SPEAKER10.16 -0.16 Massachusetts0.16 Cranberry0.8 Revitalization1.36 Task2.32 Force.2.64 The3.6 objective3.76 of4.24 which4.32 was4.56 to4.8 examine4.88 the5.28 status5.44 of5.84 the6 industry6.08 and6.56 the6.8 complex6.96 challenges7.52 ahead,8.08 and8.64 to8.88 develop9.04 a9.36 multi9.6 pronged10 action10.64 plan11.04 geared11.44 towards11.68 stabilizing12.08 and12.24
23.55 separated23.55 from23.6 Chapter23.64 61.24.28 Developing25.17 renewable25.65 energy26.05 on26.37 land26.61 separated26.93 from27.49 chapter27.65 6128.37 a.28.85 The29.57 key29.81 provisions30.05 of30.61 this30.69 bill30.93 allow31.73 the31.97 farmer32.13 landowner32.53 to33.09 separate33.25 land33.81 from34.29 the34.53 provisions34.61 of35.09 chapter35.25 6135.65 a36.13 without36.92 requiring37.24 a37.65 municipal37.8 right38.28 of38.52 first38.6 refusal38.84 prior39.41 to39.73 separation.39.88 The41.09 farmer41.24 ultimately41.65 will42.28 be42.45 able42.6 to42.84 maintain42.92 ownership43.41 rights43.88 without44.77 the45.09 threat45.24 of45.56 a45.8 forced45.88 sale.46.28 It47.41 also47.65 eliminates47.97 the48.52 548.68 year48.84 rollback49.09 or49.56 conveyance49.8 tax50.45 requirement,50.84 allowing51.94 the52.26 farmer52.42 to52.74 reinvest52.98 in53.38 their53.54 business53.7 operations54.1 as54.74 opposed54.9 to55.22 making55.38 a55.7 payment55.78 to56.1 the56.26 municipality.56.42 The58.18 positive58.26 impacts58.82 include59.3 helping60.1 the60.42 farmer60.58 generate60.98 income61.38 to61.7 support61.86 their62.18 agricultural62.42 activities,63.22 while64.19 generating64.44 clean65.08 local65.72 electricity66.28 in67.39 support67.63 of67.88 the68.03 Commonwealth's68.11 clean68.75 energy68.92 and69.31 climate69.39 goals.69.8 The70.99 other71.16 positive71.39 impact71.88 is72.27 generating72.52 tax72.99 revenue73.31 for73.72 the73.88 town.73.95 Separated74.92 land75.56 will75.8 be75.88 subject76.03 to76.44 real76.59 estate76.83 taxes77.23 and77.72 personal77.95 property78.35 taxes78.83 Last79.11
85.16 session85.16
91.3 Last91.3 session,91.45 an91.69 identical91.85 pill92.49 was92.73 reported92.97 out93.45 favorably,93.77 by94.73 the95.05 Joint95.22 Revenue95.53 Committee.96.02 It96.33 was96.41 a96.66 a97.3 bill97.38 that97.69 was97.85 sponsored98.17 by98.66 former99.05 senator99.45 Sue99.94 Moran100.17 and100.66 co100.81 sponsored101.05 by101.45 my101.61 predecessor,101.77 representative102.73 Bill103.3 Strauss.103.53 I103.58 strongly103.61 urge103.65 the103.69 committee's103.94 support105.63 of106.07 this106.51 bill.106.59 Thank106.83 you.107.23
107.79 SPEAKER2107.79 -107.79 Great.107.79 Thank108.11 you,109.39 representative.109.47 Alright.111.31 Good111.55 morning.111.79 Just112.11 for112.51
112.59 SPEAKER3112.59 -112.59 a112.59 little112.67 background,112.99 this114.43 was114.67 designed114.91 from116.11 the116.35 task116.51 force116.75 to117.15 help117.31 primary117.55 farmers,117.95 provide119.59 another119.91 source120.23 of120.39 income.120.55 It121.19 would121.35 not121.59 be121.83 taking121.99 away122.31 property123.44 that123.91 is124.08 in124.23 agricultural124.39 land,124.95 so125.19 this125.35 is125.59 adjacent125.83 land126.31 that's126.55 not126.8 in127.03 production.127.19 It128.72 is128.88 applicable129.11 to129.59 all129.75 of129.91 our130.07 culture,130.24 but130.56 I'm130.92 speaking131.08 just131.4 for131.48 cranberry.131.72 So132.36 the132.6 idea132.68 behind132.92 it133.24 was133.48 to133.64 help133.8 generally134.2 small134.68 to135 mid135.16 sized135.32 growers135.64 who136.36 are136.52 looking136.6 to136.92 put137 in137.24 a137.8 relatively137.96 small138.6 sized139 array.139.4 We're139.64 not139.8 talking140.04 a140.28 40140.36 acre140.6 swath140.92 here.141.16 We're141.32 talking141.56 something142.12 to142.44 kinda142.52 supplement142.84 their143.4 farm143.56 that144.04 will144.2 just144.36 provide144.52 enough144.92 residual145.16 income145.64 to146.12 help146.19 keep146.44 their146.59 whole146.84 farm147.08 more147.72 sustainable.148.03 So148.59 that148.75 that's149 the149.24 genesis149.4 behind149.88 it.150.12
151.47 SPEAKER2151.47 -151.47 Thank151.47 you.151.72
154.59 SPEAKER4154.59 -154.59 Well,154.59 good155 morning,155.16 chair155.64 Eldridge,155.88 chair156.44 Madrow,156.68 and157.16 members157.47 of157.96 the158.12 committee.158.36 Thank158.75 you159 very159.24 much159.4 for159.64 the160.44 opportunity160.6 to161.16 speak161.32 to161.56 you161.8 on161.88 this162.04 bill162.2 this162.52 morning.162.76 Again,164.04 my164.36 name164.44 is164.68 Kate164.76 Daniel.165 I'm165.32 the165.4 Northeast165.64 Regional166.04 Director166.44 of166.76 the166.92 Coalition167.08 for167.56 Community167.8 Solar168.36 Access168.76 or169.16 CCSA.169.4 We're170.52 a170.76 national170.84 coalition171.24 of,172.12 businesses172.84 and173.4 organizations173.64 that174.36 build,174.6 own,175 and175.24 operate175.4 community176.13 solar176.53 projects.176.93 We178.13 work178.28 across178.6 the178.93 country179.08 on179.41 on179.72 designing179.97 programs180.44 and180.84 policies181.08 to181.72 ensure181.88 access182.28 to182.69 solar182.84 and183.81 make183.97 sure184.13 that184.36 those184.53 programs184.76 are185.25 designed185.49 effectively185.97 to186.69 meet186.84 multiple187.32 goals187.88 and188.44 address188.76 multiple189.08 stakeholder189.48 issues.190.2 Here191.56 in191.88 the192.04 Commonwealth,192.12 land193.56 use193.88 is194.28 a194.68 big194.84 concern195.08 around195.72 how196.2 we196.52 meet196.68 both197.08 our197.48 climate197.8 and198.2 clean198.36 energy198.68 goals199.16 as200.28 well200.44 as200.84 make201.24 sure201.5 that201.74 we201.89 meet201.97 our202.29 conservation202.61 and203.81 agricultural204.06 land204.85 use205.17 goals.205.5 I206.46 think206.61 this206.78 bill207.01 is207.5 a207.81 major208.06 important208.78 step209.41 in209.81 the209.97 right210.13 direction210.46 of210.94 of211.17 striking211.41 that211.89 balance.212.06 As213.17 we213.33 think213.5 about213.81 how214.13 we214.38 can214.53 best214.85 protect215.74 and216.3 improve217.34 our217.9 conservation218.7 of219.42 critical219.74 habitat220.54 and221.02 prime221.74 farmland,222.14 we222.78 need222.94 to223.18 think223.26 about223.58 how223.82 we223.98 reduce224.22 barriers224.7 to225.74 being225.9 able226.14 to226.46 develop226.62 solar227.18 on227.66 suitable228.22 sites.228.63 The230.22 separation230.47 from231.34 land231.66 on232.06 on232.31 61232.63 a233.26 protections233.66 would234.47 indeed235.26 allow235.91 us236.38 to236.78 to237.19 build237.34 solar237.66 on238.22 suitable238.38 sites238.94 in239.34 conjunction239.5 with240.15 active240.47 farming240.87 operations241.43 and242.71 remove242.95 the243.43 penalties243.67 and244.47 barriers244.71 for245.35 doing245.59 so.245.99 Putting247.35 renewable247.75 energy248.23 on,248.95 farm249.67 properties249.99 is250.55 a250.79 really250.95 important251.27 tool251.83 for252.15 farmers252.31 to252.79 be252.95 able253.11 to253.35 maintain254.72 control255.04 on255.53 their255.69 land255.93 and256.25 keep256.56 their256.88 land257.13 and257.93 keep258.17 it258.4 in258.56 farming258.81 operations.259.29 The260.32 supplemental260.56 revenue261.21 from261.69 land261.93 leases262.17 for262.56 solar262.81 projects263.13 and263.52 other263.69 renewable263.93 energy264.4 projects264.81 can265.93 make266.17 ends266.4 meet266.73 in266.96 really267.29 tough267.76 economic268.17 situations268.83 for269.39 farmers.269.55 And270.43 so270.59 we270.83 see270.99 a271.23 really271.39 important271.79 synergy272.27 in272.83 being272.91 able273.23 to273.55 use273.71 these273.95 properties274.27 effectively274.75 and275.79 removing276.03 that276.43 right276.67 of276.83 first276.99 refusal277.23 and277.79 and278.11 the278.27 rollback278.43 taxes278.91 are279.47 important279.71 steps280.19 in280.59 being280.67 able280.91 to281.15 do281.23 that281.39 effectively.281.71 So283.23 I283.39 urge283.87 the284.02 committee284.19 to284.58 support284.75 this285.14 bill,285.38 and,285.71 thank286.26 you286.5 very286.67 much286.82 for287.06 your287.23 time287.38 and287.55 consideration.287.71
289.31 SPEAKER2289.31 -289.31 Great.289.31 Thank289.63 you289.79 very289.94 much,290.19 miss290.58 Daniel.290.82 And291.31 I'm291.46 just291.63 curious,291.94 with293.14 respect293.38 to293.79 your293.87 organization,294.11 have294.75 you294.9 done295.55 projects295.87 that296.43 have296.67 put296.9 solar297.14 on297.55 on297.79 farms297.94 or298.35 adjacent298.5 to298.95 farms?299.03
300.15 SPEAKER4300.15 -300.15 Yeah.300.15 Our300.39 our300.63 members300.79 have.301.27 Several302.23 of302.63 our302.79 members302.95 are303.51 working,303.75 specifically305.35 on306.07 agrivoltaics306.47 projects307.35 that307.83 really308.31 look308.71 at309.03 active309.35 farm310.07 use310.39 integrated310.79 into311.51 the311.91 solar312.07 project.312.47 But313.66 others313.9 are314.54 looking314.78 at,315.26 you315.5 know,315.66 taking315.99 some316.31 of316.46 that316.54 marginal316.78 land317.35 on317.66 farm317.9 properties,318.14 dedicating319.58 that320.14 towards320.38 a320.78 solar320.94 operation,321.35 which321.82 allows322.14 the322.63 rest322.78 of323.1 the323.26 the323.66 property323.9 to324.46 remain324.7 in325.02 active325.19 farm325.5 use.325.82
326.7 SPEAKER2326.7 -326.7 Okay.326.7 Excellent.327.1 Excellent.327.66 Do328.94 any329.1 members329.37 of329.69 the329.85 committee329.93 have330.41 questions?330.73 Yes.331.93 Yes,332.41 mister332.65 chairman.332.97 Thank334.01 you,334.25 senator.334.33 Mister334.97 Wigt,335.29 you335.45 mentioned335.61 that335.93 you're336.17 not336.33 talking336.49 about336.81 40337.05 acres.337.45 Do337.77 you337.93 have338.01 a338.25 a338.49 size338.57 of338.89 the338.97 land339.13 restriction339.37 in339.77 mind?339.93
341.29 SPEAKER3341.29 -341.29 I341.29 don't341.37 have341.63 a341.82 size342.02 of342.5 my342.53 because342.58 I342.82 I343.31 don't343.38 I344.02 feel344.11 that344.43 it344.54 this344.82 is344.99 something345.06 that,345.38 through345.63 the345.79 process,345.87 we346.26 need346.5 to346.58 figure346.75 out346.99 whether347.23 it's347.46 a347.63 percentage347.79 of348.26 land348.5 or349.23 a349.55 certain349.63 megawatt.349.94 So351.14 I'm351.23 not351.46 recommending351.7 a352.19 particular352.35 size.352.75 I352.99 think353.06 that's353.31 something353.46 that353.79 should354.41 be354.65 probably354.81 cleared355.21 up355.53 with355.69 people355.93 who356.25 know356.49 more356.65 than356.89 I357.05 about357.69 what358.01 that358.17 best359.13 would359.37 work.359.53 Because359.77 there's359.93 a360.09 certain360.25 size360.49 that360.73 the360.89 solar361.05 developers361.29 are361.69 gonna361.77 want361.93 in362.57 order362.81 to363.05 make363.21 it363.37 profitable363.53 for363.93 them.364.09 There's365.37 a365.61 certain365.77 amount366.01 of366.25 land366.33 that366.65 the366.97 agricultural367.29 people367.93 probably368.41 don't368.73 wanna368.97 give369.23 up,369.35 so369.46 you369.54 gotta369.63 find369.94 that370.11 balance.370.19 So370.5 I370.67 think370.75 that'll370.9 be371.15 all371.38 part371.79 of372.02 the372.19 conversation.372.26 But372.99 I373.15 just373.23 wanna373.46 make373.71 sure373.79 it373.94 was374.11 clear374.35 we're374.67 not374.82 talking374.99 these375.79 big376.26 solar376.67 fields376.99 where377.23 this377.55 is377.79 more378.11 of378.26 a378.43 niche378.5 that379.15 we're379.38 looking379.55 at379.79 here.379.94 At381.06 least381.15 that's381.38 the381.55 intent.381.63
384.71 SPEAKER2384.71 -384.71 Any384.71 other384.95 questions?385.11 Yes,385.43
388.63 SPEAKER5388.63 -388.63 Well,388.63 my388.95 question389.03 is,389.35 the389.99 next.390.15 We391.59 have391.75 6391.91 farms,392.15 1393.59 of393.83 this,393.91 my394.15 Orchard.394.49 They395.04 have395.37 solar395.69 panels,396 and397.04 they397.28 use397.44 the397.69 solar397.84 panels398.08 to398.32 redo398.49 the398.72 high398.88 cost399.04 of399.37 electricity.399.52 They400.56 say400.81 they401.2 save401.37 thousands402.4 of402.81 dollars402.96 every403.28 year.403.52 The404.96 the405.28 high405.37 cost405.6 of405.93 electricity406 is406.88 harming407.44 farmers407.93 across408.4 the408.81 country,408.96 especially409.44 here409.93 in410.08 Massachusetts.410.25 Massachusetts,410.59 the411.23 best411.31 place411.63 to411.87 to412.91 be412.99 farm.413.15 However,414.43 I415.55
