by4748.66 a4748.9 call4748.98 of4749.14 the4749.22 ayes4749.38 and4749.54 nays.4749.78
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


4781.24 REP4781.24 LEWIS4781.24 -4781.24 AMENDMENT4781.56 184781.96 -4781.96 Mr.4781.96 Speaker,4781.96 through4781.96 you4782.2 to4782.36 the4782.44 members,4782.6 I4783.08 rise4783.24 in4783.48 opposition4783.72 to4784.28 amendment4784.44 18.4785 The4786.52 underlying4786.68 bill4787.16 before4787.4 us4787.72 is4788.12 a4788.28 reasonable4788.44 yet4789.08 direct4789.4 response4789.96 to4790.59 changing4790.74 realities4791.15 on4791.7 the4791.94 ground4792.1 in4792.59 all4792.74 of4792.98 our4793.06 communities4793.3 and4793.7 across4793.94 our4794.26 commonwealth.4794.51 The4795.47 underlying4795.7 bill4796.26 maintains4796.82 who4797.3 we4797.55 are4797.63 as4797.86 a4797.94 commonwealth,4798.02 operating4799.06 from4799.47 a4799.7 place4799.78 of4800.1 compassion4800.34 without4801.23 being4801.55 ignorant4801.86 to4802.26 the4802.43 challenges4802.59 before4803.15 us4803.63 today.4803.78 The4805.23 underlying4805.39 bill4805.86 makes4806.56 permanent4806.88 changes4807.36 to4807.76 keep4808 families4808.24 and4808.64 communities4808.88 safe4809.44 through4810 requiring4810.24 CORI4810.72 checks4811.04 and4811.6 disclosures4811.92 of4812.56 criminal4812.72 records.4813.12 But4814.64 the4814.8 underlying4815.04 bill4815.52 also4815.84 allows4816.48 us4816.88 to4817.2 stay4817.44 nimble.4817.84 The4819.15 amendment4819.31 before4819.72 us4820.11 would4820.35 put4820.59 greater4820.84 restrictions4821.31 on4822.35 allowing4822.68 us4823.23 to4823.47 make4823.55 the4823.8 important4823.95 decisions4824.35 that4824.76 need4824.99 to4825.15 be4825.31 made4825.47 over4826.03 the4826.27 next4826.35 several4826.59 months.4826.91 We're4827.88 beginning4828.11 to4828.43 take4828.51 up4828.76 the4828.84 budget.4828.99 These4829.8 conversations4830.03 about4830.76 how4831.07 we4831.23 fund4831.4 emergency4831.72 shelters4832.35 and4833.1 the4833.26 restrictions4833.42 that4833.98 are4834.22 in4834.46 place4834.54 or4834.86 may4835.1 need4835.34 to4835.5 be4835.58 in4835.74 place4835.9 are4836.38 going4836.62 to4836.86 continue.4837.02 The4838.38 previous4838.62 speaker4839.02 talked4839.42 about4839.66 his4840.06 concerns4840.38 that,4840.94 these4842.22 bills4842.38 before4842.78 us4843.18 are4843.5 only4843.66 nibbling4844.22 away4844.7 at4845.02 the4845.18 edges4845.34 of4846.3 the4846.54 underlying4846.78 issue.4847.42

4847.42 But4848.98 our4849.14 great4849.69 colleague,4850.09 the4850.41 gentle4850.65 lady4850.98 from4851.3 Wellesley,4851.61 reminded4852.18 us4852.49 that4853.05 we're4853.38 not4853.61 talking4853.77 about4854.09 issues,4854.34 we're4855.05 talking4855.3 about4855.61 families.4855.94 We're4856.73 talking4856.98 about4857.38 families4857.69 with4858.34 children.4858.65 And4860.01 what4860.18 we4860.34 need4860.49 today4860.73 is4861.14 to4861.38 not4861.53 have4861.69 conversations4861.94 about4862.65 what4862.81 it4862.98 means4863.14 to4863.38 treat4863.53 them4863.77 as4863.94 issues4864.18 that4864.79 we4864.95 may4865.07 or4865.19 may4865.43 not4865.59 be4865.83 nibbling4865.91 away4866.31 at4866.55 the4866.63 edges4866.79 of,4867.11 but4867.75 instead,4867.99 how4868.55 we4868.71 can4868.87 maintain4869.27 who4871.43 we4871.67 are4871.83 as4871.99 a4872.15 commonwealth,4872.23 and4873.19 how4873.43 we4873.59 can4873.67 make4873.91 sure4874.15 that4874.63 we4874.87 are4875.03 nimble4875.27 as4876.15 we4876.39 face4876.55 the4876.79 realities4876.95 before4877.59 us.4877.99 I4878.99 urge4879.15 you4879.31 to4879.63 reject4879.86 this4880.27 amendment4880.51 so4881.07 that4881.23 we4881.39 can4881.47 continue4881.7 having4882.1 those4882.43 conversations.4882.82 So4884.03 we4884.19 can4884.35 accept4884.59 the4885.07 temporary4885.23 changes4885.78 before4886.19 us4886.59 today.4886.74 So4887.55 we4887.7 can4887.86 be4888.1 nimble4888.27 as4888.91 we4889.07 wait4889.31 and4889.63 see4889.86 what4890.59 happens4891.95 in4892.43 DC4892.67 and4893.39 how4893.63 it4893.79 affects4893.95 families4894.35 in4894.99 all4895.23 of4895.39 our4895.55 districts.4895.71 I4896.99 ask4897.07 you4897.31 to4897.47 reject4897.55 this4897.95 amendment4898.11 so4898.59 we4898.83 can4898.91 be4899.15 nimble4899.39 as4900.35 we4900.51 continue4900.67 to4901.15 discuss4901.39 eligibility,4902.27 which4903.07 we4903.31 are4903.47 doing4903.71 here4903.95 today,4904.19 and4904.94 funding,4905.26 which4905.81 we4906.05 will4906.22 continue4906.45 doing4906.85 with4907.41 our4907.65 budget4907.81 coming4908.14 up4908.38 in4908.69 just4908.94 a4909.18 couple4909.34 months.4909.65 The4911.98 underlying4912.14 bill,4912.69 again,4913.34 makes4913.98 permanent4914.3 changes4914.85 that4915.34 most4915.65 of4915.98 us,4916.05 many4916.38 of4916.61 us4916.77 have4916.94 been4917.09 seeking.4917.26

