REP1.28 FARLEY-BOUVIER1.28 -1.28 Good1.28 afternoon.1.6 It's4.64 a4.72 popular4.8 room5.28 today.5.52 Very6.16 happy6.4 to6.72 have6.8 you7.04 all7.2 here7.36 today.7.6 This8.4 is8.64 a9.44 committee9.44 hearing.9.92 I'm10.32 a10.56 jointist10.72 committee11.2 for11.6 advanced11.84 information12.24 technology,12.56 the13.35 committee13.51 hearing.13.75 I'm13.91 on14.07 the14.07 joint14.43 committee14.79 for15.14 the15.51 advanced15.53 information15.55 technology,15.58 the15.6 Internet,15.63 and15.65 cybersecurity.15.67 There15.7 are15.72 215.75 other15.99 hearings16.23 happening16.55 at17.02 the17.11 same17.19 time.17.43 So17.59 if17.75 this17.82 is18.07 not18.23 the18.39 right18.55 hearing,18.7 I19.35 invite19.51 you19.75 to19.91 vote20.07 on21.43 primary21.43 hearings21.82 to22.14 be22.23 at.22.55 We're23.82 delighted24.07 to24.46 have24.55 our24.79 first24.95 hearing25.28 of25.48 the25.68 committee.25.84 I'm26.72 always27.04 happy27.36 to27.76 be27.84 working28 with28.32 my28.56 senate28.88 co-chair,30 Senator30.48 Michael30.48 Moore,30.8 and31.84 to32.4 welcome32.64 the33.36 people33.44 who33.76 are33.92 in34 this34.16 room.34.4 And35.2 we35.44 do35.68 have35.92 a36.16 number36.24 of36.56 people36.72 who37.12 are37.52 participating38.32 virtually.39.12 We40.16 are40.32 proud40.63 in40.78 the40.91 Massachusetts41.02 legislature41.66 that42.3 we42.55 have42.78 packed43.02 the43.34 ability43.5 to44.38 testify45.27 virtually46.06 as46.78 a46.95 permanent47.02 rule49.1 of49.74 our49.91 committees.50.14 I50.95 think51.1 that51.34 is51.59 really51.82 good52.14 government,52.38 and52.78 I'm53.02 gonna53.18 just53.51 say53.67 personally,54.39 it54.71 is54.87 very55.11 good55.43 for55.83 my55.99 constituents,56.31 in57.83 the57.99 Berkshires.58.15 I'm59.51 gonna59.67 start59.91 by60.23 welcoming61.67 my62.47 House62.47 colleagues,62.87 and63.35 then63.59 the63.99 Senator64.15 will64.63 welcome64.95 his65.43 Senate65.67 colleagues.65.99 We67.03 have67.27 here67.51 Vice67.91 Chair68.31 Jim69.42 Hawkins.69.73 Thanks70.22 for70.45 being70.69 here.71.02 Tom72.06 Coakley72.38 is74.22 here.74.38 Orlando76.06 Ramos,76.61 not77.97 quite78.22 here78.53 yet.78.69 Tommy79.09 Vitolo79.49 is80.22 here.80.38 Steve81.41 Owens,81.81 Steve82.61 Bolett,83.13 Joe83.61 Moschino,84.01 Mark86.09 Lombardi,86.41 and87.05 Sean87.29 Ghesqui88.17 are,88.81 are89.53 our89.61 members.90.33
90.73 I'd90.73 also90.97 like91.29 to91.45 take91.85 a92.09 moment92.17 to93.29 thank93.53 my94.25 staff,94.49 researcher96.02 Claire96.98 Roman,97.22 and98.1 counselor98.66 David98.66 Herbstich.99.06 My100.5 chief101.3 of101.63 staff101.78 is102.1 here102.34 helping102.83 with103.22 sign-ups,103.7 and104.02 my104.34 legislative104.66 aide,105.38 district106.34 aide106.66 are106.98 helping107.47 us107.93 with108.17 online108.49 work.108.97 So109.29 to109.77 put109.93 a110.09 carry110.17 on110.49 this110.57 together110.81 is111.29 a111.53 great111.69 deal111.85 of112.17 work112.33 and112.57 we112.73 could112.89 possibly113.61 do114.09 it114.33 without114.41 the114.81 staff.114.89 And115.69 for115.85 all116.01 of116.33 you116.57 who116.81 are117.05 testifying,117.21 if117.77 you118.01 need118.17 more118.41 information118.65 or120.57 wanna120.89 give121.21 us121.37 further121.53 information123.58 or124.3 feedback124.45 on124.86 this125.02 bill,125.33 please125.58 reach125.9 out126.06 to126.3 the126.45 staff.126.53 You128.29 may128.53 know130.38 that130.62 I130.85 do130.94 have131.18 some131.34 strong131.5 opinions131.9 about132.46 this132.78 topic.133.01 In134.29 today's134.46 increasingly134.94 connected135.57 world,136.14 our137.34 personal138.85 information139.17 has139.65 become139.89 a140.61 valuable140.93 commodity.142.05 In143.09 other143.25 words,143.49 people143.89 are144.29 buying144.61 and145.09 selling145.41 our145.81 personal146.05 data.146.45 And147.25 we147.65 are147.89 constantly148.13 generating149.09 data149.65 through150.21 our150.37 online150.61 activities,151.58 whether152.3 that's152.53 purchases,153.01 health154.53 decisions,155.09 or156.38 even156.62 our156.94 physical157.18 movements.157.66 This158.78 data159.09 tells159.74 a160.14 story160.3 about160.78 us.161.09 Our162.14 beliefs,162.38 our163.25 health163.7 conditions,163.78 our164.74 financial164.9 status,165.62 and166.58 our166.82 most167.06 private167.62 decisions.168.18
168.98 All168.98 of169.3 that169.38 is169.54 at169.7 the169.94 time.170.02 Particularly171.54 sensitive172.34 information,172.98 like174.02 our174.34 health174.5 data,174.82 our175.54 precise175.78 location,176.42 our177.38 financial177.54 details,178.26 and179.07 our179.39 children's179.47 information,180.67 deserve181.88 heightened182.59 protection.183.24 No184.44 company184.75 should185.39 be185.63 able185.88 to186.44 buy186.67 and187.07 sell187.31 that187.63 data.187.96 I189.56 believe189.79 that190.19 it's190.35 been190.51 way190.83 too191 long191.31 that192.11 the192.44 burden192.67 to193.16 protect193.31 our193.72 data193.88 has194.19 fallen194.7 on194.94 the195.18 individual195.42 as197.1 opposed197.34 to197.9 the,198.06 of199.18 that199.34 burden199.58 all200.38 on200.78 the201.1 industry201.34 that's201.74 collecting202.06 that203.18 data.203.34 So204.62 it's204.78 not205.1 just205.34 about205.58 individual205.82 protection,206.38 but215.38 we215.38 need220.25 to220.74 have220.74 the220.74 process220.74 that221.14 we're221.29 going221.53 to221.78 do221.86 here222.01 as,222.85 is223.57 customary,224.53 in225.49 the225.57 legislature.225.81 We227.01 take227.25 our228.61 colleagues228.93 who229.33 are229.49 the229.65 lead229.89 sponsors230.21 first.230.77 You're231.17 gonna231.41 be231.73 seeing231.89 that.232.13 We233.25 will233.49 then233.65 be233.89 going234.05 back234.29 and234.72 forth234.88 with235.28 people235.51 who235.83 have236 signed236.31 up236.56 to236.72 be236.79 here236.95 in237.19 person237.28 and237.59 people237.83 who238.07 are238.31 signed238.47 up.238.72 You're239.59 gonna239.75 see240 that240.16 throughout240.47 the240.72 year.240.88 And241.75 I'm242.16 going242.39 to242.63 ask242.79 for243.28 a243.51 little243.59 extra244.07 patience244.79 from245.28 all245.51 of245.75 you.245.83 You're246.07 gonna246.31 see246.56 a246.72 lot246.79 of247.03 activity247.19 here.247.75 The248.76 house248.92 is249.24 in249.48 session249.72 today.250.52 And250.92 so251.16 house251.4 members,251.72 whether252.28 they252.68 are252.84 here252.92 to253.08 testify253.32 or253.96 they254.2 are254.36 on254.52 the254.68 committee,254.76 are255.32 need255.48 to255.72 be255.88 I256.36 think256.44 it's256.6 out257.32 of257.72 the259.16 hearing.259.32 And260.42 I260.65 also260.9 wanna261.38 say261.62 a261.78 special261.94 welcome.262.42 There263.54 are263.77 some263.94 first264.18 years265.38 in266.34 attendance266.42 here266.9 today,267.06 and267.69 this267.94 is268.18 their268.34 first268.5 year268.74 for269.38 some269.62 of269.86 them.269.94 And270.5 so270.74 that's271.06 pretty271.38 cool.271.62 So,271.86 members,272.75 if273.07 you273.23 do273.39 have273.63 to273.71 go273.87 up274.03 to274.19 vote,274.27 you'll274.91 be275.15 notified275.55 here276.03 in276.19 the276.35 steering276.43 room.276.83 Thanks277.87 to278.19 the278.27 court278.43 officer278.67 who279.15 takes279.31 such279.55 good279.79 care279.95 of280.19 us.280.27 But281.23 do281.79 come281.95 back.282.19 Do284.11 come284.35 back.284.51 There's284.75 a285.07 lot285.15 of285.31 really285.47 important,288.25 So,288.25 I289.44 am289.85 going290.17 to290.49 start290.73 by291.29 calling,291.52 our,292.49 first293.44 legislator's293.85 up.294.4
296.4 SPEAKER4296.4 -296.4 Oh,296.4 that's296.65 right.296.81
299.78 SEN299.78 MOORE299.78 -299.78 She299.78 enjoys300.42 working300.82 with301.14 you301.38 so301.54 much.301.86 Thank304.34 you,304.58 representative.304.82 I307.22 first307.46 wanna307.62 thank307.94 everyone308.58 for309.06 being309.3 here309.54 today.309.78 And310.26 as310.58 the311.06 representative311.22 said,312.1 you312.26 know,312.34 we've312.5 got312.74 a312.9 lot312.98 going313.22 on,313.46 and313.62 we've314 got314.24 2314.71 other314.88 hearings315.19 going315.6 on.315.92 So316.48 we316.79 have317.04 some317.35 Senate317.6 colleagues317.92 who318.31 are318.4 on318.48 this318.63 committee318.79 that,319.19 not319.92 with320.24 us.320.39 But320.63 I320.79 do320.95 wanna321.12 rep321.44 just321.68 read322.31 out322.63 who322.88 is323.12 on323.27 the323.44 committee323.6 with324.07 us.324.24 As325.12 the325.27 vice325.35 chair325.68 from325.92 the326.07 senate,326.15 we326.4 have326.56 Senator326.72 Peano,327.04 we328 have328.16 Senator328.4 Feingold,329.44 we330.24 have330.48 Senator330.64 Barrett,331.04 Senator331.6 Mark,332.16 and332.48 Senator332.72 Durant.333.52 Yeah.337.68 As337.92 we338.16 start338.24 the338.48 hearing,338.56 I338.8 just338.88 wanna339.04 follow340.44 my340.69 coach341.08 here341.4 as341.64 lead341.72 and342.13 let343 you343.16 know343.32 where343.56 I'm343.72 coming343.81 from344.13 as344.44 we344.6 look344.76 at345 the345.08 legislation345.25 today346.2 and346.76 going346.85 forward.347.16 Almost349.4 a349.64 week349.72 almost350.13 weekly,350.44 we351.16 read351.32 about351.56 data351.81 breaches352.2 that353.01 compromise353.17 the353.73 data353.89 of354.21 our354.29 constituents.354.53 These356.45 breaches356.69 are357.65 made357.81 worse358.05 by358.45 the358.61 fact358.69 that359.01 companies359.17 gather360.05 larger360.45 and360.77 larger360.93 amounts361.33 of361.89 data361.97 on362.37 us.362.53 We363.81 are364.05 told364.21 that364.45 self-regulation365.12 works,365.92 only367.19 to367.6 read367.75 the368.24 next368.39 week368.63 that368.88 a369.12 company369.19 suffered369.75 a370.07 massive370.24 data370.71 breach.371.04 We372.48 get372.63 told372.88 by373.19 companies373.36 not374.56 to374.88 limit374.88 the375.19 collection375.36 and375.75 sale375.92 of376.24 location376.39 data,376.88 only377.92 to379.04 read379.19 that380.41 the380.73 FTC380.97 found382.09 that382.33 a382.57 location382.89 data383.53 broker383.77 unfairly384.25 collected384.81 sensitive385.21 data,385.69 and386.41 then386.73 read387.85 that388.17 the388.81 same388.97 broker389.53 got390.17 hacked390.33 by390.65 a390.81 Russian390.97 cyber391.53 criminal392.25 with393.2 huge393.6 amount393.93 huge394.49 amounts394.88 of395.37 personal395.6 data396.08 leaked.396.56
398.08 We398.08 have398.16 also398.4 seen398.73 breaches398.96 in399.37 health399.6 care,399.85 federal,400.64 state,401.2 and401.44 municipal401.6 government,402.16 schools,404 and405.13 finance.405.13 These406.72 are406.96 just407.04 some407.42 examples407.66 of408.18 reality408.7 that409.18 we409.42 all409.58 know.409.82 In410.7 my410.78 opinion,410.94 self-regulation411.58 does412.14 not412.3 work,412.46 but413.18 it413.42 has413.5 to413.74 be413.82 a413.98 balance.414.14 You415.42 know,415.58 we415.74 have415.9 to416.06 work416.22 with416.54 our417.1 stakeholders417.34 to417.98 try418.14 to418.38 find418.46 that418.7 balance.418.86 It's419.26 that's419.66 not419.98 going420.22 to420.38 stifle420.62 innovation,421.1 stifle421.57 the422.13 economy,422.38 but423.1 provide424.45 the424.85 protections425.01 that425.97 our426.13 constituents426.38 in426.94 Massachusetts427.1 actually427.89 need.428.29 All430.29 of430.54 this430.69 is432.13 made432.38 worse432.69 by433.33 the433.5 actions433.9 of434.22 the434.46 federal434.62 government434.94 that436.62 have436.86 deployed437.1 the437.58 data437.74 of437.98 Americans438.22 who438.86 further439.02 what440.46 some440.7 of440.86 us441.02 feel441.1 is441.34 are441.34 unlawful441.5 and442.14 unconstitutional443.34 agenda.444.22 For445.58 example,445.74 we446.3 have446.46 just446.7 seen446.94 a447.26 deal447.5 reached447.82 between448.3 the449.1 IRS449.69 and450.81 ICE451.21 for452.01 immigration452.25 enforcement452.81 that453.38 likely453.46 violates453.86 federal454.33 policy454.65 law455.13 excuse455.86 me,456.18 federal456.33 privacy456.81 law.457.3 Also,458.57 in459.06 their459.21 efforts459.54 to460.1 appease461.06 the461.54 president,461.69 I'm462.65 also462.89 very463.21 disturbed463.46 for479.06 San479.29 Francisco479.54 Pride.480.01 A481.29 tech481.62 CEO481.94 has482.65 gone482.89 on483.29 a483.62 certain483.85 podcast484.25 to484.81 state484.98 that485.54 companies485.85 need486.33 to486.57 bring486.65 masculine486.98 aggression487.62 back488.18 and488.81 stated489.13 that489.62 he489.77 believes489.94 the490.33 workplace490.5 has490.98 become,491.13 quote,491.54 neutered.491.54
491.54 We493.06 all493.21 know493.38 what493.54 he493.69 meant.493.85 It495.03 is495.19 no495.43 surprise495.67 to496.07 hear496.23 President496.71 Trump497.03 declare497.35 that497.75 every497.99 tech498.31 CEO499.35 wants499.67 to500.07 be500.23 his500.39 friend.500.63 We502.55 have502.79 also502.95 seen503.35 data503.99 that504.95 can505.11 be505.35 weaponized,505.51 for506.31 example,506.55 to507.27 undermine507.51 women's508.23 health508.79 and509.11 their509.35 access509.67 to510.15 reproductive510.31 health511.04 care.511.19 Congress512.55 should513.12 act513.43 to513.67 protect513.75 our514.15 residents,514.32 but514.88 we515.04 know515.2 they515.43 will515.6 not.515.75 I517.12 cannot517.27 support517.6 any517.92 legislation518.08 that519.27 leaves519.51 our520 privacy520.24 to521.2 companies521.36 with522.08 policies522.24 when523.41 these523.65 companies523.89 abandon524.77 their525.33 principles525.57 and526.29 policies526.53 to527.49 appease527.65 the528.69 current528.85 president529.17 and529.73 Elon530.05 Musk.530.37 The531.89 legislature532.13 must533.01 act533.25 to533.49 establish533.65 real534.21 data534.61 protections534.93 that535.81 address536.05 these536.53 issues536.77 and537.27 protect537.43 our537.8 constituents538.15 because539.27 it539.67 is539.84 clear540.08 that540.48 the540.79 status540.79 quo541.27 cannot542.24 and542.96 will543.12 not543.27 work.543.51 Before544.55 turning544.88 to,545.2 before546.39 turning546.79 to547.12 my547.2 back547.43 to547.6 my547.75 house547.84 chair,548.08 I548.24 also548.39 wanna548.63 thank551.07 Vice552.03 Chairman552.03 Payano.552.03 We552.03 have552.19 the552.43 data.552.59 It552.99 should553.15 be553.31 the,553.47 Shield554.19 Act554.99 Shield555.39 Location555.63 Act556.03 that556.43 was556.67 originally556.91 sent557.47 to557.71 another557.87 committee.558.27 It's558.75 consumer559.71 consumer560.35 protection,560.83 Leisinger.561.39 And561.95 with576.53 us576.69 and576.85 make576.93 sure577.17 we're577.33 trying577.41 to577.65 get577.73 to577.89 the577.97 time578.13 limits578.37 that578.69 we578.77 can578.93 establish.579.09 But579.89 other580.05 than580.21 that,580.29 let's580.69 hope580.85 we581.09 have581.25 a581.33 successful581.49 session581.97 and,582.21 you582.37 know,582.45 we'll582.69 be582.93 here583.09 to583.33 vote.583.81 So583.97 thank584.21 you.584.37 Thank585.41 you,585.65 Senator.585.81
FARLEY-BOUVIER587.01 -587.01 I'm587.01 going587.25 to587.73 call587.97 up588.29 our588.45 first588.61 panelist,589.01 which589.65 is589.89 my590.53 colleague590.69 David591.27 Rivera,591.6 and592.15 Myra.593.67 As594.24 they're594.48 getting594.63 settled,594.96 our597.04 announcement,597.12 the598.24 first598.24 announcement,598.48 is598.96 to599.12 say599.27 that599.43 we599.91 are600.15 not600.39 taking600.72 today's601.6 testimony.602.08
625.32 UNIDENTIFIED625.32 SPEAKER625.32 1625.32 -625.32 H625.32 86625.32 -625.32 Alright.625.32 Thank625.63 you625.88 so625.96 much,626.12 Chairs626.36 Farley-Bouvier627.15 and627.63 more627.88 and628.12 members628.27 of628.6 the628.75 committee,628.84 for629.63 the629.8 opportunity629.88 to630.36 come630.43 before630.6 you630.92 today.631.08 I'm631.32 here631.48 to631.63 speak631.8 in631.96 strong632.2 support632.44 of632.76 H633 86633.32 and634.36 act634.52 to634.76 protect634.84 location635.16 privacy635.64 with636.12 my636.28 co-file636.6 representative,636.84 David637.4 Viera,637.72 and638.04 I'm638.2 really638.28 thrilled638.6 to638.92 have639 this639.16 partnership639.4 this639.96 session.640.12 Frequently,641 like641.64 you,641.88 I'm642.04 mindful642.2 that642.52 our642.68 federal642.84 and643.16 state643.4 laws643.64 have644.04 not644.2 kept644.44 pace644.6 with644.84 the645 rapid645.08 development645.64 of646.12 digital646.28 technology.646.68 So647.77 I'm647.93 very648.18 proud648.25 to648.65 have648.74 refiled648.89 the649.3 location649.46 shield649.86 at650.18 this650.34 session650.5 to650.89 update651.06 our651.38 statutory651.54 framework652.18 to653.62 ensure653.86 that654.25 we654.42 are654.58 reflecting654.74 the655.13 digital655.3 nature655.7 of656.01 our656.18 lives.656.34 I656.89 was657.06 thrilled657.3 to657.7 see657.77 this657.93 bill658.18 receive658.5 much658.89 legislative659.22 and659.77 external659.93 support660.42 last660.85 session.661.17 The661.57 House661.81 unanimously662.05 voted662.93 in663.33 favor663.49 of664.13 a664.21 narrower664.45 version664.93 of665.25 it,665.41 and665.81 we666.05 have666.13 seen666.29 that666.53 support666.77 continue667.09 to667.73 grow667.89 and668.21 be668.29 increasingly668.53 bipartisan669.09 this669.97 session670.13 as670.53 well,670.69 supported671.25 by671.73 our671.89 legislative672.05 colleagues672.53 with672.85 more673.09 than673.25 90673.41 cosponsorships.673.81 Given675.32 the675.55 current675.88 efforts676.2 of676.51 the676.68 federal676.75 administration677.15 and677.72 other677.88 states,678.2 this678.51 legislation678.75 is679.39 critical679.55 for680.36 ensuring680.6 that680.92 we681.08 continue681.24 to681.63 protect681.8 the682.27 autonomy682.51 and683.08 privacy683.32 of683.8 those683.96 in684.27 the684.43 commonwealth.684.6
685.72 Every685.72 day,685.96 we're686.2 making686.43 decisions,686.75 engaging687.32 in687.72 commerce687.96 and688.27 leisure,688.43 and688.92 communicating689.15 across689.87 digital690.19 platforms.690.59 If691.47 each691.71 of691.87 us692.03 is692.19 to692.35 continue692.51 to692.91 be692.99 the693.23 protagonist693.39 of694.19 our694.43 1694.67 life,694.91 we695.31 must695.47 ensure695.79 that696.27 our696.43 laws696.67 assert697.07 and697.31 protect697.55 the697.95 right698.11 to698.35 individual698.59 privacy699.07 so699.87 that700.03 we700.27 can700.35 continue700.51 to700.91 write701.07 our701.31 narratives701.47 with701.87 autonomy.702.11 In703.12 the703.19 20703.43 first703.51 century,703.91 that704.24 means704.48 our704.71 laws704.95 must705.36 establish705.75 guardrails706.24 and706.71 protections706.88 on707.43 the707.6 digital707.75 data708.15 we708.39 create708.63 so709.27 that709.51 corporate709.75 interests710.15 do710.63 not710.79 collect711.03 and711.36 monetize711.6 it712 in712.24 ways712.39 that712.63 impede712.88 our713.43 agency.713.67 The714.63 location714.88 shield715.27 act715.6 takes715.75 a716 critical716.07 step716.48 in716.79 addressing716.95 this717.36 paradigm.717.6 If718.38 enacted,718.62 Massachusetts718.78 would719.82 lead719.98 the720.22 nation720.38 in720.78 ensuring720.78 that721.26 individuals'721.5 location722.14 data722.62 cannot722.94 be723.26 collected723.5 and723.98 sold.724.3 You725.02 can725.18 still725.42 use725.66 your725.9 cell726.06 phone726.22 to726.46 route726.62 your726.86 next727.02 car727.26 trip.727.58 You728.06 can728.14 still728.3 check728.54 the728.78 weather728.94 forecast,729.26 but730.06 vendors730.3 and730.7 third-party731.02 interests731.34 cannot731.74 sell732.22 your732.38 personal732.7 device733.1 location733.42 information733.9 to734.51 the734.75 highest734.83 bidder.735.32 This736.2 legislature736.43 in737 a737.15 bipartisan737.32 response738.03 spring738.6 into738.83 action739.07 in739.39 the739.48 wake739.55 of739.79 the739.88 Dobbs740.03 decision740.36 almost740.91 3741.32 years741.55 ago741.79 now742.03 to742.6 reaffirm742.83 the743.79 right743.88 to744.12 abortion744.2 in744.6 Massachusetts744.75 and745.39 to745.63 shield745.79 our746.12 medical746.27 providers746.67 and747.15 their747.32 patients747.48 from747.51 regressive747.54 lawsuits747.57 originating747.6 in747.63 other747.66 states,747.69 including747.72 those747.75 that747.78 have747.81 enacted747.84 vigilante747.88 justice749.07 originating749.59 in749.83 other749.91 states,750.15 including750.95 those751.27 that751.59 have751.75 enacted751.91 vigilante752.39 justice753.03 regimes753.43 that753.75 encourage753.99 persons754.39 to754.79 track754.95 and755.19 bring755.27 to755.51 prosecution755.67 women756.71 and757.03 their757.27 providers.757.43
759.19 The759.19 location759.35 shield759.83 act760.07 is760.23 critical760.39 for760.79 ensuring760.95 that761.43 our761.67 reproductive761.83 justice762.39 law762.87 actually763.03 has763.35 meaning763.59 in763.99 a764.15 world764.23 where764.84 there765 currently765.15 is765.48 no765.72 prohibition765.96 on766.51 using766.68 a766.92 woman's767 location767.39 data767.8 to768.12 determine768.27 the768.6 medical768.75 care769.08 she769.39 is769.55 receiving.769.72 Just770.68 last771 year,771.15 a771.55 federal771.63 investigation772.04 revealed772.75 that773.15 a773.39 data773.48 brokerage773.72 company774.27 tracked775 people's775.32 interstate775.72 visits776.2 using776.6 cell776.84 phone777.15 location777.32 data777.8 to778.36 planned778.51 parenthood778.84 locations779.39 across779.8 48780.2 states,780.89 including781.21 right781.53 here781.77 in782.01 Massachusetts,782.09 and783.05 then783.29 provided783.45 that783.93 data784.09 to784.49 1784.65 of784.81 the784.89 largest785.05 anti785.53 abortion785.85 campaigns786.41 in786.89 the786.97 nation.787.05 The788.17 location788.33 shield788.81 act789.13 further789.53 holds789.85 importance790.09 for790.49 members790.65 of791.05 groups791.21 that791.77 are792.01 disproportionately792.17 vulnerable792.81 to793.21 danger793.29 and793.61 living793.77 their794.01 authentic794.25 lives.794.73 Those795.13 seeking795.28 gender795.68 affirming796 care,796.57 religious797.2 minorities797.76 attending798.25 services798.8 in799.28 mosques799.52 and799.85 synagogues,800 our800.96 judges801.13 and801.52 public801.68 safety802.08 officials,802.4 and802.88 domestic803.04 violence803.52 survivors,803.92 to804.33 name804.4 several.804.73 You805.52 will805.68 hear805.76 from806 many806.16 data806.4 privacy806.73 experts807.13 and807.45 advocates807.61 today,808 and808.25 I808.49 am808.57 very808.73 grateful808.96 for809.36 their809.52 support809.68 and810.08 collaboration810.32 on810.8 this810.96 bill.811.12 I811.76 would811.92 be812.08 pleased812.24 to812.56 work812.64 with812.8 this812.96 committee813.2 as813.6 it813.76 reviews813.92 the814.24 location814.24 shield814.64 act815.04 and815.28 request815.68 that816.08 you816.16 provide816.32 it816.64 with816.8 a816.88 favorable817.04 review.817.44 Thank817.92 you.818.16
REP821.86 VIEIRA821.86 -821.86 Thank821.86 you,822.1 Chair822.89 Farley823.21 Bavier823.53 and824.01 Chair824.25 Moore.824.5 We825.38 just825.53 heard825.86 from826.5 my826.82 colleague827.45 here827.86 of828.25 some828.65 specific828.98 instances829.53 where830.25 this830.5 location830.65 shield831.13 act831.62 is832.01 important.832.17 But833.97 as834.13 I834.29 said834.37 on834.69 the834.77 day834.93 that835.09 we835.17 had835.33 the835.57 unanimous835.65 vote836.21 in836.45 the836.61 house837.09 in837.73 the837.97 last838.13 session,838.37 privacy839.89 is841.25 a841.41 fundamental841.65 human842.85 right,843.25 and844.85 that845.09 human845.33 right845.73 underpins846.2 our847.16 freedom847.4 of847.88 association,848.2 thought,850.13 expression,851.64 as853.25 well853.49 as853.8 freedom853.96 from854.45 discrimination.854.76 The857.08 location857.25 shield857.8 act858.04 that858.2 we're858.28 talking858.52 about858.76 now859.08 is859.8 a859.96 necessary860.2 safeguard860.92 of862.79 our862.87 right863.11 to863.35 privacy,863.59 and864.79 it's864.95 a865.19 fundamental865.35 value866.07 that867.51 we867.59 proved867.91 in868.31 the868.47 house868.63 in869.11 a869.27 limited869.43 situation870.23 around872.07 abortion872.55 and874.15 access874.39 to875.11 transgender875.35 health.876.15 So877.35 you877.42 can877.5 imagine877.66 that878.07 that878.3 issue878.47 itself878.79 divides879.35 some879.9 of880.14 our880.3 colleagues.880.47 But881.83 because882.23 this882.79 was883.02 a883.35 first883.59 step883.99 in885.5 that885.75 limited885.99 situation,886.95 Republicans888.63 and889.18 Democrats889.42 came890.14 together890.38 without891.67 regard892.23 for893.27 political893.51 ideology.894.15 I'm895.75 hopeful895.91 that896.31 this896.55 committee896.79 will897.67 not897.91 only898.07 report898.39 this898.71 out898.95 but899.91 also900.15 report900.15 the900.55 language900.71 of901.91 the902.07 protections902.23 of902.87 location903.03 shield903.59 along904.63 with905.03 comprehensive905.43 privacy,906.98 which907.93 we908.17 all,908.41 again,908.74 have909.53 a909.77 fundamental909.93 human910.82 right911.13 to.911.45 A913.53 couple913.69 of913.69 years913.86 ago,914.1 many914.33 of914.5 us914.65 went914.74 throughout914.98 our915.21 districts,915.45 and915.77 we916.01 spoke916.25 about917.77 the918.01 anniversary918.17 of918.74 the918.89 United920.02 Nations920.26 human921.7 rights922.02 declaration.922.42 In924.58 1948,924.82 the925.7 former925.86 first926.18 lady926.42 of927.7 the927.78 United927.94 States,928.18 Eleanor928.5 Roosevelt,930.82 who931.94 chaired932.26 the932.58 committee,932.74 ingrained934.67 in935.07 article935.38 12,935.79 the936.99 human937.23 right937.63 to938.59 privacy.938.75 And940.18 so,940.35 as940.59 I940.83 told940.9 my941.23 colleagues941.38 on941.87 the941.95 floor942.11 in942.42 the942.67 last942.83 session,943.07 this943.87 is944.18 the944.26 first944.42 step.944.67 Let's945.63 all946.02 be946.35 together946.5 in947.9 this.948.06 But948.22 let's948.46 come948.78 back949.02 in950.06 the950.3 next950.46 session950.7 and951.66 work951.9 with952.14 our952.3 Senate952.46 colleagues952.86 and953.82 work954.06 on954.7 a954.94 more955.02 comprehensive955.34 location957.1 protection.957.98 And959.1 so,959.26 together,959.58 we960.93 can961.1 all961.34 add961.65 these961.89 protections962.22 to962.7 state962.93 law963.1 and964.13 honor964.38 our965.01 commitment965.34 to966.29 human966.53 rights.966.86
980.96 MOORE980.96 -980.96 I980.96 just981.12 want981.28 to981.44 announce981.52 that981.84 Senator982.64 Payano,983.2 the983.2 vice983.36 chair983.52 of983.68 the983.76 committee,983.84 has984.24 just984.32 arrived.984.56
987.22 FARLEY-BOUVIER987.22 -987.22 To987.22 say987.38 we987.7 were988.01 bringing988.17 up,988.42 senator988.89 Crane,989.29 and,989.86 actually,990.01 it's990.25 coming990.34 up.990.65 I990.74 did990.89 neglect991.13 to991.38 say991.77 before992.17 that992.5 we992.74 are993.13 asking993.38 for993.62 a993.93 3994.01 limit994.25 3994.74 minute995.05 time995.46 limit.995.7 We996.25 can996.42 meet996.58 it996.82 at996.98 10:00997.13 on998.42 the998.58 screen998.74 to1000.1 help1000.25 you1000.5 out1000.65 with1000.89 that.1001.05 So1002.42 we1002.58 just1002.74 wanted1023.17 to1023.17 let1023.17 you1023.17 know1023.17 and1023.17 then1023.17 my1023.17 staff1023.17 would1023.17 be,1023.17 if1023.17 I1023.17 did1023.17 it.1023.17 Testimony1023.17 is1023.17 very1023.17 welcome
1023.17 SEN1023.17 CREEM1023.17 -1023.17 SB1023.17 1971023.17 -1023.17 Thank1023.17 you.1023.33 And1023.49 I1023.73 hope1023.88 to1024.05 abide1024.37 by1024.68 the1024.85 3-minute1025.33 rule.1025.64 So1026.53 I1027.48 wanna1027.64 thank1028.05 you,1028.29 Chair1028.68 Moore1029.01 and1029.4 Chair1031.22 Fraley-Bouvier,1031.7 for1031.7 taking1031.86 me1032.18 out1032.34 of1032.58 turn1032.74 on1033.54 and1033.7 really1034.5 your1034.9 ongoing,1035.22 both1035.94 of1036.18 you,1036.26 your1036.5 ongoing1036.74 support1037.3 of1038.02 advancing1038.26 meaningful1038.9 data1039.46 privacy1039.78 reforms1040.42 in1040.9 Massachusetts.1041.14 And1042.34 in1042.5 the1042.66 last1042.74 session,1044.01 I1044.16 know1044.33 that1044.57 I1044.72 worked1044.8 with1045.68 Senator1046.24 Moore,1046.24 who1047.28 was1047.61 with1047.92 me1048.72 all1049.04 the1049.28 way1049.37 on1049.68 this.1049.85 So,1050.09 thank1050.33 you1050.57 both1050.8 for1051.13 all1051.37 your1051.61 input.1051.77 So,1052.72 I'm1053.04 speaking1053.28 today1053.77 in1054.09 support1054.33 of1054.72 my1054.88 bill,1055.13 Senate1056.24 197,1057.51 an1057.51 act1057.75 to1057.99 protect1058.15 safety1058.63 and1059.03 privacy1059.35 by1060.31 stopping1060.63 the1061.03 sale1061.19 of1061.51 location1061.75 data,1062.39 and1063.11 Senate1063.51 29,1063.99 an1064.63 act1064.87 to1065.19 establish1065.67 the1066.23 Massachusetts1066.47 Data1067.19 Privacy1067.51 Act.1068.07 Senate1069.11 Bill1070.55 1971071.71 would1071.71 ban1071.95 the1072.27 sale1072.36 of1072.67 location1072.91 data1073.47 in1073.88 Massachusetts.1074.12 Our1075.63 location1075.88 data1076.51 is1076.99 constantly1077.23 being1077.88 collected1078.19 by1079.23 apps1079.47 on1079.88 our1080.12 phones1080.27 and1080.91 used1081.15 to1081.47 track1082.19 our1082.67 movement,1082.91 our1083.47 identity,1083.71 and1084.6 where1084.6 we1084.84 spend1085.08 time.1085.91 Many1085.99 people1086.39 don't1086.79 even1087.11 realize1087.35 that1087.83 their1088.07 app1088.31 is1088.55 doing1088.71 that.1089.03 And1089.59 in1089.75 this1089.99 critical1090.31 moment,1090.79 and1091.35 believe1091.83 me,1092.23 it's1092.55 a1092.95 very1092.95 critical1093.27 moment,1093.75 as1094.95 we1095.19 actively1095.51 explore1096.15 how1096.71 Massachusetts1096.87 can1097.75 act1097.99 at1098.47 the1098.63 state1098.87 level1099.19 to1099.59 protect1099.83 our1100.55 residents1100.79 in1101.62 this1101.78 current1102.1 political1102.58 climate.1103.13
1104.02 Shielding1104.02 our1104.65 location1104.97 data1105.69 needs1106.17 to1106.58 rise1106.82 to1107.21 the1107.38 top1107.54 of1107.86 that1108.02 list.1108.26 It1108.97 needs1109.13 to1109.45 be1109.62 number1109.86 1.1110.17 Our1111.78 location1112.02 data1112.58 reveals1112.89 some1113.38 of1113.62 the1113.69 most1113.86 sensitive1114.1 details1114.65 about1115.21 us.1115.45 This1116.17 personal1116.66 information1117.06 can1117.7 provide1117.94 insight1118.42 into1119.22 our1119.54 health1119.78 care1120.1 providers,1120.42 religious1121.38 affiliation,1122.02 and1122.98 even1123.3 our1123.54 sexual1123.78 orientation.1124.34 And1125.46 I1125.62 wanna1125.78 say1126.18 that1126.42 I1126.66 agree1126.82 with1127.06 the1127.22 previous1127.38 speaker1127.78 who1128.18 said,1128.42 let1128.98 this1129.22 be1129.54 a1129.78 comprehensive1130.47 bill.1131.19 In1132.08 a1132.32 time1132.47 of1132.88 rising1133.91 antisemitism,1134.39 I1135.91 don't1136.08 want1136.32 my1136.55 data1136.8 to1137.12 be1137.36 used1137.43 either.1137.76 So1138.47 it's1138.8 very1139.12 broad1139.52 here.1139.91 Alarmingly,1141.36 under1142.15 current1142.47 state1142.95 and1143.52 federal1143.76 law,1144.63 privacy1145.04 data1145.67 brokers1146.25 are1146.89 able1147.05 to1147.29 purchase1147.53 this1147.93 highly1148.17 sensitive1148.57 information1149.21 from1150.17 cell1150.41 phone1150.73 apps1150.97 and1151.37 sell1151.53 it1151.77 to1151.93 the1152.09 highest1152.25 bidder.1152.65 Although1153.45 this1153.85 issue1154.09 impacts1154.73 everyone,1155.21 allowing1156.17 the1156.57 sale1156.73 of1157.13 location1157.29 data1157.93 places1158.49 certain1158.97 groups1159.29 at1159.69 heightened1159.85 risk,1160.33 including1161.05 those1161.53 seeking1162.14 reproductive1162.54 or1163.26 gender1163.42 affirming1163.83 care1164.38 in1164.94 this1165.26 Commonwealth.1165.59
1166.63 After1166.63 Roe1166.94 versus1167.26 Wade1167.66 was1167.98 overturned,1168.22 we1169.26 in1169.5 the1169.59 legislature1172.46 swiftly1172.46 passed1173.02 shield1173.74 laws1174.07 to1174.46 protect1174.54 our1175.02 patients1175.18 and1175.66 providers1175.83 so1176.87 people1177.02 felt1177.44 safe1177.76 to1177.92 seek1178.48 out1178.8 our1179.2 productive1179.6 reproductive1180.24 health1181.12 care.1181.36 But1181.92 those1182.16 were1182.4 bounty1182.64 bills,1183.12 and1183.92 those1184.16 bounty1184.48 bills1184.96 can1185.44 have1185.68 repercussions.1186 It1187.2 is1187.36 now1187.6 time1187.92 we1188.24 act1188.48 and,1188.88 again,1189.12 pass1189.92 a1190.16 law1190.24 to1190.56 fortify1190.8 our1191.44 SHIELD1191.68 law1192.08 and1192.48 protect1193.01 our1193.33 patients1193.64 and1194.04 providers1194.28 as1195.16 well1195.4 as1195.57 other1195.8 vulnerable1196.2 populations1196.85 from1197.8 having1198.04 this1198.37 data1198.68 used1199.09 against1199.96 them1200.37 through1200.92 unwarranted1201.24 surveillance.1202.13 We1203.4 already1203.64 know1204.04 private1204.28 companies1204.77 are1205.24 selling1205.4 location1205.8 data1206.44 revealing1207.01 who1207.57 was1207.72 traveling1208.2 to1208.52 and1208.84 from1209 abortion1209.32 clinics1209.88 on1210.68 the1210.92 open1211 market.1211.32 We1212.2 already1212.44 know1212.84 there1213.16 are1213.4 bad1213.56 actors1213.88 out1214.36 there1214.52 who1215.08 are1215.32 actively1215.32 seeking1215.96 to1216.44 make1216.68 examples1216.92 of1217.56 our1218.2 reproductive1218.52 care1219.32 providers1219.56 and1220.36 members1220.52 of1220.92 other1221.16 vulnerable1221.32 groups.1221.92 And1222.64 we1222.88 know1223.05 it1223.61 is1223.77 our1223.92 responsibility1224.16 as1225.2 state1225.45 legislators1225.77 to1226.72 keep1226.88 our1227.29 residents1227.53 safe1228.01 from1228.57 this1228.72 out-of-state1229.53 interference.1230.01 Notably,1231.2 we1231.92 would1232.16 not1232.4 be1232.64 the1232.88 first1233.05 state1233.45 to1233.77 ban1234.01 this.1234.33 This1234.99 legislation1235.23 was1236.03 passed1236.03 in1236.35 Maryland1236.59 last1237.15 year.1237.39 And1238.03 in1238.27 light1238.43 of1238.75 SB1239.23 81239.71 in1240.11 Texas,1240.27 with1241.07 bounty1241.47 hunter1241.87 provisions1242.27 that1242.91 allow1243.07 private1243.95 citizens1244.35 to1244.91 file1245.15 lawsuits1245.55 against1246.51 people1246.99 they1247.47 suspect,1247.79 suspect1248.99 is1249.55 the1249.79 word,1249.95 of1250.68 being1250.85 involved1251.16 in1251.57 abortions,1251.8 we1252.61 must1252.92 protect1253.16 those1253.72 seeking1254.04 care1254.61 in1255.09 Massachusetts1255.4 and1256.61 our1256.85 providers1257.09 from1257.72 those1258.04 vigilant1258.44 efforts1259.01 to1259.4 track1259.57 their1259.88 movements.1260.13
1261.09 This1261.09 is1261.33 not,1261.57 of1261.96 course,1262.13 only1262.61 reproductive;1264.26 safeguarding1264.98 our1264.98 rights1265.14 to1265.54 move1265.7 freely1266.02 without1266.5 knowingly1266.98 being1267.62 tracked1268.18 impacts1268.9 all1269.46 of1269.62 us.1269.78 The1270.42 wide1270.58 availability1271.14 of1272.42 this1272.58 information1272.74 has1273.7 serious1274.02 implications,1274.5 and1275.54 it1275.7 demands1275.94 immediate1276.58 This1277.22 should1277.38 be1277.62 our1277.78 number1277.94 11278.26 bill1278.58 to1279.38 protect1279.62 our1280.08 vulnerable1280.88 population.1281.19 Banning1283.19 the1283.6 sale1283.76 of1284.08 location1284.23 data1284.8 would1285.28 deny1285.52 these1285.91 bad1286.23 actors1286.47 the1287.04 opportunity1287.19 to1287.99 weaponize1288.23 this1288.88 information1289.12 and1290.15 protect1290.32 us.1290.8 I1291.67 also1292.09 wanna1292.33 express1292.81 my1293.21 support1293.53 for1293.93 advancing1294.33 my1294.89 bill,1295.05 which1295.29 is1295.53 Senate1295.77 29,1296.25 an1297.13 act1297.37 to1297.61 establish1297.85 the1298.33 Massachusetts1298.49 Data1299.61 Privacy1299.93 Act,1300.49 which1300.97 is1301.21 a1301.45 comprehensive1301.77 data1302.65 privacy1302.97 bill1303.61 and1304.17 includes1304.41 the1304.89 provisions1305.05 of1305.61 the1306.22 location1306.3 shield,1306.78 and1307.51 it1307.66 extends1307.98 additional1308.7 data1309.18 privacy1309.59 reforms.1310.14 However,1311.42 due1311.98 to1312.3 constraints1312.63 and1313.26 trying1313.66 to1314.07 keep1314.14 the1314.38 3-minute1314.78 rule,1315.11 I'm1315.51 not1315.66 gonna1315.83 talk1316.14 about1316.46 that1316.63 11316.78 anymore.1316.94 But1317.74 I1319.26 really1319.42 wanna1319.66 thank1320.04 you,1320.28 and1320.6 I1320.84 look1321.4 forward1321.64 to1322.92 us1323.08 working1323.56 together,1323.56 the1324.2 Senate1324.44 and1324.76 the1324.92 house,1325 to1325.64 be1325.8 proud1325.96 and1326.36 once1326.6 again1326.84 to1327.16 say1327.4 to1327.72 our1327.8 residents,1328.12 we1328.92 hear1329.16 you,1329.4 we1330.04 wanna1330.28 protect1330.6 you,1331.08 and1331.4 we're1331.64 here1331.88 to1332.12 make1332.2 you1332.44 safe.1333.02 I'm1333.02 happy1333.02 to1333.02 answer1333.02 any1333.02 questions1333.02 you1333.02 may1333.02 have.1333.02 I'm1333.17 happy1333.41 to1333.73 answer1333.82 any1334.13 questions1334.38 you1334.93 may1335.17 have.1335.17
1335.41 FARLEY-BOUVIER1335.41 -1335.41 Much,1335.41 senator.1335.65 I'm1335.97 gonna1336.13 turn1336.38 to1336.62 members1336.69 of1337.1 the1337.17 committee.1337.34 Do1337.89 you1337.97 have1338.05 any1338.13 questions1338.38 for1338.78 the1338.86 senator?1339.02
1340.62 MOORE1340.62 -1340.62 The1340.62 could1340.69 I'm1341.34 sorry,1341.65 senator.1341.89 Just1342.21 waiting1342.38 for1342.62 this.1342.62 What1343.02 other1343.17 states1343.34 have1343.65 already1343.82 enacted1344.05 this?1344.38
1344.62 CREEM1344.62 -1344.62 Maryland1344.62 is1345.1 the1345.34 11345.49 that1345.73 just1345.97 did1346.21 it.1346.38
1346.45 MOORE-1346.45 Yeah.1346.45 Okay.1346.62 Thank1347.17 you.1347.33
1348.05 CREEM1348.05 -1348.05 And1348.05 we1348.13 can't1348.61 let1348.93 anybody1349.09 be1349.65 number1349.89 1.1350.21 We're1350.77 always1351.09 new,1351.41 Marlona.1351.65 What's1352.29 the1352.61 problem?1352.85 Thank1354.93 you1355.01 so1355.41 much.1355.57
1380.05 REP1380.05 VARGAS1380.05 -1380.05 Thank1380.05 you,1380.37 Madam1380.85 Chair.1381.17 Thank1381.17 you,1381.33 Mister1381.73 Chairman1382.13 and1382.13 members1382.53 of1382.85 the1382.93 committee.1383.09 We1383.49 appreciate1383.73 your1385.17 great1385.41 attendance1385.73 today1386.69 for1387.09 this1387.25 hearing1387.41 and,1387.73 wanna1388.61 thank1388.89 you1389.06 for1389.21 your1389.38 continued1389.54 work1390.41 on1390.73 this1390.89 issue.1391.06 It's1391.38 pretty1391.86 clear1392.02 and1392.26 apparent1392.41 that1392.82 this1392.97 is1393.13 an1393.21 issue1393.3 that1393.54 is1393.7 of1393.86 high1394.02 priority1394.17 to1394.65 a1395.13 lot1395.3 of1395.46 folks1395.54 in1395.78 the1395.93 Commonwealth1396.1 and1396.49 to1396.89 this1397.06 country1397.21 at1397.54 this1397.78 time.1397.93 And1398.73 so,1398.97 just1399.13 appreciate1399.38 the1399.86 diligence1400.02 with1400.49 which1400.65 you1401.15 each1401.59 do1402.03 this1402.27 work.1402.43 My1403.55 name1403.63 is1403.87 Rep1403.95 Vargas.1404.11 I'm1404.43 here1404.59 with1404.75 Rep1404.99 Rogers.1405.23 We're1406.03 here1406.27 to1406.51 testify1406.67 in1407.07 support1407.23 of1407.47 an1407.55 act1407.71 establishing1407.95 the1408.43 Massachusetts1408.59 Data1409.15 Privacy1409.39 Act,1409.87 the1410.27 MDPA1410.43 for1410.99 short.1411.15 We1411.71 appreciate1411.87 all1412.27 the1412.35 work1412.51 that1412.67 this1412.83 committee1412.99 did1413.31 last1413.87 session1414.23 to1414.88 get1415.12 a1415.6 version1415.67 of1415.99 this1416.08 bill1416.23 out1416.47 of1416.72 committee.1416.8 And1417.6 we1417.67 hope1417.76 to1417.99 continue1418.08 to1418.39 work1418.56 with1418.72 you1418.88 all1419.04 to1419.28 make1419.52 that1419.67 possible1419.91 again.1420.32 As1421.43 you1421.6 know,1421.67 our1421.91 online1422.08 activity1422.39 is1422.8 under1422.96 constant1423.12 surveillance.1423.52 Sometimes1424.56 knowingly1425.04 and1425.52 sometimes1425.67 unknowingly.1426.32 Some1427.52 consumers1427.67 know1428.23 how1428.47 much1428.63 data1428.8 they're1429.12 providing1429.36 and1430.02 the1430.18 risks1430.26 associated,1430.74 and1431.38 others1431.54 perhaps1431.86 don't1432.1 have1432.34 the1432.5 time1432.58 or1432.82 ability1432.98 to1433.3 dig1433.46 into1433.62 the1433.86 terms,1434.02 conditions,1434.58 and1435.3 the1435.46 small1435.62 print1435.94 at1436.58 the1436.74 bottom1436.82 of1437.46 the1437.7 screen.1439.06
1440.1 Not1440.1 only1440.26 is1440.5 our1440.58 personal1440.74 information1441.06 collected1441.62 and1441.94 stored1442.1 without1442.42 our1442.74 consent,1442.82 but1443.22 it1443.22 is1443.38 also1443.54 sold1443.54 as1443.86 a1444.02 commodity.1444.1 Often1444.95 without1445.36 regard1445.6 for1445.84 the1446.08 consequences1446.23 it1446.8 may1446.95 have1447.12 for1447.28 the1447.43 individual.1447.6 Our1448.47 personal1448.71 information,1449.12 including1449.6 but1449.99 not1450.15 limited1450.39 to1450.71 our1450.95 age,1451.04 gender,1451.36 race,1451.76 and1451.99 location,1452.15 is1453.04 collected1453.19 and1453.6 shared1453.76 routinely.1454.08 Private1454.88 information1455.28 to1455.76 us1455.91 becomes1456.15 a1456.56 profit1456.63 generator1457.04 for1457.43 companies,1457.67 and1458.39 I'd1458.56 go1458.71 so1458.95 far1459.04 as1459.28 to1459.43 say1459.43 that1459.43 it's1459.6 not1459.76 only1459.91 a1460.15 profit1460.23 generator,1460.77 it1461.09 is1461.33 the1461.81 main1461.97 asset1462.29 and1462.61 profit1462.85 for1463.17 many1463.33 of1463.57 these1463.73 corporations.1463.97 Moreover,1465.33 unregulated1465.97 data1466.53 practices1466.85 allow1467.33 companies1467.65 to1468.05 collect1468.13 massive1468.53 amounts1468.85 of1469.17 personal1469.33 data1469.73 that1470.29 are1470.45 unnecessary1470.69 to1471.25 create1471.41 the1471.65 core1471.81 products1472.13 or1472.85 perform1473.09 the1473.49 core1473.65 services1473.89 that1474.84 they1474.99 are1475.15 intended1475.32 to1475.95 provide.1476.12 The1477.08 needless1477.23 aggregation1477.63 of1478.04 data1478.19 puts1478.52 consumers1478.76 at1479.23 risk1479.32 of1479.63 data1479.71 breaches1480.04 and1480.36 leaks,1480.52 and1480.84 without1481.08 a1481.39 clear1481.47 set1481.71 of1481.88 regulations1482.04 around1482.52 data1482.84 privacy,1483.08 there1483.56 is1483.71 little1483.95 incentive1484.19 for1484.84 companies1484.99 to1485.47 change1485.56 their1485.88 practices.1486.04 Many1487.15 of1487.32 these1487.47 companies1487.63 do1488.04 great1488.19 things.1488.43 We're1489.29 very1489.77 lucky1490.01 here1490.33 in1490.65 Massachusetts1490.81 in1491.37 the1491.53 United1491.69 States1491.93 to1492.09 have1492.25 some1492.41 incredible1492.73 technology1493.45 companies.1494.01 And1495.21 our1495.37 world1495.53 wouldn't1495.77 be1496.01 the1496.17 same1496.33 without1496.49 them.1496.73
1497.61
1497.61 However,1497.61 the1498.49 constant1498.89 aggregation1499.29 of1499.85 this1500.01 data1500.17 without1500.81 consumers'1501.61 knowledge1501.93 and1501.93 the1502.09 selling1502.25 of1502.49 this1502.65 data1502.73 without1503.05 consumers'1504.33 knowledge1504.72 pose1504.72 a1504.72 significant1504.88 risk1505.45 and1505.77 threat1505.92 to1506.24 consumer1506.4 privacy.1506.88 Technology1508.4 companies1509.05 deserve1509.45 the1509.77 opportunity1509.92 to1510.4 profit,1510.57 innovate,1511.21 and1511.53 grow.1511.77 But1512.48 it1512.64 should1512.81 not1512.97 come1513.13 at1513.37 the1513.45 expense1513.61 of1513.92 people's1514.09 most1514.57 sensitive1514.97 information1515.45 being1515.92 stored1516.24 and1516.57 sold1516.72 without1517.13 consent.1517.37 Effective1518.41 data1518.73 practices1519.13 should1519.53 also1519.69 not1519.93 come1520.17 at1520.33 the1520.49 expense1520.65 of1520.97 the1521.05 innovation1521.29 and1521.93 profitability1522.17 of1522.89 smaller1523.05 businesses1523.37 and1523.69 entrepreneurs.1523.93 In1525.05 the1525.21 current1525.37 regulatory1525.69 environment,1526.33 large1527.29 companies1527.53 have1527.93 the1528.09 upper1528.25 hand1528.49 over1528.73 smaller1528.97 businesses1529.29 that1530.25 don't1530.49 have1530.65 the1530.81 initial1530.97 investments1531.37 in1531.93 data1532.09 aggregation.1532.41
1533.26 Many1533.26 small1533.49 businesses1533.73 without1534.21 their1534.54 own1534.69 technical1534.93 capabilities1535.26 rely1536.78 on1537.1 web1537.26 and1537.49 data1537.58 services1537.89 of1538.38 great1538.54 companies1538.78 like1539.26 Amazon1539.49 and1539.89 Google.1540.06 However,1540.93 the1541.26 access1541.41 that1541.82 large1541.97 companies1542.21 have1542.69 to1542.86 these1543.02 data1543.26 points1543.49 has1544.06 been1544.21 leveraged1544.38 to1544.78 gain1544.86 asymmetric1545.5 benefits1545.9 in1546.22 the1546.38 marketplace,1546.54 leaving1547.42 small1547.82 businesses1548.06 at1548.62 a1548.78 constant1548.94 disadvantage.1549.34 More1550.62 plainly1550.86 put,1551.26 big1551.58 tech1551.74 companies1551.9 and1552.46 marketplaces1552.62 can1553.34 initially1553.5 help1554.22 small1554.46 businesses1554.7 get1555.34 their1555.5 products1555.66 out1556.06 to1556.14 a1556.3 wider1556.38 audience1556.7 and1557.1 market,1557.18 but1557.82 those1557.98 benefits1558.14 are1558.62 eroded1558.78 once1559.18 these1559.42 large1559.58 corporations1559.82 take1560.46 advantage1560.62 of1561.02 data1561.36 generated1561.67 by1561.99 these1562.15 small1562.32 businesses1562.56 to1563.28 then1563.43 develop1563.6 their1563.99 own1564.15 products1564.32 that1564.71 quickly1564.96 absorb1565.28 the1565.84 small1565.99 business1566.23 customers.1566.63 Our1567.84 laws1568.08 are1568.39 outdated1568.56 and1569.36 do1569.52 not1569.67 reflect1569.84 the1570.15 significance1570.32 of1570.88 this1570.96 issue.1571.2
1571.84 An1571.84 act1572.08 establishing1572.32 the1572.8 Massachusetts1572.96 Data1573.43 Privacy1573.76 Act1574.15 corrects1574.47 this1574.71 problem1575.28 and1575.67 establishes1576.15 comprehensive1576.55 data1577.03 privacy1577.35 frameworks1577.83 that1578.79 will1578.95 bring1579.11 our1579.27 laws1579.43 into1579.67 the1579.91 201580.07 first1580.31 century1580.47 and1580.79 provide1580.87 consumers1581.27 agency.1581.75 I1583.03 won't1583.19 go1583.43 through1583.59 the1583.83 entirety1584.39 of1584.79 the1584.95 bill1585.11 because1585.35 I'd1585.59 probably1585.75 bore1586.07 you,1586.23 and1586.47 you've1586.55 got1586.71 some1586.87 great1587.03 folks1587.83 coming1588.15 up1588.39 behind1588.55 us.1588.79 But1589.79 more1589.87 than1590.11 anything,1590.27 I1590.59 just1590.59 wanted1590.74 to1591.07 leave1591.31 the1591.63 impression1591.79 that1592.27 this1592.59 is1592.83 11593.22 of1593.38 the1593.55 most1593.63 important1593.79 issues1594.11 of1594.42 our1594.59 time.1594.66 And1595.55 I1595.7 hope1595.79 that1596.03 this1596.18 committee1596.42 can1596.74 continue1596.9 to1597.31 prioritize1597.38 protecting1598.59 consumers,1598.98 particularly1599.95 in1600.35 an1600.59 environment1600.66 and1601.07 small1601.31 business1601.55 small1602.42 businesses,1602.66 particularly1603.22 in1603.7 an1603.87 environment1603.95 where1604.35 at1604.98 the1605.07 national1605.35 level,1605.59 consumer1605.83 protection1606.47 and1606.95 privacy1607.11 is1607.51 being1607.67 rolled1607.91 back.1608.15 This1609.11 is1609.27 a1609.43 time1609.51 for1609.67 Massachusetts1609.83 to1610.31 step1610.39 up1610.63 to1610.71 the1610.79 plate,1610.95 to1611.19 catch1611.35 up1611.51 to1611.67 other1611.75 states,1611.99 and1612.55 to1612.71 show1612.87 the1613.11 rest1613.19 of1613.43 the1613.51 nation1613.67 how1614.47 to1614.63 move1614.79 forward1614.95 on1615.51 this1615.67 issue.1615.91 So,1616.55 with1616.79 that,1616.95 I1617.19 will1617.27 turn1617.67 it1617.91 over1617.99 to1618.23 my1618.55 colleague,1618.71 who1619.03 will1619.19 be1619.35 much1619.35 more1619.35 impressive1619.35 than1619.35 I1619.35 have1619.35 been.1619.35 much1619.51 more1619.75 impressive1621.64 than1622.05 I1622.29 have1622.77 been.1623.01
1624.44 REP1624.44 ROGERS1624.44 -1624.44 I1624.44 don't1624.61 know1624.85 about1624.92 that.1625.16 Well,1626.05 Chair1627.24 Farley1627.57 Bouvier,1627.96 Chair1628.68 Moore,1629.01 thank1629.4 you.1629.57 Members1629.81 of1630.13 the1630.2 committee,1630.37 thank1630.85 you.1631.09 Forgive1631.81 me1632.2 if1632.37 I'm1632.53 distracted.1632.68 I'm1633.33 mostly1633.4 focused1633.89 on1634.13 whether1634.29 I1634.61 look1634.77 good1634.93 on1635.09 TV1635.33 up1635.73 here.1635.89 I1636.13 think1636.61 I1636.93 actually1637.09 do,1637.41 if1637.73 I1637.89 could1637.97 say1638.21 that.1638.37 But1638.61 no.1638.69 So1640.45 you've1640.77 heard1641.01 you're1641.17 gonna1641.33 hear1641.57 so1641.81 much1641.97 today,1642.21 and1642.53 I1644.69 don't1644.85 wanna1645.09 go1645.65 on1645.81 at1645.97 great1646.13 length1646.45 because1647.35 you1647.59 have1647.83 a1648.07 lot1648.14 of1648.3 folks1648.38 from1648.7 the1648.94 public1649.11 who1649.51 wanna1649.9 testify.1650.22 But,1650.7 as1651.9 my1652.46 colleague,1652.79 representative1654.3 Vargas,1654.94 said,1655.35 this1655.51 is1655.74 a1656.07 big1656.38 issue.1656.54 I1656.94 think1657.03 221657.35 states1657.98 over1658.63 201658.87 states1659.11 have1659.51 acted.1659.66 So,1660.64 you1661.68 know,1661.92 I1662 think1662.16 it's1662.4 a1662.64 ripe1662.8 issue1663.12 for1663.44 the1663.52 legislature1663.76 to1664.32 be1664.48 looking1664.64 at1664.88 now.1665.28 And,1665.68 some1668.24 of1668.4 you1668.56 have1668.72 already1668.88 heard1669.2 me1669.36 say1669.6 this,1669.76 so1670 I1670.16 apologize1670.32 if1671.12 you1671.36 have.1671.6 But1671.84 I1672.8 kinda1672.96 like1673.28 it.1673.52 And,1674.27 it's1675.47 that1675.71 oh,1675.95 you1676.12 know,1676.19 we1676.36 don't1676.51 run1676.76 searches1677.39 on1677.88 Google.1678.12 Google1679.32 runs1679.63 searches1679.88 on1680.36 us.1680.51 And1682.27 so,1682.51 many1685.15 companies1685.39 now1685.95 are1686.19 gathering1686.43 data1687.55 at1688.03 an1688.19 astonishing1688.51 pace.1689.39 I1690.62 have1690.7 a1690.86 compendium1691.1 of1691.66 information1691.9 on1692.46 all1692.62 of1692.78 us,1692.86 where1693.18 we1693.42 go,1693.58 what1693.9 we1694.14 eat,1694.3 where1694.62 we're1694.86 driving,1695.1 what1695.66 we're1695.82 doing.1696.06 And1696.94 by1697.18 the1697.34 way,1697.5 as1697.66 representative1698.06 Vargas1698.7 said,1699.02 I'm1699.34 sure1699.42 some1699.66 rep1699.82 folks1700.54 who1700.78 represent1701.02 large1702.3 tech1702.62 companies1702.78 are1703.26 here.1703.42 The1703.66 innovation,1704.14 the1704.78 dynamism1705.02 of1705.74 our1705.9 economy,1706.24 you1706.57 know,1706.64 we1706.88 wanna1707.13 support1707.68 innovation,1708.09 and1708.64 we1708.8 want1709.04 companies1709.28 to1709.77 succeed.1710.01 But1710.88 that's1711.13 not1711.37 what's1711.61 a1711.92 question1712.01 here,1712.48 and1712.72 don't1713.28 ever1713.61 believe1713.92 that's1714.24 what's1714.48 a1714.72 question.1714.8
1715.13 We're1715.13 not1715.37 trying1716.01 to1716.33 rein1719.28 in1719.52 the1720.74 growth1720.9 or1721.3 the1721.46 success1721.62 of1721.94 these1722.02 companies,1722.26 but1722.58 we1722.74 are1722.9 saying1723.06 there1723.22 have1723.46 to1723.62 be1723.7 some1723.86 sensible1724.18 guardrails1724.74 for1725.38 how1725.7 data1726.02 is1726.26 collected.1726.42 So,1727.3 the1727.3 Massachusetts1727.46 Data1728.18 Protection1728.42 Act1728.9 regulates1729.22 how1729.78 companies1730.02 collect,1730.58 process,1731.62 and1732.34 transfer1732.66 our1733.54 personal1733.86 data.1734.26 It's1735.62 a1736.61 matter1736.85 of1737.09 privacy1737.33 rights,1737.8 and1738.13 specifically,1738.61 the1739.09 bill1739.24 will1739.48 set1739.64 limitations1740.04 on1740.68 how1740.92 and1741.09 when1741.24 sensitive1741.48 data1742.04 can1742.61 be1742.76 collected,1742.92 sold1743.8 to1744.13 third1744.28 parties1744.61 and1745.4 provide1745.64 individuals1746.04 rights1746.68 of1746.92 data1747.16 access,1747.57 correction,1747.96 deletion,1748.52 as1749.16 well1749.33 as1749.57 targeted1749.8 advertising1750.37 opt-out.1751.4 You1752.63 know,1752.79 all1752.87 of1753.11 us1753.27 have1753.43 the1753.59 experience1753.75 of1754.23 going1754.31 on1754.55 the1754.71 web.1754.87 We're1755.35 looking1755.59 around1755.99 at1756.23 different1756.39 things,1756.71 and1756.87 then1757.11 it1757.27 says,1757.35 well,1757.51 here1757.91 are1758.15 the1758.39 terms1758.39 of1758.71 service.1758.87 I'm1760.31 actually1760.55 a1761.11 lawyer1761.27 and1761.67 who1761.83 negotiates1762.39 contracts.1763.03 I1763.51 mean1763.59 but1763.83 and1764.23 even1764.43 for1764.67 me,1764.91 those1765.15 terms1765.39 of1765.72 service1765.8 are1766.2 incredibly1766.28 difficult.1766.91 They're1767.39 dense.1767.63 They1768.04 go1768.28 on1768.43 for1768.6 pages.1768.76 But1769.24 let's1769.39 face1769.63 it,1770.04 99%1770.12 of1771.24 people1771.32 never1771.72 even1771.96 look1772.2 at1772.36 them.1772.43 They1772.91 just1773.08 wanna1773.32 get1773.63 to1773.8 where1774.04 they're1774.2 going,1774.43 and1774.84 they1775.24 just1775.39 click1775.63 okay.1776.04
1776.77 And1776.77 they've1777.41 agreed1777.65 to1777.97 things1778.21 they1778.45 don't1778.61 even1778.85 understand.1779.09 So,1780.21 data1781.73 minimization1782.05 is1782.61 a1782.85 key1782.93 thing1783.33 at1783.65 the1783.81 core1784.05 of1784.45 this1784.53 bill.1784.77 In1785.17 other1785.33 words,1785.49 if1785.73 you1785.97 collect1786.05 data1786.37 as1786.69 a1786.85 company,1786.93 do1787.73 you1787.97 limit1788.37 it1789.09 to1789.09 what1789.65 the1789.97 consumer1790.13 is1790.69 using1791.37 it1791.68 for?1791.77 So1792.24 how1792.72 can1792.97 that1793.13 go1793.29 wrong?1793.53 Well,1793.77 an1794.48 ex1794.64 an1794.88 example1795.13 of1795.45 an1795.61 unsuspecting1795.85 collector1796.57 of1796.97 your1797.13 data1797.29 is1797.61 your1798.4 car.1798.72 And1800.48 then1800.97 the1801.37 car1801.61 gets1801.85 information1802.16 about1802.64 how1802.97 many1803.05 people1803.37 are1803.53 in1803.68 the1803.77 car,1803.85 how1804.01 fast1804.24 you're1804.48 going,1804.57 did1804.81 you1804.97 brake1805.13 too1805.37 fast,1805.53 did1805.77 you1805.92 and1807.38 then1807.54 there's1807.78 evidence1808.34 that1808.74 it's1808.9 being1808.98 sold1809.22 to1809.46 insurance1809.62 companies.1810.18 Unknowingly,1810.74 people1811.46 don't1811.78 even1811.94 know1812.1 this1812.34 is1812.58 happening.1812.66 In1814.42 a1814.66 free1814.82 country1815.78 that1816.1 believes1816.26 in1816.58 liberty1816.74 and1817.22 individual1818.18 rights,1818.74 that's1819.31 preposterous.1819.71
1820.66 It's1820.99 unfair,1820.99 and1822.18 it1822.42 needs1822.59 to1822.9 be1823.14 stopped.1823.47 So1824.42 data1824.74 minimization1824.99 is1825.79 just1825.95 the1826.18 notion1826.35 that1826.74 the1827.31 company1827.47 uses1827.87 it1828.27 only1828.66 for1828.99 the1829.14 specific1829.38 purpose1829.95 the1830.42 person1830.51 is1830.74 there.1830.9 They1831.07 don't1831.23 gather1831.47 all1831.71 this1831.87 other1832.03 information1832.27 and1832.74 start1832.9 selling1833.23 it1833.47 to1833.79 other1834.39 third1834.71 parties.1835.03 I1835.43 mean,1835.51 it's1835.59 just1835.83 common1835.99 sense.1836.31 It1836.63 really1836.87 is.1837.11 It's1837.35 not1837.59 overreaching.1839.03 Another1840.07 key1840.47 provision1840.71 is1841.11 data1841.35 level1841.67 exemption1841.99 as1842.47 opposed1842.55 to1842.95 entity1843.11 level1843.67 exemption,1843.99 and1844.87 that1845.19 basically1845.43 gets1846.95 to1847.19 under1847.51 federal1847.84 law1848.23 like1848.47 HIPAA.1848.71 If1849.67 a1850.23 company1850.39 collects,1850.88 say,1851.91 health1852.15 information,1852.39 that1853.43 entire1853.84 entity1854.23 is1854.8 exempt1855.04 from1855.76 our1855.91 state1856.15 laws1856.47 on1856.8 data1857.04 privacy.1857.28 That1857.99 makes1858.23 no1858.47 sense.1858.71 It's1859.99 much1860.23 more1860.47 logical1860.88 that1861.28 we1861.43 have1861.6 data-level1862.56 exemption1863.25 specifically1863.73 targeted1864.29 to1864.77 the1864.93 data1865.09 for1866.13 the1866.37 use1866.45 that1866.77 the1867.01 consumer1867.09 is1867.57 using.1867.73
1868.05 And1868.05 so1868.45 an1868.61 example1868.85 of1869.25 how1869.33 that1869.57 can1869.73 go1869.89 wrong1870.05 is1870.29 pharmacies1870.61 collect1871.33 a1872.37 lot1872.53 of1872.69 information1872.85 about1873.41 us,1873.65 and1874.13 some1874.37 of1874.53 it's1874.69 protected1874.85 by1875.33 HIPAA,1875.49 and1875.89 they're1876.05 very1876.29 good1876.48 about1876.72 keeping1876.96 it1877.29 confidential.1877.53 But1878.48 then1878.64 other1878.88 data1879.13 these1879.53 pharmacies1879.68 get1880.16 about1880.4 us,1880.64 they1880.88 sell1881.37 to1881.77 others.1881.85 And,1883.05 again,1883.2 consumers1883.61 don't1884.01 even1884.24 know1884.4 this1884.64 is1884.88 happening.1884.96 So,1885.85 I1887.44 also1887.61 wanna1887.85 note1888.09 I1888.48 wanna1888.88 wrap1889.13 up1889.29 because1889.44 you1889.68 have1889.77 a1889.92 lot1890.01 of1890.16 folks1890.24 here.1890.48 But1891.92 I1892.19 wanna1892.27 mention1892.59 H1892.91 98,1893.23 which1893.79 is1894.03 an1894.19 act1894.35 relative1894.83 to1895.63 Internet1895.87 privacy1896.27 rights1896.67 for1896.99 children1897.07 that's1897.47 modeled1897.79 after1898.11 a1898.43 California1898.51 law.1899.07 The1899.39 Eraser1899.95 Bill1900.19 aims1900.19 to1900.43 protect1900.59 the1901.07 privacy1901.07 rights1901.47 of1901.79 children.1901.95 So1902.91 please1903.15 take1903.47 a1903.63 look1903.79 at1904.03 that1904.11 1.1904.27 H1905.55 961905.71 is1905.71 an1905.79 act1905.95 to1906.27 provide1906.36 accountability1906.75 in1907.32 the1907.55 use1907.63 of1907.88 biometric1907.95 recognition1908.6 technology1909.32 and1910.27 comprehensive1910.51 enforcement;1912.19 some1912.84 of1912.99 the1913.08 concepts1913.23 in1913.71 there1913.79 are1914.03 embodied1914.27 in1914.67 the1914.84 data1914.99 privacy1915.32 bill1916.43 as1916.67 well.1916.84 So1917.08 I1917.32 could1917.47 go1917.63 on1917.71 a1917.88 greater1917.95 length,1918.27 but1918.51 I1918.67 better1918.75 not.1918.99 Thank1919.32 you1919.55 for1919.71 your1919.79 indulgence.1920.19 Thank1920.51 you1920.83 for1920.99 listening,1921.23 and1921.55 thank1921.87 you1922.03 for1922.19 all1922.35 your1922.51 hard1922.67 work1922.83 on1923.07 the1923.15 issue.1923.31 I1923.47 know1923.55 you've1923.71 been1923.87 a1924.11 great1924.35 leader,1924.59 particularly1924.99 both1925.79 of1926.03 you,1926.11 but1926.35 the1926.51 house1926.59 chair,1926.91 I1927.23 mean,1927.31 I1927.55 know1927.63 you've1927.87 really1928.19 dug1928.43 into1928.67 this,1928.91 and1929.31 so1929.47 thanks1929.71 for1929.95 your1930.11 leadership.1930.19
1957.36 FARLEY-BOUVIER1957.36 -1957.36 [Inaudible]1957.36
1957.36 VARGAS1957.36 -1957.36 Great1957.36 question,1957.36 and1957.36 I1957.36 think1957.36 there1957.36 are1957.36 a1957.36 couple1957.36 of1957.36 ways1957.36 to1957.36 think1957.36 about1957.36 it.1957.36 One1957.36 is1957.36 on1957.36 the1957.36 privacy1957.36 side1957.36 of1957.36 things,1957.36 making1957.36 it1957.36 clear1957.36 and1957.36 easier1957.6 for1958.08 small1958.32 businesses1958.56 to1959.04 be1959.12 protected1959.28 in1960.64 terms1960.8 of1961.04 how1961.2 their1961.36 customers'1961.52 data1962.08 is1962.35 being1962.42 used.1962.66 So1963.38 that's1963.54 sort1963.7 of1963.94 a1964.11 legal1964.51 protection1964.9 for1965.38 them.1965.46 And1966.18 then1966.35 there's1966.42 the1966.66 business1966.83 case1967.14 for1967.38 them1967.54 as1967.78 well.1967.94 Right?1968.18 They're1968.35 collecting1968.51 all1968.9 this1969.14 data1969.3 on1969.7 customers1969.87 and1971.07 then1971.14 providing1971.46 that1971.87 data1972.03 to1972.74 bigger1972.98 companies1973.38 that1973.78 then1974.03 can1974.18 say,1974.42 well,1974.66 I1974.83 noticed1974.98 that1975.3 you're1975.46 selling1975.63 all1975.94 of1976.11 these1976.27 coffee1976.74 mugs.1977.07 Maybe1977.75 I'll1977.99 just1978.07 go1978.23 ahead1978.31 and1978.55 make1978.63 my1978.87 own1978.95 coffee1979.11 mug1979.43 based1979.75 on1980.07 the1980.23 data1980.39 that1980.63 you've1980.79 created,1981.03 and1981.99 I'll1982.15 absorb1982.31 that1982.79 customer1983.03 segment1983.43 and1984.31 completely1984.47 take1985.27 your1985.51 customer1985.67 base.1986.07 And1986.31 so,1986.47 small1987.43 businesses1987.67 are1988.47 heavily1988.71 impacted1989.19 by1989.67 this.1989.83 We1990.15 also1990.31 have1990.55 some1990.71 exemptions1990.79 in1991.35 here1991.43 to1991.67 ensure1991.83 that1992.07 small1992.55 businesses1992.71 aren't1993.19 overly1993.43 burdened1993.75 by1994.55 this1994.79 as1995.03 well.1995.19 And1995.99 so1996.15 I1996.23 think1996.32 it's1996.47 a1996.63 really1996.79 important1997.03 component1997.43 that1997.99 often1998.39 isn't1998.71 talked1998.95 about1999.19 enough1999.51 when1999.75 we1999.91 think2000.08 about2000.23 this2000.47 issue.2000.63
2001.6 SPEAKER82001.6 -2001.6 Thank2001.6 you.2001.84
2002.63 FARLEY-BOUVIER2002.63 -2002.63 Questions2002.63 from2003.03 the2003.27 committee.2003.36
2005.75 REP2005.75 VITOLO2005.75 -2005.75 As2005.75 with2005.99 much2006.32 of2006.55 the2006.71 legislation2006.88 we2007.6 consider,2007.75 there's2008.29 a2008.53 tension2008.69 between2009.17 specializing2010.61 something2011.25 for2011.57 our2011.81 commonwealth2011.97 and2012.85 the2013.25 legislation2013.49 of2013.97 the2014.21 other2014.37 492014.61 states.2015.17 Can2015.97 you2016.21 speak2016.45 to2016.77 how,2017.01 legislating2018.45 on2019.01 this2019.17 topic,2019.33 we2021.01 manage2021.25 that2021.57 balance?2021.81 How2022.21 we2022.37 make2022.45 sure2022.62 we're2023.02 getting2023.49 it2023.82 right,2023.97 the2024.78 tension2024.86 between2025.34 state2025.89 and2026.21 federal2026.3 visions2027.02 of2027.41 this.2027.49 Sure.2027.97
2028.38 ROGERS2028.38 -2028.38 Well,2028.38 rep2028.62 representative2029.02 Vitolo,2029.58 thanks2030.13 for2030.38 that2030.54 excellent2030.78 question.2031.17 And2031.97 that2032.13 is2032.3 important2032.45 because2032.86 I2033.17 don't2033.26 think2033.49 we're2033.73 gonna2033.97 see2034.3 federal2034.62 action2035.1 anytime2035.73 soon2036.3 on2036.62 this2036.78 issue.2036.93 We've2038.54 seen,2038.78 if2039.42 anything,2039.66 an2039.98 alliance2040.22 between2040.7 tech2041.02 CEOs2041.34 and2041.82 the2041.98 current2042.14 administration2042.38 in2043.02 Washington.2043.26 So2044.22 we2044.46 can't2044.62 wait.2045.9 And2046.14 222046.38 other2046.94 states2047.26 have2047.5 already2047.66 acted.2047.98 But2048.3 as2048.46 you2048.62 point2048.78 out,2049.02 the2049.58 companies2049.82 will2050.22 say,2050.46 look.2050.62 We2050.86 don't2051.26 want2051.5 a2051.66 patchwork2051.82 quilt2052.38 of2052.86 varying2054.61 regulations2055.01 and2055.72 laws2055.97 around2056.36 the2056.61 country.2056.77 So2057.41 there's2057.57 a2057.81 concept2057.89 that2058.36 that2058.68 you2058.93 gets2059.24 to2059.49 your2059.64 question,2059.81 perhaps2060.13 you've2060.45 already2060.68 heard2060.93 of2061.16 it,2061.24 called2061.33 interoperability,2061.72 essentially,2062.68 that2063.24 we2063.49 the2063.97 defined2064.13 terms2064.61 we2064.93 use,2065.16 the2065.49 model2066.05 that2066.53 we,2066.68 adopt2068.7 should2069.45 be,2069.77 in2071.77 harmony2071.93 with2072.73 other2072.97 states.2073.37 I2074.41 believe2074.57 that2074.97 the2076.57 bill2076.73 filed2077.05 by2077.37 chairwoman2078.73 Farley2079.29 Bouvier,2079.69 I2080.25 think,2080.33 gets2081.77 to2082.01 a2082.17 lot2082.25 of2082.49 that2082.65 and2083.53 makes2084.74 an2084.97 effort2085.14 to2085.61 address2086.49 interoperability.2086.97 So2087.86 I2088.57 think2088.66 it's2088.89 a2089.14 fair2089.3 point2089.93 for2090.49 those2091.53 who2091.86 are2092.09 advocates2092.26 for2092.66 the2092.89 tech2093.05 companies2093.3 to2093.86 raise,2094.18 but2095.78 it2096.02 what2096.18 it2096.34 can't2096.49 be2096.82 is2097.05 a2097.3 reason2097.45 to2097.86 not2098.09 act.2098.57 Too2099.94 often,2100.18 these2100.82 kinds2101.22 of2101.54 things2101.62 underlying2102.26 the2102.74 premise,2102.9 underlying2103.38 your2103.78 question,2103.94 the2104.26 concern2104.5 underlying2104.9 your2105.3 question,2105.46 become2106.1 a2106.34 roadblock.2106.5 Well,2106.98 we2107.3 best,2107.46 you2107.78 know,2107.86 and2108.02 then2108.18 we2108.66 don't2109.06 act.2109.38 So2110.18 whatever2111.06 concerns2111.62 are2112.02 being2112.1 raised2112.34 by2112.74 our2112.98 friends2113.14 in2113.54 the2113.62 technology2113.7 sector,2114.5 that's2114.82 fine,2115.06 and2115.38 we2115.59 need2115.82 to2115.98 hear2116.07 them2116.39 out2116.63 for2116.86 sure.2117.11 But2117.51 it's2117.98 not2118.3 a2118.55 reason2118.63 not2119.11 to2119.43 act.2119.43 The2119.82 time2119.98 to2120.22 act2120.3 is2120.95 now.2121.18 And2121.98 so,2122.22 but2122.78 thanks2122.95 for2123.11 your2123.34 question.2123.43
2123.91 VARGAS2123.91 -2123.91 Thank2123.91 you.2124.07 If2124.3 I2124.46 could2124.55 just2124.78 expand2125.11 that2125.51 a2125.66 little2125.74 bit.2125.91 You2126.39 know,2126.46 the2126.63 Consumer2126.78 Financial2127.26 Protection2127.59 Bureau2128.07 no2128.46 longer2128.7 exists,2129.03 for2129.51 example.2129.66 Right?2130.14 FCC2131.15 rollbacks2131.95 are2132.43 happening,2132.67 you2133.07 know,2133.23 on2133.39 a2133.55 weekly2133.63 basis2134.03 at2134.35 this2134.51 point.2134.67 So2135.55 this2135.71 is2135.95 very,2136.03 very2136.35 real.2136.59 Alright?2136.91 And2137.15 we2137.31 don't2137.47 have2138.03 the2138.27 opportunity2138.43 to2138.99 just2139.07 wait2139.31 for,2139.47 you2139.87 know,2140.03 42140.19 years2140.43 when2140.67 maybe2140.91 there's2141.07 an2141.31 administrate2141.47 a2142.11 change2142.27 at2142.51 the2142.59 administrative2142.75 level2143.31 or2143.76 when2144.01 Congress2144.09 decides2144.57 to2144.97 act2145.28 on2145.45 this.2145.68 The2146.41 reality2146.57 is2146.89 that2147.13 Massachusetts2147.36 residents2147.93 and2148.24 consumers2148.41 are2148.89 being2148.97 hurt2149.13 right2149.36 now.2149.53 And2150.09 the2150.24 fundamental2150.48 question2150.97 when2151.28 you2151.45 boil2151.61 this2151.84 question2152.24 down2152.57 is,2152.8 you2153.13 know,2153.28 does2153.53 the2153.76 additional2153.93 work2154.41 on2154.8 these2154.97 companies,2155.28 is2156.09 that2156.24 of,2156.57 is2157.69 it2157.85 too2157.93 much2158.17 work2158.41 for2158.65 them2158.81 to2159.05 do2159.13 in2159.37 order2159.53 for2159.77 us2159.85 to2160.01 protect2160.09 our2160.41 constituents?2160.57 And2161.37 I2161.53 think2161.69 the2161.85 answer2161.93 is2162.17 no.2162.33 Alright.2162.49 I2162.81 think2163.05 they2163.21 can2163.37 take2163.53 on2163.77 the2163.93 opportunity2164.09 to2164.65 figure2164.81 out2165.05 how2165.37 to2165.61 make2165.69 sure2165.85 that2166.01 they're2166.25 complying2166.49 here2166.89 in2167.05 Massachusetts2167.21 while2167.85 also2168.01 complying2168.25 in2168.57 other2168.73 states.2168.89 We2169.85 have2170.01 to2170.17 make2170.25 sure2170.41 we2170.65 do2170.81 it2170.89 in2170.97 a2171.13 way2171.21 that's2171.37 reasonable.2171.61 Right?2172.09 But2172.41 if2173.51 the2173.59 trade-off2173.91 is2174.22 a2174.55 little2174.7 more2174.95 work2175.11 in2175.74 order2175.99 to2176.11 protect2176.22 consumers,2176.63 I'll2177.11 take2177.34 that2177.51 trade2177.66 all2177.91 day.2178.07
2179.03 SPEAKER132179.03 -2179.03 Thank2179.03 you.2179.18
FARLEY-BOUVIER2180.55 -2180.55 Anybody2180.55 else2180.95 down2181.18 here?2181.34 Here.2182.86 Senator.2183.59
2209.49 MOORE2209.49 -2209.49 Yeah.2209.49 [Inaudible]
2209.82 ROGERS2209.82 -2209.82 Great2209.82 question.2210.05 Candidly,2210.53 I2213.49 don't2213.74 have2214.05 a2214.3 detailed2214.38 answer2214.86 for2215.18 you2215.34 on2215.49 that2215.66 point.2215.89 I2216.22 haven't2216.53 investigated2217.42 or2218.06 studied2218.22 that.2218.46 But2219.34 I2219.58 can2219.66 say2219.98 just,2220.3 in2221.55 speaking2222.17 in2222.8 broad2223.42 brush2223.74 strokes,2223.98 that2224.38 we2224.94 would2225.18 have2225.34 heard2225.5 about2225.66 it2225.98 in2226.06 the2226.22 National2226.3 News2226.78 or,2227.18 you2227.5 know,2227.66 Washington2228.06 Post,2228.7 the2229.02 New2229.18 York2229.34 Times,2229.5 the2229.9 Wall2229.98 Street2230.22 Journal.2230.46 We'd2231.34 be2231.58 hearing2231.82 more2232.22 and2232.46 more2232.62 about2232.91 how,2233.14 oh,2233.3 these2233.7 laws2234.03 have2234.43 really2234.66 made2234.91 our2235.14 business2235.86 model2236.26 unworkable.2236.74 To2238.66 the2238.82 best2238.98 of2239.22 my2239.3 knowledge,2239.55 that's2240.03 not2240.26 happening.2240.51 And2241.14 we2241.7 can2241.95 draft2242.11 a2242.51 law2242.66 with2243.55 the2243.78 talented2243.95 folks2244.51 on2244.91 this2245.07 committee2245.3 and2245.78 the2246.03 talented2246.11 chair.2246.59 We2246.98 can2247.07 draft2247.3 a2247.63 law2247.7 that2247.95 protects2248.18 consumers2248.83 and2249.55 still2249.79 lets2250.03 companies2250.27 do2250.75 what2250.99 they2251.15 need2251.31 to2251.55 do2251.63 to2251.87 be2251.95 successful.2252.27 And2252.83 so,2252.99 so2254.99 thanks2255.23 for2255.47 the2255.63 question,2255.71 but2256.59 I'm2256.83 not2256.99 aware2257.15 of2257.47 any2257.63 major2257.95 disruptions2258.51 because2259.23 of2259.63 laws2259.71 that2259.95 have2260.11 been2260.27 passed2260.43 so2260.75 far.2260.91 Okay.2261.47 Now,2262.43 they2262.72 may2262.8 impose2263.05 some2263.36 costs2263.53 on2263.84 these2264.01 companies,2266.01 but2266.41 that's2266.89 true2267.13 in2267.36 every2267.53 industry.2267.77 Right?2268.16 I2268.49 mean,2268.64 that's,2269.05 you2269.36 know,2269.53 we2269.68 need2269.84 to2270.09 protect2270.16 the2270.49 public.2270.64 So2270.97 thanks.2271.2
2273.53 FARLEY-BOUVIER2273.53 -2273.53 Any2273.53 else?2273.77 Thank2274.09 you2274.41 very2274.57 much,2274.8 and2275.05 I2275.2 appreciate2275.28 it.2275.77 Next,2278.47 we2278.71 have2278.95 representative2279.19 Lindsay2279.75 Sabadosa.2280.23 And2281.35 then,2281.59 on2282.55 deck,2282.79 we2283.19 have2283.43 Andrew2283.83 Kingman.2284.23 Welcome,2294.72 representative.2295.11 Nice2295.84 to2296.07 see2296.24 you2296.32 today.2296.47
2296.95 REP2296.95 SABADOSA2296.95 -2296.95 HB2296.95 992296.95 -2296.95 SB2296.95 472296.95 -2296.95 Nice2296.95 to2297.2 see2297.28 you.2297.43 Good2297.68 afternoon.2297.91 I'm2298.8 so2299.11 sure2299.28 we're2299.52 gonna2299.59 be2299.84 called2299.91 up2300.16 to2300.32 vote2300.39 the2300.64 second2300.72 I2301.03 start2301.11 speaking2301.43 to2301.84 see2301.99 if2302.16 I2302.32 can2302.39 get2302.47 through2302.64 this.2302.95 I2304.93 am2305.25 here2305.49 today2305.73 to2306.05 speak2306.13 about2306.53 H2306.85 992307.09 and2307.97 S2308.21 47,2308.45 an2309.01 act2309.17 relative2309.33 to2309.73 surveillance2309.89 pricing2310.29 in2310.61 grocery2310.77 stores,2311.09 which2311.33 I2311.41 filed2311.65 with2312.29 Chairman2312.77 Moore.2313.17 So,2314.45 as2315.01 we've2315.17 heard2315.57 today2316.05 from2316.49 everyone2316.8 who's2317.05 testified2317.36 thus2317.77 far,2318.01 technology2318.32 is2318.8 moving2319.05 at2319.36 a2319.53 rapid2319.68 pace.2320.16 Some2321.05 people2321.28 who2321.68 would2321.93 have2322.09 written2322.16 their2322.57 testimony2322.8 by2323.2 hand2323.36 a2323.61 few2323.68 years2323.84 ago2324.01 are2324.32 probably2324.57 now2324.97 writing2325.13 it2325.36 by2325.53 ChatGPT.2325.93 So2326.64 we2327.2 know2327.45 that2327.61 things2327.84 have2328.24 changed.2328.49 And2329.54 one2330.02 of2330.26 the2330.42 things2330.58 that2330.98 I2331.22 think2331.3 we2331.54 need2331.7 to2331.86 be2332.02 proactive2332.26 in2332.98 preventing2333.22 is2334.58 surveillance2334.9 pricing2335.46 and2335.78 surveillance2335.94 advertising.2336.58 These2337.62 are2337.86 the2338.02 22338.18 issues2338.34 that2338.66 are2338.9 at2339.38 the2339.54 heart2339.7 of2339.94 this2340.02 legislation,2340.26 which2340.82 focuses2341.06 particularly2341.08 on2341.09 grocery2341.11 stores.2341.12 And2341.14 you'll2341.16 see,2341.17 from2341.2 the2341.22 written2341.47 particularly2342.14 on2342.3 grocery2342.53 stores.2343.01 And2343.66 you'll2343.82 see,2344.05 from2344.78 the2345.09 written2345.34 testimony2345.66 that2346.21 will2346.38 be2346.53 submitted2346.78 and2347.18 others2347.34 who2347.66 have2347.82 written2347.97 today,2348.21 we2349.09 have2349.26 a2349.41 lot2349.49 of2349.73 food2349.97 banks2350.21 and2350.45 food2350.61 justice2350.86 organizations2351.26 that2351.82 are2351.97 in2352.14 support2352.3 of2352.69 this2352.78 bill2353.01 because2353.82 they2354.14 understand2354.45 that2355.2 the2355.52 future2355.76 could2356.16 be2356.4 very2356.56 grim2356.88 if2357.2 we2357.36 don't2357.52 take2357.68 action.2357.84
2358.16 And2358.16 I2358.32 just2358.4 wanna2358.64 say,2358.88 I'm2359.84 talking2360.08 about2360.32 the2360.56 future,2360.72 but2361.04 already2361.28 in2361.6 02/2019,2361.84 Kroger,2362.88 a2363.28 grocery2363.44 store2363.76 in2364 the2364.16 United2364.24 States,2364.48 piloted2365.2 technology2365.68 with2366.56 Microsoft,2366.8 and2368 they're2368.16 now2368.32 working2368.66 with2368.82 a2368.93 company2369.05 to2369.53 sell2369.78 this2370.09 technology2370.41 countrywide.2371.14 So2371.93 the2372.26 future2372.41 may2373.14 be2373.38 much2373.53 sooner2373.86 than2374.09 we2374.34 think.2374.49 I2375.45 wanna2375.7 dig2375.93 into2376.18 just2376.73 a2376.97 tiny2377.14 bit2377.53 about2377.86 what2378.18 this2378.34 actually2378.66 means,2378.97 though.2379.3 So2379.53 what2379.78 is2380.01 surveillance2380.18 pricing?2380.81 So,2381.61 surveillance2381.85 pricing2382.41 can2382.89 happen2383.21 in2383.53 a2383.69 couple2383.85 of2384.09 different2384.09 ways.2384.41 It2384.73 can2384.89 happen2385.13 through,2385.45 for2385.69 example,2385.85 electronic2386.41 price2386.89 tags,2387.21 which2387.85 grocery2388.09 stores2388.41 are2388.81 planning2389.05 to2389.45 roll2389.61 out.2389.85 So2390.01 that2390.17 instead2390.41 of2390.81 those2390.97 nice2391.21 little2391.53 slips2392.01 of2392.33 paper2392.41 that2392.65 teenagers2392.89 currently2393.37 put2393.77 in2393.93 there2394.09 for2394.25 you2394.41 as2394.57 you2394.65 grocery2394.81 shop,2395.13 there'll2395.29 be2395.66 an2395.82 electronic2395.91 monitor2396.63 that2397.03 tells2397.34 you2397.59 what2397.74 the2397.91 price2398.07 of2398.39 the2398.55 product2398.63 you're2399.03 buying2399.11 is.2399.43 Because2400.3 it's2400.55 electronic,2400.95 it2401.51 can2401.59 be2401.74 easily2401.91 adjusted.2402.3 This,2403.51 when2403.82 paired2404.14 with2404.39 surveillance2404.63 technology,2405.34 which2405.91 is2406.22 facial2406.47 recognition2406.95 to2407.31 a2407.66 great2407.74 extent2407.99 and2408.39 is2408.55 already2409.05 in2409.37 most2409.45 of2409.69 our2409.85 stores,2410.01 can2410.81 lead2411.05 to2411.29 surveillance2411.53 pricing.2412.09
2412.89 So2412.89 that2413.05 means2413.29 that2413.69 if2414.01 I2414.33 go2414.49 into2414.65 a2414.97 store,2415.13 the2416.01 store2416.41 can2416.81 adjust2417.13 the2417.61 price2417.85 because2418.17 they2418.49 think,2418.73 based2419.21 on2419.53 the2419.69 information2419.85 they2420.57 know2420.73 about2420.97 me,2421.37 I2421.77 could2421.93 perhaps2422.09 pay2422.57 more2422.73 for2422.97 it.2423.13 Perhaps,2423.53 Rob2423.93 Hawkins2424.09 goes2424.65 to2424.91 the2425.07 store,2425.24 and2425.88 they2426.11 think,2426.43 older2426.84 gentleman,2427.24 he2428.36 probably2428.59 is2428.99 going2429.16 to2429.39 wanna2429.55 pay2429.88 less2430.04 for2430.28 eggs2430.43 than2430.68 rep2430.91 Sabadosa2431.07 would2431.72 pay.2431.88 And2432.04 so2432.2 they2432.36 can2432.52 adjust2432.91 those2433.55 prices.2433.88 This2435.95 is2436.28 really2436.43 a2436.76 way2436.84 to2437.08 target2437.32 individual2437.56 shoppers,2438.68 and2439.08 there2439.4 are2439.96 plenty2440.2 of2440.4 ways2440.6 that2440.92 this2441 can2441.16 be2441.32 done,2441.48 including2442.28 by2442.76 providing,2443 for2443.4 example,2443.56 perhaps2443.96 a2444.28 coupon2444.36 to2445.16 rep2445.48 Hawkins2445.72 so2446.12 that2446.28 even2446.44 though2446.6 there's2446.76 12447.08 price,2447.24 he2447.56 ends2447.72 up2447.96 paying2448.12 less2448.44 than2448.92 I2449.16 do2449.32 because2449.48 I2449.8 am2449.88 not2450.04 offered2450.2 that2450.68 same2450.92 coupon.2451.39 So2452.74 that's2453.07 the2453.39 first2453.55 thing2453.79 this2454.18 legislation2454.43 applies2455.07 to2455.55 them.2455.79 The2456.27 second2456.51 piece2456.91 is2457.47 surveillance2457.7 advertising.2458.66 Now,2460.74 I2461.47 would2461.63 define2461.95 it2462.35 as2462.35 predatory.2462.59 Surveillance2463.63 technology2464.35 can2464.83 identify2465.15 and2465.71 analyze2465.95 customer2466.43 data2466.83 in2467.23 real2467.39 time2467.63 when2468.03 you2468.19 look2468.35 at2468.51 your2468.67 previous2468.91 purchases2469.31 and2470.11 other2470.35 information2470.59 the2471.07 grocery2471.15 store2471.55 has2471.79 about2471.95 you.2472.19
2472.35 And2472.35 we2472.51 all2472.59 know2472.75 the2472.91 grocery2473.07 store2473.31 has2473.55 a2473.71 lot2473.79 of2474.03 information2474.19 about2474.67 us.2474.83 Right?2474.99 You2475.15 all2475.31 get2475.47 the2475.63 coupons2475.71 at2476.11 checkout.2476.27 Know2476.75 that2476.91 they're2477.15 doing2477.39 this.2478.28 So,2478.36 depending2478.76 on2479.09 how2479.16 sophisticated2479.48 that2480.13 can2480.36 be,2480.53 the2481.01 grocery2481.16 store2481.57 can2481.8 conceivably2482.05 provide2483.09 ads2483.57 to2483.89 you2484.05 as2484.36 you2484.61 shop2484.76 based2485.09 on2485.41 what2485.57 you2485.72 most2485.96 desire2486.44 and2486.93 what2487.09 you2487.24 have2487.41 previously2487.57 purchased.2488.2 This2489.64 means2489.8 even2490.27 the2490.39 most2490.51 disciplined2490.75 shopper2491.15 could2491.55 be2491.71 enticed2491.87 to2492.19 buy2492.35 things2492.59 that2492.99 they2493.39 weren't2493.55 really2493.79 intending2494.11 upon2494.59 buying.2494.83 So2496.03 I2496.51 just2496.67 wanna2496.83 bring2497.07 this2497.31 all2497.47 back2497.71 because2497.95 we're2498.59 talking2498.83 about2499.15 food.2499.39 We're2499.79 not2500.19 talking2500.35 about2500.59 luxury2500.83 goods.2501.23 We're2501.47 not2501.71 talking2501.87 about2502.11 clothing.2502.51 We're2502.82 talking2503.07 about2503.3 something2503.55 that2503.86 is2504.03 essential2504.18 to2504.74 our2504.91 survival2505.14 every2505.7 single2506.03 day.2506.26 And2506.98 most2507.22 people,2507.55 when2508.34 they2508.51 are2508.66 looking2508.82 for2509.07 affordable2509.3 food,2509.78 go2510.26 to2510.43 the2510.59 grocery2510.74 store.2511.14 Right?2511.47 That2511.78 is2511.95 where2512.11 we2512.34 think2512.51 we2512.66 can2512.82 buy2512.98 food2513.14 that2513.86 is2514.03 the2514.18 most2514.34 reasonably2514.59 priced.2515.07 And2515.55 as2516.36 rep,2516.6 probably2516.8 Boubier2517 knows,2517.4 in2517.64 rural2517.8 parts2518.04 of2518.28 the2518.44 state,2518.52 that2518.84 can2519 mean2519.24 traveling2519.4 a2519.8 really,2519.96 really2520.2 long2520.44 distance.2520.68
2521.64 So2521.64 our2521.88 goal2522.04 in2522.36 trying2522.6 to2522.92 ban2523 these2523.32 22523.72 features,2523.88 surveillance2524.44 advertising2525.08 and2526.44 surveillance2526.68 pricing,2527.32 is2527.96 to2528.12 ensure2528.28 that2528.6 when2528.84 people2529 go2529.24 to2529.48 that2529.56 grocery2529.72 store,2530.04 they're2530.39 getting2530.55 a2530.88 fair2530.95 price.2531.28 They're2531.59 not2531.84 getting2531.99 different2532.32 prices2532.72 based2533.2 on2533.43 their2533.59 demographic2533.91 data2534.55 or2534.95 the2535.2 data2535.28 the2535.68 grocery2535.76 store2536.07 has2536.32 collected,2536.55 and2537.28 they2537.43 are2537.68 able2537.91 to2538.24 grocery2538.72 shop.2539.11 I2539.76 just2539.91 wanna2540.16 say2540.55 that2540.72 there2540.72 have2540.88 been2541.03 so2541.11 many2541.28 questions2541.52 about,2541.91 survival2542.81 of2543.45 business.2543.61 Grocery2544.41 stores2544.73 are2544.97 not2545.13 going2545.29 out2545.69 of2545.85 business.2546.01 They2547.13 are2547.29 very2547.61 profitable2547.93 industries.2548.49 Meanwhile,2549.37 180.4%2549.93 of2551.45 Massachusetts2551.61 residents2552.33 are2553.05 using,2553.45 have2554.17 reported2554.41 food2554.73 insecurity.2554.97 And2555.61 we2555.77 heard2555.93 just2556.25 yesterday2556.49 at2556.89 the2557.05 Ways2557.13 and2557.37 Means2557.53 hearing2557.77 that2558.38 about2558.61 80,0002559.09 are2559.97 going2560.21 to2560.45 food2560.61 banks2560.86 to2561.26 get2561.34 their2561.49 food.2561.73 So,2562.05 when2562.86 we're2563.01 looking2563.17 at2563.49 how2563.73 we2563.89 weigh2564.14 these2564.38 things,2564.53 the2564.86 people2565.01 of2565.26 Massachusetts2565.41 are2566.14 currently2566.3 suffering.2566.69 We2567.17 wanna2567.34 do2567.66 something2567.82 proactive2568.3 to2569.26 prevent2569.41 any2570.05 future2570.3 suffering2570.78 to2571.34 the2571.49 greatest2571.57 extent2571.97 possible.2572.45 This2573.34 is2573.57 a2573.73 first-time2574.13 file,2574.37 so2574.77 I2574.93 appreciate2575.17 the2575.57 early2575.73 hearing2576.05 on2576.37 it,2576.45 and2576.69 I2576.93 am2577.17 very2577.41 happy2577.65 to2577.89 answer2578.05 any2578.37 questions2578.53 and,2578.93 of2579.17 course,2579.33 work2579.57 with2579.81 the2579.89 committee2580.05 on2580.37 this.2580.53
FARLEY-BOUVIER-2581.01 Thank2581.01 you2581.17 so2581.33 much,2581.49 representative.2581.73 Questions2582.69 from2583.01 the2583.25 committee?2583.41 On2584.37 here?2584.53 Over2585.25 here?2585.57 Senator.2586.74 Surprise.2588.26 It's2590.18 a2590.34 great2590.43 partnership.2590.66
2590.98 SABADOSA2590.98 -2590.98 Are2590.98 you2591.3 going2591.46 to2591.63 answer2591.7 as2592.11 well?2592.26 [Inaudible]Of2595.14 course.2595.3 [Inaudible]I'm2600.99 sorry.2601.23 Any2601.47 federal?2601.63
2601.95 MOORE-2601.95 Federal2601.95 preemption2602.35 or2602.91 federal2602.99 law2603.71 discovery2604.03 decision?2604.51
2604.99 SABADOSA2604.99 -2604.99 No.2604.99 There2605.23 should2605.47 be2605.63 none.2605.79 We2606.03 have2606.27 flagged2606.59 this.2607.39 So2607.71 there's2607.87 nothing?2608.11 There2608.59 is2608.75 nothing.2608.91 No.2609.39 We,2609.71 before2610.27 the2610.75 outgoing2611.39 administration2611.79 left,2612.35 did2612.75 do2612.99 some2613.07 work2613.23 vetting2613.87 this2614.27 legislation2614.43 with2615.09 them.2615.34 This2615.49 has2615.82 been2615.89 a2616.06 long2616.14 time2616.3 in2616.54 the2616.61 making,2616.7 and2617.57 they2617.82 didn't2618.06 raise2618.3 anything.2618.61 Of2619.02 course,2619.09 the2619.26 current2619.41 administration2619.74 is2620.38 a2620.54 different2620.61 administration.2620.93 So,2622.14 you2622.38 know,2622.45 we2622.7 would2622.86 have2623.09 to2623.26 go2623.34 through2623.49 that2623.66 process2623.82 again.2624.22 Their2624.54 interpretation2624.93 of2625.41 the2625.49 law2625.57 seems2625.82 to2626.06 be2626.14 a2626.22 little2626.3 different.2626.54
2627.34 SPEAKER162627.34 -2627.34 Thank2627.34 you.2627.97 Yes.2628.3 Thank2628.54 you.2628.78
2629.55 SPEAKER12629.55 -2629.55 Thank2629.55 you.2629.79
2630.11 SPEAKER52630.11 -2630.11 Thank2630.11 you2630.51 so2630.75 much.2630.91
2631.39 SPEAKER12631.39 -2631.39 And2631.39 you2631.55 did2631.71 it.2631.87
2632.23 SPEAKER172632.23 -2632.23 I2632.23 did.2632.59
2632.83 SPEAKER52632.83 -2632.83 In2632.83 32632.99 minutes2633.31 and2633.63 before2633.71 we2633.95 got2634.03 called.2634.35 Thank2634.67 you.2634.83
FARLEY-BOUVIER2635.87 -2635.87 Up2635.87 next2636.19 is2636.43 Andrew2636.75 Kingman,2637.23 and2637.95 then2638.19 we're2638.35 gonna2638.59 go2638.91 online2639.39 for2640.43 Chris2640.67 Gilrayne.2641.23 Sir2643.78 Kingman,2644.02 welcome.2644.57 Okay.2646.41 We're2651.78 having2652.26 a2652.41 little2652.57 tech2652.74 issue2652.97 here.2653.22 I'm2653.38 sorry.2653.61
2654.09 SPEAKER72654.09 -2654.09 No2654.09 We're2654.43
2654.59 SPEAKER12654.59 -2654.59 gonna2654.59 share.2654.75 We2655.23 can2655.31 share.2655.39
ANDREW2656.83 KINGMAN2656.83 -2656.83 MARINER2656.83 STRATEGIES2656.83 LLC2656.83 -2656.83 Good2656.83 to2657.07 go.2657.15 Can2657.47 folks2657.71 hear2657.95 me2658.11 okay?2658.27 Yeah.2658.59 Good2659.47 afternoon,2659.71 Madam2661.23 Chair,2661.55 Mister2661.55 Chair,2661.55 and2661.55 members2661.55 of2661.87 the2662.03 committee.2662.11
2662.59 FARLEY-BOUVIER2662.59 -2662.59 Bring2662.59 that2662.75 mic.2662.91
2665.23 KINGMAN2665.23 -2665.23 My2665.23 name2665.39 is2665.55 Andrew2665.79 Kingman.2666.19 I2667.07 represent2667.23 the2667.63 State2668.11 Privacy2668.55 and2668.55 Security2668.72 Coalition.2669.03 We're2670.07 a2670.39 Massachusetts-based2671.52 coalition2672.55 representing2672.55 about2673.59 352673.91 companies2674.47 and2674.95 62675.2 trade2675.52 associations2675.84 across2676.55 a2676.88 number2677.03 of2677.28 different2677.43 sectors.2677.84 I2678.39 also2678.55 have2678.8 a2678.88 background2678.95 as2679.36 a2679.52 privacy2679.59 compliance2680.07 attorney2680.72 helping2681.59 businesses2682.07 work2683.47 through2683.71 various2684.03 state2684.43 privacy2684.75 laws.2685.15 Here2686.19 today2686.35 to2686.75 consider2686.91 42687.79 different2688.11 privacy2688.59 frameworks,2689.07 plus2690.51 a2690.83 number2690.91 of2691.23 sectoral2691.31 bills,2691.87 which2692.27 begs2692.59 the2692.91 question,2693.07 how2693.47 should2693.71 Massachusetts2694.03 proceed2694.83 and2695.23 navigate2695.39 this?2695.79 I2696.84 don't2696.93 wanna2697.09 sit2697.32 here2697.57 and2697.89 tell2698.05 you2698.29 that2698.45 there's2698.61 a2698.93 perfect2699.32 privacy2699.81 framework.2700.29 In2701.24 my2701.49 experience,2701.64 these2702.13 frameworks2702.36 represent2702.93 a2703.49 series2703.57 of2703.97 choices2704.13 and2704.61 trade-offs2705.09 that2705.32 legislators2705.64 must2706.84 make.2707.16 I'd2707.72 like2707.89 to2708.13 discuss,2708.29 in2708.61 particular,2708.77 HB2709.41 80,2709.81 which2710.64 is2710.8 the2711.04 framework2711.2 that2711.68 currently2711.92 covers2712.4 over2712.88 a2713.2 hundred2713.36 million2713.68 US2714.32 consumers,2714.72 has2715.68 been2715.84 adopted2716.08 on2716.64 a2716.8 bipartisan2716.96 basis2717.76 in2718.56 Connecticut,2718.8 Rhode2719.52 Island,2719.76 New2720.4 Hampshire,2720.56 and2721.36 152721.6 other2722.16 states,2722.48 and2723.52 is2723.68 the2723.92 only2724 frame2724.24 currently2724.84 effect2725.32 in2725.64 these2725.8 other2726.05 states2726.36 other2726.76 than2727.01 California.2727.4
2729.8 HB2729.8 80,2730.28 which2730.53 is2730.76 the2730.92 mass2731.57 comprehensive2732.28 Massachusetts2732.92 Consumer2733.57 Data2733.96 Privacy2734.2 Act,2734.68 which2734.92 is2735.16 different2735.48 today2735.89 than2736.2 the2736.44 Massachusetts2737.09 Consumer2737.72 Privacy2738.05 Act2738.44 and2738.48 the2738.51 Massachusetts2738.76 Data2739.48 Privacy2739.97 Act,2740.97 keeps2742.05 Massachusetts2742.69 consumers2743.41 and2744.13 businesses2744.45 integrated2745.33 with2745.89 the2746.05 rest2746.21 of2746.45 the2746.61 New2746.77 England2746.93 economy2747.33 because2747.81 it's2748.45 the2748.69 same2748.77 framework2749.01 that2749.65 other2749.81 states2750.05 are2750.85 currently2751.01 implementing.2751.98 It2752.86 establishes2753.11 heightened2753.66 restrictions2754.14 for2754.7 reproductive2755.03 health2755.59 data2755.91 for2756.95 children2757.34 data,2757.82 and2758.14 does2758.3 so2758.55 in2758.78 a2759.03 way2759.11 that2759.26 has2759.51 not2759.66 triggered2759.82 litigation2760.22 in2761.03 other2761.18 states,2761.43 along2762.63 with2762.86 heightened2763.43 protections2763.82 for2764.39 geolocation2764.63 data,2765.51 biometric2766.22 data,2766.95 etcetera.2767.26 It2768.6 uses2768.76 a2769.16 data2769.24 minimization2769.64 standard2770.44 that2770.92 currently2771.08 covers2771.88 or2772.52 is2772.76 consistent2773 with2773.64 over2773.88 600,000,0002774.12 consumers2775.64 globally,2776.28 including2777.16 the2777.96 European2778.2 GDPR2778.68 standard,2779.24 and2779.64 is2779.8 consistent2779.96 with2780.44 what2781.32 exists2781.56 in2781.96 California.2782.12
2783.86 With2784.34 regard2784.34 to2784.34 advertising,2784.97 sales2785.93 of2786.26 data,2786.41 sensitive2787.3 data,2787.86 and2788.34 when2788.49 consent2788.82 is2789.21 required,2789.45 it2789.93 is2790.09 very2790.26 clear2790.57 and2790.97 understandable.2791.45 And2792.49 in2792.73 my2792.89 experience,2793.21 clarity2794.34 in2794.97 a2795.14 law2795.3 equals2796.14 compliance.2797.02 The2797.58 more2797.82 that2798.14 businesses2798.3 can2798.86 understand2799.26 what's2800.54 required2800.86 of2801.26 them,2801.42 the2802.22 easier2802.54 and2803.1 better2803.26 it2803.58 is2803.74 for2804.14 compliance,2804.46 which2805.1 is2805.26 better2805.82 for2806.14 consumers.2806.46 In2809.03 contrast,2809.36 a2810.32 number2810.39 of2810.64 the2810.8 other2810.88 frameworks2811.19 today2811.84 would2812.71 create,2813.43 would2814.8 be2815.03 novel,2815.28 distinct2816.47 even2817.11 from,2817.51 which2818.8 was2818.95 brought2819.19 up.2819.43 The2820.23 data2820.47 provisions2821.4 in2822.2 some2822.44 of2822.68 those2822.76 frameworks2823 are2823.56 very2823.72 concerning2824.04 because2824.52 companies2824.84 don't2825.8 know2826.04 what's2826.68 expected2827 of2827.48 them2827.56 or2827.96 how2828.2 to2828.52 comply2828.76 at2829.48 this2829.64 point.2829.8 They2831.32 also,2831.64 unintentionally,2832.04 clearly,2833 but2833.48 unintentionaly,2833.72 can2835.08 have2835.32 the2835.48 effect2835.64 of2835.96 depriving2836.2 marginalized2836.95 populations2838.16 of2838.88 goods2839.03 and2839.28 services2839.51 designed2840.16 for2840.47 them.2840.64 And,2841.91 they2843.2 can2843.43 make2843.68 it2843.91 harder2844.16 for2844.64 Massachusetts2845.51 businesses2846.16 to2847.28 reach2847.36 their2847.68 own2847.84 customers2848.16 than2848.64 it2848.88 is2848.95 for2849.25 those2849.49 Massachusetts2849.73 businesses2850.21 to2850.69 reach2850.93 customers,2851.17 again,2852.05 in2852.37 New2852.53 Hampshire,2852.77 Connecticut,2854.13 and2854.93 Rhode2855.25 Island.2855.49 All2856.93 of2857.17 these2857.33 issues2858.29 are2858.69 exacerbated2859.01 by2859.89 the2860.05 existence2860.21 of2860.85 a2861.01 private2861.09 right2861.49 of2861.65 action,2861.81 which2862.86 HB2863.09 802863.57 does2863.97 not2864.22 have.2864.45 I2865.49 see2865.74 that2865.89 I'm2866.05 out2866.22 of2866.38 time,2866.61 so2867.09 I2867.74 will2867.97 stop2868.53 here2868.78 and2869.01 be2869.49 happy2869.49 to2869.82 answer2869.97 any2870.22 questions.2870.45
FARLEY-BOUVIER-2872.05 Sure.2872.05 Representative2873.26 Owens.2873.89 Okay.2874.3
2874.86 REP2874.86 OWEN-2874.86 Great.2874.86 Well,2875.74 you2876.05 ended2876.53 at2877.26 exactly2877.34 the2877.74 right2877.82 time2878.04 because2878.2 that2878.36 was2878.44 my2878.6 question.2878.76 Because2879.08 I2879.24 noticed2879.48 that2880.2 HB2880.44 802880.76 did2881.08 not2881.24 have2881.4 a2881.56 private2881.64 right2881.96 of2882.12 action.2882.2
2882.36 KINGMAN2882.36 -2882.36 It2882.36 does2882.52 not.2882.68
2883.56 OWEN2883.56 -2883.56 Have2883.56 you2883.8 had2884.12 conversations2884.52 with2885.08 the2885.32 attorney2885.4 general's2885.88 office2886.28 about2886.68 her2887.24 being2887.48 the2887.72 author2887.96 or2888.28 her2888.52 office2888.68 being2889 the2889.16 authority2889.32 for2889.72 this?2889.88 And2890.44 can2890.6 you2890.84 talk2890.92 a2891.24 little2891.32 bit2891.56 more2891.8 about2892.12 why2895.22 that2895.39 is2895.86 so2896.18 problematic2896.43 for2898.66 the2898.98 folks2899.14 that2899.3 you2899.46 represent?2899.7
2901.07 KINGMAN2901.07 -2901.07 Sure.2901.07 We2902.26 have2902.51 not2902.66 yet2903.3 talked2903.55 with2903.55 the2903.7 attorney2903.86 general's2904.26 office2904.74 about2905.3 that2905.63 issue.2906.64 I2907.12 would2907.28 note2907.44 that2907.76 no2908 other2908.24 privacy2908.56 statute,2909.52 no2910.4 other2910.56 comprehensive2910.88 privacy2911.68 law2912.16 in2912.4 the2912.48 country,2912.64 has2913.6 a2913.92 private2914.08 right2914.48 of2914.72 action.2914.88 California2915.76 does2916.4 have2916.56 a2916.8 limited2916.88 private2917.36 right2917.68 of2917.92 action2918.08 for2918.48 only2918.84 certain2919.16 types2919.64 of2920.05 data2920.36 breaches2920.68 but2921.81 not2922.05 for2922.2 privacy2922.53 violations.2923.32 What2926.13 we2926.36 are2926.61 seeing2926.84 is2927.24 states2927.64 with2927.97 attorney2928.2 general2928.61 enforcement2929.16 staff2929.89 up2930.2 their2930.53 offices2930.77 to2932.05 have2932.37 their2932.77 own2932.93 data2933.25 privacy2933.49 units2934.05 or2934.37 to2934.69 bring2934.85 on2935.09 data2935.25 privacy2935.57 attorneys2936.05 to2936.53 help2936.69 with2936.85 that2937.09 enforcement.2937.33 And2938.21 we're2938.37 seeing2938.61 that2938.93 pay2939.17 off2939.41 with2939.73 consumer2940.05 education2940.61 of2941.73 the2941.97 rights2942.13 that2942.93 consumers2943.17 have,2943.73 of2944.3 the2944.46 obligations2944.7 that2945.18 are2945.26 expected2945.51 of2945.82 businesses,2946.07 and2947.43 in2947.82 enforcement2948.63 actions2949.34 that2950.46 those2950.86 offices2951.18 are2951.82 taking.2952.07 The2952.94 reason2953.11 that2953.34 we2953.51 oppose2953.66 a2954.46 private2954.55 right2954.94 of2955.11 action2955.26 is2956.14 simply2956.55 that2956.94 they2957.74 don't2957.91 work,2958.22 and2958.55 we2958.7 have2958.98 seen2959.14 them2959.3 abused2959.54 in2959.94 other2960.18 states.2960.5 Studies2961.14 have2961.62 shown2961.78 that2962.1 funds2962.9 recovered2963.3 by2964.02 class2965.3 action2965.62 lawsuits2966.02 and2966.42 private2966.66 rights2966.98 of2967.3 action2967.38 go2967.78 to2968.02 the2968.18 trial2968.34 attorneys2968.66 and2969.22 don't2970.26 make2970.5 their2970.66 way2970.9 to2971.14 consumers,2971.3 privacy2971.64 laws.2977.95 Again,2979.64 no2979.88 comprehensive2980.11 data2980.84 privacy2981.16 laws.2981.39 We've2982.2 seen2982.51 trial2983.55 lawyers2983.8 abuse2984.2 the2984.59 private2984.76 rights2985.07 of2985.32 action2985.47 in2986.2 those2986.28 states,2986.59 and2987.24 we2987.59 don't2987.67 believe2987.83 it's2988.15 the2988.39 right2988.55 solution2988.71 for2989.19 a2989.91 state2990.07 to2990.39 take2991.03 on.2991.27 And,2991.75 again,2991.99 no2992.39 other2992.55 state2992.79 has2993.19 done2993.59 that.2993.75 That's2994.07 blue2994.31 states,2994.63 red2994.95 states.2995.27 There's2995.91 no2996.23 partisan2997.03 split2998.15 there.2998.47
3002.07 OWEN3002.07 -3002.07 You3002.07 heard3002.07 Senator3002.07 Creem3002.07 before;3002.07 we3002.07 do3002.07 like3002.07 to3002.07 be3002.07 first,3002.07 so3002.07 be3002.07 first.3002.23
FARLEY-BOUVIER3004.88 -3004.88 All3004.88 set.3005.11 Is3005.43 anybody3005.91 else3005.91 over3006.08 here?3006.32 On3007.91 this3007.99 side?3008.24 Rep.3008.8 Meschino?3009.04 Oh,3010.16
3012.24 REP3012.24 MESCHINO3012.24 -3012.24 So3012.24 thank3012.47 you3012.64 for3012.8 your3012.95 testimony.3013.04 You3014.32 started3014.47 off3014.8 by3015.04 introducing3015.28 the3016.14 state3016.14 privacy3016.62 and3017.1 security3017.34 coalition.3017.98
3018.86 KINGMAN3018.86 -3018.86 Yes.3018.86
3019.34 MESCHINO3019.34 -3019.34 Who3019.34 are3019.58 the3019.74 members?3019.9 Who3020.38 do3020.54
3020.7 SPEAKER163020.7 -3020.7 you3020.7 represent?3020.94
KINGMAN3021.22 -3021.22 We3021.22 have3021.5 353021.66 companies,3022.06 and3022.54 I3022.94 probably3023.58 would3023.98 forget3024.22 some,3024.62 so3024.86 I3025.02 won't3025.34 list3025.58 them3025.82 all3025.9 here.3026.06 No.3026.22
3026.38 MESCHINO3026.38 -3026.38 I'd3026.38 like3026.46 you3026.62 to3026.78 give3026.94 me3027.18 some3027.42 examples.3027.66
3028.22 KINGMAN3028.22 -3028.22 They're3028.22 on3028.43 our3028.59 website.3028.74 You3029.14 can3029.3 visit3029.39 our3029.7 website3029.86 at3030.27 spsc.org,3030.91 and3032.18 that's3032.34 the3032.66 best3032.82 place3032.99 to3033.3 find3033.47 out.