415.71 SPEAKER3415.71 -415.71 don't415.71 know415.79
415.87 SPEAKER5415.87 -415.87 if415.87 you415.95 remember416.03 the416.43 first416.51 thing416.75 we416.91 have,417.07 sir.417.31 We418.27 pass418.59 we418.91 tried419.07 to419.39 pass420.03 a420.27 constitutional420.43 amendment421.07 to421.79 reduce422.03 the422.43 the423.23 from424.4 5425 acres425.6 to426.03 to426.46 make426.88 less426.96 than428 that428.25 for,428.4 a428.96 lot429.2 to430 be430.08 considered430.4 farmland.431.37 And432.25 I432.88 believe432.96 that433.44 be433.52 a433.6 nice433.69 way434 for434.25 farmers435.04 to435.84 certify436.64 land436.69 as436.73 farming438 farmland.438.56 And439.29 is439.6 is439.97 this440.13 farmland?440.29 Doesn't440.85 matter.441.25 If441.49 they441.65 use441.81 part442.25 of442.69 that,443.13 solar443.57 panels443.89 to444.29 reduce444.45 the444.77 high444.85 cost445.01 of445.25 energy,445.41 and446.13 so,446.45 therefore,446.61 the447.25 cost447.57 of447.81 producing449.33 whatever449.81 they450.13 produce,450.29 whatever450.69 they're451.01 planting,451.25 so452.05 they452.29 can452.45 use452.61 that452.85 to453.17 reduce453.33 cost.453.81 If455.07 they455.24 use455.56 some455.8 land455.96 to456.27 another456.75 industry457.07 produce457.48 energy,457.96 they're458.6 no458.92 longer459.07 farmers.459.48 And460.83 we're461.07 talking461.24 about461.56 farm.461.88 I463.4 don't463.56 know463.8 all463.96 about464.12 helping464.51 them.465 That's465.8 why466.04 I'm466.44 I'm466.51 considering466.6 that467 constitutional468.04 amendment,468.6 you469.07 know,469.24 helping469.46 them469.86 to470.9 remove471.14 that471.54 limit471.78 5472.34 acres.472.58 So473.94 this474.18 is474.26 farmland.474.42 I'm475.86 all476.02 in476.26 favor476.34 so476.74 they476.9 they477.3 can477.54 use477.7 whatever478.74 tools479.14 they479.38 need479.54 to479.78 go479.94 green,480.18 to480.5 have480.66 solar480.82 panels,481.14 to481.46 do481.62 the481.78 high481.86 cost482.02 of482.34 energy.482.42 Farmers483.22 only484.82 gets485.16 96¢485.49 for486.13 each486.29 dollar486.44 they486.69 invest486.76 in487 land487.25 and487.88 all488.13 in488.37 favor488.44 of488.76 farmers.488.93 But489.64 when489.88 you490.04 target490.85 the491.32 industry491.49 in491.96 trying492.2 to492.52 get492.6 them492.85 to493.25 separate493.4 lots493.88 to494.52 enter494.69 another495 industry,495.32 unlike496.44 the496.85 labor496.93 of497.25 farmers,497.4 because497.72 they497.88 don't498.04 wanna498.2 be498.44 the498.6 farmers498.69 no499 more.499.16 They're499.53 entering499.77 another500.25 industry.500.73 It's502.09 a502.33 totally502.49 different502.81 industry,503.13 and503.77 leaving504.01 them504.41 as504.65 farmers504.73 is505.13 not505.29 fair.505.53 So506.25 I506.49 my507.21 question507.37 is,507.69 how508.09 your509.05 organization,509.21 make510.33 what510.65 what510.89 make511.05 them511.21 attractive?511.45 Is511.85 it511.93 because512.01 they512.25 have512.41 a512.65 little512.73 land?512.97 How514.25 you514.49 target514.65 that514.97 industry?515.39 How515.79 we516.12 can516.27 make516.51 sure?516.75 Like,517.32 this517.55 is517.88 gonna517.95 be518.27 exploited.519.08 Like,521 farmers521.15 trust521.63 in521.95 industry,522.12 and522.51 then522.75 then523.24 they523.48 don't523.63 have523.88 having524.2 to524.51 pay524.6 a525.15 higher525.48 tax525.88 bill.526.2 And527.08 when527.55 they527.79 have527.95 all528.12 the528.36 venue528.43 to528.75 do528.91 it,529.24 like,529.39 just529.63 when530.43 we530.6 pass530.67 the530.91 constitutional531.28 amendment,531.6 if532 you532.08 pass,532.24 they532.8 can532.88 just533.04 put533.28 some533.44 apartments533.6 if534 they534.16 do534.24 the534.4 head534.48 cost534.72 of534.96 electricity.535.04 Can536.64 you536.88 locate537.04 me537.28 with537.44 that?537.6
539.6 SPEAKER3539.6 -539.6 We539.6 always539.76 want540.08 this540.4 to540.56 be540.72 a540.96 farming541.52 first542.16 mentality.542.64 That's543.2 approach543.44 that543.76 we've543.92 taken544.4 with544.8 this.545.04 And545.92 that546.16 the546.88 primary547.05 purpose547.45 of547.69 that547.93 land548.25 needs548.73 to548.97 be549.05 farming,549.21 and549.85 that550.09 needs550.33 to550.64 continue.550.81 So551.76 the552 if552.81 there553.05 was553.21 to553.45 be553.61 a553.76 solar553.85 component554.25 to554.81 it,554.97 it555.45 would555.61 really555.85 need556.09 to556.25 be556.4 adjacent556.73 and557.21 secondary557.37 to557.93 its558.09 primary558.33 purpose558.81 of559.52 being559.69 a559.93 farm.560.09 And560.57 that's560.73 why560.97 the561.21 size,561.29 I561.61 think,561.69 is561.85 gonna562.1 be562.18 important562.42 that563.06 you563.3 can't563.46 have563.7 the563.86 scale564.1 tipped565.06 so565.38 much565.54 that566.02 now566.5 the566.74 major566.98 income567.3 stream567.62 is567.94 becoming568.18 the568.74 alternative568.9 energy569.38 and569.7 not569.78 the569.94 farm.570.1 So570.42 that570.66 I570.82 think570.9 that's571.06 gonna571.3 be571.54 important571.7 piece572.42 of572.74 this572.82 if573.06 this573.22 if573.46 this573.7 is573.94 to574.1 move574.18 forward574.34 to575.22 find575.38 that575.62 balance575.78 so576.58 that576.74 it576.9 still577.06 remains577.33 a577.64 farm577.73 first577.96 proposition.578.92 The579.57 idea579.8 about580.13 the580.92 alternative581.16 energy581.64 is581.96 another582.13 income582.61 stream583.09 to583.57 supplement,583.73 not584.37 to584.68 replace584.85 or586.04 displace586.37 that586.92 farming587.57 operation.588.13 I588.92 think589 that's589.25 the589.8 important590.04 component590.52 in591 in591.25 my591.49 view.591.64 And592.63 in594.63 Massachusetts,594.87 we're595.83 in596.47 the596.63 highest596.79 1597.19 of597.35 the597.51 highest597.59 cost597.83 farming598.63 regions.599.11 So599.59 in599.75 in599.91 cranberries,599.99 in600.47 particular,600.63 my601.03 expertise,601.27 we602.07 are602.31 the602.47 highest602.63 cost603.11 growing603.43 region603.75 in604.39 North604.55 America604.79 for605.11 growing605.35 cranberries.605.59 So606.39 it606.55 puts606.63 us606.87 at607.11 an607.27 economic607.43 our608.2 growers608.27 at608.67 an608.84 economic609.63 disadvantage.609.96 And611.08 that's611.32 just611.55 the611.88 facts612.03 and612.36 then612.6 that's612.75 just613.48 the613.72 way613.88 it614.03 is.614.2 But614.84 this615 type615.32 of615.48 program615.63 will616.12 help616.36 those616.75 growers617 compete617.96 with618.27 the618.43 other618.51 growing618.75 regions619 because619.39 they619.72 can619.88 have620.12 that620.27 opportunity620.43 for621 another621.15 income622.07 stream.622.31 And622.55 we're622.87 not622.95 talking623.19 the623.43 majority623.59 growers.623.91 This624.23 is624.47 gonna624.55 be624.71 really625.51 a625.83 a626.07 niche626.23 opportunity.626.63 Not627.27 everyone's627.43 gonna627.75 participate628.07 in628.47 this.628.63 Not629.03 every629.27 farm629.51 is629.83 gonna629.99 have630.15 the630.39 land,630.55 the631.27 connection631.51 to631.91 3632.07 way632.31 power632.63 that's632.87 needed.633.19 There's633.67 a633.91 lot633.99 of634.23 constraints634.39 already635.59 built635.91 into636.15 demographics637.38 and637.94 the638.18 geographics638.26
638.75 SPEAKER5638.75 -638.75 that638.75 we're638.82 doing.638.99 I'm639.63 all639.87 about640.18 farmers,640.58 but641.14 they're641.3 gonna641.46 be641.7 entering641.87 a642.75 another643.23 industry643.7 that644.18 had644.42 nothing644.58 to644.9 do645.06 with645.23 farming.645.38 They're645.87 gonna646.11 be646.35 entering646.5 the647.46 energy647.63 industry.648.26 They649.23 they649.63 don't649.78 know650.02 nothing650.18 about650.58 it.650.82 They651.24 don't651.4 be651.64 it's652.44 totally652.52 opposed653.08 to653.28 what653.48 they653.64 do.653.8 You655.16 know?655.32 Planting,656.36 growing657.16 food657.48 that657.88 we658.04 go658.12 and658.36 buy.658.52 That's658.84 what659.08 they659.24 do.659.32 That's659.56 what659.72 they660.04 love660.12 to660.36 do.660.44 The660.92 energy661.08 industry661.48 is661.88 a661.96 different662.04 animal.662.44 So663.08 in663.4 in663.56 and664.73 I664.88 don't664.96 know.665.68 They665.92 don't665.99 know.666.04 That666.11 they666.16 look666.33 they666.57 cannot666.73 control.666.96 So667.92 I'm668.33 afraid668.49 of668.76 of669.04 that.669.2 Like,669.52 splitting670.88 and,671.37 like,671.61 having672.73 to673.04 do673.2 a673.28 deed,673.37 splitting674.4 the674.73 land.674.88 You675.61 know,675.76 it's676
677.85 SPEAKER3677.85 -677.85 Many677.85 of678.15 our678.31 farmers678.47 have678.95 off679.27 farm679.51 income679.91 already.680.23 That's681.35 this681.83 is682.15 just682.23 another682.47 way682.71 of682.95 looking683.11 at683.35 it.683.51 And683.91 so684.31 many685.03 of685.27 the685.35 cranberry685.43 growers685.75 majority685.99 of686.31 our686.39 cranberry686.55 growers686.87 are687.19 not687.35 full687.59 time687.83 cranberry688.31 growers.688.63 They688.95 they689.11 don't689.27 make689.43 enough689.59 money689.91 at690.07 that,690.15 so690.31 they690.47 have690.63 other690.71 jobs.691.33 This691.74 is691.98 in692.13 effect,692.38 like,692.93 another693.17 job.693.41 It's693.74 a693.89 it's694.05 an694.21 income694.38 stream694.62 in694.93 this695.01 case.695.17 So695.81 it's696.05 just696.29 an696.53 opportunity696.77 to697.5 help697.65 them697.89 keep698.62 their698.86 farm699.1 as699.5 a699.74 farm699.81 because700.13 they're700.38 getting700.53 that700.77 consistent700.93 revenue701.41 stream701.81 from702.45 the702.69 solar.702.86 I703.33 I703.5 get703.65 your703.81 point.703.98 I704.21 see704.29 what704.45 you're704.69 saying,704.86 but705.01 that's705.17
706.21 SPEAKER5706.21 -706.21 I706.21 guess706.49 the706.81 housing706.89 industry,707.37 we707.69 can't707.85 come708.09 here708.25 with708.41 the708.65 same708.73 argument.708.97 We709.53 can709.69 separate709.93 it710.33 so710.49 they710.65 can710.81 build710.97 housing,711.21 and711.93 then712.09 we712.25 have712.33 the712.49 same712.57 argument.712.73 They713.13 can713.29 have713.45 income713.61 building714.33 housing,714.65 and715.05 then715.29 we715.45 have715.53 the715.69 same715.85 argument.716.01 That's716.49 what716.65 I'm716.89 meaning.716.97 Like,717.45 we,718.17 as718.81 a718.97 state,719.05 we719.29 have,719.53 give720.17 grants720.41 to720.9 some721.07 farmer721.3 just721.54 to721.79 make721.95 sure722.11 they722.67 keep722.83 farmland723.07 as723.63 farm,723.95 not724.75 to725.07 use725.3 it725.54 for725.63 other725.87 business726.42 purpose.727.23 In728.18 Metul,728.42 we728.83 have728.9 done729.07 that.729.3 We729.38 did729.54 that729.63 with729.71 the730.11 Monango730.26 family.730.75 We731.3 have731.47 done731.71 that731.87 with732.11 my732.5 ultra732.75 many733.3 other733.47 farmers733.71 in734.11 in734.76 the734.9 200%.735.04 And736.2 and736.44 I736.6 take736.76 pride736.92 of737.24 protecting737.32 my737.8 farmers.737.96 So738.6 that738.76 that's739 what739.16 I'm739.32 saying.739.4 Like,739.56 if739.72 we're739.88 gonna740.04 go740.28 to740.36 another740.44 industry,740.76 you741.8 know,741.96 like,742.2 that's742.52 totally743.08 different.743.24 And744.52 Massachusetts,744.68 we745.24 take745.32 pride745.56 of745.8 that.745.96 Historically,746.6 we747.08 have747.16 done747.32 that.747.71 Protecting747.79 farmland748.27 to748.75 remain748.91 farmland.749.32
750.2 SPEAKER3750.2 -750.2 Right.750.2 Absolutely.750.43 In750.84 the751.15 case751.24 of751.48 cranberry,751.63 because752.2 cranberry752.91 bogs753.55 are754.03 they're754.36 a754.67 wetland.754.75 They're755.15 unique.755.39 It's756.12 the756.43 rest756.6 of756.84 their757 land757.24 that757.63 is757.88 not758.12 being758.27 farmed758.6 in758.84 cranberries.759 That's759.48 where759.63 this759.79 proposed761.19 alternative761.91 energy762.47 would762.71 be762.87 going.762.95 It763.19 would763.27 not763.43 be763.59 going763.67 on763.99 the764.15 farmland.764.31 So764.71 the764.87 actual765.03 farmland765.27 would766.15 not766.39 be766.55 going766.71 away.766.95 And767.91 it768.07 would768.15 just768.39 be768.55 utilizing768.87 the769.35 support769.51 land769.91 that770.63 is771.59 just771.83 providing772.47 no773.11 income,773.35 giving774.15 them774.39 another774.71 income774.95 stream775.27 on775.51 land775.82 that775.98 they776.05 have.776.22 Did777.25 you777.41 join777.5 us?777.65