4918.25 And4918.25 it4918.41 makes4918.57 temporary4918.81 changes4919.53 that4920.33 many4920.57 have4920.81 been4920.97 proposing.4921.21 It4922.65 maintains4922.89 who4923.21 we4923.37 are4923.53 as4923.69 a4923.85 Commonwealth.4923.93 It4924.97 allows4925.13 compassion4925.61 to4926.17 be4926.33 integral4926.49 to4926.97 who4927.21 we4927.37 are4927.53 and4927.85 how4928.09 we4928.25 operate4928.49 in4928.81 our4928.97 communities.4929.21 And4930.61 it4930.85 respects4931.1 not4932.14 only4932.38 who4932.61 we've4932.77 been4932.94 as4933.1 a4933.26 Commonwealth4933.41 for4933.9 the4934.06 last4934.14 several4934.38 decades4934.77 with4935.57 a4935.81 right4935.98 to4936.14 shelter4936.3 law4936.7 on4936.85 the4936.94 books,4937.1 but4937.66 who4937.9 we4938.06 have4938.22 been4938.3 as4938.61 a4938.77 compassionate4938.94 Commonwealth4939.49 for4940.3 centuries.4940.53 The4942.22 amendment4942.3 before4942.7 us4943.02 today4943.18 prevents4944.22 us4944.7 from4944.94 being4945.18 nimble.4945.41 And4946.5 it4946.74 does4946.82 so4947.38 by4948.1 asking4948.42 families,4948.98 families4950.26 who4950.58 are4950.82 struggling,4950.98 families4952.02 with4952.66 kids,4952.98 to4954.26 somehow4954.5 prove4954.98 where4956.18 and4956.66 how4956.98 the4957.3 situation4957.54 of4958.02 their4958.18 misfortune4958.42 occurred.4959.06 The4960.3 amendment4960.45 does4960.85 not4961.09 spell4961.41 out4961.65 how4961.97 one4962.22 can4962.38 prove4962.61 the4963.34 financial4963.57 realities4964.14 of4964.69 wow4964.85 where4965.26 and4965.57 how4965.73 a4966.3 misfortune4966.61 has4967.26 occurred4967.41 in4967.73 one's4967.9 life,4968.14 and4968.85 instead4969.09 leaves4969.49 it4969.81 pretty4969.97 vague4970.3 about4970.94 who4971.26 can4971.65 and4971.97 cannot4972.14 access4973.09 these4973.9 emergency4974.14 shelters4974.85 that4975.63 are4975.79 have4975.95 been4976.11 integral4976.35 to4976.67 who4976.83 we4976.99 are4977.07 as4977.31 a4977.39 commonwealth4977.47 for4978.19 decades,4978.43 if4978.99 not4979.23 centuries.4979.47 I4980.59 urge4980.75 my4980.99 colleagues4981.15 to4981.79 join4981.95 me4982.27 in4982.91 voting4983.07 no4983.39 on4983.63 this4983.79 amendment.4984.03
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


5243.97 REP5243.97 DONATO5243.97 -5243.97 Time5243.97 for5244.2 voting5244.36 has5244.61 expired.5244.77 The5245.16 clerk5245.24 will5245.57 display5245.73 the5246.05 tally5246.2 on5246.61 this5246.77 matter.5247.01 255249.73 members5249.89 voting5250.28 in5250.61 the5250.69 affirmative5250.77 of5251.16 1275251.32 in5252.28 the5252.45 negative.5252.53 The5253.24 amendment5253.41 is5253.97 not5254.2 adopted.5254.53
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


5383.26 PEISCH5383.26 -5383.26 The5383.26 amendment5383.42 is5383.82 beyond5383.98 the5384.22 scope5384.38 of5384.62 the5384.78 subject5384.94 matter5385.26 of5385.5 the5385.58 bill.5385.74
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


5397.47 DONATO5397.47 -5397.47 The5397.47 chair5397.7 will5397.94 rule5398.26 in5398.9 favor5399.15 of5399.63 the5399.78 general5400.88 lady5401.12 from5401.44 Wellesley5401.68 that5402.24 the5402.4 matter5402.88 is5403.28 beyond5404 the5404.32 scope.5404.48 The5406.8 amendment5407.28 will5407.28 be5407.52 laid5407.6 aside.5407.92 Chair5408.8 recognizes5409.2 mister5409.84 Jones5410.16 if5410.48 not5410.64 ready.5410.96
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


DONATO5978.29 -5978.29 As5978.29 we5978.53 noted,5978.69 the5979.09 chair5979.33 the5979.73 amendment5979.89 would5980.37 impose5980.69 requirements5981.17 by5982.13 law5982.45 enforcement5982.77 and5983.65 judicial5983.89 officers5984.45 beyond5985.41 what5985.81 is5986.13 contained5987.09 in5987.57 the5987.73 original5987.89 bill,5988.37 clearly5989.31 expanding5990.98 the5991.47 provisions5991.7 of5992.27 this5992.43 bill.5992.66 Therefore,5993.47 the5993.94 chair5994.19 will5994.51 rule5994.74 that5995.47 the5995.7 amendment5995.86 is5996.51 beyond5996.74 the5997.06 scope5997.23 of5997.55 the5997.7 original5997.86 bill5998.34 and5998.9 will5999.15 be5999.31 laid5999.47 aside5999.78 accordingly.6000.19
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


6060.38 PEISCH6060.38 -6060.38 The6060.38 amendment6060.61 is6061.02 beyond6061.18 the6061.41 scope6061.57 of6061.81 the6061.98 subject6062.06 matter6062.45 of6062.69 the6062.85 bill.6062.94

