REP5.84 MICHLEWITZ5.84 -5.84 Okay.5.84 Alright.6.56 We're6.88 going7.04 to7.28 get7.28 started.7.44 My7.76 apologies7.92 for8.32 being8.48 late.8.72 Welcome9.44 to10.72 the11.76 ways12.08 and12.4 means12.56 hearing12.8 on13.2 the14.16 FY15.17 2515.25 FareShare16.3 sup,16.61 that17.25 we17.41 are,17.65 taking18.05 up18.38 today,18.45 house18.77 bill19.09 55.19.57 My20.7 name20.77 is20.93 Aaron21.09 Michlewitz.21.25 I'm21.73 the21.89 house21.97 chair.22.3 I'm22.77 joined23.09 by23.41 my23.73 colleague,24.29 chair25.02 Mike25.34 Rodrigues25.57 from25.89 the26.05 senate.26.21 I'm27.02 just27.18 going27.34 to27.65 read27.65 off27.81 the28.05 members28.38 of28.77 the28.93 house29.02 that29.34 are29.49 here,29.65 and30.57 then30.65 kick30.81 it31.05 over31.21 to31.53 my32.49 colleague32.73 here.33.13 So,33.37 starting34.33 on34.65 my34.81 left34.89 here,35.13 we35.29 have35.45 the35.69 vice35.85 chair36.09 of36.41 the36.49 committee,36.57 representative37.61 Ann-Margaret38.33 Ferrante.38.81 Next39.85 is40.17 the40.33 assistant40.41 vice40.81 chair,41.05 representative41.29 Kip41.85 Diggs.42.09 Next,43.36 further43.92 to44.41 the44.56 left44.65 is45.05 the45.32 house45.6 house46.16 Republican46.41 ranking47.05 minority47.36 member,47.84 representative49.05 Smola.49.52 Next50.56 name50.8 is50.96 representative51.13 Marsy,51.68 then52.56 representative52.88 Elliot.53.28
54.42 To54.42 my54.66 right54.82 on55.3 the55.54 house55.62 members55.94 is,56.66 representative57.14 Kerans,57.62 representative57.94 Kilcoyne,58.5 representative,59.86 Higgins.60.42 Down61.62 here61.86 on62.18 on62.42 to62.66 my62.82 left,62.98 in63.7 the63.86 front64.02 row,64.26 representative,64.58 Judith65.38 Garcia,65.78 representative,67.3 Kelly68.69 Pease,69.02 representative,69.42 McKenna,70.53 representative71.25 Xiarhos,71.73 representative72.38 Scarsdale,72.94 representative73.81 Holmes,74.3 representative74.78 Beal,75.33 representative75.81 Sabadosa,76.38 representative77.09 Owens,77.66 representative78.14 Howard,78.69 representative79.09 Moran.79.66 And80.97 as81.13 we81.29 like81.53 to81.61 say81.69 in81.85 the82.01 cheap82.09 seats,82.33 we82.89 got83.05 representative83.29 Kasner,83.85 we84.25 got84.33 representative84.57 Duffy,84.97 we85.37 got85.45 representative85.61 Mendez,86.65 representative87.77 Chasen,88.25 representative88.65 Montano,89.21 representative90.17 Souza,90.81 representative91.21 Hamilton,91.85 and92.81 I92.97 think93.05 that's93.29 all93.45 the93.69 house93.77 members.93.93 And95.47 representative95.63 Sullivan-Almeida96.34 is96.83 walking96.91 in,97.14 and97.47 representative97.63 Hawkins98.02 got98.34 his98.5 hand98.58 raised99.3 as99.55 he's99.7 walking99.86 in100.1 right100.27 now.100.42 Alright.100.98 That101.63 is101.78 all101.94 the102.1 house102.19 members.102.42 I'll102.66 turn102.83 it102.98 over103.06 to103.3 my103.63 senator103.78 colleagues.104.19
109.96 SEN109.96 RODRIGUES109.96 -109.96 Thank109.96 you,110.2 mister111.08 chairman.111.4 Good112.28 afternoon,112.6 everyone.113.08 I'm113.56 happy114.2 to114.6 be114.84 here115.08 today.115.32 I115.72 am115.88 joined116.12 in116.6 no116.84 particular117.08 order117.8 other119.08 than119.32 when119.56 I119.72 recognize119.96 them.120.52 My122.14 vice122.45 chair,122.69 Senator123.33 Joe123.81 Comerford,123.97 my124.61 assistant124.85 vice125.33 chair,125.66 Senator126.06 Paul126.53 Feeney.126.78 Joining128.22 us128.62 also128.78 is129.09 Senator129.25 Nick129.74 Collins,129.97 Senator130.53 Jake131.09 Olivera,131.41 Senator132.38 Crighton,133.18 Senator134.05 Rush,135.09 Senator135.41 Miranda,135.89 Senator137.09 Brady,137.57 Senator138.45 Cronin,139.01 Senator139.81 Mark,140.37 and141.01 Senator141.25 Dooner.141.81 Now,142.77 did143.41 I143.57 miss143.81 anyone?144.29 It's145.89 always146.13 a146.45 fear146.61 when146.85 you're147.09 starting.147.25 Joe,148.96 so149.19 thank149.44 you.149.59 We149.83 are150 happy150.16 to150.47 be150.56 here,150.79 and151.51 engaged152 with152.47 all152.72 of152.88 you.152.95 Thank153.28 you.153.44
155.83 MICHLEWITZ155.83 -155.83 HB155.83 55155.83 -155.83 So155.83 once156.16 again,156.39 I156.56 want156.72 to156.88 thank156.88 everyone157.03 for157.44 joining157.59 us157.83 today.158 We're159.03 just159.19 going159.28 to159.51 do159.51 a159.75 quick159.83 brief160.24 over160.56 opening160.88 remarks161.19 and161.67 then,161.91 turn162.24 it162.47 over162.63 to162.88 our163.03 first163.19 panel.163.44 So164.56 today164.72 we165.04 are165.2 hearing165.36 house165.68 bill166 55,166.32 the166.96 governor's167.04 proposal167.44 on167.84 how168 to168.16 spend168.32 the168.96 more169.04 than169.2 $1.3169.44 billion170.64 in170.64 surplus170.88 from171.28 the171.52 FY171.84 25172 FareShare172.72 revenue.172.96 Given174 the174.32 size174.48 of174.8 these174.88 surplus175.12 funds176 and176.61 since176.84 this177.09 is177.33 the177.41 first177.49 time177.72 we178.13 are178.37 using178.53 this178.84 type179 of179.17 revenue179.25 in179.65 this179.81 manner,180.05 we180.93 felt181.17 it181.33 was181.49 appropriate181.65 to182.05 have182.13 a182.28 public182.44 process182.77 to183.17 hear183.25 the183.41 administration183.56 and184.37 stakeholders184.61 view185.65 on185.81 how186.05 best186.21 the186.77 Commonwealth186.93 can187.33 invest187.56 this187.89 money.188.05 This189.75 process189.99 marks190.31 the190.87 completion191.03 of191.43 seeing191.59 what191.83 a192.07 full192.15 cycle192.47 of193.19 the193.35 FareShare193.75 revenue193.99 will194.39 produce194.55 for195.11 our195.35 education195.51 and196.07 transportation196.23 sectors.196.87
198.31 As198.31 we198.47 currently198.71 enter199.11 a199.35 third199.51 budget199.75 cycle200.15 where200.63 the200.95 FareShare201.31 funds201.56 have201.79 been202.03 available202.28 to202.59 be202.75 spent,203.4 we204.19 in204.35 the204.44 legislature204.68 have205.16 taken205.31 great205.56 pride205.88 in206.19 the206.28 investments206.84 these207.4 funds207.64 have208.28 been208.51 making208.68 into208.92 new209.24 programs209.47 that209.96 are210.12 helping210.28 all210.68 our210.84 residents.211 Universal216.43 school216.99 meals,217.31 free218.03 community218.35 college,218.75 and219.87 much220.03 greater220.27 investments220.67 into221.15 the221.39 MBTA,221.55 RTAs,222.27 and222.91 early223.07 childcare.223.31 These224.83 programs225.15 and225.71 more225.95 are226.27 accomplishing226.51 precisely227.15 what227.63 the227.87 FareShare228.27 of228.59 money228.67 was228.91 intended229.07 to229.47 do,229.63 fostering230.41 a230.81 stronger231.04 and231.44 more231.6 equitable231.84 Commonwealth.232.32 Now234.49 with234.72 this234.97 large235.13 pot235.84 of236.09 one236.32 time236.56 surplus236.81 funds,237.28 we238.17 have238.41 a238.56 unique238.65 opportunity239.04 to239.53 further239.69 that240 progress.240.17 Given241.37 that241.76 many241.93 of242.17 the242.25 worthy242.41 programs242.72 that243.21 have243.37 been243.44 funded243.6 in243.93 the244.09 annual244.17 budget244.56 process244.88 have245.57 been245.73 in245.89 the245.97 education246.13 sector,246.61 it247.57 is247.73 entirely247.89 appropriate248.45 that248.93 the249.09 majority249.25 of249.73 these249.89 onetime250.13 funds250.61 in251.09 this251.17 round251.41 be251.97 spent252.13 in252.37 the252.53 transportation252.77 sector253.33 of253.65 our253.81 economy.253.97
255.25 When255.25 the255.49 FareShare255.89 amendment256.13 was256.45 pitched256.93 to257.25 the257.41 voters257.49 of257.81 the257.89 Commonwealth258.05 in258.45 2022,258.61 it259.82 was260.06 presented260.15 to260.63 be260.71 distributed260.87 evenly261.35 between261.75 education262.15 and262.63 transportation262.94 funding.263.59 This264.55 supplemental264.79 budget265.35 will265.67 allow265.82 us266.15 to266.31 fulfill266.46 that266.87 commitment.267.11 Today,268.55 we268.79 will268.94 hear269.11 from269.35 senior269.5 members269.82 of270.06 the270.15 Healey270.63 Administration,271.26 secretary271.26 of271.75 A&F272.15 Gorzkowicz,272.94 education272.94 secretary273.9 Tutwiler,274.46 and275.14 transportation275.26 secretary275.38 Tibbits-Nutt277.14 to277.78 hear277.94 more278.18 of278.42 the278.5 administration's279.14 proposal.279.62 Then280.82 we281.06 will281.14 hear281.3 from281.54 a281.7 number281.78 of282.1 stakeholders282.26 from283.14 both283.38 the283.62 education283.78 and284.34 transportation284.58 sectors285.22 and285.54 how285.7 these285.86 funds286.02 can286.34 better286.5 approve286.74 the286.98 Commonwealth.287.14 We288.75 also289 encourage289.39 all289.71 those289.88 who290.12 aren't290.27 testifying290.51 today291 to291.31 submit291.48 written291.88 testimony292.19 to292.92 our293.15 committees293.31 so294.04 we294.27 can294.44 hear294.6 from294.83 as295.07 many295.24 members295.48 of295.79 the295.88 public295.95 as296.35 possible296.51 on296.92 this297.07 issue.297.24 Thank298.12 you298.35 again,298.6 and298.92 I299.07 look299.15 forward299.31 to299.63 hearing299.71 from299.95 everyone300.35 today.300.75 And301.38 with301.62 that,301.7 I301.78 will301.86 turn302.1 it302.34 over302.42 to302.66 my302.82 counterpart,303.14 chair303.94 Mike304.34 Rodrigues.304.5
306.42 RODRIGUES306.42 -306.42 HB306.42 55306.42 -306.42 Thank306.42 you,306.74 mister306.82 chair.307.14 Good307.7 afternoon,308.02 everyone,308.66 and309.14 welcome309.38 to309.78 this310.02 public310.74 hearing311.14 regarding311.62 House312.26 Bill312.5 55,312.9 an313.54 act314.1 making314.1 appropriations314.9 for315.7 fiscal315.94 year316.42 2025316.66 to317.84 provide318 for318.88 supplementing319.28 certain319.92 existing320.4 appropriations321.04 of322.31 the322.31 so-called322.8 FareShare324 surplus324.4 supplemental324.88 budget325.44 filed325.92 by326.56 governor326.71 Healey.327.12 I328.15 would328.31 like328.48 to328.63 thank328.8 our329.12 partners329.28 in329.6 the329.75 house,329.92 chair330.15 Mike330.48 Michlewitz330.71 and331.12 his331.28 team,331.92 the332.16 House332.32 Committee332.48 on332.8 Ways332.96 and333.28 Means,333.36 for333.84 the334.08 continued334.24 partnership334.72 as335.36 we335.52 work335.68 to336.56 chart336.8 a337.2 fiscally337.36 sustainable337.92 path338.56 forward338.88 for339.2 Massachusetts339.44 through340.72 the340.96 fog341.12 of341.84 this342 ongoing342.32 economic343.12 uncertainty.343.68 With345.13 today's345.37 hearing,345.93 both346.56 the346.88 house346.97 and347.21 senate347.44 will348 hear348.17 directly348.49 from348.88 the349.05 administration349.13 along350.65 with350.97 distinguished351.29 panelists351.85 about352.97 their353.37 proposed353.69 plan354.25 to354.81 appropriate355.05 $1.3355.69 billion357.13 in357.13 surplus357.29 FareShare358.25 funds358.49 available359.35 from360.07 FY360.55 24360.79 to361.91 support362.15 our362.47 Commonwealth's362.63 education363.35 and364.47 transportation364.71 systems.367.19
367.59 This367.59 hearing367.83 marks368.63 an368.87 important369.11 step369.51 and369.99 presents370.15 us370.63 with370.87 a371.11 unique371.19 opportunity371.51 to372.63 consider372.79 the373.27 governor's373.43 proposal373.91 and374.81 make375.05 our375.21 own375.44 decisions375.69 on376.25 the376.4 fate376.49 of376.96 these377.21 surplus377.44 resources378.08 and378.96 the379.21 directions379.37 we379.93 want380.17 to380.49 collectively380.64 take.381.37 Knowing382.81 how383.13 critical383.29 and383.76 important383.93 it384.25 is384.4 to384.64 direct384.73 FareShare385.44 funds385.69 to386 improve386.25 the386.73 quality386.81 of387.21 life387.37 for387.61 our387.85 residents,388.12 we388.84 will389.08 consider389.24 ways389.72 to390.04 prioritize390.28 regional391.64 equity392.04 and392.68 support393 one393.48 time393.72 education394.12 and394.68 transportation394.92 investments395.72 that396.52 strive396.84 to397.24 benefit397.4 communities397.88 in398.84 every399.08 corner399.32 of399.72 the399.8 Commonwealth.399.96 After401.3 all,401.54 there402.25 are402.5 many402.74 critical403.13 and403.62 unique403.77 needs404.1 before404.5 us404.81 in405.13 the405.3 education405.54 and406.5 transportation406.74 sectors.407.54 Whether408.81 it's409.06 in409.3 the409.46 public409.54 higher409.94 education410.18 space,410.74 K411.69 through411.94 12412.18 education,412.57 the413.54 MBTA,413.69 regional415.08 public415.4 transit415.8 authorities,416.28 and416.76 local417 roads417.4 and417.64 bridges,417.88 we418.76 know418.92 how419.16 vitally419.4 important419.88 these420.28 are420.52 to420.84 the420.92 state's421.08 broader421.48 economy421.96 and422.68 our422.84 efforts423 to423.4 advance423.56 competitiveness.424.2
425.88 However,425.88 these427.01 FareShare427.5 revenues427.81 are428.3 limited,428.54 so429.25 we429.5 must429.74 be429.98 mindful430.13 of430.62 this430.78 dynamic431.1 because431.9 any432.38 decision432.69 we433.1 make433.34 to433.57 dedicate433.74 these434.54 resources434.78 will435.57 determine435.81 whether436.78 we437.1 create437.34 challenges438.21 for438.78 the439.01 structural439.1 balance439.65 of440.14 the440.22 budget440.38 once440.86 these441.18 one441.42 time441.66 revenues441.98 are442.46 depleted.442.7 It's444.06 fair444.3 to444.54 say444.7 that444.94 we445.1 are445.34 committed445.5 to446.22 maximizing446.38 the447.02 impact447.26 of447.66 these447.74 FareShare448.3 funds448.54 and449.26 making449.5 meaningful449.82 investments450.46 in450.94 our451.1 public451.18 transportation451.66 and452.22 education452.46 sectors452.94 in453.84 a454 fiscally454.24 responsible454.88 and455.75 sustainable456.07 manner456.71 without457.44 undermining457.75 the458.4 financial458.56 integrity459.19 of459.75 the459.92 Commonwealth.460.07 To461.27 that461.51 end,461.68 we462.4 in462.71 the462.88 senate462.96 stand463.84 ready464.15 to464.56 work464.63 with464.88 the465.04 administration465.19 and466 our466.15 friends466.4 and466.63 partners466.8 in467.19 the467.36 house467.44 as468.18 we468.42 develop468.66 a469.06 concrete469.3 plan469.7 recognizing470.66 the471.38 one471.62 time471.78 nature472.1 of472.34 these472.5 funds472.74 and473.46 the473.62 unite473.78 unique474.26 opportunity474.74 in475.38 front475.54 of475.78 us475.86 to476.66 make476.82 thoughtful477.06 investments477.62 that478.5 support478.74 education479.14 and479.86 transportation480.1 initiatives480.98 in481.89 a482.06 regional482.21 and482.86 equitable483.01 manner.483.57
484.54 I484.54 look484.69 forward484.86 to485.18 hearing485.25 from485.57 our485.81 friends485.89 in486.13 the486.3 administration486.46 along487.65 with487.98 the488.21 distinguished488.38 panelists488.94 who489.65 we489.81 have489.98 invited490.13 to490.62 appear490.77 before491.33 us491.65 today491.89 as492.54 we492.69 lay492.94 the493.1 groundwork493.25 on493.81 how493.98 to494.13 responsibly494.38 invest495.1 these495.82 One495.98 time496.3 resources496.62 and497.34 support497.74 initiatives498.14 to499.42 reinforce499.66 our500.3 state's500.46 economic500.94 foundation,501.42 boost502.22 support502.62 for503.34 quality503.58 public503.98 education,504.38 and505.1 bolster505.26 the506.06 state's506.22 transportation506.7 infrastructure.507.5 Thank508.79 you508.94 all,509.26 and509.59 I509.82 look509.99 forward510.15 to510.47 today's510.87 testimony.511.26
513.42 Thank513.42 you,513.59 mister513.83 chairman.514.14 So515.5 we'll515.75 get515.9 the516.07 right516.14 started.516.3 I516.71 do516.79 I516.95 did517.11 want517.26 to517.42 recognize517.42 that517.9 representative517.99 Ramos518.71 has519.18 joined519.26 us519.59 as519.75 well.519.9 And520.72 I520.96 don't521.04 think521.2 I521.36 missed521.52 anybody521.76 else522.08 in522.32 the522.4 house,522.48 unless523.28 when523.68 anybody523.76 when524.24 you524.4 snuck524.56 in524.8 while525.04 I525.2 wasn't525.28 paying525.52 attention.525.68 But,526.08 let's528.48 start528.72 with528.88 the529.04 first529.2 panel,529.36 from529.92 the530.08 administration,530.16 secretary530.88 Gurkowitz,531.28 secretary531.76 Tetweiler,532.24 and532.72 secretary532.8 Tibbets533.2 Nuts.533.52 Thank534.08 you,534.32 for535.36 being535.91 here536.15 today.536.24 Thank536.55 you536.71 for536.88 putting537.12 this537.43 proposal537.6 forward,538.55 and539.43 and539.67 working539.83 with540.07 the540.24 governor,540.32 on541.12 this541.27 issue.541.51 And541.83 we541.91 look542.07 forward542.32 to,542.55 working542.95 with543.19 you,543.36 and543.51 I543.75 just543.91 want544.24 to544.55 hear544.55 your544.71 opening544.88 remarks.545.19 Thank545.6 you.545.75
546.88 MATTHEW546.88 GORZKOWICZ546.88 -546.88 ADMINISTRATION546.88 AND546.88 FINANCE546.88 -546.88 HB546.88 55546.88 -546.88 Great.546.88 Thank547.19 you.547.43 Good548.7 afternoon,548.86 everyone.549.5 It's550.14 a550.38 pleasure550.46 to550.86 be550.94 here.551.18 Thanks551.74 to551.98 you,552.06 Chair555.1 Michlewitz,555.34 Chair555.34 Rodrigues555.34 and555.34 the555.5 committee.555.66 It's556.62 a556.78 pleasure556.86 to,557.34 once557.82 again,558.06 be558.62 able558.78 to558.94 present,559.1 what559.9 I560.14 think560.22 are560.46 some560.7 really560.86 exciting561.18 innovative561.66 proposals562.14 that562.54 the562.7 administration562.86 has563.42 advanced,563.58 to,565 advance565.63 some565.96 of566.12 our566.2 priorities,566.43 particularly,567.32 given568.6 the569.08 nature569.15 of569.48 of569.72 the569.88 revenue570.04 and,570.51 the571.24 unique571.39 opportunity571.8 that572.27 we572.43 have,572.67 to573.15 make573.24 some573.48 meaningful,573.63 changes575.08 and,575.55 for576.6 a577.51 lot577.63 of577.88 the577.96 priorities578.04 we579.08 could579.24 equally579.59 share.579.99 I581.51 am581.75 Matthew581.83 Gorzkowicz,582.15 secretary582.63 for582.95 administration583.19 and583.67 finance,583.83 and584.39 I'm584.63 joined,584.71 as585.51 the585.67 chairman585.83 said,586.23 by586.47 our586.63 secretary586.87 of587.51 transportation,587.75 Monica589.11 Tibbits-Nutt590.23 and590.39 Dr.590.55 Dr.590.87 Patrick590.87 Tuckweil,591.19 secretary591.67 of592.07 education,592.31 secretary592.31 of592.31 education.592.31
593.11 We593.11 are593.38 pleased593.45 to593.7 be593.74 here593.77 today594.01 to594.33 present594.5 our594.82 supplemental594.98 budget595.45 for595.86 surplus596.01 FareShare596.74 revenue597.13 from597.53 fiscal597.7 year598.1 2024.600.65 It's600.89 been600.89 over601.05 two601.21 years601.38 since601.62 the601.77 voters601.86 approved602.17 the602.5 FareShare602.82 surtax,603.13 and603.86 our603.93 administration604.1 has604.74 carefully604.98 and605.53 successfully605.77 worked606.41 to606.65 deploy606.96 these607.92 funds608.88 to609.52 make610 quality610.16 education610.32 and610.4 transportation610.48 more611.68 accessible611.76 and612.08 affordable612.48 for612.96 all613.12 Massachusetts613.28 residents.614.08 In614.88 partnership615.12 with615.68 the615.76 legislature,615.92 we616.72 have616.8 stabilized617.04 the617.76 childcare617.92 sector,618.4 launched619.12 free619.52 community619.6 college,620.16 increased620.98 Chapter621.3 90621.62 support622.01 for622.34 municipalities,622.58 expanded623.62 regional624.1 transit624.42 authority624.82 services,625.22 and625.77 much626.1 more.626.34 We627.05 have627.3 achieved627.46 these627.77 results627.93 in628.34 part628.5 due628.74 to628.98 our629.13 strategy629.38 of629.86 not630.1 just630.42 spending630.82 the631.22 surtax631.46 dollars,631.86 but632.18 leveraging632.42 these634.1 funds634.25 to634.56 create634.72 new635.04 bonding635.2 capacity635.52 for635.92 capital636.16 projects.636.56
638.08 This638.08 bill,639.12 the639.68 spare639.92 share640.16 sup640.48 before640.72 you,640.96 builds641.44 on641.76 that642 successful642.24 track642.72 record643.04 and643.52 proposes643.84 investments644.32 that644.8 will644.96 continue645.2 to645.6 transform645.76 education646.32 and646.8 transportation646.96 here647.52 in647.76 Massachusetts.647.92 As649.68 we649.93 have650.09 previously650.33 testified,650.8 we651.52 have651.68 taken651.85 a652.17 fiscally652.33 responsible652.73 approach653.29 to653.52 budgeting653.68 surtax654.17 given654.73 that654.97 it655.13 is655.21 a655.37 new655.45 revenue655.68 stream656 without656.49 an656.8 established656.88 track657.45 record.657.68 Within658.57 that658.97 context,659.21 we659.68 agreed660 working660.57 with660.8 the660.97 legislature661.13 through662.17 our662.33 consensus662.49 revenue663.05 process663.45 to664.23 limit664.31 spending664.71 of665.03 surtax665.19 dollars665.59 to665.91 $1666.07 billion666.87 in666.87 fiscal667.03 year667.35 24.667.59 We668.55 did668.71 that668.87 knowing669.19 that669.59 fiscal669.75 year670.15 24670.39 was671.03 the671.27 first671.51 full671.91 fiscal672.31 year672.63 that672.87 we673.03 would673.11 be673.27 collecting674.15 surtax674.95 revenue.675.51 Since676.49 then,676.73 we676.96 have677.21 responsibly677.45 increased678.16 the678.57 limit678.73 a679.61 little679.76 each680.16 year680.4 to680.96 $1.3681.21 billion682.49 in682.49 the682.73 current682.8 fiscal683.13 year683.45 25683.61 budget684 and684.4 then684.57 finally684.73 to685.04 1.95685.28 billion686.49 in686.49 the686.64 fiscal686.8 year687.13 26687.28 budget,687.85 which688.25 you688.64 will688.8 be689.04 considering689.37 very690.16 shortly.690.49
691.74 As691.74 you691.9 know,692.06 surtax692.38 collections692.94 have693.34 outperformed693.58 projections694.38 within695.34 with695.9 the695.98 state696.14 collecting696.46 nearly696.86 $2.5697.26 billion698.62 in698.62 fiscal698.86 year699.26 25.699.5 That700.78 is701.02 what701.18 brings701.42 us701.66 here701.82 today701.98 and702.38 the702.62 bill702.78 before703.02 you703.34 which703.58 appropriates703.82 $1.3704.46 billion705.74 in705.74 surtax705.98 revenue706.46 that707.13 was707.37 collected707.61 in708 excess708.25 of708.57 the708.73 consensus708.88 revenue709.37 estimate709.68 last710.4 fiscal710.81 year.711.21 This712.09 bill712.33 proposes712.57 to712.97 spend713.05 a713.37 total713.45 of713.85 857.5714 million716.49 for716.49 transportation716.73 and717.68 462.5717.85 million720.17 for720.17 education.720.4 When721.58 taken721.74 together722.22 with722.86 surtax723.18 appropriations723.74 in724.54 the724.78 fiscal724.94 year725.26 26725.5 budget,725.98 our726.38 house726.54 one726.86 budget,727.1 we727.98 recommend728.22 a728.78 nearly728.86 50-50729.5 split729.74 between730.14 the730.54 two730.62 sectors.730.78 So731.58 we're731.74 essentially731.98 looking732.46 at732.7 all732.86 of733.1 the733.18 resources733.34 available733.82 to734.22 to734.45 date734.85 and734.92 making735.16 sure735.4 they're735.64 divided735.8 equally736.21 between736.92 education737.88 and738.37 transportation.738.61 And739.57 I739.8 want739.97 to740.13 emphasize740.21 that740.68 because740.92 our741.25 House741.49 One741.73 FareShare742.29 proposal742.45 and742.85 the743.09 SUP743.25 work743.8 together743.97 and744.52 should744.76 be744.92 considered745.09 as745.88 a746.04 package.746.21
747.25 The747.25 SUP747.4 is747.64 weighted747.8 towards748.37 investments748.76 in748.78 the748.8 MBTA748.82 and748.83 transportation748.85 where748.87 we748.88 can748.9 make748.92 an748.94 impact748.95 with748.97 more748.99 one749 time749.16 recurring758.23 education,759.11 appropriations,759.75 and760.39 programming.760.63 This761.67 approach761.91 recognizes762.47 a763.03 significant763.76 need764.33 and764.64 opportunities764.88 in765.52 both765.68 areas,765.92 and766.64 we766.8 believe766.96 that767.21 an767.52 even767.68 split767.92 aligns768.33 with768.73 the768.96 will769.13 of769.37 the769.45 voters769.52 who770 initiated770.16 the770.64 surtax.770.8 From771.92 helping772.16 local772.49 cities772.8 and773.13 towns773.21 ensure773.52 safe773.92 transportation774.25 during774.88 winter775.21 storms775.52 to776.25 providing776.4 career776.8 and777.13 technical777.28 education777.76 grants,778.25 the778.78 investments778.94 in779.18 this779.34 bill779.58 will779.82 maximize779.98 the780.54 benefits780.7 of781.1 FareShare781.58 for781.98 communities782.22 across782.78 the783.1 Commonwealth.783.26 My784.38 colleagues784.62 can785.18 share785.42 more,785.66 but785.9 you786.06 will786.22 see786.38 how786.86 we787.1 try787.26 to787.5 use787.58 these787.82 surplus787.98 funds788.38 to788.7 address788.78 challenges789.1 like789.74 the789.98 extraordinary790.22 cost790.86 of791.1 special791.26 education791.66 for792.06 districts792.46 or793.25 replenishing793.34 critical793.89 reserves794.29 at795.01 the795.17 MBTA795.34 and796.13 invest796.38 in797.74 workforce797.98 at798.77 MassDOT798.93 and799.41 regional799.58 transit799.98 authorities.800.38
801.41 As801.41 always,801.65 my802.22 team802.38 at802.62 A&F803.1 is803.25 focused803.41 on803.74 responsible803.89 fiscal804.38 management804.7 of805.1 our805.25 state805.34 resources.805.58 We806.22 are806.38 eager806.62 to807.01 continue807.17 putting808.88 FareShare809.36 funds809.6 to809.84 work810 for810.16 Massachusetts810.32 through811.12 a811.28 sustainable811.52 and812 responsible812.16 investment812.72 strategy.813.2 That's814.24 why814.48 I814.72 encourage814.88 you815.28 as815.52 you815.68 consider815.84 the816.8 supplemental816.96 budget817.52 before818.16 you818.56 to819.04 look819.2 at819.36 the819.44 entire819.68 suite820 of820.32 legislation820.48 that821.28 the821.44 governor821.6 has822.04 filed822.28 since822.76 January823.16 to823.96 know824.13 how824.37 those824.52 pieces824.68 and825 understand825.25 how825.64 those825.8 pieces826.04 fit826.28 together.826.45 For827.16 instance,827.4 we827.73 have827.88 also828.04 proposed828.28 not828.76 only828.92 expanding829.33 our829.96 innovative830.13 use830.92 of831.16 FareShare831.57 to831.96 leverage832.13 new832.61 borrowing832.76 for833.16 transportation,833.33 but834.13 to834.28 also834.45 expand834.76 that835.16 to835.53 the835.69 world835.85 of836.01 higher836.17 education.836.49 The837.13 Governor's837.37 House837.77 One838.09 budget838.25 proposes838.65 to839.05 use839.13 125839.37 million840.41 of,840.41 surtax841.13 for842.01 higher842.25 ed842.49 capital842.81 to843.29 address843.53 the843.77 significant843.93 backlog844.41 of844.81 deferred844.89 maintenance845.29 and845.93 carbon846.09 reduction846.41 projects846.89 at847.29 our847.54 campuses.847.7
848.58 And848.58 that848.83 is850.9 the851.3 125851.54 million852.9 that852.9 will853.07 finance853.3 the853.63 BRIGHT853.78 Act,854.11 which854.42 is854.66 in854.75 our855.07 House855.7 One856.02 proposal.856.26 The857.14 strategy857.3 will857.78 also857.95 make858.26 it858.42 possible858.58 to858.9 enact859.07 Chapter859.73 90859.89 bill,860.13 which860.77 is861.09 a861.25 five861.41 year861.65 300861.81 million862.53 dollar862.53 plan862.77 that863.25 will863.41 not863.65 only863.81 increase864.05 funding864.37 for864.69 roads864.85 and865.17 bridges,865.25 but865.65 also865.81 give866.13 the866.29 municipality866.45 some867.09 predictability.867.25 So868.61 please,868.93 when869.25 you869.41 look869.57 at869.73 this870.05 particular870.69 bill,871.17 the871.41 FareShare871.81 sup,872.13 please872.59 also872.75 keep872.99 in873.23 mind873.38 the873.71 House874.02 One874.35 proposal,874.35 which874.75 also875.07 leverages875.47 some876.02 of876.18 the876.35 surtax876.59 and877.23 the877.47 operating877.71 budget878.02 as878.42 well878.59 as878.99 the879.23 Chapter879.38 90879.71 bill,880.02 the880.5 BRIGHT880.66 Act.880.9 They881.95 all882.18 work882.42 together882.75 and883.38 it's884.42 important884.66 to885.07 stand885.23 back885.47 and885.63 understand885.79 how886.18 those886.89 pieces887.05 fit887.37 together.887.61 And888.73 I888.97 I889.05 think889.05 the889.37 information889.61 that890.01 we've890.17 laid890.41 out890.65 for890.81 you890.97 tries891.37 to892.33 do892.41 that892.57 in892.89 a893.05 very,893.37 in894.49 a894.65 way894.73 that's894.97 sort895.13 of895.29 hopefully895.53 easy895.93 to896.17 digest.896.33 We897.45 look897.61 forward897.77 to898.09 your898.25 continued898.41 partnership,898.88 and899.92 look900.8 forward901.04 to901.28 working901.44 with901.68 you901.85 and902 answering902.25 any902.57 questions902.73 you902.96 have.903.13 I'll903.28 now903.52 turn903.68 it903.85 over904 to904.25 my904.96 colleagues,905.2 and906.08 my906.25 colleague906.4 secretary906.73 Tibbitsnutt.907.2
910.57 MONICA910.57 TIBBITS-NUTT910.57 -910.57 MASSACHUSETTS910.57 DEPARTMENT910.57 OF910.57 TRANSPORTATION910.57 -910.57 HB910.57 55910.57 -910.57 Good910.57 afternoon.910.8 Thank911.61 you,911.85 Chair912.16 Rodrigues,913.2 Chair913.76 Michlewitz913.76 ,913.76 and913.76 esteemed913.92 committee914.32 members.914.64 My915.44 name915.6 isMonica916.4 Tibbits-Nutt.917.04 I917.04 am917.2 the917.36 secretary917.52 and918.08 CEO918.4 of918.96 the919.04 Massachusetts919.2 Department920 of920.32 Transportation.920.48 As922.24 secretary922.56 Gorzkowicz923.04 said,923.68 thank924.08 you924.24 for924.56 your924.72 continued924.88 partnership925.44 and926 support926.52 over926.85 the926.92 years927.09 and927.57 for927.8 the927.97 opportunity928.21 to928.92 testify929.16 today929.8 on930.21 House930.45 Bill930.68 55,931 which931.97 appropriates932.21 surplus932.85 FareShare933.64 funds933.88 to934.37 strengthen934.52 our935.09 state's935.33 transportation935.73 system936.45 and937 infrastructure.937.25 Whether939.32 you939.48 drive939.8 to940.04 work,940.28 ride940.76 the941.08 T,941.24 bike,941.8 or942.28 rely942.52 on942.76 safe942.92 roads943.24 and943.48 bridges,943.64 every944.2 one944.52 of944.68 us944.84 depends945.16 on945.72 transportation945.96 that947.16 is947.4 reliable,947.72 resilient,948.52 and949.16 well949.4 maintained.949.64
951 As951 we951.16 navigate951.32 a951.8 challenging951.96 fiscal951.97 environment,951.98 we951.99 remain952 firmly952 committed952.01 to952.02 making952.03 responsible,952.04 equitable,952.12 Massachusetts964.71 residents.965.59 House967 One967.24 reflects967.56 this968.04 commitment.968.28 It969.32 is969.48 a969.64 balanced,969.88 forward970.52 thinking970.84 budget971.24 that971.72 builds971.96 on972.36 our972.52 administration's972.76 successes973.64 while974.6 maintaining974.92 fiscal975.56 discipline.976.04 It977 safeguards977.24 critical977.88 programs978.28 and978.84 services979.08 across979.72 all980.28 351980.52 cities981.72 and982.04 towns,982.2 even982.94 as983.26 we983.5 manage983.66 modest984.14 revenue984.54 growth984.94 and985.35 increasing985.5 pressures.986.07 In988.14 addition988.46 to988.87 the989.02 surplus989.18 FareShare990.07 funds,990.3 Chapter990.78 90991.26 funding991.58 remains992.07 a992.38 cornerstone992.54 of993.35 our993.5 commitment993.66 to994.23 supporting994.46 local994.87 infrastructure995.26 across996.07 the996.46 Commonwealth.996.63 These997.98 dollars998.22 are998.7 critical998.94 for999.58 cities999.82 and1000.3 towns.1001.42
1001.74 Allowing1001.74 them1001.74 to1001.98 address1002.14 essential1002.7 repair1003.26 and1003.74 improvement1003.9 projects,1004.54 including1005.42 small1005.9 bridges,1006.14 road1007.1 resurfacing,1007.5 and1008.22 other1008.54 community1008.86 specific1009.5 needs.1010.06 Programs1011.25 like1011.82 our1012.05 small1012.22 bridge1012.54 program1012.86 exemplify1013.42 our1014.13 dedication1014.38 to1014.93 safety,1015.1 travel1015.98 experience,1016.38 and1017.1 better1017.25 connectivity,1017.58 especially1018.7 in1019.25 regions1019.5 where1019.82 even1020.05 minor1020.38 infrastructure1020.77 upgrades1021.42 can1021.89 have1022.05 a1022.22 major1022.38 impact.1022.77 This1023.88 year's1024.12 proposal1024.36 includes1025.08 1001025.8 million1026.04 dollar1026.44 appropriation1026.84 for1027.56 the1027.72 Commonwealth1027.88 Transportation1028.52 Fund1029.24 Debt1029.56 Service.1029.88 This1030.84 strategic1031.16 investment1031.64 will1032.2 unlock1032.52 over1033 $51033.4 billion1034.6 in1034.6 additional1034.84 transportation1035.56 funding1036.2 over1036.76 the1037 next1037.32 decade,1037.55 including1038.43 $1.51039.55 billion1041.32 over1041.32 five1041.63 years1041.88 for1042.36 Chapter1042.6 901042.99 reform1043.39 with1044.12 targeted1044.43 improvements1044.91 for1045.55 rural1045.8 roads.1047.39
1049.08 $1.51049.08 billion1049.08 for1049.08 road1049.39 and1049.71 bridge1049.88 cycle1050.28 management1051.32 supporting1051.96 long1052.44 term1052.76 infrastructure1053.4 resilience1053.96 and1054.6 sustainability.1054.76 These1056.52 local1056.84 and1057.24 regional1057.48 investments1058.04 are1058.6 vital1058.84 to1059.32 maintaining1059.56 and1060.04 modernizing1060.28 our1061.08 transportation1061.24 network.1062.04 They1063 also1063.24 directly1063.64 support1064.28 the1064.68 quality1064.76 of1065.16 life1065.32 and1065.96 economic1066.59 vitality1066.9 of1067.55 every1067.79 community1068.11 in1068.59 Massachusetts.1068.83 The1070.66 role1070.83 of1071.14 our1071.23 regional1071.47 transit1071.87 authorities1072.35 in1072.83 delivering1073.14 essential1073.71 public1074.18 transportation1074.66 across1075.47 the1075.79 Commonwealth1076.03 cannot1076.66 be1077.07 overstated.1077.31 FareShare1079.31 funding1079.55 provides1080.11 an1080.42 opportunity1080.59 for1092.29 affordability1092.29 for1093.01 riders.1093.25 At1094.36 its1094.52 core,1094.76 this1095.32 work1095.47 is1095.79 about1096.04 advancing1096.43 regional1096.99 transportation1097.63 equity,1098.43 ensuring1099.39 that1099.95 residents1100.19 across1100.67 Massachusetts,1101.23 regardless1102.28 of1102.84 zip1103.08 code,1103.32 have1103.88 access1104.12 to1104.52 reliable1104.76 and1105.39 accessible1105.71 transit1106.43 options.1106.91
1108.1 I1108.1 look1108.26 forward1108.5 to1108.82 continuing1109.06 engagement1109.62 with1110.18 both1110.34 legislators1110.74 and1111.62 RTA1112.02 leaders1112.5 to1112.9 better1113.14 understand1113.46 their1113.94 evolving1114.18 challenges1114.74 and1115.7 to1115.86 explore1116.1 potential1116.66 updates1117.14 to1117.62 the1117.78 funding1117.94 these1118.34 agencies1118.58 depend1119.22 on.1119.54 By1120.38 working1120.54 together,1120.94 we1121.35 can1121.59 ensure1121.74 RTAs1122.14 have1122.7 the1122.94 tools1123.02 they1123.42 need1123.59 to1123.83 thrive1124.07 and1124.54 serve1124.78 their1125.11 communities1125.42 effectively.1126.14 Together,1128.14 these1128.7 investments1128.94 from1129.5 Chapter1129.74 901130.14 support1130.78 to1131.18 RTA1131.42 funding1131.98 reflects1132.7 a1133.18 broader1133.35 unified1134.07 vision,1134.46 building1135.26 a1135.66 transportation1136.28 system1136.84 that1137.24 works1137.4 for1137.72 everyone1138.04 in1138.52 Massachusetts.1138.76 They1140.36 are1140.52 not1140.76 just1140.92 budget1141.24 lines.1141.56 They1142.04 are1142.2 the1142.44 foundation1142.76 of1143.56 daily1143.72 life1144.2 for1144.52 our1144.76 residents.1145 Whether1145.96 it's1146.2 getting1146.44 to1146.76 work,1146.92 making1147.56 a1147.8 doctor's1148.04 appointment,1148.44 or1148.92 visiting1149.16 family,1149.64 these1150.2 investments1150.44 make1151.16 those1151.4 moments1151.72 post1153.86 FareShare1154.17 revenue1154.17 is1154.65 already1154.89 delivering1155.3 results1155.86 and1156.34 the1156.58 surplus1156.73 allocation1157.38 allows1158.1 us1158.41 to1158.58 go1158.73 even1158.97 further.1159.3 We're1160.17 investing1160.49 in1160.97 safety,1161.21 accessibility,1162.02 and1162.89 long1163.13 term1163.45 resilience1163.7 with1164.41 targeting1164.65 funding1165.21 to1165.62 drive1165.78 impact1166.1 where1166.49 it1166.73 is1166.89 needed1167.06 most.1167.45 4001168.55 million1169.91 for1169.91 the1170.07 Federal1170.23 Transit1170.71 Administration1171.19 Reserve,1171.99 helping1172.47 to1172.87 protect1173.03 and1173.51 maximize1173.75 our1174.31 share1174.55 of1174.87 critical1175.11 federal1175.59 funding.1175.99 $3001177.35 million1178.79 to1178.79 replenish1179.03 the1179.51 MBTA1179.75 stabilization1180.55 reserve,1181.43 ensuring1182.27 fiscal1182.84 health1183.23 and1183.71 operational1184.12 stability,1184.67 $671186.03 million1187.55 to1187.55 continue1187.79 the1188.27 MBTA1188.52 income1189.32 eligible1189.71 fair1190.36 relief1190.67 program,1191.15 providing1192.03 affordable1192.6 access1193.39 to1193.95 transit1194.19 for1194.76 low1194.99 income1195.23 riders.1196.95 $251198.15 million1198.15 for1198.15 the1198.39 winter1198.55 resilience1198.87 assistance1199.51 program,1200.07 helping1200.79 municipalities1201.19 prepare1202.07 for1202.47 and1202.79 respond1203.19 to1203.59 extreme1204.07 weather1204.63 events.1205.03 251206.15 million1207.51 for1207.51 regional1207.67 transit1208.15 authority1208.55 workforce1209.11 initiatives,1209.67 including1210.82 CDL1211.38 cost1212.1 assistance1212.49 and1213.13 targeted1213.38 training1213.86 to1214.34 address1214.58 staffing1214.97 shortages.1216.89
1218.82 $17.51218.82 million1218.82 to1218.82 strengthen1218.97 MassDOT's1219.53 workforce1220.17 and1221.05 project1221.29 delivery1221.69 capacity,1222.26 ensuring1223.27 we1223.67 can1223.83 deliver1223.99 critical1224.47 projects1224.95 efficiently1225.59 and1226.39 effectively.1226.87 Dollars1228.39 101228.47 million1229.35 for1229.35 micro1229.67 transit1230.07 and1230.55 last1230.79 mile1231.11 innovation1231.43 grants,1232.07 supporting1232.63 creative1233.19 community1234.15 driven1234.71 solutions1235.19 to1235.83 transportation1235.99 access.1236.95 Each1238.43 of1238.6 these1238.76 investments1239.08 is1239.63 designed1239.96 to1240.43 support1240.6 a1240.99 stronger,1241.39 more1242.04 connected1242.36 Massachusetts,1243.08 where1244.28 every1244.67 community1245.08 from1245.8 our1246.04 densest1246.28 cities1246.76 to1247.15 our1247.32 most1247.56 rural1247.8 towns1248.12 can1248.91 rely1249.15 on1249.56 a1249.71 transportation1249.96 system1250.67 that1250.99 is1251.23 safe,1251.42 equitable,1252.38 and1252.94 built1253.18 to1253.5 last.1253.66 This1254.62 is1254.86 about1254.94 more1255.34 than1255.5 infrastructure.1255.66 It's1256.7 about1256.94 delivering1257.18 opportunity,1257.82 expanding1258.94 mobility,1259.5 and1260.14 fulfilling1260.38 our1261.02 collective1261.26 responsibility1261.82 to1262.78 ensure1262.86 every1263.5 resident1263.82 can1264.38 move1264.62 forward1264.86 no1265.72 matter1265.96 where1266.2 they1266.44 live1266.68 or1267 how1267.16 they1267.4 travel.1267.64
1268.76 We1268.76 fully1269 recognize1269.4 the1269.96 fiscal1270.04 challenges1270.52 ahead,1271 and1271.4 we1271.64 remain1271.8 committed1272.28 to1272.61 being1272.76 thoughtful1273.09 stewards1273.57 of1274.04 taxpayer1274.2 dollars,1274.85 ensuring1275.64 every1276.2 dollar1276.52 is1276.85 deployed1277 effectively1277.57 and1278.28 with1278.52 impact.1278.85 House1280.24 One1280.56 strikes1280.88 a1281.2 careful1281.36 balance.1281.76 It1282.64 protects1282.88 essential1283.36 programs1283.92 while1284.56 investing1284.96 boldly1285.6 in1286 the1286.16 future1286.4 of1286.72 our1286.88 transportation1287.2 system.We1289.04 are1289.2 deeply1289.36 grateful1289.76 for1290.08 the1290.24 legislature's1290.4 partnership1291.2 and1292.22 continued1292.46 collaboration1293.02 to1293.82 ensure1293.98 the1294.38 FY1294.62 '261295.1 budget1295.74 reflects1296.13 both1296.62 the1296.86 needs1297.02 of1297.34 our1297.41 residents1297.65 and1298.46 the1298.7 realities1298.86 of1299.58 our1299.65 economic1299.89 landscape.1300.46 Together1301.58 in1302.06 transportation,1302.3 we1303.26 continue1303.49 to1304.06 move1304.22 Massachusetts1304.62 forward.1305.49 Thank1306.38 you1306.54 for1306.62 your1306.86 time1307.1 and1307.5 consideration.1307.82 I1309.1 will1309.26 now1309.42 hand1309.66 it1309.9 over1310.14 to1310.38 the1310.46 secretary1310.7 of1311.18 education,1311.34 Dr.Tutwiler.1321.43
1321.43 PATRICK1321.43 TUTWILER1321.43 -1321.43 OFFICE1321.43 OF1321.43 SECRETARY1321.43 OF1321.43 EDUCATION1321.43 -1321.43 HB1321.43 551321.43 -1321.43 Thank1321.43 you1321.76 very1321.99 much.1321.99 Secretary,1323.04 I1324.08 was1324.23 prepared1324.39 to1324.8 use1324.96 my1325.2 teacher's1325.36 voice1325.76 and1325.99 to1326.15 shout1326.39 my1327.28 testimony,1327.43 out,1328.56 to1329.04 everyone.1329.2 But1329.6 good1329.84 afternoon,1329.99 Chair1332.95 Michlewitz,1333.99 Chair1333.99 Rodrigues,1333.99 members1333.99 of1334.55 the1334.71 joint1334.95 committee1335.27 on1335.67 ways1335.83 and1336.31 means.1336.47 My1337.43 name1337.59 is1337.75 Pat1337.91 Tutwiler,1338.15 and1338.71 I1338.87 have1338.95 the1339.11 great1339.19 honor1339.43 of1339.99 serving1340.15 as1340.63 your1340.79 secretary1341.99 of1342.63 education.1342.79 This1344.15 afternoon,1344.39 I'd1344.87 like1344.95 to1345.11 provide1345.55 a1345.79 brief1346.11 overview1346.51 of1347.31 the1347.55 administration's1347.71 proposal1348.59 on1349.38 how1349.63 FareShare1350.35 supplemental1350.99 budget1351.55 works1351.95 in1352.27 service1352.51 of1353.14 meeting1353.31 the1353.63 needs1353.79 of1354.18 all1354.42 students1354.74 in1355.31 Massachusetts.1355.47 I'd1356.66 like1356.9 to1357.14 begin1357.31 by1357.71 outlining1358.35 the1358.9 five1359.14 core1359.47 values1359.87 that1360.7 drive1360.94 the1361.18 education1361.5 secretariat's1362.14 work1362.86 to1363.58 be1363.66 more1363.82 equitable,1364.14 affordable,1365.26 and1366.06 accessible1366.3 for1366.94 all1367.18 students1367.5 and1368.38 families1368.7 and1369.26 educators.1369.66
1371.42 Advancing1371.42 equity1371.9 and1372.3 inclusion,1372.46 maintaining1373.66 a1374.46 holistic1374.7 perspective,1375.42 embracing1377.02 collaboration,1377.58 championing1379.02 innovation,1379.73 and1380.7 centering1380.93 fulfillment.1381.58 Governor1383.1 Healey's1383.49 FareShare1384.3 supplemental1384.78 budget1385.41 is1385.82 meaningfully1386.06 anchored1386.7 in1387.02 these1387.17 core1387.49 values1387.82 and1388.54 will1388.7 expand1388.93 existing1389.49 efforts1390.17 that1390.97 are1391.05 currently1391.29 working1391.77 well1392.09 to1392.41 close1392.65 gaps1392.97 and1393.61 provide1393.85 all1394.25 students1394.49 with1394.89 a1395.13 high1395.29 quality1395.61 education,1396.09 as1397.29 well1397.45 as1397.69 seed1397.85 new1398.17 initiatives1398.41 that1399.37 can1399.53 improve1401.21 learning1401.69 outcomes1402.09 and1402.85 the1403.09 success1403.24 of1403.88 our1404.13 students.1404.29 Addressing1405.64 inequitable1406.13 gaps1406.92 in1407.24 student1407.64 access1408.2 and1408.85 success1409.09 starts1410.04 in1410.61 early1410.85 education,1411.16 providing1412.44 meaningful1413.01 experiences1413.64 and1414.2 closing1414.44 the1414.85 gaps1415.01 before1415.57 a1416.04 student1416.13 enters1416.73 kindergarten.1417.05 The1418.09 governor's1418.33 FareShare1418.97 supplemental1419.29 budget1419.85 proposal1420.25 includes1420.81 $501421.69 million1422.73 to1422.73 support1422.89 universally1423.37 accessible,1424.09 affordable1425.13 preschool1425.93 access1426.57 through1428.73 the1429.13 Commonwealth1429.37 Preschool1429.93 Partnership1430.41 Initiative1430.97 or1431.61 CPPI.1431.85
1433.77 Through1433.77 the1434.09 budget1434.24 and1434.81 FareShare1435.29 supplemental1435.61 budget,1436.24 we1436.81 are1437.05 proposing1437.2 $251437.85 million1439.37 for1439.37 FY1439.77 251440.01 FY1440.81 261441.05 to1442.01 maintain1442.16 current1442.72 grantees1443.05 and1444.09 $431444.24 million1445.61 to1445.61 expand1445.77 access1446.24 over1446.91 three1447.23 years,1448.11 enabling1448.43 current1448.99 grantees1449.31 to1449.87 add1450.03 more1450.27 classrooms1450.59 and1451.55 more1451.71 affordable1452.03 seats,1452.51 as1453.31 well1453.55 as1453.71 allow1453.95 new1454.43 communities1454.67 to1455.31 join1455.47 with1456.43 a1456.59 focus1456.75 on1457.07 gateway1457.31 communities1457.79 and1458.75 a1458.99 long1459.15 term1459.39 goal1459.71 for1460.11 affordable1460.27 access1460.91 in1461.7 all1461.94 cities1462.18 and1462.59 towns.1462.74 We1464.03 also1464.18 propose1464.59 $1001465.14 million1466.18 for1466.18 early1466.51 education1466.83 and1467.38 care1467.54 capacity1467.94 building,1468.51 family1469.46 access1469.94 and1470.35 affordability,1470.59 and1471.63 workforce1471.87 support,1472.51 as1473.3 well1473.46 as1473.7 support1473.87 for1474.27 implementation1474.42 of1475.22 the1475.38 early1475.54 education1475.87 and1476.42 care1476.59 task1477.32 force1477.48 recommendations.1478.04 No1480.28 doubt,1480.52 there1480.92 is1481.08 a1481.24 robust1481.56 conversation1482.2 in1483.32 the1483.48 preschool1483.88 and1484.52 early1484.68 elementary1485 sector1485.64 on1486.12 literacy.1486.36 Literacy1487.8 skills1488.36 are1488.6 foundational1488.84 to1489.48 a1489.56 student's1489.72 ability1490.2 to1490.6 learn1490.76 in1491.08 all1491.24 content1491.76 areas1492.15 and1492.72 disciplines1492.96 throughout1493.52 their1493.84 educational1494.08 career.1494.8
1495.84 More1495.84 broadly1496.08 though,1496.56 this1496.8 is1496.96 a1497.12 foundational1497.28 skill1498.32 that1499.12 impacts1499.28 the1499.76 quality1499.91 of1500.32 one's1500.48 life.1500.88 We1501.99 propose1502.24 a1502.72 $251502.96 million1504.24 early1504.24 literacy1504.56 high1505.12 dosage1505.44 tutoring1505.84 initiative,1506.48 which1507.36 will1507.6 support1507.84 10,0001508.32 students1509.2 toward1509.6 reading1509.92 proficiency.1510.24 Public1511.76 schools1512.16 would1512.48 partner1512.72 with1513.04 approved1513.28 providers1513.76 to1514.32 accelerate1514.48 literacy1514.96 growth1515.76 for1516.4 students1516.56 in1516.96 kindergarten1517.2 through1517.76 grades1518 three1518.37 with1519.16 a1519.33 priority1519.48 on1520.13 first1520.37 grade.1520.68 The1522.13 investment1522.29 will1522.77 complement1523.09 the1523.64 more1523.81 systemic1524.13 long1524.85 term1525.16 work1525.48 happening1525.81 under1526.13 the1526.37 governor's1526.53 literacy1527.16 launch1527.72 initiative.1528.05 The1529.57 proposal1529.72 also1530.37 works1530.68 in1530.92 service1531.16 of1531.57 broad1531.81 based1532.05 literacy,1532.37 English1533.43 acquisition,1533.75 and1534.79 workforce1534.95 readiness1535.51 efforts1536.15 for1536.55 adults.1536.79 The1537.91 governor's1538.07 supplemental1538.55 budget1539.11 includes1539.51 $301539.91 million1540.87 for1540.87 adult1541.11 basic1541.59 education,1541.99 English1543.11 for1543.51 speakers1543.75 of1544.15 other1544.63 languages,1544.95 literacy1545.67 services.1546.31
1547.8 Over1547.8 the1548.04 next1548.13 three1548.37 years,1548.61 this1549.01 funding1549.16 will1549.64 expand1549.88 capacity1550.52 to1551.16 serve1551.33 an1551.96 additional1552.2 10,0001552.68 learners1553.4 to1554.13 address1554.28 the1554.68 growing1554.85 wait1555.64 list1555.88 for1556.85 ESOL1557.16 literacy1557.96 services.1558.52 The1560.05 administration1560.29 has1560.93 been1561.17 working1561.41 in1561.81 earnest1562.05 to1562.45 reimagine1562.77 high1563.57 school.1563.73 This1564.85 is1565.09 a1565.33 substantive1565.65 effort1566.29 to1566.69 strengthen1566.85 pipelines1567.33 to1567.97 high1568.13 demand1568.29 careers1568.69 and1569.49 also1569.73 deepen1570.21 relevance1570.61 of1571.49 the1571.73 high1571.89 school1572.13 experience1572.37 for1572.93 high1573.17 school1573.33 students.1573.65 The1574.86 governor's1574.93 supplemental1575.41 budget1576.06 includes1576.46 $32.51577.89 million1578.06 to1578.93 deepen1579.58 our1579.89 investments1580.13 in1580.62 early1580.78 college,1581.1 innovation1581.89 career1582.54 pathways,1582.86 and1583.73 career1584.06 technical1584.38 education1584.93 programs.1585.65 Early1587.19 college1587.51 programs1587.91 enable1588.63 high1589.03 school1589.19 students1589.43 to1589.83 take1589.99 college1590.23 classes1590.71 and1591.27 earn1591.59 college1592.23 credit1592.63 at1593.11 no1593.35 cost.1593.59 We1594.71 want1594.87 to1595.11 expand1595.27 these1595.67 programs1595.91 to1596.39 reach1596.63 over1596.87 20,0001597.19 students1597.91 by1598.39 the1598.71 year1598.87 2030.1599.11
1600.82 Similarly,1600.82 we1601.45 want1601.53 to1601.77 expand1601.93 innovation1602.34 career1602.89 pathways1603.29 to1604.34 more1604.58 than1604.82 25%1605.38 of1606.17 the1606.34 state's1606.49 public1606.82 high1607.21 schools,1607.38 giving1608.1 approximately1608.49 10,0001609.29 students1610.01 access1610.49 to1610.89 applied1611.53 hands1612.81 on1613.13 coursework,1613.37 and1614.49 work1614.73 work1614.97 opportunities1615.61 in1616.33 high1616.57 demand1616.81 industries.1617.29 In1618.65 addition1618.89 to1619.21 the1619.37 $32.51620.17 million1620.33 dollars,1620.65 this1621.37 proposal1621.61 includes1622.17 a1623.29 $751623.45 million,1625.45 proposal1625.45 to1626.09 add1626.25 more1626.57 than1626.73 3,0001627.13 new1628.37 seats1628.77 to1629.24 career1629.57 and1629.88 technical1630.13 education1630.61 opportunities1631.57 across1632.77 both1633.16 comprehensive1633.88 high1634.61 schools1634.85 and1635.48 career1635.88 tech1636.28 educational1636.61 schools1637.72 over1638.53 the1638.68 next1638.85 three1639.09 years.1639.4 Providing1640.77 the1641.24 pathways1641.4 and1642.13 experiences1642.37 is1643.33 a1643.48 big1643.57 piece1643.99 of1644.15 reimagining1644.31 high1645.11 school.1645.35 Advising1646.47 provides1647.27 the1647.67 critical1647.83 foundation.1648.31 My1649.67 Career1649.83 and1650.23 Academic1650.87 Plan1651.27 or1651.27 my1651.43 CAP1651.67 is1651.99 an1652.15 evidence1652.31 based1652.79 student1653.43 centered1653.91 multi1654.47 year1654.87 planning1655.11 tool1655.51 that1655.75 enables1656.39 students1656.87 to1657.37 plan1657.53 for1657.77 their1657.8 academic,1657.85 personal,1659.2 and1660.09 career1660.57 success1661.13 in1661.92 high1662.09 school1662.33 and1662.72 beyond.1663.05
1664.4 This1664.4 funding1664.8 will1665.2 expand1665.53 my1666.01 CAP1666.24 to1666.48 an1666.64 additional1666.8 601668.09 districts1668.57 with1669.2 over1669.53 2001669.77 schools1670.48 in1671.05 1501671.29 districts1672.48 currently1673.31 having1673.79 already1674.11 engaged.1674.59 Finally,1676.27 the1676.83 supplemental1676.99 budget1677.55 includes1677.87 $1501678.43 million1680.27 for1680.27 the1680.43 special1680.59 education1681.07 circuit1681.87 breaker.1682.19 We1683.31 know1683.55 that1683.71 special1683.87 education1684.27 and1684.29 transportation1684.31 costs1684.33 continue1684.35 to1684.37 grow.1684.39 With1684.41 the1684.43 FY1684.51 261684.75 budget,1684.75 we1684.75 are1700.42 proposing1700.42 $6821700.42 million1700.42 for1700.42 special1700.42 education1700.42 circuit1700.42 breaker,1700.42 a1700.42 24%1700.42 increase1700.42 from1700.42 last1700.42 year1700.42 for1700.42 full1700.42 funding1700.42 of1700.42 the1700.42 account.1700.74 As1702.48 secretary1702.8 Tibbits-Nutt1703.68 said,1704 we1704.64 are1704.8 currently1705.12 navigating1705.52 a1706.24 changing1706.4 federal1706.88 landscape1707.28 and1707.76 know1708 how1711.12 important1711.44 state1712.16 funding1712.48 is1712.88 at1713.2 this1713.36 moment.1713.6 We1714.4 believe1714.56 that1714.96 these1715.2 investments1715.44 are1716.16 the1716.32 right1716.48 ones1716.64 to1717.09 meet1717.24 the1717.37 moment,1717.48 addressing1718.53 some1719.09 of1719.33 the1719.4 largest1719.57 equity1720.05 gaps1720.44 in1720.77 education1720.92 today,1721.48 and1722.37 providing1722.61 a1723.09 solid1723.24 foundation1723.72 for1724.37 success1724.61 going1725.16 forward.1725.4 We1726.13 deeply1726.37 appreciate1726.77 your1727.24 partnership.1727.48
1733.69 MICHLEWITZ1733.69 -1733.69 Okay.1733.69 Good.1734.17 I1734.57 just1734.73 want1734.89 to1735.05 make1735.05 sure1735.13 you1735.29 don't1735.45 want1735.61 to1735.77 fuck1735.77 you.1735.93 I'm1736.17 close.1736.41 Thank1737.13 you1737.37 all.1737.53 Thank1738.01 you1738.17 for1738.33 the1738.49 testimony,1738.89 and1740.65 for,1740.89 again,1741.13 your1741.45 partnership1741.69 and1742.17 the1742.41 work1742.49 here.1742.73 I'm1743.13 going1743.29 to1743.45 open1743.45 it1743.69 up1743.77 with1743.93 a1744.01 couple1744.09 of1744.49 questions,1744.74 then1746.13 turn1746.38 it1746.54 over1746.62 to1746.93 my1747.1 counterpart1747.34 and,1747.73 obviously,1747.98 to1748.3 the1748.46 members1748.62 of1748.86 the1748.93 committee.1749.1 And1749.89 I1750.02 secretary1750.86 Tutwiler,1751.26 I1751.49 want1751.73 to1751.98 start1751.98 with1752.13 you1752.3 since,1752.46 you1753.58 did1753.82 touch1753.98 upon1754.3 the1754.78 special1754.93 education1755.26 circuit1755.73 breaker1756.06 costs.1756.46 And1757.98 I1758.22 know1758.3 there1758.46 are1758.7 things1758.86 that1759.17 are1759.26 addressed1759.68 here1760.72 in1761.04 this,1761.12 in1762.16 this1762.32 piece1762.72 and1762.96 then1763.2 also1763.28 with1763.52 the1763.68 FY1764 261764.16 budget.1764.56 But1765.28 I1765.52 think,1765.6 obviously,1766.8 we're1767.12 hearing1767.36 it1767.6 from,1767.68 we1768.32 hear1768.56 from1768.72 a1768.88 lot1768.96 of1769.12 members.1769.2 Obviously,1769.6 they're1770 hearing1770.16 it1770.4 from1770.48 a1770.6 lot1770.72 of1770.88 superintendents,1770.96 related1772.16 to1772.56 this1772.64 discussion.1774.27