3034.34 MESCHINO3034.51 -3034.51 So3034.51 you3034.51 are3034.51 not3034.51 prepared3034.51 to3034.51 answer3034.59 that3034.91 question.3034.99 Okay.3035.39 So3037.47 I3037.7 was3037.79 struck3038.18 by3038.59 your3038.82 remark3039.22 about3040.18 choices3040.43 and3040.91 frameworks3041.07 and3041.63 integrating3041.86 into3042.34 the3042.59 rest3042.74 of3042.91 the3043.07 New3043.22 England3043.39 economy,3043.7 and3044.47 that3044.71 it3044.79 needs3044.95 to3045.27 be3045.35 clear3045.51 and3045.83 understandable.3046.23 What3048.47 part3048.47 of3048.47 don't3048.47 sell3048.47 our3048.47 data3048.47 was3048.47 not3048.47 clear3048.47 and3048.47 understandable3048.47 to3048.47 you?3048.47 part3048.71 of3049.03 don't3049.75 sell3049.99 our3050.23 data3050.39 was3050.71 not3051.03 clear3051.27 and3052.07 understandable3052.39 to3053.35 you?3053.51
KINGMAN3055.51 -3055.51 What3055.51 bill3056.23 specifically3056.63 are3057.43 you3057.59 referring3057.83 to?3058.39 So3059.57 I3060.76 think,3060.84 HB3062.61 783062.84 that3063.41 one3063.89 of3064.05 the3064.2 concerns3064.84 that3065.24 we3065.48 have3065.64 there3065.89 is3066.28 that,3066.61 the3067.72 definition3067.89 of3068.76 sale3069.48 as3069.89 it3070.13 is3070.28 evolved3070.53 through3071.01 privacy3071.32 work3071.96 groups,3072.2 and3073.25 throughout3073.65 its3074.37 adoption3074.69 across3075.25 the,3075.65 other3076.53 states3076.77 that3077.09 have3077.25 adopted3077.57 this3077.97 framework3078.13 has3079.17 been3079.41 defined3080.53 intentionally3081.33 to3082.13 really3082.53 cover3082.85 any3083.25 transfer3083.57 of3084.37 data,3084.61 not3086.05 just3086.2 what3086.61 businesses3087.24 would3087.81 think3088.05 of3088.29 as3088.61 a3088.85 sale,3089.01 or3090.2 what3090.45 consumers3090.68 would3091.33 think3091.49 of3091.72 as3092.05 a3092.29 sale.3092.45 Right?3092.77 Just3093.01 I3093.72 give3093.89 you3094.05 data,3094.2 you3094.53 give3094.68 me3094.85 money.3095.01 It's3095.72 really3096.05 any3096.37 transfer3096.61 of3097.09 data3097.43 in3097.59 exchange3097.83 for3098.23 any3098.39 monetary3098.63 or3099.19 other3099.51 valuable3099.75 consideration.3100.47
3101.27 MESCHINO3101.27 -3101.27 So3101.27 any3101.51 transaction.3101.75 Okay.3102.39
3102.87 KINGMAN3102.87 -3102.87 So3102.87 virtually3103.11 any3103.59 transaction.3103.83 HB3105.83 783106.23 includes3107.59 a3107.99 definition,3108.15 a3108.95 term3109.11 transfer,3109.51 which3111.27 is,3111.75 I3112.55 think,3112.93 from3113.09 a3113.32 compliance3113.48 standpoint,3114.05 would3114.68 be3114.84 virtually3115.01 indistinguishable3115.41 from3116.45 the3116.68 definition3116.84 of3117.32 sale.3117.57 But3118.45 the3119.09 bill3119.32 attaches3119.64 very3120.28 different3120.68 obligations3121.24 for3122.05 sale3122.36 versus3122.84 the3123.24 obligations3123.41 it3124.13 has3124.28 on3124.61 transferring3124.84 data,3125.02 and3125.19 those3126.47 are3126.75 the3127.03 types3127.35 of3127.51 ambiguities,3127.59 again,3128.15 that3128.39 I3128.79 think,3128.91 from3129.03 a3129.27 compliance3129.35 standpoint,3129.75 makes3130.39 it3130.55 very3130.63 difficult,3131.03 and3131.51 that3131.67 would3131.75 be3131.99 further3132.15 exacerbated3132.55 by3133.75 a3133.83 PRA.3133.99
3135.51 MESCHINO3135.51 -3135.51 But3135.51 we3135.75 managed3135.91 to3136.23 do3136.39 that3136.47 with3136.63 HIPAA,3136.79 and3137.75 it3138.55 seems3138.79 to3139.03 me3139.19 you're3139.35 splitting3139.43 hairs.3139.91 So3140.95 if3141.27 you3141.51 are3141.66 collecting3141.82 data3142.22 and3142.78 you're3143.03 transferring3143.34 it3144.14 for3144.39 a3144.7 monetary3144.78 purpose.3145.34
KINGMAN3146.86 -3146.86 That's3146.86 correct,3147.18 which3147.51 is3147.74 why3147.91 having3148.22 different3148.55 obligations3149.03 on3149.59 the3149.82 definition3149.91 of3150.47 transfer3150.7 and3151.18 the3151.34 definition3151.51 of3151.99 sale3152.14 would3152.55 be3152.86 very3153.18 difficult3153.51 because3153.99 almost3155.32 any3155.64 transfer3156.04 of3156.52 data,3156.84 under3157.8 HB3158.52 803160.28 or3161.4 HB3161.4 78,3161.88 would3162.36 be3162.52 considered3162.68 a3163.16 sale.3163.32 But3163.56 s,o3164.52 trying3164.84 to3165.16 distinguish3165.4 what3165.96 the3166.28 compliance3166.6 obligations3167.32 are3167.88 between3168.2 a3168.52 sale3168.68 and3168.92 a3169.08 transfer3169.3 are3170.49 very3170.74 difficult.3170.97
3171.54 MESCHINO3171.54 -3171.54 So3171.54 I3171.7 think3171.78 you3171.93 just3172.09 explained3172.34 that3172.66 it3172.82 is3172.97 actually3173.14 consistent,3173.93 and3174.58 it3174.82 is3174.97 actually3175.22 clear.3175.7 The3176.82 other3176.97 thing3177.22 I3177.38 just3177.54 wanted3177.7 to3178.02 say3178.09 was,3178.34 could3180.26 you3180.49 talk3180.66 a3180.89 little3180.97 bit3181.22 about3181.38 depriving3182.74 marginalized3184.21 from3185.09 the3185.41 marginalized3185.73 from3186.53 services3187.01 designed3187.81 for3188.29 them?3188.45 What3189.41 is3189.73 that?3189.89
3190.85 KINGMAN3190.85 -3190.85 Sure.3190.85 So3191.33 the3195.25 age3195.25 783195.57 and3196.29 a3196.45 number3196.61 of3196.85 the3197.01 other3197.17 bills3197.41 have3198.05 extensive3202.18 definitions3202.18 of3202.74 what3202.89 constitutes3203.22 sensitive3203.86 data,3204.34 and3205.38 then3205.62 targeted3206.18 advertising3206.82 is3207.7 prohibited3208.18 using3208.97 sensitive3209.38 data.3210.02 And3211.06 so3211.38 you3211.86 may3212.1 have,3212.41 veterans3213.7 who3214.56 would3214.8 have,3215.04 discount3215.76 programs3216.32 or3216.88 particular3217.12 products3217.6 that3218.4 would3218.64 be3218.8 meant3218.88 for3219.2 them.3219.36 And3220.08 due3220.32 to3220.48 the3220.8 data3221.2 minimization3221.52 rules3222.32 in3222.72 these3222.96 bills3223.52 and3223.92 the3224.16 prohibition3224.24 on3224.8 targeted3225.36 advertising3226 based3226.56 on3226.88 sensitive3227.04 data,3227.6 those3228.48 types3228.8 of3229.04 activities3229.46 may3229.78 not3230.11 or3230.59 products3230.82 or3231.14 services3231.3 may3231.86 not3232.11 get3232.34 to3232.51 them.3232.59 Think3233.7 of3234.03 products3234.98 or3235.39 services3235.55 designed3236.18 for3236.91 the3237.55 LGBTQ3237.7 community3238.82 or3239.94 things3240.43 along3240.82 those3241.14 lines.3241.39 If3242.15 there3242.55 are3242.71 no3242.87 if3243.27 there's3243.43 no3243.67 ability3243.91 to3244.39 make3245.99 them3246.23 aware3246.39 of3246.79 products3246.87 or3247.19 services3247.35 based3248.23 on3248.55 that,3248.71 then,3248.95 you3250.15 know,3250.31 we3250.55 think3251.03 that3251.35 that's3251.43 concerning.3251.83 Under3252.63 HP3253.03 80,3253.35 they3253.67 would3253.75 have3253.99 the3254.15 opportunity3254.39 to3255.2 provide3257.04 consent3257.43 or3258.24 opt3258.64 out3258.88 of3259.04 targeted3259.28 advertising3259.84 to3260.32 say,3260.47 I3260.6 don't3260.72 want3261.04 that3261.28 to3261.43 happen.3261.68 So,3261.99 but3264.16 just3264.39 an3264.64 outright3264.8 prohibition,3265.2 we3265.84 think,3265.99 could3267.04 have3267.2 some3267.43 of3267.59 those3267.68 unintended3267.91
MESCHINO3270.02 -3270.02 so3270.02 it3270.42 does3270.66 seem3270.9 that3271.06 you3271.3 are3271.38 capable3271.62 of3272.9 the3272.98 opt3273.22 out,3273.46 but3274.66 I3274.82 would3274.98 argue3275.62 it3276.1 should3276.26 be3276.5 an3276.58 opt3276.74 in.3276.98
3277.86 KINGMAN3277.86 -3277.86 Well,3277.86 there3278.02 is3278.26 opt-in3278.74 consent3278.98 for3279.46 sensitive3279.7 data3280.26 in3280.66 HB3280.82 80,3281.3 which3281.62 we're3282.26 fine3282.49 with.3282.82 There's3283.3 just3283.54 not3283.78 an3283.93 outright3284.18 prohibition3284.66 on3285.38 targeted3285.54 advertising3286.18 using3286.66 that.3286.82 It's3287.06 up3287.22 to3287.38 the3287.54 consumer3287.7 to3288.18 decide3288.41 whether3288.74 they3289.06 want3289.7 that3290.02 information3290.18 to3290.82 be3290.97 collected3291.14 at3291.62 all3291.78 in3291.86 the3292.1 first3292.18 place3292.41 or3293.45 to3293.78 be3293.86 processed3294.74 for3295.22 that3295.45 type3296.1 of3296.26 activity.3296.49
MESCHINO-3297.78 You3297.78 might3297.93 wanna3298.1 rethink3298.36 your3298.68 idea3298.84 of3299.16 marginalized3299.4 because3299.96 I'll3300.28 go3300.44 on3300.6 the3300.76 record3300.84 of3301.08 saying3301.16 I3301.4 don't3301.56 want3301.8 you3301.96 to3302.12 capture3302.2 that3302.68 for3302.92 me,3303.08 and3303.32 I3303.48 don't3303.64 feel3303.88 that3304.12 I3304.28 am.3304.44
KINGMAN3305.96 -3305.96 And3305.96 we3306.36 believe3306.52 everybody3306.84 should3307.4 have3307.56 that3307.72 choice.3307.88
3309.08 SPEAKER73309.08 -3309.08 Thank3309.08 you.3309.4
3309.48 FARLEY-BOUVIER3309.48 -3309.48 Thank3309.48 you.3309.64 Anybody3309.96 else?3310.36 Representative3310.84 Vitolo?3311.56
VITOLO3313.28 -3313.28 Good3313.28 afternoon,3313.59 and3313.99 thank3314.23 you3314.39 for3314.8 being3315.11 here.3315.36 I3316.39 want3316.47 you3316.64 to3316.8 know3316.88 that3317.11 I3317.28 believe3317.91 in3318.32 you.3318.47 I3319.11 am3319.36 not3319.43 an3319.68 attorney.3319.91 I3320.71 have3320.8 colleagues3321.11 who3321.68 are3321.91 attorneys.3322.07 I3323.36 think3323.51 the3323.76 world3323.91 of3324.23 them;3324.39 I3325.26 know3325.5 they're3325.74 fully3325.98 capable3326.3 of3326.7 reading.3326.86 You're3327.18 the3327.26 one,13327.42 then.3327.66 Well,3328.22 that3328.46 may3328.62 be.3328.86 But3329.1 I3329.5 know3329.66 they're3329.9 fully3330.14 capable3330.46 of3330.86 reading3331.02 state3331.74 laws3332.06 in3332.38 different3332.54 states3332.94 and3333.58 understanding3333.9 the3334.46 differences.3334.62 And3335.66 I3335.9 believe3335.98 in3336.3 you,3336.46 and3336.62 I3336.78 believe3336.94 you3337.26 believe3337.66 in3338.42 me.3338.42 So3338.42 frankly,3338.66 this3339.14 idea3339.46 that3339.94 we3340.66 can't3340.9 have3341.22 a3341.46 patchwork,3341.55 I3342.18 find3342.51 absurd.3342.82 My3344.51 job3344.9 is3345.63 to3345.86 create3346.03 a3346.42 patchwork3346.51 of3346.98 laws3347.14 in3347.46 this3347.63 nation.3348.26 If3349.07 we3349.46 didn't3349.63 have3349.94 a3350.03 patchwork3350.11 of3350.51 laws,3350.59 we3350.9 wouldn't3351.07 have3351.39 jobs.3351.55 We3351.86 would3351.94 just3352.11 have3352.26 a3352.55 US3352.63 Congress.3352.87 Right?3353.51
3354.15 So3354.15 I3354.71 push3354.95 back3355.19 strongly3355.59 on3356.07 the3356.31 idea3356.39 that3356.79 you3357.03 and3357.27 your3357.43 colleagues3357.67 are3358.87 incapable3359.11 of3361.11 reading3361.27 MGL3361.67 and3362.55 understanding3362.79 what3363.35 we3363.59 expect3363.75 in3364.15 our3364.31 commonwealth,3364.47 and3365.75 reading3365.99 the3366.23 laws3366.31 of3366.55 the3366.71 great3366.79 state3367.03 of3367.27 North3367.35 Carolina,3367.59 and3368.23 figuring3368.53 out3368.77 what3368.85 they3368.93 want.3369.24 I3369.57 believe3369.64 in3369.97 you.3370.2 I3370.45 just3371.16 wholeheartedly3372.13 push3372.84 back3373.09 on3373.32 this3373.49 idea3373.72 that3374.36 we3374.61 should3374.77 have3374.93 a3375.16 single3375.32 set3375.64 of3376.13 laws3376.29 in3376.84 this3377.01 United3377.24 States3377.64 on3377.97 issues3378.2 that3378.53 affect3378.77 us,3379.09 personally3380.13 and3380.68 culturally.3380.93 And3381.72 it3381.89 just3382.05 might3382.29 be3382.45 that3382.68 the3382.84 great3383.34 state3383.5 of3383.58 Massachusetts3383.98 has3384.94 a3385.1 different3385.26 idea3385.58 of3385.98 privacy3386.22 than3386.78 even3387.26 my3387.66 state,3387.98 that3388.3 I3388.46 was3388.54 born3388.7 and3389.02 raised3389.1 in,3389.34 Connecticut.3389.5 And3390.22 frankly,3390.46 I'm3390.86 okay3391.1 with3391.34 that,3391.5 and3391.66 I3391.98 think3392.14 the3392.38 people3392.46 in3392.7 this3392.86 room3393.02 are3393.26 as3393.5 well.3393.66 I3394.3 hope3394.46 that3395.5 you3395.82 and3396.62 your3397.18 colleagues3397.5 make3398.39 lots3398.63 of3398.95 money3399.18 figuring3400.3 out3400.7 the3400.86 difference3401.03 in3401.74 these3401.91 503402.39 sets3402.7 of3403.03 laws,3403.18 and3403.99 I3404.78 wish3404.95 you3405.27 godspeed3405.43 in3406.07 doing3406.14 that.3406.47
KINGMAN3407.66 -3407.66 Yeah.3407.66 Well,3408.07 I3409.03 suspect3409.27 we3409.66 would,3409.91 I,3410.14 you3410.3 know,3410.47 I3410.63 think3410.95 we3411.11 disagree.3411.27 I3411.74 think3411.82 our3413.34 position3413.43 is3414.41 that,3414.57 you3414.89 know,3415.05 I'm3415.29 a3415.53 Massachusetts3415.69 resident.3416.33 I3416.81 travel3417.05 to3417.37 New3417.53 New3417.77 Hampshire.3418.01 I3418.49 travel3418.65 to3419.13 Maine3419.37 all3419.69 the3419.85 time.3419.93 I3420.41 think3420.49 it3420.65 makes3420.73 sense3420.97 to3421.29 have3421.37 consistent3421.61 expectations.3422.25 I3423.13 think,3423.29 as3423.85 a3424.09 consumer,3424.17 in3424.97 terms3425.13 of3425.37 what3425.45 my3425.69 rights3425.85 are,3426.53 I3426.86 think3427.09 it3427.26 makes3427.41 sense3427.66 for3427.89 businesses3428.7 to3429.26 have3429.41 consistent3429.74 expectations3430.3 of3430.86 what's3431.01 expected3431.34 of3431.74 them3431.89 across3432.22 state3432.61 lines.3432.93 So3433.66 understanding3433.97 that,3434.53 you3435.49 know,3435.57 it3435.97 may,3436.45 you3436.86 know,3437.01 a3437.26 Massachusetts3437.41 business3438.14 or3438.61 consumer3438.86 may3440.05 not3440.22 mind3440.45 whether3441.26 this3442.07 framework3442.39 works3442.95 with3443.19 Oregon3444.07 or3444.47 Montana.3444.63 I3446.07 think3446.15 it3446.39 makes3446.47 sense3446.71 to3447.03 think3447.11 of3447.35 New3447.51 England3447.75 as3447.99 a3448.15 regional3448.31 economy3448.79 as3449.59 we3449.83 do3449.99 with3450.23 many3450.55 other3450.87 things.3451.11 New3455.35 Hampshire,3455.43 go3455.75 ahead3455.83 and3456.07 advocate3456.15 for3456.47 a3456.71 sales3456.79 tax,3457.73 so3457.82 we3457.97 have3458.05 consistency.3458.45 Right?3459.66 This3459.97 idea3460.21 that3460.45 I3460.61 mean,3460.7 there's3460.93 general3461.34 consistency.3461.82 Right?3462.45 We3462.7 all3462.93 use3463.09 well,3463.57 none3463.73 of3463.82 us3463.97 use3464.05 are3464.38 using3464.45 the3464.7 metric3464.78 system3465.09 in3465.41 our3465.57 measurements,3465.73 except3466.14 for3466.53 23466.7 liters3466.86 of3467.18 soda.3467.34 But3468.61 we3468.86 are3469.18 different3469.34 in3469.73 this3469.89 idea3470.14 that3470.53 we3470.78 should3470.93 be3471.18 uniform3471.81 when3472.21 it3472.45 benefits3472.61 your3473.01 corporation,3473.25 but3474.29 not3474.53 uniform3474.77 in3475.25 other3475.41 ways,3475.65 just3476.05 doesn't3476.29 hold3476.61 water3476.93 with3477.09 me.3477.17
3477.41 KINGMAN3477.41 -3477.41 Well,3477.41 and3477.57 I3478.61 appreciate3478.77 your3480.21 hope3480.45 for3480.77 my3480.93 financial3481.49 success.3482.05 But,3482.53 you3483.97 know,3484.13 I3484.37 think3484.53 what3485.49 I3485.65 would3485.73 say3485.97 is,3486.21 you3486.45 know,3486.61 when3486.85 the3487.01 privacy3487.7 lawyers3488.03 are3488.42 getting3488.59 paid,3488.82 that's3488.98 coming3489.22 out3489.39 of3489.55 the3489.7 business's3489.78 pockets.3490.26 Right?3490.74 And3490.91 I3491.07 think3491.3 you'll3491.46 hear3491.63 from3491.78 some3492.11 of3492.18 the3492.26 small3493.63 or3493.78 the3493.94 Massachusetts-based3494.74 businesses3494.98 today3495.55 about3496.66 the3497.07 consequences3497.3 of3497.94 that3498.11 or3498.26 their3498.34 concerns3498.59 with3498.98 that.3499.14 So3499.39 thank3500.11 you.3500.34
3500.65 SPEAKER133500.65 -3500.65 Thank3500.65 you.3501.05
FARLEY-BOUVIER-3501.69 Madam3501.69 chair,3502.01 I3502.49 just3502.73 wanna3502.89 get3503.13 to3503.29 rep3503.77 Coke,3504.01 quickly3504.65 Mowgli,3505.13 and3505.53 then3505.69 we're3505.85 gonna3506.01 come3506.25 back3506.41 to3506.65 rep3506.89 Peskino.3507.13
3507.77 REP3507.77 MOAKLEY3507.77 -3507.77 Thank3507.77 you,3507.93 Madam3508.41 Chair,3508.65 and3508.65 thank3508.81 you,3508.97 Mister3509.45 Kingman,3509.77 for3510.17 your3510.25 presence3510.41 and3510.73 testimony3510.89 here3511.37 today.3511.61 Just3511.85 wanna3512.01 follow3512.33 up3512.81 on3512.81 some3512.97 of3513.13 representative3513.53 Moschino's3514.09 questions3514.81 about3515.37 the3516.86 industry3517.11 or3517.83 the3518.14 coalition3518.39 that3518.86 you3519.03 represent.3519.18 Sure.3519.59 Do3520.7 you3521.99 have3522.14 clients?3522.86 Would3523.11 it3523.11 be3523.18 fair3523.34 to3523.59 say3523.66 that3523.83 you3523.99 have3524.22 clients3524.39 that3524.79 have3525.03 sold3525.43 privacy3527.03 data3527.99 and3528.31 location3528.47 data?3528.97
3529.29 FARLEY-BOUVIER3529.29 -3529.29 Oh,3529.29 here3530.09 you3530.33 go.3530.73
3531.21 MOAKLEY3531.21 -3531.21 I3531.21 looked3531.37 it3531.53 up.3531.69
3533.53 KINGMAN3533.53 -3533.53 Yes.3533.53 Probably,3533.69 that's3534.49 the3534.81 case,3535.29 given3535.85 the3536.25 broad3536.49 definition3536.89 of3537.45 sale3537.69 here.3538.81 Again,3539.45 any3539.85 transfer3540.17 of3540.89 data3541.05 virtually3541.93 is3542.41 a3542.81 sale.3542.97
MOAKLEY3543.61 -3543.61 And3543.61 would3543.93 you3544.09 be3544.25 able3544.41 to3544.57 estimate3545.11 even3545.42 if3545.66 a3545.82 ballpark3545.91 for3546.3 this3546.55 committee,3546.7 the3547.59 portion3547.74 or3548.14 the3548.3 number3548.46 of3548.78 Massachusetts3548.86 residents3549.51 whose3550.07 data3550.39 has3550.86 been3551.03 sold3551.26 by3551.51 your3551.66 members?3551.91
3552.63 KINGMAN3552.63 -3552.63 No.3552.63
3553.26 MOAKLEY3553.26 -3553.26 And3553.26 how3553.51 about3553.66 the3553.98 amount3554.14 of3554.39 money,3554.55 say,3554.78 in3555.03 2024,3555.18 that3556.07 was3556.3 made3556.55 by3556.78 your3557.11 membership?3557.34 '3557.91
3557.91 KINGMAN3557.91 -3557.91 No.3557.91
3559.11 MOAKLEY3559.11 -3559.11 Thank3559.11 you,3559.34 Madam3560.79 Chair.3560.79
FARLEY-BOUVIER-3560.79 -3560.79 Okay.3560.79 Sure.3561.03 Rep.3561.43 Moschino?3561.75
3562.23 MESCHINO3562.23 -3562.23 Oh,3562.23 well,3562.39 so3562.63 I3562.79 as3563.03 instructed,3563.27 I3563.91 looked3564.07 it3564.23 up,3564.39 and3565.67 it's3566.07 and3567.03 we3567.27 actually3567.43 had,3567.75 Internet,3568.39 so3568.95 I3569.11 could.3569.19 It's3571.03 a3571.91 Virginia-based3572.47 organization.3573.05 Google.3574.49
KINGMAN3574.74 -3574.74 We3574.74 were3574.97 actually3575.22 incorporated3575.61 in3576.18 Massachusetts3576.34 at3576.97 this3577.05 point.3577.22 You're3577.53 probably3577.78 looking3578.18 at3578.49 a3579.14 prior3579.3 year's3579.7 tax3579.93 return.3580.26
MESCHINO3580.97 -3580.97 No.3580.97 I'm3581.22 looking3581.38 at3581.61 your3581.78 website.3581.93 Meta,3582.89 NetChoice,3583.61 Google,3584.49 Netflix,3585.14 Comcast,3586.7 I3588.3 mean,3588.46 there's3588.86 Nike.3589.34 Yes.3590.06 Those3590.46 are3590.7 all3590.86 your3591.02 members.3591.26
3591.9 KINGMAN3591.9 -3591.9 As3591.9 I3592.06 said,3592.14 we're3592.38 a3592.54 multi-sector3593.02 coalition.3593.42 So3593.82 we3594.06 have3594.14 retailers,3594.7 payment3595.42 card3595.82 companies,3596.14 health3596.7 care3596.94 companies,3597.18 and3597.74 tech3597.74 companies.3597.98
3598.46 MESCHINO3598.46 -3598.46 TechNet.3598.46 So3599.1 Verizon,3599.5 Walgreens,3601.26 Yahoo.3602.53 So3603.09 I3603.34 just3603.49 wanna3603.66 make3603.89 sure3604.05 everyone3604.22 understood3604.61 that3605.09 you3606.38 represent3606.61 pretty3608.22 much3608.45 the3608.93 broad3609.26 spectrum3609.66 of3610.22 every3610.45 single3610.7 place3611.57 that3611.82 we're3612.05 trying3612.3 to3612.7 wrangle.3613.26
KINGMAN3614.01 -3614.01 Yes.3614.01 And3614.25 we3614.49 work3614.73 to3615.05 try3615.21 to3615.45 get3615.61 solutions3615.85 that3616.33 work3616.49 on3616.73 behalf3616.81 of3617.13 all3617.29 sectors3617.61 of3618.25 the3618.33 economy.3618.49
3619.29 FARLEY-BOUVIER3619.29 -3619.29 Thank3619.29 you.3619.53 Thank3619.77 you3620.09 so3620.33 much.3620.49 Is3621.13 anybody3621.69 over3621.69 here?3621.85 I3622.49 do3622.65 have3622.81 a3622.97 couple3623.05 of3623.37 questions.3623.53 Following3625.29 up3625.77 on3626.09 rep3626.41 Mokeley,3626.65 question3627.77 about3628.33 how3628.65 many3628.81 people3629.05 in3629.37 Massachusetts3629.76 you3630.64 think3630.72 their3631.03 data3631.28 has3631.51 been3631.76 sold3631.99 to.3633.36 And3633.36 I'm3633.59 gonna3633.99 guess3634.39 I'm3634.95 gonna3635.2 give3635.43 an3635.68 estimate,3635.84 and3636.47 I3636.64 think3636.8 it's3636.95 7,000,000.3637.2 Because3639.03 I3639.36 think3639.43 every3639.76 resident3640.23 of3640.72 Massachusetts3640.88 has3641.51 had3641.76 their3641.99 data3642.16 sold.3643.03 I3644.14 do3644.3 have3644.38 a3644.42 couple3644.46 of3644.86 questions,3644.94 kind3645.66 of3645.82 specific3647.18 questions..3647.5 I3647.5 very3647.74 much3647.98 appreciate3648.22 your3648.78 presence3648.86 here.3649.18 I'm3649.58 sincere3649.66 in3650.06 that.3650.22 We're3651.1 gonna3651.26 do3651.58 a3651.66 little3651.82 bit3651.98 of3652.14 work,3652.22 though.3652.46 Okay?3652.7 I3653.34 look3653.5 forward3653.66 to3653.98 meeting3654.38 with3654.62 you3654.78 soon3655.02 to3655.9 be3656.14 able3656.38 to3656.62 wrangle3656.78 a3657.1 few3657.18 things3657.34 out.3657.58 You3657.74 mentioned3657.9 Connecticut,3658.3 and3660.03 because3660.34 you3660.59 work3660.66 in3660.99 multiple3661.14 states,3661.55 this3661.95 is3662.43 helpful3662.51 to3662.91 us.3663.07 Again,3665.14 you3665.55 do3665.78 this3666.03 work3666.27 in3666.59 real3666.74 time.3666.99 And3667.3 so3667.47 I'm3667.63 sure3667.78 you're3667.95 familiar3668.11 with3668.59 Senator3668.82 Maroney,3669.22 who's3669.7 a3669.95 Yes.3670.11 National3670.51 leader3670.99 in3671.97 this3672.05 space,3672.21 1356.3673.89 Can3676.61 you3676.85 talk3676.93 to3677.25 me3677.33 about3677.57 that3677.97 bill,3678.21 H3679.65 78,3679.97 and3681.09 the3682.21 original3682.45 Connecticut?3682.85 I3683.41 call3683.49 it3683.65 Connecticut3683.81 1.3684.29 And3685.49 I3685.65 would3685.81 like3686.13 you3686.37 to3686.53 focus3686.69 on3687.09 data3687.55 minimization3687.8 in3688.59 those3688.84 bills.3688.99 Sure.3689.39
3690.03 KINGMAN3690.03 -3690.03 I3690.03 think3690.51 data3690.99 minimization3691.32 is3692.03 13692.19 of3692.43 the3692.59 items3692.99 that's3693.39 under3693.71 discussion3694.03 in3694.76 that3694.91 state3695.16 and3695.8 that,3696.03 you3697.07 know,3697.23 I3697.47 don't3697.8 know3697.95 where3698.19 that's3698.43 going3698.76 to3698.99 end3699.16 up,3699.32 but3700.43 I3700.68 think3700.76 that3700.99 my3701.64 understanding3701.8 is3702.28 that3702.44 that's3702.6 under3702.84 discussion.3703.16 I3704.2 think3704.36 13704.6 of3704.84 the3705.16 benefits3705.64 of3707 that3707.56 we've3707.72 seen3707.96 from3710.44 Senator3710.84 Maroney's3710.84 legislation3711.32 is3713 that3713.24 it's3713.72 a3713.96 framework3714.04 that3714.52 can3714.76 be3714.92 built3715.08 on3715.4 over3715.8 time3716.04 and3718.47 modified.3718.55 So,3719.18 23721.43 years3721.59 ago,3721.99 he3724.3 added,3724.7 protections3725.74 for3726.3 consumer3726.55 health3727.03 data,3727.26 reproductive3728.55 health,3729.26 prevented3729.74 geofencing3730.39 around,3733.05 reproductive3733.61 health3734.17 clinics,3734.49 and3735.93 also3736.25 was,3737.21 worked3738.41 on3738.73 legislation3739.53 that3740.17 added3740.41 on3740.73 and3741.05 added3741.21 protections3741.53 for3742.09 children,3742.25 and,3744.09 things3745.53 like3745.85 making3746.25 sure3746.57 that,3746.89 you3747.41 know,3747.57 children3747.8 are3748.53 notified3748.84 if3749.24 their3749.49 precise3749.72 geolocation3750.2 is3750.84 being3751.01 tracked,3751.32 that3752.2 products3752.53 and3752.84 services3753.01 weren't3753.49 designed3753.8 to3754.24 extend,3754.68 significantly3757.49 extend3758.2 or3758.53 unreasonably3758.93 extend3759.64 their3759.97 time,3760.2 on3760.93 a3761.09 particular3762.96 platform,3763.44 etcetera.3764 And3765.36 then,3765.52 we've3766.16 seen3766.48 the3766.88 status3766.88 of3767.28 a3767.44 victim3767.44 of3768.24 a3768.4 crime3768.56 added3769.04 to3769.52 or3769.92 proposed,3770.32 I3770.8 think,3770.88 this3771.12 year3771.36 to3772.08 the3772.24 definition3772.4 of3772.88 sensitive3773.04 data,3773.44 status3773.84 as3774.16 transgender,3774.32 non-binary3775.28 added.3775.76 It.3776.03 So3776.18 it's3777.22 a3777.46 framework3777.86 that3778.34 has3779.14 proven3779.78 to3780.34 be3780.66 workable3780.82 over3781.55 time3781.86 that3782.26 can3782.51 be3782.66 tweaked3782.74 and3783.07 added3783.22 to,3783.55 I3784.03 guess.3784.18 I3784.42 think3784.51 it3784.74 is3784.74 the3784.98 benefit3785.39 of3785.86 that3786.51 framework3786.74 that's3787.7 reflected3787.86 in3788.42 HB3788.74 803789.14 here.3789.46
3790.26 FARLEY-BOUVIER-3790.26 Okay.3790.26 And3790.74 then3791.81 when3791.89 it3792.13 comes3792.21 to3792.45 I'm3792.61 gonna3792.77 focus3792.93 on3793.25 data3793.33 minimization.3794.85 Because3794.85 that3795.01 seems3795.17 to3795.41 be3795.49 a3795.81 big3795.97 concern.3796.13 Can3797.25 you3797.49 tell3797.65 me3797.89 some3798.21 concerns3798.53 that3799.09 you3799.33 have3799.57 around3802.13 H1043802.37 and3802.37 H783802.77 around3803.41 data3803.65 minimization3803.89 compared3804.69 to3805.09 H3805.25 80?3805.41
3806.72 KINGMAN3806.72 -3806.72 Yes.3806.72 So,3807.28 the3808.88 data3809.11 minimization3809.43 provisions3810.16 that3811.04 are3811.2 reflected3811.36 in3811.84 H3811.99 803813.36 are3814.56 the3814.72 same3814.88 data3815.84 minimization3816.16 standard3816.95 that3817.52 is3817.68 in3817.91 the3818.08 GDPR3818.24 and3819.43 is3819.43 consistent3820.1 with3820.74 California.3820.98 California3821.62 has3822.02 a3822.14 little3822.26 bit3822.42 of3822.58 a3822.74 different3822.82 twist3823.06 and3823.46 is3823.7 consistent3823.86 with3824.34 the3824.58 173825.86 other3826.34 states,3826.66 I3826.98 think,3827.06 that3827.3 that3827.54 have3827.7 adopted3827.94 a3828.98 similar3829.14 framework.3829.62 Maryland,3830.98 as3831.62 you3831.78 know,3831.94 adopted3832.58 a3833.22 very3833.3 different3833.8 framework3834.11 that's3834.59 reflected3834.91 in3836.28 H3836.76 783836.99 as3837.8 well.3837.95 And3838.76 I3838.99 think3839.08 it's3841.56 not3841.8 in3841.95 effect3842.11 yet.3842.43 So,3842.76 we3843.8 don't3844.36 have3844.76 a3845.24 lot3845.39 of3845.56 data3845.72 as3846.11 to3846.28 how3846.43 businesses3846.59 are3847.16 planning3847.39 to3847.72 comply.3847.88 But3848.99 I3849.15 think3849.31 the3849.55 concerns3849.71 are3850.43 a3850.67 couple3850.75 of3851.07 things.3851.07 The3851.55 fact3851.63 is3852.11 that3854.19 the3854.19 data3854.35 that3854.75 can3854.91 be3855.15 collected3855.71 is3856.19 only3856.51 data3857.07 to3858.19 provide3858.35 a3858.75 specific3858.91 product3859.47 or3859.87 service3860.11 requested3860.75 by3861.14 a3861.3 consumer.3861.61
3863.14 There3863.14 are3863.45 concerns3863.61 there3864.26 around3864.89 providing3866.41 product3867.05 recommendations3867.45 based3868.34 on3868.66 prior3868.97 purchasing3869.3 history,3869.78 whether3871.78 a3872.34 company3872.41 can3873.05 provide3874.18 updates3874.82 or3875.45 security3875.78 patches3876.26 to3876.89 an3877.35 app3877.59 because3877.83 that's3878.07 not3878.31 being3878.47 specifically3878.79 requested.3879.43 And3880.79 some3881.59 of3881.83 the3881.91 solutions3882.15 that3882.63 I3882.87 have3883.03 heard3883.27 companies3884.23 talk3884.71 about,3885.03 just3886.55 at3886.87 privacy3887.19 conferences,3887.75 talking3888.39 to3888.79 chief3888.95 privacy3889.27 officers,3889.75 some3890.95 of3891.19 them3891.35 are3891.59 saying,3891.83 we3892.95 may3893.11 just3893.36 put3894.16 Maryland3894.39 in3894.88 a3895.03 different3895.11 bucket3895.52 and3896.32 not3896.64 provide3898.07 those3898.39 updates3898.72 or3899.2 not3899.43 provide3899.59 product3899.91 recommendations3900.32 for3901.52 those3901.84 consumers.3902.16 It3903.43 may3903.68 be3903.91 that3904.98 we3905.54 create3905.7 many3906.58 more3906.82 click-throughs3907.46 that3907.94 consumers3908.34 will3908.98 have3909.22 to3909.46 deal3909.54 with3909.78 because3911.22 we3911.78 have3912.02 to3912.18 create3912.34 a3913.06 regulatory3913.46 trail3914.26 to3914.74 make3914.9 sure3915.14 that,3915.46 you3915.78 know,3915.94 the3916.1 enforcement3916.34 authorities3916.82 know3917.46 that3918.2 the3918.84 that3919.47 the3919.56 consumer3919.8 has3920.28 actually3920.52 requested3920.99 this3921.47 product.3921.72 So,3922.11 that3923.39 may3924.04 be3924.2 13924.99 of3925.24 the3925.32 strategies,3925.47 but3926.68 it3927.24 doesn't3927.8 exist3928.36 anywhere3928.84 else.3929.24 And3929.64 so3929.8 it's3930.68 very3930.91 untested.3931.24
3932.34 I3932.34 think3932.58 the3932.82 other3932.98 concern3933.38 is3934.1 that3934.26 businesses3936.26 may3937.06 take3937.22 different3938.18 approaches3938.74 to3939.62 how3940.1 to3940.34 comply3940.5 with3940.9 that3941.06 versus3941.78 a3942.26 more3942.42 uniform3942.74 hey.3943.22 We3943.46 understand3943.62 what3944.02 the3944.26 standard3944.42 is.3944.82 We3945.61 do3945.76 it3946.01 all3946.16 over3946.32 the3946.57 world.3946.72 We3947.61 know3948.48 how3948.8 to3949.05 do3949.2 that.3949.36 And3949.61 I3949.76 think3949.84 the3950.09 last3950.16 piece3950.57 is3950.8 that,3950.96 you3953.61 know,3953.68 13955.28 of3955.53 the3955.61 benefits3955.84 of3956.72 having3956.96 the3957.98 data3958.22 minimization3958.54 standard3959.42 be3959.98 tied3960.22 to3960.7 although,3961.18 not3962.46 13963.66 of3963.9 the3963.98 benefits3964.22 of3964.54 having3964.7 it3964.94 be3965.02 tied3965.26 to3965.5 a3965.66 privacy3965.82 notice3966.3 is3966.7 that3966.86 enforcement3967.5 authorities3968.06 can3968.62 go3968.78 directly3969.02 to3969.5 the3969.66 privacy3969.82 notice3970.22 to3970.55 say,3970.78 is3971.34 what3971.51 you're3971.74 doing3971.91 consistent3972.3 with3972.86 what3973.11 you're3973.18 telling3973.42 people3973.74 what3974.63 you're3974.78 doing?3975.03 And3975.34 is3975.51 it3975.66 reasonable3975.82 compared,3976.46 you3976.78 know,3976.94 adequate,3977.26 relevant,3977.66 reasonably3978.22 necessary?3978.78 Versus3979.91 if3980.3 a,3981.11 you3981.91 know,3982.07 bad3982.55 actor3982.78 decides3983.44 that3984.4 your3984.56 precise3984.8 geolocation3985.2 data3985.92 or3986.24 your3986.32 biometric3986.56 data3987.12 is3987.52 strictly3987.68 necessary3988.08 to3989.2 provide3989.36 that3989.76 product3989.92 or3990.32 service,3990.48 then3991.44 the3991.76 consumer3991.92 doesn't3992.48 have3992.72 the3992.88 opportunity3993.04 to3994.08 say3994.16 no.3994.48 I3994.56 don't3994.72 want3994.96 you3995.12 to3995.36 collect3995.44 that.3995.84 That's3996.4 where,3996.64 in3996.97 our3997.13 opinion,3997.28 the3997.77 consent3997.93 mechanism3998.41 in3998.97 H3999.2 803999.45 is3999.77 important.4000.41
FARLEY-BOUVIER4001.77 -4001.77 Okay.4001.77 Well,4002.01 thank4002.24 you.4002.49 It4003.93 sounds4004.09 like4004.41 we4004.97 need4005.13 to4005.36 work4005.45 together4005.68 on4006.16 data4006.32 minimization,4006.72 and4007.28 we4007.45 look4007.68 forward4007.84 to4008.24 continuing4008.41 to4008.83 select4009.07 everybody4009.23 here.4009.79 I4010.27 look4010.43 forward4010.67 to4010.99 continued4011.23 conversation4011.87 to4012.35 be4012.67 able4012.83 to4012.99 give4014.75 specific4015.15 feedback4016.91 so4017.63 that4017.87 we4018.03 can4018.27 reach4019.71 our4019.95 shared4020.11 goals4020.43 together.4020.76 Sure.4020.76 Of4021.01 protecting4021.16 the4021.57 people4021.72 of4021.96 Massachusetts.4022.13 Great.4022.61
4023.01 KINGMAN4023.01 -4023.01 Okay.4023.01 Appreciate4023.4 that.4023.96
4024.61 FARLEY-BOUVIER4024.61 -4024.61 And4024.61 I'm4025.24 gonna4025.4 let4025.64 house4025.96 members4026.2 know4026.53 that4026.76 there's4026.84 a4027.09 roll4027.24 call,4027.48 so4028.84 please4029.32 come4029.72 back4031.4 if4031.8 you4031.96 can.4032.05 And4032.61 thank4033.8 you,4033.96 mister4034.12 Kingman.4034.28 I'm4034.92 gonna4035.08 ask4035.4 for4035.72 the4036.28 indulgence4036.52 of4037.24 Chris4037.48 Gilrein,4037.8 who4038.28 I4038.52 just4038.76 said4039 was4039.24 on4039.48 deck,4039.64 but4039.88 we4040.04 are4040.12 gonna4040.28 turn4040.6 to4040.76 Senator4041.08 Driscoll,4041.64 who4042.2 is4042.44 here.4042.6 And4044.52 senator,4044.76 you'll4045.16 forgive4045.48 me,4045.8 but4045.96 I'm4046.12 gonna4046.28 go4046.52 and4046.76 vote4046.92 and4047.24 then4047.4 come4047.64 back.4047.88 Okay?4048.2 Thank4049.14 you.4049.39
4055.63 SEN4055.63 DRISCOLL4055.63 -4055.63 SB4055.63 334055.63 -4055.63 Thank4055.63 you,4055.95 Chair4056.18 Farley4056.51 Bouvier,4056.82 Chair4058.27 Moore,4058.59 and4059.63 members4059.63 of4060.03 the4060.18 committee.4060.27 I4061.47 will4061.63 submit4061.78 written4062.34 testimony4062.66 as4068.11 well4068.14 but4068.17 wanted4068.2 to4068.22 appear4068.25 before4068.28 the4068.31 committee4068.34 today4068.37 and4068.42 ask4068.45 respectfully4068.48 that4068.51 S4068.99 334069.31 enact4070.43 establishing4070.75 comprehensive4071.47 Massachusetts4072.35 consumer4072.91 data4073.47 privacy,4074.11 received4075.46 a4075.7 favorable4075.94 report4076.51 from4076.82 the4077.07 committee.4077.22 Data4078.43 privacy4078.82 and4079.39 security4079.55 are4079.94 among4080.11 the4080.34 most4080.51 pressing4080.74 issues4081.07 for4081.46 consumers4081.7 across4082.26 the4082.59 Commonwealth4082.74 and4083.3 the4083.46 country.4083.63 A4084.82 20234085.07 Pew4085.94 Research4086.18 poll4086.59 found4086.91 that4087.07 81%4087.22 of4087.86 Americans4088.03 were4088.51 concerned4088.66 about4089.14 how4089.3 companies4089.63 use4090.51 the4090.66 data4090.82 that4091.16 is4091.32 collected4091.48 about4091.52 them,4091.56 with4093.08 67%4093.32 reporting4094.36 that4095.16 they4095.4 did4095.56 not4095.64 understand4095.88 what4096.52 type4096.68 of4096.92 data4097.08 has4097.4 been4097.88 collected4098.04 about4098.84 them.4099.08 And4100.12 beyond4100.36 that4100.68 polling,4100.92 we've4101.48 all4101.8 heard4102.04 the4102.28 stories.4102.44 Someone4103.56 searches4103.88 for4104.28 a4104.52 product4104.6 on4105 14105.16 website,4105.4 and4105.96 within4106.12 a4106.48 few4106.72 days4106.8 or,4106.95 in4107.27 some4107.44 cases,4107.6 a4107.91 few4107.99 minutes,4108.23 their4109.03 social4109.27 media4109.6 feeds4109.99 are4110.4 bombarded4110.64 with4111.03 targeted4111.2 advertisements,4111.84 pushing4112.88 them4113.2 to4114.23 buy4114.4 14114.56 brand4114.8 or4115.2 another.4115.44
4116.48 Increasingly,4116.48 companies4117.11 are4117.6 gathering,4117.76 processing,4118.31 and4118.8 ultimately4118.95 selling4119.35 the4119.6 data4119.68 of4119.99 our4120.07 constituents,4120.23 many4121.43 of4121.67 whom4121.83 are4122.63 only4122.95 only4123.99 have4124.23 a4124.47 faint4124.63 understanding4125.03 of4125.51 the4125.75 nature,4125.83 the4127.35 data4127.51 scope,4128.07 and4129.03 the4129.19 depth4129.27 of4129.67 that4129.83 data4130.07 that4130.95 these4131.11 companies4131.35 are4131.75 handling.4131.99 This4132.79 goes4132.95 beyond4133.27 just4133.59 advertising,4133.83 of4134.31 course.4134.47 Often4134.79 without4135.03 consumer4135.35 knowledge,4135.75 companies4136.35 are4136.51 building4136.74 entire4137.23 personal4138.02 profiles4138.51 on4138.99 consumers,4139.15 predicting4140.27 their4140.74 feelings4140.91 on4141.23 issues4141.39 or4141.78 products,4141.95 behaviors,4142.43 and4143.23 decision4143.47 making4143.86 with4144.59 increasing4144.82 accuracy.4145.47 As4146.91 I'm4147.15 sure4147.23 you've4147.55 heard4147.78 and4148.1 are4148.6 aware,4148.76 there4149.16 really4149.32 isn't4149.56 a4149.8 federal4149.96 standard4150.36 for4150.68 consumer4150.92 data4151.56 privacy4151.96 at4152.44 this4152.52 point,4152.68 and4153.4 there4153.56 needs4153.64 to4153.96 be4154.12 needs4154.36 to4154.6 be4154.76 1.4155 So4155.72 in4155.88 that4156.04 void,4156.28 year4156.6 after4156.76 year,4157 our4157.4 use4157.56 of4157.72 tech4157.96 and4158.2 reliance4158.44 on4158.84 the4158.92 digital4159 world4159.32 grows4159.72 and4160.04 grows.4160.2 This4161.38 bill,4161.61 S4161.85 33,4162.1 is4162.98 more4163.14 than4163.38 a4163.53 conversation4163.69 starter.4164.34 It4164.81 contains4165.14 an4165.61 approach4165.77 and4166.18 proposal4166.34 that4166.9 174167.3 other4167.69 states4167.94 have4168.26 coalesced4168.49 around,4168.98 adopted,4169.45 and4170.41 implemented.4170.65
4171.85 This4171.85 legislation4172.1 aims4172.73 to4173.06 inform4173.22 and4173.53 empower4173.77 consumers4174.1 about4174.65 their4174.9 specific4175.06 nature4175.53 of4176.39 the4176.55 data4176.71 that4176.87 the4177.27 companies4177.43 are4177.83 collecting4178.07 and4178.39 processing4178.63 and4179.91 provides4180.15 our4180.63 constituents4180.79 with4181.43 tools4181.67 to4182.47 opt4182.55 out4182.79 of4183.03 the4183.19 sale4183.35 of4183.59 their4183.75 personal4183.91 data4184.31 for4184.55 advertising4184.79 or4185.43 data4185.67 profiling.4185.99 This4187.27 act4187.43 would4187.67 require4187.83 companies4188.48 doing4188.72 business4188.89 in4189.28 the4189.44 Commonwealth4189.52 to4190.09 respond4190.24 to4190.65 consumer4190.89 requests,4191.36 confirming4192.65 whether4193.2 the4193.6 company4193.76 is4194.16 collecting4194.32 and4194.72 processing4194.89 their4195.52 data,4195.68 obtaining4196.4 copies4196.89 of4197.52 that4197.68 data,4197.93 and4198.56 ultimately4198.72 mandate4199.2 the4199.84 deletion4199.93 of4200.8 their4200.97 personal4201.13 data.4201.52 Again,4203.38 174203.7 other4204.1 states,4204.34 including4204.82 several4205.3 of4205.54 our4205.7 neighbors4205.86 here4206.18 in4206.34 New4206.5 England,4206.66 have4206.98 adopted4207.22 legislation4208.1 creating4208.74 similar4209.3 or4209.78 identical4209.86 safeguards,4210.42 and4211.46 this4211.7 act4212.18 builds4212.5 on4212.9 that4213.06 critical4213.22 work4213.7 that4214.74 was4214.9 done4215.06 last4215.38 session4215.62 in4216.5 regard4216.74 to4217.06 the4217.22 Data4217.3 Shield4217.62 Act4217.98 and4218.23 expands4218.39 key4218.86 consumer4219.19 protections.4219.66 As4221.19 automation4221.59 increasingly4222.15 eases4223.02 the4223.43 workload4223.51 of4223.98 collecting,4224.15 processing,4224.55 and4225.1 interpreting4225.26 consumer4225.74 data,4226.23 consumer4227.1 privacy4227.59 is4228.23 jeopardized4228.47 in4229.1 an4229.26 unprecedented4229.43 manner.4230.23 In4230.94 massive4231.19 numbers,4231.66 websites,4232.3 apps,4234.23 and4234.47 other4234.71 programs4234.95 are4235.43 tracking4235.59 consumer4235.99 data4236.47 and4236.87 building4237.11 detailed4237.67 data4238.15 profiles.4238.55
4240.07 Massachusetts4240.07 led4240.87 the4241.03 way4241.19 on4241.83 consumer4241.99 protections.4242.47 In4242.95 the4243.11 past,4243.19 we4243.51 were4243.59 among4243.75 the4244.07 first4244.15 states4244.39 in4244.63 the4244.79 nation4244.87 to4245.11 pass4245.27 state-level4245.75 consumer4246.47 protection4246.97 laws4247.93 in4248.32 the4248.48 194248.65 sixties,4248.97 prohibiting4249.45 unfair4250.01 and4250.41 deceptive4250.56 acts4251.2 and4251.45 practices4251.52 and4252.65 empowering4252.81 our4253.2 residents4253.28 to4253.77 take4253.85 action4254.01 against4255.05 companies4255.36 that4256.41 did4256.48 that4256.81 wish4257.05 to4257.28 exploit4257.45 them.4257.77 But4258.65 our4258.89 current4258.97 consumer4259.2 protection4259.65 laws4259.97 are4260.77 under-equipped4261.33 for4261.73 our4261.89 new4262.05 AI-driven4263.17 digital4263.57 era.4263.97 This4264.85 legislation4265.09 aims4265.65 to4265.89 give4265.97 our4266.21 consumers4266.37 the4266.93 tools4267.01 they4267.33 need4267.49 to4267.73 take4267.89 agency4268.13 over4269.09 their4269.33 own4269.57 data4269.73 and4270.21 bring4270.45 our4270.69 consumer4270.85 protection4271.33 into4272.13 the4272.45 modern4272.61 age.4273.01 I4273.97 hope4274.05 the4274.2 committee4274.36 will4274.69 utilize4274.84 S4275.32 334275.48 as4275.97 the4276.2 primary4276.36 vehicle4276.76 to4277.16 advance4277.32 this4277.65 conversation4277.8 in4278.36 Massachusetts4278.52 and4279.65 to4279.73 deliver4280.13 a4280.76 comprehensive4280.84 interoperable4281.89 directive4282.84 for4283.32 how4283.48 we4283.97 handle4284.2 consumer4284.6 data4285.56 privacy4285.8 in4286.2 the4286.36 Commonwealth.4286.44 Thank4287.82 you4288.06 and4288.46 the4288.62 committee4288.86 for4289.5 hearing4289.66 my4289.9 testimony4289.98 today.4290.46 Again,4290.86 make4291.18 my4291.42 staff,4291.58 myself4291.9 available4292.22 to4293.58 answer4293.82 any4294.06 questions4294.3 and,4295.1 hopefully,4295.42 work4295.42 with4295.58 the4295.74 committee4295.82 on4296.22 this4296.3 matter.4296.54 Over4301.78 there4301.94 on4302.19 the4302.27 other4302.35 side?4302.51 So4302.82 far,4302.9 so4303.15 good.4303.31 It's4303.55 a4303.7 lot4303.78 smaller.4303.94
4304.43 FARLEY-BOUVIER-4304.43 Yeah.4304.43 Terrific.4306.19 Well,4306.66 thank4306.82 you4306.98 very4307.23 much.4307.31 Senator,4308.9 are4309.31 you4309.39 good?4309.55 Is4310.19 anybody4310.59 over4310.59 here?4310.82 Okay.4311.55 Thank4311.78 you4311.94 very4312.02 much4312.27 for4312.34 your4312.59 testimony.4312.66 So,4315.52 now4315.68 we're4315.92 going4316.08 virtual.4316.4 Chris4317.76 Gilrein.4318.08 You4319.2 hear,4319.36 Chris?4319.76 And4321.28 then4321.44 on4321.84 dates,4322.4 Katrina4322.8 Fitzgerald4323.36 is4324.24 next.4324.72 Chris?4325.68
CHRIS4327.68 GILREIN4327.68 -4327.68 TECHNET4327.68 -4327.68 SB4327.68 334327.68 -4327.68 (4327.68 R4327.92 )Thank4327.92 you,4327.92 Madam4329.81 Chair,4330.05 Chairman4330.05 Moore,4330.05 and4330.26 members4330.26 of4330.45 the4330.65 committee.4330.85 I4331.57 can4331.65 really4331.9 appreciate4332.14 the4332.53 opportunity4332.69 to4333.18 be4333.34 here.4333.49 My4334.09 name4334.22 is4334.38 Chris4334.53 Gilrein4335.26 represent4335.98 TechNet.4335.98 I'm4336.94 taking4337.09 the4337.41 liberty4337.41 of4337.81 pasting4338.45 a4338.77 link4338.85 to4339.09 our4339.26 members4339.34 in4339.73 the4339.81 chat,4339.9 but4340.14 we4340.38 represent4340.53 about4341.26 a4341.65 hundred4341.73 companies4342.22 throughout4343.01 the4343.34 innovation4343.57 ecosystem4344.14 here4345.36 in4345.68 support4345.92 of4346.64 S4346.88 334347.12 and4348.16 h4348.4 80.4348.72 Indulge4350.64 a4351.04 little4351.2 bit4351.36 of4351.52 history.4351.76 California4352.64 is4353.2 the4353.28 first4353.44 state4353.68 to4353.92 enact4354 a4354.4 comprehensive4354.56 consumer4355.12 data4355.6 privacy4355.84 law.4356.32 74357.12 years,4357.44 multiple4358.7 amendments4359.19 to4359.82 enforcement4360.06 agencies4360.7 later,4361.19 that4361.51 is4361.66 still4361.82 evolving.4362.15 A4363.51 Washington4363.74 state4364.39 senator4364.7 witnessed4365.51 that4365.9 and4366.15 sought4366.31 to4366.47 develop4366.55 a4367.02 data4367.27 privacy4367.51 law4368.06 that4368.31 was4368.47 clear4368.7 and4369.02 explicit4369.27 in4369.9 statute4370.06 and4370.85 avoided4371.09 the4371.57 hassle4371.65 and4372.05 expense4372.29 of4372.61 constant4372.77 rulemaking4373.17 and4373.81 reinterpretation.4373.89 While4375.25 it4375.49 did4375.65 not4375.73 pass4376.53 in4377.01 that4377.01 senator's4377.17 home4377.65 state,4377.89 it4378.13 was4378.29 adopted4378.61 in4379.01 Virginia.4379.25
4380.61 Colorado4380.61 and4381.25 Connecticut4381.41 followed4381.97 and4382.77 expanded4384.45 upon4385.01 that4385.65 framework.4385.97 It4387.1 has4388.55 been4388.78 the4389.02 subject4389.1 of4389.51 multiyear4390.55 public4391.43 stakeholder4391.82 meetings4392.39 in4392.78 over4393.74 a4393.98 dozen4394.06 states4394.39 and4395.66 in4396.47 hearings4396.7 and4397.34 stakeholder4397.98 processes4398.64 that4398.96 include4399.2 many4399.52 of4399.76 the4400 folks4400.08 that4400.48 you4400.64 will4400.8 hear4400.88 from4401.12 today.4402 The4402.24 result4402.32 is4402.72 a4402.8 comprehensive4402.96 risk-based4404.08 framework4404.4 of4404.96 consumer4405.12 rights4405.6 over4405.92 how4406.16 their4406.32 data4406.48 is4406.72 collected4406.88 and4407.2 used4407.36 and4407.68 who4407.92 controls4408.16 the4408.56 responsibilities4408.72 to4409.52 those4409.68 consumers4409.92 and4410.56 to4410.72 the4410.8 protection4410.88 of4411.28 that4411.44 enforced4411.97 by4412.2 the4412.45 state's4412.6 attorney4413.01 general.4413.41 It's4414.05 a4414.2 model4414.28 that4414.6 has4414.69 been4414.85 thoroughly4415.01 vetted4415.41 and4415.65 adopted4415.89 in4416.28 red,4416.52 blue,4416.85 and4417.09 purple4417.24 states,4417.65 including4418.45 our4418.77 New4418.93 England4419.09 neighbors4419.41 in4419.73 Connecticut,4419.81 New4420.36 Hampshire,4420.52 and4421.09 Rhode4421.32 Island.4421.48 This4423.01 is4423.16 where4423.24 I4423.48 acknowledge4423.56 that4424.13 compliance,4425.09 even4427.08 with4427.4 a4427.8 standard4428.92 model,4429.24 is4429.88 not4430.12 free.4430.36 This4430.68 does4430.92 come4431.08 at4431.32 a4431.56 cost4431.64 to4432.28 companies,4432.68 including4433.32 my4433.8 own.4433.96 However,4435.16 by4435.96 following4436.2 a4436.52 model4436.6 that4436.92 is4437.08 already4437.24 in4437.64 place,4437.72 the4438.2 cost4438.36 to4438.68 companies4438.84 doing4439.24 business4439.61 in4439.78 the4439.94 commonwealth4439.94 is4440.57 orders4440.81 of4441.14 magnitude4441.3 less4441.94 than4442.18 if4442.49 the4442.81 state4442.98 advances4443.22 its4443.85 own4444.02 unique4444.34 standard,4444.66 which4445.38 would4445.53 require4445.78 custom4446.18 compliance4446.66 solutions.4447.06
4448.26 Other4448.26 comprehensive4448.57 bills4449.45 on4449.78 the4449.94 docket4450.02 today4450.41 include4451.06 provisions,4451.53 as4452.02 you've4452.18 heard,4452.34 that4452.57 deviate4452.74 significantly4453.14 from4453.85 the4454.1 standard4454.1 in4454.49 184454.88 states.4455.12 They4456.24 rely4456.48 on4456.8 novel4457.92 definitions4458.48 and4459.52 are4459.68 enforced4459.84 with4460.24 private4460.4 rights4460.8 of4460.92 action,4461.04 which4461.92 is4462.08 something4463.04 that,4463.36 as4463.36 you4463.44 heard,4463.6 is4463.84 not4464.08 enforced4464.56 in4465.12 any4465.36 comprehensive4465.92 data4466.56 privacy4466.72 regime4467.2 elsewhere.4467.52 So4468.4 we4468.56 make4468.72 Massachusetts4469.12 an4469.76 outlier,4469.84 harming4470.24 our4470.64 competitiveness4470.88 and4471.52 creating4471.76 significant4472.4 confusion4473.03 and4473.44 cost.4473.6 There4474.8 are4474.95 also4475.11 a4475.44 number4475.52 of4475.76 standalone4475.84 bills4476.31 on4476.64 the4476.72 docket4476.88 to4477.28 protect4477.44 certain4477.84 types4478.24 of4478.48 data,4478.64 whether4478.95 that4479.28 be4479.44 biometrics,4479.76 location,4480.48 or4481.03 neural4481.35 data,4481.68 and4482.31 there4482.56 are4482.8 bills4482.88 in4483.03 other4483.2 committees4483.35 that4484.07 would4484.16 safeguard4484.4 health4485.28 information.4486.26 I4487.38 understand4487.46 that4487.94 there4488.26 may4488.58 be4488.74 an4488.82 instinct4488.98 after4489.38 taking4489.7 hours4490.02 of4490.34 testimony4490.42 today4490.9 that,4491.7 to4492.74 determine4492.9 this4493.3 complex4493.62 subject4494.34 and4494.74 maybe4494.82 an4495.62 incremental4495.78 approach4496.5 is4496.98 better4497.14 over4497.7 the4497.94 low4498.02 hanging4498.31 fruit,4498.63 like4498.78 location4499.19 or4499.66 health4499.91 information.4500.23 But4501.74 going4502.23 with4502.47 a4502.55 piecemeal4502.7 approach,4503.1 we4503.82 argue,4503.99 is4504.47 more4504.78 complicated4505.03 from4505.59 a4505.74 policy4505.82 perspective4506.15 and4506.7 still4507.35 requires4507.66 a4508.15 complex4508.31 compliance4509.35 infrastructure.4509.91 Leaving,4511.1 leveraging4511.82 the4512.23 work4512.31 of4512.7 more4512.96 than4513.12 a4513.24 dozen4513.36 states4513.68 and4513.92 implementing4514.24 an4514.8 interoperable4514.96 standard4515.52 is4516 the4516.24 low-hanging4516.56 fruit.4516.96 We4517.76 ask4518.08 that4518.32 you4518.48 advance4518.64 S4519.04 334519.2 and4519.68 H4519.76 80.4519.92 Thank4520.72 you.4520.96
FARLEY-BOUVIER4523.12 -4523.12 Thank4523.12 you,4523.36 Chris.4523.6 Are4524 there4524.24 questions4524.4 from4524.72 the4524.96 committee?4525.12 Senator?4526.65
MOORE4528.41 -4528.41 Thank4528.41 you.4528.65 Good4530.09 afternoon,4530.34 Chris.4530.73 A4531.3 quick4531.38 question4531.61 for4531.94 you.4532.09 Do4532.34 you4532.49 think4532.57 the4532.9 AG4533.14 has4533.61 the4533.94 resources4534.9 to4535.94 handle4536.09 the4537.05 number4537.22 of4537.45 complaints4537.61 that4538.01 could4538.49 possibly4538.65 come4538.65 in?4538.81
4540.79 GILREIN4540.79 -4540.79 So4540.79 what4541.19 we've4541.43 seen,4541.67 and4543.27 what4543.43 we've4543.51 discussed4543.83 in4544.39 other4544.63 states4544.87 where4545.59 we've4545.83 had4546.07 this4546.23 conversation,4546.55 is,4547.19 the4548.79 states4549.03 can4549.91 create4550.15 a4550.95 separate4551.67 fund4552.15 where4553.18 the4553.73 proceeds4553.97 from4554.53 any4554.85 successful4555.49 enforcement4555.97 action4556.45 would4557.18 go.4557.65 Would4557.81 you4557.81 support4558.05 future4558.69 enforcement4559.09 actions?4559.57 It's4560.45 a4560.61 concept4561.97 that4562.38 we've4562.53 discussed4562.85 in4563.26 other4563.41 states.4563.65 I4564.77 don't4565.26 know4565.49 for4566.36 a4566.52 fact4566.6 that4566.84 it's4567 been4567.24 enacted4567.8 elsewhere,4568.28 but4568.76 it's4568.92 something4569.08 that4570.12 we'd4570.2 certainly4570.52 be4571 able4571.08 to4571.32 do.4571.56
4572.68 MOORE4572.68 -4572.68 So,4573.24 just4573.48 so,4573.72 if4573.96 you'd4574.12 if4574.76 we4575 need4575.16 to4575.32 create4575.48 a4576.04 fund4576.28 with4576.52 additional4576.68 resources,4577.16 then4577.64 I4577.8 would4577.88 say4578.12 that4578.52 the4578.84 AG4579.08 does4579.48 not4579.64 have4579.88 the4580.04 resources4580.2 would4581.64 not4581.88 possibly4582.16 have4582.32 the4582.48 resources?4582.65
4584.24 GILREIN4584.24 -4584.24 I4584.24 would4584.4 say4584.56 that4584.8 if4585.05 the4585.6 AG's4586.01 office4586.48 does4586.8 not4586.97 feel4587.13 that4587.28 they4587.44 do4587.6 have4587.84 the4588.01 resources,4588.16 that's4588.56 an4589.2 avenue4589.36 that4589.76 we've4590.09 seen4590.4 discussed4590.73 elsewhere.4591.2
4592.32 MOORE-4592.32 Okay.4592.32 Alright.4592.73 Thank4592.97 you.4593.13
4595.2 FARLEY-BOUVIER4595.2 -4595.2 Thank4595.2 you,4595.44 Senator.4595.69 Anybody4596.4 else4596.89 on4597.05 the4597.2 committee?4597.36 Chris,4599.26 I4600.22 have4600.3 a4600.42 couple4600.54 of4600.86 questions4600.94 for4601.26 you.4601.42 Let's4603.5 talk4603.82 about4604.14 data-level4604.86 versus4605.18 entity-level4606.14 exemptions4606.62 that4607.26 are4607.5 in4607.66 several4608.38 other4608.7 states.4609.02 Why4609.5 don't4609.74 you4609.9 just4610.06 talk4610.46 about4610.7 the4610.94 difference4614.49 between4614.66 the4614.83 24615 of4615.17 them?4615.34
4615.51 GILREIN4615.51 -4615.51 Yeah,4615.51 absolutely.4615.68 So,4615.84 the4616.97 vast4618.01 majority4618.32 of4618.73 states4618.89 have4620.01 to4623.31 as4623.39 entity-level4623.63 exemptions.4624.43 These4625.79 are4626.03 industries4626.51 that4627.15 are4627.39 covered4628.67 under4629.31 any4630.19 14630.43 of4630.59 the4630.75 various4630.91 alphabet4632.27 of4632.91 federal4633.95 data4634.43 privacy4634.67 laws,4635.23 and4637.7 so,4638.02 in4639.85 order4640.1 to4640.26 avoid4640.66 layering4641.53 state4644.26 law4644.66 over4645.06 laws4645.45 that4645.78 these4645.94 companies4646.1 are4646.49 already4646.66 complying4647.85 with,4648.34 they4649.22 are4649.53 exempted4649.94 from4650.49 the4650.81 state4650.98 laws.4651.22
4653.28 FARLEY-BOUVIER4653.28 -4653.28 Laws.4653.28 Okay.4653.68 So4654.08 to4654.64 clarify,4654.88 for4656.24 the4656.72 definition4657.44 of4657.44 the4657.68 members4657.76 of4658.16 the4658.24 committee,4658.32 the4660.48 idea4660.64 is4661.04 if4661.36 you4661.6 are4662.48 already4662.64 complying4663.28 with,4664 for4664.32 example,4664.56 HIPAA4665.04 or4666.32 GLBA4667.48 BA,4667.89 then4669.16 you're4669.56 complying4671.24 with4671.73 these4673.16 robust4675.01 protection4675.01 laws4675.65 of4675.97 the4676.05 federal4676.2 government.4676.52 So4676.93 why4677.24 layer4677.56 the4678.28 state4678.52 law4679.16 on4679.4 it?4679.65 Is4679.73 that4679.89 what4680.05 you're4680.2 saying?4680.44
4682.14 GILREIN4682.14 -4682.14 Accurate.4682.14
FARLEY-BOUVIER4682.78 -4682.78 Okay.4682.78 So4683.42 my4684.06 concern4684.38 is4685.02 that4685.5 GLBA,4686.14 for4687.34 example,4687.5 was4688.86 created,4689.1 I4689.58 think,4689.66 in4689.9 1996.4690.14 And4692.38 if4692.62 I4692.86 have4693.02 it4693.26 right,4693.42 that4693.9 is4694.14 when4694.3 Motorola4694.62 first4695.76 introduced4695.84 the4697.11 first4697.27 flip4697.6 phone.4699.76 Okay?4700.72 Now,4700.95 I4701.19 think4701.27 that4701.52 it's4701.76 important4701.76 to4702.23 understand4702.56 how4703.35 far4703.6 technology4703.99 has4704.72 gone4704.95 since4706.56 19964707.03 and4707.99 to4708.23 kind4708.4 of4708.56 put4708.72 that4708.8 into4709.03 context.4709.35 Also,4711.48 the4712.92 world4713.8 of4714.36 data4714.6 collection,4715 because4716.12 we4716.6 have4716.76 these4717 devices,4717.32 you4718.04 know,4718.12 at4718.36 our4718.52 in4718.76 our4718.92 pockets4719.08 and4719.56 on4720.2 our4720.36 wrists4720.6 and4720.92 now4721.16 fingers4721.48 and4722.04 in4722.44 our4722.68 homes,4722.84 collecting4723.48 data4723.96 like4724.78 the4724.94 temperature4725.18 in4725.59 your4725.66 house4725.9 or4726.14 how4727.18 often4727.43 you4727.66 use4727.82 your4727.98 lights,4728.22 all4728.63 these4728.7 different4728.86 things,4729.26 means4731.43 that4731.74 so4732.06 much4732.3 more4732.63 data4733.02 is4733.66 being4733.82 collected.4734.39 And4735.26 so,4735.51 for4735.82 example,4736.06 let's4736.78 say4737.02 a4737.59 big4737.82 bank.4738.06 Right?4738.94
4739.18 All4739.18 banks4739.43 are,4739.74 you4740.58 know,4740.66 have4740.9 these4741.14 federal4741.3 regulations4742.34 about4743.62 protecting4743.94 financial4744.5 data.4745.06 Right?4745.94 That's4746.18 mostly4746.42 that's4746.9 what4747.06 they're4747.22 saying.4747.46 Protect4747.86 people's4748.26 financial4748.66 data.4749.14 But4749.86 a4750.9 big4751.06 bank4751.22 like4751.54 Citibank4751.78 has4752.5 a4752.82 lot4753.06 more4753.62 data4753.94 about4754.58 me,4754.9 a4755.38 lot4755.62 more4756.28 data4756.52 on4756.84 me4756.99 than4757.24 just4757.56 my4757.88 financial4758.2 data.4759.16 They4760.91 probably4761.31 know4761.72 what4761.95 I4762.11 had4762.28 for4762.44 breakfast4762.68 this4763.16 morning.4763.31 Citibank4764.11 does.4764.68 So,4766.52 how4767.07 you4769.43 can4769.51 see4769.83 my4769.99 concern4770.31 is4771.35 that4771.35 we4771.67 don't4771.91 tell4772.39 Citibank,4773.51 for4774.31 example,4774.47 that4775.35 they4775.59 have4775.91 to4776.15 protect4776.39 all4777.43 the4777.67 other4777.75 data4777.99 they4778.31 have4778.47 on4778.63 me,4778.87 not4779.27 just4779.51 the4779.83 financial4779.99 data.4780.47 If4781.99 you4782.07 have4782.31 a4783.7 response4784.02 to4784.49 that4784.66 and4784.9 help4785.3 us4785.61 understand4785.85 why4787.14 it's4787.45 so4787.61 important4787.85 to4788.34 you4788.57 and4788.81 your4788.98 members4789.14 to4789.61 keep4789.85 the4790.18 entity-level4790.9 exemption.4791.22 And4793.45 in4793.61 your4793.77 answer,4794.02 please4794.41 focus4794.98 on4795.53 the4796.05 consumer4796.25 of4797.13 Massachusetts.4797.53
4799.61 GILREIN4799.61 -4799.61 Sure.4799.61 So4800.89 from4801.05 Technet's4801.29 perspective,4801.77 the4803.45 support,4804.89 our4805.69 support4806.01 of,4806.57 the4807.53 entity4808.09 level4808.41 is4809.02 a4809.49 matter4809.57 of4809.98 consistency4810.14 across4810.26 states.4810.38 And4812.3 so4812.53 for4812.77 that,4812.94 for4814.06 the4814.61 consumer,4815.18 it4815.74 is,4816.14 again,4816.45 a4818.22 consistency4818.38 in4819.1 how4819.34 their4819.57 data4819.74 will4819.98 be4820.14 treated,4820.3 whether4820.61 they4820.94 are4821.26 commuting4821.66 to4822.38 Rhode4823.02 Island4823.26 or4824.22 New4824.3 Hampshire4824.7 or4824.98 what4825.26 have4825.34 you.4825.5 And4826.7 for4827.74 your4828.62 constituents4829.42 who4830.22 own4830.54 businesses,4830.78 consistency4832.46 is4833.18 important4833.18 in4833.18 how4833.9 they4834.62 are4834.86 going4835.02 to4835.18 be4835.34 held4835.5 to4835.66 a4836.06 standard.4836.3
FARLEY-BOUVIER4837.84 -4837.84 Okay.4837.84 Well,4838.15 thank4838.4 you4838.55 for4838.8 that4838.95 explanation.4839.19 Are4840.31 there4840.48 any4840.64 other4840.88 questions4841.19 from4841.51 the4841.68 committee?4841.84 Sure.4842.95 Representative4843.35 Meschino.4843.91
4845.11 MESCHINO-4845.11 Thank4845.11 you4845.27 so4845.51 much.4845.76 Did4846.72 you4846.95 just4847.27 suggest4847.59 that4848.31 because4849.19 other4849.68 states4850.07 and4850.55 other4850.8 laws4851.11 have4851.59 a4851.91 lower4852.07 threshold,4852.4 Massachusetts4854.21 consumers4855.09 should4855.81 just4856.05 put4856.29 up4856.45 with4856.61 it?4856.77
GILREIN4859.01 -4859.01 I'm4859.01 suggesting4859.41 that4860.13 our4861.41 support4862.85 is4863.41 for4863.65 a4863.97 consistent4864.29 standard4865.09 across4865.73 the4866.72 state.4867.44
4867.99 MESCHINO4867.99 -4867.99 And4867.99 you4868.24 asked4868.56 about4868.8 you4869.11 mentioned4869.28 cost.4869.76 So,4870.4 from4871.44 your4871.68 perspective,4871.99 did4872.56 I4872.72 understand4872.88 you4873.2 correctly4873.44 to4873.84 say4873.99 that4874.16 having4874.88 different4875.2 standards4875.6 is4876.24 costly4877.2 to4877.76 you4877.91 in4878.07 terms4878.24 of4878.56 how4878.72 you4878.95 manage4879.11 them?4879.44
4881.54 GILREIN4881.54 -4881.54 Yes.4881.54 So4882.02 the4883.7 support4884.02 for4884.5 a4884.98 kind4885.3 of4885.38 uniform4885.62 from4886.26 standard,4886.42 you4887.86 know,4888.02 the4889.3 compliance4889.62 infrastructure4890.42 needed4891.14 to4892.1 maintain4893.02 compliance,4893.65 to4894.14 design4896.14 a4896.53 structure4896.69 that4897.18 handles4897.65 the4898.05 data4898.14 appropriately4898.53 and4899.26 does4900.3 the4900.69 appropriate4900.85 reporting4901.34 and4901.73 disclosure,4902.14 that4903.81 costs4904.05 money,4904.53 right?4904.94 It4905.26 costs4905.41 attorneys4906.22 time.4906.94 And4908.22 the4908.53 technology4909.52 on4910.08 the4910.24 back4910.32 end4910.56 needs4910.8 to4911.04 be4911.12 adjusted.4911.44 It4912.88 is4913.04 significantly4913.84 more4914.72 expensive4915.04 if4916.08 something4916.32 needs4916.64 to4916.8 be4916.96 custom4917.6 designed4918 for4918.56 each4918.96 individual4919.44 state4920 rather4920.32 than4920.64 a4921.23 solution4921.47 that4921.78 fits4922.9 184923.94 plus4924.43 states.4924.82
4926.34 MESCHINO4926.34 -4926.34 So4926.34 a4926.66 solution4926.82 could4927.39 be4927.55 that4927.78 Massachusetts4928.1 could4928.9 just4929.06 become4929.39 the4929.7 standard4929.86 to4930.34 which4930.51 all4931.55 comply.4931.78 Just4932.98 think4933.23 about4933.47 it.4933.7 Thank4935.47 you.4935.79
4936.35 FARLEY-BOUVIER4936.35 -4936.35 Thank4936.35 you,4936.59 rep4936.91 Meschino.4937.15 Thank4938.43 you,4938.59 Chris.4938.83 We4939.15 appreciate4939.31 your4939.71 testimony.4939.95 We're4940.75 gonna4940.91 bring4941.15 up4941.39 now4942.19 Caitrina4942.67 Fitzgerald4942.67 from4943.71 the4943.95 Electronic4945.95 Privacy4946.59 Information4946.59 Center.4946.59 And4946.59 do4946.59 you4946.67 have4946.75 a4946.91 panel?4946.99 Is4947.39 it4947.55 how4947.71 are4948.03 we4948.19 doing4948.35 this?4948.59 Or4948.83 the4949.07 panels4949.15 are4949.47 coming4949.63 later,4949.87 baby.4950.16 The4950.32 panels4950.56 are4950.56 coming4950.65 later.4950.89 Okay.4951.13 Thank4951.2 you4951.44 for4951.6 that.4951.69 And4952.16 we're4952.89 then4953.28 switching4953.85 to4954.24 virtual,4954.41 and4955.13 we'll4955.44 have4955.6 Julie4955.85 Burns,4956.16 Bernstein.4956.89 Thank4958.01 you,4958.16 Katrina.4958.32 Welcome.4958.89
4959.44 CAITRIONA4959.44 FITZGERALD4959.44 -4959.44 ELECTRONIC4959.44 PRIVACY4959.6 INFORMATION4959.6 CENTER4959.6 -4959.6 SB4959.6 454959.6 -4959.6 HB4959.6 1044959.6 -4959.6 SB4959.6 2094959.6 -Thank4959.6 you.4959.6 Thank4959.77 you,4960.01 Chair4960.16 Farley4960.32 Boubie,4960.65 Chair4960.97 Moore,4961.2 and4961.44 members4961.44 of4961.77 the4961.85 committee.4962.01 My4962.48 name4962.65 is4962.73 Caitriona4962.89 Fitzgerald.4963.36 I'm4963.93 a4964.09 Wakefield4964.16 resident,4964.67 and4964.91 I'm4965.07 deputy4965.15 director4965.63 of4965.95 the4966.03 Electronic4966.27 Privacy4966.75 Information4967.23 Center4967.71 or4968.11 EPIC.4968.35 EPIC4969.23 is4969.55 an4969.79 independent4970.03 nonprofit4970.43 that4970.99 was4971.15 founded4971.31 304971.63 years4971.87 ago4972.11 to4972.35 secure4972.51 the4972.91 fundamental4973.07 right4973.55 to4973.71 privacy4973.79 in4974.27 the4974.35 digital4974.51 age.4974.83 I4975.63 wanna4975.79 commend4976.03 the4976.51 chairs4976.59 for4977.26 their4977.34 sponsorship4977.41 of4977.9 these4978.06 important4978.22 privacy4978.53 bills.4978.77 I'm4979.02 here4979.18 to4979.34 support4979.49 age4980.14 78,4980.38 the4980.94 Massachusetts4981.1 Consumer4981.66 Data4982.14 Privacy4982.38 Act,4982.94 and4983.74 S4984.06 45,4984.3 House4986.06 104,4986.7 Senate4986.7 209,4986.7 the4986.7 Massachusetts4986.7 Data4987.26 Privacy4987.57 Act.4988.06 As4989.03 you4989.19 all4989.35 know,4989.71 we're4990.07 constantly4990.31 being4990.63 tracked.4990.79 Right?4991.03 Every4991.43 click,4991.59 every4992.07 move,4992.31 and4992.63 every4992.87 like4993.11 is4993.59 being4993.83 collected4994.07 and4994.55 put4994.71 into4994.95 a4995.19 profile4995.27 about4995.75 us.4995.99 And4996.39 at4996.63 a4996.71 time4996.79 when4997.03 policymakers4997.27 are4997.83 concerned4997.99 about4998.39 affordability,4998.79 this5000.39 is5000.63 hitting5000.79 your5001.03 constituents'5001.27 wallets.5001.83 Right?5002.23 The5002.47 Texas5002.63 AG5003.03 recently5003.35 sued5003.83 Allstate5004.15 for5004.82 secretly5005.06 collecting5005.55 location5006.02 data5006.43 from5007.39 apps5007.55 like5007.78 Life5008.02 3605008.43 and5008.74 GasBuddy5008.9 and5009.47 using5009.63 it5009.86 to5010.1 raise5010.19 auto5010.51 insurance5010.74 rates.5011.15
5012.02 The5012.02 FTC5012.27 recently5012.9 found5013.94 that5014.43 retailers5014.66 are5015.39 using5015.63 our5015.94 personal5016.1 data,5016.51 even5016.82 down5017.06 to5017.23 our5017.39 mouse5017.55 movements,5018.74 to5019.86 offer5019.86 different5020.18 prices5020.58 for5020.98 the5021.14 same5021.3 goods5021.46 and5021.7 services5021.94 to5022.34 individual5022.5 consumers.5023.06 But5023.86 it5024.02 doesn't5024.18 have5024.42 to5024.58 be5024.74 this5024.82 way.5024.9 Good5025.14 privacy5025.38 laws5025.94 can5026.26 encourage5027.62 companies5028.02 to5028.5 innovate5028.58 on5028.98 privacy,5029.22 allow5030.02 them5030.34 to5030.5 reach5030.66 their5030.9 customers,5031.06 but5031.7 protect5031.94 consumer5032.26 rights.5032.74 I5033.94 wanted5034.1 to5034.42 highlight5034.5 35035.77 points5035.94 that5036.41 are5036.66 critical5036.73 in5037.06 any5037.22 privacy5037.38 legislation5037.77 the5038.41 committee5038.98 is5039.45 moving5039.45 forward.5039.77 First,5040.66 you5040.9 need5041.06 a5041.3 meaningful5041.45 data5042.02 minimization5042.18 rule.5042.73 That5042.98 word's5043.14 been5043.38 thrown5043.61 around5044.02 a5044.26 lot.5044.34 There5044.66 was5044.81 mention5044.98 of5045.3 it5045.38 in5045.53 the5045.61 Connecticut5045.77 law.5046.34 Connecticut5046.66 law5047.14 says5047.51 that5047.83 companies5047.99 can5048.39 only5048.55 collect5048.87 and5049.35 use5050.07 personal5050.31 data5050.71 as5051.11 they5051.27 disclose5051.59 to5052.15 the5052.23 consumer,5052.39 which5052.79 means5052.95 they5053.19 can5053.27 just5053.35 bury5053.59 it5053.83 in5053.91 their5053.99 privacy5054.15 policy5054.55 that5054.87 no5055.03 15055.27 reads.5055.43 The5056.55 bills5056.71 introduced5057.03 by5057.43 the5057.59 chairs5057.67 instead5058.23 say,5058.87 it5059.67 has5059.83 to5060.07 be5060.15 related5060.63 to5061.11 the5061.27 product5061.35 or5061.75 service5061.83 I'm5062.15 asking5062.39 for5062.71 as5063.28 a5063.32 consumer.5063.36 You5064.32 know,5064.41 I5064.56 don't5064.73 expect5064.89 that5065.2 when5065.36 I5065.52 visit5065.6 WebMD's5065.93 site5066.65 that5066.89 what5067.2 I'm5067.36 looking5067.52 at5067.77 is5068.01 being5068.16 sent5068.32 to5068.56 Meta5068.73 and5069.05 Google5069.2 and5069.45 a5069.6 dozen5069.69 advertisers5070.01 in5070.41 the5070.49 background,5070.56 but5070.97 that's5071.13 exactly5071.36 what's5071.77 happening5072.01 right5072.41 now.5072.65 So5073.6 Epic5073.77 supports5074.16 these5074.65 bills5074.89 because5075.2 they5075.77 better5076.09 align5076.48 companies'5077.36 data5077.68 practices5077.92 with5078.4 what5078.64 consumers5079.04 expect.5079.68
5081.2 And5081.2 Massachusetts5081.36 would5081.84 not5082 be5082.16 the5082.24 first5082.32 year.5082.56 Maryland5082.8 passed5083.2 the5083.44 Maryland5083.6 Online5083.92 Data5084.16 Privacy5084.48 Act5084.88 last5085.12 year5085.36 and5085.92 included5086.24 a5087.04 rule5087.2 that5087.52 says5087.76 companies5088.16 can5088.56 only5088.72 collect5089.04 data5089.57 as5089.9 the5090.22 comp5090.3 that5090.53 the5090.77 consumer5091.02 is5091.9 asking5092.06 for.5092.38 The5093.18 second5093.34 critical5093.98 piece5094.3 is5094.53 a5094.69 ban5094.77 on5094.94 the5095.02 sale5095.18 of5095.41 sensitive5095.49 data.5096.06 Maryland5097.02 included5097.34 this5097.73 in5097.9 their5097.98 law5098.14 as5098.3 well.5098.53 Data5099.09 brokers5099.41 and5099.73 others5099.81 simply5100.06 should5100.38 not5100.61 be5100.85 selling5101.02 sensitive5101.34 data.5101.88 I5102.2 think5102.28 we5102.36 all5102.68 agree5102.92 on5103.32 that.5103.48 That's5104.6 why5104.84 I'd5105 ask5105.16 that5105.32 in5105.48 addition5105.64 to5105.96 comprehending5106.2 the5106.6 comprehensive5106.76 privacy5107.24 bills,5107.56 the5107.88 committee5108.04 also5108.36 give5108.52 a5108.68 favorable5108.76 report5109.08 to5109.32 the5109.48 Location5109.48 Shield5109.88 Act.5110.2 The5111.08 third5111.24 piece5111.48 is5111.8 enforcement.5111.88 It5113.32 is5113.48 vital5113.72 to5114.36 pair5114.68 strong5115.08 AG5115.4 enforcement5115.93 with5116.09 a5116.24 private5116.41 right5116.73 of5116.97 action.5117.13 You5117.45 know,5117.52 we've5117.69 seen5118.32 that5118.81 in5119.05 states5119.28 where5119.6 there's5119.77 not5120.01 a5120.13 private5120.24 right5120.65 of5120.81 action5120.89 that5121.13 the5121.52 laws5121.77 just5122.09 aren't5122.24 complied5122.49 with.5122.89 Massachusetts5123.93 residents5124.41 have5124.89 been5125.05 able5125.2 to5125.45 enforce5125.77 their5126.16 consumer5126.41 rights5126.81 in5127.2 court5127.52 under5127.77 935128.09 for5128.89 decades.5129.2 This5129.77 is5130.01 what5130.12 our5130.32 legal5130.72 system5130.96 is5131.36 set5131.52 up5131.68 for.5131.84 There's5132.24 no5132.56 reason5132.8 that5133.68 privacy5134.24 laws5134.72 should5135.04 be5135.2 any5135.28 different,5135.44 that5135.76 our5135.92 privacy5136 rights5136.32 should5136.56 be5136.72 any5136.8 different.5136.96 If5137.52 the5137.76 AG5138 doesn't,5138.24 you5138.96 know,5139.2 have5139.44 the5139.68 resource5139.76 to5140.08 bring5140.16 a5140.4 case5140.48 and5140.72 my5140.88 rights5141.04 are5141.28 violated5141.36 and5141.92 the5142.08 AG5142.24 can't5142.48 bring5142.72 the5142.91 case,5143.16 I'm5143.4 just5143.72 out5143.95 of5144.07 luck,5144.19 and5144.44 the5144.68 company5144.76 gets5145.07 to5145.95 violate5146.03 the5146.44 law.5146.52 That's5146.76 not5147.4 fair.5147.56 So5147.88 private5148.03 right5148.35 of5148.52 action5148.68 is5148.99 really5149.07 critical5149.4 to5150.19 making5150.35 the5150.6 law5150.76 meaningful.5150.91 So5152.44 I5152.6 ask5152.68 that5152.84 the5152.99 committee5153.07 incorporate5153.48 those5154.27 35154.6 critical5154.76 points5155.16 into5155.48 any5155.72 bill5156.03 that5156.27 it's5156.52 reporting5156.99 out,5157.48 and5157.83 thank5158.07 you5158.23 for5158.47 the5158.71 opportunity5158.79 to5159.19 testify5159.27 today.5159.67
5160.39 FARLEY-BOUVIER5160.39 -5160.39 Thank5160.39 you,5160.55 Katrina.5160.79 Wanna5161.35 turn5161.67 to5161.83 committee5162.07 members?5162.39 Sure.5163.99 Rep5164.55 Owens.5164.79
5165.19 OWENS5165.19 -5165.19 I5165.19 just5165.43 wanna,5165.59 since5166.71 again5167.03 you5167.19 ended5167.35 on5167.59 the5167.67 private5167.83 right5168.07 of5168.31 action,5168.39 I5168.63 just5168.71 wanted5168.95 to5169.27 highlight5170.15 that.5170.47 We5170.79 heard5171.03 testimony5171.43 earlier5172.07 that5172.39 it5172.55 doesn't5172.63 work5172.87 because5173.45 consumers5173.85 don't5174.41 get5174.65 compensation.5176.09 I5177.28 think5177.36 I've5177.53 got5177.69 probably5177.85 a5178.01 check5178.16 for5178.41 $145178.57 sitting5179.28 around5179.45 or5179.69 for5179.85 14¢-5180.09 sorry,5180.97 sitting5181.36 around5181.53 from5181.85 some5182.01 something5182.24 or5182.65 another.5182.81 How5183.53 do5183.69 you5183.77 how5184.09 would5184.16 you5184.41 respond5184.57 to5184.89 that?5185.05
5185.77 FITZGERALD5185.77 -5185.77 Yeah.5185.77 I'd5186.01 say,5186.16 unfortunately,5186.41 it5187.05 does5187.2 end5187.36 up5187.53 where5187.69 so5187.92 many5188.16 consumers5188.32 are5188.8 harmed.5188.96 So5189.36 when5189.52 the5189.68 judgment5189.92 gets5190.4 divided,5190.64 it5190.96 is5191.12 the5191.28 silly5191.52 14¢5191.84 payouts,5192.4 but5193.12 I'd5193.44 say5193.6 they5193.76 are5193.92 effective5194.16 in5194.64 changing5194.88 business5195.36 practices,5195.76 which5196.32 is5196.56 the5196.72 goal.5196.8 We've5197.2 seen5197.44 this5197.68 in5197.84 Illinois.5198 They5198.56 have5198.57 a5198.58 biometric5198.59 privacy5198.6 act5198.61 that5198.62 was5198.63 passed5198.64 in5198.64 02/20085198.65 before5198.68 big5198.69 techs,5198.7 like,5198.71 lobbying5198.72 machine,5199.6 privacy5200.02 act5200.1 that5200.34 was5200.41 passed5200.57 in5200.9 02/20085201.06 before5201.61 big5201.94 techs5202.18 like5202.57 lobbying5202.9 machine5203.38 stood5203.94 up,5204.49 so5204.9 it5205.22 passed.5205.3 And5206.34 that5206.98 law5207.22 has5207.45 forced5207.69 you5207.98 to5208.02 know5208.18 there's5208.18 a5208.34 company5208.41 called5208.65 Clearview5208.9 AI5209.3 that5209.61 scans5209.85 all5210.26 of5210.49 our5210.65 photos5210.73 online5211.14 and5211.45 is5211.69 building5211.77 a5212.1 database5212.18 of5212.65 every5212.81 person5213.14 on5213.45 earth.5213.61 The5214.98 ACLU5215.14 sued5215.69 under5216.15 the5216.31 Illinois5216.63 Biometric5217.03 Privacy5217.51 Act,5218.07 and5218.39 ClearView5218.71 AI5219.19 was5219.43 forced5219.59 to5219.91 stop5219.99 selling5220.31 its5221.03 database5221.43 to5222.15 private5223.11 individuals5223.51 and5224.07 law5225.51 enforcement.5225.75 So5226.95 it's5228.15 also5228.63 remembered5228.95 when5229.35 Facebook5229.51 used5229.91 to5230.07 tag5230.23 everyone's5230.47 faces5230.87 on5231.19 Facebook5231.44 by5231.84 scanning;5231.99 it5232.4 stopped5232.56 that5232.88 business5233.03 practice.5233.35 So,5233.76 it5235.35 may5235.52 not5235.68 be5235.84 effective5235.91 in5236.23 getting5236.31 people5236.56 individual5236.88 remedies,5237.27 but5237.68 it5237.91 is5238.07 effective5238.23 in5238.8 encouraging5239.03 compliance5239.6 in5239.99 the5240.15 first5240.23 place5240.48 and5241.03 ensuring5241.6 that5242.07 if5242.07 there5242.15 are5242.4 violations5242.56 that5243.11 they're5243.27 remedied.5243.52
OWENS5244.73 -5244.73 Thank5244.73 you.5244.97
5247.45 FARLEY-BOUVIER5247.45 -5247.45 I5247.45 have5247.69 a5247.77 follow-up5247.85 to5248.41 that.5248.65 We5250.33 hear5250.65 a5250.97 lot5251.05 that5251.29 it5251.29 particularly5251.61 harms5252.17 small5252.65 business.5252.97 Can5253.45 you5253.69 tell5253.85 us5254.09 more5254.33 about5254.57 private5255.05 rights5255.45 actions5255.61 in5255.92 small5256.17 business?5256.41
5257.98 FITZGERALD5257.98 -5257.98 Yes.5257.98 You5258.94 know,5259.57
5259.73 FARLEY-BOUVIER5259.73 -5259.73 How5259.73 can5259.73 we5259.9 let5260.22 me5260.38 be5260.61 more5260.85 specific5261.09 in5261.49 that5261.57 question?5261.65 I'm5261.98 sorry5262.06 I5262.3 interrupted.5262.38 You5263.41 know,5263.57 I5264.14 have5264.3 obviously5264.53 true5265.65 small5265.98 businesses5266.38 in5267.02 my5267.26 downtown.5268.06 Yeah.5268.53 We5268.85 call5269.02 it5269.26 North5269.41 Street,5269.65 It's5270.04 a5270.28 field.5270.28 Like,5272.2 I5272.52 do5272.6 want5272.84 they're5273.16 they5273.4 are5273.64 different5273.88 Yes.5274.36 Right,5274.92 then,5275.32 Meta.5275.64 Right?5276.2 So5276.84 how5277.4 do5277.56 we5277.64 protect5278.76 them?5279.24
5280.2 FITZGERALD5280.2 -5280.2 Yeah.5280.2 We5281.08 recognize5281.24 that5281.88 even5282.28 the5282.52 threat5282.68 of5283 litigation5283.08 is5283.72 very5284.06 difficult5284.22 for5284.45 small5284.53 businesses5284.85 to5285.02 deal5285.18 with.5285.41 I5285.57 think5285.66 you5286.1 both5286.53 dealt5287.98 with5288.22 that5288.3 appropriately5288.45 in5288.85 your5289.02 bill5289.1 by5289.41 exempting5289.57 small5290.06 businesses5290.3 from5290.77 the5290.94 private5291.02 right5291.34 of5291.49 action.5291.66 I5292.14 think5292.3 that5292.38 is5294.85 a5295.34 common-sense5295.34 compromise5295.34 to5295.9 say,5296.06 look,5296.22 you5296.45 don't5296.61 need5296.7 to5296.85 worry5296.94 about5297.1 this.5297.26 If5297.41 there's5297.49 a5297.73 small5297.81 business5298.06 that's5298.38 violating5298.94 the5299.38 law5299.65 enough5299.91 that5300.18 it5300.45 rises5300.72 to5300.98 the5301.25 level5301.52 that5301.78 the5302.05 AG5302.32 is5302.58 going5302.85 to5303.12 enforce,5303.39 yes,5303.65 that5303.92 they5304.19 should5304.45 have5304.72 an5304.99 enforcement5305.25 action5305.52 against5305.79 them.5306.06 But5306.32 that5306.59 removes5306.86 kind5307.12 of5307.39 that5307.66 that5307.92 litigation5308.19 threat5308.46 from5308.73 small5308.99 businesses,5309.26 and5309.53 I5309.79 think5310.06 that's5310.59 a5310.86 common.5311.13
5316.35 FARLEY-BOUVIER5316.35 -5316.35 So5316.99 can5317.23 you5317.4 address5317.88 the5318.52 word5318.6 patchwork?5319.56 What5320.91 what5321.72 is5321.95 your5322.11 tell5323.4 me5323.56 what5323.72 you5323.8 think5323.95 about5324.11 all5324.35 that.5324.84
FITZGERALD5325 -5325 Yeah.5325 It's5325.72 not5325.96 much5326.2 of5326.36 a5326.52 patchwork5326.6 because5327.16 the5327.72 Washington5328.84 state5329.32 law5329.56 that5330.04 Chris5331.4 Colrain5331.64 mentioned5332.12 that5332.68 influenced5332.92 Virginia5333.4 and5333.96 then5334.12 a5334.84 litany5335 of5335.4 other5335.56 states,5335.72 I5336.04 think,5336.12 you5336.36 know,5336.52 say5337.32 175337.56 or5338.03 185338.2 states5338.52 have5338.84 versions5339.32 of5339.8 it5339.95 now,5340.11 was5341.4 originally5341.72 in5342.03 written5342.28 by5342.44 industry.5342.68 I'd5343.07 be5343.24 happy5343.32 to5343.56 send5343.72 articles5343.95 on5344.28 this5344.44 around5344.76 to5345.07 the5345.16 committee,5345.32 but5345.72 it's,5345.95 you5346.35 know,5346.44 been5346.68 revealed5346.84 that5347.24 Amazon5347.56 was5348.11 a5348.28 big5348.35 drafter5348.6 of5348.91 that5349.17 original5349.33 Washington5349.65 state5350.29 law,5350.53 other5351.09 big5351.33 tech5351.57 companies.5351.81 So5352.61 they5352.77 wrote5352.93 it5353.17 so5353.33 that5353.49 it5353.73 basically5353.89 bakes5354.21 the5354.45 status5354.61 quo5355.01 into5355.25 law5355.57 and5355.81 didn't5356.05 give5356.37 many5356.77 meaningful5357.25 privacy5357.81 rights5358.37 to5359.09 individuals.5359.25 Any5359.89 rights5360.13 that5360.37 they5360.45 gave5360.61 them5360.77 made5361.1 them5361.27 as5361.35 hard5361.51 as5361.59 possible5361.82 to5363.74 effectuate.5363.9 EPIC5366.63 has5366.94 a5367.19 report5367.27 out5367.59 with5367.82 the5368.15 US5368.86 PERG5368.86 Education5369.27 Fund5369.66 where5369.98 we5370.23 graded5370.31 state5370.86 privacy5371.19 laws.5371.74
5372.63 Of5372.63 the5372.86 195372.94 that5373.38 are5373.54 out5373.7 there,5374.5 85375.14 got5375.62 F's,5375.94 and5376.98 none5377.22 got5377.46 an5377.7 a.5377.86 Connecticut,5378.66 which5379.14 you've5379.3 heard5379.46 mentioned5379.7 many5380.1 times5380.34 today,5380.66 received5381.22 a5381.62 d.5381.78 The5383.06 reason5383.22 for5383.54 that5383.7 is5384.1 the5384.98 kind5385.22 of5385.46 so-called5385.86 data5386.1 minimization5386.34 rule5386.98 in5387.22 that5387.38 law5387.7 says5389.15 companies5390.35 can5390.76 collect5390.99 what's5391.47 necessary5391.88 for5392.91 the5393.07 purposes5393.15 that5393.55 they5393.64 put5393.8 in5393.95 their5394.03 privacy5394.11 policy,5394.51 and5394.84 that's5394.99 not5395.23 a5395.4 meaningful5395.47 privacy5395.95 protection.5396.27 In5396.76 fact,5396.84 it5397.07 incentivizes5397.23 them5397.88 to5398.03 write5398.19 the5398.43 purposes5398.51 in5398.84 their5398.99 privacy5399.07 policy5399.47 as5399.88 broadly5400.11 as5400.51 possible,5400.68 so5400.91 it5401.07 covers5401.15 everything.5401.47 Right?5401.8 They5402.03 can5402.11 say,5402.35 I5403.07 collect5403.23 your5403.47 data5403.64 for5403.88 marketing5404.24 purposes.5404.56 That5405.28 tells5405.52 me5405.76 nothing5405.92 but5406.4 allows5406.64 them5406.88 to5407.12 do5407.2 almost5407.36 anything.5407.68 So5409.2 that's5409.44 not5409.68 meaningful,5409.84 and5410.32 that's5410.64 why5410.88 I5411.04 think5411.12 we've5411.28 seen5411.6 the5411.84 original5412 sponsor5412.4 in5412.72 Connecticut5412.88 push5414 forward5414.24 legislation5414.48 this5415.12 session5415.36 to5416.16 strengthen5417.95 the5418.35 Connecticut5418.52 privacy5418.91 law5419.31 to5419.56 include5419.72 a5420.11 data5420.2 minimization5420.52 rule5421.07 that5421.31 limits5421.56 collection5422.03 to5422.44 what's5422.76 reasonably5422.99 necessary5423.31 for5423.64 the5423.8 product5423.88 or5424.11 service5424.27 the5424.6 consumer's5424.68 asking5425.16 for.5425.4
5426.76 FARLEY-BOUVIER5426.76 -5426.76 Again,5426.76 working5427.07 in5427.48 multiple5427.56 states5427.95 and5428.35 being5429.48 very5429.8 familiar5430.03 with5430.52 the5430.76 bill5431.5 being5431.74 currently5432.06 debated5432.54 in5432.94 Connecticut.5433.18 Also,5434.62 the5435.66 big5435.98 change5436.3 they5436.62 are5436.86 making5437.02 is5437.66 the5437.9 difference,5438.06 the5438.86 data5439.02 level,5439.26 and5439.82 exemption5439.82 versus5440.38 the5440.78 entity5441.58 level5441.98 exemption.5442.38 So,5442.86 we5443.98 did.5444.22 I5444.54 did5444.62 ask5444.86 for5445.1 comments5445.26 from5445.58 the5445.74 last5445.9 person5446.65 testifying5446.97 about5447.52 that.5447.84 Can5448.01 you5448.24 tell5448.4 us5448.65 your5449.05 thoughts5449.28 about5449.6 the5449.76 difference5449.93 between5450.24 data-level5450.8 and5451.05 entity-level5451.93 exemptions?5453.52
5453.52 FITZGERALD5453.52 -5453.52 Yes.5453.52 I5453.84 think,5454.01 you5454.24 know,5454.4 you5454.48 made5454.65 an5454.8 excellent5454.89 point5455.28 that5455.44 some5455.6 of5455.76 these5455.84 laws5456.09 were5456.32 passed,5456.48 you5456.8 know,5456.97 and5457.2 flip5457.52 flones5457.76 were5458.16 coming5458.32 out.5458.56 You5458.89 know,5458.97 GLBA5459.2 requires5459.93 we've5460.48 all5460.65 gotten5460.87 them.5461.03 Requires5461.27 them5461.67 to5461.83 be5461.99 mailed5462.15 those5462.47 paper5462.71 privacy5463.03 notices5463.51 that5464.07 come5464.23 that5464.55 that5465.11 we5465.43 just5465.59 throw5465.75 in5465.99 the5466.15 recycling5466.31 bin.5466.87 In5467.83 there,5468.07 it5468.31 says5468.39 we5468.63 can5468.79 opt5468.95 out5469.19 if5469.35 we5469.51 call5469.59 them.5469.83 I've5469.99 tried5470.23 it.5470.47 You5470.55 have5470.71 to.5471.03 You5471.11 can't5471.11 even5471.35 do5471.59 it5471.67 online.5471.83 You5472.15 have5472.31 to5472.55 call.5472.71 It5473.03 goes5473.19 through5473.35 17,5473.59 you5474.39 know,5474.47 levels5474.71 of5475.11 phone5475.19 pressing5476.24 the5476.56 buttons.5476.73 They5477.76 make5477.93 it5478.09 as5478.24 hard5478.4 as5478.56 possible.5478.65 So,5479.6 and5481.2 then5481.36 they're5481.6 also5481.84 collecting5482.16 a5482.56 ton5482.73 of5482.89 data5482.97 that's5483.28 not5483.6 even5484.01 covered5484.32 by5484.65 GLBA,5484.8 you5485.52 know,5485.6 the5485.84 website5486.16 trackers5486.65 and5486.97 whatnot.5487.13 But5487.36 by5487.52 giving5487.69 an5487.93 entity-level5488.4 exemption,5488.56 I5493.51 think5493.67 that5493.75 there's5493.99 a5494.47 balance5494.55 to5494.79 be5494.87 struck5494.95 there5495.27 and5495.51 data-level5495.99 exemptions.5496.31 Yeah.5497.03 I'd5497.27 love5497.51 to5497.67 see5497.75 exemptions5497.83 go5498.31 out5498.39 the5498.47 window5498.63 entirely,5499.27 but5500.63 I5500.79 think5500.87 data-level5501.43 exemptions5501.67 for5502.23 some5502.39 of5502.55 these5502.78 laws5503.02 are5504.47 a5504.78 good5504.95 compromise.5505.19
FARLEY-BOUVIER5507.1 -5507.1 Thank5507.1 you.5507.35 I5508.55 appreciate5508.86 your5509.27 testimony,5509.51 and,5510.15 looking5510.95 forward5511.27 to5511.59 continuing5511.74 to5512.23 work5512.39 with5512.55 you5512.7 throughout5512.86 the5513.19 session5513.27 on5513.59 this5513.74 bill.5513.91 Thank5514.15 you5514.31 so5514.47 much,5514.55 Caitriona.5519.18 Yeah.5519.18 Okay.5521.1 So5521.9 we5522.38 are5522.62 gonna5522.78 go5523.1 to5524.54 Julie5525.18 online,5525.74 and5526.78 then5527.02 we're5527.26 gonna5527.5 be5527.74 bringing5527.9 up5528.22 Senator5528.46 Fernandez.5528.94 Are5529.42 you5529.58 here5529.74 to5529.9 testify?5529.98
5531.15 SPEAKER75531.15 -5531.15 Yeah.5531.15
5531.31 FARLEY-BOUVIER5531.31 -5531.31 Awesome.5531.31 So5532.19 you'll5532.43 be5532.66 next.5532.82 Okay?5532.98 Thank5533.78 you5534.02 so5534.19 much.5534.35 Julie?5534.66
5536.35 JULIE5536.35 BERNSTEIN5536.35 -5536.35 CONCERNED5536.35 CITIZEN5536.35 -5536.35 HB5536.35 1045536.35 -5536.35 SB5536.35 455536.35 -5536.35 (5536.35 R5536.35 )5536.35 Yes.5536.35 Thank5536.74 you.5536.98 Can5537.47 you5537.7 hear5537.86 me?5538.1
5538.51 FARLEY-BOUVIER5538.51 -5538.51 We5538.51 can5538.66 hear5538.9 you.5539.06
BERNSTEIN5540.02 -5540.02 Great.5540.02 Chair5540.66 Moore,5540.98 Chair5541.31 Farley5541.63 Bouvier,5541.94 Vice-Chairs5542.66 Peano5543.06 and5543.55 Hawkins,5543.7 and5544.1 Members5544.27 of5544.47 the5544.66 committee,5544.82 thank5545.15 you5545.39 for5545.55 allowing5545.7 me5546.02 to5546.1 testify5546.57 in5546.77 support5546.97 of5547.37 the5547.53 Massachusetts5547.69 Data5548.73 Privacy5549.05 Act5549.53 H5550.65 1045550.89 S5550.89 455550.89 and5551.77 strong5552.09 enforceable5552.49 data5553.13 privacy5553.37 legislation5553.85 more5554.49 generally5554.65 on5555.13 behalf5555.37 of5555.69 the5555.77 Massachusetts5556.01 Civil5556.65 Liberties5556.89 Group5557.29 Digital5557.53 4.5557.93 We5558.74 commend5558.9 Chair5559.39 Moore5559.63 and5559.78 Chair5559.94 Farley5560.19 Bouvier5560.59 for5561.06 their5561.15 tremendous5561.39 work5561.86 toward5562.1 this5562.34 end.5562.59 As5563.23 we5563.39 witness5563.47 the5563.86 roundup5564.02 of5564.43 protesters5564.59 and5565.23 immigrants5565.47 by5565.86 the5566.02 federal5566.19 government,5566.51 we5566.9 must5567.06 recognize5567.39 the5567.94 constant5568.1 stream5568.51 of5568.82 sensitive5568.98 personal5569.47 data,5569.86 including5570.51 precise5570.98 geolocation,5571.47 social5572.47 media5572.55 posts,5572.63 affiliations,5573.59 and5574.23 more,5574.39 that5574.87 is5575.11 legally5575.27 being5575.67 sold5575.99 to5576.23 law5576.39 enforcement5576.55 at5577.11 the5577.27 local,5577.43 state,5577.75 and5578.07 federal5578.15 levels5578.55 by5578.87 data5579.03 brokers.5579.27 Our5580.15 written5580.31 testimony5580.55 documents5581.27 how5581.75 this5581.99 massive5582.23 transfer5582.71 of5583.11 data5583.19 includes5583.91 AI5584.39 analysis5584.79 that5585.27 characterizes5585.66 us5586.3 based5586.47 on5586.78 our5586.94 expressed5587.19 opinions5587.51 and5588.23 affiliations5588.47 that5589.02 are5589.19 often5589.43 flawed5589.82 but5590.39 are5590.63 nonetheless5590.78 being5591.34 used5591.51 to5591.74 assign5591.98 us5592.39 guilt5592.55 for5593.1 speech5593.34 that5593.59 the5593.74 government5593.82 identifies5594.47 as5595.1 being5595.26 either5595.59 a5595.82 terrorist5596.06 supporter5596.55 or5597.1 in5597.19 conflict5597.6 with5597.76 its5598 foreign5598.16 policy.5598.48 The5599.36 Consumer5599.6 Financial5600.08 Protection5600.64 Bureau5601.12 and5601.52 the5601.68 Federal5601.84 Trade5602.16 Commission5602.4 previously5603.04 penalized5603.92 businesses5604.48 that5604.96 abused5605.04 our5605.52 sensitive5605.6 personal5606.16 data.5606.56
5607.36 The5607.36 CFPD5607.68 has5608.64 recently5608.8 been5609.28 incapacitated.5609.52 FTC5610.96 chairman5611.52 Andrew5611.92 Ferguson5612.45 declared5612.77 that5613.34 the5613.57 agency5613.73 would,5614.3 quote,5614.69 stop5615.09 abusing5615.49 FTC5615.98 enforcement5616.53 authorities5617.18 as5618.05 a5618.22 substitute5618.45 for5619.02 comprehensive5619.34 privacy5620.05 legislation,5620.61 unquote.5621.26 The5622.22 CFPB5622.45 and5623.02 FTC5623.18 will5623.9 no5624.14 longer5624.3 protect5624.61 our5625.02 private5625.18 data.5625.57 The5626.38 California5626.53 and5627.09 Texas5627.26 attorneys5627.8 general5628.12 have5628.52 each5628.6 enforced5628.84 state5629.32 data5629.48 privacy5629.8 laws5630.6 against5631.08 violating5631.64 companies.5632.2 State5633.16 enforcement5633.48 will5634.04 be5634.2 imperative5634.44 going5635 forward.5635.24 Any5636.04 data5636.28 privacy5636.68 bill5637.16 must5637.4 include5637.64 detailed5637.96 requirements5638.44 for5638.84 data5639.08 rights5640.14 to5640.45 view,5640.61 correct,5641.01 and5641.34 delete5641.57 collected5641.9 data,5642.3 obtaining5643.26 consent5643.65 for5644.05 each5644.22 transfer5644.45 of5644.85 an5645.01 individual's5645.18 sensitive5645.65 data,5646.05 and5646.45 a5646.69 private5646.85 right5647.18 of5647.34 action.5647.49 Digital5648.53 Fourth5649.01 would5649.26 like5649.41 to5649.57 highlight5649.73 additional5650.22 valuable5650.77 provisions5651.26 from5651.65 the5651.9 Massachusetts5652.05 Data5652.69 Privacy5653.01 Act.5653.57 Section5654.05 935654.61 provides5655.34 especially5655.87 strong5656.27 protections5656.59 of5657.07 geolocation5657.31 data,5657.87 including5658.19 a5658.67 warrant5658.75 requirement5659.15 for5659.79 sharing5659.95 such5660.27 data5660.51 with5660.75 any5660.91 federal,5661.23 state,5661.63 or5661.79 local5662.03 government5662.35 agency5662.75 or5663.15 official.5663.31 We5664.03 support5664.27 the5664.67 Location5664.83 Shield5665.39 Act,5665.79 which5666.03 is5666.27 based5666.43 on5666.75 935666.91 n.5667.47
5668.03 The5668.03 MDPA5668.27 and5668.83 the5669.07 Massachusetts5669.15 Consumer5669.95 Data5670.35 Privacy5670.67 Act5671.15 both5671.69 require5672.01 companies5672.32 to5672.73 give5672.89 individuals5673.13 a5673.52 list5673.6 of5673.93 all5674.01 third5674.24 parties5674.48 to5674.89 which5675.05 their5675.2 data5675.36 has5675.6 been5675.77 transferred.5675.93 The5676.81 MDPA5677.05 further5677.93 requires5678.32 that5678.89 OCABR5679.36 host5680.48 a5680.73 searchable5680.89 website5681.36 with5681.77 the5682.01 contact5682.16 information5682.65 for5683.52 any5683.69 third5684.01 parties5684.16 who5684.56 are5684.73 data5684.89 brokers.5685.13 The5686.09 MDPA5686.32 requires5686.89 that5687.36 covered5687.66 entities5687.98 present5688.46 clearly5689.02 on5689.58 their5689.74 homepage5689.9 how5690.78 to5690.94 opt5691.02 out5691.26 of5691.5 targeted5691.58 advertising5692.14 or5692.7 profiling5692.86 and5693.66 how5693.82 to5693.98 assert5694.14 consumer5694.62 rights.5695.02 It5695.82 requires5696.06 that5696.54 privacy5696.78 policies5697.26 be5697.9 detailed5698.14 and5698.7 include5698.86 information.5707.99 NDPA5707.99 compels5708.56 separate5708.95 privacy5709.28 policies5709.84 for5710.24 biometric5710.48 and5711.11 geolocation5711.35 data.5711.91 It5712.56 requires5712.72 that5713.2 the5713.35 attorney5713.44 general5713.84 publish5714.24 on5714.56 a5714.64 website5714.72 how5715.44 to5715.65 report5715.81 violations,5716.93 reported5717.25 violations5717.73 of5718.29 consumer5718.53 rights,5718.85 investigations5719.57 made,5720.45 and5720.77 the5721.01 outcomes5721.25 of5721.65 legal5721.81 actions5722.13 taken.5722.53 Please5723.41 send5723.73 forward5723.89 the5724.29 strongest5724.45 and5725.01 broadest5725.17 possible5725.65 data5725.97 privacy5726.29 legislation.5726.77 Thank5727.57 you.5727.81
FARLEY-BOUVIER5728.74 -5728.74 Thank5728.74 you5728.91 so5729.06 much,5729.15 Julie.5729.55 Appreciate5729.86 your5730.27 testimony5730.43 today.5730.98 We're5732.19 gonna5732.43 now5732.66 go5733.23 out5733.47 of5733.63 order5733.78 and5734.1 bring5734.27 up5734.51 Senator5734.82 Dylan5735.55 Fernandez.5735.86 And5736.59 then,5736.74 on5737.06 deck5737.31 is5737.63 Megan5738.82 Evans,5739.23 who5739.23 is5739.39 joining5739.55 us5739.94 online.5740.19
5742.79 SEN5742.79 FERNANDEZ5742.79 -5742.79 SB5742.79 365742.79 -5742.79 Alright.5742.79 Well,5743.59 thank5743.99 you,5744.31 madam5745.19 chair5745.59 and5745.91 mister5746.39 chairman5746.71 and5747.19 honorable5747.51 committee5748.07 members5748.39 for5748.71 taking5748.79 me5749.11 out5749.19 of5749.35 turn.5749.43 I'll5750.15 be5750.31 brief.5750.55 I'm5750.79 here5750.87 to5751.11 testify5751.19 in5751.59 support5751.75 of5752.47 our5752.79 legislation5753.03 h5753.91 or5754.47 s5754.79 now,5755.27 365756.31 and5756.79 365757.11 and5757.81 act5757.97 to5758.85 provide5758.93 accountability5759.32 in5760.05 the5760.13 use5760.2 of5760.52 biometric5760.6 recognition5761.24 technology5761.89 and5763.16 comprehensive5763.48 enforcement.5765.16 You5767.32 know,5767.4 this5767.65 is5767.81 technology5768.6 that5769.48 has5769.65 vast5770.52 impacts5770.93 on5771.67 our5771.99 society,5772.15 but5772.63 there5772.87 are5772.95 very5773.19 few5773.43 laws5773.67 guiding5773.99 it.5774.31 And5774.47 I5774.63 think5774.71 that's5774.87 probably5775.03 why5775.35 there's5775.59 such5776.31 a5776.47 popular5776.55 hearing5777.19 today.5778.15 There5779.27 are5779.51 very5779.67 mundane5779.83 uses5780.31 for5780.63 this5780.79 technology,5781.03 such5781.67 as5781.83 scrolling5781.99 through5782.31 photos5782.55 or5783.19 opening5783.35 your5783.75 phone.5783.99 But5785.83 companies5786.15 are5786.79 also5786.95 using5787.35 facial5787.81 recognition5788.13 and5788.6 other5788.77 biometric5789.09 data5789.73 to5790.52 track5790.6 our5790.93 movements5791.09 and5791.73 effectively5792.05 end5792.69 privacy5792.93 as5794.05 we5794.2 know5794.36 it.5794.6
5795.32 Massachusetts5795.32 as5796.28 a5796.44 state5796.6 has5797.01 begun5797.24 to5797.65 consider5797.81 regulating5798.2 government5798.85 use5799.4 of5799.73 this5799.89 technology.5801.24 And5801.89 while5802.05 that's5802.28 a5802.52 good5802.6 start,5802.93 what5803.33 actually5803.57 scares5803.89 me5804.21 more5805.25 is5805.97 the5807.25 unfettered5807.73 use5808.77 of5809.57 private5810.05 companies5810.53 being5811.25 able5811.57 to5812.29 use5813.81 this5814.37 data,5814.69 our5815.28 data5815.52 that's5815.84 most5816.72 personal5817.03 to5818.31 us.5818.48 And5819.44 as5819.68 facial5819.84 recognition5820.24 technology5820.88 has5821.35 improved,5821.6 coupled5822.56 with5822.95 even5823.2 greater5823.44 saturation5823.91 of5824.48 cameras,5824.72 private5825.2 companies5825.6 love5826.16 the5826.31 ability5826.48 to5826.95 track5827.11 our5827.44 movements5827.6 without5828.61 our5828.85 permission5829.01 or5829.73 knowledge5830.05 and5830.45 sell5830.69 our5830.93 facial5831.09 data5831.49 to5832.21 other5832.37 companies.5832.69 And5833.17 there5833.33 have5833.57 already5833.57 been5834.13 instances,5834.45 well-publicized,5836.61 of5837.33 fans5837.33 being5837.81 denied5838.05 entry5838.45 to5838.77 concert5838.93 venues5839.41 based5839.89 on5840.13 the5840.29 whims5840.45 of5840.85 a5840.93 sports5841.56 stadium5841.8 owner5842.44 after5843.15 being5843.4 identified5843.72 by5845.4 facial5845.8 recognition5846.35 scans.5847.15 We5848.52 are5849.31 in5849.72 a5849.88 world5850.03 where5850.52 you5851.64 can5851.72 walk5851.95 into5852.19 a5852.44 store,5852.68 and5854.2 the5854.36 store5854.52 cameras5854.92 can5856.2 match5856.76 up5857.24 with5857.4 your5857.56 face,5857.88 with5858.2 an5858.44 online5858.6 profile,5859.8 with5860.6 data5860.92 about5861.32 your5861.64 buying5861.8 power5862.12 and5862.52 likely5862.68 preferences,5863.16 or5864.12 where5864.36 your5864.52 face5864.68 is5864.92 tracked5865.08 across5865.48 public5865.8 places,5866.2 and5866.6 that5866.76 data5866.92 is5867.32 sold5867.56 to5868.26 market5868.41 to5868.57 you.5868.73