6064.03 DONATO6064.03 -6064.03 Chair6064.03 will6064.35 rule6064.51 on6064.75 the,6064.83 request.6065.87 Chair6072.91 will6073.23 rule6073.39 in6073.87 favor6074.11 of6074.51 the6074.75 gentlelady6074.91 from6075.55 Wellesley6075.79 that6076.27 is6076.43 beyond6076.75 the6077.07 scope,6077.23 and6078.19 the6079.15 amendment6079.31 will6079.7 be6079.86 set6080.11 aside.6080.27
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


PEISCH6149.49 -6149.49 The6149.49 amendment6149.65 is6150.05 beyond6150.21 the6150.53 scope6150.61 of6150.93 the6151.01 subject6151.17 matter6151.49 of6151.81 the6151.89 bill.6151.97
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


6172.99 DONATO6172.99 -6172.99 Chair6172.99 is6173.23 gonna6173.4 rule6173.72 that6173.95 the6174.19 gentlelady6174.27 is6174.91 correct.6175.07 It6175.88 is6176.11 beyond6176.27 the6176.68 scope.6176.84
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


6256.82 REP6256.82 LOMBARDO6256.82 -6256.82 Thank6256.82 you,6257.06 Mr.6260.18 Speaker.6260.18 Wow.6260.18 I've6262.34 seen6262.66 a6262.9 lot6263.06 in6263.54 146263.86 years6264.18 in6264.5 this6264.58 building.6264.74 This6266.26 is6266.42 new.6266.66 This6269.06 is6269.3 new.6269.46 We're6269.7 ruling6269.86 out6271.54 of6271.7 the6271.86 scope6272.1 an6273.3 amendment6273.46 which6274.9 speaks6275.22 to6275.61 how6276.57 the6276.98 shelters6277.22 would6278.41 operate.6278.74 I6281.61 don't6281.78 know6281.94 how6282.18 any6282.57 of6282.98 our6283.22 colleagues6283.45 in6283.85 this6284.02 building6284.26 can6285.45 possibly6285.78 feel6287.45 that6287.7 this6287.94 is6288.1 out6288.18 of6288.41 scope.6288.49 I6289.18 mean,6289.34 great6289.5 political6289.9 games.6290.3 I6291.1 wouldn't6291.26 wanna6291.58 vote6291.9 on6292.14 this6292.3 amendment6292.46 if6292.86 I6293.02 were6293.1 you6293.26 either6293.5 because6294.22 it6294.54 is6294.7 a6294.86 horrible6294.94 vote6295.42 for6295.58 you.6295.74 Because6296.38 you6296.7 would6296.94 have6297.26 to6297.42 actually6297.66 vote6298.14 against6298.38 the6298.7 taxpayers6298.94 and6299.82 the6299.98 residents6300.22 and6301.26 say,6301.49 no.6301.74 No.6301.9 We're6302.22 gonna6302.53 protect6304.22 criminal6304.3 illegal6304.78 aliens6305.18 in6305.57 the6305.66 Commonwealth.6305.82 We6306.94 are6307.1 gonna6307.26 protect6307.57 rapists,6308.85 murderers.6310.7 Did6311.98 I6312.22 hear6312.3 a6312.53 wow?6312.61 I6313.26 mean,6313.41 I6313.66 can6313.74 I'd6314.22 be6314.38 happy6314.61 to6314.94 read6315.18 from6315.34 you6315.57 ICE's6316.53 arrests6316.93 in6317.49 the6317.81 press6317.97 releases6318.21 of6319.17 of6319.57 these6319.73 people6319.97 who6320.29 they're6320.45 arresting.6320.69 MS6321.41 136321.81 gang6322.37 members,6322.61 Honduras6323.49 gang6324.05 members.6324.37 I6325.09 mean,6325.17 I6325.57 agree6325.81 with6326.05 you.6326.29 Wow.6326.93 Wow.6328.13 That6329.01 is6329.41 who6329.65 we're6329.81 protecting6330.05 in6330.53 the6330.69 Commonwealth.6330.85 This6331.98 amendment6332.15 would6332.94 say,6333.74 if6334.23 we6334.47 come6334.78 across6335.02 dangerous6336.55 criminals6337.98 in6339.66 our6339.82 shelter6340.06 system,6340.55 we6341.35 will6341.59 collaborate6341.82 with6343.35 ICE6343.59 to6344.47 remove6344.71 these6345.19 monsters6345.51 from6346.15 the6346.39 streets6346.63 of6346.95 the6347.11 Commonwealth.6347.27 That6348.63 is6348.87 perfectly6349.11 in6349.59 scope6349.83 with6351.35 the6351.67 shelter6352.07 bill6352.55 that6352.79 we're6352.95 taking.6353.19 So6353.67 I6353.91 agree.6354.15