1774.6 Just1774.6 it's,1774.6 it's1774.84 been1774.91 somewhat1775.23 frustrating1775.55 over1775.95 the1776.12 last1777.15 couple1777.23 of1777.25 years1777.27 on1777.28 trying1777.3 to1777.32 understand1777.47 why1778.36 we're1778.99 missing1779.15 the1779.39 mark1779.47 so1779.95 so1780.36 much1780.51 on1780.91 this1781.08 number1781.47 when1781.79 we're1781.95 trying1782.19 to1782.36 project1782.51 out1782.84 these1783.08 costs1783.23 annually,1783.55 that1785.23 we're1785.39 trying1785.55 to1785.71 play1785.79 catch1786.11 up,1786.35 and1787.07 we1787.23 may1787.31 we1787.47 may1788.03 have1788.11 an1788.35 opportunity1788.51 here1788.99 with1789.23 this1789.39 with1789.71 this1789.87 piece1790.03 to1790.27 do1790.43 that,1790.51 but1790.83 I1791.31 think1791.47 the1791.71 concern1791.87 here1792.19 is1792.51 related1792.75 to1793.15 just1793.23 how1793.39 we're1793.63 just1793.71 missing1793.95 the1794.19 mark1794.35 so1794.59 much1794.67 on1794.91 the1794.99 on1795.23 on1795.55 on1795.71 the1795.87 projections.1796.03 Yeah.1797.39 Can1797.71 we1797.95 talk1798.19 a1798.43 little1798.51 bit1798.67 about1798.91 what1799.63 are1799.79 the1799.95 options1800.11 to1800.51 try1800.59 to1800.75 kind1801.2 of1801.43 figure1801.52 out1801.76 where1801.91 we1802.47 can1802.56 go1802.72 with1802.88 that1802.96 to1803.2 kind1803.36 of1804.47 get1804.47 a1804.63 little1804.8 bit1805.04 more1805.2 predictability,1805.43 related1806.63 to1807.04 this1807.12 discussion1807.36 going1807.84 forward1808.08 just1808.39 as1808.8 we're1809.04 trying1809.28 to1809.52 balance1809.6 our1809.91 our1810.23 budgets1810.56 in1810.88 these1811.04 obviously1811.28 difficult1811.67 times?1812.08
1812.88 TUTWILER1812.88 -1812.88 Yeah.1812.88 I1813.43 really1813.76 appreciate1813.76 that1814.26 question,1814.5 and1815.06 will1815.38 acknowledge1815.7 that1816.1 I1816.34 too1816.5 hear1816.82 frequently1817.3 from1817.94 superintendents1819.14 across1819.86 the1820.18 Commonwealth1820.26 about1820.9 the1821.14 challenges1821.3 of1822.18 special1822.42 ed1822.82 funding,1823.14 and1824.02 in1824.18 particular1824.34 out1824.9 of1825.06 district,1825.22 costs,1826.02 the1826.66 cost1826.82 related1827.06 to1827.46 transportation,1827.62 as1829.11 well.1829.35 I1829.74 think1829.9 part1830.23 of1830.47 this1830.63 is,1830.95 getting1832.23 more1832.87 settled,1833.18 in1834.07 the1834.23 context1834.47 of1834.87 the1835.03 Student1835.27 Opportunity1835.66 Act.1836.31 Right?1836.79 It's1837.03 been1837.27 hard1837.51 to1837.83 sort1838.14 of1838.31 project1838.55 once1839.27 the1839.66 instructional1840.38 costs1841.11 are1841.42 covered1843.32 what's1844.04 left,1844.44 for1845.16 reimbursement1845.32 around1846.12 transportation.1846.44 In1847.88 the1848.04 current1848.2 year,1848.44 we're1848.76 looking1849.32 at1849.56 about1849.72 44%1850.04 reimbursement.1851.72 Last1852.52 year1852.76 was1852.92 around1853.16 57%.1853.48 What1854.66 we've1854.83 proposed1855.22 in1856.11 FY1856.51 261856.66 will1857.38 get1857.63 us1857.78 to1857.94 the1858.02 full1858.18 entitlement,1858.51 the1859.07 instruction1859.22 cost1860.02 covered1860.35 plus1860.74 75%1861.3 reimbursement1862.27 for1862.98 transportation,1863.14 which1863.87 is1864.02 what1864.59 the1865.38 entitlement1865.63 calls1866.11 for.1866.42 And1867.3 so1867.54 I1867.87 would1868.35 say1868.51 part1868.83 of1868.98 it1869.14 is1869.3 just1869.46 getting1869.78 settled1870.11 with1870.56 the1870.72 Student1870.8 Opportunity1871.04 Act,1871.76 but1872.24 I1872.4 think1872.48 we're1872.64 in1872.88 a1872.96 much1873.12 better1873.36 place1873.6 now1873.84 to1874.16 make1874.24 projections1874.48 going1875.12 forward.1875.44 And1875.68 I'm1875.92 not1876 sure1876.16 if,1876.4 secretary,1877.44 you1878 want1878.16 to1878.56 add1878.56 anything1878.72 to1879.2 that.1879.36 The1880.24 look1880.32 on1880.48 his1880.64 face1880.88 is1881.12 no,1881.28 but1881.52 that1881.76 that's1881.84 my,1882.16 that's1882.56 my1882.88 response.1883.04
1886.33 MICHLEWITZ1886.33 -1886.33 Yeah.1886.33 The,1886.88 and1887.45 I1887.68 appreciate1887.77 that.1888.16 So,1888.49 I1888.61 mean,1888.73 the1889.05 feeling1889.21 is1889.53 that1889.77 in1890.97 the1891.45 next1891.61 couple1891.77 years,1892.01 we'll1892.25 be1892.49 able1892.57 to1892.73 get1892.81 a1892.97 little1893.13 bit1893.85 more1894.01 predictability1894.33 related1895.05 to1895.53 that1895.61 in.1897.02 Okay.1897.18 I1897.18 appreciate1897.42 that.1897.74 I1897.98 hope1898.14 I1898.38 hope1898.46 you're1898.62 correct1898.86 in1899.9 that1900.06 sense.1900.22 The1900.62 other1900.7 thing1900.78 I1901.02 wanted1901.1 to1901.34 talk1901.42 about1901.5 is1901.66 a1901.82 little1901.9 more1902.06 timely,1902.3 and1903.42 not1903.66 necessarily1903.98 directly1904.46 related1904.86 to1905.18 what's1905.34 in1905.5 the1905.66 FareShare,1905.98 but,1906.14 obviously,1906.3 the1906.78 discussion1906.94 around1907.58 education1907.98 funding,1908.56 and1908.72 that's1908.88 obviously1909.04 what1909.43 happened1909.6 on,1909.91 I1910.08 think,1910.24 Monday,1910.39 in,1911.43 with1912.32 the,1912.48 with1912.8 the1912.96 federal1913.04 government1913.43 clawing1914.08 back,1914.48 about1915.43 $1001915.84 million1916.15 or1916.88 whatever1917.2 the1917.52 exact1917.67 number1917.99 was.1918.24 I'm1918.39 not1918.96 not1919.2 a1919.43 %1919.6 sure,1920.08 but,1920.32 previously1921.76 allocated1922.24 funds1922.67 to1922.91 local1923.07 school1923.47 districts,1923.71 has1924.83 left1925.07 obviously1925.39 some1926.11 of1926.27 them1926.43 in1926.67 much1926.75 in1927.31 in1927.55 much1927.71 power1927.95 related1928.19 to,1928.67 you1928.83 know,1928.99 immediacy1929.15 on1930.03 that1930.27 number.1930.51 Can1931.47 you1931.63 just1931.79 give1931.95 us1932.11 a1932.27 little1932.35 understanding1932.67 of1933.07 how1933.71 we1933.79 got1933.95 to1934.11 that1934.27 point?1934.43 And1934.75 it1935.48 is1935.64 what1936.13 is1936.37 what1936.68 is1937.81 this1937.97 money1938.13 going1938.45 to1939.24 mean1939.24 for1939.48 those1939.64 school1939.88 districts1940.21 and1940.61 how1940.85 should1941.48 we1941.64 be1941.81 approaching1941.97 that1942.37 conversation1942.68 going1943.33 forward?1943.57
1945.01 TUTWILER1945.01 -1945.01 So,1945.01 just1945.57 for1945.81 everyone's1945.97 edification,1946.45 we1947.57 received1947.73 no1948.21 notice1948.61 from,1949.09 the1950.09 United1950.41 States1950.73 Department1951.13 of1951.45 Education,1951.69 on1952.97 Friday1953.29 at1953.77 5:001953.93 PM,1955.61 that1955.61 they1955.85 intended1956.33 to1956.81 take1957.29 back,1957.53 approximately1958.65 1061959.69 million1960.73 from1960.73 201961.29 school1961.61 districts1961.93 across1962.49 the1962.89 Commonwealth1962.97 who1963.83 are1963.98 still1964.07 working1964.31 to1964.63 spend1964.79 down1965.11 their1965.51 ESSER1965.83 funding.1966.14 The1967.42 vast1967.83 majority1968.14 of1968.63 these1968.79 dollars1969.03 are,1969.74 sort1971.51 of1971.66 angled1971.83 towards,1972.31 facilities,1973.74 challenges.1974.95 Right?1975.74 HVAC1976.38 challenges,1977.03 making1978.91 sure1979.15 that1979.31 there's1979.39 proper1980.67 air1981.31 circulation1981.55 in1982.27 buildings.1982.43 Having1983.71 been1984.11 a1984.35 superintendent1984.51 during1985.23 this1985.55 period1985.63 of1986.03 time1986.11 and1986.43 having1987.07 led1987.39 one1987.63 of1987.79 the1987.87 districts1987.95 that's1988.43 on1988.75 that1988.99 list,1989.23 I1989.87 can1989.95 tell1990.19 you1990.35 that1990.59 it1990.83 was1991.07 hard.1991.31 It's1991.71 hard1991.95 to1992.19 spend1992.42 those1992.74 dollars1992.9 in1993.38 the1993.78 amount1994.51 of1994.9 time1995.14 that1995.54 was1995.7 allocated.1996.35
1996.83 And1996.83 so,1997.07 whether1997.87 there's1998.11 supply1998.42 chain1998.83 issues,1999.14 labor1999.63 shortage1999.94 issues,2000.35 there2001.14 are2001.38 delays2001.54 in2002.51 making2002.66 sure2002.98 that2003.14 these2003.38 projects2003.7 are2004.35 brought2004.74 to2005.07 completion.2005.7 And2006.63 so,2006.87 in2007.43 the2007.51 month2007.67 of2007.91 March,2008.07 there2008.71 was2008.87 a2009.11 request2009.11 from2009.59 the2009.83 administration2009.91 to,2010.87 or2013.51 an2013.67 opportunity2013.83 for2014.39 districts2014.55 to2015.03 apply2015.19 for2015.99 an2016.31 extension.2016.55 Those2017.59 202017.91 districts2018.23 applied2018.87 and2019.29 were2019.45 granted2019.68 that2020.16 extension.2020.33 And2020.81 then2020.97 Friday,2021.21 we2022.24 got2022.4 a2022.73 notice,2023.13 essentially2024.09 saying2024.57 that2024.81 there's2024.97 a2025.29 different2025.45 tune,2025.68 and2026.88 they2027.29 have2027.53 the2027.68 opportunity2027.85 to2028.48 ask2028.57 again,2028.81 but2029.21 ultimately,2029.53 the2030.49 suggestion2030.62 is2030.66 that2030.7 those2030.74 dollars2030.79 would2030.83 be2030.87 coming2030.91 back.2030.96 And2031 so2031.04 because,2031.08 for2031.21 the2037.11 vast2037.11 majority2037.27 of2037.91 these2038.07 districts,2038.31 this2038.87 work2039.03 is2039.27 underway,2039.51 in2040.63 process,2040.95 this2042.31 would2042.55 ultimately2042.87 mean,2043.59 a2044.87 real2044.95 challenge2045.19 around2045.67 finding2046.07 a2046.39 way2046.47 to2046.71 complete2047.43 them.2047.75
2048.32 I2048.32 think2048.48 it2048.72 differs2048.96 per2049.45 district.2049.68 Some2050.09 districts2050.32 have2050.89 a2051.05 relatively2051.2 small2051.76 amount2052.09 of2052.41 money2052.57 left.2053.13 Some2054.48 districts2054.72 have2055.61 a2055.84 significant2056.09 amount2056.72 of2057.05 money2057.2 left2057.53 and2057.68 would2057.93 be2058.16 hard2058.41 to2058.72 sort2058.89 if2059.13 this2059.61 is2059.76 not2060.01 the2060.32 kind2060.48 of2060.72 funds2060.8 that2061.13 you2061.28 find2061.45 in2061.68 your2061.76 seat2062.09 cushion,2062.32 so2062.8 to2062.96 speak.2063.13 And2063.45 so,2063.61 right2065.34 now,2065.58 the2066.3 message2066.54 has2067.5 been,2067.74 that2068.38 we'll2068.54 sort2069.02 of2069.26 understand2069.58 what2070.22 the2070.46 opportunities2070.7 are.2071.18 We2071.42 work2071.58 closely2071.82 with2072.06 the2072.22 attorney2072.38 general's2072.78 office2073.18 to2073.74 determine2073.9 whether2074.3 or2074.54 not2074.62 there's2074.78 a2075.18 legal2075.5 path2076.22 forward.2076.61 But2077.72 this2078.05 is2078.36 going2078.53 to2078.76 create2078.76 a2078.92 real2079.09 challenge2079.24 for2079.64 those2079.8 202080.05 districts.2080.36 I2080.76 should2080.84 also2081.09 name2081.32 that2081.89 some2082.13 of2082.36 those2082.44 dollars2082.68 were2083.01 being2083.24 used2083.57 for2083.8 direct2083.96 services2084.28 to2084.84 students,2085.01 high2086.2 dosage2086.44 tutoring2086.92 and2087.4 math,2087.57 mental2088.61 health2089.01 supports.2089.32 And2089.8 so,2089.96 this2090.68 will2091.4 have2091.57 an2091.72 impact.2091.72
2092.53 MICHLEWITZ2092.53 -2092.53 Thank2094.53 you2094.69 for2094.85 the2095.01 clarification.2095.17 Obviously,2096.45 it's2096.85 moving.2097.01 A2097.41 very2097.49 fluid2097.81 discussion,2098.13 taking2099.33 place,2099.57 and2099.81 so2099.97 I2100.21 appreciate2100.29 you2101.09 taking2101.25 the2101.49 time2101.57 to2101.81 kind2101.89 of2102.53 delve2102.53 into2102.69 that.2103.01 Secretary2103.65 Tibbits-Nutt,2105.49 wanted2107.01 to2107.32 ask2107.41 you2107.57 a2107.64 little2107.72 bit2107.89 about2108.05 the2108.28 MBTA,2108.44 and2108.84 I2109.01 see2109.24 the2109.41 general2109.57 manager2109.8 is2110.93 here2111.01 as2111.09 well,2111.16 and2111.41 thank2111.48 you2111.64 for2111.89 being2111.96 here.2112.2 More2114.36 in2114.61 relation2114.68 to2115.09 the2115.41 reserve2115.48 replenishment2116.2 proposal,2117.32 that's2118.2 put2118.44 in2118.68 place2119.32 here,2119.62 by2120.1 the2120.26 governor.2120.5 Trying2122.66 to2122.9 get2122.98 a2123.06 sense2123.14 of2123.38 where2123.78 we2124.02 stand2124.26 on2124.82 operational2125.22 costs2125.78 and2126.1 gaps2126.26 that2126.58 we're2126.74 going2126.9 to2127.14 be2127.14 facing2127.3 for2127.7 FY2128.18 262128.34 and2129.14 maybe2129.38 even2129.7 beyond.2129.86 I2131.14 think2131.22 that's2131.46 something2131.84 that2132.07 we've2132.95 heard2133.19 a2133.43 lot2133.51 of2133.67 speculation2133.76 related2134.39 to2134.63 what2134.71 the2134.88 most2134.95 potential2135.43 numbers2135.76 will2136.07 be.2136.23
2136.39 I2136.39 think2136.47 we2136.63 need2136.8 to2136.95 feel2137.76 like2137.91 we2138.07 need2138.15 to2138.32 have2138.39 a2138.47 better2138.55 sense2138.88 of2139.03 what2139.11 exactly2139.36 it2139.91 could2140.07 be.2140.23 I2140.63 don't2140.71 know2140.95 if2141.03 if2141.28 we2141.36 have2141.51 any2141.67 further2141.99 clarification2142.55 on2143.11 exactly2143.36 what2143.76 what2144.19 we're2144.43 looking2144.59 at,2144.91 from2145.55 the2145.71 MBTA's2145.87 operating2146.35 costs2146.75 in2146.99 terms2147.15 of2147.39 particularly2147.47 for2147.79 FY2148.11 262148.27 as2148.67 we2148.83 craft2148.91 the2149.23 budget,2149.31 but2149.55 also2149.71 with2149.95 this2150.11 opportunity2150.35 here2150.75 with2150.91 the2151.15 FareShare2151.39 and2151.63 how2151.71 to2151.87 approach2152.27 it2152.67 and2152.99 what2153.15 that2153.39 gap2153.63 is2153.87 actually2154.11 looking2154.59 like.2154.83 And2155.23 if2155.55 we're2157.76 not2157.91 able2158.07 to2158.39 fulfill2158.47 that2158.8 necessarily,2159.59 how2160.16 are2160.39 we2160.47 going2160.64 to2160.88 adjust,2160.88 you2162.8 know,2163.04 to2163.28 to2163.52 get2163.59 to2163.84 that2163.91 to2164.24 get2164.32 to2164.47 the,2164.64 you2164.88 know,2165.11 those2165.28 numbers2165.52 and2165.84 make2165.99 and2166.16 balance2166.32 those2166.72 books2166.88 in2167.11 the2167.28 right2167.36 way?2167.59 So.2167.76
2171.42 TIBBITS-NUTT2171.42 -2171.42 You2171.42 want2171.66 to2171.82 take2171.82 this,2171.98 or2172.14 you2172.3 want2172.38 me2172.54 to2172.7 just2172.78 go2172.94 ahead2173.02 and2173.18 take2173.34 a2173.5 shot?2173.58 Okay.2173.98 That2174.62 has2177.5 been2177.66 the2177.82 fantastic2177.98 thing2178.46 about2178.62 this2178.78 proposed2179.02 budget.2179.42 It2179.98 is2180.22 actually2180.78 closing2181.9 this2182.38 for2182.82 the2182.97 t2183.21 for2183.49 the2183.78 next2183.93 fiscal2184.26 year.2184.66 Going2185.21 forward,2185.53 the2186.01 general2186.18 manager2186.41 and2186.82 his2186.89 team2187.05 have2187.3 done2187.38 a2187.61 fantastic2187.69 job2188.41 of2188.82 controlling2189.05 costs2189.53 and2190.41 especially2190.66 around2190.97 their2191.21 project2191.45 projections.2191.86 So2192.82 we2192.97 feel2193.14 confident2193.38 that2194.18 for2194.41 the2194.57 next2194.66 fiscal2194.89 year,2195.21 that2195.45 they2195.61 have2195.78 the2196.02 resources2196.18 they2196.42 need2196.82 as2197.06 we're2197.22 going2197.46 into2197.78 FY2198.5 27.2198.74 It'll2200.02 just2200.34 be2200.5 another2200.66 reevaluation2200.98 to2202.02 make2202.18 sure2202.42 that2202.66 they're2202.9 living2203.14 within2203.46 their2203.7 means.2203.86
2206.26 MICHLEWITZ2206.26 -2206.26 So2206.26 this2206.5 full2206.74 $3002207.22 million2209.06 is2209.06 going2209.22 to2209.62 clear,2209.62 in2210.58 terms2210.74 of2210.98 any2211.06 potential2211.8 deficit,2212.13 pieces2213.01 that2213.32 we2213.49 may2213.57 and2213.8 I'm2213.97 sorry.2214.28 And2214.61 the2214.77 proposal2214.84 that2215.24 was2215.41 made2215.57 in2215.8 H2215.89 1,2216.13 we'll2216.61 get2216.84 to2217.09 the2217.16 we'll2217.41 clear2217.72 any2218.05 potential,2218.28 deficit2219.09 issues2220.05 we2220.45 may2220.61 face2220.77 with2220.93 the2221.09 MBTA2221.16 for2221.64 FY2221.8 '26?2222.05
2222.84 TIBBITS-NUTT2222.84 -2222.84 Stabilizes2222.84 for2223.57 FY2223.72 '26.2224.05 Yes,2224.61 sir.2224.84
2225.62 MICHLEWITZ2225.62 -2225.62 It's2225.62 good2225.78 to2225.94 know.2226.66
2227.1 GORZKOWICZ2227.1 -2227.1 Mr.2227.94 Chairman,2228.42 if2228.42 I2228.58 could2228.66 just,2229.46 there's2230.42 two2230.66 pieces2230.9 to2231.14 this2231.3 up.2231.46 It's2231.54 the2231.7 $4002231.86 million2232.66 for2232.66 the2232.9 FTA2233.14 safety2233.54 reserve,2233.78 which2234.1 also2234.34 funds2234.66 a2235.38 lot2235.46 of2235.62 the2235.78 employees2236.02 doing2236.58 the2236.82 critical2236.98 work2237.38 that's2237.62 necessary2237.86 that2238.26 offsets2238.82 payroll2238.97 costs.2239.22 That,2239.45 in2239.86 combination2240.18 with2240.97 the2241.14 $3002241.3 million2242.58 is2242.58 the2242.89 proposal2243.06 that's2243.45 needed2243.78 to2244.1 help2244.49 address2245.38 the2245.78 fiscal2246.49 cliff2246.82 that2247.14 the2247.38 t2247.54 is2247.7 experiencing.2247.93 That2248.74 combined2249.06 with2249.38 what2249.61 we're2249.7 proposing2249.93 in2250.41 the2250.49 House2250.66 One2250.89 budget,2251.14 which2251.45 is2251.7 operational,2251.93 dollars2253.02 going2253.42 forward,2253.66 is2254.22 really2254.38 taking2254.62 a2254.86 multiyear2255.02 look.2255.58 This2255.82 is2255.98 something2256.06 that2256.3 we2256.54 spent2256.7 some2256.94 time2257.18 with2257.34 the2257.5 Transportation2257.74 Task2258.3 Force2258.54 looking2258.78 at,2259.02 and2259.74 the2259.9 recommendation2260.06 was2260.86 put2261.1 forward2261.26 to,2261.58 again,2261.74 really2262.06 stabilize2262.38 it,2262.86 addressing2263.02 their2263.42 needs,2263.58 over2264.46 the2264.7 next2264.78 several2265.5 years2265.82 to2266.14 be2266.3 able2266.38 to2266.62 continue2267.03 to2267.19 do2267.36 the2267.59 work2267.76 they're2267.91 doing2268.07 to2268.32 improve2268.55 service2269.51 and2269.84 increase2269.99 ridership.2270.39
2272.88 MICHLEWITZ2272.88 -2272.88 And2272.88 then2273.03 one2273.2 other2273.36 piece2273.59 related2273.84 to2274.16 that2274.32 is2274.47 the,2274.64 is2275.59 related2275.84 to2276.16 that2276.32 safety2276.47 and2276.8 workforce2276.95 reserve,2277.51 which,2277.91 obviously,2278.55 We've2279.28 been2279.76 supporting2279.99 in2280.55 previous2281.46 budgets,2281.86 and2282.58 we'll2282.82 want2283.14 to2283.38 continue2283.38 to2283.86 work2284.1 with2284.34 you2284.58 guys2284.66 on2284.9 that.2285.06 I2285.94 think2286.02 the2286.34 one2286.66 of2286.82 the2286.9 questions2286.98 I've2287.46 been2287.7 getting2287.86 is2288.18 related2288.34 to2288.66 the2288.82 FTA's,2288.98 corrective2290.98 action2291.54 plans2291.86 and,2292.34 the2293.3 timing2293.46 of2293.86 that2293.94 is2294.48 supposed2294.72 to2295.2 be2295.53 finished2295.61 up2296.01 within2296.72 FY2297.28 26,2297.53 if2298.16 is2298.41 that2298.57 correct2298.8 in2299.13 kind2299.28 of2299.61 saying2299.61 that?2299.76 Do2299.93 we2300.09 have2300.16 a2300.41 time2300.48 line2300.72 on2300.96 exactly2301.2 when2301.61 that2301.84 what2302.48 the2302.72 what2302.96 that2303.2 timing2304.09 looks2304.48 like2304.72 in2304.96 terms2305.13 of,2305.36 how2305.68 that2305.84 you2306.48 know,2306.64 we2306.8 are2307.05 talking2307.2 early2307.53 to2307.64 FY2307.93 26?2308.01 Are2308.48 we2308.57 talking2308.64 later2308.89 FY2309.19 26?2309.35 So2309.67 do2310.07 we2310.15 have2310.23 any2310.39 more2311.19 concrete2311.59 timeline2311.99 on2312.39 that?2312.55
2313.75 TIBBITS-NUTT2313.75 -2313.75 The2313.75 general2313.91 manager2314.23 feels2314.71 confident2315.03 that2315.51 in2315.75 this2315.91 House2316.39 One2316.63 proposal2316.63 that2317.03 they're2317.27 going2317.43 to2317.67 be2317.75 able2317.91 to2318.07 meet2318.23 the2318.39 corrective2318.47 action2318.87 plans,2319.27 not2319.75 just2319.99 those2320.23 that2320.55 were2320.63 initially2320.87 identified2321.35 from2321.91 the2322.07 FTA,2322.23 but2322.63 as2322.87 they've2323.03 been2323.27 doing2323.51 additional2323.75 work,2323.95 any2325.91 additional2326.07 issues2326.63 that2326.79 they2326.95 have2327.11 found.2327.27
2329.34 MICHLEWITZ2329.34 -2329.34 Okay.2329.34 Thank2329.74 you2330.07 for2330.14 that.2330.3 Do2330.63 you2330.74 have2330.86 any2331.03 questions?Senator,2331.18 Senator2332.39 Rodrigues2332.39
2332.39 RODRIGUES2332.39 -2332.39 Thank2334.14 you,2334.39 Mr.chairman.2337.19 I2337.19 know2337.35 I2337.59 do2337.83 have2337.99 some2338.15 questions,2338.31 but2338.63 I2338.79 also2338.95 have2339.35 a2339.51 number2339.59 of2339.83 colleagues2339.99 that2340.31 want2340.39 to2340.71 ask2340.71 questions.2340.95 So2341.43 we'll2342.15 let2342.39 them2342.63 ask2343.03 questions2343.27 and2343.67 we'll2343.91 see2344.07 if2344.23 any2344.79 of2345.03 the2345.11 questions2345.19 I2345.59 had2345.83 were2346.07 not2346.31 ones2346.63 that2346.87 they2347.11 had2347.35 asked.2348.31 But2348.66 first2348.89 of2349.05 all,2349.14 thank2349.38 you2349.78 want2349.93 me2350.09 to2350.26 say2350.34 thank2350.49 you2350.74 to2350.89 all2351.05 of2351.3 you2351.38 for2352.74 appearing2352.89 here2353.3 today2353.45 for2353.78 your2353.93 testimony2354.18 and2354.74 for2356.66 always2356.89 being2356.89 available2357.22 and2357.7 accessible2357.93 to2358.57 us,2358.74 knowing2360.02 that2360.41 if2360.57 there2360.66 are2360.82 any2360.97 questions2361.14 that2361.53 we2361.7 have2361.86 to2362.18 follow-up2362.34 with,2362.82 you2363.27 are2363.75 always2363.91 here2364.23 to2364.47 answer2364.63 them.2364.95 So2365.03 I2365.19 thank2365.35 you2365.59 very2365.75 much.2365.99
2369.03 MICHLEWITZ2369.03 -2369.03 Representative2369.03 Smola.2369.51
2372.79 REP2372.79 SMOLA2372.79 -2372.79 Good2372.79 afternoon,2373.11 and2373.51 thank2373.67 you2373.91 to2374.23 the2374.55 panel2374.63 for2374.87 your2375.03 testimony2375.19 here2375.75 today.2375.99 I2376.19 appreciate2376.39 the2377.75 information2377.91 that2378.32 you've2378.69 provided2379.06 on2379.43 this2379.79 proposal.2380.16 Secretary2380.89 Tibbits-Nutt,2381.63 I2381.99 want2382.36 to2382.73 focus2382.73 on2383.09 the2383.46 transportation2383.83 component2384.2 of2384.56 this.2384.93 As2385.3 I2385.66 look2386.03 at2386.4 the2386.76 breakdown2387.13 here,2387.5 these2388.23 numbers2388.6 are2388.96 a2389.33 little2389.7 jarring2390.07 to2390.43 some2390.8 of2391.17 us2391.53 in2392.46 Western2392.7 Massachusetts,2393.1 and2393.82 I2394.06 know2394.14 that2394.3 you're2394.46 aware2394.62 of2394.94 the2395.02 situation.2395.18 And2396.38 I2396.62 think2396.7 there's2397.18 probably2397.58 not2398.22 a2398.54 legislator2399.42 that's2400.06 on2400.3 this2400.54 panel2400.78 that2402.06 looks2402.38 at2402.7 this2402.78 and2403.02 says,2403.18 for2403.58 the2403.74 sake2403.9 of2404.14 Western2404.3 Massachusetts2418.76 we2419.23 are2419.23 given2419.23 our2419.23 best2419.23 shot2419.23 here.2419.23 But2419.23 I2419.23 just2419.23 want2419.23 to2419.23 talk2419.23 about2419.23 a2419.23 couple2419.23 of2419.23 numbers.2419.23 You2419.23 get2419.23 $7802419.23 million2419.23 here2419.23 for2419.23 MBTA2419.23 focus.2419.23 And2419.23 $77.52419.23 million,2419.23 for2419.23 the2419.23 other2419.23 categories2419.23 which2419.23 include2419.23 Mass2419.23 DOT,2419.23 munis,2419.23 RTAs,2419.71 and2420.03 micro2420.19 transit.2421.45 That's2422.57 about2422.97 the2423.29 same2424.17 amount2424.49 that2425.21 you2425.37 have2425.53 budgeted2425.69 just2426.33 for2426.57 low2427.05 income2427.29 fare2427.69 reserve2428.01 on2428.49 MBTA.2428.65 And2429.69 that's2430.41 troubling,2430.73 I2431.53 think,2431.69 to2432.01 me2432.17 and2432.61 to2432.78 a2432.93 lot2433.01 of2433.13 my2433.26 colleagues2433.49 in2433.82 Western2433.97 Massachusetts.2434.38
2435.01 And2435.01 I2435.17 get2435.34 the2435.49 fact2435.57 that2435.82 the2435.97 MBTA2435.97 is2436.45 a2436.61 big2436.69 system,2437.41 and2437.73 we2437.89 don't2438.05 want2438.14 it2438.3 to2438.45 fail.2438.53 I2438.78 think2438.86 we2439.09 all2439.34 recognize2439.57 its2440.05 importance.2440.21 But2440.78 in2441.41 the2441.66 rural2441.97 part2442.86 of2443.17 the2443.26 commonwealth,2443.41 where2444.38 transportation2444.61 is2445.49 always2445.89 the2446.45 top2446.61 concern,2446.86 it2447.17 doesn't2447.17 matter2447.49 what2447.66 we're2447.82 talking2447.97 about.2448.21 If2448.59 we're2448.67 talking2448.75 about2448.99 health2449.63 care,2449.79 we're2450.11 talking2450.35 about2450.59 education,2450.91 we're2451.95 talking2452.19 about2452.43 employment,2453.31 the2454.67 primary2454.99 issue2455.55 at2455.95 the2456.11 top2456.27 of2456.43 the2456.59 list2456.67 is2457.15 always2457.39 transportation.2457.87 And2459.15 that2459.39 equation2459.55 is2459.95 different2460.19 for2460.83 the2460.99 rural2461.15 part2461.39 of2461.55 the2461.71 Commonwealth2461.79 because2462.27 we2462.67 don't2462.83 have2463.07 the2463.31 same2463.55 options2463.86 that2464.51 everybody2464.66 else2465.07 does2465.47 in2466.27 more2466.66 densely2466.91 or2467.31 higher2467.47 populated2467.7 territories.2468.51 So2469.07 has2469.7 the2469.95 Commonwealth2470.11 conducted2470.99 an2471.47 analysis2471.7 about2472.99 the2473.63 investment2473.95 that2475.14 we2475.47 make2475.7 on2476.63 MBTA2476.95 riders2478.07 compared2478.71 to2479.27 RTAs?2479.59 Like,2480.31 what's2480.47 the2480.79 dollar2480.95 amount2481.27 that2481.99 is2482.23 being2482.39 spent2482.63 and2482.95 invested2483.19 by2483.67 the2483.83 Commonwealth2483.91 by2484.55 comparison?2484.79 MBTA2485.83 riders2486.63 versus2487.51 anybody2487.91 that's2488.31 using2488.63 another2489.19 mode2489.67 of2489.91 transportation2490.07 like2490.63 an2490.79 RTA2490.95 system.2491.22 Do2491.45 we2491.61 have2492.09 a2492.18 breakdown2492.26 about2492.58 that?2493.06
2495.22 TIBBITS-NUTT2495.22 -2495.22 We2495.22 do,2495.45 but2496.26 I2496.49 don't2496.58 have2496.74 it2496.89 in2497.06 front2497.22 of2497.38 me.2497.54 But2497.86 we2498.02 do.2498.18 We2498.41 have2498.66 by2499.14 ridership2499.45 for2500.18 the2500.41 RTAs,2500.58 not2501.06 just2501.22 as2501.45 a2501.61 collective2501.7 group,2502.09 but2502.34 each2502.58 individual2502.89 RTA2503.61 in2504.02 addition2504.26 to2504.58 the2504.74 ridership2504.89 from2505.38 the2505.61 MBTA.2505.7 But2506.93 as2507.09 you2507.25 pointed2507.33 out,2507.73 the2508.13 investment2508.77 in2509.41 the2509.65 T2509.81 is2510.61 significant2510.93 and2512.13 is2512.37 much2512.53 more2512.77 significant2513.01 than2513.57 our2513.73 regional2513.81 transit2514.21 authorities.2514.69
2515.97 SMOLA2515.97 -2515.97 How2515.97 would2516.21 you2516.45 recommend2516.61 it,2517.33 especially2517.33 when2518.13 when2518.61 this2518.77 proposal2518.93 came2519.49 out,2519.73 we2520.13 all2520.37 in2521.2 Western2521.36 Massachusetts2521.68 heard2522.32 from2522.57 people2522.8 that2523.76 this2524.01 didn't2524.32 look2524.57 like2524.8 equity2525.05 or2525.61 anything2525.76 close2526.09 to2526.49 equity.2526.57 And,2527.61 you2528.89 know,2529.05 again,2529.45 I've2529.84 said2530.09 this2530.24 at2530.41 these2530.49 hearings2530.72 before.2530.97 We2531.28 toss2531.45 that2531.68 term2531.84 around2532.09 loosely,2532.41 but2533.52 these2534.72 numbers2534.96 are2535.28 tough.2535.36 How2535.6 would2535.76 you2535.92 recommend2536.08 those2537.04 of2537.28 us2537.36 in2537.52 the2537.6 rural2537.68 part2537.92 of2538.16 the2538.2 Commonwealth2538.24 go2538.8 back2538.96 to2539.68 the2539.92 constituency2540.08 we2540.72 represent,2540.96 the2541.36 same2541.44 constituency2541.68 that2542.72 the2542.88 governor2543.04 represents,2543.52 and2544.64 deal2545.12 with2545.36 this2545.52 issue2545.68 and2546 say,2546.32 look.2546.72 We've2547.04 got2547.39 a2547.71 $7802547.8 million2549.47 investment2549.47 that's2549.95 being2550.19 proposed2550.43 for2550.84 these2550.99 funds.2551.16 Again,2551.95 this2552.43 decision2552.68 was2552.99 made2553.16 at2553.32 the2553.39 ballot.2553.55 So,2553.95 you2554.19 know,2554.36 I2554.68 accept2555.07 that,2555.32 and2555.64 I2555.8 think2555.88 we2556.11 all2556.19 have2556.43 to2556.59 accept2556.68 that.2556.99 But2557.71 the2557.95 breakdown2558.11 of2558.59 these2558.76 funds2558.99 is2559.47 a2559.71 really,2559.95 really2560.51 difficult2560.91 pill2561.47 for2561.8 a2561.95 lot2562.03 of2562.19 people2562.41 to2562.73 swallow2562.81 in2563.21 other2563.37 parts2563.61 of2563.93 the2564.01 state.2564.17 So2564.97 how2565.29 would2565.45 you2565.61 recommend2565.77 we2566.33 go2566.49 back2566.65 and2566.97 we2567.21 try2567.53 and2567.93 convince2568.25 folks2569.29 in2569.93 other2570.09 parts2570.33 of2570.57 the2570.65 Commonwealth2570.81 outside2571.45 of2571.77 the2571.93 MBTA2572.09 system.2574.01
2574.33 That,2574.33 yep,2574.33 $7802575.11 million2576.55 versus2576.55 the2576.95 other2577.11 pot2577.27 of2577.51 money,2577.59 which2577.91 is2578.14 less2578.31 than2578.55 $802578.79 million.2580.39 Pretty2580.39 good2580.55 investment2580.86 for2581.27 transportation.2581.51 And2582.63 meanwhile,2582.86 every2583.59 single2583.82 year,2584.22 there's2584.47 not,2584.7 again,2585.03 a2585.34 member2585.43 in2585.74 Western2585.91 Massachusetts2586.22 or2586.86 rural2587.03 Massachusetts2587.34 that2588.14 isn't2588.31 hearing2588.7 from2589.18 the2589.93 municipality2590.09 constituency2590.65 that2591.45 we2591.61 need2591.77 more2592.01 money2592.33 in2593.13 Chapter2593.29 90.2593.69 Right?2594.01 They2594.17 are2594.41 all2594.57 begging2594.81 us.2595.21 You2595.77 brought2596.01 up2596.17 the2596.33 small2596.57 bridge2596.89 program,2597.21 and2597.61 I2598.01 mentioned2598.17 at2598.65 the2598.89 hearing2598.97 a2599.29 couple2599.37 of2599.61 days2599.69 ago,2599.93 a2600.25 great2600.25 program.2600.49 Excellent.2600.97 We2601.53 appreciate2601.69 the2602.17 investment2602.33 that2602.97 the2603.13 administration2603.29 is2603.93 making2604.09 on2604.41 that.2604.57 We2605.07 appreciate2605.32 the2605.8 other,2605.95 positive2607.16 steps2607.55 that2607.8 the2607.95 administration2608.04 is2608.59 making2608.68 on2608.91 transportation2609.16 initiatives.2609.8 But2610.68 this2610.91 one2611.07 is2611.32 a2611.55 tough2611.8 one.This2612.52 is2612.76 these2613.16 numbers,2613.39 when2613.72 you2613.88 look2613.95 at2614.11 them,2614.2 are2614.52 very,2614.76 very2615.16 hard2615.47 to2616.28 digest2616.76 and2617.32 to2617.47 comprehend.2617.72 So2618.28 I'm2618.68 trying2618.84 to2618.97 get2619.11 a2619.26 better2619.39 sense2619.64 sense2620.53 from2620.65 the2620.77 administration2620.89 about2621.01 how2621.33 we2621.57 go2621.73 back2621.89 and2622.13 we2622.29 sell2622.45 this2622.69 idea2622.93 when2623.65 people2623.81 feel2624.05 it's2624.29 woefully2624.61 inadequate2625.09 for2625.89 the2626.21 RTAs2626.45 and2626.93 other2627.09 parts2627.33 of2627.49 the2627.65 state.2627.81
2629.01 TIBBITS-NUTT2629.01 -2629.01 Do2629.01 you2629.17 want2629.25 to2629.41 go2629.41 first?2629.57
2631.57 GORZKOWICZ2631.57 -2631.57 Sure.2631.57 I2631.73 would2631.81 like2632.05 to,2632.21 if2633.25 I2633.49 could,2633.68 take2633.84 a2634.01 minute2634.09 to2634.32 just2635.45 take2635.77 a2635.93 stab2636.09 at2636.32 your2636.41 question2636.57 and2636.81 then2636.97 turn2637.13 it2637.29 over2637.36 to,2637.53 secretary2638.09 for2638.57 transportation.2638.72 First,2639.61 as2640.57 I2640.72 mentioned2640.81 in2641.2 my2641.29 testimony,2641.45 I2641.93 think2642.01 it's2642.16 important2642.32 that2643.05 you2643.2 stand2643.36 back2643.61 and2643.77 look2644.01 at2644.16 all2644.41 of2644.64 the2644.89 budget2645.05 proposals2645.45 that2645.93 have2646.16 been2646.41 advanced,2646.81 alongside2648.4 this2648.64 FareShare2649.12 sup.2649.44 And2650.24 while2650.48 you2650.72 simply2650.88 do2651.36 the2651.52 math2651.6 the2651.92 way2652 you've2652.16 done2652.4 it2652.56 in2652.72 the2652.88 sup,2652.96 I2653.2 would2653.36 argue2653.68 that,2654.16 that2655.2 does2655.44 look2655.84 disproportionately2656.24 unfair2657.36 to2657.84 Western2658.08 Mass.2658.56 However,2658.88 when2659.44 you2659.6 look2659.76 at2659.92 the2660.16 overall2660.32 proposal,2660.72 I2661.28 think2661.36 you2661.6 should2661.92 be2662.08 able2662.16 to2662.34 go2662.41 back2662.57 to2662.73 Western2662.82 Mass2663.21 with2663.3 a2663.53 lot2663.61 of2663.86 confidence2664.09 in2664.49 what2664.82 we're2664.97 proposing2665.21 here.2665.53 Out2665.78 of2665.93 an2666.09 $82666.26 billion2667.14 transportation2667.14 plan,2667.7 nearly2668.01 5.62668.41 per2669.21 billion2669.45 of2669.78 it2669.86 is2670.49 outside2670.82 of2671.21 the2671.3 MBTA.2671.53
2672.34 Nearly2672.34 only2672.73 25%2673.05 of2673.78 that2673.86 plan2674.01 is2674.34 really2674.41 going2675.14 towards2675.66 the2675.82 MBTA.2675.98 We2676.46 have2676.62 a2676.78 billion2676.86 five2677.34 going2677.98 towards,2678.3 enhanced2679.74 Chapter2680.22 902680.54 program,2680.86 which2681.26 is2681.5 turning2681.58 it2681.9 into2681.98 a2682.22 $32682.38 billion2683.22 a2683.22 year2683.34 program2683.58 over2683.9 five2684.14 years2684.3 with2684.54 an2684.7 enhanced2684.94 formula,2685.26 benefiting2686.78 rural2687.74 communities2688.14 out2688.62 in2688.78 Central2688.86 And2689.18 Western2689.26 Massachusetts.2689.66 We2690.56 are2690.8 investing2690.95 in2691.6 our2691.76 accelerated2692.08 bridge2692.64 program2692.88 through2693.28 investments2693.52 in2693.91 MassDOT,2694.08 an2694.72 additional2694.95 $2002695.28 million2696.24 going2696.24 from2696.47 zero,2696.64 by2696.95 the2697.04 way,2697.11 to2697.36 $2002697.52 million2698.39 for2698.39 culverts,2698.64 and2700.47 investments2700.8 in2701.28 RTAs2701.43 and2701.84 their2701.99 workforce.2702.24 So2702.95 the2703.2 vast2703.36 majority2703.68 of2704.08 the2704.24 proposal,2704.32 when2704.88 taken2705.2 holistically2705.52 across2706.08 all2706.53 the2706.61 items2706.93 that2707.29 we2707.65 filed,2708.01 is2708.37 a2708.53 very2708.69 thoughtful2708.93 plan.2709.25 It's2709.57 one2709.73 that2709.97 was2710.13 developed2711.01 through2711.49 our2711.73 work2711.81 with2712.05 the2712.13 transportation2712.37 finance2713.09 task2713.57 force2713.73 and2714.29 one2714.45 that2714.69 was2714.85 meant2715.09 to2715.41 not2715.65 only2715.81 stabilize,2716.13 but2716.53 to2716.69 begin2716.85 enhancing2717.17 our2717.49 transportation2717.73 services2718.37 recognizing2719.01 a2722.78 different2722.78 picture2722.93 from2723.49 what2723.57 you2723.61 have2723.66 just2725.49 described,2725.82 to2726.78 folks2726.86 here2727.18 today.2727.41
2730.21 TIBBITS-NUTT2730.21 -2730.21 Just2730.21 building2730.38 off2730.86 of2731.01 this,2731.09 I2731.57 spent,2731.82 as2732.14 you2732.3 know,2732.45 a2732.7 significant2732.86 amount2733.34 of2736.22 time2736.23 with2736.24 our2736.24 regional2736.25 transit2736.26 authorities,2736.27 especially2736.28 over2736.28 the2736.29 last2736.3 year2736.54 and2736.78 a2736.86 half.2737.02 And2737.26 the2737.5 big2737.66 thing2737.82 we2738.06 heard2738.22 from2738.46 them,2738.62 workforce2739.58 issues,2740.06 number2741.82 one,2742.06 workforce2742.54 issues.2743.02 And2743.82 I2743.98 think2744.06 the2744.3 second2744.46 part2744.78 is2745.1 a2745.34 lot2745.42 of2745.58 discussion2745.74 about2746.22 the2746.38 changes2746.54 that2746.94 they2747.1 have2747.29 made2747.61 in2747.93 their2748.09 operations2748.41 to2749.13 not2749.36 only2749.68 provide2750.24 more2750.89 service2751.2 weekends,2752.33 evenings2752.97 for2753.53 their2753.84 service2754.57 areas,2754.89 but2755.29 also2755.53 to2755.93 cross2756.41 service2756.41 boundaries.2756.81
2757.93 So2757.93 for2758.16 us,2758.33 that's2758.64 why2758.89 we2759.05 are2759.2 committed2759.36 to2759.93 spending2760.16 the2760.72 next2760.81 fiscal2761.11 year2761.51 working2761.83 with2762.15 all2762.31 of2762.47 you,2762.63 working2762.87 with2763.19 our2763.35 RTAs2763.59 to2764.79 actually2765.11 look2765.67 at2765.99 the2766.23 funding2766.39 and2767.03 how2767.35 it2767.67 is2767.83 playing2768.07 out2768.55 with2769.43 this2769.75 new2769.91 focus2770.15 on2770.47 workforce.2770.71 But2771.83 we2771.99 understand2772.15 the2772.55 challenges.2772.71 We2773.35 understand2773.59 that2774.31 a2774.55 lot2774.71 of2774.87 people2775.03 are2775.43 working2775.91 very2776.16 hard,2776.39 as2776.64 secretary2776.88 Tutwiler2777.28 said,2777.91 to2778.39 get2778.55 to2778.72 education,2778.88 to2779.91 get2779.99 to2780.16 health2780.39 care,2780.64 to2780.88 get2781.04 to2781.28 employment2781.43 opportunities.2781.99 And2783.11 we2783.28 are2783.59 really2783.84 focused2784.16 on2784.64 increasing2784.88 those2785.28 opportunities2785.52 and2786.24 closing2786.39 those2786.8 gaps2787.04 for2787.43 the2787.68 riders2787.84 that2788.24 are2788.32 outside2788.47 of2788.8 the2788.95 MBTA2789.04 service2789.59 area.2789.91
2790.64 SMOLA2790.64 -2790.64 I2790.64 appreciate2790.95 that.2791.36 Just2791.7 the2792.02 last2792.1 comment2792.5 on2792.82 this,2792.9 and2793.14 then2793.3 I'll2793.46 close2793.7 it2793.94 up.2794.1 If2794.9 you2795.14 can2795.22 get2795.38 us2795.54 that2795.78 information2795.94 relative2796.58 to2796.98 the2797.14 investment2797.38 of2797.7 the2797.78 Commonwealth2797.86 of2799.38 the2799.62 riders,2799.86 those2801.14 that2801.38 are2801.46 participating2801.62 in2802.26 MBTA2802.34 versus2803.54 other2804.18 networks2804.5 like2804.98 RTAs2805.14 in2805.54 the2805.62 Commonwealth,2805.7 that2806.1 would2806.26 be2806.42 helpful.2806.64 I2806.72 think2806.88 it's2807.11 going2807.33 to2807.55 give2807.55 us2807.76 a2807.98 better2808.2 grasp.2808.41 I2808.63 know2808.85 this2809.06 job2809.28 isn't2809.5 easy,2809.71 and2809.93 I2810.15 appreciate2810.58 the2810.8 work2810.88 that2811.11 you're2811.2 doing2811.36 on2811.68 this2811.76 because2811.99 this2812.39 is2812.8 a2812.88 big2812.95 mountain2813.11 to2813.43 climb.2813.68 And,2814.55 even2815.28 with2815.59 this2815.91 investment,2816.07 we2816.88 have2816.95 a2817.04 long2817.11 way2817.36 to2817.43 go2817.51 in2817.68 transportation.2817.91 But2818.95 I2819.2 would2819.43 be2819.59 remiss2819.76 if2820.07 I2820.24 didn't,2820.32 you2820.64 know,2820.72 bring2820.88 up2821.11 this2821.36 question2821.59 of2822.66 when2822.9 people2823.06 see2823.38 these2823.62 numbers.2823.94 And,2824.66 secretary2824.9 Gorzkowicz,2825.3 I2825.86 appreciate,2825.94 you2826.5 know,2826.74 you2826.9 talking2827.06 about2827.38 these2827.54 other2827.78 investments2828.02 elsewhere.2828.5 But,2829.7 again,2830.18 because2830.74 we2831.06 have2831.22 this2831.38 in2831.62 front2831.78 of2832.02 us,2832.1 it's2832.34 tough2832.66 to2832.98 be2833.14 able2833.3 to2833.62 connect2834.26 those2834.74 dots.2834.75 And2834.77 when2834.78 the2834.79 public2834.81 sees2834.82 this,2835.14 filed2838.99 in2839.07 isolation.2839.47 So2840.03 I2840.35 don't2840.66 think2840.91 I2841.14 think2841.22 we2841.27 can2841.3 do2841.59 better2841.86 with2842.14 that2842.43 message2843.3 by2843.79 getting2844.03 it2844.31 out2844.59 there,2844.86 especially2845.14 when2845.63 it2845.7 comes2845.79 to2846.03 this2846.11 question2846.27 of2846.51 regional2846.66 equity.2847.07 And2847.3 I2847.55 appreciate2847.79 the2848.18 time2848.27 and2848.43 the2848.51 indulgence,2848.66 mister2849.07 chairman.2849.22 Thank2849.55 you2849.7 very2849.86 Much.2850.03
2850.44 TIBBITS-NUTT2850.44 -2850.44 We2850.44 will2850.52 get2850.68 you2850.84 that2851.08 data,2851.24 representative.2851.48
2852.84 MICHLEWITZ2852.84 -2852.84 Senator2852.84 Comerford.2853.24
2855.4 SEN2855.4 COMERFORD2855.4 -2855.4 Thank2855.4 you2855.72 very2855.96 much,2856.2 Mr.2856.76 Chair.2857.64 Secretaries,2857.64 all2858.12 of2858.28 you2858.44 thank2858.6 you.2858.84 It2859.32 is2859.48 a2859.64 terribly2859.96 difficult2860.44 time2860.92 to2861.24 govern,2861.48 and2862.52 we're2862.84 grateful,transportation2868.24 conversation.2869.2 And2870.72 specifically,2871.36 I2871.76 want2871.84 to2872.16 talk2872.16 about2872.49 micro2872.72 transit.2873.13 I2874.24 agree2874.41 that2875.93 the2876.49 governor2876.72 has2876.73 done2876.74 an2876.74 able2876.75 job2876.75 splitting2876.76 this2876.77 between2876.77 education2876.78 and2876.78 transportation2876.79 as2876.79 the2876.8 voters2876.8 wished.2878.72 And2884.86 Secretary2885.42 Gorzkowicz,2885.42 I2885.42 also2885.58 agree2885.9 that2886.3 we2886.54 have2886.7 to2886.86 look2887.02 at2887.18 H2887.42 55,2887.66 the2888.22 bill2888.38 before2888.62 us,2888.94 you2889.5 know,2889.66 as2889.82 a2890.06 sister2890.14 to2890.54 H2890.78 1,2891.02 right,2891.8 so2891.96 that2892.05 we2892.36 see2892.61 the2892.76 FareShare,2893.24 money2894.93 across2895.57 both2896.13 bills.2896.44 I2897.32 think2897.64 that's2897.89 very2898.13 important.2898.44 If2899.16 my2899.41 math2899.64 is2899.96 correct,2900.2 as2901.96 we2902.2 look2902.36 at2902.68 H2902.93 12903.16 and2903.41 next2904.24 to2904.48 H2904.8 55,2905.12 79%2906.64 of2908.24 the2908.48 spending2908.72 is2909.12 going2909.28 to2909.44 the2909.6 MBTA,2909.76 8%2910.8 is2911.6 going2911.76 to2912 the2912.16 RTAs.2912.32 So2913.2 I'm2913.36 just2913.52 going2913.68 to2914 pull2914 those2914.32 two2914.72 out2915.04 now2915.36 and2915.68 look2915.92 at2916.16 them2916.32 with2916.56 you.2916.72
2918.53 So2918.53 I2918.68 think2918.93 about2919.24 my2919.49 own2919.72 FRTA2920.05 in2920.93 Franklin2921.09 County.2921.57 Secretary2921.89 Tibbits-Nutt2922.77 knows2923.01 this2923.24 very2923.41 well.2923.64 You2924.68 have2924.93 been2925.16 there,2925.33 secretary,2925.57 and2926.45 you've2926.68 talked2926.93 to2927.09 the2927.24 people.2927.41 So2928.77 right2929.16 now,2929.41 nine2930.13 communities2930.92 in2931.24 Franklin2931.56 County2931.96 have2932.44 no2932.76 service2933.24 whatsoever,2933.8 double2935 that2935.32 have2935.72 no2936.04 fixed2936.52 route2937 service.2937.24 You2939.56 know,2939.64 I2940.16 think2940.68 that2940.92 it's2941.16 hard,2941.4 we'd2941.8 be2942.04 hard2942.2 pressed,2942.52 in2943.56 Eastern2944.04 Massachusetts2944.52 to2945.24 see2945.4 a2945.56 community2945.64 not2946.2 served2946.7 by2947.43 an2947.66 RTA.2947.91 Right?2948.63 Yet2948.86 in2949.11 rural2949.34 communities,2949.74 we2950.31 still2950.47 have2950.63 no2950.79 buses2950.95 running.2951.34 And2952.07 now2952.31 I2952.55 understand,2952.79 right,2953.27 Leiden,2953.59 a2953.99 community2954.14 of2954.63 700,2954.79 it's2955.43 hard2955.66 to2955.83 send2955.99 a2956.14 big2956.31 bus2956.47 up2956.7 into2956.86 the2957.11 hills2957.18 of2957.51 Leiden,2957.59 but2958.39 we2958.63 can2958.79 send2959.03 a2959.34 zippy2959.43 little2959.83 micro2960.07 transit2960.47 bus.2960.86 Right?2961.18 And2962.15 we2962.39 have2962.47 in2962.87 Franklin2963.03 County2963.51 piloted2964.07 on2964.79 demand2965.03 service2965.51 to2965.99 very2966.23 great2966.55 ends.2966.87
2968.31 But2968.31 when2968.63 I2968.79 look2968.87 at2969.11 line2969.35 15-96-25-06,2973.27 the2973.59 micro2973.75 transit2974.07 102974.47 million,2975.11 I2975.11 see2975.27 it's2975.43 a2975.59 grant2975.67 program.2975.99 Right?2976.89 So2977.05 not2977.36 guaranteed2977.77 to2978.8 the2978.97 RTAs.2979.2 And2980.64 you2980.89 know2980.97 as2981.2 well2981.36 as2981.53 I2981.68 do2981.93 that2982.41 small2982.8 RTAs2983.61 with2984.24 fewer2984.49 staff2984.97 are2985.45 less2985.61 competitive2985.93 in2987.13 writing2987.28 in2987.68 being2987.77 able2988.01 to2988.16 carve2988.32 out2988.57 the2988.72 grant2988.89 the2989.68 the2989.93 time2990.09 to2990.32 write2990.49 the2990.72 grants.2990.89 And2992.07 I2992.31 wonder2992.47 if2993.27 we2993.51 if2993.91 you2994.15 could2994.47 react2994.87 to2995.27 an2995.59 idea,2995.91 say,2996.39 to2996.63 not2996.79 make2996.95 it2997.19 a2997.43 grant2997.59 program,2997.91 but2998.23 make2998.47 it2998.63 a2998.87 direct2999.11 authorization,2999.59 and3000.87 perhaps3001.11 what3001.51 you3001.75 would3001.91 say3002.07 if3002.31 we3002.47 said,3002.63 can3002.87 we3003.11 carve3003.27 out3003.51 a3003.67 bit3003.83 more3004.07 there3004.87 so3005.19 that3005.43 the3005.91 governor3006.07 could3006.89 say3007.13 in3007.61 this3007.77 supplemental3008.24 that3009.45 in3009.68 fact3009.84 every3010.32 community3010.72 in3011.2 the3011.36 Commonwealth3011.53 has3012.57 some3012.97 sort3013.53 of3013.93 RTA3014.16 service?3014.89 Again,3016.16 with3016.89 this3017.13 as3017.36 it3017.53 is,3017.68 I3018.01 think3018.24 I3018.57 can't3018.72 go3019.05 home3019.2 and3019.89 say3020.13 this,3020.29 that3020.61 we3020.85 have3021.01 a3021.17 commitment3021.33 through3021.73 FareShare3022.37 dollars,3022.69 which3023.33 our3023.57 voters3023.73 in3024.05 Western3024.13 Massachusetts3024.53 campaigned3025.25 hard3025.73 for.3025.97
3027.25 I3027.25 just3027.41 don't3027.65 think3027.89 it's3028.13 super3028.53 fair3028.93 currently.3029.65 Right?3030.29 And3030.53 I3030.85 guess3031.01 I'll3031.25 say3031.49 the3031.65 last3031.81 thing,3031.97 which3032.21 is3032.45 in3032.77 Western3032.93 Massachusetts,3033.49 we3035.34 do,3035.59 we3037.11 do,3037.26 we're3037.74 aware3037.98 that3038.46 we3038.7 pay3038.86 a3039.03 penny3039.11 of3039.42 our3039.59 sales3039.66 tax3039.98 for3040.3 the3040.46 MBTA,3040.55 and3041.34 most3041.66 of3041.91 my3041.98 people3042.14 will3042.55 never3042.7 ride3042.94 it.3043.18 And3043.66 we3043.82 understand3044.14 the3044.94 whole3045.18 Commonwealth3045.51 argument,3046.55 right,3047.26 that3047.59 we3047.74 need3047.98 a3048.22 whole3048.3 commonwealth3048.63 to3049.34 do3049.51 well.3049.74 I3050.28 just3050.44 want3050.68 to3050.76 say3050.76 that3051.08 we3051.24 understand3051.48 that3051.96 in3052.12 Western3052.28 Massachusetts.3052.6 I3053.56 want3053.8 it3053.96 to3054.12 say3054.28 I3054.52 want3054.6 us3054.84 to3055.08 see3055.16 that3055.32 on3055.56 the3055.64 other3055.8 side,3056.12 that3056.6 when3056.84 Franklin3057.16 County3057.64 can3058.2 develop3058.44 and3059.56 we3059.72 all3059.96 can3060.28 rise3060.6 in3061 Franklin3061.24 County,3061.8 the3062.36 whole3062.52 Commonwealth3062.84 will3063.64 do3063.8 well.3063.96 Thank3065.42 you3065.66 for3065.74 considering3065.98 this,3066.46 and3066.7 I'd3066.94 I'd3067.18 I'd3067.59 be3067.74 pleased3067.9 for3068.3 your3068.46 reaction.3068.63
3069.59 TIBBITS-NUTT3069.59 -3069.59 And3069.59 that's3069.74 why3069.9 we3070.07 want3070.22 to3070.46 be3070.46 having3070.55 this3070.86 conversation3071.11 over3071.74 the3071.98 next3072.14 fiscal3072.39 year3072.78 because3073.03 I3073.34 think3073.42 it's3073.66 not3073.98 only3074.3 about3075.51 these3076.3 grant3076.7 programs,3077.03 It3078.15 is3078.31 also3078.55 how3079.27 are3079.51 we3079.67 better3079.91 partners3080.15 around3080.47 technical3080.79 assistance3081.19 to3081.75 the3081.83 regional3081.99 transit3082.39 authorities,3082.87 but3083.67 we3083.91 want3083.99 to3084.31 have3084.31 this3084.39 conversation3084.71 about3085.27 the3085.51 grant3085.67 programs3085.91 and3086.39 about3086.63 the3086.87 current3087.03 funding3087.35 and3087.83 how3088.07 we3088.15 structure3088.31 it.3088.71
3089.11 COMERFORD3089.11 -3089.11 But,3089.11 secretary,3089.27 if3089.99 we3090.07 wait3090.31 a3090.55 year,3090.71 we3091.43 will3091.59 be3091.75 yet3091.99 one3092.31 more3092.55 year3092.87 behind3093.11 with3094.36 no3094.53 service3094.84 in3095.24 these3095.49 towns3095.72 that3095.97 are3096.2 declining3096.36 population3097.01 at3098.13 a3098.61 pretty3098.76 significant3099.16 rate.3099.89 So3100.2 I'll3100.53 leave3100.68 it3100.84 there.3100.93 Thank3101.09 you,3101.24 Mr.Chair.3101.72
3102.76 MICHLEWITZ3102.76 -3102.76 Thank3102.76 you.3103.09 Representative3104.2 Holmes.3104.68
3108.76 REP3108.76 HOLMES3108.76 -3108.76 Mr.3108.76 secretary,3109.08 Tutwiler,3109.96 are3111.16 you3111.32 familiar3111.56 with3111.96 the3112.2 conversation3112.52 that's3113.08 happening,3113.4 on3115.56 23115.72 sides3115.96 about,3116.44 how3118.36 we3118.52 should3118.76 spend3119 this3119.4 and3119.64 if3119.88 the3120.04 money3120.2 should3121.03 be3121.18 if3122.31 there's3122.47 a3122.79 more3122.86 expansive3123.18 view3123.66 of3124.63 where3124.86 the3125.27 money3125.43 should3125.83 be3125.99 spent3126.22 or3126.63 it3126.86 should3126.95 just3127.18 be3127.51 in3128.14 public3128.39 schools.3129.74 Are3130.47 you3130.7 familiar3130.79 with3131.18 this3131.34 conversation3131.51 yet?3132.07
3135.53 TUTWILER3135.53 -3135.53 You3135.53 might3135.69 need3135.93 to3136.09 say3136.25 a3136.41 little3136.49 bit3136.73 more.3136.89 I'm3137.45 familiar3137.77 with3138.17 a3138.33 lot3138.41 of3138.65 conversations,3138.89 but3139.53 I'm3139.69 not3139.85 this3140.33 one.3140.73
3141.05 HOLMES3141.05 -3141.05 So3141.05 there3141.13 are3141.37 there3141.53 there's3142.01 there3142.41 are3142.57 activists3142.73 who3143.29 are3143.53 saying3143.69 that3144.41 we3144.57 should3144.73 take3144.89 some3145.13 of3145.29 the3145.37 FareShare3145.77 money3146.01 and3146.41 also,3147.21 advocate3148.25 for3148.65 it3148.99 to3149.08 go3149.16 towards3149.39 some,3150.2 education3150.76 that3151.16 gets3151.39 us3151.64 into3151.88 more3152.2 workforce3152.52 housing3152.91 I3153.88 mean,3154.04 workforce3154.28 development3155.16 and3155.88 not3156.04 simply3156.28 go3157.32 into3157.47 k3157.8 through3158.04 123158.28 and3158.76 only3159.24 public3159.72 education3160.91 versus,3161.88 health3163.99 centers3164.31 and3164.79 others3165.03 who3165.27 may3165.51 be3165.67 able3165.83 to3165.99 have3167.11 access3167.43 to3167.83 the3167.91 money.3168.07 Are3168.39 you3168.55 familiar3168.71 with3169.11 this3169.19 conversation3169.43 yet?3169.91
3171.35 TUTWILER3171.35 -3171.35 I'm3171.35 not3171.59 aware3171.83 of3172.31 that3172.47 specific3172.87 conversation,3173.59 but3174.15 it's3174.31 one3174.63 I3174.87 would3175.03 deeply3175.43 be3177.55 interested3177.8 in3178.28 engaging3178.51 because3178.91 I3179.23 would3179.39 say3179.55 definitively3179.88 the3180.99 way3181.16 that3181.32 we're3182.43 leveraging3182.76 these3183.32 dollars3183.55 to3184.03 win3184.28 in3184.43 the3184.59 education3184.76 space3185.39 is3185.88 uniquely3186.76 focused3187.23 on3187.71 workforce,3188.03 pipeline3189.39 development.3189.88 And3190.89 so3191.13 I'm3191.93 not3192.17 familiar3192.57 with3192.97 this3193.13 specific3193.37 thing3193.69 that3193.93 you're3194.09 raising3194.25 around3194.57 that.3195.05
3195.05 HOLMES3195.77 -3195.77 Maybe3195.77 beThat's3195.93 not3195.93 clear.3196.25 I3196.89 see3197.05 both3197.29 sides3197.53 of3197.77 the3197.93 conversation3198.01 in3198.49 the3198.57 room.3198.65 I'm3198.89 trying3199.05 my3199.37 best3199.37 to3199.69 do3201.53 just3201.93 one,3201.93 understand3201.93 if3202.33 you're3202.49 familiar3203.13 with3203.53 it.3203.69 If3203.77 you're3203.93 not,3204.17 then,3204.89 I3205.99 am3206.07 sure3206.22 the3206.31 black3206.39 and3206.7 Latino3206.78 caucus,3207.18 we3207.43 will3207.59 send3207.74 you3207.91 over3208.14 something3209.03 to3209.34 give3209.51 you3209.66 a3209.82 little3209.91 bit3210.07 more3210.14 information3210.47 about3210.95 it.3211.18 How3211.27 about3211.51 I3211.74 start3211.82 there?3212.14 And3212.7 then3212.86 we3213.18 can3213.34 have3213.51 another3213.74 conversation3214.07 after3214.55 That.3214.78
3215.27 TUTWILER3215.27 -3215.27 Greatly3215.27 appreciated.3215.66 Not3216.14 trying3216.3 to3216.47 wiggle3216.63 out3216.86 of3217.03 the3217.11 question.3217.18 I'm3217.59 just3217.66 not3217.91 familiar3218.12 with3218.44 it,3218.52 but3219 happy3219.24 to3219.48 talk3219.64 about3219.88 how3220.12 these3220.76 dollars3221 work3221.4 in3221.56 service3221.72 of3222.04 workforce3223.08 development,3223.8 if3224.52 you3224.68 would3224.84 like.3225
3225.4 HOLMES3225.4 -3225.4 But3225.4 let3225.64 me3225.96 guess,3226.28 I3226.4 can3226.52 ask3226.76 it3226.92 this3227.08 way,3230.84 from3231.16 your3231.4 perspective,3231.56 are3232.12 the3232.28 FareShare3232.76 money3233.74 only3235.03 for3235.11 public3235.42 k3236.3 through3236.55 123236.78 and3237.59 public3237.82 universities?3238.55
3240.94 TUTWILER3240.94 -3240.94 Probably3240.94 want3241.51 to3241.82 lean3241.82 on,3242.07 Secretary3243.9 Gorzkowicz3244.14 was3244.14 to3244.3 say3244.46 more,3244.63 but3244.78 my3245.03 understanding3245.18 is3245.9 that3246.07 these3247.03 dollars3247.34 are3247.98 for3248.22 public3248.46 entities.3249.68 Right?3250.56 For3250.96 public3251.2 education.3251.6
3253.52 HOLMES3253.52 -3253.52 Only.3253.52 Okay.3256.4 No3256.88 problem.3257.04 Well,3257.84 I3258.24 just3258.32 want3258.48 to3258.64 make3258.72 sure3258.88 I3258.96 understood3259.12 what3259.52 we3259.68 were3259.76 today.3260 Yeah.3260.32 Alright.3260.56 We're3260.96 going3261.2 to3261.52 try3261.52 to3261.76 continue.3261.76
3261.76 TUTWILER3261.76 -3261.76 Got3263.98 you.3264.46