778.05 SPEAKER1778.05 -778.05 Yeah.778.05 No.778.29 I778.46 was778.53 I778.77 was778.93 just779.1 gonna779.34 make779.58 the779.82 same779.98 comment780.38 is780.7 that780.86 in781.1 particularly781.34 in781.89 the782.05 case782.13 of782.38 the782.53 cranberry782.62 industry,783.1 the783.74 bogs783.89 will784.22 continue784.38 to784.86 operate.785.01 That's785.41 you786.13 can't786.29 put786.53 solar786.86 over787.25 bogs787.5 unless787.82 it's788.13 dual788.38 use,788.62 and788.94 that's789.1 a789.26 different789.34 opportunity789.98 for790.54 farmers.790.7 But791.1 in791.26 this791.42 case,791.58 for792.22 cranberry792.46 growers,792.94 I793.66 think793.74 it's793.98 up794.14 to794.3 50%794.46 of795.18 the795.42 land795.5 that's795.74 held796.06 in796.22 '61796.46 a796.94 can797.1 be797.18 accessory797.42 land798.14 under798.7 the799.02 5799.18 acre799.58 requirement.800.14 And800.86 so801.02 what801.18 we're801.34 talking801.5 about801.74 is801.98 that802.14 accessory802.38 land802.86 that803.33 otherwise803.58 is804.05 not804.21 used804.46 for804.86 the805.74 actual805.89 farming806.29 of806.93 cranberries807.25 that807.98 they808.13 would808.29 utilize.808.46 We'd809.25 separate809.41 that809.89 from810.13 61.810.38 The811.33 farmer811.5 would811.89 still812.05 own812.29 the812.46 land.812.62 The813.41 developer813.65 owner814.13 operator814.46 would814.93 own815.1 the815.33 solar815.65 system816.05 and816.46 pay816.62 lease816.86 revenue817.17 back817.89 to818.21 the818.4 farmer.818.56 So818.8 the818.88 farmer819.12 would819.44 still819.6 retain819.84 that820.16 land.820.4
822.48 SPEAKER2822.48 -822.48 Thank822.48 you.822.8 Amber823.68 Simcaster.824
826.32 SPEAKER6826.32 -826.32 Thank826.32 you.826.56 I826.72 think826.8 you827.04 actually827.2 just827.52 answered827.68 my827.92 question.828.08 I828.4 do828.48 have828.64 a828.72 lot828.8 of828.96 agricultural829.12 lands,829.68 and829.92 I830.08 appreciate830.32 your830.64
833.58 farmer833.58 first,833.61 look833.66 at833.9 this.834.07 And834.71 I834.87 think834.95 you835.11 just835.26 answered835.42 my835.66 question.835.75 My835.99 question836.14 was,836.46 does836.71 the836.95 farmer837.75 or838.07 property838.23 owner838.63 still838.95 need839.18 to839.35 main839.5 to839.83 still840.07 need840.38 to840.63 keep841.02 it841.26 under841.5 common841.75 ownership842.07 as842.95 the843.18 agricultural843.35 land?844.07 And844.78 if845.18 that,845.42 if846.28 they846.36 were846.68 to846.84 sell847.08 what847.4 was847.64 leased848.36 or848.68 used849 as,849.4 energy,850.2 would850.68 they850.92 then851.24 trigger851.56 the,852.04 the853.4 61853.72 a854.28 provisions854.44 of854.84 right855 of855.16 first855.24 refusal855.56 at856.04 that856.28 point856.36 if856.6 it856.76 was856.92 sold857.08 in857.32 the857.48 future857.56 under857.88 what858.2 you're858.36 thinking858.6 about?858.92
860.57 SPEAKER3860.57 -860.57 That's860.57 that861.2 would861.45 be861.61 how861.85 I862 would862.16 think.862.32 If862.57 it's862.73 not862.96 written863.45 that863.76 way863.92 currently,864.08 I864.32 think864.57 it864.73 probably864.96 should865.37 be865.61 in866.08 that866.25 if867.28 it867.45 goes867.52 from868 into868.8 solar869.2 and869.92 then870.08 something870.32 else,870.64 that871.52 that's872.02 when872.1 the872.34 town872.42 should872.74 have872.82 their873.06 right873.22 of873.38 first873.46 refusal.873.62
874.02 SPEAKER6874.02 -874.02 So874.02 the874.18 community874.42 would874.9 be875.14 able875.3 to875.46 have875.54 that875.7 opportunity875.94 as876.42 well.876.5
876.74 SPEAKER3876.74 -876.74 That's876.74 that's876.9 what877.14 I877.3 think877.38 is877.7
877.86 SPEAKER7877.86 -877.86 the877.86 fairs.877.94 Yeah.878.26 Okay.878.66
878.9 SPEAKER4878.9 -878.9 Thank878.9 you879.06 very879.14 much.879.38
881.46 SPEAKER2881.46 -881.46 Great.881.46 And881.78 I881.94 would882.02 just882.26 note882.5 in882.66 in882.82 the882.98 district883.06 I883.46 represent,883.62 which,885.97 has887.33 a887.57 large,887.73 many889 apple889.33 orchards889.64 is890.04 that890.21 1890.37 of890.52 the890.68 farms890.76 at891.16 Carlson891.4 Apple891.88 Carlson892.61 Orchards,893.16 several894.21 years894.52 ago894.76 built895.09 solar895.33 on,895.73 I'd895.97 say,896.13 less896.37 than896.61 an896.76 acre,896.92 and897.4 it897.57 cove897.73 it898.13 now898.28 covers898.52 90%898.92 of899.57 the899.95 energy900.19 needs900.43 of900.75 the900.91 farm.901.07 So901.39 it's901.63 basically901.87 saved902.27 the902.51 family902.67 farm903.07 from903.39 perhaps,903.87 you904.43 know,904.59 being905.07 developed905.39 or905.79 turned905.95 into906.19 housing906.43 or906.75 something.906.91 So,907.31 senator908.83 Rausch,909.15 did909.39 you909.55 have909.71
909.95 SPEAKER5909.95 -909.95 a909.95 question?910.03
910.51 SPEAKER6910.51 -910.51 Thanks,910.51 mister910.75 chair.911.15
915.88 SPEAKER8915.88 -915.88 I'm915.88 wondering916.2 why917 why918.67 solar919 as919.48 distinct919.71 from920.12 anything920.27 else.920.6 Right?921.39 Why921.71 should921.88 we922.03 offer922.2 this922.51 particular922.67 benefit923.15 for923.63 the923.71 for923.95 the925.15 depositing925.39 of925.88 creation926.2 of926.67 solar926.83 or927.68 as927.84 distinct928.16 from,928.56 say,928.72 water929.04 for929.44 your929.52 pure929.6 fuel.929.84 These930.24 are930.4 all930.56 needs930.72 like,931.12 there's931.2 obviously931.44 a931.76 nexus931.92 as932.32 as932.56 the932.8 chair933.04 the933.68 good933.84 chair934.08 just,934.32 you935.16 know,935.44 cited935.68 an936 example936.16 of936.64 where936.8 farms937.12 need937.44 power.937.68 Right?938.08 Farms938.64 need938.96 power939.12 to939.36 be939.44 able939.6 to939.76 operate.939.84 This940.16 is940.4 true940.48 for940.72 for941.21 all941.45 of941.61 our941.76 agricultural942 businesses942.49 throughout942.88 the943.21 state.943.37 And945.21 many945.37 of945.61 them945.68 have945.85 relied946.09 on946.4 on946.64 solar,946.88 and947.29 many947.45 of947.68 them947.76 can948 can948.25 produce948.49 a948.81 lot948.88 of949.13 solar.949.29
951.85 But951.85 why952.09 it's952.64 not952.97 just953.13 energy953.52 that954.09 they954.25 need.954.4 They954.57 also954.81 need955.05 clean955.29 water,955.52 and955.85 they956 need956.17 need956.36 housing956.52 for956.76 people957 who957.16 come957.32 and957.48 work.957.64 And957.96 so958.52 why958.84 should959 we959.16 provide960.28 this960.68 for960.92 solar961.16 only961.48 as962.44 opposed962.6 to962.92 any963.16 of963.4 the963.48 other963.64 needs964.92 of965.64 our965.72 agricultural966.04 businesses?966.68
970.75 SPEAKER1970.75 -970.75 I970.75 can970.9 start.971.14 So971.46 the972.02 bill972.42 actually972.83 refers973.23 to973.54 renewable973.71 energy,974.18 and974.42 it974.66 states974.9 the975.23 specific975.38 statute975.87 that976.26 defines976.59 renewable977.07 energy.977.38 So977.71 it's977.95 not978.11 just978.26 solar978.42 conceivably.978.9 It979.46 could979.63 be979.78 a979.87 wind980.02 turbine980.18 or980.66 another980.83 renewable981.71 energy982.18 technology982.66 defined983.3 under983.71 statute.984.16
984.56 SPEAKER9984.56 -984.56 Mhmm.984.56
984.88 SPEAKER1984.88 -984.88 But984.88 in985.04 this985.12 instance,985.28 the986.16 the986.48 and986.72 and987.12 Brian987.44 can987.84 speak988.08 in988.24 more988.48 detail988.72 about989.12 the989.52 report989.76 that990.08 came990.32 out990.48 from990.64 the990.88 Cranberry991.04 Growers991.52 Task991.92 Force,992.16 which992.4 specifically992.64 identified993.28 renewable993.84 energy994.32 as994.64 a994.8 priority,994.88 that995.76 this995.92 is996.16 an996.24 opportunity996.48 to997.43 meet997.56 multiple997.68 goals,998.24 the999.12 agricultural999.36 goals999.92 of1000.15 the1000.32 Commonwealth,1000.39 generate1001.51 clean1002 energy,1002.32 and1002.88 provide1003.12 a1003.6 revenue1003.75 source.1004.24 And1004.63 so1004.88 those1005.68 were1005.84 the1006.08 reasons1006.24 why1006.72 this1006.96 bill,1007.12 I1007.43 think,1007.51 was1007.75 prioritized1007.92 by1008.48 the1008.56 cranberry1008.72 growers,1009.12 but1009.43 I'll1009.6 let1009.75 Brian1009.92 speak1010.56 in1010.8 more1010.88 detail.1011.12
1012.16 SPEAKER31012.16 -1012.16 Yeah.1012.16 That1012.32 that's1012.56 really1013.12 it.1013.52 It1013.6 was1013.76 during1014.72 the1015.04 task1015.2 force1015.44 hearings,1015.68 we1016 had1016.08 a1016.2 few1016.32 growers1016.56 who1016.96 came1017.12 in1017.36 who1017.6 were1017.76 having1017.92 challenges1018.24 looking1019.2 to1019.52 put1019.68 some1019.84 solar1020.08 on1020.4 their1020.56 adjacent1020.8 land,1021.2 and1021.44 and1021.68 they1021.76 were1021.92 running1022.08 into1022.32 right1023.2 of1023.36 first1023.52 refusal1023.76 issues1024.24 and1024.56 and1024.72 things1024.8 like1025.06 that.1025.3 So1025.62 that1025.93 was1026.1 the,1026.74 genesis1027.22 behind1027.7 it.1028.02 Because1028.34 Cranberry1028.74 Land1029.22 is1029.54 suited1029.78 well1030.17 and1031.06 I'm1031.22 I'm1031.46 speaking1031.54 solar,1031.93 but1032.17 it1032.34 it1032.46 could1032.58 be1032.74 wind,1032.89 etcetera.1033.06 But1033.46 solar1033.7 is1034.26 an1034.65 easier1034.89 avenue,1036.26 more1036.89 accept1037.13 generally1037.46 accepted.1037.78 So1039.22 the1039.38 the1039.7 solar1039.86 opportunities1040.26 were1041.06 quite1041.54 large1041.86 because1042.34 of1042.58 the1042.74 way1042.82 that1043.06 the1043.3 cranberry1043.54 bogs1044.02 are1044.26 relatively1044.42 open.1044.82 The1045.14 adjacent1045.3 land1045.7 is1045.94 already1046.1 cleared1046.34 of1046.66 trees.1046.82 There's1047.54 a1047.7 lot1047.86 of1048.02 positive1048.1 aspects1048.58 where1048.98 you1049.14 could1049.22 put1049.38 in1049.54 a1049.78 solar1049.94 array,1050.34 not1050.66 have1050.82 to1050.98 take1051.06 trees1051.3 down,1051.54 clear1051.86 a1052.1 forest,1052.18 to1053.13 do1053.29 some1053.45 of1053.49 those1053.53 things.1053.77 So1053.92 it's1054.09 it1054.33 was1054.4 set1054.57 up1054.81 nicely.1055.05 So1056.09 it1056.33 was1056.48 really1056.73 more1056.88 of1057.13 an1057.29 opportunity1057.45 than1058.01 necessarily1058.24 looking1058.88 to1059.92 shut1060.01 out1060.24 other1060.4 opportunities1060.64 that1061.21 there's1061.77 not1062.4 a1062.73 lot1062.81 of1063.05 options1063.21 for1063.68 in1064.01 Cranberry1064.16 Land1064.64 just1065.53 due1065.92 to1066.24 the1066.67 way1066.83 it's1067.87 built,1068.11 you1068.59 know,1068.75 the1068.91 the,1068.99 geology1070.19 behind1070.75 it.1070.99 So1071.63 it1071.95 in1072.51 this1072.75 particular1072.91 case,1073.31 alternative1073.63 energy1074.11 and1074.51 solar1074.67 and1075.39 specificity,1075.55 fits1077.15 well.1077.39
1078.59 SPEAKER81078.59 -1078.59 Yeah.1078.59 I've1078.75 I've1078.99 been1079.07 to1079.23 the1079.31 Cranberry1079.39 Box1079.87 myself.1080.27 Right?1080.59 I've1080.83 taken1080.99 a1081.23 tour1081.39 and1081.63 even1081.79 gone1082.06 in1082.22 with1082.46 the1082.54 waiters1082.78 on1083.02 and1083.26 and1083.49 harvested1083.74 some1084.13 myself.1084.38 So1084.7 I,1084.93 you1085.17 know,1085.26 was1085.58 chair1085.74 of1086.13 the1086.38 environmental,1086.62 and1087.17 and,1087.34 formally,1087.49 we1087.82 had1087.89 agriculture1088.13 within1088.54 the1088.86 scope1088.93 of1089.17 that1089.26 committee.1089.41 Mhmm.1089.82
1092.86 But1092.86 I1093.1 so1093.26 the1093.41 I'm1093.89 I'm1094.13 still1094.3 kind1094.46 of1094.62 left1094.7 with1094.97 the1095.13 question.1095.29 Right?1095.45 And1095.77 and,1096.09 you1096.73 know,1096.89 why1097.13 the1097.85 bill1098.01 as1098.25 it's1098.41 written1098.57 unless1098.81 I'm1099.13 misunderstanding1099.29 it,1099.85 which1099.93 is1100.09 entirely1100.25 possible.1100.65 And1101.29 if1101.53 I1101.69 am,1101.77 I1101.93 encourage1102.09 you1102.33 to1102.49 please1102.65 correct1102.97 me.1103.21 You1104.81 know,1104.97 it1105.29 is1105.61 limited1105.69 to1106.17 energy1106.33 as1106.89 opposed1106.97 to1107.37 any1107.53 of1107.69 the1107.85 other1107.93 needs1109.05 agricultural1110.55 businesses.1111.36