6354.95 Wow.6354.95 What6355.99 are6356.23 we6356.39 doing?6356.63 We6357.9 don't6358.14 have6358.45 the6358.61 courage6358.77 to6359.41 vote?6359.57 That's6360.61 what6360.85 this6361.02 comes6361.26 down6361.49 to.6361.74 Where6362.94 is6363.26 where6363.49 is6363.81 the6363.98 courage?6364.14 Where6364.94 is6365.49 the6365.9 stance6366.14 you6366.53 so6366.7 strongly6366.94 wanna6367.49 support6367.81 protecting6368.53 illegal6369.1 immigrants6369.49 who6370.22 are6370.38 dangerous6370.61 criminals6371.26 that6372.14 we're6372.3 not6372.46 gonna6372.7 we're6373.34 gonna6373.5 call6373.66 it6373.9 out6373.98 of6374.22 scope6374.3 to6374.62 avoid,6375.02 to6375.9 dodge6376.3 the6376.78 issues.6376.86 We're6377.82 not6378.06 talking6378.3 about6378.7 ICE6379.58 going6379.9 after6380.22 women6380.54 and6380.86 children6381.02 because6381.42 I'm6381.66 sure6381.82 that6381.98 will6382.22 be6382.38 the6382.46 next6382.54 arguments.6382.86 I6385.55 mean,6385.63 the6385.86 Democratic6386.19 Party6386.66 of6386.98 Massachusetts6387.15 does6387.86 not6388.1 corner6388.27 the6388.59 market6388.66 on6389.06 compassion6389.3 like6389.78 I've6390.02 heard6390.1 earlier.6390.34 It6390.9 is6391.06 not6391.23 compassionate6391.55 to6392.74 allow6392.9 residents6393.78 of6394.27 the6394.34 Commonwealth6394.51 to6395.39 become6395.55 rape6396.02 victims,6396.27 to6397.39 become6397.47 murder6397.86 victims,6398.19 become6399.16 victims6399.4 of6399.8 assault,6400.12 drug6401.16 trafficking,6401.48 dying6402.28 of6402.68 fentanyl6402.84 overdoses.6403.32 That6403.96 is6404.2 not6404.36 compassion,6404.6 my6405.16 colleagues.6405.4 Whereas6406.44 compassion6406.84 is6407.4 doing6407.56 everything6407.96 we6408.44 can6408.68 in6409.16 the6409.32 commonwealth6409.48 to6410.36 protect6410.52 our6411.4 residents,6411.56 to6412.04 protect6412.28 our6413 children.6413.16 And6414.51 that's6414.66 what6414.82 this6415.07 amendment6415.31 would6415.63 do.6415.78 It6415.95 is6416.19 perfectly6416.43 in6416.82 scope.6417.07 So6417.95 I6418.19 would6418.27 encourage6418.59 you6418.99 all6419.23 to6420.91 join6421.07 me6421.39 and6422.51 overrule6422.82 the6423.31 chair,6423.47 and6424.35 let's6424.59 vote6424.91 on6425.15 the6425.31 amendment6425.39 so6425.95 that6426.1 we6426.35 can6426.51 protect6426.74 the6427.54 residents6427.78 of6428.26 the6428.34 Commonwealth6428.5 against6429.38 heinous6429.86 monsters6430.9 who6431.86 are6432.02 hurting6432.18 our6433.22 families.6433.54 Thank6434.5 you,6434.74 Mr.6435.3 Chairman.6435.3
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


6461.61 REP6461.61 GREGOIRE6461.61 -6461.61 Good.6461.61 Thank6462.25 you,6462.57 Mr.6463.05 Speaker.6463.29 And6463.29 through6463.45 you6463.61 to6463.77 the6463.85 members,6464.01 I6464.41 rise6464.49 in6464.73 support6465.05 of6465.69 the6465.77 ruling6466.01 of6466.49 the6466.65 chair.6466.81 And6467.37 I6467.61 would6467.77 like6467.85 to6468.01 remind6468.25 my6468.73 colleagues6468.81 that6469.55 we6469.7 are6469.94 not6470.02 having6470.27 a6470.51 political6470.74 discussion.6471.23 The6472.02 clerk6472.27 of6472.59 the6472.74 House6472.82 of6473.06 Representatives6473.23 has6474.19 made6474.34 a6474.59 ruling6474.66 that6475.06 this6475.23 amendment6475.47 is6475.86 beyond6476.1 the6476.59 scope6476.74 of6477.55 this6477.7 narrowly6477.94 tailored6478.74 funding6479.3 bill.6479.78 And6480.34 I6480.59 will6480.66 remind6480.9 my6481.23 colleagues6481.39 as6481.7 well6481.86 that6482.1 there6482.27 is6482.51 several6482.66 pieces6483.15 of6484.03 legislation6484.27 that6484.83 were6485.07 filed6485.31 this6485.63 session6485.79 that6486.43 will6486.67 deal6486.83 with6487.39 the6487.55 issue6487.71 which6488.19 has6488.43 been6488.59 raised6488.75 by6489.39 my6489.55 colleagues6489.71 in6490.03 the6490.19 minority6490.27 party6490.67 and6490.91 the6491.07 gentleman6491.23 who6491.55 proceeded6491.79 me6492.19 at6492.35 the6492.51 microphone.6492.67 I6493.23 ask6493.31 my6493.63 colleagues6493.79 to6494.11 join6494.27 me6494.51 in6494.67 supporting6494.83 the6495.15 rule6495.31 of6495.55 our6495.71 clerk6495.79 and6496.11 the6496.27 rule6496.35 of6496.59 this6496.67 chair.6496.83 Thank6497.15 you,6497.31 Mr6497.79 Speaker.6497.79
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


6816.44 GREGOIRE6816.44 -6816.44 The6816.44 amendment6816.64 is6816.96 beyond6817.12 the6817.44 scope6817.52 of6817.76 the6817.92 subject6818.08 matter6818.32 of6818.56 the6818.64 bill.6818.72
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


DONATO6826.4 -6826.4 Once6826.4 again,6826.64 the6826.96 chair6827.12 will6827.36 rule6827.6 that6827.92 it6828.24 is6828.48 beyond6828.64 the6829.04 scope6829.2 and6829.76 the6830 amendment6830.32 will6830.8 be6830.96 set6831.12 aside.6831.36
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