3264.46 HOLMES3264.46 -3264.46 No.3264.46 No.3264.55 No.3264.7 I3264.78 haven't3265.34 got3265.59 you3265.98 yet.3265.98 But3266.39 I'll3266.86 send3266.94 you.3267.11 We're3268.14 getting3268.3 your3268.55 way.3268.63 Yep.3268.94 I3269.18 don't3269.42 want3269.59 to3269.74 throw3269.74 you3269.9 a3270.07 curveball3270.14 at3271.34 this3271.42 moment.3271.59 Alright.3272.14 And3272.94 then3273.11 my3273.26 other3273.42 question3273.59 was3273.9 around3274.22 transportation.3274.55 Madam3275.84 secretary,3276.24 as3278.16 you3278.32 heard3278.48 me3278.64 say3278.8 on3279.04 Tuesday,3279.2 I'm3280.64 still3280.96 very3281.2 disappointed3281.52 with3282 the3282.16 R&V.3284.08 I3285.6 heard3285.68 the3286.16 registrar,3286.72 really3288.32 comment3288.72 on3290.18 Tuesday,3290.41 a3291.86 sincere3292.41 belief3293.14 that3294.18 our3295.22 R3295.45 and3295.54 V3295.7 is3295.93 working3296.09 well3296.41 because3296.74 it's3296.97 all3297.22 by3297.45 appointment.3297.7 And3298.66 and3298.97 from3299.22 my3299.45 perspective,3299.7 that3301.06 has3301.22 truly3301.61 emptied3302.02 our3302.41 R&V's3302.89 because3303.06 you3303.38 go3303.45 there3303.61 now3303.86 because3304.02 it's3304.26 by3304.41 appointment,3304.66 and3305.19 you3305.35 have3305.51 all3305.67 these3305.83 seats3306.07 and3306.39 they're3306.47 empty3306.63 because3306.95 of3307.11 the3307.27 fact3307.35 that3307.59 from3308.23 her3308.79 analogy3309.11 of3309.59 the3309.75 way3309.83 she3310.07 gave3310.23 it3310.47 as3310.55 a3310.71 perspective,3310.87 the3312.15 R&V3312.31 used3312.71 to3312.79 be3312.87 treated3313.03 as3313.27 an3313.51 emergency3313.51 room.3314.07 And3315.03 now,3315.27 this3316.79 appointment3317.03 by3317.51 appointment3317.67 only3318.15 gets3318.71 things3318.95 really,3319.19 really3319.59 settled.3320.41
3320.8 And3320.8 my3320.89 comment3321.13 to3321.45 her,3321.53 as3321.76 you3321.84 heard,3322.01 the3322.96 other3323.13 day3323.28 is3323.53 that3323.68 emergencies3324.01 are3324.57 still3324.64 happening.3324.96 There's3325.76 just3326.01 no3326.24 emergency3326.32 room3326.8 to3327.05 go3327.13 to.3327.36 Right?3328.24 And3328.48 so3328.72 you3328.96 still3329.2 have3329.53 it3329.68 so3329.93 that3330.09 folks3330.72 are3331.13 learning3331.28 about3332.24 they3333.77 need3333.93 to3334.41 get3334.65 their3334.81 license3334.97 today.3335.37 They3335.69 didn't3335.93 realize3336.49 all3337.13 of3337.37 the3337.53 things3338.01 that3338.25 may3338.41 have3338.57 happened3338.65 from3338.97 a3339.21 fee3339.29 and3339.53 a3339.77 fine,3339.93 and3340.41 they3340.65 can't3340.73 go3341.05 and3341.21 get3341.37 their3341.61 license3342.65 or3343.05 whatever.3343.21 And3344.33 in3345.13 this3345.37 new3345.69 budget,3345.93 it3346.33 seems3346.49 like3346.73 we3346.97 have3347.13 a3347.45 lot3347.53 of3347.77 things3347.93 listed.3348.33 My3349.88 big3350.2 question3350.44 is3350.84 COVID3352.13 has3352.53 changed3352.68 the3353.88 way3354.05 we3354.28 view3355.32 many,3355.96 many3356.28 things.3356.53 Many3357.16 people3357.4 don't3357.64 want3358.13 to3358.36 go3358.36 to3358.44 work.3358.61 They3358.84 want3358.92 to3359.16 work3359.16 from3359.4 home,3359.57 all3359.8 of3360.05 those3360.2 things.3360.53 But3361.4 in3361.72 so3361.96 many3362.13 ways,3362.36 it3362.61 seems3362.76 like3363.09 we3363.32 are3363.48 hiding3363.64 from3364.05 constituents.3364.28 Like,3365.94 we're3366.18 going3366.5 to3366.74 hide3366.74 behind3366.98 an3367.7 appointment.3367.94
3368.5 We're3368.5 going3368.82 to3369.06 hide3369.06 behind.3369.3 You3369.86 need3370.02 to,3370.26 send3371.46 me3371.7 an3371.86 email.3372.02 going3372.42 to3372.74 hide3372.74 behind3372.98 a3373.22 voice3373.3 mail.3373.62 But3374.42 those3375.62 who3375.94 are3376.18 most3376.42 in3376.82 need3376.98 still3377.93 are3378.64 going3378.81 to3379.2 want3379.2 to3379.53 show3379.61 up3379.84 to3380.09 an3380.32 R&V,3380.72 which3380.89 is3381.05 where3381.2 we3381.36 most3381.53 of3381.84 the3381.93 time3382.01 interface3382.57 with3383.2 transportation.3383.53 Is3384.97 there,3385.29 in3386.32 any3386.57 of3386.72 this,3386.89 has3390.09 your3390.33 office3390.73 and3391.13 the3391.37 r3391.45 and3391.69 d3391.77 just3392.01 gotten3392.57 content3393.29 that3393.77 we're3394.09 going3394.33 to3394.65 always3394.65 just3395.05 be3395.37 appointment3395.61 only3396.09 or3396.73 to3397.37 I'm3397.45 going3397.61 to3397.85 use3397.85 just3398.17 her3398.49 analogy3398.73 since3399.21 that's3399.45 the3399.61 one3399.69 she3399.93 used.3400.09 Hospitals3400.81 would3401.61 like3401.85 everyone3402.17 to3402.73 show3402.81 up3403.05 to3403.39 their3403.55 doctor.3403.78 Right?3404.82 That's3405.3 what3405.46 they3405.63 would3405.78 love3405.94 it3406.26 that3406.51 we3406.66 did,3406.91 but3407.39 they3407.63 still3407.86 have3408.34 an3408.59 emergency3408.74 room3409.3 in3410.03 case3410.18 something3410.43 goes3410.82 wrong3411.14 in3411.3 an3411.46 emergency.3411.63 And3412.59 there3412.74 seems3413.07 like3413.39 there3413.55 must3413.86 be3414.18 a3414.34 way3414.51 that3414.98 maybe3415.22 we3415.46 could3415.63 have3415.7 it3415.94 so3416.11 that3416.26 appointments3416.43 were3417.63 freed3417.63 up3417.86 at3418.67 a3418.83 certain3418.99 hour3419.31 every3419.47 day,3419.79 that3420.35 we3420.59 had3420.67 maybe3421.39 just3421.79 a3422.03 long,3422.11 long,3422.35 long3422.67 wait3422.99 time,3423.23 and3423.71 at3423.87 least3423.95 one3424.27 person3424.51 worked3424.75 in3424.99 the3425.15 registry3425.31 to3426.11 deal3426.35 with3426.59 the3426.75 emergencies.3426.91
3427.55 I3427.55 love3427.71 it3427.95 when3428.11 Saint3428.51 Elizabeth3428.75 used3429.39 to3429.55 have3429.71 it3429.87 where3430.03 you3430.19 can3430.35 see3430.59 them3431.3 literally3431.69 on3432.01 their3432.18 board,3432.41 they3432.73 would3432.89 say3433.05 the3433.38 wait3433.61 time3433.78 in3434.01 our3434.09 emergency3434.26 room3434.66 right3434.89 now3435.05 is3435.3 five3435.53 minutes3435.78 or3436.01 whatever.3436.18 You3436.49 know?3436.57 It3436.82 used3436.97 to3437.21 be3437.45 that3437.86 you3437.86 could3438.01 kind3438.34 of3439.3 figure3439.3 out3439.61 in3439.78 the3439.93 R&V3440.34 which3440.49 one3440.73 you3440.89 want3441.05 to3441.3 go3441.3 to3441.45 because3441.61 this3441.86 time3442.18 was3442.49 long3442.73 and3442.89 this3443.05 one3443.21 was3443.45 not.3443.69 Are3445.34 we3445.58 with3446.38 all3446.62 of3446.86 this3446.94 money3447.66 from3448.06 a3448.3 FareShare?3448.62 Is3449.98 there3450.22 not3450.46 a3450.7 place3450.86 that3451.34 we3451.5 can3451.74 at3452.06 least3452.22 make3452.94 it3453.18 so3453.34 that3453.58 when3453.82 these3453.98 emergencies3454.22 happen,3454.78 that3455.58 people3455.74 can3456.14 be3456.38 served3456.7 today3457.84 and3458.97 not3459.2 have3459.36 to3459.61 wait.3459.76 I3460.41 gave3460.57 the3460.8 emerge3460.97 I3461.36 gave3461.45 the3461.76 analogy.3461.93 I3462.41 had3462.49 to3462.64 drive3462.72 an3463.05 853463.45 year3463.93 old3464.16 to3464.64 Fall3464.89 River3465.2 because3466.09 he3466.49 couldn't3466.64 get3467.05 an3467.28 appointment3467.45 for3468.57 three3468.72 weeks3468.97 when3469.28 he3469.45 learned3469.61 his3469.84 license3470.01 was3470.41 about3470.57 to3470.89 expire.3471.05 That3471.93 does3472.24 not3472.57 seem3474.03 appropriate.3474.27 So3474.83 are3475.07 we3475.23 ever3475.39 going3475.63 to3475.87 go3475.87 back3476.03 to3476.27 being3477.47 able3477.79 to3478.03 have3478.11 it3478.27 so3478.43 that3478.59 we3478.83 still3479.07 serve3479.47 emergencies3479.79 at3481.15 the3481.31 R&V?3481.79
3483.07 TIBBITS-NUTT3483.07 -3483.07 Thank3483.07 you.3483.31 We3484.19 do3484.43 track3484.67 very3484.99 closely3485.31 when3485.95 we3486.11 are3486.27 having3486.43 issues3486.75 with3487.07 people3487.15 getting3487.47 appointments3488.01 and3488.41 complaints3488.72 that3489.05 come3489.13 in3489.36 about3489.45 that.3489.68 It's3490.01 part3490.09 of3490.32 the3490.41 real3490.48 ID.3490.8 There3491.28 are3491.45 certain3491.61 registries3491.93 where3492.41 we3492.64 have3492.8 opened3493.2 up3493.53 windows3493.68 for3494.16 people3494.32 who3494.64 are3494.89 doing3495.05 walk-ins3495.61 or3496.32 doing3496.57 simpler3497.05 transactions,3497.61 whether3498.41 it's3498.64 a3498.89 registration,3498.97 or3499.76 reregistration.3499.76 So3501.12 we3501.2 do3501.36 have3501.52 the3501.68 ability3501.84 to3502.16 do3502.32 it.3502.48 We've3502.56 done3502.8 it3503.04 in3503.2 a3503.28 number3503.36 of3503.6 registries.3503.76 This3504.32 is3504.56 just3504.72 not3504.96 a3505.12 practice3505.28 that3505.6 we3505.76 have3505.92 across3506.16 all3506.72 of3506.88 our3506.96 registries.3507.2
3509.6 HOLMES3509.6 -3509.6 So,3509.6 again,3509.92 you're3510.16 saying,3510.4 no.3510.72 We're3510.96 not3511.2 going3511.44 to3511.68 go3511.68 back3511.92 to3512.16 being3512.8 able3513.12 to3513.28 handle3513.36 emergencies.3513.84 That3514.72 is3515.2 just3515.44 not3515.84 the3516.44 philosophy3516.61 that3517.57 we're3517.72 going3517.96 to3518.2 have3518.2 in3518.44 the3518.61 future.3518.76
3519.72 TIBBITS-NUTT3519.72 -3519.72 We3519.72 will3519.96 not3520.13 go3520.28 back3520.44 to3520.84 only3521.09 being3521.64 able3521.89 to3522.13 handle3522.2 emergencies.3522.61
3523.32 HOLMES3523.32 -3523.32 Yes.3523.32 But,3523.72 we3524.2 have3524.68 a3524.84 path3525.01 for3525.41 emergencies,3525.64 like,3526.28 literally3526.76 some3527.24 solution3527.57 that3528.05 appointments3528.68 open3529.09 every3529.32 single3529.57 day.3529.89 Someone's3530.36 going3530.84 to3531.09 be3531.09 able3531.24 to3531.48 have3531.57 it.3531.72 So3531.89 will3532.36 there3532.6 ever3532.68 be3533.08 a3533.24 plan3533.4 again3533.72 to3534.04 be3534.12 able3534.28 to3534.44 handle3534.52 the3534.84 emergencies3535 of3535.96 people,3536.2 or3536.84 is3537.16 it3537.24 just3537.4 an3538.92 appointment3538.92 only?3539.32 Do3539.88 you3540.68 have3541.08 an3541.24 idea3541.4 on3541.64 that?3541.72
3542.52 TIBBITS-NUTT3542.52 -3542.52 We3542.52 will3542.76 continue3542.92 with3543.32 the3543.48 registries3543.64 where3544.28 we3544.52 are3544.68 seeing3544.92 the3545.48 most3545.8 customers3546.68 to3547.43 be3547.66 able3547.91 as3548.55 I3548.79 said,3548.86 we're3549.18 doing3549.34 it3549.59 for3549.74 Real3549.91 ID3550.07 to3551.27 be3551.34 able3551.51 to3551.66 take3551.74 emergencies.3552.07 But3552.86 also3553.11 as3553.43 part3553.59 of3553.82 this,3553.91 we3554.22 have3554.47 open3554.79 appointments3555.11 throughout3556.55 the3556.79 day3556.95 that3557.82 are3558.07 not3558.14 completely3558.39 booked.3558.79 So3559.11 if3559.27 someone3559.6 comes3559.92 in3560.24 and3560.56 they3560.72 need3560.96 an3561.12 appointment,3561.28 we3561.92 have3562.16 appointments3562.4 at3562.88 the3562.96 registry3563.12 for3564 them3564.24 to3564.4 be3564.56 able3564.64 to3564.88 take3565.04 that.3565.28 Is3566.48 it3566.64 always3566.88 available?3567.2 No.3567.92 It3568.32 isn't.3568.56
3571.28 HOLMES3571.28 -3571.28 Okay.3571.28 I3571.6 don't3571.92 want3572.08 to3572.32 belabor3572.32 it.3572.8 It's3572.96 not3573.12 in3573.36 Boston.3573.52 Right?3574.24 So,3574.56 you3576.03 know,3576.18 from3576.43 my3576.91 perspective,3577.07 it3577.47 would3577.55 be3577.78 great3577.86 to3578.03 get3578.18 the3578.43 R&V3579.39 back3579.55 in3579.7 Rosendale.3580.11 I3580.59 know3580.74 that's3580.91 a3581.07 whole3581.14 other3581.3 conversation.3581.63 But3582.51 to3582.74 have3582.91 it3583.07 so3583.22 that3583.39 we're3583.55 trying3583.7 to3583.95 serve3584.03 700,0003584.34 people3585.14 plus3585.47 our3585.86 neighboring3587.07 counties3587.63 and3588.11 towns3588.66 with3589.59 one3590.47 R&V3590.71 at3590.71 Haymarket.3590.87 It3591.67 is3591.83 typically3593.35 weeks3594.15 if3594.15 you3594.31 learn3594.47 today3594.71 you3594.95 need3595.19 an3595.35 appointment3595.51 to3596.15 get3596.31 something3596.55 there.3596.95 And3597.27 it3597.43 is3597.59 just3597.59 as3598.47 you're3598.63 hearing3598.79 about3599.03 the3599.27 western3599.35 part3599.75 of3599.91 the3599.99 state3600.15 that3600.39 they3600.87 feel3601.11 as3601.43 though3601.67 I3602.15 can3602.23 go3602.39 many3603.16 times3603.41 on3603.72 the3603.89 appointment.3604.05 And3604.77 if3604.84 I3605.01 could3605.09 drive3605.24 out3605.49 to3605.64 Pittsfield,3605.8 I3606.2 could3606.36 probably3606.45 get3606.68 an3606.77 appointment3606.93 in3607.57 the3607.72 next3607.8 couple3608.05 of3608.36 days.3608.45 That's3608.93 not3609.09 the3609.32 way3609.41 it3609.57 is3609.64 on3609.8 the3609.97 Eastern3610.13 part3610.45 of3610.61 the3610.77 state.3610.93 So3611.32 it's3611.57 the3611.8 reverse3611.97 of3612.36 what3612.53 you're3612.84 hearing3613.09 about3613.32 the3613.57 Western3613.64 part3614.05 of3614.29 the3614.36 state3614.45 for3615.01 the3615.09 R&V.3615.57 I3616.05 really3616.2 wish3616.53 someone3617.32 would3617.89 start3618.97 to3619.29 realize3619.37 the3619.77 emergencies3619.93 are3620.33 still3620.49 happening,3620.73 and3621.29 we3621.45 need3621.69 to3622.01 serve3622.17 emergencies3622.49 as3622.97 well.3623.13 Thank3623.29 you.3623.53
3624.17 TIBBITS-NUTT3624.17 -3624.17 Thank3624.17 you.3624.33
3624.73 MICHLEWITZ3624.73 -3624.73 Senator3624.73 Feeney.3625.13
3628.01 SEN3628.01 FEENEY3628.01 -3628.01 Thank3628.01 you,3628.25 Mr.3628.73 Chairman,3629.61 and3629.61 thank3629.93 you,3630.09 to3630.65 you3630.81 all3630.97 for3631.29 the3631.45 work3631.61 that3631.77 you're3631.93 doing3632.01 and3632.25 for3632.33 testifying3632.41 today.3632.97 Questions,3634.94 Secretary3635.66 Tutwiler.3636.14 And3636.14 I3636.22 enjoyed3636.55 our3637.42 back3637.66 and3637.91 forth,3637.98 at3638.7 the3638.86 FY3639.03 263639.34 budget3639.91 hearing3640.14 specifically3640.94 about3641.51 vocational3641.66 and3642.22 career3642.7 technical.3643.03 And3643.66 I'm3643.91 very3643.98 appreciative3644.14 of3644.55 the3644.63 administration.3644.78 I3645.34 think3645.42 you3645.59 had3645.74 mentioned,3645.91 in3647.03 this3647.18 particular3647.59 bill,3648.22 $753648.78 million3650.07 for3650.07 career3650.51 technical3650.67 education,3651.07 you3652.83 know,3652.99 to3653.15 build3653.31 out3653.55 capacity.3653.79 And3654.27 I3654.43 really3654.51 do3654.67 appreciate3654.91 the3655.31 new3655.47 seats3655.63 because3655.95 as3656.27 you3656.43 know,3656.59 that3657.07 is3657.23 something3657.39 that3657.63 we've3657.79 been3658.03 focusing3658.19 heavily3658.67 on,3659.07 is3659.87 how3660.11 we3660.27 build3660.51 capacity.3660.83 How3662.75 does3663.79 the3663.95 administration3664.03 intend3664.67 to3664.99 use3665.15 that3665.31 $753668.3 million?3668.53
3668.53 You3668.53 know,3668.53 one3668.78 time3669.02 investment,3669.57 obviously,3670.14 in3670.86 FareShare,3671.41 funding3672.05 to3673.41 ensure3673.57 that3673.89 capacity3674.14 is3674.7 built3674.86 you3676.3 know,3676.45 in3676.78 the3676.86 workforce3677.02 pipeline3677.49 and3677.85 the3677.93 trades3678.09 that3678.33 actually3678.57 need3678.89 it.3679.05 Right?3679.29 So3679.53 that3679.77 we're3679.85 not,3680.09 we're3680.41 not3680.65 just3680.81 educating3681.05 for3681.53 the3681.69 sake3681.77 of3681.93 educating,3682.09 but3682.81 that3683.05 we're3683.21 actually,3683.45 you3683.93 know,3684.17 creating3684.41 synergy3684.89 between,3685.45 you3686.25 know,3686.41 especially3686.89 in3687.37 mechanical3687.45 trades,3687.93 electrical,3688.25 plumbing,3688.89 those3689.69 things3689.85 people3690.17 are3690.49 having3690.57 trouble3691.29 finding,3691.61 you3692.05 know,3692.21 workers3692.53 in3693.01 that3693.18 field.3693.34 Does3694.53 the3694.78 administration3694.86 have3695.41 a3695.57 plan3695.66 to3695.97 use3696.05 that3696.3 $753696.53 million3698.14 including,3698.14 you3698.69 know,3698.93 increasing3699.34 the3699.73 amount3699.82 of3700.14 seats3700.21 but3700.78 to3701.01 ensure3701.09 that3701.57 we're3701.89 actually3702.14 educating3702.61 the3703.41 workforce3703.57 what3705.26 are3705.42 we3705.42 facing?3705.42 And3706.06 then3706.22 just3706.38 a3706.7 follow-up3706.94 to3707.34 that3707.42 if3707.66 I3707.82 could.3707.9 Is3710.46 the3710.7 administration3710.78 taking3711.34 action3711.74 with3712.14 that?3712.38 Again,3712.62 a3712.94 very3712.94 significant3713.42 and3713.98 important3714.06 investment.3714.38
3715.18 Is3715.18 the3715.26 administration3715.42 taking3715.98 actions,3716.38 to3717.5 make3717.66 sure3717.9 that3718.06 we're3718.3 we're3718.54 we're3718.78 helping3719.53 kind3720.26 of3721.45 move3721.45 those3721.45 students3721.69 into3722.26 those3722.57 fields.3722.97 Right?3723.38 So,3723.69 again,3723.93 you3723.97 know,3724.01 I3725.3 always3725.69 tell3725.93 young3726.34 students,3726.66 look.3726.97 There3727.14 are3727.38 no3727.53 rules.3727.69 You3727.93 be3728.09 you,3728.26 and3728.49 you3728.57 do3728.73 what3728.89 you3729.05 want3729.21 to3729.45 do.3729.45 But3729.93 if3730.01 the3730.17 The3730.34 Commonwealth3730.34 is3730.82 making3730.97 investments3731.38 into3732.09 CTE3732.57 education,3733.05 does3734.28 the3734.4 administration3734.52 have3735.08 a3735.32 plan3735.4 to3735.64 say,3735.72 look.3735.96 We're3736.2 we're3736.44 going3736.6 to3736.76 make3736.76 sure3736.92 that3737.16 that3737.4 we're3737.64 kind3737.88 of3737.96 ushering3738.6 them3739 into3739.24 those3739.48 fields3739.72 that3740.04 we've3740.2 educated3740.44 them3740.92 in3741.08 so3741.64 that3741.8 they're3741.96 not3742.2 going3742.36 and,3742.68 you3743 know,3743.24 taking3743.4 electrical3743.8 or3744.36 plumbing3744.52 or3744.84 some3745 of3745.16 the3745.24 other3745.32 trades3745.56 and3746.04 then3746.2 saying,3746.84 I3747.24 want3747.4 to3747.64 become3747.64 a3747.88 CPA3748.04 for3748.52 my3748.76 career.3748.92 Right?3749.32 So3750.11 I3750.26 appreciate3750.34 the3750.82 investment,3750.91 but3751.3 if,3751.55 you3751.78 know,3751.95 if3752.11 you3752.18 can3752.34 dig3752.51 into3752.66 that3752.91 a3753.07 little3753.14 bit3753.3 deeper,3753.47 I3753.7 appreciate3753.78 it.3754.03
3754.43 TUTWILER3754.43 -3754.43 Yeah.3754.43 Really3754.74 appreciate3755.07 the3755.55 question,3755.63 senator.3756.51 First,3757.07 I3757.3 would3757.47 say,3757.63 the3759.22 the3759.63 guidance3759.95 or3760.43 support3760.66 around3761.07 student3761.39 decision3762.02 making3762.26 or3762.42 student3762.66 election3763.14 around,3763.62 you3763.94 know,3764.1 what3764.26 path3764.5 do3764.66 I3764.9 want3764.98 to3765.22 take3765.22 and3765.38 what3765.54 am3765.7 I3765.86 interested3765.94 in,3766.42 really3767.3 begins3767.54 with3767.94 the3768.1 advising3768.34 space,3768.82 which3769.14 is3769.38 why3769.46 I3769.7 would3769.78 really,3770.26 lift3771.7 up3772.02 the3772.18 importance3772.34 of3773.14 my3773.3 cap,3773.62 my3773.94 career3774.18 and3774.74 academic3774.9 plan,3775.54 because3776.82 that3777.14 helps3777.3 students3777.68 understand3778.01 what's3778.4 available3778.72 for3779.13 them.3779.28 How3779.44 do3779.61 I3779.76 make3779.84 a3780.32 really3780.48 thoughtful3780.8 and3781.13 careful3781.28 decision3781.68 around3782.09 what3782.32 path3782.64 I3783.53 want3783.61 to3783.92 take?3783.92 Helps3784.4 them3784.64 sort3784.8 of3785.05 explore3785.2 their3785.68 entrance3786.01 interests.3786.57 It's3787.2 an3787.36 evidence3787.53 based3787.92 program.3788.24 It's3789.13 expanding3789.36 very3789.92 rapidly3790.24 in3790.64 Massachusetts.3790.8 These3791.44 dollars3791.68 will3792.32 help3792.48 us3792.64 expand3792.72 it3793.2 even3793.44 further.3793.6
3794.8 We've3794.8 made3795.36 an3796.08 expressed,3796.32 goal3797.68 of3798 reaching3798.16 every3798.72 single3799.04 high3799.36 school3799.6 in3800.16 Massachusetts,3800.32 but3800.88 we've3801.12 also3801.28 begun3801.68 to3802 expand3802.72 these3803.12 programs3803.36 in3803.92 middle3804.08 school,3804.32 so3804.64 that3804.8 the3804.96 conversation3805.2 around3806.24 students'3806.56 path3807.04 forward,3807.41 goal3808.21 setting,3808.53 identifying3809.01 a3809.65 path3809.89 toward,3810.13 a3810.69 career3810.78 that3811.09 I'm3811.26 interested3811.49 in3811.82 or3812.05 might3812.38 be3812.53 interested3812.69 in3813.01 really3813.57 starts3813.89 in3814.13 seventh3814.38 and3814.78 eighth3814.93 grade.3815.17 So3815.49 I3815.57 would3815.65 lift3815.89 that3816.05 up3816.21 first3816.38 to3816.61 your3816.78 second3816.93 question.3817.26 The3818.45 first3818.53 question3818.86 is,3819.41 how3821.57 are3821.73 we3821.82 ensuring3822.45 that3822.77 the3823.33 kinds3823.57 of3823.81 expansions,3824.05 the3825.49 kinds3825.65 of3825.89 new3826.13 shops,3826.37 that3827.09 are3827.25 you3827.57 know,3827.65 these3827.89 dollars3828.13 would3828.45 help,3828.61 support3829.49 the3829.81 construction3829.97 of,3830.45 are3831.49 actually3831.65 servicing3832.21 the3832.85 high3832.93 demands3833.17 that3833.57 we3833.65 have.3833.89 CareerTechEd3835.41 schools3836.21 are3836.77 intimately3836.93 aware3837.57 of3838.55 what3839.2 the3839.43 needs3839.59 are3839.99 in3840.16 industry3840.39 through3840.8 their3840.95 close3841.2 partnerships.3841.59
3842.64 They3842.64 engage3842.88 in3843.2 research3843.91 surveys3845.91 plus3846.39 student3846.72 election3847.11 sort3847.52 of3847.68 tells3847.84 us3848.16 a3848.32 little3848.39 bit3848.55 about3849.03 where3849.36 we3849.59 should3849.68 be3849.91 sort3850.07 of,3850.24 anchoring3850.72 our3851.28 dollars.3851.43 So3851.76 for3851.91 example,3852.07 years3853.14 ago3853.38 when3853.62 I3853.86 was3854.02 the3855.54 superintendent3855.78 in3856.42 Lynn,3856.66 there3857.22 was3857.38 a3857.7 radio3857.94 and3858.42 TV3858.66 shop3859.22 there3859.86 when3860.1 I3860.34 first3860.5 started,3861.06 nearly3861.54 no3862.26 student3862.42 signed3862.82 up3863.06 for3863.22 it.3863.38 There's3863.38 no3863.62 interest.3863.78 The3864.26 the3864.74 industry3864.82 demands3865.38 aren't3866.05 really3866.36 there3866.61 for3867.01 that3867.41 kind3867.64 of3867.89 instruction.3868.2 Instead,3869.72 there3870.2 was3870.36 huge3870.68 demand3871.09 around3871.57 HVAC,3872.05 advanced3873.81 manufacturing.3874.29 And3875.01 so,3875.24 we3876.29 both3876.77 started3877.16 an3877.57 HVAC3877.81 program3878.27 at3878.47 LinTech3878.67 and3879.39 expanded3879.87 our3880.35 advanced3880.67 manufacturing3881.07 program.3882.27 And3882.59 I'm3882.83 seeing3882.99 that3883.23 already3883.47 happening3883.95 subs3884.67 that3885.15 kind3885.31 of3885.55 sort3885.87 of3886.03 tradition3886.19 happening3886.99 substantively3887.47 in3888.43 career3888.67 tech3888.99 ed3889.23 schools3889.47 across3889.87 the3890.19 state.3890.36 For3890.59 example,3890.76 we3891.72 just3891.95 recently3892.2 celebrated3892.76 the3893.23 opening3893.39 of3894.03 a3894.91 brand3895.07 new3895.32 HVAC3895.64 shop3896.51 at3896.68 McCann3896.99 Tech3897.39 in3897.72 North3897.88 Adams.3898.11
3898.99 This3898.99 is3899.23 not3899.39 only3899.55 going3899.88 to,3900.11 sort3900.84 of3901.07 satisfy3901.32 the3901.88 appetite,3902.03 and3903.17 the3903.41 demand3903.65 for3904.05 people3904.37 who3904.69 have3904.93 that3905.09 skill3905.33 set3905.65 in3905.81 that3906.05 region3906.29 of3906.93 the3907.09 state,3907.25 and3907.49 there's3907.65 a3907.97 huge3908.05 demand.3908.45 But3910.53 also3910.69 it3911.01 allows3911.17 McCann3911.89 Tech3912.29 to3912.53 invite3912.85 more3913.33 students3913.65 to3914.69 come3914.77 to3915.01 their3915.49 school.3915.73 Right?3916.05 The3916.29 enrollment3918.91 or3919.8 or,3919.88 availability3920.51 challenge3921.39 that3921.71 many3921.88 career3922.28 tech3922.67 ed3923.07 schools3923.23 experience3923.95 is3924.84 through3924.99 the3925.23 shop3926.51 class3926.91 size3927.23 maximums.3927.71 Right?3928.28 They're3928.51 only3928.84 allowed3929.15 to3929.39 have3929.47 a3929.63 certain3929.84 number3930 of3930.12 students3930.24 in3930.64 a3930.8 shop3930.96 at3931.2 a3931.28 time3931.36 for3931.6 safety3931.76 purposes.3932.32 These3933.28 dollars3933.52 help3933.84 us3934.16 both,3934.32 support3935.44 those3935.84 schools3936 with3936.32 building3936.48 new3936.8 shops,3937.04 expanding3937.44 the3938 existing3938.24 ones3938.72 to3939.28 allow3939.44 for3939.76 more3939.92 students3940.16 to3940.56 be3940.72 serviced,3940.88 serviced3942 in3942.48 those3942.64 shops.3942.8 And3943.12 so,3943.28 I3944.16 would3944.24 say3944.48 there's3944.64 a3944.88 really3944.96 thoughtful,3945.28 attentive,3946.22 process3948.93 involved3949.49 in3949.97 terms3950.14 of3950.45 which3950.61 types3951.41 of3951.74 shops3951.89 are3952.7 are3952.93 opening,3953.02 and3953.66 I'm3953.89 sure3954.06 that3954.22 these3954.45 dollars3954.61 will3955.02 will3955.34 will3955.66 will3955.82 definitely,3955.97 serve3957.26 a3957.49 really3957.66 important3957.89 need.3960.01
3960.57 FEENEY3960.57 -3960.57 Thank3960.57 you,3960.65 secretary.3960.89 I3961.29 just3961.45 again,3961.93 great3962.73 answer.3963.05 I3963.37 just3963.45 want3963.61 to3963.85 make3963.85 sure3963.93 that3964.09 we3964.25 are3964.49 focusing3964.57 on3964.97 that3965.13 every3965.29 time3965.45 we3965.69 spend3965.77 a3966.09 dollar3966.17 in3966.89 career3967.05 technical3967.37 education,3967.85 that3968.65 we're3968.81 doing3968.97 it3969.21 to3969.29 get3969.45 a3969.53 return3969.61 on3969.93 the3970.09 investment3970.17 and3970.65 actually,3970.81 you3971.61 know,3971.69 make3972.57 sure3972.81 that3972.97 we're3973.05 maximizing3973.21 the3973.77 amount3973.85 of3974.09 people3974.17 that3974.41 are3974.66 putting3974.66 into3974.82 the3975.05 trades3975.14 that3975.45 are3975.61 needed.3975.61 So3976.02 Right3976.26 on.3976.41 Again,3976.57 Thank3976.82 you.3976.97 I3977.14 think3977.22 if3977.38 we3977.53 opened3977.7 up3977.93 a3978.57 state3978.82 government3979.05 shop,3979.53 maybe3980.41 nobody3980.74 would3981.14 go3981.3 into3981.53 that3981.78 particular3982.02 shop.3982.66 So,3982.89 I3983.78 appreciate3983.86 the3984.34 answer.3984.41 Thank3984.66 you,3984.82 Mr.3985.22 Chairman.3985.7
3985.7 TUTWILER3985.7 -3985.7 For3985.7 sure.3985.78
3986.49 MICHLEWITZ3986.49 -3986.49 Thank3986.49 you.3986.66 Representative3987.53 Diggs.3988.57
3989.37 REP3989.37 DIGGS3989.37 -3989.37 Thanks,3989.37 Mr.3992.73 Quick3992.73 question.3992.97 MBTA,3993.53 outdoor3995.37 advertising3996.73 budget,3997.53 what3998.73 does3998.97 that3999.29 revenue3999.45 bring3999.93 in?4000.17
4003.05 TIBBITS-NUTT4003.05 -4003.05 I4003.05 don't4003.13 know4003.36 the4003.61 total4003.68 on4004.01 this4004.16 one.4004.32
4006.89 DIGGS4006.89 -4006.89 How's4006.89 that?4007.36 Peter,4011.2 could4011.61 you4011.84 could4012.57 you4012.72 Phil.4012.89 Sorry.4013.2 Phil,4013.68 could4013.93 you4014.09 answer4014.24 that4014.57 question4014.72 about4015.13 the4015.61 MBTA4015.84 and4016.41 how4016.8 much4017.05 the4017.28 outdoor4017.45 budget4019.46 for4019.7 the4019.94 outdoor4020.18 advertising?4020.34
4028.42 PHILLIP4028.42 ENG4028.42 -4028.42 MBTA4028.42 -4028.42 Representative,4028.42 I4029.22 don't4029.3 have4029.62 the4029.78 specific4030.02 information4030.76 with4031.09 me.4031.32 We4031.57 can4031.8 certainly4032.05 provide4032.45 that4032.76 to4033.09 everyone.4033.72 The4034.45 one4034.61 thing4034.68 I4034.93 will4035.01 say4035.16 is4035.41 as4035.97 we4036.2 continue4037.09 to4037.64 see4037.8 ridership4038.05 come4038.61 back,4038.76 those4039.09 are4039.32 the4039.41 discussions4039.64 that4040.13 we4040.28 will4040.45 have4040.68 with4041.01 the4041.97 advertisers,4042.2 with4043.24 regards4043.48 to,4044.05 existing4044.93 contracts4045.48 and4046 the4046.08 existing4046.16 ability4046.56 to4047.04 actually4047.2 do4047.68 more4047.92 advertising4048.24 within4048.8 our4049.2 system.4050.08 So4051.36 those4051.68 are4051.84 the4051.92 things4052 that4052.24 we4052.4 certainly4052.64 bring4053.04 back4053.28 with4053.52 the4053.68 information4053.84 regarding4054.4 what4054.8 kind4054.96 of4055.12 revenue4055.2 we4055.6 generate.4055.76
4056.8 DIGGS4056.8 -4056.8 They're4056.8 also4057.04 asking4057.44 if,4057.84 if4058.96 we4059.12 could4059.28 build4059.44 a4059.84 car4060.32 wash,4060.64 would4061.3 that4061.55 if4061.95 they4062.18 wanted,4062.34 would4062.74 that4062.99 would4063.22 that4063.39 budget4063.63 would4063.95 that4064.18 be4064.43 able4064.59 to4064.82 be4064.91 covered4064.99 in4065.39 that?4065.55
4067.55 ENG4067.55 -4067.55 Sorry.4067.55 A4067.86 car4067.95 wash4068.27 in?4070.34
4071.3 DIGGS4071.3 -4071.3 Zoning.4071.3 Could4071.3 they4071.55 build4071.86 a4072.11 car4072.34 wash4072.59 if4073.14 they4073.63 wanted?4073.78 More4074.34 meaning,4074.66 if4075.14 if4075.39 the4075.47 if4076.81 the4076.89 exclusionary4077.13 local4077.93 local4078.25 zoning4078.65 covers,4079.13 could4079.93 that4080.17 cover4080.73 up4081.13 car4081.29 wash4081.53 with4081.93 the4082.17 with4082.33 the4082.49 on4082.81 that4083.05 budget4083.21 if4083.77 it4084.33 was4084.41 covered?4084.65
4085.37 ENG4085.37 -4085.37 Oh,4085.37 meaning4085.61 could4085.93 the4086.17 revenue4086.33 from4086.81 advertising4087.45 cover?4088.57
4089.82 DIGGS4089.82 -4089.82 Yes4089.82
4089.82 ENG4089.82 -4089.82 Rolling4089.82 stock4090.07 car4090.55 wash,4090.7 train4091.11 car4091.43 wash?4091.66 I'd4092.78 have4093.03 to4093.18 check4093.34 on4093.59 that.4093.74 We4094.7 do4094.95 have4095.11 car4095.34 wash4095.59 facilities.4095.91 One4096.55 of4096.78 the4096.86 things4097.02 that4097.19 we're4097.34 investing4097.59 in4098.06 our4098.23 capital4098.39 program,4098.78 it's4099.59 not4099.82 only4099.98 modernizing4100.39 facilities,4101.27 for4101.66 instance,4101.9 for4102.23 battery4102.47 electric4102.86 buses4103.31 as4103.63 as4103.79 we4104.03 start4104.19 to4104.43 procure,4104.51 receive4105.23 them,4105.55 but4106.19 also4106.43 ensuring4106.67 that4107.15 our4107.31 existing4107.47 facilities,4107.95 can4109.15 continue4109.31 to4109.95 support,4110.27 the4111.47 rolling4111.71 stock4112.03 that4112.35 we4112.51 currently4112.75 have4113.23 until4113.71 new4114.11 rolling4114.27 stocks4114.59 start4114.91 to4115.15 come4115.23 in.4115.39
4116.68 DIGGS4116.68 -4116.68 Thank4116.68 you.4116.91
4118.59 MICHLEWITZ4118.59 -4118.59 Senator4118.59 Croner.4119.07
4121.64 SEN4121.64 CRONIN4121.64 -4121.64 Thank4121.64 you4121.88 very4122.03 much,4122.19 Mr.Chairman.4122.68 Secretary4123.4 Tutwiler,4123.95 first,4124.51 I4124.84 just4125.15 want4125.4 to4125.64 say4125.64 thank4125.88 you4126.11 for4126.35 all4128.19 your4128.44 work4128.59 and4128.84 all4128.99 your4129.15 leadership4129.31 and4130.03 focus4130.27 on4130.76 vocational4131.15 education,4131.23 expanding4140.8 career4141.36 technical4141.76 opportunity4142.08 and4142.72 the4142.88 governor's4142.96 FareShare4143.6 sup.4143.92 You4145.61 know,4145.78 I4145.94 think4146.1 you4147.14 spoke4147.3 about4147.61 reimagining4148.02 high4148.82 school,4148.98 and4149.38 I4149.53 think4149.61 this4149.78 is4150.02 an4150.18 opportunity4150.34 for4151.06 us4151.22 to4151.38 shift4151.53 the4151.85 paradigm4152.02 kind4153.06 of4153.3 around4153.38 the4153.7 controversy4153.85 of4154.41 vocational4154.66 schools.4155.22 Right?4155.61 And4155.85 I4156.49 hope4156.57 that4156.9 as4157.22 we4157.38 look4157.61 to4157.85 invest4158.02 new4158.98 dollars4159.22 and4159.71 build4159.87 more4160.11 capacity,4160.43 we4160.99 can4161.15 align4161.95 that4162.51 with4162.91 kids4163.23 who4163.63 are4163.71 going4163.87 into4164.03 the4164.27 labor4164.51 market.4165.79
4165.95 Who4165.95 are4165.95 not4166.11 pursuing4166.43 post4166.91 secondary4167.15 education4167.79 and4168.51 will4169.07 benefit4169.23 the4170.51 most4170.67 from4170.99 new4171.39 programming4171.63 and4172.27 take4173.02 the4173.18 skills4173.26 that4173.49 they4173.73 learn4173.81 to4174.05 benefit4174.14 our4174.53 local4174.69 and4174.94 regional4175.02 economies4175.49 too.4175.98 With4177.02 that4177.26 in4177.49 mind,4177.65 I'm4178.05 wondering4178.3 if4178.69 you4178.85 can4178.94 speak4179.18 to4179.49 how4180.3 the4180.45 administration4180.69 is4181.34 thinking4181.49 about4181.81 prioritizing4182.22 investments,4183.18 not4183.9 just4184.14 in4184.38 our4184.53 vocational4184.69 schools,4185.34 but4186.05 in4186.3 integrating4186.45 Chapter4186.94 744187.34 programs4188.1 and4188.42 vocational4188.82 capacity,4189.46 and4190.66 programs4190.9 into4191.54 our4191.78 comprehensive4192.1 high4192.74 schools.4192.9 And4193.78 and4194.18 and4194.5 I4194.74 know4194.82 there4194.98 are4195.14 innovative4195.3 programs4196.34 across4196.74 the4197.06 state4197.22 that4197.46 are4197.7 aligned,4198.34 new4199.54 programs4199.78 to4200.34 juniors4200.5 and4200.9 seniors,4201.06 and4201.46 that4201.62 population4202.42 that4206.9 is4206.9 headed4206.9 to4206.9 the4206.9 labour4206.9 force.4206.9 Could4206.9 you4206.9 speak4206.9 to4206.9 that?4206.9 The4206.9 opportunities4206.9 there?Thank4207.85 you.4208.02
4208.34 TUTWILER4208.34 -4208.34 Absolutely.4208.34 Thank4208.81 you4208.98 for4209.14 the4209.38 question.4209.45 So,4210.9 first,4212.02 I4212.34 want4212.49 to4212.98 just4212.98 be4213.45 clear4213.61 that4214.02 the4214.34 $754219.36 million4219.36 is4219.36 designed4219.68 to4220.08 create4221.2 expansion4221.6 of4222.32 capacity,4222.64 both4223.52 in4223.84 comprehensive4224.08 high4224.88 schools,4225.12 your4225.44 traditional,4225.68 comprehensive4226.96 high4227.52 school4227.68 and4227.92 career4228.24 tech4228.72 ed4228.96 schools.4229.12 So4229.36 if4229.52 you've4229.68 got4229.84 a4230.4 school4230.56 that4230.88 has4231.92 a4232.08 Chapter4232.28 744232.6 program4233.24 and4233.56 is4233.81 looking4234.05 to4235.01 expand4235.09 capacity4235.56 so4236.2 that4236.45 more4236.52 students4236.77 are4237.09 able4237.24 to4237.41 engage4237.56 in4237.89 that4238.05 experience,4238.36 these4239.32 dollars4239.65 support4240.13 that4240.6 expansion.4240.85 And4241.32 so4241.48 I4241.73 just4241.81 want4241.97 to4242.2 be4242.2 clear4242.28 that4242.52 it4242.93 touches4243.09 both4243.56 of4244.52 those4244.6 schools.4245.79 The4246.11 other4246.27 thing4246.43 that4246.59 I4246.75 would4246.83 lift4246.99 up4247.15 really4247.39 quickly4247.63 is4248.51 that4248.67 in4248.99 the4249.15 reimagining4249.63 high4250.43 school,4250.67 proposal,4251.55 the4252.03 32.54254.03 million$,4254.35 there4254.35 is4254.51 an4254.99 allocation,4255.15 in4256.43 there4256.59 about4256.83 $34257.15 million4258.03 that's4258.03 designed4258.27 to4258.99 support4259.23 Chapter4259.55 744260.03 start4260.81 up,4261.05 for4261.85 schools4262.09 that4262.41 don't4262.73 have4263.05 any4263.3 Chapter4263.45 744263.85 programs,4264.49 but4265.3 are4265.45 interested4265.53 in4266.34 doing4266.65 the4267.05 research,4267.22 planning,4267.85 and4268.9 exploration4269.05 to4269.69 bring4269.94 one4270.18 into4270.49 their4270.81 school.4271.05
4271.61 There4271.61 are4271.94 dollars4272.01 there4272.34 to4272.65 support4272.81 that4273.61 exploration4273.85 as4274.49 well.4274.65 The4275.13 other4275.29 thing4275.37 that4275.45 I4275.77 would,4275.93 I4276.97 think4277.05 it's4277.29 important4277.45 to4278.01 share4278.17 that's4278.49 not4278.81 part4279.05 of4279.29 this4279.45 explicit,4280.25 budget4280.97 conversation,4281.37 but,4282.09 in4282.73 the4282.89 bright4284.09 bond4284.49 bill,4284.81 there4285.77 is4286.33 $1004286.73 million4287.05 that4288.59 is4288.66 set4288.82 aside4289.15 for4289.47 these4289.7 skills4290.02 capital4290.35 grants.4290.82 These4291.63 are4291.78 dollars4291.94 that4292.43 support,4292.66 the4294.1 modern4294.51 modernizing4295.31 of4296.02 space,4296.27 the4296.66 purchasing4296.91 of,4297.55 equipment,4298.51 for4299.47 schools4299.63 that4300.02 are4300.19 providing4300.35 these4300.82 work4300.98 based4301.23 learning4301.55 experiences,4302.1 whether4302.66 through,4303.06 innovation4304.08 career4304.56 pathways4304.88 or4305.6 other4305.84 programs,4306.16 so4306.88 that4307.04 students4307.2 have4307.6 access4307.92 to4308.24 the4309.04 industry4309.2 recognized,4309.68 materials,4310.96 the4311.84 the4312.08 machinery,4312.32 the4312.88 tools,4313.04 to4313.92 prepare4314.08 them4314.48 for,4314.8 readiness,4315.6 in4316.48 in4316.72 their,4316.96 whatever4317.52 field4318.44 or4318.6 pathway4318.84 they4319.24 take,4319.4 after4319.89 high4320.6 school.4320.84 And4321.01 so,4321.16 there4321.89 is4322.05 a4322.2 holistic4322.36 approach4322.93 that4323.24 we're4323.4 taking4323.56 here.4323.89 It's4324.13 not4324.36 just,4324.6 within4326.05 the4326.36 career4326.6 tech4326.93 ed4327.16 schools.4327.4 It4327.72 is4327.89 a4328.36 holistic4328.52 impact,4329.09 that4330.36 we4330.52 think,4330.68 you4331.01 know,4331.16 ultimately4331.4 will4331.89 have4332.13 an4332.28 impact.4332.44
4335.82 MICHLEWITZ4335.82 -4335.82 Representative4335.82 McKenna.4336.46
4338.46 REP4338.86 MCKENNA4338.86 -Thank4338.86 you4338.86 very4339.02 much,4339.26 mister4339.5 chairman.4339.82 There4340.22 certainly4340.54 is4341.02 a4341.1 lot4341.18 to4341.42 digest4341.74 in4342.14 this4342.3 presentation,4342.54 and4343.1 a4343.26 lot4343.34 of4343.58 the4343.66 questions4343.74 that4344.14 I4344.38 had4344.54 had4344.86 been4345.18 asked.4345.55 So4345.78 I4346.02 appreciate4346.47 the4346.9 conversation4347.15 we4347.63 just4347.78 had4347.94 about4348.19 TechEd,4348.51 the4349.15 VocTechs,4350.34 as4350.9 well4350.98 as4351.23 the4351.39 CTEs.4351.55 But4352.59 to4352.74 me,4352.9 the4353.06 most4353.23 important4353.47 thing4353.86 was4354.19 asked4354.59 by4354.82 Rep4354.98 Smola,4355.23 and4355.63 I4355.78 keep4355.86 coming4356.1 back4356.34 to4356.59 the4356.66 apparent4357.47 inequity4357.94 in4358.74 regional4358.98 balance4360.84 on4361.32 transportation4361.72 funding.4362.44 And4362.76 so,4363 though4363.96 I4364.12 had4364.28 it4364.44 in4364.6 my4364.76 head4364.92 when4365.24 Rep4365.64 Smola4366.04 asked4366.44 the4366.68 question,4366.76 I'll4367.08 take4367.24 credit4367.64 for4367.96 his4368.12 question,4368.36 and4369.16 just4369.4 want4369.56 to4369.8 amplify4369.88 what4370.52 he4370.68 said.4370.92 That4371.08 it's4371.32 not4371.48 just4371.72 Western4371.96 Mass4372.44 that4372.76 feels4372.92 this4373.32 inequity.4373.64 It's4374.44 Central4374.68 Mass.4375.24 It's4375.88 The4376.03 Cape4376.11 and4376.43 The4376.59 Islands.4376.68 It's4377.55 the4377.8 North4377.95 Shore,4378.27 the4378.68 South4378.84 Shore.4379.15 And4379.8 I4379.95 would4380.11 argue4380.27 even4380.68 those4380.91 areas4381.15 with4381.95 a4382.27 commuter4383.15 rail4383.64 MBTA4384.03 access,4384.68 see4385.95 a4386.11 fraction4386.27 of4386.68 the4386.84 population4386.99 of4387.47 those4387.55 communities4387.8 actually4388.35 riding4388.68 the4389.07 commuter4389.31 rails4389.88 and4390.11 many4390.65 more4390.81 stay4391.13 on4391.29 the4391.45 road.4391.53 So4391.77 I'll4392.25 simply4392.57 amplify4392.89 that4393.37 concern4393.61 and4394.25 the4394.49 need4394.97 to4395.29 have4395.45 regional4396.01 equity.4396.49 Thank4396.97 you.4397.21
4398.01 TIBBITS-NUTT4398.01 -4398.01 Thank4398.01 you.4398.25
4401.13 MICHLEWITZ4401.13 -4401.13 Senator4401.13 Creighton.4401.61
4403.85 SEN4403.85 CRIGHTON4403.85 -4403.85 Thank4403.85 you,4404.18 Mr.4404.65 Chairman.4405.22 This4405.22 is4405.34 kind4405.45 of4405.61 building4405.77 off4406.02 the4406.26 previous4406.57 question.4406.9 First,4407.14 thank4407.38 you4407.53 to4407.69 the4407.85 secretary,4408.02 as4408.41 all4408.57 of4408.65 you4408.81 for4408.98 your4409.3 hard4409.53 work4409.77 in4409.94 this4410.09 bill4410.26 and4410.49 your4410.98 testimony4411.14 here4411.69 today.4411.85 So4412.81 I4413.14 I4413.38 really4413.53 appreciate4413.77 this4414.34 administration's4414.57 when4416.76 it4416.84 comes4416.96 to4417.08 implementing4417.56 the4418.44 low4418.84 income4419.16 fare4419.32 program.4419.64 It's4421.32 been4421.4 a4421.8 long4422.2 time4422.28 coming,4422.44 and4422.68 we4422.92 really4423.24 appreciate4423.48 it.4423.88 I'd4424.04 first4424.52 like4424.84 to4425.08 get4425.64 any4425.8 updates4426.04 on4426.44 how4426.6 that4427.56 is4427.64 going4427.8 in4428.12 terms4428.2 of4428.52 usage.4429.64 And4430.04 if4430.2 there4430.28 are4430.36 any4430.52 statistics4430.76 that4431.14 you4431.26 could4431.38 share,4431.53 that4431.61 would4431.93 be4432.09 great.4432.26 And4432.73 also4432.97 when4434.57 you4434.81 look4434.97 at,4435.22 I4435.53 guess,4435.61 our4435.93 most4436.09 expensive4436.41 mode4436.97 of4437.45 public4437.61 transportation4438.01 outside4438.57 of4438.89 ferries4438.97 on4439.3 our4439.45 commuter4439.53 rail4439.93 system4440.09 over4440.41 4004440.65 miles,4441.14 obviously,4441.69 the4442.18 further4442.26 you4442.81 get4442.97 outside4443.22 of4443.69 the4444.01 Boston4444.18 core,4444.73 it4446.38 becomes4446.54 more4446.94 expensive,4447.34 oftentimes4447.82 more4448.78 unreliable4449.1 just4449.74 because4449.98 of4450.22 travel4450.62 distance.4450.94 I'd4451.74 be4451.9 curious4451.98 what4452.38 steps,4452.62 the4454.3 MBTA4454.38 is4454.94 taking4455.18 to4456.06 ensure4456.22 that,4456.78 our4457.5 low4457.66 income4457.9 riders4458.46 are4458.94 aware4459.1 of4459.34 the4459.42 program,4459.58 how4459.9 we4460.15 can4460.31 get4460.47 them4460.7 to4460.94 encourage4461.35 them4462.55 to4462.78 utilize4462.94 it4463.35 more4464.23 frequently.4464.55 And4467.27 yeah.4467.59 Thank4467.82 you.4468.06 That's4468.47 that4468.7 I4469.02 don't4469.1 know4469.27 if4469.43 it's4469.51 to4469.66 the4469.82 secretary4469.9 or4470.78 the4471.02 GM,4471.19 but.4471.59
4472.62 TIBBITS-NUTT4472.62 -4472.62 I'll4472.62 take4472.86 a4472.9 first4472.94 crack4473.34 at4473.58 it.4473.66 As4474.62 you4474.86 know,4474.94 we4475.58 have4475.74 worked4475.9 on4476.14 the4476.3 low4476.38 income4476.54 fair4476.86 for4477.02 a4477.18 really4477.26 long4477.58 time.4477.74 And4478.38 one4478.62 of4478.78 the4478.86 biggest4479.02 things4479.34 that4479.74 came4479.98 out4480.22 of4480.46 it4480.54 was4480.94 talking4481.34 about4481.74 education.4482.38 Not4483.5 just4483.74 on4484.86 the4485.1 website,4485.18 not4485.9 just4486.06 on4486.78 message4486.94 boards,4487.35 but4487.6 really4487.76 working4487.91 with4488.23 the4488.4 community4488.56 groups4489.03 and4489.84 the4490.07 ones4490.15 that4490.31 are4490.56 especially4490.88 representing4491.52 the4492.23 majority4492.4 of4492.88 these4492.95 populations,4493.27 and4494.07 also4494.4 working4494.64 with4494.95 the4495.11 schools4495.19 to4495.6 make4495.68 sure4495.84 that4495.99 people4496.15 do4496.4 know4496.64 about4496.8 these4497.03 programs.4497.19 We4497.99 can4498.07 get4498.23 you4498.4 the4498.64 exact4498.8 number4499.19 of4499.68 people4499.84 who4500.07 are4500.23 currently4500.4 utilizing4500.88 the4501.35 low4501.52 income4501.76 fair.4502.15 And4502.87 then4503.11 also,4503.27 as4503.99 many4504.23 people4504.39 know,4504.71 the4505.03 RTAs4505.27 134505.91 of4506.23 the4506.39 154506.55 also4506.95 went4507.27 fare4507.51 free.4507.75 So4508.23 we4508.39 can4508.55 also4508.71 get4508.95 you4509.03 that4509.19 information.4509.43
4510.79 CRIGHTON4510.79 -4510.79 Great.4510.79 Thank4511.03 you.4511.27 I4511.35 mean,4511.43 I4511.67 think4511.75 you've4511.99 heard,4512.23 the4512.71 theme4512.87 of4513.03 regional4513.11 equity4513.51 brought4513.83 up4514.07 again4514.23 and4514.47 again4514.55 in4514.79 the4514.95 questions4515.03 here4515.35 today.4515.59 But4516.15 even,4516.4 representing4516.95 community4517.43 only4517.99 104518.4 miles,4518.64 from4519.27 Boston4519.51 in4519.91 the4519.99 city4520.07 of4520.31 Lynn4520.47 with4520.95 the4521.19 commuter4521.35 rail4521.76 system4522.07 there,4522.31 but4522.64 a4523.03 $74523.19 one4523.76 way4523.99 ticket,4524.31 you4524.8 know,4524.95 obviously,4525.11 the4525.68 cost4525.76 of4525.99 transfers4526.15 and4526.55 parking,4526.72 my4527.91 entire4528.23 life,4528.61 our4529.17 community4529.41 many4529.97 members4530.21 of4530.45 our4530.61 community4530.69 have4531.49 never4531.65 been4531.81 able4531.97 to4532.21 ride,4532.29 the4533.01 commuter4533.25 rail4533.57 that4533.81 runs4533.89 through4534.21 their4534.45 backyard.4535.01 So,4535.81 it's4536.37 obviously4536.61 a4537.33 big4537.57 impact4537.73 to4538.13 have4538.21 that4538.45 low4538.61 income4538.85 fare4539.17 option4539.49 there,4539.81 but4540.05 we4540.21 want4540.37 to4540.61 make4540.61 sure4540.77 that4541.01 everyone4541.86 is4542.35 well4542.9 aware4543.31 of4543.63 the4543.78 program.4543.94 But4544.59 again,4544.74 thank4545.06 you4545.23 so4545.39 much4545.55 for4545.78 implementing4546.1 it4546.59 and4546.82 look4547.15 forward4547.31 to4547.7 getting4547.86 those4548.1 statistics.4548.35
4549.23 TIBBITS-NUTT4549.23 -4549.23 Thank4549.23 you,4549.39 Senator.4549.63
4550.66 MICHLEWITZ4550.66 -4550.66 Representative4550.66 Pease.4551.31
4555.4 REP4555.4 PEASE4555.4 -4555.4 Thank4555.4 you,4555.72 Mr.4556.28 Chairman.4557.32 And4557.32 thank4557.48 you,4557.64 panel.4557.88 I4558.2 appreciate4558.76 it.4558.76 It's4559.72 been4559.88 a4560.04 long4560.12 time4560.36 since4560.6 we4560.84 saw4561 each4561.16 other,4561.32 I4561.56 know.4561.8 But,4563.72 a4565.16 couple4565.32 of4565.64 quick4565.8 quick4566.12 things.4566.44 I4568.28 see4568.52 that4568.77 there's4568.93 no4569.24 funding4569.73 for4570.69 the4570.93 rural4571.09 aid4571.56 in4572.28 the4572.45 H4574.2 14574.45 budget4574.69 or4575.01 in4575.24 the4575.41 supplemental4575.56 budget.4576.2 Is4576.52 that4576.69 just4577.65 because4577.89 I4578.93 mean,4579.09 you4579.24 got4579.41 the4579.56 culverts4579.73 and4580.13 bridges,4580.28 but4580.77 nothing4581.41 specifically4582.13 under4582.93 the,4583.16 rural4584.5 aid4585.54 money4585.62 for4585.94 the4586.26 roads.4586.42 And4586.74 I4586.9 was4586.98 wondering4587.14 if4587.54 that's4587.78 because4588.02 you're4588.26 looking4589.14 at4589.38 what's4589.54 tied4589.78 in4590.02 with4590.26 the4590.42 bigger4590.58 picture4591.62 or4592.26 not,4592.74 I4593.06 guess.4593.22
4594.1 TIBBITS-NUTT4594.1 -4594.1 It4594.1 is4594.26 tied4594.42 in4594.66 with4594.82 the4594.98 bigger4595.06 picture.4595.3 Secretary4595.62 Gorzkowicz4596.1 ,4596.52 don't4596.52 know4596.77 if4597.01 you4597.26 want4597.5 to4597.74 add4597.74 anything4597.98 to4598.23 that?4598.47
4598.72 GORZKOWICZ4598.72 -4598.72 Yeah.4598.72 No.4598.96 I4599.2 think4599.45 what4599.69 you're4599.93 looking4600.18 at4600.42 is,4600.66 in4601.15 prior4601.39 fiscal4601.64 years,4601.88 we4602.12 had4602.37 a4602.61 separate,4602.85 small4603.34 pot4603.58 of4603.83 money4604.07 that4604.31 was4604.56 for4604.8 rural4605.04 aid.4605.29 That4605.53 has4605.77 been,4606.02 in4606.5 fiscal4606.75 year4606.99 264607.23 proposal4607.72 rolled4607.96 into4608.21 the4608.45 Chapter4608.69 904608.94 proposal4609.18 where4609.42 we're4609.67 adding4609.91 an4610.15 additional4610.4 $1004610.64 million4610.96 a4611.36 year4611.52 with4611.84 a4612.32 rural4612.48 aid4612.8 formula.4612.96 So4613.44 it4613.6 really4613.92 sort4614.16 of4614.48 began.4614.88 It4615.36 got4615.6 its4615.76 start,4616 in4616.64 prior4616.8 fiscal4617.12 years4617.36 as4617.6 a4617.84 smaller4617.92 pot4618.24 of4618.48 money.4618.56 We've4618.96 rolled4619.12 it4619.36 into4619.52 a4619.76 larger4619.92 multi4620.32 five4620.88 year,4621.04 $1.54621.76 billion4622.96 proposal4622.96 of4623.36 which,4623.52 that4624.32 is4624.48 a4624.72 significant,4625.12 $5004626.03 million4626.99 over4626.99 five4627.15 years4627.39 investment4627.63 using4628.03 that4628.27 rule4628.51 formula.4628.74 So4629.07 it's4630.43 evolved4630.59 into4631.31 a4631.86 larger4632.03 proposal4632.35 that4632.74 we've4632.91 presented4633.15 as4633.63 part4633.78 of4633.95 this4634.27 plan.4634.43
4635.15 PEASE4635.15 -4635.15 Well,4635.15 thank4635.39 you.4635.63 I4635.86 appreciate4635.95 that.4636.43 And4636.59 I4637.15 hope4637.23 it's4637.47 just4637.63 the4637.86 beginning4637.95 since4638.35 we4638.59 haven't4638.74 gone4639.07 up4639.23 in4639.39 Chapter4639.55 904639.86 in4640.19 about4640.35 154640.66 years,4641.07 but4641.39 it's4641.94 good4642.1 I4642.26 see4642.5 that.4642.74 And4642.9 one4643.38 other4643.7 quick4643.94 question4644.18 on4644.5 the4646.18 circuit4646.42 breaker.4646.82 You4647.3 said4647.54 that4647.78 you're4647.86 going4648.1 to4648.26 be4648.26 funded4648.42 at4648.74 75%.4649.86 Well,4650.98 I4651.46 know4651.62 in4651.78 my4651.94 district4652.18 that4652.58 they've4652.82 gotten4652.98 proposals4653.38 or4653.94 they've4654.18 got4654.42 a4654.58 letter4654.74 of4655.06 warning4655.14 that4657.31 two4657.55 of4657.55 the4657.63 schools4657.78 that4658.19 they4658.43 send4658.66 seven4658.98 kids4659.31 to4659.63 is4659.94 going4660.1 to4660.51 increase,4660.51 one4660.98 of4661.15 them4661.23 by4661.39 a4661.63 91%4662.59 increase4663.63 in4664.02 the4664.1 tuition,4664.27 going4665.31 from4665.55 65,0004665.78 per4666.74 student4666.98 to4667.39 a4667.55 hundred4667.63 and4667.86 125,000.4668.02 And4669.6 another4669.84 one4670.16 where4670.32 the4670.56 only4670.64 one4670.8 child4671.12 is4671.52 going4671.68 to4671.92 go4671.92 from4672 315,0004672.16 up4673.52 to4673.76 371,000.4673.84 So4676.16 I4676.48 don't4676.64 know4676.8 if4676.96 you've4677.12 taken4677.28 that4677.6 in4677.76 fact4677.92 that4678.24 you'll4678.4 be4678.64 able4678.72 to4678.88 cover4679.04 the4679.28 75%4679.44 with4680.32 those4680.48 increases4680.8 coming4681.36 from4681.6 the4681.76 school,4681.92 which4682.08 I4682.32 think4682.4 they4682.56 have4682.72 to4682.88 get4683.04 approval4683.2 from4683.76 us,4683.92 if4684.74 I'm4684.9 not4684.98 mistaken.4685.22 So4685.7 I4685.78 just4685.85 wonder4686.1 if4686.41 you've4686.49 thought4686.74 of4686.98 that.4687.06
4689.06 TUTWILER4689.06 -4689.06 I4689.06 thought4689.22 the4689.45 mic4689.53 was4689.78 by.4690.02 Secretary4690.26 Gorzkowicz4690.66 was4690.98 not4691.14 looked4691.38 over4691.53 and4691.7 it's4691.85 right4692.02 at4692.18 me.4692.34 So4692.49 I4692.74 guess4692.82 I4693.14 guess4693.3 I'm4693.45 taking4693.61 this.4693.94 I4695.38 would4696.74 like4696.9 to4696.9 connect4696.9 with4697.22 you4697.38 and4697.53 learn4697.7 more4697.94 about4698.1 that4698.41 particular4698.82 challenge.4700.63 But,4701.03 to4701.59 be4701.83 clear,4701.99 you4702.39 know,4702.55 The4703.67 increase4703.75 in4704.31 circuit4704.71 breaker,4705.11 the4705.43 proposed4705.59 increase,4705.99 a4706.39 24%4706.47 increase4707.35 is4707.99 for4708.07 FY4708.47 26.4708.71 There4709.83 are4710.15 provisions4710.31 in4710.95 the4711.03 current4711.19 budget4711.51 when4712.07 districts4712.31 experience4712.87 increases4713.99 within4714.39 the4714.79 year4714.87 over4715.19 a4715.43 certain4715.73 threshold4715.97 that4716.61 kick4717.34 in4717.57 support4717.81 for4718.3 this4718.69 year.4718.93 So4719.73 happy4719.9 to4720.14 circle4720.38 back4720.69 with4720.93 you4721.01 and4721.26 talk4721.73 about4721.9 how4722.85 that's4723.01 if4723.41 that4723.57 support4723.81 applies4724.14 in4724.85 the4724.93 case4725.09 that4725.26 you4725.41 mentioned.4725.57
4726.05 PEASE4726.05 -4726.05 I'd4726.05 really4726.69 like4726.93 to4727.18 just4727.41 let4727.9 you4728.05 know4728.22 at4728.45 least4728.53 that4728.81 one.4728.97 I'm4729.21 sure4729.29 it's4729.53 affecting4729.77 other4730.17 schools4730.41 as4730.81 well.4730.97 But4731.21 thank4731.69 you4731.93 very4732.01 much4732.25 because4732.41 I4732.65 know4732.73 what4732.89 you4732.97 do4733.13 is4733.29 not4733.45 easy.4733.69 So.4733.93
4734.33 TUTWILER4734.33 -4734.33 Appreciate4734.33 you.4734.89
4736.49 MICHLEWITZ4736.49 -4736.49 Senator4736.49 Collins.4736.97
4742.9 SEN4742.9 COLLINS4742.9 -4742.9 Thank4742.9 you,4743.22 Chairman4743.45 Michlewitz.4743.77 Thank4745.22 you,4745.38 Secretary4745.53 Gorzkowicz4745.94 ,4746.49 for4746.49 your4746.57 work4746.73 and4747.3 that4747.53 of4747.7 your4747.85 team4748.02 in4748.41 these4748.57 complex4748.9 and4749.77 challenging4750.02 fiscal4750.57 times.4750.9 I4751.61 think4751.7 we4751.94 currently4752.1 are4752.73 able4753.22 to4753.53 boast4753.7 with4754.45 the4754.53 partnership4754.77 with4755.25 this4755.33 committee4755.49 the4756.45 highest4756.69 bond4757.09 rating4757.33 that4757.65 we've4757.81 had4758.05 at4758.21 least4758.37 since4758.61 my4758.93 time4759.01 in4759.25 the4759.41 legislature,4759.49 if4760.37 not4760.53 our4760.77 state's4760.93 history.4761.25 With4763.81 that,4764.05 I4765.01 know,4765.09 last4766.05 session4766.64 we4766.95 moved4767.2 to,4767.52 I4767.76 think,4767.91 prudently4768.16 create4768.72 a4768.95 mechanism4769.03 to4769.6 leverage4769.68 the4770.07 interest4770.23 of4770.56 the4770.72 surplus4770.8 account,4771.76 for,4772.95 I4773.6 guess,4773.76 you'd4773.91 call4774.07 it4774.2 the4774.31 federal4774.48 match4774.88 account.4775.11 I'm4775.91 wondering4776.07 if4776.48 you4776.64 could4776.72 shed4776.88 some4777.11 light4777.35 on4777.68 the4778.31 utilization4778.56 so4779.2 far4779.44 of4779.68 that4779.84 program4780.72 and4781.35 its4781.52 benefits.