1112.23 SPEAKER101112.23 -1112.23 Yeah.1112.23 It1112.39 is.1112.52
1113.12 SPEAKER81113.12 -1113.12 I1113.12 understand1113.19 it.1113.52 Or,1113.67 you1113.84 know,1113.99 a1114.15 a1114.55 sort1114.95 of1115.12 related1115.19 a1115.84 related1116.08 question.1116.39 Right?1116.88 This1117.12 came1117.28 from1117.52 the1118.08 Cranberry1118.39 Growers1118.88 Task1119.36 Force.1119.76 Where1120.55 what1121.04 are1121.36 the,1121.52 what1121.8 are1121.85 the1121.9 positions1121.95 of1121.99 the1122.39 agricultural1123.68 sectors1124.24 of1124.56 Massachusetts1124.72 on1125.6 this1125.76 legislation?1125.92 I1126.85
1128.72 SPEAKER11128.72 -1128.72 do1128.72 you1128.8 know1128.88 I1128.96 can1129.12 see1129.36 yeah.1129.52 The1129.84 I1130 know1130.16 the1130.32 farm1130.48 bureau1130.8 is1131.28 gonna1131.52 be1131.76 meeting1131.92 on1132.32 this1132.56 in1133.2 May.1133.52 We've1134.16 also1134.48 we're1134.88 also1135.04 inquiring1135.36 with1136.08 the1136.24 farmland1136.4 trust1137.04 to1137.84 get1137.92 their1138.08 feedback1138.24
1142.63 agricultural1142.63 communities.1143.35 I1144.07 know1144.31 this1144.38 is1144.46 a1144.55 bill1144.63 that's1144.71 been1144.79 filed1144.87 in1144.95 multiple1146.55 sessions,1147.03 and1147.98 so1148.31 we1148.79 can1148.95 certainly1149.03 go1149.51 back1149.74 and1149.9 see1150.07 what1150.31 the1150.55 position1150.79 has1151.18 been1151.22 in1151.25
1151.28 SPEAKER91151.28 -1151.28 the1151.28 past,1151.31 but1151.35 we're1151.38 actively1151.41
1151.44 SPEAKER11151.44 -1151.44 in1151.44 conversations1151.47 with1151.51 the1151.59 past,1151.91 but1152.07 we're1152.15 actively1152.39 in1152.87 conversations1153.19 with1153.83 the1154.55 Farm1154.79 Bureau1155.03 and1155.51 the1155.83 Farmland1155.99 Trust.1156.55
1157.75 SPEAKER81157.75 -1157.75 Okay.1157.75 But1158.15 the1158.39 Farm1158.55 Bureau,1158.79 at1159.11 least1159.27 to1159.59 my1159.75 recollection,1159.99 doesn't1160.47 you1161.27 know,1161.35 that1161.51 is1161.67 a1161.91 a1162.15 government1162.39 entity1163.03 and1163.43 not1163.67 an1163.83 advocacy1164.07 organization1164.71 for1165.27 the1165.51 growers1165.67 themselves.1166.07 The1166.1 Massachusetts1166.13 Farm1166.17 Bureau1166.2 represents1166.23 the1166.31
1169.96 SPEAKER11169.96 -1169.96 agricultural1169.96 community,1170.67 and1170.99 they're1171.15 usually1171.48 11171.88 of1172.04 the1172.28 interest1172.91 groups1173.23 that1173.63 we1174.28 would1174.52 turn1174.84 to1175.08 to1175.32 get1175.39 their1175.56 feedback.1175.8
1176.99 SPEAKER81176.99 -1176.99 Okay.1176.99 And1177.32 what1177.48 about1177.63 the,1177.88 you1178.04 know,1178.2 maple1178.6 syrup1178.99 folks?1179.56 They're1180.36 they're1180.91 busy1180.99 right1181.39 now.1181.56 And,1182.52 you1182.84 know,1182.91 the1183.08 apple1183.15 apple1183.38 orchards1183.62 and1184.58 the1185.22 the1185.58 peach1185.94 growers1186.26 and1186.66 other1186.82 sorts1187.06 of1187.3 agro1187.46 I1187.7 mean,1187.78 our1188.02 agricultural1188.18 businesses1188.82 in1189.14 Massachusetts1189.3 are1189.86 quite1190.02 extensive.1190.26 More1190.98 extensive1191.14 than1191.54 most1191.7 of1191.94 us1192.02 realize.1192.18
1194.18 SPEAKER31194.18 -1194.18 Yeah.1194.18 I1194.5 think1194.66 as1194.98 as1195.78 this1195.94 moves1196.26 through1196.58 its1196.82 process,1197.06 I1197.54 think1197.62 those1197.86 groups1198.1 will1198.34 need1198.58 to1198.73 weigh1198.89 in1199.21 accordingly.1199.45 It1200.58 was1200.89 a1201.21 cranberry1201.29 specific1202.02 proposal1203.13 initially1203.86 and1204.26 came1204.41 out1204.58 of1204.73 the1204.82 cranberry1204.89 task1205.29 force.1205.53 And1206.17 somewhere1206.49 along1206.89 the1207.05 line,1207.13 the1207.29 decision1207.45 was1207.77 made1207.93 to1208.1 open1208.26 up1208.49 to1208.58 all1208.82 of1208.97 ag.1209.21 I1209.62 mean,1209.69 ultimately,1209.86 if1210.34 all1210.49 of1210.58 ag1210.73 is1210.97 not1211.13 interested1211.29 and1211.69 we1211.86 wanna1212.28 make1212.52 it1212.56 cranberry1212.6 specific,1213.08 I1213.4 suppose1213.56 we1213.88 could1214.04 do1214.84 that1215 as1215.24 well,1215.4 because1216.44 I1216.76 don't1216.84 wanna1217 speak1217.24 for1217.4 the1217.56 other1217.64 sectors1217.88 of1218.28 ag.1218.36 But1218.6 for,1219.56 again,1220.04 for1220.36 cranberries1220.52 in1221 particular,1221.08 it1221.64 sets1221.88 up1222.12 nicely1222.36 because1222.84 our1223.24 non1223.48 ag1224.68 land,1224.97 our1225.21 adjacent1225.38 land1225.86 is1226.58 is1226.82 just1226.97 useless1227.29 land,1227.78 so1228.1 to1228.26 speak.1228.41 It's1229.13 open1229.29 space1229.62 and1229.86 all1230.1 those1230.41 benefits.1230.65 But,1231.05 I1231.21 mean,1231.29 from1231.62 a1232.41 revenue1232.49 stream,1232.97 it1233.21 has1233.38 no1233.62 value.1233.78 So1234.26 putting1234.58 something1234.89 on1235.21 it1235.38 that1235.54 provides1235.69 value1236.1 works.1236.49 Other1237.13 farms1237.45 may1237.86 may1238.1 not1238.34 have1238.58 that1239.33 that1239.41 same1239.57 model.1239.81
1240.21 SPEAKER111240.21 -1240.21 Mhmm.1240.21 Okay.1240.53
1240.85 SPEAKER81240.85 -1240.85 And1240.85 what's1241.17 the1241.41 impact1241.57 of1241.89 this1242.05 on1242.29 the1242.45 ecosystems?1242.61
1244.93 SPEAKER31244.93 -1244.93 In1244.93 my1245.17 estimation,1245.41 people1245.97 who1246.29 know1246.45 solar1246.69 better1247.01 can1247.33 speak1247.65 to1247.81 it,1247.97 but,1248.13 I1249.65 don't1249.81 think1249.97 there1250.21 should1250.37 be1250.53 any1250.69 impact1250.93 other1251.25 than1251.49 you1251.73 you're1251.93 driving1252.26 some1252.58 stakes1253.78 in1254.02 the1254.17 ground1254.26 to1254.49 put1254.65 the1254.82 solar1255.05 panels1255.45 up.1255.78 But1256.02 short1256.41 of1256.65 that,1256.82 it's1257.45 it's1257.86 passive1258.02 energy1258.65 development.1259.13 Would1260.17 you1260.41
1262.49 SPEAKER41262.49 -1262.49 Yeah.1262.49 I1262.73 mean,1262.89 of1263.29 of1263.54 course,1263.69 any1264.49 solar1264.82 or1265.29 renewable1265.71 energy1266.03 development1266.43 would1266.83 still1267.07 need1267.31 to1267.39 go1267.47 through1267.71 the1267.87 proper1268.11 permitting1268.43 processes1268.91 to1269.55 make1269.71 sure1269.79 that1270.11 all,1271.15 you1271.47 know,1271.63 water1272.35 runoff1272.75 issues1273.15 are1273.63 addressed1273.95 appropriately1274.43 and,1275.31 that1276.67 the1276.91 site1277.07 is1277.31 graded1277.47 appropriately1277.87 and1278.51 and1278.75 the1278.99 like.1279.15 But,1279.47 you1279.95 know,1280.11 those1280.35 are1280.67 manageable1281.54 impacts1282.34 that,1282.89 in1283.78 net,1284.02 you1284.58 know,1284.73 we1284.97 find1285.21 to1285.54 have1285.7 a1286.1 a1286.34 good1286.49 footprint1286.73 on1287.3 on1288.02 the1288.17 or1288.49 a1288.82 good1288.89 impact1289.13 on1289.54 the1289.7 footprint.1289.78
1291.06 SPEAKER81291.06 -1291.06 Sorry.1291.06 I'm1291.3 I'm1291.54 not1291.7 sure1291.78 I1291.93 understand1292.1 what1292.41 a1292.65 good1292.82 impact1292.97 on1293.3 the1293.45 footprint1293.54 means.1293.93
1294.59 SPEAKER41294.59 -1294.59 The1294.59 in1294.83 net1294.99 that1295.39 it's1295.79 it1296.35 is1296.59 a1296.83 ecological1296.99 benefit1297.63 and1298.03 a1298.27 a1298.79 reliable1299.31 and1300.83 beneficial1301.15 use1302.11 of1302.43 the1302.51 land.1302.67
1304.83 SPEAKER81304.83 -1304.83 Okay.1304.83 And1305.23 is1305.47 wildlife1305.71 included1306.27 in1306.67 those,1306.83 reviews?1308.83
1309.71 SPEAKER61309.71 -1309.71 Yeah.1309.71 Okay.1310.07
1310.47 SPEAKER81310.47 -1310.47 Yep.1310.47 So1310.87 and1311.83 out1312.07 of1312.22 curiosity,1312.31 I1313.42 can't1313.59 imagine1313.83 that1314.14 we're1314.22 actually1314.38 at1314.95 this1315.11 point.1315.27 But,1315.74 if1317.59 at1317.74 some1317.9 point1318.07 down1318.71 the1318.87 line,1319.03
1322.47 the1322.47 owner1322.63 let's1323.95 say1324.11 we1324.27 put1324.31 this1324.35 into1324.67 place1324.91 and1325.15 or1325.47 or1325.71 even1325.95 the1326.27 the1326.51 farms1326.67 that's1326.99 that1327.23 already1327.39 have1327.71 this,1327.95 the1328.19 ag1328.35 land1328.59 that1328.75 already1328.99 has1329.23 solar.1329.47 They1330.99 wanna1331.07 convert1331.39 it1331.71 back1331.79 to1332.03 usable1332.27 agricultural1332.75 land.1333.23 Is1334.19 that1334.27 possible?1334.51
1335.31 SPEAKER41335.31 -1335.31 Yeah.1335.31 I1336.09 think1336.16 that1336.4 is1336.73 11337.05 way1337.92 in1338.24 which,1338.4 you1338.96 know,1339.05 solar1339.44 is1340.48 a1340.72 different1340.81 land1341.2 use1341.53 than,1342.09 say,1342.48 housing1342.81 or1343.44 other1343.77 more1344.64 permanent1344.96 uses1345.92 of1346.33 the1346.48 land1346.64 that1347.05 are1347.29 harder1347.44 to1347.85 reverse1348.64 back1349.2 to1349.44 the1349.61 original1349.77 source.1350.33 Okay.1351.45
1353.37 SPEAKER11353.37 -1353.37 Yeah.1353.37 And1353.69 I'll1353.85 I'll1354.09 just1354.17 mention1354.33 with1354.73 all1354.97 solar1355.21 projects,1355.53 there's1355.93 decommissioning1356.25 languages,1356.89 decommissioning1357.53 bonds,1358.25 which1358.65 speaks1358.89 specifically1359.29 to1359.93 that1360.09 and1360.57 the1360.73 cost1360.89 associated1361.21 with1361.85 taking1362.09 the1362.33 system1362.49 removing1362.81 the1363.21 system1363.29 from1364.14 the1364.31 site.1364.46
1365.74 SPEAKER81365.74 -1365.74 Yeah.1365.74 Okay.1365.83 Thanks1366.07 very1366.31 much.1366.46 And1366.63 representative,1366.87 congratulations1367.35 and1367.98 and1368.22 welcome.1368.38 We1368.79 have1368.95 good1369.03 chance1369.18 to1369.42 connect1369.51 since1369.9 you're1370.14
1370.31 SPEAKER111370.31 -1370.31 a1370.31 win.1370.38 Thank1370.79 you,1370.95 senator.1371.03
1372.63 SPEAKER51372.63 -1372.63 Just1372.63 rep1372.95 Sylvia.1373.18 Just1373.83 give1373.98
1374.14 SPEAKER91374.14 -1374.14 me1374.14 11374.22 second.1374.46
1374.59 SPEAKER21374.59 -1374.59 I1374.59 just1374.71 wanna1374.87 write1375.11 a1375.35 senator1375.42 Keenan's1375.74 here.1376.14 Thank1376.31 you,1376.55 senator.1376.71 Yes,1377.51 representative?1378.09
1378.89 SPEAKER51378.89 -1378.89 Absolutely.1378.89 Thank1379.53 you1379.77 so1379.85 much.1380.01 Welcome1380.57 to1380.89 the1381.05 house.1381.13 Just1381.37 a1381.61 quick1381.69 question.1381.93 You1382.25 just1382.33 said,1382.49 if1383.37 they're1383.53 gonna1383.69 reverse1384.65 back1384.97 to1385.21 the1385.45 farm,1385.61 ma'am,1385.85 they1386.25 can.1386.49 But1387.61 out1388.01 of1388.17 curiosity,1388.33 please,1389.29 when1389.61 you've1389.77 researched1390.25 more,1390.73 tell1391.77 me1391.93 what1392.25 what1392.41 are1392.62 the1392.7 terms1392.78 of1393.02 those1393.82 solar1394.13 panels1394.45 leases1394.93 because1395.34 they1395.65 go1395.82 for1395.97 20,1396.21 301396.69 years,1397.02 and1397.41 they1397.65 wanna1397.82 reverse1398.05 back.1398.45 Those1399.49 leases1399.73 cannot1400.13 be1400.38 terminated.1400.62 So1401.02 how1401.17 can1401.26 I1401.41 reverse1401.49 back1401.89 when1402.05 those1402.21 farmers1402.45 may1403.02 not1403.17 have1403.34 the1403.49 money1403.58 to1403.82 terminate1403.97 those1404.38 leases?1404.62 And1405.4 they1405.88 don't1406.04 own1406.2 the1406.44 the1406.84 the1407 the1407.32 all1407.56 the1407.72 energy1407.8 generated1408.36 with1408.76 those1408.84 solar1409.24 panels.1409.64 And1410.2 when1410.44 they1410.68 plant1410.92 when1411.4 they1411.64 when1412.52 they1412.84 are1413.08 planting1414.6 any1415.08 crop,1415.24 they1415.56 own1415.8 the1415.96 product.1416.04 They1416.36 don't1416.52 own1416.68 the1416.92 electricity.1417.08 They1417.48 just1417.64 get1417.8 a1418.04 residual.1418.52 So1419.08 I1419.32 want1419.4 more1419.64 information1419.96 about1420.28 it.1420.6 How1420.76 much1420.99 what's1421.56 the1421.88 percentage1421.96 of1422.52 the1422.67 energy1422.99 that1423.48 they1423.72 generate1423.96 with1424.6 that1424.76 with1425.08 that1425.23 that1425.72 they're1425.96 gonna1426.2 really1426.99 own?1427.32 And1427.96 what's1428.28 the1428.6 length1428.76 of1429.08 those1429.15 contract?1429.39 Because1429.96 when1430.36 we're1430.52 talking1430.67 about1430.91 speeding,1432.04 I1432.36 don't1432.43 wanna1432.67 know1432.99 for1433.32 how1433.48 long1433.63 they're1433.8 gonna1434.04 be1434.24 on1434.32 the1434.4 hook1434.56 for1434.76 those1434.96 leases1435.28 if1435.6 they1435.76 really,1436.08 really,1436.56 legally1436.8 can1438 go1438.16 back1438.4 and1438.8 convert1439.04 that1439.44 land1439.68 into1440.24 finance1440.96 again.1441.36 You1442.4 know?1442.56 Like,1442.8 we're1443.44 talking1443.52 about1443.84 contracts1444.08 and1444.48 and1444.72 no1445.36 contract1446.16 that1446.64 restricted,1446.8 they1447.2 cannot1447.51 terminate1447.83 and1448.47 and1449.27 and1449.35 contract1449.59 that1449.99 have1450.23 restriction1450.47 of1450.95 transferability.1451.11 We1452.14 can1452.38 just1452.55 say,1452.79 okay.1452.95 They1453.11 can't1453.35 revert1453.66 to1453.99 that.1454.14 What1454.55 about1454.71 those1454.95 leases?1455.18 So1456.38 the1456.87 conversation1457.11 has1457.74 to1458.07 be1458.14 more1458.31 comprehensive.1458.55 We1459.59 need1459.83 more1459.99 information.1460.23 Please1460.87 provide1461.99 us.1462.31