7025.55 REP7025.55 DECKER7025.55 -7025.55 AMENDMENT7025.55 277025.55 -7025.55 Thank7025.55 you.7025.79 I7026.43 wanna7026.99 say,7027.23 thank7027.79 you7027.95 to7028.19 the7028.35 gentleman7028.51 from7028.91 the7029.15 North7029.23 End7029.47 and7029.79 thank7030.03 you7030.27 to7030.43 the7030.59 speaker,7030.75 not7031.87 only7032.11 for7032.43 your7032.59 support7032.75 of7033.07 this7033.23 amendment,7033.39 but7033.95 just7034.11 to7034.35 give7034.99 some7035.23 context7035.47 of7035.95 what's7036.11 happening7036.43 in7036.75 this7036.91 chamber7037.07 today.7037.39 This7038.45 is,7038.61 I7038.94 have7039.26 to7039.41 say,7039.49 one7039.73 of7039.9 the7040.06 most7040.14 challenging7040.38 days7040.85 that7041.18 I7041.41 have7041.57 experienced7041.9 in7042.53 127042.69 years,7043.02 and7043.49 I7043.73 know7043.81 that's7043.98 true7044.22 for7044.45 so7044.69 many7044.77 of7045.1 my7045.18 colleagues7045.34 for7045.73 different7045.9 reasons.7046.22 We7046.94 are7047.18 all7047.41 responding7047.65 to7048.3 the7048.85 stress7049.1 of7049.9 our7050.14 communities7050.38 that7051.18 the7052.01 unprecedented7052.25 number7052.81 of7053.05 people7053.21 coming7053.45 into7053.69 our7053.93 state7054.17 who,7054.89 need7055.61 shelter.7055.93 And7056.49 to7056.73 remember,7056.89 these7057.29 are7057.53 people7057.61 who've7057.85 been7058.01 legally7058.25 entering7058.81 this7059.45 country,7059.69 who've7060.33 required7060.65 shelter7061.21 with7061.61 their7061.77 children.7062.01 Massachusetts7062.57 has7063.29 been7063.45 a7063.61 beacon7063.69 of7064.01 hope.7064.17 We've7064.49 been7064.65 only7064.89 state7065.13 in7065.37 the7065.45 country7065.61 that7066.01 has7066.17 said7066.41 that7066.9 we7067.06 will7067.3 make7067.45 sure7067.69 that7067.94 children7068.09 actually7068.73 are7069.06 housed7069.22 safely7069.53 at7069.94 night.7070.09 With7071.38 the7071.61 unprecedented7071.77 number7072.49 of7072.73 of7072.98 people7073.22 who've7073.45 come7073.77 into7073.94 our7074.41 state7074.73 because7075.38 of7075.69 our7075.85 values,7076.09 it7076.9 has7077.06 also7077.22 put7077.45 an7077.69 incredible7077.85 strain7078.49 on7078.98 many7079.22 of7079.45 our7079.53 communities.7079.69 Many7080.47 communities7080.79 that7081.19 were7081.35 not7081.43 prepared7081.67 with7081.99 the7082.15 resources,7082.31 with7083.35 the7083.59 with7083.75 the7083.91 communication,7084.15 and7085.67 have7086.47 really7086.79 struggled7087.11 over7087.59 the7087.75 last7087.91 107088.15 years.7088.39

7088.39 I7089.11 would7089.27 say7089.43 we7089.67 stand7089.83 here7090.15 today7090.39 because7091.43 it7091.99 has7092.15 not7092.39 been7092.63 managed7092.79 in7093.19 a7093.27 way7093.35 that7093.59 has7093.67 allowed7093.83 communities7094.34 to7094.73 figure7094.97 out7095.14 how7095.38 to7095.53 respond7095.69 to7096.01 those7096.18 needs7096.49 while7096.97 also7097.3 responding7097.69 to7098.09 the7098.26 needs7098.34 of7098.57 those7098.65 who7099.22 have7099.38 been7099.61 living7099.69 in7099.93 their7100.09 communities7100.34 much7100.81 longer.7101.05 So7101.69 this7101.85 is7102.01 a7102.18 difficult7102.26 day7102.65 for7102.9 all7103.05 of7103.22 us.7103.3 And7103.45 I'll7103.69 just7103.85 remind7104.09 us7104.49 that7105.05 the7105.85 difficult7106.01 days7106.41 are7106.73 still7106.9 ahead7107.14 of7107.38 us.7107.45 We've7107.69 got7108.01 several7108.65 more7108.89 years,7109.21 I7109.61 think,7109.77 for7110.09 many7110.33 of7110.49 us7110.65 of7110.81 more7110.97 challenging7111.13 days.7111.69 And7112.49 today7112.73 is7113.05 an7113.21 example7113.37 of7113.77 what7114.01 it7114.17 means7114.25 for7114.57 those7114.73 of7114.97 us7115.05 who7115.21 are7115.37 in7115.77 earnest7116.09 trying7116.57 to7116.81 represent7116.97 the7117.29 needs7117.37 of7117.61 our7117.77 communities7117.93 that7118.65 are7118.89 at7119.13 odds7119.29 at7119.69 times.7119.85 I7120.57 wanna7120.73 really7121.13 commend,7121.61 the7122.57 speaker7122.73 and7123.77 the7124.09 gentleman7124.16 from7124.56 the7124.81 North7124.97 End7125.28 for7126.16 their7126.48 integrity,7127.28 for7128.48 their7128.73 compassion,7128.97 and7129.93 for7130.09 their7130.32 leadership7130.56 on7131.52 trying7131.69 to7132.09 figure7132.32 out7132.65 how7132.89 to7133.13 get7133.28 to7133.52 the7133.6 right7133.69 place.7133.85 The7134.65 administration7134.89 didn't7135.52 get7135.85 us7136.01 there.7136.16 This7136.4 is7136.56 where7136.73 this7136.89 is7137.13 supposed7137.28 to7137.6 come7137.77 from.7138.01 So7138.46 we7138.54 have7138.78 been7138.82 responding7138.86 and7139.9 trying7140.22 not7140.62 to7140.94 micromanage7141.18 how7142.3 this7142.62 actually7142.86 gets7143.18 implemented.7143.42 But7144.22 each7144.46 time7144.7 along7144.94 the7145.18 way,7145.26 we've7145.5 been7145.74 left7145.9 to7146.22 do7146.3 that7146.38 community7146.62 by7147.1 community.7147.34