4783.67 GORZKOWICZ4783.67 -4783.67 Sure.4783.67 Thanks4785.11 for4785.43 the4785.59 question4785.75 and4786.07 thank4786.63 you4786.79 for4786.95 your4787.19 support4787.43 for4787.83 that4787.99 important4788.47 piece4788.87 of4789.11 legislation.4789.19 It4790.23 has4790.39 been4790.63 incredibly4791.83 important.4793.19 To4794.95 date,4795.19 we4795.59 have,4795.99 I4797.02 believe4797.19 roughly4797.59 a4798.66 little4798.78 over4799.02 $3004799.27 million,4801.27 of4801.27 awards4801.43 that4802.39 have4802.55 been4802.78 made4803.43 possible4803.66 because4804.15 of4804.39 the4804.55 match4805.19 mechanism.4805.59 And4806.31 for4806.47 those,4806.7 who,4807.43 don't4808.01 recall4808.04 or4808.29 know4808.54 recall4808.95 or4809.19 know4809.67 what4809.83 the4809.99 senator4810.15 is4810.39 referring4810.47 to,4810.79 there4810.95 was4811.03 a4811.19 piece4811.27 of4811.43 legislation4811.51 that4811.99 you4812.15 all4812.39 supported,4813.19 last4813.83 session4814.07 that4814.31 allows4814.47 us4814.79 to4814.95 use4815.03 interest4815.27 from4815.59 the4815.75 stabilization4815.83 fund4816.47 to4816.71 then4816.95 create4817.19 a4817.43 program4817.59 of,4818.07 to4819.03 match4820.47 federal4820.87 grants.4821.27 The4822.63 program4822.79 also,4823.43 was,4824.23 it4825.06 was4825.15 a4825.31 program4825.39 we4825.63 also4825.86 worked4826.1 on4826.27 with4826.34 the4826.43 treasurer's4826.59 office4826.9 that4827.23 allowed4827.39 for4827.78 some4828.34 provisions4828.51 to4828.98 allow4829.15 us4829.39 to4829.55 mitigate4829.63 and4830.02 to4830.27 fuse4830.34 debt.4830.59
4830.74 And4830.74 so4830.98 when4831.39 we4831.63 talk4831.7 about4832.02 leveraging4832.34 federal4832.82 grants,4833.15 it's4833.39 about4833.55 $3004833.7 million4834.9 that4834.9 we've4835.06 been4835.23 able4835.39 to4835.63 put4836.34 out4836.59 there,4836.74 to4837.47 leverage4837.7 those4838.19 dollars.4838.43 About4839.25 2004839.49 of4839.81 those4839.89 are4840.13 awards4840.21 that4840.61 have4840.77 been,4841.01 grants4842.05 that4842.29 have4842.45 been4842.53 awarded4842.69 to4842.93 us.4843.01 I4843.33 think4843.41 about4843.65 1004844.85 million4845.09 might4845.41 still4845.65 be4845.81 pending,4845.89 to4847.33 date.4847.57 We4847.97 have4848.21 not4848.37 seen4848.53 any4848.77 interruption4849.01 in4849.49 those4849.57 grants,4849.81 which4850.05 is4850.21 good4850.37 news.4850.53 And4850.69 so4850.85 we're4851.01 continuing4851.25 to4851.73 forge4852.13 ahead4852.45 and4852.77 we4852.87 continue4852.97 to4853.07 work4853.17 on4853.31 in4855.44 addition,4855.6 we4856.09 have4856.24 utilized4856.56 some4857.13 of4857.2 those4857.28 funds4857.6 to4857.93 pay4859.13 down4859.28 some4859.52 old4860.32 debt,4860.56 $974861.28 million4862.65 of4862.65 MBTA4862.8 debt.4863.36 That4864.4 is4864.56 some4865.05 legacy4865.28 debt4865.69 that4865.77 the4865.93 MBTA4866.09 was4866.49 carrying4866.57 that4866.81 creates4867.13 approximately4870.33 $154870.97 million4871.69 of4871.69 operational4871.85 savings,4872.25 a4872.57 part4872.73 of4872.89 our4873.05 plan4873.21 for4873.53 addressing4874.49 the4874.97 deficit,4875.69 at4876.49 the4876.65 T.4876.89
4877.53 And4877.53 we're4877.69 also4877.93 using4878.17 about4878.49 a4878.65 hundred4878.81 million4879.05 of4879.29 it4879.37 to4879.53 bring4879.61 down4879.77 our4880.01 GO4880.17 debt.4880.49 So,4881.23 from4881.47 a4881.7 rating4881.78 agency's4882.1 perspective,4882.51 and4882.82 I'm4882.99 glad4883.15 you4883.31 mentioned4883.47 it,4883.7 I4883.78 think4883.86 it's4884.02 a4884.27 really4884.43 innovative4884.74 tool4885.23 to4885.47 not4885.63 only4885.78 leverage4886.43 interest4887.47 earnings4887.78 on4888.1 the4888.27 fund,4888.35 meaning4888.59 we're4888.82 not4888.99 touching4889.15 the4889.47 corpus4889.63 of4889.95 it.4890.02 We're4890.51 bringing4890.74 in4890.99 more4891.15 dollars4891.39 and4891.7 investment4891.86 into4892.27 the4892.43 state4892.59 while4892.74 at4892.91 the4893.06 same4893.23 time4893.39 reducing4894.08 our4894.64 overall4894.96 debt4895.84 obligations4896.08 in4896.64 a4896.88 number4896.96 of4897.12 areas,4897.28 which,4898.08 you4899.2 know,4899.36 is4899.52 important4899.76 to4900 the4900.08 rating4900.24 agencies.4900.48 They4901.2 look4901.36 closely4901.6 at4901.92 how4902 we4902.16 manage4902.32 our4902.64 long4902.8 term4902.96 liabilities,4903.2 and4903.6 so4903.76 this4903.92 is4904 certainly4904.16 one4904.48 that4904.64 you've4904.8 been4905.04 able4905.2 to4905.52 help4905.68 us4905.84 with.4906 So4906.16 this4906.32 tool's4906.48 been4906.8 incredibly4907.12 effective.4907.84 So4908.4 thank4908.8 you4908.96 for4909.04 asking4909.2 about4909.52 it.4910.23
4910.23 COLLINS4910.23 -4910.23 Thank4910.31 you.4910.55 Secretary4911.44 Tibbits-Nutt,4912.15 thank4912.48 you4912.72 for4912.88 your4913.03 testimony4913.27 and4913.76 your4913.91 work.4914.07 Given4915.11 the4915.35 uncertainty4915.51 around4916.07 federal4916.31 transportation4916.72 dollars,4917.99 do4919.99 you4920.15 think4920.31 that4920.64 we4921.44 should4921.59 be4921.84 looking4921.91 at4922.23 expanding4922.4 our4923.35 use4924.38 of4924.62 the4924.78 tax4924.94 increment4925.42 financing4925.82 options?4926.46 I4927.02 think4927.1 about4927.34 projects4927.58 in4927.9 my4928.06 district4928.14 like4928.46 Morrissey4928.7 Boulevard,4929.1 JFK4929.66 Station,4930.14 Cajun4930.94 Circle4931.26 that4931.82 served4931.98 the4932.38 region.4932.46 There's4933.58 some4933.9 major4934.06 plans4934.38 in4934.7 the4934.86 area4934.94 for4935.26 development4935.42 and4936.54 will4937.5 dramatically4937.74 increase4938.3 the4938.68 tax4938.84 base.4939.07 But4940.27 they4940.43 do4940.59 require4940.76 major4941.15 investments4941.47 in4941.88 transportation.4942.11 And,4943.55 right4944.43 now,4944.68 in4945.72 the4945.88 state,4946.03 we4946.35 have4946.51 currently4947.23 caps4947.72 for4948.03 municipalities4948.27 to4949.47 be4949.64 able4949.8 to4949.95 access4950.11 those4950.43 through4950.68 mass4950.91 development4951.15 and4952.26 other4952.5 programs4953.78 like4954.18 mass4954.42 works.4954.66 So4955.54 my4955.78 question4955.94 is,4956.26 do4956.58 you4956.74 think4956.9 that4957.06 we4957.22 should4957.38 look4957.46 at4957.7 increasing4957.86 the4958.34 cap4958.5 of4959.38 those4959.54 programs.4961.62
4961.94 Like4961.94 tax4961.94 increment4962.26 financing4962.74 and4963.22 mass4963.38 works4963.62 or4964.26 at4964.5 least,4964.66 you4965.06 know,4965.22 harnessing4965.46 development,4966.1 look4967.95 at4968.11 allowing4968.35 municipalities4968.84 to4969.72 increase4970.27 the4970.68 cap4970.84 on4971.15 the4971.4 municipality,4971.64 if4972.51 not4972.76 the4972.91 program,4973.15 if4973.88 other4974.11 municipalities4974.35 aren't4975.07 tapping4975.31 into4975.64 that4975.8 to4976.03 max4976.19 it4976.44 out.4976.59 Because4977.15 I4977.4 think4977.47 that,4977.64 you4977.88 know,4978.03 with4978.51 what4978.76 we're4978.91 looking4979.07 at,4979.31 that4979.55 uncertainty,4979.72 those4981.76 programs4982.08 have4982.48 worked4982.64 in4982.8 the4982.96 past.4983.04 I4983.36 think4983.44 we've4983.6 seen4983.84 some4984.08 limitations,4984.56 I4985.12 know,4985.2 in4985.52 the4985.6 city4985.76 of4985.92 Boston,4986.08 where4987.12 other4987.44 developments4988.48 may4988.96 have4989.04 been4989.2 able4989.36 to4989.52 support,4989.68 you4990.32 know,4990.48 situations4990.96 like4991.52 that,4991.68 but4992 we4992.24 hit4992.4 a4992.64 cap4992.72 at4993.12 this4993.56 at4993.73 the4993.89 municipal4993.97 level.4994.36 So,4994.84 you4995.16 know,4995.32 wanted4995.97 to4996.28 get4996.36 your4996.52 thoughts4996.69 on4996.93 that4997.01 or4997.09 at4997.32 least4997.4 get4998.05 a4998.2 consideration4998.28 on4999.01 whether4999.24 we4999.56 should4999.73 be4999.89 doing5000.05 that,5000.28 you5000.93 know,5001.01 providing5001.65 legislative5002.13 relief5002.76 to5003.16 agencies5003.65 like5004.13 MassDevelopment5004.28 that5004.93 support5005.09 these5005.4 types5005.56 of5005.72 projects?5007.8
5008.52 TIBBITS-NUTT5008.52 -5008.52 So5008.52 I5008.76 will5008.92 just5009.08 speak5009.24 to5009.4 the5009.56 federal5009.72 funding5010.04 very5010.44 quickly.5010.68 We5011.48 have5011.96 been5012.2 working5012.36 very5012.6 closely5012.84 with5013.24 USDOT.5013.48 We5014.68 understand5014.84 that5015.72 a5016.04 lot5016.12 of5016.28 programs5016.52 are5017.08 changing5017.32 across5017.64 the5017.96 federal5018.12 government.5018.44 But5019.08 for5019.32 us,5019.64 our5020.56 funding5020.73 has5021.2 remained5021.69 consistent.5021.93 Our5022.56 grants5022.8 are5023.2 still5023.44 in5023.6 place,5023.76 and5024.09 we5024.24 are5024.32 continuing5024.48 to5024.97 receive5025.13 reimbursements.5025.69 So5026.89 we5027.05 have5027.2 no5027.44 change5027.6 with5027.84 our5028.01 federal5028.16 grants5028.48 at5028.8 this5028.89 point.5029.13
5029.52 COLLINS5029.52 -5029.52 Great.5029.52 Okay.5030.73 That's5031.13 great.5031.36 Still5032.16 with5032.56 the5032.8 respect5033.05 to5033.44 the5033.52 caps,5034.32 I5035.01 think5035.09 there's5035.33 and5035.57 and5035.81 that5035.89 could5036.05 be5036.21 for5036.29 the5037.09 secretary5037.17 of5037.57 A&F5037.89 as5037.97 well,5038.05 but5038.21 I5038.37 think5038.53 focused5038.93 on5039.33 the5039.41 transportation5039.65 area.5040.21
5041.49 GORZKOWICZ5041.73 -Yeah.5041.73 Look.5041.73 I5041.97 think,5042.13 you5043.17 know,5043.33 going5043.65 forward,5043.97 we5044.93 are,5045.17 willing5046.21 to5046.45 look5046.61 at5046.77 all5046.93 the5047.01 resources5047.17 we5047.57 have5047.73 available5047.89 to5048.21 us.5048.37 I5048.45 think5048.53 when5048.77 we5048.85 start5049.01 looking5049.25 at5049.49 tax5049.65 incremental5050.2 financing,5050.52 you5051.16 know,5051.24 caps5051.48 are5051.72 in5051.88 place5051.95 for5052.28 various5052.44 reasons.5052.68 You5052.99 talked5053.16 about5053.31 the5053.48 rating5053.64 agencies.5053.95 Those5055.07 things5055.31 are5055.64 in5056.03 fact5056.2 important.5056.52 And5057.07 I5057.31 think5057.48 it's5057.64 on5057.88 a5058.03 case5058.11 by5058.28 case5058.44 basis5058.6 where5058.84 you5058.99 look5059.16 at5059.31 the5059.4 overall5059.56 capacity,5059.95 to5060.91 be5061.07 able5061.16 to5061.4 enter5061.56 into5061.88 those5062.03 agreements5062.2 and5062.6 then5062.76 pay5062.91 for5064.11 that.5064.28 And,5065.4 and,5065.64 so5066.12 I5066.36 think5066.44 each5066.6 circumstance5066.84 is5067.72 unique.5067.88 But,5068.92 you5069.08 know,5069.24 look,5069.48 we're5069.64 willing5069.96 to5070.28 look5070.44 at5070.6 all5070.68 the5070.84 tools5071 we5071.24 have,5071.48 available5072.12 to5072.52 us5072.68 and,5072.92 certainly5073.56 would5073.96 be5074.04 willing5074.2 to5074.44 have5074.52 those5074.68 conversations.5074.92 But5075.4 I5075.88 would5076.12 say5076.28 that,5076.52 there5077.7 are5078.02 sort5078.51 of5078.82 limitations5079.06 in5079.63 terms5079.7 of5079.94 what5080.02 can5080.27 be5080.43 generated5080.59 through5081.06 that,5081.23 and5081.47 there5081.94 are5082.19 implications5082.34 from5082.82 a5083.31 rating5083.47 agency's5083.78 perspective.5084.27 So5084.59 it5084.74 just5084.9 has5085.06 to5085.23 be5085.31 taken5085.47 into5085.7 consideration.5085.94 But5086.43 we're5086.59 happy5086.98 to5087.31 lean5087.39 in5087.63 and5087.78 do5087.94 the5088.02 analysis5088.19 and5088.59 do5088.74 the5088.9 work5088.98 and5089.15 where5089.23 it5089.39 makes5089.55 sense,5089.7 explore5091.06 that5091.47 option.5091.63
5092.49 COLLINS5092.49 -5092.49 No.5092.49 I5092.65 understand5092.81 entirely,5093.37 you5093.69 know,5093.93 given5094.25 the5094.57 executive5095.13 authority5095.93 really,5096.41 so5096.73 that's5096.89 not5097.13 a5097.29 statutory5097.45 cap5098.09 as5098.57 well5098.81 as,5098.97 meaning5100.41 particularly5100.89 as5101.45 it5101.61 relates5101.69 to5101.93 a5102.17 municipality's5102.25 use5103.53 of5103.77 those5103.93 tools.5104.09 Thank5104.57 you.5104.81 Secretary5105.69 Tutwiler,5106.41 thank5107.21 you.5107.45 For5108.7 the5109.26 FY5109.74 265109.98 budget,5110.55 the5112.86 Boston5113.1 Public5113.43 Schools5113.74 recently5114.06 approved5114.86 a5115.43 $5117.34 1.585118.3 billion5118.3 budget.5118.3 That's5118.55 with5118.78 a5119.02 B.5120.78 1895121.51 of5121.51 it5121.66 will5121.82 be5121.98 going5122.06 to5122.39 transportation.5122.7 Currently,5124.78 it5125.26 looks5125.34 as5125.58 if5125.74 Chapter5125.98 705126.38 would5126.78 come5126.94 in5127.02 there5127.18 on5127.34 2405127.58 million5128.62 for5128.62 the5128.78 city5128.94 of5129.18 Boston.5129.34 That's5130.78 a5131.1 significant5131.26 contribution.5132.38 But5132.94 with5133.18 a5133.34 hundred5133.5 and5133.74 $1895133.98 million5136.86 going5136.86 toward5137.18 transportation,5137.34 wondering5139.32 your5139.72 thoughts5139.89 on5140.13 whether,5140.28 you5140.76 know,5140.93 school5141.32 districts5141.65 who5142.36 are5142.52 spending5142.68 enormous5143.09 amounts5143.56 of5143.8 money5143.89 on5144.05 transportation5144.28 should5144.84 be5145.01 taking5145.32 a5145.72 look5145.8 at5146.05 that.5146.13
5146.44 The5146.44 Racial5146.6 Abounds5146.93 Act5147.32 of5147.56 19655147.72 was5148.93 desegregated.5149.16 The5149.89 Boston5150.05 Public5150.36 Schools5150.68 was5152.14 passed5152.38 to5152.7 prevent5152.86 inequities5153.18 in5153.74 funding5153.9 at5154.62 the5154.78 school5154.86 site5155.18 level5155.34 and,5156.14 at5157.42 the5157.5 district5157.58 level5157.98 with5158.46 Chapter5158.7 705159.02 reform,5159.42 really5160.94 pushed5161.26 to,5161.9 also,5162.46 prevent5163.34 inequities5163.74 and5164.3 really5164.46 drive5164.7 down5165.02 inequities.5165.26 Given5166.7 what5167.02 BPS5167.19 is,5167.66 should5168.31 we5168.55 be5168.7 looking5168.86 at5169.19 and5169.51 then5169.74 obviously5169.82 special5170.55 ed5170.86 transportation,5171.19 out5172.39 of5172.47 district5172.63 transportation,5173.02 Chapter5174.86 766,5175.51 approved5175.51 private5175.74 schools5176.06 if5176.39 the5176.55 school5176.7 can't5176.95 serve5177.19 school5177.66 districts5177.91 can't5178.33 serve5178.41 them5178.73 within5179.21 their5179.53 own5179.77 schools,5179.93 METCO5180.41 Charter5180.81 Schools5181.13 understand5181.85 that5182.17 that5182.33 really5182.49 can't5182.73 budge.5182.89 But5183.69 does5183.85 it5184.09 make5184.25 sense5184.41 that5184.81 what5186.57 we're5186.89 already5187.13 seeing5187.45 is,5187.69 you5188.01 know,5188.17 some5188.41 limitations5188.73 coming5189.29 in5189.61 from5189.93 the5190.17 federal5190.33 government5190.65 on5190.97 school5191.21 funding?5191.45 Well,5192.69 we5193.02 were5193.34 currently5193.65 transporting5194.14 people,5194.77 young5195.9 people5196.14 who5196.38 aren't5196.53 wearing5196.77 seat5197.02 belts,5197.18 which5198.14 is5198.3 a5198.61 law5198.69 for5199.02 people5199.26 18,5199.57 but5200.14 on5200.3 schools5200.45 school5200.85 buses,5201.18 they're5201.73 being5201.9 transported5202.14 across5202.69 the5203.02 city5203.18 without5203.73 seat5204.74 belts5204.98 in5205.46 traffi.5206.26
5206.66 Sometimes5206.66 for5206.66 hours5206.9 on5207.46 both5208.42 ends5208.66 of5208.9 the5208.98 school5209.06 day,5209.3 usually5210.26 late,5210.66 you5211.06 know,5211.22 sometimes5211.54 not5212.02 at5212.26 all.5212.34 But5212.82 spending5213.06 a5213.86 hundred5213.94 and5214.26 $1895214.34 million5215.94 with5215.94 the5216.1 diversity5216.26 of5217.38 the5217.62 school5217.78 district5218.02 now5218.34 and5219.41 the5220.53 transparency5220.77 that5221.57 we5221.73 have5221.9 in5222.14 spending5222.3 and5223.26 the5223.41 balance5223.57 of5223.97 the5224.14 school5224.3 committee,5224.45 you5225.65 know,5225.9 it5226.14 seems5226.22 that,5226.38 you5226.61 know,5226.69 it5227.01 could5227.18 be5227.34 a5227.49 budget5227.57 buster.5227.81 I5228.45 can't5228.69 speak5228.93 for5229.09 any5229.26 other5229.41 part5229.65 of5229.81 the5229.97 state,5230.05 but5230.61 old5231.81 policies,5232.14 outdated,5233.09 don't5234.87 seem5235.11 to5235.35 meet5235.43 the5235.75 needs5235.83 of5236.07 the5236.15 time.5236.23 And5236.55 while5236.71 we're5236.87 always,5237.11 you5237.75 know,5237.91 trying5238.15 to5238.39 figure5238.71 out5238.95 how5239.11 things5239.35 are5239.59 impacting5239.67 our5240.07 climate,5240.23 we're5241.19 seeing5241.43 these5241.75 buses5241.99 idling5242.55 and5242.95 running5243.03 through5243.35 towns5243.59 that5244.23 are,5244.39 you5244.71 know,5244.79 emitting,5245.43 you5245.99 know,5246.07 toxic5246.31 fossil5248.38 fuels5248.85 through5249.18 environmental5249.57 justice5250.22 communities5250.53 on5251.02 top5251.18 of5251.34 it.5251.41 So5251.9 just5252.22 wanted5252.38 to5252.61 get5252.7 your5252.85 thoughts5253.02 on5253.26 is5253.41 this5253.57 a5253.73 moment5253.81 to5254.14 take5254.3 a5254.45 look5254.53 at5254.7 reform?5254.94 How5255.73 are5255.98 we5256.61 transporting5256.61 people5257.34 across5257.66 school5257.98 districts?5258.22 And5258.61 in5258.85 the5258.94 case5259.1 of5259.26 Boston,5259.41 a5260.18 hundred5260.34 and5260.5 $1895260.74 million5262.18 for5262.18 that.5262.34
5263.54 TUTWILER5263.54 -5263.54 Yeah.5263.54 Thank5267.22 you5267.46 for5267.54 the5267.78 question,5267.86 first5268.34 of5268.58 all.5268.66 I5270.18 want5270.98 to5270.98 be5270.98 careful5270.98 not5270.98 to5270.98 get5270.98 into5270.98 the5270.98 specific5271.06 transportation5272.5 challenges5273.46 of5273.94 one5274.1 district,5274.34 because5274.9 I'm5275.93 not5276.16 sort5276.4 of5276.65 deeply5276.81 knowledgeable5277.77 around5278.4 all5279.52 the5279.69 aspects5279.85 related5280.65 to5280.97 it.5281.13 I5281.28 will5281.44 say,5281.69 the5282.48 tie5282.65 that5282.89 binds5283.05 no5283.44 matter5283.6 what5283.93 superintendent5284.16 I5284.89 speak5285.05 to5285.36 is5285.77 around5286.01 the,5286.89 the5287.52 challenges5287.69 around5288.24 the5288.65 the5288.89 increased5289.05 cost5289.44 of5289.69 transportation,5289.85 which5291.5 is5291.58 why,5291.82 we5292.86 we've5293.1 taken5293.34 some5293.66 steps5293.82 in5294.22 this,5294.38 budget5294.86 proposal,5295.26 both5295.74 with5296.22 the5296.46 circuit5296.62 breaker5296.94 and5297.42 also,5297.58 with,5298.78 regional5299.5 transportation5300.06 to5300.94 provide5301.18 relief5301.66 to5302.46 some5302.62 districts.5302.94 And5303.5 so5303.66 I5303.9 think5304.14 my5304.38 response5304.62 to5305.02 your5305.18 question5305.34 is5305.81 to5306.05 acknowledge5306.69 the5307.16 pain5307.41 point5307.65 around5308.77 transportation,5308.93 but5310.2 then5310.45 also5310.6 to5310.93 point5311.09 out5311.24 that5311.41 there5311.56 are5311.81 features5311.97 in5312.28 this5312.52 budget5312.69 that5313.09 are5313.65 designed5313.89 to5314.13 provide5314.28 districts5314.69 some5315.09 relief.5315.32
5316.13 COLLINS5316.13 -5316.13 Thank5316.13 you.5316.28 And,5316.45 again,5316.6 it's5317.01 78%5317.32 of5318.2 the5318.36 Chapter5318.45 905318.85 funds5319.24 we're5320.64 talking5320.8 about5321.2 with5321.44 respect5321.6 to5322 the5322.32 spending5322.56 on5322.96 transportation5323.12 and5323.68 12%5323.76 of5324.24 the5324.32 overall5324.48 budget.5324.72 I5324.96 don't5325.12 know5325.28 if5325.36 that's5325.44 standard,5325.68 but5326.08 it5326.48 seems5326.48 to5326.72 be5326.88 excessive.5327.04
5329.52 TUTWILER5329.52 -5329.52 Appreciate5329.52 it.5330.16
5330.32 COLLINS5330.32 -5330.32 Thank5330.32 you.5330.56
5331.6 MICHLEWITZ5331.6 -5331.6 Representative5331.6 Marsy.5332.16
5333.55 REP5333.55 MARSI5333.55 -5333.55 Thank5333.55 you,5333.78 mister5333.94 chairman.5334.26 Hi,5334.66 everybody.5334.9 Good5335.22 to5335.39 see5335.47 you5335.63 again.5335.78 It's5336.1 been5336.26 five5337.15 minutes5337.39 at5337.7 least.5337.86 So5338.98 one5339.22 of5339.39 the5339.47 things5339.55 I5339.78 brought5339.94 up5340.18 in5340.26 our5340.51 first5340.66 meeting,5340.82 in5342.02 this5342.18 auditorium5342.59 to5343.47 kick5343.55 off5343.78 the5343.94 budget5344.1 season5344.51 was,5344.98 the5346.43 use5346.59 of5346.82 one5347.46 time5347.62 sources5348.1 of5348.42 revenue,5348.58 you5349.06 know,5349.14 for5349.3 planning5349.54 purposes.5349.86 And,5350.58 just,5351.22 you5353.22 know,5353.3 there's5353.62 a5353.94 really5354.02 good5354.34 chance5354.58 that5354.98 going5355.46 forward5355.7 over5356.1 the5356.26 In5356.34 the5356.34 next5356.34 couple5356.5 of5356.7 years,5356.9 the5357.7 pool5358.18 available5358.5 for5359.06 funds5359.22 like5359.62 this5359.78 might5360.95 decrease.5361.27 And,5362.64 you5363.03 know,5363.19 not5364.15 to5364.31 belabor5364.48 the5364.88 point,5364.95 but5365.11 125365.35 years5365.68 on5365.99 a,5366.23 on5366.31 a5366.48 municipal5366.72 board5367.27 knowing5367.76 that,5367.99 you5368.64 know,5368.8 putting5369.19 money5370.4 like5370.64 that5370.88 into5371.03 operational5371.35 things,5372.07 you5372.53 know,5372.61 can5372.77 create5373.33 holes5373.57 later5373.89 on.5374.29
5374.85 So5374.85 I'm5375.17 concerned5375.33 about5375.81 that.5376.69 So5378.05 but,5378.29 you5378.45 know,5378.53 knowing5378.77 these5379.09 things5379.49 are5379.65 very5379.81 important.5379.97 We5380.45 have5380.61 the5380.77 money.5380.93 We're5381.17 going5381.97 to5382.37 invest5382.37 in5382.61 them.5383.09 How5383.09 do5383.33 we5383.65 not5384.45 rely5384.69 on5385.09 this5385.25 going5385.73 forward5386.05 for5386.45 those5386.61 operational5386.93 things5387.49 and5387.73 use5388.26 it5388.41 for,5389.22 you5389.53 know,5389.7 improvements5390.18 in5390.74 one5390.9 time5391.06 things5391.3 like5391.61 small5392.18 town5392.49 bridges.5392.74 I'll5393.06 just5393.3 you5393.61 know,5393.7 one5393.85 of5394.02 the5394.1 things5394.26 I5394.49 wanted5394.81 to5395.22 make5395.3 sure5395.45 that5395.61 we,5395.85 you5396.57 know,5396.74 I5396.9 have5396.98 one5397.22 of5397.38 those5397.45 in5397.7 my5397.85 house5398.18 really5398.18 close5398.41 to5398.74 my5398.81 house5398.98 by5399.3 just5400.57 saying.5400.81 And,5401.67 and,5403.51 yep.5404.31 We5404.71 just5404.87 don't5405.35 want5405.51 to5405.59 fall5405.67 into5405.91 that5406.15 trap.5406.31 So5406.71 how5407.03 do5407.11 we5407.19 plan5407.83 long5408.23 term?5408.39
5409.91 GORZKOWICZ5409.91 -5409.91 Well,5409.91 thank5410.47 you5410.63 for5410.79 the5410.95 question,5411.11 and5411.51 I5411.83 appreciate5411.99 your5412.55 your5412.79 focus5413.03 on5413.43 certainly5414.14 the5414.45 use5414.53 of5414.7 one5414.85 timers5415.1 and5415.41 the5415.66 one5415.74 time5415.81 nature5416.06 of5416.38 some5416.45 of5416.53 the5416.61 funds5417.34 available,5417.74 and5419.02 being5419.18 used5419.41 through5419.66 this5419.9 FareShare5420.45 sup.5420.7 It's5421.41 important5421.57 and5421.9 it's5422.06 something5422.22 that5422.45 we've5422.61 been5422.85 thinking5423.02 about5423.34 a5423.57 lot.5423.74 I5424.14 think5424.22 when5424.38 you5424.53 look5424.7 and5424.94 break5425.18 down5425.41 the5425.57 $1.35425.74 billion5426.45 that5426.45 we're5426.61 proposing5426.78 here,5427.26 the5427.68 vast5427.84 majority5428.08 of5428.32 that5428.56 is5428.8 being5428.96 used,5429.28 as5430 a5430.4 one5432.08 time5432.24 resource.5432.56 There5433.28 are5433.52 a5433.68 couple5433.76 of5434 things5434.16 that5434.56 we're5434.8 proposing5435.12 to5435.52 use5435.68 and5435.92 we're5436.16 thinking5436.32 about5436.64 it5436.8 over5436.96 a5437.2 multi5437.28 year5437.68 strategy.5437.69 So5437.7 the5437.71 funds5437.72 that5437.73 have5437.74 been5437.75 made5437.75 available5437.76 are5437.77 available5437.78 over5437.79 a5437.8 couple5437.8 of5437.81 fiscal5437.82 years.5437.83 So5437.84 we're5437.85 taking5437.86 sort5437.87 of5437.88 a5437.89 multi5437.9 year5437.91 strategy.5437.92 So5438.4 available5440.66 over5441.7 a5442.18 couple5442.34 of5442.49 fiscal5442.66 years.5442.82
5443.14 So5443.14 we're5443.16 taking5443.19 sort5443.21 of5443.24 a5443.41 multi-year5443.78 approach5444.18 to5444.57 that,5444.74 with5445.45 the5445.84 idea5446.22 that5446.6 it5447.06 would5447.22 not5447.61 be5447.61 expanded5448.26 this5448.41 year.5448.57 It5448.82 is5448.98 somewhat5449.3 operational5449.78 in5450.34 nature,5450.41 but5450.66 trying5450.9 to5451.06 gather5451.22 ourselves5451.45 for5451.78 a5451.78 couple5451.86 of5452.1 years.5452.18 The5452.76 one5452.84 thing5453 I5453.16 would5453.4 remind5453.64 folks,5453.96 as5454.36 I5454.52 mentioned5454.6 in5454.84 my5455 testimony,5455.16 you5455.48 know,5455.8 we,5456.08 working5456.76 with5457.08 the5457.64 chairs5457.72 of5458.04 this5458.12 committee,5458.28 agreed5459.24 to5459.48 only5459.64 spend5459.88 a5460.12 billion5460.2 dollars5460.52 in5460.76 FY5460.92 24.5461.16 So5461.56 we5461.72 knew5461.88 and5462.12 put5462.28 ourselves5462.44 in5462.76 a5462.92 position5463 where5463.32 we5463.48 knew5463.64 we5463.8 would5463.88 have5464.04 this5464.2 resource5464.44 available5464.84 to5465.24 us.5465.39 We5465.55 didn't5465.55 know5465.7 exactly5465.78 how5466.1 much,5466.26 but5466.43 we5466.59 knew5466.66 we5466.82 would5466.98 have5467.06 something5467.22 and5467.47 it5467.63 certainly5467.7 performed5468.26 better5468.66 than5468.9 we5469.06 thought.5469.14 As5469.7 we5469.86 start5470.02 looking5470.26 at5470.51 fiscal5470.66 year5470.98 25,5471.14 our5471.63 second5471.78 year5472.1 of5472.43 Certax,5473.14 we5473.55 have5473.7 only5473.86 budgeted5474.02 a5474.43 billion,5474.51 meaning5474.9 we've5475.14 only5475.39 increased5475.55 it5475.86 by5475.94 $3005476.1 million5476.82 year5476.82 over5477.06 year.5477.3
5478.2 And5478.2 right5478.68 now,5478.92 based5479.32 on5479.64 revenue5479.96 performance,5480.36 we5480.84 expect5481.08 that5481.48 our5482.44 estimate5482.6 for5483 this5483.16 year5483.32 is5483.48 about5483.56 $2.55483.8 billion5484.92 again.5484.92 So5485.48 we5485.64 know5485.8 that5486.04 we'll5486.2 be5486.44 back5486.6 here5486.84 next5487.08 year5487.24 having5487.48 a5487.72 conversation5487.8 with5488.28 you5488.44 about5488.52 it.5488.76 So5488.84 there's5489 an5489.24 opportunity5489.4 for5489.96 us5490.12 to5490.28 think5490.36 about5490.6 this5490.84 over5491.24 multiple5491.48 years5491.88 so5492.2 far.5492.44 We5492.68 know5492.84 that5493.08 much.5493.4 And5493.81 then5494.13 I5494.28 think5494.36 our5494.6 consensus5494.85 revenue5495.24 number5495.48 for5495.73 FY5495.97 '26,5496.2 again,5496.85 that5497.24 we've5497.48 developed5497.73 working5498.13 with5498.44 economists5498.6 and5499.24 other5499.65 folks,5499.81 relies5501.32 on5501.73 another5501.89 2.5.5502.28 So5502.77 we5502.93 haven't5503.09 necessarily5503.4 grown5504.05 that5504.36 revenue5504.69 source5505.09 by5505.4 a5505.56 lot,5505.65 but5506.76 we've5506.92 continued5507.16 to5507.72 be5508.04 measured5508.28 in5508.6 terms5508.76 of5509 how5509.08 much5509.24 we're5509.4 building5509.64 into5509.88 the5510.04 budget,5510.2 leaving5510.76 what5511.72 we5511.96 know5512.04 will5512.36 be5512.52 surplus5512.84 funds5513.32 at5513.64 the5513.8 end5513.88 of5514.04 the5514.12 year.5514.28 I5515.32 do5515.48 think5515.64 that5515.88 there's5516.04 a5516.36 point5516.52 where5516.76 we'll5516.92 get5517.16 to,5517.4 you5518.28 know,5518.44 a5518.84 point5519 where5519.24 we'll5519.48 we'll5519.72 we'll5520.04 have5520.28 to5520.52 decide5520.68 if5520.92 we've5521.16 where5521.69 we5521.85 stop5522.01 in5522.4 terms5522.56 of,5522.81 maxing5523.6 out5523.93 our5524.16 capacity5524.32 within5524.81 the5524.97 operating5525.13 budget,5525.52 knowing5526.01 that5526.32 anything5526.65 that's5527.05 over5527.28 a5527.6 certain5527.85 threshold5528.09 will5528.48 be5528.65 available5528.81 through5529.52 mechanisms5529.77 like5530.32 that.5530.4
5530.65 And5530.65 that's5530.81 a5530.97 conversation5531.05 we'll5531.6 have5531.77 with5532.24 the5532.4 chairs5532.56 in5532.97 terms5533.13 of5533.44 as5533.77 we5533.93 think5534.09 about5534.32 future5534.65 fiscal5534.97 years5535.28 and5535.52 what's5536.23 appropriate.5536.55 But5536.95 to5537.51 your5537.67 point,5537.91 you5538.31 know,5538.39 the5538.55 vast5538.71 majority5538.95 of5539.43 the5539.59 stuff5539.67 that5539.91 we've5540.07 programmed5540.31 in,5540.63 particularly5540.79 around5541.27 transportation5541.51 and5541.99 some5542.23 of5542.31 the5542.39 one5542.55 time5542.71 costs5542.95 are5543.19 truly5543.27 one5543.59 time,5543.75 meaning5543.99 that,5544.47 those5545.03 expenses5545.27 will5545.91 not5546.07 need5546.31 to5546.47 be5546.55 reoccurring.5546.71 Some5547.43 of5547.67 the5547.75 things5547.83 that5548.07 we5548.31 have5548.47 done5548.71 are5549.11 multi-year.5549.83 I5550.16 think5550.24 the5550.4 one5550.48 area5550.64 where5550.95 we5551.11 do5551.2 have5551.35 some5551.52 operational5551.76 costs5552.24 are,5552.72 are5553.52 sped5553.68 and5554.07 that's5554.32 in5554.56 recognition5554.72 to5555.28 some5555.44 of5555.68 the5555.76 extraordinary5555.99 challenges5556.56 that5556.95 we've5557.11 noted,5557.35 experienced5557.99 this5558.64 year,5558.8 particularly5559.11 with,5559.68 with5560.72 the5560.72 cost5560.73 and5560.74 recognizing5560.75 that5560.76 because5560.76 of5560.77 transportation5560.78 being5560.79 a5560.8 significant,5561.03 transportation5563.72 being5564.22 a5564.72 significant,5565.22 contributor5566.12 to5566.68 that5567 cost5567.08 that5567.24 we5567.32 wanted5567.4 to5568.12 get,5568.2 districts5568.6 to5568.88 75%.5569.16 We5569.96 felt5570 that5570.04 that5570.28 was5570.44 important5570.6 to5570.92 do5571 in5571.4 this5571.48 environment.5571.64 And5572.12 so5572.28 I5572.48 think5572.68 that's5572.92 the5573.16 one5573.32 area5573.48 that5573.72 as5573.88 we5574.04 go5574.2 forward,5574.28 we're5574.6 going5574.68 to5574.92 need5575 to5575.08 find5575.49 the5575.73 operating5575.81 capacity5576.45 to5576.85 deal5577.02 with5577.18 that.5577.26
5577.34 But5577.34 for5577.49 the5577.65 most5577.81 part,5577.98 we've5578.14 tried5578.38 to5578.61 be5578.77 measured5578.94 about5579.41 how5579.65 we5579.81 think5579.9 about5580.14 this5580.3 knowing5580.53 that5580.85 we5581.34 have5581.49 some5581.65 dry5581.81 powder5582.06 in5582.45 a5582.61 sense,5582.69 again5583.34 next5583.73 year5583.98 and5584.3 perhaps5584.53 the5584.85 year5585.02 after.5585.26 So,5585.49 I5586.22 don't5586.3 know5586.53 that5586.61 I'm5586.85 willing5587.02 to5587.26 sort5587.81 of5587.98 make5588.22 any5588.45 forecasts5589.26 or5590.19 predictions5590.43 about5590.83 beyond,5591.23 2026.5592.27 But,5594.03 you5594.55 know,5594.75 certainly5594.99 we've5595.31 been5595.55 thinking5595.71 about5595.95 that.5596.11 And5596.27 some5596.51 of5596.67 the5596.83 other5596.99 resources5597.47 that5597.87 we've5598.03 programmed5598.27 to5598.67 this5598.75 up5598.91 also,5599.15 utilize5600.11 early5601.87 education5602.11 trust5602.75 fund,5602.99 which5603.23 you've,5603.47 set5604.56 up,5604.65 I5605.44 think5605.6 very5605.77 thoughtfully5606.01 and5607.36 and5607.41 and5607.44 very5607.52 wisely5607.77 in5608.32 prior5608.73 fiscal5609.05 years5609.28 has5609.52 been5609.69 one5609.85 that5610.16 we5610.32 use5610.48 some5610.65 of5610.81 these5610.89 one5611.05 time5611.28 funds5611.52 to5611.77 populate5611.93 to5612.41 allow5612.56 us5612.89 to5613.05 deal5613.2 with5613.36 some5613.44 extraordinary5613.69 costs5614.24 down5614.48 the5614.65 road.5614.73 So5614.89 we're5615.05 setting5615.28 ourselves5615.52 up5616.01 to5616.32 be5616.48 able5616.56 to5616.81 mitigate,5617.28 I5617.77 think,5617.85 where5618.09 we5618.65 have5618.81 some5618.97 pressures5619.35 down5619.67 the5619.71 road.5619.75 So5619.91 it's5620.55 an5620.95 important5621.03 question.5621.43 It's5621.75 one5621.91 that5622.15 we've5622.31 continued5622.63 to5623.19 think5623.27 about.5623.51 And5623.83 for5624.15 each5624.39 item5624.55 in5625.03 that5625.19 sup,5625.35 we've5625.75 thought5626.15 about5626.39 sort5626.87 of5627.03 what5627.11 the5627.27 future5627.35 impact5627.67 is5627.99 and,5628.15 and5629.43 we'll5629.59 continue5629.75 to5630.15 monitor5630.31 that5630.63 going5630.79 forward.5631.77
5631.77 MARSI5631.77 -5631.77 No.5632.41 I5632.56 appreciate5632.73 that.5633.2 That5633.45 makes5633.85 a5634.01 lot5634.16 of5634.24 sense.5634.32 Multi5634.65 year5634.97 strategy5635.28 is5635.69 important,5635.85 and5636.24 I'm5636.49 happy5637.13 that5637.45 we5637.6 have5637.77 that.5637.93 It's5638.49 just5638.73 so5638.89 easy5639.05 to5639.36 get5639.45 addicted5639.6 to5640.56 things5640.65 like5640.97 this,5641.13 and5641.36 every5641.69 year5641.93 is5642.16 going5642.81 to5643.13 go5643.13 by5643.28 quickly,5643.45 and5643.8 there's5643.88 always5644.12 going5644.2 to5644.52 be5644.52 something5644.68 we5645 want5645.24 and5645.4 need.5645.56 You5646.2 know,5646.28 there's5646.44 a5646.76 long,5647.08 long,5647.48 long5647.72 list,5647.96 you5648.28 know.5648.44 So5648.68 I5648.84 just5649 want5650.36 everybody5650.6 to5651 remember5651.24 that.5651.56 So5652.04 I5652.28 appreciate5652.44 you5652.92 guys.5653 Thank5653.24 you.5653.4
5653.88 GORZKOWICZ5653.88 -5653.88 Thank5653.88 you5654.04 for5654.2 the5654.44 question.5654.52
5655.96 MICHLEWITZ5655.96 -5655.96 Senator5655.96 Dooner.5656.44
5659.53 SEN5659.53 DOONER5659.53 -5659.53 Thank5659.53 you,5659.7 mister5659.85 chair.5660.34 Secretary5661.85 Tutwiler5663.53 we5663.85 meet5664.02 again.5664.26 Just5666.02 want5666.34 to5666.66 say5666.66 I5666.98 appreciate5667.14 seeing5668.66 the5668.98 755669.38 million5670.34 towards5670.34 expanding5670.66 tech5671.22 schools.5671.45 I5671.85 know5671.94 we5672.18 had5672.34 a5672.57 conversation5672.66 on,5673.48 you5673.72 know,5673.8 the5674.04 need5674.28 to5674.44 be5674.52 more5674.76 forward5675.08 thinking5675.4 for5675.88 our5676.12 tech5676.28 schools,5676.6 in5678.28 order5678.52 to5678.84 expand,5679.08 to5679.48 create5679.72 more5680.12 opportunities5680.52 for5681.24 students.5681.48 So5682.36 I5682.68 do5682.76 wish5682.92 it5683.16 was5683.32 more,5683.56 but5683.88 I5684.04 understand5684.2 you5684.68 have5684.84 to5685 work5685.24 within5685.48 the5685.8 means5685.96 that5686.28 you5686.44 have.5686.6 I5688.41 heard5688.65 you5688.81 say5689.05 focusing5689.45 on5690.18 gateway5690.81 communities,5691.53 and5692.34 then5692.49 I5692.65 read5692.81 a5692.97 little5693.14 bit5693.38 about5693.53 rural.5693.85 Is5694.18 there5694.41 any5694.57 focus5694.81 on5695.22 regional5695.85 school5696.41 districts5696.81 and5697.3 helping5697.69 them?5698.02
5700.21 TUTWILER5700.21 -5700.21 Yes.5700.21 First,5703.01 I5703.33 should5703.49 name5703.73 the5705.25 proposal5705.49 in5706.05 this5706.21 budget,5706.45 that,5707.73 you5708.53 know,5708.69 sort5708.85 of5709.09 supports5709.33 the5709.81 notable5710.29 increase5710.77 in5711.33 circuit5711.49 breaker5711.97 impacts5712.85 in5713.61 almost5713.61 every5714.01 district,5714.32 in5715.05 the5715.2 state5715.36 of5715.61 Massachusetts,5715.69 regardless5716.81 of5718.49 where5718.81 it5718.97 is.5719.13 The5720.09 other5720.24 thing5720.41 that5720.57 I5720.73 would5721.69 lift5721.85 up5722.16 as5722.32 I5722.49 did5722.81 before5723.05 is5723.45 the5723.61 notable5723.77 increase5724.16 in5724.73 regional5725.05 transportation5725.61 reimbursement.5726.41 That5728.38 is5729.66 not5729.9 in5730.14 this5731.02 particular5733.02 proposal,5733.02 but5733.5 lives5734.3 in5734.54 another5734.7 place5735.02 in5735.26 our5735.42 budget.5736.14 The5737.42 proposal5737.66 brings5738.14 us5738.46 to5738.62 a5738.7 95%,5738.86 reimbursement5740.14 up5740.78 from5740.94 85,5741.18 which5741.99 will5742.23 have5742.31 significant,5742.48 impact5743.59 on5744.4 the,5744.56 nearly5745.52 40%5745.84 of5746.72 rural5746.95 districts5747.27 that,5747.76 engage5748.56 in5748.88 in5749.03 regional5749.19 transportation5749.68 and5750.23 any5750.4 other5750.64 district5751.84 that5752.23 falls5753.35 in5753.68 that5753.84 category5753.99 of5754.48 regional.5754.64 So5755.03 I5755.19 would5755.27 say,5755.52 yes,5755.99 indeed.5756.23
5757.27 DOONER5757.27 -5757.27 Alright.5757.27
5759.81 MICHLEWITZ5759.81 -5759.81 Thank5759.81 you.5760.05 My5760.29 pleasure.5760.53 Not5760.77 seeing5761.01 any5761.25 other5761.41 questions5761.65 from5761.97 members5762.21 of5762.45 the5762.53 committee5762.61 unless5762.93 I'm5763.17 missing5763.33 anybody.5763.57 Secretaries,5766.85 thank5767.49 you5767.65 for,5767.89 for5768.37 being5769.09 here5769.33 and5769.57 for5769.65 testifying5769.89 for5770.45 your,5770.61 and,5771.15 for5771.55 your5771.86 patience5772.1 and,5772.59 and5773.06 answering5773.22 all5773.55 the5773.7 questions.5773.78 We5774.1 appreciate5774.26 you5774.59 being5774.74 here5774.9 today,5775.06 and5775.3 I5775.47 look5775.63 forward5775.78 to5776.1 working5776.18 with5776.43 you,5776.59 going5777.39 forward5777.7 in5777.94 the5778.1 future.5778.26 Thank5778.59 you.5778.82 Our5782.59 next5782.82 panel5783.06 panelist5784.16 is5784.72 Jessica5785.04 Tang5785.36 from5785.68 the5785.92 American5786.16 Federation5786.56 of5786.96 Teachers5787.12 of5787.6 Massachusetts.5787.76 Before5789.52 Jessica5789.92 comes5790.24 up,5790.48 I5790.64 just5790.8 want5790.96 to5791.2 recognize5791.2 that5791.6 we5791.84 also5791.92 have5791.92 two5792.08 senators5792.24 that5792.56 join5792.72 us.5792.96 Senator5793.04 Fattman,5793.44 and5794.08 Senator5794.72 Kennedy5795.12 are5796.08 as5796.48 well.5796.64 So5796.89 thank5797.05 you5797.28 both5797.36 for5797.6 being5811.6 here.5811.85 Alright.5835.64 We're5836.03 going5836.2 to5836.44 keep5836.44 going.5836.68 Jessica5838.76 Tang5839.24 from5839.4 the5839.64 American5839.72 Federation5840.21 of5840.45 Teachers,5840.53 Massachusetts.5841.33 The5841.81 floor5841.89 is5842.13 yours.5842.21
5843.33 JESSICA5843.33 TANG5843.33 -5843.33 AFT5843.33 MASSACHUSETTS5843.33 -5843.33 HB5843.33 555843.33 -5843.33 Thank5843.33 you5843.57 and5843.73 good5843.97 afternoon.5844.13 My5845.25 name5845.41 is5845.49 Jessica5845.65 Tang5846.05 and5846.29 I5846.45 am5846.53 a5846.69 mom.5846.85 I5847.17 am5847.33 a5847.57 middle5847.73 school5847.97 teacher5848.21 and5848.93 currently5849.57 serving5849.97 as5850.29 the5850.45 president5850.53 of5850.93 the5851.01 American5851.17 Federation5851.57 of5851.89 Teachers5852.05 Massachusetts.5852.37 Greatly5853.74 appreciate5854.38 the5854.7 opportunity5854.85 to5855.34 be5855.41 here5855.57 and5855.81 testify5855.98 today5856.38 on5856.7 behalf5856.85 of5857.18 the5857.34 25,0005857.41 AFT5858.3 Massachusetts5858.7 educators5859.26 and5860.06 staff5860.3 working5860.61 in5860.94 our5861.1 public5861.26 schools,5861.49 our5861.9 universities,5862.14 libraries,5862.85 health5863.41 offices,5863.66 and5864.14 the5864.38 tens5864.45 of5864.7 thousands5864.85 of5865.18 families5865.34 that5865.74 they5865.9 serve.5866.14 AFT5867.38 Massachusetts5867.86 is5868.58 also5868.66 a5868.98 proud5869.14 member5869.46 of5869.86 the5869.94 Raise5870.18 Up5870.5 Massachusetts5870.82 Coalition5871.54 with5872.1 whom5872.26 we've5872.5 spent5872.74 the5873.06 past5873.14 decade5873.38 working5873.78 on5874.1 critical5874.26 issues5874.66 like5875.06 raising5875.3 the5875.62 minimum5875.7 wage,5876.1 establishing5876.5 earned5877.06 sick5877.38 and5877.54 paid5877.7 family5877.94 medical5878.26 leave,5878.66 and5879.28 passing5879.52 the5879.69 FareShare5880.16 Amendment,5880.48 the5881.2 source5881.36 of5881.69 revenue5881.77 we5882.09 are5882.24 here5882.48 today5882.65 to5883.05 discuss.5883.2
5884.24 And5884.24 we5884.41 believe5884.56 that5884.81 the5884.97 investments5885.13 in5885.6 transportation5885.85 and5886.48 education5886.65 that5887.13 the5887.2 FareShare5887.69 Amendment5887.85 has5888.24 enabled5888.48 has5888.97 been5889.13 life5889.36 changing5889.69 for5890.09 so5890.32 many5890.48 and5890.89 could5891.05 not5891.2 have5891.45 come5891.6 at5891.77 a5891.93 better5892.09 time5892.32 as5892.56 we5892.73 confront5892.89 challenges5893.36 that5894.73 we've5894.89 never5895.45 seen5895.69 before.5896.33 So5897.61 education5898.01 funding5898.41 in5898.73 Massachusetts5898.89 is5899.53 tutoring5899.77 at5900.09 the5900.25 edge5900.33 of5900.57 a5900.65 fiscal5900.81 cliff,5901.13 and5901.61 this5901.85 was5902.01 the5902.25 case5902.33 before5902.81 the5903.21 executive5903.45 order5903.93 was5904.33 signed5904.57 to5904.81 dismantle5904.97 the5905.45 Department5905.53 of5905.93 Education5906.01 and5906.49 before5906.73 the5907.45 recent5907.61 $1065908.51 million5908.66 cut5909.63 in5909.86 active5910.1 grants,5910.34 which5910.82 was5911.06 rescinded5911.39 last5911.94 Friday.5912.26 And5913.22 in5913.39 this5913.55 context,5913.86 public5914.34 education,5914.66 like5915.15 every5915.39 other5915.63 system,5915.86 must5916.26 adapt5916.51 to5916.82 the5916.98 current5917.06 reality5917.3 to5917.78 serve5917.86 those5918.18 who5918.43 rely5918.59 on5918.9 us.5919.06 And5919.94 for5920.18 our5920.34 schools,5920.51 that5920.9 means5921.06 meeting5921.3 the5921.55 shifting5921.7 needs5922.02 of5922.18 our5922.34 students5922.43 and5922.82 preventing5922.98 further5923.39 harm.5923.78 And5924.58 today,5924.82 we5925.06 are5925.3 still5925.38 trying5925.7 to5925.94 make5926.02 up5926.26 for5926.42 ground5926.58 loss5926.9 during5927.14 the5927.38 COVID5927.46 195927.78 pandemic,5928.1 while5928.98 the5929.22 number5929.38 of5929.86 students5930.18 needing5930.66 services5931.06 and5931.46 support,5931.62 especially5932.34 mental5932.98 health,5933.46 continues5933.78 to5934.26 grow.5934.34
5935.38 And5935.38 the5935.54 cost5935.7 for5936.02 many5936.18 school5936.42 districts5936.74 to5937.45 ensure5937.69 every5938.1 child5938.41 has5938.73 a5938.98 free5939.06 and5939.3 equal5939.38 public5939.69 education5939.94 outpaces5940.73 the5941.45 investment5941.61 and5942.02 reimbursement5942.18 they5942.9 receive5943.06 from5943.38 the5943.53 state.5943.69 And5944.49 this5944.73 has5944.9 been5945.06 a5945.3 reality5945.45 for5946.02 many5946.26 years.5946.49 And5947.14 since5947.3 January5947.61 20,5948.02 that5948.41 reality5948.65 has5949.06 become5949.3 a5949.61 nightmare.5949.77 Services,5951.33 protections,5951.97 and5952.37 investments5952.61 are5953.09 being5953.25 stripped5953.41 at5953.65 an5953.81 alarming5953.97 pace.5954.45 And5954.93 while5955.09 nearly5955.33 every5955.73 aspect5955.97 of5956.29 life5956.45 is5956.69 being5956.77 impacted5957.09 by5957.49 this,5957.65 the5957.97 administration's5958.13 attack5958.93 on5959.25 children5959.41 is5959.89 especially5960.05 appalling.5960.53 The5961.81 widespread5961.97 layoffs,5962.61 funding5963.01 cuts,5963.33 and5963.57 attempts5963.73 to5964.13 shift5964.21 services5964.37 to5964.77 departments5965.19 without5965.43 the5965.82 knowledge5965.9 of5966.22 structure5966.39 in5966.78 place5966.94 or5967.51 its5967.74 structure5967.98 in5968.3 place5968.47 to5968.7 implement5968.86 them5969.19 is5969.43 a5969.59 dangerous5969.74 game.5970.15 And5971.1 in5971.26 this5971.43 shell5971.66 game,5971.9 our5972.22 children5972.39 are5972.78 the5972.94 victims.5973.02 And5973.82 the5973.98 greatest5974.06 harm5974.55 will5974.78 fall5975.1 upon5975.34 our5975.59 most5975.74 vulnerable5975.98 students,5976.86 students5977.43 with5977.74 disabilities,5977.9 students5978.55 from5978.86 low5979.02 income5979.19 families,5979.51 English5980.51 and5980.83 multilingual5981.07 language5981.71 learners,5982.11 and5982.59 kids5982.75 from5982.99 rural5983.23 communities.5983.55
5985.23 Massachusetts,5985.23 long5986.51 heralded5986.75 as5987.39 a5987.55 beacon5987.63 for5987.95 public5988.19 education,5988.51 has5989.07 an5989.31 opportunity5989.47 to5990.19 continue5990.43 to5990.99 be5991.15 that5991.39 beacon5991.63 if5992.4 we5992.56 use5992.72 the5992.88 FareShare5993.35 funds5993.68 to5993.99 protect5994.07 our5994.4 children.5994.64 We5995.76 stand5995.99 to5996.23 lose5996.4 generations5996.64 of5997.03 students5997.19 who5997.52 will5997.6 no5997.76 longer5997.91 have5998.15 access5998.31 to5998.72 the5998.8 free5998.88 and5999.11 public5999.19 education5999.6 they5999.99 deserve,6000.23 and6000.72 that6000.95 is6001.19 not6001.52 hyperbole.6001.84 The6002.95 well-being6003.11 of6003.68 hundreds6003.84 of6004.15 thousands6004.23 of6004.56 Massachusetts6004.72 children6005.27 and6005.6 students6005.68 are6006.15 in6006.23 jeopardy.6006.4 We've6007.58 already6007.9 lost,6008.22 in6009.02 just6009.26 the6009.42 last6009.58 three6009.82 weeks,6010.06 $126010.86 million6011.5 in6011.5 federal6011.66 funding6011.98 to6012.3 provide6012.38 local6012.7 healthy6013.02 food6013.34 to6013.58 childcare6013.74 programs6014.14 and6014.54 schools6014.78 from6015.02 the6015.26 USDA.6015.34 Federal6016.54 grants6016.94 for6021.77 transportation6022.65 as6023.05 well6023.2 for6023.45 electric6023.6 buses.6024.01 And6024.41 then6024.65 most6024.81 recently6025.93 $1066026.81 million6026.81 in6026.81 cuts6026.97 previously6027.28 allocated6027.93 and6028.41 dispersed6028.65 grants6028.97 that6029.36 provided6029.53 tutoring6029.93 and6030.32 supports6030.41 to6030.81 address6030.89 pandemic6031.13 learning6031.53 loss,6031.85 mental6032.09 health6032.41 services,6032.65 high6033.38 quality6033.54 instructional6033.86 materials,6034.34 building6035.14 upgrades6035.46 to6035.86 improve6036.02 air6036.34 quality,6036.5 professional6036.98 development,6037.46 and6038.1 support6038.42 for6038.42 emergency6038.58 license6039.06 holders6039.38 that6039.78 are6039.94 addressing6040.26 teacher6040.82 shortages.6041.14
6043.62 The6043.62 Northeast6043.86 Regional6044.34 Head6044.74 Start6044.98 office6045.3 was6045.7 just6045.86 abruptly6046.1 closed.6046.58 We're6047.99 also6048.23 looking6048.56 at6048.8 potential6049.03 funding6049.99 losses6050.4 from6050.8 the6051.03 Department6051.19 of6051.44 Education6051.68 that6052.15 provide6052.31 funding6052.64 for6053.03 special6053.44 education6053.84 through6054.4 IDEA,6054.72 low6055.59 income6055.76 students6056.07 through6056.48 title6056.72 one,6057.03 career6057.68 tech6058.07 education,6058.64 early6059.68 intervention6059.91 for6060.56 babies6060.72 and6061.03 toddlers,6061.19 and6061.76 more.6061.99 However,6064.09 because6064.89 of6065.29 the6065.37 FareShare6065.77 amendment,6066.01 we6066.33 in6066.57 Massachusetts6066.73 have6067.45 the6067.69 ability6067.77 to6068.25 alleviate6068.41 some6069.05 of6069.21 the6069.29 harm6069.45 and6069.77 protect6069.93 our6070.33 most6070.49 vulnerable6070.73 students6071.13 and6071.69 continue6071.85 to6072.25 make6072.33 investments6072.49 in6073.13 our6073.37 future6073.53 by6074.41 providing6074.73 relief6075.13 now.6075.61 Again,6076.84 even6077.4 before6077.72 these6078.2 recent6078.44 cuts6078.76 were6079.07 made,6079.24 our6079.64 school6079.8 districts6080.11 were6080.52 struggling6080.68 with6081.07 the6081.24 fiscal6081.4 crisis6081.8 and6082.6 are6082.76 projecting6082.91 layoffs6083.48 without6083.95 intervention6084.44 from6084.99 the6085.16 state.6085.31 The6087.31 budgeting6087.56 process6088.03 for6088.52 the6088.68 next6088.84 school6089.07 year6089.31 is6089.56 already6089.8 well6090.35 underway.6090.68 With6092.57 H.55,6093.21 we're6093.53 here6093.77 to6093.93 share6094.09 how6094.49 best6094.73 we6095.05 believe6095.29 we6095.69 can6095.85 maximize6096.09 the6096.73 impacts6096.97 of6097.37 the6097.53 surplus6097.69 FareShare6098.33 revenue6098.57 from6098.89 past6099.13 years6099.37 that6099.85 has6100.01 not6100.17 been6100.33 spent6100.57 to6101.21 prevent6101.37 future6101.93 cuts6102.33 to6102.89 our6103.05 school6103.21 budgets.6103.53
6104.74 The6104.74 extra6104.9 1.326105.15 billion6106.34 for6106.34 education6106.59 and6106.98 transportation,6107.15 which6108.19 is6108.34 completely6108.51 separate6108.9 from6109.3 the6109.47 1.1856109.63 billion6110.9 FSA6110.9 funds6111.3 to6111.55 be6111.7 allocated6111.86 in6112.19 the6112.34 fiscal6112.43 year6112.74 266112.98 budget,6113.47 provide6114.02 an6114.43 opportunity6114.59 for6115.23 the6115.47 immediate6115.63 relief6116.02 that's6116.43 needed.6116.66 In6117.83 H.55,6118.47 we're6118.71 glad6118.87 to6119.19 see6119.27 proposals6119.51 including6120.07 1506121.03 million6122.07 more6122.07 for6122.31 special6122.47 education6122.79 circuit6123.27 breaker6123.67 to6124.31 help6124.39 defray6124.71 some6125.03 of6125.19 the6125.27 costs6125.43 incurred6125.67 this6125.99 school6126.15 year.6126.39 756127.11 million6127.99 for6127.99 capital6128.15 improvements6128.55 to6128.95 help6129.11 increase6129.35 capacity6129.67 at6130.15 our6130.31 career6130.47 state's6131.03 career6131.35 and6131.67 technical6131.75 schools.6132.23 256133.07 million6133.78 to6133.78 support6133.95 the6134.19 Commonwealth6134.35 Preschool6134.82 Partnership6135.31 Initiative,6135.7 which6136.27 we6136.51 hope6136.66 will6136.91 expand6137.07 more6137.55 universal6137.78 pre6138.27 K6138.51 in6138.74 our6138.91 public6139.07 schools.6139.47 With6140.66 additional6140.99 FareShare6141.63 revenue,6141.78 we6142.1 can6142.27 further6142.43 protect6142.74 public6143.15 education6143.47 in6143.95 regions6144.1 across6144.51 the6144.82 Commonwealth.6144.99 These6146.68 are6146.92 our6147.16 suggestions.6147.24 The6149.08 1066149.72 million6150.52 that6150.52 would6150.92 be6151.08 made6151.24 up6151.48 from6151.8 the6152.12 ESSER6152.36 funding6152.68 ripped6153.16 out6153.56 from6153.8 under6154.04 the6154.2 206154.36 school6154.68 districts6155 this6155.48 week6155.64 when6155.96 the6156.12 administration6156.28 reversed6156.92 course6157.32 and6157.56 ended6157.8 funds6158.12 that6158.52 were6159 already6159.32 being6159.8 used.6160.2