1464.17 SPEAKER31464.17 -1464.17 And1464.17 we1464.33 can1464.41 certainly1465.45 look1466.17 to1466.41 get1466.49 more1466.73 information.1466.97 There's1467.45 gonna1467.61 be1467.93 some1468.09 site1468.57 specificity1468.97 with1469.93 each1470.17 proposal1471.45 as1472.01 as1472.25 it1472.41 moves1472.57 forward,1472.81 but1473.13 we1473.29 can1473.45 look1473.61 to1473.77 get1474.49 a1474.73 little1474.81 bit1475.05 more1475.29 comprehensive1475.61 data.1476.17
1476.81 SPEAKER11476.81 -1476.81 Yeah.1476.81 No.1477.05 And1477.29 I1477.45 I1477.61 would1477.69 say,1479.47 typically,1479.8 you1480.52 have1480.67 a1480.84 201481.08 year1481.39 lease1481.63 term1481.88 with1482.19 21482.36 51482.52 year1482.76 extensions.1482.99 That's1483.47 kind1483.8 of1483.95 the1484.04 typical1484.28 depending1484.91 on1485.32 the1486.04 array.1486.28 Many1487.15 times,1487.39 it's1487.8 a1488.04 situation1488.19 where1488.67 it's1488.91 a1489.15 community1489.23 solar1489.8 project1490.12 where1490.43 the1490.76 electrons1490.91 that1491.39 are1491.56 generated1491.71 from1492.28 that1492.43 site1492.67 are1492.99 actually,1494.22 credits1495.02 that1495.42 go1495.66 to1495.9 homeowners1496.06 possibly1497.1 in1497.5 the1497.66 area,1497.82 in1498.14 the1498.3 local1498.46 area,1498.7 but1498.94 certainly1499.18 in1499.66 the1499.82 utility1500.54 load1501.02 zone.1501.26 So1501.5 there's1501.66 a1501.9 benefit1501.98 if1502.54 it's1502.7 a1502.86 community1502.94 solar1503.42 project.1503.66 It1503.98 may1504.06 not1504.22 be.1504.38 It1504.54 may1504.62 just1504.86 be1505.1 simply1505.26 sending1505.58 the1505.82 electricity1505.98 into1506.54 the1506.78 grid1506.86 and1507.5 then1507.58 getting1507.74 compensated1508.23 for1508.88 that.1509.12 But1509.6 it's1509.84 typically1509.91 201510.47 year1510.8 leases1511.04 with1511.36 21511.6 51511.76 year1511.99 extensions1512.15 is1513.12 what1513.28 a1513.6 a1514.08 typical1514.15 solar1514.56 project1514.88 is1515.28 in1515.52 the1515.6 industry1515.67 today.1516.08
1518.39 SPEAKER21518.39 -1518.39 Great.1518.39 Any1518.71 other1519.04 questions1519.28 from1519.67 committee1519.91 members?1520.32 Real1520.95 quick,1521.18 senator.1521.42 I1521.66 wanna,1521.74 first1522.22 of1522.46 all,1522.54 congratulate1522.78 representative1523.5 Sylvia.1524.06 Welcome1524.62 to1524.94 the1525.02 house,1525.18 and1525.42 congrats1525.58 on,1526.06 your1526.46 first1526.7 official1527.02 testimony1527.42
1527.98 SPEAKER91527.98 -1527.98 Thank1527.98 you.1528.06
1528.3 SPEAKER51528.3 -1528.3 To1528.3 the1528.38 representative.1528.54 I1529.22 will.1529.9
1530.3 SPEAKER21530.3 -1530.3 I1530.3 also1530.38 wanna1530.7 recognize,1530.94 committee1531.9 vice1532.3 chair1532.54 for1532.78 the1532.86 house1533.02 representative1533.26 David1533.74 Litsky.1533.98 Thank1534.46 you.1534.62
1535.62 SPEAKER121535.62 -1535.62 Great.1535.62 Thank1536.17 you.1536.34
1536.65 SPEAKER21536.65 -1536.65 Great.1536.65 Thank1536.89 you1537.06 so1537.22 much1537.38 for1537.54 coming1537.62 for1537.86 the1538.02 committee.1538.17 Thank1538.49 you.1540.73 The1541.54 next1541.7 bill1541.93 we1542.26 have1542.34 testimony1542.98 on1543.62 is1543.86 senate1544.1 21544.49 01544.82 01545.13 9,1545.38 enact1545.62 relative1545.93 to1546.41 regional1546.49 transportation1547.06 ballot1548.1 initiatives1548.49 filed1548.98 by1549.22 senator1549.38 Cindy1549.78 Friedman.1550.1 And1550.96 I1551.12 believe1551.36 we1551.76 have,1552 Pete1553.04 Wilson1553.36 from1553.92 Transportation1554.16 for1554.72 Mass1554.88 and1555.12 Georgia1555.36 Barlow1555.76 from1556.16 MAPC.1556.48
1559.76 While1559.76 folks1560 are1560.24 coming1560.32 up,1560.56 I1560.72 just1560.96 wanna1561.04 recognize,1561.36 representative1562.32 Gomez.1562.96 Thank1563.36 you1563.52
1566.24 for1566.24 being1566.56 here.1566.88 Good1567.2 morning.1567.52
1567.91 SPEAKER51567.91 -1567.91 Good1567.91 morning.1568.15
1570.56 SPEAKER111570.56 -1570.56 Good1570.56 morning,1570.8 chair1571.12 Eldridge,1571.36 chair1571.84 Mataro,1572.08 and1572.56 members1572.8 of1573.12 the1573.28 committee.1573.43 My1573.91 name1574.08 is1574.24 Georgia1574.39 Barlow.1574.8 I'm1575.2 here1575.43 on1575.6 behalf1575.76 of1576.08 the1576.42 Metropolitan1576.5 Area1577.14 Planning1577.46 Council,1577.78 which1578.18 is1578.42 the1578.58 regional1578.74 planning1579.14 agency1579.46 for1579.94 Greater1580.1 Boston.1580.42 We1581.22 serve1581.38 1011581.7 cities1582.66 in1583.06 the1583.3 Greater1583.38 Boss1583.7 cities1584.1 and1584.26 towns1584.42 in1584.74 the1584.9 Greater1584.98 Boston1585.3 region1585.62 and1586.5 work,1586.74 daily1587.46 to1587.86 create1588.18 a1588.58 more1588.66 safe,1588.9 efficient,1589.3 reliable1589.7 transportation1590.26 system1591.83 for1592.54 each1592.69 of1592.83 these1592.97 cities1593.11 and1593.26 towns,1593.4 knowing1593.54 that1593.68 it1593.83 is1593.9 really1594.22 the1594.54 backbone1594.78 of1595.35 our1595.42 economy1595.51 here.1596.07 MAPC1597.27 has1597.74 long1598.07 supported1598.22 legislation1598.78 to1599.42 enable1599.51 a1599.83 regional1599.9 ballot1600.22 initiatives1600.63 in1601.18 Massachusetts.1601.27 These1601.33 would1601.39 enable1601.45 any1601.51 municipality1601.58 or1601.64 groups1601.7 of1601.76 municipalities1601.83 to1602.78
1611.4 local1611.4 and1611.48 regional1612.36 transportation1613.24 projects.1614.04 Things1614.76 like1615.48 transit1615.88 design,1616.44 transportation1617.08 programs,1617.72 road1618.53 and1618.69 bridge1618.93 construction,1619.26 bikeways,1620.05 pathways,1620.62 a1621.26 variety1621.41 of1621.82 these1621.97 projects.1622.13 These1623.17 revenue1623.49 raising1623.82 options1624.21 are1624.62 as1624.86 flexible1625.1 as1625.49 possible1625.73 because1626.29 we1626.62 know1626.78 what1626.93 works1627.1 in1627.34 11627.49 community1627.73 might1628.38 not1628.53 work1628.69 in1628.93 another1629.1 municipality.1629.49 For1630.62 example,1630.78 a1631.17 sales1631.42 tax1631.75 might1631.99 make1632.15 sense1632.39 in1632.63 11632.87 city1633.35 or1633.59 town,1633.75 whereas1634.15 a1634.47 local1634.63 room1634.87 occupancy1635.27 might1636.07 make1636.31 more1636.79 sense1637.03 in1637.27 another1637.43 town.1637.75 And1638.15 we1638.31 want1638.55 local1639.19 municipalities1639.75 to1640.31 be1640.47 able1640.55 to1640.71 make1640.79 those1640.95 decisions1641.19 for1641.67 themselves.1641.91 Across1643.03 most1643.43 of1643.67 the1643.83 country,1643.99 regional1644.39 initiatives1646.12 are1646.43 regularly1646.76 used1647.15 to1647.39 finance1647.56 transportation1648.04 projects1648.6 ranging1649.39 from1649.71 road1650.04 repairs1650.28 to1650.67 public1650.84 transit1651.15 expansions.1651.63 In1652.76 the1652.91 201653.08 241653.39 elections,1653.8 across1655.08 the1655.39 country,1655.56 461656.04 out1656.67 of1656.91 531657.08 RBIs1657.88 were1658.43 approved1658.6 by1659.23 their1659.39 municipalities.1659.56 These1660.52 range1660.76 from1661.44 lower1661.52 income1661.92 areas1662.32 to1662.72 higher1663.04 income1663.44 areas1663.84 and1664.16 have1664.32 been1664.56 used1664.72 to1665.04 implement1665.12 a1665.6 variety1665.76 of1666.16 different1666.4 projects.1666.8 Flagstaff,1667.76 Arizona1668.32 will1668.8 be1668.96 electrifying1669.04 their1669.6 bus1669.76 fleet1670 as1670.32 a1670.56 in1670.88 response1671.12 to1671.68 the1672.08 passage1672.24 of1672.72 an1672.88 RBI.1673.04 Regions1675.12 throughout1675.43 Michigan1675.67 renewed1676.23 operations1676.72 for1677.12 their1677.36 regional1677.52 transit1677.84 authorities.1678.23 And1679.12 in1679.36 Colorado,1679.67 they1680.15 will1680.23 actually1680.39 be1680.72 building1680.8 a1681.2 gondola1681.36 to1681.99 give1682.15 free1682.39 transportation1682.63 from1683.2 11683.43 town1683.6 to1683.84 another1683.91 using1684.32 RBI.1684.72 So1685.2 really,1685.6 it1685.91 could1685.99 look1686.15 a1686.47 variety1686.63 of1687.04 different1687.2 ways.1687.52 Across1688.72 the1689.04 country,1689.41 cities1689.73 and1690.05 towns1690.37 are1690.77 joining1691.01 together1691.33 for1691.65 limited1691.81 periods1692.13 of1692.53 time1692.61 to1692.93 invest1693.09 in1693.33 these1693.49 projects1693.73 of1694.13 local1694.29 or1694.61 regional1694.77 significance.1695.17 But1696.05 in1696.21 Massachusetts,1696.37 we're1697.01 unable1697.33 to1697.73 do1697.81 that,1697.97 often1698.37 operating1698.77 with1699.17 11699.33 hand1699.49 tied1699.73 behind1699.97 our1700.29 backs,1700.45 to1701.57 make1701.73 these1701.97 local1702.21 contributions1702.61 to1703.11 projects1703.27 that1703.51 the1703.9 municipality1704.22 wants1704.87 to1705.18 see.1705.27 The1706.31 inability1706.55 to1707.11 propose1707.27 these1707.66 types1707.83 of1708.07 infrastructure1708.22 and1708.79 transit1708.95 revenue1709.42 sources1709.9 is1710.46 really1710.87 glaring1711.18 in1711.66 the1711.9 face1711.98 of1712.38 federal1712.55 transportation1713.11 cuts1713.83 that1714.14 we1714.31 are1714.55 already1714.63 seeing.1715.03 At1715.74 MAPC,1716.07 we've1716.79 already1717.03 experienced1717.35 a1717.75 loss1717.83 of1718.07 federal1718.23 transportation1718.71 grants,1719.35 and1719.75 we1719.91 expect1720.15 that1720.47 there1720.63 will1720.79 be1720.95 more1721.11 to1721.27 come1721.43 and1721.67 that1721.83 there1721.99 will1722.15 be1722.39 fewer1722.47 opportunities1722.79 for1723.83 our1724.07 municipalities1724.23 to1724.95 apply1725.19 for1725.43 federal1725.67 funding1725.99 in1726.31 the1726.47 next1726.63 few1727.03 years.1727.27 This1728.31 type1728.55 of1728.79 revenue1728.95 raising1729.35 option1729.75 is1730.39 common1730.63 throughout1730.87 the1731.19 rest1731.27 of1731.43 the1731.51 country.1731.59 Municipalities1732.15 and1732.88 cities1733.12 and1733.43 states1733.6 are1733.91 going1734.08 to1734.32 be1734.39 relying1734.56 on1735.04 these1735.2 options1735.43 in1735.91 other1736.15 states,1736.39 and1737.12 we1737.28 really1737.43 see1737.67 this1737.84 as1737.99 the1738.15 moment1738.23 for1738.56 Massachusetts1738.72 to1739.43 also1739.67 ensure1740.08 that1740.39 we1740.56 have1740.72 this1740.96 ability,1741.2 this1741.91 tool1742.15 to,1742.72 be1743.36 able1743.52 to1743.76 create1743.84
1743.88 SPEAKER91743.88 -1743.88 and1743.88 provide1743.91 resources1743.96 for1744 our1744.04