7147.34 So7148.06 today,7148.3 here7148.62 we7148.86 are7149.02 two7149.18 years7149.42 later7149.66 saying7149.98 we7150.22 need7150.38 to7150.54 figure7150.62 out7150.86 a7151.02 better7151.1 path7151.34 moving7151.66 forward7151.98 because7152.74 there's7152.98 a7153.06 lot7153.31 of7153.55 resources7153.78 that7154.59 our7154.74 communities7154.98 need.7155.47 And7155.86 so7156.02 this7156.27 is7156.43 a7156.51 shift7156.59 in7156.82 resources,7157.06 so7157.55 we7157.7 can7157.86 continue7158.02 meeting7158.43 some7158.98 of7159.15 the7159.31 basic7159.39 needs7159.7 that7159.94 our7160.1 communities7160.27 are7160.82 already7160.98 counting7161.39 on7161.7 us7161.86 to7162.02 deliver.7162.19 I7163.47 wanna7163.7 remind7163.94 us7164.34 also7164.59 that7164.98 the7165.55 gentleman7165.7 from7166.19 the7166.43 North7166.51 End7166.74 and7166.98 the7167.23 speaker7167.39 have7168.23 really7168.47 maintained7168.95 a7169.51 strong7169.75 commitment7170.23 to7170.87 what7171.03 it7171.19 means7171.35 to7171.59 recognize7171.83 that7172.31 people7172.55 who7172.79 need7172.95 shelter,7173.19 particularly7173.83 those7174.31 with7174.47 children,7174.63 have7175.03 a7175.19 place7175.35 to7175.59 stay.7175.75 A7176.39 year7176.55 ago,7176.71 it7177.03 was7177.19 this7177.35 chamber7177.67 that7178.39 actually7178.55 stood7178.95 up.7179.19 We7179.43 were7179.59 the7179.75 only7179.91 chamber7180.15 that7180.55 stood7180.79 up7180.95 and7181.11 talked7181.35 about7181.59 the7181.83 importance7181.99 of7182.79 figuring7182.95 out7183.35 how7183.89 to7184.05 make7184.2 sure7184.45 that7184.85 children7185.16 have7185.65 a7185.81 place,7185.97 a7186.28 safe7186.36 place7186.6 to7186.85 sleep7187.01 at7187.24 night.7187.41 I7188.13 wanna7188.28 say7188.52 that7188.69 I7188.85 wanna7189.01 thank7189.24 you7189.48 for7189.73 what7189.89 I7190.05 think7190.13 is7190.45 it7191.01 is7191.16 a7191.32 hard7191.89 day,7192.13 but7192.45 it7192.6 is7192.77 a7192.93 really7193.01 thoughtful7193.32 bill,7193.89 and7194.13 I7194.28 hope7194.36 people7194.6 are7194.93 reading7195.09 it7195.32 carefully,7195.48 and7196.13 that7196.28 we7196.52 have7196.69 tried7196.85 to7197.16 weave7197.32 a7197.65 safety7197.81 net7198.28 that7198.81 allows7199.05 us7199.37 to7199.53 still7199.69 move7199.93 forward.7200.17 This7200.73 amendment7201.05 today,7201.53 also7202.89 adds7203.29 to7203.61 the7203.93 hardship7204.09 waivers7204.57 that7204.97 were7205.13 provided7205.37 for7205.85 veterans7206.09 and7206.57 victims7206.81 of7207.21 domestic7207.37 violence.7207.77

7207.77 We're7208.41 also7208.73 continuing7209.05 to7209.53 say7209.69 that7210.17 we7210.41 have7210.57 a7210.81 responsibility7210.89 and7211.77 obligation7212.2 to7212.6 ensure7212.77 that7213.09 the7213.32 youngest7213.56 members7213.97 of7214.36 our7214.52 society7214.77 also7215.56 have7215.89 a7216.05 place7216.13 to7216.36 stay.7216.52 So7216.77 it7216.93 provides7217.01 presumptive7217.73 eligibility7218.2 for7218.84 children,7219.01 and7219.65 it7219.89 also7220.05 ensures7220.44 that7220.84 there's7221.01 an7221.24 extension7221.4 if,7222.05 in7222.2 fact,7222.36 those7222.6 families7222.84 with7223.16 the7223.32 youngest7223.48 amongst7223.89 us7224.28 still7224.74 have7225.14 a7225.46 shelter7225.7 over7226.1 their7226.34 heads7226.5 while7226.98 they're7227.3 trying7227.46 to7227.78 use7227.94 the7228.1 resources7228.34 to7228.82 get7228.98 to7229.14 get7229.38 back7229.54 on7229.86 their7230.02 feet7230.18 and7230.42 transition7230.66 out7231.22 of7231.38 shelter.7231.54 So7233.06 I7233.38 again,7233.62 this7234.5 is7234.74 a7234.9 complicated7235.7 day,7236.26 but7236.42 this7236.58 is7236.82 what7236.9 we're7237.06 supposed7237.3 to7237.62 do.7237.78 When7238.26 we7238.41 get7238.57 elected,7238.65 our7239.22 jobs7239.45 are7239.77 to7239.93 try7240.01 to7240.18 figure7240.26 out7240.57 how7240.73 to7240.9 meet7240.97 the7241.3 complicated7241.38 challenges7242.01 of7242.41 our7242.57 communities.7242.73 And7244.26 it's7244.49 not7244.65 easy.7244.97 And7245.69 today,7246.09 leadership7246.65 is7247.14 about7247.3 saying7247.53 that7247.77 we're7247.93 going7248.26 to7248.49 talk7248.65 to7248.9 each7249.05 other7249.22 and7249.45 we're7249.61 going7249.85 to7250.01 find7250.18 a7250.41 way7250.49 to7250.65 move7250.81 forward7250.97 that7251.56 allows7251.72 us7251.96 to7252.2 speak7252.44 to7252.6 the7252.76 needs7252.84 of7253.16 the7253.24 things7253.4 that7253.56 we7253.8 care7254.04 most7254.28 about7254.52 that7254.84 we7255 were7255.16 elected7255.32 to7255.64 do.7255.8 And7256.28 so7256.52 I7256.76 am7256.92 so7257.32 grateful7257.56 to7258.12 be7258.28 able7258.44 to7258.6 stand7258.68 here7258.92 and7259.16 ask7259.32 you7259.48 to7259.72 join7259.88 me7260.12 in7260.28 support7260.52 in7260.84 the7260.92 adoption7261.08 of,7261.88 the7262.28 redrafted7262.44 amendment7263.08 of7263.48 '277263.64 and7264.44 to7264.6 know7264.76 that7265 to7265.44 the7265.6 youngest7265.76 members7266.09 of7266.4 society,7266.56 we7266.97 continue7267.2 to7267.93 actually7268.09 understand7268.56 how7269.05 important7269.28 it7269.6 is7269.76 that7270.01 collectively7270.24 we7270.97 take7271.2 care7271.36 of7271.52 you7271.69 and7271.84 center7272.09 your7272.48 needs,7272.65 in7273.6 these7273.84 really7274.09 unprecedented7274.65 complicated7275.36 times.7276.09 Thank7276.8 you.7276.97
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