5869.45 And5869.45 maybe5869.69 that5869.94 doesn't5870.34 sound5870.65 like5870.9 a5870.98 problem,5871.14 but5871.45 what5871.61 if5871.77 a5871.94 store5872.09 used5872.41 or5873.14 a5873.53 company5873.61 used5874.09 facial5874.41 recognition5874.73 data5875.38 to5875.77 match5876.01 your5876.41 face5876.65 to5876.98 an5877.14 online5877.3 profile5877.77 that5878.57 projects5878.81 your5879.22 likelihood5879.45 of5880.09 theft5880.34 or5881.14 uses5881.45 tracking5881.85 data5882.18 to5882.57 deny5882.65 you5882.98 insurance5883.22 or5884.48 a5885.28 loan5885.44 or5885.84 some5886.32 other5888.56 service?5888.8 So,5888.8 we5888.8 should5888.96 all5889.12 have5889.36 a5889.6 right5889.68 to5890.24 privacy.5890.56 Companies5893.04 that5894.08 have5894.24 compiled5894.48 these5894.96 databases5895.28 with5896.16 billions5896.32 of5896.72 pictures5896.88 of5897.36 our5897.52 faces5897.68 should5898.56 have5898.8 some5898.96 regulations.5899.2 And5899.76 so5900.06 what5900.22 we're5900.45 proposing5900.53 is5901.81 something5902.3 that's,5902.7 you5903.18 know,5903.34 this5903.49 is5903.74 a5903.81 hard5903.98 thing5904.22 to5904.45 regulate,5904.61 I5905.02 think.5905.1 I5905.34 know5905.41 a5905.66 lot5905.74 of5905.9 states5905.98 are5906.38 grappling5906.53 with5906.85 this.5906.94 You5907.1 know,5907.26 the5907.41 federal5907.49 government's5907.81 kind5908.3 of5908.61 trying5908.7 well,5909.1 maybe5909.98 someday5910.38 we'll5910.7 hopefully5910.94 grapple5911.34 with5911.66 this.5911.81 We're5913.05 just5913.37 proposing5913.61 that5915.05 we5915.69 implement5916.09 a5916.89 fiduciary5917.05 responsibility5918.09 on5919.85 these5920.09 companies.5920.49 We've5921.77 seen5922.17 that5922.49 the5922.81 fiduciary5922.97 responsibility5923.69 actually5924.57 works5924.89 quite5925.29 well5925.61 in5926.65 the5927.05 financial5927.81 space5928.45 when5929.02 it5929.26 comes5929.41 to5929.73 protecting5929.98 people's5931.81 best5933.26 interests.5933.57 And5934.45 so5934.61 we5934.85 think5934.94 that5935.26 model5935.49 can5935.98 be5936.22 used5936.45 here5936.94 in5937.49 our5937.66 data5938.94 privacy5939.34 space5940.06 in5940.45 a5940.69 way5940.85 that5941.26 puts5941.41 the5941.97 consumer5942.21 or5943.49 the5943.73 person5943.89 in5944.45 your5944.85 most5945.09 personal5945.41 data5945.97 and5946.93 proper5947.57 care.5948.05 And5948.53 so5948.77 that's5949.09 what5949.25 this5949.41 legislation5949.65 simply5951.01 does.5951.57 It5952.13 kind5953.17 of5953.33 imposes5953.57 this5954.05 fiduciary5954.97 responsibility5955.6 model5956.4 that5956.81 works5957.05 really5957.44 well5957.77 in5958.56 this5958.73 other5958.97 sector5959.28 with5959.69 some5959.93 flaws,5960.16 but5960.4 decently5960.65 well,5961.05 on5962.97 this5963.13 space5963.44 that5963.84 sorely5964.24 needs5964.89 some5965.13 regulation.5965.36 So5965.93 with5966.66 that,5966.82 thank5966.98 you5967.06 so5967.38 much5967.54 for5967.86 taking5968.26 me5968.58 out5968.74 of5968.9 turn,5969.06 and,5969.3 happy5970.58 to5970.82 answer5970.98 any5971.22 questions.5971.38
5972.02 FARLEY-BOUVIER5972.02 -5972.02 Sure.5972.02 Thank5972.18 you5972.42 so5972.5 much,5972.66 Senator.5972.82 Anybody5973.22 here?5973.62 Thank5974.9 you,5975.14 Senator.5975.3 We5975.62 appreciate5975.78 your5976.1 testimony5976.26 today.5976.82 We're5978.26 now5978.5 gonna5978.74 go5979.06 virtually5980.18 to5980.82 Megan5981.14 Evans,5981.62 and5982.57 on5982.9 deck5983.14 will5983.38 be5983.53 Ben5983.85 Winters.5984.1 Megan?5985.3
5988.66 MEGAN5988.66 EVANS5988.66 -ACOG5988.66 -5988.66 HB5988.66 865988.66 -5988.66 SB5988.66 1975988.66 -5988.66 (5988.66 R5988.66 )5988.66 Hi.5988.66 Thank5988.9 you.5989.06 Can5989.38 you5989.53 hear5989.7 me,5989.85 okay?5990.02
5990.74 FARLEY-BOUVIER5990.74 -5990.74 We5990.74 can.5990.9 Thank5991.14 you5991.3 so5991.53 much.5991.7
5992.49 EVANS5992.49 -5992.49 Great.5992.49 Committee5993.94 Chair5994.34 Farley5994.57 Beauvais5994.98 and5995.53 Chair5995.7 Moore,5996.02 as5996.34 well5996.49 as5996.74 members5996.81 of5997.14 the5997.22 committee,5997.38 thank5997.85 you5998.07 for5998.23 the5998.39 opportunity5998.47 to5998.95 present5999.11 testimony5999.51 in5999.99 support6000.15 of6000.47 House6000.79 Bill6000.95 866000.95 and6001.51 Senate6002.39 Bill6003.03 197,6003.03 the6003.03 location6003.11 shield6003.59 act.6003.91 I'm6004.63 an6004.87 OB6005.03 GYN6005.27 practicing6005.83 in6006.31 Boston,6006.47 and6006.79 I'm6006.95 here6007.11 speaking6007.43 on6007.75 behalf6007.91 of6008.15 the6008.31 American6008.39 College6008.79 of6009.11 Obstetricians6009.27 and6009.91 Gynecologists,6010.07 for6010.87 which6011.11 I6011.27 am6011.35 currently6011.51 the6011.83 Massachusetts6011.99 vice6012.63 chair.6012.87 The6013.8 Massachusetts6014.03 section6014.51 of6014.76 ACOG6014.91 represents6015.39 more6015.8 than6015.95 1,4006016.19 OB6016.84 GYNs6017.15 who6017.72 are6017.88 committed6018.03 to6018.43 providing6018.68 safe,6020.03 evidence-based6020.35 health6020.35 care6020.51 for6020.76 the6020.99 women6021.07 and6021.39 patients6021.55 in6021.95 our6022.03 state6022.27 and6022.91 the6023.07 patients6023.23 who6023.55 travel6023.8 for6024.11 care6024.27 within6024.51 our6024.84 borders.6024.99 I6026.06 wanna6026.14 first6026.46 thank6026.62 our6026.86 legislative6027.1 colleagues6027.58 and6027.9 their6028.06 commitment6028.3 to6028.7 protecting6028.86 reproductive6029.34 health6029.98 care6030.22 within6030.38 the6030.7 Commonwealth.6030.78 We6031.82 have6032.06 worked6032.22 as6032.54 partners6032.78 over6033.18 the6033.42 years6033.5 on6033.82 a6033.9 number6034.06 of6034.3 legislative6034.46 priorities,6035.02 including6035.42 the6035.82 passage6035.82 of6036.22 the6036.3 Roe6036.46 Act6036.7 and,6037.1 recently,6037.5 a6037.5 comprehensive6037.58 maternal6038.22 health6038.62 bill.6038.86
6039.88 Massachusetts6039.88 continues6040.68 to6041.23 serve6041.4 as6041.72 an6041.88 example6042.03 across6042.76 the6043.07 country6043.23 of6043.64 what6043.8 access6044.03 to6044.52 comprehensive6044.59 life-saving6045.72 and6046.03 equitable6046.27 reproductive6046.76 health6047.4 care6047.64 looks6047.8 like.6047.95 However,6049.07 recently,6049.64 we6049.95 have6050.11 seen6050.27 the6050.52 anti-choice6051.07 movement6051.4 change6051.88 its6052.11 tactics6052.35 to6052.91 attempt6053.07 to6053.48 curtail6053.56 access6054.35 in6054.51 states6054.67 like6054.91 Massachusetts.6055.23 Recent6056.43 reporting6056.83 demonstrates6057.31 that6057.79 the6057.95 threat6058.11 of6058.43 location6058.59 data6059.07 brokers6059.39 selling6059.95 information6060.35 about6060.91 abortion6061.23 patients6061.71 and6062.03 providers6062.27 is6062.75 already6062.91 happening.6063.23 The6064.19 widespread6064.35 availability6064.91 of6065.55 granular6065.71 cell6066.27 phone6066.51 location6066.67 information6067.15 enables6067.71 anyone6068.27 with6068.67 a6068.83 credit6068.91 card6069.23 to6069.47 purchase6069.84 and6070.15 track6070.31 the6070.55 location6070.72 data6071.19 of6071.51 people6071.59 seeking6071.99 or6072.47 providing6072.72 reproductive6073.35 health6073.84 care6074.07 in6074.23 our6074.4 state.6074.55 As6075.76 long6075.91 as6076.15 the6076.31 cell6076.47 phone6076.64 location6076.88 market6077.27 remains6077.59 entirely6078.15 unregulated6078.72 in6079.27 Massachusetts,6079.43 we6080.31 as6080.55 providers6080.8 and6081.27 patients6081.51 that6081.84 seek6082.07 care6082.09 continue6082.11 to6082.14 face6082.15 the6082.18 risk6082.18 of6082.19 personal6082.22 harm.6082.23 This6082.26 is6082.27 especially6082.3 true6082.31 now6082.64 that6082.85 digital6083.07 privacy6095.56 by6096.05 drawing6096.28 geofences6096.69 around6097.32 sensitive6097.65 locations6098.13 like6098.6 clinics6098.93 and6099.32 hospitals6099.65 can6100.69 not6100.84 only6101.01 have6101.24 the6101.4 unintended6101.56 consequence6102.36 of6102.93 actually6103.09 undermining6103.56 the6104.05 protections6104.2 the6104.84 legislature6105.01 has6105.65 passed6105.89 for6106.13 those6106.28 in6106.44 our6106.6 profession6106.77 but6107.65 also6107.81 fails6108.2 to6108.52 secure6108.89 location6109.13 privacy6109.53 for6110.01 each6110.17 and6110.41 every6110.57 person6110.81 seeking6111.21 critical6111.61 care.6112.01
6112.89 This6112.89 includes6113.13 victims6113.53 of6113.93 domestic6114.09 violence6114.57 seeking6115.05 aid6115.37 and6115.61 shelter6115.77 and6116.25 patients6116.57 seeking6116.97 gender6117.29 affirming6117.69 care6118.09 and6118.25 abortion6118.41 services,6118.89 especially6119.85 those6120.25 traveling6120.57 from6120.97 hostile6121.13 states.6121.61 Passing6122.61 the6123.02 Location6123.98 Shield6124.22 Act6124.22 is6124.22 critical6124.38 to6124.78 mitigate6125.02 the6125.41 potential6125.57 for6126.06 hostile6126.3 actors,6126.7 whether6127.49 they6127.81 be6127.98 anti6128.14 abortion6128.45 extremists,6128.94 abusive6129.57 ex-partners6130.38 or6130.78 spouses,6130.94 or6131.49 anyone6131.74 else6132.14 from6132.53 weaponizes6132.85 our6133.49 personal6133.66 information6134.06 to6134.61 further6134.78 their6135.1 dangerous6135.34 agenda.6135.81 As6136.94 reproductive6137.18 health6137.74 care6138.08 providers,6138.24 we6138.72 are6138.96 concerned6139.12 not6139.6 just6139.76 about6140 the6140.24 privacy6140.4 of6140.8 patients6140.96 and6141.36 their6141.52 families6141.76 but6142.16 also6142.4 our6142.4 safety6142.64 and6143.04 the6143.28 safety6143.36 of6143.68 our6143.84 colleagues.6144 We6144.96 feel6145.2 strongly6145.44 that6145.92 every6146.08 citizen6146.4 of6146.8 the6146.96 commonwealth6147.04 and6147.68 any6147.92 person6148.16 who6148.48 may6148.72 travel,6148.88 work,6149.6 worship,6150.24 or6150.56 seek6150.88 health6151.2 care6151.35 or6151.6 shelter6151.91 here6152.4 deserves6153.11 location6153.6 privacy.6154.07 This6155.03 is6155.35 precisely6155.52 why6156.07 Massachusetts6156.32 ACOG6156.95 has6157.28 endorsed6157.52 the6157.99 location6158.07 shield6158.48 act6158.72 again6158.95 in6159.35 this6159.44 session.6159.68 Thank6160.56 you6160.8 for6160.95 your6161.11 time.6161.28
6161.99 FARLEY-BOUVIER6161.99 -6161.99 Thank6161.99 you6162.24 so6162.4 much,6162.56 doctor.6162.8 Does6163.99 anybody6164.47 have6164.47 any6164.63 questions?6164.79 Thank6166.23 you.6166.47 We're6166.79 now6166.95 gonna6167.19 go6167.35 to6167.51 a6167.67 panel6167.75 with6168.31 Ben6168.63 Winters,6168.87 Matt6169.43 Schwartz,6169.83 and6170.23 Nicole6170.47 Gill.6170.95 Very6171.83 welcome6172.15 here.6172.71 And6173.11 on6173.67 deck6174.15 are6175.19 Professor6176.39 Woodrow6176.39 Harzog6177.03 and6177.95 Lisa6178.19 Lavazier.6179.78 Thank6182.74 you6182.98 so6183.15 much.6183.31 Thanks.6183.95
6185.7 BEN6185.7 WINTERS6185.7 -6185.7 CFA6185.7 -6185.7 HB6185.7 786185.7 -6185.7 HB6185.7 866185.7 -6185.7 Chair6185.7 Moore,6186.02 chair6186.35 Farley6186.66 Bouvier,6186.98 and6187.39 members6187.55 of6187.78 the6187.86 committee,6188.02 thanks6188.74 for6188.98 the6189.06 opportunity6189.23 to6189.63 testify6190.01 in6190.17 strong6190.33 support6190.65 of6191.13 HB6191.37 86,6191.69 the6192.81 Logation6192.97 Shield6193.29 Act,6193.69 HB6194.09 78,6194.49 the6194.97 Massachusetts6195.05 Consumer6195.69 Data6196.09 Privacy6196.33 Act,6196.81 and6196.97 HB6197.13 99,6197.45 which6198.17 would6198.33 address,6198.57 surveillance6199.13 pricing6199.61 in6199.93 grocery6200.01 stores6200.41 using6200.73 biometric6201.05 information6201.69 that6202.09 is,6202.33 immutable.6203.05 My6204.01 name6204.09 is6204.25 Ben6204.41 Winters.6204.65 I'm6205.13 the6205.29 director6205.55 of6205.78 AI6206.02 and6206.19 privacy6206.43 at6206.74 the6206.9 Consumer6206.98 Federation6207.39 of6207.78 America6207.94 or6208.51 CFA.6208.74 CFA6209.78 was6210.19 established6210.34 in6210.74 19686210.9 and6211.78 has6212.19 over6212.51 2006212.74 members6213.15 that6213.55 are6213.63 state6213.86 and6214.1 local6214.19 agencies6215.15 and6215.78 other6216.19 nonprofits6216.9 that6217.63 work6217.78 in6218.02 the6218.1 public6218.19 interest6219.07 through6219.71 education,6220.43 advocacy,6221.07 and6221.63 research.6221.79 So6222.91 right6223.23 now,6223.47 what6223.71 we're6223.95 seeing6224.11 is6224.43 that6224.59 consumers6224.83 are6225.23 facing6225.39 a6225.87 mosaic6226.03 of6226.59 unfair6226.75 and6227.07 deceptive6227.23 trade6227.63 practices6228.43 that6229.15 pervade6229.31 life6229.71 both6230.03 online6230.35 and6230.83 off.6230.99 Consent6232.11 is6232.59 rarely6232.95 truly6233.35 informed6233.76 when6234.23 you6234.4 are6234.56 breezing6234.64 through6234.95 these6235.11 agreements6235.35 or6236.07 just6236.31 getting6236.56 to6236.88 the6236.95 next6237.03 thing.6237.27 And6237.52 you6237.6 need6237.76 to6237.91 go6238.07 on6238.23 Google6238.4 Maps.6238.64
6238.8 You're6238.8 not6238.95 gonna6239.11 be6239.68 able6239.76 to6239.91 try6240.07 to6240.23 do6240.31 a6240.48 research6240.56 project6240.88 to6241.11 figure6241.19 out6241.44 whether6241.6 you6241.76 consent,6241.91 and6242.15 then6242.31 you6242.48 don't6242.64 have6242.8 any6242.95 choice6243.11 when6243.44 you6243.6 go6243.68 there.6243.84 Device6244.8 and6245.19 location6245.35 information6246.01 is6246.41 collected6246.81 and6247.13 sold6247.29 without6247.69 notice,6248.01 consent,6248.65 compensation,6249.93 accountability-6250.57 anything.6251.37 And6252.33 biometric6252.57 information,6253.13 like6253.61 your6253.85 eyes,6254.09 face,6254.41 and6254.73 thumbprint,6254.97 that6255.37 you6255.53 have6255.69 no6255.85 control6256.01 over6256.33 or6256.49 ability6256.73 to6257.13 mute,6257.29 is6258.25 collected6258.41 and6258.89 used6259.13 in6259.36 opaque6259.68 ways6260.09 that6260.4 could6260.56 affect6260.72 the6261.13 price6261.44 you6261.6 pay6261.76 for6261.93 groceries6262.09 or6262.48 if6262.64 you6262.72 are6262.89 targeted6263.05 for6263.36 ads6263.6 or6264.32 any6264.56 fill6265.2 in6265.44 the6265.52 blank.6265.68 So,6266.8 Massachusetts6267.2 residents6267.84 deserve6268.24 better,6268.56 and6268.8 I6269.05 think6269.13 y'all6269.36 know6269.84 that.6270.09 I6270.32 think6270.4 that6270.64 is6270.89 evident6271.2 by6271.68 the6271.84 fact6272.01 that6272.24 we6272.32 have,6272.48 whatever,6272.72 206273.28 bills6273.52 on6274.24 today6274.32 that6274.74 are6275.01 all6275.28 on6275.55 this6275.82 topic.6276.09 But6276.62 in6276.89 particular,6277.16 I'm6277.43 urging6277.7 out6277.97 to6278.24 prioritize6278.51 HB6279.05 78,6279.32 which6280.12 is6280.39 a6280.66 strong6280.93 comprehensive6281.2 consumer6281.47 privacy6281.74 bill6282.01 that6282.28 would6282.55 create6282.82 clarity,6283.09 not6283.35 just6283.62 for6283.89 the6284.16 companies6284.43 and6284.7 the6284.97 entities6285.24 doing6285.51 the6285.78 collection6286.05 of6286.32 data6286.58 but6286.85 for6287.12 consumers.6287.39 Right?6287.66 So6287.93 you6288.2 don't6288.47 have6288.74 to6289.01 try6289.28 to6289.55 figure6289.98 out6290.22 the6290.3 maze6290.45 of6290.69 it.6290.77 Even6291.02 as6291.34 a6291.49 consumer6291.57 protection6291.9 attorney,6292.3 I6292.69 could6292.85 not6293.02 even6293.26 hope6293.49 to6293.73 try6293.81 to6293.98 understand6294.22 every6294.61 way6294.85 my6295.02 data6295.18 is6295.41 being6295.49 used.6295.73 And6296.22 again,6296.45 even6296.94 if6297.18 I6297.34 did,6297.41 I6297.73 would6297.81 have6297.98 no6298.22 control6298.38 over6298.69 it.6298.94 So6299.26 it's6299.41 good6299.57 to6299.81 get6299.9 clear6300.14 baselines6300.45 for6301.02 both6301.18 the6301.41 businesses,6301.57 small6302.06 and6302.3 big,6302.45 as6302.77 well6302.94 as6303.18 consumers,6303.34 everyday6303.81 people.6304.22
6305.1 But6305.1 particularly,6305.34 this6307.42 bill6307.66 does6307.82 36308.06 great6308.3 things.6308.46 1,6309.1 it6309.9 gives6310.06 consumers6310.38 a6310.86 specific6310.86 common6311.26 sense6311.58 right6311.82 to6312.38 know6312.7 who6312.86 has6313.02 their6313.26 data,6313.42 delete6314.22 data,6314.54 ask6315.1 them6315.26 to6315.5 delete6315.58 data6315.9 that's6316.14 held6316.3 about6316.54 them,6316.7 and6317.18 opt6317.42 out6317.58 of6317.74 certain6317.98 targeted6318.3 advertising6318.77 as6319.18 well6319.34 as6319.65 profiling6319.81 that6320.3 influences6320.53 important6321.1 credit6321.49 or6321.81 employment6322.06 or6322.45 housing6322.61 decisions.6322.94 2,6323.98 it6324.45 just6324.69 straight6324.85 up6325.02 restricts6325.26 entities6325.65 from6326.14 collecting6326.38 data6326.85 that6327.18 they6327.34 don't6327.57 need6327.9 to6328.14 provide6328.38 the6328.69 service6328.77 that6329.1 you're6329.26 requesting.6329.49 And6330.38 3,6330.61 it6331.02 gives6331.18 a6331.41 private6331.49 right6331.81 of6331.98 action.6332.06 It6332.75 lets6332.83 people6333.07 that6333.31 are6333.55 hurt6333.71 sue6334.59 to6334.99 make6335.31 themselves6335.55 whole.6335.95 As6336.75 we6336.91 have6337.15 talked6337.31 about,6337.55 the6338.83 attorney6338.99 general,6339.31 while6339.79 awesome6340.59 and6341.07 great,6341.39 would6341.95 never6342.19 be6342.51 able6342.67 to6342.91 get6343.15 every6343.39 single6343.63 case.6343.95 And,6344.35 also,6344.51 the6344.83 incentives6344.91 are6345.39 off.6345.55 If6345.79 you6345.95 are6346.11 harmed6346.35 by6346.67 somebody,6346.83 you6347.23 should6347.31 be6347.55 able6347.77 to6347.93 sue6348.97 and6349.2 get6349.36 your6349.44 day6349.6 in6349.69 court6349.85 and6350.09 get6350.24 the6350.41 sort6351.6 of6351.85 resolution6352.16 you6352.56 need.6352.73 If6353.13 comprehensive6353.36 laws6353.85 cannot6354.16 something6354.41 that6354.65 can6354.81 be6354.97 passed6355.05 right6355.28 now,6355.52 I6356.01 urge6356.24 y'all6356.48 to6356.73 do6357.36 the6357.52 sensitive6357.6 location6358.09 data.6358.73 92%6359.77 of6360.65 Massachusetts6360.81 residents6361.53 support6361.85 a6362.17 ban6362.25 on6362.57 the6362.73 sale6362.81 of6363.13 location6363.21 data,6363.53 and6364.01 it's6364.17 clear6364.41 why.6364.73 Whether6365.05 it's6365.29 a6365.37 bad6365.53 actor6365.69 like6365.93 an6366.09 abuser6366.25 or6366.65 someone6366.81 trying6367.13 to6367.29 get6367.37 you6367.53 to6367.69 buy6367.77 something,6367.93 it's6368.17 invasive,6368.41 unaccountable,6368.89 and6369.37 unacceptable.6369.37 So6370.73 I'll6370.89 follow6371.05 up6371.45 more6371.45 in6371.77 writing6371.93 on6372.57 why6372.73 I6372.97 support6373.13 those6373.53 as6373.85 well6374.01 as6374.33 the6374.57 Surveillance6375.21 Pricing6375.69 and6376.01 Groceries6376.09 Act.6376.41 But6376.57 I6376.73 see6376.81 my6376.97 time's6377.06 up,6377.3 and6377.38 I'm6377.45 happy6377.53 to6377.94 answer6378.02 any6378.26 questions6378.34 later.6378.66 Thank6379.06 you6379.3 so6379.53 much.6379.7
6382.02 MATT6382.02 SCHWARTZ6382.02 -6382.02 CONSUMER6382.02 REPORTS6382.02 -6382.02 HB6382.02 786382.02 -6382.02 SB6382.02 456382.02 -6382.02 HB6382.02 1046382.02 -6382.02 SB6382.02 296382.02 -6382.02 Chair6382.02 Moore,6382.34 chair,6382.57 chair6382.81 Farley6383.14 Bouvier,6383.45 and6383.85 members6383.94 of6384.26 the6384.34 committee,6384.49 thank6384.9 you6385.06 for6385.22 allowing6385.45 me6385.78 to6385.94 testify6386.1 today.6386.57 Thank6387.22 you6387.38 for6387.61 all6387.78 of6387.94 your6388.1 work6388.34 to6389.22 advance6389.45 strong6389.78 privacy6390.02 protections6390.49 for6391.45 Massachusetts6391.61 residents.6392.52 My6393.24 name6393.4 is6393.56 Matt6393.72 Schwartz.6394.04 I'm6394.52 a6394.68 policy6394.76 analyst6395.16 with6395.56 Consumer6395.8 Reports.6396.28 Like6397.64 Ben,6397.88 I'm6398.2 here6398.28 in6398.44 support6398.6 of6399 a6399.16 few6399.24 bills:6400.12 H6400.28 78,6400.28 the6400.84 Massachusetts6401 Consumer6401.56 Data6401.96 Privacy6402.28 Act,6402.76 as6403.32 well6403.48 as6403.72 S6403.88 45,6404.12 H6406.04 104,6406.28 S6406.28 29,6406.28 and6407 the6407.16 Location6407.52 Shield6407.84 Act.6408.64 These6409.44 efforts6409.69 together6410.16 indicate6410.56 that6410.97 the6410.97 committee6411.13 is6411.6 already6412.09 well6412.48 aware6412.65 of6412.97 the6413.05 importance6413.2 of6413.6 strong6413.76 data6414.16 privacy6414.56 rules.6414.97 As6416.16 you've6416.32 heard,6416.56 companies6417.2 are6417.84 increasingly6418.09 surveilling6418.72 our6419.2 every6419.44 move,6419.76 both6420.09 off6420.4 and6420.65 online.6420.89 This6422.09 has6422.24 led6422.4 to6423.19 an6423.27 erosion6423.51 of6423.99 the6424.15 basic6424.31 expectation6424.79 of6425.43 privacy6425.59 as6426.39 long6426.55 as6426.79 well6427.27 as6427.51 concrete6427.67 harms6428.31 that6429.11 can6429.27 negatively6429.51 impact6430.15 consumers6430.71 in6431.27 a6431.35 variety6431.43 of6431.91 ways,6431.99 including6432.31 financially.6433.03 That's6434.71 where6434.87 we're6435.03 glad6435.19 to6435.43 see6435.51 that6435.67 Massachusetts6435.83 is6436.79 taking6436.95 steps6437.27 towards6437.59 giving6437.91 consumers6438.51 more6438.82 control6438.99 over6440.03 how6440.27 their6440.43 information6440.99 is6441.47 collected6441.63 and6442.1 used.6442.35 We6443.23 support6443.47 H6443.86 786444.1 in6444.59 particular6444.74 for6445.23 36445.47 main6445.78 reasons.6446.1
6447.95 First,6447.95 the6448.35 bill6448.51 has6448.74 strong6448.91 data6449.31 minimization6449.55 provisions.6450.35 As6450.91 you've6451.07 heard,6451.31 data6452.03 minimization6452.35 is6453.21 the6453.37 idea6453.61 that6454.73 companies6454.97 should6455.45 really6455.77 only6456.01 be6456.25 collecting6456.41 and6456.97 using6457.13 data6457.53 that's6458.09 necessary6458.49 to6459.05 provide6459.21 the6459.53 service6459.69 that6460.09 consumers6460.25 ask6460.73 for.6461.05 We6462.33 need6462.57 this6462.81 protection6463.05 because6463.61 companies6464.01 are6464.57 routinely6464.73 collecting6465.37 and6466.28 using6466.44 data6466.84 in6467.16 ways6467.24 that6467.48 are6467.56 adversarial6467.8 to6468.44 consumers.6468.6 Neither6469.95 an6470.35 opt-in6470.84 nor6471.4 opt-out6471.95 issue6472.2 on6472.52 its6472.68 own6472.91 can6473.24 solve6473.48 that.6473.72 You6475.88 know,6476.03 for6476.35 example,6476.68 my6477.31 weather6477.64 app,6478.11 obviously,6479.4 unrelated6488.24 purposes.6489.2 We've6489.63 heard,6490.05 industry6491.6 argue6492.32 that,6492.64 you6493.12 know,6493.13 companies6493.14 wouldn't6493.14 necessarily6493.15 know6493.16 how6493.17 to6493.18 comply6493.18 with6493.19 such6493.2 know,6493.48 companies6493.64 wouldn't6494.35 necessarily6494.84 know6495.23 how6495.48 to6495.64 comply6495.8 with6496.76 such6496.91 a6497.15 framework6497.31 and6497.72 that6497.8 the6498.03 legislature6498.11 should6498.84 instead6499.15 adopt6499.72 the6500.03 Connecticut6500.19 standard6500.76 to6501.15 give6501.31 them6501.48 clarity.6501.64
6502.84 But6502.84 that6503.07 standard6503.31 doesn't6504.19 actually6504.52 create6505.15 any6505.48 new6505.8 requirements6506.03 for6506.6 companies6506.84 and6507.96 simply6508.12 states6508.44 that6508.76 businesses6509 can't6509.48 lie6509.8 about6510.6 what's6510.84 in6511 their6511.16 privacy6511.4 policy.6511.8 That's6512.2 already6512.52 the6513 law.6513.16 As6514.68 we6514.84 know,6514.92 those6515.16 privacy6515.4 policies6515.8 are6516.36 designed6516.52 to6516.84 be6516.92 as6517.16 vague6517.4 as6517.64 possible.6517.88 So,6518.28 we6518.52 need6518.68 privacy6518.92 laws6519.4 to6519.64 do6519.88 more.6520.04 Second,6521.65 the6522.05 bill6522.2 creates6522.44 heightened6522.69 protections6523.09 for6523.56 sensitive6523.81 data,6524.28 including6525.4 an6525.81 outright6525.97 ban6526.36 on6526.69 the6526.77 sale6526.85 of6527.09 data,6527.16 like6527.48 our6527.73 cell6527.81 phone6528.05 location6528.28 data,6528.77 religious6529.48 and6529.97 political6530.2 beliefs,6530.69 health6531.24 information,6531.56 and6532.77 information6533.01 collected6533.48 for6534.06 minors.6534.22 This6535.1 information6535.42 can6535.9 be6536.22 easily6536.46 purchased6536.94 and6537.34 weaponized6537.58 by6538.22 a6538.54 number6538.62 of6538.94 folks,6539.1 stalkers,6540.22 scammers,6541.18 and6541.82 malicious6541.82 political6542.38 actors.6542.94 We6544.06 note6544.22 that6544.38 the6544.54 Location6544.7 Shield6545.1 Act6545.5 would6545.74 provide6545.9 similar6546.3 protections6546.62 for6547.18 location6547.34 data6547.9 in6548.22 particular.6548.38 We6549.59 urge6549.68 the6550.07 committee6550.23 to6550.95 advance6551.11 that6551.51 measure6551.76 as6552.23 well.6552.4 And6553.35 then,6553.51 finally,6553.68 we6554.07 note6554.31 that6554.47 the6555.27 bill6555.51 would6555.76 be6555.91 enforced6556.23 in6556.64 part6556.8 by6557.11 a6557.35 private6557.44 right6557.76 of6557.91 action,6558.07 which6558.4 we6558.55 believe6558.72 is6559.03 appropriate.6559.19 Under6560.55 the6560.88 13,6561.11 state6562.23 privacy6562.55 laws6563.11 that6563.44 are6563.59 active6563.76 Currently,6564.19 there6565.47 have6565.79 only6565.79 been6566.03 a6566.27 handful6566.35 of6566.75 public6567.07 enforcement6567.55 actions.6568.19 At6570.19 the6570.19 same6570.27 time,6570.43 you6570.67 don't6570.83 have6571.07 to6571.23 look6571.31 very6571.55 hard6571.71 to6571.95 find6572.11 obvious6572.43 violations6572.91 of6573.31 those6573.47 laws.6573.79 CR6574.67 recently6575.07 released6576.03 AG6587.91 enforcement6587.99 has6588.64 not6588.88 markedly6589.11 improved6589.76 privacy6590.23 outcomes6590.72 for6591.19 consumers,6591.35 so6592.43 we6592.59 need6592.67 a6592.75 more6592.83 balanced6593.23 approach.6593.63 So6594.27 I'll6594.51 wrap6594.59 it6594.75 up6594.91 there.6595.07 Thanks6595.47 again6595.79 for6596.03 your6596.19 time.6596.27 Happy6596.51 to6596.75 answer6596.83 any6597.15 questions.6597.31
6598.03 FARLEY-BOUVIER6598.03 -6598.03 Thank6598.03 you.6598.19 And6598.35 I6598.43 understand6598.67 16599.15 of6599.31 your6599.39 panel6599.71 mates6600.11 is6600.51 joining6600.67 us6600.99 online.6601.31 Nicole,6601.87 are6602.27 you6602.51 online?6602.67
6606.75 SPEAKER286606.75 -6606.75 Yes.6606.75 Trying6607.55 to6607.72 get6607.88 my6608.11 camera6608.27 on.6608.59
6608.99 SPEAKER76608.99 -6608.99 Okay.6608.99
6610.11 SPEAKER286610.11 -6610.11 Great.6610.11
6610.76 SPEAKER16610.76 -6610.76 Okay.6610.76
6610.99 NICOLE6610.99 GILL6610.99 -6610.99 ACCOUNTANT6610.99 TECH6610.99 -6610.99 HB6610.99 786610.99 -6610.99 HB6610.99 866610.99 -6610.99 (6610.99 R6610.99 )6610.99 -6610.99 There6610.99 we6611.23 go.6611.8 It6611.95 worked.6612.19 Okay.6612.51 Woo-hoo.6613.95 Yeah.6614.84 All6616.84 right.6616.99 Chairs6617.4 Farley,6618.03 Bovier,6618.51 and6619.4 more,6619.64 and6619.88 members6620.03 of6620.43 the6620.51 committee,6620.68 thank6620.99 you6621.23 for6621.4 inviting6621.55 me6621.71 to6622.75 testify.6622.75 My6623.31 name6623.47 is6623.63 Nicole6623.87 Gill.6624.27 I'm6624.91 a6625.15 resident6625.31 of6625.71 Waltham,6625.95 Massachusetts,6626.59 and6628.35 also6628.75 the6629.07 cofounder6629.23 and6629.79 executive6629.95 director6630.51 of6631.07 Accountable6631.23 Tech,6631.87 a6632.27 nonpartisan6632.51 nonprofit6633.39 that6634.43 advocates6634.67 for6635.31 safer6635.47 online6636.03 platforms.6636.67 I6639.11 am6639.44 here,6640.15 on6640.64 behalf6640.8 of6641.11 my6641.19 organization,6641.44 to6642.23 ask6642.4 the6642.64 committee6642.8 to6643.19 favorably6643.35 report6644.23 out6644.72 26645.68 bills6645.91 that6646.23 would6646.4 provide6646.55 comprehensive6647.11 privacy6648.07 protections6648.64 for6649.19 Massachusetts6649.35 residents:6650.83 the6651.71 Mass6653.87 Consumer6654.19 Data6654.19 Privacy6654.19 Act,6654.19 H6654.19 78,6654.19 and6654.91 H6655.31 86,6655.63 the6656.51 location6656.75 shield6657.31 act.6657.63 Now6658.43 I'm6659.63 calling6659.87 a6660.19 nodible.6660.27 I6660.91 was6660.99 supposed6661.23 to6661.55 talk6661.71 about6661.87 geolocation.6662.27 Instead,6663.87 I6665.4 actually6665.56 wanna6665.95 tell6666.2 you6666.44 about6666.84 the6667.48 app6667.72 that6668.27 my6668.44 children's6668.68 daycare6669.4 and6670.03 school6670.27 uses.6670.84 The6672.99 app6673.16 was6673.4 introduced6673.56 about6674.11 a6674.24 year6674.35 ago.6674.68 Many6675.56 of6675.8 the6675.95 parents6676.03 are6676.84 thrilled.6677.07 Right?6677.8 Because6678.03 we6678.44 all6678.6 use6678.76 apps6679.16 for6679.56 everything.6679.8 And6681.16 from6681.48 the6681.72 school's6682.04 perspective,6682.44 I6683.32 understand6683.48 why6683.96 it's6684.84 nice6685.16 to6685.56 kind6685.88 of6686.2 centralize6686.36 all6687.32 of6687.48 your6687.64 communications,6687.88 the6689.32 sharing6689.48 of6689.8 information.6690.04
6691.8 However,6691.8 the6693.48 app6694.28 is6695.03 used6695.27 to6695.52 share6696.4 health6696.8 information,6697.11 including,6697.76 you6698.64 know,6698.8 those6698.95 forms6699.19 you6699.6 get6699.76 from6699.91 your6700.15 pediatrician6700.4 outlining6701.35 everything6702.48 that6703.27 has6703.44 to6703.68 do6703.76 with6703.99 your6704.07 child's6704.31 health6704.72 concerns.6705.03 They6706.8 share6706.95 pictures6707.27 and6707.84 videos6708.07 in6709.39 the6709.63 app.6709.71 And6711.39 I've6711.95 read6712.27 the6712.67 terms6712.83 and6713.15 conditions.6713.39 I'm6714.19 probably6714.43 the6714.75 only6714.91 person6715.07 who6715.39 read6715.63 the6715.87 terms6716.03 and6716.35 conditions,6716.51 and6717.95 there's6718.11 a6718.43 million6718.59 loopholes.6718.91 Right?6719.79 The6720.11 company6720.27 advertises6720.75 itself6721.47 as6721.95 not6722.19 selling6722.83 its6723.55 data.6723.87 However,6724.67 they6726.24 are6726.56 free6726.89 to6727.28 give6728.48 it6728.73 to6728.89 a6729.05 marketing6729.13 partner.6729.69 They6730.56 are6730.89 explicitly6731.69 using6732.41 it6732.73 for6733.2 what6733.69 they6733.93 call6734.16 personalized6734.48 advertising.6735.93 So,6736.65 surveillance6737.05 advertising.6737.69 Consumer6741.8 not6742.12 consumer6742.36 parts.6742.92 Sorry.6743.4 I'm6744.2 trying6744.44 to6744.6 remember6744.76 this.6745.16 Common6747 Sense6747.32 Media6747.72 and6748.28 EFF,6749 the6749.56 Electronic6749.8 Frontier6751.24 Foundation,6751.8 both6752.92 have6753.64 reviewed6754.2 the6754.76 app6754.84 and6755.36 noticed6755.6 and6756.56 noted6756.89 that6757.28 it6757.52 has6757.69 significant6757.93 privacy6758.89 concerns.6759.69 Also,6762.16 data6762.65 from6762.97 parents6763.2 and6763.69 educators6764.01 working6764.65 with6764.97 young6765.2 children6765.45 is6765.85 incredibly6766.41 valuable.6767.2 A6768.33 researcher6768.49 a6768.97 decade6769.13 ago6769.45 found6769.77 that6770.01 identifying6770.41 a6771.21 single6771.37 pregnant6771.85 woman6772.33 online6773.21 is6774.33 worth6774.65 as6775.05 much6775.21 as6775.45 knowing6775.69 the6776.01 age,6776.25 sex,6776.81 and6777.13 location6777.37 of6777.77 up6778.01 to6778.17 2006778.33 people.6778.81 I6780.48 can6780.65 only6780.89 imagine6781.28 that6781.85 that6782.09 has6782.32 increased6782.81 in6783.44 time.6783.6 So,6785.44 yeah.6788.73 I'll6789.13 stop6789.44 there.6789.85 Thank6790.41 you.6790.65
6792.01 FARLEY-BOUVIER6792.01 -6792.01 Thank6792.01 you6792.24 very6792.48 much,6792.81 Nicole.6793.05 And6793.29 I6793.53 just6793.69 think6793.77 that6793.93 that6794.09 was6794.17 a6794.41 personal6794.49 story6795.05 that6795.45 everybody6795.61 can6796.01 relate6796.25 to.6796.49 Right?6796.89 We6797.05 talked6797.29 about6797.53 the6797.77 daycare6798.09 app.6798.33 I6799.29 wanna6799.61 ask6800.01 a6800.25 question.6800.33 This6800.81 is6800.97 a6801.29 pretty6801.61 yes6802.49 or6802.73 no.6802.97 Maybe6803.21 call6803.45 this6803.61 lightning6803.85 round6804.25 question6804.49 for6804.73 the6804.89 36805.05 of6805.29 you.6805.37 Are6808.17 you6808.41 Republican,6809.28 Democrat?6810.65 Like,6811.36 where6811.6 do6811.85 you6812.01 where6812.24 do6812.48 you6812.56 sit6812.73 when6812.97 it6813.2 comes6813.28 to6813.52 partisanship?6813.69 Each6814.65 16814.97 of6815.13 you.6815.28
6816.16 WINTERS6816.16 -6816.16 We're6816.16 a6816.32 nonpartisan6816.48 organization.6816.97 We're6817.52 a6817.69 nonprofit.6817.85
6818.97 SCHWARTZ6818.97 -6818.97 Likewise.6818.97 Nonpartisan.6819.85 Nonpartisan.6820.56 Nicole?6821.2
6822.24 GILL6822.24 -6822.24 Yeah.6822.24 We're6822.48 also6822.73 nonpartisan.6823.05
6823.9 FARLEY-BOUVIER6823.9 -6823.9 Okay.6823.9 So6824.22 this6824.54 really6825.58 doesn't6825.9 have6826.06 anything6826.22 to6826.54 do6826.7 with6826.86 left6827.02 or6827.26 right6827.42 when6828.06 it6828.3 comes6828.38 to6828.62 this.6828.7
6829.1 GILL-6829.1 No.6829.1 It6829.42 has6829.5 to6829.66 do6829.82 with6829.98 privacy6830.14 and6830.54 safety.6830.7
6833.26 FARLEY-BOUVIER6833.26 -6833.26 Well,6833.26 I6833.58 appreciate6834.14 the6834.62 perspectives6834.78 that6835.58 each6835.82 16835.98 of6836.22 you6836.38 bring6836.54 to6836.86 this,6837.02 and6837.42 the6838.1 fact6838.18 that6838.41 you6838.49 are6838.57 putting6838.82 the6839.14 consumer6839.3 at6840.1 the6840.26 center6840.34 of6840.66 it6840.74 is6841.3 really6841.45 helpful.6841.78 So,6842.82 as6844.26 announced6844.49 before,6844.98 we6845.3 are6845.45 gonna6845.61 go6845.85 to6846.1 our6846.18 next6846.41 panel.6846.74 This6847.14 panel6847.38 is6847.78 online.6848.02 I'm6848.41 sorry.6849.06 16849.45 question.6849.78 Oh,6850.18 I'm6850.26 so6850.49 sorry.6850.66 Sorry.6851.33 I6851.89 Yeah.6852.05 Please.6852.29
6853.01 OWENS6853.01 -6853.01 I've6853.01 actually6853.33 asked6853.65 this6853.73 question6853.81 for6854.13 Nicole.6854.29 I6854.61 wanna6854.69 talk6854.93 about6855.09 your6855.25 app6855.49 for6855.65 a6855.77 second.6855.89 Not6857.89 your6858.05 app.6858.21 I'm6858.45 sorry.6858.61 You6861.33 said6861.57 your6862.05 parents6862.77 are6863.17 downloading6863.33 or6863.81 uploading6863.97 health6865.41 information,6865.88 stuff6866.19 from6866.51 pediatrician6866.68 immunizations?6867.39 Yeah.6868.84 Would6869.07 Yeah.6869.31 Would6869.55 you6869.72 say6869.88 an6870.11 average6870.35 person6870.76 would6871.15 assume6871.39 that6871.8 that6872.03 is6872.27 covered6872.68 by6873.15 HIPAA?6873.47 I6875.39 don't6875.55 mean6876.03 to,6876.35 but6876.35 put6876.51 your6876.68 place6876.84 in6877.07 the6877.23 right.6877.55
6878.59 GILL6878.59 -6878.59 It6878.59 might6878.84 be,6879.07 but6879.29 HIPAA6879.37 often6879.93 refers6880.41 to6880.97 the6883.13 use6883.45 of6883.77 the6884.09 sharing6884.25 of6884.65 medical6884.81 data6885.13 for6885.77 medical6886.09 purposes.6886.49 You6889.29 know,6889.45 it's6889.61 not6889.85 clear6890.09 to6890.33 me6890.49 that6890.89 it6891.05 is6891.21 covered6891.55 under6891.86 HIPAA.6892.19
6892.66 OWENS6892.66 -6892.66 My6892.66 understanding6892.74 is6893.22 that6893.39 it6893.86 is6894.02 not.6894.19 Although,6895.15 when6896.26 I6896.51 talk6897.47 to6897.63 people6897.78 about6899.15 it,6899.7 yeah.6899.7 Medical6899.7 data,6900.1 they6900.51 assume6900.74 that6901.06 it6901.22 is.6901.39 And6902.1 so6902.51 that6902.98 is6903.47 a6903.78 just6905.1 to6905.34 just6905.5 to6905.58 point6905.82 out6906.06 that6906.14 red6906.38 flag6906.62 for6907.82 me6908.06 on6908.22 that.6908.38
6908.78 GILL6908.78 -6908.78 The6908.78 bun,6908.86 fortunately,6909.1 has6909.66 a6909.82 lot6909.98 of6910.22 loopholes.6910.3 Yeah.6910.86 To6911.26 it.6911.42 And6912.22 app6913.58 developers6913.82 are6914.38 smart.6914.46 They6914.94 figured6915.1 them6915.42 out,6915.74 and6916.14 they're6916.3 utilizing6916.46 them.6917.1 But6918.62 the6918.86 school6919.02 needs6919.42 to6919.66 know6919.74 about6919.98 my6920.14 daughter's6920.3 nut6920.7 allergy.6921.16 The6922.03 Internet6922.2 broadly6922.84 does6923.4 not.6923.64
6924.84 OWENS6924.84 -6924.84 Thank6924.84 you.6925.07 Fair.6925.64
FARLEY-BOUVIER6926.28 -6926.28 Thank6926.28 you.6926.6 Thank6926.84 you6926.99 all6927.16 so6927.4 very6927.56 much.6927.72 We're6927.95 gonna6928.2 go6928.44 online6929.8 to6930.35 the6930.52 next6930.68 panel6931.07 of6934.98 professor6934.98 Woody6935.86 Herzog,6936.66 Lisa6937.94 Levasseur,6938.34 and6939.38 Eric6939.7 Noll.6940.02 And6940.42 on6940.74 deck6940.98 is6941.54 our6942.18 colleague,6942.42 representative,6943.86 Simon6945.14 Cataldi.6945.54 And6946.68 I6946.91 just6946.99 wanna6947.31 make6947.56 sure6947.72 we6947.95 welcome6948.27 representative6949.4 John6949.95 Gaski,6950.27 who's6950.99 joining6951.31 us6951.48 for6951.64 the6951.72 committee.6951.8 Thanks6952.11 for6952.35 joining6952.52 us6952.76 here6952.91 today.6953.07 Professor?6954.35
6956.35 SPEAKER296956.35 -6956.35 Thank6956.35 you6956.6 so6956.76 much.6956.91 Can6957.16 you6957.31 hear6957.48 me,6957.64 okay?6957.8
6958.27 SPEAKER16958.27 -6958.27 We6958.27 can.6958.44 Perfect.6958.84
6960.11 WOODROW6960.11 HARTZOG6960.11 -6960.11 BOSTON6960.11 UNIVERSITY6960.11 -6960.11 HB6960.11 1046960.11 -6960.11 HB6960.11 786960.11 -6960.11 (6960.11 R6960.11 )6960.11 Fantastic.6960.11 Thank6960.76 you.6960.91 Dear6961.28 committee6961.52 members,6961.76 thank6962.16 you6962.32 for6962.48 allowing6962.64 me6963.04 to6963.12 provide6963.36 remote6964 testimony6964.4 today.6964.8 I6965.04 appreciate6965.36 it.6965.76 My6966.08 name6966.24 is6966.4 Woodrow6966.8 Hartzog,6967.28 and6967.28 I'm6967.36 a6967.52 Newton6967.68 resident6968 and6968.56 a6968.72 professor6968.88 at6969.28 Boston6969.44 University's6969.84 School6971.04 of6971.36 Law.6971.52 I6971.84 have6972 spent6972.16 the6972.4 last6972.56 156972.96 years6973.28 researching6973.68 and6974.16 teaching6974.4 data6975.2 privacy6975.93 law,6976.16 and6976.24 building6976.56 on6976.89 that6977.05 today,6977.28 I6977.52 recommend6977.77 36978.49 things.6978.81 First,6979.6 I6979.93 recommend6980.09 that6980.49 this6980.56 legislature6980.81 favorably6981.52 report6982.16 on6982.56 H6982.81 78,6983.05 the6983.93 Massachusetts6984.09 Consumer6984.81 Data6985.2 Privacy6985.45 Act,6985.93 and6986.09 H6986.81 104,6987.13 the6987.13 Massachusetts6987.36 Data6988.16 Privacy6988.49 Act.6989.07 These6989.31 bills6989.55 contain6990.03 the6990.91 36991.07 most6991.39 important6991.63 features6992.19 of6992.67 any6992.91 effective6993.23 privacy6993.79 bill:6994.35 a6994.99 substantive6995.23 data6995.87 minimization6996.19 provision,6996.83 bright6997.71 line6998.03 prohibitions6998.35 on6999.31 the6999.55 most6999.63 dangerous7000.03 data7000.51 processing,7000.83 and7014.03 so7014.19 with7014.43 these7015.07 statutes,7015.31 Massachusetts7015.95 has7016.67 a7016.83 chance7016.91 to7017.23 pass7017.31 the7017.55 first7017.71 truly7018.27 effective7018.67 privacy7019.15 law7019.79 in7019.95 the7020.19 country.7020.35 Big7021.15 companies7021.39 collect7021.87 everything7022.27 they7022.67 can7022.83 about7023.07 us7023.39 for7023.55 profit.7023.79 That's7024.19 why7024.51 strong7024.99 data7025.39 minimization7025.71 rules7026.35 are7026.73 so7026.89 important.7027.13
7027.85 They7027.85 limit7028.16 data7028.48 collection7028.81 to7029.2 what's7029.28 necessary,7029.6 not7030.56 whatever7030.81 self-serving7031.93 purpose7032.4 a7032.81 company7032.89 can7033.28 get7033.44 away7033.69 with7033.93 by7034.48 bearing7034.73 it7035.13 in7035.36 the7035.44 fine7035.6 print.7035.85 For7036.73 privacy7036.97 regulation7037.44 to7037.93 be7038.09 meaningful,7038.24 it7038.65 must7038.81 also7039.05 be7039.29 consistently7039.53 enforced.7040.41 State7041.21 attorneys7041.53 general7042.01 do7042.41 amazing7042.65 work,7043.05 but7043.37 they7043.53 can7043.69 only7043.93 do7044.25 so7044.49 much.7044.65 The7045.29 only7045.61 thing7045.93 that7046.25 can7046.49 meaningfully7046.73 hold7047.37 Big7047.93 Tech7048.17 accountable7048.17 is7049.13 a7049.29 private7049.45 cause7049.85 of7050.17 action7050.33 combined7050.73 with7051.05 AG7051.37 enforcement.7051.61 Anything7052.57 less7053.13 is7053.61 a7053.85 gift7054.01 to7054.48 large7054.73 tech7054.97 companies.7055.28 Representatives7056.4 for7057.13 big7057.28 tech7057.52 companies7057.69 have7058.09 told7058.32 you7058.48 today7058.73 that7059.05 this7059.2 bill7059.36 is7059.6 too7059.76 burdensome7060.01 and7060.8 will7060.97 be7061.2 bad7061.28 for7061.52 the7061.76 industry.7061.76 They've7062.32 been7062.56 singing7062.8 this,7063.2 I7063.6 think,7063.76 misleading7064.09 tune7064.73 for7065.44 years,7065.76 and7066.16 their7066.4 lack7066.65 of7066.89 accountability7067.05 is7068.09 what7068.24 got7068.48 us7068.65 into7068.8 this7069.13 mess7069.28 in7069.6 the7069.69 first7069.84 place.7070.01 Place.7070.65 Responsible7070.89 businesses7071.61 do7072.25 not7072.49 need7072.73 to7072.97 exploit7073.21 the7073.61 people7073.77 of7074.01 Massachusetts7074.25 with7074.97 impunity7075.21 in7076.25 order7076.41 to7076.65 thrive.7076.89 My7077.77 second7078.01 recommendation7078.33 is7079.05 to7079.21 favorably7079.45 report7080.01 on7080.49 H7080.73 86,7080.97 which7081.53 protects7081.69 location7082.25 privacy.7082.73 Every7084.01 day,7084.33 companies7084.73 sell7085.29 our7085.45 precise7085.77 location7086.16 data7086.56 to7086.89 random7087.05 strangers7087.52 on7087.93 the7088.09 Internet.7088.16
7088.89 This7088.89 is7089.05 17089.2 of7089.36 the7089.44 most7089.52 dangerous7089.93 kinds7090.48 of7090.81 data7090.89 that7091.2 you7091.36 could7091.52 possibly7091.77 sell.7092.24 It7092.81 exposes7093.05 our7093.6 movements,7093.77 our7094.24 beliefs,7094.48 our7094.97 health7095.13 status,7095.44 and7096.09 so7096.32 much7096.56 more.7096.81 In7097.28 our7097.52 modern7097.69 dystopian7098.09 world7098.73 of7099.13 vanishing7099.2 reproductive7099.85 rights7100.48 and7101.32 vanishing7101.48 people,7102.2 it7103.08 is7103.32 vital7103.56 that7103.96 the7104.2 location7104.36 data7104.92 of7105.16 the7105.32 people7105.48 of7105.8 Massachusetts7105.96 be7106.84 protected.7107.08 Finally,7108.12 I7108.6 want7108.76 to7108.92 encourage7109.08 lawmakers7109.56 to7110.04 favorably7110.2 report7110.76 on7111.16 H7111.4 907111.72 9.7112.04 Grocery7112.68 stores7113 have7113.4 started7113.56 experimenting7113.96 with7114.52 surveillance7114.68 pricing,7115.24 which7115.64 is7115.8 the7115.96 practice7116.19 of7116.43 using7116.51 people's7116.9 data7117.31 trails7118.02 to7118.35 give7118.51 them7118.74 different7118.98 prices7119.31 than7119.63 everybody7119.86 else.7120.27 Companies7120.74 do7121.31 this7121.47 for7121.7 17121.86 reason,7122.1 to7122.66 tighten7122.9 the7123.15 screws7123.31 on7123.7 customers7123.94 and7124.51 figure7124.66 out7124.98 the7125.23 highest7125.39 price7125.86 that7126.51 we7126.74 are7126.9 willing7127.06 to7127.39 pay7127.55 when7127.78 we7128.02 walk7128.27 into7128.51 a7128.82 store.7128.98 This7129.76 disastrous7130 practice7130.72 leads7131.2 to7131.44 price7131.68 gouging,7132 discrimination7132.8 by7133.52 proxy,7133.68 inability7134.48 to7135.04 budget,7135.28 data7136 hoarding,7136.4 and7136.8 the7136.96 suffocating7137.2 feeling7137.92 that7138.64 every7138.96 choice7139.28 you7139.6 make7139.76 while7140.08 shopping7140.32 is7140.8 a7140.96 trap.7141.12 This7141.68 bill7141.92 would7142.08 prohibit7142.24 food7142.64 stores7142.88 from7143.2 using7143.44 tools7143.68 like7143.94 facial7144.19 recognition7144.43 to7145.22 charge7145.47 people7145.78 different7146.19 prices7146.51 and7146.9 provide7147.15 vital7147.47 breathing7148.34 room7148.66 for7148.9 customers7149.86 while7150.26 still7150.51 allowing7151.55 people7151.7 to7152.02 receive7152.1 discounts.7152.51 In7153.78 conclusion,7154.02 Massachusetts7154.59 has7155.22 in7155.47 front7155.63 of7155.78 it7155.94 today7156.1 the7156.51 perfect7156.84 opportunity7157.16 to7157.8 lead7157.96 the7158.2 country7158.36 once7158.76 again7159.08 in7159.56 protecting7159.8 people's7160.28 privacy7160.68 while7161.16 fostering7161.4 an7161.88 innovative7162.12 and7162.84 flourishing7163.08 marketplace.7163.72 Thank7164.28 you7164.52 for7164.68 the7164.84 opportunity7165 to7165.56 testify7165.72 today,7166.12 and7166.6 I7166.76 look7166.92 forward7167.08 to7167.32 your7167.4 questions.7167.56
FARLEY-BOUVIER7169.05 -7169.05 Thank7169.05 you,7169.2 professor.7169.84 Would7170.48 you7170.8 just7170.97 mind7171.2 taking7171.52 a7171.84 moment7172.01 to7173.05 talk7173.2 about7173.36 where7174.09 you7174.32 teach7174.56 and7174.89 what7175.05 you7175.28 do7175.44 in7175.69 this7175.84 space?7176.09
7177.36 HARTZOG7177.36 -7177.36 Sure.7177.36 So,7177.76 I7178.01 teach7178.16 at7178.4 Boston7178.65 University7179.13 School7179.69 of7180.01 Law.7180.16 I7180.4 teach7180.56 courses7180.8 on7181.63 information7181.95 privacy7182.51 law,7182.99 advanced7183.39 privacy,7183.87 and7184.27 I7184.43 hope7184.59 some7184.99 of7185.15 my7185.31 advanced7185.47 privacy7185.79 students7186.19 are7186.67 watching7186.91 today,7187.23 and7187.79 digital7187.95 civil7188.35 liberties.7188.75 And7189.15 I've7189.39 been7189.55 writing7190.59 about7190.91 data7191.63 privacy7191.95 rules7192.43 now7192.83 for7193.23 quite7193.71 some7193.95 time.7194.19
7195.3 FARLEY-BOUVIER7195.3 -7195.3 Thank7195.3 you,7195.61 professor.7196.26 And7197.22 now7197.53 we7197.77 have7198.02 other7198.26 people7198.49 on7198.81 the7199.06 same7199.14 panel7199.45 that7199.77 are7199.94 also7200.1 online,7200.49 so7200.98 we're7201.22 gonna7201.45 turn7201.77 now7202.02 to7202.26 Lisa.7202.66 Are7208.98 you7209.06 there,7209.3 Lisa?7209.46
7210.82 LISA7210.82 LEVASSEUR7210.82 -7210.82 INTERNET7210.82 SAFETY7210.82 LAB7210.82 -7210.82 HB7210.82 787210.82 -7210.82 HB7210.82 1047210.82 -7210.82 (7210.82 R7210.82 )7210.82 Yep.7210.82 Sorry.7211.22 Looking7212.66 for7213.06 the7213.38 unmute.7214.02 Hi.7214.74 Thank7215.06 you7215.3 so7215.46 much,7215.62 Chair7215.86 Moore7216.1 and7216.34 Chair7216.5 Farley7216.74 Bouvier,7217.06 and7217.54 members7217.78 of7218.1 the7218.18 Committee.7218.34 My7219.06 name7219.22 is7219.38 Lisa7219.54 LeVasseur,7219.86 and7220.34 I'm7220.5 the7220.66 Research7220.82 Director7221.14 and7221.46 Founder7221.7 of7221.94 Internet7222.1 Safety7222.5 Labs.7222.82 I7223.22 call7223.3 it7223.46 ISL.7223.7 I'm7224.61 here7224.94 today7225.02 to7225.57 support7225.74 H787226.14 and7227.1 H104.7227.41 ISL7229.26 is7229.66 a7229.82 nonprofit,7229.98 nonpartisan,7230.7 digital7231.9 product7232.3 safety7232.61 testing7233.02 organization7233.49 that7234.22 studies7234.53 safety7234.94 and7235.26 privacy7235.41 risks7235.9 in7236.22 websites7236.45 and7236.94 mobile7237.1 apps.7237.41 We've7238.24 done7238.56 extensive7238.88 empirical7239.44 research7239.92 in7240.32 quantifying7240.56 and7241.12 identifying7241.28 risky7241.92 third-party7242.56 data7242.96 sharing7243.28 in7244.16 apps.7244.4 In7245.2 2022,7245.36 we7246.08 studied7246.32 more7246.64 than7246.8 1,7007247.04 apps7247.84 recommended7248.24 or7248.64 required7248.8 by7249.36 K-twelve7249.6 schools7250.16 across7251.03 the7251.68 U.S.7252.4 We've7252.4 subsequently7252.72 developed7253.52 and7253.84 published7254.07 robust7254.56 safety7255.03 labels7255.44 that7256.31 show7256.56 all7256.88 of7257.03 the7257.2 third-party7257.68 companies7257.99 observed7258.72 to7259.76 be7259.91 receiving7260.16 data7260.72 from7261.11 those7261.35 apps,7261.68 including7262.16 identifying7263.44 the7264.4 registered7264.56 data7265.11 brokers.7265.44
7266.59 Last7266.59 year,7266.91 we7267.07 published7267.31 research7267.79 describing7268.19 the7268.75 global7268.91 commercial7269.31 surveillance7269.71 infrastructure7270.43 identifying7271.63 entities,7272.19 customer7273.31 data7273.79 platforms,7274.11 and7274.67 identity7274.91 resolution7275.47 platforms7276.11 that7277.07 allow7277.23 marketing7277.71 and7278.03 advertising7278.27 companies7278.83 to7279.31 aggregate7279.47 millions7280.03 of7280.43 personal7280.59 data7280.99 elements7281.31 data7283.47 elements7283.63 from7283.78 disparate7283.94 sources7284.1 through7284.27 bulk7284.59 customer7285.15 database7285.7 transfers7286.19 as7287.23 well7287.39 as7287.7 transactionally7288.1 through7289.39 digital7289.63 advertising7290.19 with7290.91 the7290.98 inclusion7291.23 of7292.27 proprietary7292.59 personal7293.47 identifiers7294.1 conveyed7295.43 in7295.67 the7295.91 real7296.07 time7296.31 bidding7296.63 protocol.7297.03 That's7297.99 a7298.23 mouthful.7298.39 We're7299.35 techy.7299.59 We're7300.07 super7300.31 techy.7300.63 We7301.75 dig7302.07 under7302.31 the7302.55 hood.7302.63 Both7303.27 methods7303.67 may7304.23 qualify7304.47 as7304.95 the7305.11 selling7305.19 of7305.51 data.7305.67 Of7306.47 the7306.71 combined7306.87 3607307.91 customer7308.39 data7308.79 platforms7309.11 and7309.59 identity7309.75 resolution7310.31 platforms7311.01 we7311.32 looked7311.4 at,7312.36 only7312.44 16.4%7312.76 of7314.13 these7314.28 platforms7314.6 were7315.09 registered7315.32 data7315.8 brokers.7316.05 Many7317.01 more7317.24 of7317.48 them7317.72 should7318.13 be.7318.44 Note7319.8 also7320.13 that7320.44 these7320.6 platforms7320.84 indiscriminately7321.4 hoover7322.13 up7322.44 and7322.6 monetize7322.76 personal7323.4 data7323.8 without7324.59 regard7324.83 to7325.31 age.7325.47 539,7326.35 or7327.79 35%7328.19 of7329.15 the7329.23 K-twelve7329.39 apps7330.03 in7330.35 our7330.51 20227330.67 research,7331.55 have7332.67 sent7332.67 data7332.99 to7333.47 these7333.71 commercial7334.11 surveillance7334.67 platforms.7335.31 We7336.85 are7337.01 delighted7337.81 that7338.45 the7338.69 MCDPA7338.93 and7339.89 MDPA7340.28 provide7341.01 27341.49 crucial7341.73 measures7342.2 to7343.09 make7343.24 digital7343.57 products7344.05 safer.7344.36 First,7345.41 meaningful7345.97 data7346.77 minimization.7347.16 In7348.36 2022,7348.61 we7349.57 published7349.81 107350.28 principles7350.53 for7351.01 safe7351.24 software.7351.57
7352.53 Principle7352.53 number7353.01 47353.25 is7353.65 data7353.89 collection7354.21 minimization,7354.61 where7355.97 data7356.13 collection7356.45 must7357.01 be7357.25 proportional7357.65 to7358.69 the7358.93 deal7359.09 being7359.49 established7359.89 between7360.93 the7361.49 product7361.73 and7362.05 the7362.29 consumer.7362.45 This7363.41 kind7363.57 of7363.81 contextual7363.97 proportionality7364.45 is7365.33 vital7365.49 for7365.89 meaningful7366.05 data7366.61 minimization.7366.85 We're7368.03 happy7368.27 to7368.59 see7368.66 the7368.99 alignment7369.15 in7369.55 H787369.7 and7370.43 H104.7370.66 It's7371.7 17371.86 of7372.03 the7372.19 easiest7372.35 and7372.74 best7372.91 ways7373.15 to7373.39 keep7373.55 people7373.78 safe7374.11 when7374.43 using7374.66 digital7374.91 products7375.31 by7376.19 not7376.43 collecting7376.66 the7377.15 information7377.23 in7377.7 the7377.86 first7378.03 place.7378.19 Secondly,7379.07 a7379.86 prohibition7379.86 on7381.23 the7381.31 sale7381.47 of7381.7 sensitive7381.86 personal7382.27 data7382.74 is7383.38 a7383.46 much-needed7383.78 and7384.26 profoundly7384.42 important7384.98 measure,7385.3 and7385.62 we're7385.78 happy7385.94 to7386.26 see7386.34 it7386.5 in7386.66 age7386.74 78.7387.06 The7388.02 selling7388.34 of7388.34 sensitive7388.5 personal7388.9 data7389.3 has7389.62 been7389.78 shown7389.94 repeatedly7390.26 to7390.74 present7390.9 physical,7391.94 emotional,7392.42 and7392.82 reputational7392.98 risks7393.62 to7393.94 individuals7394.1 and7394.58 groups.7394.74 We7395.48 believe7395.72 personal7396.44 data7396.76 markets7397.16 are7397.8 profoundly7398.05 risky7398.6 to7399.09 individuals7399.24 in7399.72 society,7399.89 especially7400.93 children.7401.48 The7403.09 proposed7403.32 H787404.6 definition7404.84 of7405.4 sensitive7405.56 data,7406.13 plus7406.93 the7407.24 prohibition7407.32 of7407.97 the7408.13 sale,7408.2 is7408.85 an7409.01 excellent7409.25 start7409.73 to7409.97 keeping7410.13 everyone7410.37 safer.7410.85 ISL7412.85 and7413.33 our7413.57 empirical7413.73 research7414.29 are7414.77 at7415.01 your7415.17 disposal.7415.41 Thank7415.97 you7416.21 for7416.53 the7417.01 opportunity.7417.25
7419.65 FARLEY-BOUVIER7419.65 -7419.65 Thank7419.65 you7419.81 so7420.45 much,7420.53 Lisa.7420.97 We'll7421.13 turn7421.36 to7421.6 Eric,7421.84 and7422.32 then7422.56 when7422.8 people7423.05 have7423.36 people7423.6 can7423.84 have7424.01 questions7424.16 for7424.65 the7424.89 panel.7425.13 Eric?7425.52
7427.6 ERIC7427.6 NULL7427.6 -7427.6 CENTER7427.6 FOR7427.6 DEMOCRACY7427.6 AND7427.6 TECHNOLOGY7427.6 -7427.6 HB7427.6 1047427.6 -7427.6 (7427.6 R7427.6 )7427.6 Hello.7427.6 Thank7428.09 you7428.24 very7428.56 much,7428.72 co-chairs7429.84 Moore7430.4 and7430.8 probably7431.13 Bouvier7431.44 and7431.84 members7432.01 of7432.32 the7432.4 committee.7432.56 I7432.97 appreciate7433.05 you7433.44 inviting7433.84 me7434.24 to7434.4 speak7434.56 to7434.8 you7434.89 today7435.05 on7435.44 27435.6 important7436.44 privacy7436.84 bills.7437.32 The7437.64 Massachusetts7437.88 consumer7438.52 data7438.92 privacy7439.16 act,7440.04 age7440.6 787440.92 and7441.64 Massachusetts7441.88 data,7442.28 data7443.88 privacy,7444.2 sorry,7444.76 consumer7445.16 data7445.56 privacy7445.8 act,7446.2 age7446.44 787446.6 and7447.16 data7447.32 privacy7447.56 act,7447.96 H7449.41 104.7449.65 And7449.65 thank7449.89 you7450.05 for7450.2 your7450.45 clear7450.85 hard7451.24 work7451.48 on7451.73 this7451.89 important7452.05 issue.7452.45 My7453.65 name7453.81 is7453.97 Eric7454.13 Null.7454.36 I'm7454.69 the7454.85 co-director7455.24 of7455.56 the7455.73 privacy7455.81 and7456.28 data7456.45 program7456.69 at7457.09 the7457.16 Center7457.32 for7457.65 Democracy7457.89 and7458.36 Technology.7458.6 A7459.48 30-year-old7461.65 non-partisan7462.09 non-profit7462.09 organization7462.09 focusing7462.33 on7462.73 protecting7462.97 individual7463.53 rights,7464.01 civil7464.49 rights,7464.81 and7465.13 civil7465.29 liberties7465.61 in7466.01 the7466.17 digital7466.33 age.7466.65 While7467.69 there7467.93 are7468.01 many7468.17 great7468.41 aspects7468.65 of7469.13 these7469.21 bills,7469.45 I'll7469.85 focus7470.09 here7470.49 on7470.81 37471.05 issues.7471.29 1,7471.93 moving7472.41 us7472.65 beyond7472.89 the7473.29 notice7473.45 and7473.77 consent7473.85 regime7474.25 to7474.57 a7474.73 data7474.89 minimization7475.13 regime.7475.85 2,7477.05 2,7477.57 protecting7477.74 civil7477.82 rights.7478.06 And7478.38 37478.53 ensuring7478.94 strong7479.41 enforcement.7479.82 First,7481.41 17481.82 of7482.06 the7482.22 primary7482.3 goals7482.7 of7483.1 privacy7483.26 legislation7483.66 should7484.3 be7484.53 to7484.78 move7484.85 us7485.1 beyond7485.26 the7485.66 failed7485.74 notice7486.14 and7486.45 consent7486.61 regime.7486.94
7487.57
7487.57 Which7487.57 has7487.82 been7487.98 dominant7488.22 since7488.61 the7488.85 1990s7489.02 and7489.57 ultimately7489.74 places7490.22 the7490.61 privacy7490.78 burden7491.18 on7491.74 already7491.98 overburdened7492.3 individuals.7492.85 However,7494.31 we7494.63 know7494.95 people7495.27 don't7495.99 view7496.31 privacy7496.63 policies7497.11 as7497.75 effective7497.99 or7498.39 useful.7498.47 We7499.35 know7499.51 people7499.75 don't7500.07 read7500.31 privacy7500.63 policies,7501.03 and7501.75 we7501.99 know7502.07 that7502.23 privacy7502.55 policies,7502.95 if7503.43 people7503.59 did7503.99 read7504.23 them,7504.47 it7505.03 would7505.03 require7505.27 hundreds7505.75 of7506.07 hours7506.23 per7506.63 year7506.87 to7507.11 read.7507.27 As7508.56 a7508.73 result,7508.81 people7509.2 have7509.52 a7509.69 sense7509.77 of7510.01 futility7510.16 and7510.89 feel7511.05 a7511.28 lack7511.28 of7511.44 control7511.69 over7512.16 privacy7512.48 risks,7512.97 and7513.28 they7513.44 often7513.6 underestimate7513.85 the7514.65 risks7514.73 of7515.05 disclosing7515.2 their7515.77 data.7516.01 Both7517.36 bills7517.6 CDT7517.93 supports7518.4 would7518.81 shift7519.05 the7519.36 primary7519.44 burden7520.29 to7520.53 the7520.61 companies7520.85 who7521.17 benefit7521.33 most7521.89 from7522.21 the7522.37 collection7522.53 and7522.93 exploitation7523.17 of7523.81 that7523.97 data.7524.13 The7525.25 bills7525.41 accomplish7525.81 that7526.21 through7526.45 strong7526.85 data7527.17 minimization7527.49 provisions7528.05 that,7528.69 unlike7529.09 many7529.41 other7529.73 states,7529.97 require7530.61 companies7530.93 to7531.41 justify7531.49 their7532.05 data7532.13 practice7532.45 in7532.89 the7532.97 first7533.13 instance.7533.28 Data7534.49 minimization7534.81 helps7535.6 prevent7536.01 privacy7536.49 harms7536.97 at7537.28 the7537.45 outset7537.53 because7538.49 data7538.73 a7539.13 company7539.2 does7539.6 not7539.77 have7539.93 cannot7540.24 lead7540.56 to7540.73 downstream7540.89 harms7542.32 through7542.65 misuse,7542.89 unauthorized7543.77 access7544.32 or7544.65 disclosure,7544.81 or7545.53 some7545.69 other7545.85 harmful7546.09 action.7546.56 Data7547.85 minimization7548.09 is7548.65 also7548.81 bipartisan.7549.05 A7549.69 recent7549.85 Consumer7550.17 Reports7550.57 survey7550.89 found7551.29 that7551.53 72%7551.69 of7552.33 Republicans7552.57 and7553.37 79%7553.61 of7554.49 Democrats7554.65 support7555.21 a7555.53 law7555.61 that7556.01 limits7556.17 companies7556.57 to7556.97 using7557.13 only7557.45 the7557.69 data7557.77 they7558.09 need7558.25 to7558.41 provide7558.57 their7558.97 service.7559.13
7560.66 Second,7560.66 these7561.22 bills7561.45 provide7561.78 increased7562.18 civil7562.66 rights7562.9 protections.7563.22 Privacy7564.1 rights7564.49 are7564.9 civil7564.98 rights.7565.22 A7565.94 privacy7566.1 law7566.57 should7566.81 protect7567.06 civil7567.45 rights7567.7 because7568.02 we7568.26 have7568.41 already7568.57 seen7568.9 data7569.22 being7569.53 used7569.78 in7570.02 a7570.18 discriminatory7570.34 way,7571.06 particularly7571.53 through7572.1 the7572.26 training7572.59 of7572.75 and7572.91 decisions7573.23 made7573.63 by7573.87 algorithms.7574.27 For7575.39 instance,7575.63 credit7576.19 scores7576.51 and7576.83 the7576.99 factors7577.15 used7577.55 to7577.79 calculate7577.95 them7578.43 are7578.67 deeply7578.83 correlated7579.15 with7579.63 race.7579.79 According7580.51 to7580.99 the7581.07 Brookings7581.23 Institute,7581.63 black7582.19 and7582.35 Hispanic7582.59 individuals7582.99 are7583.55 much7583.71 more7583.95 likely7584.11 to7584.43 have7584.51 credit7584.67 scores7584.91 below7585.31 6207586.15 than7586.39 white7586.63 individuals.7587.02 And7588.15 facial7588.39 recognition7588.7 software7589.19 exhibits7589.66 similar7590.06 biases7590.39 leading7590.94 to7591.19 the7591.27 misidentification7591.43 and7592.39 wrongful7592.55 arrests7593.02 of7593.35 37593.51 Black7593.74 men,7594.06 at7594.86 least7594.94 37595.27 Black7595.43 men:7595.66 Robert7595.91 Williams,7596.23 Najia7596.7 Parks,7597.1 and7597.43 Michael7597.66 Oliver.7597.98 Last,7599.61 privacy7600.17 laws7600.49 are7600.81 only7600.97 as7601.21 strong7601.29 as7601.53 their7601.61 enforcement.7601.85 They7603.05 should7603.21 be7603.37 enforced7603.45 through7603.85 multiple7604.01 channels.7604.41 Both7604.89 of7605.13 these7605.37 bills7605.61 provide7606.01 the7606.41 Massachusetts7606.57 attorney7607.37 general7607.77 with7608.17 rule-making7608.57 authority7608.81 and7609.37 civil7609.61 penalty7609.85 authority7610.33 and7610.73 provide7610.89 individuals7611.21 with7611.77 a7611.85 private7611.93 right7612.25 of7612.41 action.7612.57 That7612.97 way,7613.13 both7613.37 the7613.61 state7613.77 and7614.09 individuals7614.45 can7614.77 ensure7615.01 that7615.32 privacy7615.32 is7615.73 protected.7615.97 To7616.93 ensure7617.09 proper7617.41 enforcement,7617.73 the7618.13 AG7618.36 should7618.69 be7618.77 appropriated7619.01 enough7619.49 funds7619.81 to7620.05 build7620.2 a7620.45 dedicated7620.6 office7621.09 and7621.32 team7621.56 like7621.89 in7622.05 Texas.7622.2 Thank7623.41 you7623.65 for7623.81 your7623.97 time.7624.05 I7624.28 look7624.45 forward7624.53 to7624.77 answering7624.93 any7625.24 questions7625.41 you7625.81 have.7625.97
7627.21 FARLEY-BOUVIER7627.21 -7627.21 Thank7627.21 you7627.29 so7627.53 much,7627.77 Eric.7628.49 Are7628.97 there7629.13 any7629.37 questions7629.61 for7630.09 this7630.25 panel?7630.49 So7630.81 that7630.89 would7631.05 be7631.21 the7631.53 professor,7631.69 Lisa,7633.53 or7633.93 Eric.7634.25 Rep.7636.17 Fotolo.7636.49
7641.35 VITOLO7641.35 -7641.35 This7641.35 is7641.51 a7641.59 question7641.74 for7642.06 anyone7642.23 on7642.55 the7642.7 panel.7642.86 You7643.19 didn't7643.43 testify7643.66 specifically7644.39 about7644.94 this,7645.19 but7645.59 I7645.82 trust7646.06 that7646.31 your7646.47 expertise7646.78 may7647.66 allow7648.15 me7649.02 some7649.51 wisdom.7649.74 I7650.7 have7650.86 a7651.02 10-year-old7651.59 daughter7651.74 and7651.98 a7652.15 14-year-old7652.78 son.7653.02 Their7654.55 experiences7655.77 on7656.57 the7656.73 Internet7656.89 are7657.37 very7657.45 different7657.69 from7658.09 each7658.25 other.7658.49 They're7659.93 both7660.17 minors,7660.49 but7661.21 they're7661.45 very7661.61 different.7661.85 Can7662.25 you7662.41 give7662.65 me7663.85 some7664.17 guidance7664.49 about7665.53 how7666.01 we7666.17 ought7666.41 to7666.57 think7666.73 about7667.05 different7667.57 age7668.2 groups7668.45 of7668.85 young7669.09 people7669.41 and7670.36 their7672.13 data7672.53 privacy7672.93 or7673.57 needs7673.81 above7674.2 and7674.53 beyond7674.77 minimization?7675.81 Or7677.09 at7677.24 least7677.41 can7677.65 you7677.81 point7678.13 me7678.36 offline7678.6 to7679.09 some7679.5 resources7679.74 to7680.22 better7680.46 understand7680.78 how7681.82 to7682.06 think7682.14 about7682.38 different7682.7 ages7683.1 of7683.42 young7683.66 people,7683.9 different7684.22 cohorts,7684.62 and7685.42 how7685.66 to7685.82 protect7685.9 them,7686.38 especially7687.58 because7688.06 they7688.38 age7688.62 out7688.86 of7689.1 the7689.34 cohort7689.58 they're7689.98 in,7690.14 and7690.38 that7690.54 makes7690.78 it7691.02 even7691.18 more7691.42 complicated.7692.14
7696.69 FARLEY-BOUVIER7696.69 -7696.69 Thank7696.69 you.7696.76 Since7697.8 you're7698.13 not7698.28 there7698.44 to7698.69 nudge7698.84 each7699.16 other7699.24 with7699.56 your7700.36 elbows7700.52 and,7700.93 on7701.4 the7701.56 table7701.73 in7702.05 front7702.2 of7702.36 us,7702.44 is7703.48 anybody7703.65 I7704.6 just7705.1 invite7705.26 you7705.5 to7705.74 pipe7705.82 it.7706.06
7708.7 HARTZOG7708.7 -7708.7 I'm7708.7 happy7709.1 to7709.42 talk7709.5 about7709.82 it7710.06 for7710.22 a7710.86 little7710.94 while.7711.18 Thank7711.34 you7711.58 for7711.74 that7711.9 question.7712.14 So7712.54 it's7712.78 a7713.26 really7713.42 important7713.74 1.7714.3 And7715.74 I've7716.7 long7717.02 said7717.34 that,7717.66 while7720.44 it's7720.6 important7720.91 to7721.48 be7721.64 able7721.8 to7722.03 have7722.11 protections7723.4 for7723.95 kids,7724.19 it's7724.52 important7725.07 not7726.19 to7726.44 sort7726.99 of7727.15 understate7727.4 the7727.95 overall7728.11 danger.7728.6 And7728.99 so7729.07 there's7729.31 a7729.64 lot7729.72 of7729.88 protections7731.84 that7732.32 I7732.56 would7732.64 advocate7732.96 for7733.36 that7733.6 would7733.84 apply7734.08 to7734.48 all7735.68 ranges7735.92 of7736.32 children,7736.48 particularly7737.04 those7737.6 involving7738 data7739.28 collection7739.68 or7740.4 actually7740.72 the7741.12 design7741.28 of7741.68 certain7741.92 information7742.8 technology.7743.44 So7743.92 anti-engagement,7747.76 anti-dark-patterns7748.64 strategies.7748.64 People7749.19 should7749.52 be7749.68 protected7749.76 at7750.55 every7750.72 age7751.03 and7751.44 no7751.68 matter7751.84 what7752.07 choices7752.23 they7752.64 make7752.8 online.7752.95 And7754.31 so7754.48 I7754.8 think7754.88 that7755.19 by7755.44 a7756.15 heavy7756.31 focus7756.55 on7756.88 privacy,7757.11 you're7757.59 actually7757.84 able7758.31 to7759.03 be7759.19 more7760.31 responsive7760.63 to7761.11 a7761.27 broad7761.43 set7761.67 of7761.83 needs7761.99 that7762.39 are7762.55 less7762.71 sensitive7763.03 to7764.55 differences,7765.91 in7767.11 ages,7767.35 at7768.07 least7768.23 with7768.39 perspective,7768.55 the7769.03 bills7769.11 that7769.35 we're7769.51 considering7770.15 here7770.71 today.7770.95 I7772.07 hope7772.23 that7772.39 helps.7772.63 I7772.87 don't7772.95 know7773.19 exactly7773.48 how7773.8 responsive7774.03 that7774.44 was,7774.68 but7774.99 I7775.4 hope7775.48 it7775.72 was7775.8 at7775.95 least7776.03 somewhat7776.44 responsive.7776.91
LEVASSEUR7778.52 -7778.52 Yeah.7778.52 I7778.76 wanna7778.84 second7779.23 that.7779.56 You7780.35 know,7780.52 we7780.76 say7780.99 on7781.56 the7781.64 internet,7781.8 everyone's7782.27 a7782.68 child.7782.84 We7784.35 believe7784.52 that7784.91 everybody7785.23 deserves7786.27 strong7786.84 protection,7787.23 strong7788.16 privacy7788.48 protections.7788.96 Yeah.7790.72 So.7791.2
7793.12 FARLEY-BOUVIER7793.12 -7793.12 Thank7793.12 you.7793.44 Anybody7793.92 else7794.32 from7794.48 the7794.64 committee?7794.8 So,7796.32 Lisa,7797.84 I7798.24 just7798.32 have7798.56 a7798.72 quick7798.8 question7798.96 for7799.28 you.7799.44 Like,7800.08 what7800.32 incredible7800.77 work7801.01 that7801.4 you7801.48 do7801.65 to7801.89 be7802.13 tracking7802.28 all7802.69 these7802.84 apps.7803.09 I7803.32 mean,7803.48 just7803.65 counting7803.97 all7804.36 the7804.44 apps7804.6 would7804.84 be7805.01 a7805.09 hard7805.16 thing7805.4 to7805.56 do.7805.65 But7806.77 is7807.24 it7807.56 there7807.73 on7808.2 your7808.28 website?7809.01 Is7809.16 there7809.16 a7809.4 resource7809.56 for7810.2 people7810.6 to7811.01 go7811.16 in7811.89 a7812.2 consumer-friendly7813.4 way7813.97 to7814.36 learn7814.44 learn7814.76 about7815 these7815.24 apps7815.96 to7816.36 say7816.52 what's7816.76 happening7817.08 with7817.48 this7817.64 app?7817.88
7819.16 LEVASSEUR7819.16 -7819.16 Yeah.7819.16 Appmicroscope.org7819.72 is7821.64 the7822.12 web7822.52 service7822.76 that7823.08 we7823.32 have7823.4 that7823.72 displays7823.96 the7824.52 safety7824.68 labels.7825.08 The7825.72 safety7825.88 labels7826.28 that7826.68 you7826.84 see7827.16 right7827.32 now7827.56 are7827.96 heavy7828.2 on7828.6 privacy7828.92 risk.7829.48 We're7830.34 adding7830.65 in7830.98 dark7831.14 pattern7831.45 risk.7831.77 We're7832.26 adding7832.49 in7832.81 other7833.05 kinds7833.38 of7833.69 risks.7833.85 But7835.14 right7835.38 now,7835.61 they're7835.85 heavy7836.09 on7836.41 privacy7836.57 risk,7837.05 and7837.3 you7837.45 can7837.61 see7837.85 them,7838.01 and7838.18 we're7838.34 adding7838.49 new7838.81 ones7838.98 every7839.61 day.7839.94
7841.3 FARLEY-BOUVIER7841.3 -7841.3 Would7841.3 you7841.53 just7841.61 say,7842.01 talk7842.9 about7843.05 what7843.45 dark7843.69 patterns7844.01 are?7844.49
7846.03 LEVASSEUR7846.03 -7846.03 Yeah.7846.03 So,7846.27 dark7846.75 patterns7847.15 are7847.87 techniques7848.67 that7849.79 software7850.27 developers7850.75 deploy7851.55 in7852.75 designing7853.23 the7854.75 user7855.07 interface7855.71 that7856.99 consumers7857.47 interact7858.19 with.7859.49 These7860.06 are7860.3 patterns7861.02 in7861.57 the7861.81 sense7861.9 that7862.22 they7862.45 are7867.18 repeatable7867.18 techniques.7868.69 So7869.34 here's7869.57 17870.06 that7870.22 you've7870.38 all7870.61 seen.7870.85 The7871.95 consent7872.27 to7872.91 cookies.7874.03 The7875.15 button7875.39 is7875.71 big7875.87 and7876.03 green7876.27 on7876.59 the7876.67 bottom7876.75 of7877.07 your7877.15 screen,7877.39 and7877.63 if7877.87 you7878.03 wanna7878.19 change7878.51 it's7878.99 maybe7879.31 in7880.11 shaded7881.15 gray,7881.79 hard7882.43 to7882.75 find7882.91 a7883.55 link7883.55 somewhere7884.03 else.7884.51 Right?7885.39 That's7885.71 a7885.95 dark7886.11 pattern.7886.43 It's7887.8 funneling7888.13 you7888.6 down7888.84 a7889.32 particular7889.48 path7890.13 to7890.44 take7890.68 a7891.01 particular7891.16 action.7891.72 We7892.52 have7892.76 been,7892.93 in7893.24 our7893.48 software7893.72 safety7894.13 standards7894.52 panel,7894.93 we7895.72 have7895.97 been,7896.13 aggregating7897.32 work7898.44 from7899.13 academia7899.37 and7899.93 from7900.33 laws7900.73 that7901.13 enumerate7901.77 and7902.41 define7902.65 dark7903.13 patterns,7903.37 and7904.17 we've7904.49 come7904.81 up7904.97 with7905.05 a7905.29 list7905.37 of7905.85 some7906.17 nearly7906.81 707907.21 atomic-level7908.33 dark7909.29 patterns7909.61 that7910.09 have7910.41 been7910.65 defined7910.89 that7911.78 are7911.95 forms7912.1 of7912.51 manipulation.7912.74 Really,7913.95 that's7914.35 the7914.59 way7914.74 to7914.91 think7915.06 about7915.23 it.7915.39 They7915.63 are7915.78 forms7916.02 of7916.35 manipulation7916.51 that7917.63 have7917.78 been7917.95 codified7918.19 so7919.47 that7919.55 they're7919.7 repeatable.7920.02 And7920.98 you've7921.15 seen7921.39 these7921.63 in7921.86 like7922.1 infinite7922.51 scroll7922.98 is7923.86 a7924.02 highly7924.28 addictive7924.68 pattern,7925.16 and7925.72 people7925.96 know7926.28 this,7926.44 developers7926.76 know7927.32 this,7927.48 they've7927.72 known7928.04 this7928.2 for7928.44 quite7928.84 some7929.24 time.7929.48 Same7930.28 with7930.52 the7930.76 like7930.84 button.7931.16 It7931.48 is7931.64 an7932.2 addictive,7932.28 dark7933.96 pattern.7934.36 So,7935.24 we7935.48 are7935.64 cataloguing7935.88 and7936.6 categorizing7936.92 those,7937.64 and7937.71 we7937.77 will7937.84 make7937.9 those7937.97 available7938.03 in7938.1 the7938.16 safety7938.23 labels7938.3 as7938.36 well.7938.61
7946.45 FARLEY-BOUVIER7946.45 -7946.45 Thank7952.81 you7952.81 very7952.81 much.7952.81 Really7952.81 appreciate7952.81 the7952.81 testimony7952.81 of7952.81 this7952.81 panel.7952.81 And7952.81 hope7952.81 that7952.81 you7952.81 will7952.81 continue7952.81 to7952.81 engage7952.81 with7952.81 the7952.81 committee.7952.81 I7952.81 want7953.13 to7953.69 bring7954.01 up7954.41 Rep7954.73 Cataldo.7955.05 And7956.01 I7956.25 understand7956.41 you7956.89 have7957.13 some7958.33 people7958.49 with7958.81 you.7959.05 Rep,7959.69 if7960.01 you7960.09 want7960.25 to7960.49 introduce.7960.57 And7961.45 as7961.69 you're7961.85 coming,7962.09 to,7963.21 up7964.01 front,7964.17 we7964.57 want7964.73 to7964.97 welcome7965.13 representative,7965.74 Lombardo.7966.7 Thanks7967.9 for7968.22 being7968.38 here.7968.53 Nice7968.85 to7969.1 see7969.18 you.7969.34 Representative.7974.14
REP7984.03 CATALDO7984.03 -7984.03 HB7984.03 1037984.03 -7984.03 Madam7984.03 chair?7984.27 Yes.7984.67 Chair7985.15 Moore,7985.47 thank7986.03 you7986.27 so7986.43 much7986.59 for7986.83 the7987.07 opportunity7987.23 to7987.63 testify,7987.79 and7988.11 thanks7988.35 for7988.51 taking7988.75 us7989.07 out7989.31 of7989.47 turn.7989.63 Online7990.43 should7990.99 be,7991.23 Sean7991.63 Diamatos.7991.95 Okay.7992.75 And7993.71 here7993.87 is7994.11 Sean7994.51 Kaczowski7994.83 with7995.39 me.7995.61 He's7995.78 coming7996.02 all7996.1 the7996.34 way7996.41 from7996.66 Colorado7996.98 today.7997.53 This7998.49 committee7999.06 has7999.61 heard7999.86 some8000.18 terrifying8000.57 testimony,8001.53 and,8002.57 sorry8003.22 to8003.45 say8003.61 it's8003.78 about8003.94 to8004.18 get8004.26 worse.8005.53 When8005.53 you8005.86 hear8006.1 what8007.3 my8007.53 colleagues8007.7 have8008.34 to8008.49 say.8008.66 The8010.21 bill8010.45 was8010.69 then8010.85 summarized8010.85 briefly8011.33 by8011.81 the8012.21 chair,8012.53 a8012.53 Vargas8012.53 representative.8013.57 So8013.97 I'm8014.13 not8014.29 gonna8014.37 go8014.69 into8015.49 that8015.73 again,8015.89 and8016.21 I'm8016.45 gonna8016.53 turn8017.01 it8017.17 over8017.41 to8018.53 them8018.69 in8018.93 a8019.09 minute.8019.17 I8019.49 just,8019.57 you8019.81 know,8019.89 the8020.05 only8020.21 point8020.45 that8020.61 I8020.77 would8020.85 make8021.01 before8021.17 they8021.49 begin8021.65 is8021.97 that8022.13 the8023.1 hands8023.34 in8023.66 which8023.82 this8024.22 technology8024.45 exists8025.34 now8025.82 are8026.86 not8027.1 necessarily8027.34 the8028.06 folks8028.22 that8028.53 I8028.78 would8028.86 trust8029.1 with8029.49 data8030.22 about8030.61 my8030.86 brain.8031.02 So8031.74 this8031.9 is8033.26 H103.8034.3 It's8034.3 called8034.61 an8034.94 act8035.18 to8035.41 establish8035.75 the8036.07 Massachusetts8036.23 Neural8036.87 Data8037.27 Privacy8037.51 Protection8038.07 Act,8038.55 and8039.59 we8039.83 drafted8039.99 it8040.39 in8040.55 such8040.71 a8040.83 way8040.95 that8041.27 I8041.67 think8041.83 it8042.07 could8042.23 be8042.39 neatly8042.63 tucked8043.19 into8043.43 any8044.63 of8044.79 the8044.95 more8045.03 comprehensive8045.43 bills8046.71 on8047.11 data8047.27 privacy8047.59 that8048.07 have8048.23 been8048.47 proposed.8049.03 And8049.99 happy8050.23 to8050.47 work,8050.63 of8050.87 course,8050.95 with8051.32 the8051.49 committee8051.57 on8051.69 that.8051.81 But8052.93 I8053.57 will8053.81 turn8053.97 it8054.2 over8054.36 to8054.77 Sean.8054.93
SEAN8056.53 PAUZAUSKIE8056.53 -8056.53 THE8056.53 NEURORIGHTS8056.53 FOUNDATION8056.53 -8056.53 Alright.8056.53 Thank8056.85 you8057.09 so8057.24 much,8057.41 Representative8058.05 Cataldo.8058.45 Thank8059.16 you,8059.32 Madam8059.73 Chairwoman8060.36 Farley8060.36 Boubier8060.69 and8062.13 Senator8062.6 Moore.8062.6 My8063.16 name8063.34 is8063.5 Sean8063.66 Pauzauskie,8063.82 and8064.62 I'm8064.86 here8065.02 today8065.26 on8065.58 behalf8065.74 of8066.06 the8066.46 nonprofit8066.7 Neuro8067.34 Rights8067.58 Foundation.8067.9 I8068.86 serve8069.02 as8069.26 medical8069.34 director.8069.66 I'm8069.98 a8070.22 practicing8070.38 neurologist8070.78 and8071.34 clinical8071.5 researcher8071.9 in8073.02 Colorado,8073.26 and8073.82 I8073.9 also8074.06 conduct8074.3 clinical8074.7 research8075.1 with8075.42 companies8075.58 that8076.06 are8076.3 employing8076.62 neurotechnology8077.02 in8078.54 a8078.99 consumer-driven8080.19 space,8080.52 including8080.91 some8081.23 in8081.48 Massachusetts.8081.72 So,8082.35 thank8082.59 you8082.84 for8082.91 the8083.56 opportunity8083.64 to8084.19 testify.8084.35 While8085.4 we8085.64 neurologists8085.8 tend8086.27 to8086.44 be8086.52 a8086.68 little8086.76 cerebral,8086.99 not8087.64 to8087.8 make8087.95 a8088.11 pun,8088.19 I8089.8 wanna8089.88 speak8090.11 to8090.35 you8090.44 today.8090.52
8090.84 FARLEY-BOUVIER8090.84 -8090.84 Thank8090.84 you8090.91 for8091.07 that,8091.23 man.8091.4 It's8091.72 all8091.8 men.8092.11
8094.27 PAUZAUSKIE8094.27 -8094.27 Yeah.8094.27 But,8095.12 today,8096 I8096.4 wanna8096.48 speak8096.72 to8096.88 you8097.04 from8097.12 the8097.28 heart,8097.44 just8098 to8098.24 talk8098.4 about8098.64 this8098.8 issue.8098.96 So8100 my8100.24 interest8100.72 in8101.04 this8101.2 issue8101.36 comes8101.6 from8101.84 I8102.08 was8102.24 approached8102.48 by8102.72 my8102.88 research8103.04 office8103.44 about8103.76 doing8104 a8104.24 research8104.32 project8104.72 using8105.36 a8105.6 consumer8105.76 neurotechnology8106.32 device8106.96 that8107.28 anyone8107.44 can8107.76 buy8108 off8108.16 the8108.24 Internet8108.4 today,8108.8 have8109.28 it8109.45 shipped8109.69 to8109.77 you,8110.01 to8110.65 do8110.81 clinical8111.05 research,8111.53 because8112.49 the8112.89 data8113.05 collected8113.36 from8113.77 these8113.93 devices,8114.09 is8115.13 medical8115.36 grade.8115.77 And8116.01 that8116.16 just8116.32 struck8116.49 me8116.73 as8116.89 somewhat8117.05 concerning.8118.24 And8118.65 so,8118.73 that's8118.97 kind8119.2 of8119.36 what8119.45 started8119.69 me8120.01 on8120.32 this8120.56 path8120.73 towards,8120.97 you8121.77 know,8122.01 this8122.09 issue8122.24 that8122.49 we8122.73 probably8122.81 define8123.2 as8123.53 neuro8123.69 rights,8124.01 including8124.98 the8125.14 right8125.3 to8125.38 mental8125.54 privacy.8125.94 There8127.22 are8127.38 approximately8127.54 308128.1 of8128.26 these8128.42 companies8128.58 across8128.98 the8129.3 country8129.38 collecting8130.18 this8130.5 neural8130.74 data,8131.06 including8131.46 in8131.86 Massachusetts,8132.1 and8133.3 doing8133.46 so8133.7 with8133.94 things8134.1 as8134.34 simple8134.42 as8134.74 a8134.9 headband8135.3 or8136.26 earbuds.8136.58
8137.7 And8137.7 as8137.86 I8138.02 mentioned,8138.1 this8138.42 data8138.82 is8139.16 medical8139.32 grade,8139.65 but8140.2 we8140.44 enjoy8140.6 the8140.85 protections8141.01 of8141.32 HIPAA8141.48 in8141.81 the8141.89 clinic8141.97 and8142.28 in8142.44 the8142.52 research8142.6 setting,8142.93 but8143.65 that's8143.81 not8143.97 the8144.2 case,8144.28 for8144.85 the8145.09 citizens,8145.16 more8146.2 broadly,8146.52 including8146.93 up8147.32 to8147.48 30000008147.56 in8148.13 Massachusetts8148.28 who8148.93 suffer8149.09 from8149.41 anxiety8149.65 and8149.97 depression,8150.13 4500008151.01 with8152.2 schizophrenia,8152.44 hundreds8153.48 of8153.81 thousands8153.97 with8154.28 cognitive8154.52 disorders,8154.98 700008155.38 with8156.02 epilepsy,8156.26 all8157.3 at8157.54 risk8157.62 of8157.86 undue8158.02 identification,8158.42 and8159.54 possibly8159.7 having8160.1 that8160.34 data8160.5 sold8160.82 to8161.22 third8161.54 parties8161.86 for8162.18 purposes8162.42 of8162.82 manipulation,8163.22 or8164.66 possibly8165.38 discrimination.8165.86 Some8166.98 of8167.14 the8167.3 most8167.46 sensitive8167.62 data8168.02 that8168.26 you8168.34 could8168.5 possibly8168.66 share8168.98 with8169.14 anyone8169.3 is8169.7 data8170.18 coming8170.53 from8170.7 your8170.94 brain.8171.53 My8172.3 concerns8172.45 go8172.85 beyond8173.02 this8173.81 into8174.7 more8174.7 of8174.82 the8174.94 realm8175.1 of8175.34 mental8175.49 privacy,8175.9 more8176.38 generally8176.53 speaking.8176.94 We8177.73 know8177.81 that8177.98 in8178.14 the8178.3 laboratory,8178.38 you8178.94 can8179.02 decode8179.26 thought8179.9 to8180.22 text,8180.38 using8181.34 the8181.73 same8181.9 kind8182.06 of8182.3 data8182.38 with8182.7 up8182.85 to8183.02 40%8183.1 accuracy8183.73 today.8184.3
8184.3 If8184.79 things8184.95 continue8185.11 to8185.59 advance8185.75 in8186.07 a8186.23 few8186.31 years,8186.47 and8187.19 with,8187.43 the8187.83 big8187.91 tech8188.15 companies8188.31 getting8188.71 ready8188.95 to8189.19 introduce8189.35 products8190.15 that,8190.63 can8191.03 collect,8191.27 you8192.15 know,8192.31 brainwaves8192.55 from8193.03 simple,8193.27 you8193.67 know,8193.83 ear8194.07 pods8194.31 or,8194.71 you8195.59 know,8195.75 from8195.91 your8196.15 wrist,8196.31 the8196.63 level8196.79 of8197.03 your8197.11 wrist,8197.27 that8197.91 hundreds8198.07 of8198.39 millions8198.55 of8198.87 people8198.95 could8199.47 be8199.63 at8199.7 risk8199.86 of8200.18 having8200.42 this8200.58 data8200.83 taken8201.31 and8201.55 even8201.7 their8201.86 thoughts8202.02 decoded8202.34 in8202.75 several8202.91 years8203.15 if8203.47 things8203.55 progress8203.78 at8204.26 the8204.34 rate8204.5 that8204.67 we8204.83 anticipate.8204.98 So8206.26 I'm8206.42 not8206.58 just8206.67 here8206.91 worried8207.06 about8207.39 my8207.55 patients,8207.7 but8208.34 about8208.83 things8208.98 more8209.47 broadly8209.7 that8210.02 if8210.18 this8210.26 data8210.5 was8210.75 aggregated,8210.98 that8211.78 it8211.94 could8212.1 be8212.26 used8212.34 to8212.58 even8212.67 decode8213.06 the8213.47 thoughts8213.55 of8214.34 people8214.5 across8215.69 the8216.01 country8217.13 in8217.37 the8217.45 coming8217.61 years.8217.93 And8218.17 so8218.41 I8218.57 think8218.65 that8218.89 h8219.53 1038220.09 provides8220.33 us8220.65 with8220.89 a8220.89 simple,8221.61 common-sense8221.85 solution8221.85 to8222.25 this,8222.33 providing8222.57 robust8223.53 protections8223.93 that8224.41 this8225.45 sensitive8225.53 data8226.01 deserves,8226.33 and8227.21 I8227.45 urge8227.45 your8227.69 support.8227.85 I8228.33 would8228.81 be8228.81 happy8229.05 to8229.29 answer8229.37 any8229.69 questions.8229.85
8231.19 FARLEY-BOUVIER8231.19 -8231.19 Thank8231.19 you8231.43 so8231.67 much.8231.83 So8232.15 we're8232.88 just8233.19 checking8233.43 in8233.75 to8233.92 see8234.08 if8234.23 your8234.4 other8234.48 panelist8234.72 is8235.19 online.8235.43 Sean,8235.92 are8236.15 you8236.31 online8236.56 with8236.95 us?8237.11 Didn't8237.92 see8238.48 him8238.72 listed.8239.11
8243.84 SPEAKER348243.84 -8243.84 Oh,8243.84
8244.16 SPEAKER18244.16 -8244.16 here8244.16 we8244.48 go.8244.81 Hi.8245.13
STEPHEN8245.45 DAMIANOS8245.45 -8245.45 THE8245.45 NEURORIGHTS8245.45 FOUNDATION8245.45 -8245.45 (8245.45 R8245.45 )8245.45 -8245.45 Yes.8245.45 Yes.8245.77 This8246.1 is8246.42 Steven8246.75 Damiano.8247.07 Hi.8247.39 Yes.8247.71 Chair8248.36 Farley8248.68 Bovier,8249.01 Chair8249.33 Moore,8249.65 members8249.98 of8250.3 the8250.62 committee,8250.94 and8251.27 Rep.8251.59 Cataldo,8251.59 thank8251.92 you8252.24 very8252.56 much8252.89 for8253.21 your8253.85 consideration8254.18 of8254.5 this8254.82 important8255.15 bill8255.47 and8255.79 your8256.12 leadership8256.44 in8256.76 this8257.08 space.8257.41 My8257.73 name8258.14 is8258.22 Steven8258.45 Damianos.8258.69 I8259.5 am8259.65 the8259.81 Executive8259.98 Director8260.45 of8260.85 the8260.93 NeuroRights8261.09 Foundation,8262.38 which8262.77 is8262.93 a8263.09 nonpartisan8263.25 501C38264.38 nonprofit8265.09 dedicated8266.22 to8266.61 promoting8266.69 the8267.09 ethical8267.25 innovation8267.73 of8268.3 neurotechnologies.8268.45 To8270.06 be8270.14 clear,8270.22 when8270.53 we're8270.69 talking8270.85 about8271.09 neurotechnologies,8271.42 we're8272.53 talking8272.69 about8273.01 any8273.25 device8273.49 that8273.89 is8274.05 capable8274.37 of8275.09 either8275.49 monitoring8276.05 or8276.85 manipulating8277.17 the8277.89 activity8278.13 of8278.53 the8278.61 brain8278.77 and8279.17 the8279.33 wider8279.49 nervous8279.81 systems.8280.13 At8281.09 the8281.33 NeuroRight8281.41 Foundation,8281.89 we8282.29 believe8282.45 in8282.85 the8283.09 exciting8283.25 potential8283.73 of8284.37 emerging8284.61 neurotechnologies,8285.09 and8286.53 we8286.69 want8286.77 to8286.85 make8287.01 sure8287.25 that8287.58 these8287.74 technologies8287.98 are8288.45 designed8288.61 and8288.93 deployed8289.09 responsibly.8289.5 Our8290.38 goal8290.53 is8290.69 to8290.85 leverage8291.01 these8291.33 technologies8291.5 for8291.98 social8292.22 good8292.53 while8292.77 safeguarding8293.09 them8293.74 from8293.9 misuse.8294.22 My8295.42 colleagues8295.58 and8295.9 I8295.98 are8296.14 strongly8296.22 in8296.61 support8296.77 of8297.17 this8297.42 bill.8297.74 Neurotechnologies8298.69 have8298.76 existed8298.83 in8298.9 medical8298.96 settings8299.03 for8299.1 decades8299.16 but8299.23 are8299.3 quickly8299.36 proliferating8299.43 into8299.5 the8299.82 medical8299.95 settings8302.43 for8302.59 decades8302.99 but8303.07 are8303.15 quickly8303.35 proliferating8303.55 into8303.75 the8303.95 consumer8304.03 space.8304.27 When8304.71 used8305.15 in8305.79 medical8305.87 settings,8306.19 they8306.35 are8306.67 heavily8306.99 regulated8307.23 by8307.71 health8308.03 privacy8308.19 laws8308.75 such8309.15 as8309.31 HIPAA8309.39 and8309.71 others.8309.95
8310.51 But8310.51 once8310.75 taken8311.23 out8311.55 of8311.71 medical8311.95 settings,8312.35 neurotechnology8312.83 is8313.55 considered8313.63 consumer-facing8314.64 and8315.03 not8315.19 subject8315.44 to8315.92 any8316.08 regulation8316.4 at8316.8 all.8316.95 The8318 reason8318.08 this8318.4 gap8318.56 is8318.95 so8319.52 concerning8319.92 is8320.56 because8320.8 of8321.11 the8321.27 extreme8321.52 sensitivity8322.08 of8322.8 neural8323.11 data.8323.44 When8324.72 paired8325.11 with8325.52 generative8325.75 artificial8326.32 intelligence8326.95 algorithms,8327.92 neural8329.26 data8329.5 are8329.98 capable8330.3 of8330.62 revealing8330.86 deeply8331.42 intimate8331.9 information8332.62 about8333.1 consumers,8333.34 including8334.06 information8334.94 about8335.42 their8336.06 health,8336.3 mental8336.78 states,8337.18 emotions,8338.06 and8338.46 cognitive8338.7 processing.8339.18 And8339.58 as8339.82 my8339.98 colleague8340.14 Dr.8340.78 Pauzauskie8341.34 just8341.34 said,8341.5 there's8342 increasing8342.4 ability8342.8 also,8343.27 you8343.59 know,8343.67 in8343.92 addition8344.08 to8344.4 accessing8344.64 diagnoses8345.27 about8346 neuropsychiatric8347.03 disorders,8348.64 also8349.19 the8349.51 ability8349.75 to8350.24 decode8350.48 human8351.59 thought8352 from8352.4 these8352.64 devices.8352.8 At8354.31 the8354.4 NeuroRights8354.48 Foundation,8355.11 my8355.83 colleagues8356 and8356.59 I8356.83 conducted8356.99 extensive8357.39 research8357.87 studying8358.35 the8358.75 privacy8358.91 practices8359.39 and8359.87 data8360.03 rights8360.35 of8360.91 consumer8361.07 neurotechnology8361.55 companies,8362.43 and8363.07 we're8363.31 deeply8363.47 concerned8363.87 to8364.35 find8364.51 widespread8364.83 deficiencies8365.71 and8366.35 enormous8366.51 gaps8366.99 between8367.39 the8367.63 data8367.79 protection8368.03 standards8368.59 globally8369.6 and8370 actual8370.32 industry8370.64 practice.8371.11 This8373.19 isn't8373.35 a8373.68 problem8373.84 just8374.16 for8374.48 the8374.72 future.8374.88 I8375.19 want8375.35 to8375.6 emphasize8375.76 that8376.16 this8376.32 is8376.56 a8376.64 problem.8377.19
8378.08 Consumer8378.08 neurotech8378.48 is8379.03 not8379.19 exactly8379.52 mainstream8380.16 yet,8380.8 but8380.95 it8381.11 isn't8381.27 fringe,8381.52 either.8382 For8382.72 example,8382.88 18383.27 leading8383.52 neurotechnology8383.76 company8384.78 claims8385.02 to8385.34 have8385.9 already8386.22 collected8386.22 over8386.62 1000000008386.86 minutes8387.98 of8388.38 consumer8388.62 neural8389.18 data.8389.42 So8389.98 it's8390.14 approximately8390.3 1700000.08390.94 hours,8392.14 while8392.94 another8393.26 leading8393.66 neurotechnology8393.98 company8394.62 shared8395.02 with8395.26 us8395.42 that8395.58 they8395.82 have8395.98 10000000008396.22 minutes,8396.94 which8397.81 is8397.89 170000008398.13 hours.8399 And,8399.25 of8399.49 course,8399.57 you8399.81 could8399.97 train8400.13 an8400.36 algorithm8400.52 on8401 just8401.08 a8401.41 fraction8401.49 of8401.89 this.8401.97 And8402.77 I'll8402.92 note8403.08 that8403.33 tech8404.2 giants8404.44 like8404.92 Meta8405.17 and8405.41 Apple8405.65 are8406.05 in8406.2 the8406.28 process8406.44 of8406.85 developing8407 and8408.13 commercializing8408.28 their8409 own8409.25 products8409.49 as8409.97 well.8410.13 And8410.89 so,8411.13 there's8411.69 an8412.49 enormous8412.49 need8413.13 to8413.53 safeguard8414.65 this8415.21 space,8415.85 and8416.81 this8416.81 bill8417.13 would8417.37 have8417.61 important8418.09 implications8418.49 for8418.89 Massachusetts8419.13 consumers8419.69 and8420.17 companies8420.41 that8420.81 want8420.97 to8421.13 sell8421.29 their8421.45 products8421.61 in8422.01 the8422.17 Massachusetts8422.33 market.8423.05 I'm8423.53 happy8423.69 to8424.01 answer8424.17 any8424.41 more8424.57 questions,8424.73 and8425.05 I'll8425.21 just8425.37 note8425.53 quickly8425.77 that8426.44 Colorado8427.32 and8427.72 California8427.95 recently8428.6 passed8429.64 similar8429.88 amendments.8430.27 And8430.76 just8430.92 last8431.16 week,8431.4 Montana8431.72 passed8432.27 legislation,8432.52 passing8433.88 the8434.11 senate8434.27 on8434.6 a8434.76 vote8434.84 of8435.08 498435.16 to8435.64 18435.8 and8436.11 the8436.35 house8436.52 on8436.84 a8437 vote8437.08 of8437.32 1008437.48 to8438.03 0.8438.19 And8439.01 so8439.09 there's8439.25 growing8439.65 bipartisan8439.97 recognition8440.61 of8441.17 the8441.25 importance8441.33 of8442.21 this8442.45 type8442.61 of8442.85 effort.8443.17 Thank8443.65 you8443.81 very8443.97 much.8444.21
8444.85 FARLEY-BOUVIER8444.85 -8444.85 Thank8444.85 you.8445.09 Thank8445.81 you8445.97 to8446.13 all8446.37 the8446.69 members8446.77 of8447.09 the8447.17 panel.8447.25 Are8447.57 there8447.73 questions8447.89 from8448.29 the8448.53 members8448.61 of8448.93 the8449.09 committee?8449.17 Senator.8451.38
8453.45 MOORE8453.45 -8453.45 So8453.45 what8454.33 is8454.5 this8454.74 so8456.09 help8456.33 me.8456.58 What8456.74 would8457.06 this8457.22 be8457.45 used8457.61 to8457.93 detect8458.09 for8458.9 your8459.06 fifth?8459.22
8460.17 PAUZAUSKIE8460.17 -8460.17 Yeah.8460.17 So8460.5 today,8460.66 it8460.98 could8461.06 be8461.22 used,8461.3 for8461.77 example,8462.01 if8462.42 you8462.58 had,8462.74 I'll8463.53 just8463.69 take8463.85 probably8464.09 the8464.42 most,8465.3 you8467.18 know,8467.26 defined8467.5 example8467.82 of8468.22 epilepsy.8468.38 So8469.1 epilepsy8469.42 is8469.9 not8469.98 just8470.78 as8470.94 simple8471.1 as8471.42 you're8471.42 having8471.66 a8471.9 seizure8471.98 or8472.3 you're8472.46 not,8472.62 but8472.86 brain8473.42 patterns,8473.66 easily8474.54 detectable8474.94 from8476.06 things8476.38 like8476.7 consumer8476.86 brainwave8477.58 data,8478.06 could8478.7 be8478.86 detected8479.02 from8479.42 this8479.66 data.8479.82 So8480.06 if8480.3 I8480.58 had8480.67 epilepsy8480.83 and8481.23 I'm8481.39 I'm8481.55 using8481.63 18481.86 of8482.02 these8482.1 products,8482.34 my8482.75 data8482.99 gets8483.15 sent8483.39 to8483.55 the8483.7 company.8483.78 They8484.1 could8484.26 easily8484.42 decode8484.75 that8485.15 I8485.31 had8485.39 epilepsy8485.55 and8486.34 perhaps8486.58 use8486.91 that8487.15 to8487.31 sell8487.55 me8487.78 whatever8488.34 I8488.75 might8488.91 need8489.15 for8489.31 that8489.47 or8489.7 to8490.5 use8490.67 that8490.83 to,8491.06 you8491.23 know,8491.31 sell8491.55 to8491.78 insurance8491.94 companies,8492.34 things8493.31 of8493.55 that8493.7 nature.8493.86 That's8495.44 just8495.52 18495.76 example.8496
8496.96 MOORE8496.96 -8496.96 Alright.8496.96 But8497.2 this8497.44 device8498.72 that's8499.04 being8499.28 used8499.44 is8499.68 being8499.84 prescribed8500.16 by8500.56 a8500.8 physician.8500.96
8502 PAUZAUSKIE8502 -8502 So8502 these8502.16 are8502.32 consumer8503.12 devices.8503.52 That's8503.76 a8504 great8504.16 distinction.8504.72 These8505.52 are8505.68 the8505.84 same8506 types8506.24 of8506.56 data8507.22 that8507.45 I8507.53 collect8507.69 in8508.01 the8508.17 clinic8508.25 and8508.5 the8508.65 hospital8508.81 every8509.22 day8509.45 but8509.93 that8510.17 are8510.25 available8510.5 through8510.9 Amazon8511.06 or8511.93 the8512.09 company8512.17 websites.8512.57
8513.85 MOORE8513.85 -8513.85 So8513.85 I8513.93 guess8514.01 if8514.33 I8514.5 wasn't8514.65 going8514.9 to8515.14 my8516.42 primary8516.57 care8516.98 or8517.14 a8517.45 specialist,8517.53 why8517.93 would8518.17 I8518.33 purchase8518.73 18519.06 of8519.3 these8519.38 these8520.42 equipment?8520.92
8521.32 PAUZAUSKIE8521.32 -8521.32 Yeah.8521.32 Exactly.8521.48 So8521.88 a8522.28 lot8522.36 of8522.52 them8522.6 are8522.76 being8522.84 marketed8523.08 as8523.4 wellness8523.56 devices8524.04 for8524.52 things8524.76 like8525 meditation,8525.24 for8526.36 sleep,8526.68 to8527 enhance8527.24 your8527.56 mood,8527.72 to8528.04 help8528.2 your8528.36 cognition,8528.52 and8529.4 just8529.56 growing8529.8 more8530.12 and8530.36 more,8530.52 applications8531 for,8531.8 the8532.68 reason8533.08 that8533.32 there's8533.4 this8533.64 loophole8533.8 is8534.28 because8534.44 of8534.84 the8535 wellness8535.16 category,8535.72 of8537.06 device.8537.22 So8537.53 you8537.77 can8537.94 get8538.1 a8538.74 brain8538.98 wellness8539.38 device8539.85 now8540.18 that8540.5 uses8540.74 the8541.14 same8541.3 types8541.45 of8541.69 data8541.77 that8542.02 we8542.18 use8542.33 in8542.5 the8542.58 clinic.8542.74
8544.26 MOORE8544.26 -8544.26 Okay.8544.26 Alright.8544.74 Thank8545.14 you.8545.45
FARLEY-BOUVIER8547.14 -8547.14 So8547.14 just8547.45 to8547.61 clarify,8547.85 nothing8549.38 about8549.94 this8550.42 bill8550.74 or8551.23 the8551.47 other8551.63 data8552.03 privacy8552.27 bills8552.67 being8553.55 heard8553.79 today8554.03 is8554.83 stopping8555.23 this8555.95 advanced8556.35 technology.8556.91 It8558.03 is8558.19 about8558.35 protecting8558.67 the8559.23 data.8559.39 That's8560.27 what8560.43 you're8560.67 bringing8561.55 to8561.87 us8561.95 today.8562.11 We're8562.43 not8562.67 saying8562.91 it8563.47 shouldn't8563.63 be8563.95 consumer.8564.11 You're8564.59 not8564.75 asking8564.91 it8565.23 for8565.39 not8565.55 to8565.71 be8565.79 at8565.95 the8566.03 consumer8566.19 level.8566.59 Level.8567.27 You're8567.35 asking8567.59 that8568.08 the8568.56 data8568.8 be8569.03 protected.8569.19
8569.75 PAUZAUSKIE8569.75 -8569.75 Exactly.8569.75 Great8570.08 distinction.8570.56 Yes.8570.95 In8571.11 fact,8571.27 our8571.51 first8572 stated8572.24 mission8572.48 is8572.8 to8572.88 promote8573.03 innovation,8573.35 and8574 we8574.16 feel8574.32 like8574.48 that8574.64 we8574.8 can8574.95 do8575.11 that8575.27 by8575.51 both8576.08 lending8576.32 structure8576.72 to8577.11 an8577.27 emerging8577.35 industry8577.75 and8579.27 also8579.57 really8580.53 legitimizing8580.85 this8581.49 technology8581.73 through8582.21 things8582.45 like8582.69 legislation8582.85 so8583.33 that8583.49 people8583.65 are8583.89 more8584.05 aware8584.21 of8584.45 it.8584.53
8585.73 SPEAKER168585.73 -8585.73 Thank8585.73 you.8585.97 Sure.8586.29
8587.41 MOORE8587.41 -8587.41 So,8587.41 why8588.37 wouldn't8588.61 this8588.85 be8589.01 classified8589.17 under8589.65 HIPAA?8590.05
8591.09 PAUZAUSKIE8591.09 -8591.09 That's8591.42 a8591.75 great8591.83 question.8591.99 That's8592.47 why8593.42 we're8593.67 here.8594.06 It's8594.39 because8594.55 they're8594.86 these.8595.5 It8595.58 wasn't8595.58 an8595.91 intentional8596.06 oversight,8596.55 either.8596.94 We're8597.18 not8597.42 saying8597.58 that8597.83 when8598.23 HIPAA8598.39 was8598.63 written8598.78 or8599.02 when8599.18 any8599.34 of8599.5 these8599.58 state8599.75 privacy8599.91 laws8600.31 were8600.55 written,8600.7 that8600.86 neural8601.02 data8601.26 was8601.58 an8601.75 oversight.8601.91 It's8602.39 just8602.63 such8602.78 a8602.94 new8603.1 and8603.26 emerging8603.42 technology8603.83 that8604.31 they8604.47 just8604.63 weren't8605.24 aware8605.48 of8605.8 at8606.12 the8606.2 time8606.28 that8606.52 these8606.6 laws8606.84 were8607.08 written.8607.64