6161.99 Six6162.63 million6162.63 to6162.63 pay6162.78 for6162.95 the6163.1 teacher6163.19 preparedness6163.59 programs6164.23 in6164.55 Boston,6164.7 Holyoke,6165.1 and6165.43 Springfield,6165.59 another6166.39 group6166.7 of6166.95 funds6167.02 that6167.35 was6167.51 snatched6167.66 more6168.06 than6168.23 a6168.47 year6168.55 after6168.7 the6169.1 original6169.27 disbursement.6169.66 4656173.43 million6174.86 would6174.86 be6175.02 needed6175.1 to6175.35 address6175.59 the6176.39 upcoming6176.55 school6177.21 year's6177.45 inflation6177.85 glitch,6178.41 something6179.13 that6179.37 schools6179.61 have6179.85 come6180.09 to6180.25 expect6180.41 which6180.89 greatly6181.13 lessens6181.45 the6181.93 investments6182.09 of6182.65 the6182.81 Student6182.97 Opportunity6183.37 Act.6184.01 1206185.77 million6186.33 to6186.33 reimburse6186.49 school6186.89 districts6187.13 for6187.45 regional6187.69 transportation6188.09 cost6188.97 at6189.93 100%6190.17 and6190.81 nonregional6190.97 transportation6191.61 cost6192.33 at6192.89 25%.6193.05 Three6195.13 million6195.85 to6195.85 support6196.09 existing6196.48 and6196.97 new6197.13 community6197.36 schools6197.93 throughout6198.24 the6198.56 state.6198.73 A6199.36 nationally6199.6 recognized6200.09 strategy6200.48 to6200.97 promote6201.05 equity6201.28 in6201.69 our6201.85 schools6201.93 and6202.24 communities6202.32 by6202.89 organizing6203.05 the6203.52 resources6203.69 of6204.16 the6204.24 community6204.32 around6204.89 efforts6205.2 to6205.6 accelerate6205.69 academic6206.24 and6206.81 social6206.89 developments6207.28 for6207.81 students.6207.97 We've6208.77 already6209.09 seen6209.41 this6209.65 successfully6209.81 implemented6210.37 in6210.85 five6210.93 cities6211.17 across6211.57 the6211.89 state6211.97 and6212.45 believe6212.61 in6212.85 even6213.09 greater6213.33 investment6213.73 as6214.45 part6214.69 of6214.93 reimagining6215.01 high6215.65 schools6215.81 plan.6219.57
6220.05 Three6220.05 million6220.05 would6220.05 sustain6220.13 the6220.53 current6220.61 community6220.85 community6221.43 schools,6221.66 but6221.91 an6222.23 additional6222.39 investment6222.78 would6223.19 address6223.27 many6223.66 of6223.78 the6223.91 current6223.99 challenges6224.23 we6224.63 are6224.7 seeing6224.86 in6225.1 our6225.27 secondary6225.35 education6225.82 as6226.7 well.6226.95 Funding6228.31 to6228.7 create6228.78 a6228.99 healthy6229.19 and6229.51 sustainable6229.66 schools6230.23 office6230.55 to6230.86 conduct6231.02 energy6231.43 audits6231.82 at6232.06 our6232.15 schools,6232.31 many6232.63 of6232.95 which6233.02 were6233.19 built6233.35 before6233.75 World6233.91 War6234.07 II6234.15 and6234.39 help6234.63 districts6234.87 create6235.27 healthier,6235.51 greener6235.99 learning6236.31 environments6236.63 for6237.03 their6237.11 students6237.27 and6237.59 community,6237.75 especially6238.71 important6239.19 considering6239.59 the6239.91 rollback6239.99 of6240.39 federal6240.55 clean6240.87 energy6241.03 initiatives6241.43 and6241.83 environmental6241.99 justice6242.63 protections.6242.95 An6244.55 additional6244.71 $6245.43 486246.16 million,6246.16 to6246.16 extend6246.32 charter6246.65 school6246.89 tuition6247.13 reimbursement6247.44 for6248.16 four6248.4 years6248.56 instead6248.89 of6249.2 three6249.36 to6250.01 support6250.16 school6250.48 districts6250.72 during6251.05 this6251.36 current6251.52 funding6251.76 crisis.506253.36 million6254.01 to6254.01 support6254.09 the6254.4 Commonwealth6254.56 Preschool6255.13 Partnership6255.44 initiative.6256.01
6257.05 2006257.93 million6257.93 for6257.93 reserve6258.16 fund6258.56 to6258.89 protect6259.05 the6259.36 ability6259.52 of6259.84 our6260.01 public6260.09 higher6260.4 education6260.65 system6261.2 to6261.75 maintain6261.99 staffing6262.39 and6263.03 meet6263.27 the6263.51 needs6263.59 of6263.91 students6264.07 where6264.47 there6264.71 are6265.03 significant6265.35 reductions6265.83 in6266.23 federal6266.39 funding6266.79 and6267.35 to6267.59 fund6267.75 wage6268.39 adjustments6268.71 that6269.51 bring6269.67 staff6269.99 and6270.23 faculty6270.39 wages6270.87 in6271.19 line6271.35 with6271.59 their6271.75 peers6271.83 in6272.15 other6272.31 states6272.47 and6272.87 accounting6273.03 for6273.43 the6273.59 cost6273.67 of6273.99 living.6274.07 We6275.44 also6275.69 believe6275.84 it6276.16 would6276.32 be6276.4 prudent6276.48 to6276.89 fund6277.05 a6277.16 portion6277.28 of6277.52 the6277.69 pension6277.84 liability6278.16 associated6278.8 with6279.28 retirement6279.44 plus6280.01 fixed6280.24 bill,6280.56 providing6281.05 teachers6281.44 hired6281.84 before6282.09 07/01/20016282.4 the6283.93 opportunity6284.09 to6284.65 join6284.72 the6284.97 retirement6285.05 plus6285.52 program6285.76 as6286.48 done6286.65 in6286.8 House6286.97 Bill6287.2 2932,6288.09 Senate6288.32 Bill6288.72 1884.6289.52 Due6290.93 to6291.25 the6291.33 revenue6291.41 from6291.81 the6291.97 FareShare6292.29 Amendment,6292.53 we6293.01 are6293.17 better6293.33 positioned6293.57 than6294.05 most6294.21 states6294.53 to6294.93 weather6295.09 the6295.33 current6295.49 storm6295.81 and6296.21 for6296.37 our6296.61 Commonwealth6296.69 to6297.25 continue6297.41 to6297.81 lead6297.97 by6298.45 taking6298.69 critical6299.01 steps6299.41 to6299.81 fill6299.89 the6300.13 gaps6300.29 and6300.53 do6300.77 whatever6300.93 we6301.25 can6301.41 to6301.65 prevent6301.81 further6302.13 harm6302.45 while6303.01 continuing6303.33 to6303.81 enact6304.05 proactive6304.69 measures.6305.33
6306.45 Considering6306.45 the6306.85 level6307.01 of6307.24 uncertainty6307.41 we6308.45 have6308.6 across6308.85 sectors6309.16 with6309.65 the6309.73 cuts6309.89 and6310.13 threats6310.28 to6310.53 critical6310.69 programming6311.09 we're6311.81 hearing6312.05 from6312.36 the6312.53 White6312.6 House,6312.93 we6313.49 also6313.65 urge6313.97 you6314.2 to6314.36 take6314.53 action6314.77 early6315.16 this6315.49 session6315.56 to6315.97 identify6316.13 new6316.6 sources6316.85 of6317.16 revenue6317.24 and6318 ways6318.16 the6318.4 state6318.48 can6318.88 invest6319.12 and6319.44 ensure6319.68 economic6320.16 security6320.64 for6321.2 all,6322 including6322.08 passing6323.04 the6323.36 corporate6323.52 FareShare6324.16 bill,6324.48 also6324.88 known6325.2 as6325.44 the6325.52 GILTI6325.76 bill,6326.24 filed6327.04 this6327.28 session.6327.52 While6329.52 the6329.76 right6329.92 to6330.08 public6330.16 education6330.56 may6331.12 not6331.28 be6331.44 explicitly6332.01 protected6332.32 in6332.73 the6332.89 US6333.13 Constitution,6333.45 it6334.16 is6334.49 in6334.73 the6334.89 Massachusetts6335.05 Constitution.6335.77 And6336.81 if6337.05 the6337.2 White6337.28 House6337.53 is6337.77 going6337.93 to6338.16 try6338.24 to6338.49 dismantle6338.73 public6339.13 education6339.45 as6339.93 we6340.09 know6340.16 it,6340.32 the6340.65 state6340.73 has6341.05 the6341.2 obligation6341.36 to6341.93 step6342.09 up6342.32 and6342.57 ensure6342.73 that6343.13 all6343.36 children6343.6 of6344.01 Massachusetts6344.16 have6345.11 the6345.27 resources6345.51 they6345.99 need6346.15 to6346.55 access6346.71 quality6347.11 public6347.51 education6347.75 they6348.47 are6348.71 afforded6348.79 under6349.19 the6349.35 Massachusetts6349.51 Constitution.6350.23 We6351.91 believe6352.39 in6352.79 Massachusetts.6353.03 We6355.11 believe6355.27 we6355.59 can6355.67 do6355.91 it,6355.99 and6356.55 we6356.79 look6357.03 forward6357.19 to6357.51 continuing6357.67 to6358.07 partner6358.23 with6358.63 all6358.79 of6358.95 you6359.11 to6359.47 identify6359.63 and6360.02 implement6360.34 the6360.66 solutions6360.82 we6361.22 need6361.47 to6361.78 protect6361.94 our6362.34 students,6362.59 families,6363.22 and6363.7 communities.6363.86 Thank6364.98 you.6365.14
6367.63 MICHLEWITZ6367.63 -6367.63 Thank6367.63 you6367.94 for6368.18 your6368.43 testimony,6368.59 for6369.14 your6369.3 time.6369.47 Appreciate6370.02 you,6370.43 the6370.9 perspective6371.06 as6371.63 well.6371.78 I6373.19 don't6373.35 have6373.51 any6373.59 questions.6373.83 I'm6374.31 not6374.47 counting6374.55 on6374.87 any6374.95 questions6375.59 from6375.91 the6376.07 members6376.15 of6376.39 the6376.55 committee6376.63 here?6376.95 Senator6379.75 Feeney.6380.15
6382.55 FEENEY6382.55 -6382.55 Thank6382.55 you,6382.79 mister6382.87 chairman.6383.11 And6383.35 I6383.43 want6383.59 to6383.83 thank6383.83 you,6384.07 president6384.23 Tang.6384.63 It's6384.87 good6385.03 to6385.11 see6385.27 you6385.35 again,6385.51 and6385.67 thank6385.83 you6385.99 for6386.23 being6386.31 here,6386.55 in6387.51 what6387.75 is6387.91 no6388.23 doubt,6388.39 historically,6389.65 probably6390.05 one6390.28 of6390.44 the6390.52 most6390.6 challenging6390.93 times6391.24 in6391.65 education.6391.81 I6392.28 want6392.44 to6392.69 thank6392.69 you6392.77 and6392.93 your6393.65 members6393.81 and6394.2 and6394.44 and,6394.77 all6395.65 the6395.89 the6396.2 folks6396.44 across6396.77 the6397.01 Commonwealth6397.16 in6397.56 the6397.73 education6397.89 sector6398.36 for6398.69 the6398.77 work6398.85 that6399.09 They're6399.4 doing6400.36 it.6400.36 I'm6400.36 wrestling6400.6 here6401.09 a6401.32 little6401.4 bit6401.65 through,6402.65 you6402.97 know,6403.05 the6403.21 conversation6403.45 that6403.85 we6403.93 just6404.09 had6404.25 with6404.49 the6404.65 secretaries,6404.81 and6406.33 hearing6406.57 about6406.89 all6407.13 the6407.21 priorities6407.37 that6407.85 you're6407.93 identifying,6408.17 certainly,6408.73 that6409.13 we're6409.29 hearing6409.45 from6409.69 our6410.17 communities6410.33 and6411.13 school6411.37 committees6411.61 and6412.17 and,6412.41 you6413.37 know,6413.45 those6413.77 in6414.17 our6414.49 schools6414.65 and6415.05 our6415.21 districts.6415.29 And6416.61 mindful6417.09 of6417.57 my6417.65 new6417.73 role6417.98 in6418.14 the6418.22 committee6418.3 and6418.69 hearing6418.85 chair6419.49 Roderick's6419.81 on6420.3 my6420.45 left6420.61 shoulder6420.77 literally6421.18 and6421.65 figuratively.6422.77
6423.09 Who's6423.09 always,6423.09 you6424.22 know,6424.38 telling6424.85 us6425.18 how6425.34 important6425.49 it6425.73 is6425.9 to6426.05 balance6426.22 fiscal6426.69 responsibility6427.09 with6427.65 the6427.81 needs6427.9 of6428.14 our6428.22 communities6428.38 and6429.09 understanding6429.34 that6429.81 we're6429.98 talking6430.26 about6430.5 FareShare6431.14 surplus6431.54 money,6432.1 Tay.6432.34 So6432.58 this6432.74 is6432.9 one6433.06 time6433.3 temporary6434.1 money.6434.5 And6435.54 I6436.26 want6436.42 to6436.66 make6436.66 sure6436.74 that6436.9 we're6437.06 looking6437.14 at6437.46 the6437.62 whole6438.02 picture,6438.26 the6438.58 big6438.74 picture,6438.9 the6439.38 kind6439.54 of6439.7 long6439.86 term6440.1 success6440.42 of6441.38 education6441.62 in6442.1 the6442.26 Commonwealth.6442.34 So6443.22 I'm6443.38 wondering6443.61 if6443.78 you6443.94 can6444.02 kind6444.26 of6444.49 help6444.49 me6444.74 understand6444.9 this6445.3 because6445.53 I'm6445.85 worried,6446.1 and6447.3 it's6447.61 I6448.18 was6448.34 with6448.57 the6448.74 conversation6448.9 that6449.3 we6449.45 just6449.53 had6449.7 before6449.85 us,6450.49 that6450.98 if6451.22 if6451.45 we6451.7 try6451.85 and6452.1 solve,6452.26 you6453.3 know,6453.45 all6453.7 of6453.85 these6454.02 priorities6454.41 that6454.9 you6455.06 had6455.22 mentioned6455.38 and6455.61 that6455.78 we're6455.94 hearing6456.1 about6456.41 with6457.04 one6457.36 time6457.44 temporary6458 funding,6458.48 does6458.88 that6459.12 then6459.52 create6459.84 a6460.72 structural6460.88 deficit6461.44 for6461.84 us6462.08 in6462.24 the6462.32 future6462.48 with6463.28 education?6463.52 Would6465.28 you6465.44 agree6465.6 with6465.84 that?6466 Is6467.04 there6467.12 an6467.36 argument6467.44 against6467.84 that?6468.24 I6468.56 just6468.72 want6468.88 to6469.12 make6469.12 sure6469.28 that6469.44 we6469.6 are6469.76 who6470 we6470 are.6470.32 We6470.4 are6470.4 thinking6470.56 long6471.44 term6471.76 here,6472.94 right?6473.49
6473.49 TANG6473.49 -6473.49 Yeah.6473.49 Sure.6473.98 So,6474.3 you6474.45 know,6474.53 we6474.7 are6474.94 partnering6475.1 with6475.57 our6475.9 school6476.14 committees6476.45 and6476.94 our6477.1 school6477.26 superintendents6477.49 because6478.38 we6478.85 understand6479.1 that6479.81 there6480.14 are6480.3 immediate6480.45 needs6480.85 right6481.18 now.6481.41 But6482.22 like6482.53 I6482.77 said,6482.85 the6483.26 budgeting6483.66 for6484.14 our6484.38 school6484.45 dishes6484.7 for6484.94 next6485.1 school6485.41 year6485.57 is6486.21 already6486.37 well6486.69 underway.6486.93 And6487.81 so6487.97 what6488.21 this6488.37 does.6489.17 it6489.49 actually6489.49 buys6489.97 us6490.21 some6490.37 time6490.61 to6490.93 prevent6491.17 further6491.49 harm6491.73 because6491.97 we're6492.21 talking6492.37 about6492.61 layoffs6492.93 that6493.33 are6493.49 happening6493.57 immediately.6493.97 We6495.17 anticipate,6495.41 you6496.21 know,6496.37 I6496.61 think6496.77 even6497.25 while6497.49 we're6497.73 sitting6497.89 here,6498.13 I6498.29 think6498.37 I6498.53 saw6498.69 a6498.85 headline6498.93 that6499.49 they're6499.73 going6500.05 to6500.21 try6500.41 to,6500.49 and6500.57 we6500.81 anticipated6500.9 this,6501.61 try6502.66 to6502.9 tie6503.06 federal6503.3 funding6503.61 to6504.34 things6505.61 that6505.94 are6506.1 not6506.18 aligned6506.34 with6506.66 our6506.81 values.6507.77
6508.1 Like6508.1 getting6508.1 rid6508.34 of6508.57 diversity,6508.81 equity,6509.3 and6509.69 inclusion6509.85 initiatives,6511.3 talking6513.22 about6513.53 real6513.85 history6514.1 in6514.57 our6514.66 schools,6514.9 etcetera.6515.38 And6516.81 I6517.13 think6517.29 we6517.53 do6517.69 anticipate6517.93 that6518.41 that's6518.57 happening.6518.81 But,6519.69 again,6519.93 that6520.17 doesn't6520.33 mean6520.65 that6520.89 right6521.13 now6521.29 then6521.53 in6521.85 the6521.93 short6522.09 term,6522.33 these6522.73 funds6522.89 can't6523.21 be6523.45 used6523.61 to6523.93 stem6524.17 that6524.41 harm6524.65 so6524.89 that6525.13 we6525.21 can6525.37 plan6525.53 forward6525.93 in6526.57 figuring6526.81 out6527.21 what6527.37 are6527.53 the6527.69 other6527.85 solutions6528.09 and6528.49 ways6528.65 that6528.89 we6529.13 can6529.21 prevent6529.37 further6529.77 harm6530.01 for6530.25 our6530.33 students6530.49 and6530.81 school6530.97 districts.6531.21 So6531.95 I6532.1 think6532.19 it6532.59 is6532.74 both6532.98 and.6533.23 But6534.1 if6534.43 we6534.59 can't6534.74 stem6535.31 the6535.63 immediate6535.78 harm,6536.82 then6537.63 it's6537.86 going6538.1 to6538.35 make6538.35 even6538.74 planning6539.06 for6539.31 reducing6539.95 further6540.43 harm6540.74 in6540.98 the6541.06 future6541.23 harder.6541.55
6543.06 FEENEY6543.06 -6543.06 Thank6543.06 you.6543.23 That's6543.47 helpful.6543.7 I6544.02 appreciate6544.1 that.6544.51 I'm6545.46 just6545.78 always6545.78 cautious6546.42 with6546.9 one6547.14 time6547.38 solves6547.7 for6548.1 what6548.58 we6548.82 could6548.98 see6549.14 with6549.38 the6549.78 structural6549.94 deficit6550.34 in6550.66 the6550.82 future.6550.9 I6551.22 want6551.3 to6551.54 give6551.54 you6551.7 about6551.78 some6552.02 answers.Thank6552.34 you.6552.58 Appreciate6552.66 your6552.9 time.6553.14
6553.38 TANG6553.38 -6553.38 mister.6553.38 And6553.78 like6554.1 I6554.26 said6554.34 here6554.58 too,6554.82 FareShare6556.18 alone6556.42 is6556.82 an6556.98 opportunity,6557.14 and6557.7 we6557.86 are6558.02 so6558.18 grateful6558.42 that6558.82 we're6558.98 even6559.14 here6559.54 having6560.64 this6560.95 hearing6561.27 to6561.68 talk6561.84 about6561.99 how6562.23 we6562.4 can6562.56 use6562.72 the6562.88 fund6563.03 to6563.27 prevent6563.91 further6564.23 harm.6564.56 But6565.44 we6566.16 are6566.31 also6566.48 invested6566.8 in6567.27 the6567.52 FareShare,6567.84 I'm6568.31 sorry,6568.48 the6568.72 raise6568.88 up6569.11 coalition6569.35 and6570.07 the6570.23 GILTI6570.4 corporate6570.8 FareShare6571.44 attacks6571.6 because6571.99 we6572.31 know6572.4 that6572.64 short6573.55 term,6573.79 it's6573.87 not6574.11 going6574.35 to6574.51 be6574.51 enough,6574.59 and6574.91 we've6575.07 got6575.23 to6575.39 look6575.47 at6575.71 other6575.79 ways6576.03 in6576.59 longer6576.91 term6577.23 to6577.79 help6577.95 fill6578.27 the6578.51 gaps.6578.67
6581.47 MICHLEWITZ6581.47 -6581.47 Thank6581.47 you,6581.63 president6581.87 Ting.6582.27 I6582.51 appreciate6582.59 your6583.07 testimony.6583.31 Any6584.11 other6584.35 questions?6584.51 Thank6586.93 you6587.09 again.6587.32 I6588.36 appreciate6588.6 it.6588.6
6588.6 TANG6588.6 -6588.6 Thank6588.6 you.6589.65 I6589.65 appreciate6589.65 it.6589.65
6590.52 MICHLEWITZ6590.52 -6590.52 Next6590.52 on6590.76 the6590.93 panel6591.01 or6591.32 next,6591.48 to6591.97 testify6592.28 is6592.68 Doug6592.84 Haugate6593.09 from6593.4 the6593.56 Massachusetts6593.65 Taxpayers6594.2 Foundation.6594.76
6607.3 DOUG6607.3 HOWGATE6607.3 -6607.3 MASSACHUSETTS6607.3 TAXPAYERS6607.3 FOUNDATION6607.3 -6607.3 HB6607.3 556607.3 -6607.3 Chair6607.3 Michlewitz,6607.46 Chair6608.1 Rodrigues,6608.34 members6608.74 of6609.06 the6609.14 committee,6609.22 my6609.94 name6610.1 is6610.26 Doug6610.34 Howgate.6610.58 I'm6610.98 the6611.14 president6611.22 of6611.62 the6611.79 Massachusetts6612.03 Taxpayers6612.44 Foundation,6612.91 and6613.48 want6613.88 to6614.2 thank6614.2 you6614.35 so6614.6 much6614.68 for6615.48 the6615.64 opportunity6615.8 to6616.27 testify6616.44 here6617.07 today6617.23 on6617.64 House6618.2 Bill6618.52 55,6618.52 which6619.8 is6620.03 Governor6622.2 Healey's6622.68 $1.36622.68 billion6622.68 supplemental6622.68 budget6623.16 proposal6623.56 related6624.35 to6624.68 education6624.91 and6625.48 transportation6625.72 innovation6626.44 and6626.91 capital6627.07 trust.6627.56 And6628.38 we're6628.46 going6628.62 to6628.86 cover6628.86 three6629.34 broad6629.66 topics.6629.98 So6630.46 one,6630.62 some6630.94 general6631.26 principles6631.58 for6632.06 use6632.14 of6632.38 resources6632.54 in6633.1 the6633.34 innovation6633.5 and6633.9 capital6634.06 trust6634.38 fund,6634.62 which6634.94 is6635.1 kind6635.26 of6635.42 what6635.5 we've6635.74 just6635.9 been6636.14 hearing6636.3 from6636.62 Senator6636.94 Feeney's6637.26 question6637.58 and6637.9 a6638.14 lot6638.22 of6638.38 the6638.46 questions6638.54 we've6638.86 heard,6639.1 some6639.82 specific6640.14 recommendations6640.62 related6641.42 to6641.74 Governor6643.59 Healey's6643.82 bill.6643.82
6643.82 And6643.82 then6643.82 to6643.9 take6643.98 a6644.22 step6644.3 back6644.47 and6644.7 talk6644.78 a6645.02 little6645.1 bit6645.26 about,6645.51 what6646.3 you6646.55 all6646.7 are6646.94 facing6647.1 in6647.51 terms6647.66 of6648.55 uncertainty,6648.7 economic6649.43 uncertainty,6649.98 federal6650.63 policy6651.02 uncertainty,6651.43 and6651.9 how6652.06 it6652.22 relates6652.3 to6652.7 whether6652.78 it's6652.94 this6653.18 bill,6653.34 the6653.59 FY6653.9 266654.06 budget,6654.55 or6654.86 any6655.1 number6655.26 of6655.51 decisions6655.59 you're6655.98 going6656.22 to6656.47 be6656.47 faced6656.63 with6656.94 over6657.18 the6657.34 next6657.51 however6657.9 many6658.3 years.6658.55 But6659.43 I6659.55 do6659.67 want6659.99 to6660.31 start6660.31 by6660.71 offering6661.43 our6661.91 appreciation6662.23 and6662.79 acknowledge6663.03 the6663.59 structure6663.83 that6664.23 was6664.39 put6664.55 in6664.71 place6664.79 for6665.19 SIR6665.43 tax6665.59 use6666.39 collection,6666.79 and6667.91 tracking6668.07 a6668.55 couple6668.63 years6668.95 ago.6669.19 So6669.59 we6669.83 were6670.31 at6670.47 the6670.63 consensus6670.71 revenue6671.27 hearing6671.67 back6671.99 in6672.31 before6672.71 the6672.95 FY6673.27 246673.51 budget,6673.99 and6674.23 we6674.39 talked6674.55 about6674.79 the6675.03 challenges6675.32 that6675.65 you6675.73 face,6675.97 how6676.77 to6677.01 use6677.09 these6677.48 resources6677.81 in6678.36 the6678.52 operating6678.69 budget6679.09 in6679.41 a6679.48 sustainable6679.65 way,6680.13 how6680.77 to6680.93 balance6681.09 against6681.41 future6681.73 volatility,6682.05 how6682.6 to6682.77 balance6682.85 against6683.09 the6683.32 fact6683.48 that6683.65 we6683.81 don't6683.89 know6684.13 how6684.28 much6684.44 people's6685.01 behaviors6685.48 are6685.97 going6686.05 to6686.36 change,6686.36 and6686.93 how6687.16 to6687.32 balance6687.48 operating6687.97 needs6688.44 versus6688.85 capital6689.16 needs.6689.65
6690.58 And6690.58 I6690.7 think6690.82 the6690.98 fact6691.14 that6691.3 we're6691.38 here6691.62 today6691.78 talking6692.1 about6692.5 this6692.74 bill6692.9 is6693.14 indicative6693.3 of6693.7 the6693.78 fact6693.86 that6694.02 the6694.1 structure6694.26 that6694.66 was6694.82 put6694.9 in6695.06 place6695.14 works6695.46 and6695.7 makes6695.94 sense.6696.18 And6697.06 so6697.38 I6697.62 want6697.78 to6698.1 thank6698.1 you6698.26 for6698.58 doing6698.74 that.6699.06 To6700.02 get6700.26 to6700.42 general6700.66 principles6701.14 on6701.62 use6701.78 of6701.94 the,6702.02 innovation6702.58 and6703.14 capital6703.3 surtax,6703.78 The6704.8 first6704.95 one6705.19 we'll6705.44 put6705.51 out6705.68 there6705.76 is6705.99 even6706.64 distribution6706.95 of6707.59 education6707.84 and6708.31 transportation6708.55 resources.6709.27 This6709.68 is6709.84 something6709.91 MTF6710.31 has6710.64 been6710.8 talking6710.88 about6711.19 for6711.35 several6711.51 years,6711.84 but6712.4 I6712.55 want6712.72 to6712.88 talk6712.88 about6713.11 what6713.27 we6713.44 mean6713.59 by6713.84 that6713.99 for6714.07 a6714.23 second6714.31 because6714.55 we6714.88 know6715.03 that6715.68 the6715.91 needs6715.99 change6716.89 from6717.13 year6717.21 to6717.45 year.6717.61 Education6718.17 is6718.65 a6718.81 little6718.89 more6719.05 aligned6719.29 on6719.45 the6719.61 operating6719.77 budget,6720.09 though6720.41 certainly6720.57 there6720.89 are6721.05 capital6721.21 spending6721.53 needs6721.85 as6722.09 well.6722.25 Transportation6722.89 relies6723.53 more6723.77 on6723.93 the6724.09 capital6724.25 budget,6724.49 though6724.81 there6724.97 are6725.21 certainly6725.29 operating6725.61 costs6726.01 as6726.25 well.6726.41 And6727.13 so6727.29 we6727.53 think6727.61 that6727.85 the6728.01 approach6728.09 that6728.41 the6728.57 Healey6728.73 administration6729.05 put6729.61 forward6729.93 in6730.33 her6730.49 operating6730.73 budget6731.13 proposal6731.53 and6732.09 this,6732.33 innovation6733.02 and6733.41 capital6733.57 sup6733.98 to6734.61 get6734.86 to6735.02 50:506735.49 in6735.82 combination6736.14 of6736.61 those6736.78 two6736.94 bills,6737.18 this6737.57 kind6737.74 of6737.98 holistic6738.06 approach6738.45 to6738.78 50:50,6739.26 we6739.66 think6739.82 that6740.06 makes6740.22 sense6740.53
6741.1 .6741.1 We6741.1 think6741.26 that6741.49 evenly6741.74 dividing6742.22 the6742.61 resources6742.78 is6743.74 important6743.98 given6744.53 what6744.86 the6745.1 question6745.18 spoke6745.82 to6746.06 and6746.22 what6746.3 the6746.45 voters6746.61 voted6746.94 on,6747.26 but6747.57 doing6747.73 it6747.97 in6748.05 an6748.21 adaptable6748.45 way6748.93 that6749.49 speaks6749.73 to6750.05 some6750.13 of6750.29 the6750.45 different6750.53 needs6750.85 in6751.17 education6751.33 and6751.73 transportation6751.89 is6752.45 a6752.61 smart6752.69 way6752.93 to6753.09 do6753.17 it.6753.33 The6754.29 second6754.45 thing6754.69 I6754.93 want6755.09 to6755.33 talk6755.33 about6755.49 is6755.73 kind6755.97 of6756.21 what6756.45 the6756.69 funds6756.85 in6757.17 this,6757.33 innovation6757.97 and6758.37 capital6758.53 trust6758.93 fund6759.17 should6759.41 be6759.65 used6759.73 for6760.05 and6760.72 some6760.88 cautions6761.11 about6761.51 other6761.84 ways6761.99 to6762.23 use6762.31 them.6762.47 I6762.72 think6762.8 our6763.03 priority6763.35 for6763.84 use6763.99 of6764.23 these6764.31 funds6764.55 are6765.19 things6765.35 related6765.59 to6766.07 one6766.39 time6766.64 cost6766.95 for6767.19 infrastructure.6767.43 Right?6768.15 It's6768.39 PAYGo6768.64 Capital.6769.11 It's6769.59 retiring6769.84 long6770.47 term6770.72 debt6770.95 liabilities.6771.11 It's6771.99 innovative6772.31 solutions,6772.88 and6773.96 we'd6774.04 caution6774.28 against6774.68 using6775 it6775.32 for6775.56 operating6775.88 costs.6776.36 And6777.08 and6777.32 I'll6777.48 get6777.64 to6777.8 some6777.96 kind6778.12 of6778.28 math6778.44 reasons6778.68 for6779 that6779.16 in6779.4 a6779.48 second,6779.56 but6779.88 I6780.04 think6780.12 at6780.44 a6780.6 more6780.76 basic6781.08 policy6781.48 level,6781.96 we6783.24 incorporate6783.56 in6784.12 the6784.28 budget6784.44 an6784.84 operating6785 threshold6785.48 for,6785.96 spending6786.68 of6787.08 the6787.24 surtax,6787.4 which6787.8 has6787.96 been6788.12 used6788.36 and6788.94 now6789.18 devotes6789.49 about6789.9 $1.956790.14 billion6791.18 in6791.18 the6791.26 FY6791.57 266791.73 proposal6792.22 for6792.61 operating6792.77 costs.6793.09
6793.81 There6793.81 are6794.14 a6794.22 lot6794.3 of6794.53 capital6794.69 needs,6795.02 especially6795.34 when6795.81 we6796.05 look6796.22 at6796.38 our6796.53 transportation6796.69 sector,6797.34 When6797.65 we6797.9 look6797.98 at6798.14 education,6798.3 it's6799.09 important6799.34 that6799.73 we6799.9 have6800.05 a6800.3 vehicle6800.45 that6801.18 is6801.41 able6801.65 to6801.9 kind6802.14 of6802.3 deploy6802.45 to6802.94 those6803.18 capital6803.41 needs6803.81 as6804.8 well.6804.88 But6805.04 it's6805.2 also6805.44 important6806.08 that6807.04 we6807.28 have6807.44 an6807.6 opportunity6807.76 to6808.32 spend6808.8 resources6809.68 on6810.16 innovative6810.4 uses.6810.88 One6811.76 thing6811.92 that6812.08 I6812.32 know6812.4 just6812.56 from6812.8 my6812.96 time6813.12 working6813.28 on6813.6 the6813.68 budget6813.84 that6814.08 we6814.24 don't6814.4 do6814.72 a6814.96 great6815.12 job6815.28 of6815.6 in6815.68 the6815.84 annual6816 budget6816.32 is6816.56 long6816.8 term6817.04 thinking6817.28 of6817.6 challenges6817.76 We6818.16 know6818.24 that6818.48 they6818.56 are6818.56 before6818.64 us.6818.96 We've6819.04 heard6819.2 about6819.47 a6819.63 bunch6819.7 of6819.86 those6819.94 today.6820.19 And6821.06 I6821.15 do6821.22 think6821.39 on6821.63 the6821.78 education6821.94 and6822.34 transportation6822.59 side,6823.3 the6823.86 ability6824.1 to6824.43 set6824.59 aside6824.82 some6825.15 resources6825.39 to6826.26 tackle6826.51 some6826.9 long6827.15 term6827.39 problems6827.7 and6828.1 long6828.34 term6828.51 challenges6828.74 we6829.22 have6829.39 in6829.55 education6829.7 and6830.19 transportation6830.26 is6831.3 a6831.47 really6831.63 important6831.94 aspect6832.43 of6832.82 this6832.9 trust6833.06 fund6833.39 and6833.7 one6833.86 we6834.1 hope6834.26 to6834.51 see,6834.66 in6835.23 the6835.39 bill6835.47 that6835.71 comes6835.87 out6836.03 of6836.19 the6836.27 house6836.35 and6836.59 the6836.67 senate6836.75 in6837.07 the6837.39 weeks6837.55 ahead,6837.71 and6837.95 we6838.11 have6838.27 some6838.35 specific6838.59 recommendations6839.07 on6839.55 that.6839.71
6840.51 I6840.51 think6840.59 the6840.83 third6840.91 general6841.31 principle,6841.71 which6842.43 gets6842.67 back6842.91 to6843.15 the6843.23 importance6843.39 of6843.87 avoiding6844.11 operating6844.75 spending6845.23 in6845.63 this6845.79 bill6846.27 before6846.51 you,6846.83 is6847.56 we6847.88 know6848.03 that6848.35 the6848.52 resources6848.76 that6849.4 are6849.64 going6849.72 to6849.95 go6849.95 into6850.11 this6850.27 trust6850.52 fund6850.76 are6850.88 going6851.23 to6851.64 be6851.64 reduced6851.64 over6851.64 the6851.72 next6851.88 couple6852.11 years.6852.27 Irrespective6852.99 of6853.56 volatility,6853.8 irrespective6854.35 of6854.91 what6854.99 happens6855.23 to6855.56 the6855.64 Commonwealth's6855.8 economy,6856.27 the6857.56 $1.36857.88 billion6859.15 in6859.15 Governor6859.64 Healey's6859.95 proposal6859.95 is6860.52 basically6860.68 the6861.23 result6861.31 of6861.83 $2.456863.75 billion6863.99 collected6863.99 in6864.55 FY6864.95 246865.11 and6865.91 a6866.15 billion6866.23 dollar6866.63 operating6867.03 budget6867.35 threshold6867.75 we6868.07 spent6868.23 in6868.47 that6868.55 budget.6868.71 The6869.59 next6869.75 year,6869.91 the6870.07 operating6870.23 budget6870.55 threshold6870.87 went6871.11 up6871.27 to6871.43 1.36871.51 billion.6872.31 This6872.31 year,6872.39 it's6872.55 going6872.71 to6872.95 go6872.95 up6873.11 to6873.19 1.956873.35 billion.6874.71 And6874.71 we6874.79 expect6875.28 surtax6875.52 collections6875.93 to6876.41 probably6876.56 stay6876.89 in6877.05 that6877.2 2.4,6877.36 2.5,6878.89 2.66879.36 range.6879.36 We6879.85 still6880.01 don't6880.16 know6880.32 exactly6880.48 where6880.89 they're6881.13 going6881.2 to6881.45 go,6881.45 but6881.77 I6882.01 don't6882.09 think6882.24 we6882.48 expect6882.65 them6883.05 to6883.28 double6883.45 as6884.09 we've6884.16 doubled6884.48 the6884.81 operating6884.97 spending6885.45 threshold.6885.85 So6886.24 we6886.48 know6886.65 just6887.28 because6887.52 we've6888.47 gotten6888.55 a6888.79 better6888.87 sense6889.11 of6889.35 those6889.43 collection6889.67 trends6889.99 over6890.23 the6890.47 time6890.55 that6890.79 the6890.95 amount6891.11 of6891.43 resources6891.59 in6892.63 this6892.79 trust6892.95 fund6893.27 are6893.59 going6893.83 to6893.83 probably6893.83 stabilize6894.15 in6894.55 the6894.71 $4006894.87 to6895.35 $6895.51 5006896.47 million6896.47 range.6896.47
6896.79 And6896.79 so6896.95 it's6897.11 vital6897.43 that6897.99 as6898.15 you6898.31 make6898.47 spending6898.71 decisions6899.03 in6899.43 the6899.59 upcoming6900.23 weeks,6900.63 you6901.22 do6901.34 it6901.45 based6901.7 on6901.94 the6902.1 fact6902.18 that6902.41 next6902.57 year,6902.73 it's6902.9 probably6903.06 not6903.38 going6903.45 to6903.61 be6903.61 1.326903.7 billion.6904.57 And6904.57 that's6904.73 not6904.98 a6905.14 statement6905.22 on6905.53 this6905.7 on6906.02 the6906.18 tax6906.34 or6906.57 if6906.98 it's6907.06 going6907.3 up6907.53 or6907.61 down.6907.77 It's6908.02 just6908.18 how6908.57 that6908.9 intersection6909.22 of6909.7 the6909.94 operating6909.94 budget6910.34 and6910.9 the6911.06 total6911.61 funds6912.02 collected6912.26 goes.6912.73 So6913.38 those6913.53 are6913.7 kind6913.77 of6914.02 the6914.1 general6914.26 recommendations.6914.81 To6915.74 be6915.98 a6916.06 little6916.14 more6916.38 specific,6916.7 regarding6918.3 the6918.7 Governor's6918.86 proposal,6919.26 we6919.74 strongly6919.9 support6920.38 the6921.02 transportation6921.34 finance6922.06 plan,6922.54 Governor6923.66 Healey6923.98 put6923.98 forward6924.14 as6924.46 part6925.42 of6925.66 the6925.82 transportation6925.98 finance6926.54 task6927.02 force.6927.26 And6928.34 I6928.57 want6928.66 to6928.98 talk6928.98 about6929.22 what6929.78 we6930.02 mean6930.18 by6930.41 that.6930.49 Deploying6931.61 significant6932.26 new6932.82 resources6932.98 to6933.61 transportation6933.78 in6934.66 a6934.9 way6934.98 that6935.3 marries6935.94 capital6936.41 funds,6936.82 operating6937.3 funds6937.85 in6938.26 the6938.41 budget6938.57 and6938.9 in6939.14 the6939.3 surtax6939.45 and6940.33 provides6940.57 one,6941.37 predictability.6941.77 We'll6942.65 talk6942.89 about6943.05 the6943.21 MBTA6943.37 in6943.77 this6943.85 in6944.01 a6944.09 second,6944.25 but6944.49 predictability6944.65 in6945.21 terms6945.37 of6945.61 funding,6945.77 but6946.17 also6946.33 I6946.49 think6946.65 demonstrates6946.97 to6947.61 taxpayers6947.77 that6948.33 we6948.49 have6948.65 a6949.05 thoughtful6949.21 plan6949.69 for6950.01 using6950.25 surtax6950.65 resources6951.13 on6951.69 transportation.6952.01
6952.73 There's6952.73 going6952.89 to6953.13 be6953.13 a6953.2 lot6953.32 of6953.45 conversations6953.69 in6954.24 the6954.41 coming6954.48 years6954.81 about6955.52 the6955.85 transportation6956.09 system6956.65 we6956.97 want,6957.13 what6957.69 it6957.85 costs.6958.01 And6958.65 the6958.89 first6959.05 thing6959.2 we6959.36 need6959.52 to6959.69 make6959.77 sure6959.93 we6960.09 do6960.24 is6960.41 demonstrate6960.56 that6960.97 resources6961.13 that6961.6 are6961.77 available6962.56 to6962.97 us6963.13 are6963.28 being6963.45 used6963.69 effectively6963.85 on6964.41 transportation.6964.56 The6966.25 second6966.49 specific6966.81 recommendation,6967.29 which6967.85 kind6968.09 of6968.33 follows6968.33 from6968.65 that,6968.73 and6968.97 it6969.29 kind6969.45 of6969.69 builds6969.69 on6969.93 some6970.09 of6970.25 the6970.33 discussion6970.41 we've6970.73 heard6970.89 here6971.13 today6971.29 is6971.53 we6972.09 do6972.25 think6972.41 that6972.57 it's6972.81 critically6973.05 important,6973.53 and6974.65 this6974.89 is6974.97 Something6975.37 MBTA6975.85 wrote6975.85 about6976.01 last6976.25 year,6976.57 that6977.29 the6977.61 house6977.85 senate6978.09 administration6978.41 moved6979.05 forward6979.21 with6979.53 a6979.61 plan6979.69 to6979.7 address6979.72 MBTA6979.73 operating6979.75 deficits6979.76 for6979.78 a6979.8 three6979.81 year6979.82 period.6979.84 Now6979.85 why6979.87 is6979.89 that?6979.9 It's6979.91 because6979.93 we6981.77 have6984.24 that?6984.24 It's6985.77 because6985.85 we've6985.89 seen6985.93 some6986.11 major6986.3 improvements6986.49 of6987.52 the6987.69 MBTA6987.82 in6987.95 terms6988.09 of6988.24 workforce,6988.41 in6988.89 terms6988.97 of6989.13 reliability,6989.28 and6989.85 I6990.09 think6990.16 most6990.41 importantly,6990.56 in6990.97 terms6991.36 of6991.45 the6991.52 confidence6991.85 that6992.32 riders,6992.56 policymakers,6993.05 and6993.69 the6993.85 public6994.09 feel6994.32 in6994.56 the6994.73 tea.6994.81 And6995.77 that6995.93 kind6996.4 of6996.64 progress6996.72 is6997.2 critical.6997.52 It's6997.92 critical6998.24 to6998.8 the6998.88 economy6999.2 of6999.76 the6999.92 Commonwealth.7000
7000.72 It's7000.72 critical7000.96 to7001.36 a7001.68 unique7001.84 asset7002.32 that7002.72 Massachusetts7002.88 has7003.52 that7003.76 a7004 lot7004.08 of7004.24 other7004.4 urban7004.8 areas7005.12 don't7005.52 have,7005.68 and7005.84 we7006 need7006.24 to7006.56 make7006.72 sure7006.96 that7007.52 we7008.08 don't7008.24 take7008.4 a7008.56 step7008.64 backwards7008.88 there.7009.36 That7010.63 doesn't7010.86 mean7011.1 there's7011.34 not7011.59 an7011.82 opportunity7011.98 and7012.55 it's7012.7 not7012.94 critically7013.1 important7013.59 to7013.9 address7014.15 the7014.47 issues7014.55 of7014.86 regional7014.94 equity7015.26 that7015.51 were7015.74 raised7016.39 earlier,7016.7 and7017.02 I'm7017.18 happy7017.34 to7017.59 discuss7017.66 that.7018.06 But7018.55 I7018.78 don't7018.94 think7019.26 that7019.51 that7019.66 should7019.9 come7020.06 at7020.22 the7020.39 expense7020.47 of,7020.78 I7020.86 think,7020.94 a7021.18 very7021.43 important7021.82 and7022.39 practical7022.63 step7023.4 to7023.88 stabilize7023.96 the7024.44 T7024.6 for7024.84 a7024.92 few7025 years7025.24 to7025.48 build7025.64 on7025.8 what7025.96 we've7026.12 seen.7026.28 The7027.4 third7027.64 specific7027.96 recommendation7028.44 relates7029.48 to7029.8 this7029.88 idea7030.12 of7030.36 innovation7030.52 in7031.16 the7031.32 innovation7031.48 and7031.88 capital7032.04 sup.7032.44 Using7033.48 some7033.96 of7034.52 these7034.68 resources7034.92 to7035.94 tackle7036.26 some7036.66 really7036.98 big7037.3 challenges7037.53 that7037.94 we7038.1 face7038.26 that7038.49 we7038.66 maybe7038.82 don't7039.14 have7039.3 any7039.45 great7039.7 ideas7039.86 for7040.18 right7040.34 now.7040.49 And7040.74 the7040.82 one7040.9 we7041.14 would7041.3 identify7041.45 for7042.02 this7042.26 year7042.49 is7042.9 special7043.06 education7043.38 transportation.7043.94 And7044.9 we7045.06 recommend7045.22 setting7045.61 aside,7045.86 we7046.26 would7046.34 say,7046.49 $157046.66 million,7047.82 happy7047.82 to7048.06 work7048.14 with7048.3 staff7048.54 on7048.78 kind7049.1 of7049.26 a7049.42 build7049.5 up7049.74 for7049.9 what7050.22 the7050.46 resources7050.7 would7051.18 be7051.34 required7051.5 to7051.98 do7052.06 two7052.3 things.7052.46
7052.86 Right?7052.86 one,7053.5 we've7053.82 seen7054.06 some7054.3 innovative7054.54 approaches7055.02 at7055.42 the7055.58 local7055.66 level7055.98 to7056.62 do7056.78 some7056.94 things7057.1 to7057.34 try7057.5 to7057.74 get7057.82 their7057.98 arms7058.22 around7058.46 special7058.7 education7059.02 transportation7059.58 costs.7060.14 Let's7060.82 see7060.98 if7061.06 those7061.22 are7061.61 expandable7062.02 and7062.66 replicable7062.9 in7063.38 other7063.53 communities.7063.78 And7064.41 at7064.66 the7064.82 same7064.98 time,7065.14 let's7065.38 work7065.61 with7065.85 some7066.02 researchers7066.26 in7066.74 academia7066.9 and7067.61 education7067.85 policy7068.41 to7068.9 figure7068.98 out7069.3 what's7069.61 the7069.85 way7070.02 to7070.18 get7070.26 our7070.41 arms7070.57 around7070.82 these7071.06 costs7071.38 and7071.78 effective7071.94 deployment7072.98 of7073.45 these7073.53 services7073.78 going7074.26 forward.7074.57 And7075.12 so7075.28 that's7075.44 something7075.68 that7075.92 we7076.16 think7076.24 would7076.48 be7076.64 a7077.12 really7077.44 important7077.76 element7078.24 of7078.72 the7079.28 bill7079.44 that7079.76 you7079.84 folks7080 are7080.24 going7080.4 to7080.8 act7080.8 on7081.04 in7081.2 the7081.36 relatively7081.44 near7081.92 term.7082.24 So7083.52 the7083.84 last7083.92 thing7084.24 I7084.4 want7084.56 to7084.88 talk7084.88 about,7085.04 relates7085.68 to7086.08 this7086.24 bill,7086.4 relates7086.72 to7087.04 the7087.2 operating7087.28 budget,7087.68 but7087.92 I7088.08 think7088.16 is7088.4 a7088.56 broader7088.64 topic,7089.2 which7089.6 is7089.84 how7090.95 do7091.11 we7091.27 react7091.59 and7092.07 respond7092.23 to7092.64 ongoing7092.8 economic7093.35 and7093.76 federal7093.91 policy7094.31 uncertainty?7094.72 We've7095.27 seen7095.51 so7095.84 much7095.99 this7096.23 week.7096.47 We're7096.88 going7097.03 to7097.27 see7097.27 a7097.43 lot7097.51 next7097.68 week.7097.91 Right?7098.15 So7098.47 much7098.64 has7098.88 happened.7099.03
7099.76 We7099.76 don't7099.99 know7100.23 what7100.55 the7100.8 impacts7100.88 are7101.27 going7101.43 to7101.59 be,7101.59 and7101.68 we7101.91 don't7102.07 know7102.23 what's7102.4 going7102.64 to7102.8 happen.7102.95 And7103.44 so7103.68 how7103.76 does7104 the7104.24 state7104.32 respond7104.64 to7104.96 that7105.12 when7105.36 we7105.6 know7105.76 that7105.92 the7106.08 resources7106.24 available7106.8 to7106.96 us,7107.12 whether7107.36 it's7107.6 financial7107.84 resources,7108.24 time,7108.88 process,7109.28 they're7109.92 all7110.08 limited.7110.32 Right?7110.8 It's7112.16 critically7112.48 important7112.96 that7113.44 we7113.6 create,7113.76 I7114.08 think,7114.16 an7114.4 approach7114.56 across7115.12 the7115.44 administration,7115.52 house,7116.24 and7116.48 senate7116.64 that7117.04 allows7117.2 us7117.55 to7117.7 collect7117.86 information,7118.19 assess7119.7 options,7120.19 and7120.74 coordinate7120.98 a7121.55 response.7121.7 And7122.02 I7122.19 think7122.34 it's7122.51 critically7122.74 important7123.23 that7123.63 as7123.86 that7124.02 exercise,7124.34 obviously7125.3 takes7125.78 into7126.02 account7126.27 how7126.51 we7126.66 listen7126.82 to7127.06 our7127.15 communities,7127.3 constituents,7127.86 fellow7129.3 members,7129.63 but7130.34 it7130.51 also7130.74 needs7131.15 to7131.39 reside7131.55 pretty7132.1 closely7132.34 to7132.74 budget7132.9 decisions.7133.15 Right?7133.52 At7134.48 the7134.56 end7134.88 of7135.2 the7135.28 day,7135.36 so7135.68 much7135.97 of7136.27 what7136.56 is7136.64 going7136.72 to7136.8 be7136.8 coming7136.92 down7137.04 the7137.28 pike7137.52 related7137.68 to7137.76 whatever7138.24 the7138.4 feds7138.56 do7138.72 or7139.28 don't7139.36 do,7139.52 whatever7139.84 happens7140.24 to7140.64 the7140.72 economy,7140.88 is7141.36 going7141.52 to7141.84 be7141.84 intertwined7142 with7142.32 the7142.8 budget.7142.88 It's7143.2 going7143.36 to7143.52 be7143.52 intertwined7143.68 with7144.24 the7144.32 financial7144.4 decisions.7145.53
7145.78 That7145.78 chair7145.78 Michlewitz,7145.85 chair7146.26 Rodrigues,7146.49 members7147.06 of7147.22 the7147.38 committee,7147.45 and7147.94 Secretary7148.57 Gorzkowicz,7149.7 are7149.7 going7149.78 to7150.02 be7150.02 tasked7150.18 with.7150.49 And7150.81 so7151.06 finding7151.3 a7151.61 way7151.7 we're7152.02 not7152.26 suggesting7152.41 something7152.98 formal7153.78 or7154.18 something7154.34 statutory,7154.74 but7155.45 to7155.7 create7155.78 a7156.1 kind7156.26 of7156.41 state7156.9 federal7157.22 response7157.53 team7158.02 centered7158.49 around7158.98 administration7159.85 and7160.49 finance,7160.57 and7160.94 the7161.02 ways7161.1 and7161.34 means7161.42 committees7161.58 to7162.14 help7162.38 us7162.62 understand7162.94 what7163.58 is7163.82 happening7164.06 and7164.54 what7164.62 those7164.86 options7165.02 are.7165.5 Because7165.74 one7166.06 of7166.22 the7166.3 things7166.46 that7166.62 we7166.78 talk7167.02 about7167.18 is7167.5 what7169.02 would7169.26 be7169.42 a7169.66 mistake7169.74 is7170.3 to7170.54 act7170.86 in7171.42 a7171.58 way7171.66 now7171.9 that7172.3 kind7172.62 of7172.7 reduces7173.2 our7173.84 options7173.99 in7174.48 the7174.64 future7174.8 when7175.27 the7175.52 world7175.68 we're7175.99 faced7176.16 with,7176.4 especially7176.64 once7177.03 we7177.27 see7177.35 what7177.52 the7177.64 federal7177.76 fiscal7178.07 year7178.4 '267178.72 budget7179.2 looks7179.52 like,7179.84 is7180.4 going7180.56 to7181.03 inform7181.03 so7181.6 many7183.84 of7184.07 the7184.16 things7184.23 that7184.48 are7184.56 in7184.72 the7184.8 state7184.88 budget,7185.03 from7185.35 certainly7185.6 Medicaid7185.91 to7186.4 other7186.56 areas7186.8 as7187.11 well.7187.27
7187.68 That's7187.68 not7187.91 to7188.16 say7188.23 we7188.48 shouldn't7188.56 be7189.01 proactive7189.09 in7189.41 the7189.57 meantime.But7190.37 we7190.61 need7190.77 a7190.93 strategy7191.09 that7191.57 understands7191.81 that7192.29 short7192.53 game,7192.77 long7193.09 game,7193.33 and7193.89 the7194.13 fact7194.21 that7194.53 outside7195.09 of7195.49 whatever7195.73 happens7196.05 in7196.45 terms7196.53 of7196.85 actual7196.93 federal7197.33 policy,7197.73 what7198.45 happens7198.61 to7198.93 the7199.09 economy7199.25 could7200.05 have7200.29 an7200.69 even7200.93 far7201.25 greater7201.57 impact7201.97 on7202.37 state7202.53 resources,7202.85 and7203.33 we7203.49 can't7203.65 act7204.16 like7204.32 those7204.48 are7204.73 two7204.89 different7205.05 things.7205.28 And7205.93 so7206.01 that's7206.24 why7206.4 we7206.65 think7206.73 it's7206.89 critically7207.13 important7207.52 to7207.93 think7208.01 about7208.24 how7208.56 we7208.73 create7208.89 some7209.28 kind7209.52 of7209.76 an7210.24 information7210.4 sharing7211.05 coordination7211.44 structure7212.16 that7212.73 again7212.89 is7213.2 centered,7213.36 I7213.69 think,7213.76 pretty7213.93 close7214.09 to7214.32 how7214.48 we7214.65 make7214.73 financial7214.89 decisions.7215.28 So7216.09 thank7216.16 you7216.32 for7216.48 the7216.65 opportunity7216.8 to7217.2 testify.7217.36 Happy7217.84 to7218.09 take7218.24 any7218.4 questions.7218.65
7219.82 MICHLEWITZ7219.82 -7219.82 Thank7219.82 you,7219.98 Doug.7220.22 Appreciate7220.46 your7220.78 testimony7221.02 as7221.58 always7221.82 and,7222.14 your,7223.34 continued7224.06 partnership7224.62 with7225.18 us,7225.34 and7225.9 and7226.14 giving7226.62 us7226.94 information,7227.18 giving7227.82 us7228.14 perspective,7228.3 and,7229.02 working7229.82 with7230.14 working7230.38 with7230.7 us7230.94 to7231.18 kind7231.34 of7231.58 find7231.66 solutions7231.9 to7232.38 some7232.62 of7232.78 our7232.86 challenges.7233.02 Thank7233.74 you.7233.9 Wanted7235.36 to7235.69 just7235.84 ask7236.09 about7236.32 FareShare7237.36 in7237.52 general,7237.69 and7237.93 we've7238.01 had7238.4 these7238.56 conversations7238.8 before,7239.28 but7239.6 I'm7239.76 going7239.93 to7240.24 continue7240.24 to7240.72 bring7240.97 them7241.13 up.7241.28 Yeah.7241.52 This7241.84 is7242.16 always7242.32 a7242.65 continuous7242.72 moving7243.28 target.7243.6 And7243.84 as7244.97 every7245.2 year7245.52 goes7245.76 by7246.01 or7246.16 as7246.32 now7246.48 we,7246.65 you7246.8 know,7246.89 start7247.13 to7247.36 go7247.52 through7247.69 these7247.84 processes,7249.17 processes,7249.89 we7250.21 know7250.37 more7251.09 and7251.49 more7251.49 information.7251.65 We7252.13 have7252.29 more,7252.53 you7252.77 know,7252.93 understanding7253.41 of7253.97 it.7254.05 We7255.33 were7255.49 all7255.73 pretty7256.45 off7256.85 on7257.25 this7257.57 number7257.81 that7258.45 we7258.69 got7258.85 to7259.09 at7259.49 2.4.7259.89 If7261.73 I7261.85 mean,7261.93 we7262.09 budgeted7262.24 it7262.89 conservatively7263.05 at7263.69 a7263.77 billion7263.85 intentionally,7264.24 knowing7265.53 it7265.85 was7265.93 the7266.09 first7266.16 thing.7266.32 The7266.49 DOER's7266.73 first7267.2 number7267.45 was7267.77 1.6.7268.32 I7269.13 don't7269.2 recall7269.45 what7269.85 what7270.09 you7270.49 guys7270.65 said7270.89 exactly,7271.05 but7271.36 I7271.53 think.7271.6
7271.85 HOWGATE7271.85 -7271.85 it7271.85 was7271.93 2.456,7272.16 not7273.53 2.46.7273.77
7274.32 MICHLEWITZ7274.32 -7274.32 You7274.32 had7274.49 it7274.65 exactly7274.81 on7275.13 the7275.28 number?7275.36 Yeah.7275.69 I7276.77 didn't7276.93 think7277.17 so.7277.97
7279.17 HOWGATE7279.17 -7279.17 We7279.17 were7279.33 smart7279.49 enough7279.73 to7279.89 not7280.05 provide7280.21 an7280.45 estimate.7280.53
7281.09 MICHLEWITZ7281.09 -7281.09 Okay.7281.09 Yeah.7281.49 Yeah.7283.33 Well,7283.65 you7283.81 can7283.97 do7284.13 that.7284.29 But,7286.29 all7287.81 can7288.05 decide,7288.29 we're7288.61 trying,7289.33 as7289.97 we're7290.13 trying7290.29 to7290.53 maneuver7290.61 through7291.01 this7291.09 thing,7291.25 I7291.64 think7291.72 we're7291.8 trying7292.03 to7292.11 figure7292.68 out7293.23 certainty,7293.31 you7294.91 know,7295.07 expectations,7295.39 as7297.72 we7297.95 move7298.19 towards,7298.51 having7299.95 full7300.27 implementation7300.59 of7301.23 this7301.39 discussion.7301.64 And,7302.19 you7303.07 know,7303.23 as7303.47 a7303.81 couple7303.97 more7304.13 budgets7304.37 go7304.69 through,7304.85 we7305.09 will7305.25 have7307.29 a7307.33 full7307.41 amount7307.73 of,7308.21 you7308.77 know,7308.93 FareShare7309.41 money7309.65 that7309.81 we'll7309.97 just7310.37 be7310.61 using,7311.17 hopefully7311.49 just7311.89 through7312.13 the7312.37 regular7312.61 budget7313.01 process7313.33 and7313.65 not7313.81 having7313.97 a7314.21 surplus7314.37 conversation7314.77 of7315.33 this7315.41 magnitude.7315.65 We7316.37 will7316.53 certainly7316.77 have7317.17 a7317.25 surplus7317.41 to7318.21 some7318.37 degree7318.66 next7319.06 year,7319.86 maybe7320.02 by7320.35 the,7320.51 you7320.91 know,7320.98 the7321.31 following7321.39 year7321.86 that7322.02 that7322.27 number7322.43 is7322.66 going7322.82 to7323.06 start7323.06 getting7323.31 smaller.7323.7
7324.43 But7324.43 I7324.74 think7324.82 the7324.98 question7325.15 is,7325.47 one,7325.7 do7326.74 you7326.91 think7326.98 that7327.23 2.47327.47 is7328.19 sustainable,7328.66 or7329.94 in7330.19 that7330.43 range7330.66 is7330.98 sustainable?7331.15 And7332.1 then7332.27 two,7332.59 is,7333.89 you7335.25 know,7335.41 how7335.65 soon7335.81 and7336.13 I've7336.29 asked7336.45 this7336.69 question7336.85 before,7337.17 but7337.49 how7337.65 soon7337.81 do7338.05 we7338.21 start7338.37 getting7338.69 to7339.01 that7339.09 point7339.33 where7339.65 we7340.21 can7340.45 start,7341.41 you7341.57 know,7341.57 relying7341.89 on7342.29 certain7342.45 things7342.77 related7343.09 to7343.49 FareShare,7343.89 as7344.85 opposed7345.09 to,7345.49 you7346.02 know,7346.18 going7346.73 low7346.98 and7347.22 then7347.45 trying7347.61 to7347.77 play7348.26 this7348.49 game7348.66 of,7348.9 like,7349.06 combining7349.3 FareShare7350.02 with7350.18 that,7350.34 you7350.45 know,7350.57 with7350.81 the7351.94 next7352.02 fiscal7352.26 budget,7352.57 which7352.81 is7352.98 what7353.14 the7353.45 administration's7353.69 talking7354.34 about.7354.57 You7354.9 know,7355.06 we're7355.14 going7355.3 to7355.53 certainly7355.53 have7355.85 those7356.02 conversations7356.26 over7356.73 the7356.9 next7356.98 couple7357.22 weeks7357.38 here.7357.61 And7358.03 I7358.11 think7358.19 we're7358.35 just7358.43 trying7358.67 to7358.91 figure7359.07 out7359.31 when7359.47 it7360.19 becomes7360.27 more7360.59 certain,7360.75 from7362.03 your7362.91 perspective7363.15 in7363.63 relation7363.79 to7364.11 that.7364.19