7717.25 DONATO7717.25 -7717.25 And7717.25 257717.49 members7718.05 voting7718.45 affirmative7718.85 and7720.13 257721.09 in7721.73 the7721.97 negative.7722.13 The7723.23 amendment7724.03 is7724.51 adopted.7724.84
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


7796.83 REP7796.83 CONSALVO7796.83 -7796.83 Thank7796.83 you,7797.07 Mr.7797.63 Speaker.7798.03 And7798.03 for7798.11 you7798.19 to7798.35 the7798.43 members,7798.59 and7798.99 when7799.31 we7799.55 take7799.79 up7799.95 this7800.11 amendment,7800.27 I7800.67 ask7800.75 that7800.91 we7801.07 take7801.23 up7801.39 by7801.55 a7801.71 call7801.79 of7802.03 the7802.11 yays7802.19 and7802.43 nays.7802.59
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


7829.19 CONSALVO7829.19 -7829.19 AMENDMENT7829.19 277829.19 -7829.19 Thank7829.19 you,7829.43 Mr.7829.99 Speaker.7830.39 And7830.39 let7830.55 me7830.71 take7830.87 the7831.03 opportunity7831.19 to7831.67 thank,7831.75 the7832.31 speaker,7832.39 the7833.23 chair7833.39 of7833.63 ways7833.7 and7833.95 means,7834.19 for7834.59 allowing7834.82 me7835.06 to7835.15 come7835.23 up7835.39 on7835.55 this7835.63 amendment.7835.86 This7836.27 is7836.43 a7836.78 very7837.15 important7837.39 amendment.7837.7 I7838.02 wanna7838.1 recognize7838.43 my7838.82 colleague,7838.98 Rep7839.39 LeBoeuf,7839.63 who7840.1 worked7840.43 on7840.74 this7840.91 at7841.15 length7841.23 as7841.55 well,7841.7 and7842.02 it's7842.27 an7842.43 important7842.51 amendment7842.91 for7843.31 him.7843.47 This7844.1 is7844.27 an7844.43 amendment7844.59 that7844.98 will7845.15 help7845.31 protect,7845.55 people7846.53 with7846.77 disabilities7847.17 who7847.73 are7847.89 in,7847.97 shelters,7848.61 whether7849.73 it7849.97 be7850.05 a7850.21 family7850.37 member7850.77 or7851.01 a7851.17 head7851.25 of7851.41 household7851.57 who's7851.97 diagnosed7852.21 with7852.61 a7852.77 disability.7852.93 It7853.81 will7853.97 allow,7854.21 individuals7854.93 with7855.57 disabilities7855.81 to7856.45 be,7857.01 extended7857.49 beyond7857.89 the7858.29 six7858.45 months,7858.69 particularly7859.91 individuals7860.47 who7861.1 are7861.27 already7861.43 in7861.74 a7861.91 program7861.99 to7862.78 find7862.95 supportive7863.27 transitional7863.74 housing.7864.39 So7864.78 in7864.95 some7865.1 cases,7865.35 they'll7865.99 need7866.23 extra7866.47 time7866.78 as7867.19 they're7867.35 transitioning7867.82 through7868.47 their7868.63 programming,7868.78 and7869.27 it7869.43 may7869.51 take7869.66 them7869.91 beyond7870.06 the7870.39 six7870.55 months.7870.7

7871.68 And7871.68 we7871.76 wanna7871.92 make7872.16 sure7872.24 that7872.48 those7872.64 individuals7872.96 with7873.28 disabilities7873.52 have7874.4 the7874.56 time7874.64 that7874.88 they7875.04 need7875.2 to7875.44 be7875.6 able7875.76 to7876 move7876.08 forward.7876.24 It7877.2 helps7877.36 extremely7877.76 low-income7878.48 individuals,7878.88 those7879.68 who7879.92 are7880.08 working7880.24 but7880.56 are7880.8 making7880.96 less7881.36 than7881.6 30%7881.84 of7882.4 area7882.56 median7882.88 income.7883.28 And7883.91 it,7884.07 also,7884.8 make7885.76 sure7885.99 that,7886.23 these7887.19 individuals,7887.44 once7888.64 they7888.88 do7889.11 transition7889.35 and7889.99 find7890.15 that7890.31 supportive7890.56 housing,7890.88 whatever7891.19 the7891.52 time7891.68 frame,7891.84 can7892.07 then7892.31 get7892.64 into7892.8 that7893.11 more7893.27 supportive7893.52 long-term7894.15 housing,7894.31 which7894.72 is7895.27 what7895.44 we7895.59 want7895.76 the7895.91 shelter7896.15 shelter7896.48 system7896.88 to7897.27 help.7897.35 Right?7897.59 We7897.84 wanted7897.91 to7898.23 help7898.4 find7899.12 people7899.36 long-term7900.08 supportive7900.56 necessary7901.36 housing.7901.92 And7902.56 in7902.8 this7902.88 amendment,7903.12 we7903.44 make7903.6 sure7903.76 we're7904 doing7904.08 that7904.32 by7904.48 looking7904.64 out7904.88 for7904.96 those7905.12 who7905.28 need7905.44 our7905.6 help7905.76 the7905.92 most,7906.16 those7906.48 individuals7906.72 with7907.2 disabilities.7907.44 Thank7908.08 you.7908.24
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