MOORE-8608.84 Okay.8608.84 Thank8609.36 you.8609.88
FARLEY-BOUVIER8611.96 -8611.96 And8611.96 I'll8612.2 just8612.6 also8612.92 say8613.24 around8613.64 HIPAA8614.04 because8614.36 I8614.6 think8614.68 that8614.84 comes8615.08 up8615.32 a8615.48 lot8615.56 when8615.8 we8615.96 talk.8616.12 I8616.68 think8616.84 thank8617.16 you8617.4 for8617.56 saying8617.72 wellness.8618.12 There's8618.6 a8618.84 lot8618.92 of8619.16 health8619.24 space8619.56 that8619.88 we8620.04 think8620.2 of8620.36 health8620.85 information.8621.25 It's8621.81 really8622.05 health8622.28 insurance,8623.25 right,8624.77 that8625.01 HIPAA8625.25 covers.8625.65 If8625.97 it's8626.2 covered8626.28 by8626.6 insurance,8626.93 then8627.89 that's8628.13 what's8628.28 really8628.6 protected,8628.85 not8629.33 actually8629.65 your8629.97 health8630.13 information.8630.44 So8631.73 thank8632.36 you8632.6 very8632.77 much.8633.09 Any8633.81 else?8634.13 Okay.8634.78 We're8635.58 gonna8635.82 now8636.06 sure.8636.38
8636.7 SPEAKER78636.7 -8636.7 Sure.8636.7 Of8636.78 course.8636.94 Thank8637.1 you8637.18 so8637.26 much.8637.42
FARLEY-BOUVIER8637.66 -8637.66 We're8637.66 gonna8637.82 now8638.06 bring8638.22 up8638.46 Christy8638.62 Lynch8639.02 from8639.26 the8639.5 AFL8639.66 CIO.8639.98 And8640.86 on8641.1 deck8641.34 will8641.66 be,8641.9 virtually,8643.02 Robert8645.03 Okanowski.8647.27 I8647.51 never8647.67 have8648 to8648.15 say8648.23 his8648.4 last8648.64 name.8648.8 We8649.03 just8649.19 call8649.35 him8649.51 Bob8649.67 o.8650 Okay?8650.56 Chrissy,8651.83 thanks8652.15 for8652.48 joining8652.56 us8652.8 here8653.03 today.8653.19
8653.67 CHRISSY8653.67 LYNCH8653.67 -8653.67 MASSACHUSETTS8653.67 AFL-CIO8653.67 -8653.67 HB8653.67 788653.67 -8653.67 HB8653.67 868653.67 -8653.67 SB8653.67 1978653.67 -8653.67 Thank8653.67 you.8653.83 Good8654.4 afternoon.8654.64 Chair8655.67 Farley8656 Boubie,8656.31 Chair8656.8 Moore,8657.11 and8657.67 members8657.67 of8658.07 the8658.15 joint8658.31 committee,8658.56 thank8659.67 you8659.92 for8660.07 the8660.23 opportunity8660.4 to8660.95 testify8661.49 before8661.89 you8662.13 today8662.29 about8662.53 an8662.77 issue8662.93 threatening8663.17 workers8663.65 across8663.97 the8664.37 country:8664.53 data8665.41 privacy8665.73 in8666.29 the8666.45 context8666.61 of8667.09 rapidly8667.33 evolving8667.81 technology8668.37 that8668.85 knows8669.17 exactly8669.49 how8669.97 to8670.13 squeeze8670.29 the8670.69 most8670.85 possible8671.09 out8671.57 of8671.65 workers8671.89 and8672.69 consumers.8672.85 My8674.08 name8674.17 is8674.33 Christy8674.41 Lynch.8674.73 I'm8675.05 honored8675.13 to8675.44 be8675.52 the8675.68 president8675.76 of8676.08 the8676.25 Massachusetts8676.41 AFL-CIO,8677.6 representing8678.49 over8678.97 8008679.28 local8679.92 unions8680.33 and8680.65 nearly8680.89 half8681.13 a8681.36 million8681.44 members8681.76 from8682.56 all8682.81 sectors8683.05 of8683.36 work8683.52 across8683.76 the8684.17 state.8684.25 I8684.81 am8684.97 here8685.13 today8685.36 to8685.68 testify8685.84 in8686.33 strong8686.49 support8686.89 of8687.28 H8687.6 86,8688.33 S197,8689.6 the8690.21 Location8690.58 Shield8690.96 Act,8691.34 and8691.71 H8692.09 78,8692.47 the8693.22 Massachusetts8693.6 Consumer8693.97 Data8694.35 Privacy8694.73 Act.8695.1 Massachusetts8695.48 workers8695.86 are8696.23 being8696.61 tracked.8696.99 They8697.36 are8697.74 being8698.12 profiled.8698.49 And8698.87 their8699.25 most8699.62 sensitive8700 data8700.38 about8700.75 their8701.13 health,8701.51 their8701.89 finances,8702.26 and8702.64 their8702.64 physical8703.17 location8703.5 is8703.98 being8704.22 sold,8704.53 stored,8704.93 and8705.25 analyzed8705.42 without8706.06 their8706.38 meaningful8706.53 consent.8707.01 In8707.98 countless8708.22 workplaces,8708.69 surveillance8709.73 is8710.3 no8710.45 longer8710.61 limited8710.93 to8711.33 security8711.5 cameras.8711.98 It's8712.69 happening8712.85 through8713.25 wellness8713.5 platforms8713.98 that8714.38 monitor8714.61 health,8715.01 collect8717.4 keystroke8717.8 data,8718.44 and8719 shift8719.4 scheduling8719.72 tools8720.2 that8720.52 use8720.76 algorithms8721 to8721.56 score8721.8 employees.8722.12 Workers8723.4 are8723.8 rarely8724.04 informed8724.44 about8725.08 when8725.32 and8725.56 how8725.64 this8725.96 data8726.2 is8726.52 being8726.68 used8726.92 and8727.48 are8727.64 even8727.88 less8728.12 frequently8728.44 given8729.32 a8730.6 choice8731.33 about8731.35 whether8731.38 this8731.41 data8732.05 should8732.23 be8732.42 collected8732.6 at8732.69 all.8732.77
8733.2 This8733.2 bossware,8733.65 as8734.2 it's8734.44 known,8734.52 is8734.57 becoming8734.6 increasingly8735.08 pervasive,8735.65 and8736.36 it8736.6 has8736.69 a8736.77 chilling8736.85 effect8737.41 on8737.65 worker8737.89 organizing.8738.28 Despite8739.65 its8740.13 benefits8740.2 to8740.77 our8740.85 daily8741.01 lives,8741.41 personal8742.05 cell8742.52 phone8742.77 location8743.01 data8743.41 can8743.73 be8743.89 used8744.18 and8744.34 sold8744.5 to8744.66 the8744.82 detriment8745.06 of8745.46 many.8745.62 Every8746.42 day,8746.98 unregulated8746.98 data8747.78 brokers8748.02 buy8748.42 and8748.74 sell8748.9 personal8749.14 location8749.62 data8750.02 from8750.26 apps8750.5 and8750.74 our8750.82 cell8750.98 phones,8751.14 revealing8751.86 where8752.34 we8752.5 live,8752.74 work,8753.3 play,8753.78 worship,8754.26 and8754.66 seek8754.82 health8755.14 care.8755.38 This8756.19 is8756.27 a8756.44 major8756.6 concern8757.08 not8757.48 only8757.64 for8757.88 our8758.03 own8758.19 personal8758.44 privacy8758.83 but8759.56 for8759.8 the8759.95 privacy8760.11 of8760.52 our8760.67 families8760.83 when8761.24 they8761.48 access8761.64 essential8762.03 health8762.52 care.8763.64 These8764.35 invasive8764.6 practices8765.08 also8765.64 intimidate8765.95 workers8766.52 who8766.92 are8767.08 considering8767.16 taking8767.72 collective8768.03 action8768.52 or8769 whistleblowing8769.24 around8769.95 safety8770.19 concerns8770.6 in8771.08 their8771.24 jobs.8771.4 Imagine8772.8 a8773.12 corporation8773.28 buying8774.24 cell8774.8 phone8775.04 location8775.52 data8776 for8776.32 their8776.4 workers8776.64 in8777.12 order8777.36 to8777.68 determine8777.92 exactly8778.4 where8778.88 and8779.52 when8779.76 those8779.92 workers8780.16 are8780.56 meeting.8780.72 Without8782.96 strong8783.08 controls8783.2 on8783.32 the8783.44 sale8783.52 of8783.76 and8797.45 requirements8809.19 to8809.67 ensure8809.75 the8810.15 only8810.31 data8810.63 businesses8810.95 collect8810.96 is8810.96 what8810.97 is8810.98 necessary8810.99 to8810.99 do8811 the8811.01 job8811.01 of8811.02 their8811.02 business.8811.03 And8811.75 is8812 what8812.08 is8812.25 necessary8812.97 to8813.76 do8813.92 the8814.08 job8814.17 of8814.41 their8814.56 business,8814.65 and8815.6 strong8815.84 enforcement8816.17 provisions,8816.73 including8817.2 rule8817.6 making8817.84 and8818.25 enforcement8818.41 authority8818.97 for8819.6 the8819.84 AG8820 in8820.41 the8820.56 private8820.65 right8820.97 of8821.2 action8821.28 for8821.68 consumers.8821.92
8823.13 We've8823.13 seen8823.36 what8823.68 it8823.84 looks8824 like8824.25 to8824.49 have8824.56 big8824.81 tech8825.05 CEOs8825.36 sit8826 at8826.26 the8826.34 right8826.42 hand8826.85 of8827.28 the8827.72 president.8828.15 Tens8828.58 of8828.9 millions8829.06 of8829.38 Americans8829.54 have8830.02 had8830.26 their8830.42 sensitive8830.66 data8831.14 accessed8831.86 through8832.66 the8832.9 Doge8833.06 takeover.8833.38 Bad8834.58 actors8834.82 have8835.3 been8835.46 already8835.7 on8836.1 the8836.18 prowl8836.34 for8836.66 sensitive8836.82 data8837.22 for8837.54 years,8837.94 and8838.6 now8838.68 we8838.92 have8839.08 a8839.24 federal8839.4 government8839.8 willing8840.19 to8840.52 hand8840.6 it8840.75 over.8840.83 It8841.4 is8841.64 imperative8841.8 that8842.35 Massachusetts8842.52 acts8843.32 on8843.56 this.8843.8 We8844.83 are8845.08 poised8845.24 to8845.56 enact8845.72 comprehensive8846.11 data8846.68 privacy8847.08 protections8847.48 like8847.95 those8848.11 passed8848.35 in8848.6 Maryland.8848.75 We8849.48 need8849.64 to8849.8 strengthen8849.95 our8850.35 legal8850.52 framework8850.83 to8851.24 protect8851.4 workers8851.72 on8852.03 the8852.11 job8852.39 and8852.63 as8852.79 members8853.03 of8853.43 our8853.59 communities8853.75 where8854.15 our8854.39 workers8854.55 live.8854.95 Any8855.99 consumer8856.31 data8856.79 privacy8857.03 legislation8857.51 that8858.07 moves8858.23 forward8858.47 must8858.87 include8859.11 those8859.51 38859.67 provisions8859.91 in8860.63 order8860.79 to8861.03 protect8861.11 our8861.51 communities8861.67 from8862.23 the8862.39 exploitation8862.55 of8863.43 shady8863.67 corporations.8864.15 Additionally,8865.7 the8866.1 Massachusetts8866.34 AFL8866.98 CIO8867.31 strongly8867.78 opposes8868.18 the8868.58 industry-backed8869.15 proposals8869.39 to8870.02 so-called8871.86 regulate8872.1 this8872.83 privacy8872.98 data.8873.47 We8873.94 heard8874.1 today,8874.42 and8875.31 the8875.47 labor8875.63 movement8875.94 is8876.26 all8876.42 too8876.58 familiar8876.75 with8877.15 what8877.39 happens8877.55 when8877.94 corporations8878.18 are8878.83 left8878.98 to8879.15 regulate8879.31 themselves.8879.86 And8880.83 as8880.99 we've8881.23 heard8881.55 today,8881.79 the8882.99 big8883.31 tech8883.55 industry8883.79 tries8884.35 to8884.99 make8885.15 their8885.31 legislation8885.55 seem8886.27 like8886.43 a8886.67 good8886.75 thing.8886.99 But8887.95 in8888.11 reality,8888.27 it8888.67 is8888.83 window8888.99 dressing8889.39 that8889.79 leaves8890.03 consumers8890.27 and8890.83 working8891.07 people8891.39 vulnerable8891.87 to8892.35 exploitation.8893.52 Thank8894.24 you8894.48 for8894.73 your8894.89 time.8894.97 Thank8895.28 you8895.44 for8895.6 your8895.68 public8895.84 service.8896.24 Thank8896.97 you8897.13 for8897.28 your8897.44 dedication8897.6 to8898.16 ensuring8898.4 that8898.81 rapidly8899.05 evolving8899.76 technology8900.24 keeps8900.89 evolving,8901.2 that8901.92 our8902.08 state8902.32 is8902.56 keeping8902.65 up.8902.97 I'm8903.68 happy8903.84 to8904.08 answer8904.24 any8904.48 questions.8904.65
FARLEY-BOUVIER8906 -8906 Thank8906 you8906.24 so8906.48 much,8906.56 Christy.8906.88 I'm8907.12 gonna8907.36 first8907.6 turn8907.76 to8908 the8908.16 committee.8908.24 Representative.8910.72
8912.4 REP8912.4 LOMBARDO8912.4 -8912.4 Thank8912.4 you.8912.4 You8912.72 mentioned8912.88 companies8914.32 potentially8914.8 wanting8915.2 to8915.2 help8915.21 their8915.21 employees.8915.22 Were8915.23 there8915.23 any8915.24 examples8915.25 you8915.25 can8915.26 share8915.26 where8915.27 that8915.27 may8915.27 have8915.28 happened?8915.84
8921.53 LYNCH8921.53 -8921.53 Amazon.8921.53 You8922.58 know?8922.66 And8922.98 Amazon8923.53 does8924.42 hiring,8924.82 firing,8925.53 and8926.1 discipline8926.33 just8927.06 based8927.3 on8927.77 an8927.85 algorithm8928.02 that8929.22 has8929.45 bias8929.77 baked8930.25 right8930.58 into8930.82 it.8931.06 We8931.75 see8931.91 Amazon8932.23 tracking8932.79 workers8933.35 when8933.99 they8934.15 go8934.31 to8934.47 the8934.55 bathroom,8934.71 when8935.19 they8935.35 drive8935.51 their8935.83 cars,8935.99 and8936.63 when8936.63 they're8936.87 in8937.11 between8937.27 shifts.8937.67 So8939.03 that's8939.43 just8939.67 18939.91 example.8940.15
8941.03 LOMBARDO8941.03 -8941.03 And8941.03 you8941.19 mentioned8941.35 bias8941.67 built8941.99 in.8942.23 What8942.39 does8942.63 that8942.79 mean?8943.03
8944.39 LYNCH8944.39 -8944.39 The8944.39 algorithms8944.63 that8945.51 are8945.83 behind8946.15 a8946.71 lot8946.79 of8946.95 this8947.2 data8947.44 actually8947.92 are8948.49 put8949.05 together8949.28 through8949.84 equations8950.73 that,8951.36 you8951.76 know,8952 for8952.41 example,8952.65 we'll8953.05 use8953.2 Amazon8953.52 as8954.25 another8954.49 example.8954.81 Some8957.68 of8957.92 the8958.08 applications8958.49 that8959.44 Amazon8959.68 was8960.33 getting8960.49 automatically8961.21 were8961.61 screening8961.93 women8962.25 out.8962.49 I8964.73 would8964.89 use8965.05 that8965.29 as8965.45 an8965.61 example8965.69 of8966.33 bias.8966.57
8968.01 SPEAKER328968.01 -8968.01 Thank8968.01 you.8968.25
FARLEY-BOUVIER8969.37 -8969.37 Anything8969.37 else?8969.77 Is8970.65 anybody8971.05 else8971.05 over8971.29 here8971.53 on8972.09 this8972.33 side?8972.57 Thank8973.93 you8974.25 so8974.41 much.8974.57
8974.97 SPEAKER58974.97 -8974.97 Thank8974.97 you8975.13 very8975.21 much.8975.45
FARLEY-BOUVIER8975.69 -8975.69 Thank8975.69 you8975.81 for8975.93 your8976.01 service.8976.09 Good8976.2 to8976.48 get8976.64 the8976.8 perspective8976.95 of8977.44 the8977.52 worker.8977.6 Okay.8980.16 Bob8980.88 O,8981.19 are8981.44 you8981.6 online?8981.83 And8982.4 then8982.56 we8982.8 have8983.03 Alexander8984 Matthews8985.68 from8986.48 Digital8986.8 Force,8987.19 who8988.4 will8988.4 be8988.72 next.8989.76 Thanks8990.48 so8990.72 much,8990.88 much,8991.06 Bob.8991.22
ROBERT8992.5 O'KONIEWSKI8992.5 -8992.5 MSADA8992.5 -8992.5 (8992.5 R8992.5 )8992.5 -8992.5 Anytime.8992.5 Well,8993.06 thank8993.3 you.8993.46 I8994.18 appreciate8994.34 the8994.74 graciousness8994.9 that8995.54 you've8995.7 played8996.9 out8997.22 there8997.3 today.8997.54 And9002.02 met9002.74 Senator9002.74 Chairman9002.74 Moore,9002.74 through9003.46 to9003.86 the9003.94 members.9004.1 Bob9004.9 Okaneski,9005.22 the9006.58 Polish9006.83 guy,9007.23 executive9008.34 vice9008.83 president9009.06 and9009.47 general9009.55 counsel9009.78 for9010.1 the9010.26 Massachusetts9010.34 State9010.9 Auto9011.15 Dealers9011.39 Association.9011.86 We9012.98 represent9013.23 the9013.7 4279013.86 franchise9015.86 car9016.5 and9016.67 truck9016.83 dealers9017.06 across9017.47 the9017.78 Commonwealth.9017.86 We9019.25 have9019.41 over9019.57 25,0009019.89 employees9020.85 at9021.49 our9021.73 dealerships.9021.89 We're9022.93 approximately9023.65 20%9024.13 of9024.77 the9024.93 retail9025.01 economy9025.41 in9025.81 Massachusetts.9026.05 We9027.73 sell,9027.97 right9028.85 around9029.09 300,0009029.41 new9030.29 cars9030.53 per9030.93 year9031.09 and9031.89 an9032.13 equal9032.37 number9032.69 of9032.85 used9033.09 cars9033.33 per9033.73 year,9033.89 give9034.13 or9034.37 take,9034.53 up9034.99 or9035.07 down9035.15 20,0009035.39 a9036.1 year.9036.19 So9037.47 our9037.78 economic9038.1 activity9038.67 is9039.23 very9040.58 well9040.91 founded.9041.63 We9042.67 also,9042.91 as9043.78 part9044.02 of9044.19 our9044.35 dealerships,9044.58 service9045.39 and9045.94 repair,9046.1 diagnose9046.67 and9047.07 repair9047.23 vehicles9047.7 on9048.19 behalf9048.35 of9048.58 the9048.75 consumers.9048.83 So9049.83 you9049.99 can9050.07 imagine9050.23 that9050.55 there's9050.79 quite9051.19 a9051.43 bit9051.51 of9051.83 information9051.91 that9052.63 dealerships9052.87 take9053.59 in9053.75 as9054.95 it9055.11 relates9055.27 to9055.75 selling9056.47 or9056.87 leasing9056.95 a9057.27 vehicle9057.35 to9057.75 a9057.91 consumer,9058.07 repairing9058.87 a9059.27 vehicle,9059.43 and9061.59 arranging9061.59 financing9062.15 for9062.95 a9063.11 consumer9063.19 if9063.67 they9063.83 need9063.99 it.9064.15 And9064.87 it's9065.22 a9065.38 very9065.45 heavily9065.93 regulated9066.33 industry,9067.3 whether9067.77 we're9068.17 talking,9068.33 federal9069.14 law,9069.45 state9070.5 law,9071.06 or9071.14 regulations.9071.14 We9072.81 do9073.06 a9073.22 lot9073.3 with9073.61 the9073.77 association9074.01 for9074.9 our9075.14 dealers9075.3 in9075.69 terms9075.85 of9076.09 webinars,9076.25 compliance9077.92 materials,9078.4 and9079.92 meetings9081.28 to9081.28 try9081.52 to9081.76 make9081.84 sure9082 that9082.24 they9082.4 are9082.56 in9082.72 compliance9082.8 with9083.52 everything9084.64 from9085.6 advertising9086 laws9086.72 to9087.44 data9088.08 protection.9088.4
9089.68 The9089.68 commitment9089.84 from9090.24 the9090.4 dealership,9090.48 dealership,9092.88 industry9094.47 is9094.86 very9095.18 well,9095.42 founded,9096.63 well9097.67 written9097.98 about.9098.23 There's9099.02 a9099.26 lot9099.34 that9099.58 we9099.83 go9099.98 through.9100.23 Chairwoman,9101.02 you9101.9 had9102.06 mentioned9102.23 the9102.63 Gramm9102.7 Leach9102.94 Biley9103.26 Act.9103.9 Yes.9105.42 It's9105.83 over9106.47 259106.71 years9107.27 old,9107.51 but9108.15 it9108.31 is9108.79 also9108.95 a9108.95 very9109.11 fluid9109.67 law9109.91 in9110.15 the9110.39 sense9110.47 that9110.71 it9111.59 is9111.83 subject9111.99 to9112.47 change.9112.55 The9113.27 dealers9113.43 just9113.83 went9114.07 through9114.31 a9115.11 major9115.27 re-up9115.91 of9116.23 compliance9116.79 through9117.51 the9120.56 Gramlich9121.01 Viola9121.24 in9122.19 terms9122.35 of9124.27 the9125.24 rules9125.24 that9125.64 were9125.8 kicked9126.03 in9126.27 in9126.44 June9126.6 '23,9127.32 which9128.03 we9128.27 talked9128.52 about9128.75 at9129.16 the9129.8 last9129.95 hearing.9130.27 So9131.56 we9133.56 don't9133.72 come9133.95 here9134.19 as9134.44 necessarily9134.6 an9134.99 opponent.9135.15 We9136.35 think9136.59 that9137.39 there9137.71 are9137.71 some9137.71 things9137.87 that9138.11 could9138.27 be9138.43 done9138.59 better9139.15 in9140.03 terms9140.19 of9140.51 our9141.07 industry9141.31 to9141.95 clarify9142.11 some9142.59 of9142.75 the9142.83 language.9142.99 If9145.15 you9145.39 we've9145.79 asked9146.19 for9146.51 in9146.83 the9146.91 past9147.07 because9148.99 of9149.39 our,9149.99 the9150.55 heavily9150.78 regulated9151.43 aspects9152.07 of9152.55 the9152.7 business9152.86 in9153.19 all9153.43 realms.9153.67 And9154.1 we've9156.15 offered9156.47 up9156.78 amendments9157.1 to9157.58 that9157.67 effect9157.91 as9158.23 well9158.39 as9158.63 tweaked9159.27 some9159.35 of9159.43 the9159.5 language9159.67 on9160.23 the9161.75 data9161.91 and9162.31 information9162.47 carve-out9163.27 that9163.43 the9163.67 bills9163.83 have.9164.15
9164.91 So9164.91 it's,9165.07 you9165.63 know,9165.71 we9165.79 view9166.03 the9166.27 bills9166.43 as,9166.91 we9169.31 like9169.55 to9169.71 sit9169.79 down9169.95 and9170.27 talk9170.43 about9170.67 where9171.23 some9171.63 of9171.79 this9171.95 is9172.19 going9172.35 in9173.31 terms9173.55 of9173.87 how9174.11 we9174.27 can9174.43 play9174.59 a9174.83 better9175.07 role9175.31 in9176.03 helping9176.27 you9176.67 all9176.91 understand9177.23 where9177.87 we're9178.11 at,9178.35 both9179.19 within9179.51 the9179.83 federal9180 scheme9180.4 of9180.64 things9180.8 and9181.11 the9181.43 state9181.51 scheme9181.83 of9182.08 things.9182.24 And9182.88 I9183.03 would9183.11 just9183.27 finish9183.43 up9183.83 by9184 saying,9184.16 you9185.11 know,9185.27 we're9185.51 all9185.75 consumers9186 as9186.56 well.9186.64 So,9187.51 you9188.64 know,9188.8 none9189.11 of9189.35 us9189.51 on9189.83 the9190 dealer9190.16 side9190.56 are9190.88 interested9191.11 in9191.51 engaging9191.75 in9192.08 behavior9192.24 that9193.51 would9193.83 put9194.08 a9194.32 consumer9196.05 in9196.61 a9196.85 bad9197.01 position9197.33 in9198.69 relation9198.93 to9199.41 data9200.37 and9201.33 information.9201.57 So9202.29 we9203.25 go9203.41 through9203.57 a9203.81 lot9203.89 of9204.05 activities9204.69 and9205.25 compliance9205.81 efforts9206.21 at9206.61 the9206.77 dealerships9206.85 to9207.49 protect9207.57 that9207.97 data9208.93 and9209.17 information9209.33 moving9209.89 forward.9210.21 And9210.61 I9210.91 know9211.07 my9211.31 time9211.47 is9211.7 up,9211.86 but9212.02 I9212.27 would9212.34 just,9212.42 you9212.67 know,9212.83 circle9213.07 back9213.39 on9213.63 19213.78 other9213.94 issue9214.19 that9214.42 came9214.67 up9214.91 a9215.07 couple9215.15 of9215.39 years9215.39 ago,9215.63 which9216.75 is9216.75 the9216.91 right9216.99 to9217.15 repair9217.31 litigation.9217.63 The9219.07 federal9219.39 district9219.7 court9220.02 came9220.42 up9220.58 with9220.83 a9221.07 decision9221.63 in9222.42 February9222.67 of9223.15 this9223.23 year9223.39 to9224.42 dismiss9224.58 the9224.69 manufacturer's9224.78 lawsuit9224.89 on9224.99 the9225.24 right-to-repair9227.58 amendments.9227.82 The9228.78 manufacturers9229.26 in,9230.46 March,9231.74 filed9233.1 a9233.42 notice9234.22 of9234.54 appeal9234.7 on9235.1 that.9235.18 So,9235.98 although9236.22 the9237.66 right-to-repair9238.78 folks9239.18 court9243.4 side,9243.72 there's9244.27 still9244.52 gonna9244.68 be9244.92 an9245 appeal9245.16 process.9245.48 And9245.8 as9246.03 you9246.19 know,9246.27 there's9246.52 that9246.83 type9247 of9247.16 information9247.4 that's9247.88 in9248.68 the9248.83 vehicle9249 that's9249.48 been9249.72 the9250.19 subject9250.27 of9250.6 some9250.75 controversy9251 as9251.64 that9251.95 plays9252.27 its9252.6 way9252.75 through9253 the9253.16 court.9253.24 I9254.52 appreciate9254.6 your9255.08 time9255.24 today.9255.32 Thank9255.72 you9255.88 very9255.96 much9256.12 for9256.2 coming9256.36 in.9256.68
9257.4 FARLEY-BOUVIER9257.4 -9257.4 Sure.9257.4 Thank9257.8 you9258.04 so9258.28 much,9258.44 Bob.9258.68 Anybody9259 on9259.32 the9259.48 committee?9259.64 Thanks,9261.08 Bob.9261.48 We're9262.04 moving9262.28 on9262.6 now9262.84 to9263.08 Alex9263.64 Ames.9263.88 Oh,9264.52 I'm9264.6 so9264.84 sorry.9265 Who9265.56 did9265.72 I9265.88 miss?9266.04 Oh,9266.92 representative9267.48 Gasky.9268.12 I'm9268.44 sorry.9268.67 I9268.75 didn't9268.83 see9268.99 you9269.07 down9269.15 there.9271.47 He's9271.7 still9271.94 with9272.1 us,9272.34 Bob?9272.5 There9272.99 he9273.15 is.9273.31
9273.63 O'KONIEWSKI9273.63 -9273.63 Of9273.63 course.9273.7 Okay.9274.18
REP9275.86 GASKEY9275.86 -9275.86 Yes,9275.86 sir.9276.1 What9279.07 type9279.23 of9279.55 data9280.02 anonymization9280.42 do9281.23 you9281.31 guys9281.47 do9282.72 with9282.88 regard9283.12 to,9283.44 customer9284.16 data9284.8 that9286.56 you9286.8 collect?9286.96
9287.36 O'KONIEWSKI9287.36 -9287.36 Do9287.36 you9287.44 have9287.52 some9287.6 more9287.84 specific9288.08 in9288.48 mind?9288.56 Dealers9289.12 are9289.52 not9289.68 in9290.88 the9291.04 business9291.12 of9291.52 selling9291.68 data.9292 The9294.56 data9294.72 that9295.12 or9295.36 information9295.52 that9295.67 vehicle,9297.9 there's9299.18 warranty9299.5 issues,9299.98 there's9300.3 recall9300.61 issues,9301.02 there's9301.5 service9301.74 issues,9302.14 there's,9303.42 information9305.02 that9305.58 we9305.74 collect9305.9 on9306.53 behalf9306.61 of9307.02 the9307.1 registry9307.26 of9307.74 motor9307.82 vehicles9308.14 on9309.02 transactions.9309.26 You9311.91 know,9312.07 so9312.31 there9312.79 the9313.11 dealers9313.27 are9313.67 not9313.83 in9313.99 the9314.15 business,9314.31 it's9315.11 not9315.27 part9315.35 of9315.59 their9315.75 business9315.91 model9316.23 to9316.63 be9316.79 collecting9317.43 and9317.83 selling9317.99 data.9318.31 There's9318.55 a9318.87 number9318.95 of9319.19 forms9319.35 that9319.75 dealers9319.99 also9320.39 proffer9321.03 to9321.35 the9321.51 consumer9321.67 that9323.59 explain9324.92 what9324.92 dealerships9325.07 are9325.64 going9325.72 through9325.95 in9326.27 terms9326.35 of9328.51 compliance9328.67 matters9329.23 as9329.72 it9329.95 relates9330.03 to9330.51 information.9330.59 And,9332.11 again,9332.27 I'm9332.51 speaking9332.59 of9332.92 the9332.99 franchise9333.15 dealers.9333.72 I9335.56 don't9335.64 represent9335.8 the9337.15 used9337.4 car9337.64 guys9337.95 at9338.19 all.9338.35
9341 GASKEY9341 -9341 So,9341 along9341.88 those9342.2 lines,9342.44 when9342.76 a9343.08 vehicle9343.56 comes9343.96 in9344.2 for9344.36 service,9344.52 how9347.88 much9348.12 data9348.36 do9348.68 you9348.76 collect,9349.48 and9350.52 where9350.52 is9350.84 that9352.12 data9352.36 reported9352.68 to?9353.14 Like,9353.53 do9353.85 you9354.09 report9355.85 information9356.9 directly9356.9 to9357.3 insurance9357.53 companies9358.01 or9359.14 anything9359.3 else9359.61 like9359.85 that?9360.01
9362.09 O'KONIEWSKI9362.09 -9362.09 Well,9362.09 in9362.33 terms9362.42 of9362.73 it9362.98 for,9363.22 for9363.77 a9363.93 vehicle.9364.09 So,9364.5 let's9364.65 say9364.98 you9366.04 go9366.2 into9366.36 a9366.68 dealership9366.84 to9367.56 get9367.72 service.9367.96 So9368.68 they9368.84 will9369 have,9369.32 they9370.68 will9370.84 collect9372.04 and9373 retain9373.24 the9373.64 information9373.8 for9374.76 that9374.92 vehicle9375.16 and9375.8 for9376.04 who9376.28 the9376.44 owner9376.6 of9376.92 that9377 vehicle9377.16 is.9377.56 I9382.57 don't9382.73 know9382.89 if9382.97 you've9383.13 gone9383.36 through9383.69 a9384 dealership9385.13 in9385.69 terms9385.85 of9386.25 getting9386.41 reminders9387.69 as9388.81 to9389.05 service9389.52 on9391.28 that9391.44 vehicle.9391.6 If9392.81 there9392.97 are9393.2 warranty9393.2 issues9393.69 or9394 recall9394.17 issues,9394.57 there's9395.52 a9395.84 flow9396 of9396.24 information9396.4 that9397.12 goes9397.36 from9397.68 the9398.24 manufacturers9398.48 and9399.2 the9399.36 feds,9399.52 through9400.96 to9401.36 the9401.52 consumer9401.84 directly9402.32 on9403.28 a9404.16 recall.9404.24 If9406.24 it's9406.4 a9406.64 recall,9406.8 you9408.44 know,9408.6 obviously,9408.84 the9409.25 car9409.65 owner9409.89 can9410.13 go9410.28 anywhere9410.44 that's9411.33 a9411.57 dealer9412.13 for9412.52 that9412.68 line9412.92 make9413.17 to9413.73 get9413.89 that9414.13 addressed.9414.44 So,9416.13 there9416.36 is9416.52 a9416.68 lot9416.76 of9416.92 information9417.08 that9417.57 flows9417.81 back9418.13 and9418.28 forth.9418.44 The,9420.6 you9422.25 know,9422.49 19422.65 of9422.81 the9422.97 concerns9423.13 that9423.61 we9423.77 have9423.93 that9424.17 we9424.33 bring9424.49 up9424.73 is,9425.53 some9426.73 of9426.89 the9427.05 bills,9427.21 have9428.73 talked9429.05 talked9429.37 about9429.53 the,9430.09 deletion9431.05 of9431.85 information.9432.01 And9432.97 what9433.21 we've9433.37 pointed9433.61 out9434.01 that9434.17 if9434.58 a9434.67 consumer,9434.91 deletes,9436.34 that9437.31 type9437.55 of9437.7 information9437.94 once9438.99 the9439.23 service9439.39 is9439.78 done9439.86 at9440.1 the9440.18 dealership,9440.34 it9440.75 makes9440.91 it9441.15 very9441.23 difficult9441.55 then9442.02 for,9442.34 a9444.42 dealer9444.67 in9445.06 that9445.23 line9445.55 make,9445.86 to9447.41 keep9448.05 track9448.37 of9448.69 that9448.85 vehicle,9449.09 for9450.21 that9450.45 consumer9450.69 or9451.73 that9451.89 car9452.13 owner,9452.37 if9452.69 you9452.85 will.9452.93 So,9453.41 if9454.77 you9455.01 are,9455.17 let's9455.57 say,9455.89 a9456.21 Ford9456.45 owner,9456.77 you9457.25 can9457.41 go9457.57 to9457.73 any9457.81 Ford9458.05 dealership9459.4 to9459.65 have9459.89 that9460.13 warranty9460.52 or9461 recall9461.17 addressed.9461.65 If9462.52 the9463.08 information9463.24 is9463.97 deleted9464.68 by9465.32 a9465.56 consumer9465.73 car9466.28 owner,9466.52 it9467.65 would9467.81 make9467.97 it9468.2 difficult9468.36 for9468.92 the9470.28 manufacturer9470.52 and,9471.81 hence,9471.97 a9472.52 dealer9472.6 in9473 the9473.08 dealer9473.24 network9473.65 to9474.82 address9475.38 a9475.86 problem9476.02 that9476.34 may9476.5 come9476.74 up9476.9 with9477.06 that9477.14 vehicle.9477.38 Does9480.34 that9480.58 answer9480.66 your9480.98 what9481.14 you're9481.3 looking9481.46 for?9481.7
9483.7 GASKEY9483.7 -9483.7 A9483.7 little9483.78 bit.9484.02
9486.18 O'KONIEWSKI9486.18 -9486.18 What9486.18 am9486.66 I9486.74 leaving9486.82 out?9487.14 Because9487.62 I9487.86 don't9487.94 want9488.34 you9488.5 feeling,9488.74 you9489.67 know,9489.75 unanswered.9490.39
9491.02 GASKEY9491.02 -9491.02 Yeah.9491.02 I9491.27 well,9491.59 I'm9491.91 not9492.07 sure9492.23 that9492.39 you9492.55 I'm9492.7 not9492.94 sure9493.1 that9493.27 you9493.35 would9493.51 be9493.67 able9493.83 to9494.07 answer9494.39 my9494.63 question.9494.78 I'm9495.19 not9495.35 sure9495.51 that9495.67 I9495.91 have9495.99 my9496.15 question9496.31 formed9496.63 exactly9497.02 the9497.43 way9497.51 it9497.67 needs9497.83 to9498.07 be9498.15 formed,9498.31 but9499.83 I'm9500.55 okay9500.7 with9501.02 everything9501.19 right9501.67 now.9501.83 Thanks.9502.07
9502.78 SPEAKER19502.78 -9502.78 Thank9502.78 you,9503.02 representative.9503.27
O'KONIEWSKI9503.99 -9503.99 But9503.99 I9504.23 would9504.31 just9504.47 representative.9505.24 I9505.4 would9505.56 just9505.8 offer9506.04 up9506.28 that9506.52 there9506.68 if9506.92 there9507.08 a,9507.48 you9507.56 know,9507.72 further9507.88 issues9508.2 you9508.52 wanna9508.6 do9509.08 a9509.24 deeper9509.32 dive9509.64 on,9509.8 I'd9510.04 be9510.12 more9510.28 than9510.44 happy.9510.6 We9511.24 can9511.4 meet9511.56 at9511.72 a9511.96 dealership,9512.04 and9512.6 we9512.84 can9513 walk9513.72 through9513.96 those9514.2 types9514.44 of9515.96 scenarios9517.5 to9517.5 get9517.58 a9517.73 better9517.9 sense9518.22 of9518.45 just9518.69 what's9518.93 going9519.25 on9519.5 at9519.73 the9519.98 dealer9520.14 level.9520.45
GASKY9521.42 -9521.42 Okay.9521.42 That9521.9 sounds9523.65 good9524.69 because9526.14 the9526.61 amount9526.85 of9527.17 information9527.33 that9527.81 is9527.98 collected9528.22 by9528.61 vehicles9528.85 these9529.33 days9529.5 is9529.98 astonishing9530.53 when9531.09 you9531.25 actually9531.42 dig9531.73 deep9532.57 into9532.65 it.9533.37 And,9533.69 it9535.61 does,9535.85 at9536.73 higher9536.89 levels,9537.53 get9539.29 a9539.29 lot9539.37 of9539.53 data9539.61 transferred9540.17 over9540.65 to9540.81 insurance9540.97 companies,9541.45 and,9542.81 affects9543.61 pricing9545.29 in9545.85 different9546.97 areas9547.37 of9547.69 the9547.77 country.9548.43 So9548.91
9549.07 O'KONIEWSKI9549.07 -9549.07 Well,9549.07 you9549.15 know,9549.23 I'm9549.31 glad9549.47 you9549.7 brought9549.78 that9550.02 up.9550.27 I'm9550.67 glad9550.83 you9551.07 brought9551.23 that9551.47 up9551.63 because9551.78 the9552.27 chairwoman9552.35 was9553.7 very9553.94 active9554.75 on9555.07 this9555.23 matter9555.47 a9556.51 couple9556.58 of9556.83 years9556.83 back.9557.07 There9558.83 is9559.07 a9559.23 lot9559.31 of9559.47 information9559.55 that9559.94 is9560.1 collected9560.27 in9560.67 the9560.83 vehicle9560.91 that9561.23 has9561.39 nothing9561.55 to9561.86 do9562.02 with9562.1 the9562.27 dealers.9562.35 And,9563.82 you9564.22 know,9564.38 19564.54 of9564.78 the9564.94 things9565.02 that,9565.34 happens9566.14 on9567.02 the9567.18 insurance9567.34 side,9567.82 if9568.38 I9568.62 recollect9568.78 correctly,9569.26 from9570.06 what9570.3 I've9570.46 been9570.62 told,9570.78 is9571.02 that9571.18 if9571.74 there9571.9 is9572.06 an9572.22 accident9572.38 or9572.86 or9573.18 some9573.5 sort9573.74 of9573.98 reporting9574.3 that,9575.6 a9576.16 consumer9576.4 or9576.88 car9576.95 owner9577.19 needs9577.44 their9577.76 vehicle9578.08 addressed,9578.48 the9579.44 insurance9579.6 companies9580 out9580.4 there9580.56 downloading9581.03 data9581.52 out9581.84 of9582 the,9582.08 out9582.72 of9582.8 the9582.95 black9583.27 box9583.52 and9583.84 other9584.08 mechanisms9584.48 in9585.03 the9585.19 vehicle.9585.35 So9586.4 they9586.64 are9586.8 getting9586.95 extensive9588.08 data9588.64 on9589.52 vehicles9589.76 that9591.09 is,9591.41 separate9593.41 of9594.05 what9594.21 a9594.45 dealer9594.61 may9595.01 need9595.25 information9595.49 for,9596.13 to9597.49 address9598.21 a9598.53 consumer9598.69 issue.9599.17 And9601.17 it9601.41 goes9601.49 for9601.65 the9601.89 same9601.97 goes9602.13 for9602.29 the9602.45 manufacturers.9602.61 That's9603.49 19603.73 of9603.89 the9604.05 disputes9604.21 that,9604.77 that,9606.09 the9606.73 manufacturers9606.98 are9607.61 in9607.77 with9608.01 the9609.45 aftermarket9609.69 folks9610.33 and9610.65 the9610.81 right9610.98 to9611.14 repair9611.22 folks9611.61 is9611.93 just9612.17 what9612.57 information9612.81 is9613.53 in9613.77 the9613.93 vehicle9614.01 that's9615.14 personal,9615.61 that9616.98 is9617.22 sensitive,9617.38 that,9618.56 may9619.28 not9619.44 have9619.68 anything9619.84 to9620.32 do9620.4 with9620.72 the9621.84 diagnostic9622 and9622.72 repair9622.96 activities9623.36 at9623.84 a9624.08 dealership,9624.24 which9625.28 the9625.76 independent9625.92 repairers9626.4 are9627.44 are,9627.76 have9629.68 access9630 to9630.32 under9631.12 the,9631.52 the9632.52 right9632.6 to9632.84 repair9632.92 laws9633.33 that9634.05 have9634.2 been9634.44 passed9634.52 in9634.84 the9634.92 commonwealth.9635.08
9635.97 FARLEY-BOUVIER-9635.97 Okay.9635.97 Thank9636.52 you.9636.76 And9636.92 in9637.08 the9637.41 interest9637.48 of9637.81 time,9637.89 I'm9638.13 gonna9638.28 let9638.68 the9639 representative9639.17 and9639.73 you9639.89 take9640.05 this9640.52 offline.9641 We9642.13 still9642.28 have9642.52 several9642.84 more9643.17 people9643.41 to9643.97 get9644.13 through9644.36 today,9644.52 several9644.92 dozen.9645.33
9645.81 O'KONIEWSK9645.81 -9645.81 Thank9645.81 you,9646.2 madam9646.36 chair.9646.76 Appreciate9647 it.9647.65
9647.81 FARLEY-BOUVIER9647.81 -9647.81 Great.9647.81 We're9647.97 gonna9648.29 now9648.53 move9648.69 to9649.01 Alexander9649.41 Matthews,9650.05 and9651.09 then9651.33 on9651.57 deck,9651.81 Doctor,9652.13 Nick9653.17 Dadek.9654.05 Thanks9655.97 for9656.37 being9656.45 here.9656.77
MATTHEW9660.99 ALEXANDER9660.99 -9660.99 ACLU9660.99 -9660.99 Chair9660.99 Farley-Bouvier,9662.43 Chair9662.83 Moore,9662.83 and9663.23 members9663.39 of9663.7 the9663.86 committee,9663.94 thank9664.43 you9664.59 for9664.83 the9664.99 opportunity9665.15 to9665.78 talk9665.94 to9666.19 you9666.27 today.9666.43 I9667.63 am9667.78 the9668.02 co-chair9668.51 of9668.91 the9669.23 volunteer9669.23 civil9669.94 liberties9670.27 organization9671.23 Digital9671.94 Force.9672.51 I9673.56 and9673.8 my9674.04 colleagues9674.44 who9675 are9675.24 all9675.32 testifying9675.56 here9676.2 today,9676.44 Julie,9677.08 Tasha,9677.56 Alex,9678.2 and9678.6 Karen,9678.76 we're9679.56 not9679.8 here9680.12 because9680.44 we're9680.76 paid9681.08 by9681.64 big9681.96 law9682.28 or9683.08 by9683.32 big9683.72 privacy9684.12 or9685 by9685.24 George9685.48 Soros9685.88 or9686.36 anyone9686.52 else.9686.92 We9688.77 are9689.17 here9689.5 because9690.14 we're9690.45 worried.9690.77 We're9691.66 not9691.98 in9692.45 control9693.33 of9694.14 our9694.3 data,9694.53 and9695.42 we9695.73 need9695.9 your9696.06 help.9696.3 I'd9698.3 like9698.53 to9698.77 speak9698.93 briefly9699.17 regarding9700.14 the9700.69 testimony9700.85 of9701.82 Mr.9701.98 Kingman9702.38 of9702.78 the9702.94 State9703.1 Privacy9703.42 and9703.9 Security9704.06 Coalition.9704.78 There's9706.14 a9706.38 political9706.54 article9707.42 just9708.14 about9708.46 him,9708.78 and9709.74 about9710.22 the9710.7 activities9710.94 of9711.66 his9711.74 coalition9711.98 and9712.46 how9712.62 he9712.86 goes9712.94 from9713.26 state9713.5 to9713.74 state,9713.9 putting9715.89 out9716.13 the9716.28 same9716.44 talking9716.77 points9717.17 to9717.49 a9717.65 range9717.81 of9718.05 small9718.28 businesses9718.6 who9719.81 then9720.05 communicate9720.69 with9721.25 representatives9721.57 and9722.36 with9722.52 governors.9722.77 and9725 give9725.73 the9726.05 impression9726.2 that9727.25 there9727.49 is9727.73 broad-based9728.36 opposition9728.69 to9729.41 strong9729.73 privacy9730.13 bills.9730.69 He9731.49 doesn't9731.73 find9732.13 grassroots9732.77 opposition9733.49 to9734.05 privacy9734.21 bills.9734.69 He9735.33 astroturfs9735.81 it.9736.53
9739.09 HP9739.09 80,9739.65 which9740.13 he9740.37 supports,9740.61 is9741.25 not9741.49 consistent9741.73 with9742.29 GDPR's9742.53 opt-out9743.65 approach9743.97 to9744.53 privacy.9744.61 Mister9745.98 Kingman9746.3 and9746.77 TechNet9747.02 and9747.5 others9747.66 take9748.45 a9748.69 race9748.77 to9749.1 the9749.33 bottom,9749.42 where9750.22 consumers9750.53 will9751.42 continue9751.58 to9752.22 be9752.38 unable9752.53 to9752.94 control9753.1 their9753.42 data.9753.66 A9755.1 private9755.26 right9755.66 of9755.9 action9755.98 is9756.45 not9756.61 for9756.77 the9757.02 fun9757.1 of9757.33 it.9757.5 I'm9758.06 not9758.3 gonna9758.45 make9758.77 a9759.02 dime9759.1 from9759.42 it.9759.58 Only9760.35 a9760.75 meaningful9761.07 threat9761.71 of9761.95 litigation9762.11 holds9763.15 corporations9763.55 accountable9764.35 for9765.07 whatever9765.39 other9765.79 rules9766.19 you9766.83 wanna9766.99 pass.9767.31 The9768.11 AG's9768.35 office9768.75 already9769.55 doesn't9770.11 intervene9770.43 in9770.99 half9771.15 of9771.39 the9771.55 responsibilities9771.79 it9772.67 already9772.75 has,9773.07 recent9780.85 abduction9781.25 by9782.14 ICE9782.45 of9782.85 Rumeza9783.17 Ozturk,9783.81 the9785.01 trust9785.42 grad9785.9 student9786.22 who9786.61 wrote9786.77 a9787.01 pro9787.17 divestment9787.5 op9788.14 ed.9788.38 To9789.23 pick9789.39 her9789.55 up,9789.63 I9790.03 didn't9790.27 go9790.59 to9790.75 her9790.99 apartment9791.47 or9792.35 to9792.59 a9792.75 PhD9792.99 seminar.9793.55 No.9794.51 They9794.99 picked9795.23 her9795.47 up9795.63 on9795.95 the9796.19 street9796.35 and9797.15 likely9797.39 used9798.03 her9798.51 location9798.83 data9799.47 to9799.79 do9799.95 it.9800.11 They9800.75 probably9800.99 bought9801.71 it9801.95 from9802.11 a9802.35 data9802.51 broker,9802.75 maybe9803.47 even9805.09 a9805.33 data9805.42 broker9805.81 represented9806.38 by9807.01 19807.17 of9807.42 the9807.58 industry9807.65 spokespeople9808.3 who9808.77 have9808.93 testified9809.09 today.9809.65 In9811.17 her9811.33 name,9811.58 in9812.3 these9812.53 discussions,9812.93 you9813.81 could9813.98 ask9814.22 whether9814.53 any9814.85 of9815.09 the9815.25 corporations9815.42 represented9816.14 by9816.61 lobbyists9817.05 here9817.29 today9818.25 sell9818.49 location9818.97 data9819.69 to9820.25 ICE9820.49 and9821.05 facilitate9821.37 what9822.49 the9822.81 Trump9822.89 administration9823.21 is9824.01 trying9824.17 to9824.41 do.9824.49 It9825.29 is9825.45 dangerous9825.69 to9826.65 allow9826.81 a9827.13 free-for-all.9827.77 We9828.49 support9828.73 strong9829.37 and9829.77 broad9830.33 privacy9830.57 protections,9831.28 such9832.33 as9832.65 those9832.81 in9833.05 the9833.28 bills9833.36 the9833.68 chairs9833.84 have9834.17 proposed,9834.33 including9835.13 a9836.08 private9836.25 right9836.65 of9836.89 action9836.97 and9837.52 appropriate9837.84 thresholds9838.57 to9839.36 protect9839.52 small9840.08 businesses9840.41 in9840.97 our9841.13 towns9841.36 and9841.6 cities.9841.84 Thank9842.77 you.9842.85
9843.41 FARLEY-BOUVIER9843.41 -9843.41 Thank9843.41 you.9843.57 Appreciate9843.89 you9844.37 being9844.53 here.9844.77 Can9845.09 we9845.25 bring9845.41 up9845.57 Doctor9846.53 Adenekan9847.09 Dedeke,9847.09 please?9847.09 And9847.73 then,9847.97 on9848.29 deck9848.45 is9848.93 Nancy9849.33 Brombeck.9849.81
9862.16 ADENEKAN9862.16 DEDEKE9862.16 -9862.16 NORTHEASTERN9862.16 UNIVERSITY9862.16 -9862.16 SB9862.16 459862.16 -9862.16 Chair9862.16 Moore,9862.56 Chair9863.03 Fraley9863.35 Bavier,9863.75 and9864.95 distinguished9864.95 members9865.44 of9865.92 the9866.08 Joint9866.48 Committee9866.95 on9866.95 Advanced9868.24 Information9869.03 Technology,9869.03 the9869.03 Internet,9869.19 and9869.59 cybersecurity,9869.83 Thank9871.35 you9871.51 for9871.83 the9871.99 opportunity9872.15 to9872.71 testify9873.11 this9873.51 afternoon9873.75 on9874.23 bill9874.39 45,9874.79 an9875.83 act9876.07 to9876.31 establish9876.39 the9876.87 Massachusetts9877.03 Data9877.83 Privacy9878.15 Act.9878.71 My9879.35 name9879.51 is9879.75 Adenekan9880.55 Dedeke.9882.07 I9882.07 have9882.23 to9882.47 pronounce9882.63 it9883.03 as9883.27 a9883.43 cross9883.59 culture,9883.91 so9884.31 that's9884.47 a9884.79 good9885.44 way9885.67 to9885.83 pronounce9885.92 it.9886.24 I'm9886.64 a9886.8 professor9886.95 of9887.27 management9887.44 information9887.83 systems9888.24 at9888.64 Northeastern9888.8 University.9889.27 I've9889.92 been9890.08 teaching9890.24 at9890.56 the9890.72 college9890.72 level9891.11 for9891.35 over9891.59 29892.4 decades.9893.19 I9894.08 teach9894.32 technology,9894.64 and9896.48 I'm9897.35 interested9898.48 in9898.95 ethics9899.27 and9899.75 privacy9899.92 on9900.32 the9900.48 other9900.56 side.9900.72 So9900.93 I'm9901.09 kind9901.33 of9901.41 a9901.65 person9901.81 in9902.13 the9902.29 middle9902.37 that9902.97 I9903.57 know9903.81 I9904.29 want9904.45 technology9904.69 to9905.09 work9905.25 very9905.49 well,9905.73 but9905.97 I'm9906.13 also9906.37 very,9906.69 very9906.93 aware9907.25 of9907.57 the9907.73 risk9907.89 that9908.29 it9908.53 plays.9908.69 And9909.09 it's9909.25 kind9909.49 of9909.65 very9909.73 interesting9909.97 to9910.45 tease9910.61 that9910.85 out9911.01 with9911.17 my9911.33 students9911.49 and9911.97 in9912.21 my9912.37 research.9912.53 I9913.36 have9913.52 personal9914.33 reasons9914.73 for9915.52 supporting9915.68 the9916.08 enactment9916.33 of9916.73 Bill9916.97 45.9917.28 Personally,9918.57 I've9919.13 been9919.2 affected9919.52 by9919.92 several9920.08 of9920.49 the9920.57 data9920.73 breaches9921.05 that9921.44 have9921.6 been9921.76 reported9921.92 in9922.41 the9922.57 Massachusetts9922.57 media,9923.28 from9924.25 the9924.65 Target9924.81 to9925.2 the9925.36 TJX9925.52 data9926.15 breaches.9926.31 In9927.27 the9927.51 past9927.59 59927.91 years,9928.07 I9928.31 have9928.47 received9928.63 data9929.35 breach9929.75 notification9930.23 letters9930.79 from9931.11 third9931.35 parties.9931.67 Most9932.31 of9932.55 them9932.63 have9932.87 never9933.11 had9933.27 any9933.51 business9933.67 with9933.99 them.9934.15 That9935.43 gave9935.91 me9936.07 the9936.31 somber9936.39 awareness9936.87 that9937.67 my9938.15 data9938.31 is9938.63 being9938.79 shared9939.03 and9939.35 sold9940.07 without9940.31 my9940.63 consent.9942.53
9943.01 Also,9943.42 during9943.42 COVID-19,9943.73 I9944.14 had9944.14 a9944.3 rude9944.45 awakening9944.85 when9945.42 I9945.65 found9945.73 out9945.98 that9946.06 someone9946.3 had9946.53 applied9946.85 for9947.65 a9947.9 million-dollar9948.38 COVID9948.77 loan9949.17 in9950.06 my9950.22 name.9950.38 And9951.57 I9951.81 happened9951.98 to9952.61 be9953.72 looking9953.96 for9954.12 a9954.44 house9954.52 during9954.76 that9955.08 time9955.32 when9955.64 someone9955.96 told9956.2 me,9956.44 oh,9956.6 you9956.76 have9956.92 a9957.08 business?9957.16 I9957.56 said9957.64 no.9957.8 I9957.96 don't9958.04 have9958.2 a9958.36 business.9958.44 I'm9958.76 a9958.92 poor9959 professor.9959.32 And9960.44 he9960.68 told9960.76 me9961.08 the9961.24 details9961.48 of9961.96 how9962.2 someone9962.6 had9963.08 applied9963.72 COVID9964.76 loan.9965.32 So9965.56 I9965.72 was9965.8 very9966.04 fortunate9966.28 to9966.6 be9967.08 able9967.17 to9967.41 stop9967.81 it.9968.2 So,9968.6 I9968.84 have9969.08 very9969.49 strong9969.81 reasons9970.13 to9970.92 want9971.17 a9971.97 ATA9972.28 privacy9972.28 law.9973.17 Personally,9974.52 in9975.08 my9975.25 research9975.41 life,9975.89 what9976.2 I9976.36 do9976.52 is9976.68 I9977 review9977.73 the9978.13 strengths9978.28 and9978.6 weaknesses9978.76 of9979.25 national9979.41 security9979.89 standards.9980.44 I've9980.84 also9981 done9981.25 some9981.41 things9981.65 about9981.89 looking9982.3 through9982.62 privacy9982.86 laws,9983.34 how9983.66 they're9983.82 structured.9984.06 I've9984.54 looked9984.7 at9984.86 the9985.02 GDPR.9985.18 During9987.1 my9987.42 research,9987.58 I9987.98 came9988.14 across9988.38 bill9988.86 SB9989.34 459989.5 last9990.06 year.9990.3 I9991.26 reviewed9991.42 it,9991.82 and9991.9 I9992.06 felt9992.3 that9992.62 it9992.86 was9992.94 very9993.9 well9994.14 crafted.9994.3 19994.98 privacy9995.3 law9995.77 that9996.02 I9996.26 could9996.33 get9996.74 behind.9996.9 I9997.45 was9997.61 pleased9997.77 to9998.1 spend9998.18 several9998.5 hours9998.9 reviewing9999.22 the9999.53 bill9999.61 and10000.18 sending10000.42 my10000.74 feedback10002.1 and10002.66 comments10002.74 to10003.22 Senator10003.38 Moore's10003.94 staff.10004.18 To10004.5 my10004.66 surprise,10004.9 they10005.53 got10007.22 back10007.45 to10007.69 me10007.85 on10008.02 it.10008.1 I'll10008.33 just10008.42 say,10008.66 oh,10008.82 that's10008.98 saying10009.22 it's10009.38 gonna10009.53 be10009.85 a10009.94 back10010.78 home.10011.02 And10011.26 it's10011.42 been10011.82 very,10012.54 very10012.78 encouraging10014.14 just10015.1 to10015.34 send10015.58 them10015.82 this10016.06 what10016.3 I10016.46 feel,10016.54 this10016.7 what10016.94 I10017.1 know,10017.18 and10017.42 for10017.66 them10017.82 to10018.06 be10018.14 very,10018.3 very10018.46 receptive10018.78 to10019.26 it.10019.34 And10019.58 it10019.74 gave10019.9 me10020.06 and10020.46 also10020.7 reading10020.94 the10021.26 bill10021.34 gave10021.58 me10021.82 an10021.9 idea10022.06 that10022.38 the10022.94 people10023.02 who10023.34 were10023.5 doing10023.74 the10023.98 bill10024.14 necessarily10024.7 communicated10025.5 with10025.98 people10026.27 that10026.44 they're10026.6 trying10026.92 to10028.03 manage10028.27 or10028.68 control,10028.75 which10029.16 I10029.4 appreciated.10030.35
10031.24 There10031.24 are10031.4 a10031.56 few10031.64 elements10031.88 that10032.27 I10032.44 think10033.24 make10033.56 the10033.56 bill10033.88 stand10034.19 out10034.44 in10034.6 my10034.75 view.10034.92 I10035.72 think10035.88 that10036.11 data10036.35 minimization10036.68 is10037.4 aery,10037.95 very10038.11 crucial,10038.35 and10039.16 I10039.32 think10039.4 there10039.64 are10039.88 some10039.88 issues10040.35 related10041.32 to10041.72 it10041.88 that10041.95 I10042.17 think10042.33 the10043.93 con10044.01 the10045.29 senators10045.61 and10046.17 house10046.41 speakers10046.73 should10047.05 also10047.29 consider.10047.53 But10047.93 I10048.09 think10048.17 it's10048.41 very,10048.65 very10048.81 important,10049.05 and10049.37 I10049.53 think10049.61 it's10049.77 a10049.93 strong10050.09 suit10050.33 of10050.57 the10050.73 law.10050.89 I10051.45 think10051.53 the10051.93 clear10052.17 affirmative10052.57 consent10053.45 and10054.17 revoking10054.41 consent10054.97 is10055.29 very,10055.77 very10056.01 powerful10056.25 and10056.82 necessary10056.98 for10057.45 the10057.61 law.10057.69 Also,10058.42 I10058.74 think10058.82 it's10059.06 very10059.3 important10059.53 the10059.94 idea10060.1 that10060.5 we10061.3 require10062.25 the10062.25 people10062.42 to10062.74 communicate10063.38 the10064.58 request10065.22 of10065.94 the10067.06 data10067.3 subject10067.69 to10068.25 everybody.10068.42 And10069.22 I10069.38 think10069.45 that's10069.69 very,10070.25 very10070.42 important10070.58 because10070.98 they10071.45 have10071.69 to10071.85 communicate10072.02 it.10072.21 Other10080.97 views,10081.13 than10081.85 what10082.09 other10082.33 people10082.57 have.10082.89 I10083.29 do10083.53 not10083.69 claim10083.85 that10084.09 a10084.25 bill10084.41 is10084.65 perfect.10084.81 Nothing10085.29 is10085.69 perfect.10085.85 I10086.94 think10087.18 as10087.67 moving10088.39 to10088.63 the10088.78 future,10088.94 that10089.18 we10089.34 need10089.5 to10089.75 adjust10089.91 it10090.23 a10090.39 little10090.47 bit10090.7 here10090.78 and10090.94 there,10091.02 but10091.26 I10091.42 think10091.5 it's10091.67 a10091.83 very,10091.98 very10092.23 solid,10092.55 law,10093.58 a10093.98 solid10094.15 bill10094.47 that10094.7 is10094.94 needed,10095.1 and10095.34 that'll10095.58 be10095.83 very,10095.98 very10096.31 helpful.10096.55 And10097.42 I10097.75 think10097.91 it's10098.31 a10098.7 good10098.86 thing10099.02 to10099.67 see10100.71 that10100.95 the10101.19 senators10101.43 in10101.99 the10102.15 house10102.47 look10103.27 into10103.51 it.10103.75 Again,10104.07 thank10104.39 you10104.55 for10104.71 the10104.87 opportunity10105.03 to10105.51 testify10105.59 this10106.07 afternoon.10106.31 I10107.03 urge10107.27 the10107.51 committee10107.67 to10108.23 favorably10108.79 report10109.43 Bill10110.31 45,10110.71 and10111.59 I'll10111.75 be10111.91 happy10112.07 to10112.31 take10112.47 any10112.63 of10112.79 your10112.95 questions.10113.11
10113.59 FARLEY-BOUVIER10113.59 -10113.59 Thank10113.59 you10113.83 so10113.99 much.10114.23 Appreciate10114.63 your10115.03 testimony10115.49 today.10116.52 I10116.84 think10117 we're10117.17 gonna10117.33 now10117.57 move10117.89 to10118.77 Nancy10119.08 Brombeck10119.57 of10120.05 the10120.28 League10120.36 of10120.6 Women10120.84 Voters.10121.17 I'm10121.73 sorry.10121.97 Oh,10123.08 no.10123.25 Okay.10123.49 Okay.10124.05 Then,10124.92 on10125.73 deck,10126.05 we10126.36 have10126.52 a10126.77 panel10126.84 led10127.43 by10127.67 Carrie10127.83 Rich10128.15 Jones.10128.47 So,10129.43 Nancy10130.15 Braubek.10130.63
10133.99 NANCY10133.99 BRUMBACK10133.99 -10133.99 LWVMA10133.99 -HB10133.99 8610133.99 -10133.99 SB10133.99 19710133.99 -10133.99 (10133.99 R10133.99 )10133.99 Good10133.99 afternoon,10134.23 Chair10135.67 Farley10135.99 Bouquet,10136.39 the10136.95 chair10136.95 M,oore10138.39 and10138.39 members10138.55 of10138.87 the10138.95 committee.10139.11 Just10141.03 make10141.51 sure10141.75 you10141.92 can10142 hear10142.23 me.10142.48
10142.88 FARLEY-BOUVIER10142.88 -10142.88 Yes.10142.88 Are10143.27 we10143.43 good?10143.59 Coming10143.83 in10144.07 loud10144.23 and10144.48 clear,10144.64 and10144.95 your10145.67 video10146.64 is10147.11 also10147.27 great.10147.67
10150.07 BRUMBACK10150.07 -10150.07 I'm10150.07 Nancy10150.23 Brumback.10150.72 I'm10151.19 a10151.27 legislative10151.51 advocate10152.48 for10153.35 the10153.51 League10153.67 of10153.92 Women10154 Voters10154.31 of10154.72 Massachusetts,10154.88 and10156 I'm10156.15 representing10156.69 our10157.01 4410157.25 local10158.21 leagues10158.53 in10158.93 5510159.25 communities10160.29 from10161.41 Cape10161.65 Cod10161.97 to10162.21 Berkshires.10162.45 The10163.97 league10164.13 urges10164.45 you10164.93 to10165.09 act10165.25 swiftly10165.49 on10166.13 the10166.29 Location10166.53 Shield10167.09 Act,10167.57 bills10168.45 HB10171.73 86,10173.06 SB10173.06 19710173.06 to10173.06 ban10173.23 the10173.55 sale10173.63 of10173.94 cell10174.1 phone10174.34 location10174.67 data10175.31 in10175.63 Massachusetts.10175.86 The10177.86 league10178.1 strongly10178.42 agrees10178.9 with10179.31 the10179.47 advocates10179.7 who10180.18 are10180.34 making10180.42 arguments10180.82 today10181.31 on10182.26 behalf10182.42 of10182.82 domestic10182.98 violence10183.47 survivors10184.02 and10184.77 people10185.01 seeking10185.97 reproductive10186.45 health10187.17 care10187.41 and10187.97 immigrants,10188.29 but10189.65 we10189.89 think10190.05 there10190.21 are10190.37 other10190.53 groups10190.77 that10191.01 need10191.17 to10191.29 be10191.41 sure10191.57 their10191.89 location10192.13 data10192.69 isn't10193.09 private10193.49 as10193.89 well.10194.05 The10196.05 current10196.21 political10196.69 climate10197.41 has10198.53 encouraged10198.97 organized10199.68 groups10200.24 and10201.05 so-called10201.52 lone10201.92 wolves10202.4 to10203.36 threaten10203.52 and10204.08 harass10204.32 individuals10205.44 they10206 disagree10206.24 with.10206.65 Access10208.17 to10208.65 their10208.89 target's10209.13 location10209.92 data10210.48 provides10210.97 them10211.44 with10211.68 additional10211.92 ways10212.4 to10212.89 do10213.05 that.10213.28 Judges,10214.78 doctors,10215.9 journalists,10217.1 and10217.98 even10217.98 election10218.3 workers10218.7 have10219.82 been10219.98 threatened10220.14 and10220.54 harassed10220.86 just10221.58 for10221.82 doing10222.06 their10222.38 jobs.10222.62 Public10224.78 figures10225.26 and10225.74 politicians10225.98 become10226.94 targets10227.42 based10228.38 on10228.62 the10228.78 positions10228.94 they10229.58 take.10230.65 You10230.89 may10231.13 have10231.28 experienced10231.52 that.10232.25
10234.48 My10234.48 own10234.73 local10235.05 league10235.36 received10236.41 a10236.89 request10237.28 last10237.92 month10238.25 from10238.73 a10238.97 candidate10239.13 in10239.6 our10239.76 town10240 election10240.41 to10241.76 remove10242 their10242.48 home10242.73 address10243.05 from10243.76 our10244 league's10244.16 voter10244.64 guide.10245.04 We10246.72 removed10246.96 all10247.52 the10247.68 candidates'10247.92 home10248.48 addresses.10248.72 And10250.8 there's10251.04 a10251.28 bill10251.44 that10251.84 was10252 filed10252.24 this10252.56 session10252.8 to10253.76 end10254 the10254.24 practice10254.48 of10255.52 printing10255.68 the10256.08 home10256.24 addresses10256.48 of10257.12 candidates10257.28 on10258.72 ballots.10258.88 This10259.92 is10260.08 the10260.24 world10260.4 we10260.72 are10260.88 living10261.03 in.10261.35 People10263.52 who10263.92 exercise10264.16 their10264.72 first10264.95 amendment10265.19 right10265.68 to10266 free10266.24 speech10266.48 by10267.52 participating10267.84 in10268.56 rallies10268.72 and10269.19 marches10269.44 for10270.16 various10270.32 causes10270.8 are10271.84 now10272.08 targets.10272.4 Extremist10274.08 groups10274.8 make10275.99 and10276.39 distribute10276.71 lists10277.27 of10277.59 people10277.75 who10278.55 demonstrate10278.87 for10279.43 causes10279.67 that10280.07 those10280.31 groups10280.55 disagree10281.27 with.10281.75 The10283.67 private10283.91 cell10284.39 phone10284.63 location10284.95 data10285.51 of10285.91 people10285.99 in10286.31 all10286.55 these10286.71 targeted10286.95 groups10287.43 must10288.31 be10288.55 protected.10288.79 The10289.24 location10299.8 shield10300.08 act10300.35 favorably10300.64 and10300.92 quickly10301.08 out10302.6 the10303.1 location10303.26 shield10303.82 act10303.98 favorably10304.3 and10305.18 quickly10305.58 out10306.7 of10306.94 committee10307.02 and10307.42 bring10307.58 it10307.82 to10307.9 the10308.06 floor10308.14 for10308.54 a10308.78 vote.10308.86 It10309.9 almost10310.14 passed10310.54 last10310.94 session.10311.18 Let's10311.98 not10312.3 delay10312.54 any10312.94 longer.10313.18 In10314.54 the10314.78 meantime,10314.94 you10315.74 might10315.9 want10316.14 to10316.38 go10316.46 to10316.62 the10316.78 settings10316.94 on10317.42 your10317.58 own10317.82 cell10318.06 phone10318.91 and10319.31 switch10319.55 the10319.94 location10320.1 button10320.58 to10320.91 off.10321.15 Thank10322.26 you,10322.5 and10322.67 I'll10322.91 take10322.98 any10323.31 questions.10323.47
FARLEY-BOUVIER10324.58 -10324.58 Thank10324.58 you,10324.75 Nancy.10324.98 Appreciate10325.55 your10326.1 testimony.10326.26 We're10327.47 now10327.7 gonna10327.86 go10328.18 to10328.42 a10328.58 panel10328.75 that10329.23 is10329.47 online,10329.78 led10330.34 by10330.5 Carrie10330.75 Ridge10331.23 Jones.10331.78 Oh,10333.46 you're10333.62 here.10333.86 We're10334.18 here10334.42 in10334.66 person.10334.74 Yay.10335.06 Bring10335.78 your10336.02 panel10336.18 up,10336.5 Gary.10337.3 And10350.68 as10351 you're10351.24 settling10351.48 down,10351.81 I'll10352.05 just10352.13 let10352.36 you10352.6 know10352.68 that10352.92 Elizabeth10353.16 Mahoney10353.65 is10354.2 on10354.44 deck.10354.6
10359.4 CARRIE10359.4 RICHGELS10359.4 -10359.4 PPAF10359.4 -10359.4 SB10359.4 2910359.4 -HB10359.4 10410359.4 -10359.4 SB10359.4 4510359.4 -10359.4 Good10359.4 afternoon.10359.65 And10361 thank10361.32 you,10361.81 Chair10362.2 Moore,10362.2 Chair10362.76 Farley10363.16 Bouvier,10363.62 and10364.02 members10364.1 of10364.5 the10364.66 committee.10364.82 My10365.86 name10366.1 is10366.26 Carrie10366.58 Riggles,10366.9 and10367.54 I'm10367.86 the10368.1 policy10368.26 manager10368.74 at10369.22 Planned10369.46 Parenthood10369.78 Advocacy10370.42 Fund10371.06 of10371.3 Massachusetts.10371.46 And10372.82 I'm10373.06 joined10373.22 today10373.54 by10373.86 Doctor10374.1 Kendra10374.5 Harris10374.98 and10375.54 Megan10375.78 Donnelly.10376.18 We're10377.23 here10377.47 in10377.63 support10377.86 of10378.34 several10378.58 data10379.15 privacy10379.55 bills,10380.02 an10381.15 act10381.31 to10381.47 protect10381.63 location10382.02 privacy,10382.74 H10383.47 86,10383.78 an10384.98 act10385.15 establishing10385.39 the10386.02 Massachusetts10386.18 Data10386.9 Privacy10387.23 Act10389.15 H10389.39 104,10389.39 S10389.39 45,10389.39 and10389.94 S10390.1 29,10390.34 and10391.39 an10391.63 act10391.78 establishing10392.1 the10393.17 Massachusetts10393.17 Consumer10393.81 Data10394.29 Privacy10394.77 Act10395.49 H10395.89 78.10396.13 We10397.73 appreciate10398.13 the10398.77 urgency10399.01 that10399.81 the10399.97 committee10400.13 is10400.53 demonstrating10400.85 by10401.65 hearing10401.89 these10402.21 bills10402.53 so10402.93 early10403.25 in10403.57 the10403.73 session.10403.81 The10405.1 threats10405.35 that10407.19 they10407.5 address10407.99 are10408.55 more10408.78 and10409.02 more10409.19 pressing10409.5 each10410.07 day.10410.31 Planned10411.5 Parenthood10411.83 League10412.31 of10412.55 Massachusetts10412.7 is10413.35 the10413.5 Commonwealth's10413.67 largest10414.47 freestanding10415.02 sexual10415.83 and10416.23 reproductive10416.39 health10417.02 care10417.26 provider.10417.74
10418.94 Across10418.94 410419.42 locations10419.74 and10420.62 via10420.78 telehealth,10421.18 we10421.74 offer10422.06 birth10422.54 control,10422.78 STI10423.74 testing10424.38 and10424.78 treatment,10424.94 life-saving10426.22 cancer10426.7 screenings,10427.18 abortion10427.98 care,10428.62 and10429.02 gender10429.34 affirming10429.74 care.10430.22 We10431.34 strongly10431.74 believe10432.46 that10433.4 everyone10433.48 should10434.03 have10434.35 access10434.67 to10435 this10435.32 safe,10435.8 compassionate10436.44 care10437.24 free10437.95 from10438.27 stigma10438.59 and10439.08 judgment.10439.16 Each10440.59 year,10440.92 PPLM10441.4 provides10442.27 abortion10442.67 care10443.16 to10443.48 more10443.64 than10443.8 9,00010444.03 patients,10444.92 with10445.4 more10445.64 than10445.8 5010446.11 percent10446.44 choosing10446.98 medication10447.38 abortion.10448.02 Location10449.3 data10450.02 that10450.42 shows10450.66 access10451.38 to10451.94 these10452.18 services10452.5 puts10453.22 our10453.62 community10453.86 at10454.58 risk.10454.74 PPLM10456.02 has10456.74 been10456.9 a10457.06 target10457.22 for10457.7 a10457.94 long10458.02 time,10458.26 but10459.3 the10459.54 current10459.62 attacks10460.67 make10461.23 it10461.39 even10461.7 more10462.18 important10462.58 to10463.23 create10463.47 and10463.78 strengthen10464.02 protections10464.58 in10465.06 Massachusetts10465.23 for10466.1 our10466.34 providers,10466.5 our10467.31 staff,10467.63 our10468.18 community10468.42 supporters,10469.15 and10469.78 most10470.1 of10470.34 all,10470.5 our10470.82 patients.10471.06 Fear10473.12 of10473.44 violated10473.76 privacy10474.48 should10475.04 not10475.28 keep10475.52 anyone10475.92 from10476.72 seeking10476.96 legally10477.52 protected10478.24 health10478.96 care.10479.28 While10480.32 our10480.64 organization10480.8 is10481.6 particularly10481.84 concerned10482.64 about10483.04 location10483.36 data,10483.84 we10484.96 also10485.12 support10485.44 broad,10485.92 robust10486.4 data10487.12 privacy10487.44 legislation.10488.23 So,10488.94 please10489.67 consider10489.99 us10490.39 a10490.63 resource10490.78 and10492.15 a10492.31 partner10492.47 in10492.86 your10492.94 efforts10493.19 to10493.58 move10493.75 policy10493.99 that10494.47 prohibits10494.78 the10495.27 sale10495.5 of10495.75 location10495.91 data10496.47 and10496.94 grants10497.27 these10497.58 bills10497.83 a10498.15 favorable10498.23 report.10498.86
10499.58 SPEAKER110499.58 -10499.58 Thank10499.58 you.10499.83 So10500.07 much.10500.23
10502.96 DR.10502.96 KENDRA10502.96 HARRIS10502.96 -10502.96 PPLM-10502.96 Good10502.96 afternoon,10503.28 and10503.68 thank10503.84 you10504.08 for10504.24 the10504.8 opportunity10504.88 to10505.28 testify10505.44 today.10505.92 My10506.88 name10506.96 is10507.12 Doctor10507.28 Kendra10507.6 Harris.10507.92 I10508.24 use10508.4 sheher10508.56 pronouns,10508.96 and10509.28 I10509.44 live10509.52 in10509.68 Jamaica10509.84 Plain,10510.16 Massachusetts.10510.48 I'm10511.52 a10511.76 board-certified10512.88 OB-GYN10513.44 and10513.44 complex10513.68 family10514.08 planning10514.4 fellow10514.72 at10514.96 Brigham10515.12 and10515.36 Women's10515.52 Hospital.10516 In10516.56 my10516.92 current10517 fellowship,10517.33 I10518.13 provide10518.28 abortion10518.6 care10519 and10519.25 contraceptive10519.48 care10520.13 at10520.36 Planned10520.6 Parenthood10520.84 League10521.33 of10521.56 Massachusetts.10521.73 I'm10523.4 also10523.56 a10523.81 fellow10523.89 with10524.2 Physicians10524.36 for10524.76 Reproductive10524.92 Health.10525.4 I'm10526.36 here10526.52 today10526.68 to10527 speak10527.33 on10527.33 my10527.48 behalf10527.81 and10528.2 to10528.2 voice10528.36 my10528.6 strong10528.84 support10529.17 for10529.56 data10529.65 privacy10530.09 protections.10530.49 These10531.29 laws10531.61 will10531.93 improve10532.17 patient10532.57 access10532.97 to10533.29 health10533.37 care,10533.61 and10534.33 I10534.49 believe10534.65 are10534.89 essential10535.05 if10535.53 Massachusetts10535.77 wants10536.49 to10536.65 truly10536.81 be10537.21 a10537.37 safe10537.45 haven10537.69 for10538.01 reproductive10538.17 health10538.73 care.10538.97
10540.57 My10540.57 patients10540.81 are10541.21 very10541.37 concerned10541.69 about10542.09 their10542.33 health10542.49 data,10542.73 and10543.13 reproductive10543.45 health10544.01 data10544.17 in10544.49 particular,10544.65 criminalization.10546.92 I'll10548.67 bet10548.83 most10549.24 of10549.4 us10549.56 in10549.64 this10549.8 room10549.95 can't10550.19 remember10550.44 the10550.75 last10550.83 time10551 we10551.24 went10551.32 literally10551.64 anywhere10552.11 without10552.44 our10552.75 cell10552.83 phones.10553.08 Last10553.88 of10554.19 all,10554.35 a10554.44 medical10554.59 appointment10554.92 where10555.24 we10555.48 might10555.64 need10555.8 to10555.95 call10556.03 someone10556.27 for10556.59 a10556.75 ride10556.83 home,10557.08 look10557.8 up10558.03 old10558.19 medical10558.44 records,10558.75 or10559.34 update10559.58 a10559.9 loved10560.06 110560.22 on10560.38 how10560.62 the10560.78 appointment10560.86 went.10561.34 But10562.14 many10562.38 of10562.62 my10562.7 patients10562.94 have10563.34 opted10563.58 to10563.82 leave10563.9 their10564.14 phones10564.3 at10564.54 home10564.7 out10565.02 of10565.18 fear10565.34 of10565.46 their10565.58 location10565.82 being10566.3 tracked10566.54 and10566.86 shared.10567.02 Just10568.38 a10568.62 few10568.7 weeks10568.94 ago,10569.1 I10569.42 had10569.5 110569.66 of10569.74 my10569.82 patients10569.98 had10570.78 an10570.94 old10571.1 flip10571.26 phone.10572.22 She10572.78 told10573.02 me10573.18 she'd10573.34 gotten10573.5 it10573.78 to10573.86 just10574.02 coordinate10574.19 her10574.67 medical10574.75 care10575.07 and10575.47 communicate10575.7 with10576.19 her10576.34 friend10576.5 who10576.83 had10576.99 dropped10577.15 her10577.31 off10577.47 and10577.63 would10577.78 pick10577.94 her10578.1 up.10578.19 She10578.91 took10579.15 all10579.31 of10579.47 these10579.55 extra10579.78 steps10580.1 so10580.42 that10580.58 there10580.83 would10580.99 be10581.15 no10581.31 paper10581.55 trail10581.86 or10582.42 location10582.75 data10583.15 to10583.55 trace10583.7 her10583.94 back10584.1 to10584.34 our10584.5 health10584.75 care10584.99 clinic.10585.15
10586.1 That10586.1 is10586.34 how10586.58 scared10586.91 people10587.23 are10587.47 of10587.7 being10587.86 tracked,10588.1 harassed,10588.5 or10588.99 investigated.10589.15 Just10590.21 for10590.37 getting10590.53 health10590.85 care10591.01 that10591.17 is10591.41 safe,10591.57 essential,10591.89 and10592.37 normal.10592.61 And10593.73 this10593.89 fear10594.93 is10595.17 not10595.33 hysteria.10595.57 It10596.13 is10596.21 warranted.10596.45 Trust10597.49 and10597.81 security10597.97 are10598.45 fundamental10598.69 to10599.33 me10599.49 being10599.65 able10599.81 to10600.05 provide10600.13 health10600.45 care10600.69 to10600.93 my10601.09 patients.10601.33 It10602.49 is10602.65 unfair10602.81 to10603.36 add10603.52 this10603.77 layer10604 of10604.33 anxiety10604.49 for10604.97 folks10605.05 who10605.36 are10605.52 just10605.69 trying10605.92 to10606.17 navigate10606.33 their10606.73 own10606.89 survival10607.13 and10607.52 care10607.69 for10607.92 their10608.08 families.10608.25 It10609.2 is10609.36 unfair10609.6 for10610.08 providers10610.33 to10610.89 be10611.05 made10611.2 unwittingly10611.52 into10612.08 sites10612.41 of10612.65 fear10612.81 and10612.97 criminalization.10613.13 The10614.73 hostility10614.89 toward10615.36 sexual10615.69 and10616.05 reproductive10616.29 health10616.61 care10616.85 across10617.09 the10617.41 country10617.57 makes10617.89 the10618.13 need10618.29 for10618.45 stronger10618.61 data10619.17 privacy10619.57 laws10619.97 more10620.21 urgent10620.37 for10620.69 providers10620.85 like10621.25 myself,10621.49 too.10621.89 I10622.85 am10623.01 incredibly10623.25 proud10623.65 of10623.89 the10624.05 work10624.13 I10624.29 do,10624.45 and10624.93 my10625.09 commitment10625.25 to10625.65 my10625.81 patients10625.97 and10626.29 their10626.45 right10626.61 to10626.77 decide10626.93 what's10627.33 best10627.57 for10627.81 their10627.97 bodies10628.05 is10628.37 unshakable.10628.53 Because10641.29 of10641.45 my10641.69 physical10641.85 appearance10642.25 and10642.65 the10642.81 work10642.89 I10643.13 do.10643.29 To10644.17 protect10644.41 myself10644.73 and10645.21 my10645.37 family,10645.61 I10646.25 do10646.33 not10646.49 post10646.65 my10646.89 family10647.05 on10647.29 social10647.45 media.10647.69 I10648.09 use10648.25 a10648.49 P.O.10648.89 Box10649.13 for10649.13 mail,10649.29 and10649.77 I10649.93 use10650.01 DeleteMe,10650.25 which10650.65 is10650.81 an10650.97 Internet10651.13 data10651.53 privacy10651.77 service.10652.33 Despite10653.21 all10653.69 of10653.85 these10653.93 steps,10654.2 my10654.84 location10655.17 data10655.49 being10655.81 available10656.13 still10656.6 leaves10656.76 me10657 vulnerable.10657.17 I10658.44 urge10658.6 you10658.76 to10658.92 support10659 this10659.25 bill10659.49 without10659.73 hesitation10660.05 and10660.52 give10660.68 it10660.92 a10661 favorable10661.17 report.10661.73
10662.68 SPEAKER110662.68 -10662.68 Thank10662.68 you,10662.84 doctor.10663.08 Great.10665.33
10669.85 MEGAN10669.85 DONNELLY10669.85 -10669.85 PLANNED10669.85 PARENTHOOD10669.85 PATIENT10669.85 -10669.85 I10669.85 really10670.01 appreciate10670.25 your10670.73 attention10670.97 for10671.37 the10671.53 next10671.61 310671.85 minutes.10672.09 I10672.33 know10672.41 it's10672.57 been10672.73 a10672.89 long10672.97 day,10673.13 so10673.45 thank10673.69 you10673.93 for10674.09 listening10674.57 to10674.97 our10675.13 panel10675.21 and10675.53 our10675.69 testimonies.10675.85 My10676.73 name10676.89 is10676.97 Megan10677.21 Donnelly.10677.45 I10678.25 am10678.49 a10678.65 resident10678.81 of10679.13 Cambridge,10679.21 Massachusetts.10679.77 And10680.41 today,10680.57 I'm10680.97 here10681.13 as10681.37 a10681.53 Planned10681.61 Parenthood10681.85 patient10682.33 and10683.13 an10683.29 advocate10683.45 personality10696.19 trait10696.83 for10697.08 me.10697.24 I10697.64 have10697.93 visited10698.09 over10698.49 4210698.81 states10699.45 and10699.77 1510700.01 countries,10700.33 and10700.65 I'm10700.81 always10700.89 very10701.13 proud10701.37 to10701.77 announce10701.93 this10702.33 state10702.41 as10702.73 my10702.89 home.10702.97 I10703.85 grew10703.93 up10704.09 on10704.25 Cape10704.41 Cod10704.73 and10705.13 was10705.37 raised10705.61 there10705.85 until10706.09 my10706.33 parents10706.57 moved10707.05 to10707.37 Florida10707.53 my10708.01 senior10708.17 year10708.49 of10708.65 college10708.81 to10709.13 support10709.29 my10709.61 dad10709.77 in10710.33 fighting10710.41 his10710.73 battle10710.97 with10711.29 stage10711.45 410711.77 non-Hodgkin's10712.17 lymphoma.10712.65
10714.24 I10714.24 became10714.4 a10714.64 resident10714.72 of10715.11 Florida10715.27 when10715.6 I10715.75 moved10715.83 in10716.08 to10716.16 care10716.32 for10716.48 my10716.64 dad10716.72 in10716.95 the10717.11 final10717.19 years10717.44 of10717.56 his10717.68 life10717.92 and10718.08 traveled10718.32 quite10718.72 pregnant,10718.95 excuse10719.6 me,10719.92 quite10720.24 frequently,10720.48 between10721.6 here10722 and10722.24 there.10722.4 In10722.72 February,10722.88 I10724.4 found10724.48 out10724.72 I10724.88 was10725.03 pregnant.10725.19 I10726.74 felt10726.98 very10727.22 lucky10727.46 to10727.94 be10728.1 in10728.18 Massachusetts10728.34 at10729.06 that10729.22 time.10729.38 The10730.26 decision10730.42 to10730.82 have10730.98 an10731.06 abortion10731.22 was10731.7 easy10732.1 110732.42 for10732.58 me,10732.74 and10733.22 I10733.38 knew10733.54 that10733.7 Planned10733.94 Parenthood10734.18 would10734.74 provide10734.9 me10735.22 with10735.38 the10735.62 care10735.78 and10736.34 kindness10736.66 and10737.3 anonymity10737.46 I10738.26 desired.10738.42 Had10739.38 I10739.66 been10739.74 in10739.9 Florida,10740.06 where10740.38 my10740.61 job10740.69 and10740.94 health10741.1 insurance10741.33 were10741.74 based,10741.9 I10742.22 worried10742.38 about10742.61 what10742.77 it10742.85 would10743.02 mean10743.17 for10743.42 me10743.58 to10743.82 go10743.9 back10744.14 to10744.3 a10744.45 state10744.61 that10745.25 might10745.42 be10745.66 on10745.74 the10745.9 brink10745.98 of10746.3 criminalizing10746.53 abortion.10747.25 Had10748.38 I10748.61 been10748.69 in10748.85 Florida,10749.02 I10749.5 firmly10749.74 believe10750.14 that10750.45 even10750.69 then,10751.02 I10751.42 would10751.58 have10751.74 come10751.9 back10752.2 home10752.44 for10752.72 this10753 care.10753.24 The10755.32 procedure10755.56 was10756.2 my10756.76 choice.10756.92 It's10757.64 110757.96 of10758.12 a10758.28 series10758.36 of10758.84 millions10759 of10759.48 choices10759.72 we10760.52 make10760.76 in10760.92 our10761 lives,10761.24 from10761.56 trivial10761.8 choices,10762.28 like10762.84 what10763.48 outfit10763.72 to10764.12 wear10764.28 or10764.68 what10764.92 to10765.08 eat10765.24 for10765.4 dinner,10765.56 to10765.88 big10766.04 ones,10766.28 like10766.6 if10766.92 I10767 could10767.16 be10767.32 a10767.48 mom10767.56 or10768.17 if10768.33 I10768.5 wanted10768.58 to10768.81 be10769.06 a10769.14 mom.10769.22 All10770.17 of10770.42 these10770.58 choices,10770.81 big10771.53 and10771.85 small,10772.09 are10773.06 mine.10773.22 They10773.85 are10774.09 mine10774.17 to10774.42 hold.10774.58 They10774.98 are10775.14 mine10775.3 to10775.53 choose,10775.69 and10776.01 they10776.17 are10776.33 mine10776.42 to10776.65 share.10776.81
10777.93 The10777.93 day10778.17 that10778.33 I10778.5 got10778.58 the10778.73 blood10778.9 test10779.14 confirmation10779.38 that10779.93 my10780.09 medication10780.25 abortion10780.65 had10781.22 been10781.38 successful10781.75 was10782.47 06/24/2022,10782.71 the10785.19 day10785.35 the10785.51 Supreme10785.75 Court10786.15 overturned10786.63 Roe10787.43 v10787.83 Wade.10788.07 The10789.67 relief10789.91 I10790.23 had10790.39 at10790.71 first10790.87 felt10791.19 was10791.91 overwhelmed10792.15 by10793.51 knowing10793.67 that10793.99 millions10794.15 of10794.55 women,10794.63 especially10795.19 my10795.67 friends10795.83 and10796.07 family10796.23 in10796.63 Florida,10796.79 were10797.43 now10797.67 terrified10797.92 about10798.4 what10798.64 this10798.8 would10798.95 mean10799.11 for10799.35 them.10799.43 I10800.23 had10800.4 to10800.64 watch10800.8 everywhere10801.19 on10801.75 social10801.99 media,10802.31 on10802.8 the10802.95 news,10803.19 on10803.59 the10803.75 street,10803.92 what10804.48 everyone10804.72 thought10805.03 about10805.27 this10805.43 choice10805.67 that10805.99 I10806.15 had10806.23 made10806.4 even10806.72 though10806.88 they10807.19 didn't10807.35 know10807.59 I'd10807.75 made10807.92 it.10808.07 I10808.8 chose10808.95 then10809.27 not10809.51 to10809.67 share.10809.83 I10811.46 will10811.62 tell10811.86 you10812.02 why10812.18 I10812.34 am10812.42 choosing10812.66 to10812.98 share10813.14 today.10813.46 A10814.58 report10814.74 last10815.14 year10815.38 revealed10815.62 that10815.94 location10816.18 data10816.58 that10816.98 included10817.22 people's10817.7 visits10818.02 to10818.34 nearly10818.5 60010818.82 Planned10819.46 Parenthood10819.7 locations,10820.18 including10820.66 in10821.14 Massachusetts,10821.38 was10822.58 sold10822.82 and10823.22 used10823.38 to10823.61 target10823.77 people10824.17 who10824.42 visited10824.58 Planned10824.9 Parenthood10825.14 in10825.77 a10825.85 nationwide10826.09 anti10826.82 abortion10827.14 campaign.10827.61 There10828.9 are10829.14 people10829.3 all10829.77 over10830.01 the10830.25 country10830.42 who10830.82 think10830.98 they10831.22 have10831.38 the10831.53 right10831.61 to10831.85 police10832.01 our10832.42 bodies,10832.66 my10833.22 body,10833.45 and10834.17 the10834.43 data10834.59 collected10834.83 on10835.31 our10835.47 phones10835.63 that10835.87 track10836.11 our10836.35 movements10836.51 to10836.91 help10836.91 them10837.07 do10837.31 that.10837.47 Let's10838.43 make10838.67 it10838.83 a10839.07 lot10839.15 harder10839.31 for10839.71 them10839.79 to10840.03 do10840.11 that.10840.27 Let's10841.39 make10841.63 Massachusetts10841.87 a10842.19 state10842.51 where10842.75 no10842.99 110843.15 can10843.23 access10843.47 your10843.79 location10843.95 data10844.35 without10844.59 your10844.83 consent,10845.07 where10845.87 the10846.11 only10846.27 way10846.51 you10846.67 will10846.83 know10847.07 my10847.23 choices10847.31 is10847.79 because10847.95 I10848.19 sit10848.43 in10848.67 this10848.75 room10848.92 and10849.15 I10849.4 choose10849.56 to10849.8 share10849.95 them.10850.19 Let's10850.92 continue10851.15 to10851.56 be10851.64 proud10851.8 of10852.11 this10852.27 place10852.43 that10852.67 we10852.75 call10852.92 home,10853.15 and10853.8 I10853.95 urge10854.03 the10854.35 committee10854.43 to10854.75 grant10854.92 this10855.15 bill10855.31 a10855.56 favorable10855.64 report.10856.19 Thank10856.67 you.10856.83
10857.31 FARLEY-BOUVIER10857.31 -10857.31 Thank10857.31 you.10857.48 Thank10857.72 you10857.95 all10858.11 for10858.27 your10858.51 testimonies.10858.67 I10859.15 do10859.23 have10859.48 a10859.64 question,10859.72 Doctor.10860.69 So10862.85 you10863.09 mentioned10863.41 that10863.97 there10864.45 you10864.93 know10865.25 a10865.41 patient10865.57 or10865.89 maybe10866.05 maybe10866.61 more10866.93 than10867.09 110867.25 who10867.49 leaves10867.81 their10868.13 cell10869.01 phone10869.25 at10869.49 home,10869.73 right,10870.53 to10870.85 protect,10871.01 them10872.7 from,10872.94 you10873.67 know,10873.98 having10874.15 a10874.55 location10874.63 generally.10875.58 So10876.39 if10876.7 that10877.02 same10877.34 patient10877.75 and10878.63 we10878.86 can10879.02 substitute10879.26 in10879.91 the10880.47 clinic10880.63 for10881.75 a10882.55 gay10882.7 bar,10883.02 a10883.98 synagogue,10884.23 any10886.12 place,10886.36 any10886.84 mental10887.32 health10887.72 facility,10888.6 anything10889.24 like10889.56 that.10889.72 But10889.96 let's10890.12 you10890.68 you10890.84 brought10891 up10891.24 this10891.32 example,10891.56 so10891.96 I10892.12 wanna10892.2 use10892.44 it.10892.68 How10893.8 did10894.04 they10894.2 figure10894.44 out10894.68 where10894.92 the10895.08 clinic10895.24 was?10895.72
10898.68 HARRIS10898.68 -10898.68 So10898.68 in10898.92 this10899.08 case,10899.32 you10899.72 know10899.88 what10899.92 I'm10899.95 saying?10900.2 Right?10900.44 This10901.35 was10901.59 a10901.92 patient10903.03 that10903.35 came10903.43 out10903.67 of10903.83 state,10904 and10904.48 they10904.88 were10905.27 with10905.51 a10905.67 friend10905.75 that10906 was10906.16 familiar10906.32 with10906.8 the10906.88 location10907.03 of10907.43 the10907.67 clinic.10909.03 But,10910 I10911.75 mean,10911.83 I10912.32 use10912.48 my10912.72 Google10913.77 Maps10914.01 or10914.41 my10914.57 everyday10914.89 to10915.29 get10915.45 to10915.53 work10915.61 even10915.85 though10916.09 I10916.17 go10916.25 there10916.49 all10916.65 the10916.81 time.10916.89
10917.93 FARLEY-BOUVIER10917.93 -10917.93 So,10917.93 but10917.93 could10917.93 they10918.09 have10918.33 Googled10918.49 the10918.81 address?10918.97
HARRIS10919.69 -10919.69 Not10919.69 with10919.85 the10920.01 phone10920.17 that10920.33 they10920.49 had.10920.65
10921.21 FARLEY-BOUVIER10921.21 -10921.21 Okay.10921.21 But10921.61 you10921.77 could10921.93 before10922.25 they10922.65 arrived.10923.61 Did10923.85 they10923.85 Google10924.09 where10924.49 to10924.65 go?10924.89 Yeah.10925.29 Did10925.74 they10925.98 say10926.14
10926.14 HARRIS10926.14 -10926.14 Yes.10926.3 They10926.53 did.10926.69
10927.17 FARLEY-BOUVIER10927.17 -10927.17 Is10927.17 it10927.33 safe10927.98 to10928.3 have10928.38 an10928.53 abortion?10928.69 Is10929.1 it10929.33 too10929.5 late10929.66 to10929.82 have10929.9 an10929.98 abortion?10930.06 They10930.45 could10930.53 have10930.69 Googled10930.77 all10931.17 that10931.33 information.10931.58
10932.06 HARRIS10932.06 -10932.06 They10932.06 did10932.14 a10932.22 lot10932.3 of10932.45 searching10932.53 in10932.85 order10933.02 to10933.25 get10933.33 that,10934.45 yeah.10934.45 Essential10934.45 health10934.94 care10935.1 to10935.25 get10935.42 to10935.5 Massachusetts.10935.66
FARLEY-BOUVIER10936.22 -10936.22 So10936.22 I10936.38 just10936.45 wanna10936.61 clarify10937.02 that10937.66 the10937.9 Location10937.98 Shield10938.72 Act10938.96 is10940.24 good10940.32 only10940.72 if10941.68 you're10943.12 tracking10943.44 the10943.92 exact10944.08 location10944.4 at10944.96 that10945.12 time10945.36 when10945.6 you10945.84 go.10946 But10946.4 all10946.72 the10947.04 other10947.2 ways10947.44 that10947.76 you10947.92 get10948.24 the10948.48 information10948.64 around10949.52 where10950.48 to10950.73 go,10950.89 trying10951.92 to10952.24 decide10952.48 what10952.89 you're10953.05 gonna10953.2 do,10953.44 all10953.92 that10954.16 information10954.32 is10954.81 not10955.05 covered10955.28 in10955.68 patient10956 feedback.10956.4 So10956.97 I10957.13 just10957.28 wanna10957.44 clarify10957.76 that10958.24 for10958.48 everybody.10958.65
10960.81 RICHGELS10960.81 -10960.81 I10960.81 absolutely10960.97 agree.10961.68 And10962.16 the10963.13 other10963.36 example10963.6 that10964.08 we10964.32 used,10964.56 it10966.08 comes10966.32 traveling10966.78 from10967.1 out10967.5 of10967.58 state,10967.66 from10968.06 Florida,10968.3 from10968.86 the10969.26 state10969.42 where10969.74 these10969.9 patients10970.14 came10970.54 from,10970.78 all10971.02 of10971.26 the10971.42 steps10971.5 that10971.9 they10972.06 had10972.3 to10972.54 take10972.62 online10972.94 to10974.22 figure10974.46 out,10974.78 you10975.1 know,10975.26 to10975.66 buy10975.82 a10976.06 plane10976.22 ticket,10976.54 to10977.26 search10977.66 where10977.98 to10978.3 go.10978.46 All10979.34 of10979.58 those10979.82 other10980.06 pieces10980.3 of10980.33 information,10980.37 you're10980.41 absolutely10980.44 right,10980.48 would10980.51 point10980.58 to10980.62 their10980.94 would10983.76 point10984 to10985.13 their10985.76 medical10986.17 decisions,10986.33 which10986.89 are10987.05 private.10987.2
FARLEY-BOUVIER10987.84 -10987.84 Yeah.10987.84 Thank10988.08 you.10988.33 I10988.81 really10988.97 do10989.13 appreciate10989.36 all10989.84 of10990.08 your10990.17 testimony.10990.41 Megan,10991.36 thank10991.84 you10992 for10992.89 sharing10993.05 your10993.36 story.10993.52 I10993.84 know10994 that10994.17 it's10994.33 not10994.49 easy10994.73 to10994.97 do,10995.13 but10995.6 you've10995.76 taken10996 the10996.33 decision10996.65 to10997.97 do10998.21 that10998.45 in10998.77 order10998.93 to10999.09 make10999.25 a10999.57 change.10999.57 It's11000.21 very11000.37 empowering.11000.61 Thank11001.01 you11001.25 very11001.41 much.11001.65 Thank11002.69 you.11003.01 Okay.11003.73 So,11004.21 Senator.11004.45
11008.05 MOORE11008.05 -11008.05 It's11008.05 actually11008.29 not11008.53 a11008.69 question,11008.77 Megan.11009.09 I11009.33 just11009.41 wanna11009.57 thank11009.81 you.11009.97 It's11010.05 very11010.29 hard11010.45 for11010.61 people11010.77 to11011.01 go11011.09 up11011.25 and11011.33 testify11011.33 in11011.34 front11011.35 of11011.35 strangers,11011.35 and11011.36 also,11011.36 virtually,11011.37 hybrid.11011.37 But11011.38 I11011.38 just11011.39 wanna11011.39 thank11011.4 you11011.4 for11011.4 coming11011.41 to11011.41 share,11015.59 strangers,11016.4 and11016.4 also,11016.43 virtually,11016.49 hybrid.11016.52 But11016.56 I11016.59 just11016.62 wanna11016.65 thank11016.68 you11016.72 for11016.88 coming,11017.03 sharing11017.43 your11017.75 story,11017.92 and11018.08 letting11018.23 us11018.64 know11018.72 what11019.59 you11019.75 went11019.92 through11020.16 and11020.31 what11020.95 we11021.19 should11021.35 be11021.51 looking11021.67 out11021.92 for11022.08 in11022.23 other11022.4 people.11022.64 So11022.95 thank11023.19 you.11023.43
11026 FARLEY-BOUVIER11026 -11026 Thank11026 you.11026.31 We11026.48 now11026.64 have11026.88 Elizabeth11027.11 Mahoney11027.75 from11028.4 the11028.56 Mass11028.72 High-tech11028.96 Council,11029.44 and,11030 on11030.96 deck,11031.2 is11031.52 Bruce11031.84 Schneider.11032.96 Schneider.11033.6 I'm11034.48 sure11034.64 I11034.96 got11035.28 that11035.52 111035.68 wrong.11035.92 Sorry.11036.56 Nice11039.84 to11040.16 see11040.32 you,11040.48 Elizabeth.11040.64 Thank11041.28 you.11041.44
11042.4 ELIZABETH11042.4 MAHONEY11042.4 -11042.4 MASSACHUSETTS11042.4 HIGH11042.4 TECHNOLOGY11042.4 COUNCIL11042.4 -11042.4 And11042.4 if11042.56 you11042.64 love11043.2 me11043.52 waiting.11048.99 Thank11048.99 you11049.15 to11049.31 the11049.39 chairs11049.47 and11049.78 the11049.94 committee11050.02 for11050.35 the11050.5 opportunity11050.58 to11051.07 testify.11051.31 My11052.27 name11052.42 is11052.5 Elizabeth11052.75 Mahoney,11053.15 and11053.55 I'm11053.7 the11053.78 vice11054.02 president11054.27 of11054.67 policy11054.75 and11055.23 government11055.31 affairs11055.78 for11056.1 the11056.27 Massachusetts11056.42 High11057.07 Technology11057.31 Council,11057.7 the11058.39 Commonwealth's11058.55 oldest11059.19 cross-sector11059.83 association11060.23 of11060.79 CEO11061.03 level11061.51 leaders11061.83 of11062.23 technology,11062.39 professional11063.35 services,11063.83 and11064.23 research11064.47 institutions.11064.95 The11066.39 council11066.63 and11066.87 its11067.03 members11067.27 are11067.51 very11067.67 engaged11067.83 in11068.15 the11068.31 issues11068.39 addressed11068.71 by11069.03 a11069.27 number11069.35 of11069.51 the11069.67 bills11069.75 before11070.07 you11070.31 today.11070.47 The11071.19 council's11071.35 mass11071.67 vision11072 2011072.24 5011072.56 initiative11072.88 is11073.27 a11073.44 multiyear11073.52 effort11074.08 to11074.32 bring11074.48 together11074.72 private,11075.11 public,11075.52 and11075.83 academic11076.08 leaders11076.48 with11076.88 an11077.03 eye11077.19 towards11077.44 supporting11077.75 the11078.16 key11078.32 sectors11078.56 that11079.27 are11079.44 likely11079.52 to11079.83 drive11080 employment11080.24 and11080.64 economic11080.88 growth11081.27 in11081.52 Massachusetts11081.67 in11082.32 the11082.48 coming11082.56 decades11082.88 and11083.52 ensuring11083.67 Massachusetts11084.08 is11084.67 a11084.75 leader11084.83 in11085.07 these11085.15 sectors.11085.39 MassVision11086.35 2011086.91 5011087.23 focuses11087.55 on11087.95 911088.11 sectors,11088.35 including11088.75 artificial11089.15 intelligence11089.71 and11090.19 cybersecurity.11090.43 The11091.47 council11091.71 is11092.03 grateful11092.19 to11092.51 the11092.67 legislature11092.75 for11093.31 supporting11093.55 a11093.95 hundred11094.03 million11094.27 dollars11094.59 in11094.83 funding11095.07 for11095.63 applied11095.87 AI11096.51 in11096.59 last11096.67 year's11096.91 economic11097.15 development11097.55 bill,11098.28 and11098.52 we11098.76 and11098.84 our11099 members11099.17 have11099.48 been11099.56 actively11099.73 engaged11100.13 with11100.44 the11100.6 Healy11100.68 administration11101.08 as11101.65 they11101.73 establish11101.97 a11102.44 mass11102.52 AI11102.84 hub.11103.08
11104.36 The11104.36 council11104.52 has11104.92 also11105.08 established11105.4 a11105.89 cybersecurity11105.97 community11106.76 with11107.25 our11107.4 members,11107.56 an11108.2 opportunity11108.36 for11108.84 member11109 CIOs11109.4 and11109.89 cyber11110.13 leads11110.44 to11110.76 share11110.92 best11111.25 practices11111.48 and11112.05 learn11112.28 from11112.52 other11112.76 content11113 experts.11113.33 We're11114.41 pleased11114.65 to11114.89 have11114.97 the11115.13 chairs11115.29 join11115.61 us11115.85 to11116.01 share11116.17 their11116.33 expertise11116.49 with11117.05 this11117.21 group11117.37 last11117.61 year.11117.93 The11118.73 council11118.89 shares11119.29 the11119.61 legislature's11119.77 goal11120.33 of11120.65 providing11120.81 robust11121.29 consumer11121.69 protections11122.17 and11122.73 appropriate11122.89 guardrails11123.37 around11123.93 new11124.25 and11124.41 emerging11124.57 technologies.11125.05 We11126.01 will11126.17 provide11126.33 more11126.65 detailed11126.81 thoughts11127.13 on11127.37 the11127.53 bills11127.61 for11127.85 you11128.09 in11128.25 our11128.41 written11128.49 testimony,11128.81 but11129.65 today,11129.97 I'd11130.13 like11130.28 to11130.52 offer11130.6 some11130.85 overarching11131.08 thoughts11131.57 on11131.89 how11132.05 to11132.2 achieve11132.36 these11132.69 shared11132.93 goals11133.17 while11133.49 also11133.73 supporting11134.05 the11134.52 growth11134.69 and11135.01 innovation11135.17 of11135.65 these11135.73 industries.11135.97 111137.08 of11137.33 the11137.41 challenges11137.57 of11138.05 regulating11138.2 areas11138.69 like11139.01 cybersecurity11139.25 and11139.89 artificial11140.13 intelligence11140.6 is11141.17 that11141.33 the11141.49 technology,11141.65 the11142.28 landscape,11142.44 and11143.01 the11143.08 potential11143.17 dangers11143.73 change11144.2 so11144.52 rapidly.11144.86 While11145.9 it11146.14 makes11146.22 sense11146.38 to11146.62 put11146.78 core11147.02 requirements11147.42 and11147.98 frameworks11148.14 in11148.7 statute,11148.94 the11149.42 council11149.58 appreciates11149.98 that11150.86 several11151.1 of11151.34 the11151.42 bills11151.58 before11151.82 you11152.14 establish11152.38 entities11152.78 within11153.26 state11153.66 government11153.9 charged11154.62 with11154.86 developing11155.1 detailed11155.58 rules11156.06 and11156.3 regulations11156.54 around11157.26 AI11157.66 and11157.9 cybersecurity11158.14 standards.11158.94 This11159.82 will11160.06 allow11160.22 the11160.55 state11160.55 government11160.86 to11161.18 be11161.34 nimble11161.5 and11161.91 responsive11162.15 to11162.63 changing11162.78 needs11163.18 and11163.5 circumstances.11163.75
11165.18 Including11165.18 representatives11165.75 from11166.23 impacted11166.47 industries11166.94 on11167.34 these11167.5 boards11167.67 also11168.39 provides11168.7 an11169.02 opportunity11169.26 for11169.83 subject11169.98 matter11170.31 experts11170.63 to11171.34 ensure11171.5 any11171.91 impacts11172.15 on11172.47 these11172.63 industries11172.86 are11173.34 carefully11173.42 considered.11173.98 The11175.41 council11175.65 also11175.97 appreciates11176.29 the11176.69 recognition11176.85 that11177.41 smaller11177.65 businesses11177.97 may11178.53 have11178.69 different11178.85 abilities11179.17 and11179.57 challenges11179.81 when11180.29 it11180.45 comes11180.53 to11180.69 implementing11180.93 cyber11181.57 security11181.97 measures.11182.37 Another11183.49 challenge11183.89 for11184.21 the11184.37 state11184.45 regulation11184.77 of11185.25 AI11185.49 and11185.73 cyber,11185.97 and11187.25 data11187.65 security11187.97 is11188.37 situating11188.61 this11189.09 regulation11189.33 within11190.03 the11190.19 existing11190.35 federal11190.75 and11191.08 other11191.24 state11191.48 frameworks,11191.8 with11193.48 which11193.72 companies11194.44 must11195 comply.11195.24 To11196.27 make11196.44 it11196.59 easier11196.75 for11197 businesses11197.16 to11197.64 comply,11197.8 we11198.11 do11198.35 support11198.51 efforts11198.83 to11199.24 align11199.4 with11199.88 existing11200.11 standards11200.51 and11201 best11201.16 practices11201.32 to11201.95 the11202.03 extent11202.11 possible11202.51 and11203.32 to11203.48 avoid11203.64 duplicative11203.88 reporting11204.51 requirements11205.17 for11205.33 certain11205.57 cyber11205.97 incidents11206.29 when11206.69 appropriate.11207.01 While11207.97 there11208.21 are11208.37 many11208.45 challenges11208.69 to11209.09 consider11209.25 with11209.57 these11209.73 new11209.89 technologies,11210.13 there's11210.69 also11211.01 an11211.25 opportunity11211.41 for11211.89 Massachusetts11212.05 to11212.69 be11212.77 a11212.89 global11213.01 leader11213.41 in11213.65 the11213.81 innovation11213.89 and11214.37 development11214.45 of11214.93 these11215.01 sectors11215.25 while11215.57 also11215.81 protecting11216.13 consumers.11216.53 We11217.41 will11217.57 be11217.73 submitting11217.81 written11218.21 testimony11218.53 with11219.01 more11219.17 detailed11219.41 input,11219.73 and11220.29 the11220.45 council11220.82 welcomes11221.06 the11221.22 opportunity11221.38 to11221.94 continue11222.1 to11222.5 engage11222.66 with11222.9 this11223.06 committee11223.22 on11223.53 these11223.69 topics11223.94 and11224.33 share11224.5 the11224.74 insights11224.9 and11225.3 recommendations11225.45 of11226.18 our11226.25 members.11226.5
11227.45 SPEAKER511227.45 -11227.45 Thank11227.45 you,11227.61 Elizabeth.11227.85 211228.1 seconds.11228.25
11228.66 FARLEY-BOUVIER11228.66 -11228.66 You11228.66 did11228.74 really11229.14 well11229.38 practice11229.69 or11230.82 something.11231.06 So11232.74 we11232.9 shifted11233.38 a11233.77 little11233.85 bit11234.1 talking11234.33 about11234.66 the11234.9 sec11234.98 security11235.38 bills,11235.85 but11236.4 we11236.48 see11236.72 how11236.8 this11237.12 all11237.28 comes11237.52 together.11237.76 But11238.16 I11238.32 just11238.4 wanna11238.64 check.11238.88 Senators,11239.84 are11240.32 you11240.4 good?11240.56 Anybody11241.12 else11241.44 on11241.6 the11241.76 committee?11241.84 Thank11243.12 you.11243.36
11243.6 SPEAKER711243.6 -11243.6 Thank11243.6 you.11243.76 Thank11243.92 you11244.08 so11244.32 much.11244.4
FARLEY-BOUVIER11244.64 -11244.64 Looking11244.64 forward11244.88 to11245.2 continuing11245.28 to11245.6 work11245.76 with11245.92 you.11246.08 Absolutely.11246.24 We11247.6 now11248 have11248.32 Bruce11248.32 Schneier.11248.72 And,11249.36 up11250.53 on11250.85 deck,11251.17 virtually11251.98 is11252.61 Haley11252.93 Tukayama.11254.53 Bruce11256.61 here?11256.85 No.11257.82 Okay.11258.77 So,11259.33 Haley,11259.74 I11260.14 didn't11260.3 give11260.53 you11260.69 a11261.01 very11261.25 long11261.58 heads11261.82 up11262.14 that11262.3 you're11262.38 coming11262.69 up.11263.01 Are11263.17 you11263.41 there,11263.49 Haley?11263.65 And11264.45 then11264.61 we11264.85 have11265.01 Jonathan11265.57 Cohen11266.05 after11267.01 Haley.11267.49
11269.25 SPEAKER4311269.25 -11269.25 I11269.25 am11269.41 here.11269.57 Hello.11269.89
11270.13 FARLEY-BOUVIER11270.13 -11270.13 How11270.13 are11270.29 you?11270.45 Terrific.11270.61 Thank11272.13 you11272.37 so11272.69 much.11272.93
HAYLEY11274.29 TSUKAYAMA11274.29 -11274.29 EFF11274.29 -11274.29 HB11274.29 8611274.29 -11274.29 SB11274.29 19711274.29 -11274.29 (11274.29 R11274.29 )11274.29 -11274.29 Thanks11274.29 for11274.53 allowing11274.85 me11275.17 to11275.42 speak11275.5 today.11275.67 So,11276.78 good11277.02 afternoon.11277.26 My11277.75 name11277.98 is11278.06 Hayley11278.23 Tsgayama.11278.63 I'm11279.26 speaking11279.42 today11279.75 on11280.06 behalf11280.23 of11280.55 the11280.7 Electronic11280.94 Frontier11281.5 Foundation,11281.91 or11282.31 EFF,11282.63 in11283.42 strong11283.58 support11283.91 of11284.31 H8611284.47 S197,11285.26 the11286.31 Location11286.47 Shield11286.94 Act.11287.26 EFF11288.06 is11288.47 a11288.63 nonprofit,11288.78 nonpartisan,11289.5 3511290.39 year11290.86 old11291.1 digital11291.3 rights11291.62 organization11292.02 that11292.58 fights11292.82 for11293.06 civil11293.22 liberties11293.54 in11294.02 the11294.18 digital11294.34 age.11294.74 We11295.46 have11295.62 more11295.78 than11296.02 30,00011296.1 supporters11296.74 across11297.14 the11297.54 country,11297.62 including11298.1 in11298.42 Massachusetts,11298.66 and11299.3 we11299.46 advocate11299.46 for11299.86 policies11300.02 that11300.5 protect11300.66 people's11300.98 privacy11301.38 and11301.86 encourage11302.02 innovation.11302.5 Thank11303.54 you11303.7 all11303.86 for11304.1 your11304.26 commitment11304.42 to11304.82 enacting11305.06 robust,11305.53 meaningful11305.94 data11306.33 privacy11306.66 legislation11307.14 to11307.69 protect11307.77 all11308.17 people11308.33 in11308.66 Massachusetts11308.82 from11309.61 inappropriate11309.85 surveillance11310.5 and11311.38 exploitation11311.61 of11312.25 their11312.5 personal11312.66 information.11313.06 We11314.01 deeply11314.33 appreciate11314.74 the11315.22 leadership11315.38 the11315.85 chairs11316.01 have11316.33 demonstrated11316.5 by11317.06 recognizing11317.3 the11317.85 need11317.94 for11318.17 strong11318.33 consumer11318.66 data11319.13 privacy11319.37 laws.11319.61 The11320.49 Location11320.73 Shield11321.13 Act11321.45 would11321.69 ban11321.77 the11322.01 sale11322.09 of11322.33 all11322.41 cell11322.65 phone11322.81 location11323.05 data11323.45 in11323.77 the11323.85 Commonwealth11324.01 with11324.57 reasonable11324.73 exceptions.11325.37 This11326.01 is11326.17 a11326.33 crucial11326.41 privacy11326.89 protection.11327.29 There11328.25 are11328.41 many11328.57 reasons11328.81 why11329.21 location11329.37 privacy11329.77 is11330.25 particularly11330.41 important.11331.21