1744.08 SPEAKER111744.08 -1744.08 for1744.08 our1744.88 for1747.12 our1747.28 residents.1747.44 Our1748.4 cities1748.64 and1748.88 towns1749.04 really1749.28 just1749.52 need1749.76 this1750 ability1750.16 to1750.72 raise1751.28 local1751.52 dollars,1751.84 invest1752.32 in1752.56 their1752.72 communities,1752.88 and1753.84 be1754.16 a1754.32 partner1754.4 to1754.72 the1754.88 state1754.96 in1755.28 these1755.44 times.1755.6 I1756.88 will1757.04 just1757.2 note1757.6 that1757.76 we1757.92 often1758.16 hear1758.48 about1758.64 residents1758.88 not1759.36 wanting1759.52 to1759.84 raise1760 taxes1760.56 for1761.08 broad1761.32 based1761.55 region1761.88 reasons.1762.36 But1763.47 RBIs1763.71 really1764.19 allow1764.51 municipalities1764.99 and1765.79 residents1765.88 to1766.36 know1766.43 exactly1766.76 where1767.08 their1767.23 money1767.39 is1767.71 going,1767.88 how1768.27 it's1768.51 going1768.67 to1768.99 be1769.08 spent,1769.23 and1769.79 kind1770.03 of1770.19 adds1770.84 that1771.08 level1771.32 of1771.55 transparency1771.79 that1772.6 makes1772.76 it1772.99 easier1773.08 for1773.79 people1773.95 to1774.27 hold1774.51 the1775.41 money1775.57 accountable1775.89 and1776.21 ensure1776.45 that1776.77 that1776.93 project1777.09 is1777.49 really1777.73 something1777.89 that1778.29 community1778.53 wants.1779.01 I1780.93 will1781.09 just1781.25 say1781.41 that1781.65 we,1781.89 across1782.93 the1783.17 board,1783.33 know1783.65 we1783.81 need1784.05 more1784.21 tools1784.37 for1784.69 transportation1784.93 and1785.57 infrastructure1785.81 finance,1786.37 and1786.77 we1786.93 think1787.01 this1787.17 is1787.41 an1787.57 important1787.65 part1788.77 of1789.01 that1789.17 larger1789.73 system.1790.21 We1790.69 don't1790.77 think1790.93 this1791.22 should1791.3 be1791.46 the1791.63 only1791.7 option1791.94 on1792.18 the1792.42 table.1792.51 We1793.07 encourage1793.22 this1793.63 committee1793.87 to1794.27 think1794.42 broadly1794.98 about1795.63 increasing1796.51 the1796.83 availability1796.98 of1797.54 different1797.7 tools1798.03 to1798.27 raise1798.42 revenue1798.66 throughout1798.98 the1799.14 Commonwealth.1799.3 So1800.18 MAPC1800.51 will1800.98 be1801.14 submitting1801.3 testimony1801.79 written1802.35 testimony1802.66 with,1803.14 additional1804.09 information1804.89 about1805.45 what's1805.61 happening1805.77 in1806.09 our1806.17 communities1806.33 and1806.73 how1806.89 we've1807.53 heard1807.85 from,1808.09 both1808.97 mayors1809.21 and1809.61 town1809.93 managers1810.17 how1810.73 they1810.89 would1811.13 like1811.29 to1811.53 use1811.69 this1812.01 option1812.17 if1812.57 it1812.73 were1812.81 available1812.97 to1813.45 them,1813.53 and1813.93 we're1814.01 happy1814.25 to1814.41 answer1814.49 any1814.81 other1814.97 questions.1815.13 I'll1815.87 pass1816.11 it1816.18 to1816.42 Pete.1816.51
1817.94 SPEAKER51817.94 -1817.94 Thank1817.94 you.1818.27
1820.66 SPEAKER121820.66 -1820.66 I'm1820.66 gonna1820.9 be1821.14 brief1821.3 because1821.54 she1821.7 took1821.87 most1822.02 of1822.27 my1822.42 talking1822.59 points.1822.83 So,1823.22 thank1824.27 you1824.51 for,1824.66 having1825.87 me,1826.11 chair1827.07 Eldrigine,1827.38 chair1827.87 Matero,1828.11 members1828.59 of1828.9 the1828.98 committee.1829.07 My1829.54 name1829.7 is1829.78 Pete1829.94 Wilson.1830.18 I'm1830.74 senior1830.9 policy1831.39 director1831.71 at1832.19 Transportation1832.43 for1832.99 Math.1833.23 T1834.11 for1834.27 Math1834.43 is1834.67 a1834.75 statewide1834.91 coalition1835.39 of1835.95 community1836.11 based1836.51 organizations,1836.83 transportation1837.87 advocates,1838.43 and1838.83 others1838.99 who1839.23 work1839.39 to1839.63 improve,1839.79 transportation1841.07 so1841.71 residents1841.87 can1842.43 thrive.1842.67 As1843.76 my1843.91 colleague1844.08 pointed1844.47 out,1844.71 RVIs1845.04 are1845.52 widely1845.67 used1846.08 across1846.39 the1846.71 country,1846.88 as1847.84 a1847.99 way1848.15 to1848.32 raise1848.47 local1848.8 transportation1849.28 revenue.1849.91 I1851.43 wanna1851.6 point1851.84 out1852.08 a1852.23 couple1852.32 of1852.56 things.1852.71 This1854.08 is1854.32 not1854.47 a1856.08 revenue1856.32 raising1856.95 bill.1857.43 This1857.67 does1857.84 not1857.99 raise1858.32 any1858.63 revenue.1858.88 It1859.2 simply1859.37 allows1859.69 municipalities1859.93 the1860.81 tools1860.97 to1861.61 do1861.69 so.1861.93 If1862.41 they1862.57 choose1862.73 not1863.05 to1863.29 use1863.45 this1863.69 tool,1863.85 nothing1864.73 changes.1865.13 If1865.85 the1866.09 ballot1866.17 initiatives1866.57 are1867.21 defeated,1867.37 which,1868.09 as1868.41 she1868.57 said,1868.81 most1869.13 of1869.37 them1869.53 are1869.85 approved,1870.17 nationwide,1870.81 Again,1872.93 nothing1873.41 changes,1873.82 and1874.22 it1874.38 gives,1874.54 cities1875.34 and1875.65 towns1875.73 the1875.89 flexibility1876.06 to1876.54 choose1876.78 which1877.34 revenue1877.58 sources1878.06 and1878.86 for1879.02 how1879.26 long1879.49 because1879.82 there1880.13 are1880.38 sunset1880.54 provisions1880.93 in1881.41 the1881.58 bill1881.65 about,1882.06 you1882.46 know,1882.62 once1882.78 the1883.1 the1883.34 project1883.49 is1883.89 over,1883.98 etcetera,1884.22 the1884.86 the,1885.17 the1885.73 appropriation,1886.38 for1886.7 lack1886.84 of1886.98 a1887.12 better1887.26 term,1887.58 goes1888.06 away.1888.3 And1889.74 then1889.9 I1890.38 also1890.7 wanna1891.02 point1891.34 out1891.58 that1891.74 just1892.14 in1892.46 the1892.7 in1892.94 the1893.26 broader1893.42 context1893.82 of1894.22 transportation1894.46 funding1895.02 statewide,1895.42 the1896.46 governor's1896.62 transportation1897.1 funding1897.9 task1898.3 force1898.54 did1898.86 an1899.02 examination1899.1 of1899.82 comparatives1899.98 across1900.54 the1900.94 country1901.02 to1901.34 other1901.65 states,1901.82 including1902.06 Minnesota,1902.86 Colorado,1903.34 North1903.82 Carolina,1904.06 etcetera.1904.7 And1905.89 while1906.13 the1906.54 task1906.78 force1907.02 chose1907.34 not1907.73 to,1907.89 support1909.34 or1909.82 focus1910.46 on1910.86 any1911.1 future1911.34 revenues1911.73 or1912.3 other1913.02 revenue1913.34 sources1913.73 beyond1914.13 what1914.38 we're1914.54 currently,1914.78 collecting.1915.87 11917.23 of1917.47 the1917.63 provisions1917.79 and1918.35 11918.51 of1918.67 the1918.83 staples1919.23 of1919.63 the1919.71 report1919.95 was1920.27 to1920.51 enhance1920.75 revenue1921.23 streams1921.63 by1922.75 reviewing1922.99 and1923.71 updating1923.95 streams1924.43 that1924.83 fund1924.99 transportation1925.23 for1925.87 the1926.03 future.1926.11 So1926.91 we1927.15 believe1927.31
1932.47 that,1932.47 there's1933.99 a1934.76 couple1935.52 of1935.8 different1936.08 things.1936.32 Like,1936.88 she1937.28 mentioned1937.6 some1937.99 provisions.1938.15 Just1938.71 more1939.43 recently,1939.76 in1940.47 November1940.88 2020,1941.36 voters1941.84 approved1942.16 Project1942.56 Connect1942.88 in1943.28 Austin,1943.52 Texas1943.92 to1944.8 raise1944.96 7,000,000,0001945.28 to1945.92 improve1946.08 mobility1946.48 in1946.88 the1947.04 region1947.12 through1947.36 adding1947.6 new1947.84 rail1948.08 lines,1948.24 cap1949.36 metro1949.6 rapid1950.08 lines,1950.32 and1950.72 more1951.04 services1951.28 across1951.84 the1952.16 city.1952.32 Voters1953.89 in1954.21 Richland1954.38 County,1954.86 South1955.17 Carolina1955.41 improved1955.97 a1956.21 measure1956.3 in1956.54 20241956.7 that1957.65 would1957.89 renew1958.3 a1958.78 1%1958.93 tax1959.49 called1959.73 the1959.89 penny1960.06 tax1960.38 and1961.02 generate1961.26 41961.97 and1962.21 a1962.3 half1962.38 billion1962.62 over1963.02 251963.26 years1963.65 for1963.89 road1964.06 bridges1964.3 and1964.7 pedestrian1964.86 projects.1965.89 And1966.21 voters1966.37 in1966.69 Nashville1966.93 improved1967.49 a1967.97 half1968.21 cent1968.45 increase1968.85 to1969.17 the1969.33 sales1969.41 tax1969.73 to1970.29 prod1970.61 to1971.17 fund,1971.33 the1971.97 Nashville's1972.21 choose1973.01 how1973.25 you1973.41 move1973.57 transportation,1973.89 which1974.53 includes1974.77 sidewalks,1975.41 transit,1976.05 bus1977.57 service,1977.81 and1978.21 other1978.37 things.1978.61 So,1978.93 happy1979.65 to1979.89 answer1979.97 any1980.21 questions,1980.37 and1980.69 I1980.85 really1981.27 appreciate,1981.42 the1982.14 time1982.23 and,1982.87 for1983.35 you1983.51 having1983.66 us.1983.9
1984.79 SPEAKER21984.79 -1984.79 Thank1984.79 you.1985.11 Great.1985.42 Thank1985.9 you1986.07 both.1986.31 Are1986.95 there1987.11 questions1987.18 from1987.75 the1987.99 committee?1988.63 Questions?1989.59 Okay.1991.18 We're1991.83 we're1991.99 all1992.23 set.1992.38 Thank1992.71 you1993.03 so1993.18 much.1993.27 Thank1993.51 you.1993.59 Appreciate1993.75 you1994.14 coming1994.23 for1994.47 the1994.63 committee.1994.79 The1996.63 next1996.79 bill1997.03 that1997.19 we1997.43 have,1997.51 individuals1998.31 testify1998.87 on1999.67 is1999.91 senate2000.15 192000.87 22,2001.35 an2001.83 act2001.99 relative2002.23 to2002.63 the2002.71 Massachusetts2002.87 Fund2003.43 for2003.67 vulnerable2003.91 communities2004.31 most2004.95 affected2005.19 by2005.59 climate2005.83 change,2006.23 filed2006.55 by2006.79 senator2006.95 Michael2007.43 Barrett.2007.67 And2008.55 we2008.79 have2008.95 a2009.19 panel,2009.27 12010.55 person2010.79 in2011.03 Virgil2011.27 Virgil,2011.83 Keith2012.46 Bergman2012.79 and2013.18 Larry2013.51 Yu2013.9 in2014.38 person.2014.63 Good2016.38 morning.2016.55
2020.14 SPEAKER92020.14 -2020.14 Good2020.14 morning.2020.31
2020.7 SPEAKER132020.7 -2020.7 Good2020.7 morning.2020.79
2021.51 SPEAKER92021.51 -2021.51 My2021.51 colleague,2021.66 mister2021.98 Bergman,2022.22 should2022.55 be2022.7 joining2022.87 remotely,2023.18 and2023.66 I2023.9 believe2024.07 he2024.31 was2024.38 gonna2024.55 speak2024.87 first.2025.11
2025.59 SPEAKER22025.59 -2025.59 If2025.59 you2025.74 I2025.9 think2025.98 I2026.14 just2026.28 heard2026.44 him.2026.6 Yes.2026.68 So2026.84 I2026.96 don't2027.08 know2027.16 if2027.32 you2027.4 want2027.48 him2027.72 to2027.88 speak2027.96 or2028.12 you'd2028.28 like2028.44 to2028.6 speak.2028.68 I2028.84 think2028.92
2029.08 SPEAKER92029.08 -2029.08 he2029.08 can2029.16 kick2029.32 off.2029.48 Thank2029.64 you.2029.8 Very2029.96 good.2030.2
2030.6 SPEAKER22030.6 -2030.6 Go2030.6 ahead,2030.84 Keith.2031
2031.32 SPEAKER132031.32 -2031.32 Thank2031.32 thanks2031.88 so2032.2 much.2032.44 Thanks2033 so2033.32 much,2033.48 chair2034.12 Eldridge,2034.52 chair,2035.24 Madero,2035.88 and2036.52 members2036.84 of2037.24 the2037.32 committee.2037.48 My2038.62 name2038.69 is2038.78 Keith2039.02 Bergman.2039.34 I'm2039.73 a,2039.89 Concord,2040.53 resident,2041.41 a2041.97 retired,2042.13 town2042.93 manager2043.17 speaking2043.82 today2044.13 as2044.62 part2044.93 of2045.1 a2045.26 panel2045.41 from2045.97 the2046.69 Climate2046.86 Reality2047.34 Projects2047.89 Boston2048.53 Metro2049.26 chapter.2050.38 Larry,2051.73 you2052.3 and2052.61 I2052.93 are2053.26 here.2053.41 We're2054.51 both,2054.67 former2055.39 chairs,2055.87 and2056.99 we're2057.31 here2057.55 to2057.79 urge2057.95 the2058.35 committee's2058.67 favorable2059.23 action2059.79 on2060.19 Senate2060.43 Bill2060.75 192061.47 22,2061.87 which2062.91 would2063.07 allow2063.31 donations2063.71 to2064.19 a2064.35 Massachusetts2064.51 fund2065.39 for2065.71 vulnerable2066.11 communities2066.75 most2067.47 affected2067.79 by2068.75 climate2068.99 change.2070.22 This2070.46 bill,2071.34 filed2071.42 by2071.74 my2071.98 state2072.3 senator2072.63 Mike2073.03 Barrett,2073.34 supports2074.46 combating2075.34 the2075.74 climate2075.9 crisis2076.3 around2076.78 the2077.03 world2077.11 by2078.07 establishing2078.3 a2078.86 model,2079.03 for2079.98 the2080.3 nation,2080.55 for2081.98 enabling2082.38 state2083.03 taxpayer2083.42 donations2084.07 to2085.19 the2085.43 United2085.51 Nations2085.99 Least2086.47 Developed2086.79 Countries2087.19 Fund.2088.39 In2088.55 fact,2088.71 without2089.03 this2089.35 legislation,2089.75 there's2090.47 no2090.79 way2090.95 for2091.19 state2091.51 tax2091.91 taxpayers2092.47 to2093.19 make2093.35 private2093.59 donations2094.07 to2094.71 the2094.79 UN's2095.03 fund.2095.51 Let2096.71 me2096.87 thank2097.11 this2097.51 committee,2097.95 for2100.36 having2100.51 favorably2101.47 reported2102.11 this2102.59 bill2102.84 out2103.07 in2103.71 each2103.95 of2104.19 the2104.28 last2104.51 32104.91 legislative2105.8 sessions.2106.43 And2108.67 the2109.16 stakes2109.32 are2109.8 higher2109.95 this2110.43 year2110.67 with2110.99 the2111.16 recent2111.32 dismantling2111.71 of2112.59 USAID.2113.43 The2114.87 needs2115.03 of2115.99 these,2116.23 442117.11 least2117.83 developed2118.07 countries2118.55 on2118.95 the2119.19 UN's2119.27 list2119.67 have2120.31 never2120.55 been2120.79 more2121.03 acute.2121.19 So2122.55 by2122.87 passing2123.11 this2123.67 bill2123.91 this2124.39 year,2124.71 Massachusetts2125.47 can2126.11 make2126.28 a2126.43 real2126.59 difference.2126.84 Since2128.59 its2128.91 creation,2129.16 the2129.64 UN's2129.95 fund2130.28 has2130.59 supported2131.24 over2131.72 42132.03 232132.59 projects2133.64 with2134.11 some2134.43 $2,100,000,0002134.68 in2136.91 grants2137.07 benefiting2138.04 over2139.32 74,000,0002139.48 people2140.52 in2141.32 least2141.48 developed2141.8 countries.2142.2 These2143.08 projects2143.32 are2143.72 crucial2143.88 to2144.36 support2144.52 countries2145.4 in2145.88 building2146.12 resilience2146.6 to2147.24 the2147.4 climate2147.56 impacts2148.12 they2148.6 are2148.84 already2149 facing.2150.45 And2150.86 by2151.09 creating2151.26 a2151.66 voluntary2151.89 check2152.53 off2152.78 on2153.18 personal2153.49 state2154.21 income2154.53 tax2155.01 returns,2155.34 Massachusetts2156.38 residents2157.09 would2157.57 be2157.73 able2157.89 to2158.14 contribute2158.3 directly2158.86 to2159.73 those2159.89 around2160.14 the2160.45 world2160.53 most2160.93 vulnerable.2161.26 So2162.59 we2162.83 urge2162.91 this,2163.31 committee2163.87 to2164.27 report2164.43 out2164.91 favorably,2165.07 senate,2166.43 bill,2167.23 19222168.03 and2169.55 help2169.95 make2170.35 the2170.67 world2170.75 a2171.07 better2171.23 place.2171.47 So2172.11 thanks2172.51 very2172.83 much2173.07 for2173.31 your2173.39 consideration2173.63 and2174.51 support.2174.75