8125.67 DONATO8125.67 -8125.67 1528125.67 members8126.95 vote8127.27 in8127.51 the8127.67 affirmative,8127.75 none8128.23 the8128.47 negative.8128.55 The8129.19 amendment8129.35 is8129.75 adopted.8129.91
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE


9101.71 DONATO9101.71 -9101.71 At9101.71 the9102.3 request9102.89 of9103.48 representative9104.07 Saunders9104.66 of9105.25 Belchertown,9105.84 Duffy9106.43 of9107.02 Holyoke,9107.61 will9108.2 members9108.79 and9109.38 guests,9109.97 and9110.56 employees9111.15 please9111.9 stand9112.22 at9112.45 a9112.61 moment9112.69 to9113.02 sign9113.18 a9113.42 tribute9113.58 to9114.22 the9114.38 memory9114.53 of9115.02 Doug9115.33 Selphick,9117.82 who9118.69 passed9118.94 away9119.18 unexpectedly9119.58 at9120.85 the9121.1 age9121.18 of9121.5 549121.66 on9122.69 01/28/2025.9123.02 Doug9125.76 was9126 a9126.24 lifelong9126.32 resident9126.88 of9127.28 Holyoke9127.36 and9127.84 dedicated9128.56 his9129.12 professional9129.36 life9129.84 to9130.16 public9130.32 service,9130.72 serving9131.44 nearly9131.92 209132.4 years9132.8 as9133.36 a9133.44 town9133.52 planner9133.92 of9134.64 the9134.8 town9134.96 of9135.2 Ludlow.9135.44 Among9136.64 his9137.04 accomplishments,9137.28 Doug9138.4 Zephas9138.72 helped9139.36 to9139.76 develop9140 renewable9141.1 energy9141.83 projects9142.31 and9142.86 the9143.19 revitalization9143.42 of9144.63 the9144.78 Ludlow9144.94 Mills.9145.5 He9146.23 is9146.47 certified9146.63 by9147.5 his9147.75 mother,9147.99 Florence,9148.31 sister9149.75 Karen,9150.23 and9151.35 her9151.58 husband,9151.91 former9152.31 representative9152.78 Michael9153.35 Caine9153.58 of9153.99 Holyoke,9154.07 and9154.97 his9155.13 brother,9155.37 Clint9156.09 Sefic9156.65 of9157.37 Holyoke,9157.53 as9158.09 well9158.33 as9158.57 many9158.73 other9158.97 members9159.21 and9159.85 extended9160.17 families,9160.73 and9161.37 he9161.53 will9161.69 be9161.93 greatly9162.09 missed.9162.57 Thank9173.49 you.9173.81
SHOW NON-ESSENTIAL DIALOGUE

Speaker List:

  • Rep. Garballey Chair
  • Rep. Michlewitz Ways and Means Chair
  • Rep. Mariano House Speaker
  • Rep. Jones Jr. Minority Leader
  • Rep. Day Member
  • Rep. Frost Member
  • Rep. Livingstone Member
  • Rep. Hogan Clerk
  • Rep. Muradian Jr. Member
  • Rep. Peisch Member
  • Rep. Lewis Member
  • Rep. Donato Member
  • Rep. Lombardo Member
  • Rep. Gregoire Member
  • Rep. Decker Member
  • Rep. Consalvo Member
  • Rep. LeBoeuf Member
  • Rep. Saunders Member
  • Rep. Duffy Member

Bill List:

  • HB 57 - An act making supplemental appropriations for the fiscal year of 2025.

Synopsis:

The legislative committee hearing primarily focused on House Bill 57, which addresses supplemental appropriations for the fiscal year 2025, with a significant discussion around the emergency shelter system and the provision for legal asylum-seeking migrants. Rep. Michlewitz emphasized the importance of the bill to sustain the emergency shelter program amidst increasing pressures, advocating for an allocation of $425 million to continue operations through the fiscal year. He detailed the necessity of reforms requested by the governor, including a verification process for eligibility and a cap on the shelter system capacity to 4,000 families by the end of 2025.

Rep. Jones Jr. highlighted concerns regarding the depth of the background checks associated with the shelter program, advocating for more comprehensive checks beyond Massachusetts. This suggestion was met with opposition from Rep. Day, who argued that the proposed changes targeted vulnerable individuals such as pregnant women and young families, potentially undermining the emergency shelter law.

Amendment discussions were a central theme, with Amendment 6 seeing varied perspectives on enhancing the background checking process. Proponents like Rep. Frost and Rep. Livingstone supported extended checks, whereas others like Rep. Peisch raised concerns about constitutional challenges linked to alienage restrictions.

Throughout the hearing, various amendments were introduced and debated, notably Amendment 8 proposed by Rep. Muradian Jr., which sought to drastically reduce funding to the emergency shelter program from $425 million to $200 million. Rep. Michlewitz opposed this, labeling it impractical due to the major reforms being implemented.

Another amendment, proposed by Rep. Frost, Focusing on a one-year residency requirement for emergency shelter eligibility, was fundamentally opposed by Rep. Peisch on constitutional grounds, highlighting precedent inalienability-related cases.

Rep. Consalvo and Rep. Decker emphasized compassion-driven approaches in their amendments, aiming to extend program support to disabled individuals and ensure children's housing security. Their proposals received substantial support, illustrating a strong legislative intent to weave safety nets for vulnerable populations despite fiscal constraints.

The hearing also witnessed a special commemoration for Doug Selphick, a public servant and town planner, highlighting the assembly's community-focused spirit amidst intense policy discussions.

Ultimately, the examination of House Bill 57 underscored the balance the legislature seeks between compassionate policy measures and responsible fiscal management, with the fate of the emergency shelter law hanging prominently in the balance due to its social implications and economic demands.