7364.75 HOWGATE7364.75 -7364.75 Yeah.7364.75 Great7365.23 question.7365.47 And7365.87 I'd7366.59 answer7366.83 it7367.15 in7367.31 a7367.47 few7367.79 different7367.95 ways.7368.27 So7368.59 when7370.19 you7370.43 look7370.51 at7370.75 estimating7371.66 where7372.22 tax7372.45 collections7372.77 are7373.18 going7373.26 to7373.49 go,7373.49 there's7373.66 kind7374.22 of7374.45 two7374.45 things7374.45 you7374.7 can7374.85 look7375.26 at7375.66 as7375.98 your7376.06 prior.7376.3 One7376.77 is7377.1 total7377.34 tax7377.66 collections.7377.98 Right?7378.61 Which7378.94 and7379.18 if7379.26 you7379.41 look7379.57 at7379.74 those,7379.9 the7380.45 biggest7380.7 the7381.18 most7381.34 volatile7381.57 time7381.98 in7382.22 total7382.38 tax7382.77 collections7383.02 was7383.66 in7383.98 the7384.14 last7384.22 307384.47 years7384.71 or7384.83 so7384.95 was7385.19 the7385.35 great7385.51 recession7385.75 when7386.23 we7386.39 had7386.55 declined7386.71 about7387.11 15%,7387.35 and7388.31 the7388.47 biggest7388.63 increase7388.95 we've7389.27 had7389.51 in7389.75 total7389.99 tax7390.31 collections7390.55 in7390.95 a7391.03 given7391.11 year7391.51 was7391.91 about7392.07 20%7392.39 during7392.95 during7393.27 the7393.59 pandemic.7393.75 Right?7394.31 So7394.55 that's7394.71 the7394.95 order7395.11 of7395.35 magnitude7395.43 there.7395.91 But7396.39 the7396.55 other7396.71 thing7396.87 you7397.03 can7397.11 look7397.27 at7397.43 is7397.51 capital7397.75 gains7398.07 taxes.7398.39 Right?7398.87 And7399.35 capital7399.59 gains7399.91 tax7400.15 have7400.52 fallen7400.69 by7400.93 well7401.16 more7401.32 than7401.48 50%7401.8 in7402.36 a7402.44 year7402.52 and7402.76 have7403.01 more7403.09 than7403.24 doubled7403.4 in7403.72 another7403.89 year.7404.2 And7404.52 so7404.6 I7404.76 think7404.84 the7406.28 best7406.6 guess7406.93 is7407.24 surtax7407.48 revenues7407.89 are7408.28 probably7408.36 going7408.69 to7408.93 look7408.93 more7409.09 like7409.32 capital7409.56 gains7409.89 taxes7410.2 than7411.01 they7411.09 are7411.24 like7411.48 underlying7411.72 taxes.7412.36
7412.98 And7412.98 so7413.14 when7413.22 we7413.3 think7413.46 about7413.7 what7413.94 that7414.1 standard7414.34 error7414.74 is7414.98 in7415.22 terms7415.38 of7415.62 the7415.94 average7416.18 may7416.5 be7416.66 2.6,7416.9 but7417.94 your7418.1 average7418.9 deviation7419.22 may7419.86 be7420.1 7007420.26 million7421.3 either7421.3 way.7421.46 Obviously,7422.58 on7423.22 top7423.38 of7423.62 that7423.78 is7423.94 what7424.26 happens7424.5 with7424.74 behavioral7424.98 impacts7425.38 and7425.78 things7425.94 like7426.18 that,7426.34 but7426.5 those7426.74 will7426.9 play7427.06 out7427.22 over7427.46 time.7427.7 Right?7428.02 So7428.26 if7429.16 I7429.41 had7429.49 to7429.73 give7429.89 my7430.45 kind7430.85 of7431.09 best7431.24 guess7431.49 for7431.73 this,7431.97 right,7432.2 and7432.6 I7432.69 do7432.85 think7433.01 that7433.24 this7433.65 year's7433.81 budget7434.05 did7434.69 this7434.93 appropriately7435.24 is7435.73 let's7436.6 stick7436.85 around7437.09 2.57437.41 billion7438.6 for7438.6 right7438.77 now.7438.93 Right?7439.32 We're7439.49 going7439.65 to7439.89 see7439.89 if7440.05 it7440.13 goes7440.2 up,7440.36 if7440.52 it7440.69 goes7440.77 down,7441.01 but7441.65 build7442.45 in7442.61 a7442.77 process7442.85 that7443.25 understands7443.41 that7443.97 in7444.13 any7444.21 given7444.45 year,7444.85 that7445.17 standard7445.41 deviation7445.81 is7446.45 going7446.53 to7446.77 be7446.77 a7447.09 lot7447.17 wider7447.57 probably7447.97 than7448.53 it7448.69 is7448.77 in7449.01 general7449.17 budget7449.57 revenues.Which7450.69 could7450.93 mean7451.09 in7451.41 FY7452.45 25,7452.53 you7452.53 know,7452.53 one7452.85 of7452.93 the7453.09 challenges7453.17 that7453.49 we7453.57 talked7453.65 about7453.89 in7454.29 January7454.45 is7454.85 we7454.93 don't7455.01 have7455.25 a7455.33 great7455.41 kind7455.65 of7455.89 under7455.89 the7456.13 hood7456.21 look7456.45 at7456.61 the7456.69 composition7456.77 of7457.26 revenues7457.41 in7457.65 '257457.9 to7458.38 date.7458.45 Certax7459.26 could7459.81 outperform7459.97 last7460.45 year7460.61 significantly7460.85 in7461.34 FY7461.65 25.7461.81
7462.38 Right?7462.38 That7463.26 doesn't7463.41 necessarily7463.73 mean,7464.3 given7464.53 what7464.77 we've7464.93 got7465.09 going7465.34 on7465.49 with7465.73 FY7466.05 26,7466.3 that7466.69 we're7466.85 going7467.01 to7467.26 see7467.26 the7467.41 same7467.49 thing.7467.65 And7468.05 so7468.3 I7468.61 I7468.77 think7468.77 that7469.01 the7469.18 smartest7469.34 way7469.81 to7469.97 go7470.05 for7470.22 the7470.38 next7470.45 few7470.77 years7470.93 is7471.26 this7471.49 idea7471.65 of7472.05 you're7472.38 probably7472.65 going7472.89 to7472.97 have7472.97 about7473.21 $2.47475.21 billion,7475.37 $2.67475.37 billion7475.37 to7475.93 work7476.01 with7476.25 on7476.89 a7477.05 kind7477.61 of7477.85 straight7478.25 line7478.57 basis.7478.89 And7479.61 then7479.77 after7479.93 a7480.17 few7480.25 years,7480.33 you7480.57 may7480.65 want7480.81 to7481.05 adjust7481.05 that7481.37 up7481.53 a7481.61 little7481.69 bit7481.85 if7482.01 we've7482.17 seen7482.33 that7482.57 we7482.89 continue7483.05 to7483.53 see7483.69 big7483.93 growth,7484.09 or7484.33 maybe7484.57 you7484.81 start7484.97 to7485.21 see7485.29 some7485.45 behavioral7485.61 impacts7486.01 that7486.41 require7486.49 you7486.89 to7486.97 downgrade7487.13 that.7487.61 But7487.93 I7488.09 think7488.17 the7488.41 challenge7488.63 for7489.26 next7489.43 year's7489.59 budget7489.82 is,7490.15 like,7490.3 the7490.78 average7491.02 may7491.34 be7491.51 that,7491.66 but7492.06 what's7492.22 going7492.47 to7492.7 happen7492.7 from7492.94 year7493.1 to7493.34 year?7493.43 And7493.59 that7493.98 is7494.15 why7494.3 I7494.55 think7494.63 the7494.78 structure7494.94 that7495.26 you7495.43 folks7495.59 put7495.82 in7495.98 place7496.06 makes7496.94 a7497.19 lot7497.34 of7497.51 sense.7497.59 And7497.82 sticking7497.98 probably7498.39 around7498.78 that7499.02 ,1.957499.19 billion7500.47 threshold7500.47 for7501.02 ongoing7502.17 operating7502.49 spending.7503.77 You7503.93 probably7503.93 don't7504.17 want7504.33 to7504.57 go7504.57 too7504.73 much7504.81 north7505.13 of7505.29 that7505.45 in7505.61 the7505.77 next7505.85 year7506.09 or7506.33 two.7506.57
7507.61 MICHLEWITZ7507.61 -7507.61 Well,7507.61 I7507.85 appreciate7508.01 that.7508.41 I'll7509.93 follow-up7510.01 and7510.49 say7510.73 that,7510.89 you7511.13 know,7511.29 I7511.37 think7511.45 to7512.09 your7512.25 point,7512.49 pinpointing7512.73 this7513.29 is7513.45 going7513.61 to7513.93 be7513.93 very7514.01 difficult.7514.25 Trying7514.57 to7514.81 create7514.98 us7515.23 to7515.39 have7515.47 flexibility,7515.78 and7517.06 allowing7517.3 us7517.63 to7517.94 have7518.19 that7518.59 flexibility7518.82 through7519.47 whatever7520.43 process7520.9 we7521.15 decide7521.39 to7521.63 take7521.7 this7521.94 in7522.1 is7522.26 going7522.34 to7522.59 be7522.59 important,7522.74 because7524.34 as7525.23 we've7525.39 seen,7525.63 no7526.1 one7526.26 got7526.51 very7527.23 few7527.55 got7527.78 it7527.94 right7528.1 the7528.34 first7528.43 time.7528.66 I'm7529.77 you7530.17 know,7530.33 we'll7530.49 see7530.73 what7530.89 we7531.05 were,7531.29 how7531.53 far7531.77 off7532.01 we7532.17 are7532.41 the7532.57 second7532.65 time,7532.89 and7533.21 hopefully,7533.37 we'll7533.69 get7533.85 a7534.01 little7534.09 closer7534.33 on7534.73 the7534.89 third7534.97 time.7535.13 And7536.01 so7536.25 I7536.41 appreciate7536.81 that7537.29 that7537.53 flexibility7538.09 conversation7538.73 is7539.37 a7540.01 component7540.09 of7540.57 how7540.73 we7540.89 can7541.05 do7541.21 these7541.29 budgets7541.53 in7541.85 relation7542.01 to7542.49 that.7542.57 So7542.73 thank7542.97 you.Senator7543.13 Collins.7545.03
7545.03 COLLIS7545.03 -7545.03 Thank7546.95 you,7547.2 Chair7551.03 Michlewitz.7551.03 Just7551.03 to7551.35 clarify,7551.52 what7551.99 are7552.88 you7553.03 recommending7553.44 the7554.16 threshold7554.48 be7555.11 for7555.27 the7555.44 utilization7555.52 of7556.31 this7556.48 fund7557.27 for7557.68 the7559.06 backing7559.38 of7559.7 bonds7559.86 versus7560.26 operational7561.22 cash7561.94 expenditures?7562.74
7563.94 HOWGATE7563.94 -7563.94 So7563.94 the7564.26 supplemental7565.3 budget7565.7 that7565.94 Governor7566.42 Healey7566.66 filed7566.66 includes7567.06 about7567.38 $1,37567.62 billion,7568.82 which7568.82 is7568.98 basically7569.14 the7569.54 balance7570.42 of7570.74 this7570.9 fund.7571.14 And7571.65 what7571.73 we're7571.97 saying7572.05 is7572.28 we7572.6 believe7572.93 that7573.24 this7573.4 fund7573.65 should7573.97 really7574.13 primarily7574.36 be7574.93 used7575.09 for7575.4 those7576.05 capital,7576.36 needs7577.16 innovative7577.56 one7578.36 time7578.6 things.7578.84
7580.13 COLLINS7580.13 -7580.13 So7580.13 what7580.44 percentage7580.69 of7581.16 the7581.4 because7581.89 you7582.13 talked7582.36 about7582.52 the7582.77 potential7582.93 fluctuation7583.4 going7583.97 forward.7584.2 If7584.6 you7584.77 were7584.93 to7585.01 give7585.16 a7585.32 percentage7585.48 of7585.89 what7585.97 you7586.2 think7586.28 we7586.52 should7586.69 leave7586.84 for7588.58 the7589.78 backing7589.94 of7590.34 capital7590.5 expenditures7590.98 versus7591.62 utilization7592.74 for7593.22 cash7593.38 incentives?7593.62
7594.1 HOWGATE7594.1 -7594.1 So7594.1 the7594.26 way7594.34 the7594.58 structure7594.74 works7595.14 right7595.3 now7595.46 is7595.7 we7595.78 would7596.1 estimate7596.26 it7596.82 about7596.98 probably7597.22 between7597.62 $4007598.66 and7598.9 $5007598.9 million7598.9 a7599.46 year.7599.62 Is7599.78 it7599.94 what's7600.02 going7600.27 to7600.43 be7600.43 in7600.59 there?7600.86 I7601.15 think7601.23 what7601.39 we7601.63 will7601.78 probably7601.94 need7602.19 to7602.35 recalibrate7602.51 is7603.06 what7603.23 that7603.39 balance7603.63 should7604.02 be.7604.19 I7604.43 think7604.51 as7604.66 Chair7605.31 Michlewitz7605.47 was7605.47 just7605.55 pointing7605.7 out,7605.86 when7606.1 we7606.27 put7606.35 together7606.59 that7606.91 structure,7607.15 I7607.7 don't7607.78 think7607.94 people7608.1 knew7608.27 if7608.43 it7608.59 was7608.66 going7608.74 to7608.98 be7608.98 two7609.94 billion,7610.02 2.47610.66 billion7610.91 or7610.91 2.87610.91 billion.7610.91 And7611.31 so7611.47 once7611.63 we7611.86 start7612.02 to7612.27 get7612.35 a7612.43 better7612.51 sense7612.77 of7612.93 where7613.17 those7613.25 numbers7613.57 land,7613.97 I7614.61 think7614.69 there7614.85 is7615.09 another7615.25 conversation7615.57 to7616.05 have7616.13 about7616.45 what7616.77 is7617.01 the7617.25 right7617.33 distribution7617.57 of7618.21 ongoing7618.45 operating7619.09 versus7619.73 that7620.13 capital7620.29 and7620.69 innovation.7620.77 I7621.57 think7621.73 this7622.53 is7622.77 going7622.93 to7623.17 be7623.17 an7623.25 interesting7623.41 year7623.73 because7623.97 we7624.21 have7624.37 a7624.61 significant7624.77 balance7625.33 in7625.65 this7625.81 fund,7625.97 right.7626.37
7626.53 Which7626.53 is7626.53 going7626.69 to7626.93 be7626.93 reduced.7627.09 I7627.9 think7628.06 looking7628.45 at7628.77 it7629.02 next7629.18 year7629.41 and7629.57 the7629.73 year7629.81 forward7630.06 to7630.38 see7630.45 if7630.69 that7630.85 if7631.26 we7631.34 are7631.57 right,7631.73 that7631.9 it7632.14 ends7632.3 up7632.61 stabilizing7632.77 at7633.34 4007634.22 or7634.61 5007634.61 or7634.61 we're7634.77 wrong,7634.94 and7635.81 then7635.98 seeing7636.22 how7636.45 that7636.69 fits7637.02 into7637.34 the7637.73 needs7637.9 in7638.14 the7638.3 capital7638.45 budget7638.77 versus7639.02 the7639.26 operating7639.34 budget.7639.65 I7639.9 will7640.06 say7640.22 just7640.45 as7640.61 part7640.77 of7640.94 that,7641.09 one7641.47 of7641.55 the7641.71 things7641.79 Governor7642.51 Healey7642.91 proposes7642.91 in7643.23 her7643.31 budget7643.47 is7643.79 securitizing7643.95 $7657645.15 million7647.07 in7647.07 operating7647.79 surtax7648.51 dollars7648.91 through7649.23 the7649.39 Commonwealth7649.47 Transportation7649.95 Funds.7650.59 That's7651.07 something7651.23 we've7651.47 supported,7651.87 because7653.15 that7653.47 allows7653.79 our7654.35 kind7654.95 of7655.11 capital7655.27 dollars7655.76 to7656.07 go7656.15 farther.7656.4 Right?7656.8 So7657.03 I7657.19 think7657.27 part7657.76 of7657.99 what7658.23 is7658.4 necessary7658.64 in7659.11 this7659.35 versus7659.6 the7660.07 operating7660.31 budget7660.72 is7661.03 also7661.11 determined7661.35 by7661.76 some7661.91 of7662.07 the7662.15 choices7662.31 that7662.64 are7662.8 made7662.95 in7663.52 some7663.76 of7663.91 those7663.99 other7664.15 proposals7664.4 that7664.88 are7665.03 before7665.11 you7665.68 folks7665.91
7666.56 COLLINS7666.56 -7666.56 Thank7666.56 you.7666.8
7675.27 MICHLEWITZ7675.27 -7675.27 Representative7675.83 Ferrante.7676.71
7676.71 REP7676.71 FERRANTE7676.71 -7676.71 How7676.71 are7677.03 you7677.11 doing7677.27 today?7677.51 I7677.91 just7678.55 want7678.71 to7679.03 go7679.03 outside7679.27 of7679.98 FareShare7680.86 for7681.1 a7681.26 minute7681.34 because7681.66 you7682.06 tend7682.78 to7683.02 provide7683.34 so7684.63 much7684.78 insightful7685.1 advice7686.39 on7686.78 so7687.02 many7687.19 different7687.43 levels.7687.74
7688.3 HOWGATE7688.3 -7688.3 Thank7688.3 you.7688.47
7689.02 FERRANTE7689.02 -7689.02 I7689.02 don't7689.19 think7689.34 we7689.51 noticed7690.23 that7690.7 yesterday,7691.19 the7692.16 federal7692.4 government7692.88 announced7693.68 enormous7694.24 tariffs,7694.72 which7696.24 I7696.72 think7696.8 you7697.12 and7697.28 I7697.44 would7697.52 both7697.68 agree7697.92 are7698.24 a7698.48 tax7698.56 on7698.88 the7699.52 consumers,7699.76 anywhere7700.56 from7700.96 107701.36 to7701.6 50%7701.76 depending7702.48 on7702.88 the7703.44 goods7703.6 that7703.84 we're7704 looking7704.24 at.7704.48 In7705.36 addition7705.52 to7705.93 that,7706.16 the7706.97 president7707.28 has7707.93 said7708.16 that7708.4 he7708.56 wants7708.81 to7709.13 give7710.65 a7710.81 massive7710.89 tax7711.44 cut7711.77 and7713.05 at7713.6 the7713.93 same7714.09 time7714.4 bring7715.28 down7715.6 government7715.85 spending.7716.32 And7717.33 as7717.49 we7717.65 look7717.81 at7718.13 those7718.37 three7718.69 factors,7719.01 I7719.49 don't7719.65 think,7719.97 you7720.29 know,7720.45 we7720.61 can7720.77 all7720.93 talk7721.17 about7721.33 what7721.65 happened7721.81 during7722.13 the7722.37 Great7722.45 Depression.7722.69 I7723.49 think7723.57 separate7723.89 and7724.21 aside,7724.45 this7724.85 is7725.09 really7725.25 different,7725.57 because7725.89 he7726.13 has7726.29 a7726.85 number7727.01 of7727.33 volatile7727.57 pieces7728.13 moving7728.61 simultaneously7729.17 at7730.53 the7730.77 same7730.93 time,7731.25 not7731.65 because7731.97 of7732.53 outside7734.02 forces,7734.51 but7734.98 forces7735.15 that7735.55 are7735.78 all7735.86 within7736.02 his7736.35 control.7736.59 In7737.63 terms7737.78 of7738.1 instability,7738.43 what7739.15 would7739.31 you7739.47 predict7739.7 right7740.19 now?7740.43 And7741.31 I7741.47 know7741.63 that's7741.78 hard7742.02 because7742.27 of7742.51 the7742.59 amount7742.74 of7742.98 volatility7743.23 and7743.86 instability,7744.35 but7745.15 I'm7745.31 just7745.55 curious7745.7 as7746.27 to7746.51 what7747.03 your7747.27 outlook7748.39 is7748.87 and7749.19 I7749.43 know7749.51 it7749.67 could7749.83 change7749.99 tomorrow7750.23 with7750.71 whatever7750.95 he7751.27 decides.7751.51 But7752.87 what7753.19 are7753.51 you7753.67 thinking7753.83 right7754.23 now7754.39 in7754.63 terms7754.79 of7755.11 where7755.83 we're7756.07 at?7756.31
7757.35 HOWGATE7757.35 -7757.35 Yeah.7757.35 Great7757.91 question.7758.15 And7758.71 we're7759.43 going7759.59 to7760.06 publish7760.06 something7760.3 next7760.47 week7760.63 that7760.94 gets7761.1 to7761.26 that7761.43 a7761.51 little7761.59 bit7761.74 of7761.9 just7761.98 kind7762.15 of7762.39 how7762.39 to7762.47 think7762.55 about7762.78 some7762.94 of7763.02 these7763.1 things.7763.26 We7763.51 don't7763.59 have7763.74 any7763.9 answers7764.06 just7764.39 like7764.55 anyone7764.7 else7764.86 doesn't7765.1 have7765.34 any7765.51 answers.7765.66 But7766.06 there's7766.3 four7767.34 things7767.51 in7767.74 what7767.9 you7768.06 talked7768.22 about.7768.47 Right?7768.7 We7769.26 will7769.43 know7769.66 what7769.82 the7770.06 feds7770.15 do7770.47 with7770.63 their7770.78 budget7770.94 in7771.66 probably7772.55 July.7772.86 Right?7773.51 And7773.67 we7773.83 will7773.99 probably7774.15 know7774.47 what7774.63 happens7774.79 in7775.19 terms7775.27 of7775.51 Tax7776.79 Cuts7777.03 and7777.27 Jobs7777.43 Act7777.83 extension.7778.07 And7778.63 so7778.79 those7779.03 will7779.19 be7779.35 things7779.51 that7779.75 we7779.91 will7779.99 know7780.15 what7780.39 will7780.55 happen.7780.63 What7781.27 the7781.51 total7781.67 impacts7781.99 on7782.31 Massachusetts7782.47 will7782.95 be7783.11 a7783.27 little7783.35 unclear.7783.51 I7784.07 think7784.15 the7784.31 things7786.23 that7786.55 are7786.71 more7787.19 challenging7788.26 because7788.49 they're7788.9 more7788.98 uncertain7789.3 just7789.85 in7790.02 terms7790.18 of7790.41 how7790.57 to7790.74 plan7790.81 for7791.06 them7791.3 are7791.53 what7791.85 happens7792.1 to7792.41 the7792.49 global7792.66 economy.7793.06
7793.61 Right?7793.61 And7794.18 also7794.34 what7794.66 happens7794.9 in7795.22 terms7795.38 of7795.7 take,7796.1 for7796.41 example,7796.57 federal7797.3 regulatory7797.77 action7798.41 or7798.81 federal7799.06 administrative7799.53 action7800.1 through7800.57 things7800.81 like7801.14 the7801.45 centers7801.61 for7802.02 Medicaid7802.18 and7802.57 Medicare.7802.74 Right?7803.14 We7803.78 can7803.94 know7804.02 what7804.26 congress7804.58 wants7804.9 to7805.14 do7805.22 with7805.38 Medicaid,7805.54 but7806.1 it's7806.26 hard7806.42 to7806.66 know7806.74 what7807.06 the,7807.86 actually,7808.18 administration7808.58 is7809.38 going7809.54 to7809.86 do7809.94 in7810.26 terms7810.42 of7810.66 compliance7811.06 requirements7811.62 and7812.02 things7812.18 like7812.42 that.7812.58 And7812.74 so7812.98 you7813.7 can7813.86 only7814.1 kind7814.42 of7814.66 plan7814.82 for7815.14 the7815.38 information7815.46 you7816.02 have.7816.18 And7816.34 so7816.5 that's7816.66 why7816.82 I7816.98 do7817.14 think7817.22 as7817.46 you7817.62 think7817.7 about7817.94 the7818.58 the7819.02 actions7819.26 that7819.59 the7819.82 house7819.9 senate7820.15 administration7820.47 are7820.94 taking,7821.1 keying7821.82 in7822.15 on7822.3 the7822.63 congressional7822.86 budget7823.43 process7823.74 and7824.15 the7824.3 tax7824.47 cuts7824.7 extension7825.1 along7825.74 with7826.06 what's7826.22 going7826.47 on7826.63 in7826.78 the7826.86 stock7827.02 market7827.19 and7827.43 what's7827.59 going7827.74 on7827.9 with7828.06 the7828.22 economy,7828.39 those7828.78 are7829.02 the7829.1 three7829.26 things7829.43 we7829.66 can7829.82 best7829.98 track7830.22 day7830.47 to7830.63 day7830.78 to7830.94 day7831.02 because7831.59 I7831.82 think7831.9 we're7832.06 going7832.22 to7832.47 have7832.47 to7832.63 hedge7832.86 quite7833.26 a7833.51 bit7833.59 for7833.9 federal7834.81 policy7835.13 uncertainty7835.69 that's7836.25 going7836.57 to7836.81 continue7836.81 to7837.29 be,7837.37 I'm7837.93 sure,7838.17 quite7838.65 a7838.89 roller7839.05 coaster7839.37 ride,7839.77 you7840.73 know7840.81 for7841.05 the7841.21 next7841.37 three7841.61 plus7841.93 years.7842.25
7846.57 MICHLEWITZ7846.57 -7846.57 Senator7846.57 Comerford?7847.05
7849.7 COMERFORD7849.7 -7849.7 Thank7849.7 you7849.95 so7850.1 much,7850.19 Mr.7850.74 Chair.7851.78 Doug,7851.78 thank7852.1 you.7852.27 And7852.59 thank7852.74 you7852.99 for7853.15 your7853.31 I'll7853.63 start7853.78 by7854.1 thanking7854.19 you7854.51 for7854.74 your7856.03 recommendation,7856.35 right,7856.91 that7857.15 the7857.31 administration7857.47 brings7858.1 in7858.43 the7858.59 House7858.66 and7858.91 the7858.99 Senate7859.15 to7859.47 problem7859.7 solve7860.1 in7860.35 real7860.51 time7860.74 the7861.63 impact7861.86 of7862.59 federal7863.34 cuts7863.66 and7864.06 policy7864.3 shifts.7864.78 I7865.1 think7865.26 that's7865.42 right.7865.74 Let's7867.66 talk7867.9 about7868.14 regional7868.14 equity.7868.62 I7869.34 think7869.66 this7869.9 is7870.14 not7870.22 surprising7870.78 to7871.26 you.7871.42 So7872.3 I7872.7 heard7872.86 you7873.18 make7873.5 the7873.74 case7873.9 for7874.22 the7875.02 MBTA7875.26 funding7875.9 that's7876.3 in7876.7 the7876.94 proposals,7877.18 both,7877.91 I7878.07 think,7878.23 H.7878.48 17878.72 and7878.88 H.7879.03 55.7879.19 And7881.44 I7882.15 know7882.31 you7882.64 were7882.8 here7883.03 when7883.27 I7883.52 pointed7883.76 out7884.07 this7884.31 79%7884.88 versus7886.07 8%7886.48 discrepancy.7887.11 Right?7887.91 That's7888.31 real.7888.56 That's7888.95 when7889.35 we7889.59 look7889.76 at7889.91 both7889.99 of7890.23 these7890.4 proposals,7890.56 which7891.03 Secretary7891.85 Gorzkowicz7892.25 suggested7892.89 that7893.21 we7893.37 did,7893.53 as,7894.81 you7895.13 know,7895.29 sister7895.53 proposals,7896.01 that's7896.65 the7896.97 discrepancy.7897.21 So7898.17 how7898.81 do7899.53 you7899.85 think7900.65 in7901.53 your7901.77 big7902.01 brain7902.25 we7903.05 can7903.29 achieve7903.61 better7904.17 regional7904.49 equity?7905.05 And7906.6 is7906.99 it7907.16 securitizing7907.88 RTA7909.16 funding7909.64 like7910.03 we're7910.28 proposing7910.44 to7910.84 do7910.99 with7911.16 the7911.24 MBTA?7911.4 Can7912.03 we7912.2 not7912.84 do7913.16 competitive7913.48 grants7914.03 for7914.35 goodness7914.6 sake,7914.91 because7916.2 the7916.52 small7916.68 guys7916.99 always7917.24 get7917.48 left7917.72 out?7917.95 Like,7918.2 what7918.44 do7918.6 we7918.76 do,7918.84 Doug?7919.07
7920.11 HOWGATE7920.11 -7920.11 So7920.11 let7921.56 me7921.8 answer7922.12 that7922.44 in7922.6 two7922.76 ways7922.92 as7923.16 well.7923.32 I7923.64 think7923.72 that7923.96 in7925.64 terms7925.8 of7926.04 the7926.2 focus7926.36 we7926.76 heard7926.92 from7927.16 several,7927.48 of7928.04 the7928.2 members7928.28 of7928.6 committees7928.68 in,7929.08 in7929.4 regional7929.56 equity,7929.88 I7930.2 think7930.28 there7930.44 are7930.6 ways7930.76 to7930.92 improve7931.08 that.7931.4 What7931.96 I7932.28 worry7932.52 about7932.92 is7933.4 we7934.15 end7934.39 up7934.55 with7934.7 a7934.86 neither7934.94 nor7935.34 approach7935.74 where7936.15 we7936.47 don't7936.55 do7936.7 what's7936.86 sufficient7937.1 for7937.51 the7937.59 MBTA7937.74 and7938.22 we7938.47 don't7938.63 do7938.78 what's7938.86 sufficient7939.1 for7939.43 regional7939.59 equity.7939.9 Right?7940.22 And7940.39 so7940.55 I7940.63 would7940.78 just7940.94 warn7941.18 the7941.9 committees7942.06 as7942.55 you7942.7 think7942.78 about7942.94 wherever7943.18 you7943.51 land7943.66 on7943.9 these7944.06 things,7944.22 is7945.34 there7945.51 a7945.74 way7945.82 to7945.98 accomplish7946.15 significant7946.55 resources7947.1 for7947.43 transportation,7947.59 addressing7948.47 MBTA7948.94 budget7949.34 gaps,7949.64 and7949.88 making7950.04 meaningful7950.36 improvement7950.84 in7951.48 terms7951.56 of7951.88 regional7951.96 equity,7952.36 micro7952.76 transit7953 RTAs?7953.4 I7953.96 think7954.04 the7954.12 answer7954.28 is7954.52 yes.7954.68 Right?7955 I7955.88 will7956.28 say7956.6 part7957.16 of7957.4 this7957.56 is7957.8 context,7957.96 and7958.52 this7959.64 is7959.88 neither7960.04 good,7960.44 bad,7960.68 nor7960.92 indifferent,7961.08 but7961.56 it7961.72 is7961.88 true.7962.12
7963.1 RTA7963.1 support7963.57 in7963.9 the7964.06 budget7964.22 has7964.69 more7965.18 than7965.41 doubled7965.57 in7965.98 the7966.06 last7966.14 three7966.38 years.7966.61 Now7967.18 that's7967.41 not7967.65 to7967.9 say7967.98 that7968.22 it7968.77 was7968.85 enough7969.02 before,7969.34 it's7969.65 enough7969.9 now,7970.14 but7970.61 part7970.85 of7971.02 this7971.1 is7971.34 kind7971.49 of7971.73 building7971.73 on7972.06 what7972.22 came7972.38 before.7972.69 Right?7973.1 And7973.34 and7973.65 and7973.98 the7974.14 unfortunate7974.61 reality,7975.18 especially7975.65 in7976.06 an7976.22 area7976.3 like7976.53 micro7976.69 transit,7977.02 which7977.34 historically7977.49 has7977.98 gotten7978.14 nothing7978.54 from7978.86 the7979.02 state7979.1 budget,7979.42 you7980.46 gotta7980.7 build7980.94 up7981.18 from7981.34 nothing.7981.5 Right?7981.9 And7982.22 I7982.46 do7982.62 when7983.02 you7983.18 look7983.34 at7983.5 some7983.66 of7983.9 the,7983.98 I7984.06 think,7984.22 really7984.46 meaningful7984.78 impacts7985.26 that7985.82 microtransit7986.14 grants7986.78 could7987.1 have7987.26 around7987.58 the7987.82 Commonwealth,7987.98 they7988.78 seem7989.02 like7989.26 an7989.42 area7989.58 where7989.82 you7990.14 get7990.3 a7990.46 lot7990.54 of7990.7 bang7990.86 for7991.1 your7991.26 buck7991.34 in7991.58 terms7991.74 of7991.98 connected7992.06 communities7992.54 that7993.2 don't7993.35 have7993.52 reliable7993.68 transportation7994.24 in7994.88 a7995.03 way7995.2 that7995.6 comes7995.84 at7996.07 a7996.24 relatively7996.31 low7997.11 cost7997.35 big7997.84 picture7998.07 wise.7998.4 I7998.95 think7999.03 when7999.2 we7999.35 look7999.52 at7999.76 RTA7999.91 support8000.48 and8001.03 look8001.2 at8001.52 the8002.56 composition8002.88 of8003.52 the8003.68 grants,8003.84 predictability8004.31 versus8005.52 competitive8005.91 grants.8007.27
8007.51 Obviously,8007.51 you8007.51 want8007.75 to8007.99 make8007.99 sure,8008.15 and8008.39 I8008.47 think8008.55 this8008.71 is8008.79 an8008.87 issue8009.03 that's8009.27 been8009.43 attention8009.59 in8009.91 the8010.07 past,8010.15 how8010.31 do8010.47 we8010.63 make8010.71 sure8010.87 that8012.23 different8012.87 RTAs8012.87 are8013.27 run8013.43 efficiently8013.83 and8014.23 things8014.39 like8014.55 that.8014.71 But8014.95 as8015.19 I8015.35 said8015.43 before,8015.67 one8016.15 of8016.31 the8016.39 things8016.47 we're8016.71 trying8016.87 to8017.11 do8017.27 for8017.35 the8017.51 MBTA8017.59 is8018.07 provide8018.15 them8018.39 with8018.55 some8018.71 budget8018.79 predictability.8020.23 That8021.26 argument8021.34 certainly8021.65 applies8022.05 to8022.38 any8022.53 transportation8022.85 agency8023.41 around8023.81 the8024.09 commonwealth.8024.85 Right?8025.34 And8025.65 so8025.81 I8025.9 think8025.97 that's8026.22 a8026.38 part8026.53 of8026.69 the8026.85 conversation8026.93 as8027.41 well.8027.57 I8027.97 think8028.05 the8028.3 other8028.38 part8028.69 of8028.85 it8028.93 is8029.18 so8029.73 much8029.9 of8030.05 what8030.22 was8030.3 in,8030.45 especially8030.69 the8031.01 securitization8031.26 of8031.9 the8032.05 7658032.14 is8033.27 really8033.43 about8033.59 what8033.91 we8034.07 do8034.23 on8034.39 the8034.55 capital8034.71 side.8035.03 Right?8035.35 It's8035.91 Chapter8036.31 90,8036.71 but8036.95 it's8037.11 other8037.27 things8037.51 as8037.75 well.8037.91 And8038.39 a8038.51 lot8038.63 of8038.79 that's8038.95 kind8039.19 of8039.75 still8039.75 a8040.23 little8040.31 blank8040.55 canvas8040.87 in8041.27 terms8041.35 of8041.59 what8041.67 would8041.83 happen8041.99 there,8042.31 and8042.47 I8042.55 think8042.63 that's8042.79 another8043.03 opportunity8043.27 to8043.75 have8043.83 that8043.91 conversation.8044.15 So8044.55 those8044.71 would8044.87 be8045.03 just8045.19 a8045.43 few8045.51 things8045.67 off8045.83 the8045.99 top8046.07 of8046.23 my8046.39 head.8046.47
8047.44 COMERFORD8047.44 -8047.44 That's8047.44 really8047.68 helpful.8047.91 I8048.31 actually8048.48 think8048.72 that's8048.88 very8049.11 helpful8049.44 in8049.84 terms8049.99 of8050.23 capital,8050.4 because8051.27 we'll8051.52 need8051.76 these8051.99 little8052.23 zippy8052.55 microbuses,8053.11 right,8054.07 for8054.4 these8054.55 RTAs.8054.8 I'll8055.44 just8055.68 say,8055.84 you8056.07 know,8056.23 our8056.48 the8056.95 RTA8057.19 would8057.68 say8057.91 to8058.15 you,8058.31 and8058.8 they're8058.95 not8059.19 monoliths,8059.35 that8060.42 they8060.58 are8060.9 they8061.14 live8061.38 within8061.7 their8062.02 budgets8062.26 all8062.9 the8063.06 time,8063.3 whereas8063.86 the8064.26 MBTA,8064.42 no8065.86 shade8066.1 on8066.42 the8066.66 current8066.82 general,8067.22 manager,8068.26 but8068.66 the8068.9 MBTA8069.06 continues8069.7 to8070.26 come8070.34 saying,8070.9 oh,8071.14 sorry.8071.3 You8071.62 know8071.78 what?8071.94 We8072.18 just8072.26 couldn't8072.5 make8072.82 that8072.98 meeting,8073.22 and8073.54 we8073.7 continue8073.94 to8074.34 give8074.42 them8074.58 money.8074.82 So8075.85 I,8076.18 you8076.34 know,8076.41 I8077.3 have8077.45 a8077.7 little8077.78 concern8078.57 about8078.9 that.8079.22 Thank8079.38 you,8079.53 Doug.8079.7
8080.1 HOWGATE8080.1 -8080.1 And8080.1 I8080.34 would8080.41 just8080.57 say8080.74 I8080.98 absolutely8081.14 hear8081.45 that.8081.7 The8081.85 other8082.02 thing8082.18 that8082.34 I8082.57 think8082.66 is8082.81 important8082.98 in8083.38 context8083.45 is8083.7 that8083.7 the8083.94 MBTA8084.02 is,8084.66 if8084.9 not8085.06 the8085.3 largest8085.38 state,8085.85 the8086.41 MBTA8086.57 operates8087.06 hundreds,8087.81 if8088.13 not8088.37 thousands8088.53 of8088.93 miles8089.09 of8089.49 heavy8089.57 rail,8089.89 and8090.13 it8090.53 does8090.69 a8090.93 lot8091.01 of8091.17 stuff.8091.33 Right?8091.73 And8091.89 so8092.05 I8092.29 do8092.37 think8092.45 there8092.69 is8092.85 it8093.17 hap8093.41 you8093.57 know,8093.73 it8093.89 is8095.57 important8095.73 for8096.13 us8096.29 to8096.45 kind8096.69 of8096.85 take8097.17 into8097.33 account8097.57 as8097.89 well8098.05 that8098.85 the8099.09 size8099.74 and8099.98 the8100.23 value8100.47 that8100.86 that8101.19 Boston8101.51 and8101.9 Massachusetts8102.06 accrue8102.78 from8103.1 a8103.34 heavy8103.51 rail8103.74 system8103.98 that8104.3 very8104.55 few8104.78 other8105.02 cities8105.26 in8105.66 the8105.74 country.8106.3 Right?8106.7 And8107.51 so8107.82 that's8108.23 the8109.51 system8109.66 we're8109.98 in,8110.15 and8110.39 it8110.55 is8110.78 going8110.86 to8111.19 be8111.19 an8111.34 expensive8111.51 system8111.9 to8112.3 maintain,8112.39 but8112.86 that8113.02 doesn't8113.19 mean8113.59 that8113.98 we8114.18 can't8114.26 have8114.42 a8114.58 similar8114.82 level8115.06 of8115.3 prioritization8115.46 in8115.94 other8116.02 areas.8116.34 I8116.98 really8117.14 believe8117.3 there's8117.54 a8117.78 way8117.86 to8118.02 kind8118.1 of8118.42 do8118.42 both8118.58 of8118.74 those8118.9 things.8119.14
8122.58 MICHLEWITZ8122.58 -8122.58 Chair8122.58 Rorodrigues8122.58
8122.58 RODRIGUES8122.58 -8122.58 Thank8124.5 you,8124.74 Mr.8125.86 Chairman.8126.26 Doug,8126.26 great8126.5 to8126.74 see8126.82 you.8126.98 Thank8127.14 you8127.3 very8127.46 much8127.7 for8127.86 your8128.02 testimony.8128.18 I8130.05 appreciate8130.28 your8131.56 comments8131.81 on8132.2 the8132.45 potential8132.69 volatility8133.24 of8134.36 FareShare8134.93 revenue.8135.16 And8136.28 I8136.85 know8136.93 we're8137.09 here8137.32 to8137.56 talk8137.73 about8137.97 today8138.36 the8138.85 FY8139.97 258140.28 supplemental8140.85 with8141.49 the8141.73 surplus8141.81 that8142.28 it's8142.45 a8142.69 known8142.77 number.8143.01 Right?8143.47 It's8143.71 a8143.87 fixed8144.67 number.8145.15 But8146.27 we8146.59 are8146.75 also8146.99 concurrently8147.55 working8148.19 on8148.59 the8148.75 FY8148.99 268149.39 operating8149.87 budget,8150.35 which8150.67 includes8150.91 a8152.59 FareShare8152.99 consensus8153.23 revenue8153.87 spend8154.27 in8154.59 the8154.75 budget8154.83 of8155.15 1.95.8155.31 Things8158.09 are8158.24 happening8158.4 quickly.8158.8 We8159.2 saw8160.01 the8162.16 tariff8162.56 announcement.8163.05 I8163.97 think8164.01 the8164.32 Dow8164.56 Jones8164.89 is8165.2 down8165.28 1,3008167.2 points8167.84 already8168.16 today.8168.48 Who8170.73 knows8170.89 where8171.2 it's8171.44 going8171.6 to8171.84 go,8171.84 if8172.01 it's8172.16 going8172.32 to8172.65 rebound.8172.65 All8173.69 indications8173.93 are,8174.57 for8174.97 what8175.13 I'm8175.29 hearing,8175.45 it's8175.77 only8176.01 going8176.25 to8176.49 get8176.49 worse8176.65 before8176.97 it8177.21 gets8177.37 better.8177.61 Should8178.73 we8179.13 be8179.53 reconsidering8180.49 what8182.57 we8182.89 had8183.05 proposed8183.37 for8183.93 FY8184.33 268184.65 given8185.21 the8185.53 actions8185.69 of8187.05 the8187.13 president?8187.29
8189.35 HOWGATE8189.35 -8189.35 It's8189.35 a8189.51 great8189.59 question.8189.66 And8190.27 my8191.02 answer8191.27 would8191.59 be8191.82 a8191.99 provisional8192.15 no.8192.7 And8193.1 I'll8193.91 answer8194.31 it8195.75 that8195.83 way8195.99 for8196.15 this8196.39 reason.8196.55 We8198.63 still8198.94 are8199.5 at8199.91 about8200.07 the8200.7 halftime8201.02 of8201.75 the8201.91 budget8202.07 process.8202.39 Right?8202.9 We're8203.06 going8203.14 to8203.3 have8203.3 the8203.54 house8203.62 budget8203.94 in8204.18 a8204.42 couple8204.5 weeks.8204.66 We're8204.9 going8205.06 to8205.22 have8205.22 the8205.3 senate8205.38 budget,8205.7 and8205.94 then8206.1 we8206.26 will8206.34 have,8206.58 you8207.3 know,8207.46 the8207.54 conference8208.26 committee8208.58 process8208.98 that8209.3 will8209.46 take8209.62 us8209.78 through8209.94 certainly8210.26 June.8210.66 Right?8211.06 And8211.94 we8212.18 will8212.34 have8212.66 more8212.98 information8213.3 there8214.02 as8214.34 we8214.5 go.8214.66 And8215.14 so8215.46 the8215.7 question8215.86 is,8216.34 as8216.95 you8217.19 think8217.35 about8217.67 making8218.4 adjustments8218.8 to8219.27 revenue8219.43 assumptions,8219.83 making8220.31 spending8220.72 adjustments,8221.03 when8221.92 are8222.16 those8222.23 adjustments8222.48 most8223.03 thoughtfully8223.35 made?8223.92 And8224.8 the8225.19 answer8225.35 obviously8225.59 is8225.92 before8226.31 the8226.64 process8226.72 starts.8227.11 That's8227.35 the8227.51 best8227.67 time8227.83 to8228.08 make8228.16 them.8228.31 Right?8228.56 And8228.64 when8229.11 consensus8229.27 revenue8229.75 happens,8230.08 that's8230.4 the8230.56 best8230.64 time8230.88 to8231.03 make8231.19 them.8231.27
8231.66 That's8231.66 not8231.82 the8231.94 world8232.06 we're8232.46 in.8232.54 And8233.74 so8233.98 the8235.02 question8235.26 is8235.58 if8235.9 you8235.98 were8236.14 to8236.3 make8236.46 different8237.82 assumptions8238.3 now,8238.94 what8239.42 would8239.58 that8239.82 be8239.98 based8240.22 on,8240.46 and8240.7 would8240.86 they8241.02 be8241.18 better8241.34 than8241.58 the8241.74 assumptions8241.9 you'll8242.38 make8242.54 in8242.7 May8242.94 or8243.1 June8243.26 once8243.58 you8243.74 see8243.98 some8244.14 of8244.3 those8244.38 numbers?8244.62 And8245.57 my8245.81 gut8246.36 is8246.69 the8246.85 answer8247 to8247.25 that8247.33 is8247.49 probably8247.73 no.8248.13 Now8249.08 setting8249.57 correct8249.89 expectations8250.36 for8251 folks8251.25 that8251.97 this8252.44 stuff8252.85 may8253.17 not8253.25 be8253.41 written8253.57 in8253.89 pen8253.97 right8254.28 now,8254.44 and8254.85 we8255 may8255.17 need8255.33 to8255.49 make8255.65 some8255.81 serious8256.05 adjustments8256.36 just8256.85 as,8257 both8258.1 chairs8258.34 made8258.82 in8259.14 20208259.38 when8260.1 I8260.9 think8260.98 you8261.22 did8261.7 take8262.1 the8262.34 appropriate8262.42 action8262.98 in8263.3 terms8263.38 of8263.62 adjusting8264.1 the8264.5 budget,8264.66 adjusting8265.06 the8265.46 timeline8265.54 in8265.94 light8266.18 of8266.42 circumstances.8266.58 We're8267.3 not8267.54 in8267.7 that8267.86 world8268.02 right8268.26 now,8268.5 but8268.9 folks8269.14 need8269.38 to8269.54 know8269.7 that8269.86 when8270.02 stuff8270.18 changes,8270.42 we8270.82 have8270.98 to8271.14 adapt8271.3 as8271.62 well.8271.78 I8272.51 think8272.59 that8272.83 needs8272.92 to8273.15 be8273.23 out8273.4 there,8273.56 but8273.8 I8274.43 don't8274.59 know8274.75 that8274.92 you8275 would8275.15 have8275.31 better8275.56 information8275.88 to8276.35 make8276.51 informed8277.31 adjustments8277.88 right8278.35 now8278.51 compared8278.83 to8279.23 a8279.4 little8279.48 later8279.72 in8279.95 the8280.03 process.8280.11
8284.35 MICHLEWITZ8284.35 -8284.35 Senator8284.35 Feeney.8284.75
8286.13 FEENEY8286.13 -8286.13 Thank8286.13 you,8286.37 Mr.8286.77 Charman,8287.09 and8287.09 thank8287.17 you,8287.33 Doug,8287.57 for8288.21 your8288.37 work8288.53 as8288.85 always8289.01 and8289.33 for8289.49 being8289.65 here8289.89 today.8290.05 Just8291.09 to8291.33 follow-up8291.49 on8291.81 the8291.97 question8292.29 I8292.61 asked8292.77 in8293.01 a8293.09 previous8293.25 testifier8293.65 too.8294.13 I8294.53 have8294.69 a8295.65 big8295.89 fear,8296.13 which8296.45 I8296.61 tried8296.77 to8297.01 articulate,8297.25 that8298.61 we8298.93 find8299.49 ourselves8299.73 in8300.45 a8300.85 serious8300.85 structural,8301.5 you8301.9 know,8302.31 deficit8302.47 going8302.94 forward8303.5 in8303.83 the8303.9 years8303.98 ahead,8304.15 especially8305.34 with8305.75 what's8305.98 going8306.15 on8306.47 federally8306.63 and8307.18 kind8307.34 of8307.5 volatility8307.75 there.8308.31 Understanding8309.67 that,8310.7 you8311.18 know,8311.34 we8311.83 are8311.98 blessed8312.06 with8312.39 the8312.55 opportunity8312.63 that8313.1 we8313.26 actually8313.42 have8313.75 today,8313.9 to8314.94 use8315.02 this8315.34 funding8315.58 for8315.98 various8316.91 purposes.8317.23 Thinking8318.75 about8319.07 my8319.31 own8319.47 district8319.71 and8320.03 talking8320.27 to8320.51 my8320.67 colleagues8320.83 in8321.31 kind8321.47 of8321.63 minimum8321.71 aid8322.03 communities8322.27 and8322.75 suburban8322.99 and8323.39 exurban8323.55 districts,8323.95 there8325.07 are8325.31 many8325.55 communities.8325.87
8326.35 I8326.35 have8326.51 two8326.91 in8327.23 my8327.39 district8327.55 right8327.87 now8328.03 that8328.27 are8328.43 facing8328.51 overrides,8328.83 specifically8330.27 with8330.99 the8331.23 pressures8331.47 of8331.94 education.8332.34 Costs8333.31 are8333.63 going8333.7 up8333.94 across8334.27 the8334.67 Commonwealth.8334.83 That8335.55 is,8335.86 to8336.34 me,8336.67 the8336.99 absolute8337.23 number8337.63 one8337.94 priority8338.1 to8338.42 make8338.58 sure8338.75 we're8338.91 getting8339.07 right.8339.23 With8341.7 that8341.94 kind8342.42 of8342.75 understanding8342.75 and8343.31 and8343.47 and8343.7 knowing8343.94 that8344.34 that's8344.5 going8344.75 to8345.2 continue8345.2 to8345.44 happen,8345.52 that8345.76 that8345.92 trend8346.08 is8346.32 going8346.4 to8346.64 continue8346.64 to8346.8 happen,8346.96 we8347.6 just8347.84 heard8348 about,8348.32 you8348.64 know,8348.72 the8348.96 need8349.04 for8349.28 additional8349.52 revenue.8349.84 And8350.16 I8350.32 know8350.4 MTF8350.56 is8350.96 reluctant8351.12 to,8351.52 you8351.92 know,8352.08 to8352.24 go8352.4 that8352.56 way.8352.72 And8352.88 I8352.96 think8353.04 you8353.2 articulated8353.36 in8354 your8354.08 remarks8354.64 about8355.04 how8355.2 important8355.44 it8355.76 is8355.92 to8356.08 make8356.16 sure8356.32 that8356.48 we're8356.72 prioritizing8357.36 with8358.24 these8358.4 one8358.64 time8358.88 funds,8359.36 you8359.98 know,8360.14 innovative8360.45 ideas,8361.18 right,8361.66 and8361.9 kind8362.06 of8362.22 capital8362.38 items8362.69 that8364.14 are8364.3 important8364.45 as8364.94 well.8365.1 But,8366.14 you8366.61 know,8366.77 I've8367.02 always8367.18 been8367.42 a8367.66 supporter8367.74 of8368.22 the8368.3 guilty8368.45 tax,8368.85 and8369.1 I8369.26 know8369.33 it's8369.5 something8369.66 that,8369.98 you8370.77 know,8370.85 we've8371.1 had8371.26 many8371.5 debates8371.74 about8372.14 here8372.53 over8372.85 the8373.1 years.8373.18
8374.77 Should8374.77 we8374.94 really8375.97 start8376.21 taking8376.61 a8377.33 candid8377.41 look8377.89 at,8378.29 you8379.49 know,8379.57 kind8379.89 of8380.05 places8380.21 where8380.53 Massachusetts8380.77 is8381.33 an8381.49 outlier8381.65 and8382.05 things8382.21 like8382.53 that,8382.61 where8383.25 additional8383.57 revenue8383.97 could8384.45 be8384.61 realized8384.77 so8385.41 that8385.65 we8385.81 don't8385.97 get8386.13 ourselves8386.29 into8386.69 a8387.01 situation8387.09 where8387.65 it's8387.81 not8388.05 too,8388.29 you8388.95 know,8389.03 communities8389.19 in8389.59 my8389.75 district8389.92 that8390.16 are8390.31 facing8390.48 an8390.72 override8390.88 to8391.35 be8391.43 able8391.59 to8391.83 to8392 do8392.16 the8392.4 most8392.48 basic8392.8 fundamental.8393.11 They're8393.67 not8393.83 facing8394 overrides8394.31 because8394.8 they8395.03 need8395.11 to8395.27 fix8395.35 the8395.59 roads.8395.75 Facing8396.31 overrides8396.64 because8397.03 we8397.19 need8397.35 to8397.51 educate8397.67 our8398 children.8398.16 Should8400.4 we8400.64 be8400.88 really8401.11 looking8401.59 seriously8402.24 at8402.8 that,8403.03 or8403.41 is8403.57 there8403.73 a8403.81 way8403.97 that8404.21 we8404.37 can8404.53 I8405.25 don't8405.33 know?8405.49 Is8405.73 there8405.89 a8406.25 kind8406.69 of8406.93 way8407.09 to8407.25 balance8407.41 that8407.81 going8408.05 forward8408.29 so8408.53 that8408.69 we're8408.85 not8409.01 sitting8409.25 here8409.49 trying8409.65 to8409.77 put8409.89 band8410.13 aids8410.29 on8410.61 it8410.77 through,8410.85 you8411.57 know,8411.65 surplus8411.97 budgets8413.01 and8413.49 and8413.81 onetime,8414.21 funding?8415.17
8416.93 HOWGATE8416.93 -8416.93 Great8416.93 question.8417.25 And8417.89 where8418.8 I'll8419.03 start8419.11 is8419.51 with8420.4 rates8420.72 of8421.03 growth8421.19 as8421.51 opposed8421.67 to8422 revenue8422.15 basis,8422.56 spending8422.88 basis.8423.27 Right?8423.67 And8423.92 pick8425.59 whatever8425.92 revenue8426.4 structure8426.8 you8427.19 want.8427.35 Pick8427.83 whatever8428.07 tax8428.4 rates8428.72 you8428.95 want.8429.19 They're8429.75 going8429.92 to8430.23 grow,8430.23 if8430.48 you're8430.56 lucky,8430.72 at8431.03 3%8431.19 to8431.35 4%8431.51 a8432 year.8432.07 And8432.68 one8432.92 of8433 the8433.08 challenges8433.32 we're8433.8 facing8434.04 now8434.36 in8434.52 mass8434.68 health,8434.92 challenges8435.48 we're8435.88 facing8436.04 in8436.36 a8436.44 number8436.52 of8436.76 areas8436.84 of8437.08 spending8437.24 is8437.56 that8437.8 the8438.04 spending8438.2 is8438.6 growing8438.84 by8439.24 more8439.4 than8439.64 3%8439.8 or8440.04 4%8440.12 a8440.6 year.8440.68 And8441.32 to8441.48 me,8441.64 that's8441.8 a8442.04 structural8442.2 issue8442.76 that8443.24 is8443.4 going8443.56 to8443.88 require8443.88 a8444.2 lot8444.28 of8444.44 hard8444.6 conversations8444.84 for8445.4 all8445.56 of8445.72 us8445.8 about8445.96 how8446.2 to8446.36 get8446.44 our8446.6 arms8446.76 around8447 those8447.48 cost8447.86 growth8448.1 factors.8448.35 And8449.15 so8449.39 if8450.35 you8450.5 generate8450.75 more8451.15 revenue,8451.39 can8451.7 you8451.86 spend8452.02 more8452.19 revenue?8452.42 And8452.58 the8452.75 answer8452.83 to8452.99 that8453.15 question8453.23 is8453.47 yes.8453.63
8453.86 Are8453.86 there8454.02 consequences8454.27 for8454.75 different8454.91 proposals8455.31 to8455.63 generate8455.78 more8456.1 revenue?8456.27 Absolutely.8456.67 There8457.15 are8457.31 as8457.55 well.8457.7 And8458.35 have8459.15 we8459.31 already8459.55 passed8460.42 a8460.67 major8460.83 tax8461.15 increase8461.39 in8461.7 Massachusetts8461.78 over8462.42 the8462.67 last8462.75 few8462.99 years,8463.15 and8463.89 it8464.61 has8464.77 allowed8466.29 you8466.61 to8466.85 have8467.01 this8467.25 supplemental8467.57 budget8467.97 before8468.29 you8468.53 today,8468.69 but8469.25 there8469.41 are8469.57 also8469.65 a8469.89 lot8469.97 of8470.05 fiscal8470.21 pressures.8470.45 And8470.77 to8470.93 me,8471.01 so8471.25 what's8471.41 the8471.57 bottom8471.65 line?8471.97 kind8472.13 of8472.45 what's8472.45 the8472.61 big8472.69 takeaway8472.93 for8473.25 that?8473.33 And8473.81 to8473.97 me,8474.13 it8474.29 is8474.45 the8474.61 fact8474.69 that8474.93 the8475.25 revenue8475.49 base8475.89 we're8476.21 going8476.37 to8476.61 have8476.61 is8477.24 a8477.4 base8477.56 that's8477.72 going8477.95 to8478.19 have8478.19 constrained8478.44 rates8480.27 of8480.52 growth8480.75 wherever8481.88 we8482.35 decide8482.52 to8482.83 pick8483 that.8483.16 Right?8483.48 And8484.52 what8484.75 we're8484.92 seeing8485.08 on8485.4 some8485.48 of8485.72 those8485.8 spending8486.03 cost8486.44 lines8486.92 for8487.56 a8487.8 totally8487.88 understandable8488.27 reason,8488.75 many8489.08 of8489.32 which8489.4 related8489.64 to8489.95 things8490.03 that8490.27 we8490.44 saw8490.52 happen8490.75 during8491 the8491.16 pandemic.8492.11
8492.35 Is8492.35 cost8492.35 growth8492.68 of8493.3 7%,8494.5 8%,8495.3 9%.8495.3 And8495.3 if8495.54 we8495.7 don't8495.86 get8496.18 those8496.34 things8496.58 equalized8496.9 over8497.46 time,8497.78 it8498.82 it8498.98 it's8499.7 not8500.02 going8500.18 to8500.42 work8500.42 no8500.66 matter8500.82 what8501.06 you8501.22 pick8501.38 as8501.62 your8501.78 revenue8501.86 base.8502.26 And8502.5 one8502.9 of8503.14 the8503.22 things8503.3 we've8503.54 talked8503.7 about8503.94 we8504.26 talked8504.42 about8504.58 special8504.82 education8505.14 transportation8505.54 as8506.1 an8506.26 example8506.34 of8506.66 that8506.74 related8506.98 to8507.3 this.8507.78 Another8508.02 thing8508.26 we've8508.5 talked8508.67 to8508.91 folks8508.99 about8509.31 in8509.78 the8509.94 context8510.1 of8510.42 the8510.58 FY8510.83 268511.07 budget8511.7 is8512.26 the8512.42 mass8512.5 health8512.75 program.8512.99 Right?8513.39 When8514.02 you8514.1 look8514.26 at8514.42 where8514.75 the8514.99 new8515.15 spending8515.31 in8515.63 Governor8516.1 Healey8516.5 's8516.5 budget8516.5 grows8516.83 compared8517.31 to8517.7 the8517.78 budget8517.86 she8518.26 signed8518.34 last8518.67 year,8518.91 80%8519.78 of8520.26 it8520.58 is8520.75 in8520.75 health8520.99 and8521.23 human8521.31 services.8521.63 And8522.18 that's8522.34 not8522.58 because8522.75 we're8522.99 expanding8523.41 our8523.73 mass8523.89 health8524.21 program8524.53 or8524.93 doing8525.17 major8525.41 new8525.73 things.8525.89 As8526.05 I'm8526.29 sure8526.45 all8526.61 of8526.77 you8526.93 are8527.09 aware,8527.17 that8527.65 comes8527.89 with8528.13 some8528.29 challenging8528.45 decisions8529.41 or8529.89 proposals8530.13 that8530.53 have8530.69 already8530.85 been8531.17 made.8531.25
8531.89 But8531.89 what8532.05 it8532.21 speaks8532.37 to8532.69 is8532.77 the8532.93 fact8533.09 that8533.25 we've8533.41 got8533.65 a8533.81 real8533.89 mismatch8534.13 there8534.69 between8534.93 that8535.25 growth8535.65 in8535.97 some8536.13 areas8536.29 of8536.61 the8536.69 budget8536.77 and8537.17 our8537.33 ongoing8537.49 revenues.8537.89 And8538.61 there's8538.81 not8538.97 going8539.05 to8539.13 be8539.13 any8539.28 easy8539.52 solutions8539.84 for8540.16 how8540.32 to8540.4 do8540.48 that.8540.65 But8540.81 18540.97 thing8541.13 I'd8541.28 love8541.52 to8541.76 see8541.84 in8542.08 this8542.24 year's8542.4 budget,8542.65 especially8543.36 given8543.84 the8544.16 uncertainty8544.32 of8544.73 whatever8544.89 the8545.2 feds8545.36 are8545.6 going8545.68 to8545.84 do,8545.84 especially8546.08 related8546.48 to8546.81 Medicaid,8546.89 is8547.6 to8547.76 start8548 to8548.24 task8548.48 some8548.81 folks8548.97 with8549.2 saying,8549.44 how8550 do8550.16 we8550.32 start8550.48 to8550.73 manage8550.97 Medicaid8551.76 costs8552.16 long8552.65 term?8552.89 What8553.29 does8553.45 that8553.61 mean8553.69 for8553.85 our8554.01 larger8554.17 health8554.41 care8554.57 system?8554.73 Right?8555.05 We8555.13 don't8555.21 want8555.37 to8555.61 just8555.61 push8555.69 it8555.93 down8556.09 in8556.25 one8556.33 place8556.49 to8556.73 have8556.81 it8556.97 explode8557.05 in8557.45 another8557.53 area8557.77 of8557.93 our8558.09 health8558.17 care8558.33 system.8558.49 And8558.97 are8559.21 there8559.37 some8559.53 things8559.61 we8559.85 can8560.01 do8560.09 to8560.25 help8560.33 us8560.49 get8560.65 our8560.81 arms8560.97 around8561.21 that8561.37
8562.17 Depending8562.17 on8562.57 what8562.73 happens8562.89 in8563.21 the8563.37 next8563.53 six8563.77 to8564.01 nine8564.17 months8564.41 with8564.73 federal,8564.97 you8565.77 know,8565.93 with8566.09 federal8566.33 state8566.89 federal8567.13 partnership,8567.45 with8568.28 the8568.52 larger8568.77 economy.8569.17 Who8570.44 knows8570.69 what8571.25 kind8571.65 of8571.97 policy8572.2 questions8572.6 you8572.92 folks8573.08 are8573.41 going8573.49 to8573.65 have8573.65 to8573.81 answer8573.97 in8574.28 terms8574.44 of8574.69 whether8574.77 it's8575.08 spending,8575.25 balancing8575.57 the8575.97 budget,8576.13 resources?8576.6 I8577.73 don't8577.97 think8578.13 I8578.36 or8578.52 any8578.69 of8578.84 you8579 could8579.17 kind8579.33 of8579.57 say8579.57 what's8579.81 going8580.05 to8580.36 be8580.36 there.8580.52 What8580.92 I8581.08 will8581.17 say8581.33 though8581.57 is8581.73 wherever8583.1 those8583.5 questions8583.74 lie,8584.22 ultimately,8584.78 we're8585.74 going8585.98 to8586.22 need8586.22 to8586.38 be8586.46 in8586.54 a8586.62 situation8586.78 where8587.26 we're8587.5 aligning8587.66 those8588.14 long8588.38 term8588.54 spending8588.78 and8589.18 revenue8589.34 pressures,8589.74 and8590.22 I8590.38 think8590.46 that's8590.7 a8591.02 big8591.1 part8591.34 of8591.58 what8591.66 we8591.82 need8591.98 to8592.14 start8592.3 getting8592.54 our8592.7 arms8592.94 around8593.1 as8593.42 well.8593.58