2178.28 SPEAKER92178.28 -2178.28 Amazing.2178.28 So2179.32 thank2179.57 you.2179.72 Thank2180.2 you,2180.36 Keith,2180.53 for2180.84 that.2181.01 Thank2181.49 you,2181.64 chairs2181.8 Eldridge2182.2 and2182.68 Madaro2183.01 Madero.2184.2 Excuse2184.77 me.2185.16 Thank2186.13 you,2186.36 vice2186.68 chair2186.93 Linsky,2187.16 and2187.64 and2187.8 all2187.97 members2188.13 of2188.45 the2188.61 committee,2188.68 for2190.04 having2190.2 me.2190.44 It's2190.52 a2190.68 pleasure2190.76 to2191 be2191.08 here.2191.16 It's2191.4 an2191.56 honor2191.72 to2191.88 be2191.96 here.2192.12 And2192.28 and2192.44 I2192.6 say2192.68 it's2192.84 a2192.92 pleasure2193 to2193.32 be2193.36 here2193.4 because2193.64 I2193.8 I2193.96 think2194.04 this2194.2 bill2194.36 should2194.68 should2195 give2195.24 us2195.4 some2195.56 some2195.8 joy,2196.04 some2196.76 pride.2197 So2197.32 hopefully,2197.48 we2197.88 can2198.04 we2198.28 can2198.44 smile2198.6 when2198.92 we,2199.16 successfully2200.04 pass2200.6 this2200.84 bill.2201 My2202.04 name2202.12 is2202.28 Larry2202.36 Yu.2202.68 I'm2202.84 a2202.92 Somerville2203.16 resident2203.64 and,2204.2 former2204.84 co2205.23 chair2205.47 as,2205.8 mister2206.51 Bergman2206.84 pointed2207.23 out2207.39 of2207.52 Climate2207.64 Reality2207.95 Project's2208.28 Boston2208.59 Metro2208.99 chapter.2209.32 I2210.84 just2210.91 wanna2211.16 note2211.39 that,2211.64 the2212.36 Boston2212.51 Metro2212.84 chapter2213.16 has2213.47 been2213.64 working2213.88 with2214.28 our,2214.76 colleagues2215.72 in2216.03 the2216.2 South2216.36 Coast2216.59 Massachusetts2216.91 chapter.2217.55 So2217.95 it's,2218.2 it's2218.68 a2219.23 mouthful2219.55 with2220.03 Climate2220.27 Reality2220.51 Project2220.83 Boston2221.07 Metro2221.39 chapter,2221.71 Climate2222.03 Reality2222.27 South2222.67 Coast2222.83 Massachusetts2223.15 chapter.2223.63 And2224.43 we've2224.59 also2224.83 been2225.07 working2225.15 alongside,2225.55 Oxfam2226.35 America,2226.83 whose2227.95 CEO2228.27 Abby2228.67 Maxman2228.91 has2229.39 provided2229.71 some2230.11 written2230.27 testimony,2230.59 I2231.07 believe.2231.15 Simply2232.97 put,2233.36 we2233.61 we2233.84 view2234.01 this2234.16 bill2234.32 really2234.57 as2234.81 a2234.97 win2235.13 win2235.45 win.2235.93 It2237.53 doesn't2237.68 cost2237.93 the2238.41 Commonwealth2238.49 anything.2239.29 It2240.49 doesn't2240.64 burden2240.97 Massachusetts2241.45 taxpayers2242.16 unless2243.13 they2244.24 want2244.41 to2244.64 voluntarily2244.81 step2245.45 up2245.68 to2246.72 contribute,2246.89 and2247.66 it2247.82 helps2247.98 the2248.14 communities2248.46 that2248.86 are2249.1 literally2249.34 the2249.82 most2249.98 vulnerable2250.38 to2251.1 climate2251.26 change.2251.66 So2252.22 that's2252.46 32252.78 wins.2252.94 On2254.22 that2254.46 last2254.62 point,2254.86 as2255.18 as2255.5 mister2255.66 Bergin2255.98 pointed2256.3 out,2256.62 this2256.86 is2257.1 a2257.26 particularly2257.5 perilous2258.06 time.2258.62 Even2260.06 in2260.38 our2260.54 most2260.7 generous2261.02 times,2261.9 national2263.54 governments2263.93 around2264.34 the2264.58 world2264.66 have2265.22 have2265.54 not2265.86 fully2266.18 fulfilled2266.58 their2267.22 commitments2267.45 to2268.34 climate2268.58 finance.2268.97 And2270.58 so2270.82 I2271.86 I2272.1 think2272.26 now2272.58 is2273.14 it's2274.02 more2274.34 important2274.58 than2274.89 ever,2275.14 for2275.15 Massachusetts2275.16 to2275.17 put2275.17 a2275.18 stake2275.19 in2275.2 the2275.2 ground2275.21 and2275.22 say,2275.23 we2275.23 are2275.24 still2275.25 in2275.26 it.2275.26 We2275.27 are2275.28 still2275.29 in2275.3 it.2275.55
2281.62 This2281.62 fight2281.78 against2282.1 climate2282.34 change.2282.74 That2284.58 symbolism2284.9 matters,2285.62 but2287.3 this2287.46 bill2287.7 is2287.94 not2288.02 just2288.18 a2288.38 symbolic2288.58 act.2289.22 So2289.7 the2289.86 least2290.02 developed2290.26 countries2290.66 fund,2291.06 helps2292.39 to2292.71 provide2293.03 grants2293.43 for2293.76 projects2293.99 like2294.23 12294.47 in2294.64 The2294.8 Gambia2294.95 that2295.51 that2295.91 will2296.07 improve2296.32 extreme2296.71 weather2297.11 forecasting,2297.43 and2298.39 crucially2298.64 to2299.03 communicate2299.43 that2299.99 forecasting2300.23 to2300.95 vulnerable2301.19 communities2301.68 such2302.07 as2302.32 fishing2302.47 fleets.2302.71 It2303.84 funds2303.99 shifts2304.32 in2304.71 farming2304.88 practices2305.36 in2306.16 Togo,2306.32 away2307.36 from2307.59 rain2308.37 fed2308.53 agriculture2308.69 to2309.73 climate2311.09 resilient2311.49 practices2311.97 that2312.37 sustain2312.53 both2312.93 livelihoods2313.25 and,2314.29 ecosystems.2315.17
2317.97 The2317.97 average2318.21 grant2318.53 is2318.77 less2318.93 than2319.09 $5,000,0002319.25 as2320.21 if2320.77 if2321.01 you2321.09 do2321.25 the2321.41 math2321.49 quickly2321.73 on2322.05 on2322.29 the2322.37 numbers2322.53 that,2322.85 mister2323.41 Bergman2323.73 shared,2323.97 and,2324.89 and2325.89 so2327.01 we're2327.09 not2327.16 talking2327.57 about2328.13 billion2328.16 dollar2328.2 projects2329.81 involving2330.29 massive2331.24 engineering2331.81 seawalls.2332.36 We're2333.16 talking2333.33 about2333.64 small,2333.97 smaller2334.84 dollar,2335.33 projects2336.54 that2336.94 help2337.1 communities2337.34 directly,2337.82 and2338.62 importantly,2338.86 smaller2339.74 donor2340.14 contributions2340.94 matter.2341.98 So,2342.38 I2343.26 think2343.42 that2343.58 people2343.82 in2344.06 Massachusetts2344.22 will2344.94 be2345.1 able2345.26 to2345.5 make2345.66 a2345.82 difference2345.9 directly.2346.3 The2347.74 bill2347.98 can2348.14 also2348.38 make2348.54 a2348.7 difference2348.86 across2349.18 The2349.58 US,2349.74 by2351.07 setting2351.23 a2351.47 model2351.71 that2352.19 other2352.36 states2352.59 can2352.99 follow,2353.15 particularly2353.47 the2353.95 402354.11 or2354.43 so2354.59 other2354.84 states2355.23 that2355.55 have2355.71 income2355.88 taxes.2356.19 And2356.99 frankly,2357.23 other2358.28 subnational2359.55 governments,2360.28 as2360.99 as2361.15 they2361.32 call2361.39 them2361.55 in2361.8 the2361.95 in2362.03 the2362.19 business,2362.36 you2363.6 know,2363.76 provinces,2364 counties,2365.28 cantons,2366.16 what2366.8 have2367.04 you,2367.2 municipalities2367.6 perhaps,2368.32 can2369.28 also2369.52 take2369.84 the2370 lead2370.24 and2370.8 pass2371.04 their2371.2 own2371.36 legislation,2371.6 that2373.12 allows,2373.28 concerned2374.96 residents2375.86 to2376.66 make2376.89 donations2377.21 to2377.61 this2377.78 United2378.01 Nations2378.34 Fund.2378.66 And2379.21 and2379.45 again,2379.53 as2379.86 mister2380.01 Bergen2380.34 pointed2380.57 out,2380.82 only2381.05 government2381.3 bodies2381.69 can2382.01 make2382.17 these2382.34 donations.2382.49 So2383.05 I2383.3 literally2383.45 cannot2383.86 write2384.57 that2384.82 check,2384.97 to2385.86 the2386.01 least2386.17 developed2386.34 countries2386.66 fund2387.05 without2387.3 this2387.53 bill.2387.78 Just2389.69 to2389.93 wrap2390.01 up2390.26 quickly,2390.41 the2390.73 the2390.97 bill2391.05 is2391.13 a2391.37 win2391.45 win2391.69 win.2391.93 It2392.33 provides2392.65 meaningful2392.97 help2393.53 to2393.69 the2393.85 communities2393.93 most2394.33 vulnerable2394.65 to2395.13 climate2395.21 change,2395.53 and2396.09 it2396.21 sets2396.33 a2396.57 model2396.65 that2396.97 other2397.13 states2397.37 can2397.69 follow.2397.85 So2398.17 we2398.65 do2398.81 urge2398.97 the2399.29 committee2399.37 to2399.85 report2400.01 out2400.33 favorably2400.41 s2401.05 12401.29 92401.53 22401.93 2.2402.17 Thank2403.61 you.2403.85 Happy2404.65 to2404.97 answer2405.21 some2405.77 questions2405.93 if2406.25 if2406.63 I2406.7 if2406.79 I'm2406.95 able.2407.11
2408.07 SPEAKER22408.07 -2408.07 Great.2408.07 Thank2408.39 you2408.55 so2408.7 much,2408.86 mister2409.11 Yu.2409.43 Appreciate2409.66 your2409.99 testimony.2410.14 Are2411.03 there2411.27 questions2411.34 from2411.83 the2412.14 committee2412.22 members?2412.55 Senator2412.95 Rauch?2413.27
2413.66 SPEAKER82413.66 -2413.66 Thank2413.66 you,2413.83 mister2413.99 chair.2414.31 Good2415.03 morning.2415.27
2418.14 Who2418.14 decides2418.31 which2418.86
2422.07 SPEAKER92422.07 -2422.07 who2422.07 decides2422.47 which2422.56 countries2422.66 go2422.75 on2422.84 the2422.94 list?2423.03 The2423.22 the2423.31 least2423.4 developed2423.5 countries2423.59 list2424.15 is2424.47 a2424.63 list2424.87 that's2425.11 maintained2425.27 by2425.67 the2425.83 United2425.99 Nations,2426.39 and2426.79 it2427.03 changes,2427.43 I2428.15 believe,2428.31 year2428.63 by2428.79 year.2429.03 Mhmm.2429.75 I2430.71 believe2430.79 there2431.11 are2431.27 462431.43 nations2431.99 currently2432.47 on2432.87 the2433.03 list.2433.11
2433.12 SPEAKER122433.12 -2433.12 So2433.12 currently,2433.14 if2433.15 I'm2433.16 looking2433.18 at2433.19
2433.44 SPEAKER52433.44 -2433.44 the2433.44
2441.21 SPEAKER82441.21 -2441.21 UN2441.21 website.2441.3 Yes.2442.01 It2442.82 includes2443.05 countries2443.45 like2443.93 Afghanistan2444.26 and2445.14 Yemen.2445.53 Is2445.65 that2445.78 correct?2445.86 You're2446.49 not?2446.74 Is2448.75 that2448.91 correct?2448.99
2449.23 SPEAKER92449.23 -2449.23 You're2449.23 not?2449.47 That's2449.71 correct.2449.87 Yeah.2450.27
2451.15 SPEAKER82451.15 -2451.15 So2451.15 we'd2451.39 be2451.55 sending2451.79 American2452.19 tax2452.67 dollar2452.99 dollars2453.47 to2453.87 the2454.11 country2454.43 of2454.75 Yemen?2454.91
2455.87 SPEAKER92455.87 -2455.87 We2455.87 would2456.11 be2456.27 allowing2456.51 voluntary2456.91 contributions,2457.47 to2459.71 projects2459.79 potentially2461.51 in2461.91 those2462.15 countries.2462.32 I'm2462.71 I'm2462.95 not2463.19 sure2463.43 if2463.76 there2463.91 are2464.23 current2464.55 projects2464.95 in2465.51 the2465.84 country2465.91 of2466.23 Yemen.2466.39
2467.19 SPEAKER82467.19 -2467.19 What2467.19 sort2467.36 of2467.51 protections2467.67 are2468.15 there2468.39 for2468.55 the2468.71 American2468.88 taxpayer2469.28 who2469.91 might2470.07 unknowingly2470.32 put2470.95 their2471.11 tax2471.28 dollars2471.59 into2471.84 something2472.07 that2472.39 sounds2472.55 good2472.88 but2473.11 could2473.28 be2473.43 sent2473.59 to2473.84 countries2473.91 that2474.39 are,2474.55 perpetuating2476.15 horrible2476.88 crimes2477.35 against2477.59 humanity2477.83 Yeah.2478.87 And2479.43 engaging2480.15 in2480.31 gross2481.11 identity2482.31 based2482.79 discrimination,2483.27 harassment,2484.07 torture,2484.71 and2485.19 mutilation,2486.15 murder,2487.03 from2489.43 receiving2489.67 these2490.15 funds.2490.31 And2490.63 what2490.71 sort2490.87 of2491.03 information2491.45 would2491.61 be2491.84 provided2491.93 to2492.32 the2492.49 taxpayers2492.64 about2493.2 where2493.36 those2493.61 dollars2493.68 are2494.01 actually2494.16 going2494.41 to2494.53 end2494.64 up?2494.8