11332.25 Where11332.25 we11332.49 go11332.57 says11332.89 a11333.13 lot11333.21 about11333.37 who11333.7 we11333.86 are.11334.02 Location11334.67 information11335.15 can11335.55 reveal11335.78 where11336.18 we11336.34 live,11336.58 where11336.91 we11337.07 work,11337.23 where11337.63 our11337.78 children11337.86 go11338.18 to11338.42 school,11338.5 what11338.91 organizations,11339.31 support11340.02 services,11340.42 and11340.91 businesses11341.15 we11341.7 may11341.86 frequent,11342.02 and11342.67 where11342.83 we11342.99 worship.11343.15 It's11343.94 very11344.26 easy11344.58 to11344.91 re-identify11345.39 people11345.86 based11346.18 on11346.5 their11346.67 location11346.83 information,11347.39 particularly11348.26 if11348.99 the11349.44 information11349.6 set11350.32 captures11350.64 habitual11351.2 trips,11351.68 such11352 as11352.24 commutes.11352.48 Corporations11353.68 eye11354.48 this11354.8 information11355.04 for11355.52 profit,11355.76 disclosing11356.24 huge11356.72 quantities11357.12 of11357.52 often11357.76 sensitive,11358.08 granular11358.64 data11359.12 about11359.52 all11359.76 of11359.92 us11360 in11360.24 ways11360.48 a11360.72 normal11360.88 person11361.2 would11361.52 never11361.76 expect,11362.08 and11362.8 they11363.04 sell11363.2 it11363.44 to11363.6 whoever11363.76 can11364.24 pay11364.32 them11364.52 for11364.6 it.11364.85 Companies11365.49 have11365.97 also11366.13 shown11366.36 that11366.69 despite11366.93 the11367.25 clear11367.41 risks11367.73 that11367.97 the11368.2 sale11368.28 of11368.6 this11368.69 information11368.85 can11369.33 present11369.49 to11369.81 individual11370.05 people,11370.6 the11371.25 business11371.41 motivation11371.81 of11372.28 profit11372.44 outweighs11372.85 the11373.57 willingness11373.57 to11374.13 change11374.36 any11374.69 practice.11374.85
11374.87 That's11374.87 why11374.89 it's11374.92 important11374.94 for11374.97 the11374.99 legislature11375.01 to11375.04 weigh11375.06 in.11375.08 This11375.57 vulnerable11381.21 population11381.77 such11382.17 as11382.49 immigrants11382.65 to11382.97 this11383.05 country11383.37 who11383.93 may11384.01 be11384.17 rightfully11384.33 wary11384.81 of11385.37 location11385.45 tracking11386.17 happening11386.65 as11387.05 they11387.21 go11387.37 about11387.45 their11387.69 daily11387.85 lives.11388.25 The11388.81 same11388.97 may11389.21 be11389.37 true11389.45 of11389.61 domestic11389.88 violence11390.11 victims11390.59 who11391 wish11391.23 to11391.4 conceal11391.56 their11391.88 location11392.11 or11392.83 people11393.23 who11393.56 are11393.72 merely11393.95 attending11394.35 protests11394.75 or11395.15 rallies.11395.31 The11396.11 truth11396.35 is11396.59 that11396.75 everyone11397 deserves11397.4 location11397.88 privacy.11398.27 We11399.08 all11399.23 have11399.4 moments11399.64 in11399.95 our11400.11 lives11400.27 where11400.59 our11400.75 movements11400.92 make11401.4 us11401.64 vulnerable.11401.8 No11402.66 111402.82 wants11403.06 to11403.18 have11403.3 all11403.54 of11403.7 their11403.78 movements11403.94 tracked,11404.34 and11404.74 no11404.9 111405.06 should11405.22 have11405.38 to11405.62 worry11405.7 that11405.94 information11406.42 about11406.98 their11407.3 daily11407.46 lives11407.78 will11408.1 be11408.18 weaponized11408.42 against11408.98 them.11409.3 The11410.02 Location11410.18 Shield11410.58 Act11410.9 is11411.06 a11411.14 common-sense11411.62 measure11411.86 that11412.1 protects11412.26 this11412.66 data11412.74 from11413.06 unexpected11413.3 sale11414.02 while11414.58 also11414.82 letting11415.14 consumers11415.38 elect11415.43 to11415.48 use11415.53 technologies11415.58 that11415.63 require11415.68 location11415.73 data.11428.55 Thank11428.55 you11428.78 for11428.86 your11429.19 attention11429.27 and11429.67 your11429.83 consideration.11429.91
11431.38 FARLEY-BOUVIER11431.38 -11431.38 Thank11431.38 you,11431.54 Haley.11431.86 I'm11432.18 gonna11432.26 turn11432.5 to11432.74 the11432.82 committee,11432.9 see11433.22 if11433.34 there11433.46 are11433.7 any11433.7 questions.11433.94 Appreciate11435.7 your11436.18 perspective.11436.42 We're11437.3 now11437.54 gonna11437.7 move11438.02 to11438.18 Jonathan11438.42 Cohen11438.9 from11439.22 Progressive11439.46 Massachusetts,11439.86 and11440.98 on11441.3 deck11441.46 will11441.7 be11441.94 Don11442.26 Bell.11442.82
11451.75 JONATHAN11451.75 COHN11451.75 -11451.75 PROGRESSIVE11451.75 MASSACHUSETTS11451.75 -11451.75 S19711451.75 -11451.75 HB11451.75 8611451.75 -11451.75 Chair.11451.75 Good?11453.26 Okay.11453.58 Awesome.11453.9 Thank11454.55 you11454.94 so11455.1 much.11455.26 Chair11455.98 Farley-Bouvier,11456.94 Chair11457.18 Moore,11457.18 and11457.42 members11457.58 of11457.9 the11458.06 joint11458.23 committee11458.47 on11458.94 advanced11459.18 information11459.58 technology,11460.15 Internet,11460.7 and11461.21 cyber11461.21 security.11461.53 My11462.57 name11462.73 is11462.81 Jonathan11462.97 Cohn.11463.37 I'm11463.61 the11463.69 policy11463.85 director11464.17 of11464.41 Progressive11464.57 Massachusetts,11464.97 a11466.09 statewide11466.09 advocacy,11466.57 grassroots11467.21 advocacy11467.69 group11468.09 fighting11468.33 for11468.57 a11468.73 more11468.81 equitable,11468.97 just,11469.37 sustainable,11469.69 and11470.17 democratic11470.25 commonwealth.11470.81 As11472.25 many11472.41 others11472.73 have11472.97 done11473.29 before,11473.61 we11474.17 urge11474.33 you11474.57 to11474.65 give11474.81 a11474.97 favorable11475.05 report11475.53 to11475.85 S11477.16 197,11477.56 which11477.56 enacts11477.56 to11477.56 protect11477.88 safety11478.27 and11478.6 privacy11478.76 by11479.16 stopping11479.32 the11479.64 sale11479.72 of11479.95 location11480.03 data,11480.44 and11481 H11481.24 86,11481.48 which11482.03 enacts11482.35 to11482.35 protect11482.44 location11482.83 privacy.11483.24 There11484.76 were11485 many11485.16 other11485.4 excellent11485.56 bills11485.88 that11486.19 people11486.35 testified11486.68 on11487.08 today,11487.24 and11487.48 so11487.64 I'll11487.88 give11488.03 a11488.19 shout-out11488.44 to11488.6 those11488.68 of11488.92 the11489 many11489.16 steps11489.4 to11490.35 support11490.52 privacy11490.83 rights.11491.32 To11492.57 give11492.73 a11492.89 recent11493.05 example,11493.45 this11494.25 Saturday,11494.49 tens11495.21 of11495.45 thousands11495.53 of11495.93 Massachusetts11496.01 residents11496.81 rallied11497.29 to11497.69 protest,11497.85 kind11498.73 of11498.89 the11499.05 chaos,11499.13 cruelty,11499.53 and11499.77 encryption11499.77 of11500.17 the11500.25 Trump11500.41 administration.11500.65 That11501.69 may11501.85 include11502.01 some11502.33 of11502.57 you.11502.65 Here,11503.29 if11504.09 you11504.17 attended11504.25 a11504.65 rally,11504.73 you11505.05 know11505.21 when11505.37 you11505.61 arrived11505.69 and11506.09 when11506.17 you11506.4 left11506.64 and11506.88 where11507.11 you11507.35 went11507.51 next.11507.67 Your11508.72 friends11508.95 and11509.11 family11509.27 might11509.67 not11509.83 know11510.8 that11510.95 too11511.11 if11511.35 you11511.51 texted11511.59 them.11511.91 But11513.35 do11514.07 you11514.15 know11514.23 who11514.4 doesn't11514.64 need11514.95 to11515.11 know11515.19 that11515.35 information?11515.59 Somebody11516.31 like11516.64 Elon11516.88 Musk,11517.19 bad11517.75 actors11517.99 seeking11518.4 to11518.64 surveil,11518.8 protesters11519.89 exercising11520.29 their11520.85 first11521.09 amendment11521.25 rights,11521.65 the11522.21 list11522.37 goes11522.61 on.11522.85
11523.97 As11523.97 folks11524.21 before11524.45 me11524.69 have11524.85 noted,11525.09 right11525.49 now,11525.57 there's11525.81 there11526.13 are11526.37 no11526.53 laws11526.69 preventing11527.01 anyone11527.97 with11528.37 a11528.53 credit11528.61 card11528.93 from11529.09 purchasing11529.25 cell11529.73 phone11529.97 location11530.13 data.11530.61 The11531.57 purchase11531.65 and11532.05 sale11532.13 of11532.52 that11532.6 data11532.77 can11533.17 empower11533.41 bad11533.81 actors.11534.05 Right-wing11534.93 extremists11535.25 seeking11535.73 to11535.97 target11536.05 individuals11536.44 seeking11537.01 abortion11537.25 care11537.65 or11537.89 gender11538.05 affirming11538.36 care,11538.85 domestic11539.41 abusers11539.89 seeking11540.36 to11540.6 track11540.77 their11541.01 victims,11541.25 predatory11542.05 bosses11542.69 seeking11543.17 to11543.49 spy11543.57 on11543.81 their11543.89 employees,11544.13 and11544.76 the11545 list11545.08 goes11545.4 on.11545.64 And11546.52 by11546.68 attacking11546.84 privacy11547.88 rights,11548.2 it11549.56 also11549.8 weakens11550.2 the11550.52 basic11550.68 rights11551 of11551.24 free11551.4 expression11551.64 and11551.96 dissent11552.12 in11552.44 democracy.11552.6 We11553.88 have11553.96 already11554.12 seen,11554.92 as11555.4 folks11555.4 before11555.64 me11555.88 have11556.04 noted,11556.2 that11556.52 the11556.6 Trump11557.48 administration11557.72 detained11558.2 and11558.52 threatened11558.68 to11559 deport11559.08 students11559.48 merely11560.02 for11560.18 the11560.34 act11560.58 of11560.82 attending11560.98 protests,11561.53 and11562.42 they11562.58 are11562.74 not11562.9 subtle11563.14 about11563.45 their11563.69 desire11563.94 to11564.34 ramp11564.5 up11564.74 targeting11564.9 and11565.45 to11565.61 target11565.77 citizens11566.1 as11566.66 well.11566.74 And11567.61 we11567.77 should11567.94 not11568.1 be11568.26 giving11568.42 them11568.74 any11569.22 more11569.45 tools11569.61 to11570.02 do11570.1 so.11570.26 Azure11571.3 Chamber11571.69 deliberates11572.02 on11572.58 our11572.74 Commonwealth's11572.82 response11573.45 to11573.94 what's11574.18 happening11574.42 in11574.82 DC.11574.9 We11576 urge11576.16 you11576.32 to11576.4 make11576.56 this11576.72 bill11576.88 a11577.04 part11577.2 of11577.44 it.11577.52 211578.32 5011578.56 years11578.88 ago11579.12 this11579.44 month,11579.6 Massachusetts11580.08 was11580.72 the11580.96 site11581.04 of11581.28 taking11581.36 a11581.68 stand11581.84 against11582.08 the11582.4 abuses11582.56 of11582.88 civil11583.44 liberties,11583.84 and11585.12 so11585.28 that's11585.44 a11585.6 legacy11585.68 that11586.08 we11586.24 should11586.32 continue.11586.56 So11587.12 thank11587.36 you11587.52 again11587.68 for11588 being11588.16 here11588.4 this11588.56 afternoon.11588.8
11589.52 FARLEY-BOUVIER11589.52 -11589.52 Thank11589.52 you,11589.76 Jonathan.11590 Any11591.6 questions11591.84 from11592.32 the11592.48 committee?11592.56 We11593.92 appreciate11594.08 it.11594.64
11594.88 COHN11594.88 -11594.88 Thank11594.88 you11595.03 so11595.19 much.11595.35
FARLEY-BOUVIER11596.48 -11596.48 Okay.11596.48 So11597.03 we11597.35 understand11597.52 Don,11598.16 isn't11598.95 able11599.27 to11599.68 wasn't11600 able11600.32 to11600.56 stay.11600.72 And11601.27 so11601.44 we're11601.68 gonna11601.92 go11602.24 to11602.48 Amy11602.72 Van11603.84 der11604.08 Heil,11604.48 who's11605.52 online.11605.92 And11607 then11607.16 up11607.48 next11607.72 is11608.12 a11608.44 panel11608.68 led11609.16 by11609.48 Mel11609.96 De11610.44 Silva.11610.6 Amy,11612.12 are11612.6 you11612.76 with11612.84 us?11613.08
11616.6 SPEAKER1511616.6 -11616.6 I11616.6 am.11616.84 Thank11617.08 you11617.24 very11617.4 much.11617.64
FARLEY-BOUVIER11618.2 -11618.2 Excellent.11618.2 I11619.56 hear11619.64 you11619.88 well.11620.04
11620.28 AMY11620.28 VAN11620.28 DER11620.28 HIEL11620.28 -11620.28 CONCERNED11620.28 CITIZEN11620.44 -11620.44 HB11620.44 8611620.44 -11620.44 (11620.44 R11620.44 )Thank11620.44 you11620.44 very11620.6 much.11620.84 Thank11622.42 you11622.58 to11623.23 the11623.39 members11623.7 of11624.02 this11624.18 committee.11624.42 My11625.47 name11625.55 is11625.7 Amy11625.86 Van11626.18 Der11626.58 Hiel,11626.58 and11626.58 I11626.75 live11626.83 in11627.06 Maynard,11627.23 Massachusetts.11627.63 I'm11628.9 here11629.15 in11629.39 support11629.55 of11630.02 Bill11630.18 H86.11630.67 I'm11632.5 testifying11632.75 in11633.39 support11633.55 of11633.86 this11633.94 bill11634.1 to11634.42 prohibit11634.67 companies11635.06 from11635.55 selling11635.78 our11636.02 location11636.26 data.11636.75 It's11638.15 an11638.31 urgent11638.47 and11638.79 powerful11639.03 opportunity11639.67 for11640.15 our11640.39 legislators11640.63 to11641.43 step11641.59 forward11641.91 to11642.63 protect11642.79 the11643.11 privacy11643.19 of11643.67 the11643.75 people11643.91 of11644.31 Massachusetts.11644.55 Although11645.43 I'm11645.83 speaking11646.07 as11646.47 a11646.55 private11646.63 citizen,11647.03 not11647.99 from11648.15 my11648.39 employer,11648.55 I've11649.27 worked11649.43 in11649.67 the11649.75 Web11649.83 technology11650.07 field11650.63 for11650.95 more11651.11 than11651.27 2011651.43 years.11651.83 We've11652.68 all11652.92 seen11653.16 incredible11653.48 innovations11653.95 like11654.6 the11654.83 web11654.92 and11655.56 smartphones11655.8 in11656.44 the11656.52 past11656.68 decades11656.92 and11657.24 how11657.4 they've11657.56 all11657.72 changed11657.95 our11658.27 lives,11658.44 enabled11659.4 us11659.88 to11660.11 access11660.27 much11660.68 of11660.92 the11661.08 combined11661.16 knowledge11661.64 of11661.88 the11661.95 world,11662.03 and11662.35 be11662.52 connected11662.68 in11663.16 ways11663.32 never11663.72 before11664.03 imagined.11664.35 It's11665.32 even11665.56 allowed11665.72 us11665.96 to11666.2 participate11666.36 in11666.84 democracy11667.16 in11667.56 new11667.8 ways,11667.96 like11668.28 me11668.44 being11668.68 able11668.84 to11669.08 attend11669.32 this11669.56 hearing11669.8 and11670.6 testify11670.84 to11671.32 you11671.48 now,11671.56 for11671.88 which11672.04 I'm11672.28 grateful.11672.44 However,11673.88 just11674.36 as11674.6 these11674.76 technologies11675 allow11675.64 us11675.88 to11676.04 connect11676.12 in11676.44 wonderful11676.68 ways,11677.08 we've11677.52 sadly11677.77 learned11678.17 over11678.49 and11678.73 over11678.89 that11679.05 they11679.28 can11679.36 be11679.52 misused11679.77 to11680.73 take11680.89 advantage11681.13 of11681.44 us11681.6 or11681.77 even11682 in11682.33 dangerous.11682.49 As11683.52 has11683.77 been11683.85 noted11684.08 before,11684.41 privacy11684.81 is11685.28 a11685.36 human11685.52 right.11685.77 In11686.81 2019,11687.05 the11687.77 U.N.11688
11688.17 Human11688.17 Rights11688.33 Council11688.65 declared11689.05 that11689.44 the11689.6 same11689.77 rights11690 that11690.41 people11690.57 have11690.97 offline11691.28 must11692.25 also11692.41 be11692.81 protected11693.05 online,11693.69 including11694.17 the11694.65 right11694.81 to11694.97 privacy.11695.13 However,11696.57 these11696.97 technologies11697.21 we11697.77 use11697.93 have11698.17 become11698.33 so11698.73 complex11698.97 that11699.37 it11699.53 can11699.61 feel11699.77 almost11700.01 impossible11700.33 for11700.89 us11701.05 to11701.21 protect11701.37 our11701.77 data,11702.01 even11702.97 as11703.21 individuals,11703.37 since11704.02 location11704.27 and11704.83 identifying11705.07 data11705.7 can11706.1 be11706.35 gathered11706.5 from11706.91 so11707.15 many11707.31 different11707.55 sources,11707.86 including11708.67 GPS,11709.31 Wi11709.94 Fi,11710.1 Bluetooth,11710.5 innocent11711.55 seeming11712.02 apps,11712.5 and11712.75 even11712.99 motion11713.31 sensors11713.7 on11714.19 our11714.35 phones.11714.58 As11715.55 so11715.7 many11715.86 people11716.1 have11716.35 said,11716.5 data11716.83 about11717.55 where11717.78 we11717.94 go11718.1 and11718.19 whom11718.35 we11718.58 see11718.75 should11718.99 not11719.15 be11719.31 for11719.77 sale11719.93 to11720.17 the11720.21 highest11720.25 bidder.11720.73 Without11721.69 such11722.01 a11722.25 law11722.33 that11722.57 protects11722.73 our11723.21 data,11723.45 Massachusetts11723.85 residents11724.41 and11725.05 visitors11725.29 face11725.77 growing11726.09 new11726.49 threats11726.65 to11727.37 our11727.53 fundamental11727.69 freedoms11728.17 and11728.57 our11728.81 personal11728.97 safety,11729.37 as11729.69 so11729.93 many11730.17 here11730.41 have11730.73 so11730.97 well11731.21 described.11731.45 This11732.5 bill11732.66 strongly11732.82 protects11733.3 us,11733.53 and11733.77 it's11734.01 more11734.25 than11734.5 fair11734.82 in11735.61 that11735.77 it11736.01 simply11736.17 requires11736.5 companies11736.98 who11737.3 want11737.53 to11737.69 use11737.77 our11737.93 data11738.09 to11738.42 get11738.5 our11738.66 consent11738.82 first,11739.22 and11739.45 it11739.69 still11739.77 allows11740.09 for11740.42 positive11740.66 use,11741.06 such11741.77 as11742.01 during11742.17 emergencies.11742.5 I11743.53 ask11743.61 all11743.85 of11744.01 you11744.09 to11744.25 please11744.43 pass11744.67 this11744.91 important11745.15 bill11745.47 to11745.71 protect11745.87 the11746.27 people11746.35 of11746.67 Massachusetts.11746.75 I11747.87 want11748.03 to11748.19 thank11748.27 the11748.51 committee11748.67 and11748.99 its11749.23 chairs,11749.39 Senator11750.11 Michael11750.51 Moore11750.75 and11750.99 Representative11751.23 Tricia11751.71 Fairley11752.11 Bovier,11752.83 as11753.47 well11753.71 as11753.87 the11753.95 sponsors11754.11 and11754.59 cosponsors11754.75 of11755.39 the11755.55 bill,11755.71 which11756.11 I'm11756.35 proud11756.51 to11756.75 say11756.83 include11757.07 my11757.39 own11757.55 Senator11758.11 James11758.67 B.11758.99 Eldridge,11759.23 for11760.38 all11760.61 your11760.85 work11760.94 to11761.25 stand11761.33 strong11761.66 and11762.06 to11762.3 fight11762.45 to11762.61 protect11762.69 the11763.02 liberty,11763.17 freedom,11763.66 and11763.98 privacy11764.22 of11764.69 the11764.94 people11765.1 of11765.42 our11765.5 state.11765.66 Thank11766.3 you11766.53 for11766.69 your11766.85 public11767.02 service11767.33 and11767.66 your11767.74 dedication11767.98 to11768.45 the11768.61 people11768.69 of11768.94 Massachusetts.11769.1
FARLEY-BOUVIER11770.06 -11770.06 Thank11770.06 you11770.3 so11770.45 much,11770.69 Amy.11771.02 To11771.82 the11771.9 committee?11772.06 Anybody?11772.77 Thank11773.66 you.11773.98 We're11774.94 now11775.1 gonna11775.18 move11775.66 to11775.9 a11776.3 panel11777.1 led11777.74 by11777.9 Mel11778.14 DeSilvia.11778.54 And11780.14 on11781.18 deck11781.58 is11782.14 another11782.46 panel11782.94 led11783.5 by11783.74 Cindy11783.98 Roe.11784.38 Do11791.48 we11791.72 need11791.88 another11792.03 chair11792.43 pulled11792.92 in?11793.23 I11795.07 have11795.23 another11795.48 chair.11795.72 Okay.11795.88 I'll11796.8 be11797.72 welcome.11797.88 I'll11798.43 get11798.51 you11798.67 both.11798.75 Do11798.92 you11799.07 care11799.23 who11799.4 starts?11799.65
11804.24 SPEAKER3611804.24 -11804.24 Do11804.24 you11804.4 care11804.48 who11804.64 starts?11804.8
11805.2 FARLEY-BOUVIER11805.2 -11805.2 No.11805.2 I11805.36 do11805.52 not11805.68 care11805.84 who11806.08 starts.11806.16
11807.28 SPEAKER1611807.28 -11807.28 Alright.11807.28
11807.68 FARLEY-BOUVIER11807.68 -11807.68 You11807.68 guys11807.76 decide11808 amongst11808.4 yourselves.11808.8 Cool.11809.28 Yeah.11809.6 We11809.84 sort11810.16 of11810.4 did.11810.8 Okay.11811.2
11811.6 ARLENE11811.6 ISAACSON11811.6 -11811.6 MASSACHUSETTS11811.6 GLBTQ11811.6 -11811.6 HB11811.6 7811811.6 -11811.6 SB11811.6 45-11811.6 The,11811.6 good11813.2 afternoon.11813.52 For11814 the11814.24 record,11814.4 my11814.72 name11814.88 is11815.04 Arlene11815.2 Isaacson.11815.69 I'm11816.18 testifying11816.33 today11816.98 in11817.22 my11817.38 capacity11817.61 as11818.5 the11818.74 co-chair11818.98 of11819.22 the11819.3 Massachusetts11819.45 GLBTQ11820.1 political11820.98 caucus,11821.38 formerly11822.58 the11823.14 mass11823.3 gay11823.45 and11823.61 lesbian11823.77 political11824.18 caucus.11824.58 I11825.45 wanna11825.61 start11826.1 by11826.66 thanking11827.3 the11827.69 chairs11827.85 for11828.9 filing11829.14 strong,11829.69 terrifically11830.5 important11830.69 privacy11831.77 legislation,11832.33 data11833.21 privacy11833.53 legislation,11834.09 House11834.89 78,11835.21 Senate11836.17 45.11836.97 My11837.77 testimony11838.01 today11838.73 will11840.09 be11840.25 in11840.49 support11840.65 of11841.53 those11841.61 bills11841.85 and11842.09 the11842.25 other11842.41 data11842.57 several11843.13 other11843.45 data11843.61 privacy11843.93 bills,11844.33 but11844.57 I'll11844.73 be11844.89 focusing11845.05 on11845.98 location11846.22 privacy11847.25 in11847.82 particular11848.06 because11848.77 of11849.09 the11849.17 shortness11849.25 of11849.66 the11849.82 time,11849.9 of11850.06 course.11850.22 So11850.45 House11850.69 8711851.02 and11851.58 Senate11852.38 197.11852.94 But11852.94 I11853.09 don't11853.17 want11853.42 that11853.58 to11853.74 overshadow11853.82 our11854.69 support11854.94 for11855.25 the11855.42 chair's11855.58 bills,11855.9 as11857.02 well11857.17 as11857.33 Senate11857.5 2911857.82 and11858.3 House11859.17 104.11859.84 I'm11859.84 speaking11860.32 specifically11860.88 from11861.36 the11861.52 vantage11861.6 point11861.92 of11862.08 the11862.16 LGBTQ11862.32 community.11863.2 Many11864.56 people11864.96 in11865.36 our11865.6 community,11865.84 many11867.36 folks11867.6 in11867.84 the11868 LGBTQ11868.16 community,11869.04 in11870.24 this11870.4 world,11870.64 don't11871.2 feel11871.44 particularly11872.86 safe.11873.35 Lots11874.7 of11874.94 us11875.1 are11875.67 not11875.91 yet11876.07 out11876.39 of11876.63 the11876.78 closet.11876.86 I11877.19 shouldn't11877.35 say11877.58 us11877.75 in11877.91 that11878.07 case,11878.23 obviously.11878.47 But11880.94 there11881.19 are11881.35 plenty11881.51 of11881.91 plenty11882.15 of11882.47 my11882.63 people11882.78 that11883.1 feel11883.43 they11884.55 are11884.7 afraid11884.86 to11885.19 come11885.35 out11885.51 because11885.67 they're11885.91 afraid11886.07 of11886.31 losing11886.47 their11886.78 jobs11886.94 or11887.55 their11887.63 family11887.95 connections.11888.43
11889.87 Too11889.87 few11890.11 people,11890.27 of11890.59 course,11890.75 realize11891.15 that11891.63 many11891.87 of11892.11 our11892.27 apps,11892.35 as11892.59 you've11892.83 heard,11893.07 sell11893.39 our11893.55 location11893.79 information,11894.27 as11894.83 you11895.07 know11895.23 very11895.47 well.11895.87 And11896.19 they11896.35 sell11896.59 them11896.75 to11896.91 anyone11897.07 from11897.47 our11897.79 nosy11898.11 neighbor11898.75 or11899.39 our11899.79 inappropriate11899.95 neighbor11900.75 to11901.39 our11901.55 employer11901.79 or11902.35 worse,11902.51 in11902.83 our11903.1 case,11903.27 to11904.23 extremists11904.63 who11905.43 believe11905.67 that11906.07 our11906.31 very11906.47 existence11906.78 is11907.43 a11907.67 scourge11907.83 upon11908.31 the11908.63 universe.11908.78 So,11909.99 the11910.15 LGBTQ11910.31 folks,11911.27 that11911.83 can11911.99 be11912.15 terrifying.11912.39 It11913.58 exposes11913.91 us11914.39 to11914.55 harassment.11914.78 And,11915.83 candidly,11916.07 it's11916.97 downright11917.21 creepy.11917.77 We11920.25 already11920.49 know11920.89 that11921.21 the11921.53 right11921.69 wing11921.85 that11922.25 right-wing11922.73 groups11922.89 have11923.29 used11923.45 location11923.77 information11924.33 to11925.05 out11925.37 gay11926.01 men11926.33 and11926.97 cause11927.21 them11927.45 to11927.69 lose11927.85 their11928.09 jobs.11928.33 As11929.61 for11929.69 the11929.93 trans11930.09 community,11930.42 my11930.73 colleagues11930.98 will11931.38 cover11931.53 that,11931.77 so11932.01 I11932.25 won't11932.33 do11932.58 it11932.73 here,11932.9 lest11933.3 it11934.17 be11934.33 more11934.5 redundant.11934.66 But11935.77 I11936.01 will11936.09 speak11936.25 on11936.5 a11936.66 personal11936.73 level.11937.14 As11938.17 some11938.42 of11938.5 you11938.66 who11938.9 know11939.06 me11939.3 know11940.25 that11940.42 I've11940.66 been11940.81 doing11940.9 LGBTQ11941.22 advocacy11941.77 for11942.58 311942.9 decades.11943.77 Many11945 times11945.48 during11945.88 those11946.12 years,11946.36 I11946.84 received11947 threats11947.96 from11948.44 anti11948.76 LGBTQ11949.32 extremists11950.2 that11950.68 they11950.92 would11951.24 kill11951.24 me11951.56 or11951.8 do11952.2 this11952.44 to11952.68 me11952.76 or11952.92 that11953.08 to11953.32 me11953.48 or11953.88 hurt11954.12 my11954.36 family.11954.52
11955.64 The11955.64 threats11955.8 were11956.12 commonplace.11956.68 And11957.75 the11957.91 threats11958.07 were11958.39 bad11958.55 enough11958.78 that11959.19 after11959.42 911,11960.07 during11960.39 the11960.78 anthrax11961.02 scare,11961.67 my11962.31 then11962.55 partner11962.7 asked11963.19 me11963.42 to11963.67 not11963.75 stop11964.55 opening11964.94 our11965.42 organizational11965.67 mail,11966.39 our11966.7 snail11966.94 mail,11967.26 at11968.07 our11968.23 home11968.47 in11969.1 case11969.34 there11969.67 might11969.83 be11970.07 white11970.23 powder11970.55 included11970.94 in11971.34 them.11971.58 Which,11972.31 as11972.31 you11972.47 may11972.63 recall,11972.78 was11973.18 a11973.34 fear11973.5 back11973.66 then.11974.78 Now,11975.1 I11975.26 was11975.34 able11975.5 to11975.74 protect11975.82 myself11976.22 somewhat11976.7 back11977.02 then.11977.18 I11977.42 never11977.58 listed11977.82 my11978.14 address11978.3 or11978.7 my11978.94 phone11979.1 number11979.34 publicly.11979.58 I11980.54 lived11980.94 in11981.18 a11981.26 secure11981.42 building11981.82 with11982.22 strong11982.54 locks11983.1 on11983.42 the11983.58 doors11983.74 and11983.98 the11984.14 windows.11984.22 I11985.53 can't11985.77 imagine11986.01 what11986.66 I'd11986.9 have11987.06 done11987.3 if11987.77 some11988.09 anti11988.33 LGBTQ11988.74 hater,11989.85 perhaps11990.33 from11990.74 Texas,11990.98 had11992.09 been11992.25 able11992.42 to11992.66 track11992.82 my11993.14 movements,11993.3 know11994.33 where11994.58 I11994.82 live,11994.98 where11995.93 I11996.17 shop11996.42 for11996.66 groceries,11996.9 where11997.61 I11997.85 worshiped,11998.01 or11998.66 where11998.82 I11998.98 pick11999.14 my11999.38 kids11999.61 up11999.93 from12000.09 school12000.42 every12000.9 day.12002.4 That12002.64 would12002.88 have12003.04 been12003.12 not12003.28 just12003.44 creepy12003.68 but12004 downright12004.24 dangerous.12004.64 So12005.76 I12006.08 ask12006.24 you12006.4 to12006.56 help12006.72 protect12007.04 us12007.28 by12007.6 limiting12007.76 access12008.24 to12008.56 location12008.72 information,12009.28 by12010.08 banning12010.32 its12010.64 sale,12010.88 and12011.28 by12011.52 providing12011.76 privacy12012.24 protections12012.72 for12013.36 other12013.52 kinds12013.76 of12014.08 data12014.16 as12014.56 well.12014.72 Thank12015.12 you.12015.47 Thank12015.86 you.12015.94
12021.55 MEL12021.55 DE12021.55 SILVA12021.55 -12021.55 TRANS12021.55 HEALTH12021.55 -12021.55 Thank12021.55 you12021.86 for12022.02 the12022.18 opportunity12022.34 to12022.91 testify12022.98 this12023.55 afternoon.12023.7 My12024.42 name12024.67 is12024.83 Mel12024.91 De12025.15 Silva.12025.39 I12025.78 use12025.86 them12026.1 pronouns.12026.5 I12027.06 am12027.15 the12027.31 director12027.47 of12027.86 development12027.94 and12028.5 communications12028.67 at12029.39 Trans12029.55 Health,12029.86 and12030.68 I12030.76 am12030.92 the12031 proud12031.08 parent12031.48 of12031.8 a12031.88 trans12032.04 kid.12032.28 Located12033.56 in12034.04 North12034.2 Hampton,12034.44 TransHealth12034.92 is12035.48 the12035.72 only12035.88 independent12036.36 nonprofit12037 healthcare12037.64 organization12038.12 in12038.84 the12039 United12039.16 States12039.56 solely12040.52 devoted12040.92 to12041.24 serving12041.4 the12041.72 trans12041.88 and12042.12 gender12042.28 diverse12042.6 community.12042.92 Transhealth12044.3 supports12045.01 comprehensive12045.65 data12046.53 privacy12046.85 legislation,12047.33 and12048.53 today,12048.77 I12049.09 will12049.25 speak12049.42 specifically12049.9 about12050.69 location12051.17 data12051.81 privacy12052.14 as12053.09 it12053.25 relates12053.42 to12053.81 gender12054.06 affirming12054.45 care12054.93 providers.12055.17 This12056.93 legislature12057.17 has12058.06 worked12058.3 tirelessly12058.78 to12059.82 make12059.98 Massachusetts12060.3 112060.94 of12061.18 the12061.26 safest12061.42 states12061.82 for12062.14 the12062.3 trans12062.46 community.12062.78 However,12063.82 given12064.3 the12064.62 unrelenting12064.86 federal12065.58 attacks12066.06 on12066.54 trans12066.7 people,12067.02 there12067.82 is12068.06 an12068.22 urgent12068.38 need12068.78 to12068.94 take12069.1 additional12069.34 legislative12069.9 action12070.64 to12070.64 protect12071.03 the12071.27 residents12071.51 of12071.83 the12072 Commonwealth.12072.08 Delivering12073.67 gender12074.23 affirming12074.56 care12074.95 is12075.19 increasingly12075.51 dangerous12076.31 work.12076.8 Nationwide,12077.75 70%12078.72 of12079.92 gender12080.15 affirming12080.48 care12080.95 providers12081.11 surveyed12081.67 reported12082.56 receiving12083.11 threats,12083.51 and12084.95 that12085.19 was12085.35 in12085.59 02/2023.12085.75
12087.23 So12087.23 if12087.39 we12087.63 redid12087.79 the12088.03 survey12088.19 this12088.43 year,12088.59 I12088.83 think12088.91 it12089.07 would12089.15 be12089.31 a12089.39 lot12089.47 worse,12089.63 actually.12090.03 Adding12091.47 to12091.71 that12091.87 risk,12092.11 it12092.43 is12092.59 currently12092.67 legal12093.15 in12093.47 Massachusetts12093.63 for12094.35 bad12094.51 actors12094.75 to12095.07 purchase12095.23 location12095.87 data12096.43 to12096.83 track12096.91 the12097.23 movements12097.31 of12097.87 anyone12098.03 who12098.48 works12098.72 in12099.27 the12099.43 field12099.51 of12099.83 gender12099.99 affirming12100.31 care.12100.72 This12101.27 could12101.43 be12101.59 health12101.75 care12101.99 providers,12102.15 nurses,12102.64 medical12103.11 assistants,12103.43 medical12104.31 receptionists,12104.72 and12105.35 even12105.35 researchers.12105.75 With12107.03 this12107.27 data,12107.51 anyone12107.92 with12108.23 an12108.48 intent12108.64 to12109.03 cause12109.19 harm12109.51 and12109.92 commit12110.15 violence12110.48 could12110.99 pinpoint12111.07 the12111.71 locations12111.87 of12112.83 any12112.99 trans12113.31 health12113.63 employees,12113.95 including12114.59 where12115.15 we12115.39 live,12115.63 putting12116.59 us12116.91 and12117.07 our12117.23 families12117.39 at12117.79 risk.12117.95 Without12119.39 a12119.71 ban12119.87 on12120.19 location12120.35 data12120.83 purchasing,12121.15 the12121.55 expansion12121.79 of12122.19 the12122.35 state12122.51 address12122.83 confidentiality12123.31 program12124.19 to12125.48 include12125.72 those12126.11 working12126.44 in12126.83 gender12126.92 affirming12127.24 care12127.64 has12127.88 a12128.11 limited12128.11 effect12128.52 and12129 offers12129.24 little12129.56 security.12129.88 We12131.08 need12131.32 this12131.48 additional12131.72 protection.12132.19 It12133.8 is12134.03 critical12134.27 that12134.75 legislature12134.92 act12135.64 quickly12135.88 to12136.27 pass12136.44 comprehensive12136.68 data12137.4 privacy12137.64 legislation12138.11 that12138.68 includes12138.83 banning12139.32 the12139.64 purchase12139.8 of12140.27 location12140.73 data,12140.97 which12141.61 can12141.93 be12142.09 used12142.17 to12142.33 harass,12142.57 stalk,12143.61 and12144.25 commit12144.41 violence12144.73 against12145.13 those12145.45 who12145.69 care12145.85 for12146.09 and12146.25 support12146.49 the12146.81 trans12146.97 community.12147.29 I12148.41 would12148.49 like12148.65 to12148.89 thank12148.97 this12149.21 committee12149.45 again12149.85 for12150.17 the12150.33 sup12150.49 for12150.81 the12150.97 opportunity12151.13 to12151.69 testify12151.85 today12152.33 on12152.57 this12152.73 important12152.89 issue.12153.29 And,12154.09 And12154.27 if12155 you12155.24 have12155.32 any12155.48 questions,12155.72 I12156.19 can12156.44 answer12156.6 them.12156.76 Thank12157.72 you.12157.95
12158.27 SPEAKER112158.27 -12158.27 Thank12158.27 you12158.44 so12158.6 much.12158.76 Continue12159.56 with12159.95 the12160.19 panel.12160.27
12162.76 KELSEY12162.76 GRUNSTRA12162.76 -12162.76 MASSACHUSETTS12162.76 TRANSGENDER12162.76 POLITICAL12162.76 COALITION12162.76 -12162.76 HB12162.76 8612162.76 -12162.76 SB12162.76 19712162.76 -12162.76 Hello12162.76 there.12163.08 I12163.56 am12163.64 Kelsey12163.8 Grunstra,12164.11 and12164.52 I'm12164.68 the12164.83 deputy12164.92 director12165.32 of12165.72 the12165.8 Massachusetts12166.03 Transgender12166.6 Political12167.16 Coalition,12167.56 the12168.7 oldest12168.78 trans,12169.26 transgender12170.22 advocacy12170.78 and12171.34 community12171.58 development12171.98 organization12172.46 in12172.94 the12173.02 United12173.18 States.12173.42 Thank12174.54 you12174.7 so12174.86 much12175.02 to12175.26 the12175.34 committee12175.42 for12175.74 hearing12175.98 my12176.22 testimony12176.38 today12176.86 in12177.1 support12177.26 of12177.5 the12177.66 Location12177.74 Shield12178.22 Act,12178.54 H12178.86 8612179.1 and12179.58 S12180.46 197.12181.42 Although12181.42 there12181.67 are12181.82 many12181.98 reasons12182.23 to12182.63 focus12182.7 on12183.42 location12183.74 privacy,12184.23 it12184.7 is12184.94 especially12185.18 urgent12185.67 for12185.98 vulnerable,12186.23 multiply12186.78 marginalized12187.26 communities,12187.82 such12188.23 as12188.47 transgender,12188.7 nonbinary,12189.5 and12189.9 gender12190.06 diverse12190.31 people.12190.63 Trans12191.58 people12191.9 already12192.31 navigate12192.55 the12193.02 world12193.1 facing12193.34 more12193.67 risk12193.9 than12194.15 our12194.31 cisgender12194.47 peers.12194.94
12196.17 Many12196.17 of12196.41 us12196.57 must12196.73 contend12197.05 with12197.29 family12197.53 members,12197.85 current12198.25 and12198.65 former12198.73 partners,12199.13 and12199.53 others12199.77 in12200.01 our12200.17 lives12200.25 who12200.73 refuse12200.97 to12201.37 respect12201.61 our12201.93 identities12202.09 and12202.57 may12202.73 want12202.97 to12203.21 perpetrate12203.29 harm12203.77 against12204.01 us.12204.33 The12205.13 open12205.37 availability12205.69 of12206.25 location12206.41 data12206.89 to12207.21 brokers12207.37 and12207.69 other12207.85 third12208.09 parties12208.25 makes12208.65 it12208.89 easier12209.05 for12209.39 stalkers,12209.63 abusers,12210.34 and12210.83 other12210.98 would-be12211.31 perpetrators12211.55 to12212.18 track,12212.34 harass,12212.75 and12213.06 persecute12213.31 us.12214.5 Moreover,12214.58 location12215.06 tracking12215.55 can12215.94 also12216.1 reveal12216.42 when12216.83 a12216.98 trans12217.06 person12217.31 has12217.63 access12217.86 to12218.18 gender12218.18 affirming12218.5 services,12218.9 support,12219.47 or12220.18 health12220.42 care,12220.58 which12221.15 can12221.39 be12221.55 increasingly12221.7 risky12222.18 if12222.5 they12222.67 are12222.83 trying12222.9 to12223.06 avoid12223.23 prosecution12223.55 or12224.34 harassment12224.5 because12225.77 of12225.88 it.12225.98 This12226.09 is12226.33 particularly12226.49 salient12227.13 as12227.61 we12227.77 are12227.93 being12228.09 actively12228.33 persecuted12228.89 by12229.61 a12229.77 federal12229.93 government12230.25 that12230.57 is12230.73 attempting12230.89 to12231.29 outright12231.45 eradicate12231.85 the12232.33 right12232.41 to12232.73 safety12232.73 and12233.37 privacy12233.61 of12234.57 all12234.73 trans12234.97 and12235.21 nonbinary12235.53 Americans.12236.01
12237.51 In12237.51 particular,12237.67 gender12238.07 affirming12238.48 health12238.88 care12239.03 for12239.19 trans12239.43 and12239.67 non-binary12239.99 youth12240.31 is12240.56 under12240.64 attack.12240.95 There12241.83 are12242.15 incredibly12242.31 high12242.95 risks12243.19 for12243.83 these12243.99 children's12244.23 caregivers12244.72 and12245.19 the12245.43 providers12245.51 of12245.99 this12246.07 life-saving12246.56 pediatric12246.95 care.12247.51 Many12248.4 people12248.72 come12248.95 to12249.11 Massachusetts12249.27 to12249.99 seek12250.15 gender12250.4 affirming12250.72 care12251.11 that12251.35 they12251.51 can12251.67 no12251.83 longer12251.99 access12252.31 in12252.64 their12252.8 home12252.95 states.12253.19 Increasingly,12254.21 they12254.77 may12254.93 face12255.09 prosecution12255.41 in12256.05 other12256.21 states12256.45 whose12257.01 activist12257.33 legislatures12257.89 have12258.53 passed12258.77 overreaching12259.25 laws.12259.81 Let12260.53 me12260.69 be12260.93 clear12261.01 that12261.41 no12261.65 112261.81 in12261.97 Massachusetts12262.21 should12262.93 ever12263.25 be12263.57 concerned12263.73 about12264.45 a12264.69 bounty12264.85 hunter12265.25 tracking12265.73 them12266.13 down12266.29 because12266.83 their12267.08 location12267.31 data12267.8 is12268.03 up12268.27 for12268.43 grabs12268.59 online,12268.92 especially12269.64 not12270.03 a12270.27 child,12270.43 a12271 loving12271.23 parent,12271.56 or12271.95 a12272.19 dedicated12272.27 health12272.75 care12273 provider.12273.23
12274.35 Since12274.35 Donald12274.67 Trump's12274.92 inauguration12275.31 in12275.88 January,12276.03 MTPC12276.59 has12277.15 already12277.4 had12277.72 to12277.88 shift12277.95 a12278.27 public12278.35 name-change12279 clinic12279.15 event12279.56 at12280.03 the12280.19 Somerville12280.35 Public12280.92 Library12281.19 to12281.59 a12281.67 virtual12281.83 event12282.15 out12282.47 of12282.71 concern12282.79 for12283.11 the12283.27 safety12283.43 and12283.75 privacy12283.99 of12284.71 our12284.87 clients,12285.11 staff,12285.51 and12285.99 community12286.39 partners12286.79 due12287.19 to12287.35 hateful12287.51 and12287.91 threatening12288.07 comments.12288.55 Fear12289.67 should12289.99 never12290.39 be12290.79 a12291.03 factor12291.11 for12291.83 why12292.07 trans12292.23 and12292.55 nonbinary12292.87 people12293.19 are12293.67 unable12293.83 to12294.39 access12294.55 supportive12295.66 and12296.06 affirming12296.14 resources12296.61 or12297.09 care.12297.25 We12297.98 must12298.14 be12298.38 free12298.53 to12298.69 leave12298.85 our12299.09 homes,12299.25 doctors,12299.82 offices,12300.3 workplaces,12300.77 and12301.74 community12301.98 spaces12302.53 without12303.17 the12303.58 fear12303.74 of12303.98 being12304.14 tracked12304.38 or12304.94 bringing12305.09 any12305.5 danger12305.74 upon12306.14 ourselves,12306.45 our12307.25 providers,12307.5 or12308.68 our12308.92 communities.12309 We12310.2 at12310.36 MTPC12310.6 are12311.16 incredibly12311.4 grateful12311.8 for12312.2 this12312.28 committee's12312.52 commitment12312.92 to12313.32 upholding12313.48 the12313.96 privacy12314.12 rights12314.6 of12315.08 people12315.32 across12315.64 Massachusetts,12316.04 including12317 omnibus12317.48 privacy12317.96 legislation12318.44 and12319.08 regulation12319.24 that12319.96 would12320.12 prohibit12320.36 the12320.39 sale12320.42 of12320.44 location12320.47 and12320.5 all12320.53 other12320.56 sensitive12320.59 private12320.62 data.12320.65 We12320.67 strongly12320.7 urge12320.73 the12320.76 committee12324.94 to12325.5 report12325.82 the12326.06 location12326.22 shield12326.61 back12326.94 favorably.12327.18 The12328.22 people12328.42 of12328.61 Massachusetts12328.77 deserve12329.58 to12329.98 use12330.14 their12330.3 devices12330.53 without12331.02 worrying12331.58 about12332.06 their12332.3 information12332.45 being12333.02 sold12333.18 to12333.42 anyone12333.58 who12333.98 wants12334.14 it.12334.38 Thank12334.53 you12334.69 for12334.85 your12335.02 time.12335.18
12335.42 SPEAKER112335.42 -12335.42 Thank12335.42 you.12335.58
12339.74 RAYNA12339.74 HILL12339.74 -12339.74 MASSACHUSETTS12339.74 COMMISSION12339.74 ON12339.74 LGBTQ12339.74 YOUTH12339.74 -12339.74 Good12339.74 afternoon,12340.06 and12340.54 thank12340.7 you.12341.02 My12341.34 name12341.42 is12341.58 Reyna12341.82 Hill.12342.14 I12342.38 use12342.46 sheher12342.62 pronouns,12342.94 and12343.34 I12343.5 am12343.58 the12343.74 legislative12343.9 and12344.38 policy12344.54 manager12344.94 with12345.26 the12345.42 Massachusetts12345.58 Commission12346.14 on12346.54 LGBTQ12346.7 Youth.12347.58 And12347.9 I12348.06 wanna12348.22 thank12348.46 you12348.62 all12348.78 for12349.02 the12349.18 opportunity12349.26 to12349.82 share12349.98 the12350.3 commission's12350.46 support12350.94 for12351.34 data12351.58 privacy12352.1 protections12352.42 broadly.12352.9 And12353.77 specifically,12354.1 in12354.66 this12354.9 instance,12355.06 I'm12355.3 gonna12355.53 be12355.77 talking12355.85 about12356.18 the12356.42 location12356.42 shield12356.9 act12357.3 and12357.45 location12357.61 safety.12358.1 And12359.22 I12359.38 also12359.45 wanna12359.69 thank12359.85 you12360.02 just12360.1 for12360.26 being12360.42 here12360.58 today.12360.74 I12360.98 know12361.06 that12361.14 my12361.3 nightmares12361.45 have12361.94 gotten12362.02 more12362.34 specific12362.58 after12363.14 this12363.45 hearing,12363.69 and12364.1 so12364.34 I'm12364.58 sure12364.82 for12365.06 you12365.22 as12365.45 well;12365.97 this12365.97 is12366 quite12366.03 terrifying.12366.06 It's12366.1 not12366.5 terrifying.12367.05
12367.69 FARLEY-BOUVIER12367.69 -12367.69 It's12367.69 not12367.69 quite12368.17 serving12368.49 on12368.73 this12368.89 committee.12369.05 A12370.17 lot12370.25 more12370.65 scared.12370.97
12371.77 HILL12371.77 -12371.77 Yeah.12371.77 I'm12372.73 gonna12372.97 share12373.13 212373.53 points12373.77 for12374.09 you12374.33 today,12374.49 and12374.73 we'll12374.97 follow12375.13 up12375.53 with12375.53 some12375.69 written12375.85 testimony12376.25 early12377.29 next12377.61 week.12377.85 The12378.65 first12378.81 is12379.05 that12379.29 this12379.61 location12379.85 shield12380.41 act12380.65 and12380.89 data12381.05 protection12381.5 privacy12381.83 specifically12382.47 is12383.18 going12383.34 to12383.5 help12383.67 protect12383.9 LGBTQ12384.31 youth12385.02 and12385.18 families12385.34 in12385.83 Massachusetts.12385.98 As12387.18 has12387.42 already12387.58 been12387.98 shared12388.15 and12388.47 as12388.63 we12388.78 are12388.94 all12389.1 aware,12389.83 the12390.15 unrelenting12390.31 attacks12391.1 on12391.5 the12391.67 safety12391.83 of12392.15 transgender12392.39 and12393.1 nonbinary12393.75 kids12394.06 and12394.63 anyone12394.94 supporting12395.42 them12395.9 are12396.44 clear.12396.6 Over12397.4 the12397.72 last12397.8 year,12397.96 the12398.28 commission12398.36 has12398.76 seen12398.92 a12399.08 significant12399.24 increase12399.8 in12400.2 outreach12400.36 from12400.84 terrified12401.08 parents12401.64 who12402.12 are12402.2 asking12402.36 how12402.68 the12402.92 state12403 can12403.32 help12403.48 protect12403.64 them12404.04 and12404.28 their12404.44 children,12404.6 especially12405.56 from12406.12 families12406.36 who12406.84 have12407.08 already12407.32 begun12407.8 to12408.52 flee12408.68 from12409 their12409.24 led12410.07 states12410.31 to12410.63 here12410.78 in12410.94 Massachusetts.12411.1 We12412.23 have12412.47 heard12412.55 from12412.78 parents12413.02 and12413.35 youth12413.58 that12413.91 they12414.07 are12414.15 terrified12414.39 to12414.86 go12414.94 to12415.1 public12415.27 events,12415.58 support12416.31 spaces,12416.63 and12417.02 find12417.27 other12417.5 services,12417.83 particularly12418.47 after12419.19 we've12419.5 seen12419.75 the12419.99 bomb12420.15 threats12420.39 at12420.7 Boston12420.86 Children's12421.19 Hospital12421.67 for12422.07 their12422.23 gender12422.39 affirming12422.76 care12423.16 program,12423.24 the12424.04 violence12424.28 and12424.6 harassment12424.84 at12425.32 LGBTQ12425.48 centered12426.36 library12426.84 events,12427.32 school12428.2 committees12428.52 in12429 schools12429.24 just12429.72 in12429.96 general12430.12 for12430.52 meetings12430.68 over12431.08 their12431.32 curriculum12431.48 and12431.96 books,12432.2 and,12432.92 graffiti12433.88 and12434.28 vandalism12434.44 to12435 LGBTQ12435.16 spaces12435.96 over12436.44 the12436.68 last12436.76 several12437 years.12437.32
12438.09 By12438.09 passing12438.42 these12438.73 bills12438.98 to12439.22 provide12439.38 a12439.69 data12439.85 privacy12440.25 safety12440.81 net12441.14 over12441.38 Massachusetts,12441.61 parents12442.42 of12442.73 trans12442.9 and12443.3 non12443.38 binary12443.61 kids12444.01 can12444.33 have12444.57 a12444.81 little12444.9 bit12445.3 more12445.45 breathing12445.85 room12446.17 to12446.9 also12447.14 not12447.45 have12447.69 to12447.85 worry12448.01 about12448.25 anti12448.57 LGBTQ12448.81 hate12449.61 groups,12449.85 of12450.09 which12450.25 we12450.5 have12450.65 several12450.9 centered12451.53 and12451.93 founded12452.09 here12452.5 in12452.65 Massachusetts,12452.9 using12454.31 their12454.55 location12454.87 data12455.35 to12455.75 stalk12455.91 and12456.23 harass12456.39 their12456.79 families12456.95 at12457.43 home,12457.59 at12458.23 school,12458.39 and12458.79 at12458.95 the12459.11 library12459.27 for12459.67 just12459.91 being12460.07 supportive12460.39 and12460.87 loving12461.03 parents12461.43 to12461.75 their12461.91 children.12462.07 The12463.03 second12463.19 point12463.43 we12463.67 wanna12463.83 share12464.07 with12464.23 you12464.39 is12464.63 that12464.71 this12464.87 bill12465.03 will12465.27 help12465.43 protect12465.67 teachers12466.07 and12466.55 librarians.12466.79 The12467.92 commission12468.08 has12468.32 seen12468.56 an12468.88 alarming12469.11 increase12469.83 in12470.48 the12470.64 number12470.72 of12471.03 educators12471.27 reporting12471.92 that12472.4 they12472.56 are12472.72 scared12472.95 to12473.35 go12473.51 to12473.67 work.12473.83 They're12474.24 scared12474.56 for12474.88 their12475.03 safety12475.27 because12476 of12476.24 the12476.4 LGBTQ12476.56 inclusive12477.27 curriculum12477.67 that12478.24 they12478.4 teach12478.56 and12478.88 the12479.03 affirming12479.19 events12479.75 that12480.08 they12480.24 hold,12480.4 and12480.64 the12480.8 books12480.95 that12481.34 they12481.42 display12481.58 in12482.06 their12482.22 communities.12482.46
12483.5 We12483.5 have12483.66 librarians12483.82 describing12484.54 instances12485.18 of12485.66 aggressive12485.82 community12486.38 members12486.78 entering12487.18 libraries12487.58 and12488.14 threatening12488.3 librarians12489.1 to12489.66 remove12489.82 book12490.22 displays12490.46 featuring12490.94 books12491.34 with12491.58 black12491.82 trans12492.06 characters12492.46 and12493.26 teachers12493.42 getting12493.82 verbal12494.14 and12494.46 written12494.89 threats12495.13 to12495.28 remove12495.52 supportive12496 signage12496.4 and12496.81 flags12496.97 from12497.36 their12497.52 classrooms.12497.68 No12498.97 person12499.2 should12499.6 be12499.76 afraid12499.92 to12500.32 go12500.4 to12500.65 work12500.89 simply12501.36 because12501.76 they12502 are12502.25 trying12502.4 to12502.65 make12502.81 their12502.97 communities12503.2 more12503.76 safe12504 and12504.25 affirming12504.48 for12504.97 children.12505.13 We12507.08 need12507.24 to12507.4 increase12507.48 the12507.88 protections12508.04 for12508.52 our12508.68 teachers12508.84 and12509.16 librarians,12509.32 and12509.8 these12510.04 bills12510.2 will12510.44 help12510.6 do12510.84 that,12511 specifically12511.4 around12511.96 preventing12512.28 the12512.76 sale12512.84 of12513.08 location12513.24 data.12513.8 The12514.52 easy12514.68 access12514.92 to12515.32 location12515.48 data12515.88 for12516.2 Massachusetts12516.36 residents12517 poses12517.48 an12517.8 extreme12517.96 danger12518.36 to12518.76 the12518.92 constituents,12519.08 to12519.96 schools,12520.2 communities,12520.68 parents,12521.24 and12521.68 kids.12521.92 And12522.32 it's12522.56 not12522.73 a12522.89 matter12522.97 of12523.28 if12523.6 people12524.32 are12524.81 going12524.89 to12525.13 use12525.2 a12525.44 sata,12525.52 it's12526 a12526.24 matter12526.32 of12526.56 when.12526.73 And12527.2 I12527.36 think12527.44 that's12527.6 really12527.84 clear.12528.17 And12528.48 I'll12528.73 say,12528.89 I12530 would12530.17 say12530.4 for12530.65 the12530.89 commission12530.97 as12531.44 well,12531.6 just12531.84 for12532.08 our12532.32 staff,12532.4 we've12532.73 gotten12532.97 a12533.28 lot12533.36 of12533.6 threats12533.68 and12534.08 doxing.12534.24 And12534.56 I'll12534.81 say12534.97 that12535.13 just12535.36 state12536.01 employees12536.41 staff12536.97 are12537.29 really12537.45 scared12537.69 right12538.01 now,12538.17 and12538.81 this12538.97 will12539.13 help.12539.37 So12539.77 thank12539.93 you.12540.09
FARLEY-BOUVIER12540.49 -12540.49 Thank12540.49 you12540.65 so12541.05 much,12541.29 for12542.25 there's12542.97 a12543.21 lot12543.29 of12543.45 different12543.53 perspectives12543.77 on12544.17 this12544.33 panel,12544.49 and12544.81 we12544.97 appreciate12545.13 it.12545.53 I12547.37 just12547.61 wanna12547.77 see12548.17 if12548.41 there's12548.57 anybody12548.73 on12549.17 the12549.33 yes.12549.57 Sorry.12550.84 Representative12551.08 Owens.12551.65 It's12552.2 okay.12552.36
12553.65 OWENS12553.65 -12553.65 Most12553.65 of12553.81 the12553.97 panel12554.05 knows12554.36 me12554.52 and12554.68 Steve12554.76 anyway.12555.08 Thank12557.57 you12557.73 so12557.89 much12558.05 for12558.28 coming12558.44 out12558.68 today.12559.08 I12559.49 appreciate12559.81 this.12560.13 I12560.28 wasn't12560.44 gonna12560.6 ask12560.84 this,12561 but12561.08 I12561.2 know12561.33 most12561.49 of12561.65 you12561.81 have12561.89 been12562.05 here12562.13 all12564.38 day,12564.4 and12564.41 I12564.43 wanted12564.44 to12564.46 give12564.48 you12564.49 a12564.51 chance12564.52 because12564.54 we12564.78 had12565.02 a12565.18 comment12565.34 earlier12565.74 about,12566.38 how,12567.1 the12568.14 downside12568.38 of12568.86 some12569.02 of12569.18 these12569.26 rules12569.5 would12569.82 be12569.98 vulnerable12570.22 populations12570.7 would12571.34 maybe12571.58 not12571.9 get12572.14 the12572.46 correct12572.78 ads12573.26 served12573.58 to12573.98 them,12574.06 at12575.58 the12575.82 where12576.06 they12576.3 need.12576.46 So12576.7 I12576.86 just-12576.94 is12577.98 that12578.22 a12578.3 concern12578.45 that12579.98 you12580.14 feel12580.61 members12581.01 of12581.33 the12581.58 LGBT12581.74 community12582.38 might12582.93 have?12583.09
12584.85 GRUNSTRA12584.85 -12584.85 I12584.85 just12585.01 have12585.17 112585.33 really12585.58 quick12585.82 comment,12586.06 which12586.45 is12586.69 that,12586.93 we12587.66 are12587.98 all,12588.69 you12588.93 know,12589.09 in12591.39 rep12591.63 Meschino's,12591.95 dutiful12594.27 research12594.75 of12595.55 the12595.79 prior12596.11 speak,12596.59 testifiers,12597.23 clients,12598.67 I12599.39 can12599.55 say12599.79 that12600.11 MTPC12600.51 is12601.31 already12601.63 barred12602.03 from12602.35 advertising12602.59 on12603.39 services12603.63 and12604.24 platforms12604.56 such12604.95 as12605.11 Meta,12605.35 because12606.32 of12606.64 our12606.8 of12607.44 our12607.75 allegiance12607.92 to12608.56 supporting12608.72 transgender12609.11 and12609.67 non12609.83 binary12610 individuals.12610.4 We12611.44 have12611.6 been12611.75 banned12611.92 multiple12612.24 times12612.56 from12612.88 advertising12613.11 on12613.6 that12613.75 platform,12613.92 and12614.95 we12615.19 are12615.44 also12615.6 banned12615.92 from12616.32 specifically12617.27 targeting12617.92 people12618.4 based12618.72 on12618.95 their12619.03 gender12619.28 identity12619.68 and12620 their12620.16 race.12620.4 So12621.12 that12621.28 fell12621.52 flat12621.84 on12622.16 deaf12622.32 ears.12622.56 Thank12623.52 you.12623.76
12624.24 SPEAKER812624.24 -12624.24 Very12624.24 interesting.12624.56 Senator.12625.28
12627.92 ISAACSON12628.08 -12628.08 May12628.08 I12628.08 just12628.24 at12628.48 some12628.64 point12628.88 respond12629.12 to12629.36 that?12629.6 I'd12630.72 just12630.88 like12631.12 to12631.28 say12631.44 that12631.6 the12632.6 LGBT12632.84 community12633.33 is12633.81 deeply12634.05 touched12634.44 by12634.92 the12635.08 concern12635.33 from12636.76 the12637 advertising12637.25 industry.12637.97 And12640.28 we12640.52 appreciate12640.76 that12641.41 they12641.57 are12641.73 concerned12641.97 about12642.44 our12642.69 ability12642.84 to12643.57 have12643.73 ads12644.05 provided12644.69 to12645.65 us.12645.73 Nonetheless,12647.52 we12648.24 are12648.48 willing12648.64 to12648.8 make12648.96 that12649.12 terrible12649.52 sacrifice12650 in12651.36 order12651.6 to12651.92 have12652.16 privacy12652.48 and12653.52 protection12653.68 in12654.16 our12654.32 lives.12654.48
12655.92 MOORE12655.92 -12655.92 Just12655.92 my12656.16 quick12656.32 question12656.56 to12657.12 anyone12657.28 of12657.6 you12657.76 is12657.92 how12658.08 long12658.24 has12658.4 that12658.64 been12658.8 in12658.96 place,12659.04 the12659.17 restriction?12659.45
12660.66 GRUNSTRA12660.66 -12660.66 I12660.66 can12660.81 tell12660.98 you12661.14 the12661.22 first12661.3 time12661.53 our12661.77 account12661.93 was12662.17 banned12662.33 was12662.58 in12662.74 2023,12662.9 and12663.85 it12664.09 happened12664.17 twice12664.42 in12664.74 2024.12664.9 And12665.93 we12666.09 have12666.17 made12666.42 the12666.58 executive12666.74 decision12667.3 at12667.61 our12667.85 organization12668.01 that12668.58 we12668.81 will12668.9 no12669.14 longer12669.3 even12669.61 attempt12669.85 to12670.17 advertise12670.33 on12670.74 Meta's12670.9 platforms.12671.22
12674.95 FARLEY-BOUVIER12674.95 -12674.95 That's12674.95 really12675.35 helpful,12675.59 and12675.99 I12676.23 appreciate12676.31 your12676.79 testimony.12677.03 We12677.59 look12677.83 forward12677.99 to12678.39 continuing12678.63 to12679.11 work12679.27 on12679.59 this12679.67 as12679.91 these12680.71 bills12680.95 move12681.27 forward12681.43 in12681.83 the12681.99 process.12682.07 Okay.12683.19 So12683.67 we12683.91 have12683.99 our12684.23 next12684.39 panel,12685.19 which12685.51 is12685.51 led12685.51 by12685.83 Cindy12686.23 Roe.12686.63 Cindy,12687.99 if12688.23 you12688.31 wanna12688.47 bring12688.78 your12689.1 crew12689.42 up,12689.75 and12689.99 then12690.15 there's12690.55 a12690.94 panel12691.19 following12691.67 led12692.47 by12692.7 Brianna12693.02 Savage.12693.5 I12694.31 just12694.47 wanna12694.7 say12695.58 something12695.83 that12696.15 the12696.47 time12696.63 is12696.94 getting12697.1 late.12697.34 This12698.15 committee12698.47 is12699.19 here12699.34 for12699.95 as12700.11 long12700.35 as12700.67 you12700.91 need12701.07 us.12701.23 The12701.87 only12702.03 thing12702.27 I'm12702.43 gonna12702.59 ask12703.07 for12703.31 is12703.63 your12703.87 consideration12704.11 of12704.83 the12704.99 peeps12705.15 other12705.39 people12705.55 who12705.87 have12706.03 been12706.19 waiting.12706.51 And12707.31 so12707.47 if12707.63 we12707.79 can,12707.95 you12708.59 know,12708.75 maybe12709.07 even12709.47 on12709.63 panels,12709.87 if12710.27 we12710.43 cut12710.59 it,12710.83 like,12711.07 each12711.39 person12711.63 down,12711.95 like,12713.07 a12713.39 bit.12713.63 We're12714.19 just12714.35 trying12714.44 to12714.75 tighten12714.83 it12715.16 up12715.32 a12715.4 little12715.48 bit12715.64 so12716.03 everybody12716.35 waiting12716.83 has12717.24 a12717.4 chance.12717.48 And12719.32 written12719.95 testimony12720.27 is12721 awesome.12721.32 So12721.8 anything12722.11 you12722.44 wanna12722.59 provide12722.92 in12723.24 writing12723.32 is12723.95 super12724.11 helpful12724.35 to12724.75 us.12724.92 Cindy,12725.88 go12726.19 ahead.12726.35
CINDY12727 ROWE12727 -12727 JALSA12727 -12727 Thank12727 you.12727.32 Thank12727.56 you12727.72 to12727.95 both12728.35 chairs12728.59 and12728.92 to12729.16 the12729.32 members12729.4 of12729.8 the12730.09 committee.12730.17 My12731.45 name12731.61 is12731.77 Cindy12731.93 Rowe.12732.25 I12732.57 am12732.73 the12732.97 CEO12733.37 of12733.77 the12733.93 Jewish12734.01 Alliance12734.41 for12734.89 Law12735.05 and12735.21 Social12735.37 Action,12735.69 a12736.49 membership-based12737.37 nonprofit12737.69 organization12738.49 based12739.29 in12739.53 Boston12739.69 with12740.41 thousands12740.65 of12741.13 members12741.37 and12741.77 supporters12742.01 statewide.12742.65 Guided12744.06 by12744.38 our12744.61 Jewish12744.85 teachings12745.17 and12745.65 values,12745.9 we12746.3 are12746.53 devoted12746.69 to12747.17 the12747.33 defense12747.49 of12747.9 civil12748.14 rights,12748.45 the12749.65 preservation12749.9 of12750.38 constitutional12750.69 liberties,12751.41 and12751.9 the12752.06 passionate12752.22 pursuit12752.85 of12753.33 social,12753.57 economic,12753.98 racial,12754.61 and12755.01 environmental12755.57 justice12756.3 for12756.77 all12756.93 people.12757.17 She12758.42 also12758.5 wishes12758.82 to12759.14 offer12759.3 testimony12759.62 in12760.26 strong12760.5 support12760.82 of12761.14 the12761.3 location12761.38 shield12761.94 act.12762.34 Additionally,12763.22 she12763.78 would12764.18 also12764.42 support12764.74 more12765.14 expansive12765.46 omnibus12766.26 legislation12766.82 that12767.62 would12767.78 protect12768.02 privacy12768.5 and12769.06 include12769.3 the12769.7 location12769.86 shield12770.34 act.12770.66
12771.9 We12771.9 know12772.15 that12772.31 unscrupulous12772.63 and12773.26 unregulated12773.5 data12774.23 brokers12774.55 currently12775.1 buy12775.67 and12775.83 sell12776.06 personal12776.55 location12777.02 data12777.5 from12777.9 apps12778.15 on12778.47 our12778.63 cell12778.78 phones,12779.1 revealing12779.83 much12780.31 about12780.63 us12780.86 without12781.1 our12781.5 knowledge.12781.67 Moreover,12782.7 these12783.18 data12783.42 brokers12783.75 are12784.15 not12784.31 the12784.55 only12784.7 entities12785.11 who12785.43 procure,12785.91 use,12786.47 and12786.87 abuse12787.27 personal12788.23 location12788.71 data.12789.27 Anybody12790.31 can12790.71 procure12791.03 this12791.51 data,12791.75 including12792.23 those12792.71 seeking12793.03 to12793.51 perpetuate12793.67 hate12794.39 crimes12794.63 driven12795.27 by12795.59 antisemitism12795.91 and12797.03 any12797.27 other12797.63 form12797.86 of12798.1 hatred.12798.26 We12799.78 are12800.02 living12800.18 in12800.5 a12800.67 time12800.83 of12801.07 heightened12801.23 hatred12801.7 and12802.02 bigotry.12802.18 From12803.31 2,02212803.63 to12805.15 2023,12805.39 the12806.67 number12806.91 of12807.23 recorded12807.39 antisemitic12807.94 incidents12808.75 across12809.31 New12809.63 England12809.86 skyrocketed12810.26 by12810.99 more12811.23 than12811.31 22,12811.55 by12812.18 more12812.34 than12812.58 200%,12812.82 reaching12814.26 a12814.66 40-year12815.3 high12815.78 for12816.1 the12816.26 region,12816.42 according12816.74 to12817.22 a12817.38 recent12817.46 report.12817.78 In12818.74 Massachusetts,12819.06 the12819.86 number12820.02 of12820.26 antisemitic12820.5 incidents12821.22 soared12821.7 from12822.02 15212822.26 in12823.7 202212823.86 to12825.3 44012825.46 in12826.9 2023.12827.22 Massachusetts12829.14 recorded12829.93 the12830.42 fifth12830.57 highest12830.98 number12831.38 of12831.77 incidents12832.01 per12832.65 state12832.81 in12833.14 the12833.3 entire12833.53 country,12834.09 followed12835.06 only12835.53 by12835.85 Calif12836.17 by12836.65 California,12836.98 New12838.01 York,12838.17 New12838.57 Jersey,12838.81 and12839.22 Florida.12839.38 Furthermore,12841.08 these12841.56 incidents12841.88 touch12842.36 all12842.68 corners12843 of12843.32 the12843.48 Commonwealth.12843.56 12712844.68 different12845.96 municipalities.12846.36 So12847.56 at12847.8 least12847.96 112848.28 antisemitic12848.6 incident12849.4 in12849.8 2023,12849.96 and12851.16 it12851.4 increased12851.4 from12851.96 7112852.28 in12852.92 2022.12853.31
12855.55 Imagine12855.55 a12856.02 white12856.1 supremacist12856.43 group12857.15 buying12857.63 the12857.94 location12858.19 data12858.83 for12859.39 those12859.55 who12859.86 enter12860.19 a12860.43 synagogue12860.58 or,12861.86 for12862.02 that12862.27 matter,12862.51 a12862.91 mosque,12863.07 or12863.47 predominantly12863.63 black12864.51 church,12864.83 or12865.63 any12865.94 other12866.19 place12866.58 of12866.83 worship12867.07 that12867.7 serves12867.94 a12868.35 community12868.51 that12869.12 could12869.28 be12869.52 targeted12869.68 by12870.16 those12870.32 who12870.64 are12870.8 looking12870.96 to12871.28 commit12871.44 violent12871.84 acts12872.4 driven12872.72 by12873.04 hate.12873.28 Failure12874.64 to12875.04 address12875.2 this12875.6 violation12875.84 of12876.4 our12876.56 privacy12876.8 when12877.6 we12877.92 have12878.16 the12878.4 means12878.56 to12878.8 protect12878.96 people12879.36 is12880.08 irresponsible12880.32 and12881.2 could12881.44 lead12881.68 to12881.92 tragedy.12882.16 The12883.92 voters12884.17 who12884.49 elected12884.81 you12885.2 put12885.76 their12886 trust12886.33 in12886.65 you12886.81 to12887.36 enact12887.52 laws12888 that12888.33 protect12888.57 people12889.05 in12889.28 our12889.44 commonwealth.12889.68 I12891.13 can12891.28 think12891.44 of12891.68 no12891.92 better12892.17 example12892.57 for12893.68 you12893.84 to12894 live12894.17 up12894.49 to12894.65 that12895.28 responsibility12895.52 than12896.6 to12896.84 enact12897 this12897.64 bill.12897.88 In12898.92 doing12899.08 so,12899.48 you12899.88 may12900.04 be12900.28 preventing12900.44 the12900.92 next12901.08 tragedy12901.4 from12901.88 taking12902.12 place12902.36 here12902.68 in12902.92 our12903.16 state.12903.4 She12904.68 also12904.84 strongly12905.16 urges12905.72 the12906.04 members12906.2 of12906.76 the12906.84 joint12907 committee12907.32 to12908.6 favorably12909.65 report12910.38 this12910.69 bill12910.93 out12911.17 as12911.5 soon12911.73 as12911.98 possible.12912.22 And12913.17 to12913.42 support12913.57 more12914.06 expansive12914.38 omnibus12915.09 legislation12915.65 that12916.61 would12916.77 protect12917.01 privacy12917.5 and12918.06 include12918.3 the12918.69 location12918.85 shield12919.33 act.12919.73
LYV12927.13 NORRIS12927.13 -12927.13 REPRODUCTIVE12927.13 EQUITY12927.13 NOW12927.13 -12927.13 Good12927.13 afternoon,12927.37 chairs12928.01 and12928.73 members12929.05 of12929.29 the12929.45 committee.12929.61 My12930.01 name12930.17 is12930.33 Liv12930.49 Norris,12930.73 and12931.13 I12931.29 am12931.37 here12931.53 on12931.69 behalf12931.85 of12932.17 Reproductive12932.33 Equity12932.89 Now12933.37 in12933.77 strong12934.01 support12934.41 of12934.65 the12934.81 Location12934.97 Shield12935.37 Act.12935.77 Location12936.73 privacy12937.13 is12937.6 not12937.85 just12938 a12938.25 data12938.33 privacy12938.73 issue.12939.28 It12940.25 is12940.41 fundamental12940.65 to12941.6 personal12941.85 autonomy12942.33 and12942.97 safety12943.2 and12943.6 is12943.85 directly12944.08 connected12944.49 to12944.89 reproductive12945.05 justice.12945.6 Corporations12947.05 collect12947.85 and12948.25 sell12948.41 vast12948.81 amounts12949.05 of12949.52 highly12949.69 detailed12950.26 sensitive12950.58 data12951.06 about12951.46 all12951.7 of12951.86 us.12952.02 And12952.74 unless12952.98 and12953.38 until12953.62 Massachusetts12954.1 takes12954.9 action,12955.22 individuals12956.02 in12956.42 our12956.58 communities12956.82 are12958.02 vulnerable12958.26 to12958.74 real12958.9 harm12959.22 at12959.54 a12959.7 time12959.78 in12960.02 our12960.18 country12960.26 when12960.66 protecting12960.98 information12961.54 about12962.11 your12962.35 private12962.6 reproductive12963.16 health12963.64 choices12963.88 is12964.67 more12964.83 urgent12965.08 than12965.32 ever.12965.56
12967 Efforts12967 to12967.32 criminalize12967.48 abortion12968.03 care12968.52 are12968.92 ever-evolving,12969.32 with12970.11 patients12970.35 and12970.67 providers12970.92 facing12971.4 both12971.8 civil12972.19 and12972.52 criminal12972.75 threats12973.24 from12973.72 hostile12973.95 states.12974.52 Last12975.53 year,12975.69 it12975.85 was12975.93 discovered12976.33 that12976.65 an12976.81 anti12976.97 abortion12977.29 group12977.61 had12977.93 targeted12978.17 patients12978.97 from12979.45 nearly12979.69 60012980.01 Planned12980.65 Parenthood12980.89 locations12982.09 across12982.65 the12982.97 country12983.05 with12984.01 anti12984.33 abortion12984.65 political12985.05 advertising.12985.53 It's12986.97 incredibly12987.29 disturbing12987.85 that12988.33 unregulated12988.73 data12989.13 brokers12989.44 are12989.93 profiting12990.17 from12990.57 selling12990.81 the12991.13 location12991.28 data12991.77 of12992 abortion12992.17 patients12992.73 and12993.36 that12993.6 anti12993.93 abortion12994.25 extremists12994.73 are12995.36 among12995.52 their12995.77 buyers.12996 And12997.52 there12997.77 are12997.85 bigger12998 threats12998.25 on12998.49 the12998.65 horizon12998.73 when12999.2 it12999.36 comes12999.44 to12999.69 reproductive12999.85 freedom13000.41 and13000.81 data13000.97 privacy.13001.2 With13002.08 a13002.33 federal13002.41 administration13002.81 that13003.53 poses13003.69 an13004.01 existential13005.29 threat13005.53 to13006.01 abortion13006.33 access,13006.89 anti13007.77 abortion13008.09 politicians13008.57 are13009.05 emboldened13009.29 to13010.33 weaponize13010.49 location13011.05 data13011.45 as13011.85 a13012.01 way13012.17 to13012.25 repress13012.41 patients13012.97 who13013.29 are13013.45 seeking13013.61 abortion13013.93 care13014.33 across13014.57 state13014.89 lines.13015.21
13016.42 As13016.42 patients13016.57 travel13017.06 here13017.38 for13017.61 care13017.85 and13018.17 our13018.42 shield13018.57 law13018.98 protects13019.22 providers13019.61 offering13020.17 medication13020.57 abortion13021.06 across13021.93 state13022.33 lines,13022.57 the13023.14 significant13023.38 danger13023.93 of13024.25 selling13024.42 location13024.73 data,13025.14 which13025.45 identifies13025.61 where13026.25 we13026.49 live,13026.65 where13027.45 we13027.61 work,13027.77 and13028.01 get13028.25 health13028.42 care,13028.65 is13028.98 clear.13029.22 The13030.28 Location13030.6 Shield13031.32 Act13031.32 provides13031.32 straightforward13031.8 protections13033.24 to13033.48 give13033.64 ordinary13033.88 people13034.36 robust13034.92 location13035.32 data13035.8 privacy13036.04 and13036.92 is13037.16 an13037.32 essential13037.48 step13037.96 to13038.44 ensuring13038.6 that13039 Massachusetts13039.01 residents13039.01 and13039.02 visitors13039.02 are13039.03 able13039.04 to13039.04 use13039.05 everyday13039.06 technologies13039.06 without13039.07 compromising13039.07 on13039.08 their13039.33 committee13042.49 to13043.32 give13044.15 a13044.98 favorable13045.82 report13046.65 out13047.48 to13048.32 the13049.15 Location13049.98 Shield13050.81 Act.13051.65 Thank13052.48 you13053.31 for13054.15 that.13054.98 So13056.65 much.13056.9 Committee13057.75 to13057.99 give13058.03 a13058.07 favorable13058.31 report13058.79 out13059.19 to13059.35 the13059.43 location13059.59 show13060.07 act.13060.23 Thank13060.55 you13060.71 for13060.87 that.13060.95
13061.11 SPEAKER113061.11 -13061.11 Thank13061.11 you13061.27 so13061.43 much.13061.51
NITHYA13065.91 BADRINATH13065.91 -13065.91 JANE13065.91 DOE13065.91 INC.13065.91 -13065.91 HB13065.91 8613065.91 -13065.91 SB13065.91 19713065.91 -13065.91 Good13065.91 afternoon,13066.15 chairs13066.71 Moore13067.03 and13067.27 Farley13067.35 Bouvier13067.67 and13068.55 honorable13068.79 members13069.19 of13069.51 the13069.59 joint13069.75 committee13069.99 on13070.23 advanced13070.47 IT,13070.87 Internet,13071.11 and13071.51 cybersecurity.13071.67 My13072.79 name13072.95 is13073.17 Nithya13073.25 Badrinath,13073.58 and13074.14 I'm13074.22 the13074.38 policy13074.53 director13074.85 at13075.17 Jane13075.33 Doe13075.58 Inc.13076.14 The13076.3 Massachusetts13076.3 Coalition13076.85 Against13077.42 Sexual13077.73 Assault13078.06 and13078.3 Domestic13078.45 Violence.13078.77 I'm13079.73 here13079.81 today13080.06 to13080.38 testify13080.69 in13081.17 support13081.33 of13081.66 the13081.73 Location13081.9 Shield13082.3 Act13082.61 H13082.93 8613083.17 and13083.66 S13084.3 197.13085.83 As13085.83 the13086.07 state13086.15 coalition13086.55 with13086.95 6013087.19 member13087.59 programs13087.99 that13088.39 work13088.55 directly13088.79 with13089.19 victims13089.35 and13089.75 survivors13089.91 of13090.39 sexual13090.55 assault13090.95 and13091.19 domestic13091.35 violence,13091.75 I'd13092.47 like13092.63 to13092.79 take13092.87 a13093.03 couple13093.11 of13093.43 minutes13093.43 to13093.75 discuss13093.91 our13094.23 support13094.39 for13094.71 these13094.87 important13095.03 bills.13095.43 The13096.07 Location13096.23 Shield13096.71 Act13097.11 would13097.43 stop13097.67 the13097.99 sale13098.15 of13098.39 cell13098.55 phone13098.59 location13098.62 data13098.66 while13098.7 still13098.77 allowing13098.81 companies13098.85 to13098.88 collect13098.92 and13098.96 process13098.99 this13099.03 data13099.14 with13104.13 consent.13104.13
13105.13 Data13105.13 brokers13106.13 have13106.6 access13106.69 to13107.05 and13107.42 sell13107.79 vast13108.16 quantities13108.52 of13108.76 cell13108.92 phone13109.08 data.13109.25 Data13109.25 brokers13109.25 will13109.26 sell13109.26 this13109.26 information13109.27 to13109.27 anyone13109.27 with13109.28 the13109.28 money13109.28 to13109.29 buy13109.29 it,13109.3 including13109.3 people13109.3 causing13109.31 harm,13109.31 such13109.31 as13109.32 domestic13109.32 violence,13109.33 and13111.57 anyone13112.19 with13112.43 the13112.59 money13112.67 to13112.91 buy13113.07 it,13113.31 including13113.55 people13114.03 causing13114.35 harm13114.83 such13115.15 as13115.39 domestic13115.55 violence13115.95 or13116.35 stalking.13116.51 The13117.55 location13117.71 data13118.19 broker13118.43 business13118.83 threatens13119.23 every13119.71 person13119.95 in13120.27 our13120.43 state13120.67 but13120.99 is13121.15 especially13121.39 dangerous13121.79 for13122.35 people13122.51 in13122.75 abusive13122.91 relationships13123.47 and13124.03 those13124.19 targeted13124.51 by13124.91 stalkers.13125.07 An13126.17 individual's13126.58 personal13127.69 location13128.1 information13128.58 reveals13129.38 the13129.85 most13130.02 sensitive13130.33 and13130.9 intimate13131.14 things13131.61 about13131.94 them.13132.33 Survivors13133.3 often13133.85 take13134.25 careful13134.5 steps13134.98 to13135.38 conceal13135.45 their13135.94 locations,13136.1 but13137.06 all13137.3 their13137.53 efforts13137.69 can13138.33 be13138.58 undermined13138.74 by13139.22 the13139.38 sale13139.63 of13139.79 location13139.95 data13140.43 that13140.75 shows13140.91 where13141.31 they13141.47 seek13141.71 shelter13141.95 and13143.07 reveals13143.31 their13143.71 daily13143.87 routines.13144.19
13145.71 Last13145.71 year,13146.03 Massachusetts13146.51 passed13147.23 incredibly13147.55 important13148.11 legislation13148.59 allowing13149.31 survivors13149.71 to13150.27 seek13150.35 protection13150.59 orders13151.07 for13151.47 experiencing13151.83 a13152.23 course13152.23 of13152.48 control.13152.64 Abusers13153.59 having13154.15 access13154.48 to13154.88 a13155.11 survivor's13155.27 personal13155.83 data13156.15 through13156.56 data13156.8 brokers13157.11 enables13157.75 a13158.23 course13158.23 of13158.48 controlling13158.64 behaviors.13159.11 A13160.08 common13160.23 113160.56 is13160.88 tracking13161.11 a13161.51 survivor's13161.59 location13162.15 to13162.64 stalk,13162.88 intimidate,13163.35 harass,13164.12 and13164.36 even13164.6 monitor13164.84 and13165.16 monitor13165.4 a13165.8 survivor.13165.88 The13167.08 threat13167.24 of13167.48 this13167.64 dangerous13167.88 industry13168.28 that13168.76 facilitates13168.92 stalking13169.56 and13169.96 abuse13170.12 is13170.52 alarming,13170.76 but13171.48 we13171.72 know13171.88 that13172.04 the13172.2 legislature13172.28 can13172.92 act13173.16 again13173.4 this13173.72 year13173.88 to13174.12 further13174.28 support13174.68 a13175 survivor's13175.16 access13175.8 to13176.2 privacy13176.36 and13176.92 safety.13177.08 Survivors13178.12 of13178.6 domestic13178.76 violence13179.16 and13179.56 stalking,13179.88 people13180.51 seeking13180.83 sensitive13181.16 health13181.64 care,13181.8 and13182.11 everybody13182.35 in13182.67 Massachusetts13182.92 should13183.64 have13183.88 control13184.03 of13184.51 their13184.59 own13184.75 personal13185 data.13185.4 We13186.19 ask13186.43 the13186.67 committee13186.75 for13187.16 a13187.31 favorable13187.4 report13187.95 of13188.27 the13188.43 location13188.51 shield13189 act13189.4 and13189.8 also13189.95 broad,13190.75 robust13191 privacy13191.48 legislation13192.64 such13193.28 as13193.52 the13193.68 Massachusetts13193.84 Data13194.32 Privacy13194.64 Act13195.12 and13195.6 Massachusetts13195.84 Consumer13196.4 Data13196.8 Privacy13197.04 Act.13197.44 Thank13197.68 you13197.84 for13198 your13198.16 consideration.13198.32
13199.2 FARLEY-BOUVIER13199.2 -13199.2 Terrific.13199.2 Thank13199.68 you.13199.92 Any13200.8 questions13201.12 for13201.76 the13201.92 panel?13202.08 We13203.6 really13203.84 do13204.08 appreciate13204.24 your13204.72 testimony.13204.88 Thank13205.52 you13205.68 very13205.92 much.13206.68 We13207.16 have13207.64 an13208.03 then13208.19 our13208.35 next13208.68 panel,13209 led13209.88 by13210.19 Brianna13210.44 Sav13211 Savidge,13211.32 and13211.8 then13211.95 we13212.19 are13212.35 going13212.6 to13212.83 move13213 to13213.24 Sam13213.48 Larson13213.72 of13214.11 the13214.27 Associated13214.35 Industry.13214.83 And13221.42 then13221.58 we're13221.66 gonna13221.9 go13222.22 back13222.38 online13222.7 to13222.78 CG.13224.7 In13235.1 any13235.42 order13235.74 you13235.98 would13236.14 like.13236.3
BRIANNA13238.14 SAVAGE13238.14 -13238.14 YW13238.14 BOSTON13238.14 -13238.14 HB13238.14 8613238.14 -13238.14 SB13238.14 19713238.14 -13238.14 Good13238.14 afternoon.13238.45 Thank13238.94 you,13239.18 chairs13239.42 and13239.66 members13239.9 of13240.22 the13240.3 committee.13240.38 My13241.58 name13241.74 is13241.9 Brianna13242.14 Savage.13242.61 I13243.1 am13243.33 the13243.58 associate13243.82 director13244.3 of13244.69 advocacy13244.94 at13245.5 YW13245.66 Boston.13246.14 I'm13246.61 also13246.85 a13247.1 lifelong13247.33 Massachusetts13247.73 resident,13248.45 a13249.17 homeowner13249.41 in13249.81 North13249.97 Reading,13250.21 and13250.61 a13250.77 new13250.85 mom.13251.09 I13251.97 am13252.13 here13252.29 representing13252.53 myself13253.01 and13253.41 YW13253.65 Boston.13254.13 YW13255.17 Boston13255.57 is13255.89 a13256.13 nonprofit13256.21 organization13256.85 that13257.57 works13257.81 to13258.05 eliminate13258.21 racism,13258.69 empower13259.25 women,13259.81 and13260.37 promote13260.45 peace,13260.93 justice,13261.42 freedom,13261.66 and13261.82 dignity13262.06 for13262.53 all.13262.69 We13263.25 do13263.42 that13263.58 through13263.74 our13263.98 industry-leading13264.53 leadership13264.85 development,13265.33 consulting13265.98 and13266.38 training,13266.53 and13267.42 youth13267.66 development,13267.9 and13268.45 through13268.61 advocacy13268.85 work13269.33 focused13269.58 on13269.9 reducing13270.06 barriers13270.53 to13270.93 equity13271.17 in13271.58 Massachusetts,13271.74 which13272.69 is13272.93 why13273.09 I'm13273.25 here13273.42 today13273.66 in13275.36 strong13275.6 support13276 of13276.32 H13276.56 8613277.04 and13278.4 S197,13278.96 the13278.96 location13279.12 shield13279.52 act.13279.84 YW13280.72 Boston13281.2 is13281.6 committed13281.68 to13282 upholding13282.24 the13282.64 rights13282.72 of13283.04 all13283.12 citizens13283.36 regardless13283.84 of13284.4 their13284.48 background,13284.72 especially13285.36 of13285.76 those13285.84 who13286.08 have13286.24 been13286.32 historically13286.56 targeted13287.12 or13287.52 marginalized.13287.68 As13288.96 technology13289.2 continues13289.82 to13290.14 advance13290.38 with13290.77 the13291.02 support13291.1 of13291.5 private13291.58 entities,13291.98 we13292.85 must13293.02 advance13293.33 our13293.66 laws13293.82 to13294.53 protect13294.69 our13295.02 civil13295.17 rights.13295.42 We13296.06 cannot13296.14 let13296.53 their13296.77 ruthless13297.17 need13297.74 for13297.98 profit13298.14 and13298.53 power13298.69 outpace13299.33 our13299.9 fundamental13300.06 right13300.61 to13300.85 privacy13300.94 and13301.5 protection.13301.58
13303.01 Location13303.57 privacy13303.57 is13303.97 fundamental13304.13 to13304.69 personal13304.85 autonomy,13305.25 safety,13305.81 and13306.13 the13306.37 exercise13306.45 of13306.93 our13307.01 other13307.49 basic13307.73 rights.13308.05 But13308.37 unfortunately,13308.53 no13309.09 current13309.25 law13309.57 forbids13309.81 companies13310.21 from13310.61 buying13310.77 and13311.01 trading13311.09 our13311.49 location13311.65 information.13312.05 Extremely13313.01 sensitive13313.49 information13313.97 revealing13314.53 who13314.93 we13315.09 are,13315.25 what13315.49 we13315.65 do,13315.81 with13316.21 whom13316.45 we13316.61 associate,13316.77 what13317.25 we13317.49 are13317.65 interested13317.73 in,13318.21 and13318.69 how13318.85 we13318.94 behave13319.1 is13319.42 up13319.66 for13319.74 grabs13319.98 in13320.22 a13320.38 multibillion-dollar13321.18 marketplace.13321.58 We13322.53 must13322.77 challenge13323.02 those13323.33 who13323.58 wanna13323.74 monetize13324.06 discrimination.13324.69 This13326.14 data13326.38 has13326.69 been13326.85 used13327.02 to13327.25 track13327.33 and13327.58 identify13327.74 people13328.22 seeking13328.61 reproductive13328.94 health13329.74 care13329.9 services,13330.06 attending13330.53 religious13330.94 services,13331.51 visiting13331.83 homeless13332.23 and13332.55 domestic13332.79 violence13333.27 shelters,13333.83 and13334.71 going13334.87 to13335.11 sites13335.27 that13335.51 provide13335.67 addiction13335.99 services13336.39 for13336.79 treatment.13336.95 Imagine13338.23 the13338.63 people13338.71 who13338.95 would13339.11 likely13339.27 need13339.67 to13339.83 seek13339.91 reproductive13340.39 services,13340.95 be13341.35 targeted13341.51 for13341.91 attending13342.07 religious13342.47 service,13342.79 visit13343.11 shelters,13343.44 and13343.69 receive13343.93 treatment.13344.33
13344.73 And13344.73 I'm13344.89 sure13345.13 you13345.28 can13345.36 see13345.52 why13345.69 this13346.41 is13346.57 a13346.73 civil13346.89 rights13347.2 issue.13347.6 We13348.33 know13348.57 that13348.73 women,13348.97 people13349.36 of13349.69 color,13349.85 and13350.17 folks13350.33 with13350.57 marginalized13350.81 gender13351.28 identities13351.69 are13352.25 especially13352.41 vulnerable13353.52 to13354.08 the13354.17 sale13354.33 of13354.57 this13354.73 data.13354.89 Today,13357.49 authoritarianism13357.73 is13358.93 a13359.09 growing13359.17 threat13359.57 to13359.81 our13359.89 most13360.05 cherished13360.29 democratic13360.61 values13361.25 and13361.57 civil13361.73 rights.13362.05 Passing13362.77 the13363.89 Location13364.05 Shield13364.05 Act13364.05 will13364.05 ensure13364.21 that13364.53 our13364.69 cell13364.85 phones13365.01 cannot13365.33 be13365.57 weaponized13365.73 against13366.37 us.13366.61 And13367.17 so,13367.41 YW13367.65 Boston13368.61 respectfully13369.01 asked13369.58 this13369.75 committee13369.91 to13370.31 favorably13370.47 report13371.26 the13371.67 location13371.75 shield13372.23 act,13372.55 and13372.7 we13372.86 strongly13373.1 support13373.42 including13373.83 a13374.15 ban13374.23 on13374.47 the13374.63 sale13374.7 of13375.02 location13375.1 data13375.5 generated13376.15 from13376.55 electronic13376.78 devices13377.26 in13377.67 the13377.75 Commonwealth13377.91 in13378.63 omnibus13378.86 consumer13379.42 privacy13379.83 legislation,13380.23 as13380.7 you13380.86 did13381.02 last13381.26 session.13381.42 Thank13381.98 you13382.15 so13382.39 much13382.47 for13382.63 your13382.78 attention13382.94 and13383.26 consideration.13383.67
13383.99 SPEAKER113383.99 -13383.99 Thank13383.99 you.13384.23 So13385.67 nice13386.55 to13386.71 see13386.79 you.13386.95 Nice13387.19 to13387.43 see13387.59 you.13387.67
13388.79 FAYERUTH13388.79 FISHER13388.79 -13388.79 JCRC13388.79 -13388.79 HB13388.79 8613388.79 -13388.79 SB13388.79 18713388.79 -13388.79 Thank13388.79 you,13389.03 Chair13389.19 Moore,13389.59 Chair13390.07 Farley13390.07 Bouvier,13390.47 and13391.11 members13391.35 of13391.75 the13391.91 committee,13391.99 for13392.87 your13393.03 time13393.27 and13393.51 attention13393.67 to13394.15 the13394.23 important13394.39 matters13395.03 for13395.43 you13395.59 today.13395.75 I13396.15 will13396.23 submit13396.55 written13397.59 testimony13397.91 and13398.47 try13398.89 and13399 self-edit.13399.52 But13400.24 for13400.48 the13400.65 record,13400.81 my13401.13 name13401.2 is13401.36 Faye13401.52 Ruth13401.76 Fisher,13401.92 and13402.24 I'm13402.32 the13402.48 chief13402.65 of13402.89 public13403.05 affairs13403.36 and13404.08 community13404.32 relations13404.81 for13405.2 the13405.44 Jewish13405.52 Community13405.92 Relations13406.4 Council13406.81 of13407.28 Greater13407.52 Boston.13407.84 And13408.4 I'm13408.65 testifying13408.81 in13409.44 strong13409.68 support13410.08 of13410.56 H13411.05 8613411.36 and13412.08 S13412.97 187,13414.32 known13414.32 as13414.7 the13414.94 location13414.94 shield13415.42 act.13415.74 Our13416.62 mission13416.94 is13417.42 to13417.58 promote13417.74 an13418.14 American13418.38 society13418.86 that13419.26 is13419.5 democratic,13419.74 pluralistic,13420.54 and13421.34 just.13421.58 The13423.1 core13423.26 of13423.26 any13423.26 pluralistic13423.5 society13424.22 is13424.94 ensuring13425.1 that13425.58 residents13425.74 can13426.3 live13426.72 self-determined13427.35 lives13427.83 with13428.23 safety13428.56 and13429.19 meaning.13429.35 S13431.75 8613432.56 I'm13433.35 sorry.13433.51 I'm13433.83 flipping13434.08 my13434.48 bills.13434.64 But13434.88 this13435.11 bill13435.27 would13435.51 help13435.67 forward13435.92 this13436.23 goal13436.48 by13436.8 helping13436.95 some13437.27 of13437.51 the13437.59 most13437.67 vulnerable13438.48 residents13439.03 to13439.77 protect13440.01 them13440.41 to13440.73 have13440.81 the13441.05 freedom13441.21 and13441.61 autonomy13441.85 to13442.57 make13442.65 decisions13442.89 without13443.77 fear13444.17 of13444.41 violence,13444.57 including13445.53 the13446.01 freedom13446.09 to13446.57 access13446.73 health13447.13 care13447.37 and13448.01 worship13448.25 how13448.89 and13449.13 where13449.37 they13449.69 choose.13449.85
13451.05 These13451.05 are13451.37 basic13451.61 fundamental13452.33 principles13453.05 that13453.53 have13453.77 helped13454.01 govern13454.25 our13454.65 commonwealth13454.81 that13455.98 we13456.31 as13456.55 a13456.78 Jewish13456.86 community13457.18 have13458.39 relied13458.63 upon.13458.94 And13459.98 we13460.15 are13460.31 grateful13460.47 for13460.86 the13461.02 steps13461.18 the13461.5 legislature13461.75 has13462.39 taken13462.7 to13463.18 safeguard13463.34 these13463.9 and13464.15 to13464.31 invest13464.47 in13464.78 communal13465.02 security.13465.42 As13466.78 others13467.02 on13467.34 this13467.65 panel13467.81 will13468.21 have13468.85 shared,13469.17 our13469.65 communities13469.81 are13470.45 continuing13470.69 to13471.33 experience13471.65 this13472.21 rise13472.37 in13472.93 extremism13473.25 with13474.21 the13474.37 targeting13474.61 of13475.01 worship13475.17 spaces13475.57 and13476.45 community13476.69 organizations.13477.25 We13478.93 are13479.17 grateful13479.33 that13479.81 113480.13 such13480.61 recent13481.09 incident13481.49 targeting13482.05 the13482.45 Jewish13482.53 community13482.93 was13483.69 prevented,13483.94 resulting13484.66 in13485.14 an13485.3 arrest13485.45 in13485.77 Beverly13485.94 and13487.06 the13487.22 confiscation13487.45 of13488.09 weapons,13488.25 including13488.82 ghost13489.3 guns.13489.53 The13490.58 person13490.82 had13491.14 both13491.3 the13491.61 means13491.77 and13492.17 the13492.33 violent13492.5 intention,13492.9 which13493.69 is13493.94 frightening13494.17 and13494.74 chilling.13494.9 These13496.01 statistics13496.33 increased13496.98 year13497.53 over13497.77 year,13498.65 as13499.21 Cindy13499.37 Roe13499.85 shared13500.17 what13500.57 those13500.81 statistics13501.05 were,13501.53 but13501.85 some13502.17 of13502.33 the13502.41 ones13502.57 that13502.89 were13503.13 shared13503.37 were13503.69 from13503.85 the13504.09 Massachusetts13504.17 Executive13504.97 Office13505.53 of13505.85 Public13506.09 Safety13506.81 and13507.21 Security.13507.45 The13508.81 JCRC13508.81 endorsed13509.53 both13510.09 of13510.33 these13510.49 bills13510.73 in13511.13 202313511.37 and13512.33 continues13513.19 to13513.51 strongly13513.83 support13513.83 them13514.15 as13514.55 important13514.86 and13515.35 needed13515.5 interventions13516.07 to13517.27 stop13517.5 someone13517.83 or13518.39 people13518.63 with13519.02 means13519.27 and13519.58 intention13519.75 from13520.39 accessing13520.7 personal13521.27 location13521.75 data13522.23 to13522.55 do13522.7 real13522.94 harm.13523.1 We13524.07 respectfully13524.39 urge13525.02 you13525.27 to13525.43 report13525.5 these13525.83 bills13526.07 favorably13526.39 out13526.86 of13527.1 committee13527.19 as13527.74 a13527.82 practical13528.06 next13528.54 step13528.78 to13529.1 protect13529.34 so13529.74 many13529.98 diverse13530.22 communities.13530.7 Thank13531.74 you13531.98 so13532.14 much13532.38 for13532.54 your13532.78 time13532.94 and13533.18 attention.13533.42 Thank13534.06 you.13534.3
NASIR13537.26 ELEDRUSE13537.26 -13537.26 COLOR13537.26 OF13537.26 CHANGE13537.26 -13537.26 SB13537.26 19713537.26 -13537.26 Thank13537.26 you,13537.42 chairs.13537.58 Thank13538.06 you,13538.22 members13538.38 of13538.62 the13538.78 committee,13538.86 for13539.18 this13539.34 opportunity13539.5 to13540.06 speak.13540.22 My13540.62 name13540.78 is13540.94 Nasir13541.1 Eledruse.13541.5 I'm13542.06 from13542.14 an13542.58 organization13542.74 called13543.06 Color13543.38 of13543.69 Change.13543.85 We13544.74 are13544.98 a13545.14 racial13545.3 justice13545.69 organization13546.17 advocating13546.82 on13547.3 behalf13547.38 of13547.69 black13547.85 people13548.09 in13548.42 the13548.5 Commonwealth13548.58 and13549.14 across13549.38 the13549.77 country.13549.85 I'm13550.98 here13551.14 testifying13551.53 in13552.09 support13552.25 of13552.66 the13552.74 Location13552.9 Shield13553.38 Act,13553.77 age13554.33 86,13554.58 and13555.22 S13557.3 197.13557.56 This13557.56 legislation13557.72 is13558.36 critical13558.52 for13558.92 protecting13559.16 privacy13559.48 and13560.12 promoting13560.52 racial13560.92 justice.13561.32 Members13562.76 of13563.08 the13563.16 committee,13563.32 what13563.88 does13564.2 mass13564.76 data13565.08 collection13565.4 feel13565.88 like?13566.12 It13566.92 might13567.08 depend13567.32 on13567.64 who13567.72 you13567.96 are.13568.12 For13568.92 most13569.16 people,13569.48 your13570.12 location13570.36 data13570.92 might13571.48 be13571.72 harvested13572.27 from13572.59 weather13572.91 apps13573.15 or13574.02 your13574.43 gas13574.67 station13574.83 finder,13575.23 primarily13576.51 to13577.15 target13577.31 you13577.63 with13577.78 ads13578.02 based13578.43 on13578.67 where13578.83 you13578.99 go13579.15 in13579.39 both13579.63 good13579.86 and13580.02 bad13580.27 weather13580.51 or13581.15 after13581.39 filling13581.7 your13582.02 tank.13582.19 But13583.15 the13583.31 average13583.47 phone13583.86 has13584.19 about13584.43 2513584.67 apps13585.23 collecting13585.55 and13586.1 selling13586.34 this13586.58 data.13586.82
13587.94 But13587.94 what13588.18 if13588.34 you13588.5 use13588.66 apps13588.98 specific13589.46 to13589.86 your13590.02 community?13590.26 Just13591.38 last13591.62 week,13591.86 Muslims13592.34 in13592.98 my13593.22 community13593.46 in13593.86 Worcester13594.02 gathered13594.74 for13595.06 the13595.3 Eid13595.46 prayer.13595.62 We13596.58 often13596.82 relied13597.14 on13597.46 using13597.7 this13598.02 app13598.26 called13598.5 Muslim13598.74 Pro13599.3 for13599.86 prayer13600.1 times13600.42 and13600.9 a13601.22 pocket13601.3 Quran.13601.78 In13602.8 2020,13603.03 we13603.59 learned13603.75 that13604 this13604.24 app13604.48 collected13604.72 location13605.11 data13605.52 and13605.92 that13606.16 it13606.32 was13606.32 accessed13606.56 by13606.95 federal13607.27 agencies,13607.67 including13608.64 the13609.03 military,13609.19 circumventing13610.4 the13610.95 Fourth13611.35 Amendment13612.24 like13612.24 giving13612.56 a13612.88 landlord13613.03 cash13613.59 to13614.64 access13614.8 an13615.11 apartment13615.35 without13615.83 a13616.08 warrant.13616.24 Imagine13616.8 if13618.05 you13618.21 use13618.45 any13618.69 other13619.01 app13619.33 that13619.73 is13619.89 unique13620.05 to13620.45 a13620.61 community13620.77 that13621.17 you13621.33 are13621.49 part13621.57 of.13621.81 Jewish13622.85 communities13623.25 use13623.89 an13624.21 app13624.45 like13624.85 Sephiria13625.17 to13625.81 interface13625.97 with13626.37 the13626.53 Torah13626.61 or13627.01 other13627.17 religious13627.41 texts.13627.89 Black13628.93 people13629.17 using13629.89 the13630.37 BLK13630.77 dating13631.09 app13631.49 or13631.81 LGBTQ13632.41 people13633.05 using13633.28 another13633.6 dating13633.84 app,13634.08 Grindr.13634.49 Women13635.76 using13636.17 fertility13636.41 apps,13636.97 children13637.76 on13638.17 social13638.33 media,13638.65 nothing13639.13 stops13640.08 these13640.49 apps13640.81 from13641.05 selling13641.28 your13641.6 location.13641.76
13643.05
13643.05 In13643.05 02/2019,13643.2 the13644.08 New13644.17 York13644.25 Times13644.49 opinion13644.73 team13645.13 showed13645.68 just13646 how13646.25 specific13646.49 this13647.05 data13647.2 is.13647.52 They13648.59 tracked13648.83 a13649.15 worker13649.31 on13649.79 their13650.03 day13650.27 off13650.51 interviewing13651.07 for13651.47 a13651.59 new13651.71 job13651.87 and13652.67 even13652.83 identified13653.15 a13653.71 musician13653.79 who13654.27 played13654.43 in13654.59 Trump's13654.99 first13655.55 inauguration13655.95 band.13656.67 The13657.63 Heritage13657.79 Foundation,13658.27 a13658.91 conservative13658.99 think13659.63 tank,13659.87 proudly13660.51 boasted13660.99 online13661.75 about13662.08 being13662.23 able13662.56 to13662.72 use13662.88 this13663.11 data13663.27 to13663.59 ID13663.83 people13664.31 and13664.88 organizations13665.27 helping13666.95 migrants13667.19 across13667.92 the13668.23 Southern13668.31 US13668.72 border.13669.03 For13670.48 those13670.72 already13670.95 marginalized13671.43 by13672.08 police13672.23 or13672.64 dependent13672.88 on13673.43 government13673.59 support,13674.08 this13674.88 data13675.11 is13675.92 and13676.31 could13676.56 further13676.88 be13677.35 used13677.73 without13678.13 consent13678.45 to13678.77 make13678.93 decisions13679.09 about13679.49 their13679.81 lives13679.97 or13680.85 even13681.09 threaten13681.33 their13681.65 safety.13681.89 This13682.93 is13683.17 wrong.13683.33 Companies13684.45 don't13684.93 need13685.17 to13685.41 track13685.57 our13685.97 every13686.21 move13686.53 to13687.01 provide13687.17 services.13687.57 Massachusetts13688.69 has13689.49 the13689.65 opportunity13689.73 to13690.29 lead13690.45 on13690.69 data13690.85 privacy13691.09 by13692.05 enacting13692.44 this13692.69 legislation13693.2 and13693.73 protecting13693.97 personal13694.44 freedoms13694.84 for13695.25 all13695.41 communities.13695.73 I13696.84 ask13697 that13697.17 you13697.33 please13697.49 report13697.81 this13698.05 bill13698.2 favorably13698.44 and13699.08 urgently13699.41 out13700.2 of13700.36 committee,13700.44 with13701.49 an13701.65 unstable13701.89 federal13702.36 government.13702.77 Lives13703.41 are13703.65 at13703.81 stake.13703.97 Thank13704.28 you.13704.44
13705.67 FARLEY-BOUVIER13705.67 -13705.67 Thank13705.67 you.13705.91 Thank13706.15 you13706.39 all13706.55 so13706.79 much.13706.95 Just13707.19 checking13707.43 in13707.75 with13707.91 the13707.99 committee.13708.15 It's13709.19 terrific.13709.43 We13709.91 appreciate13710.07 your13710.47 viewpoints.13710.63 Thank13711.27 you.13711.51 We're13712.71 gonna13712.95 go13713.19 now13713.35 to13713.51 Sam13713.75 Larson,13714.07 and13714.71 then13714.95 we13715.27 are13715.43 gonna13715.59 go13715.83 to13715.99 CJ13716.23 Niket,13716.79 who13717.75 will13717.91 be13718.07 joining13718.23 us13718.55 virtually.13718.85 Nice13719.26 to13719.66 see13719.74 you,13719.82 Sam.13719.98
13720.38 SPEAKER713720.38 -13720.38 Nice13720.38 to13720.53 see13720.58
13720.61 SPEAKER3513720.61 -13720.61 you13720.61 all.13720.69
13723.1 SPEAKER5213723.1 -13723.1 I13723.1 will13723.26 be13723.58 brief.13723.74
13724.22 SPEAKER113724.22 -13724.22 Appreciate13724.22 your13724.69 patience13725.02 today.13725.66
13726.14 SPEAKER5213726.14 -13726.14 No.13726.14 No.13726.3 I'm13726.45 the13726.61 lobbyist.13726.77 No13727.1 113727.26 should13727.42 ever13727.58
13727.98 SPEAKER713727.98 -13727.98 be13727.98 working.13728.06 Okay.13729.1
13729.74 SPEAKER113729.74 -13729.74 Noted.13729.74 Yeah.13730.38 It's13730.77 my13731.02 job13731.18
13731.42 SPEAKER5213731.42 -13731.42 to13731.42 be13731.5 here.13731.74