8598.15 MICHLEWITZ8598.15 -8598.15 Representative8601.67 Elliott.8602.31
8603.19 REP8603.19 ELLIOTT8603.19 -8603.19 Thank8603.19 you,8603.35 Mr.8603.83 Chairman.8604.23 Just8604.23 very8604.48 briefly.8604.72 Thank8605.75 you,8605.92 Mr.8607.35 Howgate.8607.45 I8607.45 just8607.53 want8607.77 to8607.93 just8607.93 revisit8608.33 the8609.29 special8610.17 education8610.17 circuit8610.65 breaker8610.97 a8611.29 little8611.37 bit.8611.53 And8611.77 in8611.93 particular,8612.17 the8612.89 transportation8613.45 cost,8614.33 has8614.89 the8615.61 state8615.85 engaged8616.33 in,8616.97 as8618.01 you8618.25 correctly8618.49 outlined,8618.97 strategies8619.61 to8621.66 address8621.9 these8622.45 increasing8623.02 costs.8623.5 As8624.14 we8624.3 already8624.38 know,8624.69 on8624.94 the8625.02 municipal8625.33 level,8625.82 they8627.18 know,8627.5 and8628.38 they8628.61 feel8628.77 it.8629.1 And8629.33 luckily,8629.66 these8630.22 revenues8630.94 are8631.5 available.8631.9 But8632.38 moving8632.61 forward8632.85 into8633.18 FY8633.58 26,8633.82 as8635.27 we8635.43 know,8635.59 it8635.75 takes8635.83 some8636.07 time8636.31 to8636.63 either8636.87 implement8637.11 any8637.91 regulations8638.15 or8638.79 strategies.8639.03 And8639.51 I8639.67 understand8639.83 you8640.23 it's8640.71 important8640.95 to8641.43 engage8641.51 communities8642.15 and8642.63 universities8642.95 and8643.91 academia8644.15 to8644.87 develop8645.27 these.8645.67 But8645.91 is8646.15 there8646.39 something8646.63 in8647.03 the8647.19 process8648.63 that8648.95 is8649.61 being8649.85 discussed8650.33 to8650.82 reign8651.53 in8651.93 these8652.01 unsustainable8652.5 costs8653.3 as8653.61 you8653.77 correctly8654.17 outlined8654.66 in8655.06 the8655.14 memo?8655.38
8656.17 HOWGATE8656.17 -8656.17 Sure.8656.17 So8656.42 I8656.82 know8656.9 the8657.06 Department8657.22 of8657.53 Elementary8657.61 and8658.01 Secondary8658.17 Education8658.74 works8659.14 with8659.38 districts8659.53 all8660.01 the8660.17 time8660.33 on8660.74 issues8661.22 related8661.3 to8661.38 transportation,8661.45 issues8661.53 related8661.61 to8662.01 transportation,8662.54 issues8662.86 related8663.26 to8663.42 special8663.58 education.8663.9 So8664.22 I8664.38 don't8664.54 doubt8664.78 that8664.94 there8665.1 are8665.42 things8665.66 that8665.98 they're8666.06 doing8666.3 with8666.54 individual8666.7 districts.8667.18 I8667.74 think8667.82 the8668.06 broader8668.14 point8668.46 we're8668.7 trying8668.94 to8669.1 make8669.18 is8669.34 as8669.58 you8669.66 folks8669.82 put8670.06 together8670.22 your8670.62 budget,8670.78 as8671.1 you8671.26 folks8671.42 plan8671.66 for8671.9 next8672.06 year,8672.3 some8672.78 kind8673.02 of8673.18 combined8673.42 effort8673.9 to8674.22 understand8674.38 that8674.94 process,8675.1 understand8676.02 what8676.35 those8676.58 options8676.75 are,8677.07 I8677.23 think8677.31 would8677.47 really,8677.63 generate8679.07 some8679.47 benefits.8679.63 And8680.42 I8680.83 don't8680.91 believe8681.15 anything8681.39 like8681.7 that8681.86 is8682.02 currently8682.19 ongoing.8682.5
8683.63 ELLIOTT8683.63 -8683.63 Thank8683.63 you,8683.86 Mr.8684.27 Chair.8686.35
8686.35 MICHLEWITZ8686.35 -8686.35 Any8686.35 other8686.58 questions8686.83 or8687.15 comments8687.31 from8687.63 members8687.78 of8688.1 the8688.19 committee?8688.27 Doug,8689.73 thank8690.05 you8690.13 for8690.29 your8690.45 testimony,8690.53 your8691.01 time8691.17 in,8691.41 answering8691.73 our8692.13 questions.8692.29 I8692.61 appreciate8693.01 you8693.01 being8693.17 here8693.33 today.8693.57 Thank8695.17 you.8695.33 Next8697.33 on8697.81 the8698.05 agenda8698.13 is8698.85 Kate8699.01 Dineen8699.25 from8699.65 A8699.81 Better8699.89 City.8700.21
8707.34 KATE8707.34 DINEEN8707.34 -8707.34 A8707.34 Better8707.34 City8707.34 -8707.34 HB8707.34 558707.34 -8707.34 Hi,8707.34 everybody.8707.58 Chairman8708.55 Michlewitz,8709.1 Chairman8709.34 Rodrigues,8709.67 members8710.23 of8710.55 the8710.63 committee.8710.78 My8711.34 name8711.42 is8711.58 Kate8711.75 Dineen.8711.91 I'm8712.23 president8712.39 and8712.78 CEO8712.94 of8713.34 an8713.5 organization8713.67 called8714.15 A8714.47 Better8714.55 City8714.78 based8715.18 here8715.42 in8715.58 Boston.8715.75 And8716.68 it8717.32 is8717.56 a8717.88 real8718.04 pleasure8718.28 to8718.6 be8718.76 here8718.92 today8719.16 to8719.64 testify8719.88 in8720.28 support8720.52 of8721.32 House8721.48 Bill8721.72 55,8721.96 which8722.68 as8723.08 we8723.32 now8723.4 know8723.64 will8723.88 provide8724.04 vital8724.76 funding8725.08 to8725.48 stabilize8725.64 our8726.12 transportation8726.28 system8727.08 in8727.64 addition8727.88 to8728.28 supporting8728.52 important8729.08 education8729.88 investments8730.36 as8730.84 well.8731.13 And8731.52 before8731.76 I8732 begin,8732.17 and8733.13 share8733.2 the8733.44 A8733.6 Better8733.68 City8733.92 perspective,8734.17 I'd8734.65 like8734.89 to8735.05 acknowledge8735.2 the8735.68 complexity8735.84 of8736.57 building8736.81 a8737.2 budget8737.28 in8737.68 this8737.84 climate8738 and8738.65 to8738.89 thank8739.05 you8739.2 for8739.44 everything8739.6 you're8740 doing8740.25 to8740.65 lead8740.97 our8741.28 Commonwealth8741.44 through8742.08 this8742.33 very8742.57 uncertain8742.81 time.8743.36
8743.92 I'd8743.92 also8744.08 like8744.41 to8744.57 recognize8744.81 my8745.28 colleagues8745.44 in8745.92 education,8746.08 for8747.34 all8747.42 of8747.5 their8747.58 tireless8747.82 efforts8748.38 to8749.02 improve8749.5 our8749.9 system8750.06 in8750.3 our8750.46 state.8750.62 I'm8751.18 a8751.26 mom8751.34 of8751.58 a8751.74 five8751.9 year8751.98 old8752.14 pre8752.94 K8753.18 student8753.5 and8753.98 a8754.14 one8754.3 year8754.54 old8754.7 daycare8755.02 baby,8755.98 and8756.62 I'm8757.42 so8757.66 grateful8757.82 for8758.3 all8758.7 of8758.86 their8759.02 efforts.8759.18 And8760.2 I'd8760.28 also8760.44 like8760.76 to8761 share8761.08 that8761.32 I'm8761.48 a8761.73 Western8761.89 Mass8762.28 native,8762.52 and8763.32 I8763.65 still8764.05 have8764.28 a8764.36 4138764.76 area8765.08 code,8765.4 and8765.65 I8765.89 deeply8766.05 appreciate8766.44 all8766.92 the8767.08 very8767.32 thoughtful8767.56 questions8767.97 regarding8768.44 geographic8769.32 equity.8769.89 And8771.08 today,8771.32 I8771.73 represent8771.89 an8772.76 organization8772.92 called8773.4 A8773.65 Better8773.73 City8774.05 that8774.28 has8774.99 been8775.07 around8775.31 since8775.55 1989,8776.03 and8776.91 we've8777.15 represented8777.55 the8778.11 Greater8778.27 Boston8778.67 business8779.15 community8779.55 on8780.27 a8780.51 wide8780.59 range8780.91 of8781.23 transportation8781.55 matters.8782.43
8783.23 Because8783.23 from8783.87 our8784.11 perspective,8784.35 our8785.31 transportation8785.55 infrastructure8786.27 is8786.91 in8787.07 many8787.23 ways8787.47 the8787.79 foundation8787.95 upon8788.83 which8789.23 our8789.55 regional8789.63 economy8790.44 is8790.69 built.8791.49 A8791.73 Better8792.13 City8792.36 now8792.36 focuses8792.6 on8793 transportation,8793.41 climate8794.13 and8794.52 land8794.69 use8794.92 issues,8795.25 which8795.65 are8795.89 obviously8796.05 very8796.44 intertwined,8796.77 and8797.73 we8797.97 represent8798.28 a8798.84 multi8799.08 sector8799.49 group8799.89 of8800.13 nearly8800.28 1308800.69 business8800.7 leaders8800.71 and8800.71 institutions8800.72 that8800.72 are8800.73 united8800.73 around8800.74 the8800.74 common8800.75 vision8800.75 of8800.76 creating8800.76 a8800.77 more8800.84 equitable8809.19 city8810.47 and8810.79 region8811.11 for8811.59 all.8811.83 From8812.87 our8813.11 perspective,8813.27 a8813.83 high8813.99 quality8814.15 public8814.63 transit8815.44 system8816 is8816.33 a8816.57 prerequisite8816.81 to8817.76 achieving8818 any8818.65 of8818.97 those8819.13 goals,8819.44 and8819.84 so8820.08 that8820.25 is8820.41 why8820.57 we8820.81 must8820.97 act8821.28 urgently8821.52 to8822.41 stabilize8822.57 the8823.28 MBTA's8823.36 operating8824.08 budget8824.57 now.8824.97 As8826.25 such,8826.41 a8826.81 Better8827.2 City8827.52 supports8827.52 Governor8828.08 Healey8828.57 's8829.13 proposed8829.13 surplus8829.84 surtax8830.59 supplemental8831.23 budget8831.63 because8832.19 it8832.43 would8832.59 do8832.75 three8832.91 things.8833.07
8833.95 One,8834.27 it8834.27 would8834.51 advance8834.83 the8835.31 initial8835.47 recommendations8835.95 of8836.51 the8836.67 Governor's8836.83 transportation8837.39 funding8838.03 task8838.51 force.8838.75 Two,8839.63 it8839.95 would8840.11 deliver8840.35 on8840.99 the8841.15 promise8841.23 of8841.79 that8841.87 50:508842.27 split8843.39 of8843.86 FareShare8844.35 revenue,8844.5 and8845.39 three,8845.63 it8845.94 would8846.1 stabilize8846.5 the8847.23 MBTA's8847.39 operating8848.1 budget8848.5 in8848.91 the8848.99 near8849.15 term.8849.39 A8851.39 Better8851.47 City8851.78 was8852.02 honored8852.27 to8852.67 serve8852.83 on8853.15 the8853.31 Governor's8853.47 transportation8853.94 funding8854.58 task8854.99 force,8855.23 and8855.86 as8856.19 you8856.35 know,8856.5 the8856.91 core8857.15 recommendations8857.39 of8858.19 that8858.42 task8858.58 force8858.91 report8859.53 really8859.93 prioritize8860.33 the8861.05 use8861.21 of8861.53 FareShare8862.09 revenue8862.41 to8863.13 stabilize8863.37 our8864.01 transportation8864.41 system8865.13 statewide.8865.61 The8866.73 task8866.89 force8867.13 does8867.61 make8867.93 additional8868.17 recommendations8868.65 to8869.53 enhance8870.25 and8870.81 transform8871.05 our8871.77 statewide8872.01 system8872.65 over8873.13 time,8873.45 such8874.14 as8874.3 continuing8874.77 to8875.33 aggressively8875.65 pursue8876.22 federal8876.53 funds,8876.93 which8877.25 is8877.41 obviously8877.65 more8878.06 challenging8878.22 now,8878.61 rationalizing8879.41 existing8880.22 transportation8880.77 fees,8881.49 and8882.14 assessing8882.38 the8882.85 feasibility8883.01 of8883.65 new8883.98 pricing8884.22 strategies8884.93 as8885.65 well.8885.9
8886.63 So8886.63 we8886.95 will8887.11 undoubtedly8887.35 all8887.99 have8888.15 work8888.39 to8888.63 do8888.79 together8888.95 in8889.43 coming8889.59 sessions.8889.91 In8890.95 your8891.03 broader8891.19 budget8891.59 negotiations,8891.91 we8892.71 encourage8892.95 you8893.35 to8893.59 consider8893.75 the8894.39 approach8894.55 to8894.95 leveraging8895.11 FareShare8895.91 funding8896.15 that's8896.87 reflected8897.51 in8897.91 the8898.07 Governor's8898.23 House8898.63 one8898.95 budget.8899.33 But8899.73 in8899.89 the8900.05 immediate,8900.28 what8900.84 we're8901 here8901.17 to8901.33 discuss8901.57 today,8901.89 House8902.69 Bill8902.92 558903.25 is8903.73 a8903.89 critical8904.05 step8904.52 in8904.84 implementing8905.17 that8905.81 broader8905.97 plan.8906.36 The8907.25 task8907.49 force8907.73 ultimately8908.13 did8908.84 recommend8909.17 an8909.73 even8909.97 split8910.44 of8910.84 FareShare8911.25 revenue8911.49 between8911.89 transportation8912.36 and8913.08 education.8913.33 Over8914.36 the8914.6 past8914.76 two8915.22 years,8915.46 transportation8916.1 has8916.66 received8916.9 roughly8917.46 40%8918.02 of8918.82 FareShare8919.3 funding8919.46 despite8920.34 the8920.74 ballot8920.9 question's8921.22 promise8921.7 of8922.26 an8922.34 equitable8922.58 distribution,8923.06 and8924.02 House8924.5 Bill8924.74 558924.98 would8925.54 move8925.94 toward8926.26 that8926.66 more8926.9 equitable8927.22 split8927.7 over8928.42 time.8928.74
8929.97 When8929.97 we8930.2 step8930.44 back8930.69 and8930.93 we8931.17 consider8931.33 our8932.2 statewide8932.52 transportation8933.17 needs,8933.89 the8934.28 most8934.44 immediate8934.69 and8935.33 challenging8935.57 is8936.36 at8936.6 the8936.77 MBTA,8936.93 where8937.81 the8938.13 financial8938.36 gap8938.85 begins8939.17 in8939.57 FY8939.73 26,8940.05 which8940.69 as8941 we8941.17 know8941.25 is8941.41 less8941.65 than8941.81 three8942.05 months8942.28 away8942.6 now.8942.93 Our8943.75 region,8943.99 and8944.55 I8944.79 would8944.95 argue8945.11 our8945.51 entire8945.67 Commonwealth,8946.07 cannot8946.95 survive,8947.91 let8948.55 alone8948.71 thrive8949.03 without8949.43 a8949.83 safe,8949.99 reliable,8950.39 and8950.95 accessible8951.11 MBTA.8951.67 The8952.79 MBTA8952.95 service8953.59 area8953.91 of8954.39 1648954.63 municipalities8955.99 represents8956.87 over8957.43 70%8957.75 of8958.47 the8958.55 state's8958.88 population,8959.11 74%8960 of8960.88 the8961.03 jobs,8961.19 and8961.51 84%8961.75 of8962.64 the8962.8 GDP,8963.03 and8963.83 we8964.08 know8964.16 that8964.4 every8965.27 dollar8965.75 invested8966.16 in8966.56 public8966.8 transit8967.19 generates8968.08 at8968.8 least8968.95 $58969.27 in8969.83 economic8970.08 returns,8970.64 and8971.11 that8971.27 same8971.51 ratio8971.75 is8972.41 proven8972.49 true,8972.73 when8973.53 you8973.69 look8973.77 at8973.93 the8974.01 MBTA.8974.17 Under8975.61 General8976.01 Manager8976.33 Eng's8976.73 leadership8976.97 and8977.93 with8978.17 the8978.41 support8978.57 of8979.29 the8979.45 legislature,8979.61 the8980.73 T8980.89 has8981.13 made8981.37 tremendous8981.53 progress8982.41 toward8983.05 addressing8983.45 decades8984.09 of8984.49 underinvestment8984.65 and8985.37 getting8985.53 the8985.77 system8985.93 back8986.33 on8986.57 track8986.73 and8987.21 really8987.8 rebuilding8988.19 trust8988.67 with8989 the8989.23 public.8989.4
8990.59 From8990.59 hiring8990.92 sorely8991.4 needed8991.72 bus8992.11 operators8992.35 at8993 a8993.08 record8993.31 pace8993.56 to8993.88 removing8994.11 slow8994.59 zones8994.92 across8995.48 the8995.95 subway8996.11 system8996.51 to8997.16 most8997.56 recently8997.8 realizing8998.27 the8998.83 vision8999 of8999.31 South8999.56 Coast8999.8 Rail,9000.11 the9000.83 current9001 MBTA9001.4 leadership9001.95 is9002.49 delivering9002.65 for9003.37 our9003.61 riders9003.69 and9004.25 delivering9004.49 for9004.97 our9005.21 economy.9005.45 And9006.49 without9006.73 additional9007.13 funding9007.53 provided9008.33 by9008.81 this9008.97 proposal,9009.21 the9010.01 MBTA9010.25 would9011.05 undoubtedly9011.45 be9012.01 forced9012.17 to9012.57 contemplate9012.73 service9013.61 cuts,9014.01 layoffs,9014.49 and9015.21 dire9015.53 funding9015.93 reallocation9016.89 decisions.9017.69 Plainly,9018.7 from9019.18 a9019.42 Better9019.75 City’s9020.15 perspective,9020.15 the9020.7 MBTA9020.94 would9021.58 risk9021.75 returning9022.06 to9022.55 a9022.7 state9022.86 of9023.1 crisis9023.26 that9024.39 would9024.55 potentially9024.94 destabilize9025.58 our9026.23 economy9026.39 and9026.86 threaten9027.02 all9027.5 of9027.67 our9027.75 shared9027.98 goals.9028.39 In9029.5 closing,9029.67 transportation9030.55 is,9031.5 in9031.91 many9032.06 ways,9032.31 the9032.55 key9032.7 to9033.02 unlocking9033.26 a9034.22 more9034.38 affordable,9034.62 equitable,9035.42 and9035.98 competitive9036.14 Commonwealth,9036.7 and9037.82 the9038.06 key9038.22 to9038.46 recruiting9038.78 and9039.34 retaining9039.58 top9040.14 talent9040.46 in9040.94 this9041.02 unstable9041.42 economy.9042.06
9043.34 Our9043.34 major9043.58 employers,9043.98 including9044.86 our9045.42 higher9045.66 education9045.98 and9046.62 health9046.78 care9047.1 institutions,9047.26 our9048.45 life9048.69 sciences9048.85 companies,9049.42 our9050.3 law9050.45 firms,9050.69 all9051.5 of9051.66 which9051.82 are9051.98 now9052.14 under9052.61 federal9052.93 attack,9053.33 rely9054.3 on9054.69 the9054.85 MBTA9055.09 to9055.98 move9056.14 the9056.45 workers9056.61 that9057.09 move9057.33 our9057.66 economy.9057.9 With9059.01 unprecedented9059.42 uncertainty9060.38 at9060.93 the9061.09 federal9061.25 level,9061.66 one9062.14 thing9062.3 is9062.77 certain,9063.01 Massachusetts9063.03 can9063.05 and9063.07 must9063.08 take9063.1 this9063.12 near9063.14 term9063.15 action9063.17 to9063.19 take9063.2 control9063.22 of9063.24 our9063.25 own9063.5 transportation9068.27 future.9069.07 House9069.95 Bill9070.27 559070.51 is9071.07 a9071.23 critical9071.39 step9071.87 at9072.27 a9072.43 critical9072.59 moment,9072.99 and9073.63 a9073.87 Better9074.91 City9075.79 respectfully9075.79 urges9076.19 the9076.51 committee9076.67 to9077.24 support9077.4 this9077.64 proposal.9077.88 Thank9078.92 you9079.08 for9079.4 your9079.56 leadership,9079.72 for9080.19 your9080.35 partnership,9080.6 and9081.32 for9081.56 your9081.72 commitment9081.95 to9082.27 the9082.35 Commonwealth.9082.52
9084.19 MICHLEWITZ9084.19 -9084.19 Okay.9084.19 Thank9084.44 you9084.6 for9084.68 your9084.83 testimony,9085 your9085.56 patience,9085.8 and9086.35 your9088.11 continued9088.27 efforts9088.75 and9089.16 work9089.24 with9089.48 us,9089.64 in9090.03 the9090.19 legislature9090.35 here9090.92 as9091.16 we9091.32 move9091.48 forward9091.64 on9091.95 this9092.03 discussion9092.19 and9092.6 further9092.83 other9093.21 transportation9093.45 issues9093.85 as9094.17 well.9094.33 So9094.57 thank9094.73 you9094.89 for9095.05 being9095.13 here.9095.29 Any9095.93 other9096.17 senator9097.29 Collins.9097.69
9099.05 COLLINS9099.05 -9099.05 Thank9099.05 you,9099.29 Chair9100.17 Michlewitz.9100.73 And9100.73 thank9100.89 you9101.13 to9101.45 ABC9101.77 for9102.33 your9102.49 testimony9103.77 and9104.33 work.9104.49
9105.13 TANG9105.13 -9105.13 Thank9105.13 you,9105.29 senator.9105.45
9106.08 COLLINS9106.08 -9106.08 History9111.19 has9111.43 been9111.43 an9111.59 important9112.4 part9117.92 in9118.32 planning9118.4 and9118.8 transportation,9119.03 particularly9119.59 in9120.08 my9120.48 district.9120.64 As9122.22 we're9122.46 talking9122.62 about9122.94 precious9123.18 transportation9123.82 dollars9124.54 and9124.94 the9125.26 enormous9125.34 challenges9125.74 that9126.14 we're9126.3 trying9126.46 to9127.42 face9128.06 and9128.38 meet9128.46 head9129.26 on,9129.42 I9129.98 also9130.22 think9130.54 about9130.62 competitiveness.9131.02 We9131.98 just9132.14 talked9132.62 about9132.94 tariffs9134.06 and9134.54 the9134.78 potential9135.18 effects9135.66 there.9136.06 The9136.38 competitors9136.85 of9137.09 the9137.2 Port9137.33 Of9137.57 Boston9137.65 and9138.85 that9139.81 being9139.97 at9140.28 risk.9140.36 Do9141.81 you9141.97 think9142.05 that9142.28 we9142.93 should9143.17 be9143.41 including9143.49 legislative9147.97 frameworks,9147.97 when9149.94 cities9150.26 and9151.22 towns9151.46 or9151.86 or9152.1 the9152.26 state9152.42 wants9153.14 to,9153.38 you9154.02 know,9154.18 basically9154.42 restructure9154.98 our9156.02 transportation9156.18 network9156.82 through,9157.22 you9157.86 know,9157.94 bike9158.26 lane9158.58 infrastructure9158.9 or9159.62 bus9160.1 lane9160.42 infrastructure9160.66 to9161 get9162.19 stakeholder9163.16 buy-in?9163.6
9163.82 Because9163.82 it9164.03 doesn't9164.27 seem9164.51 to9164.75 be9164.95 that9165.16 that's9165.24 the9165.48 case9165.64 across9165.72 the9166.19 board.9166.35 We9166.83 look9167 at9167.16 the9167.24 disaster9167.48 that9167.95 was9168.03 on9168.27 the9168.44 street9168.51 that9168.92 luckily9169.16 got9169.64 pulled9169.8 back,9170.11 and9170.92 ABC9171.24 had9171.8 a9172.03 big9172.19 role9172.44 in9172.67 the9172.83 planning9172.92 for9173.32 the9173.33 Crossroads9173.34 Initiative.9173.35 That9173.37 was9173.38 basically9173.4 from9173.41 the9173.42 convention9173.44 center9173.45 to9173.46 South9173.48 Station9173.49 Yep.9173.51 With9173.54 the9173.56 truck9173.72 basically9175.06 from9175.38 the9175.46 convention9175.62 center9175.94 to9176.18 South9176.26 Station9176.5 Yep.9176.9 With9177.62 the9177.94 truck9178.1 routes9178.42 on.9178.74 I9178.98 mean,9179.14 we9179.38 were9179.46 literally,9179.62 you9180.02 know,9180.18 the9180.58 Port9180.74 Of9180.9 New9181.06 England,9181.22 you9181.78 know,9181.86 UPS,9182.34 FedEx,9183.06 DHL,9184.02 Connolly9184.9 Terminal,9185.38 Marine9186.02 Industrial9186.26 Park9186.74 Bus9187.38 lane9187.7 right9188.02 through9188.18 it9188.34 for9188.5 two9188.66 years.9188.82 And,9190.15 you9190.47 know,9190.63 where9191.26 the9191.5 bike9192.06 lane9192.31 infrastructure9192.55 that9193.02 was9193.18 planned9193.34 thoroughly9193.67 with9194.06 ABC9194.31 at9194.78 the9194.94 table,9195.02 for9196.06 the9196.23 crossroadness9196.39 of9197.1 works9197.34 just9197.75 fine9197.98 from,9198.55 the9199.34 convention9199.5 Center9199.98 to9200.23 South9200.39 Station.9201.58
9201.75 You9201.75 know,9201.75 we9201.98 didn't9202.06 have9202.39 the9202.55 same9202.7 stakeholder9203.18 process9203.83 at9204.31 all9204.47 and9205.07 spent9205.23 a9205.47 million9205.71 upfront,9206.11 probably9207.15 a9207.35 million9207.55 to9208.03 slowly9208.27 remove9208.75 that,9209.71 all9210.75 the9210.83 while9210.99 stakeholders9211.39 like9211.87 the9212.11 Massport9212.27 Authority,9212.67 the9213.47 Convention9213.55 Authority,9213.95 hotels,9214.91 and9215.39 everybody9215.63 was,9216.03 you9216.27 know,9216.35 raising9216.51 alarm9216.91 and9217.39 other9217.55 stakeholder9217.79 groups.9218.35 Is9218.75 that9218.94 something9219.1 that9219.35 we9219.42 should9219.58 be9219.91 putting9220.55 in9220.86 legislation9221.42 to9222.23 ensure9222.39 that9222.86 when9223.35 we're9223.58 spending9223.67 significant9224.23 tax9224.86 dollars9225.19 or9225.75 providing9226.15 it9226.55 to9226.63 municipalities9226.78 to9227.99 make9228.15 improvements9228.31 that9229.1 we9229.27 at9229.42 least9229.5 have9229.75 that9229.91 kind9230.15 of9230.31 buy-in?9230.55 Because9230.63 it9230.88 seems9230.96 to9231.04 be9231.28 not9231.36 a,9231.68 you9232 know,9232.24 common9232.8 threat9233.84 that9234.16 it9234.4 happens9234.56 sometimes,9234.88 doesn't9235.36 happen,9235.68 and9236 then9236.24 we9236.48 see9236.64 situations9236.88 like9237.44 this9237.68 when9238.16 you9238.32 bring9238.48 up9238.64 competitiveness9238.8 in9239.44 this9239.6 particular9239.84 case9240.4 with9241.2 respect9241.44 to9241.68 the9241.84 Port9241.92 Of9242.16 Boston.9242.24
9242.72 DINEEN9242.72 -9242.72 Yeah.9242.72 Well,9243.15 thank9243.31 you9243.39 for9243.47 your9243.7 question,9243.86 senator.9244.1 I9244.5 think9244.58 it's9244.75 a9244.83 timely9244.99 one.9245.31 You9246.19 know,9246.27 from9246.43 a9246.67 better9246.75 cities9246.99 perspective,9247.31 as9247.86 you9248.02 know,9248.19 we9249.15 feel9249.55 strongly9249.78 that9250.35 as9251.15 a9251.47 city9251.55 and9251.86 as9252.1 a9252.19 region,9252.27 we9252.67 do9252.83 need9252.99 multimodal9253.31 transportation9254.1 options9254.83 to9255.39 thrive,9255.55 and9255.86 that9256.1 includes9256.27 driving,9257 transit,9257.64 active9258.2 transportation,9258.6 and9259.24 we9259.64 will9259.8 need9260.12 to9260.36 build9260.52 out9260.84 that9261.08 active9262.04 transportation9262.44 infrastructure9263.08 and9263.56 also9263.72 transit9264.04 infrastructure9264.44 to9265.08 support9265.24 those9265.56 multimodal9265.8 uses.9266.36 So9266.84 we9267.16 need9267.32 to9267.48 see9267.64 the9267.8 continued9267.88 development9268.36 of9268.92 bus9269.48 lanes9269.64 and9269.96 bike9270.12 lanes,9270.28 and9270.68 to9270.92 your9271.08 point,9271.32 it9271.64 has9271.8 to9272.03 be9272.08 thoughtful,9272.11 and9272.92 it9273.15 has9273.31 to9273.48 ensure9273.72 that9274.19 all9274.43 stakeholders9274.59 are9275.15 at9275.31 the9275.4 table.9275.48 And9276.19 I9276.43 think,9276.51 especially9277 from9277.48 our9277.72 perspective,9277.88 to9278.27 consider9278.43 the9278.92 needs9279.08 of,9279.31 potentially9279.95 impacted9280.51 businesses,9281.08 and9282.19 economic9282.35 drivers,9282.92 like9283.48 many9283.72 of9283.95 whom9284.03 you9284.27 referenced9284.43 and9284.92 that9285.23 you9285.48 represent.9286.51
9287.73 Regarding9287.73 your9287.97 question9288.21 about9288.61 requiring9289.73 that9290.13 in9290.29 statute,9290.53 I9291.01 think9291.09 there9291.33 are9291.49 a9291.57 lot9291.65 of9291.73 different9291.89 ways9292.21 to9292.77 get9292.93 there9293.09 to9293.41 that9293.57 same9293.73 outcome.9293.97 I9294.45 think9294.61 that9294.93 is9295.09 certainly9295.33 one9295.73 approach.9296.05 I9297.01 know9297.33 that9297.57 we9297.73 at9297.89 a9297.97 Better9298.29 City9298.69 are9298.69 looking9298.85 forward9299.17 to9299.49 reviewing9299.57 Mayor9300.21 Wu's,9300.61 309301.33 day9301.65 review9301.89 plan9302.37 where9302.85 she's9303.19 taking9303.44 a9303.68 backward9303.83 looking9304.4 look9304.72 at,9305.03 I9305.52 believe,9305.68 all9306.16 transportation9306.56 infrastructure9307.19 that's9307.68 been9307.83 installed9308 in9308.4 the9308.56 last9308.64 three9308.88 years9309.11 to9309.68 see9309.83 what9310 changes9310.16 may9310.56 need9310.72 to9310.88 be9310.95 made9311.11 to9311.27 infrastructure9311.6 that's9312.08 already9312.4 in9312.64 place,9312.8 and9313.35 also9313.68 to9314.24 take9314.32 a9314.56 forward9314.72 looking9315.11 view9315.92 of9316.32 how9316.68 can9316.84 the9317.08 process9317.16 be9317.64 improved9317.88 moving9318.28 forward,9318.52 how9318.92 can9319.16 we9319.24 ensure9319.4 that9319.72 we9319.88 have9319.96 really9320.44 robust9320.84 stakeholder9321.56 engagement,9322.12 and9323 not9323.8 just9324.04 input,9324.36 but,9324.84 that9326.68 that9327 folks9327.16 are9327.4 at9327.64 the9327.8 table9327.96 early9328.44 enough9328.68 to9329 influence9329.16 the9329.8 design,9329.88 right,9330.6 and9331 not9331.32 just9331.56 to9331.72 kind9332.39 of9332.63 approve9332.78 it.9333.1 So9333.5 we're9333.82 really9333.98 looking9334.23 forward9334.47 to9334.7 reviewing9334.86 that9335.18 plan,9335.42 and9336.31 to9336.47 be9336.63 a9336.7 partner9336.86 moving9337.18 forward9337.42 on9337.66 this.9337.9
9338.63 COLLINS9338.63 -9338.63 Thank9338.63 you.9338.86 Yeah.9339.02 I9339.18 just9339.26 think9339.5 most9339.74 people's9339.98 philosophy9340.31 is9340.86 they9341.1 shouldn't,9341.26 it's9341.58 not9341.74 that9341.9 bike9342.06 lanes9342.31 and9342.47 bus9342.63 lanes9342.86 shouldn't9343.1 be9343.34 anywhere.9343.42 They9343.9 just9344.06 can't9344.31 be9344.47 everywhere.9344.7
9345.1 TANG9345.1 -9345.1 Right.9345.1 Yep.9345.93 Thank9346.17 you.9346.49
9348.01 MICHLEWITZ9348.01 -9348.01 Any9348.01 other9348.25 questions9348.49 or9348.73 comments9348.89 from9349.29 members9349.45 of9349.69 the9349.77 committee?9349.85 Okay.9351.21 Thank9351.61 you9351.85 so9352.09 much9352.17 for9352.41 your9352.49 testimony.9352.65 I9353.13 appreciate9353.53 it.9353.53 Next9355.13 up9355.45 from9355.61 the9355.77 Massachusetts9355.85 Municipal9356.41 Association,9356.81 Adam9357.37 Chapdelaine.9358.49
ADAM9364.38 CHAPDELAINE9364.38 -9364.38 MASSACHUSETTS9367.17 MUNICIPAL9367.17 ASSOCIATION9367.17 -9367.17 HB9367.17 559367.17 -9367.17 Good9371.5 afternoon,9371.74 Chair9373.25 Michlewits,9373.82 Chair9373.82 Rodrigues9373.82 and9373.82 distinguished9373.98 members9374.45 of9374.77 the9374.85 committee.9375.02 I9375.97 want9376.05 to9376.21 start9376.21 by9376.45 thanking9376.61 you9376.85 for9377.09 inviting9377.25 the9377.57 MMA9377.81 to9378.21 be9378.29 here9378.45 today9378.69 and9379.33 for9379.57 holding9379.73 this9380.29 important9380.53 hearing.9380.93 For9382.05 the9382.29 record,9382.45 my9382.93 name9383.17 is9383.33 Adam9383.49 Chapdelaine,9383.81 and9384.45 I'm9384.61 proud9384.85 to9385.17 serve9385.33 as9385.73 the9385.89 executive9386.05 director9386.61 and9387.41 CEO9387.65 of9388.13 the9388.29 Massachusetts9388.45 Municipal9389.17 Association,9389.73 which9390.82 serves9390.98 local9391.53 government9391.85 in9392.33 all9392.66 corners9392.9 of9393.3 the9393.38 Commonwealth9393.53 representing9394.66 all9395.22 3519395.45 cities9396.82 and9397.14 towns.9397.3 Since9398.58 the9398.9 enactment9399.06 of9399.69 the9399.94 voter9400.02 approved9400.33 surtax,9400.82 we've9401.69 appreciated9402.1 your9403.14 strong9403.45 support9403.94 with9404.86 targeted9405.18 and9405.74 thoughtful9406.06 investments9406.54 that9407.26 have9407.5 benefited9407.74 local9408.38 government9408.78 in9409.26 Massachusetts.9409.42
9410.86 Through9410.86 funding9411.1 for9411.5 public9411.74 schools,9412.06 school9413.1 building9413.5 projects,9413.98 universal9414.94 free9415.66 school9415.98 meals,9416.3 local9417.34 road9417.74 and9417.98 bridge9418.14 funding,9418.46 and9419.18 much9419.42 more,9419.74 You've9420.9 all9421.23 been9421.47 excellent9421.78 stewards9422.34 of9422.83 these9422.98 new9423.23 critical9423.86 resources,9424.34 and9425.39 municipalities9425.63 are9426.67 grateful9426.9 for9427.63 your9427.78 partnership.9428.02 As9430.02 we9430.26 highlighted9430.5 last9431.06 week9431.39 at9431.7 the9431.86 joint9431.94 committee9432.26 state9432.67 budget9432.9 hearing,9433.23 today,9434.36 cities9435.48 and9435.72 towns9435.88 are9436.36 facing9436.52 daunting9438.12 fiscal9438.44 challenges.9438.84 They're9440.2 facing9440.44 a9440.84 perfect9441 storm9441.4 of9442.28 fiscal9442.52 pressures,9442.92 inflation9444.2 hitting9444.84 all9445.32 city9445.64 and9445.88 town9446.04 departments,9446.28 health9447.64 care9447.96 cost9448.28 increases,9448.68 federal9450.19 funding9450.6 uncertainty,9451 and9452.19 as9452.44 we9452.6 learned9452.75 earlier9453 this9453.4 week,9453.56 even9454.03 federal9454.27 funding9454.68 rescissions.9455.24 And9457.08 now9457.32 all9457.48 of9457.72 this9457.8 must9458.03 be9458.27 managed9458.44 within9459.24 the9459.56 confines9459.8 of9460.83 proposition9461.08 two9461.64 and9461.8 a9461.95 half,9462.03 which9462.68 as9462.92 we9463.16 know9463.24 caps9463.56 local9463.88 revenues9464.27 through9464.73 property9464.97 taxes.9465.45
9467.13 Despite9467.13 these9467.53 challenges,9467.77 cities9468.89 and9469.21 towns9469.29 have9469.61 been9469.77 proud9470.01 to9470.97 partner9471.13 with9471.45 speaker9471.69 Mariano,9472.09 senate9473.05 president9473.37 Spilka,9473.85 and9474.73 the9474.89 leadership9475.05 of9475.61 this9475.77 entire9476.01 committee9476.41 to9477.37 target9477.61 strategic,9478.01 one9479.05 time9479.29 investments9479.61 that9480.28 can9480.44 make9480.69 a9480.77 true9480.84 difference9481.25 for9481.57 local9481.81 officials9482.13 and9482.84 the9483.08 residents9483.25 that9483.65 they9483.89 serve.9484.05 So9485.73 when9485.97 we9486.2 think9486.28 about9486.44 this9486.69 opportunity9487 that9487.49 you9487.65 all9487.81 have9487.97 before9488.13 you,9488.52 the9489.57 MMA9489.73 advises9490.13 a9490.6 framework9490.69 that9491.81 supports9492.13 all9492.84 regions9493.17 in9493.89 all9494.2 communities9494.44 in9494.92 the9495.08 Commonwealth,9495.17 whether9496.34 a9496.66 gateway9496.82 city9497.3 along9497.54 Route9497.78 Two,9498.1 a9499.06 small9499.22 town9499.62 on9499.86 the9500.02 South9500.18 Shore,9500.42 or9501.3 a9501.54 hill9501.7 town9501.94 in9502.34 Western9502.58 Mass,9502.98 all9504.18 have9504.66 unique9504.9 strengths9505.3 and9506.26 needs.9506.58 Providing9508.1 strategic9508.58 investments9509.3 through9510.17 a9510.41 lens9510.56 of9510.89 regional9511.13 equity9511.6 will9512.56 further9512.81 empower9513.28 our9513.76 communities9514 and9514.97 bolster9515.2 critical9515.68 services9516.17 provided9516.89 by9517.28 our9517.44 cities9517.6 and9517.92 towns.9518.08
9519.92 So9519.92 to9520.17 talk9520.25 about9520.48 transportation,9520.81 first,9522.48 again,9523.05 we9523.68 want9523.84 to9524.08 express9524.17 our9524.73 gratitude9524.97 for9525.63 the9525.79 investments9526.03 that9526.43 the9526.59 state9526.75 has9527.07 made9527.23 over9527.55 recent9527.71 years9528.03 in9528.83 improving9529.15 municipal9529.95 roadways.9530.43 That9531.79 really9532.11 has9532.43 made9532.59 important9532.91 progress.9533.31 Yet,9534.67 with9535.47 more9535.71 than9535.95 30,0009536.19 miles9537.07 of9537.39 roads9537.55 under9537.79 municipal9538.25 control,9538.58 which9539.3 accounts9539.61 for9539.93 nearly9540.09 90%9540.5 of9541.22 all9541.38 roads9541.69 statewide,9542.01 funding9543.53 dedicated9543.93 to9544.42 supporting9544.58 our9544.98 local9545.14 roads9545.61 and9545.85 bridges9545.93 is9546.65 still9546.9 desperately9547.22 needed.9547.77 Our9549.14 most9549.38 recent9549.61 Chapter9550.01 909550.5 survey9550.73 has9551.14 totaled9551.38 the9552.09 gap9552.25 in9552.5 funding9552.65 to9553.2 be9553.36 in9553.44 the9553.6 hundreds9553.68 of9554.32 millions9554.56 of9554.88 dollars9555.12 just9555.84 to9556.08 bring9556.16 our9556.4 roads9556.56 to9556.88 the9557.04 state9557.12 of9557.28 good9557.44 repair.9557.6 Over9558.88 time,9559.2 cost9560.32 drivers9560.56 and9560.96 inflation9561.12 have9561.68 further9561.84 decreased9562.24 the9562.72 value9562.88 of9563.28 available9563.36 funding,9563.84 which9564.48 has9564.72 now9564.88 only9565.12 been9565.36 made9565.52 worse9565.76 by9566 construction9566 inflation9566.01 and9566.01 economic9566.02 threats9566.02 from9566.03 Federal9569.09 Action.9569.66
9570.53 And9570.53 again,9570.69 under9571.17 a9571.22 tightly9571.25 capped9571.74 property9572.06 tax,9572.61 communities9573.02 simply9573.74 don't9573.9 have9574.18 the9574.45 adequate9574.77 resources9575.25 to9575.73 make9576.22 headway9576.61 on9577.33 bringing9577.42 roads9577.9 to9578.14 a9578.3 state9578.45 of9578.53 good9578.77 repair.9578.94 So9579.17 to9580.51 address9580.75 this,9581.23 we9582.19 urge9582.43 your9582.67 consideration9582.83 of9583.95 an9584.11 additional9584.35 $1009584.91 million9586.19 of9586.19 supplemental9586.43 funding9587.07 for9587.63 Chapter9587.87 909588.27 eligible9588.67 projects.9589.23 I9590.35 know9590.51 you9590.67 can9590.83 all9590.99 appreciate9591.15 and9591.63 understand9591.87 this9592.51 need.9592.67 We9593.58 all9593.75 know9593.91 that9593.99 you9594.23 hear9594.39 from9594.55 your9594.78 own9595.02 local9595.18 officials9595.5 on9595.91 the9596.06 importance9596.15 of9596.63 this9596.78 funding.9596.94 But9598.15 it's9598.39 also9598.55 important9598.78 to9599.1 remember9599.26 that9599.67 this9599.91 funding9600.06 could9600.39 be9600.55 put9600.78 to9601.1 use9601.26 immediately9601.75 in9602.63 cities9602.78 and9603.1 towns9603.26 across9603.58 the9603.83 Commonwealth.9603.99 Every9604.86 one9605.18 of9605.34 them9605.42 has9605.58 a9605.75 shovel9605.83 ready9606.15 project9606.47 that9607.1 could9607.26 repair9607.5 crumbling9607.99 roads9608.47 or9609.04 advance9609.28 another9609.6 type9609.92 of9610.16 critical9610.4 Chapter9610.8 909611.2 project9611.44 and9612.08 improve9612.32 safety9612.72 on9613.44 our9613.6 neighborhood9613.76 roadways.9614.32
9616.48 Next,9616.48 we'd9617.28 urge9617.6 consideration9617.84 of9619.12 $259619.28 million9620.48 to9620.48 support9620.64 local9621.04 bridges9621.44 and9621.84 culverts.9622.64 Culverts,9623.95 it's9624.92 a9625.16 municipal9625.23 nerd9625.64 alert,9625.95 are9626.27 a9626.43 significant9626.59 part9627.08 of9627.8 local9627.95 infrastructure,9628.35 but9629.56 they're9629.8 often9629.95 only9630.43 noticed9630.75 when9631.23 they9631.4 fail.9631.56 But9632.51 when9632.75 that9633 happens,9633.16 sizable9634.19 costs9634.83 are9635.31 incurred,9635.56 which9636.43 would9636.67 be9636.83 a9637.08 massive9637.16 hit9637.56 to9637.88 any9637.95 budget9638.27 but9639 are9639.24 especially9639.4 impactful9640.76 on9641.4 our9641.56 smaller9641.8 and9642.28 rural9642.52 communities.9642.92 Across9644.44 the9644.76 Commonwealth9644.92 municipalities9645.64 are9646.28 in9646.44 need9646.6 of9646.76 support9646.92 to9647.64 maintain9647.8 and9648.44 upgrade9648.68 the9649.32 countless9649.48 culverts9649.96 under9650.52 municipal9650.76 care9651.24 to9652.65 meet9652.73 the9652.97 necessary9653.2 resiliency9653.69 standards,9654.33 especially9655.36 as9656.25 we9656.41 face9656.65 increased9657.05 and9657.6 unpredictable9657.84 precipitation9658.73 patterns.9659.44 The9660.57 funding9660.81 would9661.05 support9661.28 upgrades9661.69 of9662 municipally9662.17 owned9662.65 small9662.89 bridges9663.13 and9663.44 culverts9663.6 in9664.25 order9664.41 to9664.65 protect9664.73 public9665.13 safety,9665.52 improve9666.4 climate9666.72 resiliency,9667.12 and9667.92 restore9668.16 ecosystem9668.88 connectivity.9669.6
9671.52 I9671.52 also9671.68 want9671.92 to9672.24 highlight9672.24 the9672.56 proposal9672.72 included9673.36 in9673.84 house9674.08 559674.32 for9674.96 the9675.12 Winter9675.2 Resilience9675.6 Assistance9676.16 Program9676.72 or9677.52 RAP.9677.76 The9678.97 MMA9679.13 greatly9679.52 appreciates9680 the9680.4 Healey9680.48 Driscoll9680.81 administration9681.2 for9681.92 including9682.08 this9682.56 important9682.73 provision,9683.13 which9683.52 would9683.76 distribute9683.92 supplemental9684.56 aid9685.13 to9685.36 municipalities9685.52 based9686.4 on9686.65 road9686.89 miles.9687.13 This9688.08 is9688.25 a9688.4 successful9688.73 method9689.36 for9690 supplemental9690.4 apportionments9691.13 to9691.76 assist9691.92 all9692.33 communities9692.56 again9693.55 while9693.79 prioritizing9694.03 regional9695.23 equity.9695.63 For9697.07 wrap,9697.39 we9698.03 respectfully9698.35 request9698.99 consideration9699.47 of9700.43 $50,000,000,9700.67 which9702.11 is9702.35 an9702.51 increase9702.67 over9703.07 the9703.31 administration's9703.47 proposal.9704.19 Each9705.39 municipality,9705.63 again,9706.75 has9707.3 a9707.45 list9707.61 of9707.77 shovel9707.93 ready9708.25 projects9708.5 in9709.38 need9709.61 of9709.85 supplemental9710.01 funding,9710.58 all9711.53 of9711.69 which9711.77 can9712.09 be9712.17 put9712.66 to9712.9 use9713.06 right9713.77 away.9713.93 The9714.42 construction9714.66 season9715.14 is9715.45 upon9715.61 us.9715.93 With9716.98 the9717.14 effects9717.3 of9717.61 climate9717.77 change9718.09 exacerbating9718.5 the9719.14 damage9719.3 to9719.69 local9719.77 roads,9720.09 this9720.81 is9721.06 an9721.22 essential9721.3 investment9722.01 to9722.65 improve9722.89 access9723.37 and9723.93 quality9724.17 of9724.49 life9724.73 for9725.37 residents9725.53 across9725.93 the9726.25 Commonwealth.9726.49
9727.85 Through9727.85 these9727.93 proposed9728.97 investments9729.37 in9730.41 local9730.57 roads,9730.81 bridges,9731.85 and9732.73 culverts,9732.89 the9734.09 legislature9734.33 has9734.89 a9735.05 great9735.13 opportunity9735.45 to9736.17 address9736.33 a9736.73 backlog9736.89 of9737.2 needs9737.52 across9738.08 all9738.56 3519738.81 cities9740 and9740.32 towns,9740.4 all9741.28 while9741.52 promoting9741.84 regional9742.32 equity9742.73 with9743.28 a9743.6 limited9743.68 infusion9744.17 of9744.89 surplus9745.05 resources.9745.6 So9747.76 to9748 shift9748.17 to9748.4 education,9748.56 I'd9749.96 start9750.2 by9750.52 appreciating9750.92 the9751.56 attention9751.72 on9752.28 the9752.44 special9752.6 education9753 circuit9753.48 breaker,9753.8 which9754.84 is9755 an9755.24 essential9755.4 program9755.88 to9756.52 reimburse9756.76 districts9757.24 for9757.8 the9758.04 cost9758.2 of9758.52 services9758.68 and9759.32 transportation9759.64 to9760.28 students9760.36 with9760.68 some9760.92 of9761.08 the9761.16 highest9761.32 needs9761.56 in9761.8 the9761.88 Commonwealth.9762.04 We9763.2 support9763.44 fully9763.92 funding9764.25 this9764.56 critical9764.73 account9765.13 and9765.84 look9766 forward9766.17 to9766.48 working9766.65 with9766.97 you9767.05 all9767.28 in9767.6 determining9767.92 the9768.4 best9768.56 approach9768.81 in9769.36 the9769.52 coming9769.68 months.9770 Further,9771.52 school9772.4 transportation9772.89 accounts9773.52 continue9774.25 to9774.73 be9774.81 a9774.97 high9775.13 priority9775.28 for9775.84 municipalities.9776 Inadequate9777.71 funding9778.27 for9778.59 these9778.75 programs9778.91 can9779.47 create9779.71 major9780.11 hardships9780.51 for9781.07 school9781.23 districts9781.47 and9782.03 municipal9782.35 budgets.9782.83
9784.11 We're9784.11 grateful9784.43 for9784.83 your9784.99 ongoing9785.23 support9785.79 in9786.27 recent9786.51 years9786.83 for9787.15 the9787.31 needs9787.39 of9787.63 regional9787.79 school9788.19 transportation,9788.51 out9789.87 of9790.03 district9790.19 vocational,9790.75 and9791.86 special9792.26 education9792.75 transportation,9793.31 as9794.75 well9794.91 as9795.07 the9795.23 transportation9795.47 of9795.94 homeless9796.18 students9796.5 under9797.15 McKinney9797.55 Vento.9797.94 As9799.55 we9799.7 view9799.94 this9800.18 unique9800.5 funding9800.83 opportunity9801.23 in9801.94 terms9802.1 of9802.34 programs9802.5 that9802.91 are9803.07 both9803.23 related9803.47 to9803.94 education9804.18 and9805.15 transportation,9805.55 we're9807.34 respectfully9807.58 requesting9808.14 a9809.1 special9809.34 one9810.06 time9810.3 pothole9811.1 account9811.66 to9812.54 address9812.7 in9813.5 district9813.74 transportation.9814.38 Regular9816.14 day9816.54 in9817.34 district9817.58 school9818.06 transportation9818.38 is9819.52 a9819.65 major9819.77 area9820.41 of9820.89 high9821.13 cost9821.36 with9822.17 no9822.41 current9822.73 financial9823.13 support9823.6 from9824 the9824.17 state.9824.33 While9825.52 state9825.84 law9826.17 provides9826.41 for9826.81 state9826.97 funding9827.2 for9827.52 regular9827.77 day9828.17 in9828.57 district9828.73 transportation,9829.05 municipalities9830.41 haven't9831.13 seen9831.36 financial9831.69 support9832.08 from9832.41 the9832.57 Commonwealth9832.73 for9833.28 decades9833.52 as9834.18 the9834.34 section9834.42 is9834.9 subject9835.06 to9835.54 appropriation.9835.7 But9837.38 at9837.62 a9837.86 time9837.94 when9838.18 districts9838.42 are9838.82 facing9838.98 such9839.3 acute9839.62 increases9840.26 in9840.74 school9840.9 transportation.9842.82
9842.98 We9842.98 believe9842.98 this9843.46 proposed9843.62 account9844.1 could9844.5 mitigate9844.66 the9845.14 impact9845.22 they're9845.62 having9846.1 on9846.42 local9846.58 school9846.9 budgets.9847.14 And9848.2 based9848.36 on9848.6 this,9848.69 we're9848.84 respectfully9849.25 requesting9849.73 consideration9850.28 of9851.49 a9851.65 one9851.73 time9852.05 $459852.6 million9853.73 pothole9853.73 account9854.2 towards9854.69 this9855.08 effort.9855.33 Research9856.76 consistently9857.41 demonstrates9858.13 a9858.84 strong9859 link9859.33 between9859.65 reliable9860.05 and9860.44 accessible9860.6 school9861.17 transportation9861.49 and9862.48 improved9862.72 student9863.04 attendance,9863.44 particularly9864.24 for9864.8 economically9865.12 disadvantaged9865.84 students.9866.32 Studies9867.6 have9867.92 shown9868.08 that9868.4 transportation9868.56 access9869.28 can9869.68 increase9869.84 attendance9870.24 rates9870.72 and9871.2 reduce9871.44 chronic9871.84 absenteeism.9872.4 So9874.24 again,9874.48 thank9875.28 you9875.6 for9875.76 your9875.92 time.9876.16 We're9876.95 deeply9877.19 grateful9877.75 for9878.31 the9878.48 committee's9878.56 attention9879.03 to9879.43 all9879.59 of9879.75 these9879.83 priority9880.07 issues9880.48 for9880.8 local9880.95 government.9881.27 We9882.15 look9882.31 forward9882.48 to9882.72 partnering9882.95 with9883.27 you9883.43 in9883.67 the9883.75 months9883.92 ahead9884.15 on9884.72 all9884.88 of9885.11 these9885.19 issues,9885.43 and9886.07 we9886.31 appreciate9886.56 your9886.95 consideration9887.19 of9887.92 important9888.07 investments9888.48 supporting9889.19 all9889.75 3519890 cities9891.07 and9891.15 towns9891.39 in9891.63 the9891.71 Commonwealth.9891.87 Thank9892.83 you.9893.07
9894.03 MICHLEWITZ9894.03 -9894.03 Adam,9894.03 thank9894.35 you9894.51 for9894.83 your9895.07 patience9895.31 and9895.63 your9895.79 testimony.9895.95 Appreciate9896.51 you9896.83 being9897.07 here9897.23 and,9897.47 given9897.87 the9898.19 perspective9898.35 from9898.83 the9899.07 MMA.9899.15 We9899.55 appreciate9899.63 that.9900.03 Thank9900.35 you.9900.51 Any9901.15 questions9901.39 or9901.71 comments9901.87 from9902.11 members9902.35 of9902.59 the9902.67 committee?9902.83 Representative9904.19 Peace.9904.67
9906.7 PEASE9906.7 -9906.7 Thank9906.7 you,9906.94 mister9907.1 chairman,9907.5 and9907.98 and9908.23 thank9908.47 you9908.63 for9908.86 your9909.02 testimony.9909.18 And9910.94 I9911.1 guess9911.26 something9911.58 that9911.91 came9912.23 to9912.47 my9912.55 attention9912.78 recently,9913.18 and9913.67 we9914.06 talk9914.31 a9914.55 lot9914.63 about9914.78 regional9915.02 transportation9915.58 budgets.9916.31 And,9917.02 but9918.31 also,9918.47 I9919.02 think9919.18 within9920.06 a9920.55 city,9921.02 they're9921.59 having9921.83 issues9921.99 because9922.55 they9922.87 usually9923.19 have9923.75 one9923.99 person9923.99 to9924.47 bid,9924.55 one9925.27 company9925.43 to9925.83 bid.9925.99 It's9926.39 not9926.63 very9926.87 competitive.9927.59 At9928.63 least9928.79 in9929.03 my9929.19 area,9929.35 we're9929.67 seeing9929.91 those9930.15 costs9930.39 go9930.79 up9931.03 quite9931.19 a9931.43 bit9931.51 because9931.83 of9932.31 the9932.47 lack9932.47 of9932.71 competition.9932.95 So9933.64 I9933.88 don't9933.95 know9934.03 how9934.19 we9934.43 deal9934.51 with9934.75 that,9934.92 but9935.07 that's9935.23 something9935.48 else9935.72 that's9935.95 going9936.19 to9936.43 come9936.43 down9936.59 the9936.67 road9936.83 and9937.07 really9937.23 add9937.56 to9937.72 our9937.88 increased9938.43 cost9938.92 of9939.15 education.9939.4 So9939.88 I9940.03 just9940.11 want9940.35 to9940.51 point9940.59 that9940.83 out.9941.07
9942.59 CHAPDELAINE9942.59 -9942.59 Thank9942.59 you9942.83 for9942.92 raising9943.15 that.9943.48 I9943.72 would9943.95 say9944.11 we've9944.27 had9944.51 some9944.75 dialogues9945 with9946.61 some9946.85 of9947.01 your9947.17 colleagues9947.25 in9947.57 this9947.65 committee9947.81 about9948.13 this,9948.37 and9948.61 we9948.85 are9949.09 very9949.25 open9949.57 to9949.81 continuing9950.13 a9950.69 dialogue9950.85 about9951.41 any9951.89 potential9952.21 avenue9952.69 to9953.01 increasing9953.17 the9953.57 competitiveness9953.73 of9954.69 that9954.85 market.9955.09 Thank9955.81 you.9956.05
9958.4 MICHLEWITZ9958.4 -9958.4 Any9958.4 other9958.73 questions9958.81 or9959.13 comments9959.28 from9959.6 members9959.76 of9960 the9960.08 committee?9960.17 Adam,9962.32 thank9962.65 you9962.81 again9962.89 for9963.13 being9963.36 here.9963.44
9963.52 CHAPDELAINE9963.52 -9963.52 Thank9963.52 you9963.68 very9963.76 much.9963.92 I9964 appreciate9964.65 it.9964.65
9964.73 MICHLEWITZ9964.73 -9964.73 Your9964.73 testimony.9964.89 I9965.44 appreciate9965.84 it.9965.84 Next9967.13 up,9967.36 Ed9967.6 Lambert9967.84 from9968.32 the9968.48 Massachusetts9968.65 Business9969.68 Alliance9970.08 for9970.4 Education.9970.65
9980.42 EDWARD9980.42 LAMBERT9980.42 -9980.42 MASSACHUSETTS9980.42 BUSINESS9980.42 ALLIANCE9980.42 FOR9980.42 EDUCATION9980.42 -9980.42 HB9980.42 559980.42 -9980.42 Good9980.42 afternoon,9980.74 Chairman9981.94 Rodrigues,9982.26 Chairman9982.9 Michlewitz9983.22 ,9983.62 members9983.62 of9983.94 the9984.02 committee.9984.18 Thank9984.89 you9985.05 very9985.13 much9985.28 for9985.52 the9985.68 opportunity9985.84 to9986.32 be9986.4 here9986.56 with9986.65 you9986.81 this9986.97 afternoon,9987.2 and9988.65 to9988.89 offer9989.52 some9989.84 comments.9990.08 I'm9991.6 here9991.68 representing9991.92 the9992.32 Mass9992.48 Business9992.73 Alliance9992.97 for9993.28 Education.9993.44 Our9993.84 members9994.08 come9994.32 from9994.56 every9994.73 corner9994.89 of9995.2 the9995.28 state9995.44 representing9996.08 every9996.65 business9996.81 type9997.13 and9997.28 industry9997.52 and9997.84 every9998 major9998.16 business9998.48 organization9998.89 from9999.44 every9999.68 region.9999.92 We're10000.94 committed10001.18 to10001.58 advocating10001.74 for10002.22 high10002.38 quality10002.54 educational10002.94 experiences10003.5 for10003.9 all10004.06 students10004.22 to10004.62 prepare10004.7 them10005.02 for10005.18 college,10005.42 career,10006.38 and10006.78 citizenship.10007.1 We10008.7 very10009.02 much10009.26 recognize,10009.5 how10010.7 uncertain10010.94 these10011.5 times10011.74 are10012.06 and10012.38 offer10012.86 our10013.83 gratitude10013.99 to10014.47 you10014.7 all,10014.86 with10015.67 great10015.91 appreciation10016.23 for10016.94 the10017.1 work10017.26 and10017.5 the10017.75 very10017.83 thoughtful10018.06 consideration10018.47 that10019.58 you10019.67 have10019.83 given10019.99 over10020.31 the10020.47 last10020.55 couple10020.78 of10021.02 years10021.1 relative10021.42 to10022.15 the10022.31 expenditure10022.47 of10023.42 FareShare10023.83 revenues10024.15 and10024.86 doing10025.1 so10025.34 in10025.5 a10025.67 way10025.75 that10025.99 protects10026.15 and10026.63 preserves10026.78 the10027.34 opportunity10027.42 to10028.27 fund10028.43 important10028.67 investments.10029.15