2495.36 SPEAKER92495.36 -2495.36 Sure.2495.36 So,2495.68 the2498.09 best2498.24 way2498.49 to2498.64 put2498.72 it2498.89 is2498.97 that2499.13 the2499.28 is2499.45 that2499.61 the2499.84 the2500.32 least2500.64 developed2500.89 countries2501.2 fund2501.61 facility2501.93 is2502.64 administered2502.97 by2503.45 the2503.61 United2503.76 Nations,2504.01 global2504.8 global2505.53 energy2506.24 fund,2506.89 GEF.2507.39 It2508.75 might2508.83 be2508.99 Global2509.07 Environment2509.39 Fund.2509.79 Excuse2510.03 me.2510.27 And2511.15 they2511.39 themselves2511.63 have2512.11 protections2512.83 and2513.47 guards,2513.63 that2514.75 conform2515.07 with2515.55 with2515.87 United2516.11 Nations2516.51 standards2516.83 on2517.23 that.2517.39 Beyond2518.11 that,2518.43 I'm2518.67 I'm2518.91 afraid2519.07 that2519.31 I2519.47 can't2519.63 provide2519.87 more2520.11 details.2520.27
2521.3 SPEAKER82521.3 -2521.3 And2521.3 would2521.61 any2521.78 information2522.02 be2522.58 provided2522.74 to2523.14 the2523.3 taxpayer2523.54 before2524.82 they2525.14 make2525.38 this2525.61 election2525.78 about2526.49 where2526.74 the2527.06 money2527.22 would2527.54 go?2527.7
2530.49 SPEAKER92530.49 -2530.49 I2530.49 do2530.66 not2530.82 know,2531.06 if2532.82 I'm2533.06 honest.2533.14
2534.02 SPEAKER82534.02 -2534.02 That2534.02 is2534.18 concerning2534.41 to2534.97 me.2535.14 Thank2536.22 you,2536.38 mister2536.54 chair.2536.86
2538.22 SPEAKER22538.22 -2538.22 Great.2538.22 Thank2538.46 you,2538.7 senator.2538.86 And,2539.26 senator2539.66 Keenan?2540.06
2540.62 SPEAKER102540.62 -2540.62 Great.2540.62 Thank2540.86 you,2541.02 mister2541.18 chair.2541.5 Just2541.66 a2541.82 a2542.06 quick2542.22 follow-up.2542.38 So2543.1 the2543.34 fund2543.5 can2543.82 go2544.06 to2544.3 the2544.54 UN2545.02 Youth2545.82 Developed2546.14 Country2546.7 Fund,2547.5 but2548.3 it2548.46 also2548.62 has2548.86 a2549.1 provision2549.18 that2549.58 they2549.74 can2549.9 go2550.06 to2550.3 a2550.38 not2550.46 for2550.7 profit2550.94
2557.07 organization2557.07 would2558.51 be2558.59 able2558.76 to2559.07 be2559.16 funded2559.39 through2559.95 this2560.2 state2560.68 program?2560.99
2562.2 SPEAKER92562.2 -2562.2 The,2562.2 the2564.32 funds2564.4 flow2564.8 to2565.04 the2565.28 United2565.68 Nations2566 least2566.32 development2566.56 least2567.2 developed2567.44 countries2567.76 fund,2568.08 which2568.32 is2568.48 administered2568.64 by2569.04 the2569.28 United2569.44 Nations,2569.68 Global2570.8 Environment2571.12 Fund.2571.52
2573.44 SPEAKER102573.44 -2573.44 It's2573.44 a2573.68 I'm2573.92 looking2574.08 at2574.32 the2574.4 language2574.48 here.2574.8 It2575.04 says2575.12 that2575.44 all2575.68 amounts2576.02 on2576.41 deposit2576.57 shall2576.97 thereafter2577.22 be2577.7 available2577.86 for2578.34 transfer2578.57 to2579.06 a2580.09 UNLDCF2580.57 upon2581.45 request2581.78 by2582.26 a2582.49 UNLDCF2583.06 trustee,2583.7 or2585.61 b2585.93 this2586.82 is2587.06 or2587.22 b,2587.86 not2588.66 for2588.89 profit2589.06 organization2589.45 that2590.02 is2590.18 tax2590.34 exempt2590.57 under2591.02 section2591.26 52591.9 02592.22 12592.38 c2592.54 32592.7 and2593.5 whose2593.66 work2593.9 furthers2594.3 the2594.54 mission2594.7 of2595.02 the2595.1 UN2595.26 LTCF.2595.58 So2596.7 that2596.86 contemplates2597.1 funds2598.14 going2598.54 somewhere2598.78 other2599.42 than2600.14 to2600.22 the2600.62 UN2601.1 LTCF,2601.5 to2602.7 a2602.86 nonprofit,2603.1 provide2603.82 that2604.22 nonprofit's2604.46 mission2605.1 is2605.5 consistent2605.58 with2606.14 the2606.3 UN2606.38 LCTL.2607.64 But2608.03 it2608.28 doesn't2608.36 say2608.76 who2609.64 would2609.88 determine2610.43 what2611.55 nonprofit2611.8 gets2612.59 the2612.91 funding,2613.07 reviews2614.28 the2614.91 funding2615.07 request,2615.95 how2616.59 that2616.84 funding2616.99 request2617.39 would2617.71 come2617.88 in.2617.95 Would2618.11 it2618.28 come2618.43 into2618.59 the2618.91 state,2619.07 to2620.11 the2620.28 treasurer's2620.43 office?2621.47 I'm2622.43 sorry.2622.59 I2622.89 just2622.97 think2623.13 that2623.29 needs2623.53 some2623.77 clarification.2624.01
2626.17 SPEAKER92626.17 -2626.17 Thank2626.17 you.2626.33 We2626.65 will2626.81 provide2626.97 some2627.29 clarification2627.53 on2628.01 that.2628.09
2628.33 SPEAKER102628.33 -2628.33 Thanks.2628.33 Yep.2628.73
2630.57 SPEAKER22630.57 -2630.57 Any2630.57 questions2631.13 from2631.69 any2632.33 of2632.57 the2632.65 other2632.81 committee2632.97 members?2633.37 Okay.2634.57 Alright.2635.13 Thank2635.53 you2635.69 very2635.93 much2636.17 for2636.33 your2636.41 testimony.2636.74
2637.05 SPEAKER52637.05 -2637.05 Thank2637.05 you.2637.14
2639.05 SPEAKER22639.05 -2639.05 And2639.05 I2639.3 do2639.38 see2639.53 we2639.7 have2639.86 representative2640.02 Michelle2640.49 Ciccolo2640.82 here.2641.3 Representative.2641.86
2647.93 SPEAKER72647.93 -2647.93 Thank2647.93 you,2648.18 chairman2648.34 Eldridge2648.66 and2649.05 Chairman2649.39 Mataro2649.63 and2649.87 members2650.11 of2650.35 the2650.51 committee.2650.59 I'm2651.63 here2651.79 to2652.03 testify2652.11 on2652.67 a2652.83 bill2652.91 that2653.07 I2653.31 have2653.39 filed2653.55 along2653.87 with2654.19 my2654.35 predecessor2654.59 for2655.15 many,2655.31 many2655.55 years,2655.79 h2656.27 3,051.2656.67 It's2658.11 an2658.27 act2658.43 relative2658.67 to2659.07 taxes2659.23 due2659.71 upon2659.95 the2660.19 death2660.35 of2660.75 active2661.15 duty2661.47 personnel2661.87 and2662.36 the2662.53 elderly.2662.61 I2663.32 thought2663.49 I2664.13 would2664.28 potentially2664.53 submit2665.01 written2665.32 testimony,2665.57 and2666.05 I2666.2 will2666.36 still2666.45 do2666.68 that.2666.84 But2667.01 I2667.16 wanted2667.24 to2667.36 come2667.49 in2667.72 honor2667.89 of2668.2 the2668.36 late,2668.61 great2668.93 Pat2669.24 Costello,2669.41 who2669.97 championed2670.2 this2670.68 bill2670.84 for2671.32 years2671.57 and2671.89 years2672.05 and2672.36 years.2672.53 She2673.8 was2674.05 an2674.61 award2674.77 winning2675.01 recipient2675.49 of2675.97 the2676.21 Minuteman2676.45 Caine2677.01 in2677.33 my2677.49 community2677.73 and2678.21 beloved2678.53 and,2679.17 quite2679.65 an2679.89 activist.2680.05 And2680.45 this2680.61 was2680.77 an2680.93 important2681.09 bill2681.49 to2681.73 her2681.89 because2682.29 she2682.61 felt2682.77 it2683.01 was2683.09 12683.25 of2683.41 the2683.57 things2683.65 that2683.89 was2683.97 impeding,2684.21 seniors2685.25 from2685.81 actually2686.05 using2686.45 the2686.77 senior2686.93 tax2687.25 deferral2687.49 program.2688.05 What2689.17 the2689.41 bill2689.57 does2689.81 is2690.2 very,2690.51 very2690.84 simple.2691.07 When2692.59 seniors2692.84 choose2693.39 to2693.64 defer2693.8 their2694.11 taxes,2694.2 the2694.68 community2694.84 can2695.47 set2696.03 a,2696.36 interest2697.07 rate2697.39 on2697.64 the2697.8 repayment2697.88 of2698.43 those2698.51 tax2698.84 property2699.16 tax2699.55 bills,2699.88 which2700.91 is2701.24 capped2701.39 at2701.64 8%.2701.8 However,2702.51 after2703.09 they2703.25 pass,2703.57 the,2704.29 interest2705.33 rate2705.65 immediately2705.97 shoots2706.45 up2706.77 to2706.93 16%.2707.09 It's2708.45 the,2709.01 provision2709.65 of2710.13 law2710.29 is2710.61 is2710.93 in2711.17 the2711.41 section2711.49 of2711.97 the2712.29 property2712.53 tax,2713.09 statutes2713.97 that2714.53 really2715.09 were2715.33 meant2715.57 to,2715.89 recapture2716.77 delinquent2717.65 taxpayers.2718.21 But2718.84 it's2719.01 this2719.4 is2719.72 a2719.8 situation2719.96 where2720.44 it's2720.61 not2720.76 a2720.92 delinquent2721.01 tax2721.48 bill.2721.8 It's2722.05 just2722.28 the2722.61 problem2722.76 becomes2723.16 that2723.57 the2723.8 family2723.89 trying2724.92 to2725.24 settle2725.32 the2725.64 estate2725.8 has2726.28 to2726.44 deal2726.61 with2726.76 a2726.92 very2727.01 large2727.32 interest2727.64 payment,2727.96 which2728.28 is2728.44 really2728.61 usury2729.01 and2729.48 inappropriate.2729.72 All2731.24 the2731.4 bill2731.48 does2731.64 is2731.8 ask2732.05 for2732.2 a2732.36 12732.44 year2732.61 deferral2732.76 to2733.24 allow2733.48 that2733.89 senior,2734.13 that2734.98 senior's2735.14 family2735.62 members,2735.94 their2736.34 heirs2736.66 to2737.06 settle2737.38 the,2737.78 the2738.42 debt.2738.74 It2739.54 doesn't2739.62 release2740.66 the2740.98 debt,2741.22 reduce2741.46 it2741.78 in2742.02 any2742.26 way.2742.42 It2742.66 just2742.82 asks2742.98 for2743.22 a2743.46 deferral2743.54 on2743.94 that2744.1 16%2744.26 interest2744.9 rate2745.3 so2745.7 that2745.94 things2746.1 can2746.34 be2746.5 settled.2746.66 I2747.3 recognize2747.38 that2747.86 this2748.02 is2748.26 actually2748.42 part2748.74 of2748.9 a2749.06 much2749.14 larger,2749.38 by2750.18 the2750.42 way,2750.46 this2750.51 also2750.9 applies2751.14 to2751.46 veterans2751.63 who2751.94 use2752.11 the2752.34 property2752.51 tax2752.9 deferral2753.22 program.2753.63 And2754.11 so2754.26 the2754.98 feeling2755.14 is2755.63 that2756.34 seniors2757.94 and2758.26 veterans2758.42 will2758.82 do2759.22 not2759.39 use2759.55 the2759.78 program2759.86 because2760.18 they2760.51 don't2760.66 wanna2760.82 saddle2761.14 their2761.55 their2761.94 kids2762.18 with2762.59 these2762.97 large2763.29 or2763.69 their2763.93 spouses2764.25 with2764.73 these2764.89 large2765.13 interest2765.53 rates2765.85 that2766.09 shoot2766.25 up.2766.49 I2768.17 just2768.41 wanna2768.57 make2768.81 mention2768.97 of2769.29 the2769.37 fact2769.45 that2769.69 last2770.01 session,2770.25 the2770.73 house,2770.89 put2773.21 together2773.45 a2773.85 commission2773.93 in2774.57 a,2774.73 to2776.33 look2776.49 at2776.65 all2776.73 of2776.99 the2777.16 deferral2777.24 programs2777.64 more2778.2 comprehensively,2778.52 and2779.16 that2779.32 makes2779.56 a2779.72 lot2779.88 of2780.04 sense.2780.2 But2780.36 unfortunately,2780.6 it2781.08 didn't2781.24 have2781.47 a2781.64 chance2781.72 to2782.04 go2782.12 forward2782.28 in2782.6 the2782.68 senate.2782.84 So2783.24 it2783.64 that2783.8 was2783.95 h2784.2 42784.43 72784.91 92785.32 1.2785.56 And2785.8 I2786.04 do2786.2 encourage2786.6 and2786.91 recommend2787.16 that2787.56 if2787.72 we2787.88 try2788.04 again2788.36 to2788.6 do2788.76 a2788.91 commission2788.99 to2789.39 look2789.47 at2789.64 all2789.72 the2789.72 many2789.72 different2789.73 opportunities2789.74 for2789.74 deferrals2789.74 that2789.75 help2789.76 make2789.76 staying2789.77 in2789.77 one's2789.78 home2789.78 more2789.79 affordable,2789.79 the2789.8 the2790.12 deferrals2792.52 that2792.76 help2793 make2793.24 staying2793.96 in2794.36 one's2794.44 home2794.68 more2795.08 affordable.2795.32 But2796.12 the2796.36 commission2796.52 also2797 look2797.24 at2797.48 this2797.56 particular2797.8 issue,2798.2 this2798.6 12798.92 small2799.16 thing,2799.4 and2799.72 I2800.12 thank2800.28 the2800.52 committee2800.68 for2801.32 its2801.72 time.2801.96
2803 SPEAKER22803 -2803 Great.2803 Thank2803.24 you2803.48 so2803.64 much,2803.72 representative.2803.96 Are2804.68 there2804.76 any2804.99 questions2805.16 from2805.64 committee2806.11 members?2806.43 Okay.2807.16 Thank2807.47 you2807.8 so2807.95 much.2808.11 Appreciate2808.43 it.2808.76
2811.64 That2811.64 is2811.95 all2812.11 the,2812.36 written2814.03 sign2815.64 ups2815.88 that2816.11 we2816.2 have.2816.36 Does2816.59 anyone2816.76 here2817.07 wish2817.32 to2817.64 testify2817.8 on2818.36 any2818.59 other2818.84 bill2818.99 before2819.23 the2819.55 committee2819.72 today?2820.11 Okay.2822.45 That2822.93 marks2823.17 the2823.41 end2823.49 of2823.65 the2823.73 hearing.2823.89 Thanks2824.13 everybody2824.45 for2824.85 coming,2825.01 and2825.25 thanks2825.33 to2825.65 the2825.81 revenue2825.97 committee2826.37 members2826.53 for2826.85 being2826.93 here.2827.17