13732.45 SAM13732.45 LARSON13732.45 -13732.45 AIM13732.45 -13732.45 HB13732.45 8013732.45 -13732.45 SB13732.45 3313732.45 -13732.45 Okay.13732.45 Good13732.77 afternoon,13733.02 Chair13733.42 Farley13733.74 Bouvier,13734.06 Chair13734.56 Moore,13734.72 members13734.96 of13735.16 the13735.36 committee,13735.44 and13735.76 staff.13736 You're13736.32 all13736.56 here,13736.72 too.13736.96 My13737.28 name13737.52 is13737.6 Sam13737.76 Larson.13738.08 I'm13738.48 the13738.64 vice13738.8 president13739.04 of13739.36 government13739.52 affairs13739.76 at13740.32 the13740.48 Associated13740.64 Industries13741.12 of13741.6 Massachusetts.13741.68 We13742.64 are13742.72 the13742.88 largest13743.6 statewide13743.92 business13744.4 association.13744.88 On13745.68 behalf13745.84 of13746.08 our13746.24 3,40013746.32 members,13747.11 particularly13747.44 our13748 small13748.16 and13748.4 medium-sized13748.88 businesses,13749.11 I13750 am13750.16 here13750.24 to13750.48 testify13750.56 in13750.95 favor13751.11 of13751.44 House13752.88 Bill13753.11 8013753.11 and13753.11 Senate13753.11 Bill13753.11 33,13753.11 an13753.59 act13753.75 establishing13754 the13754.72 comprehensive13754.95 Massachusetts13755.59 Consumer13756.24 Data13756.72 Privacy13756.95 Act,13757.44 followed13757.83 by13758.08 leader13758.24 Hogan13758.48 and13758.8 Senator13758.95 Driscoll.13759.35 This13760.09 legislation,13760.33 if13760.89 adopted,13761.13 would13761.53 create13761.69 a13761.93 New13762.01 England13762.17 framework13762.49 to13763.21 regulate13763.37 the13763.77 use13763.85 of13764.09 data13764.17 privacy13764.41 and13764.81 doing13765.13 so,13765.45 give13765.77 Massachusetts13766.01 consumers13766.57 some13767.05 of13767.21 the13767.29 strongest13767.45 comprehensive13767.93 protections13768.65 in13769.05 the13769.21 country13769.85 and,13770.01 at13770.01 the13770.17 same13770.33 time,13770.49 set13770.81 strict13771.05 limits13771.29 on13771.77 how13771.93 businesses13772.17 collect13772.65 and13772.89 use13773.05 consumer13773.29 data.13773.69 Consumers13774.4 who13774.72 have13774.8 only13775.03 control13775.19 their13775.6 data13775.67 by13776 deleting13776.16 it13776.56 or13776.8 opting13776.95 out13777.27 of13777.44 various13777.52 services.13777.92
13778.56 They13778.56 also13778.88 enjoy13779.11 enhanced13779.52 protection13780 on13780.48 sensitive13780.64 data13781.19 and13781.67 have13782.16 to13782.32 opt13782.4 in13782.64 for13782.8 the13782.95 use13783.03 of13783.27 that.13783.35 Adopting13784.24 a13784.72 New13784.8 England13784.95 model13785.27 will13785.6 do13785.75 213786 things.13786.24 1,13786.56 it's13786.88 gonna13787.11 establish13787.52 consistent13788 rules,13788.56 definitions,13789.66 and13790.06 regulations13790.3 for13790.78 our13791.02 members,13791.1 which13791.42 in13791.66 turn13791.82 is13792.14 gonna13792.3 reduce13792.54 compliance13792.94 costs.13793.42 Conversely,13793.98 every13794.54 unique13794.86 state-specific13795.5 data's13795.9 private13796.3 law13796.78 privacy13797.34 law13797.82 increases13798.06 compliance13798.54 costs.13799.02 For13799.42 example,13799.58 the13799.98 California13800.22 attorney13800.7 general13801.1 estimates13801.74 that13802.23 small13802.39 businesses13802.63 with13803.18 under13803.34 2013803.66 employees13803.98 spend13804.39 on13804.7 average13804.86 $50,00013805.26 each13806.31 just13806.55 to13806.63 comply13806.86 with13807.18 their13807.42 state's13807.58 data13807.98 privacy13808.39 law13808.94 when13809.26 it13809.5 rolled13809.58 it13809.82 out.13809.9 Regulatory13810.7 uncertainty13811.34 and13811.98 chaos13812.23 are13812.7 the13812.78 order13812.94 of13813.18 the13813.34 day13813.42 in13813.58 Washington.13813.74 I13814.47 think13814.55 during13814.78 this13815.02 hearing,13815.18 we've13815.5 changed13815.82 our13816.28 national13816.44 trade13816.84 policy13817.16 about13817.48 313817.72 times.13818.04 And13819.16 so13819.48 we13819.72 are13819.88 asking13820.04 that13820.36 you13820.44 create13821 some13821.16 predictability13821.4 here13822.12 for13822.36 businesses.13822.6 Given13823.8 the13824.12 complexity13824.28 of13824.76 the13824.84 subject13825 matter,13825.4 we13825.8 ask13825.96 that13826.2 you13826.28 carefully13826.52 consider13827 businesses13827.4 that13827.88 do13828.04 not13828.35 have13828.52 sophisticated13828.68 compliance13829.32 teams,13829.8 cannot13830.11 afford13830.52 outside13830.92 counsel,13831.24 and13831.95 will13832.35 limit13832.52 the13832.76 unintended13833 consequences13833.4 for13834.11 those13834.27 companies.13834.44
13835.24 Enforcement13835.24 is13835.72 equally13835.88 important13836.19 as13836.6 compliance.13836.76 Under13837.48 this13837.72 bill,13837.88 the13838.11 attorney13838.27 general13838.6 is13838.92 charged13839.08 with13839.4 enforcement.13839.56 And13840.29 there13840.37 is13840.53 no13840.69 private13841.04 right13841.39 of13841.74 action.13842.08 Legal13842.43 comp13842.78 legal13843.48 compliance13843.83 schemes,13844.18 complicated13844.52 as13844.87 data13845.22 privacy,13845.57 enforcement13846.21 is13846.77 best13846.93 left13847.17 into13847.41 the13847.73 hands13847.81 of,13848.21 you13849.01 know,13849.17 responsible13849.41 policymakers.13850.05 And13850.93 private13851.17 attorneys,13851.49 if13852.45 given13852.61 the13852.85 power,13853.01 will13853.41 weaponize13853.65 data13854.21 privacy13854.37 laws13854.85 against13855.35 businesses13855.52 for13856.08 personal13856.16 profit.13856.56 The13857.03 financial13857.27 incentives13857.83 are13858.24 simply13858.48 too13858.72 strong.13858.95 Our13859.6 decision13859.76 to13860.16 endorse13860.48 this13860.88 bill13861.11 and13861.35 the13861.6 recently13861.68 engrossed13862.08 pay13862.56 transparency13862.95 legislation13863.68 represents13864.48 a13864.88 new13864.95 direction13865.11 for13865.6 the13865.92 organization.13866 We've13866.95 heard13867.11 loud13867.27 and13867.52 clear13867.6 that13867.92 the13868.08 business13868.24 community13868.64 needs13869.06 to13869.22 step13869.3 up13869.46 and13869.54 offer13869.86 solutions13870.18 instead13870.74 of13870.98 just13871.14 complaints.13871.38 So13872.18 we13872.42 believe13873.06 this13873.3 bill13873.46 does13873.7 just13873.94 that.13874.1 I13874.5 have13874.66 thoughts13874.74 on13875.06 many13875.22 other13875.38 bills13875.62 and13875.86 will13876.1 expand13876.26 in13876.58 written13876.74 testimony13876.98 in13877.54 light13877.62 of13877.86 everybody's13877.94 time.13878.42 I'm13878.74 open13878.9 to13879.14 questions.13879.22
FARLEY-BOUVIER13879.86 -13879.86 Sure.13879.86 Just13880.58 checking13880.82 in13881.14 with13881.38 the13881.54 committee.13881.62 So,13882.5 I13882.74 have13882.82 a13882.98 couple13883.06 of13883.41 questions.13883.41 Yeah.13883.73 Okay.13884.05 Let's13884.36 do13884.52 it.13884.69 So13885.49 we13886.28 heard13886.6 earlier.13888.44 About13888.69 how13888.84 the13890.05 more,13890.28 the13891.81 other13892.28 Comprehensive13892.6 data13893.33 privacy13893.57 bills13894.13 are13894.77 good13895 for13895.25 small13895.41 businesses.13896.66 And13896.66 there13896.82 seems13896.98 to13897.22 be13897.38 some13897.62 conflict13897.94 in13898.42 that,13898.98 yeah.13899.38 Which13899.38 bills13899.62 are13900.02 better13900.26 for13900.58 small13900.82 business.13901.3 And,13902.34 so13903.14 I'd13903.62 like13904.02 you13904.18 to13904.34 talk13904.42 about13904.58 small13905.3 business.13905.54 And13905.86 Yeah.13906.1 You13906.34 know,13906.5 Sam,13906.82 the13907.54 real13907.78 small13908.1 businesses.13908.34
13908.74 SPEAKER713908.74 -13908.74 Yeah.13908.74 Yeah.13909.14
13909.3 LARSON13909.3 -13909.3 For13909.3 sure.13909.46 Many13909.62 of13909.86 them13909.94 sit13910.18 on13910.34 our13910.59 board13910.67 and13911 talk13911.48 to13911.72 me13911.8 very13912.03 frequently.13912.27 I13914.67 think13914.75 there13915 are13915.4 maybe13915.48 some13915.8 benefits13916.03 in13916.59 the13916.67 other13916.75 bill,13917 but13917.15 speaking13917.48 to13917.72 ours,13917.88 I13918.19 know13918.35 that13918.51 there13918.67 are13919 clear13919 carveouts13921.31 for13921.56 many13921.72 small13921.95 businesses.13922.27 And13922.67 for13922.75 those13923 that13923.15 aren't13923.31 carved13923.8 out13924.11 because13924.27 they,13924.59 you13924.83 know,13925 sell,13925.95 you13926.27 know,13926.43 large13926.73 volumes13927.05 of13927.37 things,13927.45 there13928.41 are13928.81 clear13928.81 rules13929.37 in13930.17 place.13930.33 If13931.05 you13931.29 have13931.37 a13931.61 customizable13931.85 rule13932.73 that13934.09 doesn't13934.33 follow13934.89 a13936.25 New13936.33 England13936.49 framework13936.81 or13937.29 neighboring13937.61 states,13938.01 it's13939.05 gonna13939.29 get13939.61 extremely13939.85 expensive13940.25 to13940.73 comply13940.81 with13941.23 it.13941.31 And13941.39 that's13941.63 where13942.02 we're13942.26 coming13942.34 from13942.67 in13942.9 terms13942.98 of13943.23 small13943.39 businesses.13943.63 Okay.13944.1
13944.98 FARLEY-BOUVIER13944.98 -13944.98 Well,13944.98 thank13945.23 you13945.39 for13945.55 that.13945.7 I13945.86 have13946.02 heard13946.18 from13946.5 several13947.31 small13947.7 businesses,13948.02 and13948.42 what13948.67 they13948.9 have13949.15 said13949.47 to13949.86 me13950.02 is13950.67 that,13951.78 especially13951.78 those13952.34 who13952.5 work13952.67 in13952.9 multiple13952.98 states.13953.39 Yeah.13953.7 Listen.13954.27 We13955.52 just13955.68 go13955.76 with13956 the13956.16 strictest13956.24 state,13956.64 and13957.12 that's13957.28 what13957.52 we13957.6 do,13957.76 and13958.08 then13958.32 we're13958.56 good.13958.8 And13959.28 we13959.52 don't13959.6 worry13959.76 about13960 all13961.36 the13961.52 others13961.6 because13962 we're13962.72 meeting13963.2 that13963.52 threshold,13963.68 and13964.32 then13964.48 everything13964.72 falls13965.12 into13965.36 place.13965.6
LARSON13965.92 -13965.92 I13965.92 think13966.16 this13966.32 bill13966.48 gets13966.72 you13966.96 there.13967.04 And13967.36 I13967.44 think13967.52 this13967.68 bill13967.84 puts13968.08 you13968.24 on13968.4 a13968.56 very13968.74 strong13969.02 path13969.31 to13969.6 have13969.89 the13970.18 strongest13970.47 state13970.76 rules,13971.05 and13971.34 we're13971.63 not13972.21 talking13972.5 about13972.79 at13973.08 all.13973.36
13973.65 FARLEY-BOUVIER13973.65 -13973.65 Okay.13973.65 Thank13973.94 you13974.23 so13974.52 much,13974.81 Sam.13975.1
13975.39 LARSON13975.39 -13975.39 I13975.39 know.13975.68 Appreciate13975.97 it.13976.26
FARLEY-BOUVIER13976.55 -13976.55 Alright.13976.55 Thank13976.84 you13977.13 for13977.42 your13977.7 time.13977.99 Okay.13978.28 We're13978.57 gonna13978.86 go13979.15 now13979.44 to13979.73 CG,13980.31 who13980.6 is13980.89 online.13981.18 And13981.47 then13981.75 on13982.04 deck,13982.33 we13982.62 have13982.91 another13983.49 online13983.86 person,13984.26 Olga13984.58 Medina.13984.98 CG,13987.38 are13987.78 you13987.94 here?13988.02
LARSON13988.9 -13988.9 I13988.9 sure13989.06 am.13989.3
FARLEY-BOUVIER13989.7 -13989.7 Okay.13989.7 Terrific.13990.02
13991.78 CG13991.78 NIQUETTE13991.78 -13991.78 FINDHELP13991.78 -13991.78 (R13991.78 )13991.78 Excellent.13991.78 Thank13993.14 you.13993.38 Good13993.7 afternoon,13993.94 honorable13994.5 chairs13994.9 and13995.14 members13995.3 of13995.54 this13995.7 committee,13995.86 and13996.18 thank13996.26 you13996.42 for13996.58 the13996.74 opportunity13996.9 to13997.46 speak13997.62 today.13997.94 My13998.61 name13998.77 is13998.85 CJ13999.33 Niquette,13999.58 and13999.98 I'm14000.14 here14000.22 on14000.45 behalf14000.61 of14000.93 FindHelp,14001.33 a14001.58 social14001.74 care14002.06 data14003.01 company14003.25 that14003.98 has14004.14 proudly14004.3 connected14004.69 the14005.01 citizens14005.17 of14005.58 Massachusetts14005.66 to14006.53 a14006.77 network14006.93 of14007.25 over14007.5 9,00014007.74 free14008.38 and14008.93 reduced-cost14009.17 services14009.17 over14009.82 the14010.06 past14010.14 decade.14010.45 We14011.25 are14011.42 here14011.58 in14012.22 strong14012.38 support14012.69 of14013.3 the14013.38 Massachusetts14013.46 Data14014.18 Privacy14014.42 Act,14014.82 and14015.06 we14015.22 deeply14015.3 appreciate14015.7 the14016.02 committee's14016.18 leadership14016.58 in14017.14 moving14017.3 this14017.54 critical14017.78 legislation14018.18 forward.14018.66 As14020.1 technology14020.34 continues14020.82 to14021.22 shape14021.38 every14021.7 aspect14021.86 of14022.34 our14022.5 lives,14023.06 from14023.46 the14023.7 way14023.86 we14024.02 work,14024.18 interact14024.58 with14025.06 our14025.22 families,14025.3 we14026.02 access14026.18 essential14026.74 services,14027.06 data14027.94 privacy14028.25 has14028.58 never14028.74 been14028.98 more14029.3 important.14029.53 In14030.33 this14030.42 landscape,14030.74 age14031.53 7814031.77 stands14032.33 as14032.66 a14032.9 vital14032.98 safeguard14033.38 for14033.85 the14034.02 privacy14034.09 of14034.5 Massachusetts14034.66 residents,14035.3 ensuring14036.02 that14036.42 individuals14036.58 are14037.22 protected14037.3 from14037.69 the14037.85 misuse,14038.02 exploitation,14038.58 and14039.57 inappropriate14039.65 sale14040.37 of14040.61 their14040.77 personal14040.93 information.14041.33 FineHills'14042.61 mission14043.17 is14043.49 to14043.65 connect14043.73 people14044.05 in14044.37 need14044.53 to14044.77 the14044.85 programs14045.01 that14045.41 serve14045.57 them14045.81 with14046.29 dignity14046.53 and14047.01 ease.14047.25
14048.05 As14048.05 the14048.21 nation's14048.37 largest14048.77 social14049.09 care14049.41 network14049.65 and14049.97 closed14050.13 loop14050.37 referral14050.53 system,14050.93 we14051.57 handle14051.73 significant14052.21 amounts14052.85 of14053.41 extraordinarily14053.73 sensitive14054.53 data,14055.01 and14055.63 this14055.86 includes14055.94 social14056.42 care14056.75 data,14056.98 information14057.39 ranging14057.86 from14058.18 housing14058.91 status14059.39 to14059.78 food14059.86 and14060.18 security14060.26 to14061.15 transportation14061.31 needs.14061.94 And14062.67 since14062.91 our14063.06 founding14063.31 in14063.7 2010,14063.86 we14064.67 have14064.83 committed14064.98 to14065.63 never14065.86 sell14066.18 data.14066.5 Our14067.39 network14067.63 is14067.94 built14068.1 on14068.34 a14068.5 consumer-directed14069.06 privacy14069.47 model14069.86 where14070.34 individuals14070.58 will14071.23 opt14071.44 in14071.68 to14071.92 share14072 their14072.32 information14072.56 for14072.96 each14073.12 referral,14073.44 and14074.16 access14074.48 to14074.8 referral14074.96 history14075.36 is14075.68 permission-based.14076.24 Our14077.36 industry14077.6 moves14078.48 at14078.72 the14078.88 speed14079.04 of14079.28 trust,14079.36 and14080 our14080.16 users14080.32 trust14080.72 us14080.96 with14081.12 their14081.28 most14081.52 personal14081.76 information14082.08 because14082.88 we14083.2 protect14083.36 it.14083.68 And14084.19 that's14084.35 why14084.52 we14084.83 strongly14085.32 support14085.8 the14086.19 Massachusetts14086.35 Data14087.16 Privacy14087.4 Act.14087.88 This14088.52 bill14088.75 represents14088.92 a14089.48 step14089.64 toward14090.11 ensuring14090.75 that14091.24 all14091.4 personal14091.56 data14091.88 is14092.19 protected.14092.35
14093.32 The14093.32 bill's14093.48 provisions14093.72 on14094.19 data14094.27 minimization,14094.52 consumer14095.32 rights,14095.8 and14096.03 protection14096.27 of14096.6 sensitive14096.75 data14097.24 are14097.87 essential14098.03 as14098.51 they14098.67 ensure14098.83 that14099.15 data14099.31 is14099.55 only14099.71 collected14099.95 when14100.43 necessary14100.59 and14101.39 that14101.55 individuals14101.71 have14102.27 the14102.43 right14102.51 to14102.75 access,14102.83 correct,14103.55 and14103.95 delete14104.11 their14104.51 data.14104.59 We14105.39 humbly14105.63 believe14105.95 that14106.27 the14106.43 bill14106.59 can14106.83 be14106.99 further14107.15 strengthened14107.47 to14107.95 define14108.19 social14108.51 care14108.91 data14109.07 and14109.73 include14109.89 it14110.05 among14110.68 the14110.92 protected14111.16 data14111.48 and14112.13 banning14112.28 the14112.68 sale14112.84 of14113.08 social,14113.16 or14114.13 of14114.6 banning14114.84 the14115.16 sale14115.32 of14115.56 monetization14115.65 of14116.36 data14116.44 collected14116.76 in14117.08 systems14117.24 like14117.65 find14117.81 help.14118.05 In14118.76 a14118.92 world14119.08 where14119.32 data14119.48 breaches14119.73 and14120.13 privacy14120.28 violations14120.68 are14121.24 becoming14121.48 increasingly14122.05 common,14122.76 age14123.48 7814123.73 represents14124.2 the14124.6 kind14124.76 of14124.92 forward-thinking14125.32 legislation14125.78 we14126.58 need14126.82 to14126.98 safeguard14127.14 the14127.62 privacy14127.78 of14128.18 our14128.26 citizens.14128.5 By14129.46 setting14129.62 clear14129.86 standards14130.26 for14130.98 how14131.14 companies14131.38 collect,14131.86 process,14132.74 and14133.22 store14133.46 personal14133.7 data,14134.1 Massachusetts14134.66 will14135.3 lead14135.46 the14135.62 way14135.78 in14136.18 protecting14136.34 residents14136.74 in14137.3 the14137.38 digital14137.46 age.14137.94 As14138.66 technology14139.08 continues14139.48 to14139.8 evolve,14140.03 it's14140.27 critical14140.51 that14140.83 our14141 laws14141.16 evolve14141.4 with14141.72 it14141.88 to14142.03 protect14142.19 the14142.51 fundamental14142.59 rights14143.08 of14143.56 Massachusetts14143.8 residents.14144.43 This14145.24 bill14145.4 is14145.64 an14145.72 essential14145.88 step14146.35 towards14146.59 that14146.92 goal.14147.08 Thank14147.8 you14148.03 for14148.11 your14148.27 time,14148.43 and14148.59 happy14148.83 to14149.08 answer14149.16 any14149.48 questions.14149.64
FARLEY-BOUVIER14151.16 -14151.16 Committee?14151.16 I14153 have14153.16 a14153.32 couple14153.4 of14153.64 questions.14153.8 I'm14154.82 a14154.98 little14155.22 surprised14155.55 to14156.58 hear14156.82 sounds14157.94 like14158.26 you14158.58 are14158.74 a,14158.98 you14159.38 know,14159.63 an14160.42 upcoming14160.42 tech14161.14 company.14161.55 You14162.5 have14162.74 access14163.14 to14163.78 sensitive14164.26 data,14164.9 which14165.86 you14166.18 could14166.42 make14166.58 a14166.82 lot14166.9 of14167.06 money14167.22 on,14167.55 but14168.34 you14168.66 are14168.9 in14169.54 strong14169.7 support14170.26 of14171.14 Comprehensive14171.46 data14172.1 privacy14174.58 100%.14174.58 So14174.58 this14174.82 is14175.06 not14175.22 gonna14175.38 hurt14175.62 your14175.94 business?14176.18
NIQUETTE14177.3 -14177.3 Nope.14177.3 It14177.7 wouldn't14177.86 we14178.5 would14178.66 never,14178.82 never14179.14 have,14179.46 never14179.78 will,14180.1 would14180.82 never14181.06 need14181.3 to14181.54 sell14181.62 data.14181.86 And14182.61 so14182.73 we're14182.85 strongly14184.38 in14184.85 support14184.93 of14185.34 this14185.41 and14185.57 applaud14186.3 your14186.61 leadership14186.86 on14187.18 the14187.33 issue.14187.49
FARLEY-BOUVIER14188.21 -14188.21 And14188.21 alright.14188.53 Is14188.93 it14189.18 a14189.65 bill14189.81 like14190.13 this14190.38 or,14190.7 you14191.73 know,14191.81 squashing14192.45 innovation?14193.25
14195.09 NIQUETTE14195.09 -14195.09 Not14195.09 at14195.41 all.14195.65 I14195.81 think14195.89 this14196.13 honestly14196.3 encourages14196.77 innovation.14197.25 And14198.42 I14198.58 think,14198.66 ultimately,14198.9 this14199.46 is14199.7 about14199.86 trust.14200.18 Right?14200.5 For14200.82 us,14200.98 social14202.34 care14202.66 data14202.9 relating14203.3 to14203.62 your14203.78 housing14204.02 status,14204.34 your14204.66 food14204.82 insecurity14205.94 needs14206.1 to14206.34 be14206.42 protected.14206.66 And14207.14 if14207.3 folks14207.46 don't14207.7 feel14207.86 like14208.02 their14208.18 data14208.42 is14208.82 being14208.98 protected,14209.3 they14210.74 aren't14210.9 going14211.22 to14211.46 trust14211.54 the14211.86 systems14211.94 and14212.74 platforms14212.99 that14213.95 can14214.11 help14214.27 them,14214.43 hopefully,14214.83 at14215.55 the14215.63 end14215.7 of14215.86 the14215.95 day.14216.02
FARLEY-BOUVIER14216.82 -14216.82 Thank14216.82 you14217.06 so14217.22 much.14217.38 Appreciate14218.27 your14218.66 testimony14218.82 today.14219.46 We're14220.03 gonna14220.18 now14220.5 move14220.75 on14220.9 to14221.14 Olga14221.3 Medina.14221.71 And14222.58 then14222.82 up14223.22 next14223.46 is14223.86 Sarah14224.26 Guggenhagen.14225.46 I'm14227.68 sure14228 I14228.24 got14228.32 that14228.56 right14228.72 from14228.96 Epic14229.2 Go14230.4 ahead14230.56 Olga14230.88
14232.16 OLGA14232.16 MEDINA14232.16 -14232.16 BSA14232.16 -14232.16 SB14232.16 3314232.16 -14232.16 HB14232.16 8014232.16 -14232.16 (14232.16 R)14232.16 Thank14232.16 you.14232.4 Good14232.64 afternoon,14232.88 members14233.36 of14233.6 the14233.84 committee.14233.92 My14234.48 name14234.64 is14234.8 Olga14234.96 Medina,14235.28 and14235.84 I14236.08 represent14236.24 the14236.8 Business14236.96 Software14237.36 Alliance.14239.04 We14239.2 are14239.2 the14239.36 leading14239.52 advocate14239.92 for14240.4 the14240.64 global14240.72 software14241.44 industry,14241.68 so14243.33 our14243.57 members14243.82 make14244.69 the14244.93 business-to-business14245.57 technologies14246.05 used14246.69 by14246.93 companies14247.18 in14248.05 every14248.3 sector14248.53 of14248.86 the14249.01 economy.14249.25 BSA14250.53 strongly14251.01 supports14251.5 a14251.89 comprehensive14252.05 national14253.01 framework14253.5 that14254.05 provides14254.22 consumers14254.61 with14255.17 meaningful14255.33 rights14255.89 over14256.22 their14256.46 personal14256.69 data,14257.17 but14258.09 we14258.33 also14258.41 recognize14258.97 that14259.45 states14259.77 are14260.17 leading14260.81 in14261.37 adopting14261.61 privacy14262.17 laws,14262.73 and14263.21 we14263.45 welcome14263.69 your14264.09 committee's14264.41 careful14264.97 consideration14265.37 of14266.57 privacy14266.81 issues.14267.29 My14268.33 testimony14268.49 today14269.13 focuses14269.53 on14270.42 BSA's14270.58 core14271.14 priorities14271.46 in14272.18 privacy14272.42 legislation,14272.9 which14274.18 include14274.42 promoting14275.38 interoperability14276.1 with14276.98 existing14277.22 state14277.7 privacy14278.02 laws,14278.5 distinguishing14279.86 between14280.42 controllers14280.9 and14281.46 processors,14281.7 focusing14283.24 on14283.8 consumer14284.04 privacy14284.6 by14285.24 exempting14285.56 employee14286.36 data,14286.92 and14287.72 providing14287.96 for14288.52 exclusive14288.84 AG14289.56 enforcement.14290.04
14291.4 First,14291.4 we14291.8 urge14292.04 the14292.36 committee14292.52 to14292.92 recognize14293.08 the14293.72 value14293.88 in14294.36 adopting14294.6 a14295.08 privacy14295.24 law14295.8 that's14296.2 consistent14296.52 with14297.16 other14297.4 state14297.72 laws.14298.04 To14298.95 date,14299.03 nearly14299.51 all14300.07 states14300.31 have14300.63 agreed14300.88 on14301.27 the14301.44 same14301.59 structural14301.99 model14302.47 for14302.88 protecting14303.19 privacy14303.75 but14304.71 have14304.95 adjusted14305.27 that14305.75 model14305.99 to14306.39 provide14306.55 different14307.11 levels14307.44 of14308.31 substantive14308.55 protections14309.35 for14309.83 consumers.14310.15 To14311.19 illustrate14311.44 the14311.91 broad14312.07 consistency14312.39 across14313.4 state14313.64 privacy14314.04 laws,14314.44 BSA14315.64 has14316.12 published14316.36 a14316.76 document14316.92 cataloguing14317.64 different14318.76 models14319.08 of14319.48 state14319.64 privacy14319.96 legislation,14320.52 and14321.4 we14321.64 believe14321.8 that14322.2 214322.44 bills14322.68 before14323.08 the14323.4 committee,14323.64 SB14324.52 3314324.84 and14325.48 HB14325.8 80,14326.28 also14327.05 known14327.36 as14327.52 the14327.77 Massachusetts14328 Consumer14328.8 Data14329.36 Privacy14329.69 Act,14330.16 promote14330.88 a14331.28 consistent14331.44 approach14331.92 to14332.41 protecting14332.56 consumer14333.13 privacy14333.69 and14334.49 should14334.72 guide14334.88 the14335.21 committee's14335.36 approach14335.92 to14336.32 privacy14336.49 legislation.14337.05 We14338.32 also14338.56 encourage14338.8 you14339.21 to14339.36 distinguish14339.52 between14340 controllers14340.32 and14340.88 processors.14341.05
14342.2 Leading14342.2 global14342.44 and14342.84 state14343 privacy14343.32 laws14343.72 reflect14344.04 the14344.36 fundamental14344.52 distinction14345.16 between14345.72 processors,14346.12 which14346.92 handle14347.16 data14347.48 on14347.88 behalf14348.04 of14348.44 another14348.6 company,14349 and14349.56 controllers,14349.88 which14350.84 decide14351.16 when14351.64 and14351.88 why14352.12 to14352.44 collect14352.68 a14353.08 consumer's14353.16 personal14353.8 data.14354.2 Privacy14354.84 law14355.4 should14355.64 also14355.88 create14356.12 important14356.52 but14357.32 different14357.49 obligations14357.88 for14358.52 both14358.77 controllers14359.08 and14359.57 processors14359.8 that14360.69 reflect14361 their14361.56 different14361.72 roles.14362.05 BSA14363.16 also14363.72 supports14364.05 focusing14364.44 consumer14364.92 privacy14365.49 laws14365.88 on14366.44 consumers.14366.69 To14367.64 do14367.8 that,14367.88 a14368.21 privacy14368.36 law14368.77 should14369 clearly14369.24 define14369.72 consumers14370.13 and14370.77 exclude14371.43 individuals14371.75 acting14372.31 in14372.63 an14372.79 employment14372.95 contest.14373.59 Furthermore,14374.47 we14375.11 urge14375.27 the14375.51 legislature14375.67 to14376.23 advance14376.39 privacy14376.87 legislation14377.19 that14377.75 provides14377.91 strong14378.71 and14379.03 exclusive14379.19 enforcement14380.55 by14381.11 the14381.27 state's14381.43 attorney14381.75 general.14382.07 State14382.79 attorneys14383.03 general14383.43 have14383.75 a14383.91 strong14383.99 track14384.39 record14384.63 of14384.95 enforcing14385.03 privacy-related14385.99 laws14386.39 and14387 should14387.24 be14387.48 provided14387.72 with14388.13 the14388.28 resources14388.52 to14389.08 enforce14389.32 any14390.05 new14390.28 state14390.52 privacy14390.76 law14391.24 in14391.4 Massachusetts.14391.64 So,14392.68 to14392.84 conclude,14393 I'd14393.4 like14393.64 to14393.8 thank14393.88 the14394.13 committee14394.2 for14394.6 the14394.76 opportunity14394.92 to14395.4 testify.14395.64 We14396.36 would14396.52 welcome14396.68 a14397 chance14397.16 to14397.4 discuss14397.56 these14397.88 issues14398.13 with14398.44 you14398.6 in14398.76 more14398.84 detail14399.08 as14399.4 you14399.56 continue14399.72 to14400.13 consider14400.28 this14400.68 important14400.92 topic.14401.48 Thank14401.96 you.14402.13
FARLEY-BOUVIER14402.82 -14402.82 Thank14402.82 you.14403.14 Well,14403.46 I14403.62 appreciate14403.7 it.14404.26 From14405.3 the14405.54 committee,14405.62 all14406.74 set.14407.06 We're14407.7 gonna14407.86 now14408.1 move14408.34 to14408.58 Sarah.14408.9 And14409.62 then14409.86 on14410.26 deck14410.5 is14411.38 Thomas14411.7 Kadri.14412.18
14414.5 SARAH14414.5 GEOGHEGAN14414.5 -14414.5 EPIC14414.5 -14414.5 HB14414.5 9914414.5 -14414.5 SB14414.5 4714414.5 -14414.5 (R)14414.5 Thank14414.5 you,14414.74 Chair14415.06 Moore,14415.3 Chair14415.62 Farley14415.94 Bouvier,14416.26 and14416.74 members14416.98 of14417.3 the14417.38 committee.14417.46 My14418.11 name14418.27 is14418.43 Sarah14418.59 Gagan,14418.99 and14419.39 I'm14419.47 senior14419.71 counsel14420.03 at14420.43 the14420.59 Electronic14420.83 Privacy14421.47 Information14421.88 Center,14422.35 or14422.75 EPIC.14422.99 EPIC14424.03 is14424.35 an14424.51 independent14424.75 research14425.31 and14425.63 advocacy14425.88 center14426.43 focused14426.75 on14427.15 protecting14427.39 privacy14427.88 in14428.27 the14428.43 digital14428.59 age.14428.99 I14430.11 am14430.27 here14430.43 to14434.41 surveillance14434.41 the14435.05 pricing14435.05 in14435.29 grocery14435.69 stores.14436.17 Surveillance14437.29 pricing14437.77 or14438.25 the14438.29 practice14438.33 of14438.97 changing14439.13 prices14439.45 for14440.09 the14440.17 same14440.33 good14440.49 based14441.05 on14441.37 a14441.45 person's14441.53 browsing14442.17 history14442.57 and14443.05 personal14443.37 information,14443.42 which14443.46 results14443.51 in14443.56 214443.6 people14443.65 seeing14443.7 214443.74 different14443.79 prices14443.83 for14444.08 Surveillance14458.49 pricing14459.21 is14459.69 fueled14459.94 by14460.33 over14460.65 collection14460.73 and14461.29 out14461.53 of14461.77 context14461.93 processing14462.49 of14463.05 our14463.21 personal14463.45 information,14463.93 but14464.81 this14465.05 practice14465.29 is14465.85 exponentially14466.17 more14466.73 invasive14466.97 when14467.37 it14467.61 uses14467.77 biometric14468.25 information.14468.89 Biometric14470.73 information14471.29 is14471.93 highly14472.09 sensitive14472.66 because14472.98 it14473.22 is14473.38 unique14473.55 to14473.94 each14474.1 individual14474.42 person,14474.98 and14475.63 unlike14475.86 a14476.1 credit14476.26 card14476.5 number,14476.74 it14477.22 cannot14477.38 be14477.78 changed14477.94 if14478.26 it's14478.42 been14478.58 breached.14478.82 This14480.02 information14480.26 is14480.82 too14481.06 sensitive14481.3 to14481.78 be14481.86 used14482.02 for14482.34 surveillance14482.5 pricing14482.98 purposes.14483.38 Surveillance14484.82 pricing14485.22 is14485.55 fueled14485.78 by14486.1 the14486.18 data14486.34 economy.14486.66
14487.85 Apps,14487.85 websites,14488.25 wearable14489.29 tech,14489.69 cars,14490.25 and14490.73 smart14490.97 devices14491.29 constantly14492.41 collect14493.05 information14493.37 about14493.85 us14494.17 and14494.65 share14494.89 this14495.13 information14495.29 with14495.93 data14496.17 brokers14496.41 and14496.89 advertisers14497.21 to14498.01 profile14498.17 us.14498.65 Surveillance14499.93 pricing14500.57 uses14500.97 these14501.38 profiles14501.61 to14502.09 deliver14502.33 prices14502.65 tailored14503.45 to14503.93 each14504.01 individual.14504.33 While14505.61 this14505.93 may14506.09 seem14506.33 like14506.57 a14506.81 neutral14506.97 or14507.53 even14507.69 benevolent14508.09 corporate14508.73 favor14509.21 to14509.53 us,14509.69 offering14510.25 a14510.73 nominal14510.89 discount14511.29 here14511.77 or14511.93 there,14512.17 this14513.21 practice14513.45 costs14514.17 consumers14514.85 more14515.49 money.14515.89 Consultants14517.09 recommend14517.73 surveilling14518.21 pricing14518.77 to14519.73 their14519.89 clients,14520.05 promising14521.01 their14521.49 profits14521.73 will14522.05 increase14522.37 214523.01 to14523.33 7%14523.49 in14524.45 as14524.69 little14524.85 as14525.17 314525.33 to14525.57 614525.73 months.14525.97 This14527.16 is14527.32 a14527.4 practice14527.48 in14527.56 which14528.28 companies14528.52 extract14529.32 and14530.05 exploit14530.28 our14531 personal14531.32 information14531.81 to14532.68 charge14532.92 us14533.24 the14533.4 highest14533.64 price14533.96 we14534.28 are14534.44 willing14534.52 to14534.84 pay.14535 This14535.96 is14536.13 corporations14536.37 increasing14537.24 their14537.72 profits14538.05 while14538.84 taking14539.09 money14539.4 out14539.72 of14539.88 our14540.05 pockets.14540.2 Surveillance14542.22 pricing14542.7 unlocks14543.1 an14543.74 even14544.14 more14544.38 nefarious14544.54 window14545.02 when14545.42 we14545.58 are14545.74 talking14545.9 about14546.14 essential14546.54 products14547.18 and14547.58 services.14547.74 Across14548.86 Massachusetts14549.26 and14549.9 across14550.06 the14550.38 country,14550.54 consumers14550.94 are14551.42 hurting.14551.58 Our14552.46 costs14552.78 are14553.1 increasing,14553.34 including14554.06 for14554.54 absolute14554.7 necessities14555.26 like14555.82 groceries.14556.06 Companies14557.22 should14557.7 not14557.94 be14558.1 able14558.26 to14558.59 further14558.82 exploit14559.22 our14559.78 personal14560.03 information14560.5 to14561.38 charge14561.55 us14561.87 higher14562.03 prices,14562.34 which14563.06 is14563.31 surveillance14563.7 pricing's14564.19 ultimate14564.59 goal.14565.06 I14566.03 support14566.19 Bill14566.59 H14566.82 9914567.06 and14567.55 S14567.7 4714567.94 to14568.82 prohibit14569.06 our14569.66 most14569.9 sensitive14570.14 information14570.7 from14571.42 being14571.58 used14571.82 to14572.78 charge14572.86 us14573.34 higher14573.74 and14573.98 higher14574.22 prices.14574.54 Thank14575.34 you14575.58 for14575.74 your14575.9 time14575.98 today.14576.3
MOORE14577.66 -14577.66 Thank14577.66 you14577.9 very14578.14 much.14578.3 Do14578.62 we14578.78 have14578.86 any14578.94 questions?14579.1 Oh,14581.18 I14581.34 guess14581.42 there's14581.7 no14581.78 114581.94 here.14582.1 Thank14583.94 you14584.19 very14584.35 thank14584.59 you14584.82 very14584.98 much.14585.14 Next,14586.35 we14586.66 have14586.82 Thomas14586.98 Kydre.14587.47 He's14590.19 still14590.42 here.14590.66
14592.59 SPEAKER714592.59 -14592.59 Hello.14592.59 Can14592.98 you14593.14 hear14593.22 me,14593.47 okay?14593.55
14593.94 SPEAKER614593.94 -14593.94 Oh,14593.94 virtually.14594.1 Okay.14594.59 I'm14594.91 sorry.14595.06 Yep.14595.38
THOMAS14597.22 KADRI14597.22 -14597.22 UGA14597.22 SCHOOL14597.22 OF14597.22 LAW14597.22 -14597.22 (14597.22 R14597.22 )14597.22 -14597.22 Perfect.14597.22 Thank14597.7 you14598.1 for14598.34 yeah.14599.14 Thank14599.38 you14599.54 for14599.7 the14599.86 opportunity14600.1 to14600.82 speak14600.98 with14601.3 you14601.46 today.14601.62 My14602.18 name14602.26 is14602.42 Thomas14602.66 Kadri,14602.98 and14603.46 I'm14603.7 a14603.86 law14604.1 professor14604.34 at14604.66 the14604.82 University14604.98 of14605.46 Georgia.14605.62 I'm14606.5 also14606.66 the14607.3 legislative14607.54 and14608.18 policy14608.34 director14608.82 at14609.38 Cornell's14609.54 clinic14610.5 to14610.98 end14611.06 tech14611.38 abuse.14611.62 My14612.68 work14613.08 focuses14613.4 on14613.88 technology-related14614.68 interpersonal14615.64 abuse.14616.2 So,14616.6 I14616.76 work14616.84 with14617.08 survivors14617.4 who14618.28 are14618.44 experiencing14618.68 this14619.4 abuse.14619.56 And14620.44 my14620.68 scholarship,14620.84 in14621.8 particular,14621.96 a14622.52 recent14622.6 article14622.92 that14624.04 I've14624.2 coauthored14624.47 with14624.95 Chinmayi14625.11 Sharma14625.67 and14626.15 Sam14626.55 Adler14626.87 called14627.35 Brokering14627.59 Safety,14628.23 explores14629.27 how14629.75 data14630.15 brokers14630.47 are14631.03 complicit14631.27 in14632.31 various14633.19 types14633.67 of14633.99 interpersonal14634.15 abuse.14634.71 And14635.59 I'm14635.83 here14636.07 today14636.31 really14636.63 just14636.87 to14637.19 make14637.67 the14637.91 point14638.07 that14638.55 others14638.79 have14639.33 made.14639.49 So14639.65 to14639.81 really14640.05 echo14640.29 it,14640.53 that14641.17 location14641.41 privacy,14641.89 in14642.93 particular,14643.09 is14643.73 a14644.05 huge14644.21 concern14644.61 for14645.09 survivors.14645.65
14646.85 Knowing14646.85 someone's14647.25 whereabouts14647.97 can14648.61 leave14648.77 them14649.01 intensely14649.73 vulnerable14650.29 when14651.01 they're14651.25 trying14651.41 to14651.73 escape14652.05 an14652.38 abusive14652.61 relationship14653.09 or14654.36 a14654.84 stalking14655 situation,14655.48 and14656.28 it14656.52 can14656.6 really14656.76 jeopardize14657.08 their14657.72 long-term14658.12 security14659 and14659.8 recovery.14660.76 And14661.88 this14662.04 is14662.2 in14662.36 part14662.44 because14662.68 companies14663.08 are14663.56 selling14663.8 vast14664.52 amounts14664.84 of14665.24 our14665.4 data14665.56 that14666.2 create14666.44 all14666.68 sorts14666.92 of14667.16 revealing14667.32 inferences.14667.72 And14668.91 for14669.15 survivors,14669.63 these14670.19 inferences14670.43 can14670.99 have14671.23 dangerous14671.63 and14672.11 even14672.43 deadly14672.67 consequences.14673.15 And14674.59 I'm14675.63 hesitant14675.79 to14676.99 repeat14677.79 what's14677.79 been14678.11 said14678.35 already.14678.51 And14678.83 in14679.07 the14679.23 interest14679.31 of14679.71 time,14679.79 maybe14680.11 I'll14680.35 just14680.51 try14680.67 and14680.83 say14680.99 something14681.15 that14681.39 I14681.63 haven't14681.88 heard14682.27 spoken14682.91 enough14683.39 about.14683.71 And14684.47 that's14684.71 the,14685.11 what14686.23 is14686.47 really,14686.71 I14686.95 think,14687.03 a14687.43 traumatic14687.59 burden14688.23 that14688.87 a14689.11 lot14689.27 of14689.43 survivors14689.59 now14690.15 face14690.47 in14690.79 the14690.95 digital14691.11 age14691.51 to14692.39 be14692.55 constantly14692.79 monitoring14693.51 online14694.15 for14695.27 traces14695.51 of14696.07 their14696.23 data.14696.47 Right?14697.17 So14697.32 there14697.49 are14697.56 risks14697.97 involved14698.28 in14698.76 their14698.93 data14699.17 being14699.4 shared,14699.73 and14700.52 those14700.61 risks14700.84 can14701.08 have14701.32 awful14701.49 consequences.14701.8 But14702.52 there's14702.68 also14702.93 this14703.24 added14703.49 burden14703.88 that14704.28 they14704.52 face14704.68 to14705.4 be14705.56 checking14705.73 up14706.13 for14706.76 what14707 is14707.24 out14707.56 there14707.73 about14708.05 them.14708.28
14709.24 And14709.24 this,14709.49 I14709.8 think,14709.88 can14710.21 be14710.45 triggering14711.25 and14711.65 distressing14711.89 for14712.37 them14712.53 in14712.77 a14712.85 way14712.93 that14713.09 is14713.25 underappreciated14713.65 because14715.01 it14715.33 forces14715.49 them14715.81 to14716.05 be14716.21 constantly14716.53 grappling14717.33 with14718.37 the14718.61 abuse14718.77 that14719.09 they've14719.25 already14719.49 faced14719.89 again14720.45 and14720.69 again14720.85 while14721.97 they14722.13 try14722.45 and14723.17 clear14723.41 up14723.65 any14723.81 digital14724.05 footprints14724.37 that14724.8 may14725.03 be14725.19 left.14725.36 And14725.68 data14725.92 brokers14726.15 are14727.12 really14727.36 kind14727.68 of14727.83 complicit14728 in14728.48 this.14728.56 And14729.27 so14729.51 laws14729.92 like14730.8 the14731.19 Location14731.43 Shield14731.92 Act14732.24 and14732.48 some14732.56 of14732.8 the14732.88 other14733.03 privacy14733.19 legislation14733.75 that14734.24 you14734.39 have14734.56 before14734.8 you14735.12 today14735.68 could14736.31 at14736.56 least14736.63 go14736.88 some14737.19 small14737.43 way14737.75 to14738.68 alleviating14739.48 that14740.28 burden14740.52 that14741.16 survivors14741.4 and14741.8 many14741.96 other14742.2 folks14742.44 face14743.32 to14744.2 be14744.44 engaging14744.6 in14745.08 this14745.24 kind14745.48 of14745.72 privacy14745.8 self-management14746.68 that14748.04 is14748.2 the14748.68 norm14748.84 of14749.16 today.14749.4 And14750.12 so14750.28 I14750.52 just14750.68 wanted14750.92 to14751.16 kind14751.32 of14751.4 highlight14751.56 that14751.88 because14751.96 I14752.28 hadn't14752.44 heard14753.08 that14753.63 element14753.8 of14754.27 this14754.43 situation14754.59 being14755.31 discussed14756.19 as14756.75 much.14756.92 And14757.88 so,14758.03 for14758.19 those14758.43 reasons,14758.59 I14758.99 commend14759.8 the14760.27 committee14760.36 and14760.92 those14761.39 of14761.55 you14761.72 who14761.88 are14762.03 proposing14763.07 and14763.95 supporting14764.19 the14764.68 Location14764.83 Shield14765.31 Act14765.63 and14765.88 other14766.11 bills14766.66 that14766.9 I14766.98 know14767.06 contain14767.46 similar14767.86 protections14768.9 in14769.38 there.14769.54 You14770.74 know,14770.98 lowering14771.38 the14771.86 chance14771.94 that14772.26 survivors'14772.5 location14772.98 data14773.46 can14774.42 be14774.66 bought14774.82 or14775.06 shared14775.22 with14775.54 their14775.7 abusers14775.86 would14776.82 be14777.7 a14778.1 huge14778.26 help14778.5 to14778.74 them.14778.82 And14779.06 so,14779.22 thank14779.97 you14780.21 again14780.61 for14780.85 allowing14781.09 me14781.25 to14781.97 testify14782.13 today.14782.61
14783.73 MOORE14783.73 -14783.73 Thank14783.73 you.14783.97 Thank14784.21 you14784.45 for14784.61 waiting14784.77 this14785.57 afternoon.14785.89 Any14788.45 questions,14788.69 Steve?14789.01 No.14789.41 No?14789.89 Okay.14789.97 So14790.53 next,14790.77 we14791.01 have14791.25 a14791.49 panel.14791.65 Roy14792.58 Rindberg.14792.74 Do14794.42 you14794.58 see14794.58 it14794.7 with14794.82 the14794.98 panel?14795.14 So,14810.8 just14811.51 start14811.75 whenever14811.99 you14812.31 want14812.48 and14812.72 just14812.8 identify14813.19 who14813.75 you14813.99 are14814.07 as14814.31 you14814.55 go14814.95 to14815.03 speak.14815.19 Thank14815.92 you.14816.15
14822.37 SARAH14822.37 RADWAY14822.37 -14822.37 HARVARD14822.37 UNIVERSITY14822.37 -14822.37 SB14822.37 4514822.37 -14822.37 HB14822.37 7814822.37 -14822.37 And14822.37 members14822.69 of14823.01 the14823.17 committee.14823.33 My14824.45 name14824.53 is14824.69 Sarah14824.85 Radway,14825.17 and14825.73 I'm14826.05 here14826.21 in14826.45 support14826.61 of14827.01 S14827.25 4514827.49 and14828.13 HB14828.61 78.14828.85 I14830.13 am14830.29 a14830.37 PhD14830.53 student14831.01 in14831.33 computer14831.57 science14831.9 at14832.31 Harvard.14832.38 My14833.19 research,14833.82 though,14834.06 is14834.06 interdisciplinary,14834.38 so14835.26 I14835.43 spend14835.58 a14835.82 lot14835.9 of14836.06 time14836.14 at14836.38 the14836.47 law14836.63 school14836.78 as14837.02 well.14837.19 My14838.31 research14838.55 focuses14838.94 on14839.43 looking14839.58 at14839.9 how14840.06 consumer-facing14840.94 technology14841.34 companies14841.9 interpret14842.78 law14843.26 and14843.43 policy14843.58 when14843.99 they14844.23 design14844.38 their14844.67 systems.14844.83 So,14845.71 for14845.95 example,14846.19 in14846.59 my14846.75 research,14846.91 I14847.71 may14847.87 reverse14848.11 engineer14848.51 the14848.99 implementation14849.07 of14849.87 a14850.03 consumer14850.19 device14850.59 that14850.99 collects,14851.23 for14851.79 example,14851.95 biometric14852.43 data14852.99 to14853.71 see14853.87 how14854.03 the14854.27 devices14854.35 collect,14854.91 protect,14855.39 process,14855.87 and14856.35 store14856.51 user14856.83 information.14857.15 So14858.24 essentially,14858.48 I14858.97 perform14859.13 compliance14859.61 evaluations14860.08 of14860.88 consumer14861.13 tech,14861.52 and14862.64 I14862.97 see14863.13 how14863.44 it's14863.76 possible14863.92 for14864.32 companies14864.64 to14864.97 make14865.13 privacy14865.36 protective14865.76 choices14866.24 in14866.56 the14866.73 design14866.88 of14867.13 their14867.2 products14867.44 or14867.84 not14868.17 so14868.4 much.14868.56
14869.97 In14869.97 terms14870.29 of14870.53 problems14870.69 I14871.09 see14871.33 in14871.65 my14871.81 research,14872.05 I'll14872.45 keep14872.69 this14872.85 short,14873.01 that14873.97 are14874.13 relevant14874.29 to14874.69 this14874.93 legislation.14875.09 I14875.73 see14875.89 that14876.05 current14876.29 legislative14876.69 structures14877.17 do14877.73 not14877.89 encourage14878.13 a14878.61 culture14878.69 of14879.09 privacy.14879.17 In14880.05 my14880.21 work,14880.37 I've14880.61 seen14880.77 organizations14880.93 intentionally14881.73 make14882.29 it14882.45 very14882.69 difficult14882.93 to14883.65 understand14883.81 what14884.29 their14884.53 data14884.69 collection,14885.08 protection,14885.48 processing,14886.13 and14886.6 storage14886.76 process14887.16 practices14887.56 are.14888.2 Companies14888.84 want14889.24 to14889.48 ensure14889.56 that14889.8 they14889.97 will14890.04 not14890.2 be14890.36 punished14890.44 for14890.76 behavior14890.92 that14891.24 they14891.4 view14891.64 as14891.8 out14892.13 of14892.2 alignment14892.36 with14892.76 consumer14892.92 expectations.14893.48 So14894.52 I14894.84 have14895 to14895.16 spend14895.32 114895.64 to14895.88 214896.04 years14896.2 trying14896.68 to14896.92 understand14897.18 the14897.42 practices14897.5 associated14898.14 with14898.78 114899.26 device14899.5 from14899.98 114900.3 single14900.54 company,14900.86 which14901.26 is14901.5 a14901.74 pretty14901.74 long14901.98 time14902.22 for14902.46 me.14902.62 I14904.22 also14904.38 see14904.7 that14904.78 there's14904.94 a14905.26 lack14905.34 of14905.58 accountability14905.9 or14906.38 enforcement14906.54 capability14907.1 when14908.22 companies14908.46 may14908.94 be14909.1 out14909.26 of14909.42 compliance.14909.58 So14910.46 enforcement14910.7 largely14911.18 relies14911.5 upon14912 government14912.24 agencies.14912.64
14914.32 So14914.32 Yeah.14914.73 In14915.52 terms14915.61 of14915.84 how14916 I14916.17 think14916.24 this14916.48 legislation14916.64 addresses14917.52 these14918.24 bills14918.48 or14918.97 these14919.36 issues14919.61 well,14919.92 I14920.56 think14920.73 that14920.97 these14921.2 bills14921.44 encourage14921.92 principles14922.32 of14922.8 transparency14922.97 and14923.68 privacy14923.84 by14924.32 design.14924.56 So14925.44 by14925.61 addressing14925.76 features14926.17 like14926.56 dark14926.73 patterns,14926.97 they14927.44 allow14927.74 consumers14927.98 to14928.38 make14928.46 informed14928.86 choices,14929.26 and14929.98 they14930.22 require14930.38 transparency14930.78 about14931.34 what14931.5 data14931.98 controllers14932.22 have14932.86 about14933.1 consumers14933.34 and14933.82 allow14933.98 for14934.22 a14934.46 relationship14934.54 to14935.02 form14935.1 between14935.66 the14935.9 companies14936.06 and14936.38 consumers.14936.62 So14937.1 it14937.34 kind14937.5 of14937.9 negates14938.22 this14938.62 need14938.78 for14939.1 me14939.5 to14939.58 go14940.3 through14940.46 and14940.78 reverse14941.1 engineer14941.42 all14941.82 these14942.12 implementations14942.27 just14942.92 to14943.07 answer14943.15 these14943.48 questions.14943.72 Additionally,14944.59 by14945.72 introducing14946.03 a14946.44 private14946.51 right14946.83 of14947 action,14947.15 I14947.63 think14947.72 this14947.88 creates14948.03 the14948.36 opportunity14948.44 for14948.92 accountability14949.15 for14949.72 non-compliant14950.59 organizations14951.88 and14951.88 puts14952.03 sufficient14952.36 guardrails14952.75 in14953.24 place14953.39 for14953.72 misbehavior.14953.95 Thank14955 you14955.24 for14955.46 your14955.54 time.14955.7 I14955.94 appreciate14956.1 it.14957.22
14957.94 SPEAKER614957.94 -14957.94 Thank14957.94 you.14959.86
14959.86 SHANNON14959.86 ESPINOZA14959.86 -14959.86 CONCERNED14959.86 CITIZEN14959.86 -14959.86 HB14959.86 7814959.86 -14959.86 SB14959.86 4514959.86 -14959.86 SB14959.86 2914959.86 -14959.86 HB14959.86 10414959.86 -14959.86 Dear14960.58 chairs,14960.82 vice14961.54 chairs,14961.78 and14962.18 members14962.34 of14962.5 the14962.66 committee,14962.82 thank14963.46 you14963.62 for14963.7 the14963.86 opportunity14964.02 to14964.42 testify.14964.58 My14965.14 name14965.3 is14965.46 Shannon14965.62 Espinosa.14965.94 I'm14966.58 a14966.74 Filipina14966.82 immigrant,14967.38 a14968.1 Boston14968.1 Latin14968.34 School14968.74 graduate,14968.98 and14969.38 a14969.54 senior14969.7 at14970.02 Northeastern,14970.18 double14970.82 majoring14971.06 in14971.46 data14971.63 science14971.94 and14972.18 biology.14972.42 I've14973.38 conducted14973.54 undergraduate14973.94 research14974.5 in14974.9 computational14975.06 drug14975.78 discovery,14976.1 represented14976.82 the14977.22 United14977.38 States14977.63 internationally14978.02 in14978.74 quantum14978.9 computing14979.3 and14979.7 AI14979.86 competitions,14980.1 interned14980.82 at14981.38 a14981.38 congress14981.38 on14981.86 AI14982.1 policy,14982.26 and14982.73 served14982.89 as14983.05 a14983.08 visiting14983.1 scholar14983.13 at14983.93 the14984.01 United14984.17 Nations.14984.41 I'm14985.29 currently14985.53 a14985.85 Fulbright14986.01 semifinalist14986.41 in14987.05 computer14987.21 science14987.61 research,14987.93 and14988.33 I'm14988.49 here14988.57 today14988.81 to14989.05 strongly14989.21 encourage14989.61 your14990.25 support14990.49 for14990.81 H14990.97 78,14991.13 the14991.61 Massachusetts14991.77 Consumer14992.33 Data14992.73 Privacy14992.97 Act,14993.45 as14994.01 well14994.17 as14994.49 S14994.73 45,14994.97 S14995.64 29,14995.73 and14996.13 H14996.28 104,14996.52 the14997.17 broader14997.32 Massachusetts14997.73 Data14998.2 Privacy14998.52 Act.14999.64 And14999.97 we15000.13 are15000.28 grateful15000.44 for15000.76 this15000.93 committee,15001.17 especially15001.56 Chair15001.97 Moore15002.28 for15002.84 for15003.08 confronting15003.97 115004.36 of15004.52 the15004.61 most15004.76 overlooked15005 and15005.49 urgent15005.8 ethical15006.2 rights15006.68 issues15006.93 of15007.32 the15007.56 digital15007.64 age.15008.2
15009.24 So,15009.49 my15009.49 generation15009.73 has15010.2 never15010.44 had15010.68 the15010.76 luxury15011.1 of15011.42 privacy.15011.5 Take15012.22 the15012.46 college15012.62 board15012.86 a15013.1 few15013.18 years15013.34 ago,15013.58 it15013.74 saw15013.9 the15014.06 data15014.22 of15014.46 over15014.54 237,00015014.86 students15016.14 in15016.54 New15016.7 York.15016.86 Data15017.82 is15018.14 surrendered15018.14 not15018.54 by15018.78 choice15018.86 but15019.18 as15019.42 the15019.58 price15019.66 of15019.9 access15020.06 to15020.54 higher15020.78 education.15021.1 When15022.14 I15022.3 applied15022.46 for15022.78 scholarships15022.94 and15023.5 research15023.66 funding,15023.98 I15024.22 would15024.38 end15024.46 up15024.7 on15024.78 websites15024.86 seeking15025.42 excessive15025.74 personal15026.22 information15026.72 from15027.52 715027.76 years15028 of15028.32 address15028.48 history15028.88 to15029.28 medical15029.44 disclosures.15029.84 And15030.56 I15030.72 filled15030.8 it15031.04 out15031.2 anyway15031.28 because15031.68 what15032 choice15032.16 did15032.4 I15032.56 have15032.72 if15032.96 I15033.13 needed15033.2 to15033.44 fund15033.52 my15033.84 education?15033.92 The15035.13 Commonwealth15035.28 of15035.76 Massachusetts15035.92 is15036.88 the15037.04 national15037.28 epicenter15037.68 in15038.32 research,15038.56 health15039.04 care,15039.28 tech,15039.68 and15040.08 education.15040.24 Industries15040.27 handling15040.28 some15040.29 of15040.3 the15040.31 most15040.32 sensitive15040.33 and15040.34 high-stakes15040.36 data15040.37 in15040.38 the15040.39 country.15040.4 And15041.13 handling15043.31 some15043.55 of15043.79 the15043.95 most15044.11 sensitive15044.43 and15044.75 high15044.99 stakes15045.23 data15045.39 in15045.47 the15045.87 country.15046.19
15046.83 As15046.86 a15046.86 student15046.88 researcher,15046.91 I15047.23 work15047.51 with15047.79 protected15048.07 genomic15048.35 and15048.67 health15048.91 information.15049.23 Like15049.79 institutional15050.11 data15050.59 sets15050.91 used15051.07 to15051.39 analyze15051.47 patterns15051.87 of15052.35 cognitive15052.51 resilience15052.91 and15053.47 early15053.63 neurodegeneration15053.95 among15054.75 those15055.07 with15055.31 Alzheimer's15055.47 disease.15056.51 And15056.83 that15057 data15057.24 is15057.63 locked15057.88 behind15058.12 review15058.44 boards,15058.75 ethics15059.15 approval,15059.56 and15060.03 secure15060.03 access15060.44 protocols15060.83 because15061.32 it15061.56 involves15061.72 real15062.19 people's15062.36 biology15062.83 and15063.32 features.15063.56 When15065.15 designing15065.39 quantum15065.8 and15066.12 AI15066.27 frameworks,15066.44 I15066.92 scrutinize15067.07 datasets15067.63 for15068.19 accuracy,15068.44 sensitivity,15069 and15069.72 risk.15069.95 I'm15070.59 trained15070.83 to15071.15 ask,15071.24 is15071.5 this15071.66 data15071.9 necessary?15072.14 Are15072.7 we15072.94 protecting15073.1 the15073.42 subject's15073.5 privacy?15073.9 And,15074.78 ironically,15075.18 I15075.82 have15075.98 fewer15076.22 rights15076.46 over15076.86 the15077.1 data15077.26 collected15077.5 from15077.82 my15078.06 own15078.14 browser15078.3 history15078.62 than15079.58 I15079.74 do15079.82 over15080.06 anonymized15080.38 neurons15080.94 from15081.5 research15081.74 patients.15082.14 The15083.26 digital15083.42 tools15083.82 I've15084.14 relied15084.3 on15084.62 since15084.86 grade15085.1 school,15085.42 learning15085.74 apps,15086.14 test15086.46 prep15086.78 tools,15086.94 and15087.47 even15087.47 school15087.79 Wi15087.95 Fi15088.27 have15088.67 quietly15088.91 harvested15089.39 and15089.79 sold15090.03 my15090.43 personal15090.59 data15090.91 even15091.39 as15091.63 a15091.79 minor.15091.88
15092.59 For15092.59 years,15092.83 virtually15093.31 no15093.79 oversight.15094.03 My15095.47 location,15095.71 device15096.27 ID,15096.67 academic15096.99 performance,15097.47 and15097.95 search15098.11 patterns15098.35 are15098.83 fed15098.99 into15099.15 a15099.49 black15099.57 box15099.81 algorithm15100.13 I'll15100.69 never15100.93 see.15101.17 And15101.89 I'm15102.13 held15102.29 to15102.53 a15102.69 high15102.77 ethical15103.01 research15103.41 standard15103.73 when15104.37 handling15104.61 others'15105.09 data15105.57 but15106.05 denied15106.29 agency15106.69 over15107.25 my15107.41 own.15107.65 We15108.61 are15108.77 315109.01 among15109.25 the15109.57 approximately15109.89 115110.53 and15110.77 a15110.85 half15110.93 million15111.09 students15111.41 in15111.81 Massachusetts15111.89 from15112.73 kindergarten15112.88 through15113.24 college15113.61 facing15114 the15114.32 digital15114.49 norm15114.8 of15115.13 silent15115.28 invasions15115.68 of15116.08 privacy15116.32 every15116.8 day.15117.05 And15117.52 I15117.76 respectfully15117.93 ask15118.49 that15118.73 the15118.88 committee15118.97 give15119.36 a15119.44 favorable15119.52 report15119.93 to15120.73 H15120.97 7815121.2 and15121.68 S15121.84 4515122 with15122.64 a15122.8 minimum15122.88 of15123.44 the15123.44 critical15123.76 the15124.32 315124.49 critical15124.77 protections,15125.17 strong15126.13 data15126.45 minimization,15126.77 a15127.41 ban15127.57 on15127.73 the15127.89 sale15127.97 of15128.21 sensitive15128.37 information,15128.77 and15129.25 a15129.41 private15129.49 right15129.89 to15130.05 action.15130.21 You15131.17 have15131.33 heard15131.57 from15131.73 others15131.97 about15132.29 the15132.29 harms15132.45 associated15132.77 with15133.25 the15133.41 sale15133.49 of15133.73 location15133.89 data.15134.29 So,15134.69 I15134.85 also15135.01 urge15135.33 the15135.57 committee15135.65 to15135.97 advance15136.13 H15136.53 8615136.69 or15137.25 S15137.72 115137.88 85,15138.03 the15138.59 location15138.83 shield15139.39 act,15139.63 should15140.35 a15140.59 full15140.67 omnibus15140.92 bill15141.48 not15141.79 move15141.95 forward15142.11 in15142.43 this15142.59 session.15142.75 This15143.79 is15144.03 a15144.11 once-in-a-generation15144.67 opportunity15145.15 for15145.72 the15145.79 Commonwealth15145.88 to15146.83 lead15146.99 the15147.15 nation15147.31 in15147.63 protecting15147.79 the15148.27 most15148.43 basic15148.59 digital15148.99 rights15149.31 of15149.63 students,15149.96 families,15150.44 and15150.84 future15151 generations15151.48 from15152.44 the15152.68 perpetuated15152.84 status15153.48 quo15153.8 of15154.2 data15154.36 exploitation.15154.76 Thank15155.48 you15155.72 so15155.88 much15156.04 for15156.28 your15156.44 time15156.6 and15156.92 consideration.15157.08
15162.7 ROY15162.7 RENBERG15162.7 -15162.7 HARVARD15162.7 UNIVERSITY15162.7 -15162.7 HB15162.7 7815162.7 -15162.7 HB15162.7 10415162.7 SB15162.7 2915162.7 -15162.7 Thank15162.7 you,15162.94 Chair15163.11 Moore,15163.43 Chair15164.14 Farley15164.63 Pavier,15165.02 and15165.43 the15165.67 rest15165.9 of15166.14 the15166.3 committee.15166.38 My15167.26 name15167.34 is15167.5 Roy15167.74 Renberg.15167.99 I'm15168.47 a15168.63 computer15168.78 science15169.11 PhD15169.5 at15169.99 Harvard15170.38 University,15170.86 and15171.43 I15171.67 have15171.9 previously15172.14 worked15172.55 as15172.78 a15172.94 software15173.02 engineer15173.43 and15174.14 as15174.38 a15174.63 cybersecurity15174.78 consultant15175.5 at15175.52 a15175.54 fine15175.54 financial15175.58 technology15175.6 company.15175.62 I15175.63 live15175.65 in15175.66 Cambridge,15175.68 Massachusetts.15175.7 My15175.71 research15175.73 focuses15175.74 on15175.99 the15178.15 company.15178.15 I15178.63 live15178.87 in15179.03 Cambridge,15179.19 Massachusetts.15179.51 My15180.71 research15180.87 focuses15181.35 on15181.75 data15181.99 privacy15182.23 and15182.55 minimizing15182.71 the15183.19 ability15183.27 of15183.67 algorithms15183.83 to15184.31 potentially15184.47 learn15185.67 potentially15185.91 harmful15186.39 things15186.79 about15187.11 individuals.15187.27 I'm15188.31 here15188.55 to15188.79 speak15188.95 about15189.11 the15189.27 importance15189.43 of15189.75 privacy15189.91 laws,15190.23 and15190.47 in15190.63 particular,15190.79 I'm15191.35 in15191.51 support15191.67 of15191.99 H15192.15 78,15192.47 Massachusetts15193.74 Consumer15194.22 Data15194.54 Privacy15194.86 Act,15195.18 SB15195.5 45,15195.74 HB15197.74 104,15197.98 S15197.98 29.15197.98 In15199.18 particular,15199.42 I15199.98 wanna15200.06 talk15200.3 about15200.47 privacy15200.78 laws15201.18 in15201.42 relation15201.58 to15201.98 data15202.06 brokers.15202.38
15203.42 MOORE15203.42 -15203.42 Excuse15203.42 me,15204.7 can15204.7 you15204.94 just15204.94 talk15205.26 up15205.5 a15205.58 little15205.66 bit15205.9 louder15206.06 so15206.54 everyone15206.78 can15207.1 hear.15207.26
15209.32 RENBERG15209.32 -15209.32 In15209.32 particular,15209.48 I15209.96 wanna15210.36 share15210.68 and15211.16 wanna15211.16 speak15211.48 about15211.64 privacy15211.96 laws15212.36 in15212.6 relation15212.68 to15213 data15213.16 brokers.15213.4 I'd15214.2 like15214.36 to15214.52 share15214.6 a15214.84 personal15214.92 anecdote.15215.32 Before15216.12 this15216.28 hearing,15216.44 215216.84 weeks15217 ago,15217.24 I15217.48 issued15217.64 a15217.88 data15218.04 access15218.28 request15218.6 and15218.92 data15219.08 deletion15219.32 request15219.72 to15220.12 115220.36 of15220.52 the15220.6 major15220.76 data15221.16 broker15221.4 companies,15221.72 Acxiom.15222.28 And15222.92 this15223.09 morning,15223.25 I15223.41 received15223.65 an15224.05 email15224.29 containing15224.7 5315225.01 pages15225.58 of15225.89 my15226.05 own15226.22 personal15226.45 information,15226.77 including15227.65 every15228.05 apartment15228.38 I've15228.7 ever15228.93 lived15229.09 in,15229.33 inference15230.05 about15230.45 my15230.7 credit15230.85 scores,15231.17 and15231.97 perhaps15232.29 most15232.7 concerningly,15232.93 my15233.58 Social15233.73 Security15234.05 number.15234.45 For15236.93 companies15237.28 like15237.28 data15237.52 brokers,15237.68 having15238 this15238.24 data15238.4 is15238.64 bad15238.8 for15239.04 many15239.12 reasons.15239.36 It15239.76 enables15240 discrimination15240.48 and15241.2 exploitation.15241.44 It15242.16 makes15242.32 me15242.56 more15242.8 vulnerable15242.96 to15243.36 security15243.52 breaches.15244.08 I15245.76 share15245.84 this15246.16 because15246.32 as15246.72 someone15246.8 who15247.12 works15247.28 full15247.52 time15247.76 on15247.92 data15248 on15248.4 data15248.64 privacy,15248.96 if15249.44 a15249.6 single15249.84 data15250.16 broker15250.4 has15250.72 5315250.88 pages15251.57 on15251.81 me,15251.97 I15252.22 can15252.38 only15252.53 imagine15252.77 what15253.17 parents,15253.41 teachers,15253.89 and15254.29 seniors,15254.45 people15255.09 with15255.41 less15255.57 time15255.81 or15256.05 technical15256.22 know-how15256.93 might15257.41 have15258.05 technical15259.17 know-how15259.73 to15259.89 protect15259.97 themselves.15260.29
15263.66 The15263.66 only15263.74 reason15263.98 I15264.22 was15264.46 able15265.9 to15266.14 request15266.3 my15266.62 data15266.7 was15267.02 thanks15267.18 to15267.42 the15267.58 California15267.74 privacy15268.46 law,15268.86 CCPA.15269.18 As15269.98 a15270.14 Massachusetts15270.38 resident,15270.94 I15271.34 have15271.5 no15271.66 such15271.9 act15272.14 and15272.46 no15272.46 such15272.62 right.15272.94 At15273.34 the15273.58 moment,15273.66 these15273.98 companies15274.14 don't15274.62 check15274.86 where15275.1 I15275.26 am.15275.42 That's15275.98 not15276.22 a15276.38 legally15276.46 protected15276.86 right15277.34 at15277.58 this15277.74 moment.15277.9 I15279.43 stand15279.51 before15279.75 the15280.07 Massachusetts15280.31 legislature15281.03 asking15281.67 to15281.99 pass15282.07 a15282.39 comprehensive15282.55 Massachusetts15283.11 comprehensive15284.63 privacy15285.19 law15285.67 emphasizing15285.99 at15286.63 least15286.79 315287.03 concerns:15287.35 right15288.72 to15288.95 knowledge,15289.03 right15289.51 to15289.75 erasure,15289.91 and15290.39 a15290.63 strong15290.97 privacy15291.53 by15291.93 default15292.17 for15292.49 data15292.73 minimization15292.97 as15293.69 opposed15293.93 to15294.25 consent-based15294.89 privacy.15295.21 I15298.41 urge15298.57 you15298.81 to15298.97 act.15299.13 Thank15299.69 you.15300.09 I15300.09 thank15300.25 the15300.41 legislator15300.65 for15301.13 his15301.29 time.15301.45
15303.75 FARLEY-BOUVIER15303.75 -15303.75 Terrific.15303.75 Thank15304.15 you15304.39 all15304.55 for15304.79 coming.15304.95 I15305.19 wanna15305.27 turn15305.51 to15305.67 the15305.83 committee15305.91 to15306.23 see15306.31 if15306.47 there15306.55 are15306.79 any15306.79 questions.15307.03 I15308.07 think15308.23 anytime15308.39 we15308.72 have15308.79 students15309.03 in15309.43 the15309.51 space,15309.67 it's15309.91 a15310.07 very15310.23 good15310.47 thing.15310.63 So15310.88 I15311.11 really15311.19 do15311.43 appreciate15311.59 you15311.99 being15312.15 here.15312.39 Thank15312.95 you.15313.27 We're15313.75 now15314.07 gonna15314.23 move15314.55 to15314.88 Elizabeth15315.27 Mitchell,15316.07 who15316.63 is15317.67 online,15318.03 and15319.31 you15319.63 are15319.95 part15320.19 of15320.51 a15320.59 panel.15320.67 So15321.07 this15321.23 would15321.39 be15321.55 a15321.71 panel.15321.79 Then15323.15 we15323.47 will15323.63 move15323.79 to15324.03 if15324.43 she15324.83 is15325.07 still15325.31 here,15325.55 except15326.51 for15326.75 her15326.91 teach15326.99 out.15327.31 And15328.11 after15328.35 that15328.75 is15329.31 Caitlin,15329.79 Vergara.15331.19
15333.67 SPEAKER1315333.67 -15333.67 Elizabeth?15333.67
ELIZABETH15335.51 MITCHELL15335.51 -15335.51 MAMA15335.51 -15335.51 HB15335.51 7815335.51 -15335.51 SB15335.51 4515335.51 -15335.51 SB15335.51 2915335.75 -15335.75 HB15335.75 10415335.75 -15335.75 (15335.75 R)Yep.15335.75 I'm15335.75 here.15335.99 Thank15336.15 you15336.39 so15336.47 much.15336.63 My15337.67 name15337.75 is15337.91 Elizabeth15338.07 Mitchell,15338.47 and15338.79 I'm15338.95 testifying15339.11 today15339.59 on15339.91 behalf15340.07 of15340.31 MAMA,15340.47 Mothers15340.79 Against15341.11 Media15341.51 Addiction,15341.83 in15342.31 support15342.55 of15342.95 H78,15343.19 S45,15344.58 S29,15345.54 and15346.5 H104.15346.82 Mothers15348.1 Against15348.42 Media15348.66 Addiction15348.98 is15349.3 a15349.38 grassroots15349.54 movement15350.02 of15350.42 parents15350.58 and15350.82 allies15351.06 fighting15351.46 back15351.78 against15352.02 media15352.34 addiction15352.66 and15352.98 creating15353.14 a15353.46 world15353.54 where15353.78 real-life15354.26 experiences15354.5 and15355.06 interaction15355.3 remain15356.18 at15356.5 the15356.66 heart15356.74 of15356.98 a15357.06 healthy15357.14 childhood.15357.46 We15358.34 have15358.5 a15358.74 3-part15359.06 mission:15359.22 educating15359.62 parents,15360.27 getting15360.59 smartphones15360.91 out15361.31 of15361.55 school15361.63 so15361.95 kids15362.03 can15362.27 learn,15362.51 and15363.23 ensuring15363.39 technology15363.79 products15364.27 have15364.67 basic15364.91 safeguards15365.23 like15365.72 other15365.88 consumer15366.03 products.15366.43
15367.39 Like15367.39 Mothers15367.55 Against15367.88 Drunk15368.19 Driving,15368.35 we15368.67 are15368.83 standing15368.99 up15369.31 to15369.47 massive15369.63 public15370.03 health15370.35 threats15370.51 and15370.91 making15371.15 changes15371.47 in15371.88 our15372.03 homes,15372.19 communities,15372.51 and15372.99 across15373.15 the15373.55 nation.15373.63 We15374.38 appreciate15374.62 the15374.94 leadership15375.1 of15375.58 this15375.66 committee,15375.9 and15376.22 in15376.38 particular,15376.46 the15376.94 chairs15377.1 have15377.34 shown15377.5 themselves15378.14 to15378.46 be15378.46 enacting15378.46 meaningful15378.94 privacy15379.34 protections15379.74 for15380.14 Massachusetts15380.38 residents15380.86 by15381.42 sponsoring15381.58 these15381.98 bills.15382.14 Part15382.94 of15383.18 the15383.26 work15383.34 at15383.5 MaMa15383.66 is15383.98 raising15384.06 awareness15384.38 of15384.78 the15384.94 critical15385.02 importance15385.34 of15385.82 protecting15385.98 children's15386.46 data,15386.86 as15387.58 data15387.82 is15388.06 often15388.22 used15388.54 in15388.86 ways15388.94 that15389.02 are15389.18 ultimately15389.42 not15389.82 in15390.14 children's15390.3 best15390.7 interests.15390.94 Last15391.9 year,15392.06 the15392.3 College15392.47 Board15392.7 reached15393.02 a15393.26 settlement15393.5 with15393.98 the15394.06 New15394.22 York15394.38 Attorney15394.54 General15394.86 and15395.18 the15395.26 New15395.42 York15395.58 State15395.82 Education15396.06 Commission15396.54 for15396.86 collecting15397.1 students'15397.5 personal15397.9 information15398.3 when15398.7 they15398.86 were15399.02 taking15399.18 the15399.5 PSAT,15399.66 SAT,15401.16 and15401.64 AP15402.04 exams15402.28 in15402.68 schools,15402.92 and15403.56 then15403.72 selling15403.96 that15404.28 data15404.44 to15404.68 colleges,15404.84 scholarship15405.48 programs,15405.96 and15406.44 other15406.6 customers15406.84 who15407.24 used15407.4 it15407.56 to15407.72 solicit15407.8 students15408.2 to15408.52 participate15408.6 in15409.16 their15409.24 programs.15409.48 This15410.44 was15410.68 in15410.84 violation15410.92 of15411.4 New15411.48 York15411.64 State15411.8 privacy15412.04 laws,15412.52 which15412.76 require15413 consent15413.48 for15413.96 such15414.2 transfers.15414.52 The15415.34 investigation15415.58 found15416.14 that15416.38 in15416.47 201915416.7 alone,15417.58 the15418.3 college15418.47 board15418.78 had15419.1 improperly15419.26 sold15419.74 the15420.06 personal15420.14 information15420.54 of15421.02 more15421.1 than15421.34 23715421.82 New15423.98 York15424.14 students.15424.3
15425.18 The15425.18 more15425.26 egregious15425.5 example15425.9 also15426.3 comes15426.63 from15426.86 New15427.02 York,15427.18 Seattle,15427.74 and15428.14 Baltimore,15428.3 where15428.78 contracts15428.94 worth15429.34 millions15429.63 of15429.95 dollars15430.03 were15430.51 signed15430.67 with15430.99 the15431.15 virtual15431.55 mental15431.95 health15432.27 care15432.51 provider15432.75 in15433.15 their15433.23 Talkspace15433.39 to15433.95 support15434.11 struggling15434.43 youth.15434.99 According15435.55 to15435.87 privacy15436.03 advocates,15436.43 Talkspace15436.99 was15437.47 leaking15437.55 data15437.95 about15438.35 who15438.59 visited15438.75 the15439.07 website15439.23 to15439.87 TikTok,15440.03 Meta,15440.51 Snap,15440.91 and15441.15 other15441.39 social15441.55 media15441.79 companies15442.11 that15442.51 multiple15442.75 attorney15443.36 generals15443.6 are15443.84 currently15444 suing15444.4 for15444.88 harming15445.13 teen15445.44 mental15445.68 health.15445.92 Consent15447.04 alone15447.44 won't15447.76 fix15447.92 this15448.24 problem.15448.4 Parents15449.13 of15449.52 teens15449.68 cannot15449.92 be15450.24 expected15450.48 to15450.88 read15451.52 every15451.76 lengthy15452 privacy15452.48 policy15452.88 they15453.28 are15453.44 faced15453.52 with15453.76 in15454 order15454.16 to15454.32 prevent15454.48 their15454.72 data15454.88 from15455.2 being15455.36 sold.15455.6 And15455.61 even15455.61 if15455.62 they15455.62 did15455.63 read15455.63 those15455.63 policies,15455.64 they15455.64 are15455.65 left15455.65 with15455.66 a15455.66 take15455.66 it15455.67 or15455.67 leave15455.68 it15455.68 choice.15455.68 A15456 policies,15457.36 they15458.24 are15459.12 left15459.15 with15459.17 a15459.2 take15459.84 it15460.48 or15460.56 leave15460.61 it15460.66 choice.15460.71 A15460.76 team15460.81 would15460.86 have15460.91 to15460.96 choose15461.16 between15461.36 taking15461.52 the15461.6 SAT15461.76 and15462.08 preventing15462.24 their15462.64 personal15462.88 data15463.28 from15463.44 being15463.6 sold.15463.76 It's15464.48 not15464.56 a15464.72 real15464.8 choice.15465.04
15465.52 Unfortunately,15465.52 most15466.16 state15466.4 privacy15466.56 laws15466.96 don't15467.28 do15467.44 enough15467.52 to15467.76 protect15467.92 people's15468.48 privacy.15468.8 These15469.6 laws,15469.76 including15470.26 the15470.42 Virginia15470.59 and15470.83 Connecticut15470.83 laws,15471.23 most15471.54 often15471.71 cited15471.95 by15472.26 the15472.35 industry15472.5 as15472.83 models15472.99 states15473.38 should15473.71 follow,15473.95 simply15474.5 cement15474.9 the15475.14 status15475.3 quo15475.63 into15475.87 law.15476.26 Unfortunately,15477.54 the15479.23 bills15479.38 I'm15479.78 sorry.15480.02 These15480.99 bills15481.23 contain15481.54 the15481.95 315482.02 most15482.57 critical15482.73 elements15483.05 needed15483.37 in15483.61 a15483.77 strong15483.85 privacy15484.17 bill:15484.49 strong15484.97 data15485.29 minimization15485.61 rules15486.17 number15486.57 2,15486.81 restrictions15487.13 on15487.53 the15487.61 sale15487.77 of15488.01 sensitive15488.09 data,15488.57 and15489.29 strong15489.61 enforcement15490.65 mechanisms.15491.13 These15492.01 bills15492.17 require15492.49 that15492.89 entities15493.05 only15493.69 collect,15494.01 use,15494.41 and15494.73 transfer15494.89 data15495.29 that15495.53 is15495.69 reasonably15495.77 necessary15496.25 and15496.84 proportionate15496.84 to15497.72 prove15497.88 or15498.2 maintain15498.36 a15498.75 product15498.75 or15498.99 service15499.24 requested15499.63 by15500.03 the15500.2 consumer.15500.36 They15500.84 set15500.99 a15501.15 heightened15501.24 protection15501.63 based15502.11 on15502.43 heightened15502.6 protections15502.84 for15503.24 sensitive15503.39 data15503.79 that15504.11 cannot15504.2 be15504.6 used15504.75 for15505.31 advertising15505.55 purposes15506.03 and15506.75 ban15506.91 of15507.15 sale,15507.31 a15507.72 protection15507.79 included15508.36 in15508.51 the15508.66 recently15508.91 enacted15509.31 Maryland15510.27 Online15510.59 Data15510.83 Privacy15511.15 Act15511.63 that15511.87 we15512.11 urge15512.27 Massachusetts15512.51 to15513.15 adopt.15513.31 Sorry,15514.03 I'm15514.27 out15514.43 of15514.59 time,15514.67 but15514.91 please15515.15 also15515.47 pass15515.71 the15516.03 Location15516.43 Shield15516.91 Act,15517.15 and15517.31 thank15517.47 you15517.63 for15517.71 the15517.87 opportunity15518.03 to15518.51 testify.15518.67
FARLEY-BOUVIER15519.87 -15519.87 You're15519.87 terrific,15520.19 Elizabeth.15520.59 Thank15520.99 you15521.15 so15521.39 much.15521.55 Also15521.87 on15522.19 this15522.35 panel15522.59 are15522.99 Ariel15523.47 Fox15523.95 Johnson15524.27 and15525.39 Ava15525.63 Ava15526.06 Smithing.15526.3
15530.06 SPEAKER1515530.06 -15530.06 Ariel?15530.06 Hello.15530.47
ARIEL15531.5 FOX15531.5 JOHNSON15531.5 -15531.5 COMMON15531.5 SENSE15531.5 MEDIA15531.5 -15531.5 HB15531.5 7815531.5 -15531.5 SB15531.5 4515531.5 -15531.5 (15531.5 R15531.5 )15531.5 Thank15531.5 you,15531.82 chairs15532.14 and15532.47 committee15532.78 members.15533.18 My15533.9 name15534.14 is15534.3 Ariel15534.63 Fox15535.02 Johnson,15535.26 and15535.66 I'm15535.82 a15535.9 senior15536.06 advisor15536.38 in15536.78 data15536.94 privacy15537.18 with15537.74 Common15537.9 Sense15538.22 Media,15538.54 the15539.02 nation's15539.18 leading15539.5 nonpartisan15540.06 organization15540.63 dedicated15541.26 here15548.78 today15548.94 in15549.1 support15549.82 of15550.38 H7815551.58 and15551.82 S45.15552.06 These15553.42 bills15553.66 are15554.06 critical15554.22 steps15555.02 towards15555.1 protecting15555.42 kids15555.9 and15556.14 teens15556.3 online15556.81 and15557.38 minimizing15557.61 the15558.17 use15558.25 of15558.57 everyone's15558.73 personal15559.22 data.15559.61 Current15561.29 federal15561.69 law15562.09 does15562.49 not15562.73 protect15562.97 teens15563.29 and15563.61 does15563.77 not15564.01 adequately15564.17 protect15564.89 children.15565.38 Youth15566.41 are15566.73 especially15566.97 vulnerable15567.53 to15568.01 privacy15568.09 harms15568.57 because15568.89 they15569.13 spend15569.29 a15569.61 lot15569.69 of15569.93 time15570.01 online,15570.25 including15571.13 on15571.69 school,15571.85 and15572.41 their15572.57 brains15572.84 are15573.08 still15573.16 developing.15573.56 By15573.96 age15574.2 4,15574.52 more15574.92 than15575.08 half15575.32 of15575.56 kids15575.64 have15575.88 their15576.04 own15576.2 devices,15576.44 and15577.4 research15577.64 shows15578.04 that15578.36 young15578.6 teens15578.84 spend15579.16 an15579.4 average15579.64 of15580.04 315580.12 and15580.36 a15580.44 half15580.52 hours15580.76 a15581.08 day15581.16 on15581.32 social15581.48 media.15581.88 Further,15583 kids'15583.48 brains15583.8 are15584.04 not15584.2 fully15584.44 developed,15584.68 and15585.08 neither15585.24 children15585.64 nor15586.2 teens15586.44 have15586.92 a15587.08 good15587.16 understanding15587.48 of15588.28 long-term15588.89 consequences15589.13 online15589.85 or15590.34 elsewhere.15590.49 Young15591.46 children15591.7 don't15592.17 understand15592.41 what15592.81 happens15592.97 when15593.29 they15593.46 share15593.7 information15593.93 online.15594.41
15595.22 They15595.22 believe15595.46 deleting15595.85 an15596.41 app15596.65 or15596.81 information15597.13 in15597.53 that15597.7 app15597.93 deletes15598.25 it15598.58 from15598.73 the15598.89 Internet.15599.05 They15599.93 do15600.09 not15600.25 expect15600.49 or15600.89 understand15601.05 that15601.53 a15601.7 game15601.77 that15602.09 they15602.17 play15602.41 may15602.88 gather15603.04 information15603.44 about15604 them15604.24 from15604.4 external15604.64 sources.15605.12 They15606.64 can't15606.8 understand15607.04 advertisements15607.6 or15608.4 that15608.56 they're15608.8 trying15608.88 to15609.12 sell15609.2 them15609.44 something.15609.68 Teens15610.96 are15611.28 primed15611.44 to15611.76 prioritize15611.92 rewards15612.48 and15612.88 ignore15613.04 risks15613.44 and15613.84 are15614 susceptible15614.16 to15615.2 being.15615.28 Information15625.38 is15625.47 collected15625.54 from15626.5 children15626.66 and15626.98 teens,15627.3 and15627.54 it15627.54 can15627.63 be15627.74 used15627.86 to15628.18 label15628.26 and15628.34 limit15628.5 them,15628.82 affecting15629.52 their15629.84 academic15630 and15630.48 economic15630.72 opportunities.15631.28 It15632.08 also15632.32 makes15632.56 them15632.8 targets15632.96 for15633.28 data15633.44 breaches.15633.68 Massachusetts15634.96 must15635.6 act15635.92 now15636.16 to15636.48 enhance15636.56 privacy15636.88 protections15637.28 for15638.48 children15638.64 and15639.2 teens.15639.52 Protections15640.4 should15641.2 be15641.36 by15641.52 default.15641.98 Kids15642.38 and15642.63 their15642.78 parents15642.95 shouldn't15643.34 bear15643.59 the15643.83 burden15643.9 of15644.22 learning15644.38 how15644.71 to15644.95 change15645.02 privacy15645.26 settings.15645.74 Protection15646.86 should15647.34 include15647.59 bans15647.9 and15648.22 targeted15648.38 ads.15648.86 Flat15649.66 prohibitions15649.9 are15650.47 best15650.63 here15650.86 because15651.1 they15651.34 ensure15651.5 no15651.9 115652.06 will15652.22 be15652.38 tricked15652.54 into15652.86 consenting15653.1 to15653.66 something15653.74 they15653.75 do15653.76 not15653.76 understand15653.77 or15653.78 think15653.78 is15653.79 required15653.79 to15653.8 use15653.81 the15653.81 service.15653.82 It's15653.83 also15654.08 critical15656.48 that15658.08 companies15658.96 not15658.98 be15658.99 able15659.01 to15659.02 turn15659.04 a15659.12 blind15659.28 eye15659.47 to15659.65 youth15659.84 being15659.96 on15660.08 their15661.08 platforms.15662.08
15663.36 Companies15663.36 like15663.76 Meta15664.08 and15664.32 TikTok15664.48 have15664.96 avoided15665.04 compliance15665.52 with15666 current15666.16 federal15666.56 privacy15666.88 law15667.36 by15667.92 pretending15668.16 that15668.56 they15668.72 don't15668.88 have15669.12 kids15669.2 on15669.52 their15669.6 site15669.76 because15670.45 the15670.61 child15670.85 didn't15671.09 self-identify15671.73 as15672.13 a15672.29 kid.15672.45 At15673.17 the15673.33 same15673.41 time,15673.57 these15673.81 companies15674.05 profit15674.53 off15674.93 of15675.09 such15675.25 child15675.49 users15675.89 for15676.69 advertising15677.01 purposes15677.57 because15677.97 their15678.29 algorithms15678.53 have15679.01 identified15679.25 them15679.73 as15679.89 children.15680.05 Companies15681.17 must15681.73 protect15681.97 youth15682.38 when15682.61 they15682.85 know15682.93 or15683.17 should15683.41 have15683.57 known15683.81 about15684.13 young15684.38 users15684.61 on15684.93 their15685.09 site,15685.33 at15685.93 the15686.17 very15686.25 least15686.57 when15686.73 they15686.97 willfully15687.21 disregard15687.69 youth.15688.17 Companies15688.89 should15689.29 not15689.53 only15689.61 be15689.85 liable15690.01 when15690.41 they15690.57 have15690.65 nearly15690.81 construed15691.21 actual15691.69 knowledge15692.01 of15692.33 children.15692.49 We15693.37 know15693.53 kids15693.77 are15694.01 using15694.17 social15694.49 media,15694.81 and15695.29 companies15695.53 know15696.01 it15696.17 too.15696.41 It's15696.81 time15697.05 we15697.29 hold15697.45 them15697.61 accountable15697.77 and15698.25 protect15698.41 kids15698.73 and15698.97 teens15699.13 online.15699.45 Other15699.93 states15700.34 have15700.58 done15700.74 so,15700.82 and15701.06 I15701.3 will15701.47 note15701.54 without15701.7 triggering15702.02 lawsuits.15702.42 And15703.3 Massachusetts15703.54 residents15704.18 deserve15704.74 the15705.14 same15705.22 protections15705.47 as15705.94 well.15706.1 Thank15706.66 you.15706.9
15708.02 SPEAKER115708.02 -15708.02 Thank15708.02 you.15708.26 Ava?15709.78
15711.7 AVA15711.7 SMITHING15711.7 -15711.7 YOUNG15711.7 PEOPLE'S15711.7 ALLIANCE15711.7 -15711.7 HB15711.7 7815711.7 -15711.7 (R)15711.7 Hi.15711.7 Can15712.1 you15712.26 hear15712.42 me?15712.58
FARLEY-BOUVIER15713.06 -15713.06 Yes.15713.06 We15713.3 can.15713.47 And15714.1 we15714.26 can.15715.31 The15715.47 video15715.47 is15715.47 great,15715.63 too.15715.87
15717.39 SMITHING15717.39 -15717.39 Okay.15717.39 Perfect.15717.71 Thank15719.39 you,15719.55 members15719.71 of15720.03 the15720.11 committee,15720.27 and15720.59 Chair15720.83 Bouvier15721.15 and15721.63 Farley15722.03 Beauvoir15722.67 and15723.23 more.15723.39 Thank15723.95 you15724.11 for15724.35 having15724.51 me15724.83 here15725.07 to15725.39 testify15725.55 in15726.11 support15726.27 of15726.51 age15726.75 70.15726.91 My15727.8 name15727.97 is15728.13 Ava15728.21 Smithing.15728.52 I'm15729 the15729.16 advocacy15729.33 director15729.8 at15730.21 the15730.36 Young15730.45 People's15730.68 Alliance.15731.09 We're15731.56 a15731.8 youth-led15732.13 and15732.36 youth-run15732.76 organization,15733.09 and15733.88 our15734.04 mission15734.28 is15734.52 to15734.68 elevate15734.76 youth15735.16 perspectives15735.4 and15735.88 policy15736.04 conversations15736.52 that15737.09 impact15737.24 us.15737.64 I15738.28 want15738.45 to15738.6 share15738.76 with15738.92 you15739.09 today15739.33 why15739.64 this15739.8 bill15739.97 matters15740.25 so15740.45 deeply15740.65 to15741.13 me,15741.21 the15741.77 young15741.85 people15742.09 I15742.33 represent15742.49 and15742.89 why15743.05 we15743.21 feel15743.37 so15743.61 strongly15743.77 it15744.17 should15744.25 become15744.41 law.15744.73 When15745.37 I15745.61 was15745.69 1215745.85 years15746.17 old,15746.33 I15746.57 downloaded15746.73 Instagram.15747.21 What15748.09 had15748.33 started15748.65 as15748.65 innocent15748.81 scrolling15749.29 quickly15749.77 changed,15750.17 and15750.41 the15750.57 platform15750.73 started15751.13 showing15751.45 me15751.69 bikini15751.85 advertisements15752.17 of15753.59 my15753.59 friends.15753.74
15754.3 These15754.3 ads15754.63 featured15754.95 models15755.42 with15755.74 unrealistic15755.9 bodies,15756.54 and15756.86 as15757.11 a15757.18 young15757.26 peer-sensitive15757.74 girl,15758.3 I15758.54 found15758.71 myself15758.95 lingering15759.35 on15759.9 them.15759.98 My15760.54 human15760.71 instinct15760.95 to15761.35 pay15761.59 more15761.74 attention15761.98 to15762.38 threatening15762.47 or15762.95 native15763.11 information15763.42 was15764.14 exploited.15764.17 The15764.19 platform15764.21 detected15764.23 my15764.25 lingering,15764.27 stored15764.29 it15764.32 as15764.34 data,15764.36 and15764.38 wrongly15764.4 inferred15764.42 I15764.44 would15764.47 want15764.54 more15764.59 of15764.63 that15765.26 content.15765.74 My15770.64 insecurity15770.88 became15771.52 a15771.76 data15771.92 point.15772.16 It15772.64 was15772.8 linked15772.96 to15773.28 my15773.36 profile,15773.52 and15773.84 through15774.08 collaborative15774.32 filtering,15774.8 it15775.28 determined15775.44 what15775.92 content15776.16 and15776.48 ads15776.56 I15776.8 would15776.88 see15777.04 next.15777.28 Platforms15778.16 analyze15778.72 patterns15779.76 between15780.08 my15780.48 data15780.65 and15780.89 the15781.05 data15781.29 of15781.53 millions15781.61 of15781.93 users.15782.17 Because15782.73 users15783.13 who15783.46 looked15783.53 at15783.7 bikini15783.85 ads15784.34 also15784.49 tend15784.81 to15784.97 engage15785.13 with15785.38 exercise15785.7 ads15786.09 and15786.34 content,15786.49 the15787.05 algorithm15787.29 predicted15787.7 I15788.09 would15788.25 do15788.41 the15788.58 same.15788.73 This15789.38 pipeline15789.61 took15790.09 me15790.25 all15790.41 the15790.49 way15790.58 from15790.81 exercise15791.05 videos15791.46 to15792.17 diet15792.34 tips15792.65 and,15793.13 eventually,15793.6 to15793.6 content15793.84 that15794.2 promoted15794.56 an15795.84 eating15796 disorder.15796.96 I15797.2 never15797.44 consciously15797.76 chose15798.24 to15798.4 see15798.56 any15798.8 of15798.96 this15799.12 content.15799.28 My15800 data,15800.24 personalized15800.72 recommendation15801.28 systems,15801.84 and15802.24 first-party15802.64 advertising15802.96 are15803.68 chosen15803.92 for15803.92 me.15804.08
15804.88 The15804.88 platform15805.04 shared15805.52 what15805.76 they15805.84 had15806 learned15806.16 about15806.48 me15807.12 between15807.44 themselves15807.76 and15808.25 outside15808.49 advertisers,15808.73 and15809.69 the15809.93 harmful15810.01 content15810.49 followed15810.89 me15811.13 across15811.29 the15811.53 web15811.69 into15811.93 different15812.25 social15812.49 media15812.73 platforms.15813.05 This15814.09 reinforced15814.41 that15814.81 what15815.05 I15815.13 was15815.29 seeing15815.53 was15815.77 what15815.93 I15816.09 was15816.17 supposed15816.33 to15816.73 be15816.81 seeing15816.97 and15817.45 that15817.61 my15817.77 eating15818.01 disorder15818.33 was15818.73 how15818.89 I15819.05 was15819.13 supposed15819.38 to15819.69 be15819.85 acting.15820.01 It15820.73 was15820.81 inherently15821.13 it15821.93 was15822.09 the15822.48 insecurity-based15823.12 beauty15823.36 industry15823.68 that15824.08 we15824.24 all15824.4 know15824.56 on15824.8 crack.15825.04 A15825.68 supercomputer15825.92 following15826.72 me15827.04 everywhere15827.2 I15827.6 go,15827.76 learning15828.24 from15828.56 my15828.8 every15828.96 action15829.28 how15829.68 to15829.84 be15830 more15830.16 effectively15830.32 predatory,15830.96 adopting15831.76 itself15832.16 specifically15832.64 to15833.2 me.15833.36 The15834.4 harmful15834.64 content15835.04 was15835.36 damaging15835.52 enough,15835.92 but15836.15 what15836.39 made15836.55 it15836.63 truly15836.79 life-threatening15837.35 was15837.84 how15837.99 the15838.23 platforms15838.23 kept15838.72 me15838.88 engaged.15839.11 They15839.99 use15840.15 variable15840.39 reward15840.79 schedules,15841.2 the15841.67 same15841.84 psychological15842.08 mechanism15842.96 used15843.43 in15843.59 slot15843.75 machines,15843.99 to15844.63 mix15844.79 content15845.03 that15845.43 triggers15845.59 both15846.08 positive15846.31 and15846.63 negative15846.88 reactions15847.2 in15847.67 an15847.84 unpredictable15847.99 order15848.72 based15849.2 on15849.51 what15849.67 my15849.84 data15849.99 said15850.5 I15850.66 would15850.78 react15850.9 to.15851.54 This15852.18 kind15853.3 of15853.54 reward15853.62 schedule15854.02 leaves15854.34 users15854.66 constantly15855.06 scrolling15855.62 and15856.26 always15856.58 looking15856.82 to15857.06 that15857.22 next15857.38 dopamine15857.62 hit.15858.1
15858.98 Together,15858.98 these15859.38 215859.62 mechanisms15859.78 addict15860.42 users15860.74 to15861.14 a15861.3 perfectly15861.38 tailored15861.78 feed15862.18 of15862.72 increasingly15863.03 extreme15863.75 content15864.08 that15864.72 exploits15865.03 their15865.43 most15865.67 personal15865.91 biases,15866.39 fears,15867.03 and15867.36 insecurities.15867.51 This15868.55 process15868.79 is15869.2 not15869.36 designed15869.6 for15869.91 user15870.08 well-being15870.39 or15870.88 exploration15871.12 but15871.91 solely15872.24 to15872.63 maximize15872.72 the15873.2 time15873.36 spent15873.6 online15873.84 and15874.24 generate15874.39 profit15874.72 for15875.03 the15875.23 platforms.15875.39 H15876.91 7815877.15 addresses15877.71 this15878.03 harmful15878.27 design15878.59 at15878.91 its15879.07 source.15879.23 By15879.87 classifying15880.11 miners'15880.67 data15880.99 as15881.23 sensitive15881.39 data,15881.79 it15882.11 prevents15882.27 platforms15882.59 from15883.07 building15883.23 excessive15883.55 profiles15884.11 that15884.51 track15884.67 in15884.91 securities,15885.15 and15885.95 it15886.19 also15886.27 prevents15886.59 platforms15886.99 from15887.47 manipulating15887.63 content15888.86 in15889.1 an15889.42 order15889.5 that15889.82 would15890.06 addict15890.22 us15890.54 to15890.86 it15891.02 addict15891.26 us15891.58 to15891.74 its15891.9 delivery.15892.14 By15893.18 prohibiting15893.34 the15893.74 sale15893.9 of15894.22 sensitive15894.3 data15894.7 and15894.94 banning15895.1 both15895.42 targeted15895.74 and15896.14 first-party15896.54 advertising15896.94 to15897.82 minors,15897.9 age15898.7 7815898.86 protects15899.34 young15899.74 people15899.98 from15900.22 ads15900.47 designed15900.63 to15900.94 exploit15901.24 their15901.48 vulnerabilities.15901.64 So15903.16 it's15903.48 because15903.72 of15904.04 this15904.12 that15904.36 Massachusetts15905 has15905.56 an15905.72 opportunity15905.96 to15906.52 establish15906.68 a15907.16 pry15907.32 a15907.64 strong15907.88 data15908.2 privacy15908.52 minimization15909.08 requirement,15909.8 prevent15910.52 the15910.92 sale15911.16 of15911.56 sensitive15911.64 data,15912.2 and15912.6 enforce15912.84 this15913.24 all15913.48 with15913.72 a15913.88 strong15914.04 federated15914.36 action15915.01 to15915.34 ensure15915.41 companies15915.81 will15916.22 be15916.38 held15916.53 accountable.15916.7 I15917.65 urge15917.81 you15918.05 to15918.22 report15918.46 H15918.86 7815919.1 favorably.15919.58 Thank15920.22 you15920.38 for15920.53 your15920.7 time15920.77 and15921.01 consideration.15921.17
15922.05 FARLEY-BOUVIER15922.05 -15922.05 Thank15922.05 you.15922.29 Thank15922.62 you15922.77 for15922.93 the15923.17 testimony15923.34 of15923.98 all15924.13 315924.29 of15924.62 you.15924.7 To15925.98 the15926.13 panel,15926.29 well,15926.86 first,15927.17 we'll15927.41 turn15927.58 to15927.81 the15927.98 committee.15928.13 To15929.83 all15930.39 of15930.71 you,15930.79 yeah.15932.55 Go15932.71 ahead.15932.87
MOORE-15934.95 I'm15934.95 sorry.15935.27 Do15935.51 you15935.59 know15935.67 that15936.15 this15936.47 language15936.71 has15937.27 been15937.27 included15937.59 in15937.91 other15938.31 states?15938.55
15940.87 JOHNSON15940.87 -15940.87 Which15940.87 specific15941.27 language15941.75 are15942.11 you15942.27 talking15942.35 about?15942.59
15943.07 MOORE15943.07 -15943.07 On15943.07 that15943.39 you15943.63 just15943.79 talked15943.95 with15944.11 the15944.27 youth15944.35 language?15944.59
15946.03 JOHNSON15946.03 -15946.03 Yeah.15946.03 So,15946.35 for15946.51 example,15946.75 Maryland15947.47 has15948.03 flat-out15948.75 banned15949.07 targeted15950.11 advertising15950.67 to15951.72 kids15951.95 18,15952.35 which15953.47 I15953.63 think15953.72 is15953.95 good.15954.27 It15954.51 also15954.67 has15954.91 the15956.19 knowledge15956.35 standard15956.75 no15957.31 newer15957.55 should15958.09 have15958.25 known.15958.41 California15959.05 has15959.77 willful15960.81 disregard.15961.37 So,15964.09 there15964.25 are15964.41 different15964.57 states.15964.89 And15965.21 I'm15965.37 sorry.15965.53 There15965.77 are15966.09 many15966.25 states15966.57 that15966.81 have15966.97 special15967.21 protections15967.45 for15967.93 teenagers15968.17 now.15968.73 10.15969.37 But15970.25 some15970.49 of15970.65 the15970.73 strongest15970.89 ones15971.29 are15971.69 in15971.93 Maryland15972.49 and15973.73 California,15974.61 and15975.57 New15975.97 York15976.22 passed15976.53 a15976.77 child15976.93 privacy15977.25 act15977.97 last15978.29 year15978.53 as15978.77 well15978.93 that15979.25 has15979.49 good15981.25 productions.15981.41
MOORE15982.53 -15982.53 Thank15982.53 you.15982.85
15983.81 FARLEY-BOUVIER15983.81 -15983.81 So15983.81 to15984.13 follow15984.29 up15984.85 on15984.85 that,15985.01 I15985.41 think15985.57 that15985.89 what15986.29 we15986.53 do15986.77 see15987.01 in15987.25 cross15988.53 states15989.13 is15989.69 the15989.93 definition15990.09 of15990.65 minor.15990.89 At15993.53 age15993.77 78,15994.09 we15994.81 define15995.21 a15995.61 minor15995.69 as15996.09 18,15996.73 and15998.33 so15998.57 your15998.81 thoughts15999.13 on15999.45 that.15999.69 And16001.21 any16001.61 of16002.33 you16002.47 can16002.76 jump16003.05 in16003.34 on16003.62 that.16003.91
16004.2 JOHNSON16004.2 -16004.2 So16004.2 yeah.16004.77 Sorry.16005.06 I16005.35 didn't16005.64 mean16005.92 to16006.21 go16006.78 ahead.16007.07 Talk.16007.65 I16008.22 think16008.51 that's16009.08 where16009.37 people16009.66 are16010.23 moving.16010.52 That's16010.81 where16011.09 our16011.38 lawmakers16011.67 are16011.96 moving16012.24 to16012.53 18.16012.82 You16013.1 know,16013.39 California16013.68 was16013.97 the16014.25 first16014.54 law,16014.83 CCPA,16015.12 to16015.4 protect16015.77 teens,16016.09 and16016.17 it16016.41 was16016.57 under16016.73 16,16016.97 and16017.37 that16017.45 was16017.61 a16017.77 big16017.85 fight.16018.09 I16018.73 worked16018.89 on16019.13 that.16019.29 Maryland16020.73 is16021.21 under16021.37 18.16021.69 New16022.41 York's16022.57 Child16022.89 Data16023.13 Protection16023.45 Act16023.93 is16024.17 under16024.41 18.16024.73 We16025.13 see16025.37 federal16025.93 proposals16026.33 now16026.89 up16028.01 to16028.25 1716028.49 and16028.89 sometimes16029.05 18.16029.61 So16030.01 while16032.02 there16032.26 is16032.5 a16032.59 variation,16032.75 we16033.71 are16033.87 supportive16034.02 of16034.5 under16034.59 18.16034.83
16035.87 FARLEY-BOUVIER-16035.87 Thank16035.87 you.16036.11 Does16036.66 anybody16037.06 else16037.06 from16037.3 the16037.47 panel16037.71 have16038.11 thoughts16038.35 on16038.59 that?16038.66
16040.26 SMITHING16040.26 -16040.26 Terrific.16040.26 Leaving16040.9 under16041.14 1816041.71 is16042.18 the16042.75 right16042.9 oh,16043.14 I16043.41 am.16043.49 Am16043.97 I16044.45 muted?16044.61 No.16044.93
FARLEY-BOUVIER16045.17 -16045.17 No?16045.17
16045.57 SMITHING16045.57 -16045.57 We16045.57 leave16045.57 under16045.81 1816046.13 is16046.53 the16046.69 right16046.85 way16047.01 to16047.25 go.16047.33 These16047.65 harms16047.97 don't16048.29 magically16048.45 disappear16049.01 when16049.41 you16049.57 turn16049.73 17.16050.05
FARLEY-BOUVIER16051.57 -16051.57 Thank16051.57 you.16051.73 Appreciate16052.21 that.16052.61
16052.93 JOHNSON16052.93 -16052.93 Okay.16052.93 Yep.16053.49 I16053.89 totally16054.13 agree16054.53 with16054.69 the16054.85 other16054.93 panelists.16055.17
FARLEY-BOUVIER16056.77 -16056.77 Excellent.16056.77 Alexandra16071.08 Thorne16071.4 is16071.88 on16071.96 deck.16072.2 Good16080.12 afternoon,16080.28 and16080.76 welcome16080.92 to16081.24 you.16081.4
16084.4 SPEAKER1116084.4 -16084.4 Good16084.4 afternoon.16085.36
16085.6 SPEAKER116085.6 -16085.6 Just16085.6 pull16085.92 that16086.09 right16086.24 up16086.48 to16086.64 you.16086.8
CAITLYN16089.36 VERGARA16089.36 -16089.36 HARVARD16089.36 UNIVERSITY16089.36 -16089.36 HB16089.36 9816089.36 -16089.36 Thank16089.36 you,16089.68 Chair16090.72 Farley16091.36 Bouvier,16091.92 Chair16093.13 Moore,16093.68 and16094.24 the16094.56 members16094.72 of16095.04 this16095.21 committee.16095.45 I16096.56 know16096.72 we've16096.88 been16097.13 here16097.28 for16097.52 a16097.68 long16097.76 time16098 today.16098.16
16098.72 FARLEY-BOUVIER16098.72 -16098.72 We16098.72 appreciate16098.97 your16099.52 patience.16099.68