10030.43 And10030.43 as10030.67 such,10030.83 we're10031.63 not10031.95 here,10032.27 to10033.55 add10033.79 to10034.11 a10034.27 growing10034.75 list10035.15 of10035.47 competing10035.63 priorities,10036.11 but10036.75 rather10036.99 to10037.87 ask10038.03 for10038.27 some10038.51 very10038.67 targeted10038.99 investments10039.55 and10040.28 a10040.36 very10040.6 small10040.92 handful10041.25 of10042.05 things10042.2 that10042.44 we10042.6 think10042.76 will10043 make10043.25 a10043.57 difference10043.73 for10044.44 students.10044.69 Four10046.2 on10046.52 that10046.69 short10046.92 list,10047.08 three10047.41 of10047.57 which10047.73 are10047.89 already10048.05 included10048.36 in10049.25 House10049.41 Bill10049.65 55.10049.89 Today,10051.17 we're10051.49 here10051.73 to10051.97 support10052.13 several10052.91 highly10053.31 targeted10053.63 evidence-based10054.51 investments10054.83 in10055.55 the10055.71 supplemental10055.87 budget10056.35 proposal10056.67 that10057.15 have10057.23 the10057.47 potential10057.55 we10057.87 believe10058.11 to10058.35 be10058.51 transformative10058.67 for10059.31 students10059.47 and10060.03 for10060.19 our10060.43 state's10060.51 public10060.83 education10061.23 system.10061.71 These10062.59 are10062.83 tenuous10062.99 times10063.55 in10063.71 our10063.95 state's10064.03 education10064.43 ecosystem.10064.99 Student10066.16 outcomes10066.56 are10067.03 on10067.19 a10067.31 downward10067.43 trend.10067.83 Many10068.8 of10068.95 our10069.11 students10069.27 are10069.67 still10069.75 struggling10070.08 to10070.48 recover10070.64 learning10071.03 impacted10071.51 by10072 the10072.08 pandemic.10072.24 Racial10073.35 and10073.75 socioeconomic10073.92 achievement10074.8 gaps10075.27 are10075.92 growing10076.08 wider.10076.4
10077.67 Standing10077.67 by10078.08 as10078.72 we10078.88 lose10079.03 one10079.35 of10079.51 our10079.67 major10079.83 competitive10080.24 advantages10080.95 in10082.13 Massachusetts,10082.29 an10082.93 education10083.17 system10083.65 that10083.89 has10084.13 been10084.29 the10084.45 envy10084.61 of10085.01 the10085.09 nation,10085.17 clearly10086.13 standing10086.61 by10086.93 is10087.17 not10087.25 an10087.49 option.10087.57 And10088.37 so10088.53 we10088.77 ask10089.01 for10089.65 some10089.81 urgent10090.05 action10090.37 now10090.69 on10091.01 behalf10091.17 of10091.41 our10091.49 students10091.65 or10092.05 our10092.21 economy10092.45 will10093.17 suffer10093.33 for10093.73 many10093.89 years10094.13 to10094.37 come.10094.53 We10095.52 have10095.68 the10095.92 opportunity10096.17 with10096.89 the10097.05 targeted10097.2 use10097.6 of10097.84 this10098 surplus10098.25 surtax10098.73 funding10099.2 to10100.17 invest10100.33 in10100.56 some10100.81 game10100.97 changing10101.44 strategies10101.92 that10102.41 have10102.56 been10102.65 shown10102.81 to10103.05 make10103.13 a10103.36 big10103.44 difference10103.6 for10103.92 students.10104.17 Let's10104.97 start10105.2 with10105.6 early10105.84 literacy10106.08 high10106.65 dosage10106.81 tutoring.10107.2 We10108.26 support10108.5 the10108.82 Governor's10108.98 proposal10109.46 to10109.78 allocate10109.94 $2510110.34 million10111.94 to10111.94 allow10112.1 10,00010112.42 students10113.06 to10113.38 participate10113.62 in10114.1 early10114.26 literacy10114.58 high10114.98 dosage10115.14 tutoring10115.54 in10115.94 the10116.1 next10116.18 school10116.42 year.10116.66 We10117.46 must10117.7 get10117.94 all10118.18 students10118.34 reading10118.74 on10118.98 grade10119.14 level10119.38 before10119.86 they10120.18 fall10120.42 too10120.66 far10120.9 behind10121.06 and10121.38 the10121.54 research10121.7 shows10122.5 very10122.82 clearly10123.06 that10123.75 high10124 dosage10124.16 tutoring10124.48 is10124.8 an10124.95 effective10125.11 intervention10125.75 that10126.24 can10126.4 help10126.56 do10126.8 that.10126.95
10128 Currently,10128 only10128.4 42%10129.19 of10129.51 our10129.67 state's10129.75 third10130.08 graders10130.31 were10130.64 proficient10130.88 in10131.27 reading10131.43 on10132.24 the10132.4 202410132.88 MCAS,10133.43 and10134.16 that10134.4 number10134.56 dropped10134.95 to10135.19 24%10136.16 for10136.95 our10137.11 low10137.27 income10137.43 students.10137.75 These10139.19 numbers10139.43 are10139.75 alarming10139.91 when10140.63 you10140.79 consider10141.03 that10141.35 students10141.51 who10141.83 can't10141.99 read10142.23 by10142.47 third10142.63 grade10142.87 can't10143.59 read10143.99 to10144.31 learn,10144.55 which10145.19 then10145.43 affects10145.67 all10146.15 of10146.31 their10146.39 academic10146.63 outcomes,10147.11 following10148.71 in10149.35 all10149.59 subject10149.83 areas10150.23 and10150.63 impact10150.87 their10151.34 future10151.5 success.10151.82 We10153.1 can10153.34 significantly10153.58 change10154.23 that10154.47 trajectory10154.7 with10155.26 this10155.5 investment.10155.75 A10156.78 recent10156.94 analysis10157.26 by10157.75 Johns10157.98 Hopkins10158.15 University10158.63 of10159.18 this10159.26 model,10159.42 as10160.15 it's10160.31 currently10160.55 being10161.02 practiced,10161.9 through10162.78 philanthropic10163.18 funding10163.82 in10164.31 many10164.63 of10164.94 your10165.02 districts10165.26 across10165.9 Massachusetts,10166.39 showed10167.72 that10167.88 participating10168.2 students10168.76 grew10169.08 their10169.32 reading10169.56 skills10169.88 substantially10170.28 more10170.84 than10171 expected10171.24 as10172.04 compared10172.2 to10172.52 their10172.6 peers,10172.84 achieving10173.32 5.410174.36 months10175.4 of10175.88 additional10176.28 learning10177.4 in10177.8 comparison10178.04 to10178.52 their10178.68 peers10178.84 over10179.16 the10179.4 course10179.48 of10179.8 the10179.88 year.10179.96
10180.75 They10180.75 were10180.92 much10181 more10181.31 likely10181.48 to10181.8 be10181.95 reading10182.11 on10182.35 grade10182.51 level10182.83 by10183.4 the10183.56 end10183.72 of10184.03 that10184.19 school10184.43 year.10184.75 With10185.8 this10186.03 investment10186.19 over10186.67 time,10186.92 in10187.95 districts10188.19 with10188.67 this10188.92 strategy10189.15 combined10189.8 with10190.35 high10190.59 quality10190.75 curriculum10191.15 material10191.72 and10192.27 science10192.59 of10193.07 reading10193.23 instruction,10193.64 we10194.76 could10194.92 expect10195.08 those10195.48 third10195.72 grade10195.96 proficiency10196.28 rates10196.76 to10197.08 rise10197.24 to10197.64 as10197.8 high10197.88 as10198.2 80%.10198.36 To10200.52 scale10200.76 this10201.08 up,10201.32 to10202.28 do10202.36 it10202.6 the10202.76 way10202.84 some10203.08 other10203.32 states10203.48 have10203.8 invested,10204.04 in10205 this10205.24 game10205.88 changing10206.2 strategy,10206.6 we're10207 recommending10207.24 $2510207.72 million10208.92 a10208.92 year10209 for10209.16 several10209.52 year10209.77 period10210.65 aligned10210.81 with,10211.36 investing,10212.81 the10214.08 investments10214.33 being10214.73 made10214.97 in10215.13 literacy10215.36 launch10215.85 by10216.25 the10216.41 administration10216.57 to10217.69 line10217.85 that10218.17 time10218.41 frame10218.73 up,10218.97 and10219.93 to10220.17 do10220.25 so10220.49 in10220.65 a10220.81 way10220.89 that10221.2 gets10221.44 us10221.77 to10222.08 the10222.17 point10222.33 where10222.57 we10222.81 scale10222.97 it10223.2 up,10223.36 but10223.85 also10224.08 giving10224.41 us10224.73 the10224.97 next10225.13 few10225.58 years10225.9 to10226.22 determine10226.54 how10227.02 we10227.26 will10227.42 integrate10227.74 this10228.22 into10228.78 district10229.1 operating10229.5 budgets10229.98 in10230.38 a10230.54 more10230.62 sustainable10230.94 state10231.5 local10231.82 partnership10232.14 way.10232.7
10234.14 We're10234.14 also10234.38 here10234.62 to10234.78 support10234.94 the10235.26 proposed10235.34 $32.510235.66 million10236.94 allocation10236.94 to10237.34 reimagine10237.5 high10237.98 school10238.14 in10238.38 Massachusetts.10238.54 As10239.83 fewer10240.07 students10240.31 enroll10240.78 in10241.1 college10241.19 and10241.91 far10242.15 too10242.39 many10242.55 struggle10242.78 to10243.1 transition10243.27 to10243.67 the10243.83 workforce,10243.91 we10244.78 have10244.94 to10245.1 accelerate10245.34 our10245.75 efforts10245.91 to10246.23 redesign10246.31 that10246.78 high10246.94 school10247.19 experience,10247.42 make10247.91 it10248.07 more10248.23 relevant,10248.47 and10249.27 create10249.5 a10249.83 more10249.99 personalized10250.31 pathway10251.27 for10251.83 all10252.07 students.10252.23 Too10253.45 many10253.53 high10253.77 schools10253.85 in10254.25 Massachusetts10254.41 are10255.05 stuck10255.13 in10255.37 the10255.45 past10255.61 using10256.17 old10256.41 models10256.65 of10257.05 teaching10257.13 and10257.45 learning10257.61 that10257.85 are10258.01 not10258.17 aligned10258.33 with10258.73 the10258.89 realities10258.97 of10259.45 education10259.61 in10260.33 the10260.49 2010260.65 first10260.89 century.10261.21 Those10262.25 traditional10262.49 models10262.97 are10263.37 holding10263.53 too10263.77 many10263.93 students10264.17 back10264.65 from10264.81 reaching10265.29 their10265.61 full10265.77 potential10266.01 with10266.41 many10266.65 of10266.81 them10266.97 just10267.21 disengaging10267.53 from10268.09 school.10268.33 We10269.44 support10269.67 the10269.92 Governor10270.08 and10270.48 Secretary10270.64 Tutwiler's,10271.11 proposal10272.16 to,10272.8 invest10273.92 in10274.32 reimagining10274.56 that10275.27 high10275.44 school10275.59 experience,10275.83 in10277.03 ways10277.19 that10277.51 can10277.59 support10277.83 a10278.16 variety10278.24 of10278.64 initiatives10278.8 that10279.35 include10279.51 expansion10280 of10280.4 pathways10280.56 like10280.95 early10281.19 college10281.44 and10281.75 innovation10281.92 career10282.4 pathways,10282.72 the10283.58 awarding10283.82 of10284.06 industry10284.3 recognized10284.62 credentials.10285.5
10285.66 And10285.66 as10285.66 secretary10285.82 Tuckweiler10286.22 said,10286.78 the10287.02 expansion10287.18 of10287.58 MYCAP10287.98 dedicated10288.54 career10289.02 counseling10289.26 for10289.74 all10289.9 students.10290.06 We10291.66 need10291.82 to10291.98 continue10292.14 to10292.54 expand10292.62 early10292.94 college,10293.18 which10293.5 is10293.66 an10293.82 initiative10293.98 that10294.38 the10294.62 data10294.7 is10295.02 showing10295.18 is10295.42 having10295.58 great10295.82 impact.10296.06 It's10296.86 an10297.17 important10297.33 way10297.49 to10297.81 increase10297.97 student10298.28 opportunity10298.6 and10299.08 equity10299.25 as10299.56 well10299.65 as10299.89 sustaining10299.97 our10300.36 state's10300.52 economic10300.84 competitiveness.10301.33 Mass10302.76 Inc,10303 as10303.89 many10304.05 of10304.28 you10304.36 might10304.52 already10304.68 know,10305 projects10305.25 that10305.65 the10305.81 state10305.89 will10306.2 have10306.36 200,00010306.6 fewer10307.81 college10308.68 educated10309.33 workers10310.05 by10310.92 2030.10311.17 And10312.51 so10312.59 we10312.75 need10312.91 to10313.07 double10313.15 down10313.47 on10313.71 investments10313.87 like10314.35 early10314.59 college,10314.91 which10315.23 actually10315.79 doubles10316.67 the10317.15 odds10317.39 for10317.79 sustained10318.03 college10318.43 enrollment10318.83 for10319.23 students,10319.31 meaning10320.03 more10320.35 degrees10320.51 and10320.83 more10320.99 homegrown10321.23 talent10321.71 for10322.35 our10322.51 state's10322.67 key10322.99 industries.10323.23 I10324.27 will10324.35 point10324.59 out10324.83 that10325.77 this10326.58 year's10326.9 House10327.45 One10327.69 proposal10328.02 from10328.42 the10328.58 Governor10331.38 contains10332.42 $410332.42 million10332.42 less10332.42 than10332.98 what10333.14 is10333.3 needed10333.45 to10333.85 expand10334.02 early10334.42 college10334.66 next10335.06 year.10335.3
10335.53 I10335.53 believe10335.69 that,10336.02 there10336.58 may10336.74 have10336.9 been10337.06 an10337.22 intent10337.38 to10337.69 use10337.94 some10338.25 of10338.42 this10338.58 reimagining10339.71 high10340.19 school10340.43 money10340.67 for10340.91 that,10341.07 and10341.23 so10341.47 we10341.63 would10341.79 recommend10341.95 that10342.51 that10342.83 get10342.91 shifted10343.23 somehow,10343.71 through10345.31 financial10345.63 support10346.03 in10346.43 House10346.83 One10347.15 as10347.15 something10347.39 that10347.63 we10347.79 know10347.95 will10348.11 be10348.35 in10348.43 the10348.59 base10348.67 and10348.91 need10349.15 to10349.27 be10349.39 in10349.55 the10349.71 base10349.79 for10350.51 years10350.75 going10351.07 forward.10351.39 The10352.94 other10353.1 investment10353.34 we10353.67 strongly10353.9 support10354.31 is10354.7 the10354.86 $7510355.02 million10355.83 for10355.83 expanding10356.06 career10356.94 technical10357.26 education,10357.67 and10358.06 we're10358.31 very10358.47 enthusiastic10358.7 about10359.5 this10359.83 investment.10359.98 As10361.18 many10361.42 of10361.58 you10361.75 know,10361.83 families10362.06 and10362.39 business10362.55 leaders10362.78 are10363.18 clamoring10363.26 for10363.67 more10363.83 seats10363.98 in10364.23 these10364.39 important10364.63 pathways.10364.94 We10366.06 know10366.14 that10366.3 Massachusetts10366.62 has10367.26 some10367.42 of10367.58 the10367.66 most10367.74 successful10368.06 CTE10368.38 programs10368.86 in10369.26 the10369.34 country,10369.5 thanks10369.74 in10370.06 large10370.14 part10370.38 to10370.62 the10370.7 funding10370.78 and10371.1 the10371.26 support10371.42 given10372.06 to10372.46 that10372.54 sector10372.78 by10373.18 this10373.26 legislature.10373.5 They10375.02 are10375.18 producing10375.34 exceptional10375.9 results10376.38 for10376.78 students.10376.94
10377.74 However,10377.74 we10379.02 know10379.19 that10379.58 demand10379.83 is10380.15 much10380.31 greater10380.55 than10380.86 the10381.1 supply10381.27 of10381.58 available10381.75 seats10382.15 and10382.86 that10383.02 many10383.19 VocTech10383.5 schools10383.91 have10384.31 far10384.55 more10384.7 applicants10384.94 than10385.27 they're10385.5 able10385.67 to10385.99 accept,10386.07 leading10386.7 to10387.02 long10387.19 waiting10387.34 lists10387.67 and10388.07 denied10388.15 entry10388.55 for10388.94 many10389.1 applicants.10389.42 Worse10390.39 yet,10390.78 we10391.96 know10392.12 that10392.28 many10392.44 of10392.6 the10392.68 students10392.84 turned10393.16 away10393.4 are10393.56 those10393.72 who10393.96 could10394.04 benefit10394.28 most10394.76 and10395.4 would10395.64 be10395.72 most10395.88 likely10396.04 to10396.36 enter10396.44 the10396.68 skilled10396.84 fields10397.16 that10397.4 such10397.56 programs10397.8 are10398.2 designed10398.36 and10398.84 prepare10399.08 graduates10399.8 for.10400.36 So10401.56 that's10401.72 why10402.04 we10402.2 I10402.44 recommend10402.44 you10402.76 support10403 the10403.24 proposal10403.4 to10403.8 allocate10403.88 $7510404.28 million10405.08 to10405.08 be10405.24 used10405.32 to10405.56 provide10405.64 grants10405.96 to10406.5 allow10406.67 for10406.91 the10406.99 expansion10407.15 of10407.47 CTE10407.63 slots10408.18 in10408.83 all10409.06 schools.10409.39 I10410.18 appreciated10410.42 the10410.83 conversation,10410.99 earlier10412.1 from10412.42 both10412.75 Senator10412.99 Feeney,10413.31 senator10413.78 Cronin,10414.18 both10414.83 of10415.06 whom10415.23 we10415.39 know10415.47 have10415.7 been10415.86 focused10416.02 on10416.34 this10416.5 issue10416.67 with10417.23 regard10417.47 to10417.78 how10417.94 that10418.1 $7510418.34 million10419.47 will10419.47 get10419.63 invested.10419.78
10421.02 We10421.02 understand10421.26 the10421.74 need10421.9 to10422.06 reduce10422.22 waiting10422.54 lists,10422.7 but10423.02 we10423.18 also10423.26 want10423.58 to10423.82 make10423.82 sure10423.98 that10424.46 those10424.7 investments10424.94 go10425.42 to10426.22 comprehensive10426.54 high10427.02 schools10427.26 as10427.5 well10427.66 where10427.82 there's10427.98 a10428.22 very10428.38 significant10428.62 need,10429.18 for10429.9 there10430.06 to10430.22 be10430.38 more10430.62 work10431.02 based10431.18 learning10431.5 opportunities10431.9 for10432.54 students,10432.7 in10433.58 many10433.74 of10434.06 those10434.14 schools.10434.38 And10435.33 so10435.5 we10435.58 would10435.81 ask10436.06 for10436.3 prioritization10436.53 of10437.25 those10437.33 things10437.58 as10437.81 well10437.98 as10438.22 programs10438.3 that10438.77 meet10438.93 both10439.25 regional10439.65 and10440.06 state10440.3 labor10440.61 market10440.85 needs10441.17 and10441.73 then10441.9 expand10442.14 access10442.53 to10442.77 CTE10442.93 and10443.42 training10443.5 in10443.81 equitable10443.98 ways.10444.45 And10445.17 finally,10445.42 let10445.81 me10445.98 close10446.14 by,10446.53 asking,10447.59 your10448.55 permission10448.87 to10449.27 propose10449.51 for10449.91 your10450.07 consideration,10450.23 a10451.59 new10451.75 item,10451.91 the10452.87 establishment10453.03 of10453.59 a10453.75 student10453.83 support10454.15 model10454.55 that10454.79 will10454.95 protect10455.11 the10455.51 investment10455.59 that10456.07 this10456.23 legislature10456.47 has10457.03 made10457.27 to10457.75 create10457.91 universal10458.23 access10458.79 to10459.11 public10459.27 higher10459.67 education.10459.99 We10461 are10461.25 very10461.41 grateful,10461.65 as10462.44 an10462.6 organization,10462.84 for10463.33 the10463.56 historic10463.65 investments10464.13 that10464.68 you10464.84 all10465 have10465.17 made10465.41 to10465.89 expand10466.13 higher10466.52 education10466.76 access10467.33 and10467.97 affordability.10468.28
10469.56 The10469.56 increases10469.73 in10470.2 college10470.36 enrollment10470.68 we've10471.17 seen10471.33 is10471.65 evidence10471.89 of10472.44 the10472.6 success,10472.84 but10473.71 we10473.87 also10474.03 know10474.35 that10474.43 the10474.67 return10474.83 on10475.23 that10475.39 investment10475.63 will10476.03 be10476.19 diminished10476.35 if10476.75 we10476.91 don't10476.99 have10477.15 a10477.31 commensurate10477.39 focus10477.95 on10478.27 college10478.51 completion10478.91 rates,10479.39 which10480.11 we10480.35 all10480.59 know10480.83 need10481.15 to10481.31 be10481.47 improved.10481.63 And10482.67 so10482.75 we10482.99 believe10483.15 this10483.47 sub-budget10483.79 might10484.19 be10484.35 the10484.51 most10484.99 appropriate10485.23 vehicle10485.71 for10486.11 a10486.27 one10486.35 time10486.59 investment10486.83 of10487.7 approximately10487.86 $710488.42 million10489.31 to10489.31 be10489.39 spent10489.47 over10489.78 the10489.94 next10490.02 three10490.26 years10490.42 to10491.23 develop,10491.39 pilot,10492.42 and10492.91 launch10493.15 a10493.7 student10493.94 success10494.26 model10494.67 showing10495.31 great10495.63 results10495.78 in10496.18 other10496.34 states,10496.5 which10496.83 is10496.99 called10497.15 ASAP,10497.47 Accelerated10500.42 Study10501.23 And10501.23 Associates10501.23 Programs.10501.23 The10501.23 evidence10501.39 is10501.78 very10501.94 clear,10502.18 and10503.05 we10503.21 believe10503.37 that10503.69 as10503.93 you10504.09 have10504.33 made10504.65 these10504.81 historic10505.13 investments,10505.61 you10506.41 will10506.57 want10506.73 to10507.05 protect10507.05 those10507.45 investments,10507.69 to10508.73 ensure10508.89 that10509.29 students10509.53 are10509.85 not10510.01 just10510.17 attending10510.49 college,10510.97 but10511.61 they10511.77 are10511.93 completing10512.17 in10512.57 some10512.73 very10512.89 significant10513.13 ways.10513.69 ASAP10514.73 has10515.21 a10515.37 very10515.53 robust10515.77 evidence10516.33 base,10516.81 can10517.15 be10517.31 easily10517.55 adapted10517.86 to10518.26 our10518.34 system,10518.5 and10519.23 would10519.47 serve10519.63 as10519.86 a10520.1 short10520.18 money10520.42 protection10520.66 for10521.06 your10521.23 larger10521.39 higher10521.7 and10522.02 investment,10522.18 and10522.82 do10523.06 so10523.31 over10523.47 the10523.7 course10523.94 of10524.26 the10524.34 next10524.42 couple10524.66 of10524.9 years.10525.15
10525.39 Maybe10525.39 with10525.39 a10525.55 million10525.63 dollars10525.86 in10526.18 planning10526.34 grants10526.66 for10526.9 next10527.15 year,10527.31 and10527.78 $210527.94 or10528.1 $310528.26 million10529.23 to10529.23 pilot10529.39 it10529.78 on10529.86 three10530.1 to10530.26 five10530.42 campuses,10530.58 in10531.74 the10531.9 two10532.06 years10532.3 beyond10532.62 that,10533.02 so10533.34 that10533.58 you10533.74 could10533.9 make10534.06 some10534.22 smart10535.5 decisions10535.82 to10536.3 protect10536.46 that10536.94 overall10537.26 public10537.66 higher10537.98 ed10538.3 investment.10538.46 Let10539.34 me10539.5 close10539.66 by,10540.06 voicing10540.94 our10541.5 support10541.66 for10542.3 the10542.78 other10542.94 proposed10543.18 investments10543.74 in10544.22 House10544.91 5510545.15 related10545.78 to10546.19 education,10546.26 the10546.75 funding10546.91 of10547.23 the10547.31 SPED10547.47 circuit10547.78 breaker,10548.02 reducing10548.58 ESOL10550.02 wait10550.58 lists,10550.91 and10551.23 certainly10551.55 expanding10551.86 access10552.34 to10553.86 pre-k,10554.42 particularly10555.31 as10555.78 a10555.94 strategy10556.1 for10556.83 having10556.99 high10557.31 quality10557.47 early10557.86 childhood10558.1 available,10558.58 particularly10558.99 in10559.47 gateway10559.63 communities.10560.1 We10561.38 appreciate10561.62 the10561.94 challenges10562.1 you10562.58 face.10562.74 We10563.38 know10563.54 that10563.7 you're10563.78 weighing10563.94 competing10564.34 priorities,10564.74 but10565.14 we're10565.3 certainly10565.46 grateful10565.78 for10566.42 your10566.58 consideration10566.74 of10567.22 these10567.3 recommendations.10567.54 And10568.1 as10568.26 always,10568.42 we10568.74 look10568.82 forward10569.06 to10569.7 continuing10569.86 our10570.34 work10570.5 with10570.66 you10570.82 on10570.98 behalf10571.14 of10571.38 the10571.54 state10571.62 students.10571.94 Thank10572.34 you10572.5 very10572.66 much10572.9 for10573.06 your10573.22 time10573.38 today.10573.54
10574.65 MICHLEWITZ10574.65 -10574.65 Ed,10574.65 thank10574.81 you10574.97 for10575.13 your10575.28 testimony.10575.52 Appreciate10576.17 your10576.65 perspective,10576.89 as10577.84 always.10578 Thank10578.81 you.10578.97 And,10579.28 we10579.84 will10580.08 certainly10580.4 take10580.89 all10581.28 that10581.44 into10581.6 consideration10581.84 in10582.48 this10582.81 discussion.10583.05 So10583.52 thank10583.76 you.10583.92 Senator10584.97 Collins.10585.28
10586.4 COLLINS10586.4 -10586.4 Thank10586.4 you,10586.73 chair10587.36 Mike10587.68 Woods.10587.92 I10589.79 had10590.75 a10590.87 question10590.99 about10591.79 your10592.43 thoughts10592.91 about10593.55 the10594.11 effectiveness10594.75 of10595.39 regional,10595.63 vocational10596.67 schools10597.15 versus10597.55 ones10598.67 that10598.91 are,10599.07 you10599.31 know,10599.47 led10599.71 within10600.03 a10600.43 school10600.51 district.10600.75 Obviously,10601.55 we've10601.87 struggled10602.19 in10602.67 Boston10602.83 and,10603.23 you10603.47 know,10603.55 I10603.71 know10603.93 they're10604.09 coming10604.17 up10604.42 to10604.65 ask10604.73 for10604.98 significant10605.77 help10606.65 from10606.98 the10607.14 Mass10607.38 School10607.61 Building10607.77 Authority,10608.09 that10609.38 I10609.53 would10609.69 support,10609.85 you10610.33 know,10610.49 major10610.9 renovation10611.3 long10611.93 overdue.10612.17 Understanding10614.17 that10614.65 places10615.14 like10615.45 Worcester10615.69 that10616.01 have10616.17 it10616.33 inside10616.42 the10616.81 school10616.98 district10617.22 have10617.61 had10617.85 success,10618.09 but10618.91 seems10619.31 to10620.43 a10620.51 lot10620.59 of10620.75 others10620.83 that10621.15 are10621.47 regional10621.71 or10622.27 county10622.43 based.10622.75 Do10624.03 you10624.11 have10624.19 an10624.35 opinion10624.51 one10624.75 way10624.91 or10625.15 the10625.23 other10625.39 on10625.55 how10626.11 the10626.35 model10627.71 is10628.11 more10628.27 effective10628.43 one10628.99 way?10629.15
10630.03 LAMBERT10630.27 -10630.27 I10630.27 don't10630.35 know10630.59 that10630.75 one10630.91 model10631.07 is10631.39 better10631.81 than10632.05 the10632.17 other.10632.28 I10632.52 think10632.69 as10632.85 you10633.08 correctly10633.25 pointed10633.73 out,10634.05 there10634.28 are10634.52 some10634.6 really10634.93 stellar10635.33 regional10635.81 vocational10636.2 technical10636.69 schools,10637.17 in10638.2 Massachusetts,10638.44 and10639.08 then10639.25 you10639.41 have10639.57 an10639.73 example10639.89 like10640.28 in10640.52 Worcester,10640.69 where10641.81 you've10642.2 got10642.6 a10643.49 school10643.57 with10643.89 a10644.05 great,10644.13 a10645.08 great10645.17 history10645.49 that10645.97 has10646.2 done10646.36 tremendous10647.01 work.10647.33 I10648.61 know10648.77 that10648.93 the10649.33 BPS10649.41 has10649.89 struggled10650.05 with10650.45 Madison10650.85 Park10651.33 and10651.65 the10651.73 mission10651.81 and10652.45 all10652.85 of10653.01 that10653.17 over10653.41 time.10653.73 I10654.85 don't10655.65 know10655.89 that10656.05 there's10656.21 one10656.53 quick10656.85 fix10657.25 for10657.49 that,10657.65 but10657.89 I10658.05 do10658.21 think10658.37 that10658.69 the10661.14 idea10661.3 here10661.77 is10662.42 to10662.81 not10663.22 just10663.77 segregate10664.09 Voc10664.81 Ed10665.14 in10665.38 those10665.53 schools,10665.77 but10666.09 to10666.33 start10666.5 to10666.73 expand10666.98 it10667.22 to10667.93 all10668.09 schools.10668.42 That10669.22 indeed10669.45 every10669.77 student,10670.09 even10670.42 if10670.58 they're10670.73 on10670.9 a10671.06 career10671.14 path,10671.45 should10671.69 have10671.85 some10672.01 work10672.25 based10672.42 learning10672.65 opportunities,10673.06 and10674.11 every10674.27 student10674.43 who's10674.91 getting10675.15 some10675.39 CTE10675.63 work10676.11 should10676.35 have10676.59 access10676.75 to10677.07 college10677.23 credit10677.63 and10677.95 the10678.19 like,10678.35 so10678.67 that10678.83 we10678.99 don't10679.15 track10679.31 students.10680.27
10680.43 But10680.43 we10680.43 give10680.59 them10680.83 really10681.07 kind10681.39 of10681.47 a10681.63 wide10681.79 range10681.95 of10682.19 things.10682.35 That10682.59 doesn't10682.75 mean10682.99 we10683.15 shouldn't10683.31 invest10683.55 in10684.43 schools10684.83 like10685.15 Madison10685.39 Park,10685.87 particularly10686.35 for10686.91 some10687.22 of10687.38 the10687.45 very10687.61 specific10687.93 technical10688.73 skills10689.14 that10689.45 are10689.61 needed10689.77 in10690.42 a10690.5 region,10690.9 electricians,10691.77 carpenters,10692.58 etcetera.10693.45 The10694.98 only10695.06 other10695.3 advice10695.53 though10695.85 I10696.01 would10696.09 offer10696.33 is10696.66 that10696.9 that10697.14 we've10697.38 we10697.69 feel10698.01 very10698.33 strongly10698.66 that10699.83 these10700.23 investments,10700.55 the10701.03 $7510701.11 million10701.83 there,10701.83 and10702.07 and10702.23 this10702.39 legislature10702.63 has10703.11 already10703.27 taken10703.59 care10703.83 on10703.99 this,10704.15 to10704.95 ensure10705.11 that10705.43 they10705.67 are10705.83 aligned10705.99 with10706.31 labor10706.47 market10706.87 need.10707.19 We're10708.07 not10708.31 doing10708.47 students10708.71 any10709.67 service10709.99 if10710.47 we10710.71 put10710.95 them10711.11 into10711.35 vocational10711.59 education10712.15 programs10712.63 for10713.03 which10713.19 there10713.43 is10713.59 no10713.75 future.10713.91 And10715.35 so10715.51 trying10715.75 to10716.08 identify10716.31 where10717.03 that10717.27 work10717.75 is10718.08 going,10718.23 making10718.95 those10719.27 smart10719.67 investments10720 in10720.56 those10720.72 particular10720.95 areas,10721.43 we10721.67 think10721.83 is10722 the10722.15 best10722.31 way10722.56 to10722.72 go,10722.8 and10722.88 there's10723.11 no10723.35 reason10723.51 why10724.08 Madison10724.31 Park10724.72 or10724.88 any10725.03 other10725.27 high10725.43 school10725.59 couldn't10725.83 be10726.08 part10726.23 of10726.48 a10726.56 dynamic10726.72 new10727.19 future.10727.35
10728.48 MICHLEWITZ10728.48 -10728.48 Thank10728.48 you.10728.64
10728.95 COLLINS10728.95 -10728.95 Thank10728.95 you.10729.19
10730.68 MICHLEWITZ10730.68 -10730.68 Thank10730.68 you.10730.92 Any10731.24 other10731.48 questions10731.64 or10731.96 comments10732.12 from10732.68 members10732.92 of10733.24 the10733.32 committee?10733.48 Okay.10734.76 Ed,10735.24 thank10735.48 you10735.72 so10735.88 much.10736.04
10736.28 TUTWILER10736.28 -10736.28 Thank10736.28 you10736.52 so10736.68 much.10736.76
10737.08 MICHLEWITZ10737.08 -10737.08 Thank10737.08 you.10737.32 Our10738.76 final10739 testimony10740.12 will10740.76 be10740.92 from10741 Reggie10741.24 Ramos10741.64 from10742.2 Transportation10742.6 for10743.24 Massachusetts.10743.4
10757.4 REGGIE10757.4 RAMOS10757.4 -10757.4 TRANSPORTATION10757.4 FOR10757.4 MASSACHUSETTS10757.4 -10757.4 HB10757.4 5510757.4 -10757.4 Thank10757.4 you,10757.64 chair10757.96 Michaelowitz,10758.28 chair10759.56 Rodericks,10759.88 and10760.68 members10760.84 of10761.16 the10761.32 committee10761.4 for10761.8 inviting10761.96 us10762.36 here10762.52 today.10762.76 My10763.32 name10763.48 is10763.72 Reggie10763.88 Ramos.10764.2 I'm10764.6 the10764.76 executive10765 director10765.48 of10765.88 transportation10766.12 for10766.68 mass10766.92 Massachusetts10767.49 or10768.15 t10768.39 T4MA.10769.02 And10769.35 I10769.58 am10769.67 joined10769.91 by10770.31 my10770.63 colleague,10770.78 Pet10771.35 Wilson.10771.67 T4MA10777.83 is10777.99 a10778.15 statewide10778.23 coalition10778.78 of10779.35 community10779.51 based10780.07 organizations,10780.63 transportation,10782.18 housing10782.98 and10783.46 public10783.7 health10784.02 advocates10784.42 who10785.3 are10785.62 collectively10785.86 working10786.58 to10786.98 improve10787.22 our10787.54 transportation10787.78 system10788.5 across10789.22 the10789.62 commonwealth10789.78 so10790.58 residents10790.82 can10791.38 flourish.10791.7 T4MA10793.14 has10793.86 long10794.1 been10794.34 a10794.58 supporter10794.66 of10795.3 new10795.62 revenue10795.78 for10796.34 transportation10796.66 and10797.46 a10812.17 FareShare10814.35 amendment10814.35 has10814.35 significantly10814.35 increased10814.35 the10814.35 amount10816.53 of10818.71 available10818.96 funding10818.96 for10818.96 transit,10818.96 roads,10818.96 bridges,10818.96 and10818.96 roadway10818.96 safety.10818.96 In10818.96 2023,10818.96 T4MA,10818.96 and10818.96 over10818.96 3010818.96 other10818.96 organizations10818.96 asked10818.96 the10818.96 legislature10822.03 for10822.03 three10822.03 things.10822.03
10822.03 One,10831.48 split10831.48 FareShare10831.48 spending10831.48 50:50,10831.48 with10831.48 education.10831.48 Two10831.48 spend10831.48 the10831.48 funds10831.48 in10831.48 a10831.48 transparent10831.48 way.10831.48 Three,10831.48 do10831.48 not10831.48 supplement10831.48 current10831.48 funding10831.48 with10831.48 FareShare10831.48 dollars.10831.48 To10831.48 the10831.48 credit10831.48 of10831.48 your10831.48 leadership,10831.48 for10831.48 the10831.48 most10831.48 part10831.48 you10831.48 have10831.48 supported10832.27 three10834.14 requests.10834.14 You10834.14 have10834.38 recognised10834.62 that10835.18 these10835.42 funds10835.66 were10835.98 initially10836.22 skewed10836.7 towards10837.18 education10837.74 and10838.86 transportation10839.18 remains10840.22 in10841.26 significant10841.5 need10842.14 of10842.46 funding.10842.62 The10844.14 education10844.46 and10844.94 transportation10845.18 fund10846.06 has10846.38 shown10846.62 voters10846.94 exactly10847.66 how10848.22 these10848.54 funds10848.78 are10849.47 being10849.7 spent.10849.94 And10850.98 funding10851.31 has10851.78 increased10852.02 for10852.67 transportation,10852.9 especially10854.34 for10855.15 the10855.39 1510855.63 Regional10857.31 Transit10857.94 Authorities10857.94 or10857.94 RTAs10858.18 across10858.82 the10859.23 state.10859.39 Our10860.42 members10860.67 and10861.23 your10861.39 constituents10861.7 are10862.64 now10862.88 seeing10863.12 the10863.36 benefits10863.52 of10863.92 low10864.24 income10864.56 fares10864.8 on10865.2 the10865.28 MBTA10865.44 and10866.32 free10866.64 fares10866.88 on10867.28 the10867.44 RTAs.They10868.72 are10868.88 also10869.12 seeing10869.44 expanded10869.92 service10870.48 on10870.96 RTAs10871.2 to10871.76 include10871.92 evenings10872.4 and10873.12 Sundays,10873.36 as10874.24 well10874.48 as10874.72 no10875.04 slow10875.28 zones10875.6 on10876.08 the10876.24 T10876.4 for10877.04 the10877.28 first10877.44 time10878.05 in10878.28 decades.10878.52
10879.89 These10879.89 investments10880.28 have10880.84 reduced10881.08 commute10881.65 times10882.05 and10882.68 aggravation10883 for10884.13 residents10884.44 who10884.92 take10885.08 transit,10885.32 but10886.13 we10886.44 still10886.68 have10887.08 many10887.32 needs10887.65 to10888.52 address10888.76 across10889.25 the10889.73 Commonwealth.10889.89 We're10891.16 still10891.32 at10891.88 rank10892.04 number10892.44 four10892.76 in10893.16 the10893.32 country10893.48 for10893.88 congestion10894.12 in10894.76 the10894.92 Boston10895 area.10895.4 Transportation10896.44 is10897.24 the10897.4 leading10897.56 source10897.88 of10898.2 emissions,10898.44 and10899.32 we10899.56 have10899.72 billions10899.96 of10900.36 dollars10900.52 of10900.92 backlog10901.16 maintenance10901.64 at10902.2 the10902.36 MBTA.10902.52 Bridges10903.69 needing10904.17 repair10904.58 and10905.45 RTA10905.85 service10906.42 have10906.81 yet10907.06 to10907.3 grow10907.45 with10907.77 increasing10908.01 resident10908.58 needs.10909.06 We10910.17 are10910.42 fortunate10910.66 to10911.14 have10911.3 the10911.53 FareShare10911.93 funds10912.17 available10912.58 to10913.45 prevent10913.61 draconian10914.25 service10914.81 cuts10915.22 and10915.85 fare10916.09 increases10916.33 at10916.9 the10917.06 MBTA.10917.22 However,10918.25 as10919.51 you10919.67 can10919.91 see10920.07 from10920.23 the10920.47 graph10920.63 that10920.87 we10921.03 asked10921.27 the10921.51 court10921.67 officers10922.07 to10922.47 distribute.10923.83 The10924.07 unexpended10924.07 resources10924.87 or10925.51 surplus10925.67 of10926.23 FareShare10926.63 dollars10927.03 will10927.59 not10927.83 be10928.07 sustained10928.39 over10928.95 the10929.19 next10929.35 few10929.75 years10929.99 as10930.87 we10931.03 land10931.27 more10931.75 accurate10932.07 revenue10932.63 projections10933.11 and10934.35 thus10934.6 have10934.83 increased10935.16 budgeted10935.8 funds.10936.35
10937.48 Whichever10937.48 way10938.19 we10938.35 invest10938.6 these10939 funds,10939.32 particularly10939.8 the10940.44 surplus,10940.67 we10941.32 need10941.48 to10941.72 make10941.8 sure10941.95 that10942.67 they10942.92 are10943.16 for10943.4 one10943.64 time10943.88 spending10944.27 and10944.75 that10944.92 they10945.16 are10945.4 not10945.56 over10946.44 committed10946.67 to10947.39 programmatic10947.63 investments10948.43 that10948.99 need10949.23 to10949.55 be10949.63 funded10949.79 in10950.19 future10950.43 years10950.75 as10951.47 there10951.71 will10951.87 not10952.11 be10952.27 enough10952.51 FareShare10953.15 revenue10953.39 to10953.63 pay10953.87 for10954.11 them.10954.27 In10955.31 short,10955.63 while10956.11 FareShare10956.91 dollars10957.39 are10957.87 serving10958.19 us10958.67 well,10958.91 the10959.89 reality10960.05 is10960.6 investing10961.16 in10961.56 the10961.81 Massachusetts10961.81 transportation10962.6 system10963.32 for10964.2 the10964.44 long10964.68 term10964.92 as10965.65 we10965.97 should10966.28 also10967.08 require10967.56 new10968.28 sustainable10969 and10969.73 dedicated10969.97 revenue10970.52 services.10971.08 Finally,10972.34 as10972.74 we10973.06 deliberate10973.46 about10974.1 how10974.58 to10974.9 spend10975.14 for10975.62 transportation10976.02 or10976.74 how10976.98 to10977.22 fund10977.54 transportation,10977.94 I10979.22 would10979.46 be10979.7 very10979.94 remiss10980.42 not10980.82 to10981.06 underscore10981.38 the10982.26 changing10982.5 landscape10983.06 of10983.78 marriage10998.03 rates10998.03 in10998.03 the10998.03 distribution10998.03 of10998.03 federal10998.03 funds.10998.03
10998.03 The10998.03 new10998.03 administration10998.03 via10998.03 a10998.03 USDOT10998.03 directed10998.03 ordered10998.03 preferential10998.03 treatment10998.03 for10998.03 places10998.03 with10998.03 higher10998.03 births10998.03 and10998.03 marriage10998.03 rates10998.44 in10999.1 the10999.26 distribution10999.5 of11000.22 the11000.38 federal11000.38 funds.11000.86 Massachusetts11001.66 does11002.62 not11002.78 rank11003.26 in11003.74 either11003.98 of11004.3 these11004.46 categories.11004.86 We11005.42 are11005.66 at11005.82 the11005.98 bottom.11006.14 The11007.34 bipartisan11007.58 infrastructure11008.38 bill11009.02 is11009.34 set11009.42 to11009.58 expire11009.74 in11010.06 September11010.22 2026,11010.93 and11012.11 every11012.27 indication11012.75 from11013.48 the11013.64 Trump11013.88 administration11014.27 is11015.23 that11015.4 future11015.64 federal11016.11 government11016.92 spending11017.4 will11018.19 be11018.35 reduced11018.51 across11019.08 the11019.4 board.11019.56 In11020.11 addition,11020.35 tariffs11021.4 will11021.88 spike11022.11 the11022.35 cost11022.35 of11022.67 infrastructure11022.92 projects,11023.72 dramatically11024.84 reducing11025.4 the11025.88 buying11026.04 power11026.44 of11026.76 the11026.92 funds11027.08 we11027.48 have.11027.72 Simply11028.84 put,11029.24 we11029.64 are11029.88 most11030.12 likely11030.36 to11031.32 be11031.48 on11031.72 our11031.96 own11032.12 as11032.52 a11032.68 commonwealth.11032.84 And11033.96 the11034.12 residents11034.28 of11034.76 Massachusetts11035 recognize11036.12 this11036.63 to11036.86 be11037.1 so.11037.99
11038.07 In11038.07 a11038.31 recent11038.39 statewide11038.78 poll,11039.34 nearly11040.39 60%11041.02 of11041.91 residents11042.15 said11042.63 they11043.26 believe11043.5 that11043.99 we11044.23 need11044.47 to11044.78 come11044.86 up11045.91 with11046.15 a11046.31 transportation11047.26 funding11047.99 plan11048.47 without11048.86 relying11049.42 on11049.99 federal11050.15 funds.11050.63 While11051.97 we11052.21 support11052.45 the11052.77 shoring11053.01 up11053.41 of11053.89 funds11054.13 from11054.93 FareShare11055.25 for11055.89 transportation11056.21 to11057.25 address11057.41 the11057.97 urgency11058.21 of11058.93 the11059.09 moment,11059.25 it11060.13 behooves11060.45 us11060.93 to11061.25 do11061.41 more.11061.65 We11062.69 believe11062.85 we11064.21 can11064.45 do11064.69 more.11064.85 A11065.66 strong11065.9 transportation11066.14 infrastructure11067.17 and11067.74 network11067.98 benefits11068.53 the11068.94 entire11069.09 economy11069.58 and11070.14 connects11070.38 people11070.85 with11071.17 opportunities.11071.42 We11072.69 can11072.94 only11073.17 truly11073.5 have11073.9 this11074.14 if11074.45 we11074.69 have11074.85 consistent11075.17 funding11075.74 streams11076.22 made11076.94 up11077.25 of11077.5 various11077.74 and11078.22 dedicated11078.45 revenue11079.33 sources.11079.82 We11080.94 encourage11081.34 and11081.82 respectfully11082.14 implore11082.86 this11083.58 committee11083.9 to11084.54 look11084.7 beyond11085.02 FareShare11085.66 for11085.98 new11086.22 alternative11086.46 equitable11087.5 ways11087.98 to11088.38 fund11088.54 transportation11088.94 in11089.98 the11090.14 Commonwealth11090.3 to11091.02 benefit11091.18 all11091.66 residents11091.98 so11092.46 we11092.62 can11092.78 address11092.8 our11092.82 transportation11092.84 challenges11092.86 for11092.88 the11092.9 long11092.92 haul11092.94 and11092.96 for11092.98 good.11093 And11093.02 so11093.1 cyclical11101.17 cliff11101.97 two11102.76 years11102.92 hence.11103.25 With11104.68 that,11104.84 I'd11105.17 like11105.32 to11105.48 turn11105.56 over11105.89 to11106.28 Pet11107.32 Wilson11107.56 for11108.03 remarks11108.27 on11108.43 the11108.67 Governor11109.87 supplemental11110.35 budget11110.91 proposal.11111.23
11114.27 PETER11114.27 WILSON11114.27 -11114.27 TRANSPORTATION11114.27 FOR11114.27 MASSACHUSETTS11114.27 -11114.27 HB11114.27 5511114.27 -11114.27 Thank11114.27 you,11114.51 Reggie11114.75 and11115.07 members11115.31 of11115.63 the11115.71 committee.11115.79 I'll11116.35 be11116.59 brief11116.75 because11116.99 I11117.23 know11117.31 the11117.47 hour11117.55 is11117.87 getting11117.95 late11118.19 as11118.67 they11118.91 say.11119.15 I'm11120.11 Pet11120.38 Wilson,11120.61 senior11120.93 policy11121.42 director11121.74 at11122.14 T4MAS.11122.61 I11122.77 just11122.93 want11123.17 to11123.5 make11123.5 a11123.66 couple11123.74 of11124.06 comments11124.3 on11124.77 the11124.93 Governor's11125.09 sub11125.98 proposal11126.22 as11127.25 well11127.42 as11127.81 her11127.98 FY11128.45 26,11128.69 House11129.74 one11129.98 proposal.11130.3 We11131.66 more11131.98 or11132.14 less11132.22 support11132.53 the11134.05 one11134.29 time11134.53 expenditures11134.93 that11135.49 are11135.65 in,11135.81 House11136.85 Bill11137.41 5511137.81 to,11139.01 put11139.49 the11139.73 MBTA11140.61 on11141.25 stable11141.57 footing.11142.45 However,11143.25 we11144.85 do11145.17 recognize11145.73 the11149.41 disparity11149.65 in11150.44 the11150.6 regional11150.76 equity11151.25 piece11151.65 that11151.97 Senator11152.28 Commerford11152.68 and11153.17 others11153.33 have11153.65 pointed11153.81 out.11154.13 And11155.17 we11155.33 think11155.57 that11155.89 combined11156.36 with11156.76 the11157 FY11157.25 2611157.49 budget11158.2 that11158.68 it11158.92 needs11159.08 to11159.41 be11159.49 addressed,11159.85 significantly.11160.33 If11161.69 you11161.85 look11162.01 at11162.41 the11163.93 Governor's11164.17 FY11164.65 2611165.05 House11165.85 One11166.09 proposal,11166.09 the11167.13 MBTA11167.29 receives11168.01 an11168.65 additional11168.89 $37311169.37 million11171.61 over11171.61 what11171.85 they11172.09 received11172.25 in11172.65 FY11172.97 25.11173.28 The11174.73 RTAs11174.97 received11176.4 no11176.81 additional11177.13 funding.11177.44 It's11178.08 the11178.33 exact11178.48 same11178.81 amount11178.97 with11179.2 the11179.36 exact11179.52 same11179.76 distribution11180.08 as11180.65 this11181.2 current11181.44 fiscal11181.76 year.11182.17
11183.2 We11183.2 implore11183.52 these11185.6 committees11185.92 and11186.48 the11186.73 House11186.89 and11187.13 the11187.28 Senate11187.36 to11187.76 look11187.92 significantly11188.76 at11189.32 RTA11189.56 funding11190.12 for,11190.92 across11192.36 the11192.68 Commonwealth.11192.76 The11193.32 1511193.48 RTAs11193.8 across11194.36 the11194.6 Commonwealth11194.68 serve11195.08 over11195.4 25011195.72 communities.11196.52 With11197.88 the11198.04 fareShare11198.52 funds11198.68 that11198.92 they11199.08 have11199.24 received11199.48 over11199.8 the11199.96 last11200.12 few11200.28 years,11200.44 they've11200.68 expanded11201 service,11201.48 including11202.72 Sunday11203.27 service,11203.75 as11204.24 well11204.48 as11204.72 adopted11205.03 free11205.44 fares11205.75 in11206.08 1311206.32 of11206.72 the11206.88 1511206.95 RTAs.11207.35 The11208.16 Worcester11208.32 RTA11208.72 in11209.11 particular11209.27 has11209.67 seen11209.83 record11210.08 ridership11210.32 as11210.88 a11211.03 result11211.11 of11211.44 this,11211.59 and11212.08 the11212.32 Merrimack11212.48 Valley11212.95 Planning11213.35 Commission11213.67 just11214.08 published11214.81 a11215.05 report11215.21 that11215.69 because11216.57 of11216.97 fare11217.13 free11217.45 services11217.69 in11218.57 the11218.73 Merrimack11219.21 Valley,11219.69 they've11220.01 seen11221.13 a11221.37 $211221.45 million11222.41 boost11222.41 in11222.65 economic11222.89 activity.11225.29 People11226.94 need11227.19 to11227.42 get11227.58 to11227.75 where11227.99 they11228.23 need11228.31 to11228.47 go.11228.55 We11228.86 also11229.1 would11229.75 support11230.07 more11231.5 additional11231.91 and11232.47 sustained11232.63 funding11233.19 for11233.58 micro11233.83 transit.11234.23
11235.67 Currently,11235.67 there11236.15 is11236.31 no11236.55 definition11237.26 of11237.83 micro11238.07 transit11238.39 in11238.86 state11239.26 law,11239.58 So11240.22 we11240.46 don't11240.62 know11240.7 exactly11241.26 what11242.22 these11242.46 services11242.7 are,11243.1 what11243.34 definitions11243.66 they11244.22 fall11244.38 under11244.62 for11244.94 sustainable11245.18 funding,11245.74 but11247.34 we11247.5 don't11247.66 think11247.9 grant11248.22 funding11248.46 is11248.86 the11249.02 way11249.1 to11249.34 go.11249.42 It's11249.74 no11250.46 way11250.62 to11251.58 run11251.74 a11251.98 railroad11252.06 as11252.54 they11252.78 say,11252.94 pun11253.26 intended.11253.5 And11255 the11255.16 second11255.32 thing11255.56 I'd11255.8 like11256.03 to11256.27 point11256.35 out11256.59 in11256.67 the11256.83 Governor's11257.56 FY11257.8 2611257.8 budget11258.27 proposal,11258.59 when11259.4 the11259.64 education11259.8 and11260.19 transportation11260.35 trust11260.92 fund11261.16 was11261.4 established,11261.56 to11263.32 Reggie's11263.48 point,11263.88 it11264.83 is11265 very11265.24 transparent11265.48 how11266.19 FareShare11266.75 dollars11267 were11267.32 being11267.48 spent.11267.64 Line11268.44 items,11268.75 allocations,11270.65 exactly11272.57 language11273.29 where11273.77 it's11273.93 going.11274.17 If11274.65 you11274.81 look11274.97 at11275.13 the11275.21 Governor's11275.37 proposal11276.33 to11276.97 securitize11277.13 the11277.85 transfer11278.49 to11279.37 make11279.53 more11280.01 or11280.25 less11280.33 an11280.65 off-budget11280.89 transfer11281.29 to11281.77 the11282.01 Commonwealth11282.33 Transportation11283.32 Trust11283.64 Fund,11284.03 you11285.48 will11285.64 not11285.8 see11286.19 that11286.59 language11287 anymore11287.64 moving11288.27 forward11288.59 in11288.92 the11289.08 budget.11289.16
11290.35 We11290.35 would11290.59 ask11290.92 that11291.24 the11291.4 legislature11291.64 establish11292.35 a11294.83 real11295 time11295.32 public11296.03 dashboard11296.59 for11297.61 how11297.85 FareShare11298.09 dollars11298.49 on11298.73 transportation11298.89 are11299.45 being11299.61 spent.11299.85 It's11300.73 transparent11301.05 to11301.61 the11301.77 voters.11301.85 It11302.65 allows,11302.81 advocates11304.57 like11305.13 myself11305.37 and11305.69 Reggie11305.85 and11306.17 other11306.33 organizations11306.49 to11307.21 understand11307.37 how11307.85 these11308.09 dollars11308.25 are11308.57 being11308.65 spent,11308.97 as11309.61 well11309.85 as11310.09 members11310.41 of11310.73 the11310.89 legislature11311.05 to11311.69 understand11311.93 not11313.03 only11313.27 the11314 direct11314.24 allocations11314.72 from11315.11 the11315.35 CTF,11315.51 but11315.92 also11316.08 the11316.32 bonding11316.48 implications11317.03 that11317.51 we11317.75 have11317.83 moving11318.08 forward11318.4 for11318.95 the11319.11 Governor's11319.75 $811320.32 billion11320.32 dollar11320.32 1011320.64 year11320.88 plan.11321.19 We11323.03 feel11323.19 that11323.44 transparency11323.67 is11324.32 the11324.48 best11324.64 way11324.95 to11325.19 move11325.35 forward11325.51 when11325.83 it11326 comes11326.16 to11326.4 spending11326.56 these11326.88 dollars,11327.11 and11327.83 that11328.08 the11328.32 CIP11328.93 process11329.33 and11330.21 the11330.45 fFareShare11331.65 spending11332.45 report11332.77 that11333.09 A&F11333.49 does11333.73 at11333.89 the11333.97 end11334.05 of11334.21 every11334.37 year11334.61 is11335.01 not11335.17 sufficient11335.41 enough.11335.89 So,11336.29 thank11337.01 you11337.25 for11337.33 your11337.57 time.11337.73 And11338.05 with11338.21 that,11338.45 we're11338.61 happy11338.85 to11339.09 answer11339.17 any11339.41 questions.11339.65
11341.41 MICHLEWITZ11341.41 -11341.41 Rajeev11341.41 and11341.89 Pete,11342.05 thank11342.29 you11342.53 for11342.69 your11343.23 testimony.11343.47 Appreciate11344.19 it11344.67 in11344.83 the11344.99 perspective11345.15 as11345.7 well.11345.86 Open11347.39 up11347.7 for11347.78 any11347.86 questions11348.02 or11348.35 comments11348.58 from11348.99 members11349.47 of11349.86 the11349.94 committee.11350.1 It11352.91 is11353.07 the11353.23 witching11353.39 hour,11353.7 so11354.02 you11354.58 got11354.99 off11355.15 easy.11355.31 We11355.63 appreciate,11355.78 again,11356.35 you11356.58 being11356.83 here.11357.07 Thank11357.78 you,11357.94 once11359 again.11359.24 And11359.32 so,11359.56 and11359.96 we'll11360.12 keep11360.36 talking11360.92 as11361.24 we11361.4 move11361.48 forward11361.64 in11361.88 this11361.96 discussion.11362.2 Thank11362.52 you.11362.68
11362.92 WILSON11362.92 -11362.92 Thank11362.92 you.11362.96
11363 RAMOS11363 -11363 Thank11363 you.11363.4
11364.12 MICHLEWITZ11364.12 -11364.12 So11364.12 that11364.36 is11364.44 the11364.68 testimony.11365.32 That11366.28 is11366.44 it11366.6 for11366.76 the11366.92 hearing.11367.08 Our11367.56 next11367.72 Ways11367.96 and11368.2 Means11368.28 hearing,11368.52 we're11368.68 going11368.92 back11369.16 to11369.32 the11369.48 FY11369.64 2611369.96 budget11370.92 on11371.32 Monday,11371.48 in11372.7 Attleboro,11372.94 with11373.82 health11373.9 and11374.15 human11374.31 services,11374.55 at11375.42 11:00AM,11375.58 I11376.23 believe.11376.31 So11377.34 thank11377.9 you11378.15 all,11378.31 and,11378.55 we'll11379.02 talk11379.26 soon.11379.42 Thanks.11379.74