16100.86 VERGARA-16100.86 My16100.86 name16100.94 is16101.1 Caitlyn16101.34 Vergara,16101.66 and16102.22 I'm16102.38 a16102.54 child16102.7 online16103.26 safety16103.74 advocate.16104.22 I'm16105.26 a16105.5 research16105.58 assistant16106.06 at16106.62 Harvard16106.86 Medical16107.26 School16107.66 studying16108.3 youth16108.86 mental16109.26 health.16109.58 Before16110.38 HMS,16110.94 I16111.74 was16111.9 an16112.22 online16112.3 child16112.86 safety16113.18 researcher16113.66 across16114.54 both16115.02 industry16115.34 and16116.52 nonprofits16116.76 for16117.48 the16117.64 past16117.8 316118.04 years.16118.28 But16119.56 today,16119.8 I'm16120.28 here16120.52 as16120.84 your16121.08 constituent,16121.4 a16122.6 resident16122.76 of16123.16 Austin,16123.32 and16124.44 a16124.68 supporter16124.84 of16125.4 H16125.72 98,16126.6 the16128.49 Act16129.13 for16129.45 Internet16129.85 privacy16130.33 rights16130.81 for16131.37 children.16131.69 I'm16133.37 here16133.61 to16133.93 further16134.65 our16135.21 conversation16135.45 today16136.17 on16136.41 how16136.89 targeted16137.29 ads16137.77 are16138.09 harmful16138.41 to16139.05 children.16139.29 I16140.97 know16141.13 that16141.29 there16141.53 are16141.77 many16141.85 powerful16142.17 companies16142.65 that16143.13 don't16143.29 want16143.7 these16143.86 acts16144.1 to16144.42 be16144.58 passed,16145.47 but16145.7 I16146.02 know16146.18 my16146.58 voice16146.82 stands16147.14 with16147.54 our16147.78 community.16148.02 Who16149.47 says16149.7 that16150.1 childhood16150.42 is16151.14 not16151.38 for16151.7 sale?16151.94 As16153.86 the16154.1 first16154.26 generation16154.58 to16155.38 grow16155.63 up16155.86 with16156.18 access16156.5 to16156.9 the16157.06 Internet,16157.14 I16157.86 remember16158.02 being16158.98 on16159.22 these16159.3 social16159.54 media16159.86 platforms16160.34 talking16160.82 to16161.14 my16161.3 friends,16161.46 but16162.34 with16162.58 116162.82 swipe,16163.22 I16164.1 would16164.18 see16164.42 advertisements16164.82 for16165.7 online16165.94 dating.16166.42
16168.1 I16168.1 was16168.18 only16168.42 1416168.74 at16169.14 the16169.3 time.16169.38 Many16170.9 youths16171.38 share16171.7 similar16172.02 experiences.16172.58 116174.61 in16175.09 716175.4 916177.16 to16177.73 12-year-olds16178.45 reported16178.85 having16179.4 an16179.64 online16179.97 sexual16180.36 interaction16180.92 with16181.97 an16182.13 adult.16182.28 In16184.04 2021,16184.28 '1016185.88 percent16186.21 of16186.76 1316187 to16187.56 1716187.73 year16188.28 olds16188.36 have16189.31 reported16189.55 to16189.87 use16190.11 OnlyFans,16190.35 a16191.55 company16191.71 that16192.99 profits16193.87 off16194.51 of16194.75 people16194.99 selling16195.47 their16195.87 own16196.11 nude16196.51 images.16196.91 So16198.75 we16198.91 have16199.15 to16199.31 ask16199.47 ourselves,16199.71 how16201.23 do16201.79 harmful16202.03 advertisements16202.95 groom16203.67 children16204.07 into16205.19 accepting16205.51 adult-like16207.19 relationships?16207.43 I16209.43 know16209.59 from16209.83 working16209.99 in16210.31 the16210.47 industry16210.55 that16211.91 companies16212.31 have16213.27 the16213.43 ability16213.59 to16214.31 differentiate16214.55 between16215.19 child16215.59 profiles16215.99 and16216.55 adult16216.72 profiles.16217.11 These16218.61 things16218.85 have16219.09 been16219.33 said16219.41 again16219.65 and16219.97 again16220.13 over16220.45 the16220.69 course16220.77 of16221.09 today.16221.17 But16222.45 will16222.61 today's16222.93 children16223.33 have16224.21 to16224.45 wait16224.61 until16224.77 they16225.09 are16225.33 my16225.57 age16225.81 to16226.37 sit16226.53 in16226.77 front16226.93 of16227.17 you16227.25 talking16227.57 about16227.89 the16228.13 same16228.29 privacy16228.53 issues?16229.17 Childhood16230.85 is16231.49 not16231.73 for16232.05 sale.16232.29 This16232.37 committee16232.45 knows16232.53 that.16232.61 The16233.49 committee16234.03 knows16234.27 that.16234.43 The16236.35 children16236.59 of16236.99 Massachusetts16237.31 know16238.51 that.16238.83 But16240.03 will16240.27 the16240.51 laws16240.67 of16240.91 Massachusetts16241.15 reflect16242.19 whether16242.91 or16243.23 not16243.31 that16243.95 is16244.19 true?16244.35 Thank16246.11 you16246.43 for16246.59 your16246.83 time,16246.99 and16247.31 thank16247.47 you16247.63 for16247.87 your16248.03 public16248.11 service.16248.51
FARLEY-BOUVIER16249.86 -16249.86 Thank16249.86 you16250.1 for16250.26 that16250.42 strong16250.66 testimony.16250.98 We16251.54 appreciate16251.7 it.16252.1 Are16252.42 there16252.58 any16252.82 questions16252.98 or16253.38 comments16253.62 from16253.94 the16254.1 committee?16254.26 Terrific.16256.18 Thank16256.66 you16256.82 again16256.98 for16257.22 being16257.38 here,16257.54 and16257.7 thank16257.86 you16258.02 for16258.18 your16258.34 patience16258.5 today.16258.9 We're16259.46 gonna16259.62 now16259.86 move16260.1 to16260.34 Alexander16260.58 Thorne,16261.22 and16261.7 up16262.02 on16262.34 deck16262.58 is16262.82 Erica16263.14 Teskowick.16265.23 No.16266.03 That16266.27 was16266.59 really16266.99 bad.16267.39 Sorry.16268.03 Thank16268.51 you.16268.75 We16269.15 really16269.39 appreciate16269.72 your16270.27 patience16270.43 with16270.83 us16270.99 today.16271.15
16272.59 ALEXANDER16272.59 THORNE16272.59 -16272.59 CONCERNED16272.59 CITIZEN16272.59 -16272.59 HB16272.59 10416272.59 -16272.59 SB16272.59 4516272.59 -16272.59 SB16272.59 2916272.59 -16272.59 And16272.59 I16272.75 appreciate16272.99 yours.16273.47 Thank16274.19 you16274.43 to16274.67 the16275.07 chairs,16275.23 to16275.63 the16275.79 committee,16276.07 and16276.39 to16276.39 everyone16276.63 else16277.03 who's16277.27 still16277.51 here.16277.83 So,16280.79 I16281.11 am16281.27 here16281.43 to16281.67 testify16281.83 in16282.15 favor16282.31 of16282.55 the16282.71 strongest16282.79 possible16283.43 comprehensive16284.23 protections16284.87 for16285.43 digital16285.59 privacy16285.99 and16286.79 enforceable16286.95 regulation16287.59 of16288.15 the16288.23 collection16288.31 and16288.63 sharing16288.87 of16289.19 personal16289.35 data,16289.67 including16290.56 geolocation16290.87 data,16291.51 transactions,16292.15 and16292.63 personal16292.79 communications.16293.19 The16294.79 need16294.95 for16295.75 modernized16295.99 data16296.56 protections16296.87 has16297.35 steadily16297.59 increased16297.99 in16298.23 recent16298.39 years,16298.72 as16299.03 we16299.19 well16299.35 know16299.67 by16299.83 now,16300.07 and16301.59 is16302.07 even16302.31 more16302.56 acute16302.79 under16303.19 a16303.43 presidential16303.59 administration16304.15 with16304.63 a16304.87 clear16305.12 I16307.56 therefore16307.8 want16308.68 to16309.08 put,16309.32 throw16309.4 my16309.56 support16309.72 behind16310.2 the16310.76 Massachusetts16310.92 data16311.4 protection16311.64 Data16312.84 privacy16313.16 act,16313.72 H16315.88 104,16316.28 S16316.28 45,16316.28 and16316.84 S16317 29,16317.24 and16317.8 the16318.04 Location16318.12 Shield16318.6 Act,16319.08 H16319.8 86,16319.96 and16320.78 S16321.78 197,16323.47 as16323.47 providing16323.7 an16324.1 important16324.26 step16324.9 forward.16325.54 I'm16328.1 not16328.26 gonna16328.42 go16328.74 through16328.9 all16329.39 of16329.54 the16329.7 various16329.86 abuses16330.34 that16330.9 you16331.47 don't,16331.63 that16331.94 you16332.18 are16332.34 aware16332.42 of16332.66 by16333.14 now,16333.39 in16333.54 terms16333.7 of16333.86 what16333.89 kinds16333.91 of16333.93 data16333.96 are16333.98 collected16334 on16334.02 us,16334.1 but16337.33 I16337.43 wanna16337.53 highlight16337.63 the16337.73 role16337.81 of16337.85 data16337.89 brokers,16338.29 and16339.01 particularly,16339.49 the16340.19 critical16340.9 need16341.6 for16342.31 better16343.01 protections,16343.25 in16345.41 the16346.29 current16346.37 political16346.45 context.16346.53
16346.61 Even16346.61 before16346.69 the16346.77 current16346.85 administration,16347.17 Immigrations16351.39 and16351.94 Customs16352.1 Enforcement16352.5 bought16353.15 huge16353.47 volumes16353.86 of16354.18 cell16354.42 phone16354.66 location16354.91 data16355.31 from16355.63 the16355.94 data16356.1 brokers,16356.34 Ventel16356.98 and16357.47 Babble16357.7 Street.16358.02 This16358.98 is16359.15 only16359.39 going16359.78 to16360.02 accelerate16360.74 if16361.39 left16361.63 unchecked.16361.94 Real-time16363.89 geolocation16364.21 data16364.93 likely16365.25 facilitated16365.73 the16366.29 abduction16366.37 of16366.85 Tufts16367.01 graduate16367.41 student16367.81 Ramesa16368.13 Ozturk16368.69 from16369.25 the16369.41 street16369.49 near16369.89 her16370.21 home16370.29 in16371.09 Somerville16371.25 on16372.29 March16372.53 27.16373.3 I16374.21 live16374.45 in16374.77 Somerville,16374.93 and16375.57 I16375.81 work16375.89 at16376.13 Tufts16376.29 University,16376.85 and16377.17 I16377.65 am16377.81 feeling16378.06 the16379.01 pain16379.17 of16379.49 this16379.57 as16379.89 an16380.06 attack16380.22 on16380.61 my16380.77 own16380.93 community.16383.89 Similarly,16383.89 the16384.61 detention16384.61 of16385.01 tourists16385.17 who16385.65 have16385.81 criticized16385.9 Donald16386.37 Trump16386.69 continues16388.06 a16388.45 pattern16388.61 of16388.93 ICE16389.09 using16389.42 media16389.99 monitoring16390.31 data16390.87 brokers,16391.19 such16391.51 as16391.83 Ghost16391.91 and16392.87 Shadow16394.39 Dragon.16394.71 The16396.47 administration16396.71 has16397.51 clearly16397.83 signaled16398.15 that16398.55 it16398.71 does16398.79 not16399.03 want16399.19 to16399.35 stop16399.51 at16400.15 legal16400.95 or16400.97 undocumented16400.99 immigrants16401.01 but16401.03 is16401.28 prepared16404.83 to16404.99 move16405.22 on16405.31 to16405.39 citizens16405.54 as16406.19 well.16406.35 The16407.31 time16407.95 to16408.19 act16408.26 is16408.5 now.16408.67 Please16409.22 pass16409.71 the16409.95 strongest16410.1 possible16410.67 comprehensive16411.15 data16411.86 privacy16412.1 bill.16412.67
FARLEY-BOUVIER16413.95 -16413.95 Thank16413.95 you,16414.26 Alexander.16414.43 We16414.91 really16415.06 appreciate16415.31 your16415.78 testimony16415.95 and16416.43 your16416.5 patience16416.67 today.16417.15 Are16417.54 there16417.56 any16417.58 comments16417.59 or16417.61 questions16417.63 from16417.64 the16417.66 committee?16417.67 Good.16417.69 Thank16417.71 you16417.72 so16417.74 much.16417.76 Could16417.77 we16417.79 go16417.82 to16418.07 our16418.4 questions16418.64 from16418.8 the16419.12 committee?16419.28 Good.16420.16 Thank16420.32 you16420.56 so16420.8 much.16420.96 If16421.44 we16421.52 could16421.68 go16421.84 to16422 Erica16422.16 Teskowick16422.96 and16422.96 then16423.2 go16423.84 back16424.16 to16424.48 virtual,16425.2 we16425.52 have16425.68 Edward16425.92 Klein.16426.48 Welcome,16428.56 Erica.16429.04
16429.76 SPEAKER1916429.76 -16429.76 Hi.16429.76 It's16430 a16430.24 beautiful16430.32
16430.56 SPEAKER116430.56 -16430.56 sign16430.56 when16430.8 I16431.04 knew16431.12 this.16431.36 We're16431.76 very16432 happy16432.24 to16432.65 have16432.72 you16432.88 here.16433.17
16433.44 SPEAKER1616433.44 -16433.44 Happy16433.44 to16433.76 be16433.84 here.16434.08
ERICA16436.8 TESKOWICK16436.8 -16436.8 CONCERNED16436.8 CITIZEN16436.8 -16436.8 HB16436.8 9916436.8 -16436.8 SB16436.8 4716436.8 -16436.8 Thank16436.8 you16436.97 to16437.28 the16437.36 committee16437.52 and16437.84 the16438 board16438.08 members.16438.32 So16440.56 I16440.97 live16441.12 in16441.36 a16441.52 particularly16441.68 rough16442.24 part16442.56 of16442.8 the16443.04 South16443.12 Boston16443.44 area,16443.84 a16444.4 neighborhood16444.65 where16445.75 most16445.99 people16446.07 I16446.47 encounter,16446.63 including16447.19 myself,16447.59 rely16448.23 on16448.55 food16448.79 stamps16449.03 or16449.83 some16449.99 other16450.23 public16450.47 benefit.16450.79 But16451.43 with16451.59 the16451.75 current16451.83 socioeconomic16452.07 climate,16453.11 those16453.91 benefits16454.15 aren't16454.55 going16454.79 to16455.03 take16455.11 us16455.35 much16455.51 further16455.67 along16455.99 in16456.23 the16456.31 months16456.39 to16456.71 come.16456.79 And16457.51 to16457.67 the16457.83 addition16457.91 of16458.31 dynamic16458.47 pricing16458.95 through16459.27 the16459.43 usage16459.51 of16459.91 dangerously16460.07 discriminate16460.92 AI16461.24 tools16461.63 will16462.27 not16462.43 only16462.6 cripple16462.92 a16463.31 source16463.47 of16463.72 sustenance16463.88 and16464.43 culture16464.51 for16465.31 my16465.56 neighborhood,16465.72 which16466.43 is16466.67 food,16466.83 but16467.4 black16467.63 families16467.95 and16468.35 other16468.51 families16468.67 of16468.99 color16469.15 make16469.47 up16469.63 for16469.79 a16469.92 majority16470.03 of16470.6 my16470.75 neighborhood,16470.83 and16471.4 this16471.56 will16471.79 make16471.95 them16472.11 fear16472.43 for16472.75 their16472.92 safety16473.15 and16473.4 privacy16473.63 while16474.19 going16474.43 out16474.67 for16474.92 a16475.08 simple16475.15 errand16475.47 most16476.03 of16476.39 us16476.55 take16476.71 for16476.79 granted16477.03 or16477.35 pay16477.51 no16477.83 mind16477.99 to.16478.15 I16479.03 think16479.19 back16479.43 to16479.67 that16479.75 brilliant16479.99 group16480.39 of16480.55 teenagers16480.71 at16481.75 the16481.91 Hyde16482.07 Square16482.31 Task16482.63 Force16482.95 who,16483.19 back16483.43 in16483.67 2023.16484.95
16485.11 Through16485.11 their16485.11 own16485.27 grassroots16485.51 experiments,16486.07 they16487.11 discovered16487.11 that16487.59 Stop16487.83 and16488.07 Shop16488.23 charged16488.56 more16488.81 and16489.28 more16489.45 diverse16489.69 neighborhoods16490.17 while16490.81 charging16491.04 more16491.45 affluent16491.6 neighborhoods16492.17 for16493.36 the16493.6 same16493.69 exact16494.08 name-brand16494.72 items.16495.04 And16495.69 I16495.93 can't16496 help16496.24 but16496.49 worry16496.72 about16497.04 AI16497.36 enabling16497.85 such16498.33 corporations16498.56 to16499.2 harm16499.45 even16499.69 more16499.93 Massachusetts16500.17 families16500.88 this16501.36 way.16502.08 For16502.32 a16502.48 public16502.64 housing16502.96 complex16503.36 that16503.76 was16503.92 originally16504.08 built16504.48 in16504.72 the16504.96 1916505.04 thirties,16505.36 I16505.92 often16506.08 feel16506.4 like16506.56 my16506.8 neighborhood16506.96 is16507.44 still16507.6 stuck16507.84 in16508 the16508.16 past.16508.32 Yet,16509.12 it16509.36 has16509.52 withstood16509.68 numerous16510.24 attempts16510.64 to16510.96 erode16511.12 its16511.44 community16511.6 far16512.08 before16512.32 my16512.64 time.16512.8 Its16513.92 people16514.17 still16514.49 find16514.72 ways16514.97 to16515.2 connect16515.28 and16515.6 help16515.76 each16516 other.16516.17 We16516.81 will16516.97 lend16517.13 a16517.36 neighbor16517.44 a16517.76 cup16517.85 of16518.08 sugar,16518.17 or16518.72 in16518.97 my16519.13 instance,16519.36 lend16519.92 a16520.17 neighbor16520.33 a16520.49 few16520.65 slices16520.89 of16521.2 pizza16521.28 when16521.6 she16521.85 hasn't16521.92 eaten16522.24 in16522.49 216522.65 days.16522.81 And16523.44 we16523.6 help16523.76 each16524 other16524.17 when16524.49 and16524.72 where16524.89 it16525.13 counts.16525.2 And16525.99 we16526.15 don't16526.31 want16526.55 nor16526.79 need16527.11 the16527.43 likes16527.59 of16527.83 proven16527.99 oppressive16528.39 technologies16529.03 to16529.51 incriminate16529.75 that.16530.23 I'm16530.63 here16530.87 in16531.03 support16531.19 of16531.51 the16531.59 bills16531.67 H16533.27 9916533.27 and16533.27 S16533.27 47.16533.27
16533.91 FARLEY-BOUVIER16533.91 -16533.91 Thank16533.91 you16534.15 so16534.39 much16534.55 for16534.71 your16534.87 testimony.16535.11 It's16535.75 really16535.99 great16536.23 to16536.55 have16536.63 you16536.79 here.16536.95 Any16537.43 comments16537.67 or16538.07 questions16538.23 from16538.63 the16538.79 committee?16539.08 Senator?16540.75 Good.16540.99 Thank16541.4 you.16541.63 Thank16541.87 you16542.11 again.16542.27
16542.75 SPEAKER816542.75 -16542.75 Have16542.75 a16542.99 good16543.08 night.16543.24
FARLEY-BOUVIER16544.19 -16544.19 We're16544.19 just16544.43 checking16544.67 quickly.16544.99 Is16545.4 Edward16545.72 Klein16546.11 online?16546.75 It16547.4 seems16547.63 like16547.87 he's16548.11 no16548.35 longer16548.51 with16548.83 us.16548.99 So16549.31 we16549.56 are16549.72 gonna16549.87 now16550.11 go16550.35 to16550.6 Kate16551.15 Crockford.16552.19 And,16552.92 on16553.66 deck16553.74 is16554.22 James16555.02 O'Keefe,16555.42 who16556.22 is16556.46 also16556.62 online.16558.3 Nice16560.22 to16560.54 have16560.7 you16560.78 here,16560.94 Kate.16561.1
16561.74 KATE16561.74 CROCKFORD16561.74 -16561.74 ACLU16561.74 -16561.74 Hi,16561.74 folks.16562.06 Good16562.86 evening.16563.1 Oh.16563.5 How16563.87 are16564.25 you?16564.62 You16564.78 did16564.86 well.16565.1 Nice16568.02 to16568.26 see16568.35 you16568.5 all.16568.67 Thank16569.22 you16569.54 so16569.7 much16569.86 for16570.1 coming16570.83 back16571.15 after16571.54 your16571.86 votes16572.02 and16572.35 to16572.5 the16572.58 chairs16572.74 and16573.39 your16573.54 staff16573.78 for16574.1 all16574.35 the16574.5 hard16574.67 work16574.91 that16575.06 you16575.31 all16575.47 have16575.63 done16575.86 on16576.02 this16576.18 issue,16576.42 this16577.54 session,16577.7 and16578.1 the16578.26 last16578.26 session.16578.58 I16579.22 wanna16579.39 sort16581.28 of16581.44 take16581.6 a16581.68 step16581.76 back16582.32 and16582.56 talk16582.96 not16583.52 about16583.84 the16584 specifics16584.24 of16584.8 the16584.88 bills16585.12 themselves16585.44 so16585.92 much,16586.08 but16586.72 about16586.96 the16587.2 moment16587.36 we16587.68 find16587.84 ourselves16588.08 in16588.56 as16589.2 a16589.44 country16589.52 and16590.64 the16591.36 importance,16591.52 I16591.92 think,16592.08 of16592.32 passing16592.4 strong16592.8 data16593.12 privacy16593.36 legislation.16593.76 I16595.76 don't16596.08 need16596.24 to16596.31 tell16596.4 you16596.47 about16596.87 the16597.19 crisis16597.35 that16597.75 we're16597.92 in.16598.15 But16600.15 I16600.4 do16600.79 wanna16600.95 say16601.27 that16601.43 for16601.6 far16601.92 too16602.08 long,16602.24 the16603.11 wealthy16603.35 and16603.67 the16603.83 powerful16603.99 in16604.31 this16604.47 country16604.63 have16605.03 been16605.19 able16605.35 to16605.51 write16605.67 the16605.92 rules.16606.08 And16607.03 in16608.09 the16608.17 case16608.33 of16608.49 consumer16608.65 privacy16609.21 law,16609.61 maybe16610.01 avoid16610.33 rules16610.81 altogether.16611.21 Right?16611.85 For16613.29 years,16613.53 we've16613.85 been16614.01 told16614.25 that16614.57 Big16615.05 Tech16615.37 is16615.37 working16615.53 in16615.93 our16616.01 favor.16616.25 But16616.97 I16617.21 think16617.29 recent16617.53 events,16617.93 such16618.49 as16618.73 the16618.89 parade16619.05 of16619.37 big16619.85 tech16620.01 billionaires16620.25 lining16620.81 up16621.13 to16621.29 pad16621.45 the16621.61 president's16621.69 pockets16622.17 at16622.57 his16622.73 inauguration,16622.89 should16624.19 clear16624.43 up16624.67 any16624.92 doubt16625.24 about16625.72 where16626.03 they16626.27 really16626.51 stand.16626.75 Data16628.11 is16628.43 the16628.59 new16628.75 oil.16628.99 That's16629.24 what16629.47 we16629.63 hear16629.79 all16630.03 the16630.11 time.16630.27
16631.24 And,16631.24 116632.35 of16632.59 the16632.67 most16632.83 precious16633.08 commodities16633.47 that16633.95 enable16634.11 companies16634.59 of16635.15 all16635.31 different16635.87 kinds16636.19 to16636.51 control16636.67 us,16636.99 manipulate16637.24 prices,16637.72 stifle16638.19 competition.16638.59 And16639.98 so16640.14 I16640.38 wanna16640.54 ask16640.78 the16641.02 committee,16641.18 and16641.58 through16641.82 you,16641.98 I16642.22 hope,16642.38 other16643.18 members16643.5 of16643.74 leadership16643.9 in16644.46 this16644.7 building,16644.86 to16645.66 think16645.82 about16646.06 data16646.3 privacy16646.62 regulation16647.1 the16647.98 way16648.14 that16648.3 our16648.38 predecessors,16648.62 your16649.26 predecessors,16649.5 people16650.22 in16650.54 the16650.7 1916650.78 sixties16651.1 and16651.5 1970s,16651.82 thought16652.46 about16652.62 environmental16653.2 protection.16653.6 Industrial16654.81 polluters16655.2 in16655.6 the16655.76 1916655.84 sixties16656.17 and16656.56 1970s16656.72 warned16657.12 that16657.44 regulations16657.68 to16658.81 stop16658.97 them16659.12 from16659.36 pumping16659.52 toxins16660.49 into16660.97 our16661.28 water16661.44 and16661.84 our16662.08 air16662.33 would16663.04 hurt16663.28 their16663.44 profits16663.68 and16664.17 disadvantage16664.4 American16665.28 businesses.16665.76 And16666.88 today,16667.12 we16667.68 hear16667.92 representatives16668.76 of16669.4 this16669.48 of16669.88 similar16670.2 Robert16670.68 Barrons16671.08 from16671.48 the16671.56 tech16671.72 industry16671.96 saying16672.92 similar16673.24 things16673.64 about16674.36 stopping16674.84 meaningful16675.32 privacy16675.96 regulations.16676.68 The16678.44 reality16678.68 is16679.08 that,16679.16 like16679.4 those16679.56 polluters,16679.88 companies16681 profit16681.64 from16682.04 the16682.2 collection.16691.65 But16691.65 the16691.97 benefits16692.13 to16693.41 the16693.56 people16693.73 of16694.04 Massachusetts16694.28 and16695.56 to16695.81 the16695.97 country,16696.13 like16697.41 clean16697.73 air16697.97 and16698.21 water,16698.37 are16699.57 more16699.81 than16700.05 worth16700.21 it.16700.53 Personal16700.69 autonomy,16701.17 democracy,16702.13 economic16703.01 freedom,16703.49 so16704.53 many16704.77 of16705.01 the16705.09 arguments16705.17 that16705.57 we've16705.73 heard16705.97 from16706.29 so16706.61 many16706.85 different16707.01 people16707.33 representing16707.73 so16708.21 many16708.37 different16708.53 communities16708.85 today.16709.41 So16711.17 I16711.4 wanna16711.72 say16711.97 something16712.2 about16712.6 elite16713 impunity.16713.32
16714.36 I16714.36 think16714.52 116714.92 of16715.08 the16715.24 reasons16715.4 that16715.8 we16716.04 find16716.2 ourselves16716.52 in16717.08 this16717.24 situation16717.49 today16718.12 with16719.08 Donald16719.49 Trump16719.97 as16720.36 the16720.6 president16720.76 again16721.32 is16722.76 the16722.92 sense16723.17 among16723.4 voters16723.72 that16724.28 people16724.68 in16725.08 power16725.32 don't16726.04 listen16726.44 to16726.6 them16726.76 and16727.24 don't16727.48 care16727.8 about16728.04 them,16728.28 that16728.6 politicians16728.84 are16729.4 corrupt,16729.56 that,16730.44 you16730.68 know,16730.84 we16731.08 gotta16731.24 drain16731.56 the16731.8 swamp.16731.96 Right?16732.52 That16733.72 the16733.88 government16734.04 doesn't16734.44 work16734.76 for16735 regular16735.16 people,16735.56 but16735.88 works16736.12 for16736.44 the16736.6 rich16736.76 and16736.92 powerful16737.08 and16737.48 the16737.64 well16737.72 connected.16737.96 And16739.06 so16739.39 before16739.63 you,16740.1 you16740.35 have16740.58 legislation16740.83 that16741.7 you16741.94 216742.43 filed,16742.91 as16743.7 chairs,16743.86 as16744.26 well16744.43 as16744.67 the16744.74 Location16744.83 Shield16745.22 Act,16745.54 that16747.63 huge16748.35 numbers16748.67 of16749.06 Massachusetts16749.22 voters16749.7 support.16750.1 Right?16750.58 The16751.06 Location16751.22 Shield16751.63 Act,16752.02 polling16752.35 shows,16752.74 is16753.06 supported16753.15 by16753.63 92%16753.86 of16754.74 likely16755.03 voters.16755.35 That's16756.07 left,16756.31 right,16756.63 center.16756.95 Our16759.03 federal16759.27 government16759.59 is16759.99 in16760.15 crisis.16760.39 It's16760.95 a16761.19 crisis16761.35 that's16761.75 enabled16761.99 by16762.39 Silicon16762.63 Valley16762.95 Billionaires.16763.27 States16764.23 like16764.47 Massachusetts,16764.71 during16765.51 this16765.75 crisis,16765.91 have16766.39 an16766.63 obligation16766.79 to16767.43 respond16767.59 not16768.46 merely16768.61 by16769.01 filing16769.18 lawsuits16769.58 as16770.06 our16770.29 attorney16770.46 general16770.77 is16771.01 doing,16771.18 but16772.53 also16772.7 by16773.1 legislating,16773.25 by16774.61 demonstrating16774.94 that16775.5 here,16775.74 the16776.38 will16776.61 of16776.77 the16776.94 people16777.1 reigns,16777.66 that16778.53 no16778.77 matter16778.94 what's16779.18 happening16779.5 in16779.81 Washington,16780.06 we16780.94 are16781.18 a16781.33 democracy.16781.42 And16781.9 in16781.94 our16781.98 democracy,16782.01 we16790.51 strongly16790.75 support16791.31 your16791.79 legislation16792.11 as16792.91 well16793.07 as16793.71 the16794.11 Location16794.27 Shield16794.75 Act16795.07 and,16795.39 really,16795.63 any16796.03 bill16796.08 that16796.13 the16796.18 committee16796.23 puts16796.28 out16796.34 that16796.39 comprehensively16796.44 deals16796.49 with16796.54 these16796.59 issues.16796.83 And16797.08 that16799.72 the16799.78 committee16799.83 puts16799.88 out16799.94 that16799.99 deals16800.85 with16801.08 these16801.24 issues.16801.41 And16801.89 as16802.13 my16802.36 many16802.69 colleagues16803.08 have16803.56 said,16803.72 you16803.89 can16804.04 tell16804.2 our16804.44 message16804.6 discipline16804.93 is16805.41 pretty16805.49 good.16805.72 Right?16805.97 We16806.6 want16806.76 strong16807.56 data16807.89 minimization,16808.2 a16809.17 ban16809.33 on16809.56 the16809.65 sale16809.81 of16809.97 sensitive16810.04 data,16810.52 and16811.08 robust16811.24 enforcement16811.72 through16812.97 a16813.01 private16813.05 right16813.09 of16813.13 action.16813.17 So16813.21 thank16813.45 you16813.53 very16813.69 much,16813.85 and16814.01 thank16814.17 you16814.33 to16814.49 your16814.57 staff16814.65 as16814.89 well.16814.97 Thank16815.13 you.16815.29
16815.45 FARLEY-BOUVIER16815.45 -16815.45 Thank16815.45 you16815.77 for16815.85 your16816.09 strong16816.25 testimony.16816.41 I16816.69 appreciate16817.85 you16817.85 being16818.01 here.16818.25 Are16818.49 there16818.57 any16818.73 comments16819.05 or16820.09 questions16820.41 from16820.89 the16821.05 committee?16821.21 Senator?16821.85
16824.97 MOORE-16824.97 Thank16824.97 you,16825.21 Kate,16825.37 for16825.61 coming16825.69 here.16825.93 I16827.02 was16827.06 actually16827.1 down16827.15 in16827.18 Washington16827.35 last16827.83 week.16827.99 I16828.22 didn't16828.31 see16828.54 you16828.78 this16828.86 time.16829.02 But16830.06 thank16831.1 you16831.26 for16831.43 testifying,16832.22 and16832.86 I16833.5 think16833.58 you16834.38 based16835.5 it16835.74 on16835.74 the16835.91 legislation16836.06 that's16836.54 filed16836.7 where16837.18 the16837.58 like.16837.91 I16838.15 think16838.22 the16838.47 consensus16838.63 opinion16839.18 is16839.58 on16839.83 what16839.99 we16840.15 should16840.31 be16840.47 looking16841.44 at.16841.68 But16843.12 as16843.6 you16844 and16844.32 the16844.96 ACLU16845.2 have16845.84 done16846.08 in16846.32 the16846.48 past,16846.56 you16846.8 know,16846.88 we16847.2 need16847.52 your16847.68 help.16847.92 I16849.2 know16849.36 it's16849.6 not16849.84 gonna16850 be16850.24 to16850.4 the16850.56 gravity16850.72 that16851.2 was16851.36 out16851.52 this16851.76 past16851.92 weekend.16852.88 People16853.2 across16853.44 the16853.76 country16854.48 and16855.12 the16855.36 state,16855.52 but16855.94 we16856.81 need16857.06 to16857.77 get16857.94 this16858.18 legislation16858.42 passed.16859.29 We16859.38 are16859.38 gonna16859.46 need16859.77 a16859.94 grassroots16860.1 effort16860.66 here16861.77 in16862.1 the16862.25 state,16862.42 in16862.9 the16863.29 state16863.46 house,16863.77 to16864.42 help16864.58 us16864.81 achieve16865.14 these16865.7 goals.16865.94 So16867.29 thank16867.7 you.16867.94 And,16868.25 again,16868.74 thank16868.98 you16869.14 for16869.29 coming16869.46 and16869.7 testifying,16869.77 and16870.18 great16871.22 testimony.16871.54
16872.34 FARLEY-BOUVIER-16872.34 Thank16872.34 you,16872.58 Senator.16872.82 Thank16873.86 you16874.1 very16874.34 much.16874.58 Appreciate16874.82 it.16875.3 Thank16875.54 you.16875.7 So,16876.1 it's16876.34 our16876.5 understanding16876.74 that16877.22 James16877.7 O'Keefe16878.02 is16878.82 no16878.98 longer16879.22 with16879.54 us16879.78 here.16879.94 But16880.66 so16880.9 we're16881.06 gonna16881.22 move16881.46 on16881.7 to16881.86 Ryan.16882.1 No.16883.14 Wait16883.22 a16883.38 minute.16883.46 Ariel16883.86 Garcia?16887.1 Here?16887.74
16888.06 SPEAKER1116888.06 -16888.06 Did16888.06 you16888.29
16888.38 SPEAKER2216888.38 -16888.38 say16888.38 Ryan?16888.45
16888.69 SPEAKER116888.69 -16888.69 Oh,16888.69 yeah.16888.77 Ryan.16889.01 Oh,16890.06 sorry.16890.29 We're16890.61 gonna16890.69 do16890.93 First,16891.1 we're16891.33 gonna16891.49 do,16891.74 Ariel16892.06 and16892.61 then16892.85 Ryan.16893.17 Okay?16893.58 Thank16893.9 you.16894.06
16897.01 SPEAKER1616897.01 -16897.01 Okay.16897.01 Alright.16897.17 Thank16897.49 you.16897.57
16897.73 SPEAKER116897.73 -16897.73 There16897.73 you16897.89 go.16898.05
16899.49 ARIELLE16899.49 GARCIA16899.49 -16899.49 CHECK16899.49 MY16899.49 ADS16899.49 INSTITUTES16899.49 -16899.49 SB16899.49 4516899.49 -16899.49 HB16899.49 7816899.49 -16899.49 (16899.49 R16899.49 )16899.49 Chairs16899.49 Moore,16899.97 Farley,16900.45 Bovier,16900.85 and16901.41 members16901.57 of16901.89 the16902.05 committee,16902.21 thank16902.61 you16902.85 for16903.09 the16903.25 opportunity16903.49 to16904.05 testify16904.29 today16904.77 in16905.01 support16905.25 of16905.81 H16905.97 78,16906.21 the16906.77 Massachusetts16906.85 Consumer16907.57 Data16908.05 Privacy16908.37 Act,16908.95 and16909.03 S16909.27 45.16909.43 My16910.08 name16910.24 is16910.4 Arielle16910.63 Garcia.16910.95 I'm16911.43 the16911.75 chief16911.75 operating16912.15 officer16912.63 of16913.11 Check16913.27 My16913.51 Ads16913.75 Institute,16914.15 an16914.95 independent16915.19 nonprofit16915.75 watchdog16916.24 advocating16916.87 for16917.27 a16917.51 transparent16917.67 and16918.15 fair16918.31 digital16918.63 ad16918.95 market.16919.11 Prior16919.92 to16920.24 joining16920.31 Check16920.72 My16920.95 Ads16921.03 in16921.27 2024,16921.35 I16922.15 spent16922.24 a16922.47 decade16922.63 in16922.95 the16923.11 ad16923.19 industry16926.66 at16926.82 UM16926.82 Worldwide,16926.82 a16927.7 global16927.86 ad16928.26 agency.16928.5 I16929.46 resigned16929.7 because16930.18 I16930.58 realized16930.74 that16931.06 the16931.3 only16931.38 winners16931.62 in16932.02 the16932.18 industry16932.34 today16932.82 are16933.22 big16933.38 tech16933.62 giants16933.94 like16934.34 Google16934.5 and16934.82 the16935.06 data16935.22 brokers16935.46 and16935.94 advertising16936.18 technology,16936.82 or16937.46 ad16937.7 tech,16937.86 middlemen16938.1 that16939.03 thrive16939.19 in16939.51 their16939.67 shadows.16939.83 My16940.79 testimony16940.95 today16941.59 will16941.83 challenge16941.99 common16942.47 fallacies16942.72 pushed16943.35 by16943.59 the16943.99 big16944.15 tech16944.56 led16944.87 industry16945.19 lobby.16945.59 The16946.63 $700,000,000,00016946.87 digital16948.4 ad16948.79 industry16949.03 is16949.35 the16949.51 main16949.67 business16949.92 model16950.24 of16950.56 the16950.63 Internet,16950.79 and16951.11 it16951.35 is16951.51 broken.16951.75
16952.31 Firms16952.31 like16952.72 Google16952.87 and16953.27 Meta16953.43 have16953.79 built16954.03 empires16954.27 on16954.83 unchecked16955.07 extraction.16955.63 Their16956.75 power16956.99 has16957.23 set16957.47 norms16957.71 that16958.03 entrench16958.27 their16958.75 power16958.91 while16959.15 har16959.55 harming16959.79 users,16960.27 advertisers,16960.91 and16961.47 publishers.16961.71 At16962.59 the16962.75 heart16962.91 of16963.15 this16963.23 model16963.47 is16963.79 programmatic16963.95 advertising,16964.67 which16965.23 relies16965.47 on16965.87 real-time16966.35 ad16966.83 auctions16967.15 powered16968.11 by16968.51 constant16968.75 tracking.16969.23 Is16969.52 an16970.4 opaque16970.56 and16970.97 unregulated16971.2 system16971.85 isn't16972.33 just16972.56 bad16972.81 for16973.04 privacy,16973.28 it's16973.85 also16974.17 bad16974.56 for16974.89 businesses.16975.13 Only16976.24 36¢16976.56 of16977.6 every16977.85 programmatic16978.17 ad16978.89 dollar16979.13 reaches16979.52 the16979.85 publisher.16980 The16980.81 rest16981.04 goes16981.28 to16981.52 ad16981.76 tech16982 middlemen16982.24 or16982.89 is16983.13 lost16983.28 to16983.6 fraud16983.76 and16984.08 spam.16984.33 Ad16985.41 fraud16985.49 alone16985.89 accounts16986.21 for16986.53 over16986.77 $84,000,000,00016987.09 globally,16988.61 second16989.81 only16990.13 to16990.45 the16990.53 drug16990.69 trade16991.01 as16991.25 a16991.41 source16991.49 of16991.73 revenue16991.81 for16992.21 organized16992.45 crime.16992.93 Now,16993.49 how16993.73 can16993.89 that16994.13 be?16994.29 The16994.85 reality16995.09 is16995.65 that16996.05 the16996.37 consumer16996.53 data16997.01 peddled16997.33 by16997.65 data16997.81 brokers16998.05 for16998.45 ad16998.61 targeting16998.77 is16999.25 shockingly16999.49 inaccurate.17000.05 Research17001.06 has17001.45 shown17001.61 that17001.85 leading17002.1 data17002.42 brokers17002.74 were17003.14 only17003.38 right17003.61 about17003.85 people's17004.18 gender17004.66 42%17005.22 of17006.18 the17006.33 time,17006.42 worse17007.06 than17007.38 guessing17007.61 at17007.94 random.17008.1 This17009.06 is17009.22 what17009.38 advertisers17009.61 are17010.33 paying17010.49 for.17010.74 Acxiom,17011.7 117012.25 of17012.49 the17012.58 largest17012.96 data17013.28 brokers,17013.68 has17014 admitted17014.24 that17014.64 their17014.88 data17015.04 is17015.44 based17015.6 on17015.92 informed17016.24 guesses.17016.72
17017.52 Their17017.52 chief17017.76 privacy17018 officer17018.48 has17018.88 said17019.04 that17019.2 he17019.36 hopes17019.6 that17019.92 if17020.16 they17020.32 guess17020.48 wrong,17020.8 it17021.12 doesn't17021.28 result17021.6 in17022 denial17022.16 of17022.64 benefits17022.72 or17023.2 credit.17023.36 But17024.08 credit17024.24 agencies17024.8 have17025.6 purchased17026 Acxiom17026.74 data.17027.42 A17028.1 different17028.26 data17028.58 broker17028.91 owned17029.22 by17029.47 Ad17029.71 giant17029.86 Publicis17030.26 has17031.31 sold17031.54 data17031.86 to17032.19 the17032.35 perpetrators17032.5 of17033.06 elder17033.22 fraud.17033.63 As17034.58 Attorney17035.47 General17036.1 Campbell17036.1 may17036.58 recall,17036.83 Publicis's17037.22 health17037.95 unit17038.26 in17038.67 202417038.83 entered17039.54 a17039.86 $350,000,00017040.47 settlement17041.75 for17042.23 its17042.39 role17042.63 in17042.79 the17042.87 opioid17043.03 crisis,17043.43 where17044.31 it17044.55 was17044.63 accused17044.87 of17045.35 using17045.59 doctor-patient17046.47 recording17047.11 data17047.59 to17048.39 gain17048.63 insight17048.95 on17049.43 how17049.67 to17049.91 push17049.99 opioids17050.31 on17050.87 pain17051.11 sufferers17051.35 in17051.83 higher17051.99 doses.17052.31 This17053.64 is17053.79 not17054.03 efficiency.17054.27 It's17055.16 a17055.4 dangerous17055.56 market17056.03 failure.17056.35 Without17057.31 privacy17057.72 laws17058.19 that17058.44 codify17058.68 transparency17059.16 and17059.79 choice,17059.95 include17060.27 principles17060.68 of17061.16 data17061.31 minimization,17061.64 and17062.27 restrict17062.51 the17062.99 use17063.08 of17063.31 sensitive17063.47 data,17063.95 these17064.75 harms17065.08 will17065.56 continue.17065.72 To17066.83 close,17066.99 these17067.78 bills17068.02 would17068.42 not17068.66 prevent17068.98 relevant17069.78 advertising.17070.42 What17071.14 they17071.3 would17071.46 do17071.62 is17071.78 reduce17072.02 the17072.34 supply17072.34 of17072.82 low-quality17073.3 and17073.7 harmful17073.94 data17074.34 and17074.74 foster17074.98 a17075.38 system17075.46 that17075.78 works17075.94 better17076.26 for17076.5 both17076.74 Massachusetts17076.98 businesses17078.1 and17079.38 for17079.86 the17080.02 safety17080.19 and17080.5 liberty17080.67 of17080.99 its17081.15 residents.17081.31 Thank17081.71 you17081.95 once17082.1 again17082.35 for17082.58 the17082.75 opportunity17082.91 to17083.54 speak17083.63 today.17083.86
17084.99 FARLEY-BOUVIER17084.99 -17084.99 Sure.17084.99 Thank17085.31 you.17085.54 It's17085.95 a17086.19 whole17086.35 different17086.58 view.17086.91 Members17089.39 of17089.78 the17089.95 committee?17090.02 Thank17091.31 you,17091.54 Ariel.17091.78 We17092.1 really17092.26 do17092.5 appreciate17092.67 your17093.15 testimony.17093.63 Up17094.67 next17094.83 is17095.15 Ryan17095.31 Kearney,17095.68 and17096.64 we17097.36 will17097.52 then17097.76 go17098 back17098.32 online17098.64 to17099.28 Grace17099.6 Geddie.17100.08
17104.4 RYAN17104.4 KEARNEY17104.4 -17104.4 RETAILERS17104.4 ASSOCIATION17104.4 OF17104.4 MASSACHUSETTS17104.4 -17104.4 HB17104.4 8017104.4 -17104.4 SB17104.4 4517104.4 -17104.4 SB17104.4 2917104.4 -17104.4 HB17104.4 10417104.4 -17104.4 Chairwoman17104.4 Follett17104.88 Bouvier,17105.2 Chairman,17105.6 and17106.4 more17106.4 members17106.64 of17106.88 the17106.96 committee,17107.04 thank17107.28 you17107.44 for17107.6 the17107.68 opportunity17107.84 to17108.24 testify17108.32 before17108.69 you17108.89 today.17109.08 For17109.49 the17109.73 record,17109.81 my17110.04 name17110.21 is17110.29 Ryan17110.36 Kearney.17110.6 I17110.93 am17111 the17111.17 general17111.17 counsel17111.49 of17112.13 the17112.21 Retailers17112.28 Association17112.85 of17113.33 Massachusetts.17113.49 We17114.21 are17114.36 a17114.52 statewide17114.76 trade17115.08 association17115.49 of17116.36 4,00017116.6 member17117.08 businesses17117.49 in17117.89 the17118.04 retail17118.21 restaurant17118.6 and17119 wholesale17119.17 sectors17119.65 of17120.13 the17120.21 retail17120.36 industry,17120.6 and17120.93 our17121.08 membership17121.24 ranges17121.73 from17122.04 the17122.28 independent17122.45 over17123 owner17123.24 operated17124.25 business17124.57 that'll17124.81 operate17125.13 in17125.53 every17125.69 single17125.85 117126.17 of17126.33 your,17126.41 districts17126.89 on17127.29 Main17127.45 Street,17127.69 all17128.33 the17128.49 way17128.57 up17128.65 to17128.81 the17128.97 regional17129.21 and17129.69 national17129.93 chains.17130.25 I'm17131.05 here17131.93 today17132.09 to17132.33 testify17132.41 on17132.97 the17133.13 various17133.21 consumer17133.53 data17134.09 privacy17134.41 bills17134.81 before17135.05 you.17135.37 Ran17137.02 as17137.1 in17137.43 support17137.5 of17137.83 house17137.91 8017138.39 and17138.63 senate17138.86 33,17139.26 and17139.99 in17140.15 opposition17140.39 to17140.86 house17141.1 78,17141.35 house17141.83 104,17143.19 Senate17143.58 29,17143.58 and17144.31 Senate17144.54 45.17144.86 By17145.99 way17146.15 of17146.39 background,17146.47 the17147.58 collection17147.75 of17148.06 consumer17148.23 data17148.71 is17149.17 an17149.25 essential17149.49 part17149.73 of17149.97 any17150.13 retail17150.37 business.17150.69 It's17151.17 utilized17151.49 for17151.89 various17152.05 purposes,17152.45 including17152.85 conducting17153.33 sales17153.73 transactions,17154.13 deliveries17154.69 and17155.09 returns,17155.25 detection17155.73 of17156.13 fraud,17156.29 and17156.77 maintenance17157.01 of17157.49 loyalty17157.65 programs.17158.05
17158.69 In17158.69 each17158.85 of17159.09 these17159.17 instances,17159.49 the17159.97 data17160.05 that's17160.37 provided17160.53 by17161.17 the17161.33 consumer17161.49 allows17161.97 for17162.39 more17162.63 efficient17162.78 business17163.18 operations17163.5 and17164.39 a17164.63 more17164.63 positive17164.86 customer17165.26 experience.17165.67 Simply17166.63 stated,17166.94 retailers17167.35 utilize17167.91 consumer17168.54 data17169.02 for17169.5 the17169.67 principal17169.74 purpose17170.22 of17170.54 serving17170.78 their17171.18 customers17171.43 as17171.83 they17172.06 wish17172.15 to17172.39 be17172.47 served.17172.54 In17173.18 speaking17173.43 with17173.74 my17173.99 membership,17174.15 none17175.58 of17175.74 them17175.91 have17176.06 said17176.22 that17176.39 they17176.47 would17176.63 be17176.73 able17176.83 they17177.02 would17177.18 not17177.47 be17177.55 able17177.63 to17177.95 comply17178.59 with17178.83 any17179.63 of17179.87 these17179.95 laws.17180.19 The17180.75 concern17180.91 is17181.39 that17181.55 the17181.71 costs17181.87 and17182.19 obligations17182.43 and17183.07 potential17183.23 liability17183.63 created17184.43 by17184.91 some17185.71 of17185.87 these17186.03 proposals17186.19 will17186.67 interfere17186.91 with17187.23 their17187.39 ability17187.55 to17188.27 continue17188.43 to17188.75 serve17188.91 customers17189.15 in17189.55 the17189.71 manner17189.79 that17190.03 they17190.11 are17190.35 accustomed17190.51 to17190.91 and17191.63 in17191.79 the17192.03 way17192.11 that17192.42 customers17192.58 expect17193.53 them17193.85 to.17193.94 For17194.74 example,17194.97 retail17195.77 loyalty17196.33 and17196.74 discount17196.9 programs,17197.22 which17197.61 are17197.85 widely17197.94 popular17198.33 amongst17198.74 consumers,17199.14 could17199.77 be17200.49 negatively17200.66 impacted.17200.66 72%17201.29 of17202.18 American17203.85 adults17204.18 online17204.49 are17205.1 members17206.7 of17206.94 117207.02 or17207.42 more17207.66 programs,17207.98 with17208.54 the17208.78 average17208.86 adult17209.18 belonging17209.42 to17209.82 917209.98 of17210.14 these17210.22 programs.17210.46
17211.5 They17211.5 rely17211.82 on17212.38 the17212.54 retailer's17212.62 ability17213.18 to17213.58 provide17213.74 exclusive17214.3 offers17214.86 to17215.18 voluntary17215.34 participants17215.82 versus17216.7 nonparticipants,17217.34 and17218.3 where17218.46 non17218.62 participate17218.94 non-participation17219.5 is17220.17 a17220.33 result17220.42 of17220.65 a17220.9 consumer17221.13 exercising17221.53 a17222.01 right17222.17 afforded17222.49 to17222.81 the17222.97 consumer17223.05 by17223.45 privacy17223.45 law.17224.13 There's17224.81 an17225.13 inherent17225.29 compliance17225.85 conflict17226.33 when17227.61 nondiscrimination17227.85 provisions17228.74 are17229.29 included.17229.45 To17230.42 allow17230.57 for17230.81 the17230.97 continued17231.13 offer17231.85 of17232.09 these17232.17 programs,17232.42 any17232.9 proposal17233.13 that17233.85 is17234.01 adopted17234.17 by17234.57 this17234.74 committee17234.9 or17235.29 referred17235.88 favorably17236.12 by17236.68 the17236.76 committees17236.84 should17237.72 make17237.96 clear17238.12 that17238.44 nondiscrimination17238.84 provisions17239.72 should17240.52 not17240.68 be17240.84 interpreted17241 to17241.48 prohibit,17241.56 restrict,17242.04 or17242.68 limit17242.84 the17243.16 ability17243.24 of17243.56 retailers17243.72 to17244.2 maintain17244.36 these17245 bona17245.24 fide17245.56 loyalty17245.8 programs.17246.36 I'd17247.32 be17247.48 happy17247.56 to17247.8 work17247.88 with17248.04 the17248.2 committee17248.28 to17248.6 make17248.76 sure17248.92 that17249.08 language17250.65 is,17250.9 in17250.9 fact,17250.97 where17251.29 it17251.61 needs17251.77 to17251.93 be17252.01 to17252.25 do17252.97 so.17253.13 It's17254.17 been17254.42 mentioned17254.65 before,17255.05 the17257.05 about17257.13 uniformity17257.53 of17258.09 laws.17258.17 RAM17258.49 does17258.81 believe17258.97 that17259.22 regulation17259.37 and17259.85 collection17259.93 of17260.25 consumer17260.57 data17261.05 privacy17261.29 should17261.85 be17261.93 dealt17262.01 with17262.25 in17262.42 a17262.49 uniform17262.57 manner17262.97 across17265.31 the17265.32 country.17265.33
17265.35 This17265.35 would17265.35 not17265.36 only17265.37 ease17265.38 compliance17265.39 but17265.95 also17266.11 provide17266.43 equitable17266.75 protections17267.23 and17268.03 rights17268.19 for17268.83 all17268.99 consumers17269.23 across17269.71 the17270.03 country.17270.11 With17270.83 2017270.99 states17271.95 already17272.43 having17272.99 laws17273.31 in17273.71 place,17273.87 Massachusetts,17274.11 should17275.63 be17275.87 looking17275.95 for17276.19 an17276.51 to17276.83 should17277.55 be17277.79 looking17277.87 to17278.11 the17278.27 emerging17279.6 body17280.24 of17280.97 state17281.13 law17281.36 for17281.69 guidance17281.93 rather17282.41 than17282.65 crafting17282.81 its17283.13 unique17283.45 framework,17283.69 which17284.17 would17284.24 come17284.41 with17284.56 additional17284.73 costs17285.13 for17286.73 compliance.17286.89 In17287.69 today's17287.76 economy,17288.33 businesses17289.6 are17290.08 rapidly17290.17 connected17290.56 across17291.04 state17291.36 lines,17291.93 in17292.33 particular17292.49 here17292.97 in17293.13 New17293.28 England,17295.76 due17295.76 to17295.79 our17295.82 close17295.86 geographic,17295.89 high-level17296.32 mobility17296.8 concerns,17297.44 that17298.32 it17298.64 would17298.72 make17298.96 for17299.12 more17299.44 streamlined,17299.6 and17301.04 expectation17301.76 from17302.32 the17302.48 consumers.17302.64 Remaining17303.76 in17304.16 line17304.24 with17304.48 state17304.64 law,17304.88 particularly17305.28 those17305.76 adopted17306 in17306.4 every17306.48 state,17306.8 would17307.12 provide,17307.28 again,17307.68 that17307.92 uniform17308.16 expectation17309.72 locally17310.67 and,17311.15 again,17311.31 needs17311.72 compliance.17311.95 We,17312.51 therefore,17313.55 post17313.55 '8017313.87 and17314.03 Senate17314.27 3317314.51 as17315.15 they17315.31 are17315.47 modeled17315.55 again,17315.87 adopting17316.99 a17317.4 growing17317.55 number17317.79 of17317.95 states17318.03 across17318.35 the17318.59 country,17318.75 including17319.24 various17319.55 states17319.87 here17320.11 in17320.27 New17320.43 England.17320.51 I'm17321.24 happy17321.55 to17321.79 work17321.95 with17322.11 the17322.19 committee17322.27 over17322.75 the17322.88 course17322.99 of17323.31 this17323.4 session17323.55 to17324.44 use17324.52 language,17324.68 in17325.4 a17325.56 way17325.64 that17325.8 it17325.88 would17325.96 be,17326.2 you17326.36 know,17327.32 create17327.56 their17327.8 rights17328.04 and17328.52 protections17329.24 that17329.56 we're17329.8 looking17329.96 for,17330.12 but17330.44 also,17330.68 having17331.88 to17332.28 interfere17332.44 with17332.84 operations17333 and17333.48 also17333.64 with17333.96 the17334.04 people17334.12 in17334.36 Wisconsin,17334.52 Massachusetts17334.92 businesses.17336.04
17337.42 FARLEY-BOUVIER17337.42 -17337.42 That's17337.42 terrific.17337.67 And17337.99 I17338.15 would17338.22 very17338.39 much17338.54 look17338.86 forward17339.02 to17339.35 working17339.5 directly17340.22 with17340.63 you17340.78 on17341.1 language17341.35 to17342.47 ensure17342.7 that17343.18 your17343.9 members,17344.22 particularly,17345.02 again,17345.58 I'm17345.83 gonna17345.99 focus17346.22 on17346.54 small17346.7 business,17347.02 true17348.06 small17348.47 business.17348.78 Understood.17349.94 Yeah.17350.58 We17350.9 heard,17351.14 a17352.02 lot17352.1 of17352.34 testimony17352.42 earlier17353.14 that17353.78 talked17354.02 about,17354.26 for17355.38 example,17355.62 age17356.1 7817356.34 being17357.22 good17357.46 for17357.7 small17357.94 business,17358.18 because17359.54 the17360.34 big17360.58 data17360.98 folks17361.7 are17362.67 hoovering17362.74 up,17363.39 you17363.71 know,17363.95 both17364.35 consumer17364.74 data,17365.22 harming17366.35 small17366.83 business,17366.99 but17367.39 also17367.54 the17367.86 small17368.1 business17368.43 data17368.83 that17369.31 can17369.47 get17369.71 you17370.1 know,17370.19 take17370.5 business17370.74 away17371.06 from17372.02 them.17372.19 So17372.5 I'd17372.99 like17373.22 your17373.78 reaction17374.02 to17374.58 that17374.74 and17375.63 how,17375.95 again,17376.44 you17377.64 know,17377.8 you17377.96 have17378.12 a17378.36 responsibility17378.44 to17379 your17379.16 members,17379.4 including17379.8 those17380.28 of17380.6 the17380.76 true17380.92 small17381.16 business.17381.4
KEARNEY17382.28 -17382.28 Sure.17382.28 So17382.68 I17384.2 will17384.36 echo17384.52 the17385.16 sentiments17385.4 that17385.8 you17386.04 heard17386.12 from17386.28 the17386.52 gentleman17386.68 in17387 the17387.16 name.17387.24 We17387.48 believe17387.64 that17388.28 House17388.44 8017388.68 and17388.92 Senate17389.08 3317389.4 do17389.96 protect,17390.2 small17390.84 businesses.17391.16 117392.04 thing17392.25 that17392.49 you're17392.65 going17392.9 to17393.22 hear,17393.29 whether17393.53 it's17393.77 small17393.85 business17394.01 or17394.33 large17394.49 businesses17394.74 from17395.22 our17395.38 association17395.61 throughout17396.9 this17397.22 session,17397.53 is17398.33 that,17398.49 there's17399.38 a17399.61 focus17399.77 in17400.01 the17400.17 Haley17401.45 administration17401.77 and17402.33 in17402.49 from17402.58 this17402.81 legislature17402.97 competitive17403.53 in17404.61 competitiveness17404.85 here17405.41 in17405.65 Massachusetts.17405.81 And17406.85 whether17407.17 it's17407.49 this17407.73 or17408.05 any17408.21 other17408.37 law,17408.61 we're17408.85 gonna17409.01 ask17409.33 you17409.49 all17409.65 to17409.81 take17410.05 a17410.37 look17410.45 through17411.17 look17411.33 at17411.49 these17411.65 legislations17411.97 that17412.37 you're17412.53 passing17412.69 through17412.93 the17413.17 lens17413.25 of17413.57 cost17413.73 compliance17413.97 and17414.37 what's17414.53 is17414.85 gonna17414.93 happen17415.17 what17415.49 what17415.65 would17415.89 potentially17416.13 happen,17416.53 once17418.04 you17418.36 implement17418.52 these17418.92 things.17419.17 On17419.49 this17419.65 issue17419.81 in17420.12 particular,17420.28 our17420.76 concern17420.92 is17421.33 that17421.49 if17421.81 you17422.04 create17422.12 a17422.52 Massachusetts-only,17425.56 that's17425.88 then17426.12 have17426.28 to17426.44 be17426.6 replicated,17426.68 there's17427.33 really17427.65 217427.97 ways17428.04 to17428.28 for17428.6 compliance,17428.85 which17429.17 have17429.4 already17429.56 been17429.81 been17430.06 mentioned.17430.22
17430.62 You17430.62 create17430.86 your17431.1 own17431.26 compliance17431.58 framework17431.98 here17432.3 in17432.46 Massachusetts,17432.54 which17433.1 is17433.26 gonna17433.34 cost17433.58 additional17434.06 dollars17434.46 and17434.7 not17434.86 just17435.1 copy-paste17435.82 what17435.98 you17436.06 see17436.22 in17436.3 other17436.38 states.17436.7 Or17437.34 you17437.74 take17437.98 all17438.22 those17438.38 2017438.54 states17438.86 that17439.1 you've17439.18 made17439.42 investments17439.58 in17440.06 already,17440.22 and17440.7 you17440.86 tie17441.02 them17441.26 up17441.42 to17441.58 the17441.66 Massachusetts17441.82 standard.17442.38 You17442.94 can17443.02 do17443.18 that.17443.34 And17443.58 that's17443.82 that's17444.1 perfectly17444.33 fine.17444.58 And17444.97 I'm17445.06 assuming17445.38 from17446.01 my17446.33 conversation,17446.58 my17446.97 members17447.38 would17447.53 be17447.7 able17447.77 to17447.94 comply17448.1 with17448.25 that.17448.33 It17448.49 may17448.66 cost17448.9 it17449.22 cost17449.38 them17449.61 additional17449.77 dollars,17450.01 but17450.18 you17450.33 have17450.42 to17450.58 be17450.66 aware17450.74 that17450.97 those17451.14 additional17451.29 dollars17451.7 come17451.94 in17452.18 and17452.58 are17452.74 seen17452.9 as17453.22 a17453.46 mandated17453.77 cost17454.33 to17455.22 businesses17455.46 in17456.27 a17456.43 state17456.51 that's17456.83 already17457.15 pretty17457.87 much17458.11 known17458.43 for17458.75 having17458.91 a17459.23 high17459.31 cost17459.47 of17459.71 doing17459.95 business17460.19 in17460.59 the17460.67 country.17460.83
17462.19 FARLEY-BOUVIER-17462.19 Okay.17462.19 You17462.91 mentioned,17463.07 you17464.11 mentioned,17464.27 other17465.07 states17465.39 including17465.71 especially17466.19 this17466.67 New17466.99 England17467.23 like17467.87 a17468.11 New17468.19 England17468.35 model.17468.75 You17470.03 aware17470.27 of17470.81 the17470.9 work17471.06 that's17471.22 been17471.61 done17471.69 in17471.93 Connecticut.17472.1 A17472.81 few17472.97 years17473.22 ago,17473.45 they17473.69 started17473.93 what17474.58 I17474.81 call17474.97 Connecticut17475.29 2.17475.77 They17476.49 made17476.74 immediate17477.13 changes17477.93 to17479.13 that17479.29 to17479.93 update17480.01 it.17480.33 And17480.81 now17481.06 the17481.29 lead17481.45 sponsor,17481.77 who17482.17 is17482.25 a17482.49 national17482.65 figure17483.77 now17484.1 in17484.58 this17484.74 space,17484.97 is17485.66 updating17485.9 his17486.7 laws.17487.1 And17487.98 quite17488.3 frankly,17488.54 it17489.58 almost17489.66 mirrors17490.06 age17490.54 78.17490.78
17491.58 KEARNEY17491.58 -17491.58 Sure.17491.58 I17492.22 understand17492.7 that17493.02 there17493.18 have17493.26 been17493.5 updates,17493.58 but17493.9 there's17494.06 also17494.3 been17494.62 217494.78 other17494.94 states17495.1 in17495.42 the17495.5 New17495.66 England17495.82 region17496.06 that17496.38 have17496.54 adopted17496.7 that17497.02 original17497.26 Connecticut17497.9 117498.54 of17499.42 model.17499.66 And17499.98 so17500.14 again,17500.38 to,17502.43 you17502.83 know,17502.99 I17503.24 think17503.4 you17503.55 and17503.79 I17503.87 have17504.03 had17504.19 a17504.35 conversation17504.43 when17504.83 we17504.99 first17505.07 had17505.31 this17505.47 conversation.17505.63 It17506.03 was17506.11 your17506.75 trip17506.92 to17507.15 England17507.4 that17507.72 you17507.79 had17507.87 mentioned.17508.19 How17508.35 confusing17508.35 it17508.55 was,17508.75 whether17508.92 I17509.15 opt17509.24 in,17509.4 whether17509.55 I17509.79 opt17509.87 out.17510.03 We17510.35 don't17510.51 want17510.67 that17510.83 in17511.07 our17511.11 system.17511.15 Despite17512.27 what17512.75 some17512.99 folks17513.24 may17513.47 think17513.63 of17513.95 the17514.03 retail17514.11 industry,17514.51 our17515.55 consumers17515.72 are17516.27 117516.59 of17516.83 our17516.92 top17517.07 assets,17517.19 if17517.51 not17517.67 the17517.91 top17518.07 asset.17518.23 Without17518.55 them,17518.79 we17519.11 don't17520.71 exist.17520.87 And17521.59 so17521.83 to17522.23 be17522.63 able17522.79 to17523.03 allow17523.27 them17523.51 to17523.75 go17523.83 to17523.99 New17524.15 Hampshire,17524.31 Massachusetts,17524.79 Connecticut,17525.51 and17525.91 the17526.07 New17526.15 England17526.31 region,17526.55 and17526.87 get17527.11 the17527.35 same17527.51 expectation17527.75 of17528.23 privacy17528.39 and17528.79 the17528.95 same17529.03 rights,17529.27 across17530.04 the17530.28 board17530.44 is17530.76 important17531.17 to17531.49 us.17531.65 And17531.72 I17531.89 think17531.97 it's17532.13 something17532.2 that17532.44 we17532.6 support.17532.76 But17533.72 again,17533.89 we17534.2 don't17534.36 we17535.17 do17535.24 not17535.49 see17535.72 the17536.13 need,17536.52 nor17536.85 do17537.08 we17537.24 want17537.41 to17538.52 kind17538.68 of17538.93 reinvent17539.17 the17539.56 wheel17539.65 on17539.97 this17540.04 issue17540.68 when17541.17 it's17541.33 already17541.56 been17541.89 kind17542.2 of17542.36 litigated17542.68 throughout17543.33 2017544.07 states17544.39 already.17544.55 And17544.95 so,17545.11 again,17545.35 I'm17545.67 happy17545.91 to17546.15 work17546.23 with17546.39 you17546.55 on17546.63 7817546.79 and17547.19 Yeah.17547.43 Perfecting17547.67 that.17548.07 But17548.71 there's17548.87 a17549.03 concern17549.19 there.17549.91
17550.07 And17550.07 again,17550.39 folks17550.79 have17551.03 mentioned17551.91 it.17552.31 Those17552.71 concerns17553.03 are17553.43 exacerbated17553.59 when17554.15 you17554.39 have17554.47 a17554.59 private17554.71 interaction.17555.19 And17555.51 that's17555.67 117555.91 thing17556.07 I17556.23 will17556.55 mention.17556.71 You17557.46 you17557.61 you17557.98 you17558.33 asked17558.58 me17558.81 about17558.98 small17559.14 businesses.17559.38 The17560.74 plaintiff's17561.14 bar,17561.77 if17562.81 they17562.98 do17563.14 start17563.46 creating17563.85 these17564.33 niche17564.66 industries17564.98 to17565.46 go17565.61 after17565.77 these17566.01 things,17566.18 and17566.42 we've17566.58 seen17566.74 them17566.9 whether17567.14 it's17567.46 in17567.7 our,17568.01 ADA17568.74 web,17569.22 webchester17569.85 laws,17570.41 whether17570.65 it's17570.89 our17571.05 Wire17571.21 Act17571.45 and17571.93 some17572.17 of17572.33 the17572.41 software17572.65 that17572.97 people17573.13 use,17573.37 online,17574.17 or17574.81 it's,17575.05 the17575.45 lie17575.61 detector,17575.85 requirement17576.57 in17577.05 job17577.21 applications.17577.45 There17578.09 are17578.33 plaintiff's17578.49 attorneys17578.97 that17579.29 will17579.45 go17579.69 out17579.93 and17580.09 start17580.25 filing17580.97 lawsuits17581.37 on17581.85 anybody17582.01 and17582.33 everybody17582.49 that17582.89 they17583.05 possibly17583.21 can.17583.53 And17583.77 the17583.85 calls17584.1 that17584.26 I17584.43 get17584.75 are17585.06 not17585.23 from17585.39 my17585.63 big17585.78 guys.17585.86 They're17586.1 I'm17586.35 getting17586.58 calls17586.83 from17587.15 the17587.47 Inn17587.54 on17587.71 the17587.86 Cape.17587.95 I'm17588.58 getting17588.74 the17588.99 call17589.15 from17589.39 the17589.63 single17589.86 operator17590.19 on17590.67 Main17590.91 Street17591.15 who17591.54 has17591.86 been17592.02 hit17592.19 with17592.35 a17592.5 lawsuit17592.67 and17593.15 now17593.39 has17593.54 to17593.71 hire17593.86 an17594.1 attorney17594.26 and17594.67 spend17594.91 10,00017595.15 to17595.71 2017595.86 thousand17596.19 dollars17596.43 just17596.91 to17597.06 prove17597.23 that17597.47 this17597.54 is17597.71 a17597.86 frivolous17597.95 lawsuit.17598.35 And17599.07 when17599.15 you17599.39 include17599.55 the17600.03 level17600.43 of17600.75 statutory,17600.99 statutory17603.23 penalties17603.79 like17604.59 this17604.83 law,17604.99 the17605.71 concern17605.87 is17606.19 that17606.43 it17606.67 makes17606.83 it17607.15 more17607.15 appetizing17607.39 for17607.95 someone17608.11 to17608.35 come17608.43 here17608.59 and17608.75 do17608.83 it17608.91 here17608.99 in17609.07 Massachusetts17609.31 than17609.79 they17609.95 would17610.03 in17610.19 other17610.35 places.17610.59 So17610.91 that's17610.99 those17611.4 are17611.64 the17611.72 concerns17611.79 that17612.19 we17612.27 have.17612.44
FARLEY-BOUVIER17612.92 -17612.92 Sure.17612.92 So17613.47 I17613.88 wanna17614.03 make17614.27 a17614.44 correction,17614.51 and17615.24 then,17615.47 and17616.11 then17616.35 note17617.08 something.17617.31 When17618.83 I17619.08 gave17619.16 you17619.4 that17619.56 story17619.79 about17620.27 Scotland17620.6 a17621.64 year17621.72 or17621.95 217622.03 ago,17622.19 I17622.6 was17622.75 delighted17623.16 that17624.11 they17624.19 were17624.44 asking17626.16 for17626.16 those.17626.24 Because17627.04 I17627.24 was17627.44 like,17627.6 look17627.76 at17628 this17628.16 really17628.4 works.17628.72 You17629.36 know?17629.52 And17629.68 I17629.84 thought17629.92 that17630.16 was17630.24 terrific.17630.48 And17631.04 it17631.28 was17631.36 a17631.52 way17631.6 that17631.76 was17631.92 easy17632.16 for17632.56 me,17632.72 the17632.96 consumer,17633.12 to17633.68 use.17634.96
17635.28 KEARNEY17635.28 -17635.28 Right.17635.28 And17635.52 it's17635.68 my17635.84 concern17636 is17636.32 if17636.56 you17637.04 went17637.2 from17637.36 Ireland17637.76 into17638.32 Mainland17638.8 Europe,17639.2 and17639.44 then17639.6 you17639.76 came17639.84 back17640 to17640.79 the17641.43 United17641.51 States,17641.83 you're17642.08 gonna17642.24 have17642.4 a17642.47 different17642.56 standard17642.87 in17643.19 each17643.27 place.17643.43 And17644.08 I17644.31 guess17644.4 you17644.56 can17644.63 expect17644.79 that17645.03 when17645.19 you're17645.35 going17645.51 crossing,17645.75 you17646.24 know,17646.31 country17646.63 lines.17646.87 But17647.19 when17647.35 you're17647.43 going17648.08 from,17648.31 I17648.72 mean,17648.79 we17648.95 have17649.11 folks17649.35 that17649.67 are17649.83 coming17649.99 from17650.24 Massachusetts17650.4 into17651.03 New17651.35 Hampshire17651.43 and17651.83 back17652.24 on17652.56 a17652.79 daily17652.99 basis17653.26 and17653.5 all17653.66 the17653.9 other17654.06 617654.14 New17654.38 England17654.54 states.17654.78 And17655.26 so17655.42 to17655.74 not17656.06 have17656.3 that17656.54 bright17657.18 line17657.34 test.17658.26 I17658.7 think17658.86 this17659.34 is17659.5 a17659.58 concern.17659.66
17660.94 FARLEY-BOUVIER17660.94 -17660.94 And17660.94 then17661.1 the17661.34 other17661.5 thing,17661.74 and17661.98 I17662.14 promise,17662.46 I17662.86 know17663.02 you're17663.18 anxious17663.34 too,17663.74 senator,17664.22 my17664.7 partner17664.94 here.17665.26 The17667.4 thresholds17667.72 within17668.51 h17668.99 7817669.24 talk17670.6 about17670.92 the17671.16 private17671.31 right17671.64 of17671.88 action17671.95 does17672.35 not17672.6 apply17672.83 I'm17673.56 sorry.17673.72 To17674.11 the17674.35 we17674.75 have17674.99 a17675.16 threshold17675.31 standard17676.27 so17676.99 that17677.24 the17677.47 true17678.11 small17678.43 business,17678.75 the17679.08 in17679.24 on17679.4 the17679.47 cape.17679.64 Right,17680.33 they're17680.49 they17680.89 are17681.13 not17681.29 subject17681.45 to17681.85 the17681.93 private17682.09 right17682.33 of17682.49 action.17682.65
KEARNEY17682.97 -17682.97 Right.17682.97 So17683.21 my17683.45 concern17683.61 is17684.17 that17684.33 the17684.65 plaintiff's17684.97 bar17685.53 will17686.49 not17686.73 show17688.01 discretion17688.33 as17688.97 to17689.13 whether17689.29 or17689.45 not17689.61 someone17689.77 is17690.17 above17690.17 or17690.41 below17690.57 that17691.05 threshold.17691.29 And17691.77 so17692.01 small17692.41 businesses17692.65 may17693.13 get17693.29 hit17693.53 with17693.61 a17693.77 demand17693.93 letter,17694.33 and17695.05 then17695.21 their17695.37 only17695.61 frivolous17701.99 lawsuit17702.22 thrown17702.54 out,17703.1 or17703.19 just17703.26 to17703.35 prove17703.43 to17703.83 the17703.9 court17703.99 that,17704.39 hey,17704.54 I'm17704.7 under17704.78 the17705.1 threshold.17705.26 I17705.83 should17705.91 not17706.06 be17706.31 called17706.54 into17706.78 this.17707.02 Whereas17707.26 the17707.58 attorney17707.74 general17708.06 is17708.83 office17708.91 or17709.31 a17709.55 dedicated17709.79 government17710.67 entity17711.07 to17711.55 enforcement17711.87 mechanism17712.35 would17713.39 be17713.71 able17713.87 and17714.27 would17714.43 probably17714.75 be17715.23 like17715.47 more17715.79 likely17715.95 to17716.35 use17716.51 that17716.75 discretion17716.91 and17717.31 say,17717.47 hey.17717.63 Wait17717.79 a17717.95 second.17718.03 This17718.51 doesn't17718.67 have17718.99 to17719.07 go17719.15 forward.17719.31 We17719.63 don't17719.79 need17719.87 anybody17720.11 spending17720.43 all17720.75 this17721.49 money17721.72 out17722.04 of17722.21 their17722.28 pot17722.36 of17722.49 pocket17722.6 for17722.93 a17723.04 small17723.17 business.17723.41
17724.52 FARLEY-BOUVIER17724.52 -17724.52 Thank17724.52 you17724.76 for17724.85 clarifying,17725 Senator.17725.49 Thanks17725.97 for17726.28 your17726.45 patience,17726.52 too.17727
17728.13 MOORE17728.13 -17728.13 Thank17728.13 you.17728.36 So17729.72 you17730.04 referenced17730.21 the17730.52 economic17730.69 development17731.17 bill17731.49 development17732.13 bill17732.6 in17732.85 how17733.08 Massachusetts17733.33 117734.13 of17734.28 the17734.36 goal17734.52 from17734.76 the17734.93 legislature17735 and17735.49 the17735.65 governor's17735.81 office17736.21 is17738.66 to17738.74 make17738.82 Massachusetts,17738.9 more17739.06 attractive17739.22 to17740.5 industry17740.66 in17741.22 bringing,17741.38 more17742.18 competitive.17742.42 More17742.9 competitive.17743.06
17743.54 KEARNEY17743.54 -17743.54 Yeah.17743.54
17743.86 MOORE17743.86 -17743.86 Alright.17743.86 The17745.62 question17745.78 has17746.18 been17746.34 asked17746.5 about17747.78 the17748.1 privacy17748.26 bills,17749.54 and17750.03 there17750.03 were17750.19 2017750.43 other17750.75 states17750.99 that17751.24 have17751.47 actually17751.64 enacted17751.95 legislation17752.43 regarding17753.88 this.17754.27 We've17755.24 had17755.56 no17755.79 data17756.03 presented17756.43 to17756.83 us,17756.99 and17757.4 no17757.56 one's17757.79 come17758.03 to17758.27 us17758.35 that17758.6 how17758.83 these17759.31 states17759.56 have17759.88 been17760.03 hurt17760.27 by17761.08 the17761.24 passage17761.4 of17761.79 these,17761.95 data17763.16 privacy.17763.56 So17764.11 what17764.35 what17764.6 hold17764.99 on.17765.24 Okay.17765.47 So17766.17 we've17766.41 had17766.49 no17766.73 data17767.29 come17767.85 forward17768.09 on17768.33 that.17768.49 The17769.53 legislation17770.09 on17771.21 data17771.61 minimization17771.93 allows17772.81 businesses,17773.53 even17774.17 small17774.41 businesses,17774.73 to17775.61 collect17775.85 the17776.25 data17776.41 necessary.17776.89 So17778.72 and17778.95 I'm17779.43 just17779.67 gonna17779.83 talk17780.08 Senate17780.31 45.17780.72 Senate17782.15 4517782.63 clearly17783.35 has17783.83 an17784.15 exemption17784.4 for17786.08 what17786.87 you've17787.11 talked17787.35 about17787.6 for17787.92 loyalty,17788.15 bona17788.95 fide17789.27 loyalty17789.6 rewards,17790.15 rewards,17790.87 premium17791.51 features,17792.08 discounts,17793.04 club17793.76 cards,17794 and17795.12 club17795.12 card17795.44 programs.17795.84 So,17796.8 you're17800.24 advocating17800.4 against17801.2 certain17802.08 bills.17802.4 But17803.44 all's17803.76 I17804 guess,17804.08 all's17804.32 I'm17804.56 gonna17804.72 be17804.88 asked17804.96 for17805.2 is17805.36 that17805.44 when17805.6 you're17805.76 advocating17805.92 for17806.48 these17806.64 that17806.96 don't17807.82 distort17808.86 the17809.18 bills17809.34 or17809.99 the17810.22 legislation17810.38 that.17811.67
KEARNEY17811.67 -17811.67 I17812.3 apologize17812.47 if17813.02 I17813.18 gave17813.26 any17813.5 distortion17813.74 as17814.06 to17814.22 what17814.3 was17814.47 going17814.54 on.17814.78
17815.42 MOORE17815.42 -17815.42 Well,17815.42 you17815.42 clearly17815.58 equally17815.82 said17816.22 that17816.38 this17816.54 that17816.62 was17816.78 an17816.94 issue17817.02 with17817.26 the17817.42 bills17817.5 that17817.82 that17818.06 you17818.3 your17818.62 your17818.94 members17819.34 have17819.82 this17819.99 issue17820.22 with17821.5 the17821.67 loyalty17821.82 reward17822.3 cards17822.78 and17823.09 the17823.25 loyalty17823.41 programs17823.89 that17824.21 that17824.45 could17824.61 subject17824.77 them17825.09 to17825.33 litigation.17825.73 So17826.85 that's17828.13 all17828.37 if17829.01 to17831.09 make17831.33 the17831.49 act17831.65 I17831.81 guess,17831.97 to17832.21 make17832.29 the17832.45 accusation17832.61 or17833.25 or17833.89 inference17833.97 that17834.77 we17835.01 are17835.17 here17835.33 trying17835.97 we17836.37 are17836.45 not17836.69 looking17837.47 at17837.79 benefiting17838.03 our17838.59 small17838.83 businesses17839.07 or17839.87 the17840.11 members17840.19 of17840.59 your17840.67 association.17840.99 This17842.27 legislation,17842.51 we17843.15 unless17843.47 you17843.87 can17844.03 produce17844.19 some17844.59 data17844.75 showing17845.55 that17845.79 California,17846.35 Maryland,17846.99 Virginia,17847.79 all17848.35 these17848.51 other17848.75 states17848.99 that17849.24 have17849.4 passed17849.63 this17850.35 from17850.67 with17850.99 any17851.31 sort17851.55 of17851.72 right17851.87 of17852.11 action17852.19 to17852.59 a17852.67 limited17852.83 right17853.15 of17853.37 action,17853.74 that17854.11 there's17854.48 been17854.85 a17855.22 detriment17855.59 to17855.96 their17856.33 economy,17856.7 then17857.07 I17857.44 don't17858.18 think17858.56 it's17858.93 fair17859.67 to17860.04 be17860.41 saying17860.78 that17861.15 this17861.52 legislation17861.89 is17862.26 going17862.63 to17863 hurt17863.37 or17863.74 make17864.11 out17864.48 Massachusetts17864.85 not17865.22 competitive.17865.59
KEARNEY17865.96 -17865.96 So17865.96 I17866.33 apologize17866.7 if17867.07 that17867.44 was17867.81 not17868.18 clear.17868.55 There17869.49 is17869.8 a17869.88 cost17870.04 associated17870.36 with17870.92 implementing17871.17 this17871.65 program17871.8 or17872.52 implementing17872.76 any17873.24 framework17873.4 whatsoever.17873.97 Right.17874.68 If17875.08 you17875.24 have17875.4 to17875.56 implement17875.65 a17876.2 Massachusetts-only17877.17 framework,17878.12 that's17878.76 gonna17879.08 be17879.32 more17879.88 expensive17880.12 than17880.84 if17881 you17881.17 were17881.32 able17881.49 to17881.66 just17881.74 take17881.9 what17882.06 you've17882.14 already17882.3 built17882.7 in17883.02 2017883.18 other17883.5 states17883.66 and17884.54 put17884.7 it17884.94 onto17885.02 the17885.26 Massachusetts17885.42 chassis.17886.06 In17887.02 addition,17887.18 there's17887.66 an17887.98 ongoing17888.22 cost17888.7 that17889.5 would17889.66 be17889.9 created17890.38 by17891.02 a17891.34 private17891.9 right17892.3 of17892.46 action17892.62 that17893.9 could17894.14 result17894.46 in17895.02 multiple17895.72 violations,17896.11 multiple17896.67 claims17896.99 that17897.24 and17897.63 that's17897.72 the17898.03 ongoing17898.19 cost17898.51 that17898.75 the17898.92 industry17898.99 will17899.31 have17899.56 to17899.72 bear17899.87 in17900.51 order17900.67 to17900.92 comply17900.99 with17901.31 the17901.63 complexity17901.79 of17902.03 these17902.27 laws.17902.51
17902.67 MOORE17902.67 -17902.67 But17902.67 shouldn't17902.83 the17903.08 consumer17903.31 have17904.11 or17904.43 have17904.67 a17904.83 right17904.99 to17905.15 expect17905.31 the17906.03 business17906.99 that17907.4 they're17907.56 dealing17907.79 with17908.03 to17908.6 comply17908.83 with17909.31 the17909.63 law17909.79 and17910.03 comply17910.19 with17910.6 not17911.08 everyone17911.5 has17911.74 a17911.82 right.17911.9 It's17912.22 been17912.38 talked17912.54 about17912.78 all17913.02 day,17913.18 but17913.34 the17913.5 right17913.66 of17913.82 privacy,17913.9 the17914.38 right17914.46 of17914.62 your17914.7 personal17914.86 information.17915.74 Not17916.22 being17916.38 sold17916.62 on17917.02 these17917.18 issues.17917.34
17917.66 KEARNEY17917.66 -17917.66 And17917.66 at17917.82 the17917.9 outset17917.98 of17918.3 my17918.46 testimony,17918.7 I17919.34 indicated17919.5 that17919.98 all17920.22 of17920.34 my17920.46 members17920.62 have17921.26 indicated17921.5 that17921.9 they17922.06 will17922.22 comply17922.46 with17922.78 and17923.02 can17923.26 comply17923.42 with17923.82 whatever17924.31 framework17924.54 you17924.94 throw17925.1 at17925.35 them.17925.5 But17926.15 to17926.39 have17926.54 a17926.7 Massachusetts17926.94 law17927.67 that17928.15 is17928.39 gonna17928.54 cost17928.86 them17929.1 more17929.35 is17930.06 going17930.31 to17930.63 impact17930.86 its17932.94 mandated17933.58 operating17934.22 cost17934.86 on17935.43 the17935.67 business.17935.83
17936.98 SPEAKER1117936.98 -17936.98 And17936.98 it17937.06
17937.14 SPEAKER1217937.14 -17937.14 says17937.14 but17937.38 Elevated.17937.62
17938.34 MOORE17938.34 -17938.34 But17938.34 there's17938.5 plenty17938.74 of17938.98 laws17939.06 that17939.3 Massachusetts17939.38 has17940.1 that's17940.34 different17940.42 from17940.74 other17940.9 states.17941.06
17941.3 KEARNEY-17941.3 Of17941.3 course17941.38 there17941.62 of17941.78 course17941.94 there17942.1 is.17942.26 And17942.5 what17943.22 our17943.46 industry17943.7 and17944.02 what17944.18 our17944.42 we17944.82 the17945.38 research17945.86 that17946.26 we've17946.42 done17946.66 on17946.98 in17947.86 general,17948.02 on17948.42 business17948.66 climate17948.98 in17949.3 Massachusetts17949.46 is17950.02 that17950.1 Massachusetts17950.34 is17950.98 117951.06 of17951.22 the17951.3 worst17951.46 and17951.78 costly17951.86 states17952.33 to17952.65 do17952.81 business17952.97 in.17953.28 And17953.6 when17953.85 we17954 adopt17954.08 laws17954.41 like17954.65 this,17954.81 or17955.28 we17955.45 adopt17955.6 a17956 health17956.17 care17956.41 mandate,17956.65 or17957.2 we17957.36 adopt17957.6 an17958.49 environmental,17959.36 climate,17960.65 mandate17961.69 on17962.08 utilities,17962.33 all17963.04 those17963.2 go17963.45 to17963.6 the17963.76 cost17963.85 of17964.17 doing17964.24 business.17964.49 And17965.04 the17965.2 concern17965.36 is17965.76 that17965.93 as17966.34 you17966.42 add17966.66 those17966.74 up17966.98 in17967.14 the17967.22 aggregate,17967.3 it17968.02 continues17968.26 to17968.58 exacerbate17968.74 the17969.22 problem17969.3 that17969.54 Massachusetts17969.7 business17970.26 has17970.58 already17970.66 had.17970.82
17970.98 MOORE-17970.98 So17970.98 there's17971.14 any17971.54 program17971.94 or17972.34 law17972.5 that's17972.66 gonna17972.9 benefit17973.14 the17973.62 public17973.78 health17974.1 or17974.34 the17974.42 consumer17974.66 or17975.22 the17975.38 is17976.26 is17976.98 a17977.14 law17977.3 we17977.46 shouldn't17977.62 pass?17978.02
17978.5 KEARNEY17978.5 -17978.5 I17978.5 didn't17978.58 say17978.82 that.17978.98 I'm17979.14 saying17979.3 that17979.46
17979.94 MOORE17979.94 -17979.94 Basically,17979.94 it's17980.34 saying17980.42 that17980.74 it's17980.9
17981.22 KEARNEY17981.22 -17981.22 I'm17981.22 saying17981.38 that17981.7 you17981.78 should17981.94 be17982.1 thoughtful17982.4 about17982.72 when17983.03 you17983.27 when17983.43 you17983.75 are17983.99 making17984.24 these,17984.56 decisions,17985.27 that17985.67 you17985.75 should17985.92 be17986.08 thoughtful17986.15 about17986.47 the17986.72 additional17986.79 costs17987.11 that17987.35 are17987.48 gonna17987.6 be17987.92 incurred17988.08 when17988.56 you17988.72 do17988.87 a17988.95 Massachusetts17989.11 only17989.75 style17990.15 bill17990.47 versus17990.72 what17991.03 we've17991.19 seen17991.43 in17991.6 the17991.75 rest17991.83 of17992.08 the17992.15 state.17992.24 Our17992.47 again,17992.87 our17993.11 members17993.27 understand17993.67 the17994.24 concern.17994.63 And17994.94 if17995.21 our17995.49 members17995.76 are,17996.04 if17996.59 our17996.86 members17997.14 are17997.41 found17997.68 to17997.96 be17998.23 using17998.51 this17999.06 information17999.33 on17999.61 this17999.88 data18000.15 in18000.7 an18000.98 inappropriate18001.25 way,18001.53 they're18001.8 gonna18002.08 lose18002.35 the18002.62 trust18002.9 of18003.17 their18003.45 consumers,18003.72 and18004 they18004.27 know18004.54 that.18004.82 So,18005.09 there's18005.37 already18005.64 an18005.92 inherent18006.47 protection18007.1 there.18007.25 I18007.49 understand18007.65 that18007.97 there's18008.22 a18009.42 sentiment,18009.49 and18009.9 there's18010.06 and18010.77 I18011.01 potentially18011.25 would18011.9 agree18011.97 with18012.14 it18012.22 that18012.38 there18012.45 are18012.69 bad18012.85 actors18013.1 out18013.33 there.18013.49 But18013.97 these,18014.53 again,18015.25 these18016.38 businesses18016.61 are18018.93 are18019.17 doing.18019.33
18020.44 They're18020.44 using18020.68 this18021.08 information18021.24 again18021.72 for18021.96 the18022.12 benefit18022.76 of18023.16 their18023.96 business18024.2 purposes,18024.52 of18024.92 course,18025.08 but18025.4 also18025.64 for18025.88 the18026.04 consumer18026.12 as18026.52 well.18026.68 And18026.84 so18027 I'm18030.52 just18030.76 not18030.76 quite18030.92 sure18031.16 I18031.48 have18031.8 an18032.04 answer18032.12 for18032.44 you.18032.6 But18034.65 again,18034.97 we18035.45 are18035.85 trying18036.17 to18036.42 figure18036.49 out18036.74 a18036.81 way18036.9 to18037.13 work18037.45 with18037.69 you18037.77 on18037.93 this.18038.1 And18038.49 I18039.06 apologize18039.22 if18039.69 I18039.85 have18039.93 to18040.01 come18040.1 off18040.25 as18040.49 making18041.06 it18041.37 sound18041.45 like18041.69 your18041.77 work18042.01 is18042.17 not18042.33 appreciated.18042.49 I18043.06 understand18043.22 it,18043.61 but18043.69 again,18043.85 it's18044.1 creating18045.22 a18045.61 Massachusetts-only18046.9 framework18047.86 that18048.42 we're18048.98 gonna18049.22 have18049.46 to18049.62 cover18051.14 for.18051.38 We18051.62 gonna18051.78 have18052.02 someone's18053.38 going18053.7 to18053.94 have18054.1 to18054.18 pay18054.26 for18054.42 that.18054.66 And18055.06 so18055.22 it's18055.38 you18055.94 can18056.1 you18056.42 can18056.58 look18056.9 at18057.06 the18057.22 big18057.3 box18057.54 stores18057.78 and18058.02 say,18058.1 it's18058.26 gonna18058.42 be18058.74 them.18058.82 But18059.46 again,18059.7 that18060.02 trickles18060.74 down18061.14 to18061.3 the18061.54 cost18061.62 of18061.94 doing18062.02 business,18062.26 which18062.58 then18062.74 goes18062.9 into18063.1 the18063.26 prices,18063.42 which18063.67 then18063.9 goes18064.06 down18064.22 to18064.39 the18064.54 consumer.18064.7 And18065.18 so18065.35 I'm18065.67 trying18065.74 to18065.99 figure18066.06 out18066.31 a18066.39 way18066.47 to18066.7 protect18066.78 the18067.02 consumer18067.18 in18068.15 a18068.27 way18068.39 that18068.78 helps18069.9 protect18070.63 them18070.94 but18070.94 also18071.18 allows18071.42 for18071.67 businesses18071.83 to18072.31 continue18072.47 to18072.78 compete18072.94 with18073.35 the18073.5 rest18073.58 of18073.74 the18073.9 country.18073.99
18074.63 MOORE18074.63 -18074.63 And18074.63 we18074.78 do18074.94 have,18075.18 I18075.58 think,18075.67 every18075.99 version18076.22 has18076.7 an18076.86 exemption18077.02 for18077.42 true18077.7 small18077.94 businesses.18078.1 So,18078.9 the18079.14 consideration18079.38 of18079.94 small18080.1 businesses18080.34 has18081.62 been18081.94 considered18082.18 in18082.66 this.18082.82
KEARNEY-18083.22 Yes.18083.22 So18083.78 that's18086.98 all.18087.22 Thank18088.1 you.18088.34 Understood.18088.66
18089.14 FARLEY-BOUVIER18089.14 -18089.14 We18089.14 appreciate18089.3 it,18089.7 and18089.78 we18090.02 particularly18090.26 appreciate18090.82 your18091.3 offer18091.46 to18091.88 continue18091.95 to18092.11 work18092.27 closely18092.67 with18092.99 us.18093.16 Absolutely.18093.4
18093.64 KEARNEY18093.64 -18093.64 You18093.64 guys18093.79 have18094.03 been18094.11 widely18094.35 receptive.18094.67 I18095.08 really18095.24 appreciate18095.47 the18095.79 work18095.88 you've18096.03 done.18096.19
18096.35 FARLEY-BOUVIER-18096.35 We're18097.4 very18097.72 earnest18097.88 in18098.27 that.18098.43 And18098.67 as18098.92 you18099.16 know,18099.24 our18099.64 timetable18099.79 is18100.35 very18100.51 different18100.75 this18101.08 session18101.16 than18101.47 it18101.64 was18101.79 last,18101.95 so18102.19 we18102.43 hope18102.51 to18102.67 hear18102.75 from18102.92 you18103.08 soon.18103.24
18103.56 KEARNEY18103.56 -18103.56 Excellent.18103.56 Thank18103.79 you.18103.95
18104.19 FARLEY-BOUVIER18104.19 -18104.19 Okay?18104.19 Thank18104.6 you18104.83 so18105.16 much.18105.24 We're18105.79 gonna18105.95 now18106.19 go18106.43 to18106.67 Grace,18107.49 who18108.29 is18108.53 online,18108.77 and18109.49 we18109.65 are18109.89 gonna18110.05 follow18110.45 up18110.85 with18110.85 Tasha18111.09 Adler,18112.13 who18112.37 will18112.37 be18112.53 on18112.69 deck.18112.85 Grace?18113.65
18115.09 SPEAKER1518115.09 -18115.09 Yes.18115.09 Good18115.41 evening,18115.65 chairs.18115.97 Can18116.29 you18116.37 hear18116.53 me?18116.69
18117.09 SPEAKER118117.09 -18117.09 Yes.18117.09 Thank18117.57 you18117.73 for18117.89 your18118.05 patience.18118.21
GRACE18119.41 GEDYE18119.41 -18119.41 CONSUMER18119.41 REPORTS18119.41 -18119.41 (R)18119.41 Fantastic.18119.41 Well,18119.97 thank18120.22 you18120.29 all18120.53 for18120.77 having18120.85 this18121.1 very18121.33 thorough,18121.66 comprehensive18122.06 hearing.18122.53 I18122.85 know18122.94 it's18123.01 been18123.18 a18123.33 very18123.42 long18123.58 day18123.74 for18123.9 you18124.06 all18124.22 and18124.38 your18124.45 staff.18124.69 Honorable18125.9 members18126.22 of18126.45 the18126.53 committee,18126.61 my18126.94 name18127.01 is18127.18 Grace18127.33 Gedye,18127.66 and18127.97 I'm18128.06 a18128.22 policy18128.29 analyst18128.69 at18129.1 Consumer18129.25 Reports,18129.81 where18130.45 I18130.61 focus18130.77 on18131.1 consumer18131.25 protection18131.74 issues18132.14 in18132.61 AI18133.1 policy.18133.33 Consumer18134.41 Reports18134.81 is18135.13 a18135.29 nonpartisan18135.45 nonprofit18136.25 with18136.81 6,000,00018137.05 members18137.61 across18137.93 the18138.33 US,18138.49 and18138.89 in18139.21 Massachusetts18139.45 specifically,18140.09 we18140.97 have18141.13 more18141.37 than18141.53 38,00018141.77 members.18142.57 I'm18144.01 here18144.17 to18144.33 testify18144.49 regarding18144.89 House18145.53 Bill18145.85 99,18145.85 which18146.57 would18146.81 prohibit18146.97 the18147.29 use18147.45 of18147.69 biometric18148.01 data18148.65 like18149.05 fingerprints18149.45 or18149.65 prints18149.93 or18150.17 retina18150.33 scans18150.81 in18151.6 pricing18151.85 grocery18152.33 store18152.72 items.18152.97 That18154.08 is18154.24 using18154.49 something18154.72 like18154.97 a18155.21 scan18155.36 of18155.69 your18155.76 iris18156 to18156.41 determine18156.56 the18156.97 price18157.04 that18157.36 you18157.6 specifically18158.08 will18158.89 pay18159.04 for18159.21 a18159.45 bundle18159.52 of18159.85 bananas.18160 It18161.28 would18161.45 be18161.6 frankly18161.69 dystopian18162.17 if18162.72 grocery18162.89 stores18163.21 widely18163.6 implemented18164 this18164.41 practice.18164.79
18165.35 Yet,18165.83 several18165.83 years18166.15 ago,18166.31 companies18166.63 were18167.11 already18167.27 piloting18167.67 these18168.23 systems.18168.47 Kroger18170.23 announced18170.71 publicly18171.03 that18171.35 I18171.51 was18171.59 working18171.75 with18171.99 Microsoft18172.23 to18172.71 produce18172.87 electronic18173.35 shelves18173.91 for18174.95 grocery18175.11 stores18175.43 that18175.75 would18175.91 use18176.07 video18176.39 analytics18176.79 so18177.35 that,18177.59 quote,18177.91 personalized18178.79 offers18179.19 and18179.51 advertisements18179.75 can18180.4 be18180.64 presented18180.79 based18181.27 on18181.6 customer18181.83 demographics,18182.4 end18183.03 quote.18183.27 As18184.47 Fast18184.72 Company18184.95 further18185.43 reported,18185.75 quote,18186.31 a18186.72 camera18186.95 at18187.35 each18187.51 display18187.75 will18188.16 determine18188.31 through18188.79 facial18189.03 recognition18189.35 AI,18190.08 the18190.72 gender18190.95 and18191.19 age18191.43 of18191.75 the18191.92 shopper18192.08 passing18192.47 by,18192.88 end18193.35 quote.18193.6 This18194.83 is18195.23 creepy.18195.55 I18196.27 don't18196.43 know18196.59 about18196.67 you18196.83 all,18196.91 but18197.15 I18197.31 don't18197.39 want18197.55 grocery18197.71 store18198.11 shelves18198.35 spying18198.75 on18199.15 me18199.31 and18199.47 detecting18199.71 my18200.27 age18200.43 and18200.67 gender.18200.83 Prohibiting18202.27 the18202.83 use18202.91 of18203.15 biometric18203.23 data18203.79 in18204.27 grocery18204.43 store18204.83 pricing18205.07 should18205.55 be18205.71 an18205.87 easy18206.03 yes.18206.43 More18207.45 broadly,18207.69 we18208.01 would18208.25 encourage18208.42 Massachusetts18208.74 to18209.29 tackle18209.45 the18209.85 larger18210.18 problem18210.58 of18210.97 personalized18211.14 pricing,18211.61 also18212.33 known18212.58 as18212.81 surveillance18212.97 pricing.18213.45
18214.49 Biometric18214.49 data18214.97 is18215.29 just18215.45 118215.77 type18216.1 of18216.33 data18216.49 that18216.74 retailers18216.9 can18217.38 use18217.61 to18217.85 offer18218.01 individualized18218.74 pricing18219.45 based18219.94 on18220.18 what18220.33 they18220.49 think18220.66 each18220.97 of18221.22 us18221.38 is18221.82 individually18221.98 willing18222.54 to18222.86 pay.18223.02 They18224.14 can18224.38 also18224.54 gather18224.7 data18225.02 on18225.26 our18225.42 location,18225.66 search18226.22 history,18226.54 what18227.1 we18227.26 look18227.42 at,18227.66 what18227.82 we18227.9 cover18228.06 online,18228.7 the18229.34 type18229.5 of18229.74 device18229.9 we're18230.22 using,18230.46 and18230.78 more18231.02 to18231.66 make18231.82 inferences18232.06 about18232.54 our18232.86 income,18233.02 specific18233.83 health18234.24 conditions,18234.4 how18235.27 old18235.43 our18235.6 kids18235.83 are,18236.15 our18236.72 compulsions,18236.88 and18237.6 our18237.99 interests.18238.31 And18238.95 they18239.19 can18239.27 use18239.43 this18239.6 data18239.75 to18239.99 increase18240.08 prices18240.47 when,18240.95 say,18241.75 a18242.24 diabetic18242.4 is18243.03 particularly18243.19 desperate18243.75 to18244.15 buy18244.24 insulin18244.47 syringes18244.95 or18245.51 when18245.75 a18245.99 person18246.08 needs18246.4 to18246.63 purchase18246.79 a18247.43 plane18247.6 ticket18247.83 to18248.24 get18248.4 to18248.56 a18248.72 funeral.18248.79 We'd18250.21 encourage18250.37 the18250.77 Massachusetts18250.77 legislature18251.33 to18252.13 tackle18252.29 this18252.53 broader18252.69 problem18253.01 of18253.41 surveillance18253.65 pricing,18254.21 and18254.77 I18255.09 look18255.17 forward18255.33 to18255.57 connecting18255.65 with18255.89 the18256.13 author18256.21 on18256.53 this18256.69 specific,18257.01 more18257.41 narrowly18257.65 targeted18258.37 bill18258.93 related18259.33 to18259.73 grocery18259.89 store18260.21 prices18260.45 and18260.85 biometric18261.01 data.18261.65 Thank18262.05 you.18262.21
18263.24 FARLEY-BOUVIER18263.24 -18263.24 Thank18263.24 you.18263.68 Any18264.13 comments18264.53 or18264.85 questions18265.08 from18265.4 the18265.56 committee?18265.72 Thank18267 you18267.24 very18267.81 much,18268.13 Grace.18268.44 We're18268.85 now18269 going18269.32 to18269.65 go18269.81 to18270.76 Tasha.18270.76 We're18271.24 going18271.4 to18271.65 Tasha18271.88 Adler.18272.28 Hi,18273.24 Tasha.18273.49 Welcome,18273.97 and18274.28 thank18274.53 you18274.68 for18274.85 your18275 patience.18275.17
18282.7 SPEAKER1718282.7 -18282.7 Go18282.7 ahead.18283.02
TASHA18283.9 ADLER18283.9 -18283.9 BOSTON18283.9 UNIVERSITY18283.9 -18283.9 Hello.18283.9 My18284.3 name18284.46 is18284.7 Tasha18285.18 Adler,18285.66 and18286.14 I'm18286.46 a18286.7 cybersecurity18286.94 PhD18287.82 student18288.22 at18288.62 Boston18288.78 University.18289.1 I18290.47 study18290.64 wireless18291.28 security18291.75 and18292.16 privacy,18292.4 and18293.92 I'm18294.08 here18294.24 to18294.47 speak18294.56 in18294.79 favor18294.88 of18295.19 the18295.28 Massachusetts18295.43 Data18295.99 Privacy18296.24 Act18296.72 and18296.95 similar18297.12 strong18297.6 comprehensive18297.99 data18298.72 privacy18298.95 legislation.18299.43 First,18301.12 I'll18301.35 say18301.52 that18301.75 as18302.56 a18302.72 researcher,18302.96 I18303.36 have18303.52 seen18303.76 up18304.24 close18304.32 the18304.8 granular18304.96 detailed18305.6 data18306 that18306.4 car18307.68 companies18307.92 have18308.48 collected18308.72 about18309.36 users,18309.6 and18310.4 I18310.56 am18310.8 very18311.12 concerned18311.36 about18311.76 it.18312 Second,18312.88 I'll18313.36 say18313.6 that18313.84 as18314.64 a18314.8 student,18314.96 I've18315.97 also18316.2 seen18316.44 the18316.77 impact18316.92 of18317.72 these18317.88 data18318.13 collection18318.44 policies18318.85 on18320.04 students18320.29 who18320.68 express18320.92 themselves18321.32 online18321.72 and,18323.49 political18323.49 beliefs.18324.04 I18326.04 believe18326.2 that18326.44 Massachusetts18326.68 should18327.72 do18327.97 everything18328.13 possible18328.6 to18329 prevent18329.17 the18329.56 transfer18329.65 or18330.53 sale18330.68 of18331.3 sensitive18331.46 information18331.94 to18332.34 companies18332.5 that,18332.9 in18333.06 turn,18333.3 sell18333.86 it18334.1 to18334.26 law18334.34 enforcement18334.5 agencies.18335.06 Many18336.74 of18336.98 my18337.06 classmates18337.22 who18338.34 have18338.58 not18338.82 engaged18338.98 in18339.38 any18339.54 public18339.7 protests18340.1 are18341.22 still18341.46 afraid18341.78 to18342.1 visit18342.18 their18342.5 families18342.66 during18343.22 summer18343.7 break18344.02 because18344.78 they're18345.01 scared18345.49 that18345.74 they're18345.97 gonna18346.06 get18346.29 blocked18346.45 from18346.69 returning18346.93 because18347.33 of,18347.57 say,18348.53 something18348.78 on18349.1 their18349.17 social18349.33 media18349.57 or18349.9 even18350.13 something18350.38 that18350.69 they,18350.85 you18351.25 know,18351.42 engaged18351.74 with18352.06 online.18352.29
18353.57 And,18353.57 you18355.42 know,18355.57 again,18355.74 these18355.97 are18356.22 students18356.29 that18356.61 did18357.25 not18358 participate18358.4 in18358.8 protests18359.04 or18359.36 do18359.6 anything18359.76 controversial.18360.08 So18361.84 I've18362.08 recently18362.4 moved18362.8 here18363.04 from18363.44 California,18363.76 you18364.32 know,18364.48 118364.64 of18364.8 the18364.88 other18365.04 states18365.2 that18365.52 has18365.68 a18366 strong18366.56 data18367.2 privacy18367.52 law.18368 And18368.88 I18370.8 feel18371.2 like18371.44 I've18371.68 lost18372.08 some18372.32 rights18372.48 coming18372.8 here18372.96 almost,18373.2 and18373.49 so18374.38 I18375.25 would18375.33 really18376.06 love18376.38 to18376.43 see18376.48 Massachusetts18376.54 enact18377.66 118377.68 of18377.7 these18377.72 policies.18377.74 So18377.76 in18377.78 Massachusetts,18377.8 it's18377.82 currently18377.9 legal18377.92 for18377.94 companies18377.95 to18377.97 collect18377.99 unnecessarily18378.02 specific18378.04 data18378.06 regarding18378.08 location,18378.1 health18378.12 history,18378.14 sexuality,18378.16 race,18378.18 and18378.2 religion,18378.22 data18386.16 regarding18386.48 location,18386.72 health18387.28 history,18387.52 sexuality,18387.92 race,18388.64 and18388.88 religion,18389.12 all18389.84 of18390 which18390.16 can18390.32 be18390.56 sold18390.64 and18390.88 weaponized18390.96 as18391.44 we've18391.6 heard18391.76 from18392 previous18393.52 testimony.18394 Some18395.36 of18395.52 the18395.68 specific18396.4 instances18396.72 that18397.2 disturb18397.36 me18397.76 the18397.92 most18398 are18398.32 health18398.48 insurance18398.72 companies18399.12 blindly18399.52 buying18399.92 client18400.16 data18400.49 and18401.38 using18401.62 this18401.85 data18402.02 to18402.42 predict18402.49 the18404.02 health18404.18 outcomes18404.42 of18404.81 their18404.9 clients,18405.14 presumably18406.25 for18406.66 the18406.9 purpose18406.97 of18407.38 eventually18407.54 raising18407.93 their18408.25 insurance18408.42 rates.18408.9
18409.85 I'm18409.85 also18410.1 disturbed18410.33 by18410.97 the18411.85 use18411.93 of18412.42 data18414.42 collected18415.06 on18416.55 apps18416.71 that18417.03 target18417.19 religious18417.67 minorities18418.07 and18419.59 also18419.99 the18420.63 anti18421.03 abortion18421.51 advocates18422.39 that18422.87 are18423.03 collecting18423.27 lists18423.59 of18423.83 women18423.99 who18424.31 frequented18424.47 or18425.11 who18425.51 visited18425.67 abortion18426.47 clinics.18426.95 Strong18428.39 comprehensive18428.87 data18429.43 privacy18429.67 legislation18430.07 would18430.71 prevent18430.87 these18431.19 sorts18431.47 of18431.56 abuses18431.79 by18432.35 requiring18432.67 that18433.08 companies18433.24 abide18433.64 by18433.95 a18434.12 strictly18434.19 necessary18434.6 standard18435.15 when18436.12 collecting18436.35 our18436.75 sensitive18436.99 data18437.4 and18437.79 demanding18438.04 that18438.75 they18438.92 get18439.15 our18439.31 consent18439.47 every18439.88 time18440.12 they18440.28 want18440.35 to18440.6 transfer18440.67 our18441.08 personal18441.24 data.18441.56 Companies18443.47 would18443.95 be18444.12 required18444.28 to18444.6 disclose18444.75 to18445.15 us18445.31 any18445.47 third18445.72 parties18446.06 to18446.22 which18446.38 they18446.62 have18446.78 transferred18446.94 our18447.34 data18447.42 and18447.74 the18447.9 purpose18448.06 of18448.3 the18448.46 transfer.18448.54 Bans18449.34 the18449.66 sale18449.82 of18450.14 geolocation18450.22 data18450.78 and18451.5 allows18451.82 Massachusetts18452.06 residents18452.7 to18453.1 request18453.26 the18453.98 correction18454.14 or18454.62 deletion18454.78 of18455.26 personal18455.34 data.18455.74 It18456.38 allows18456.54 us18456.86 to18456.94 opt18457.1 out18457.26 of18457.42 profiling,18457.58 which18458.14 is18458.3 both18458.46 dangerous18459.04 and18459.45 flawed.18459.68 Most18461.45 importantly,18461.68 I18462.24 appreciate18462.41 the18462.97 private18463.68 right18464 of18464.17 action18464.33 because18464.65 I18464.81 think18464.89 that18465.04 it's18465.2 vital18465.45 for18465.85 enforcement18466.08 because18466.56 the18466.89 attorney18467.04 general's18467.37 budget18467.77 is18468.08 limit18468.24 is18469.04 limited.18469.2 Thank18470.08 you18470.33 for18470.56 your18470.72 time.18470.89
FARLEY-BOUVIER18471.82 -18471.82 Thank18471.82 you.18472.06 Are18472.62 there18473.02 any18473.18 comments18473.42 or18473.9 questions18474.14 from18474.94 the18475.34 committee?18475.5 I18476.38 have18476.54 1.18476.78 Can18477.58 you18477.9 talk18478.06 more18478.38 about18478.54 car18479.02 data?18479.34 You18480.62 said18480.78 that18480.94 you18481.18 get18481.34 to18481.5 see18481.66 this.18481.82 Can18482.14 you18482.3 tell18482.62 me18482.86 what18483.02 that's18483.26 like?18483.5 What18483.74 does18483.98 my18484.14 car18484.57 collect18484.81 on18485.22 me?18485.38
18486.57 ADLER18486.57 -18486.57 So,18486.57 while18487.53 this18487.78 isn't18487.93 my18488.17 specific18488.42 research18488.97 project,18489.29 I18490.01 can18490.17 refer18490.42 you18490.65 to18490.65 Northeastern18491.06 University18491.69 students18492.17 who18492.81 are18493.06 working18493.13 with18493.45 this.18493.53 I've18494.49 had18494.9 the18495.06 privilege18496.81 of18497.22 sitting18498.25 with18498.49 them18498.65 and18498.9 looking18499.06 through18499.29 this18499.45 data18499.61 with18499.85 them.18500.01 And18500.39 it18500.63 depends18500.71 on18501.19 the18501.35 company.18501.43 Some18502.07 of18502.23 the18502.31 worst18502.47 are,18502.79 unsurprisingly,18503.11 Tesla.18503.91 And18505.43 they18505.67 collect,18505.91 you18506.31 know,18506.47 information18506.79 like18507.27 how18507.67 many18507.75 people18508.07 are18508.39 in18508.63 the18508.71 car18508.87 with18509.03 you18509.19 and,18509.51 you18510.39 know,18510.47 the18511.91 exact18512.07 the18515 exact18515.32 speed18518.12 and,18518.6 such,18519.88 that18521.08 you18521.32 are18521.49 apologies.18523.32 Your18524.85 speed,18525.08 when18525.96 you18526.12 use18526.28 the18526.36 brakes,18526.52 when18526.92 you18527.08 roll18527.16 down18527.4 your18527.56 windows,18527.72 sometimes18528.04 even.18528.44 Like,18528.76 these18529.08 are18529.32 very,18529.4 very18529.64 specific18529.88 pieces18530.6 of18530.92 information,18531.08 and18531.4 I18531.8 don't18531.88 really18532.2 see18532.68 what18533 the18533.24 purpose18533.4 of18533.88 collecting18533.96 them18534.36 is.18534.52 No.18534.84 That's18535.4 disturbing.18535.88
18536.76 FARLEY-BOUVIER18536.76 -18536.76 Thank18536.76 you18536.92 for18537.16 your18537.32 testimony.18537.48 Again,18538.04 here18538.49 oh.18538.81 Interesting.18539.7
18540.33 REP18540.33 HAWKINS18540.33 -18540.33 My18540.33 car18540.49 tells18540.74 me18540.97 when18541.14 the18541.29 dogs18541.38 are18541.7 in18541.78 the18541.85 back18541.93 seat.18542.18 Yeah.18542.74 And18542.97 how18543.14 does18543.29 it18543.54 know18543.62 that?18543.85 Yeah.18544.42
FARLEY-BOUVIER18544.97 -18544.97 Yeah.18544.97 So,18546.25 appreciate18547.06 your18547.45 testimony.18547.7 When18548.1 we18548.33 have18548.58 the18548.74 voice18548.9 of18549.14 students,18549.29 it18549.62 really18549.78 does,18550.02 it's18550.58 very18550.74 meaningful18550.97 to18551.45 us.18551.62 So18551.78 thank18551.93 you18552.18 very,18552.33 very18552.49 much.18552.81 Again,18553.14 thank18553.38 you18553.54 for18553.81 your18553.89 patience.18554.05
18554.77 SPEAKER818554.77 -18554.77 Thank18554.77 you.18554.85 Appreciate18555.09 it.18555.89
18556.21 FARLEY-BOUVIER18556.21 -18556.21 Okay.18556.21 So18556.69 were18556.93 you,18557.17 David?18557.33 We're18558.37 going18558.53 to18558.69 David18558.93 Twan's.18559.49 David18560.53 here?18560.93 Yes.18561.89 No.18562.85 Next18563.41 is18563.81 Christopher18564.13 Stark.18564.69
18567.45 Thank18567.45 you.18567.69 And18568.01 then18568.25 we18568.49 will18568.74 have18568.89 Emily18569.22 Anessa.18569.61
18576.89 CHRISTOPHER18576.89 STARK18576.89 -18576.89 MASSACHUSETTS18576.89 AND18576.89 RHODE18576.89 ISLAND18576.89 INSURANCE18576.89 FEDERATION18576.89 -18576.89 Chair18576.89 Farley18577.13 Bouvier,18577.53 Chair18578.01 Moore,18578.33 members18578.65 of18578.97 the18579.16 committee,18579.32 my18579.48 name18579.56 is18579.64 Christopher18579.96 Stark.18580.36 I'm18580.68 the18580.76 executive18580.92 director18581.4 of18581.72 the18581.8 Mass18581.96 Insurance18582.2 Federation.18582.6 We18583.48 represent18583.72 2518584.2 member18585 companies18585.32 from18586.52 the18586.76 property18586.92 casualty18587.32 insurance18588.12 sector.18588.68 So,18589.64 we18589.8 are18589.96 home,18590.28 auto,18590.6 workers'18591 comp,18591.56 and18591.8 commercial18592.04 lines18592.6 of18592.84 insurance.18593 It's18593.8 easier18593.96 to18594.28 say18594.36 what18594.52 we're18594.78 not.18594.85 We're18594.93 not18595.17 life,18595.33 and18595.49 we're18595.65 not18595.74 health.18595.9 But18596.69 we18596.93 pretty18597.02 much18597.33 cover18597.57 everything18597.9 else.18598.13 Chair18598.61 Farley18598.93 Bovee,18599.17 I18599.49 especially18599.65 wanna18600.13 thank18600.45 you18600.61 for18600.78 last18601.02 year18601.25 taking18601.57 the18601.81 time18601.9 to18602.13 sit18602.29 down18602.45 with18602.69 us,18602.85 really18603.1 dive18603.42 in,18603.81 to18604.69 your18604.93 legislation18605.17 last18605.9 session.18606.22 I'll18607.62 submit18607.78 written18608.26 testimony18608.66 and18609.7 consideration18609.94 of18610.42 time,18610.58 but18610.82 I18610.9 wanna18610.9 hit18611.3 on18611.46 some18611.7 of18611.94 the18612.02 issues18612.18 that18614.1 we've18614.34 heard18614.5 today.18614.98 I'll18615.14 start18615.38 with18615.7 the18616.5 entity18616.74 level18617.14 exemption18617.86 versus18618.42 the18618.9 information18619.06 level18619.62 exemption.18619.94 118620.98 of18621.22 the18621.38 key18621.54 concerns18621.94 that18622.5 some18622.81 of18623.04 our18623.13 members18623.37 have18623.77 is18624.24 how18624.72 the18625.04 definitions18625.2 work18625.92 for18626.17 GLBA.18626.49
18627.6 And18627.6 so18627.85 you18628.17 have18628.4 a18628.89 consumer18629.2 definition18629.77 and18630.81 a18631.29 customer18631.6 definition18632.81 for18633.37 that.18633.6 But18634.56 what18634.97 it18635.2 won't18635.44 capture18635.85 is18636.93 some18637.25 of18637.57 the18637.73 data18637.89 that18638.29 is18638.53 used18638.77 for18639.17 workers'18639.49 compensation18640.05 because18641.17 there,18641.57 any18642.05 of18642.21 the18642.37 data18642.45 that's18642.69 collected18642.93 on18643.33 the18643.49 employee,18643.65 they're18644.13 not18644.37 the18644.53 customer.18644.69 That's18645.41 the18645.65 protected18645.81 data18646.29 under18646.69 GLBA,18647.57 or18648.21 commercial18648.45 to18649.01 commercial,18649.09 interactions18650.53 where18651.17 we18652.42 may18652.74 be18652.9 working18653.06 with18653.38 the18653.62 insureds18653.78 to18654.35 make18654.58 some18655.14 sort18655.38 of18655.7 risk18657.06 reduction18657.38 measures18657.94 that18658.35 they18658.58 may18658.82 take18659.06 dash18662.1 cams18662.42 in18662.9 their18663.06 vehicle18663.31 on18663.7 some18663.94 commercial18664.26 vehicles.18665.54 And18666.1 how18666.26 would18666.42 that18666.63 actually18666.82 interact18667.02 with18667.22 interact18668.66 with18668.98 the18669.14 text18669.38 of18669.62 this18669.78 legislation18670.1 without18670.98 an18672.5 entity-level18673.54 exemption?18673.94 And18673.94 so,18674.1 that's18674.26 why18674.42 the18674.66 Federation18674.82 strongly18676.26 supports18676.82 H-eighty18677.3 as18678.02 the18678.26 starting18678.58 point,18679.06 mostly18680.26 because18680.66 of18681.22 that18681.38 use18681.62 of18681.86 the18682.02 entity-level18682.5 exemption.18683.92 And18684.24 so,18684.4 that18685.51 is18685.67 a18687.11 key18687.19 priority18687.51 for18689.11 us18689.28 when18689.6 it18689.75 comes18689.92 to18691.67 these18691.75 pieces18692.07 of18692.4 legislation,18692.56 any18693.43 piece18693.67 of18693.92 privacy18694.07 legislation,18694.56 is18694.95 making18695.19 sure18695.43 that18695.67 it18695.83 is18695.92 an18696.07 entity18696.24 level18696.56 exemption.18696.88
18697.65 And18697.65 that's18697.73 particularly18698.05 important18699.41 because18700.61 of18701.01 the18701.25 private18701.49 cause18701.81 of18702.05 action.18702.13 Already,18703.33 insurers18704.13 are18704.69 regulated18704.85 under18705.65 the18706.13 Gramm-Leach-Bliley18707.25 Act.18708.21 Massachusetts,18708.21 chapter18710.31 H18711.35 93,18712.22 has18712.22 some18712.47 of18712.63 the18712.79 provisions18712.86 in18713.42 this,18713.58 as18714.06 well18714.22 as18714.54 regulatory18714.79 authority18715.42 by18715.9 both18716.06 the18716.22 division18716.38 and18717.1 the18717.35 office18717.5 of18717.74 the18717.9 attorney18717.99 general's18718.38 division18719.35 of18719.74 insurance18719.82 within18720.7 them.18721.03 And18721.99 so,18722.22 that18724.38 level18724.7 of18725.02 concern18725.26 about18725.66 what18725.98 information18726.22 is18726.7 or18727.02 is18727.26 not,18727.42 how18727.66 many18727.74 of18727.98 these18728.14 cases18728.3 will18728.7 we18728.86 now18729.1 have18729.26 to18729.58 oversee,18729.98 in18731.34 a18731.58 new18731.66 era18731.9 where18732.14 we18732.38 already18732.54 know18732.86 that18733.1 abuse18733.26 of18733.58 the18733.74 legal18733.82 system18734.14 is18734.54 a18734.78 key18734.94 factor18735.5 in18736.22 the18736.53 increases,18736.78 that18737.89 we've18738.06 seen18738.29 over18738.69 the18738.93 past18739.1 518739.33 years18739.49 in18739.81 insurance18739.97 products.18740.45 The18741.81 other18741.97 aspects,18742.29 though,18742.85 that18743.1 I18743.25 do18743.57 wanna18743.81 touch18744.13 on18744.45 are18744.85 the18745.25 location18745.49 shields,18746.22 as18746.53 well18746.69 as18746.85 the18747.01 location18747.17 sections18748.78 of18749.25 the18749.97 data18750.53 privacy18750.85 bills.18751.33 And18752.21 I18753.97 think18754.13 that18754.45 gets18754.77 to18755.09 part18755.73 of18755.97 the18756.05 conversation18756.29 about18756.93 the18757.09 quote18757.17 unquote18757.41 patchwork,18757.89 or18759.01 the18759.17 importance18759.41 of18759.81 taking18759.97 a18760.53 New18760.69 England18760.85 approach.18761.33 When18762.13 we18762.37 have18762.69 specific18763.09 guidelines18763.89 for18764.45 what18764.78 the18764.79 data18764.79 can18764.81 be18764.81 collected18764.82 and18764.83 specific18764.83 guidelines18764.84 on18764.84 what,18764.85 presented18771.78 in18772.42 terms18772.58 of18772.82 consent.18773.06
18774.18 Well,18774.18 what18774.5 happens18774.74 to18775.15 our18775.47 telematics18775.78 devices18776.5 in18777.86 a18778.1 vehicle18778.18 by18779.06 the18779.31 definition,18779.47 especially18780.03 in18780.48 the18780.56 shield18780.72 act18780.96 and18781.28 individuals,18781.52 anybody18781.92 that's18782.24 even18782.48 located18782.8 in18783.52 the18783.68 Commonwealth.18783.84 So18784.4 you18784.56 signed18784.72 an18785.04 agreement18785.2 in18786.16 another18786.32 state.18786.72 It18787.04 may18787.12 not18787.28 have18787.44 been18787.6 precisely18787.92 the18789.12 language18789.44 that18790 we18790.24 have18790.4 in18790.64 our18790.8 legislation.18791.04 And18791.68 so18791.92 is18792.48 the18792.72 expectation18792.88 then18793.68 somehow,18794 that18795.2 companies18795.3 invest18795.4 in18795.5 the18795.6 capabilities18795.82 invest18796.04 in18796.29 the18796.44 capabilities18796.53 to18797.24 shut18797.56 that18797.72 off18797.88 immediately18798.2 when18799.65 they18799.81 cross18800.13 the18800.44 Massachusetts18800.6 border?18801.32 Because18801.65 there's18801.97 no18802.6 ability18802.85 to18803.49 get18803.81 that18804.04 affirmative18804.6 consent18805.24 or18805.56 that18805.72 same18805.97 level18806.13 of18806.44 consent,18806.53 other18807.72 states18808.04 in18808.36 which18808.44 they18808.68 sign18808.92 these18809.17 agreements,18809.32 especially18810.29 for18810.3 telematics18810.32 devices,18810.33 might18810.36 exist.18810.53 Similar18817.2 concern18818 with18818.4 that,18818.72 especially18819.76 on18820.4 the18820.64 Shield18821.04 Act18821.52 because18821.84 it18824 talks18824.85 about18825.17 subverting18825.33 choice.18825.9 And18826.45 so18826.61 again,18826.78 when18827.1 you18827.25 have18827.33 a18827.49 private18827.57 right18827.9 of18828.06 action18828.22 attached,18828.53 what18828.93 does18829.01 subverting18829.25 choice18829.65 mean?18829.81 Just18830.29 telling18830.61 them18830.85 that18831.1 they18831.65 could18831.81 get18832.06 a18832.22 discount18832.29 for18832.69 their18832.85 car18833.1 insurance18833.33 if18834.13 they18834.29 place18834.45 a18834.78 telematics18834.93 device18835.65 impacting18836.69 their18837.82 choice,18838.06 and18838.46 whether18838.7 or18838.94 not18839.02 they18839.18 do18839.42 this.18839.58
18840.06 And18840.06 then18840.22 that18840.46 gets18840.54 into18840.78 the18841.02 retaliatory18841.26 section18842.86 of18843.26 this,18843.42 again,18844.62 where18844.94 it18845.18 says18845.34 that18845.5 you18845.66 cannot18845.82 have18846.62 an18846.78 impact18846.94 on18847.26 price,18847.42 even18847.74 a18848.06 discount.18848.22 However,18848.78 the18848.94 division18849.1 of18849.42 insurance18849.58 requires18850.06 us18850.46 that18850.62 if18850.7 we're18850.86 going18851.02 to18851.26 use18851.34 telematics18851.5 devices,18852.14 it18852.53 can18852.9 only18853.27 be18853.63 with18854 a18854.36 discount.18854.73 And18855.1 so,18855.57 taking18855.97 the,18856.69 I18856.78 think18856.85 that18857.1 those18857.41 are18857.49 218857.57 of18857.65 the18858.29 key18858.37 components18858.61 of,18859.41 of18859.49 the18859.74 discussion18859.89 today,18860.29 that18861.01 I18861.25 just18861.33 wanted18861.57 to18861.81 highlight18861.97 how18862.29 insurance18863.1 can18863.57 illustrate18863.74 why,18864.22 1,18864.53 an18864.85 an18865.17 entity18865.25 level18865.37 exemption,18865.49 is18867.01 necessary,18867.25 and18868.05 we're18868.61 at18868.93 least18869.01 not18869.33 doing18869.49 it18869.65 for18869.81 any18869.97 nefarious18870.21 purposes,18870.77 but18871.81 more18871.97 to18872.21 make18872.29 sure,18872.53 that18873.57 the18874.53 information18874.69 that18875.17 is18875.33 needed18875.49 for18875.81 insurance18875.97 contracts18876.45 is18876.85 able18876.93 to18877.17 be18877.33 garnered18877.41 even18877.73 under18878.22 this18878.45 law,18878.61 and18879.49 then18879.65 the18879.9 necessity18880.06 of18881.9 having18882.06 at18882.45 least18882.53 some18882.85 standardization,18883.17 between18885.33 us18885.81 and18886.22 our,18886.53 New18887.33 England18887.49 neighbors18887.9 in18888.22 this18888.38 economy.18888.61 Thank18889.17 you,18889.42 Chair.18889.57 Farley,18889.81 we'll18890.13 be18890.29 getting18890.45 shared18890.61 more.18890.85 Sure.18891.25
FARLEY-BOUVIER18891.65 -18891.65 Thanks.18891.65 I'm18891.97 gonna18892.13 start18892.53 off18892.85 by18893.17 just18893.41 asking,18893.65 would18895.09 your18895.33 members,18895.57 by18896.21 and18896.37 large,18896.53 more18897.17 than18897.33 118897.57 you18897.97 have,18898.13 but,18898.29 are18898.85 they18899.17 defined18899.57 as18899.97 brokers18900.13 in18900.53 Vermont18900.69 or18901.09 California?18901.17
18904.21 STARK18904.21 -18904.21 I'll18904.21 get18904.37 back18904.53 to18904.69 you18904.85 on18905.01 that18905.09 1.18905.25 I'm18905.41 not18905.57 sure18905.73 whether18905.95 they'd18906.19 be18906.35 the18906.43 brokers18906.67 or18907.08 the18907.24 collectors,18907.4 typically,18908.35 of18910.04 that18910.12 information18910.43 under18910.92 CCPA.18911.24
18912.12 FARLEY-BOUVIER18912.12 -18912.12 So18912.12 it18912.35 would18912.52 be18912.75 it's18913.4 different.18913.63 Right?18913.95 Right.18914.28 Broker18914.52 work18914.99 definitely.18915.31 And18916.04 just18916.67 clarifying,18917.08 we18919.18 do18919.42 not18919.66 ban18919.9 the18920.22 collection18920.46 of18921.02 location18921.34 in18922.38 our18922.62 bills.18922.78 We18923.66 ban18924.06 the18924.62 buying18924.62 and18925.02 selling18925.18 of18925.82 location18926.06 precise18926.62 location18927.26 data18927.82 in18928.14 our18928.3 bill.18928.46 That's18928.7 why18929.58 it's18929.58 not18929.74 the18929.98 same.18930.14 Right?18930.86 And18932.14 so,18932.38 as18933.06 would18933.69 your18933.93 members18934.17 be18934.74 buying18935.06 location18935.85 data?18936.42
18937.69 STARK18937.69 -18937.69 It18937.69 depends18937.93 on18938.57 the18939.06 relationship.18939.29 And18939.78 so18939.93 for18940.02 1,18940.25 definitely18940.57 would18940.97 want18941.22 to18941.54 have18941.69 in18941.93 there18942.1 at18942.33 least18942.49 some18942.97 ability18943.22 for18943.69 the18943.93 transfer18944.81 to18945.29 affiliates,18945.45 because18946.74 if18947.13 they're18947.29 not18947.45 within18947.69 so18948.02 say,18948.25 I18948.49 don't18948.92 know18949.08 exactly18949.16 how18949.56 it18949.72 works.18949.8 I18949.96 won't18950.04 use18950.28 any18950.44 company18950.6 in18950.92 particular.18951.08 But18951.56 let's18951.8 use18951.96 a18952.12 telematics18952.28 device18953.4 that18953.88 uses18954.92 location18955.24 services18955.8 as18956.28 well.18956.36 If18959.48 that18959.72 company18959.88 and18960.28 the18960.52 way18960.6 they18960.97 branded18961.14 that18961.62 particular18961.93 device18962.49 has18962.9 that18963.14 as18963.29 an18963.45 affiliate18963.62 of18964.02 the18964.1 company,18964.25 I18964.97 think18965.06 that18965.14 we'd18965.29 have18965.45 to18965.62 do18965.69 that18965.78 because18965.93 then18966.25 we're18966.42 talking18966.58 about18966.81 the18967.06 transfers18967.29 even18968.49 within18968.74 the18969.45 company18970.25 umbrella18972.17 that18972.49 the18972.74 bill18972.81 hits18973.06 on.18973.38 And18973.54 so,18973.78 I'd18976.64 have18976.96 to18977.2 see18977.36 on18977.76 that.18978 The18978.24 other18978.4 aspect18978.72 of18979.2 it18979.28 is18979.44 that,18980.24 yes,18980.56 sure.18980.8 Some18981.12 of18981.36 my18981.44 largest18981.68 national18982.16 carriers18982.48 absolutely18983.04 can18983.6 afford18983.84 to18985.44 purchase18987 or18988.36 implement18989 a18989.97 telematics18990.28 or18990.85 user-based18991.49 insurance18991.81 model18992.36 on18993.08 their18993.16 own.18993.4 Several18993.72 have.18994.12 But18995 some18995.24 of18995.49 the18995.56 smaller18995.72 carriers,18996.12 especially,18997.4 we18998.2 have18998.36 a18998.6 large18998.85 percentage18999.24 of18999.72 domestic18999.97 small19000.68 mutuals19000.92 in19002.15 Massachusetts.19002.31 If19003.35 they19003.59 wanted19003.91 to19004.23 implement19004.39 a19005.03 usage-based19005.91 insurance19006.31 model,19007.59 they19008.07 would19008.31 probably19008.71 have19009.35 to19009.59 use19009.99 a19010.47 vendor19010.63 in19011.03 the19011.11 space.19011.27 So,19012.07 in19012.23 that19012.47 sense,19012.71 yes.19013.75 Even19013.99 if19014.23 it19014.39 is19014.47 the19014.87 vendor19015.03 managing19015.51 that,19015.99 there19016.65 would19016.81 be19016.97 a19017.06 monetary19017.22 exchange19017.85 and,19018.41 therefore,19019.06 a19019.06 purchase19019.29 or19019.61 a19019.78 sale19019.85 of19020.1 Okay.19020.41
19020.89 STARK-19020.89 That19020.89 data.19021.06
19021.69 FARLEY-BOUVIER19021.69 -19021.69 I19021.69 think19021.78 that19022.01 makes19022.17 sense.19022.41 What19022.74 you're19022.97 saying19023.06 does19023.45 make19023.69 sense.19023.93 So19024.49 if19024.97 there's19026.65 a19027.06 transfer19027.22 of19028.01 information19028.25 to19029.06 the19029.79 agency.19030.03 That's19031.31 119031.71 thing.19031.95 But19032.19 do19032.43 you19032.59 sell19032.75 it19032.99 to19033.07 McDonald's?19033.31 That's19035.55 a19035.79 really19035.95 different19036.19 thing.19036.51
19036.67 STARK19036.67 -19036.67 Right.19036.67 No.19036.91 I19037.15 understand.19037.23
19037.79 FARLEY-BOUVIER19037.79 -19037.79 How19037.79 do19037.95 we19038.03 capture19038.35 that19038.91 is19039.23 That19039.47 is19039.63 what19039.87 we19040.03 would19040.19 have19040.43 to19040.59 work19040.67 on.19040.91 Right.19041.15 You19041.58 know?19041.74
19042.06 STARK19042.06 -19042.06 Well,19042.06 and19042.54 yeah.19042.78 And,19043.03 because19043.18 it19043.42 also19043.67 comes19043.99 into19044.22 sort19044.94 of19045.18 the19045.35 other19045.5 kind19045.99 of19046.22 unintended19046.47 consequences,19047.18 and19047.67 it's19047.9 in19048.06 my19048.22 written,19048.38 but19049.26 just19049.58 as19049.82 a19049.99 few19050.06 of19050.31 the19050.47 examples19050.7 of19051.26 of19051.58 ways19051.74 that19052.06 we19052.22 are19052.38 required19052.78 by19053.26 law19053.42 to19053.67 report19053.82 some19054.22 personal19054.94 information,19055.26 even19055.74 sensitive19056.06 personal19056.54 information,19056.86 but19057.9 Medicaid19058.06 and19058.46 Medicare19058.54 liens,19058.94 although19059.18 probably19059.58 the19059.98 HIPAA,19060.14 language19061.02 covers19061.5 that.19061.9 Child19062.38 support19062.7 liens,19063.02 fire19063.5 loss19063.82 data19064.22 reporting,19064.54 mandates19065.9 on,19066.62 reports19067.74 of19068.38 stolen19069.34 vehicles19069.82 or19070.42 the19070.67 salvage19070.82 base,19071.31 database19071.94 that19072.35 we19072.5 passed19072.74 a19072.99 couple19073.06 of19073.38 years19073.47 ago19073.7 here,19073.94 that19074.58 includes19074.82 the19075.22 license19075.31 plate,19075.78 information.19076.74 And19077.22 so,19077.38 there's19078.42 a19078.74 lot19078.9 of19079.22 those19079.54 areas19079.7 that19080.03 we'd19080.18 have19080.42 to19080.5 work19080.58 on,19080.82 which19080.99 is19081.15 why19081.31 we19081.47 do19081.7 so19081.86 strongly19082.1 advocate19082.58 at19082.99 the19083.06 entity19083.22 level.19083.63 We19084.65 wouldn't19084.89 have19085.05 to19085.21 get19085.37 into19085.61 kind19086.01 of19086.17 having19086.33 to19086.65 okay.19087.05 We19087.45 gotta19087.61 insert19087.93 this19088.65 particular19088.89 section19089.37 and19089.69 that19089.85 particular19090.01 section.19090.57
19091.29 FARLEY-BOUVIER19091.29 -19091.29 Well,19091.29 I19091.45 appreciate19091.61 that.19092.09 Just19092.41 letting19092.73 you19092.89 know19093.05 that19093.21 this19093.53 committee19093.77 is19094.09 not19094.25 averse19095.29 to19095.61 working19095.77 hard19096.09 to19096.33 get19096.41 it19096.57 right19096.76 in19097.06 message.19097.35 Right,19097.65 I19097.65 know.19097.95 And19098.24 I19098.54 appreciate19098.83 your19099.13 staff19099.42 for19099.72 that19100.01 as19100.31 well,19100.6 Chair.19100.9 We19101.78 look19102.08 forward19102.37 to19102.67 hearing19102.97 from19103.26 and19103.26 working19103.56 with19103.85 you19104.74 over19104.74 the19105.03 next19105.33 6019105.62 days.19105.92 Okay.19106.21 Sure.19106.51 Any19106.8 other19107.1 questions?19107.39 Representative19107.69 Vitolo.19108.28
VITOLO19108.28 -19108.28 I19108.28 very19108.57 much19108.95 appreciate19109.35 the19109.99 opportunity19110.31 in19111.43 insurance,19111.75 particularly19112.47 auto19112.87 insurance,19113.27 with19114.23 vocational19114.55 data19115.03 and19115.35 helping19115.67 drivers19116.31 learn19116.95 to19117.43 go19117.59 a19117.75 little19117.91 easier19118.07 on19118.39 the19118.55 gas,19118.63 a19118.87 little19118.95 easier19119.19 on19119.43 the19119.59 brake,19119.67 a19119.83 little19119.99 easier19120.23 on19120.47 the19120.63 steering19120.79 wheel19121.11 will19121.5 all19121.74 be19121.9 safer.19122.06 My19123.26 concern19123.58 is19124.38 data19126.31 retention.19126.7 So19128.15 that19129.03 data19129.26 is19129.5 useful19129.58 for19129.99 a19130.22 period19130.38 of19130.7 time,19130.94 but19131.82 are19133.26 you19133.42 gonna19133.58 hold19133.82 it19133.99 forever?19134.15 Even19134.86 if19135.1 you're19135.26 not19135.42 buying19135.58 it19135.82 or19135.99 selling19136.15 it,19136.38 the19136.54 longer19136.63 you19137 hold19137.16 it,19137.4 the19137.88 more19138.04 likely19138.28 someone19138.6 else19138.84 gets19139.16 it,19139.4 even19140.28 though19140.52 you19140.68 didn't19140.84 want19141.08 them19141.4 to19141.56 have19141.64 it.19141.8 And19143.08 so19143.48 so19144.12 my19144.36 hope19144.6 is19144.84 in19145.24 working19145.48 with19145.96 the19147.08 chairs19147.24 about19147.88 how19149.32 to19149.48 make19149.65 sure19149.81 we19150.13 have19150.38 sensible19151.33 and19151.81 appropriate19151.97 protection19153.1 for19153.74 motorists,19154.13 that19155.65 you19155.81 also19156.06 think19156.38 about19156.69 data19157.81 retention.19158.13 You19158.69 know,19158.85 if19158.93 119159.97 insurance19160.22 company,19160.61 you19161.41 know,19161.57 moves19162.05 that19162.21 customer19162.45 onto19162.85 an19163.17 affiliate,19163.33 well,19163.81 then19163.97 that19164.13 first19164.29 company19164.45 doesn't19164.77 need19165.01 that19165.17 data19165.33 anymore.19165.57 They19165.97 should19166.13 get19166.21 rid19166.37 of19166.45 it.19166.61 They19167.33 shouldn't19167.49 keep19168.05 it.19168.29 Right?19169.09 It19169.49 should.19170.21 If19170.37 you've19170.37 gotta19170.53 move19170.77 it19170.93 around,19171.09 don't19171.97 also19172.29 hold19172.61 on19172.85 to19173.01 it.19173.09 Right?19173.89 And19174.21 so19174.45 my19174.61 hope19174.77 is19175.01 that19175.17 as19175.41 you19175.49 think19175.65 through19175.97 this,19176.21 you19176.53 also19176.69 think19177.09 about19177.41 how19178.62 to19178.86 not19179.18 just19179.42 only19179.74 collect19179.99 the19180.38 data19180.47 you19180.78 need19180.94 but19181.82 also19182.06 only19182.06 hold19182.47 it19182.7 for19183.35 the19183.58 amount19183.66 of19183.9 time19183.99 for19184.22 which19184.38 it's19184.54 actually19184.94 useful19185.42 for19186.22 the19186.38 company19186.54 and19186.94 the19187.1 customer19187.26 to19188.14 work19188.47 out19188.7 a19188.86 better19188.94 insurance19189.18 rate.19189.66 And19189.82 after19190.06 that,19190.31 you19190.94 gotta19191.23 get19191.47 rid19191.55 of19192.31 it.19193.07
19193.07 STARK19193.07 -19193.07 Well,19193.71 and19194.03 I'll19194.83 say19194.99 219195.39 fold19195.63 on19195.95 that.19196.11 That's19196.35 a19196.91 concern19197.15 to19197.55 some19197.71 level.19197.87 1,19198.27 the19199.79 telematics,19200.03 the19200.75 quote19201.15 unquote19201.39 black19201.87 box19202.11 data19202.43 can19202.83 be19202.99 very19203.23 helpful19203.47 in19203.95 a19204.67 lot19204.74 of19204.99 claims19205.06 disputes.19205.47 And19206.5 so19206.74 I19207.54 think19207.7 we'd19207.79 have19208.03 to19208.18 be19208.27 careful19208.42 about19208.83 making19209.06 sure19209.38 that19209.54 we19209.7 preserve,19209.94 at19210.74 a19210.99 minimum,19211.06 this19211.63 data19211.79 for19213.54 any19213.79 claims19214.03 that19214.35 may19214.5 be19214.67 associated19214.83 with19216.42 it.19216.67 And19217.73 then19217.89 there19218.13 is19218.37 a19218.53 question.19218.69 I'll19219.09 go19219.41 back19219.49 to19219.73 my19219.81 members19219.97 on19220.29 this,19220.45 but19220.69 how19220.85 we19221.01 kind19221.25 of19221.49 are19221.81 are19222.05 able19222.37 to19222.69 manage19223.01 that19223.57 UBI19224.85 or19225.33 telematics19225.57 data19226.37 in19227.57 year-over-year19228.61 comparisons.19229.09 Now,19231.28 there19231.75 may19231.99 be19232.15 a19232.31 way,19232.4 and19232.63 again,19232.79 I'll19233.03 go19233.28 back19233.35 and19233.51 talk19233.67 to19233.92 them19233.99 about19234.15 this19234.4 is,19234.56 you19234.88 know,19235.28 is19235.51 there19235.6 a19235.83 way19235.92 to19236.79 deidentify19237.28 or19237.83 average19238.07 some19238.63 of19238.79 that19238.95 data19239.99 from,19240.47 you19240.88 know,19240.95 initial19241.43 application19241.83 at19242.4 the19242.47 end?19242.63 We'll19242.88 see.19243.11 But,19243.35 you19244.68 know,19244.76 those19244.92 are19245.24 kind19245.48 of19245.72 219245.88 of19246.12 my19246.2 initial19246.36 thoughts19246.68 that19246.92 come19247.08 to19247.32 mind19247.4 is,19247.64 1,19248.04 you're19248.28 going19248.52 to19248.68 wanna19248.76 have19249 something19249.16 else19249.48 to19249.72 compare19249.8 it19250.2 to.19250.28 2,19250.52 there19251.16 is19251.48 some19252.12 importance19252.36 to19253.08 this19253.56 data19253.88 for19254.28 claims19254.52 investigations.19254.92
19257.4 REP19257.4 OUELLETTE-19257.4 Thank19257.4 you.19257.64 Question19258.2 on19258.68 telemetrics.19258.84 Why19259.4 couldn't19259.69 you19259.85 just19260.01 use19260.17 a19260.65 serial19260.74 number19261.06 or19261.38 something19261.45 and19262.01 keep19262.17 the19262.42 personal19262.57 data19262.97 within19263.29 your19263.61 systems19264.17 at19264.74 the19264.97 insurance19265.38 companies?19265.85 In19267.29 other19267.45 words,19267.61 you're19267.78 worried19267.93 about19268.25 it19268.49 getting19268.57 out.19268.9 Keep19269.13 it19269.38 internal19269.53 in19270.01 your19270.25 information,19270.49 whatever19271.13 it19271.42 would19271.69 be19271.85 over19271.93 the19272.17 airwaves19272.42 or19272.9 whatever19273.06 have19273.38 you.19273.61 Why19273.93 wouldn't19274.1 you19274.33 just19274.58 have19274.66 a19274.78 serial19274.9 number19275.22 or19275.46 something19275.54 that19275.78 wouldn't19275.94 have19276.1 personal19276.26 data?19276.74
19280.34 STARK19280.34 -19280.34 I19280.34 think19280.58 we'll19280.82 have19280.98 to19281.22 look19281.3 into19281.46 that19281.78 because19281.94 I19282.18 do19282.26 think19282.42 that19282.66 that's19282.82 part19283.06 of19283.38 the19284.82 complaint19285.06 that19285.54 some19285.78 of19285.86 the19286.02 advocates19286.1 for19286.9 819287.78 78,19288.02 some19288.66 of19288.9 the19288.98 more19289.14 strenuous19289.38 requirements19291 have19291.49 is19291.72 that19291.89 even19292.13 when19292.45 we19292.68 work19292.85 to19293.08 de19293.33 identify19293.49 it,19293.97 that19295.08 people19295.33 may19295.72 be19295.89 able19296.04 to19296.29 put19296.37 those19296.53 pieces19296.77 back19297.17 together19297.41 again.19297.81 It19300.6 doesn't19300.85 mean19300.85 we19301 don't19301.17 do19301.41 anything,19301.49 but19302.77 I'm19303.46 happy19303.7 to19304.02 take19304.18 a19304.26 look19304.34 at19304.46 that19304.58 and19304.82 talk19304.9 to19305.06 my19305.14 folks19305.38 about19306.74 119307.14 what19307.14 that19307.38 takes.19307.54 Is19308.42 it19308.66 possible?19308.82 But19309.3 2,19309.46 if19311.22 somebody19312.1 got19312.66 this19312.82 data19313.06 through19313.54 nefarious19313.78 purposes19314.42 or19315.38 with19315.62 nefarious19315.78 purposes,19316.26 would19316.66 they19316.82 be19317.06 able19317.14 to19317.38 recreate19317.54 that19318.1 as19318.69 de-identified19319.1 data?19319.57 Yeah.19322.53
FARLEY-BOUVIER19323.01 -19323.01 Yeah.19323.01 Go19323.25 ahead.19323.41
19323.97 MOORE19323.97 -19323.97 So,19323.97 119324.06 quick19324.22 question19324.45 I19324.78 have.19324.85 So19325.01 you're19325.49 talking19325.74 about19326.06 whether19326.53 they19326.78 shut19327.01 it19327.25 off19327.33 at19327.49 the19327.65 state19327.81 line.19328.06 Well,19328.61 I19328.78 guess,19328.85 we've19329.89 seen19330.22 some19330.61 states19330.85 now19331.33 that19331.57 are19331.81 trying19331.97 to19332.29 criminalize19332.61 certain19334.28 aspects19334.68 of19337.24 access19337.24 to19337.56 health19337.96 for19338.28 women.19338.44 So19340.12 now19340.44 we19340.84 have19341.08 someone19341.24 that19341.8 travels19342.12 from19342.6 a19342.84 state19342.92 that19343.32 criminalizes,19343.48 comes19344.36 here,19344.68 whatever19345.96 health19347 procedure19347.32 she19348.25 perceives.19348.49 Now19349.78 she19350.1 go19350.33 now19350.65 she19350.97 goes19351.22 back19351.53 to19351.78 her19351.93 estate,19352.17 and19352.97 they19353.22 now19353.53 look19353.78 at19354.02 that19354.17 location19354.42 and19355.29 say,19355.53 okay.19355.78 Now19355.93 we're19356.1 gonna19356.33 criminally19356.49 prosecute19356.97 her.19357.45 So19359.06 you19359.29 don't.19359.45 We19359.61 wouldn't19359.78 want19360.1 that.19360.33 Well,19361.28 you,19361.44 exactly.19361.68 No.19362.16 I19362.48 don't19362.64 think19362.8 anyone.19363.04 So19363.52 there's19364.24 no19364.4 way19364.64 with19364.96 technology.19365.2 I19366.56 mean,19366.72 technology19367.04 is19367.52 being19367.68 used19367.92 to19368.24 always19368.4 benefit19368.72 businesses,19370.56 profits,19372.16 increasing19373.68 employees,19374.24 or19374.96 whatever19375.44 the19375.76 so-called19376.16 benefit19376.32 is.19376.72 But19377.31 when19377.54 it19377.58 comes19377.63 to19377.94 protecting19378.1 someone's19378.5 privacy19378.99 or19379.54 protecting19379.79 someone's19380.18 rights,19380.58 we19380.9 can't19381.06 use19381.31 it19381.54 to19381.7 utilize19381.7 that19382.1 technology19382.42 in19383.22 a19383.39 way19383.47 that19383.7 it's19384.5 gonna19384.74 protect19384.99 those19385.31 rights.19385.54
19386.42 SPEAKER1119386.42 -19386.42 Well,19386.42 no.19386.58
19386.74 STARK19386.74 -19386.74 I19386.74 think19387.06 that19387.39 we19388.1 do,19388.35 you19389.7 know,19389.87 even19390.1 even19390.42 to19390.67 a19390.83 protection19390.99 level.19391.47 I19391.79 can19391.87 tell19392.03 you19392.27 that19392.42 when19393.17 it19393.33 comes19393.41 to19393.81 the19394.05 data19394.29 protection19394.61 laws19395.09 in19395.33 the19395.49 state,19395.57 especially19395.81 as19396.21 they19396.37 govern19396.53 insurance,19397.09 the19397.57 AG's19398.21 office19398.69 has19399.01 more19399.57 than19399.81 enough19400.05 resources19400.85 to19401.49 check19401.65 in19401.97 on19401.97 us.19402.13
MOORE19403.57 -19403.57 But19403.57 do19403.81 you19403.89 see19403.97 what19404.13 I'm19404.21 getting19404.37 at?19404.61
19404.85 STARK19404.85 -19404.85 Yeah.19404.85 No.19405.01 Because19405.41 I19405.81 do19405.89 think19406.61 that19407.01 there19407.17 has,19407.41 you19407.65 know,19407.86 I'll19407.94 go19408.31 back19408.35 to19408.66 my19408.74 members19408.9 and19409.22 see,19409.38 you19409.7 know,19409.78 exactly19410.5 what19410.9 I19411.31 do19411.38 know19411.54 that19411.7 119411.86 of19412.03 the19412.18 challenges19412.5 that19413.06 we19413.31 have19413.47 with19413.86 this19414.03 is,19414.35 like,19415.54 the19415.86 shield19416.03 act19416.35 for19416.5 instance,19416.74 and19416.99 just19417.14 some19417.38 of19417.54 the19417.62 kind19417.78 of19418.03 general19418.35 thoughts19418.74 out19419.14 there19419.22 about19419.38 this19419.62 is,19419.78 We19420.22 don't19420.46 know19420.82 where,19421.18 you19423.18 know,19423.34 any19423.58 reproductive19423.98 clinic19424.62 might19425.02 be,19425.18 or19425.5 LGBT19425.82 bar,19427.02 or19427.58 protest19428.62 that19429.18 is19429.58 going19430.22 on19430.54 at19430.7 any19430.86 given19431.1 time,19431.42 through19432.14 this.19432.46 And19432.62 so,19432.86 I19433.1 think19433.18 that's19433.74 where,19433.98 you19435.83 know,19435.92 it'd19436.63 be19436.88 difficult19437.03 to19437.51 make19437.6 sure,19437.83 you19438.07 know,19438.15 I19438.31 know19438.47 some19438.63 of19438.79 the,19438.88 ideas19439.92 have19440.47 been19440.56 about19440.79 making19440.95 sure19441.28 that,19441.51 you19441.67 know,19441.75 in19442.15 those19442.4 spaces,19442.72 location19443.92 data19444.31 isn't19444.63 collected.19444.88 But,19445.19 again,19445.35 that's19445.67 difficult19445.92 for19446.47 us19446.79 because19447.03 we're19447.28 not19447.51 collecting19447.83 it19448.03 for19448.23 those19448.55 purposes.19448.79 So19449.67 how19449.83 do19449.99 you19450.15 know19450.23 where19450.47 all19451.35 of19451.51 these,19451.75 you19452.07 know,19452.31 necessary19452.63 locations19453.19 may19453.67 have19453.83 been19453.91 as19454.07 well?19454.23
19454.55 FARLEY-BOUVIER19454.55 -19454.55 So19454.55 just19454.71 to19454.87 reiterate,19455.03 and19455.59 then,19455.75 you19455.99 know,19456.07 I19456.31 would19456.47 need19456.71 to19456.87 move19457.03 on.19457.19 But19457.43 to19459.19 collect19459.43 it19459.75 for19459.91 your19460.56 purposes19460.63 is19461.91 119462.15 thing.19462.4 To19463.19 sell19463.43 it19463.83 because19464.24 you19464.63 don't19464.88 know19465.11 who's19465.35 gonna19465.67 use19465.91 it,19466.07 right,19466.79 for19467.19 something19467.35 else.19467.67 You19467.99 don't19468.15 know19468.31 their19468.56 purposes,19468.72 and19469.6 so19469.83 don't19470.31 sell19470.56 it.19470.79 That's19471.43 what19471.67 we're19471.91 saying.19472.07 We19473.6 were19473.75 banning19473.91 the19474.4 sale19475.83 and19476.61 purchase19476.85 of19477.49 data.19477.97 That's19478.29 what19478.53 H19478.85 7819479.09 says.19479.89 Okay.19480.85 I19481.09 really19481.41 do19481.65 appreciate19481.81 it,19482.21 and19482.21 I19482.37 hope19482.45 you19482.93 will19483.09 stay19483.25 in19483.41 touch19483.49 with19483.57 us.19483.65
19483.73 SPEAKER2619483.73 -19483.73 Yeah,19483.73 absolutely.19483.97
19484.29 SPEAKER2819484.29 -19484.29 Thank19484.29 you.19484.45 Thank19484.69 you.19484.93
19485.65 FARLEY-BOUVIER19485.65 -19485.65 We're19485.65 going19485.89 to19486.05 move19486.21 to19486.53 Emily19486.93 Anesta.19487.57 And19488.93 I19489.65 don't19490.61 know19491.01 if19491.25 Dan19491.72 Daniel19492.12 Wolfe19492.6 is19492.99 still19493.16 online.19493.4 If19493.95 not,19494.2 then19495.08 we19495.31 would19495.47 then19495.72 go19496.04 to19496.2 Robert19496.35 Stroke.19496.83 Hello.19498.68 Welcome.19499.47 Hi.19500.28 Thank19500.6 you19500.75 for19500.83 your19501.08 patience19501.24 today.19501.64
19502.12 EMILY19502.12 ANESTA19502.12 -19502.12 BAY19502.12 STATE19502.12 BIRTH19502.12 COALITION19502.12 -19502.12 HB19502.12 7819502.12 -19502.12 HB19502.12 10419502.12 -19502.12 SB19502.12 4519502.12 -19502.12 SB19502.12 19719502.12 -19502.12 Thank19502.12 you19502.35 so19502.68 much,19502.83 chairs19503.88 and19504.35 members19504.6 of19504.99 the19505.08 committee.19505.24 As19506.99 you19507.32 know,19507.4 my19507.56 name19507.64 is19507.72 Emily19507.96 Anesta.19508.36 I19509 lead19509.24 an19509.56 organization19509.72 called19510.52 the19510.84 Bay19511.64 State19511.64 Birth19511.64 Coalition.19511.96 We're19513.48 a19513.8 consumer-led19514.44 grassroots19514.84 nonprofit19515.56 seeking19517 to19517.4 improve19517.64 maternal19518.04 health19518.44 care,19518.68 especially19519.08 access19519.64 to19520.2 community-based19521.96 care,19522.28 midwives,19523.11 and19523.51 birth19523.75 centers19524.07 in19524.47 Massachusetts.19524.72 Many19525.99 of19526.24 you19526.39 know19526.56 me19526.79 as19527.03 a19527.28 maternal19527.43 health19527.83 advocate,19528.56 but19529.35 you19529.51 may19529.67 not19529.91 know19530.15 that19530.31 I19530.56 have19530.63 a19530.79 master's19530.95 and19531.35 a19531.6 bachelor's19531.6 in19532.07 electrical19532.24 and19532.72 computer19532.87 engineering19533.28 from19534.24 Northeastern19534.47 and19535.19 WPI,19535.35 and19535.99 I19536.15 spent19536.31 2019536.63 years19536.95 working19537.28 on19537.67 new19537.91 research19538.47 technology19539.48 and19539.96 development,19540.2 both19541.4 commercial19541.72 and19542.36 government-funded.19543.16 I'm19544.36 here19544.52 today19544.76 to19545.08 share19545.24 my19545.48 support19545.72 for19546.12 and19546.92 my19547.24 plea19547.48 for19547.72 urgency19547.96 on19548.6 consumer19548.84 privacy19549.32 broadly19549.8 and19550.99 banning19551.24 location19551.64 data,19552.2 in19552.75 particular,19552.99 the19554.52 location19554.68 shield19555.24 act19555.56 H19556.04 86,19556.43 S19557.47 197,19558.04 and19558.04 the19558.2 comprehensive19558.35 data19558.99 privacy19559.24 bills19559.79 H19560.2 78,19560.43 H19562.35 104,19562.6 S19562.6 29,19562.6 and19563.08 S19563.24 45.19563.47 As19564.89 a19564.97 resident19565.21 of19565.53 Massachusetts,19565.77 an19566.65 engineer,19566.97 a19567.61 maternal19567.69 health19568.09 advocate,19568.41 a19568.89 woman,19569.05 and19569.69 a19570.17 mother,19570.33 I19570.97 am19571.13 terrified.19571.37 Like19572.49 everyone,19572.73 I19573.29 ring19573.45 my19573.69 phone19573.93 everywhere.19574.49 And19575.37 as19575.61 my19575.85 children19576.01 get19576.49 older19577.21 and19578.66 have19578.9 their19579.06 own19579.31 devices,19579.47 I'm19579.94 worried19580.1 about19580.42 their19580.66 privacy19580.9 as19581.47 well.19581.54 Even19583.78 with19584.1 my19584.26 technical19584.5 expertise19585.54 and19586.1 awareness,19586.26 I19586.99 find19587.14 it19587.38 impossible19587.7 to19588.74 protect19588.9 my19589.62 privacy19589.86 while19590.49 participating19590.73 in19591.45 modern19591.69 society.19593.69 Opting19594.17 out19594.49 of19594.65 location19594.81 tracking,19595.37 as19595.77 you19595.93 know,19596.01 it's19596.25 unrealistic.19596.73 It's19597.53 impossible.19597.69
19598.49 We19598.49 use19598.73 our19598.89 phones19599.13 to19599.37 stay19599.53 connected,19599.77 to19600.81 pay19600.97 for19601.21 things,19601.37 and19602.67 to19602.9 do19602.99 everything,19603.22 including19603.78 keeping19604.26 in19604.5 touch19604.67 with19604.9 our19605.15 children19605.22 and19605.63 vulnerable19605.86 family19606.42 members.19606.74 And19607.54 self-regulation19608.1 by19608.67 industry19608.9 does19609.47 not19609.63 work.19609.94 It's19611.15 really19611.38 incumbent19612.26 upon19612.74 governments,19613.22 and19613.78 I'm19614.1 so19614.42 grateful19614.58 for19615.15 the19615.38 attention19615.78 you19616.18 all19616.5 are19616.58 paying19616.74 to19616.98 this,19617.34 to19617.94 put19618.1 up19618.34 the19618.42 guardrails19618.58 to19619.14 prevent19619.3 the19619.7 exploitation19619.86 of19620.42 our19620.58 most19620.74 personal19621.06 details19621.46 and19622.66 everything19622.9 that19623.22 can19623.38 be19623.62 inferred19623.86 from19625.06 that19625.3 data.19625.54 The19627.54 technologies19627.7 and19628.34 the19628.5 data19628.66 exploitations19629.18 are19629.74 novel,19630.06 and19630.63 the19630.86 solutions19631.03 must19631.67 be19631.9 as19632.31 well.19632.54 In19633.67 addition19633.9 to19634.22 the19634.38 many19634.54 important19634.78 issues19635.18 raised19635.5 today,19635.82 please19636.7 all19636.94 also19637.27 understand19637.67 that19638.06 this19638.22 has19638.38 important19638.7 implications19639.18 for19639.9 maternal19640.22 health19640.78 and19641.5 for19641.67 our19641.99 state's19642.15 progress19643.05 that,19643.69 and19644.41 wonderful19644.57 work19644.97 that's19645.37 happening19645.77 here,19646.09 to19647.05 improve19647.21 health19648.25 outcomes19648.65 and19649.13 end19649.37 racial19649.61 inequities19649.93 for19650.73 mothers19651.05 and19651.37 babies.19651.61
19652.97 Privacy19652.97 fears19653.45 and19653.77 threats19653.93 can19654.73 protect19654.97 our19655.45 most19655.61 vulnerable19655.85 mothers19656.41 from19656.97 accessing19657.29 necessary19658.67 maternal19659.72 health19660.11 care,19660.43 putting19660.75 birthing19661.07 people19661.47 and19661.79 their19661.95 pregnancies19662.19 at19662.67 risk.19662.83 People19663.88 deserve19664.19 and,19664.6 in19664.75 fact,19664.92 require19665.31 privacy19665.79 when19666.35 they're19666.52 seeking19666.67 prenatal19667.07 care,19667.47 giving19668.28 birth,19668.52 needing19669.31 emergency19669.88 care19670.67 for19670.99 an19671.15 alarming19671.31 pregnancy19671.94 complication,19672.5 and19673.7 receiving19674.02 essential19674.66 postpartum19675.3 care.19675.94 And19676.82 this19677.14 includes19677.38 immigrant19678.58 mothers,19679.14 undocumented19679.86 mothers,19680.66 LGBTQ19681.22 birthing19682.18 people,19682.58 people19683.46 who've19683.7 been19683.94 victims19684.18 of19684.9 domestic19685.06 violence19685.46 and19685.86 stalking,19686.1 and19687.12 birthing19687.12 people19687.43 who19687.68 may19687.92 have19688.08 experienced19688.24 sexual19688.79 assault.19689.28 We19690.88 also19691.04 have19691.35 to19691.43 think19691.6 about19691.83 health19692.08 care19692.31 providers'19692.56 own19693.12 data,19693.35 which19693.83 is19693.99 a19694.16 concern19694.31 for19694.72 them19694.95 and19695.28 the19695.43 families19695.6 that19696.08 they19696.24 care19696.4 for.19696.64 This19697.75 threat19697.99 impacts19698.4 our.19699.35 Oh,19699.83 I'm19699.83 sorry.19699.92 Time's19700.4 up.19700.72 Anyway,19702.43 freedom19703.31 of19703.63 movement19703.87 also19704.35 reveals19704.75 a19705.15 person's19705.23 pregnancy19705.63 status.19706.19 These19706.51 are19706.67 all19706.83 concerns.19707.07 A19708.35 novel19708.43 approach19708.75 is19709.07 what's19709.23 needed19709.47 to19709.79 meet19710.43 the19710.67 moment,19710.75 not19711.15 stale19711.95 approaches19712.35 that19712.91 lag19713.23 the19713.63 technology.19713.79 So19714.51 thank19714.75 you.19714.91
19715.23 FARLEY-BOUVIER19715.23 -19715.23 Thank19715.23 you.19715.55 Thank19715.87 you.19716.11 Any19716.35 comments19716.67 or19717.07 questions19717.23 from19717.63 the19717.79 committee?19717.95 Thank19718.89 you.19719.13 I19719.37 don't19719.68 know19719.85 about19720.08 you.19720.33 Go19720.33 ahead.19720.56
MESCHINO-19720.81 You19720.81 seem19720.97 to19721.13 hesitate.19721.29 What19721.85 was19722 the19722.24 other19722.41 sentence19722.65 you19722.97 wanted19723.2 to19723.6 share19723.77 with19724 us?19724.17 I19724.33 just19724.49 wanna19724.65 hear19724.89 it.19725.04 I19725.04 think19725.29 it's19725.45 important19725.68 that19726.17 you19726.17 just19726.33 brought19726.56 in19726.81 a19726.97 different19727.04 perspective.19727.45 And19728.08 I19728.17 just19728.33 thought19728.49 it19728.65 was19728.72 an19728.81 important19728.97 piece,19729.2 and19729.45 I19729.6 just19729.68 wanted19729.85 to19730.08 hear19730.17 what19730.33 it19730.49 was19730.65 you19730.89 omitted.19731.29
ANESTA19732.86 -19732.86 Thanks.19732.86 I19733.26 was.19734.22 The19734.62 other19734.62 couple19734.94 of19735.26 quick19735.26 things19735.5 I19735.74 was19735.82 gonna19735.98 say19736.3 was19736.46 that19736.7 data19737.74 exploitation19738.06 can19738.54 reveal19738.7 a19739.02 person's19739.1 pregnancy19739.5 status,19740.06 so19740.46 that19740.62 can19740.86 potentially19741.02 expose19741.66 this19742.06 private19742.22 information19742.62 to19743.18 an19743.34 employer,19743.5 family19744.54 member,19744.94 or19745.26 abuser.19745.42 The19747.66 novel19747.82 approach19748.22 is19748.54 what's19748.7 needed19748.94 to19749.18 meet19749.35 this19749.58 moment19749.74 because19750.7 the19751.03 privacy19751.18 risks19752.06 are19752.47 cutting-edge19753.82 and19754.06 always19754.22 evolving.19754.62 And19755.26 so19756.06 we19757.03 should19757.66 not19757.9 be19758.14 looking19758.31 to19758.54 steal19758.7 solutions.19759.18 We19759.74 should19759.9 be19760.14 looking19760.22 to19760.54 lead19760.78 in19761.03 Massachusetts19761.26 on19762.55 data19762.79 privacy19763.03 and19763.51 location19763.75 data19764.15 in19764.47 particular19764.63 to19765.11 protect19765.27 maternal19765.59 health,19766.07 reproductive19766.63 justice,19767.27 and19767.67 human19767.83 rights.19768.07
19768.55 FARLEY-BOUVIER19768.55 -19768.55 Thanks19768.71 very19769.03 much.19769.11 Thank19769.27 you.19769.43 It's19769.67 really19769.91 helpful.19770.15 Thank19770.47 you.19770.71 Appreciate19770.79 it.19771.19 So19772.55 just19772.87 checking,19773.91 we19774.47 don't19774.63 see19774.87 Daniel19775.03 Wolf19775.43 still19775.91 with19776.15 us19776.31 online,19776.47 so19776.87 we're19777.03 gonna19777.27 move19777.51 to19777.67 Robert19777.91 Stroke.19778.36 And19779.32 then,19779.64 back19780.68 online19781.32 with19781.97 Lee19782.2 Hefner.19782.6
19793.5 SPEAKER2219793.5 -19793.5 Thank19793.5 you.19793.74
FARLEY-BOUVIER19794.14 -19794.14 Hello,19794.14 and19794.46 welcome,19794.7 and19795.1 thank19795.26 you19795.34 for19795.5 your19795.66 patience.19795.9 I19796.22 feel19796.38 like19796.62 you've19796.7 been19796.94 here19797.1 all19797.26 afternoon.19797.42 Yes?19797.9
19798.3 SPEAKER2919798.3 -19798.3 I19798.3 have19798.46 been.19798.62 Yeah.19798.94
19799.98 SPEAKER319799.98 -19799.98 Because19799.98 it's19800.22 been19800.38 fascinating.19800.78
BOBBY19801.74 STROOP19801.74 -19801.74 HARVARD19801.74 LAW19801.74 STROOP19801.74 -19801.74 HB19801.74 10319801.74 -19801.74 It's19801.74 been19802.06 very19802.22 interesting.19802.46 I'm19803.9 actually19804.06 I'm19804.46 here19804.86 to19806.35 speak19806.5 on19806.74 H19807.78 103,19808.26 an19808.26 act19808.5 established19808.74 in19809.14 Massachusetts19809.31 Neural19809.86 Data19810.26 Privacy19810.58 Protection19811.14 Act.19811.54 And19812.5 thank19812.82 you,19812.99 Representative19813.22 Owens,19813.78 for19814.26 telling19814.58 me19814.82 about19814.99 this19815.22 hearing19815.38 when19815.62 I19815.78 was19815.94 reaching19816.1 out,19816.35 actually,19816.5 about19816.9 a19817.14 different19817.22 tech19817.78 policy19818.1 issue.19818.5 My19820.49 name19820.65 is19820.73 Bobby19820.89 Stroop.19821.21 I'm19821.61 a19821.77 third-year19822.09 law19822.33 student19822.49 at19822.81 Harvard19822.97 Law19823.29 School,19823.53 and19824.17 I'm19824.33 here19824.41 in19824.65 my19824.73 individual19824.89 capacity19825.37 to19826.17 share19826.33 what19826.57 I've19826.65 learned19826.89 from19827.13 my19827.29 conversations19827.53 with19828.09 innovative19828.33 entrepreneurs19828.81 and19829.77 in19830.01 my19830.17 own19830.33 bioethics19830.65 research.19831.29 I19832.35 would19832.5 consider19832.67 myself19833.15 a19833.54 futurist.19833.87 I'm19834.5 constantly19834.83 thinking19835.15 about19835.47 the19835.63 world19835.79 in19836.43 which19836.67 technologists19837.7 are19838.43 going19838.67 to19838.91 be19838.99 developing19839.22 products19839.7 and19840.1 the19840.35 world19840.5 in19840.74 which19840.83 my19841.06 baby19841.31 daughter19841.63 will19842.1 grow19842.35 up.19842.58 I'm19843.39 thinking19843.54 about19843.87 all19844.1 of19844.27 us.And19845.21 we19845.53 stand19845.61 on19846.01 the19846.17 shoulders19846.33 of19846.73 data19846.97 privacy19847.29 advocates19847.69 going19848.25 back19848.49 to19848.81 the19849.13 Harvard19849.13 Law19849.37 Review19849.61 article19849.93 in19850.25 1890,19850.49 the19852.01 right19852.17 to19852.49 privacy.19852.65
19853.29 I19853.29 brought19853.45 it19853.61 up19853.77 today.19854.01 And,19854.65 unsurprisingly,19855.29 the19856.17 right19856.57 has19856.81 evolved19856.97 since19857.53 then.19857.77 So19858.7 my19858.87 work19859.1 specifically19859.43 focuses19859.99 on19860.47 BCI19861.43 or19861.91 brain-computer19862.31 interfaces,19862.7 and19863.58 specifically19863.91 even19864.39 within19864.63 that19864.87 consumer19865.27 neurotech.19865.91 A19867.18 brain19867.27 computer19867.5 interface19867.91 or19868.39 BCI19868.54 is19868.95 a19869.03 device19869.18 that19869.43 allows19869.58 a19869.91 user19870.06 to19870.31 control19870.47 the19871.13 computer19871.13 using19871.53 only19871.93 their19872.25 brain19872.41 activity.19872.73 And19873.53 non19873.77 implantable19874.09 BCI19874.65 is19875.53 a19875.77 commercial19875.85 shelf19876.65 product.19876.89 It19877.45 doesn't19877.53 require19877.85 surgery.19878.25 It19878.97 looks19879.21 like19879.53 AirPods.19879.77 It19880.33 might19880.49 be19880.73 headphones,19881.13 something19881.69 along19882.09 those19882.33 nature,19882.57 that19883.29 nature.19883.53 And19884.74 there19885.38 are19885.63 incredible19885.63 capabilities.19886.42 Duke19887.7 law19887.94 professor19888.18 Nina19888.5 Farahani19888.9 wrote19889.47 in19889.7 her19889.86 02/202319890.03 book,19890.99 an19891.47 average19891.7 tech-savvy19892.42 person19892.74 can19893.15 now19893.31 see19893.63 their19893.78 emotions,19894.03 arousal,19894.67 and19895.15 alertness19895.31 and19896.03 track19896.26 how19896.5 effectively19896.74 they19897.38 are19897.54 meditating.19897.78 The19899.37 Neural19899.53 Rights19899.85 Foundation,19900.17 upon19900.73 which19900.97 I've19901.21 actually19901.61 built19902.09 a19902.49 lot19902.57 of19902.81 my19902.97 own19903.21 research,19903.37 although19905.05 not19905.45 affiliated,19905.53 they'd19906.57 mentioned19906.81 thought19907.29 to19907.53 text,19907.69 where19908.57 researchers19908.97 have19909.61 seen19909.77 you19910.01 can19910.17 think19910.33 of19910.57 specific19910.73 letters19911.13 or19911.45 even19911.61 whole19911.85 words19912.09 and19912.1 translate19912.12 that19912.13 into19912.15 text.19912.17
19912.18 And19912.18 generative19912.19 AI19912.21 is19912.22 only19912.24 going19912.25 to19912.27 further19912.29 the19912.3 capabilities19912.31 of19912.33 neurotech,19912.58 and19919.1 investments19919.35 are19920.15 in19920.31 the19920.47 billions19920.63 of19920.94 dollars.19921.1 This19921.5 is19921.67 going19921.83 to19922.06 be19922.15 huge.19922.7 Representative19924.79 Vitolo,19925.5 I19927.08 believe19927.24 in19927.48 you.19927.56 I19927.88 believe19928.04 in19928.28 all19928.44 of19928.6 you.19928.76 I'm19929.96 less19930.2 confident19930.68 in19931.88 the19932.12 federal19932.36 government19932.84 to19933.4 address19933.56 this19933.96 issue.19934.12 Chair19934.76 Moore,19935 you19935.16 mentioned.19935.32 Thank19935.64 you.19935.88 You're19936.44 so19937.08 sorry.19937.24 Chair19938.68 Moore,19939 you19939.32 mentioned19939.64 HIPAA19939.96 earlier.19940.76 HIPAA19941.26 doesn't19941.58 cover19941.74 consumer19942.14 neurotech,19942.54 and19943.18 that's19943.35 specific19943.66 because19944.06 it19944.31 only19944.47 applies19944.7 to19945.18 covered19945.42 entities.19946.06 That's19946.54 health19946.94 plans,19947.18 health19947.74 care19947.99 clearing19948.14 houses,19948.47 and19948.78 health19948.94 care19949.18 providers.19949.5 Additionally,19950.62 the19951.5 FDA19951.74 doesn't19952.38 cover19952.7 consumer19952.94 neurotech19953.35 because19953.82 it's19954.06 not19954.14 a19954.31 medical19954.47 device,19954.78 and19955.37 that's19955.45 only19955.69 in19955.85 regard19955.93 to19956.25 physical19956.41 medical19956.81 safety.19957.13 To19958.09 summarize19958.25 the19958.65 relevant19958.73 portion19959.13 of19959.53 that19959.61 act,19959.85 if19960.33 it's19960.49 not19960.65 medical19960.81 treatment19961.13 or19961.45 advice,19961.69 it's19962.09 not19962.25 a19962.49 medical19962.57 device.19962.97 The19963.85 health19964.09 and19964.09 wellness19964.25 exception19964.73 is19965.13 for19965.37 low-risk19965.69 products19965.93 that19966.25 promote19966.33 a19966.73 healthy19966.81 lifestyle19967.21 in19968.17 which19968.33 consumer19968.65 neurotech19969.21 exists.19969.77 And19973.1 essentially,19973.18 even19974.14 with19974.29 discretionary19974.85 enforcement,19975.49 the19976.06 FTC19976.29 probably19977.1 can't19977.49 even19977.74 write19978.54 correct19978.85 rules19979.25 on19979.58 data19979.74 privacy19979.97 specifically19980.54 for19981.18 neurotech19982.22 and19982.7 some19982.85 of19983.02 the19983.1 rights19983.18 that19983.49 we19983.66 need.19984.14 I19985.42 know19985.7 that19985.94 it19986.1 gets19986.34 cold19986.5 in19986.74 Massachusetts,19986.82 and19987.46 I'd19987.7 frankly19987.86 rather19988.26 have19988.5 a19988.66 patchwork19988.74 quilt19989.22 than19989.46 nothing19989.62 at19989.86 all.19990.02
19991.3 SPEAKER1119991.3 -19991.3 Wow.19991.3 There19991.62 you19991.86 go.19992.02
19992.34 SPEAKER519992.34 -19992.34 Thank19992.34 you.19992.66 Thanks.19992.98
19993.26 FARLEY-BOUVIER19993.26 -19993.26 I19993.26 really19993.54 appreciate19993.86 this19994.34 perspective.19994.58 Thank19995.3 you.19995.54 I19995.7 really19995.78 do.19996.02 I19996.18 really19996.42 appreciate19996.5 your19997.06 patience19997.3 today.19997.7 At19998.34 least19998.5 I19998.74 hope19998.82 it19999.06 was,19999.22 it19999.94 was,20000.02 a20000.58 learning20000.66 experience20001.06 for20001.56 you.20001.65 I20001.81 just20001.97 wanna20002.04 check20002.44 with20002.6 the20002.77 committee.20002.85 Senator?20003.56
MOORE20005.4 -20005.4 If20005.4 you20005.56 have20005.81 some20006.04 spare20006.36 time20006.68 in20007 your20007.17 studies.20007.88 If20008.13 you20008.2 could20008.36 actually20008.6 put20008.85 something20009.08 in20009.32 writing20009.49 to20009.72 us20009.81 absolutely.20010.13 That20010.53 would20010.68 help20010.85 us20011 as20011.24 we20011.49 look20011.65 at20011.81 the20011.88 legislation20011.97 for20012.85 any20013 possible20013.32 changes20013.66 that20013.98 may20014.38 be20014.62 necessary.20014.78 But20015.58 thank20015.74 you.20015.9
20016.22 SPEAKER2220016.22 -20016.22 Thank20016.22 you.20016.38 Representative20017.34 Cohen?20017.82
20018.14 OWENS20018.14 -20018.14 Yeah.20018.14 Thanks20019.02 so20019.18 much20019.34 for20019.5 coming20019.66 out20019.9 today.20020.14 I'm20020.7 sorry20020.86 that20021.1 I20021.26 clued20021.34 you20021.58 into20021.74 this20021.9 and20022.06 you20022.22 had20022.3 to20022.46 come20022.54 all20023.02 day.20023.42 So,20023.58 my20023.74 condolences20023.98 and20024.62 apologies20024.86 as20025.42 well,20025.58 but20025.74 I20026.14 hope20026.14 you20026.3 learned20026.7 something.20027.02 And20027.5 thank20028.02 you20028.25 for20028.42 coming20028.58 out.20028.9 We'll20029.14 be20029.29 in20029.38 touch.20029.54 Absolutely.20029.85 Thank20030.18 you.20030.33 Representative20031.14 Mesquite.20031.69
20032.18 MESCHINO-20032.18 Just20032.18 because20032.33 you're20032.58 a20032.74 law20032.81 school20033.06 student20033.38 and20033.78 it's20033.93 all20034.1 positive,20034.33 the20035.62 thing20035.85 that20036.1 keeps20036.58 coming20036.97 up20037.22 is20037.85 this20038.1 idea20038.33 of20038.74 abuse20038.9 of20039.22 courts.20039.29 And20039.69 I20039.85 just20039.93 wanted20040.39 on20040.55 the20040.63 record20040.71 that,20041.27 you20043.03 know,20043.19 I'm20044.07 licensed20044.31 in20044.79 220044.95 different20045.11 jurisdictions,20045.51 and20046.15 you20046.39 have20046.55 to20046.71 have20046.87 a20047.59 color20047.75 blue20048.07 claim.20048.31 You20048.71 have20048.87 to20049.11 have,20049.19 you20050.39 know,20050.47 evidence20050.79 to20051.35 support20051.51 it.20052.4 You20052.72 have20052.81 to20052.97 get20053.04 past20053.36 all20053.6 your20053.85 motions20054 to20054.32 dismiss.20054.49 Then20055.28 you20055.44 have20055.6 to20055.76 be20055.92 able20056.08 to20056.32 make20056.4 your20056.49 case.20056.72 And20057.04 so20057.68 this20057.92 idea20058.08 that20058.64 somehow,20059.12 consumer20060.64 protection20061.12 and20062.08 class20062.49 actions20062.72 are20063.28 an20063.44 abuse20063.6 of20064.4 the20064.49 court20064.64 system,20064.88 and20065.44 you20065.6 just20065.76 triggered20065.92 the20066.32 thought.20066.49 I20066.81 was20066.88 trying20067.13 not20067.45 to20067.61 add20067.77 to20068.09 the20068.25 hearing20068.41 because20068.65 it20068.97 was20069.05 so20069.29 late.20069.45 So20070.09 I20070.25 kept20070.41 that20070.57 to20070.81 myself,20070.89 but20071.21 you20071.37 triggered20071.53 the20071.85 thought20072.01 when20072.25 you20072.41 were20072.57 referring20072.65 to20072.97 the20073.13 law20073.29 review20073.45 articles20073.85 and20074.33 rights20074.57 to20074.89 privacy,20075.05 and20075.61 this20076.09 is20076.33 very20076.49 much20076.73 grounded20076.97 in20078.09 all20078.73 of20078.97 our20079.77 6020080.01 years20080.33 of20080.73 jurisdiction.20080.89 So,20081.61 and20082.57 jurisprudence.20083.12 So20083.68 I20083.92 just20083.99 wanted20084.24 to20084.47 say20084.56 that20084.72 on20084.88 the20085.04 record,20085.2 and20085.52 thank20085.68 you20085.83 for20086.08 reminding20086.24 me20086.64 to20086.79 say20086.95 it.20087.12 Thank20087.83 you.20087.99
20087.99 FARLEY-BOUVIER20087.99 -20087.99 Thank20088.31 you.20088.56 Anybody20088.95 else?20089.43 Great.20089.99 Thanks20090.31 again.20090.64 Appreciate20090.95 your20091.43 testimony20091.6 today.20092.16
20092.56 SPEAKER2220092.56 -20092.56 Thank20092.56 you20092.72 for20092.79 the20092.95 time.20093.12
FARLEY-BOUVIER20095.04 -20095.04 We're20095.04 now20095.35 going20095.6 back20095.92 online20096.24 is20096.88 Lee20097.28 Hepner,20098.5 with20098.9 us20099.14 online.20099.38 And20099.86 then20100.02 we20100.34 have20100.58 Kelvin20101.14 Green.20101.7
LEE20105.14 HEPNER20105.14 -20105.14 AMERICAN20105.14 ECONOMIC20105.14 LIBERTIES20105.14 PROJECTS20105.14 -20105.14 HB20105.14 9920105.14 -20105.14 SB20105.14 4720105.14 -20105.14 (20105.14 R20105.14 )20105.14 Good20105.14 evening,20105.54 Chairs20106.26 Arlie20106.82 Bouvier20107.22 and20108.02 Moore.20108.58 Thank20109.99 you20110.22 for20110.47 engaging20110.87 in20111.27 a20111.67 remarkable20111.91 hearing20112.39 today.20112.63 I've20112.87 been20113.18 tuning20113.99 in20114.31 for20114.47 most20114.63 of20114.87 it,20114.95 but20115.18 it's20115.35 a20116.22 breadth20116.54 of20116.87 work,20116.95 and20117.1 I've20117.27 actually20117.43 learned20117.74 quite20117.99 a20118.22 bit.20118.31 My20118.54 name20118.63 is20118.79 Lee20118.95 Hepner.20119.18 I'm20120.06 an20120.15 antitrust20120.39 attorney20121.03 and20121.83 senior20121.99 legal20122.39 counsel20122.7 at20123.18 the20123.35 American20123.5 Economic20123.99 Liberties20124.47 Project.20125.06 We're20125.54 a20125.86 nonprofit,20126.1 nonpartisan20126.98 research20127.54 and20127.78 advocacy20128.1 group20128.58 that20128.98 seeks20129.14 to20129.38 understand20129.54 what20130.1 you're20130.26 doing.20130.5 Oh,20131.54 I'm20131.86 sorry.20132.02 Was20132.34 that20132.58 I20132.9 just20133.06 heard20133.3 an20133.54 echo20133.62 there.20133.94 Can20134.5 you20134.66 hear20134.74 me20134.98 alright?20135.06
20135.62 FARLEY-BOUVIER20135.62 -20135.62 Now20135.62 it's20135.78 better.20136.02 Thank20136.34 you.20136.5 We're20136.66 good.20136.82 You're20137.22 good.20137.46
20138.82 HEPNER20138.82 -20138.82 So20138.82 I20139.22 work20139.6 for20139.81 the20140.06 American20140.13 Economic20140.61 Liberties20141.01 Project.20141.33 We're20141.65 a20141.9 nonprofit20141.97 and20142.93 nonpartisan20143.1 research20143.81 and20144.22 advocacy20144.38 group20144.85 that20145.25 seeks20145.41 to20145.65 understand20145.81 the20146.29 ways20146.38 in20146.69 which20146.78 corporate20147.1 power20147.49 is20148.06 wielded20148.29 to20148.78 harm20148.93 consumers,20149.25 workers,20149.81 and20150.45 small20151.1 businesses20151.41 across20151.97 the20152.45 country.20152.61 I'm20153.73 here20153.97 to20154.29 address20154.45 the20154.85 committee20155.01 on20155.49 bills20155.73 H20156.21 9920156.45 and20156.93 S20157.09 47,20157.33 which20158.13 pertain20158.45 to20158.77 surveillance20159.01 pricing20159.65 in20160.13 grocery20160.37 stores.20160.93 Earlier20161.73 this20162.21 year,20162.45 we20163.33 coauthored20163.57 a20164.53 new20164.77 and20165.01 fairly20165.41 exhaustive20165.81 report20166.37 on20166.85 the20167.01 phenomenon20167.17 of20167.81 surveillance20168.17 pricing.20168.81 In20169.28 brief,20169.6 surveillance20170.88 pricing20171.36 refers20171.76 to20172.17 the20172.32 ability20172.49 of20172.97 corporations20173.13 to20173.92 use20174.08 vast20174.81 quantities20175.13 of20175.6 personal20175.76 data20176.24 to20176.88 set20177.04 individualized20177.36 prices20178.4 and20178.97 wages20179.28 that20180.08 are20180.32 different20180.49 for20180.97 each20181.2 person,20181.53 exploiting20182.08 consumers20182.88 based20183.55 on20183.71 their20183.87 unique20184.03 vulnerabilities20184.43 and20185.79 behaviors.20186.03 And20186.75 now20186.91 it20187.07 is20187.23 not20187.31 news,20187.55 particularly20187.79 to20188.35 you20188.51 all20188.67 who20188.83 have20188.99 been20189.15 inundated20189.55 with20190.11 this20190.27 information20190.51 today,20190.99 that20191.55 data20191.71 brokers20192.03 and20192.35 corporations20192.51 now20193.15 collect20193.39 information20194.03 about20194.51 where20194.75 we20194.91 go,20195.07 what20195.31 we20195.55 watch,20195.71 what20195.95 we20196.11 like,20196.27 what20197 videos20197.24 our20197.81 cursors20197.97 linger20198.53 over,20198.85 and20199.33 what20199.33 loans20199.65 we20199.97 take20200.2 out.20200.44
20201.24 What20201.24 is20201.49 new20201.72 is20201.97 this20202.2 phenomenon20202.44 of20203.41 firms20203.56 running20204.04 those20204.44 data20204.68 points20205 through20205.33 algorithms20205.56 to20206.2 set20206.44 individualized20207.17 prices20208.13 and20208.73 wages,20208.97 rigging20209.93 the20210.25 market20210.49 to20211.13 charge20211.37 consumers20211.69 as20212.25 much20212.33 as20212.49 they20212.65 are20212.81 willing20213.13 to20213.53 pay20213.69 and20214.17 to20214.41 pay20214.57 workers,20214.81 who20215.29 are20215.53 indeed20215.85 also20216.25 consumers,20216.57 the20217.37 minimum20217.53 amount20217.85 they20218.09 are20218.17 willing20218.33 to20218.65 work20218.73 for.20218.89 So20219.37 it20219.61 is20219.69 a20219.85 spiral20220.01 to20220.49 the20220.57 top20220.73 for20220.97 prices20221.13 and20221.65 a20221.89 spiral20222.04 to20222.44 the20222.6 bottom20222.68 for20223.08 wages.20223.33 Now,20224.13 this20224.37 issue20224.6 recently20224.92 entered20225.49 the20225.81 national20225.97 political20226.53 discourse20226.92 when20227.4 Kroger20228.13 announced20228.53 a20229 plan20229.17 to20229.4 install20229.56 digital20229.97 price20230.37 tags20231.33 and20231.65 face20231.81 recognition20232.04 surveillance20232.6 in20233.08 its20233.33 stores.20233.49 And20233.65 you've20233.81 heard20233.97 a20234.13 little20234.2 bit20234.44 about20234.6 that20234.91 today.20235.15 The20236.03 biometric20236.27 component20236.75 of20237.15 this20237.23 raised20237.47 a20237.71 lot20237.79 of20237.95 questions.20238.03 Why20238.83 would20239.07 a20239.31 grocery20239.39 store20239.87 need20240.51 to20240.83 engage20240.99 in20241.39 face20241.63 surveillance20241.95 and20242.75 biometric20242.99 identification20243.71 of20244.51 individual20244.67 shoppers20245.31 unless20246.19 the20246.59 goal20246.75 was20246.99 specifically20247.31 to20247.95 exploit20248.5 that20248.82 information20249.47 for20250.74 some20250.9 other20251.14 purpose?20252.18 Now,20252.42 this20252.42 is20252.66 far20252.82 from20252.99 just20253.22 an20253.47 in-store20253.78 issue.20254.18 In20254.74 fact,20254.82 there20255.31 is20255.54 substantial20255.78 evidence20256.35 that20256.74 the20256.9 online20257.06 applications20257.54 of20258.03 surveillance20258.18 pricing20258.74 are20259.38 already20259.54 pervasive.20259.86 In,20260.6 there's20261.16 a20261.56 very20261.96 large20262.2 grocery20262.44 delivery20262.84 app,20263.4 that20264.36 recently20264.6 announced20265.16 on20265.48 an20265.64 earnings20265.8 call20266.28 that20266.68 they20266.92 had20267.08 rolled20267.24 out20267.48 technology20267.64 to20268.36 assess20268.52 the20269.56 price20269.64 sensitivity20270.04 of20270.76 individual20271.08 consumers20271.8 using20272.44 the20272.76 app,20272.92 and20273.64 they20273.88 have20274.04 the20274.2 capability20274.36 then20275.32 to20275.56 set20275.72 different20276.04 for20276.28 prices20276.52 for20276.92 me20277.15 buying20277.31 a20277.56 banana,20277.63 than20278.43 my20278.67 neighbor20278.83 buying20279.07 a20279.31 banana20279.47 based20279.79 on20280.03 my20280.11 willingness20280.35 to20280.83 pay20280.99 and20281.24 my20281.63 price20281.88 sensitivity.20282.19
20283.07 So20283.07 this20283.24 capability20283.47 is20284.52 here.20284.75 The20285.15 incentive20285.24 is20285.88 clearly20286.11 here,20286.52 and20287.56 I20287.95 think20288.11 that20288.35 the20288.52 legislation20288.67 before20289.4 you20289.72 in20289.88 these20290.03 220290.28 bills20290.43 it's20291.24 clearly20291.58 aimed20292.62 at20292.86 grappling20293.1 with20293.58 it.20293.74 And20294.06 I20294.22 would,20294.38 you20294.62 know,20294.7 encourage20294.94 it's20295.34 a20295.5 little20295.58 bit20295.74 outside20295.9 the20296.22 context20296.38 of20296.78 these20296.86 220297.1 bills,20297.26 but20297.66 to20297.9 incur20298.14 to20298.46 engage20298.7 on20299.1 the20299.26 wage20299.42 side20299.74 of20299.98 this20300.06 as20300.22 well.20300.38 That20301.18 the20301.42 fact20301.58 that,20301.9 particularly20302.22 in20302.86 the20303.02 gig20303.18 economy,20303.42 that20304.14 different20304.38 workers20304.7 are20305.26 being20305.5 paid20305.74 different20306.14 amounts20306.62 for20307.37 the20307.6 same20307.68 type20308.24 of20308.41 work,20308.56 for20308.89 the20309.04 same20309.2 task20309.6 based20310.33 on20310.56 how20310.81 much20310.97 money20311.2 they20311.45 have20311.6 in20311.68 their20311.85 bank20312 accounts,20312.24 what20313.37 their20313.53 credit20313.77 score20314.24 is,20314.49 other20315.2 financial20315.53 vulnerabilities20316.24 that,20317.2 that20317.77 they20317.93 may20318.08 be,20318.24 you20319.13 know,20319.2 vulnerable20319.53 to.20320 So20320.24 this20320.85 is20321.09 a20321.17 really20321.25 complex20321.65 issue,20322.21 but20322.45 the20322.69 220322.85 bills20323.01 that20323.65 I'm20323.81 here20324.05 to20324.29 speak20324.37 on20324.61 today20324.77 and20325.01 indeed20325.25 a20325.49 lot20325.57 of20325.81 the20325.89 location-based20326.45 stuff20326.77 that20327.01 you20327.17 all20327.33 are20327.49 grappling20327.65 with20328.05 today20328.21 really20328.77 inform20329.17 some20330.69 real20330.85 progress.20331.09 I20331.65 genuinely20331.73 looking20332.13 forward20332.37 to20332.61 the20332.77 progress20332.85 you20333.17 guys20333.33 are20333.49 all20333.65 making20333.81 today.20334.05 This20334.29 is20334.53 tremendous20334.97 work,20335.28 and20335.53 it's20335.68 been20335.85 great20336.08 to20336.32 listen20336.49 in.20336.72
FARLEY-BOUVIER20338.64 -20338.64 Thank20338.64 you20338.88 so20339.2 much.20339.44 I'm20339.76 gonna20339.92 first20340.16 turn20340.49 to20340.72 the20340.88 committee20340.97 for20341.36 any20341.6 comments20341.76 or20342.16 questions.20342.32 Senator,20343.04 do20343.53 you20343.68 have20343.76 anything?20344 I20344.97 do20345.12 have20345.28 a20345.44 question20345.53 for20345.85 you.20346 If20346.08 you20346.24 would20346.32 indulge20346.56 me,20346.97 please,20347.2 Mister20348.19 Hefner.20348.43 You20350.03 came20350.35 for20350.59 a20350.71 specific20350.83 purpose20351.31 to20351.79 talk20352.19 about20352.43 those20352.67 bills,20353.39 and20354.67 you've,20354.91 but20355.15 you've20355.39 also20355.63 listened.20356.03 So20356.43 do20357.07 you,20357.31 with20357.47 your20357.79 multistate20358.59 view.20360.45 Do20360.54 you20360.54 have20360.78 a20361.33 view20361.49 on20361.74 comprehensive20362.06 data20362.62 privacy?20362.85
HEPNER20364.62 -20364.62 Yeah.20364.62 Absolutely.20365.49 I20366.22 mean,20366.29 I20366.45 think20366.54 that20366.78 states20367.18 have20367.58 a20368.93 tremendous20369.1 ability20369.58 to20369.97 lead20370.06 here,20370.29 particularly20371.1 on20371.97 ideas20372.29 like20372.7 data20372.85 minimization,20373.1 which20373.81 I20374 think20374.08 has20374.24 been20374.48 a20374.8 common20374.96 theme20375.28 of20375.6 what20375.68 you've20375.84 heard20376 today.20376.24 This20376.56 notion20376.72 is20377.04 that20377.04 if20377.6 data20377.84 is20378.16 being20378.32 collected20378.56 and20379.04 we20379.28 know20379.44 it's20379.6 being20379.84 collected,20380.08 let's20380.72 at20381.04 least20381.2 minimize20381.52 the20382.4 purposes20382.56 for20383.04 which20383.2 it20383.36 can20383.44 be20383.68 used.20383.76 Minimize20384.56 the20385.12 retention20385.28 of20385.84 that20386 data20386.24 so20386.56 that20386.85 it's20386.92 not20387.16 lingering20388.6 beyond20389.56 the20389.56 use20389.81 that20390.12 it20390.28 was20390.44 collected20390.68 for.20391.16 So,20392.04 I20392.12 think20392.28 that20392.44 those20392.68 principles20393 are20393.56 really20393.81 fundamental,20394.2 and20395.32 what's20395.81 kind20396.2 of20396.44 scary20396.6 is20397 particularly20397.4 the20397.97 era20398.12 of20398.52 AI20398.85 and20399.4 new20399.72 models20400.28 that20400.68 are20400.99 are20401.07 becoming20401.31 kind20401.63 of20401.87 agentic20402.11 in20402.67 their20402.83 own20403.07 right20403.31 is20403.87 the20404.11 ability20404.35 for20404.67 that20404.83 data20404.99 to20405.31 be20405.47 exploited20405.71 long20406.35 term20406.59 for20406.83 purposes20407.07 that20407.47 were20407.71 far20408.03 different20408.43 than20408.99 what20409.15 it20409.31 was20409.39 collected20409.63 for.20410.19
20411.07 Now,20411.07 I20411.23 think20411.39 that20411.55 certain20411.79 uses20412.11 should20412.59 just20412.83 be20412.99 barred.20413.15 I20413.47 don't20413.63 think20413.79 that20414.03 we20414.35 should20414.51 be20414.67 collecting20414.83 personal20415.23 information20415.71 to20416.19 charge20416.35 people20416.67 different20417.1 prices20417.33 or20417.81 to20418.06 pay20418.22 people20418.38 different20418.69 wages.20419.02 I20419.97 think20420.06 that20420.29 that20420.45 is20420.69 just20420.85 an20421.1 insidious20421.33 exploitation20421.9 of20422.54 people's20422.69 personal20423.02 information.20423.42 And20425.17 the20425.42 only20425.58 upside20425.81 is20426.13 going20426.29 to20426.54 be20426.61 for20426.85 the20427.1 large20427.17 corporations20427.42 who20428.06 are20428.13 seeking20428.29 that20428.61 steepability20428.78 on20429.97 the20430.13 backs20430.22 of20430.54 consumers20430.61 and20431.1 workers.20431.17 But20431.65 I20431.97 think20432.13 the20432.37 principles20432.53 that20433.01 you20433.09 have20433.25 been20433.49 grappling20433.65 with20434.05 all20434.29 day20434.45 today20434.69 are20435.09 super20435.17 relevant20435.41 around20435.81 your20436.21 location20436.37 data,20436.77 data20437.25 minimization,20437.57 comprehensive,20438.21 privacy20439.17 policy.20439.97 I'm20441.01 based20441.33 in20441.57 California.20441.73 Many20442.21 of20442.45 my20442.53 colleagues20442.69 are20443.01 in20443.17 DC,20443.33 but20443.65 we20443.81 have20443.89 a20444.53 very20444.69 rigorous20446.77 and20447.14 really20447.29 effective20447.45 comprehensive20449.06 privacy20449.62 law20450.33 here20450.66 in20450.9 California20451.14 that20451.85 the20451.93 business20452.1 community20452.42 has20452.81 adapted20453.06 to.20453.45 And20454.42 it's20454.74 been20454.97 a20455.29 few20455.38 years,20455.62 but20456.02 I20456.58 think20456.66 it's20456.9 working.20457.06
20458.25 FARLEY-BOUVIER20458.25 -20458.25 Thank20458.25 you.20458.49 Appreciate20458.81 that.20459.29 Pleasure.20460.45 We20460.85 thank20461.09 you20461.25 for20461.41 your20461.57 testimony,20462.61 and20463.25 we'd20463.49 be20463.81 happy20463.89 to20464.13 continue20464.29 to20464.77 engage20464.93 with20465.25 you20465.33 throughout20466.05 this20466.45 process.20466.69
20467.81 HEPNER20467.81 -20467.81 Thank20467.81 you20468.05 so20468.21 much.20468.37
20468.77 FARLEY-BOUVIER20468.77 -20468.77 Sure.20468.77 So20469.17 we're20469.41 next20469.65 gonna20469.89 go20470.21 we're20471.01 next20471.25 gonna20471.49 go20471.73 to20471.89 Kelvin20472.13 Green.20472.53 Is20472.93 Kelvin20473.17 here?20473.65 And20474.86 after20475.5 that20475.74 is20476.06 Tom20476.31 Nyer,20476.63 who20477.67 is20477.82 our20477.99 last20478.22 testifier.20480.06 Anybody20480.79 else.20481.1 Or20481.42 anybody20481.67 else20482.06 who's20482.31 here.20482.47 Signed20482.94 up.20483.27 Okay.20483.74 Oh,20484.06 good.20484.31 I've20484.7 been20484.86 watching20485.42 you,20485.82 and20485.9 I20486.15 was20486.22 wondering20486.47 about20486.86 your20487.03 name,20487.27 so20487.5 that's20487.9 okay.20488.15 We're20488.47 not20488.63 gonna20488.79 let20489.1 anybody20489.35 not20489.82 testify.20489.99 I20490.51 promise.20490.67 Especially.20491.39 Kelvin,20492.75 it20493.23 was20493.47 nice20493.47 to20493.63 see20493.79 you20493.95 today.20494.11
20494.43 SPEAKER1220494.43 -20494.43 Nice20494.43 to20494.67 see20494.75 you.20494.91 Yeah.20495.23
20496.99 KELVIN20496.99 GREEN20496.99 II20496.99 -20496.99 KAIRO20496.99 FELLOWSHIP20497.79 -20497.79 HB20497.79 10420497.79 -20497.79 SB20497.79 4520497.79 -20497.79 SB20497.79 2920497.79 -20497.79 Hello20497.79 to20497.79 the20498.03 chairs,20498.11 to20498.43 the20498.51 committee,20498.67 to20499.07 the20499.15 staff,20499.31 to20499.71 the20499.87 people20500.03 who've20500.27 also20500.51 been20500.83 waiting.20500.99 Hello.20501.63 My20502.19 name20502.35 is20502.43 Kelvin20502.59 Green20502.99 II.20503.39 I20504.59 am20504.75 a20504.91 Malden20505.07 resident.20505.39 I20505.79 also20505.87 sit20506.25 here20506.49 as20506.74 a20507.13 believer20507.22 in20507.53 Jesus20507.78 Christ20508.1 and20508.33 his20508.49 call20508.65 to20508.9 service.20509.06 I'm20509.85 an20510.1 8-year20510.33 resident20510.57 of20510.97 Massachusetts.20511.22 I'm20512.1 a20512.25 graduate20512.33 of20512.74 MIT.20513.06 I'm20513.85 a20514.1 former20514.17 community20514.57 organizer20515.06 in20515.53 Somerville,20515.69 Randolph,20516.33 Everett,20516.81 Dorchester,20517.29 Mattapan,20518.17 Rosendale,20518.81 Jamaica20519.85 Plain,20520.25 and20520.57 Woburn.20520.74 And20521.6 I'm20521.76 here20521.92 as20522.08 a20522.32 senior20522.4 organizing20522.72 specialist20523.2 at20523.6 Kairos20523.92 Action.20524.4 We20525.28 are20525.52 a20525.84 national20526 organization20526.48 focused20527.36 on20527.68 non-partisan20528.08 education20528.72 and20529.36 advocacy20529.52 at20530.48 the20530.56 intersection20530.72 of20531.28 technology,20531.52 democracy,20532.4 and20533.28 other20533.52 issues20534.16 our20534.47 communities20534.88 face20535.6 today.20535.92
20537.35 I20537.35 believe20537.52 Massachusetts20537.92 has20538.72 always20538.72 have20539.04 believed20539.28 is20539.99 always20540.24 well20540.47 positioned20540.72 to20541.19 pioneer20541.6 and20542.08 lead20542.08 the20542.31 way,20542.47 especially20543.12 in20543.6 120543.83 of20543.99 the20544.16 most20544.24 pressing20544.79 issues20545.19 facing20545.6 our20545.92 communities,20546.08 which20546.95 is20547.28 the20547.43 severe20547.67 invasion20547.99 of20548.59 privacy20548.75 by20549.55 corporations20549.79 and20550.67 mostly20551.07 the20551.47 lack20551.63 of20551.95 the20552.11 legal20552.27 guardrails20552.59 preventing20553.31 them20553.79 from20554.03 doing20554.19 so.20554.43 This20555.47 is20555.63 why20555.71 I20555.95 ask20556.03 each20556.35 of20556.59 you20556.67 to20556.91 support,20557.15 and20558.35 favorably20558.67 favorably20559.31 report,20559.95 support20561.23 for20561.55 h20561.87 86,20562.19 s20562.91 120563.15 97,20563.39 the20563.95 Location20564.03 Shield20564.81 Act.20565.36 I20565.36 also20565.44 want20565.76 to20566 register20566.17 my20566.65 support20566.88 for20567.28 the20567.53 following20567.68 comprehensive20568.17 privacy20568.72 bills:20570.72 H20571.04 104,20571.04 S20571.04 45,20571.04 S20571.85 29,20572.08 and20573.04 H20573.36 78.20573.68 In20575.36 the20575.6 work20575.68 that20575.92 I20576.17 do,20576.32 I've20576.56 been20576.72 a20576.88 witness20577.04 to20577.44 Massachusetts20577.6 residents20578.32 who've20579.13 been20579.44 doxed.20579.68 That20580.86 means20581.1 their20581.42 personal20581.74 and20582.22 private20582.38 data20582.7 has20583.02 been20583.18 published20583.42 online20583.74 for20584.62 no20584.94 other20585.1 purpose20585.26 but20585.66 to20585.82 bring20586.06 harm.20586.3 These20587.18 community20587.42 members20587.82 rightfully20588.22 feel20588.7 unsafe20589.1 in20589.98 their20590.14 own20590.3 communities.20590.54 They20591.34 live20591.58 under20591.74 threat20592.06 of20592.38 online20592.62 and,20593.02 unfortunately,20593.26 offline20593.9 violence20594.38 with20595.03 their20595.18 data20595.42 publicly20595.9 floating20596.54 in20596.86 the20597.1 ether,20597.27 and20597.99 many20598.15 remain20598.47 traumatized20598.78 by20599.35 the20599.58 fear20599.67 of20599.99 such.20600.15 I20601.35 like20601.58 to20601.74 think20601.82 of20601.99 this20602.15 I'm20602.31 at20602.54 Kairos.20602.63 We20603.1 like20603.27 to20603.42 bring20603.5 digital20603.82 issues20604.22 into20604.63 in-person20605.5 reality.20606.15
20606.78 So20606.78 I20607.18 tell20607.42 folks,20607.66 you20607.82 know,20607.9 imagine20608.22 your20608.54 home20608.78 without20609.74 a20610.06 front20610.22 door.20610.46 Imagine20611.42 how20611.9 many20612.06 people20612.22 could20612.46 come20612.7 in20612.86 without20613.5 you20613.82 knowing.20614.06 Imagine20614.46 folks20614.86 in20615.58 your20615.82 home20615.98 observing20616.3 you20616.7 with20616.94 cameras,20617.1 reporting20618.22 back20618.7 to20618.86 their20619.02 collaborators,20619.26 stealing,20620.35 plotting,20621.54 and20621.86 even20621.86 selling20622.18 what20622.5 they20622.67 discovered20622.9 to20623.47 someone20623.63 else.20623.86 This20624.99 is20625.22 what20625.31 our20625.63 current20625.7 digital20625.94 landscape20626.35 looks20626.9 like.20627.06 And20628.03 so,20628.27 strong20628.5 consumer20628.99 privacy20629.54 legislation20630.1 erects20631.22 a20631.7 stable20631.86 door.20632.18 We20632.5 just20632.58 want20632.83 a20632.99 front20633.06 door.20633.38 With20634.03 a20634.27 lock20634.42 on20634.67 all20634.9 of20635.61 our20635.85 digital20635.93 lives20637.21 to20637.61 protect20637.77 us,20638.17 so20638.57 We20638.81 The20639.05 People20639.29 can20639.77 safely20639.93 live20640.41 online20640.65 and20641.05 offline.20641.21 This20642.25 door20642.57 provides20642.89 protection20643.37 and20643.85 authority20644.01 to20644.65 We20644.81 The20644.97 People20645.13 over20645.85 what20646.09 happens20646.33 with20646.65 our20646.81 data,20646.97 whether20647.37 we20647.69 want20647.85 folks20648.09 in20648.49 or20648.97 keeping20649.21 perceived20649.69 threats20650.17 out.20651.28 So,20651.51 in20651.67 order20651.83 to20652.07 protect20652.24 Bay20652.56 Staters20652.87 from20653.67 being20653.91 the20654.24 victims20654.39 of20654.72 massive20654.79 breaches20655.19 of20655.51 privacy,20655.67 Massachusetts20656.56 needs20657.28 to20657.51 include20657.75 these20658.07 320658.31 components20658.47 in20658.95 its20659.03 legislation.20659.28 You've20659.91 heard20660.15 this20660.31 already20660.63 today,20661.03 but20661.35 I20661.6 will20661.67 repeat20662.31 data20662.95 minimization.20663.28 A20664.92 calculator20665.16 or20665.56 flashlight20665.72 app20666.12 doesn't20666.36 need20666.6 to20666.72 know20666.84 where20667.08 I20667.24 am20667.32 to20667.56 work.20667.72
20668.52 So20668.52 strong20668.76 privacy20669.08 legislation20669.48 needs20670.04 to20670.28 ensure20670.36 companies20670.68 are20671.08 aligning20671.32 their20671.72 data,20671.88 collecting20672.52 practices20672.92 with20673.4 what20673.56 the20673.72 user20673.88 is20674.2 expecting.20674.44 2,20675.4 a20675.8 ban20675.96 on20676.2 the20676.28 sale20676.44 of20676.68 sensitive20676.85 data.20677.25 Businesses20677.81 should20678.22 not20678.45 be20678.53 able20678.69 to20678.78 sell20678.85 sensitive20679.1 data20679.49 about20679.9 us20680.13 without20680.45 us,20680.85 especially20681.49 when20681.9 there20682.06 are20682.22 cases20682.38 of20682.69 folks20682.78 avoiding20683.1 care20683.57 or20683.81 being20683.97 denied20684.22 care.20684.61 And20685.33 lastly,20685.57 strong20686.06 enforcement,20686.38 including20687.17 a20687.57 private20687.65 right20688.06 to20688.29 action.20688.61 We20689.17 know20689.33 that20689.49 policies20689.65 are20690.22 only20690.29 as20690.61 good20690.78 as20691.02 their20691.1 ability20691.33 to20691.74 be20691.9 enforced.20692.13 There20693.23 are20693.47 real20693.55 people20693.71 depending20694.11 on20694.51 these20694.67 policies20694.91 turning20695.39 into20695.71 real-world20696.43 action20696.75 in20697.15 order20697.23 to20697.55 keep20697.71 us20697.87 safe.20698.03 At20699.31 Kairos,20699.55 we20700.03 know20700.19 people20700.27 deserve20700.59 a20701.23 say20701.31 in20701.55 how20701.63 our20701.87 data20702.03 is20702.35 used,20702.51 how20702.75 the20702.91 Internet20703.07 is20703.47 governed.20703.63 We20704.27 appreciate20704.51 Massachusetts20704.99 for20705.63 pioneering20705.79 legislation,20706.43 I20706.99 will20707.15 say.20707.39 Maryland20708.06 has20708.38 produced20708.45 something,20708.85 but20709.18 they20709.25 do20709.49 not20709.58 have20709.74 the20709.9 private20710.06 right20710.45 of20710.7 action,20710.85 so20711.18 you20711.42 would20711.66 be20711.81 pioneering20711.97 this20712.93 legislation20713.18 that20713.81 will20713.97 make20714.14 tech20714.29 work20714.54 for20714.85 all.20714.93 And20715.58 lastly,20715.81 I'll20716.14 just20716.29 say20716.45 as20716.7 someone20716.78 born20717.18 in20717.49 '98,20717.66 220718.22 years20718.38 after20718.7 the20719.02 GLBA,20719.33 I20720.7 identify20720.85 with20721.33 36%20721.49 of20722.29 Massachusetts20722.45 residents.20723.02 That's20723.46 about20723.62 2,000,00020723.74 people20724.34 who20725.06 are20725.3 under20725.54 the20725.78 29,20725.86 and20726.66 we20726.9 only20727.14 know20727.38 the20727.62 world20727.78 as20728.1 deeply20728.18 digital20728.58 and20729.06 offline.20729.78 So20730.1 we20730.26 are20730.42 excited20731.06 to20731.46 for20731.62 you20731.7 to20731.86 have20732.02 this20732.18 opportunity20732.42 to20733.06 consider20733.54 us20733.94 in20734.18 this20734.26 world20734.5 that20734.74 we've20734.82 inherited20735.14 and20735.54 to20735.7 provide20735.86 protection.20736.18 Thank20736.93 you.20737.08
20737.56 FARLEY-BOUVIER20737.56 -20737.56 Thank20737.56 you.20737.72 Thank20738.04 you20738.29 for20738.37 your20738.53 strong20738.68 testimony.20739 We20739.49 appreciate20739.65 it.20740.04 Are20740.2 there20740.37 any20740.44 comments20740.68 or20740.93 questions20741.08 from20741.41 the20741.56 committee?20741.72 Perfect.20743 Okay.20743.49 We're20743.72 gonna20743.89 go20744.2 to20744.37 Tom20744.6 Nyer20744.85 in20746.29 the20746.44 room20746.6 and20746.93 then20747.08 Karen's.20747.49 Thank20748.68 you.20748.85 Great.20749.25 And20749.57 is20749.73 there20749.89 anybody20750.13 else?20750.61 Just20750.93 let20751.09 us20751.25 know.20751.33 Okay?20751.65 Is20752.53 Tom20752.69 here?20753.01 Is20753.76 Tom20754.5 online?20755.25 Okay.20758.05 So,20758.37 Karen,20758.77 you20759.17 are20759.33 up.20759.57 Hi.20759.89 And20760.45 we20760.69 are20760.85 delighted20761.01 with20763.88 the20763.88 age.20763.95 Oh,20764.52 no.20764.67 Of20764.83 course.20765.07 Everybody20765.56 here.20766.04 You20768.11 had20768.43 a20768.52 lot20768.6 of20768.83 patience20768.92 today.20769.31 Oh,20769.72 great.20770.04 That.20770.52
20770.67 KAREN20770.67 BAUERLE20770.67 -20770.67 TOWN20770.67 OF20770.67 BELMONT20770.67 MASSACHUSETTS20770.67 -20770.67 This20770.67 is20770.92 super20770.99 important.20771.31 And20771.88 I'm20772.11 really20772.19 tired.20772.52 Yeah.20772.92 I20773.4 don't20773.56 wanna20773.72 just20773.88 lose20774.11 it20774.28 right20774.43 here20774.6 for20774.86 you.20775.15 Yeah.20775.45 My20776.04 name20776.33 is20776.62 Karen20776.92 Bauerle.20777.21 I'm20777.51 a20777.8 resident20778.09 of20778.39 Belmont,20778.68 Massachusetts.20778.97 I'm20779.27 a20779.56 member20779.86 of20780.15 town20780.44 meeting.20780.74 I20781.03 represent20781.33 the20781.62 Disability20781.91 Access20782.21 Commission20782.5 in20782.8 our20783.09 town,20783.38 and20783.68 I'm20783.97 a20784.27 member20784.56 of20784.85 the20785.15 housing20785.44 trust.20785.74 I20786.03 have20786.32 also,20786.32 have20786.91 retired20787.29 my20787.45 law20787.6 license20787.93 because20788.41 it20788.65 became20788.89 useless20789.13 to20789.53 me20789.68 because20789.85 I20790.17 have20790.24 multiple20790.41 chronic20791.04 illnesses.20791.45 And20793.85 I20794.08 wanna20794.17 say20794.41 that20794.65 it20794.89 starts20795.04 out20795.37 when20796.89 I20797.13 got20797.29 married,20797.45 when20797.85 I20798.08 was20798.17 24,20798.41 I20798.89 lost20799.13 my20799.37 health20799.45 insurance.20799.68 I20800.08 lived20800.24 in20800.49 Georgia,20800.65 and20801.33 I20801.41 was20801.57 put20801.89 on20802.13 a20802.29 computer.20802.37 I20804.13 could20804.29 no20804.45 longer20804.69 get20805.33 health20806.45 insurance20806.69 as20807.09 a20807.21 result20807.33 of20807.65 that20807.73 single20807.97 denial.20808.29 I20808.69 have20808.77 run20809.01 from20809.17 that20809.41 my20809.65 whole20809.81 life.20810.05 Wow.20810.45
20811.73 And20811.73 without20812.05 a20812.61 spouse,20812.77 I20813.25 would20813.41 have20813.57 no20813.81 protection,20813.97 except20815.01 now20815.33 that20815.41 I20815.57 live20815.65 in20815.81 Massachusetts.20816.05 But,20816.61 I20816.9 mean,20816.99 it's20817.15 really20817.58 been20818.03 this20819.54 has20819.78 been20819.94 following20820.18 me20820.5 around,20820.66 and20821.94 it's20822.18 actually20822.42 made20822.74 me20822.99 sicker.20823.15 My20824.58 mental20824.82 health20825.15 has20825.54 suffered.20825.7 My20827.94 children's20828.18 mental20828.74 health20829.06 has20829.38 suffered.20829.54 My20830.85 physical20831.01 health20831.41 has20831.65 suffered.20831.89 I20833.25 drive20833.89 my20834.45 test20835.33 results20835.73 to20836.13 my20836.29 doctors,20836.53 so20836.93 I20837.09 don't20837.25 have20837.41 to20837.57 put20837.65 it20837.89 online.20837.97 It's20838.69 really20838.93 hard20839.17 to20839.33 do20839.49 when20839.65 you're20839.89 chronically20840.13 ill.20840.69 Yeah.20841.09 And20844.21 I'm20845.57 not20845.74 employable.20846.06 You20847.97 know?20848.13 I20849.17 used20849.42 to20849.65 be20849.74 a20849.9 person.20850.06 Now20850.78 I'm20851.1 just20851.17 what?20853.65 A20856.13 number?20856.29 No.20856.78 Now20857.33 I'm20857.57 a20857.74 person20858.01 to20858.17 corporations20858.41 that20858.89 wanna20859.13 sell20859.45 my20859.69 information.20859.93 And20861.37 there's20863.45 a20863.69 great20863.85 deal20864.01 of20864.41 precarity20864.49 that's20865.13 very20865.53 practical20865.85 and20866.33 very20866.49 true.20866.81 And20867.61 some20867.93 of20868.09 it's20868.25 in20868.57 heads20868.81 and20869.21 but20869.77 but20869.97 most20870.14 of20870.38 it's20870.45 really20870.62 in20870.93 our20871.1 lives.20871.25 And20872.22 this20872.45 needs20872.7 to20872.93 be20873.1 attended20873.25 to.20873.58 I20873.81 would20873.97 argue20874.62 for20874.93 the20875.18 strongest20875.33 possible20875.74 comprehensive20876.29 data20877.1 protections20877.42 available.20878.14
20881.58 Because20881.58 I20882.06 deal20882.22 with20882.45 health20882.7 insurance20882.93 a20883.49 lot,20883.58 I20885.4 am20885.92 incredibly20886.44 exposed.20887.16 My20888.6 information20888.84 is20889.4 spread20889.64 out20889.88 on20890.04 different20890.2 networks20890.52 in20890.92 this20891.08 state.20891.32 I20891.8 have20891.96 doctors20892.2 who20892.6 cannot20892.76 communicate20893.16 with20893.64 each20893.8 other20893.96 because20894.28 they're20894.52 excluded20894.76 by20895.96 other20896.2 programs.20896.52 So20897.24 pertinent20897.64 information20898.2 falls20898.84 due20899.16 to20899.4 cracks20899.48 for20900.7 me.20900.94 It20901.42 I20901.74 need,20901.9 like,20902.22 a20902.38 team20902.54 leader.20902.94 And20904.38 I20904.62 am20905.1 a20905.26 fortunate20905.35 person.20905.99 I'm20906.86 capable,20907.1 and20909.18 I20909.42 would20909.5 like20909.74 it.20909.9 I'm20912.07 just20912.31 gonna20912.39 go20912.47 to20912.71 my20912.87 next20912.95 point,20913.19 which20913.27 is20913.51 that20913.67 I20913.67 really20913.75 want20913.99 my20914.15 personal20914.23 financial20914.55 information20915.11 made20917.03 safe.20917.27 I20917.67 have20917.83 no20917.99 financial20918.23 information20918.79 online20919.27 to20919.59 the20919.75 best20919.83 of20920.15 my20920.31 ability.20920.39 What20921.43 I20921.59 have20921.75 done20921.91 is20922.07 withdraw20922.31 from20922.79 life20923.03 as20923.59 a20923.75 result20923.83 of20924.23 this.20924.31 And20927.27 I'm20928.18 also20928.42 obviously20929.14 concerned20929.62 about20930.02 biometric20930.25 data.20930.74 I20930.97 don't20931.14 pay20931.69 the20931.93 same20932.1 price20932.25 for20932.49 my20932.66 groceries20932.74 as20933.29 anybody20933.45 else.20933.93 There20936.02 are20936.33 many20936.49 other20936.81 groups20937.06 for20937.62 whom20937.78 it's20938.33 they're20938.74 in20938.97 a20939.14 much20939.22 more20939.38 precarious20939.62 situation20940.1 than20942.55 me.20942.6 They20942.66 deserve20942.71 our20943.27 deepest20943.51 consideration.20943.99 I20946.55 also20946.71 would20947.19 argue20947.43 for20947.75 a20947.99 personal20948.07 right20948.47 of20948.63 action.20948.71 I20950.39 personally20950.63 wouldn't20951.11 mind20951.43 being20951.67 in20951.91 the20951.91 trial.20952.07 Yeah.20954.47 And20955.93 I20956.17 just20957.38 wanna20957.61 thank20958.02 you.20958.25 I'm20958.65 gonna20958.81 go20959.06 ahead20959.29 and20959.61 stop20960.1 talking.20960.42 But,20960.97
20961.69 SPEAKER1420961.69 -20961.69 Okay.20961.69
FARLEY-BOUVIER20961.93 -20961.93 And,20961.93 you20962.17 know,20962.33 your20962.57 written20962.74 testimony20962.97 is20963.45 very20963.61 valuable20963.85 to20964.17 us,20964.33 so20964.49 please20964.65 do20964.9 submit20965.13 that.20965.45 And20966.81 I20967.61 think20967.69 that20968.02 your20968.25 testimony20968.89 really20969.85 exemplifies20970.33 the20971.13 burden20971.29 on20971.69 the20971.85 consumer20972.01 and20972.89 how20973.05 we20973.29 have20973.53 really,20973.85 you20974.49 know,20974.65 we20974.81 have20974.89 that20975.13 backward.20975.29 We20975.85 do.20976.01 So,20976.33 we20976.57 appreciate20976.81 your20977.29 testimony.20977.45 I20978.01 just20978.09 wanna20978.25 look20979.13 around,20979.53 I20980.01 feel20980.17 like20980.41 we20980.57 got20980.73 to20980.97 everybody.20981.13
20982.73 MOORE-20982.73 Well,20982.73 thank20983.05 you20983.53 for20983.69 waiting.20983.85
20984.06 FARLEY-BOUVIER20984.06 -20984.06 Thank20984.06 you.20984.75 Really20985.07 do20985.24 appreciate20985.47 that.20986.03 And20987.07 so20987.4 120987.79 more,20988.03 plea20989.56 that20989.95 written20990.19 testimony,20990.52 is,20991.72 encouraged,20993.4 and,20994.19 we're20994.67 asking20994.99 for20995.31 that20995.47 to20995.63 be20995.79 submitted20995.95 by20996.35 Monday20996.52 the20996.92 fourteenth20997.07 at,20998.11 520998.73 PM.20999.53 Okay?20999.53 Thank20999.93 you,21000.09 everybody.21000.33 We're21000.65 gonna21000.81 call21000.97 that21001.13 a21001.37 close.21001.45